Remarks on the Approximation of the Euler Equations by a Low Order Model
29
0
0
Texte intégral
(2) INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE. Remarks on the Approximation of the Euler Equations by a Low Order Model Angelo Iollo. N˚ 3329 Decembre 1997 THÈME 4. ISSN 0249-6399. apport de recherche.
(3)
(4)
(5) !" $#&%' ()#+*,% - .0/ 12 (3 456()78 ,6' 9:<;>=@?BA"CDA>?E?BA FHGJI K
(6) L M0NPORQSKTJUWVYXZQ\[@]^L_X([a`bXZQ\K
(7) QWcdVeXdQS[a] f LcdgRchXdI K
(8) L c(i_[@K
(9) `JU\L jbL c kmld[anoL_XpORqorpspO tVa`J`u[aldX f LvldLwixGJL lxixGJLy]uz {@{@|a}vN~pL i L KldL
(10) }@} N|a `VaaL c YJaa U\TQ f+ [Yc-ValdL@L lZg[aXdL ]+a[Y@L lZ]JL f RgXdGJL f gR]VeK
(11) QWi c-[eVcdK,VeUSUp]RTJKL l[a i [aGJL ldL ]X chXdlZTiDXZTJlZL c QB LaS TQ f L VeXdTJlZL c (GJQWixG2¡aL L `XZGJL QSlvQS] f QSQ f TVaU\Q\Xog f TJldQS]JXdGJL,L a[@U\TbXZQ\[@] [a<XdGJL [Yv¢FHGJL`JTJlZ`[chL[a<XdGJQWc¢`Ve`uL l¢QWc¢Xd[-`ldLwchL ]@X V,£V¤g-Xd[chQSKTJUWVYXZLvXdGL¥mTJUSL l L ¦TVeXdQS[a]c [@]§XdGLVacdQSc[e(XZGJL^L a[@U\TJXdQS[a]§[e chTixGi_[@GJL lZL ]X0chXdlZTi_XdTJlZf L c §¨p]LHV¤g©XZ[ªL jRXdlxVaiDXld[@K [Y cdQSKTJUWVYXZQ\[@]c«cd[aK
(12) L¬V@chQWcT]iDXZQ\[@]c«(GQSixGi Ve]vuL®QS]XdL lZ`JlZL_XZL Vac i_[@GJL lZL ]X«chXdlZTiDXZTJlZL cQWcgvkmlZ[a`uL l ¨pldXdG[aa[@]VeU~pL i [aK
(13) `u[@cdQ¯XZQ\[@]°Ek±¨ ~ ²DFHGJL ]RgK
(14) L Ve]c[e¬V³ VeUSL lZ¡QS]^`JlZ[enoL i_XdQS[a]Q¯X QSc¢`[cdcdQSJU\L XZcd[`Va´]J] ]Jf L f XdGJRL g·chgbXdGJchXdL
(15) L KµV@[achQW cp¨ TJ~p]¥®i_c®XdQS([a]GJc QWixG-[@TJVa] `Jf `J0lZ[¤qojRcdQScdK,TJLwVYc XZL i c<[aXZ]GJi L¢L lZ`J]JlZQS[a]J-U\L XZK¶GJL,QS] coXxXZVeGJJLQSUS´Q¯Xo]gQ¯XZVaL ] f f QSK
(16) XZGJL L,]cdVaQ\[@i i_]TJVelxU>Vacdi `gVai [aL cdTixG©Va]©Ve``Jld[¤jbQSK,VYXdQS[a]·ValdL f QScZi_TcZcdL f q¸XpQWc[@TJ] f XdGVeX V-chXdlxVeQSaGXd¹B[@ldHVel f ³ VaU\L ld¡RQS]·K
(17) L_XdG[ f QWc£TJ]chXZVaJU\L@®OR[aK
(18) LpL VeXdTJlZL c£[e f QWcdi [a]XdQS]RTJ[aTc(³ VaU\L ld¡RQS]-K
(19) L_XZGJ[ f cHVelZL¢XZGJL lZL_[@ldL Q\]i_[alZ`u[alxVYXdL f Xd[ V@ixGJQSL aLvchXZVaJQ\USQ\Xoga(GQSixG·QWc`JlZ[YaL f [@l¢V
(20) USQ\]JLwVel¢cZi VaUSVal¢i V@chL@®qº]V fJf Q\XdQS[a]±L`ld[@`[chLvV,HV¤g,Xd[ lZf L f Ti_LvXZGJL
(21) i_[@chX¢[amXdGJL0i_[aK
(22) `JTJXZVYXZQ\[@]©Ve] f Xd[-QS]i ldLwVacdLf Vai i_TJlxVai f gVYXpXdGJL0cdVaK
(23) LXdQSK
(24) La OR[aK
(25) L[@]JL_f ¹ Q\K
(26) L ]chQS[a]VaUbi_[aK
(27) `JTJXZVYXZQ\[@]VeUbL jb`L ldQSK
(28) L ]XZcmValdL£`JlZL cdL ]XdL eQS]i_UST QS]JvchG[Rix¡XdTJuLchQSKTUSVeXdQS[a]c<Ve] lxVelZL_EV@iDXZQ\[@] EVe]c »·¼½>¾Z¿À YÁ a k£¨ ~u¥mTJUSL l(L ¦TVeXdQS[a]c ³ VeUSL lZ¡RQ\]K
(29) L_XZGJ[ f JUS[Y&[al f L l£K
(30) [ f L UB. Unité de recherche INRIA Sophia Antipolis 2004, route des Lucioles, B.P. 93, 06902 Sophia Antipolis Cedex (France) Téléphone : 04 93 65 77 77 - International : +33 4 93 65 77 77 — Fax : 04 93 65 77 65 - International : +33 4 93 65 77 65 à partir du 05/01/1998 Téléphone : 04 92 38 77 77 - International : +33 4 92 38 77 77 — Fax : 04 92 38 77 65 - International : +33 4 92 38 77 65.
(31) v( %'o (- _ 6( +*,% _ - 56o# %' (5 % ,6'©6o 6$!Y . ' L c i [aTJUSL K
(32) L ]Xxc TJQ f L c
(33) ch[@]X0cd[aTJ@L ]X@[aTJ@L lZ] c`Vel
(34) UWV f gR]VaK
(35) QS¦TJL f T]`uL_XZQ¯X
(36) ][aKldL f L chXdlZTi_XdTJlZL c£i_[@G lZL ]XdLwc RV¤g@Va]X®USV`JlZ[a`JlZQ X f L i [a]cdL lZaL l®USL TJl£QS] f QSQ f TVaU\Q\XvVaT-i_[@TJlZc f L,U @[aUSTbXdQS[a] f L,U wi_[aTU\L K0L ]X [aJnoL iDXZQ¯ f L i L_XhXZL _XZT f L,L chX f L,`Jl cdL ]XZL lvTJ]JL,K XdGJ[ f L f L cdQSKTJUWVYXZQ\[@] f L c w¦@TVYXdQS[a]c f ¥¬TJU\L l±cdTJl¬UWV VacdL f LU a[@U\TbXZQ\[@] f Li_Lwc¬coXZldTiDXdTldLwc¬i_[@G lZL ]XdLwc s]JL f L c0K,Ve]JQSI lZL c f L jRXdlxVeQSldL@ ©`ValhXZQ\l f L^chQSKTUSVeXdQS[a]c f i_[@TJUSL K
(37) L ]XZc f Lwc[@]iDXZQ\[@]c f LVacdL¦TJQ `uL TaL ] X _XZldLvQS]XdL ld`Jl _X Lwc£i [aK
(38) K
(39) L f L cchXdlZTi_XdTJlZL cHi_[@G lZL ]XZL c bL chXHU TbXdQSU\QWcZVYXdQS[a] f L UWV
(40) ~ wi_[aK
(41) `u[e¹ cdQ\XdQS[a] ¨pldXdGJ[@a[@]VeUSLVeTb"j !¬VaU\L TJlZc kmlZ[a`JlZL c ~¢Iwc¢US[alxc ua$l #ai %L USV-`Jld[anoL i_XdQS[a] f L,³ VeUSL lZ¡RQ\]uQSU LwcoX `u[@cZcdQ\JUSL f Lf f _XZL lZK0QS]JL l¢USfLchgbchXdI K0L f ¥®~ ¨µ¦TJQ<Vef `J`ld[bixGJLvUSf L`JlZ[aJUSI K
(42) L f Ve]c(U L cd`Vai %L f QSK
(43) L ]b¹ cdQS[a]ª´]JQSL L c [a]iDXdQS[a]c L,VacdLXdlZ[aTJ L c ¨p] QWcZi_TbXZL lxV L c `JlZ[aJUSI K
(44) LwcpUS&Q 'c USV^chXZVaJQ\USQ\X ,L_X f TJ]JL XdL USUSL Ve`J`JlZ[¤jbQ\K,VeXdQS[a] k<VelVeQSU\USL TJlxc ]J[aTcV¤a[@]cpXdlZ[aTJ
(45) ¦T TJ]JL-K XdGJ[ f L ^UWV`Jl i_QWcdQ\[@] f Q\lZL i_XdL f L-³ VeUSL lZ¡RQ\]2] L chX`V@cvcoXxVeJUSLa-r¢[aTcvV¤@[a]c f [@]i
(46) TbXZQ\USQSc ¦TJL UW¦TJL c`Jld[@`JlZQ X c f LwcvK _¹ XZGJ[ f L c f QScZi_[@]@XZQ\]RTJLwc f L³ VeUSL lZ¡RQ\]^VY´] f [aJXdL ]Q\lUWV
(47) coXxVeJQSUSQ¯X a¦TJL ]J[@Tc(V¤a[@]c£`Jld[@TJ( L f Ve]c(T] i Vac<USQ\)] VeQSlZLcdi VeUWVeQSldL@«~¢L¢`JU\Tc ]J[aTc<Q\]XdlZ[ f TJQWch[@]cmTJ]
(48) ]J[@TJaL UVeUSa[@ldQ\XdGK0L(¦TJQJ`uL lZK
(49) L_*X UWV [aQWc f L f VeTaK
(50) L ]XdL l(USV`Jl i QScdQ\[@]mr[@TcH`Jl cdL ]Xd[@]cH¦@TL UW¦@TL c(cdQ\KTJUSVeXdQS[a]c l f TJQ\lZL U\Li ([ +bX f Lvi VaUSi TJUL_X ¹¸~ cdTJl f Lwc£XdTJuL ,c
(51) ixGJ[bipL X f L cH[@] f Lwc f LvlZVal EVai_XdQS[a] - À w ¾ ( . k±¨ ~ ¦TVeXdQS[a]c /f ¥mTU\L l bK _XZGJ[ f L f L³ VaU\L ld¡RQS]bK
(52) [ f I U f [al f lZL¢EVaQ\U\L@.
(53)
(54) ! " !# %$"&(')&*+'-,.)/0 " / 21435768 !9;:<=>.(?@
(55) =>.*. {. ,6^%DC® _ ObQ\KTJUSVeXdQS[a]©cZixGJL K0Lwc¢VacdL f [@]·XdGJL0¥mTJUSL l L ¦TVeXdQS[a]c VelZLTcdL f Vac V a[R[ f i [aK
(56) `JlZ[aK
(57) QScdLuL_Xo£L L ] K
(58) [ f L UJch[@`JGJQWcoXZQSi VYXdQS[a]0Ve] f i_[@K0`TbXZVeXdQS[a]VaURVeXhXxVeQS]VeJQSUSQ¯Xog(GL ] f L VaU\QS]J (Q¯XZG0i [aK
(59) `JUSL_jaL [aK
(60) L_XZldQSL c Va] f i [aK
(61) `JlZL cZchQSJUSL [Yc F E¬L_XwRXdGJLvi_[@K
(62) `JTbXZVeXdQS[a]VaUi_[@chXH[e ¥¬TJU\L l(chQSKTJUWVYXZQ\[@]c£QScHchXdQSU\U>XZ[R[f GJQSaGQS] i [a]XdL jRXZccdTixGVac[a`bXZQ\K
(63) +Q G VYXZQ\[@]·[al¢i [a]XdlZ[aU J(GJL ldLUSVald@L ]RTJKL l¢[ami [aK
(64) `JTbXxVYXZQ\[@]cH[al IQ HuL ldL ]@X i [a]b´aTJlxVYXZQ\[@]cValdL£]JL L f L f FHGQScmQWc<`ValhXZQSi TJUSValdUSg XdlZTJLHQ\[a]LHVaQ\K,cmVeXmi [a]XdlZ[aUSUSQ\]J TJ]chXdLwV f g [Yc qº]XdGQSc(`Ve`uL lHXdGLv[bi_TcHQWc([a] f L QWcdQ\]J,Va].L J i_QSL ]X£V¤g
(65) XZ[,ldL `JlZ[ f Ti_LpXdGJLvK,VaQ\]L VeXdTJlZL cH[a T]coXZL V f g-¥mTJUSL l [Yc bJTJXHQS]chXdLwV f [e<TchQS]J
(66) USL cZc£cd[a`GJQSchXdQWi VeXdL f `JGRgbcdQSi VeU>K
(67) [ f L UWcH[al(aL ldg i [@ValZcdL Va`J`JlZ[¤jbQ\K,VYXZQ\[@]c±L^lZL cd[aldXXd[§V K
(68) L_XZGJ[ f £XdGJL^`JlZ[a`uL l
(69) [aldXdG[aa[@]VeU f Lwi_[aK
(70) `u[@cdQ¯XZQ\[@] °Bk±¨ ~ ²D¬Rg (GQSixGQ¯X(QWc±`u[@cZcdQ\JUSLXZ[
(71) L_jRXdlxVai_X®lZ[aK5Ve]L_jbQWcoXZQ\]J f VeXZVY¹¸V@chL[ai_[@K
(72) `JTbXZVeXdQS[a]cHV0i_L lhXxVeQS] ]RTJKuL l [aVacdQWc¬TJ]iDXdQS[a]c mFHGJL ch[@U\TJXdQS[a] QWc¬XZGJL ]i_[@]coXZldTiDXdL f Vac£VvXZQ\K
(73) L ¹ f L `L ] f L ]@XHUSQ\]JLwVelHi_[@KJQS]VYXZQ\[@] [a<cdTixG^TJ]iDXdQS[a]c HFHGJQWclZL `JlZL cdL ]XZVeXdQS[a]^chG[aTJU f `Jld[YRQ f LV,cd&T J i_QSL ]X f Lwcdi ldQS`bXdQS[a]^[aXZGJL f[Y Vac US[a]
(74) V@cHaUS[aVaUuL VYXZTJlZL c JchTixG^Vac(chXZVaJQSU\Q\Xog [al(@ld[YHXZG-[a<cdK,VeUSU`L lhXZTJldVYXdQS[a]c JValdL Q\]R@[aUSaL FHGJL(k±¨ ~ HVacQS]@XZld[ f Ti_L f Q\] TJQ f K0LwixGVe]QSi c«Rg TK0USL Dg K\4 LJQS]XdGJLHcoXZT f g[aJXdTldJTU\L ]@X [Yc °[al V-lZL RQSL ycdL ML K N| L²_qº]XZGVYXvchL XhXZQ\]JXdGLV@chQWcpTJ]i_XdQS[a]c [aJXZf VeQS]JL f Rgk±¨ ~VelZLlZL i [af a]IQ G L f XZ[-uL0i [aGJL ldL ]XpcoXZldTiDXdTldLwc uQB La cd`VYXZQSVaU«LwVYXdTldLwc(GJQWixGlZL `uL VYXZL USg·Ve`J`uL Val¢QS]ªcd`Vai LVe] XdQSK
(75) La qºf ]XdGL £[alZ¡bc±i Q¯XZL f XdGJLvVacdQSi VacZchTK0`JXdQS[a]-QWc£XdGf VYXHXdGJLvi [aGJL ldL ]@X(chXdlZTiDXZTJldLwcHi Ve`JXdTJlZLpK
(76) [coX([e XdGJL g]VeK
(77) QSi c[a XZGJLcdgbcoXZL K^Q LaHXdGL g^aQSaLV,@[R[ lZL `ldLwchL ]@XxVYXZQ\[@][a XZGJLlZL VaU\+Q G VeXdQS[a]c[e<XdGJL [Y QS]^XdGL`JGV@chLcd`Vai La±qº]^XdGJLVaix¡RalZ[aTJ] f [a<cdTixGVacZcdTJK
(78) `bXdQS[a]^QWcHXdGJL f QScZi_[Y@L lZg,XdGVYXXZTJldTJU\L ]i_L K
(79) QSaGX±uLpXdGJLpK
(80) Va]JQ\L chXZVYXZQ\[@] QS] XdGL¢`JGRgbchQWi VaUucd`V@i_L[a«VchXdlxVe]J@L¢VYXdXdlxVaiDXZ[al±[eUSQ\K
(81) Q\XdL ff QSK0L ]cdQ\[@] QS]^`JGV@chLvcd`Vai La ld[@K XZGJQWcpRQSL H¹¸`[@Q\]XpXdGJL0chQ\XdTVeXdQS[a]·[@lpT]coXZL V f g·¥mTJUSL l L ¦TVYXZQ\[@]cpQSc i_[@K0`U\L XdL USg f IQ HuL ldL ]@X cdQS]i_L±L0GV¤aL]J[V`JlZQ\[@ldQ lZL cdTJU¯Xpf [al XdGL`JGVacdLcd`Vai L0Va] f XdGL
(82) ¦TJLwcoXZQ\[@f ]c VYXhf XxVeQS]JQS]J XZGJL
(83) `[cdcdQ¯¹ Q\USQ¯Xog [e(cdQ\KTJUSVeXdQS]J^XdGL-TJ]chXdLwV g ¥mTJUSL lL ¦TVYXZQ\[@]cvRg©K
(84) LwVe]cv[aV^ldL Ti_L ]RTJKuL l[a(VacdQSc V·T]cdTJiDXZQ\cd[@L ]·¦TJ(L GJ]QSX ixG·QS]RlZaL_LwXxcoVeXZQSQ\]^VYXdXdGJQS[aL]« VacdrQSi [a]f L_gXd]GVeL K
(85) USL cZQSic <`Jk±ld[@¨ `~5L lhXZVaQ\]LwcVeUS°gbUSch[YQW cvch[aGl [af TJL lU f K
(86) `J[ ldf[YL @UWL
(87) ²HL (H>QSL USUiDXZuQ\@LvL XdGVeLUWch[[abno[@LwlviDX¢XdGJ[aL ¥¬TJU\L lpLw¦TVYXZQ\[@]c FHGQ\]J¡>u[alpL_jJVeK
(88) `JUSLau[e®Va]·[@cZi_QSU\UWVYXZQ\]-VeQSlh[@Q\UQ\]ªVe]·QS]RQWcdi Q f· [YP O®XZGJL lZLQWc¢V i [a]f XdQS]RTJ[aTccdGJL ff fQ\] [a@[aldXdQWi_L c«lZ[aK f XdGL±XZlZVaQ\USQS]JpL f aL±Xd[vi [aK
(89) `L ]cZVYXdL±[al<XZGJ-L Q TbXhXxVpi [a] f Q¯XZQ\[@] Va] V-JQSTJ]coXZL V g@[aldXdL j·i L ]XdL ldL [a]©XdGJL
(90) VeQSld[aQSUlZL cd`[@]cdQ\JUSL[@l XdGJL0U\Q\X qº]XdGQSc cdQ¯XZTVYXZQ\[@] Q\XcdL L K,cvlZL V@ch[@]VeU\LXd[V@cdcdTJK
(91) L0XdGVeXXdGJL,L ]XdQSldL [YH¹ ´L U f QSca[YaL ld]L f Rg©XdGJL,QS]XdL lxVai_XdQS[a]c [a XZGJL cdLvcoXZldTiDXdTldLwf c b(GJQWixG·VelZLpUSQSK0Q\XdL f Q\]^]RTJf KuL lw FHGJL^K
(92) L_XZGJ[ [e< Rdcd]Ve`cdGJ[aXZTc S-`Jld[@`[chL RgORQSlZ[YQWixUG K { L([@l
(93) Q\]i [aK
(94) `JlZL cZchQSJUSLrpV¤RQ\L lh¹oOXd[@¡aLwc Lw¦TVYXZQ\[@]c£QScHV f Ve`bXZL f GL lZLpXZ[XZGJLv¥mTJUSL l(Lw¦@TVYXdQS[a]c mFHGJQWc£K0L XdGJ[ f JXdGVeXH(QSUSUuuL [aTbXZU\QS]JL f uL US[Y f [@l i [aK
(95) `JUSL_XZL ]JLwcdc uVaU\US[Yc([@l¢XZGJL
(96) i_[a]coXZldTi_XdQS[a]·[a¬XdGJLVacdQWcTJ]iDXdQS[a]c chXZValhXZQ\],ld[@K V USQ\K
(97) Q\XdL ]RTJKL l([eV Rhcd]Va`chG[eXZTc S¢[e XdGL [Y VeX(cdTJcdL ¦TJL ]X£XZQ\K
(98) Lwc FHGJL£cdi [a`uL®[aXZGJQWc«`Va`L lQWcXZ[pi [a]XdlZQ\TbXdLmXZ[XZGJL±i [a]chXdlZTiDXZQ\[@]v[eJlZ[aJTcoXVa] f .L J,i Q\L ]X cZixGJL K
(99) L c [@l0XdGJL^QS]@XZL @lZVeXdQS[a][a¢XdGL^cdgbcoXZL K [apL ¦TVeXdQS[a]c0lZL cdTJU\XdQS]J©lZ[aK$XZGJL^`JlZ[enoL i_XdQS[a][e¢XZGJL·¥mTJUSL l Lw¦TVYXZQ\[@]c [@] XdGJL2chL X-[eVacdQSc TJ]iDXZQ\[@]c[abXxVeQS]JL f Rg k±¨ ~±qº]+EVaiDXwQS]+K
(100) [@chXVe``JU\QWi VeXdQS[a]c f f XZ`GJldL LwlZchL L ]@£XZL V@c®]Jcd[[ fEVaQWcdli T°E(cdcdGJQS[aQSix]-G i [aL ]Vai U±L lZLw]JcdQ\cd]L ]XdXdQWGVeL USUSgªchXZ(VaJQ\XdQSU\G"Q\Xog
(101) XdGJ[eLQ\cd]Ti_ix[aGK
(102) cZ`JixGJlZL L cZK0cdQ\LwJc USRL-`JrplZ[aV¤VeQSL JldUS¹ogOuXd[@L ¡ai L VecTcdL L ¦T`JVYGRXZgRQ\cd[@QW]i cxVe² U RQWcdi [@cdQ¯Xog©XdL ] f cXd[ f VeK
(103) `§[aTbX
(104) ch`TJldQS[aTc[@cZi_QSUSUSVeXdQS[a]c X f W]"L jJVeK
(105) f `JUSL [ecdTixG"cdQ¯XZTVYXZQ\[@]§f QSc[aTJ] f QS]2XdGL-Ve`J`U\QWi VeXdQS[a]2[eHXdGL-i Va]J[a]JQWi VaU®cd`LwiDXdlxVeU®K0L XdGJ[ Z Y±[@]cdQ L l XdGJLU\QS]JLwVelcZi VaUSValV @L iDXZQ\[@] A. B. [\[^]_/`4`4a4b.
(106) M. *+ . !* *I. Lw¦TVYXZQ\[@]pq¸X QWcp£L USU<¡R]J[Y(]^XdGVeX Q\®XZldQSa[@]J[aK
(107) L XdlZQSivL jb`Ve]fcdQS[a]cpVelZLf TcdL f uXZGJLlZL cdTJU\XdQS]JcZixf GJL K0L [amQ\]XdL alxVYXZQ\[@]·QSc¢TJ]chXZVeU\L@- E¬L_XwuQ\ £TJlZaL lxc L ¦TVeXdQS[a]·QWc QWcZi_lZL_Xd+Q G L RgXZGJLcZVeK
(108) LK
(109) L XdGJ[ [al GQ\@GL ]J[aTJ@GRQWcdi [@cdQ¯Xog@XdGJLcZixGJL K
(110) L QWccoXxVeJUSLa FHGJQWc QSc ]J[aX<XdGJLHi V@chL®[alm¥mTJUSL l<L ¦TVeXdQS[a] c OXZGJL£i [aK
(111) `JTbXxVYXZQ\[@]VeUbcd[aUSTbXdQS[a]K,V¤gvJUS[Y§TJ`0Q\]0VL XZQ\K
(112) LwcoXZL `c Vac V-ldLwchTJU\X [e®]RTJK
(113) L lZQWi VeU<QS]chXZVeQ\USQ¯XZQ\Lwc [alvr¢V¤RQSL ld¹ºORXd[a¡@L c(Lw¦TVYXZQ\[@]c Vacp±L U\U Q¯±XdGJL tL gR]J[aU f c<]RTJKL lmQSc XZ[[ GJQSaG«@cdQ\K
(114) QSUSVal<chXZVaJQSU\Q\Xog`JlZ[aJUSL K,cmi Ve]0LH[@ldLwchL L ]T]JU\Lwcdc®ch`uL i QSVaUJi VelZL£QSc XxVe¡@L ],QS]-K
(115) [ f L USQ\]vXdGJL TJ]JlZL cd[aUSaL f cdi VeUSL c qº]-XdGJQWc®lZL cd`uL iDXw W¢TJJlZ@g !* 8K !M L>`JlZL cdL ]XdL f VK
(116) [ f L U [@lHXdGJL VYX(`JUWVYXdL XZTJlZJTJUSL ]X[@TJ] f Valdg,UWV¤gaL lHVacdL f [a]·V,³ VeUSL lZ¡RQ\]`Jld[anoL i_XdQS[a][e rpV¤RQ\L lh¹oOXd[@¡aLwc Lw¦TVYXZQ\[@]c<f [a]Xd[vk±¨ ~&f L QSaL ]bTJ]i_XdQS[a]c<lZL cdTJU\XdQS]J ld[@K L jR`uL lZQSK0L ]XZc FHGJLT]JldLwch[@U\@L f K0f [ f Lwcm£L lZL V@i i [aTJ]XdL Rg·V-K
(117) [ L U[al XZGJL0cdK,VeUSU cZi VaU\Lwc¢(GQSixGªL ]cdTJlZL c¢XdGJL0`JlZ[a`uL l VeK
(118) [aTJ]X [e QWcZchQS`VYXZQ\[@] °BVe] f chXZVaJQ\US+Q G VYXZQ\[@]²Dch[0XdGVYX(XdGLchgbchXdL K5[e<[al f QS]VelZg f IQ HuL ldL ]XdQWVeUL ¦TVeXdQS[a]c[abXxVeQS]JL f QSc¢i_[a]chQWco¹ XZL ]X®Ve] f chXZVaJUSLVYX<Xdf GJLpcdVaK0L£XZQ\K
(119) La®¨p]0XdGL([eXdGL lmGVa] f ef [@l¬US[Yt(f L g][aU f c<]RTJKuL l®Va`J`Jf USQSi VYXZQ\f [@]c cdTixGXdGVeX`JlZL cdL ]XdL QS#] K
(120) L¸Va`J`VelZL ]XZU\g
(121) XZGJL lZL QSc(][0]L L [@l(K0[ L U\QS]J0XdGLvTJ]JlZL cd[aUSaL K
(122) [ L c FHGJLcoXxVeJQSU\Q\Xog-QWcZchTJLvGVac(QSK
(123) `[@lhXxVe]X¢i_[@]chLw¦TJL ]i L c([@]XdGJL.L J i_QSL ]i g-[e<XZGJLcdixGL K
(124) La£qº] f L L f XZGJL K,VeQS]V f YVe]XZVaaL [e VUS[Y&[al f L l£K
(125) [ f L U[YaL lwRcdV¤g@RV
(126) chXZVa] f Vel f ´]JQ¯XZL_¹¸a[@U\TJK
(127) LvcZixGJL K
(128) L chGJ[@TJU f uL^Q¯Xxc
(129) chTJ``[chL f i [aK
(130) `JTbXxVYXdQS[a]VeU£L J i_QSL ]i ga E¬L_X ±Q¯X,QWc,chG[Y(]"QS]"(GVeX0[@U\US[YcXdGVeX
(131) [@]JL£V¤g XZ[K,Va¡aLXdGJL,cZixGJL K
(132) L
(133) coXxVeJUSLaQWc Xd[^i_[@K0`TbXdL
(134) TJ`R(QS] f TbjbL c VYX XdGL0QS]XdL lhEV@i_L cp[e f QWcdi ldL Xd+Q G VYXZQ\[@] i L USUSc ®cd[XZGVYX0XdGJL^[Y@L lxVeUSU±i_[coX0[epi [aK
(135) `JTbXxVYXZQ\[@]"QWc0cdQSK0QSUWVelXd[ªXdGJL^i_[coX
(136) [e¢[aXdGJL l0i [a]RaL ]XdQS[a]VaU cZixGJL K0Lwc ¢[Y±L aL l «XdGJL ldLVelZL,[eXdGL lK
(137) L XdGJ[ f cXd[©chXZVaJQSU\+Q G Lk±¨ ~³ VaU\L ld¡RQS]cdixGL K
(138) L c ·qº] f L L f cdchXZQSK0VaJ`USU\L L Q\Ve lZXdaGJTJLvK
(139) TJL ] ]f XxL c¬lZchU\TgRQSa]Ja0Lwco´X®]JXdQ\GXdL Ve¹ X±f XZIQ H>GJL L lZ³ L ]Vai U\L L cHld¡R[aQSlH] ´Ve]J`JQ¯`JXZlZL_[¤¹¸ajb[@Q\K,U\TJVeK
(140) XdQSLw[ac(]
(141) cd[eixGJ«L VK
(142) cdL i VeQWUWc(Vel®chXZV Vef aU\L@LwiDXdQS[a],Lw¦TVYXZQ\[@],QSc QS]VeUSU\g@QS]cd`JQSldL f Rg-XZGJL£[alZ¡-[a Y±[bix¡RJTJlZ]Ve] f ORGRT K L u±L f L cZi_lZQSLV K0L XdGJ[ f Rg(GJQWixG Q\X QSc `u[@cZchQSJUSLXd[^i_USTchXdL l cd[aK
(143) L f QScZi_lZL_XZIQ GwVYXZQ\[@]i_L USUWc V@ixGJQSL RQ\] GJQSaGJL l [@l f L lpV@i i TJlZV@i_g^Ve] f i_[@K¹ `TbXZVeXdQS[a]VaUL J i_QSL ]i g-VYX(XZGJLcZVeK
(144) L XdQSK0L@ 4 -6 -$#&%'_()(*
(145) % .
(146) qº]2XZGJQWccdL iDXZQ\[@]§±L,`ldLwchL ]@X0V^]J[YaL U¬RQ\L µQS]§(GJQWixG2XdGJLk±¨ ~)QWccdL L ]2Q\]§XZGJL-cdL_XdXdQS]J[e(USQ\]L Vel QS]XdL alxVeU<L ¦TVeXdQS[a]c [al XZGJL i_[@]chXdlZTiDXZQ\[@]ª[a®XdGL,VacdQSc T]iDXZQ\[@]c [al XZGJL ¥mTJUSL lL ¦TVYXZQ\[@]c ±L L jRfJXdf L ] f XdGJL f L lZQ\YVeXdQS[a],[e K { Lu(GJQSixG Va`J`JUSQ\L f Xd[f XdGJLpQ\]i [aK
(147) `JlZL cZchQSJUSLr¢V¤RQSL ld¹ºOXZ[a¡@L c<L ¦TVeXdQS[a]c qº] V Q\XdQS[a] ch[@K
(148) L0lZL cdTJU\XZc [a±XZGJ L QSU\uL ldXh¹oObixGJK
(149) Q XvXdGL [alZg[aHcdgRK0K
(150) L XdlZQSi
(151) ¡@L lZ]JL UWc ldL U\L ¤Va]X XZ[·[aTJl chXdT f g-VelZL Q\]XZld[ f Ti L f [alcdQ\K
(152) `JUSQSi Q¯Xog±Lvi [a]cdQ f L lHXdGL ¦TV@chQ[@]JL_¹ f QSK
(153) L ]cdQ\[@]VeU¥mTU\L lL ¦TVeXdQS[a]c °ow² (Q\XdG !#"$%"&')(* !%+"$%#,-/.0"&%12'3/.04$(@5 6879 :)%+"$%5,;"$%+1<*'=/.>4&(Ve] f (GJL ld?L QWc£XdGL f L ]cdQ\Xoga@ %·QWc£XdGJLcd`L L f [e XdGJL [YvA 'QSc£XZGJL Xd[aXZVeUL ]JL lZag,`uL l¢TJ]JQ\XK
(154) V@cdcHVa] f 7/CB?DEB (Q\XdG B XdGL]J>[ G G USLvi_lZ[@cZc(chLwiDXdQS[a]·ValdLwVJmFHGJL`JlZL cZcdTJldL QWc(aQSaL ]Rg .F G;DIHJ12KMLNGE4O1PH93'QLR%5,;4 (GL lZSL K·QWcHXZGJLvch`uL i Q¯´i GL VYXxcHlZVeXdQSf [ ORT`J`[chL XdGVeXlZ[aKL_jbQSchXdQS]J VeXZV·£L GV¤@L
(155) XdGJLch[@U\TbXZQ\[@]VYUX T f IQ HuL ldL ]XXdQSK
(156) L-chXdL `c VXW2QS] XZL lZK,c[e3 Y WEZ [\1<]"^VXW54dpq¸X QWcpldLw¦@TQ\lZL f Xd[-´] f V
(157) TJ]i_XdQS[aR] _12]04=`1a_>b;"c_ , "^_#dI4Qe12f3,I1Pg4&4 d hjiF[0hlk.
(158)
(159) ! " !# %$"&(')&*+'-,.)/0 " / 21435768 !9;:<=>.(?@
(160) =>.*. (GQSixGaQSaLwc£XdGJLvuL chXldL `JlZL cdL ]XZVeXdQS[a] [a9. QS]-XZGJL [aUSUS[Y(Q\]J,cdL ]cdL. Y W)Z. 1P Y W)Z "4P,. 1 "
(161) Q4. . . . (GL lZLU1a_"^_4 f L ]J[eXZL c£XdGLi Ve][a]JQWi VaUuQS]J]JL l`JlZ[ f TiDX . Va] f XdGJLvJlxVaix¡@L_Xxc. . 1P Y WEZ "c_4P, 1a_"c_4. 1P_ b _ b _ , _ , _ d _ d 4)]. Q\] f QSi VYXdL XZGJL XdQSK
(162) LV¤aL lxVe@L. °B|a² °E{@². ° M² qº]
(163) [aXdGJL lm±[@l f c YWE[aZ ]LchL L ¡bcmVpTJ]iDXZQ\[@] _ (GJQWixG0QScmK
(164) [coX¬`ValZVaU\USL URQS],Ve],V¤aL lZVaaL±cdL ]chL£Xd[ XZGJL(aQSaL ] cd[aUSTbXZQ\[@]cdL_X Y FHGJQWc`Jld[@JUSL K ´] f cQ¯Xxc-]VeXdTJlxVeUpchL XhXdQS]JQ\] XZGJLXZGJL [@ldg[evUSQ\]JLwVel QS]XdL alxVeU¢Lw¦TVYXZQ\[@]c°EcdL L ixGVe`bXZL l®qdqhqm[a K
(165) L²D9¢L lZLpcd[aK
(166) f LlZL cdTJfJU¯Xxf c¬lZL USL YVe]X¬XZ[f [aTl±chXdT f g,ValdL¢cd¡aL XZixGJL f Q\],XZGJLlxVeK
(167) Lp[echTixG VXZGJL [@ldg@ [al(`JlZ[R[eEcH[@K0Q\XhXZL £L V lZL cZc±XdGJLvlZL V L l£Xd[XK L¸ Y±[@]chQ f L lHXdGJL¦TV f lZVeXdQWi¢QS]XdL alxVeUu[alZK 1 "Q4+ 1 E4 1 )"&V^4 12V^4 V °B a² (GL lZL 1 )"^V^49 1PVc"!E4®QWc¢V cdgRK
(168) K0L XdlZQSiv{ g{,K,VYXZldQ\jVa] f e61Pf,E12g 4$4 d ORTJ``[chLvXZGVYXpXdGJL T]iDXZQ\[@]Ve"U ªXZVaf ¡aLwcH[a]^`[chQ\XdQSaLvYVaU\TJLwc([a]U\g@JQB La$ #%O& 1 "Q4' 8)(JQS]^XdGJQWc¢i VacdL +1*"
(169) Q4®QWccZVeQ f XZ[
(170) Lv`u[@cdQ¯XZQ\@L L_´]Q¯XZLab&Z ±ORT`J`[chLvVaUScd[0XdGVeX 1 "
(171) Q4+ Ga q¸ XdGJL T]iDXZQ\[@] _>Y cdVeXdQWco´L c 1 )"&V^4_ Y b&Z 1PV^4 V ,+ b _ Y b$Z 1 E4 <° @² XZGJL ]ª[a]JL0i Va]ªcdGJ[Y XdGVe-X 1a_5Y b$Z "c_>Y b$Z 4 .+5bvQWcpXdGJL
(172) cd[aUSTbXdQS[a][a¬XdGLK,VYjbQSK
(173) IQ GwVYXdQS[a]©`Jld[@JUSL K[al XZGJL [alZ/ K 1 "4®chTJJnoL iDX(XZ[0XdGJLi [a]chXdlxVeQS]X 1*"
(174) Q4+ Ga r¢[YvRXZVe¡@L 1 )"&V^4+ T G Y WEZ 1 E410 Y WEZ 12V^4 ° e² Wb (GL lZL 0 QSc£XZGJL f gV f QWi `Jld[ f TiDX¢Ve] f QS]cdL ldXHQ\XQS]Lw¦u b3 2 LvGV¤aL 1*"4 T G 1 E4 Y WEZ 1 E4 12V^4 Y WEZ 12V^4)V 5 1P Y WEZ "4 , ° 6@² Wb 4 . [\[^]_/`4`4a4b. 1a. Y WEZ "c_04 ,. . G. T. W b. 1a. Y WEZ "c_04 ,.
(175) *+ . !* *I . XZGJL lZL_[@ldL¬XdGJL±K
(176) VejbQ\KTJK [e 1 "Q4>(Q\XdG 1*"
(177) Q4 ±G cd[aUSaL cXdGJL±`JlZ[aJUSL K chXZVYXZL f VeX«XZGJL®uL @Q\]J]Q\]J [a«XZGJQSc¢chLwiDXdQS[a]«mqº]-XZGJQSc¢i VacdL L ¦uA0Lwi_[@K0Lwc G W)Z WEZ b$Z b&Z °E}@² T Wb Y 1 E410N Y 12V^4 _ Y 1PV^4 )V-,+#bJ_ Y 1 I4 2 L¢lZL i [a@]JIQ G L(Q\],Lw¦u}Va],L QSaL ]YVaU\TJL¢`Jld[@JUSL K¶[al¬XZGJLpcdgRK
(178) K0L XdlZQSia f L aL ]JL lxVYXZLaa`u[@cdQ\XdQSaL f L ´]JQ\XdL ¡@L lZ]JL U£[epL ¦umb§qº]XZGJQSc0lZL cd`LwiDXw¬L @L lZg i [a]XdQS]RTJ[aTc0cdgK
(179) K
(180) L_XZldQWi¡aL lZ]JL U®XZGVYX f [RL c]J[eX
(181) YVe]JQWcdG Q f L ]@XZQSi VeUSU\g©`[fªcdcdL f cZchLwc L QSaL ]RYVeUSTJLwc Va] f L QSaL ]JTJ]iDXZQ\[@]c W¢UScd[·chQS]i LXZGJL,¡af L ld]L U<[e£L ¦u«}QSc lZL VaUB cdgRK
(182) K0L XdlZQSiVe] L @L ]JL lZVeXdLXdGJL ]©XZGJLL Q\@L ]RYVeUSTJL c VelZUL T Q\]ª]TKuL lvVe] VeUSU<ldLwVeU FHGJLL Q\@L ]b¹ YVaU\TJLwc(VelZL `[chQ\XdQSaLvcdQ\]i L +1*"
(183) Q4¬QS]Lw¦u) 6
(184) QScH`u[@cdQ¯XZQ\@L f L_´]Q¯XZLa FHGJL©Xd[aXZVeUSQ\Xog"[eL Q\@L ]RYVeUSTJL c-Ve] f L Q\@L ]bTJ]iDXdQS[a]c [evLw¦£}VelZL^[aT] f cdL ¦TJL ]XZQSVaU\USga ¥¬V@ixG ]L yL Q\@L ]bTJ]iDXdQS[a] QWcvch[@TJaGX V@cpXdGJL,cd[aUSTbXdQS[a]©XdGJL,K,VYjbQSK
(185) IQ GwVYXdQS[a]©`Jld[@JUSL K [e±XdGJL0TJ]iDXdQS[a]VeU cdTJbnoLwiDXvXZ[^XdGJL-i [a]chXdlxVeQS]Xv[eHL Q\]J·[@lhXZGJ[a@[a]VaU Xd[VeUSU¬`JlZL RQS[aTcdUSg·[aTJ] f L QSaL ]JTJ]iDXZQ\[@]c D W]Rg ¹ [aU f^f L @L ]JL lZVeXdL L QSaL ]RYVeUSTJL QWc(VacZch[bi_QWVYXZL f (Q¯XZG USQ\]JLwVelZU\g,QS] f L `L ] f L ]@XpL QSaL ]JTJ]iDXZQ\[@]c qº]^i_[@]i_USTcdQ\[@]@[@]i_LpXdGLpL Q\@L ]RYVeUSTJL¢`JlZ[aU\L K[e«Lw¦b}QScHcd[aUSaL f @£L ValdLpU\L X((Q¯XZGVchL X£[a+ T L Q\@L ]RYVeUSTJL c +OWVef ] f T [@lhXZGJ[a][alZK
(186) VaUeL QSaL ]bTJ]i_XdQS[a]c _ Y WEZ (GQSixG@Q\@L±Va][a`bXZQ\K,VaU@lZL `JlZL cdL f ]XxVYXdQS[a]« QS],XZGJL cdL ]chLpK
(187) V L¢`ldLwi_QWchL¢VeX®XZGJLpuL @Q\]]JQ\][eXZGJQWc±cdL i_XdQS[a]R[eXZGJL ch[@U\TbXZQ\[@],¡R]J[Y(]-VYX IQ HuL ldL ]@X XZcdQ\`K
(188) Va]JL]JchL Xdf L `Rc g,XdqºG]L cdXdLvGJ[aLldXdGJ[@U\[@US]J[Y([alZQ\K,]2VeUcdL TJi_]XdQSiD[aXZ]Q\[@c0]£c L^(Q\USU`JlZ[enoLwiDX0XdGJL¥mTU\L l,L ¦TVYXZQ\[@]c
(189) [YaL lXZGJLcd`Vai L .
(190)
(191) !. q¸XpQSc¢L Vacdg XZ[ chG[Y&XZGVYXpXdGJLL Q\@L ]bT]iDXZQ\[@]c[a Lw¦# VelZLvVeJUSLvXZ[ ldL `JlZL cdL ]XHXdGJLTJ]iDXZQ\[@]c [@]V¤@L lxVe@LaQB La #". $. $. Y WEZ. h° ('@² ¢[Y±L aL lw>XdGL0K,VaQ\]2Q f L V[a] (GJQWixG©XZGJL Ve`J`U\QWi VeXdQS[a] [e®XZGJL,k±¨ ~5Va]VeUSgbchQWc ldL U\QSL c QWc XdGVeXvV @Q\@L ]]RTJKL l [e¬V@chQWcpTJ]iDXZQ\[@]cp[aTJ] f Rg·K
(192) L Ve]c¢[a¬XdGJL
(193) k±¨ ~i Ve`bXZTJldLK
(194) [alZLL VeXdTJlZL c [a¬XdGJL [Y i_[@K
(195) `VelZL f Xd[,Ve]Rg f [aXdGJL lchL X[e[@lhXZGJ[a][alZK
(196) VaUuTJ]iDXZQ\[@]c F[ chL L XdGJQWc i_[a]chQ L l£XZGJLvL ]JL ld@g¹ USQ\¡@L ¦TVa]XdQ\Xog Y WEZ. . ) . L. G T. $. b. 1a. W b. Z Z&% ^" _ Y 4_ Y. Y WEZ. . Y WEZ 1 E4. ,. )] . . . Y WEZ 1 E4 . ¨p]XdGLvVacdQScH[a«XZGJL [aUSU\[Y(QS]J
(197) lZL cdTJU¯X(¡R]J[Y(]^Vac*^L lZi L l c±XZGJL [@ldL Kb[@]JL GVac T. G. . W b. . Y WEZ. 1 E4. Y WEZ. 12V^4+. $ + b. $ $. $. Z Z _ Y 1 E4_ Y 21 V^4. °haw² °hw|a² hjiF[0hlk.
(198) .
(199) ! " !# %$"&(')&*+'-,.)/0 " / 21435768 !9;:<=>.(?@
(200) =>.*. Va] ff GL ]i L ) Va]. $. . b +. $. mq¸ Va]J[eXZGJL lH[@lhXZGJ[a]J[@ldK,VaUV@chQWc£QSc±XZVa¡aL ]b±L GV¤@LS $. $. $. b. Y WEZ . . $W $. . $ 1 W 4 , $ 1 W 4 , °h {@² T b W b b $ $ ) W Z ¨p]2XZGJL [aXdGJL lGVa] f <Q¯X0£V@ccdGJ[Y(] WEZ XdGVeX 1P Y "^$ _>Y Z 4P,
(201) + ZY±$W USL ValdUSg[@lVe$ ]Rgª[eXdGL l (Q\Xd$ G 1*"$W 4 G·[@]JL^$ GVac $ 1P Y "
(202) Q 4a, + FHGJL lZL_[@ldL 1 4P, + Ve] f GJL ]i_L 1 P 4 , . + b b ³ QSaL ] TµXdGJLpVacdQSc® TJ]i_XdQS[a]c£lZL cdTJU\XdQS]JvlZ[aKµXdGJL k±¨ ~ GV¤@L(XdGJL V f YVa]@XxVe@L(XdGVeX®XZGJL g,@Q\@L ). . G. V-L XhXZL l f L cZi_lZQS`bXdQS[a]·[a ) i_[@K0`VelZL f Xd[Ve]Rg^[eXZGJL l chL X [a¬[aldXdGJ[@]J[alZK,VeUTJ]iDXdQS[a]c vFHGJQWc¢QWcpXdGJL K,VaQ\] ldLwVacd[a]·[@lv(GJQWixGª£L0XdlZg·Xd[·Ve``JU\gªk±¨ ~Xd[XZGJL i_[@]coXZldTiDXdQS[a]ª[eHVUS[Yy[@l f L l K0[ f L U<[al ¥¬TJU\L l(L ¦TVeXdQS[a]c .
(203)
(204)
(205) . -,. ..
(206) . ObQ\lZ[YRQSixG K N{ Lb`JlZ[a`u[@cdL f V¢£V¤gpXd[ ch[@U\@LmXdGL±L Q\@L ]RYVeUSTJL®`JlZ[aU\L K [aL ¦u¤}V@chL f [a]XdGJL±EVai_X YL Q f L ]@X QS]^XdGLcZVeK
(207) LL ¦TVeXdQS[a]XdGVeX¢XZGJLL Q\@L ]bTJ]iDXdQS[a]c¢i Va]·LL_jb`JlZL cZchL f QS]·XZL lZK
(208) c¢[e<XdGL[alZQSaQS]VeU«cdL_X [a f VeXZVbQB La WEZ _1 E4 °h M² Wb W Y 1 E4 (GL lZL W QSc V cZi VeUWVelw(q¸¬L ¦u M QWcpQ\]XdlZ[ f Ti L f QS]L ¦u>},±L0VelZLUSL_Xp(Q\XdGXdGJL0`JlZ[aJUSL K[e¬USQ\]L Vel VaU\@L JlxV[e«´] f QS]J
(209) XdGJLvL Q\@L ]RYVeUSTJL cHVa] f XZGJLvL QSaL ]RaL i_Xd[@lZc±[e ,+ °hw a² (GL lZL 1 b " $ Z " 4 Z QSc[a]JL-[e(XdGFL T L QSaL ]@L i_Xd[alxc +"QScXdGJLi_[@ldlZL cd`[@] f L ]@XL Q\@L ]RYVeUSTJLa Va] f G;D T 1P Y "^ Y"! 4m[a$l #c"&% [GE" "^Tµ" 2 GJL ]^XdGJLcd[aUSTbXZQ\[@] QWccdVaK
(210) `JU\L f [a]·V0USVald@L ]RTJKL lH[e cd]Va`chG[eXZc£Q\X(QScH@L lZg0USQS¡aL USg,XZGVYXV0i_L ldXZVaQ\]]RTJKuL l([a«L QSaL ]YVaU\TJLwc£(Q\USUL @L lZg i_US[@cdL XZ [ G L lZ[cd[XdGVYX£XdGJL f i_[@]@f XZldQSJTbXZQ\[@] [eXZGJL i_[alZlZL cd`[@] f QS]JL QSaL ]bTJf ]i_XdQS[a],XZ[XZGJL f L cZi_lZQ\`JXdQS[a] [aXdGJL [YK,V¤gL i_[a]chQ L lZL ]JL aUSQ\@Q\U\L@qº],XZGJQWc±i VacdL(±L¢i Ve] i [a]cdQ L l¬[@]JU\gXdGL´lxcoJX T('¬L Q\@L ]RYVeUSTJL c [@lHXdGJLv`ld[anoL iDXZQ\[@][aXZGJL¥mTJUSL l¢L ¦TVYXZQ\[@]cH[YaL l£XdGJLi [alZldLwch`u[a] f Q\]J0L QSaL ]bTJ]i_XdQS[a]c JQS]^[al f L l£Xd[ GV¤aL VUSQSK0Q\XdL f chL X([af lp¨ ~ ¥¬cHXdf [,cd[aUSaL@ QS]VeUSU\gQ\X cdGJ[aTJU uL]J[eXZL XZGVYX VeUSUXdGJL0Ve]VaU\gbcdQSc`JldLwchL ]XdL f cd[
(211) EVel i Ve]·uLlZL `uL VeXdL f VaU\U«XdGJL cZVeK
(212) LQ\d ]"Xo±[ [al0XZGJldL L f Q\K
(213) L ]chQS[a]c ¨¢ i_[aTlZcdL-£L(QSUSU(GV¤aL _12]04Fe 1Pf,I1Pg ,;4$4*)Ve] f _1<]04Fe 1Pf , 12g 4&4*+vlZL cd`LwiDXZQ\@L USga<FHGJL f L_´]JQ¯XZQ\[@]c([a[eXZGJL l([@`L lZVeXd[@lZc£(QSU\UixGVa]JaLvV@i i_[@l f Q\]J@U\g@
(214)
(215) / . ¨p]L[a¢XZGJL·K
(216) [ f L U`JlZ[aU\L K
(217) c,chXdT f Q\L f XZGJlZ[aTJ@GJ[aTbX
(218) XZGJQSc ±[@ld¡§QWc0XdGJL V¤YVeU(]J[G.G USL(Q¯XZG i ld[cdc cdL i_XdQS[a]-ValdLwVv[eL ¦TVYXZQ\[@] B 10!b 1<] ]32;4A0 , D*12]S/]42I4 QS] XZGJL Q\]XdL ldYVaU ]e65 A" G 7 <qº]VeUSU[aXdGJL [\[^]_/`4`4a4b.
(219) 6. *+ . !* *I. i VacdL cmchXdT f f Q\L f Q¯X±£V@c<XZVa¡aL ] ]32 8f G@ 0!b H Ve] f 0 , FHGJL TJQ f Q\]
(220) XZGJL]J[G.G USL(QWc¬QS]JQ¯XZf QSVaU\USg VeX¬ldLwcoX®Va] VYX®@Q\@L ]0`JlZL cZchTJlZLVe] XZL K
(221) `uL lxVYXdTldL@FW£X¬XZQ\K
(222) LV98©XdGJL(`JlZL cZcdTJldLVeXmXdGJL¢[@TJ] Valdg ] G QSc f L i_lZL V@chL f Xd[ VlxVaiDXZQ\[@][a«XZGJL Q\]JQ\XdQWVeU«¤VaU\TLa W]^L_jb`Va]cdQ\[@] EVe]`JlZ[a`Va@VeXdL c±V@ix¡HVel f QS]cdQ f LvXdGJL]J>[ G G USLTJ]XdQSU«Q\XplZL V@ixGJL c(XdGJL[@TJ] f Valdg ] (GJL lZLvXd[aXZVaU«`JlZL cZchTldLVa] f L ]XdlZ[a`RgVelZL QSK
(223) `[chL f W£X XdGQScp[@TJ] f ValdgXdGLEVa]QScplZL LwiDXdL f Ve] f `JlZ[a`Va@VYXZL cH[@ldHVel f TJ]XdQSU<Q¯X QScpldL L i_XdL f Vaix¡R£Val f Rg0XdGJL lZQ\@G@X±[@TJ] f Valdg@<FHGQSc±`JlZ[Ri L cZc¬L ] f c£(GJL ]VchXdL V f g [Y QWc®LwcoXxVeJUSQScdGJL f Q\]-XdGJL ]>[ G.G U\L@ FHGJLi [aK
(224) `JTbXZL li [ f LvTchL f Xd[,chQSKTUSVeXdLcdTixGV [Y&QWcHVacdL f [a]XdGL XdQSK0L ¹ f L `uL ] f L ]X J´]JQ¯XZL_¹ @[aUSTJK
(225) La TbjR¹ f IQ H>L lZL ]i Lch`JUSQ\XhXdQS]Jv[@ldKTJUWVYXdQSf [a]0[e K 6L¸+ ¢Q\@GJL l¬[@l f L l¬cd`VYXZQSf VaUVai i_TJlxVai gvQSc¬V@ixGJQSL aL f RgK
(226) LwVe]c
(227) [a ¥¬r ¨ lZL i [a]chXdlZTiDXZQ\[@U] K } LpVa] XdQSK0LV@i i TJlZV@i_g§QWc
(228) [abXxVeQS]JL Rg§XdGLFV¤gRUS[al,chL ldQSL c K
(229) L XdGJ[ f Ff HGJL ch[@U\TJXdQS[a] [aTf ] f (Q¯XZG XdGLªcZixGJL K
(230) L f Lwcdi ldQSuL f Veu[YaL·QWc-cZV¤aL f f L aL ldg ^XZQ\K
(231) L $ coXZL `f c Va] XdGJL ]RTJKL lv[e QWcdi ldL Xd+Q G VYXZQ\[@] i L USUSc QW c §¨p]i_L QScvi [aK
(232) `JTbXZL XdGJL,L Q\@L ]RYVeUSTJL c + Ve] XZGJLL Q\@L ]RaLwiDXd[@lZc 1 b;" " 4±VelZLv[aT] f ]RTJK
(233) L lZQSi VeUSU\g@< W¢U¯XZGJ[aTaG QWc¢`u[@cdQ¯XZQ\@L f L_´]JQ¯XZLa>(GJL ] QWcHUWVelZaLaXZGJL L QSaL ]RYVeUSTJLwc£i U\[chL l®XZM [ K,V¤g,uLvch[@K0L XdQSK
(234) L ]L @VeXdQSaL f TJL Xd[
(235) lZ[aTJ] f ![ HL ldlZ[alxc ¢[Y±L aL l >chTixGªL Q\@L ]RYVeUSTJL cp (Q\USUmuL f QScdldL @Val f L f chQS]i LXZGJL g£[aTU f aQSaL
(236) V-]JL aUSQ\@Q\U\L
(237) i_[@]@XZldQSJTb¹ XZQ\[@]XZ[ XdGL f Lwcdi ldQS`bXZQ\[@][e¬XZGJL
(238) ch[@fU\TbXZQ\[@f ] ¨p]JUSgXZGJL0´lxcoX L QSaL ]JTJ]iDXZQ\[@]c >i [alZldLwch`uf [a] f Q\],Xd[XdGJL UWVelZaLwcoX L QSaL ]R¤VaU\TL c (Q\USU¬uL,i_[a]chQ L lZL QS]VeUSUSgaTcdQS]J^L ¦u¬ M±L,ValdL,VeU\L0Xd[ L XdL ldK
(239) QS]JL
(240) WEXdZ GJL L Q\@L ]bT]iDXZQ\[@]Qc _·(GJQWixG·VelZL f L_´]JL f [a]XdGJLcZVeK
(241) L f QWcdi ldL Xd+Q G VYXZQ\[@]i L USUScH[aXZGJLcd]Ve`cdGJ[aXZc Y f f f (Q\XdG [a´l lZchXdX®G[@L
(242) l i f VaL cdl±L0V@cdi GJi_[YT(lZV@]ªi_gaQ\]ª FH´GJL¢m]R
(243) TJVeK] L ´l®[a| XdQSK0XZGJL L,coi_XZ[@L `K0c±`QWTbQc XZG!Ve)XdQSE[av]©VaQW] c f `uL ld [alZK0CL HIJm[@FH l GJ L Y
(244) ) )QS-=c Ve]
(245) Log of the ith eigenvalue. 1 0 -1 -2 -3 -4 -5 -6 -7. QSaTJlZL,> O£k±¨ ~ Va]VeUSgbchQWc([aXZGJL f VeXZV
(246) lZL UWVYXZQ\@LpXZ[-Ve]·L jb`Ve]cdQS[a]EVe] [@@ValdQ\XdGJK)[e<XdGJL´lZchXSHE L Q\@L ]RYVeUSTJL c ¨p]U\g0XdGSL HIGJQ\@GJL chX±L Q\@L ]RYVeUSTJL c±VelZLpcdGJ[Y(] *^[@chX±[aXdGJLpQ\]J[alZK
(247) VeXdQS[a]-Va[@TbX®XZGJL [Y QSc±Q\]-XdGJL ´lZchX¬L &L QSaL ]JTJ]iDXZQ\[@]c®Va] f lZL UWVYXZQ\@L(L QSaL ]RYVeUSTJLwc (GJQWixG
(248) XdL ] f EVachXdUSgXd[ [al±Q\]i ldLwVacdQ\] #Z<q¸X£QSc cdL L ]·XdGVYX XdGJL
(249) L QSaL ]bTJ]i_XdQS[a]c i_[@K
(250) `JTbXdL f GV¤@LK
(251) [alZLVa] f K
(252) [@ldLL_jRXdlZL K,V-V@cXZGJL
(253) i_[alZlZL cd`[@] f QS]J L Q\@L ]RYVeUSTJL f Lwi_lZL VacdL c «FHGJL®L QSaL ]JTJ]iDXZQ\[@]c«[aTJ] f ValdL±chTixG XZGVYXXdGJL£ch`Vai_L±ch`Va]J]JL f QSc«ldLwVacd[a]VaJU\g 0. 5. 10. 15. 20. i. hjiF[0hlk.
(254)
(255) ! " !# %$"&(')&*+'-,.)/0 " / 21435768 !9;:<=>.(?@
(256) =>.*. }. i U\[chL XZ[XZGVYX¢cd`Va]J]JL f f RgVa][@l f QS]Valdg [aTJlZQ\L l(chL ldQSL c mFHGJLvldLwchf TU¯Xxc£[aTJ] f QS]XdGJQWci V@chLvValdL aL ldg cdQSK0QSUWVelHXd[0XZGJ[@cdL [aTJ] [@lVEVa]^`Jld[@`VeVYXZQ\]JQ\]XZ[ V0chXdlxVeQSaGX Ti_X '_(
(257) - C¬<_ ¨p]i_LVe],[@`bXdQSK,VeUJVacdQScm[a>TJ]iDXZQ\[@]c¬QWcm[@TJ] f Q\X®QSc®U\L X¬Xd[VaiDXZTVeUSUSgi_[@]chXdlZTiDX®Va] Ve`J`JlZ[¤jbQ\K,VeXdQS[a] XZ[§L ¦Rc a 2 L©V@cdcdTJZ K
(258) L^XdGVeX,XdGJLªch[@U\TbXZQ\[@ ] \1<]"^V^4uL US[a]Jc0Xd[§XZGJL^´]JQ\XdL f Q\K
(259) L ]chQS[a]VaU¢cd`Vai L cd`Va]J]JL f Rg,XdGL _5Y"! bQ L@ Z \12]"&V^49 °h! @² b ! 12V^4_ Y ! 12]04 ! q¸XvcdGJ[aTJU f uL
(260) ]J[eXZL f XdGVeX ! QWc VcZi VaUSVal i [RL J i_QSL ]Xvch[@U\L U\gTJ]i_XdQS[a] [e¬XZQ\K
(261) L@FHGJL
(262) L @[aUSTbXdQS[a][a XZGJLcd[aUSTbXZQ\[@]·ld[@K V aQSaL ]·Q\]Q¯XZQSVaU<i [a] f Q¯XZQ\[@]·QSc f L XdL lZK
(263) Q\]L f L ]@XZQ\lZL USggXZZ GJL,¨ ~ ¥¬c cZVYXdQWch´L f Rg LwVaixG ! mqº][@l f L l£Xd[0´] f cdTixG¨ ~p¥¬c±Lv`JlZ[enoLwiDXHL ¦Rc [a]Xd[0L @L lZg _>Y ! 1P N=43_ Y"! Z E]CC °h¤e² $ $ ObTJchXdQ\XdTbXZQ\]J
(264) Lw¦>: QS]-XZGJLp`ldL QS[aTc®Lw¦@TVYXdQS[a]Ve] f i_[@]chQ f L ldQS]JXZGVYX 1P_>Y Z "c_>Y ! Z 4+ ! R±L GV¤@L °h 6@² ! +_ Y ! Z )]U _ Y ! Z )] $ L_X Tc f QScZi_lZL_XZIQ G LmXdGQSc L ¦TVeXdQS[a] ~¢L ]J[eXZQ\]¢R. g XdGJL£aL ]JL lZQSi®i_[aK
(265) `JTJXZVYXZQ\[@]VeURi_L U\URVe] f Q\]XZL alxVYXZQ\] Rg `VeldXZcH£L GV¤aL $ $ $ $ !
(266) $ 1a_ Y"!Z 4 L1P_ Y ! Z 4 L $ _ Y ! Z )] $ U_ Y ! Z )] C°h }@² b b b $ FHGL¢US[Ri VYXZQ\[@]/c #* ,b Va] f # L ,b QS] f QWi VeXdL¢XdGJLpL f @L c¬[a <FHGL¢L QSaL ]bTJ]i_XdQS[a]=c _>Y ! Z ValdL(QS] aL $ ]JZ L lxVeU f QScZi_[@]@XZ$ Q\]RZ TJ[@Tc£VYX£cdTixG[@TJ] f ValdQSL c aXZGJL lZL_[@ldLpQ¯X(QWc£]JL i L cZcdValdgXd[ f QWcdi ldQSK
(267) Q\]VeXdLpL Xo±L L ] 1a_ Y ! 4 Va] f 1P_ Y ! 4 £¬¥¬¦TVYXZQ\[@]2 }QScVa]·¨ ~ ¥ Ve] f a[Y@L lZ]c±XdGJLvL a[@U\TbXZQ\[@]-[aXZGJLi_[RL J i Q\L ]@X ! f f f u[aTFH] fGJVeL©lZg [@L TJf ] @L cVald[egbXZi_GJ[aL ] f QSQ¯cZXZi_Q\[@lZL_]XZc IQ GwVaVYldXZL^Q\[@]QSK0i_`uL US[@UWcdc L q¸L ]Jjb[a`JXU\QWL_i_jbQ\Xd`JUSUSgQWi_Q\XxXdVeUSgv¡RQSQ\]JK
(268) 2`uXd[@GJcdLªL f Ve¤`JXZ`JGJlZLH[a`[@ldTJQWVY] XZf L ValdgvTbjbi_L [@c ] f VeQ\X XdQS[aXdGJ]Lc £[aTU f uLldLwch`uL i_XdL f Q\]Va]V¤aL lxVe@L cdL ]chLvuL i VeTcdL[e XdGLHV¤g,XdGJLVacdQWcHTJ]i_XdQS[a]cpVelZL f L lZQ\@L f ¢[Y±L aL l JQ\®[@]JLVeQSK,cpVeXpTcdQS]J-cdTixG©cdQ\KTJUSVeXdQS[a]c¢Q\]ªi_[a]enoTJ]iDXZQ\[@](Q\XdGu[aTJ] f VelZgi [a]XdlZ[aU uQ¯X QSc ]L i_LwcdcZVelZg
(269) Xd[
(270) QSK
(271) `[chL XdGLv[@TJ] f Valdg-i [a] f Q¯XZQ\[@]cHL_jb`JUSQSi Q¯XZU\g@ F Ve¡RQS]J $ $ $ $ ! $ 1P_ Y ! Z 4 LN1a_ Y ! Z 4 L $ 6_ Y ! Z )]U $ U_ Y ! Z )] ° | '@² #" b b! b [\[^]_/`4`4a4b.
(272) '. *+ . !* *I. 1.2. 2.5 c b a. 2. 1 1.5 0.8 1 0.6. 0.5 0. 0.4 -0.5. #+ G. # . # G. 0.2. 0. 0. 50. 100. 150. 200. 250. 300. 350. #. -1.
(273). 400. -1.5. 0. 2. 2.5. 1.5. 2. 1. 1.5. 0.5. 1. 0. 0.5. -0.5. 0. -1. -0.5. -1.5. -1. -2 -2.5. 0. 50. 100. 150. 200. 250. 300. 350. 400. #9. -2. 0. 2. 1.5. 1.5. 1. 1. 0.5. 0.5. 0. 0. -0.5. -0.5. -1. -1. -2. #. 100. 150. 200. 250. 300. 350. 50. 100. 150. 200. 250. 300. 50. 100. 150. 200. 250. 300. 350. 400. 350. 400. -1.5. HE. -2. QSaTJlZL(|&O«k±¨ ~&Ve]VaU\gbcdQSc[eXdGJL f VeXZVpldL USVeXdQSaL±Xd[ Ve]0L_jb`Ve]chQS[a]EVe] ¥mQ\@L ]bT]iDXZQ\[@]c¬i_[@K
(274) `[@]JL ]XZc [@lHXdGJL # XZGL Q\@L ]RYVeUSTJL>OmV@² _ b J² _ , i ²J_ d 0. 400. -1.5. G H. 2. -1.5. 50. 0. 50. 100. 150. 200. 250. 300. hjiF[0hlk. 350. 400.
(275)
(276) ! " !# %$"&(')&*+'-,.)/0 " / 21435768 !9;:<=>.(?@
(277) =>.*. Q\XQWcH`[cdcdQ\U\L Xd[,(lZQ\XdL L ¦uw}V@c. @. ° |bw² ¨¢ i_[aTlZcdL-£L£[aTU f U\QS¡aLXd[2GV¤@LV coXxVeJUSLQS]XdL alxVYXdQS[a]cdixGJL K
(278) L-$ [@lXZGJQWcLw¦$ TVYXZQ\[@]OXxVeJQSU\Q\Xog f L `uL ] f c0[@]GJ[Y£LixGJ[R[@cdL,XZGJL TbjbL c0VYX0XdGJL^i_L U\U£Q\]XZL ldEVai_Lwc Ve] f qº] f L L f mXdGQSc chXZVaJQSU\Q\Xog QWcdcdTJL QSc¢chQSK
(279) Q\UWVel£Xd[
(280) XZGVYX¢ValdQWcdQ\]J0QS] f QScZi_[@]@XZQ\]RTJ[@Tc(³ VeUSL lZ¡RQ\]K
(281) L_XdG[ f c . , . !. . . !. C. f a[ [al¢Lw¦XduGJ|bL0 cdVaQ\]^¡aL([aGJmQWixVGchXdQSGJK
(282) L `JUSLTJjVe]VeVe] USgRf cdXZQWc GJLU\L i_Xp[@]Tchc L ldi_Y[@Ve]XdchQSQ aL¢L l¢YVaV ldQWUSVeQ\]JL USLvVel VelZcdLpi VeUSUWQSVe]Jl¡aL Lwf ¦TRVYg XZQ\[@]·[emXdGLcZVeK
(283) Lv[alZK 00 ° |a|a² (GL lZL 0pQWc¢V,cZi VaUSVali_[@]coXxVe]X [@l¢chQSK
(284) `JUSQSi Q¯XogU\L X 6 J *^TJU\XdQS`JUSgLw¦>|b Rg ! Ve] f cdTJK[YaL l %
(285) Xd[,aL X " ! , % ! ! ° |e{@² ! b )V H qº][al f L l®Xd[0GV¤aLpVchXZVaJU\L cdixGL K
(286) LaXdGLp]J[@ldK[aXdGJL aLwiDXZ[al£(GJ[@cdL¢L U\L K0L ]XZc£VelZLXdGL i [.L J i_QSL ]XZc chG[aTJU f VaU\HV¤gbc£Lvu[aTJ] f L f lZ[aK)Va[Y@LamFHGJL lZL_[@ldL £L lZL ¦TJLwcoXHXZGJL [aUSU\[Y(QS]J
(287) QS]JL ¦TVaU\Q\Xog,Xd[ uL ! XdlZTJL " ! , % N ° |YM² b V H ! f ObTixGV,i [a] Q¯XZQ\[@]QSK
(288) `JU\QSL c(XdGVeX ! ! ° |a a² b ! L_X(TccdL L (GJL ]XdGJQWc(QWc£XdGJLi VacdLa3 2ªLvGV¤aL $ $ $ $ R )] ! ! $ 1P 4 L1P 4 L $ ° I| @² b " b b $ ! cdQS]i_L 1P 4¬K
(289) V¤g V@cH±L U\U«L f QWcZi_[a]XZQ\]RTJ[@TcHVai_lZ[@cZc±XdGJLvi L USUL f @La spchQS]J§XZGJLUSQ\]JLwVel lZL UWVYXZQ\[@] [evL ¦u±|@| ±L©i Ve] QS]@XZL @lZVeXdL^XdGLUSV@coXQ\]XdL alxVeU([a XZGJL`JlZL RQS[aTc Lw¦TVYXZQ\[@]cd[0XdGVeX $ $ $ $ $ $ G ! ! $ 1P 4 L1P 4 L 0 1P , 4 LN1a , 4 H b ° |@e² b !. [\[^]_/`4`4a4b.
(290) ¤|. *+ . !* *I. ObTJ`J`u[@cdLmXdGVeX«`uL lZQ\[ f QWi<[@TJ] f Valdg i_[@] f Q\XdQS[a]cValdLmQSK
(291) `[chL f tL VelZlxVe]J@Q\]J±XdGL®chTK0K,VeXdQS[a]VelZ[aT] f XZGJLvL f aLvVYX #5 ,b [@]JL [abXxVeQS]c b $ $ $ ! ! $ 5 7 0 L ° | 6@² " b b $. $. !. $. ( GL lZL ,b " " Va] f 5 7 $ XZGJL TbjVYX¢i_L U\UQS]XdL lhEV@i_L cHQWc£XZVa¡aL ]-XZ[,L. . $. . ". L. . $. . 0=L 0 $ 09 0 $ " # " H H XZGVYXQWc£XdGLvTJ`R(Q\] f TJjVai i_[@l f QS]JXd[
(292) XdGLchQSa][eY0 blZ[aK5Lw¦u| 6±L GV¤@Lp´]VeUSU\g b $ ! ! $ 0 5 7 , b H ! b . $. 10 . $. H0 5 7 . . L. $. . " . . r¢[YvQ\ ° |e}@². B° { '@² FHGL lZL_[alZLa>QS]XZGJL,i VacdL0[e±VU\QS]JLwVel cdi VeUWVel L ¦TVYXZQ\[@]Q\®XdGL]RTJK
(293) L lZQWi VeU TJj©VYXv$ i_L USUmQS]@XZL ldEVai L cpQSc T`(QS] f L f @XdGJL][alZK¶[auXZGJL¢@L i_Xd[alm(G[@cdL¢i_[@K0`u[a]L ]XZc¬ValdLHXZGJLpi [RLJ i_QSL ]XZc QWc¬u[aTJ] f L f lZ[aK Va[Y@La lZ[aK5Lw¦u|e{[@]JLv[aJXZVeQS]c , 1 4 , 12@4 °B{Jw² b ! b ! ! ! q¸X¢cdGJ[@TJU f uLv]J[eXZL f JG[Y±L aL lw@XdGVeX([alV
(294) i_L ]@XZL lZL f cdixGL K
(295) L XdGJL ldL QWcVYX(USL VachX(K,VelZaQS]VeUchXZVaJQ\USQ\Xoga FHGJLvchXZVaJQ\USQ\Xog,ldLwchTJU\X(Veu[YaLpcdTJ@aL chXZc®XdGL i [a]YnoLwiDXZTJldLpXdGVYX 3:
(296) *I. N @ 4&21 = ! ! )& =>.4* 3 *Z 1*I / %=! M ! * )&4 . M * . Z 4 14*+_ qº]§EVai_X i [a]cdQ f L l®VcoXxVeJUSL(´lxcoXd¹ [@l f L l¬Vai i_TJlxVYXZL(Q\]XZL alxVYXZQ\[@],cdixGJL K
(297) L([al£VvU\QS]JLwVel®cZi VaUSVal®i_[@]chL ldYVeXdQS[a]
(298) USV¤v FHGL ]J[alZK [aHcd[aW USTbXZb Q\[@]2VeXXdQSK
(299) W L-chXdL ` W G QWcvu[aTJ] f L f RgªXdGJL ][alZK [eHXZGJL-cd[aUSTbXdQS[a]§VYXvXZQ\K
(300) L chi Xd[aL ]` cdQ mf L lZQBL Laf S3 2 LvG V¤a L G@¬FH GJLv k±¨ ¤~¹o(³ GJVeL USlZL L lZ¡R Q\]^QSc¬cZixXdGJGJL L K
(301) f LvQWcdi i ValdL ]Xd+QuG LvVYXZRQ\[@Q\L ]
(302) ±K
(303) L f VeXdV@lZc(Q¯j,V[a`uldXZ[aGJnoLpL iDcZXZixQ\GJ[@L ]K0[aL XZGJQWcmcdixGJL K
(304) Z L£[@]W Xd[ V¢US[Y f W QSK
(305) L ]cdQS[a]VaURcd`V@i_La FVa¡RQ\]J QS]Xd[ Vai i [aTJ]X XdGVe X $ GHVe] f _>Y ! Z Ga Q\XpQW c _>Y ! Y(q¸mXdGJL0ch`Ve]·[e<XZGJLk±¨ ~¶L QSaL ]bTJ]i_XdQS[a]©i [YaL lZc£W XZGJLcd[aUSTbXdZ QS[a]W cd`V@i_Laf Q LaSYQ¯XdGJL(³ VeUSL lZ¡RQ\]`ld[anoL iDXZQ\[@]VeK
(306) [@TJ]XZc«Xd[ VpixGVa]JaL®[eV@chLwc Y£L®GV¤aL J _5Y"! mVe] ´]VeUSU\!g _>Y ! Z W _5Y"! Z W p(GQSixGQSc(V,chXZVaJQSU\Q\Xog u[aTJ] f [@lHXdGJLk±¨ ~¢¹o³ VeUSL lZ¡QS]^cdixGJL K
(307) La 2 LvTcdL f XdGJLwchL lZL cdTJU\XZc£[alHXZGJL¥mTJUSL l¢L ¦TVYXZQ\[@]c(VacHL jb`JUSVaQ\]L f Q\]XdGLv]JL_jRX(`VelxVe@lZVa`JG , ". ! $#
(308) !&%4 . _L X Tc i_[@]chQ f L lpLw¦<w} (GJL ldL0±LXZVa¡aLM8[$ £L i VaTcdL[e®XdGJL0£V¤g^£LG$Y"! V¤Z aLi [a]chXdlZT$Y"i_! XdZ L f XdGJL T]iDXZQ\[@]cM_«®±LGV¤aL _ ©Q\]chQ f LL VaixG ±chL L ´ {2FHGL lZL_[alZL1a_ 4 1a_ 4 \ . hjiF[0hlk.
(309)
(310) ! " !# %$"&(')&*+'-,.)/0 " / 21435768 !9;:<=>.(?@
(311) =>.* $. w{. $ Z _>Y Z 1<] 4 C_ Y. !. [@l(L @L lZg %. "! Va] f GJL ]i_L L ¦uw} . "cTµ. !
(312) $ . b. $ Z _ Y. !. . $. . L. $. °B{@|a². . ". GE". φ U=0. i-1/2. +. i. -. i+1/2. Φ U=1. i-1/2. i. i+1. i+3/2 Φ. U=3. QSaTJlZLv{ Om~¢QWcZi_lZL_XdQ+G VeXdQS[a]^i_L U\UWc£[alH´lxchX[al f L l(Ve] f GJQSaGL l([al f L lHVa`J`JlZ[¤jbQ\K,VYXZQ\[@]ª° ORL i_XdQS[a]·{J {@²_ f f XZGJL¢]ld[a[@],K)USQ\XZ]JGJLwLVel®cdQWgbcZi_coTXZL cZKµchQS[a[e]·«[@¥m]^TU\XdL GJl®LL U\¦QS]JTLwVeVeXdQSl¢[a]cZi c VaaUSQ\VaX±lQWc¬L ¦]TL Vei_LwXdQScd[acZ]·VelZ£gLXZGi_VY[@X±]Xdi_GJUST L¢]LvTXZK0GVYL ldX QWi Q\]^VaU XZ GJTJLjR`Lwldc®LwVechX¬L ]@XdX GJL i Vai_cdL LaU\U L f aLwcvVelZL, i_[aK
(313) f `JTJXdL f RgªVa]ªT`(QS] f XogR`uL,K0L XdGJ[ f f 2ªL
(314) XZL chXdfL f cd[aK
(315) L
(316) [e£XdGL,±L U\U¬¡R]J[Y(] TbjR¹ @L i_Xd[al®[al TbjR¹ IQ H>L lZL ]i Lpcd`JU\Q\XhXZQ\][alZKTUSVeXdQS[a]c¬Va] £L[@TJ] XZGVYX±XdGJL g0`ldLwchL ld@LHXdGJL coXxVeJQSU\Q\Xog [aXZGJLcZixGJL K0L@®qº]^XZGJL cdL]RTJK
(317) L lZQSi VeUL jb`L ldQSK
(318) L ]XZcHXZGJLvXZQ\K
(319) LQS]XdL @lZVeXdQS[a]^HVac f [@]JLvRgV
(320) [@ldHVel f ¥¬TJU\L lcoXZL f ` qº]·[@l L lHXd[ GV¤aLvVe]^Q f L V,[aXZGJLvXZQ\K
(321) L chXdL `VeUSU\[Y£L f (Q\XdG©cdTixG·cdixGL K
(322) Lv±Lv£L ]XV@ix¡ XZ[,XdGJL USQS]JL Val®cdi VeUWVel®i VacdLaq¸X£i Va],LpchL L ]
(323) XdGVYX®XZGJL¢k±¨ $ ~ Z L QSaL ]bTJ]i_XdQS[a]c¬[al£chTixG
(324) Lw¦@TVYXdQS[a] ValdL(][eXdGQ\]J L UScdLXZGVe] XdGJLpXdlZQ\@[a]J[@K
(325) L_XdlZQWi£TJ]iDXZQ\[@]c Q LaS@ _ Y ! G D H 1 "% # H D 4(GL lZ L L?G¢Ve] f XZGJL¢i [aK
(326) `JTbXxVYXdQS[a]VeUJ´L U f L_jRXdL ] f c¬uL_Xo£L L ] 'Ve] f H m W¢cZchTJK
(327) QS]J`uL lZQ\[ f QWi(u[aTJ] f VelZgi [a] f Q\XdQS[a]c i-1/2. [\[^]_/`4`4a4b. i. i+1. i+2. i+3. i+7/2.
(328) M. *+ . !* *I. lZ[aK)L ¦uJ{@|£L GV¤aL FHGL L Q\@L ]RYVeUSTJL cH[a. . !. 0 . . . H. . $ b . H $ Z _ Y. $ Z $ Z _ Y 6 L _ Y b. H $Y Z _. $ Z $ Z _ Y L _ Y b. !. ". . °B{a{@². B° {eM² ValdL`JUS[eXhXZL f [a]©XdGJL
(329) i_[@K0`U\L j`JUSVa]JL^° \HIOGa0T
(330) G:E²QS]´>M L_X XdGJLDY ]TKuL l L . . . !. ( L. $ b. !. " 1. 0.5. -2. -1.5. -1. -0.5. -0.5. -1. Q\@TJldL MO<¥¬Q\@L ]RYVeUSTJL cH[aXZGJLvK,VYXdlZQ\j [@]-XZGJLi_[@K
(331) `JU\L j-`JUWVe]JL@ 0 V DEH m2¨p]XdGJL^i_[@K0`U\L j `JUWVe]La<XdGLchXZVaJQ\USQ\Xog lZL @Q\[@]2[epVa]§L_jb`JUSQSi Q¯X0´lxcoX0[al f L lvXZQ\K
(332) L QS]XdL alxVYXdQS[a]·QWc V-i Q\lxi_USL[a¬lZV f Q\Tc@u(Q\XdG i_L ]@XZL l Q\]N1$L?G)"&@4Z q¸X `JlxVai_XdQWi Va$ U\USg[Y@L lZUSVa`cHXZGJ$ LlZL @$ Q\[@] u[aT] f L f Rg,XdGLvL QSaL ]RYVeUSTJLwc®[a«XdGLvK
(333) VeXdlZQ¯j uRXdGJL ldL [alZL (GL ] GpXZGJLcZixGJL K
(334) L QSc(chXZVaJU\L@mq¸ XZGJL Tb$ jbLwcmQ\]
(335) Lw¦@{@| Ve$lZL(i_[aK
(336) $ `JTJXdL f RgVvi L ]XdL ldL f Va`J`JlZ[¤jbQ\K,VYXZQ\[@]Y Q L@\* b , G;DIHJ1P b 4 Va] f b , G;DIHJ1P b 4ZJ±L @L_X $ $ $ ' ! (S L $ _ Y ! Z _ Y Z b L6_ Y Z b " °B{@ a² b FHGL±L Q\@L ]RYVeUSTJL c [e 'mValdL£cdi VYXhXZL lZL f VelZ[aTJ] f XdGJL£QSK
(337) VaaQS]VelZgvVYjbQWc ecdL L±´a JYQ\] f QSi VYXZQ\]J K,VelZaQS]VeU chXZVaJQSU\Q\Xog
(338) [al(cdTixGcd`VeXdQWVeU f QWcdi ldL Xd+Q G VYXZQ\[@]<FHGJLvcdVaK0L lZL cdTJU¯X(QWc£[abXxVeQS]JL f ld[@KL ¦u| 6<qº] f L L f bQS] hjiF[0hlk.
(339)
(340) ! " !# %$"&(')&*+'-,.)/0 " / 21435768 !9;:<=>.(?@
(341) =>.*. ¤ . 1. 0.5. -17. -17. -17. -17. -6·10 -4·10 -2·10. -17. -17. 2·10 4·10 6·10. -0.5. Q\@TJldLv &O¬¥¬Q\@L ]RYVeUSTJL cH[a«XdGLvK
(342) VeXdlZQ¯j '([@]-XZGJLi_[@K
(343) `JU\L j-`JUWVe]JL@ XZGJLi V@chL [emV
(344) i_L ]@XZL lZL f cdixGL K
(345) L ±L aL X -1. B° {E@² ¢L ]i L Q\X0cdL L K,cXdGVeXQ\±L f [©]J[aXTJ`R(Q\] f XdGJL ldL-QSc0VYXUSL V@coXK
(346) Vald@Q\]VeU®chXZVaJQ\USQ\XogaXE¬L X mQS]§XdGJL L jb`L ldQSK
(347) L ]XZc<[@]XZGJL¥mTJUSL lmLw¦@TVYXdQS[a]c<±LH£L lZL±]J[aX¬VeJUSL£Xd[v[aJXZVeQS]
(348) V chXZVaJUSLHcd[aUSTbXZQ\[@](Q\XdG
(349) t(TJ]J@L_¹ Q TJXhXZVXZQ\K
(350) LvQS]@XZL @lZVeXdQS[a]c£TJ`Xd[0[@TJlhXZG^[al f L lw W¢U¯XZGJ[aTJ@G0XdGJQWcmQWc¬V ch`uL i Q¯´iHL jJVeK
(351) `JUSLaaQ\X¬QWcmQ\K
(352) `u[aldXZVa]@X<XZ[v]J[eXZQSi L±XZGVYX¬QS]
(353) XdGLcoXxVeJUSL(i VacdLa@chQS]i_L XZGJLHU\[Y"ldLw¦TJL ]i Q\LwcmVelZL®XZGJL([a]LHi U\[chLwcoX Xd[ XZGJL(Q\K,VaaQS]VelZgVYjbQWc YTcdQS]JvVpUSQSK0Q\XdL f ]TKuL lm[e>k±¨ ~ L Q\@L ]bT]iDXZQ\[@]c¢£LValdLL
(354) VeU\LXd[-K,ValZixG(Q\XdG V GJQSaGL lpXdQSK0LwcoXZL `vFHGJQWc QSc >Q\]©EVai_X uXdGJL0lZL cdTJU¯X [acdL aL lZVaU]RTJK
(355) L ldQWi VaUuL jb`L ldQSK
(356) L ]XZc£(Q\XdGXdGJL ¥mTJUSL l(Lw¦@TVYXdQS[a]c *·ValZixGJQS]JL_jb`JUSQSi Q¯XZU\g,QS]-XZQ\K
(357) LvVe] f XxVe¡RQS]J
(358) L Q\@L ]bTJ]iDXdQS[a]c¢£L£L lZLVeJUSLXZ[ lZL VaixGVMY [e 'Jqº] f L f L f QS]©lZL UWVYXZf Q\[@](Q\XdG©´M Q\XvQSc cdL L ]XdGVYX XdGJL,chXZVeQ\USQ¯Xogi Q\lxi_USL
(359) i Ve]ªL
(360) cdGJldT]J¡·K,Ve]Rg^XdQSK
(361) L cvVe] chXdQSU\U<QS]i_UST L0XdGL´lZchXpL L Q\@L ]RYVeUSTJL c L_X
(362) Tc
(363) i_[aK
(364) `ValdL-XdGJL^cZixGJL K
(365) L-[a¢L ¦um{@|·Xd[ V´]Q¯XZL_¹¸a[aUSTJK
(366) L c° ! ²´lZchX0[@l f L lcZixGJL K0L@<[al XZGJL-lZL V@ch[@]©XZGVYX
(367) chTixGcdixGJL K
(368) L cValdL ¡R]J[Y(] XZ[©uL K
(369) [a]J[aXd[a]L-Ve] f XZ[©i_[@]RaL lZaL0XZ[XdGL L ]XdlZ[a`Rg cd[aUSTbXZQ\[@]3 2ªL a[Vaix¡0Xd[XdGJL USQ\]L VelHcZi VeUWVel±L ¦TVeXdQS[a]-Va] f ixGJLwix¡
(370) TJ] f L l±(GJQWixGi [a] f Q¯XZQ\[@]c®£L VelZL VaJUSLpXZ[
(371) ldLwi_[YaL l®XZGJL ´lxcoX[@l f L l(cdixGL K
(372) $ L $ $ LR °B{e² " . b ! !. . [\[^]_/`4`4a4b. !. .
(373) :. *+ . !* *I $. $. (GL lZL? 95\12] 4 D5Vd¬F Ve¡@LpLw¦u{@|KTJU\XdQS`JUSg-RgF_ Y ! Z Va] f cdTJK [YaL l%0lZ[aK G Xd[ TXZ[,aL_X $ $ $ 0
(374) $ L °B{ 6@² " 8 b $ $ $ (GL lZL ! b _ Y ! Z _ $Y ! Z QSc V cdgK
(375) K
Documents relatifs
Trois autres échantillons du pool CHAT étaient également gardés au Center for Disease Control et ont été inclus dans cette analyse (CHAT pool 13, CHAT type 1 Wy4B-5, CHAT 1FL)..
Un habitat de La Tène moyenne et finale à Berry-au-Bac au lieu-dit “ Le Chemin de la Pêcherie ” (Aisne).. Jérôme Dubouloz, Michel Plateaux,
constat, unanime en Colombie, que la résolution des conflits par élimination de “l’opposant” est l’une des caractéristiques de la violence nationale. Première
Automatic test data generation, structural testing, constraint solving techniques, global constraints 1.. Structural testing techniques are widely used in unit or module testing
It is obvious that the steel showed the plastic strain memory effects at each test temperature, in other words, in spite of the hardness of the steel cyclic stress,
Les cités et leur territoire d'influence sont administrées par de puissantes familles, celles de l'aristocratie terrienne et marchande, qui tirent leur légitimité de
L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non, émanant des
In this paper, we have defined the steady-state control problem for MDP, and shown that this question is decidable for (ergodic) MDP in polynomial time, and for labeled MDP
