HAL Id: jpa-00209517
https://hal.archives-ouvertes.fr/jpa-00209517
Submitted on 1 Jan 1982
HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access archive for the deposit and dissemination of sci- entific research documents, whether they are pub- lished or not. The documents may come from teaching and research institutions in France or abroad, or from public or private research centers.
L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non, émanant des établissements d’enseignement et de recherche français ou étrangers, des laboratoires publics ou privés.
Two-dimensional films of discotic molecules at an air-water interface
F. Rondelez, D. Koppel, B.K. Sadashiva
To cite this version:
F. Rondelez, D. Koppel, B.K. Sadashiva. Two-dimensional films of discotic molecules at an air-water interface. Journal de Physique, 1982, 43 (9), pp.1371-1377. �10.1051/jphys:019820043090137100�.
�jpa-00209517�
Two-dimensional films of discotic molecules
at anair-water interface
F. Rondelez, D.
Koppel
Laboratoire de Physique de la Matière Condensée, Collège de France, 11, place Marcelin Berthelot, 75231 Paris Cedex 05, France
and B. K. Sadashiva
Raman Research Institute - Bangalore, 560080 India
(Reçu le 11 mars 1982, accepté le 30 avril 1982)
Résumé. 2014 On montre pour la première fois que des molécules discotiques de benzène-hexa-alkanoates peuvent être étalées en monocouches à un interface eau-air. Les mesures de pression superficielles donnent des résultats
très analogues à ceux des films d’acides gras. Le noyau benzénique joue le rôle de la tête polaire grâce à six groupes
carboxyliques périphériques, et se met à plat sur l’interface. Les chaines alkanoates jouent le rôle des chaines aliphatiques. Les isothermes de pression permettent une estimation des dimensions moléculaires dans le plan de
l’interface. Ces dimensions sont pratiquement identiques à celles déduites des mesures de rayons X dans les phases
à colonnes formées par les benzène-hexa-alkanoates (cristaux liquides thermotropes). Ces expériences permettent de réfuter l’interprétation de la transition liquide expansé-liquide condensé comme une transition du second ordre
entre une phase isotrope et une phase cristal liquide nématique.
Abstract. 2014 The possibility of forming Langmuir monolayers with disc-like molecules of benzene-hexa-alkanoates has been investigated for the first time. Surface pressure measurements show that these monolayers behave in
many respects as the well-known films of fatty acids. The benzene ring plays the role of the polar head group while the alkanoates chains are the long aliphatic tails. Molecular dimensions can be derived from the surface pressure- concentration isotherms. The results indicate that the benzene rings lie flat at the interface. The projection of the
molecular diameter onto the interface is practically identical to the lattice spacing measured in the liquid-crystalline
columnar mesophases formed by benzene-hexa-alkanoates in bulk. These experiments allow to refute the inter- pretation of the liquid expanded-liquid condensed transition in terms of a second order isotropic ~ nematic phase transition, as recently proposed by several theoretical groups.
Classification
Physics Abstracts
68.15 - 64.70J - 61.30E
1.
Introduction. - Soaps
andphospholipids
areclassical
examples
ofamphiphilic
molecules. Their molecular structure iscomposed
of ahydrophobic hydrocarbon
chain tail and of ahydrophilic polar
head. As a consequence of this dual character,
they generally
lie at the interfaces of emulsions or foams,forming
alarge variety
of structures : lamellar, hexa-gonal,
etc...[1].
The numerous moleculesforming thermotropic liquid crystalline phases
compose amuch less known class of
amphiphilic
molecules. It is clear however that the formation of smecticphases
for instance is due to the
partial segregation
of thealiphatic
flexible chains from therigid
aromatic cores.To the best of our
knowledge,
there have been few attempts to check if suchcompounds
could also be used as surfactants in aqueous solutions sincethey
have no
prominent
water-soluble group. There isonly
one report
by
Dbrfler et al.[2],
in which calamitic(rod-
like)
molecules of 4-4’azoxy-a-methyl
cinnamate,forming
nematicliquid crystalline phase
in bulk, havebeen
spread in.monolayers
at an air-water interface.Such observations are however very
interesting
sincethey
could lead the way to thediscovery
of two-dimensional nematic films with
quasi long
range orien-tational order of the
long
molecular axes. Thispossi- bility
is not ruled outby theory
as first shownby
deGennes as
early
as 1971[3].
In this paper, we show for the first time that the discotic class of
thermotropic liquid crystalline
mate-rials can also be
spread
asLangmuir monolayers.
Preliminary
results arepresented
on the benzene- hexa-alkanoates molecules which possess sixaliphatic
chains attached to a central benzene group. From surface pressure measurements, the benzene
rings
areobserved to lie flat on the water due to the pressure of six
carboxyl water-attracting
groups. Thealiphatic
Article published online by EDP Sciences and available at http://dx.doi.org/10.1051/jphys:019820043090137100
1372
chains are also, at least
partially, parallel
to the inter-face but
they
do notadopt
afully
extendedconfigura-
tion. The results will be
compared
with the average molecular diameters deduced from X-rays latticespacing
measurements in the columnar bulkliquid crystalline phases.
2.
Experimental.
- Surface pressures were measur-ed both
by
theWilhelmy hanging plate technique
andby
the movable barrier method[4].
The two methodsare indeed
complementary.
In the former, the total sur-face area is fixed and the
amphiphilic
molecules areadded as
drops
of solution in a volative solvent until thespreading
is nolonger
effective. In the latter, a fixednumber of
drops
isspread
at thebeginning
of theexperiment
and the surface area of thetrough
is thencontinuously
decreased up to thecollapse point
of themonolayer.
2.1 WILHELMY PLATE METHOD. - The force trans-
ducer was a Hewlett-Packard 8805-B pressure
ampli-
fier. The system was calibrated with
precisely
knownweights.
The outputvoltage
wasadjusted
so that 10 mVcorresponded
to 1.0 x 10-4 N m -1. The quartzglass
cuvette
containing
the watersubphase
had a surface of29.6 x 10-4 m2. It was
totally
enclosed in a massive,temperature-controlled,
oven in which water from aHaake F3-thermostat was
constantly circulating.
The temperature was varied between 4 OC and 60°C. The set temperature was constant to within ± 0.1 °C. Thiswas a necessary step since the
Wilhelmy technique
cannot compensate for the temperature variation of the surface tension of pure water
against
air. Thisvariation can indeed be
large, typically
1.5 x 10-4 N m - I OC - 1[5].
The total driftduring
the courseof an
experiment,
afterallowing
for thermalequili-
bration, was less than 0.4 x 10-4 N m-1.2.2 MOVABLE BARRIER METHOD. - A commercial Lauda film balance was used. All
experiments
wereperformed
at room temperature, T = 21 ± 5°C. Arigorous
temperature control was notemployed
because the film balance
directly
measures the diffe-rence between the surface pressure of pure water and that of the
monolayer.
Therefore thermal fluctuations in the water surface pressure areautomatically
can-celled out The maximum drift was observed to be about 10- 5 N m - 1 per minute. The
speed
at which thebarrier was moved was 0.25 x 10- 2
m/min.
Thiscorresponds
to an average percentage variation in the totalmonolayer
surface of 1-3%, sufficiently
low toalways
allow for mechanicalequilibration
of themonolayer,
while stillbeing compatible
with theexperi-
mental drift
during
themeasuring
time. The durationof one
single
run was about one hour. The surfacepressure was monitored both upon
compression
andexpansion
to check forpossible hysteresis
effect.2. 3 CHEMICALS. - The
synthesis
of the benzene- hexa-alkonates (BH forshort)
hasalready
been des-cribed elsewhere
[6, 7].
Five successive
homologs
were studiedstarting
from n-pentanoate up to n-decanoate.
Small
quantities
(~ 10-3g)
wereweighted
on aCahn electrobalance to an accuracy of 10-6 g and dissolved in 20 ml of
methylene
dichloride (Merck- spectrograde).
This solvent had been checked pre-viously
to be agood spreading
solvent, non misciblewith water and
highly
volatile, and also to containonly insignificant
fractions of surface-activeimpuri-
ties
[8].
The surface pressure increase when pure solventwas added and let evaporate was less than 5 x
10-6 N m-1 after 10
drops. (Up
to 60drops
could beadded for a
complete experiment
with theWilhelmy plate
and up to 300drops
with the Laudabalance.)
3. Results. - For all
compounds,
the surface pres-sure measurements have been
performed
at severalFig. 1. 2013 Surface pressure isotherms of benzene-hexa-n- pentanoate (BH-5) using either Wilhelmy hanging plate or
movable barrier (Lauda) methods. Substrate is pure water.
temperatures between 5 and 60 OC
using
thehanging plate,
and at room temperature,using
the movablebarrier
techniques. Typical
results are shown onfigures
1 and 2 forbenzene-hexa-n-pentanoate (BH-5)
and on
figures
3 and 4 for benzene-hexa-n-nonanoate(BH-9).
The curves obtained in these twoexamples
aresomewhat different.
1)
For the lowerhomolog,
the pressure 7c increasesregularly
when concentration C is increased(Wilhelmy method)
or when film surface A is decreased(Lauda balance).
Atrelatively large
pressure values,typically
between 6 x 10-3 N m -1 and 8 x 10-3 N m -1
depending
on temperature, there is a suddenchange
ofslope.
Thecorresponding
concentration will be calledCkink in
thefollowing.
Above
Ck;nk,
the 7T-C or n-A curves becomenearly
parallel
to the abscissa axis. Thisregion
ofslight
Fig. 2. - Continuously recorded surface pressure isotherms of benzene-hexa-n-pentanoate (BH-5). The monolayer is
first compressed (decreasing areas per molecule), then re- expanded (increasing areas). The data points have also
been reported in figure 1 for comparison with the Wilhelmy technique.
upward slope
hasonly
a limited width.Finally
theslope
is observed to re-increasesharply
until a state ofsaturation is reached in the film. This saturation occurs
for different surface pressures values
according
to thetechnique
ofinvestigation.
With thehanging plate technique,
wheredrops
aresuccessively deposited
onto a fixed surface area, the maximum surface pres-
sure attainable
corresponds
to theequilibrium spread-
Fig. 3. - Surface pressure isotherms of benzene-hexa-n- nonanoate (BH-9) usmg Wilhelmy hanging plate technique.
Substrate is pure water.
Fig. 4. - Continuously recorded surface pressure isotherms of benzene-hexa-n-nonanoate (BH-9). The monolayer is
first compressed (decreasing areas per molecule), then re-expanded (increasing areas).
ing
pressure n,,. This is the surface pressure obtained when themonolayer
is inequilibrium
with the stable bulkphase. Experimentally,
as n,, isapproached,
thetime
required
forequilibration
afterdeposition
of onefurther
drop
increasesdrastically.
Thecorresponding
surface concentration and surface area per molecule
are called
Ce and Ae respectively.
For BH-5 at room temperature, ne = 11.6 x 10- 3 Nm-1, Ce
= 1.05 x 10-3 g m-2and Ae
= 1.20 nm2. With the movable barriertechnique,
where the film area iscontinuously
reduced while the total number of molecules in the
monolayer
iskept
constant, the maximum surface pressure attainablecorresponds
to thecollapse
pres-sure nr. This is the
highest
surface pressure to which themonolayer
can becompressed
withoutexpulsing
molecules into the third dimension. The
corresponding
surface area and surface concentration are called
Ac
and
Cc respectively.
Above nc, three-dimensional islands start to form, and if one tries to compress the film even more, the surface pressure isactually
observ-ed to decrease
(Fig.
2). For BH-5 at room temperature, nc = 15.2 x 10-3 Nm-’, Ac
= 1.10 nm2 andCc
1.15 x 10-3 g m-2. nc is
markedly higher
than ne.However this
gives only
little difference betweenAe and Ac
because of the large pressureslope
in thatdomain of concentrations.
Experiments
at differentcompression speeds yielded
similar values of nc to within 5 %. After compression to an area per molecule less thanA, large hysteresis
was observed uponsubsequent
filmre-expansion.
On the contrary there was no detectablehysteresis
aslong
as the film surface pressure waskept
below 7rc.2) For the
higher homolog,
the overall pressure increase at room temperature is much lessgradual
thanin the lower
homolog
case. Infigure
3, the datapoints
at 22°C stay on the zero pressure line until a concen-
tration of 5 x 10-3 g m-2 is reached, at which
point
the pressure increases so
rapidly
that the maximum pressure ne = 2.9 x 10- 3 N m-’ isalready
reached at1374
Table I. - Characteristic
surface
concentrations andsurface
pressures observed in thesurface
pressure isothermsof the benzene-hexa-n-alkanoates. Ck;nk corresponds to the
surface
concentration at the onsetof
the transitionbetween the
liquid expanded
and theliquid
condensed statesof
themonolayer. Ce corresponds
to thesurface
concen-tration at the equilibrium
surface
pressure 7r,,.Cc
corresponds to thesurface
concentration at the collapsesurface
pressure of the
film
7r,,.a concentration of
Ce
= 0.68 x10-3 gM-2 .
The samefeatures are observed on the Lauda curves. As film surface is decreased, the pressure increases first very
slowly
then much morerapidly
until a maximumPressure 7rc = 3.2 x 10- 3 N m -1 is reached. The
corresponding
surface area per molecule isA,, =
2.67 nm2. For still lower surface areas, a decrease in pressure is observed
indicating
that acollapse
of thefilm has taken
place.
In
figure
3, the results for a muchhigher
temperature of 60°C have also beenplotted. Although
the measu-rements are less accurate at this elevated temperature,
we observe that some of the features discussed for the lower
homolog
case start. to re-appear. A kink in thecurve can be detected for a concentration
Cki-k -
0.2 x 10-3 g m - 2 . At
larger
concentrations it is followedby
a somewhat flatregion
until a verysharp
rise in surface pressure occurs. At this temperature the
equilibrium spreading
pressure 7r,, is found to be 6.9 x 10-3 N m-1.Unambiguous
evidence for the reappearances of three distinct domains in the surface pressure-concen- trationplots
when the temperature is increased is alsoyielded
from measurements on the BH-8 and BH-10homologs.
The
important
data for all thehomologs
which havebeen studied in the present
investigation
are summa-rized in table I.
4. Discussion. - All our
experimental
curves can be understoodby analogy
with themonolayer
behaviourof the
simpler
chainfatty
acid substances which have beenextensively
studied in the past. It is well reco-gnized
that suchmonolayers
can take at least three characteristic film states at an air-water interface. In order ofdecreasing
surface concentration,they
arereferred as condensed
(solid
orliquid)
films,liquid- expanded
films andfinally
gaseous films[4].
For a
particular
substance, all the different states may or may not be observeddepending
on theexperi-
mental conditions
(e.g. temperature).
For instance, atroom temperature,
myristic
acid shows the threephases
while
palmitic
acid showsonly
the condensed and the gaseousphases.
It should also beenpointed
out thatthe present discussion is
oversimplified.
Indeed, muchmore intricate
phase diagrams, including
mesomor-phic
states, have been described in the literature[9].
However this crude level of
presentation
isquite
suf-ficient for our present purposes.
The existence of the three
phases
isclearly
evident inour
monolayers
of benzene-hexa-alkanoates. From table I, it is seen that BH-5 at 5 and 21 °C, BH-6 at5 and 21 oC, BH-8 at 40 OC, BH-9 at 40 and 60 °C and
BH-10 at 40 OC, all show
expanded-liquid
films andcondensed-liquid
films(no
attempts to observe thealways existing
gaseous film have been made since itcorresponds
to low surface pressures andrequires
very accurate measurements
[10]).
The transition between theliquid-expanded
andliquid-condensed phases
is very obvious in the surface pressure isothermplots.
In the transitionregion
thecompressibility
of themonolayer
becomes small and there is not much of asurface pressure
change
when surface concentration is increased (seeFig. 1).
This transition, called the maintransition, is
generally
assumed to be first-orderalthough
the isotherm shows a non-zeroslope
in thetransition
region.
The fact that the main transition does not behave as anordinary
three-dimensionalsolid-liquid phase
change has been discussedby
many authors[11]. Recently,
Albrecht et al.[9]
havesuggested
that this is due to the limited size of the
cooperatively transforming
units. Forphospholipid monolayers, they
have estimated that these domainsincorporates
about 150 molecules.
Our
experimental
data show a number of caseswhere the transition between a
liquid-expanded
and aliquid-condensed
film is not observed. The pressure isotherms stay very close to the horizontal axis until the concentration reaches a certain concentration at which the curves turnupward
almostvertically.
Herethe gaseous films are
directly
converted to condensedfilms. BH-9 at 21°C
gives
agood example
of such abehaviour
(Figs.
3 and 4).We thus observe here that the range of
stability
ofthe different
phases
changes in aregular
manner with temperature. This behaviour is also encountered withsingle
chainfatty
acids materials[4].
For agiven compound
the occurrence of aliquid expanded phase
becomes less and less
probable
as the temperature is lowered.Reciprocally,
at fixed temperature, theliquid- expanded
film becomes less and lessprobable
as thechain
length
is increased from five to ten carbon atoms.It is often found in other
compounds
that the additionof one carbon atom to the
length
of onealiphatic
chain shifts the curves in
nearly
the very same fashionas a decrease of 8-10 OC in temperature. The present
experiments
corroborateroughly
that result.Going
from BH-7 to BH-8, it is necessary to increase the temperature from 21°C to 40 OC to re-observe the
expanded-liquid
film.The pressure isotherms
yield
information on the conformation of the benzene alkoanoatesspread
at anair-water interface. We will see that the present data
are
only
consistent with a model where the benzenerings
lie flat on the water while the chainalign
more orless
horizontally, although
notcompletely.
Such aconformation is
intuitively
evident since the presence of the sixwater-attracting carboxyl
groups forces the benzene to be in direct contact with the aqueoussubphase.
On the other hand, thealiphatic
chains haveno reason to stay close to the water. However there is a
certain chain
rigidity
which prevents the firstmethy-
lene groups to stand
directly upright.
This localrigi- dity
has beenamply
demonstrated in fluidbilayers by
measurements of the order parameter for each seg- ment,
using
EPR[12]
or NMR[13]
spectroscopy. Fortypical aliphatic
chains, the first five or sixmethylene
groups are in a stretched
configuration.
The average molecular dimensions can be estimated from the concentration at which the film reaches itsequilibrium spreading
pressure. Indeed atCe
the molecules can be considered as closedpacked
and therefore the averagearea per molecule
Ae
iseasily
deducedknowing
themolecular
weight
of thecompound
underinvestigation.
The measured
Ce
for the various benzene-alkanoates have beenreported
in table I and thecorresponding
calculated
Ae
values aregiven
in table II. The maximum molecularlength d,,
can then be estimatedassuming
that there is no
interpenetration
of thealiphatic
chainsbetween two
adjacent
molecules. Under these condi-tions,
simple geometric
relations shows thatd,, c!e
1.24A e ’I’
for moleculeshaving
ahexagonal shape.
The different values ford,,
are alsogiven
intable II. The
subscript
n indicates that thed,,
valuesare derived from surface pressure
experiments.
It istrue that the choice of
Ae
to calculate thed,,
values issomewhat
arbitrary.
The average molecular areas at thecollapse point, A, ,,
could also have been chosen.At any rate, the
Ae and Ac
values are very close andcertainly
within the uncertainties of theexperiments.
Therefore the
dx
values areprobably
correct to better than10 %.
Acomparison
of these values with those derived from X-ray diffractionphotographs
in thethree-dimensional columnar
mesomorphic
state isvery
interesting.
In that latter case, Chandrasekharet al.
[7]
haveproposed
analigned, liquid crystalline
Table II. - Molecular dimensions
of
the benzene-hexa-n-alkanoates as derivedfrom
monolayersurface
pressureexperiments
(dft)’ from
molecular modelsassuming fully
extended chains(dm) and from
X-ray lattice spacing bulkmeasurements
(dx-ray)’ Ae
andAc
are the areas per molecule measured at theequilibrium surface
pressure ne and atthe collapse pressure 7r,,,,
respectively.
All dataare for
T = 21 °C.1376
structure of stacked discs
forming
columns with anhexagonal close-packed
arrangement. Therefore an estimate of the disc molecular diameter can be deriveddirectly
from measurements of the latticespacing.
Unfortunately,
suchdx-,a,
data areonly
available for BH-7 and BH-8[7-14],
since for the other benzene- hexa-alkanoates the columnarmesomorphic
state doesnot exist or is
highly
metastable. Acomparison
bet-ween dn
anddx -,ay in
these twoexisting
cases show anamazingly good
agreement between the two sets of data(see
columns 3 and 5 of table II). It thereforeappears that the molecules
adopt nearly
the sameconformation when
they
arespread
as amonolayer
at an air-water interface or when
they
arepiled
on top of each other in fluid columns.In neither case are the
aliphatic
chainsfully
extendedas evidenced
by
acomparison
with the molecular diameterdm
calculated for stretched chains from mole- cularDreiding
models(see
column 4 of tableII).
Thedn
values areconsistently
lower thandm
in all cases.Lastly,
several other conformations can becertainly rejected.
Were thealiphatic
chainsfully
verticalrelative to the water surface, a much lower molecular surface area would be observed. From a
space-filling
model we can estimate that it should be in the order of 95
A2, independent
of the actual chainlength.
This isclearly
not substantiatedby
our observations which show a variation inAe
from 110 up to 3 30 A’. Anotherpossibility
would be that the benzene nucleus is forced to take anupright position
uponcompression.
Such a conformation has been indeed observed
by
Adam on benzene derivatives with various lateral substitutions
[15].
Theprojected
molecular areaoccupied by
one benzene is then of the orderof 24 A2,
much too low
again
to account for ourexperimental
results, even whenconsidering
the additional areaoccupied by
each of the sixaliphatic
chains. It shouldbe noted that the Adam
compounds
were not hexa-substituted with
water-attracting
groups. Therefore it was much easier for the benzene to tilt away from the aqueoussubphase.
5. Conclusions. - The present
experiments
showthat benzene-hexa-alkanoates form stable
monolayers
when
spread
at an air-water interface. The pressure isotherms exibit the well-known three states charac- teristic ofliquid-condensed, liquid-expanded
andgaseous films
according
to surface concentrations and temperatures. Benzene-hexa-alkanoates constitute therefore a new class of surfactant materials withproperties
as well defined as the classicalsingle long
chain
fatty
acids orphospholipids.
The benzene nucleus is observed to lie in direct contact with the water,probably
because of the existence of the sixcarboxyl
«pinning points
». Thealiphatic
chains are also, at leastpartially,
parallel to the water. A certainamount of randomness does exist however, as indi-
cated from a
comparison
between the measured mole-cular
dimensions and that offully
extended chains.In the two cases where the data are available in the literature, the measured molecular diameters are in close agreement, to better than 1
A,
with the diameters measured in themesomorphic
bulkliquid
state wherethese disc-like molecules are stacked in columns.
The
possibility
offorming monolayers
with mole-cules
having thermotropic mesomorphic
states in thebulk open
interesting perspectives
to try and demons- trate thetheoretically predicted
existence ofquasi-
nematic order in two dimensions
[3].
In that case it istrue that calamitic molecules will have to be used rather than discotic molecules. However, the present work can
give
some hints on which type of molecules will be best suitable.Monolayers
of disc-like benzene-hexa-alkanoates may proveimportant
as new systems on which to test the current ideas on two-dimensionalmelting.
Theirsix-fold symmetry is well
adapted
to detect the occur-rence of the defect-mediated hexatic
phase predicted by
Nelson andHalperin [16].
This couldperhaps
bedone
through
surfaceviscosity
measurementsalthough
such
experiments
arealways
very delicate in mono-layers.
Finally,
the presentexperiments
do not bear outthe recent
interpretation
of the kink observed in the surface pressure isotherms in terms of a second-orderphase
transition between theliquid-expanded
and theliquid-condensed
states[11].
Indeed the associated theoretical models all suppose agradual
orientation of theprojection
of thealiphatic
chains in the inter- facialplane.
Such aliquid crystalline,
uniaxial, nematicordering
isclearly
notpossible
with moleculeshaving
six-fold symmetry. Therefore the more classical inter-
pretation
of a first-orderphase
transition seems more relevant here,although
a true flat transitionregion
with infinite
compressibility
is not observed.Acknowledgments.
- We thank H. Gruler for manyhelpful
discussionsduring
his sabbatical stay at theCollege
de France. This work has beensupported
under a
joint
programby
the C.N.R.S.(France)
andthe C.S.I.R.
(India).
References
[1] PERSHAN, P. S., J. Physique Colloq. 40 (1979) C3-423.
[2] DÖRFLER, H. D., KERSCHER, W. and SACKMANN, H., J. Phys. Chem. (Leipzig) 251 (1972) 314.
[3] DE GENNES, P. G., Farad. Symp. 5 (1971) 16.
[4] GAINES, G. L., Insoluble monolayers at liquid-gas inter- faces (Wiley, New York) 1966.
[5] Handbook of Physics (Chemical Rubber Company), Cleveland, Ohio.
[6] CHANDRASEKHAR, S., SADASHIVA, B. K. and SURESH, K.
A., Pramana 9 (1977) 471.
[7] CHANDRASEICHAR, S., SADASHIVA, B. K., SURESH, K. A., MADHUSUDANA, N. V., KUMAR, S., SHASHIDAR, R.
and VENKATESH, G., J. Physique Colloq. 40 (1979)
C3-120.
[8] VILANOVE, R. and RONDELEZ, F., Phys. Rev. Lett. 45
(1980) 1502.
[9] ALBRECHT, O., GRULER, H. and SACKMANN, E., J.
Physique 39 (1978) 301.
[10] HAWKINS, G. A. and BENEDEK, G. B., Phys. Rev. Lett.
32 (1974) 524.
KIM, M. W. and CANNELL, D. S., Phys. Rev. A 13 (1976) 411.
[11] For a recent review, see BARET, J. F., Progress in Surf.
and Memb. Sci. ed. by D. A. Cadenhead and J. F. Danielli (Academic Press, New York) 1981, Vol. 14, p. 291.
[12] SEELIG, J., J. Am. Chem. Soc. 92 (1970) 3881; 93 (1971)
5017.
[13] CHARVOLIN, J., MANNEVILLE, P. and DELOCHE, B.,
Chem. Phys. Lett. 23 (1973) 345.
[14] GOOZNER, R. E. and LABES, M. M., Mol. Cryst. Liq.
Cryst. Lett. 56 (1979) 75.
[15] ADAM, N. K., Proc. Roy. Soc. 119 (1928) 628.
[16] HALPERIN, B. I. and NELSON, D. R., Phys. Rev. Lett.
41 (1978) 121. Phys. Rev. B 19 (1979) 2457.