الآثار القانونية والجزاءات المترتبة لامتناع الإدارة عن تنفيذ الأحكام النهائية الناتجة عن الطعن القضائي في قراراتها التأديبـية
Texte intégral
(2) אא. 183.
(3) ! " #$ %&' ()#* + ,- ,. /0 ! . 345 6- /1
(4) אאאא "!א א#$א . %&' )(א. א+,-,א./,א0,1א0,23,4א.,4אאא,56א+74389* ,,,.:;,,,<א#=,,,$>א,,,?,,,'@
(5) אAאאBאא#,,,C,,,D אEF@=,,,א ,<אA,C,א#,K،,IאG,CאאE8,6א-,, H5= 3 ،O,4P,,4
(6) Qא8,,I+,,74
(7) ,,אL,,,,Hא#"MAאא8,,IE8N,,
(8) אL,, A א,$א,،, א,4$אR),STא,D אEA#,S'$א+74
(9) אU#Vאא >9,"EAאא,I3،,אW,X$אAאאY,, ,I.א,אCZאE !,\3"]+743EW
(10) אVI$א،56א+7430P4
(11) QאF[Tא0. W,_,5`a[0 OO<#3$0+Ob،O5^אאWX$א KOI5[E<אOML
(12) אC+א86אA#57א Résumé La mise en œuvre de la règle finale qui conforme les décisions disciplinaires illégale prises par les pouvoirs publics et qui consiste à les modifier ou les supprimer, pose un problème important et la solution est difficile. En raison de l'incapacité du juge d'intervenir et de forcer l'administration de commette un acte de le refuser, et l'absence des méthodes directs de mise en œuvre. Afin de faire face à l'abus de l'administration. Ainsi, qu'il y a une inégalité dans la relation entre l'administration et le personnel (l'employé). En effet, dans la plupart de temps, l'administration interdit ou retard l'exécution et donne à l'employé une offre de solutions et d'idées contraires à celles du juge. En conséquence, le fonctionnaire n'a le choix que de suivre les solutions édicter hors l'avis du juge. 567 80 9 4 3 " !
(13)
(14)
(15)
(16)
(17) ــ#$ % & ' () $*+ ,-./0 121
(18) .
(19) 2009 7 א
(20) אא. 184. &7& ./,א0,1א0D4א.4אd O4 ./א56א+743FM Fd .>-F/ אAאe`,'@
(21) אAאאBאא#CE h',i אMQMj א+74
(22) ZCF5Q+74
(23) אAאfgQ56א ,,>א,,?,,א0,,1אU#,,1d,, F,,"kא,, O,,`0,,18,,C>,,? ,,+74
(24) אA,,אL,,,56אf,,l,`k49
(25) ,, אO,,>,?،#"+,,א7 ,א K01אU#V+74
(26) F8'CL
(27) [j א+74
(28) ZCF5
(29) ,,'@
(30) א,Hאא#Ck,:;AאאL56א45mF5Cא+5H O,,D3fא,,D,,,,'n ,,$אF,,א,,7X e,,[EO3,,i+,,א KAאo# אTא ،+,74
(31) אL,Aא]אא#,"MfאD' OI5gא#אא+H89 +743FM (,,,,5[e ,,א,,$אBאkא#,,DאF,,C0,, E2L320FA,,$אO
(32) ,, #"+,,א 0I/,
(33) $א2008L02L25Est,$אE09L08F,CF,א0, E282FA$אE281FA$א ,iN,+743:,iL,u-, ,4,6א,אא,$אBאkא#,DאFC ,5[Tא+,743a,vE,`@$א,+74
(34) א:-,א03! אא/ AאאwMd,, G,,D#a,,6א,,'1،R,,xאF,,אR),,S,,<A-,,א A,,A,,[א,,5$א,,H+,,74
(35) א#,, ,,13y,,א,,`,, 1,, ,,H'
(36) אM,,5[+,,74
(37) ,, IאA,,אaI
(38) ,, א0,,5*QO,,;`,,
(39) ,, Iא QO,,8,,,,'V7-,,,,אW,,X$אz,, MA,,M,,'@
(40) אא#,,אk,,:;L/,,C ,#53d, +74
(41) אLI6
(42) א א#:H<k/אL
(43) [05* ,,<אL,{#,7+,אAאאZ
(44) , א,,' B1 ,אY,, 8-,7א,'$ ,,, א[|אO,,, 5[+,,,743L,,,,,,I6,,, AאאL,,,}:/,,,QFאא -,אא#,אE,א,I5^,אא,`#:אO
(45) , #", א+H
(46) Z
(47) Q L,k/,א0,5*QO,,C#$א0 F"L
(48) ?W1983L06L27~
(49) K, , א#?G`$א/אEO-`a[./אא#V0 Qא R-,
(50) NQא,1 ,אf,b,7 85=,,56אא+,H89k/אF` E1F?8
(51) אאא0Z/` ]+,H8,9 +,743,אVAאא,`,[EO;`،e' L'3#3 8,9I
(52) ,45mF5+א[אe#1אA[א אF`5[Tא 567 80 9 4 3 " !
(53)
(54)
(55)
(56)
(57) ــ#$ % & ' () $*+ ,-./0 121
(58) .
(59) 2009 7 א
(60) אא. 185. @,1xאn, Lt $אאCe'1
(61) d
(62) אe#1+74
(63) אE ,א,I5^,אא,`#:אO,3"I"+74
(64) א0P4
(65) QאE89I
(66) $א ,,<1,, QO,,M%,,[?W,,1997L04L13~,,
(67) -,,אא#,,אE EY,,6א,,אא,,`#:./,,א,,
(68) DQאG#=,,
(69) אk,,<L,,אא ,אאBאא#,א+,743L,H'DO3B א#:AאאL56א ,אא,`#:אBאא#,CB/,
(70) $a,9
(71) Q`אFM%[H<U14$א 0,-,+,אO`/$אk=אAA!.6אאI5^\אI ,,\
(72) 4 א#-,,4#,,N,,D0,, 1 ,,אf,,b,,D0,, ,,,, I1,, KE2F? Iא1 אt $ 0,,, ]-,,,,,,$|א,,,[Q{א#,,,7Fאא,,,<0,,,5*W,,,5` AאאBאא#,Ck,:;,<אO,/,$אk=,אA,A!.,[,.5[ IאH א؟#א99אY
(73) DאB[4I/
(74) $א
(75) @'א O,,<CG1
(76) ,,QF@=,,אא+,,HE,,,i.,,,,56,,Iא,,א E3F؟+74
(77) אO875F]-. 8 9: ; ! " #$ %& <= >?1 ()#* ) #$ + ,- ,. /0 !. ,,,אא./,,,אBאא#,,,א،,,,5[Tא+,,,7430,,,AאאG,,,4
(78) ,,,C A-,,א,,,'@
(79) אAאאBאא#,,CE./,,א0,,1א0,,,,4א,,.4א L,,,,H'DM0,,5*Z,,`،,,Cj,,,,# ,,4
(80) אF,,5،,,4 ،F,5F,l+,74
(81) , `
(82) !א،d, &
(83) , QA,$א+74
(84) א ,4H,4
(85) אj,
(86) ،C F"k אe.0 N45m Kt 3#Q،#=. ,,\[,,'O,,ZNe,,[O,,DF,,7 ,,3,,4
(87) אF,,5,,C ,,4,,3|Aאא0,,-,,אP,,4
(88) QאF;,,`,,0,, O,,`/,,$אk=,,א W#=א0 Iv#`
(89) d F5،t. ,,.4א,,אאBא#,,$א,,5[Tא+,,7430,,P,,4
(90) Q'א,, WQ K,'@
(91) אAאאBאא#CE./א01א04א 567 80 9 4 3 " !
(92)
(93)
(94)
(95)
(96) ــ#$ % & ' () $*+ ,-./0 121
(97) .
(98) 2009 7 א
(99) אא. 186. ,,,5[Aאאt ,,,$,,,3#$א+,,,74
(100) א0,,,P,,,4
(101) Qא#,,,SW,,, ,'@
(102) אAאאBאא#CE./א01א4א.4אאא ,אאBא#,$א,5[Tא+,7430,P,4
(103) Q 'אWaTא1$א W,'@
(104) אAאאBאא#CE./א01א04א.4א Bאא#,,א،,,5[Tא+,,743F,,[Tא,,EAאאL,,8&
(105) ,,,,C ,,3אא#Ck,,:;,, ,,
(106) $אH,,<A-,,א,,.4א,,אא./,,א ،O,3 אkא#,Dא-, wM, Mא+,H,,7X e,[EA-,א,'@
(107) א KO[ZאCאאwM E+,74
(108) , א
(109) !אAאאW,_,CW+,74
(110) ,
(111) &א, Qא,L1 h&-,,
(112) ,, M,,'א,, Tא,,[wM,,`4
(113) ,,3y,,אBQ,,6א,, ,v0, א#,אk,:Mאא./,אא#א+743WC،#=
(114) א +,7430,AאאP,4
(115) Q,IBQ,[,42
(116) 4yאBאj$]א+H،א ،,,'@
(117) אO,3א# k,:;,4 A-א.4אאאBאא#א5[Tא WO3@ I"[א4א0 +74
(118)
(119) &אQ e,,&
(120) 3Bאj,, Z,,,,4HFMW+, 74
(121) ,,
(122) &א,, Qא,, J WH،`
(123) &אQא ,,,5[k,,,:M،8,,,3O,,,-,,,W#=,,,
(124) אh&-,,,
(125) א, ,,1 e,[E,,'@3אMא#,Ck,:;5[-FO9
(126) אא ,,V-,,
(127) Q,,6]א+,,HE،O,,
(128) \[,,56אא+,,h',,i،,,W,,X. KE4F/$א# TאAd n $D#@56א+743 QMG,C, L,# ,Q,,'@
(129) אאאא#אFH אA` , ,[E8,9I
(130) 3A,]א+,HL,Bאk49
(131) , א,OאQM،]אiMuC0. ./,א,5[Tא+,743,D#, א+,743,,'@
(132) אא#,אi אM K,'@
(133) א4 E5FאאBאא#אk:; P,< FMW@,
(134) אאא./,אא#,א,56א+,743W,C,2 ,B,f4$א,.F M8\
(135) ,$אk/,אB,< 0, +74
(136) אWC Pf,3،8\
(137) ,$אk/,אE+74
(138) אWC8. EB[Z-G
(139) I
(140) א O,(4,א, א+,H،E6F,אא,I5^א.d+"،R-
(141) NQא ,,`#:א.#,, ,?-,,4,$אBאkא#,,DאF,C0,, E2L283FA,$אE 567 80 9 4 3 " !
(142)
(143)
(144)
(145)
(146) ــ#$ % & ' () $*+ ,-./0 121
(147) .
(148) 187. 2009 7 א
(149) אא. ,M،,$א0, h#,i,VLk4،.49
(150) א7-# @Fאא ?/,,6,,C,,0,, ،א#,,VTא/,,،O,,`F,,1$אא#,,א+,,743 #=,F| HM،+74
(151) אMF;`A#7א0 h<אI" KE7F
(152) "D
(153) 4
(154) א05* ،,$אAאא8,9m,אW,X$א#,V0, ,א,V,3, O,,|אCאF،]>,,?F,,א0I/,,
(155) g#,,i7-,,F,5F|=,, K#S@ Kkא#DאAאא89mאWX$אא+-xא/[A#<, 1^א#K[ א1\
(156) Z#
(157) א1 א.# J,D K/ ,v-CWאv0 ./אא#א56אk:M–3 אM#,, k,,:M+,,743,,iEY,, א#,,C,,5[k,,:;אא#,,C,,א ,, W,,X L,,,,א#א,,99אY
(158) D,,אY
(159) ,,,,[M} ,,
(160) ,,,'@3 ,4HF53Q
(161) ،56א+743V8&
(162) 6]א+H7`، KE8FP4
(163) QאE*#D F,IאGCאאwMPD#W
(164) &אZIBQ[L ./,א,5[H+,743Fa,&
(165) `AאאL,#,13,CBQ[4H ,3,6]א+,HE,0, ?#,,,'@3, #, k,:;.4אאא +,74
(166) א,EB[Z-]א+HH1EFאFOQMF7 WY
(167) א0#-4א;[אj P4
(168) QאF"L
(169). 2.
(170) 4אGk:MAאאG1
(171) 3QCW+74
(172) אG4BiD J1 A|,`/, ' ,d, O,.:;L/,C+א,'@
(173) אא#אL3|3yא ,`O,.:;-,א,56אO,`F,1$א,,'@
(174) אא#אi0 V k/,,א,,5[F,5d+,,8,&,,C>,,?2.,
(175) ,,6]א+,HL,,,3| 0,, ,,6]א+,,HE,,Q،,,Iא,,[4א0,, O,,,,ICQ،,,#Kאא 8"=,,$אW,,
(176) ,,3h&-,,א-,,E,, TאG,,<P#=,,$א8N,,3 8-,,,gF0,,, ,,,DQ M E9Fk,,,:א,,,5[L,,,,,,'3|$א,,,4,,,4א ]+,,,H' ,,,]+,,,743G1
(177) ,,,FF./,,,C,,,5[L,,,# ,,,،# ,,, KE10FAאאODא3yאB-א. 567 80 9 4 3 " !
(178)
(179)
(180)
(181)
(182) ــ#$ % & ' () $*+ ,-./0 121
(183) .
(184) 2009 7 א
(185) אא. 188. QWH+7438&
(186) /#K2.
(187) a-6+74
(188) א0P4
(189) Q אJ2 5[F" אM+74
(190) 56אC+74
(191) א0P4
(192) Q*א#D#`
(193) 3 , 8&
(194) ,/,,#K2.,
(195) wMt,,,'@
(196) אאא#Ik:א E2 ,,4]k,,:M,,1$א,,,'@
(197) אא#,,אF,," אMd,, E11FZ, I+,,74
(198) א Bאא#,,,]א+,,,`,,,אW,,,X$אAאאY,,,,,,C
(199) ,,,
(200) 43,,,'"# ,,,I K
(201) `01א05*-74$א -,א56א+743+
(202) CW+74
(203) E$אFC
(204) &אאQאL2 ،,$[א4א0 ]+743G4B'D,'@
(205) אאא#Ik: ,\
(206) F5M،C' +743F5Q6]א+HEO !א,,,
(207) QאF,,,5,,,6]א+,,,H,,,7`،AאאU,,,10,,,,,,DN#,,,N,,,Cא E8,,,,9I
(208) 3]+,,,,743Fu,,,,[#,,,,XO
(209) ,,,,<|א0,,,,5،,,,,45m+,,,74
(210) WI`O&<3a&4 א+H،`#Kא-)=
(211) &אQא &
(212) , Qאe&
(213) 30j 4HFMW+74
(214) C
(215) &אאQ 'א,L WIHI`Cאא &
(216) ,, Qאd,3-,)=
(217) &א,, Q-,W-,)=
(218) &א,, Qא, 1 @S0 yא،O 7אWX$O3 אF )(אSE \
(219) 3yא d,SQ،>א,1N,<# O,<# ،O,3I"56א+743wMt3F AאאG`[אF[Tא0 >9"EF5C-)=א%'אF/ 0, O,}'3#,,,56אd, F," אM,iN56א+743813wM >,,,?،O6-,,,,,,5&I-,,,NO,,,
(220) [E,,,HWX$,,,8-,,,
(221) 3,,, +,,,,743,,,{#,,,,:,,,א,,,,$אB,,,'אe,,,,
(222) )`،O,,, WV,,,
(223) $א A#=,,,,i+,,א,,'אk,, ,,[O,,,,C,, d,, a,,9 KE12F,,56א P-,QאO/`،'אV#SWC#SA#=aZNE
(224)
(225) Bאא#C KE13F,'@
(226) אO3אא#C8"L:+<א y,א,Dxא#KאE89I
(227) 3&
(228) Q]א+HW`#K
(229) &אQא,2 ,,wMt,
(230) `،,,,'@
(231) אא#,אk,:;,,<א,56א+,,74
(232) },,C Y,
(233) ,$א,7Xא,i4$א#`,3[EI"،]+7435 M Aאo,,6]א+,H,7`،]+,7430,AאאG,4
(234) I
(235) ``אWX$אz M KE14F*#D3|Q
(236) +74
(237) #
(238) \
(239) אEe6א 567 80 9 4 3 " !
(240)
(241)
(242)
(243)
(244) ــ#$ % & ' () $*+ ,-./0 121
(245) .
(246) 189. 2009 7 א
(247) אא. W+74
(248) C
(249) &אאZIBQ[,L E8,9I
(250) +,74
(251) אEa5,SM,D,,3|,C
(252) &אאQ]א+H ،,,,'@
(253) אא#,,אk,,:;,,<אאאא#,,א,,56אU,,14 {,,I? ,,K4א,,Bא#1,,<אP,,C0,, =,,xא،,,$אBא,,I
(254) Qא#`,,3,, WO3@ א+H،א k,D אMW.,4אאא./,אא#,א56אU14 {I? J1 א#,,אk,,:;,,<א.,,4אאא./,,אא#,,א,,56אU,,14. ,, F,,53+,,74
(255) א,,IF,,`]+,,743,,75א,,&,,<א,,,'@
(256) א ,,,56אא+,,,H+,,,743EC,,,i،,,,4א4 ,,,[Aאאu,,, א,,, A# ,,,. א+,H85=,`،O,< +,74
(257) א,7",C14 ,g אM, ،א#א ]+,HE+,74
(258) אFאאk/,אY',،+,74
(259) א,IE,iP<$א +,74
(260) א8,אאא#,א,56אL/,
(261) n, LF5 6א k,:;,56אF@,O,3אא#CE,א,v]#,C, א+,H،E15FO,3[ אE !,`Bא+,+,74
(262) אO-4 + אU14$אEYQCאMא#C O', 0, Y', [56אL/
(263) L+74
(264) אא+Hkא#DMF5F , k,<E،O,.:;/,$א,'@
(265) אא#אO4
(266) +אP<$[אE ,,I5^אu,,CO,,`Q,,b،Aאא,,אW,,X$אF,,`#1אO,,Pf,,43 א#,א,56אא+,HL/,
(267) 7305*O"d HL M
(268) I" QL
(269) [# T א!אM،E16FO א# -3،O3[ אE+74
(270) א8אא ,Cy,א./,א, אy7
(271) ,3F,،VN >א73א אא# 73 KE17FOC14 EI? 7"EO3i Aאא,D,F,5CWO`a5SMD+74
(272) א0P4
(273) Q אJ2 h-,3]+7431$א.4א56א-[Q' H<5^א ",^א0, A-,א,5[TאwM' 4+74
(274) אEa5SMG`#' אאk/,,א,,D0,, A-,,א,,,,',,
(275) א,,5[،,,$א Eא#I
(276) , Qא،a5,S`א#,,56א-,Fwא،,6]א+H7` G,,,`L,,,,,,3|,,,$،#=,,, א#,,, +,,,74
(277) א0,,,P,,,4
(278) QאF,,,5+,,,74
(279) א KE18F+74
(280) WCא#0 a5Sא. 567 80 9 4 3 " !
(281)
(282)
(283)
(284)
(285) ــ#$ % & ' () $*+ ,-./0 121
(286) .
(287) 2009 7 א
(288) אא. 190. ,,,אא,,,5[' ,,4+,,,74
(289) אBQ5,,,SM,, CMAאאe,,,[0,,I` ,C،,,'@
(290) א,3אא#Ck:;
(291) $אd340 H<A-א.4א EQ5,SM,אא, אCMF#- EאאאI5^אB" Q،,56א+,743E,'D0
(292) 4389*QH<-א56א+743 W,CF,א,[3y,א8. אwMk\אFT
(293) t 3#@1N OI
(294) ,,F@,,S 8,,5a,,75 e,,[,,H,,`0,,1א،,,5[Tא+,,743 kא#,,D0, O,},g,,C,$אkO
(295) &-,$,O,,`F#,+,א, KE19F+74
(296) א K4א `Bא#1<אPC=N56א+7430P4
(297) Qא, 3 G,4
(298) FAאא, F#,.א !א، ,#`،#- EO#
(299) $א0 Wא 0 T,,aZ,,NM]+,,743L,,,,3|F,," אM ,,74א,,Dא,,5[+,,7430,, ,,'@3א#,Ck,:;/CC.אM5[+743O9 ،אK4א tFu=N אMA אא6אא7X e[EAאא0i Y7X$אC#z\
(300) ["אK4א0 TaZNMwMA+74
(301) א KE20F+74
(302) א0G4
(303) Fd L ,,,E,,,'$אא+,,,H#-,,, E,,,א,,,אא,,,I5^אB,,,",,, 0,,?Wa,,3%,,[19594,, #,,410E-,,א,,I5[،,,4 ,, 5[ ،./,,א,56א+,7438,1Fאאא#,,f,lQO,8,iTאF," QZ,,NMא,,`]+,,743L,,,,3|F,," אMO,,QM،F,,,,7 F,,"QM e,`# >, 8,13,4
(304) `,&""א,3+,
(305) ،¡א->א1N 0,,,5R,,,xא،#,,,7¡א-,,,אL,,,,,¡א-,,,א+,,,.4G,,,D>`,, d+,,F,,"FMF@=,,[א,,i{,,FH,,CA#/,,א,,3FA,,א# KE21F?8[ ,,4\
(306) +,74
(307) א0,,AאאP,4
(308) אFwM ,,#7א,א,,vH+, a,,QF,,"FM،,,א,,K4א،0,, Tא,,Bא#1,,<א8,,CZC,,[ P,I¡א-,#,`&/,FL@,3A#,א,אאF;`،A@אא1NL d+,,,,'3/,3G,,I אL,,,, אk,,'TאG,,f3F,,5 אEF,," אM KE22FAאאD0 3La-6אE5^@[א. 567 80 9 4 3 " !
(309)
(310)
(311)
(312)
(313) ــ#$ % & ' () $*+ ,-./0 121
(314) .
(315) 191. 2009 7 א
(316) אא. ,4
(317) AאאFMKKK?W#,.א !א,א,vBאא#,C,[MEkD ,Cu,"FM,T،, @,1N,53#3، ,74א,Dא,5[+,7430 ,Dאא+,743d, u,`, אM;`A56א+743E'DאuN O4G4
(318) ،j א+74
(319) א#X3F`F M؛K4א£7[HH KE23F?K4א0 TQZNMd EB אM #`,3,j,
(320) W,56א+,74
(321) , fZא$אBאI
(322) Qא#`3, 4 ,<אd, O,4 .,4אאא,56א+74
(323) fZא$אBאI
(324) Qא FT؛+,,74
(325) א0,,(
(326) ,,)$אW,,X$אW,,)
(327) ,,Cאj,, ,, ,,,'@3#,, k,,:; ,
(328) Ct ,']א+,H05،56א+743Fa'Ha$א#`3 >,,3،fZ,,א,,$א,,I
(329) QאL,,a-,,6!,,
(330) 3Aאא,,DFT،,,I.א Q%,,
(331) א,$א4 ,א,7E4 ,א7E+74
(332) #/אa$א KE24F
(333) א$א4 אa[ wM+74
(334) א#N@
(335) Fh- ,,E،Aאo,,h4,, ,,CP#=,,$אF,,4h/,,
(336) ]#,," e',, ,,ma d34 H<A-א.4אk/א5[+743[BQ6א ،0 T,8,¤FO@,S0 H+743F" אM,'@
(337) א3א# k:;
(338) $א a5,SM,D،]+743FaBi4Hu"אK4א ,,, fZא,,,$אBא,,,I
(339) Qא#`א,,,3,,,O,,,C14 {,,,I:،+,,,74
(340) אE ,`K+,74
(341) א, >:3F@S0 /#K2.
(342) a-6،+74
(343) א+,HF,5F|,Sא،05BQ6]א+HEAאאt P#=$א# ,,' O,,`,,א#3Fd+,,"،,,4 W ,,3FAאא,0 ,,P,,4
(344) Qא L,,,k49
(345) ,,, "P,,,4
(346) Qאא+,,,Hj,,,
(347) K,,, אk,,,'Tא,,, G,,,I אA א,,,. K אAא ,,.4א,,אאO,, 5[+,,743E,,<א1,, W,,9א,,1$א ,'@
(348) אAאאBאא#Ck:;<א אא,,56א+,,7435=,, ,,IH#,,K3e',, ,,C,, L,,AZ,, 0,I`،,אDA,0, ,'@
(349) אAאאא#Ck:;<אd O4 .4א ,אL,,H#5Aאא8IE8N
(350) Fd*Q<אF;`،[ 0, ،,56א+,743L,,H#5Fd,*Q،8,I0P4
(351) Qא8I 567 80 9 4 3 " !
(352)
(353)
(354)
(355)
(356) ــ#$ % & ' () $*+ ,-./0 121
(357) .
(358) 2009 7 א
(359) אא. 192. ,D אE#S'$א+74
(360) א8. _<אP#=$א875[ 5O5^"!א# W<9[0 ، א4$אR)STא ,,,,VI$אE.א,,,,אAאאd ,,,, ،Aאא,,,,D אE,,,,אW,,,,X$א ,,,3אא#Ck,,,:;,,,<א,,,.4א./,,,א,,,5[Tא+,,,743EW ,,,
(361) א KH+7430P4
(362) Q[אwMO`# Tא8-C+א،,'@
(363) א 8,,13F?-,,אא+,,HE0 ,,[¥,,
(364) 7א,,'
(365) ",,
(366) א,, Tא#"+,, h4,,b,,אM1,, Y,,Pא#-,,,,[א#,,K א,,?./,,א,,5[Tא+,,743 R-,e,'13O,IHL,<C،d 45 i-
(367) N'
(368) ¦ א1 ,3Pא#iH،5[0 ]- "א[|א3A#vC ,, ,,iN#,,X,,,,H8,,Y,, F,,5 #-,,L,,#-,,
(369) Q ,, Ed,, ,,5&
(370) ,,3,,I"],,XL,,8,,I3،,,I
(371) Dא-,,
(372) Cא e,,NwM#,,K]א+,,Ht,,3 ,,4Pא#-,,אא+,,H#,,K`،O,,א74O,,3C 0, ،#,N,[0, ,<[א0 Aאא0 8"YA#5`{3 k,'@O, C,4, !
(373) F,ly,א,6א,I4 8,",7X%[ ،,<א,4!,\y,א,ix'א, wMA\@אא3Q"O
(374) 7X 0, ,<אO,', ]א,, L,
(375) 7 ,`14 :
(376) )
(377) 3 K7 `e14. Pא#-,,אEAאא,, 0 ,,[¥,,
(378) 7א,,'
(379) ",,
(380) א,, TאY,,,,C WE89I
(381) 3yא<אY4 ,,<א0,, ,,"O,,P!,,
(382) 43G#=,,3א-,,
(383) אwMAאא,,I3F J1 8N3<I0-،H5`]5`O`u/34 i-
(384) Nא K<אC FO,,'13F@,,S0,, O,,4,,I5[FB,,C,, אMA@אא,,\3 J2 LG#=3א-
(385) O13wMI
(386)
(387) `A]אא#3QD' wMt ,'$אא+,HwMk,\
(388) Qא0, Z'
(389) , ,<א#,,"56אW¤. K
(390) D אEOI ,W,C,C#-,$א,א,vF9אA-]א+HwM' 4 h&-,3#=,3B-,
(391) א אM#=
(392) א1 אWC Fאi#$9[ A,,']א+,,HL,,#=,,'א,, AאאO,,
(393) '53אFe',, +,,@א,,1xאO,,` 567 80 9 4 3 " !
(394)
(395)
(396)
(397)
(398) ــ#$ % & ' () $*+ ,-./0 121
(399) .
(400) 193. 2009 7 א
(401) אא. F@,,SEe,,'1
(402) A#,,v,, ,,אCG/,,3,,H#=,,
(403) א1 ,,אFM?,, ,1 A-,,]אא+,Ha,IL,R#[F53،k[ אL`5א 8,, L,,,,iNBQ,,[E,,z#,,),,+74
(404) א1 ,,,,i#7א,,[3MF -,3F,&&,i]'
(405) @א1N0 O
(406) '53א א#Cd Mk\ ,,73FwMu,,Cא#,,t,,3I,, >,,?A#H,,K]א+,,HF M،,,D#@,, K?, #\
(407) א,, Iא0,, O,,W-,,
(408) 3,,
(409) ,, C,, א[|א#=,,
(410) אA,,א E72F4 ,E228F,CW, 1973L04L01 ,§אאאI5^א5[F KE77R34AאBא4 IxאIv 8,",<]א,i+,א56 אwM[א#iA\@אא3 J3 ,56אd, Z,NL,,IK43,אMאא#C-3F@I`IC 8,,753, P#=,,$אwMk,,\
(411) QאwM,,D[F,,IK4
(412)
(413) א1,, a,,I@ KאאIT#S'$אj א+74
(414) אf
(415) א0 OG
(416) I
(417) 3]+743 5=,,$]א+,Hh,<3E0 ,,[¥,
(418) 7א,'
(419) ",,
(420) א, Tא#1
(421) , ,#`,3B]א
(422) א+H8" 70AאאG`3L
(423) [?a` א d, ,56]א,b, , W,C wMI3C، אuCא0 >95א ,v,`#A#H,X,H،]/,
(424) +,7430,4I,<[א#,iG,4
(425) F@ ,3אא#Aאאu,D` ,4،wTאO3א4, +,4 ,#-, E,4א 0,, A,,Bא4,, aZ,,N],,
(426) 3,, ,,H،./,,C,,5[@L,,:3,,.4א U,1G ,3א, k א,אL,F,אG,C]אא4 ,F,",1 AאM,5[ ]#,#3E,MA,Sא,D,א,v,.,DL
(427) [A#HK]א+H ¥Z,iMe,A#,<wM#,K4א,
(428) 7 ،%,9אO, E,אa,I0,. ,,7",,D,,43Bא,,iu,,,,`،אאk/,,א,,KE>,,1N Q,5[T]א+,H0, /,F;`k/אא+HH-yא5[+74
(429) א K?Nא|א0 >9"E+743+743 0,,, ]-,,,,,,$|א,,,[Q{א#,,,7Fאא,,,<0,,,5*W,,,5` ,,'@
(430) אAאאBאא#,Ck,:O,/,$אk=,אA,A!.,[.5[ אIאH א؟#א99אY
(431) DאB[4I/
(432) $א KE25F؟+74
(433) אO875F]- O<CG1
(434) Q56Iא. 567 80 9 4 3 " !
(435)
(436)
(437)
(438)
(439) ــ#$ % & ' () $*+ ,-./0 121
(440) .
(441) 2009 7 א
(442) אא. 194. ,,56אF,," אM,,$,,`،7,,<A,,C5=,,$]א+,,H,,IHW,,
(443) _ ,,H,,I"A¡אא-,,,,5[,,i; א,,`،Aאא,,אW,,X$¡א-,, AאאF;,,,`،,,, א,,,7X,,,
(444) $אA#1/,,,$אB,,,f4$אO,,,3HEa,,,6א F,,,CE,,,R-,,,4$אBאkא#,,,D א,,,_א,,,,,,56א+,,,743G1
(445) ,,,3 8.,, wM@,,\3FG1
(446) ,,3,,I"-,,x!א,,\6אwM@,,\
(447) `E26FB,,`א#$א E,, Aאא,,3Q,,56אL/,,
(448) a,,ITא#,,NTא#,,S'$א+,,74
(449) א A&אא-,,,,$-,,,א,,,56א+,,,743>9,,,QK,,,56אא+,,,H+,,,743 -,א.,4א,56א,[EA5=$אIH#K3055=. א+,,H+,,7430,,5*W,,5`K,,,'@
(450) א,,Hא#Ck,,:;,,<אAאא,,< u,,CאE،,, א1 ,,אBאf,,
(451) G,,
(452) I
(453) 3y,,אAאא,,D אE,,56א ,,I"،,,a,,6אAאא8,,IE8N,,
(454) א,,<אL,,#,,Kg+,,א FQM،,, א,,4$אR),,STא,,D אE#,,S'$א+,,74
(455) א8.,, ,,43 P,,4
(456) א5=,, ,, 0,,א,,
(457) 5 W,, ,,#`Eאא,,<א ,,L,,a,,3u,,"FM،A#H,,K]א+,,HFT،O,, 5[+,,7430,,Aאא Ea,3;`،56אG
(458) I
(459) yאO/$אk=\א6Aא[|אאא d+,KO,,5^אW,X$אG, ,
(460) CZEA`אאk LuCא7 |א,[Qא,"@3wM, O,[{#,7$א,
(461) א#,K6א,?, ,<@א,\ WI`H#"+L
(462) S4`./C38. ./א5[ " Aאא#K3FVoie de fait $אk
(463) אQ[א7` ،A,O,h=
(464) 3+א1 א0 #\
(465) אE4I/?'
(466) אP#=$?>א 0,, ,,I,,<א#,,lF,,،R),,STא,, ,,'3# wMa!,,43,,;` 0,,5*,, ,,MO,,DF،א+,,Ha,,6א،],, EF,,5,,אאO
(467) :',i K3B א#?0 R)STאD אEOD3 ,3y,א1 ,א, .#א1 a-3QאwM<\@אC ,47[
(468) אZ,i
(469) )א, א,4 ,'V،O,I5[+74
(470) -
(471) )$אAאאD KE27F56א+74
(472) E.i א.#אFC#אE -,א،Aאא8,IL,:F, ,Iא,[4א0, , ,<אd,* ,5^אW,X$א0, ,VL,k,4d, ،5[0 ]i$7)$ Kf4$אEO 7&Fd*QOM%[،O. 567 80 9 4 3 " !
(473)
(474)
(475)
(476)
(477) ــ#$ % & ' () $*+ ,-./0 121
(478) .
(479) 195. 2009 7 א
(480) אא. ,,I5[,,,i+,,,א,,,,'@
(481) אא#,,,א+,,743W,,,CFd,,,*,,,I" ,,?]+,,743L,,Hא#,,iM،,,O,,\.
(482) A &אא,,3+,,א،O,,.:; Kk/א5[ 0,O,,5^אW,X$אVLk4–
(483) 56אd*I" K56א+7430AאאP4
(484) אkא#D0 >NTאא+Huiyאא#<Tא E01אFACOC4
(485) #- #`0 8"EP#=$א8`4 [ QMF,,5Q,,56א+,,743W,,CF.E28F]+,,743W,,CQאא,,56א ،,56א+743¨"א3L=¤yאא#<]#3k/`א# E0,,1אwMAאאk,,\
(486) ,, אא8,,5=,,$אC,,7
(487) 3QL,,
(488) [d,, KH+743C#E`He: F 5[Tא zZ,wMt,3Q,<א,M@,\yא8. ]א+HF£[Z +,א,'1"،,IC73G,4 #,vL,8,I3M،A9$א5=I+D Kkאא- L/F] FB45 O/# 1 W ,,,#7א,,,K4אE,,,5[Tא+,,,74
(489) ,,,ixא./,,,אF,,,\אL1 ,, #$אO4I,<،,zZ,,>`,3L,8,I،E29FA#H,,K]א+,H ,#7אP#=,$א ,v0, A-,א,5[Tא+,74
(490) Rxא1963L6L30E-אE766FC ,,5[Tא+,,74
(491) R,,xא1969L1L28E-,,א,, #$א،E30F ,,#7א,,א ,,4 0,,53wM ,,#7אP#=,,$א,,I,,CK, "אא,,^א0,, A-,,א =,
(492) ,.0, F,5
(493) 3K./,א,5[Tא+,743,I(
(494) _./C F,
(495) I K,8,",#, 0=,
(496) k/ 3E09F ,,,5[Tא+,,,7430,,,AאאP,,,4
(497) ,,,
(498) $א,,,,,,5^אB,,,'VE#,,,K43 wM#, TאG,`K+,74
(499) א0,AאאP,4
(500) 'אL#
(501) אAאa-3Qא O,,
(502) א,אאA!,DTא,[MP,4
(503) IO
(504) V[،# TאL/
(505) C אאM#fא O&
(506) , א+,א,1
(507) ,`،,56א+,743W,C
(508) K./,C,5[+7430 ,
(509) ,VL,k,4 P#=$©אyאU#1[אMP'3; #7אP#=$א k,,4،,,MA,,SאW ,,א,,4\אwMF ,,אF,,7X$א4,, F@=,, אO,, +,743,7"L,#,
(510) ,א,vwMkאf,א0, ¥/MVL O, ,D3،,,,56א+,,,743a,,,[,,,א,,,vA=,,,
(511) א،./,,,C,,,5[ KO 5[+743a[Aאoא0 BאSM 567 80 9 4 3 " !
(512)
(513)
(514)
(515)
(516) ــ#$ % & ' () $*+ ,-./0 121
(517) .
(518) 2009 7 א
(519) אא. 196. ,4 k=,;F,5QzZאFP<$אEY9['א0 'א# +,743O,8,753,I,`1 k/א8)
(520) F5M،F A ،O,
(521) א#"k/,£,7,
(522) 'H,5[#`,3F,:d, ،O 5[ ,5&IQ+א56אא+H،E31FO 5[|Qk/CICI` , אMa,6א,5 ,7,#K,`0, #,9",אWX$אO4 O KE32F I`5^אא+ O;`]+7431 k/אaN W+74
(523) א0P4
(524) Qא87#-$אP#=$א#bL2 0,, P,,4
(525) Qא8,,`#,,b#,,vL,,#-,,$אP#=,,$אW,,C #-,,
(526) Cא,,C Aאאא#,Ck,:;,<אd O4 אא56א+7430Aאא89m d,, a!,,'א6,,,,,,C,,*#DP,,4
(527) Qא8,,`,,'
(528) א،,,,'@
(529) א 1,,, ,,,[wM`,,,<d,,, ،#-,,, B,,,E123FA,,,$אL/,,,
(530) d 5[0 ]-$[|אQ*
(531) @"אyא<א
(532) א ,,56א,,\6,,7)$A]אא+,,)
(533) 3א#,,C8,,"k,,:M1 ,,O
(534) ,, I L,,56א،,אW,X$אO,4 O5^אVLk4d -א O,,5&I+74
(535) א04
(536) ''אyאא#<Tא0
(537) Aאא ,,56א,,i+,,א،F,,1$א,,,'@
(538) אא#,,א+,,743,,M،"+,,$א K]+743Bאkא#DM+)
(539) 3a!א3 AאאFQM،O.:; F@=,[א-,' ,4,$?אWF''O,8, ",I''
(540) , T"אt #1,,<א,,`d+,,،?Bא+,,k,,:א,,5[+,,743,,H,,אW,,X$אO,,4 k/,א,5[[|א,A!אאא,M5=$]א+H868N
(541) אwMP#=$א ,,#,,#3Ekא,,k,,DL,,k,,4d,, ¨،H+,,743wMA,,'$א ,
(542) ICH,73،,אk/,Cא[|אEAאאI
(543) 3QL
(544) [א ,,#,,C MAאאG,, =,,
(545) א#,,K P#=,,$א8N,,3+,,_א,,C،,,Iא +,74
(546) אF," אMk/,א,5[+,7430אIG4
(547) *0 Le'13.4D KOi-
(548) NאEZNא , #$אL/,
(549) d, #-, B,E123FA$א8
(550) d ¨C +,,7430,,א,,IG,,4
(551) *+,,אW,,X$אh',,i%,,،19524 ,,E123F,,C
(552) ,, ,,i,,،a!,,'א,6א,,
(553) ,,.4D,,*# ,,'53# ,,56א ,,D0,, H+,,7438,,13,,5[Tא+,,7430,,P,,4
(554) QאFא,,"t 1961 567 80 9 4 3 " !
(555)
(556)
(557)
(558)
(559) ــ#$ % & ' () $*+ ,-./0 121
(560) .
(561) 197. 2009 7 א
(562) אא. EO,5&I،FאC*#DY-
(563) )$אY IאY7X$א ,,'V-,,
(564) )$א,,I5^אwMA#,,S' ,,.4 א,,אG,,`e,,[,,6]א+,,H K1961
(565) 0 E72FAI א#,,iMF?W#,,C%,,[،d ,,$אא+,,H#-,,$אאאk/,,א,,",C A,،I ,DA>,1N,7 L,,14,56א+,743,L,#fא ,l,m،Yא,א0#` z#N0 O143$،O/$אk=א F0, O,(4,3I`BE123FA$א.VuGP#= >?ZI `,<א+,H،a!,'א6,,CO,
(566) 7XA1, 8I
(567) אWX 8"? D
(568) ,,،-,)S@,,1N,56א+,,7430,G,,4
(569) I$א#f,@א,,1N,'
(570) אwM K?E33FO'3|$אא#<Tא30ixאO
(571) E-)SO
(572) k. W,X 8,"a!,'א6,,C?#-, BE123FA$(א43 , 56א0, A-,א#, אTא+743WCEO
(573) 7X1 8I
(574) אI +,743W,C, #אa אTא8->N@3h.אאYאא5[ ,,Cd+,,"K-,,
(575) ,,D,,0,, ,,I5^א0,, ,,i#,, ,,5[ m# 5[+7430אIG4
(576) אIWX 8"a!'א6 56א+743F" אM#/L]א+M0 / #" K?WX$אR-
(577) NאEZNא# Tא WY
(578) *#D אA$א0I/
(579) 3 ,,5[+,,743W,,CE,,7X1,, W,,X$אaI
(580) ,, א,,*#DWwTא K5[Tא+7430IאP4
(581) Q*א#DW9אK./C #-4W3ªא#i4א#`א33'9|=O;`9*א#\' 4 4,א,I5u,`#,CK, ,7X `
(582) $אF5F{|7 a ,e,`# , NE,.א8IOM0 8"?O@אWX$א#-$א E8N,'-,4 O:,Se,#V0,אFאR)S[]א#3 ', M#-$א4אI5u/`0 K?e`#$אd+אאK4
(583) א EE34F7&-,,אB ,, t$אBאאM,,vk,, L,,,,אW,,X$א7,,i P,4
(584) Qא8,`E8,9I
(585) , ,#-,4KBE123FA$אe'13av א+,M~,3L,/ P#=$אj
(586) אK./א56א+7430 ,,,73,,,4#C,,,9,,,56א+,,,743Bאkא#,,,DM ,,,_אF(
(587) ,,,)$אW,,,X$א 567 80 9 4 3 " !
(588)
(589)
(590)
(591)
(592) ــ#$ % & ' () $*+ ,-./0 121
(593) .
(594) 2009 7 א
(595) אא. 198. +,,74
(596) א0,,P,,4
(597) Qא-,,C,,H,,4 %,,#-,,4K+, 74
(598) א0,,O,,4
(599) א Kd I3 W,X$אא+,M,HR,N5Skא#DM#`א3*# אP#=$א
(600) !א Fא+,,אא+,,HL,,,,,,k/,,אK#/,,,,L,,+,,74
(601) (
(602) ,,)$א +,743wM(
(603) ,)$אW,X$אO,'43,Hkא#,Dאא+,H0, -אFh<א،]+743 EO,R-,4$אא+,אK,.4 אt ,$אEZ
(604) Oi#7[א3M56א :-, ,,+$אA-,,אFZ;,,k,,7
(605) "QאO,,4L,,4:QB,,E2L123FA,,$א ,%,[,אa,'C#,S0, V#,Sא+,א,,MK5&+74
(606) א ,<K+74
(607) א0WX$אP4
(608) אL<א4 a
(609) yא4#א9 K+74
(610) א+74
(611) אa[WX$א-C0%&'F Bאkא#,DME63FA,$א0, 99אA#7אO
(612) #-$אP#=$א8`4 [ QB,E123FA,$אE,M=$א.א# אאI`?F53".4D ,,<,,.4 א,,אG,,`,, א,,4א,,.,,א,,.4>א,,:f,,l k,4O4 uC&4D4 }'/אaD[)
Documents relatifs
For most environmental determinants (e.g. electronic games at home, living in a cul-de-sac, playground area at school) there is no evidence or inconsistent evidence for an
The comprehensive introductory study written by Otto Zwartjes and José Antonio Flores Farfán starts with a vast “Introduction” about the reasons why one should reprint and/or read
1.. A significant amount of research on substrate influence in creole genesis has been carried out over the past 30 years. This research has mainly focused on the morphosyntactic
كﻟذﻧأ ﺔﯾرﺋازﺟﻟا ﺔﻋﺎﻧﺻﻠﻟ ضﺑﺎﻧﻟا بﻠﻘﻟا ﺎﻫزﺎﺟﻧا مﺗ ﻲﺗﻟا ﺔﯾﻋﺎﻧﺻﻟا قطﺎﻧﻣﻟا رﺑﺗﻌﺗ ﻰﻠﻋ تﻌﺑرﺗ دﻗو ﺔﻣﺎﻫ تﺎﺣﺎﺳﻣ مﺎﻋ ﻲﻓ ، ﻲﺿارﻷا نﻣ 1973 ﻰﻣﺳﯾ ﺎﻣ ترﻬظ
L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non, émanant des
Under forced ventilation conditions, the cycling water mist discharge showed a substantial improvement in extinguishing the shielded spray fire compared to the continuous water
can pass to the limit directly on arbitrarily large interval of time from the global solution of (NLS) in the energy space towards the solution of KdV in the energy space
Keywords: Brain shift; elastic properties; soft tissue characterization; inverse finite element;..