HAL Id: jpa-00247614
https://hal.archives-ouvertes.fr/jpa-00247614
Submitted on 1 Jan 1992
HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access archive for the deposit and dissemination of sci- entific research documents, whether they are pub- lished or not. The documents may come from teaching and research institutions in France or abroad, or from public or private research centers.
L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non, émanant des établissements d’enseignement et de recherche français ou étrangers, des laboratoires publics ou privés.
Self-organization of discogenic molecules at the air-water interface
Nicholas Maliszewskyj, Paul Heiney, J. Kent Blasie, John P. Mccauley Jr., Amos B. Smith Iii
To cite this version:
Nicholas Maliszewskyj, Paul Heiney, J. Kent Blasie, John P. Mccauley Jr., Amos B. Smith Iii. Self-
organization of discogenic molecules at the air-water interface. Journal de Physique II, EDP Sciences,
1992, 2 (1), pp.75-85. �10.1051/jp2:1992114�. �jpa-00247614�
Classification Physics Abstracts
68.10G 82.65D 61.30
Self-organization of discogenic molecules at the air-water interface
Nicholas C.
Maliszewskyj II),
Paul A.Heiney (~),
J. Kent Blasie(~),
John P.Mccauley,
Jr. (~) and Amos B.Smith,
III(2)
(1)
Department
ofPhysics
andLaboratory
for Research on the Structure of Matter,University
of Pennsylvania,Philadelphia,
PA 19104, U-S-A-(2)
Departrnent
ofChemistry
and Laboratory for Research on the Structure of Matter,University
of Pennsylvania,
Philadelphia,
PA 19104, U-S-A-(Received it
September
J99J,accepted
27September
J99J)Abstract. The behavior of several
species
ofdiscogenic
molecules at the air-water interface has been determinedby measuring
surface pressure vs. molecular area isotherms.Alkylthiotripheny-
lene derivatives do not appear to form
monolayers
at the interfaces, due to lack ofamphiphilic
character. Two truxene derivatives were found to
display
molecular areas on the order of 65 A2,most
likely
due to the molecules lying « edge-on » to the water surface.Hexacyclens generally
lie with the core groupparallel
to the surface of the water with the tail groupsextending
away from the interface ; a higher densityphase
maycorrespond
to conformational changes within themolecule.
1. Introduction.
The
organization
ofamphiphilic
molecules such aslipids
and soaps intomonolayers
on water surfaces is a well knownphenomenon [I]. Recently,
it has become clear[2-7]
thatLangmuir monolayers
can also be formed from thedisc-shaped
molecules of which discoticliquid crystals [8]
arecomposed.
Such moleculestypically,
but notuniversally,
have flat,conjugated
cores and 4-8
aliphatic
tails. The bulkliquid crystalline phases
may be nematic («ND »)
orhexagonal-columnar
(«Dhd »),
the latter structureconsisting
of ahexagonal
array of columnsof molecules. The column axis is
approximately
normal to the molecular core and thealiphatic
tails extend more or lessradially
from the column axis.By
contrast, surface pressure isotherm measurements have shown that severalquite
different conformations arepossible
for
discogenic
molecules at the air-water interface.For
phthalocyanines [3],
benzene hexa-n-alkanoates[2, 5],
andhexacyclens [6, 7],
themolecular areas
extrapolated
from measurements ofspreading
pressure 17 versus areaA are consistent with a model for a condensed
phase
in which the core lies flat in thesurface,
with thealiphatic
tailsprojecting
away from the surface.By
contrast, the measured moleculararea of several
alkoxytriphenylene
derivatives is much smaller than the area of such aX X la
X,R
m
SCSH,,
16
X,R
-
SC~H,~
lc
X,R
=SC7H,s
id X ~
COO(CH~)~CH~
R m
OCSH,,
1e
X,R
=
OCSH,,
R
2a R =
COO(CH~),~CH~
2b R
m
COOPhO(CH~),OCH~
R R
R
~~'~~
f~~'h
OR
~N ~j
a R =C6H40C,~H~
R~O
b R"
C6H40C~H~
~~"~ c R
=
C~HS
R d R
«
C17H35
R~s~/~ eR=C~H~OC,,H~~
~~
~~/~~
~~~~~~~
~
~~
~
~'
~N ~j ~
j
R~ 4a.d
Scheme 1.
molecule
lying flat, implying
that these molecules mostlikely
are oriented «edge-on
» to the air-waterinterface,
with at least two tailspenetrating
into thesubphase [4, 7].
Ther-modynamic
transitions between different conformations may bepossible;
inparticular,
benzene hexa-n-alkanoate isotherms have been
interpreted
both in terms of a structure for which the core liesparallel
to the interface with the tails closepacked [5],
and in terms of a transition in which the entire molecule tilts from a conformation in which the core liesparallel
(« flat
»)
to the interface to one in which it sitsperpendicular
(«edge-on »)
to the interface athigh compression [4].
We have measured surface pressure vs. molecular area isotherms at room
temperature
for three classes ofthermotropic
discotic mesogen as shown in Scheme Ihexacydens,
truxenes, andtriphenylenes.
Thermal data and literature references for thesecompounds
aregiven
in table I. Thegoal
was to furtherexplore
the role of molecular architecture indetermining
bothliquid-crystal-phase
structure and structure at the air-water interface.Small
quantities
of solute(-10~~g)
wereweighed
on a Cahn electrobalance to anaccuracy of 10 ~ g. The
hexacyclens
3a-3f and 4a-4d arequite hygroscopic [9, 10],
and forthese
compounds
it was necessary to remove waterby heating
thesample gently
to 55 °Cunder
dynamic
vacuum for at least 36 hours beforeweighing
to obtainreproducible
results.After
weighing,
the solutes were dissolved in 10 ml of HPLCgrade methylene
chloride.Methylene
chloride is known to be agood spreading
solvent, immiscible in water andquite
volatile
(boiling point -40°C) [6].
Thesubphase
for H-A measurements was waterpurified
in aMillipore
filtration system. Acommercially
available Lauda film balance was used to determine the surface pressureby
the movablebarrier/Langmuir
float method to anaccuracy of
0.lmN/m.
All measurements wereperformed
at room temperature,T
=
21 ± 3 °C. After
performing
acleaning
sweep of the surface, 0.1ml of the solution wasspread
on the interface and at least 10 min allowed forevaporation
of the solvent. The filmwas then
compressed
at a barrierspeed
of 0.75cm/min,
so that the duration of anexperiment
was
approximately
30 min. All measurements were made 3 times from different solutions and thereproducibility
was within 5 fb.In a
typical
17- Aisotherm,
steep rises in pressure are associated with a purephase,
whileapproximately
horizontalregions
are associated with coexistence between twophases.
Thereis more than one convention for
determining
the molecular area from such isotherms. Forexample,
the molecular area of 3a isvariously reported
as 160Ji2 [7]
and22512 [6],
even
though
the measured isotherms arequite
similar. The difference lies in whether the moleculararea is defined
by
the inflectionpoint
of the vertical rise in pressurecorresponding
to the condensedphase,
orby
the onset of that vertical rise. It is the former convention to which we adhere in this paper.As
recently
observed[11],
17-A isotherms inLangmuir
films are inpractice
oftenperformed
away fromthermodynamic equilibrium.
We and others[2, 4, 5, 7]
have in somecases observed a local maximum, or «
bump
», inspreading
pressure vs. molecular area. Sucha feature is an indication that the isotherm is in fact
measuring
anonequilibrium
process suchas irreversible second
layer
formation or ahysteretic
first order transition. With care,however,
the isotherms are still useful tools fordetermining
molecular surface areas close tomonolayer completion.
2. Results.
We will discuss in tum our studies of
triphenylene derivatives,
truxenederivatives,
andhexacydens.
Triphenylene
derivatives: Theliquid crystalline properties
ofalkoxy-
andalkylthio- triphenylene
derivatives have beenextensively
studied[12-15].
H-A isotherms ofJOURNAL DE PHYSIQUE II T 2, N'l,JANVJER lW2 5
Table I. Bulk transition temperatures and molecular areas at the water
su~fiace,
derived at theinflection point ofthe first
stateofthe
condensedphase of
themonolayer. References
aregiven for
the appearanceofthese compounds
in the literature. Molecular areas are measuredfrom
theinflection points
in thefirst
« state »of
the condensedmonolayer phase jkom
the isotherms infigures 1,
2, 4 and 5.Bulk
Liquid-Crystalline
Phases Reference(I
K1 ~ I
95 .c
i
la Kl - K2 -
D~d
-1[27]
1754 .c xi .c 91 °c
16 K
- H -
D~d
++[13-15]
1762c mc 91c
lc K
- D~~ -
[27]
2172 x ~c 941.c
id
D~d
-[27]
53167c
le K - D ++
[4,12]
6869 °c 122 >c
~~ ~
6~ ~~ 8~ ~~~ 1/C ~~~ 2~C
~~~ ~~~ ~~2b K ++ D~d +-
ND
- D~d +-N~
+-1[17-23]
749u .c 117 c 179 °c 284 °c 297 °c
3a K - T
[6], [7], [10]
15997 °c ml °c
3b K ++ I
[IQ]
168125 °c
3c
glass
-[10]
17157 °c
3d K
+-
[10]
12292 °c
3e K +- T ++
[10]
17658 °c 144 °c
3f K +-
l10]
165v6 °c
4a K
-
[10]
16371 >c
4b K - 155
25-61 °c
4c K ++
l10]
157118 °c
4d K +- I
[10
1242 °c
compounds
la-le are shown infigure
I. Our isotherm for le agrees within 6 fb with theprevious
determination[4]
of a 7-9mN/m
pressure and70h2
area per molecule at the inflection
point. Compound
ldgives
a similar molecular area, with a smallercompressibility
in the condensed
phase.
Thissupports
thehypothesis
of an «edge
on » arrangement for bothcompounds.
Thealkylthiotriphenylenes (la-c)
lackpolarizable
atoms which would serve toanchor the molecule to the
surface, suggesting
thatthey might
be lesslikely
to formN° DISCOGENIC MOLECULES AT AIR-WATER
~~
Q lall~R-SC,H~~
40
~
RO ~
O
R10
~
0
70 60
50
lbll~R=SCJf~,
40 30
_
20
~
10~ o
Z
E
~~
©$
lcll~R=SC~II~,
20
idX=COOICH~)sCBj
lo
R=OC,H~~
o
iell~RmOC~lI~~
loo 200
Area (A~/molecule)
Fig.
I. 1I A isotherms for several derivatives oftriphenylene.
Note the extremely small molecularareas for the
alkylthiotriphenylenes
la-c- The low molecular areas andhigh
surface pressures indicatethat these
compounds
are notforming monolayers,
but rather oilyphases
ormicrocrystallites
at the surface.Triphenylenes
id and le areproposed
to lieedge-on
to the water surface, with at least two tailspenetrating
into thesubphase.
monolayers
on water.Indeed,
the very small measured molecular areas for thesecompounds
is smaller than the known area for
packing
ofhydrocarbon
chains attached tohydrophilic
groups(m18h~), leading
us to conclude that these
alkylthiotriphenylenes
do not formLangmuir
films[16].
Truxene derivatives The
liquid crystalline properties
of the truxenederivatives,
hexa-n-alkanoyloxytruxene (2a)
andhexa-n-alkoxybenzoyloxytruxene (2b),
are also well understood[17-23].
Thespreading
behavior of these mesogens is shown infigure
2. The H Adiagrams
all show the formation of
relatively incompressible monolayers
with surface pressures at the inflectionpoint
on the order of 17.5mN/m.
The areas measured at the inflectionpoints
of the isotherms are much smaller than would beexpected
if the molecules were assumed to lie withthe cores flat on the surface
(about
154h2
for 2a and 380h2
for 2b). Thepresence of
highly electronegative
oxygen atoms to serve aspolar anchoring points
to the water surface andrelatively high
surface pressures(m
20mN/m) coupled
withnon-negligible
molecular areas indicate that the molecules are notbeing pulled
into thesubphase
and are not sohydrophobic
as to form
oily droplets
at the surface.R R
/ '
/ R
b~~
R
2a R
= COO lClI~)uCBj
f
Z E
~
~~
30
20 2b R
= COO
@
O(CIIz)iocBjio
°
ioo 200
Area (h~/molecule)
Fig.
2. 1I A isotherms for two derivatives of truxene cores. The low molecular areas of 2a and 2bare reminiscent of those of ld and le and are consistent with a model in which the molecules lie edge-on
to the water surface. The larger area of 2b can be attributed to the presence of
bulky phenyl rings
in thesubstituted tails.
The most
plausible explanation
of the observed molecular areas is that, like the benzene andtriphenylene
derivatives discussedabove,
the molecules lieedge-on
to the interface.Taking
the bulk core-core distance of 4.5h
for thecore-core distance in the
Langmuir film,
the
corresponding long
axis of the molecularprojection
on the water surface must be on the order of 15-20h,
consistent with the transverse dimensions of the molecule. The «edge-on
»hypothesis requires
that twohydrocarbon
tails penetrate thesubphase
to some extent.Figure
3 shows apossible
conformation for 2a at thesurface,
and illustrates the manner in which the(hydrophobic)
tails thatpenetrate
thesubphase
mostlikely
coil up so as to minimize their surface area[24].
The cross sectional area of the molecule shown infigure
3 is consistent with the measured molecular areas fromfigure
2.Fig. 3. Model of 2a at the air-water interface,
assuming
an edge-on arrangement of the truxene cores at the interface. Wepostulate
that the tailssubmerged
in the water adopt a coiled structure to reduce thefree energy of the
hydrophobic hydrocarbon
tails in direct contact with water.Hexacyclen
derivatives : We have studied avariety
of hexasubstituted[18]-N~
azacrowns, orhexacyclens (Scheme1);
H-A isotherms are shown infigure
4 and 5.Among
thehexacyclen compounds
3a-3f and 4a-4d,only
3a and 3e formliquid crystalline phases.
The bulkmesophase
structure of 3a isunclear,
and has beenvariously
described as tubular-columnar
[25]
or smectic[10].
The interfacial behavior of this molecule,however,
is muchmore
straightforward,
and we haveduplicated previous [6, 7]
H- A isotherms.Compounds
3a, 3b, and 3e are all similar to eachother, sharing
the same hexamide core andbenzoyl linkage,
anddiffering only
in thelength
of the attachedalkyl
tail. Substitution ofa hexamine core
(amounting only
tosubstituting
thecarbonyl
functional group for amethylene linkage) produces
4a and 4b. All of thesecompounds display
isotherms characteristic of a transition between alow-density, low-pressure
state and ahigh-density, high-pressure
state. The molecular areas in thelow-density
state are on the order of 160l~,
while those for thehigh-density
state are either 50 or 100Ji~.
The transition betweenthe two states
generally
involves anon-equilibrium «bump»
as discussed above. Thegenerally accepted [6, 7] interpretation
of thelow-density
state is that themacrocycle
core lies flat on the water surface and thealkyl
tailsproject
away from the water surface a space-filling
model of such an arrangementyields
a molecular area in agreement with that observed.R/)/~Q
~$ l~
N N
~~UN/~~
Q ~ R
RQ
3aRm©OICII~)iic~
3b R m
@ OICII~)sCB~
o
20
lo
3cRm@
11
*
~E
8011
6040 3d R
=
lCIIz)i~CB~
20
o
3eR-©OiC%)ioCl3i
3fR
"1C%)AC'&
100 200 300
Area (A~/molecule)
Fig. 4. 1I A isotherms for derivatives of the hexamide core 3. Note the distinct second phase at low molecular areas for several of these
compounds,
corresponding either tomultilayer
formation or amore
compact molecular conformation.
~~
/)R
4*~*©°(~~~a)i1~3
~N N
~§~)
R
40
20 4bRm@OICII~)~CH~
z
fiE tQ 20
io
o
60
40
4d
20 100
Area
Fig.
5. 1I A isotherms for derivatives of the hexamine core 4. The second phase is clearly manifest in 4a and 4b.It is conceivable that the
high-density
statecorresponds
tomultilayer formation;
ellipsometry
measurements couldhelp
resolve thisquestion. Altematively,
the second state mayquite likely correspond
to a conformationalchange
in themonolayer.
Forexample,
there may be more than one conformation of themacrocyde
core : an «expanded
» conformation in which thenitrogen
atoms arerelatively
far away from eachother,
and a «collapsed
»conformation in which the core
occupies
much less volume. If we assume a conformation in which acollapsed macrocycle
lies flat on the water surface and thealkyl
tails are constrained to extend away from the watersurface, thereby incorporating
the known cross-sectional area peralkyl
chain of 18h~,
then the minimum moleculararea is
approximately
110Ji~,
ingood
agreement with the measured areas for 3a, 3b and 4a. If we assume a linear conformation of the molecule[10],
in which three chains grouptogether
on either end of the molecule, wecalculate a molecular area of
m 55
h~,
in reasonable agreement with our results for 3e and 4b.Completely removing
thealkyl
tails leaves us withcompounds
3c and 4c.Compound
4c hasan isotherm with
only
a first stateobservable,
whereas 3c has an isotherm with a measurable molecular area of 17Ji~,
smaller than that for asingle alkyl chain,
andcertainly
too small to supportinterpretation
as amonolayer.
As thiscompound
isweakly
soluble in water, the lowmolecular area for 3c most
likely
arises from the moleculesdissolving
into thesubphase.
Finally, removing
thephenyl ring
and associated oxygen andleaving
thealkyl
tailgives
compounds 3d, 4d,
and 3f.Compounds
3d and 4d share similarspreading behavior,
withcomparable
areas per molecule and absence of a second state. The molecular areas associated with these twocompounds
appear to be consistent with thehexacyden
corelaying
flat on thewater surface with the
alkyl
tailsextending
away from thesubphase.
As 3f isstructurally
similar to 3d and
4d,
one would expect to see similarspreading
behavior.However,
the isotherm measuredclearly displays
the two statephenomenon
observed incompounds
such as 3a.3. Conclusions.
A number of
quite
dissimilar conformations arepossible
fordiscogenic
mesogens at the air-water interface.
Depending
on the details of the molecular structure,discogenic
moleculeswith flat
conjugated
cores(such
asbenzene, triphenylene,
or truxenederivatives)
may eitherlie flat on the ~vater surface with the tails
extending
away from theinterface,
oredge-on
withtwo tails
penetrating
thesubphase
to some extent. In thehexacyclen compounds,
which havequite
flexible cores, the molecules may make a transition between a conformation with thecores
lying
flat on the water surface and a second state in which either the cores arecollapsed
(I.e. compressed
such that theprojection
of the core on the water is as small aspossible)
and thealkyl
chains are closepacked,
or in which the molecule isessentially
linear(quite
similar to theedge-on
model for morerigid compounds).
De Gennes first
suggested
in 1971[26]
thatelongated
molecules at interfaces could form two-dimensional nematicphases,
withshort-range positional
order andquasi-long-range
orientational order.
Discogenic
molecules such asphthalocyanines
and benzene-hexa-alkanoates lie with their core groups flat on the water
surface, projecting roughly
circular cross-sections on the water surface. These materials are therefore notgood
candidates fortwo-dimensional nematics.
Fatty
acid molecules exhibit tiltedmonolayer phases, projecting elliptical
cross-sections on the watersurface,
but in this case the three-dimensional aspect of the molecules becomes moreimportant, making
themagain inappropriate
models for two-dimensional nematics. On the other
hand,
molecules such as thetriphenylene
and truxene alkanoatesproject elongated
cross sections on the water surface duesolely
to the molecularshape.
This raises theinteresting possibility
that similarcompounds
may exhibit two-dimensional
liquid crystal phases.
Future progress inunderstanding
the structure ofmesogenic compounds
at the air-water interface willclearly rely
on structuralprobes
such ashigh
resolution x-ray diffraction.Acknowledgements.
We thank R.
Fischetti,
V. Skita, S. Xu and T.Lubensky
for useful discussions. We thank A. R. McGhie and S. H. J. Idziak for assistance withcalorimetry
measurements. This workwas
supported by
the National Science Foundation Grants DMR MRL 88-19885 and DMR 89-01219.References
Ii GAINES G. L. Jr., Insoluble Monolayers at Liquid Gas Interfaces (Interscience, New York 1966).
[2] RONDELEz F., KOPPEL D. and SADASHIVA B. K., J.
Phys.
Fiance 43 (1982) I37I.[3] KALINA D. W. and CRANE S. W., Thin Solid Films 134 (1985) 109 ORTHMANN E. and WEGNER G., Angew. Chem. 98 (1986) 1114.
[4] ALBRECHT O., CUMMING W., KREUDER W., LASCHEWSKY A. and RINGSDORF H., Colloid Polym.
Sci 264 (1986) 659.
[5] RONDELEz F., BARET J. F. and BoIs A. G., J. Phys. France 48 (1987) 1225.
[6] MALTHETE J., POUPINET D., VILANOVE R. and LEHN J. M., J. Chem. Soc., Chem. Commun.
(1989) 1016.
[7] MERTESDORF C. and RINGSDORF H., Liq. Cryst. 5 (1989) 1757.
[8] CHANDRASEKHAR S., SADASHIVA B. K. and SURESH K., Pramana 9 (1977) 471.
[9] TATARSKY D., BANNERJEE K. and FORD W. T., Chem. Mater. 2 (1990) 138.
j10] IDzIAK S. H. J., MALISzEWSKYJ N. C., HEINEY P. A., MCCAULEY J. P. Jr., SPRENGELER P. A.
and SMITH A. B. III, J. Am. Chem. Soc. l13 (1991) 7666.
[I ii SCHLOSSMAN M. L., SCHWARTZ D. K., PERSHAN P. S., KAWAMOTO E. K., KELLOGG G. J. and LEE S.,
Phys.
Rev. Lett. 66 (1991) 1599.[12] LEVELUT A. M., J.
Phys.
France 40 (1979) L81 J. Chim. Phys. 80 (1983) 149.[13] KOHNE V. B., POULES W, and PRAEFCKE K., Chem. Zeit. 108 (1983) l13.
[14] GRAMSBERGEN E. F., HOVING J. H., DE JEU W. H., PRAEFCKE K. and KOHNE B., Liq.
Cryst.
1 (1986) 397.[15] HEINEY P. A., FONTES E., DE JEU W. H., RIERA A., CARROLL P. and SMITH A. B. III, J.
Phys.
France 50 (1989) 461.
[16] This
interpretation
wasstrengthened by
the observation of apatchy
structure when crossedpolarizers
were used to examine adeposition
ofdensity
similar to that on the surface of thetrough
or on the surface of water in a Petri dish,suggesting
that three-dimensionalmicrocrystallites
oroily droplets
werefloating
on the water surface.[17] DESTRADE C., MALTHETE J., NGUYEN H. T. and GASPAROUX H.,
Phys.
Lett. A 78(1980)
82.[18] DESTRADE C., GASPAROUX H., BABEAU A., NGUYEN H. T. and MALTHETE J., Molec. Cryst. Liq.
Cryst.
67 (1981) 693.[19] NGUYEN H. T., MALTHETE J. and DESTRADE C., J.
Phys.
France 42 (1981) L417.[20] DESTRADE C., FOUCHER P., MALTHETE J. and NGUYEN H. T., Phys. Lett. 88 (1982) 187.
[21] FONTES E., HEINEY P. A., OHBA M., HASELTINE J. N. and SMITH A. B. III, Phys. Ret,. A37 (1988) 1329.
[22] LEE W. K., WINTNER B. A., FONTES E., HEINEY P. A., OHBA M., HASELTINE J. N. and SMITH A.
B. III, Liq. Cryst. 3 (1989) 87.
[23] WARMERDAM T., FRENKEL D. and ZIJLSTRA R. J. J., Liq. Crysi. 3 (1988) 149.
[24] Figure 3
actually
shows a structure obtained viapotential
energy minimization of an isolated (gasphase)
molecule, notincluding
the effects of the air-water interface or thesurrounding
molecules. The energy was minimized using the conjugate gradient method in the Dreiding force field available on
Polygraf,
aproduct
ofBiodesign,
Inc.[25] LEHN J. M., MALTHETE J. and LEVELUT A. M., J. Chem. Soc.. Chem. Commun. (1985) 1794.
[26] DE GENNES P. G., Farad. Symp. 5 (1971) 16.
[27] Transition temperatures were measured in our laboratory using Differential