HAL Id: hal-02708176
https://hal.inrae.fr/hal-02708176
Submitted on 1 Jun 2020
HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access
archive for the deposit and dissemination of
sci-entific research documents, whether they are
pub-lished or not. The documents may come from
teaching and research institutions in France or
abroad, or from public or private research centers.
L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est
destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents
scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non,
émanant des établissements d’enseignement et de
recherche français ou étrangers, des laboratoires
publics ou privés.
Frequency of interferon alpha secreting blood leucocytes
in irradiated and bone marrow grafted pigs.
Bernard Charley, W. Nowacki, M. Vaiman
To cite this version:
Original
article
Frequency
of
interferon-alpha-secreting
blood
leukocytes
in irradiated
and
bone-marrow-grafted pigs
B Charley
W
Nowacki
M
Vaiman
2
1 INRA,
virologie
etimmunologie
moléculaires; 2Laboratoire mixte CEA-INRA deradiobiologie
appliquée, 78350Jouy-en-Josas,
France(Received
15January
1995; accepted 28 March 1995)Summary ―
The effects of irradiation were studied onporcine interferon-alpha (IFN-a) secreting
cells (IFN-a
SC).
IFN-<x SC were characterized by an ELISPOT assay on non-adherent PBMCfol-lowing
incubation with the transmissible gastroenteritis coronavirus. In vitro irradiation of PBMC wasfollowed by a decrease in the number of !FN-a SC while IFN-y production and cell viability were not affected. These data indicate that
porcine
IFN-(x SC arerelatively
radiosensitive. Indeed, thefre-quency of blood IFN-a SC decreased
markedly
andrapidly
after in vivo wholebody
orpartial
lym-phoid
irradiation. In addition, within several days of compatible bone-marrowengraftment
in the irra-diated animals, the number of blood IFN-cr SC returned to normal values. These data demonstrate thatcirculating porcine
IFN-a SC are derived from bone-marrow progenitors.interferon-alpha
/ leukocyte / bone marrow / irradiation / transmissiblegastroenteritis
virus fporcine
Résumé ―
Fréquence
desleucocytes
sécréteurs d’interféron alpha chez le porcaprès
irra-diation etgreffe
médullaire. Nous avons étudié la radiosensibilité des cellules sécrétrices d’interfé-ron alpha(IFN-(x)
dansl’espèce
porcine. Les cellules secrétrices d’IFN-a ont été étudiées par latech-nique ELISPOT, à
partir
de cellules sanguines mononucléées non adhérentes incubées enprésence
du coronavirus de la
gastro-entérite
transmissible. L’irradiation in vitro des cellules mononucléées dusang s’est traduite par une diminution du nombre des cellules secrétrices d’IFN-rx, sans affecter la
production d’IFN-y ni
la viabilité cellulaire. Ceci montre que les cellules secrétrices d’IFN-rx du porc sont relativement radiosensibles. De fait, leur fréquence dans le sang d’animaux soumis à une irradiationcorporelle
totale ou à une irradiationlymphoide partielle
s’en trouve rapidement et très fortementdimi-nuée. De
plus, quelques jours après
transfert d’une moelle osseusecompatible
à des porcs irradiés,*
le nombre des cellules secrétrices d’IFN-a redevient normal. Ces résultats montrent donc que les cel-lules secrétrices d’IFN-a présentes dans la circulation sanguine du porc proviennent de précurseurs
médullaires.
interféron
alpha
/leucocyte
/ moelle osseuse / irradiation / virus de lagastro-entérite
trans-missible/porc
INTRODUCTION
Interferon-alpha (IFN-a)
areleukocyte-secreted
proteins
and are one of the earliest host responses to viral infections. Via their antiviralproperties, they help
limit viralspread (De
Maeyer-Guignard,
1993).
Dis-tinctleukocyte
cellpopulations
can secreteIFN-a
mainly depending
on the nature of theIFN-inducing
viral structure.Thus,
macrophages
areusually responsible
forproducing
IFN-a in response to infectiousviruses,
but a distinctpopulation
oflow-den-sity, non-phagocytic,
non-adherentmono-nuclear cells can also secrete IFN-a when
exposed
to non-infectious viral structures, such as inactivated virions orglutaralde-hyde-fixed
virus-infected cells(reviewed by
Charley
andLaude,
1992).
This cellpopu-lation is often referred to as ’natural
inter-feron-producing
cells’(NIPC).
This is rareamong blood mononuclear cells and exhibits unusual
phenotypic
features. Human NIPCdo not express surface
antigens specific
forT- or
B-cells,
but arepositive
for MHC classII
antigens
and CD4(reviewed by
Fitzgerald-Bocarsly, 1993).
NIPC may becirculating
blood dendritic cells(Ferbas
etal,
1994).
Inaddition,
human NIPC showed some simi-larities with theearly progenitors
ofmyeloid
andlymphoid
cells in flowcytometry
analy-sis,
butthey
lacked the stem cell-associ-ated CD markers(Sandberg
et al,
1991
).
In the
porcine species, IFN-a-producing
cells were
produced
in response to in vitro inductionby
the coronavirus transmissiblegastroenteritis (TGEV)
or thepseudorabies
(PR,
orAujezsky disease)
viruses and werecharacterized in blood
leukocytes by
asolid-phase enzyme-linked immunospot
assay(ELISPOT)
as well asby
in situhybridization
(Nowacki
andCharley,
1993;
Arturssonef al,
1992).
TGEV-inducedIFN-a-producing
leukocytes
were also characterized inporcine gut-associated lymphoid
tissue(Naidoo
andDerbyshire, 1992).
Porcine bloodIFN-a-secreting
cells(IFN-a SC)
wereshown to share several features with their
human
counterparts
sincethey
arelow-den-sity, non-phagocytic,
non-T, non-B,
but CD4+
and SLA-class I I+ cells
(Nowacki
andCharley,
1993;
recently
reviewedby
La Bon-nardi6reef al,
1994).
Because the
precise
nature of IFN-a SCis still
poorly
defined,
thepresent
study
wasundertaken to evaluate the
possible
bone-marrow
origin
of TGEV-inducedporcine
IFN-a SC. The
frequency
of IFN-a SC wasassessed
by
ELISPOT in bloodleukocytes
from irradiated andbone-marrow-grafted
pigs, using previously
describedprotocols
(Vaiman
et al,
1975).
We found that IFN-a SCrapidly disappeared
in thecirculating
blood of irradiated animals and thatthey
reappeared
in bone-marrow-reconstitutedpigs,
whichsupports
the idea thatthey
orig-inate in bone marrow.MATERIALS AND METHODS
Animals
Large
White breedpiglets
from several litterswere used. Some of them
belonged
to a herdwere compatible for the major
histocompatibility
complex.
Virus
The
high-passage
Purdue-115 strain of TGEV was used as a virus source. The procedures for viruspropagation
in the pigkidney
cell line PD5,virus
purification,
UV inactivation and titration ofinfectivity
;n the swine testis(ST)
cell line have beenreported previously (Laude
et al, 1986; Charley et al,1994).
PBMC and bone-marrow cells
Non-adherent
porcine peripheral
bloodmononu-clear cells
(PBMC)
were obtained fromhep-arinized blood by Ficoll
density centrifugation
on MSL0
&dquo;
(density
1.077, Eurobio, Paris) followed byadherent cell
depletion
on tissue culture flasksas described
previously (Nowacki
andCharley,
1993).
PBMC weresuspended
in RPMI-1640 medium supplemented with 10°/ foetal calf serum(RPMI-10% FCS)
and antibiotics and keptovernight
at 4°C before use. Sternal bone marrow wassurgically
collected from anaesthetizedpigs.
Bone-marrow cells were prepared bycentrifuga-tion on MSL, and adherent cell depletion was
performed as described above.
Irradiation and bone-marrow
grafts
PBMC were irradiated for
increasing lengths
oftime
resulting
inincreasing
irradiation doses, asindicated in the Results,
using
cobalt-60 sources. After 48 h in culture, the percentage of dead cells was estimatedby
trypan bluedye.
Non-anaes-thetized starved
pigs
were irradiated in asling
using
symmetrically opposed
cobalt-60 sources.Whole
body
irradiation(WBI)
was carried out with 2 opposed sources at a dose rate of 9.2 rad/min n(midline-tissue
absorbed dose)(Vaiman
et al,1975).
The partial
lymphoid
irradiation (PLI) proce-dure has been describedpreviously (Vaiman
etal,1981). Briefly,
thepigs
were irradiated by 6sources at an average midline-tissue dose of 47 rad/min. The head, the upper part of the neck and parts of the thorax were protected with lead. The shielded
region
received less than 5% of thetotal dose. Two different PLI
protocols
weretested, as shown in table I: 3 x 3
Gy
for 5 d; or 5 x2.5
Gy
for 10 d. WBI was performed with 8 or8.75
Gy (table I).
The bone-marrow cells were
injected
1 or 3 dafter irradiation, as stated in the Results, at a
dose of 2.5-5 x 108cells per gram body
weight.
The preparation of bone-marrow cells,
injections
and care of the recipients has been described
previously (Vaiman
et al,1975).
Dickinson, Rutherford, NJ,
USA)
wereperformed
in order to determine the number of
lympho-cytes/ml
blood. IFN-a SC number/ml was deduced from the number of IFN-a SC per 105lymphocytes,
determined as follows.IFN-a induction
PBMC or bone-marrow cells were induced to pro-duce IFN-a
by
incubation with TGEV in 96-wellmicroplates. Non-adherent cells were incubated at final concentrations of 1-5 x 106 cells per ml in
a total volume of 200
lul
RPMI 1640plus
10%FCS, with TGEV. The virus used was either a
crude, UV-inactivated viral preparation at 0.1 I
plaque-forming
units per cell, or apurified,
inac-tivated
preparation
at 0.6pg/ml,
as indicated in theResults. After 8 h at 37&dquo;C, the induced cells were
resuspended
and 100pl
cells from each well wastransferred to nitrocellulose-bottomed
microplates
for the ELISPOT assay(see below).
The other 100 yl induced cells were further incubatedovernight
at 37°C for IFN-a immunoassay.ELISPOT
The ELISPOT assay was
performed
as describedpreviously
(Nowacki andCharley, 1993).
Nitro-cellulose-bottomed 96-well filtration plates were
coated with
anti-porcine
IFN-a monoclonalanti-body (MAb) ’K9’, and then fixed with
glutaralde-hyde
and blocked withglycine,
before the addition of TGEV-induced cells for anovernight
incubationat 37°C.
Following
extensivewashing,
theplates
were incubated with
peroxidase-conjugated
anti-porcine
iFN-a MAb ‘F17’ for 1 h at 37&dquo;C beforethe addition of diaminobenzidine with
perhydrol.
Spots
were countedusing
amagnifier.
Thefre-quency of IFN-a SC was calculated as the mean
number of spots divided
by
the total cell number in each well. Results were expressed as meansof spots per 105 cells and as IFN-cx SC/ml blood,
taking
into account the number oflymphocytes/ml.
IFN-a
immunoassay
A
specific
ELISA forporcine
IFN-a wasperformed
as described previously (De Arce et al, 1992;Splichal
et al,1994), by using
MAb K9 forcoating,
and
peroxidase-conjugated
F17 MAb as a second Ab. In each assay, our internal standard ofrecom-binant porcine IFN-a was included. The estimated
amount of IFN-a
produced by
each IFN-a SC was calculated from the titer of IFN-a(units)
in induction culture supernatants as determinedby
ELISA, and IFN-a SC number per culture, as
determined
by
ELISPOT.IFN-y
induction and titrationPBMC were incubated in microtiter plates at 3 x 10
6
per ml with 50
pg/ml
PHA(ref
HA 16 fromWellcome, Paris) for 48 h. IFN-y in supernatants
was titrated
by
a specific ELISA,using
anti-porcine IFN-y
MAb G47 forcoating,
and a rabbit antiserum (No 652;Charley
et al,1988)
as a sec-ond Ab, as describedpreviously (D’Andréa, 1995).
RESULTS
Effects of irradiation on IFN-a SC
In a
preliminary experiment,
PBMC wereirradiated in vifro for
varying
lengths
oftime,
in order to assess the
radiosensitivity
of TGEV-inducedporcine
IFN-a SC. The results in table II show thatincreasing
doses of irradiation led to a reduction of IFN-A SCfrequency,
as determinedby
the ELISPOT assay,although
the amount of IFN-apro-duced
by
each IFN-a SC(IFN-a yield)
was not affected. The reduced IFN-a SC fre-quency may not be due to increased bulk cell death in vitro since thepercentage
of dead cells at 48 h did not vary with the irra-diation doses(table II).
Moreover,
PHA-inducedIFN-y production
was also unal-teredfollowing
irradiation. These data indicate thatporcine
blood IFN-a SC arerelatively
more radiosensitive than other mononuclear cellpopulations
such asIFN-y-producing
cells(presumably T-cells).
animals irradiated in vivo. Two animals were
subjected
topartial,
non-lethal,
irradiation PLI and the number oflymphocytes
per millilitreblood,
and the number of TGEV-induced IFN-oc SC/ml blood as assessedby
ELISPOT,
were determined for 1 month after irradiation.Figure
1 shows that totallymphoid
irradiation was followedby
adra-matic and
rapid
reduction ofcirculating
totallymphocyte
and IFN-a SCnumbers,
the lowest valuesbeing
obtained 2 d after the end of the irradiationprocedure.
Within 1month of
PLI,
thelymphocytes
and IFN-cr. SC counts had almost returned to normal values.Three animals were irradiated either
by
an 8
Gy unique
dose(WBI: fig 2)
orby
5successive doses of 2.5
Gy
(PLI: fig 3). They
were then
injected
withcompatible
bone-marrow cells.
Figure
2 shows that an 8Gy
irradiation was followed
by
arapid (within
2
d)
and almost total(3
log
reduction)
dis-appearance ofcirculating
IFN-a SC.Coin-cidentally,
thecirculating lymphocyte
reappear-ance of blood IFN-a SC was observed within several
days
(from
5-12 ddepending
upon the irradiationprotocol)
after thebone-mar-row cell
injection (figs
2 and3). Figure
2shows that IFN-a SC counts returned to
normal values within 15-25 d. In contrast, the
lymphocyte
counts returned to normal values after alonger period
of time(fig 2).
The data shown in
figure
3 areincomplete
due to the death of an animal from an acute
respiratory
infection. These data indicate that thepopulation
ofcirculating
IFN-a SCwas
dramatically
affectedby
lethalirradia-tion,
but was reconstituted within severaldays
following
a bone-marrow transfer.IFN-a SC in bone-marrow
The presence of IFN-a SC among
bone-marrow cells was determined from
bone-marrow collected
by
surgery, in order toreduce blood contamination in the
samples.
In 5independent experiments,
the IFN-a SCfrequency
in bone-marrow mononuclearcells was 11.4 ± 2 per 105 cells. In
com-parison,
the value obtained with PBMC from the same animals was 21 ± 14 per 105cells.Taking
into account the concentration of red blood cells in the bone-marrow cellprepa-rations,
the presence of PBMC in these bone-marrowpreparations
was estimatedto vary from 0.06 to 0.4% total cells. These data
indicated, therefore,
that iFN-a SCpre-sent in
porcine
bone-marrow cells do notreflect blood contamination of the
samples.
DISCUSSION
The
present
study
was undertaken toper-formed with a
specific
ELISPOTtechnique.
In vitro exposure of PBMC toincreasing
irra-diation doses(table
II)
showed that IFN-A SC wasrelatively
radiosensitive(but
notsome
step
in the mechanism for IFN-ainduction
by
TGEV since the IFN-ayield
per cell remainedconstant).
Under similarconditions,
cellviability
and cellability
to secreteIFN-y,
a feature of T-cells(La
Bon-nardibreef al,
1994),
were not altered. In astudy
onherpes-simplex-virus-induced
IFN-aproduction,
Howelletal (1993)
also foundthat exposure of human PBMC to irradia-tion doses up to 100
Gy
reducedIFN-a,
butrelatively
less than the reduction of natural killer(NK) activity.
Takentogether,
thesedata
provided experimental
evidence that IFN-a SC differ from T-cells and from NKcells,
confirming
previous phenotyping
stud-ies(reviewed by Fitzgerald-Bocarsly,
1993 andCharley
andLaude,
1992).
Because of the IFN-a SC
radiosensitivity,
it was feasible to conduct irradiationexper-iments in
vivo,
in order to determine the invivo behaviour of
circulating
IFN-a SC inirradiated
pigs.
After a non-lethalpartial
irra-diation
(PLI),
IFN-A SCfrequency
wasgreatly
andrapidly
reducedbut,
similar tothe
frequency
of bloodlymphocytes,
it returned to normal values within severalweeks. Because PLI was
previously
shownto affect
circulating leukocytes
but ensured the recovery of a functionalhaematopoietic
bone-marrow(Vaiman
et al,
1981
), our
datasuggest
thatnewly developing
blood IFN-a SC after PLI were derived frombone-mar-row
progenitor
cells. To address thispoint,
pigs
were irradiated(8
Gy,
aspreviously
published,
Vaimanet al,
1975)
andrecon-stituted with
compatible
bone-marrow cells. TheWBI-depleting
effect,
duepartly
tobone-marrow destruction
(Vaiman
et al,
1975),
and the successful reconstitution effect of bone-marrow
engraftment
were demon-stratedby
the modifications inlymphocyte
counts
(figs
2 and3).
Under suchcondi-tions,
IFN-a SC counts weremarkedly
decreased
following
irradiation,
in fact muchmore than were
lymphocyte
counts. Thisresult is
compatible
with therelatively higher
radiosensitivity
of IFN-a SCcompared
with otherlymphocyte subpopulations (see
tableII).
Within severaldays following
bone-mar-row
engraftment,
IFN-a SC counts returnedto normal
values,
even morerapidly
than totallymphocytes
(fig
2).
These datastrongly
suggest
thatcirculating
IFN-a SCoriginate
from bone-marrowprogenitors.
However,
the presence of a
significant proportion
ofIFN-a SC in
pig
bone-marrowcells,
for which blood contamination may not beaccounted,
might
haveexplained
therecon-stitution observed
following
bone-marrow ivinjection.
Such anexplanation
remainsunlikely
because the transfer ofalready
func-tional IFN-a SCalong
with bone-marrowwould have
immediately
reconstituted acir-culating
IFN-a SCpopulation.
IFN-a SCreconstitution, however,
tookplace
severaldays
after thetransfer,
whichsuggests
theproduction
ofnewly
differentiated cells fromprogenitors. Although
human IFN-a SC(or
NIP
cells)
were shown to lack stem cell-associated CD markers(Sandberg
etal,
1991),
our
present
datasupported
thehypothesis
thatcirculating
IFN-a SC werederived from
haematopoietic progenitors,
and therefore constituted adistinct,
although
atypical, leukocyte population.
These results confirmed recent data from ourlaboratory
showing
that IFN-a SC werepresent
inearly
haematopoietic
organs ofpig
foetuses(Splichal
et al,
1994).
Ourpresent
study
inpigs
extended the results obtained in miceinjected
with Sindbis or Newcastle diseasevirus,
showing
that bone-marrowtrans-plantation
restored serum interferonpro-duction in
lethally
irradiated animals(De
Maeyer
etal,
1967).
Thelikely
haematopoi-eticorigin
of IFN-a SCimplies
that thepro-duction of this cell
population might
bereg-ulated
by haematopoietic
factors. It wasindeed shown that IFN-a gene
expression
in human NIP cells relies on the presence ofAlm,
1991
It
It will beimportant
to determineto what extent viruses
affecting
lympho-haematopoietic
tissues will alter the IFN-a SCpopulation.
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
The authors thank C de Vaureix
(INRA, Jouy)
forpreparing anti-IFN-a antibodies and JJ Leplat
(INRA, Jouy)
fortaking
part in the surgery and animal care.REFERENCES
Artursson K, Gobl A, Lindersson M, Johansson M, Alm G (1992) Molecular cloning of a gene encoding porcine interferon-p. J Interferon Res 12, 153-160
Cederblad B, Aim GA (1991) Interferons and the colony
stimulating factors IL-3 and GM-CSF enhance the
IFN-a response in human blood leukocytes induced
by herpes simplex virus. Scand J Immunol34, 549-556
Charley B, Mc Cullough K, Martinod S (1988) Antiviral and antigenic properties of recombinant porcine
inter-feron gamma. Vet Immunol Immunopathol 19, 95-103
Charley B, Laude H (1992) Interactions
virus-lympho-cytes pour la production d’interf6ron <x. Ann Rech Vd
t 23, 318-322
Charley B, Lavenant L, Lefbvre F (1994) Coronavirus
transmissible gastroenteritis virus-mediated induc-tion of IFN-n-mRNA in porcine leukocytes requires prior synthesis of soluble proteins. Vet Res 25,
29-36
D’Andr6a S (1995) Contribution a I’btude du r6le des interferons trophoblastiques porcins. These de doc-torat de l’Institut national agronomique Paris-Grignon, France
De Arce HD, Artursson K, L’Haridon R, Perers A, La
Bonnardibre C, Aim GV (1992) A sensitive
immunoassay for porcine interferon-a. Vet Immunol
Immunopatho130, 319-327
De Maeyer-Guignard J (1993) Interferons alpha et beta.
In: Les Cytokines (JM Cavaillon, ed), Masson, Paris, France,285-296
De Maeyer E, Jullien P, De Maeyer-Guignard J (1967)
Interferon synthesis in X-irradiated animals. 11. Restoration by bone-marrow transplantation of
cir-culating-interferon production in lethally-irradiated mice. Int J Radiat Biot 13, 417-431
Ferbas JJ, Toso JF, Logar AJ, Navratil JS, Rinaldo CR
(1994) CD4, blood dendritic cells are potent
pro-ducers of IFN-a in response to in vitro HIV-1 infection. J Immunol 152, 4649-4662
Fitzgerald-Bocarsly P (1993) Human natural
interferon-a-producing cells. Pharmacol Ther60, 39-62 Howell DM, Feldman M, Siegal FP, Pettera L,
Fitzgerald-Bocarsly P (1993) Peripheral blood of AIDS patients
contains cells capable of providing accessory func-tion for the natural killer cell-mediated, lysis of herpes
simplex virus-infected targets despite low
interferon-a production. J Acquired Immune Defic Syndro 6,
15-23
La Bonnardi6re C, Lef6vre F, Charley B (1994) Inter-feron response in pigs: molecular and biological
aspects. Vet Immunollmmunopathol 43, 29-36
Laude H, Chapsal JM, Gelfi J, Labiau S, Grosclaude J
(1986) Antigenic structure of transmissible gas-troenteritis virus. I. Properties of monoclonal
anti-bodies directed against virion proteins. J Gen Virot
67, 119-130
Naidoo D, Derbyshire JB (1992) Interferon induction in
porcine leukocytes with transmissible gastroenteritis
virus. Vet Microbiol 30. 317-327
Nowacki W, Charley B (1993) Enrichment of coronavirus-induced interferon-producing blood leukocytes
increases the interferon yield per cell: a study with pig
leukocytes. Res Immunol 144, 111-120
Sandberg K, Eloranta ML, Johannisson A, Aim GV
(1991) Flow cytometric analysis of natural
interferon-a-producing cells. Scand J Immuno/34, 565-576
Spichal I, Bonneau M, Charley B (1994) Ontogeny of
interferon-alpha secreting cells in the porcine fetal
hematopoietic organs. Immunol Letters 43, 203-208
Vaiman M, Arnoux B, Daburon F, Haag L (1975)
Allo-geneic bone-marrow grafts in genotyped swine.
Transplant Proc 7, 855-857
Vaiman M, Daburon F, Remy J et al (1981) Allograft
tol-erance in pigs after fractionated lymphoid