HAL Id: hal-02719701
https://hal.inrae.fr/hal-02719701
Submitted on 1 Jun 2020
HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access
archive for the deposit and dissemination of
sci-entific research documents, whether they are
pub-lished or not. The documents may come from
teaching and research institutions in France or
abroad, or from public or private research centers.
L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est
destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents
scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non,
émanant des établissements d’enseignement et de
recherche français ou étrangers, des laboratoires
publics ou privés.
Physiological studies on the sex-linked dwarfism of the
fowl : a review on the search for the gene’s primary
effect.
M. Tixier-Boichard, L.M. Huybrechts, E. Kühn, Eddy Decuypere, J. Charrier,
P. Mongin
To cite this version:
Review article
Physiological
studies
on
the sex-linked dwarfism
of the fowl:
a
review
on
the search for the
gene’s
primary
effect
M.
Tixier-Boichard
L.M.
Huybrechts
E. Kühn
2
E.
Decuypere
3
J.
Charrier
P.
Mongin
1 Institut National de la Recherche
Agronomique,
Laboratoire deGénétique Factorielle,
78350Jouy-en-Josas,
France;2
Zoological Institute,
Laboratory
ofComparative Endocrinology,
Naamsestraat 61, 3000 Leuven,Belgium;
3
Laboratory
forPhysiology
of Domestic Animais, Kardinaal Mercierlaan 92, 3030 Heverlee,Belgium;
4Institut National de la Recherche
Agronomique,
Station dePhysiologie
de la Croissance, 9place
Vala, 34060
Montpellier, France;
5 Institut National de la Recherche
Agronomique,
Station de Recherches Avicoles, Centre de Recherches deNouzilly,
37380 Monnaie, France(received
31May
1988,accepted
26September
1988)Summary —
The results obtained in the last 10 yars on theendocrinological
and metabolic effectsof the sex-linked dwarf gene of the fowl are reviewed in order to
identify
its mode of action ongrowth
and other traits.Among
the main factors involved ingrowth regulation, thyroid
hormones, T4 and T3,growth
hor-mone, GH, and its relatedgrowth
factor, IGF-I, were the most studied in dwarfs. These birds are characterizedby
lowcirculating
levels of T3 and IGF-I inspite
of normal or even increased levels of T4 and GH. The T3deficiency
isexplained by
a lowerperipheral activity
of T4 monodeiodination which could be related to an abnormal T4uptake by
the cell, particularly thehepatocyte.
The lowproduction
of IGF-I could be related to a deficient GH receptor, assuggested by
the decreased GHbinding
observed in the liver of dwarf birds. Both T3 and IGF-Isynthesis
may share commonpath-ways since
thyroidectomy
also decreases IGF-I level while a GHinjection
stimulates the T4 to T3 monodeiodination in the normalembryo
but not in the dwarf. Further studies are needed on the GHreceptor and the T4
uptake
in thehepatic
cell toidentify
the commonpoint
where the dwarf gene could act. Ovulation rate andlipomobilisation
are decreased in adult dwarfs but thesefindings
arenot yet
easily
related to theendocrinological changes
observedduring growth.
A
complementary approach
to compare the genotypes would be to study the DNApolymorphism
using
available molecularprobes
sex-Ilnked gene - dwarfism - chicken -
endocrinology
Résumé —
Synthèse
des étudesphysiologiques
du nanisme Ilé au sexe chez lapoule
en vue de la recherche de l’effetprimaire
dugène.
Larécapitulation
des résultats obtenusdepuis
dixans sur les effets hormonaux et
métaboliques
dugène
de nanisme lié au sexe chez lapoule
Parmi les
principaux
facteurs endocriniens affectant la croissance, les hormonesthyroidiennes,
T4 et T3, l’hormone de croissance, GH, et le facteur de croissance IGF I ont été lesplus
étudiés chez les nains. Ces animaux montrent de faibles taux circulants de T3 et d’IGFmalgré
des taux nor-maux voire augmentés de T4 et de GH. La diminution de T3s’explique
par une moindre monodeio-dinationpériphérique
de T4,probablement
reliée à unedisponibilité
insuffisante de T4 dans lacel-lule
hépatique.
La diminution d’IGFpourrait
êtrerapprochée
du déficit enrécepteurs
de GH,expérimentalement
démontré chez les nains. Lessynthèses
de T3 et d’IGFI pourraient
partagerdes voies communes car la
thyroidectomie
diminue aussi l’IGF circulante alors qu’uneinjection
deGH stimule la monodeiodination de T4 en T3 chez
l’embryon
normal, mais pas chez le nain. Lesétudes du
récepteur
à GH et des mécanismes d’entrée de T4 dansl’hépatocyte
doivent êtrepour-suivies pour
préciser
lepoint
commun oùpourrait
intervenir legène
de nanisme. La diminution du taux d’ovulation et de lalipomobilisation
observée chez l’adulte nain est encore malexpliquée.
Une
approche complémentaire
pour comparer lesgénotypes
serait d’étudier lepolymorphisme
deI ADN avec les sondes moléculaires
disponibles.
nanisme -
gène
lié au sexe -poulet - endocrinologie
Introduction
The sex-linked mutant gene
(d! causing
dwarfism in the fowl(Gallus
domesticus)
wasfirst described
by
Hutt(1959).
It has been shown to occur in differentpopulations
around theworld,
as reviewedby
Guillaume(1976).
It has beengenerally
assumed that dwarf mutations of differentorigin
correspond
to the same gene. Alarge
number ofgenetic,
zootechnical andphysiological
studies havealready
been carried out that have led to the commercial use of the mutation in the maternal lines of the broilerindustry.
However,
the mode of action of the gene has notyet
beenprecisely
defined. Suchknowledge
wouldhave both
applied
and fundamental consequences. Practical consequences would be todetermine the effects of the gene on other traits such as ovulation rate.
The identification of the
protein directly
modifiedby
the gene wouldprovide
a basis for the molecularcloning
of the gene: aprobe
for the sex-linked dwarf mutation would beuseful to compare the different mutants known in the world and
eventually
to prove theiridentity. Cloning
the gene would alsoprovide
a tool togenetically
manipulate
growth
in birds. From a moregeneral point
ofview,
dwarfism can also be used as a model tounderstand
growth regulation.
This review will
mainly
deal with the results of the last 10 years that have been ob-tained onendocrinological
and metabolic effects of the gene. The main factors involved ingrowth
regulation
will first bepresented
in the normalchicken,
then the modifications observed in thegrowing
dwarf chick will be described. Asynthesis
of these modifications mayhelp
to derive aworking
hypothesis
on theprobable primary
effect of the gene. Some data obtained in the adult dwarf hen will then bebriefly
considered in connection with thephysiological changes
which are known in the dwarf chick.Finally,
furtherexperi-ments aimed at
testing
ourhypothesis
can beconsidered,
in the field ofphysiology
andperhaps
also of molecularbiology.
Hormones involved in
growth
in chickenAccording
to Scanes et al.(1984),
growth
hormone(GH)
on the one hand andthyroid
for the normal
growth
of a chick. Growth factors arebeing
increasingly
studied,
such asinsulin-like
growth
factors I andII,
IGF-Ibeing
also calledsomatomedin-C,
epidermal
growth
factor(EGF),
nervegrowth
factor(NGF)
or vitamin D metabolites. Otherimportant
hormones such asinsulin,
glucocorticoids
or steroids alsoplay a
role ingrowth
regula-tion. Thesynthesis
and release of GHby
thepituitary
isregulated by hypothalamic
pep-tides,
in astimulating
manner forgrowth
hormonereleasing
factor(GRF)
andthyrotro-phin
releasing
hormone(TRH),
in aninhibitory
manner for somatostatin(SRIF).
The roles of vaso-active intestinalpeptide
(VIP)
andprolactin
remain to be clarified so far asgrowth
is concerned. These different hormones andgrowth
factors have beenpresented
inFigure
1,
with theirrelationships
and their sites ofsynthesis.
Some comments appearparticularly
relevant in view of astudy
on the dwarf gene: thestimulating
role of human GRF and TRH on GH secretion has been shown in several mammalianspecies
and in chicken. Growth hormone elicits thesynthesis
of IGF-I in the rat liver(Schalch
etal.,
1979;
Mathewset al.,
1986),
but other tissues are also able toproduce
IGF-I. In the chic-ken it hasrecently
been demonstrated that an intravenousinjection
of GH was also able to increase theplasma
concentration of IGF-I(Huybrechts
et al.,
1988).
The chickenthy-roid
gland
mainly
releasestetraiodothyronine (T4)
in thebloodstream,
together
withonly
a small amount of
triiodothyronine (T3) according
to Lam et al.(1986).
Themajor
propor-tion ofcirculating
T3 isproduced by peripheral
monodeiodination,
which takesplace
in the liver and in other tissues. Both T3 and IGF-I exert anegative
feed-back effect on GH secretion(Harvey,
1983; Buonomo et al.,
1987).
Effects of the sex-linked dwarf mutation
during growth
State of
knowledge
in 1976According
to the reviewby
Guillaume(1976),
dwarf chicks exhibitedhypothyroidism
which could not be
entirely
heldresponsible
for the dwarfism. Nosignificant deficiency
was found at the level of the
thyroid gland.
The saturation status of thethyroid
hormonebinding
protein
was used as a test to measuretriidothyronine plasma
level and dwarfs showedhigher
in vitrouptake
of
T3 than the normal birds(Grandhi
andBrown,
1975a).
However,
the authorssuggested
a failure to utilizethyroid
hormones(Grandhi
andBrown,
1975b)
or a difference in the cellulartransport
of T3 or T4(Grandhi
etal.,
1975).
Treatment with iodinated
proteins
(protamone)
could notcompensate
for the finalgrowth
retardation of dwarfs. The aviangrowth
hormone was notpurified
until 1974. No directimmunoassay
of GH had beenperformed
on dwarf birds. Somatomedins were known but couldonly
be studiedby biological
assay: serum from dwarf chicks seemed to be able toenhance
sulphation
in chickcartilage
as well as or even better than serum from normal chicks. Theworking
hypothesis
was thus a defect in tissuesensitivity
togrowth
factors. This was inagreement
with the observation that the difference between dwarf andnor-mal birds remained after
hypophysectomy.
These data have now been
updated
following
the use of newtechnologies :
radioim-munoassays for T4 andT3,
GH(homologous),
IGF-I(heterologous),
assay forGH-recep-tors, in vitro
techniques
for cellphysiology.
It should be noted that many studies compare a dwarf to a normal strain.
However,
a more accurate and reliable evaluation of thegene’s
effect can be obtained from thecom-parison
between dwarf and normal fullsibs,
bom fromheterozygous
sires and dwarf dams. Alinkage
with the feather color gene,silver,
enables the distinction of dwarfs from normals to be made at theembryo
stage
(Huybrechts
etal.,
1986).
Twotypes
ofbirds,
broilers orlaying
strains,
are also studied which mayexplain
some of the differences bet-ween studies.Recent
endocrinological
studies on dwarf mutationThyroid
hormonesDescriptive study.
Circulating
levels of T3 and T4 did not differ between normal and dwarfembryos
from 18days
of age to the time ofhatching (Huybrechts
etal.,
1986).
However,
animportant
difference arose afterhatching:
the T3 level exhibited asignificant
increase in the normal chick that was not seen to the same extent in the dwarf. Dwarfs showed lower levels of T3 from the age of 3 to 9
weeks,
butslightly higher
levels of T4 from the age of 1 to 7 weeks.Many
authors now agree that sex-linked dwarf chicks have decreasedcirculating
levels of T3 but normal orslightly
increased levels of T4(May
andMarks, 1983;
Scanes etal., 1983;
Stewart etal., 1984;
Hoshino etal., 1986;
Lauterioet al.,
1986).
This hasjustified
thestudy
ofperipheral
monodeiodination in dwarfs.Peripheral
monodeiodination Thepathways
of
thyroid
hormone deiodination and theirregulation
are well described in the ratby
invivo
and in vitro studies(Visser
etal.,
1984).
tis-sues such as
liver,
kidney
ormuscle; type
II in the brain andpituitary;
type
III in the brain andplacenta.
In vitro studies have not beendeveloped
to the same extent in the chicken.According
to Fekkes ef aL(1982),
in the rat the same liver enzyme isresponsible
for the 5 and the 5’ deiodination(5-D
and5’-D) leading respectively
to reverse-T3(rT3),
inactive,
or
T3,
active.Circulating
level of rT3 was found to be similar and very low in normal and dwarfchicks,
suggesting
a rather normal 5-D in dwarfs(Hoshino
eta/.,
1986).
Theregu-lation of the 5’- or 5- site of deiodination is not
fully
understood,
but could be related tointracellular
pH (Visser
etal.,
1979).
Theregeneration
of the enzyme in its active formrequires sulfhydryl
groups(Visser
etal.,
1976),
which were shown to benormally
present
in the liver of dwarf birds(Decuypere,
unpublished data).
The deiodinationactivity
isinfluenced
by
feeding
status andtemperature:
fasting
decreases it andrefeeding
has astimulating
effect on 5’-D in the chicken(Decuypere
andKuhn,
1984).
Thisrefeeding
effect could be related to insulin rather than toglucose, according
to an in vitrostudy
in the rat(Sato
andRobbins,
1981
). Cold
also increases the deiodinationactivity (Rudas
and
Pethes,
1984, 1986).
Ovine
prolactin,
GH and also TRH were able to stimulateperipheral
monodeiodination in the chickembryo
and the adult chicken but not in thegrowing
chick(Kuhn
etal., 1983,
1988).
Indeed,
thesharp
increase in T3following
theperforation
of the inner shellmem-brane
just
beforehatching
is due to ahigher
conversion rate of T4 to T3(Decuypere
et
al.,
1982).
This increase in T3 could be induced asearly
as the age of 18days
by
aninjection
of ovineprolactin
orgrowth
hormone,
but such a stimulation could not be obser-ved in dwarfembryos (Kuhn
et al.,
1986).
This lack of T3 response in dwarfs wasexplai-ned
by
a malfunction at the level of theperipheral
monodeiodination.Similarly,
a lower in vitroactivity
of the liver 5’-D was found in chicks of a dwarfLeghorn
straincompared
to a normalLeghorn
strain(Scanes
ef al.,
1983).
However,
thiscould
not be confirmed incomparing
dwarf and normal sibs within a strain ofbrown-egg
layers
at4,
8 and 12weeks of age
(Decuypere
et al.,
1986).
The in vitro assay wasperformed
on the superna-tant fraction obtained aftercentrifugation
ofhomogenized
livertissue,
and in thissystem
the enzyme was shown to bepresent
and to worknormally.
However,
itsactivity
appea-red much appea-reduced in its cellular environment(i.e.,
invivo).
This couldsuggest
a defect in the cellular environment of the enzyme and may inparticular
raise thequestion
of theavailability
of T4 as a substrate to the enzyme. The T4uptake
intohepatic
cell has been shown todepend
on both apassive
diffusion process and an active mechanismrequiring
ATP.Furthermore,
in rats, thespecific hepatic
receptor
sites for T4 may be different from the sites for T3(Gharbi
andTorresani, 1979;
Krenning
et al.,
1978, 1981
). A
defect at this level would be inagreement
with a normal in vitro but reduced in vivodeiodination,
asfound in dwarfs. It is
interesting
to note that thehypothyroidism
of dwarfs is not related tothyroid, but
to theperipheral
monodeiodinationactivity
that was not studied untilrecently
in relation to fowl dwarfism.Stimulation
experiments.
The T4 release could be stimulatedby
TRH both in normal and dwarfchicks,
with atendency
to show adelayed
increase of T4 in dwarfs(Michels
et
al., 1986;
Hoshino etal.,
1986). Depending
on age, TRH had no effect on T3 level in young chicks and elicited aslight
increase of T3 at 11 weeks of age in normal birdsonly,
again suggesting
a lowerability
of dwards to convert T4 into T3.Supplementation
experiments. Dietary
T4 did notsignificantly change
thegrowth
curveof dwarf chicks from 1 to 9 weeks of age;
however,
apositive
effect onbody weight
couldppm) significantly
depressed
growth (Leung
etal.,
1984a).
The T4 treatmentslightly
increased the T3
plasma
level ofdwarfs,
but to a much lesser extent than the stimulation found in normals. A T3dietary
treatment could stimulategrowth
of dwarf chicks at a dose of 0.1 or 0.3 ppm in some but not in all studies(Leung
etal., 1984;
Marsh etal., 1984b;
Bowen
et al., 1987;
Tixier-Boichard et al., submitted forpublication).
Agenotype
x treat-ment interaction was observed when normal chicks becamehyperthyroid
and had areduced
growth
rate,
whilegrowth
of dwarf chicks wasimproved
or not affected.Higher
doses(1 -10 ppm)
had anegative
effect due to an inducedhyperthyroid
status in dwarfs(Leung
et al., 1984a;
Scaneset al., 1986;
Tixieret al.,
1986).
However,
consistentmeta-bolic effects were
observed,
suggesting
a normalsensitivity
of dwarf tissues toT3,
suchas an increased rectal
temperature,
a deterioration of feedefficiency,
a decrease in abdominal fat content, a decrease in GH level as anegative
feedback effect(Leung
et al., 1984a;
Tixieret al.,
1986).
This lastpoint
justified
the simultaneous administrationof GH in some
experiments
of T3 or T4supplementation (Marsh
etal., 1984a;
Bowenet
aL,
1987).
Together
withT3,
GH succeeded instimulating growth
of dwarfchicks,
though
treated chicksdid
notfully
reach thebody
weight
of the control normal chicks.Growth hormone and insulin-like
growth
factor IDescriptive
studies. Theplasma
levels of GH and IGF-I did not differ betweengeno-types
at the end of theembryonic
life(Huybrechts
etal.,
1987)
as hadalready
beenobserved in
thyroid
hormones.Indeed,
no difference inbody weight
appears athatching
between
genotypes.
Dwarf chicks showed a normal or evenhigher circulating
level of GH from the age of 3 to 9 weeks. The literature data show either asimilar
or an increasedGH
plasma
level in dwarfs ascompared
to normals(Hoshino
et al., 1982;
Scaneset al.,
1983;
Stewart etal., 1984;
Lauterio etal., 1986;
Bowen etal.,
1987).
However,
IGF-Iplasma
level wasalways
found to be reducedby
about 50%(Hoshino
etal., 1982;
Huy-brechts
et al., 1985a;
Bowenet al.,
1987).
These resultsclearly
show a deficientsynthe-sis of IGF-I in dwarf
birds,
which constitutes new informationregarding
the mutation. Thegrowth
hormone of dwarf chicks isimmunoreactive,
although
itsbioactivity
has notyet
been
proved,
butelectrophoretic
studiessuggested
agood similarity
between thecircula-ting growth
hormone found in dwarf and that found in normal birds(Hoshino
andSuzuki,
1982).
Stimulation studies. The increase in GH
plasma
level afterinjection
of hGRF or TRH was ofgreater
magnitude
and lastedlonger
in dwarf than in normal birds(Hoshino
et al.,
1984;
Huybrechts
et al.,
1985b).
TRH administration could also increase the GHplasma
level in adult dwarfhens,
but had no effect in normal hens(Harvey
et al., 1984;
Scaneset
al.,
1986).
These resultssuggested
that dwarfs showed ahigher sensitivity
togrowth
hormone
releasing
factors or agreater
pool
of GH because of their lower T3circulating
level,
whichnormally
exerts aninhibitory
action on GHsynthesis
and release in birds.Surgical
or chemicalthyroidectomy
has been shown topromote
TRH-induced GHsecre-tion in adult birds
(Harvey
etal.,
1988).
Furthermore,
thedietary
administration of T3 todwarf birds could decrease a TRH-induced GH secretion
(Scanes
etal., 1986;
Tixier-Boi-chard et
al.,
submitted forpublication).
The slower decrease of GHcirculating
level could also indicate a slower rate ofperipheral
utilization of the hormone.The stimulation of IGF-I
synthesis
by
GHappeared
to takeplace
indwarfs,
but therelative increase in IGF-I
plasma
level was much smaller than in normal birdsGH
receptors.
The lowsensitivity
toGH,
asrecently
describedby
Huybrechts
et al.(1988),
combined with thedeficiency
of basal IGF-Iproduction
indwarfs,
inspite
ofhigh
levels ofcirculating
GH,
couldsuggest
a lack of response of thehepatic
cell to GH.Indeed,
hepatic binding
of avian GH has been shown to bemarkedly
reduced or almost absent in dwarf birds of 2 different strains(F.C. Leung
etal.,
1987).
These results alsosuggested
a role for thegenetic background
since noGH-binding
at all was noticed in dwarfs from alaying
strain(Leghorn),
while a few dwarf birds from a broiler strainexhibi-ted a low
binding
level. The authors found ahigher
correlation betweengrowth
rate andhepatic
GHbinding
than betweengrowth
rate and GHplasma
level.However,
thepossi-bility
of adown-regulation
of the GHreceptors
by
the hormone itself cannotyet
be ruledout in dwarfs and needs further
investigation.
IGF
receptors.
Thereceptors
for IGF-I have notyet
beendirectly
studied in dwarf birds. In vitro studies did not show anysystematic
difference in the basal level ofcarti-lage
sulfationactivity
or DNAsynthesis
between dwarfs and normals as shownby
a bet-ween-straincomparison
at 7 weeks of age(Hoshino
et al.,
1982)
andby
a within-straincomparison
from 17days
of incubation until 5 weeks of age(Charrier, unpublished
results;
Figure 2).
Theaddition
of normal chicken serum at the concentrations of 2.5 and 5% in the incubation medium ofcartilage
tended to stimulate thecartilage
activity
in dwarfs and innormals,
butonly
in a few cases so that nosignificant
differences could be established betweengenotypes
(Hoshino
et al., 1982;
Figure
3).
However,
the addition of 20% of normal chicken serum to the incubation medium could stimulate the sulfationonly
be enhancedby
the addition of 20% normal serum at 7 and 13weeks,
with nosigni-ficant differences between
genotypes.
These results showed a normal
activity
ofcartilage
indwarfs,
with a somewhathigher
sensitivity
to serumgrowth
factors,
butthey
should be confirmed on alarger sample
ofanimals,
with the use of definedgrowth
factors in the culture medium. It must also beemphasized
that these data were obtained fromlaying
strains and that the situationmight
differ inheavy
strains.Corticosteroids
Dwarf birds showed a lower
circulating
level of corticosterone from 1 to 6 weeks of age and no further difference at 12 weeks of age.Furthermore,
theplasma
corticosterone response to an acute heat stress at 12 weeks of age was lower in dwarfs than innor-mals. In vitro studies also
suggested
a decreased cellularsensitivity
to ACTH of the adrenalgland
in dwarfs ascompared
to a normal strain(Carsia
andWeber,
1986).
These results are notparticularly
related to the decreasedgrowth
indwarfs,
but the behavioralaspects
and response to stress areinteresting
to consider.However,
age should be taken into account since adult dwarf hens were shown to havehigher
corticosteroneplasma
levels,
in a fed state as well asduring
starvation(Rombauts
et al.,
1983).
Insulin
Dwarf birds showed rather lower levels of insulin after
refeeding
or aglucose
load(Simon,
1983).
However,
glucose plasma
level was not different from the control aftergenotypes,
but it lastedslightly longer
in dwarfs beforereturning
to the same basallevel,
90 minutes after the initial load. These results
suggested
an increasedsensitivity
to insu-lin action that could be related to an inefficientgrowth
hormone.Summary
of the effects of the dwarf geneduring growth
The modifications induced
by
the sex-linked dwarf geneduring growth
arepresented
inTable I. The Mendelian inheritance of dwarfism
suggests
the search for asingle
abnor-mality
which couldexplain
the different effects observed. On the onehand,
dwarfs havea reduced
synthesis
of T3 in the presence of an increased T4level,
which could be rela-ted to lower in vitro monodeiodinationactivity,
inspite
of the presence of the enzyme; onthe other
hand,
thesynthesis
of IGF-I isdepressed
and the GHhepatic binding activity
is reduced or almostabsent,
in the presence of a normal or even increased GHcirculating
level. Theprimary
effect of the gene may thus be at an interactionpoint
between the GH and IGF-I axis and thethyroid
hormones.In normal
birds,
chemical orsurgical
thyroidectomy
decreased thecirculating
level ofIGF-I but increased the GH level
(Decuypere
et al.,
1987).
Chemicalthyroidectomy
wasachieved
by
the administration of methimazole(MMI);
in that casegrowth
of normal chicks wasgreatly impaired
because notonly thyroid
hormones but also IGF-I levelswere decreased. This could
suggest
that a normalthyroid
function isrequired
for a pro-persynthesis
of IGF-I. Treatment of dwarf birdsby
T3 had astrong
negative
effect oneither
passive
or active(Krenning
etal.,
1982).
T4 administration to dwarf chicks hadsome
physiological
effects onbody weight,
on T3 and GHplasma
levels,
suggesting
that these birds were not resistant to the hormone. The T4 metabolismabnormality
in dwarfsdoes not seen to be an all-or-none trait. A normal
passive
transport
mayexplain
the effects observed with T4administration,
but the low level of T4 to T3 conversion and its lack of response to aninjection
of GH orprolactin
in theembryo
mayimply
a defect in aregulated
activetransport.
The absence of thereceptor
cannot be ruled out, but the defect could be due to achange
inreceptor
affinity,
or to a modifiedregulation
process at a level which hasyet
to be determined.Reciprocally,
GH has been shown to stimulate the T4 to T3 conversion in the normalembryo,
with no effect in the dwarf. In thechick,
this GH effect is nolonger
seen, but the conversion of T4 into T3 occurs at a muchhigher
rate than in theembryo.
Is itpossible
that ahypothetical
positive
effect of GH on the T4 to T3 deiodinationmight
nolonger
be enhancedby
exogenous hormone at thatage ?
Considering
thatgrowth
hormone may berequired
for a normalperipheral
deiodination of T4 intoT3,
a GHreceptor
defect couldthen be seen as a sufficient cause of both deficiencies in IGF-I and T3
production.
Theinjection
of GH into dwarfs of abrown-egg
type
layer
strain inducedonly
a small increase in thecirculating
level of IGF-I(Huybrechts
et al.,
1988).
This small effect alone could beseen as a sufficient reason to exclude the total absence of the
receptor
in dwarfs.How-ever, the results obtained in the
Leghorn
strainby
FC.Leung
etal.(1987) suggested
that the GHreceptor
could betotally
lacking
in dwarfs or have lost anybinding affinity
for thehormone,
but the results were not as clear-cut in the broiler strain. Furtherexperiments
are
required
to test thehypothesis
of an abnormal GHreceptor
in dwarfs. Aninteresting
stage
tostudy
would be the end of the incubationperiod
where the normal increase of T3production
does not takeplace
to the same extent in dwarfs and cannot be stimulatedby
GH as in normals.The
target
tissues such ascartilage
or muscle have not beenextensively
studied in dwarfs. Normalcartilage
may be able toproduce
its owngrowth
factors,
in an autocrinemanner
(Burch
et al.,
1986),
so that it would not beentirely dependent
on thecirculating
IGF-1.However,
thecirculating
IGF-I can stillplay a
role,
as shownby
the effects ofexo-genous IGF-I on
growth
of miniaturepoodles (Guier
et al.,
1987)
and ofhypophysecto-mized rats
(Schoenle
et al.,
1982).
In addition to in vitrostudies,
the simultaneouscom-pensation
for both T3 and IGF-I deficiencies in dwarfs wouldpermit
an in vivo evaluation of thegrowth potential
ofperipheral
tissues.Relationships
between the effects of the geneduring growth
and its effects in thelaying
hen will be considered below.Effects of the gene
during
thelaying
period
Descriptive
studiesThe sex-linked dwarf gene reduces
vitellogenesis
and ovulation rate(Guillaume,
1976;
on the basal
plasma
levels of1 7
f
i.estradiol,
which would beincreased,
and ofprogeste-rone, which would be decreased
(Tixier-Boichard
andRombauts,
1988). Consequently,
the ratio of estradiol to
progesterone
would behigher
in dwarfs. This result was mostnoticeable after the
laying
peak
whereas no trendappeared
earlier. Therelationship
of thischange
in thecirculating
levels of sex steroids to the otherendocrinological
effects of the mutation remains to be elucidated. It could also be a direct consequence of theredu-ced number of
fast-growing
ovarian follicles in the dwarf hen.Furthermore,
nosignificant
change
was observed in theluteinizing
hormoneplasma
level around the onset oflaying,
which could indicate aperipheral
defect;
but the ovariansensitivity
topituitary
factors hasnot been studied in the dwarf hen.
So far as
vitellogenesis
isconcerned,
the dwarfLeghorn
henappeared
to be moredependent
on the diet for thelipid
composition
of theyolk (Demarne
etal., 1984;
Bur-ghelle-Mayeur,
1988).
The in vitrolipolytic
andlipogenic
activities of theadipose
tissuewere
significantly
lower in dwarfLeghorn
hens whilehepatic
lipogenic
activity
was notchanged (Burghelle-Mayeur, 1988).
Adult dwarf hens have much less abdominal fat than their normal sisters(Merat
andRicard,
1974),
but theopposite
is observed at a youngage where the dwarf chicks are fatter
(Stewart
etal.,
1984).
The effect of the dwarf geneon
lipid
metabolismduring
growth
is notyet
clearly explained:
lipogenesis
was found tobe decreased in a dwarf line at 4 weeks of age
(Rosebrough
etal.,
1986),
butcontradic-tory
results were obtaineddepending
on thegenetic background
where the gene wasintroduced
(Calabotta
et al.,
1983).
Results seem to be more consistentregarding
lipoly-tic
activity
whichappeared
to be decreased in dwarf chicks(Guillaume,
1976;
Calabottaet
al.,
1983).
The balance betweenlipogenesis
andlipolysis
may differ between thegrowing
and thelaying periods,
but a constant feature in dwarfs seems to be a reducedability
to mobilize theirlipid
deposits.
This decreasedlipolytic
activity
may be related onthe one hand to the decreased T3
level,
since T3 islipolytic
in the chicken(Decuypere
et
al.,
1987),
and on the other hand to a deficientgrowth
hormone or to a defect of theGH
receptor
sincegrowth
hormone has been shown to be involved in thelipid
metabo-lism of thechicken,
with either alipolytic activity
in vivo(Campbell
andScanes,
1985)
and in vitro
(Hall
etal.,
1987),
or anantilipolytic
action in vitroconsisting.of
a short-terminhibition of the
glucagon-induced
lipolysis
in theadipose
tissue(Campbell
andScanes,
1987).
The role ofgrowth
hormone in theregulation
oflipolysis
could thus beinteresting
to
study
in the dwarf hen.Consequences
of the hormonal deficiencies associated with dwarfismduring
thelaying
period
Lower T3
production
T4
plasma
levels were increasedduring
thelaying period
in dwarfLeghorn
hens ascompared
to normalhens,
while thecirculating
levels of T3 were ratherdecreased,
thispattern
being
very close to the situation described at anearly
age(Decuypere,
unpub-lished
data).
In apreliminary experiment,
where a smallsample
of dwarf hens received0.1 ppm T3 in the diet from 18 to 22 weeks of age, the
plasma
level of T3 wasslightly
increased while the T4 level was
decreased,
but nosignificant
effect could be noticed onlaying
traits(Tixier-Boichard, unpublished
results).
An inverserelationship
isusually
broo-diness
(Sharp
andKlandorf,
1985). Thyroid
hormones seem to have aninhibitory
actionon the secretion of
luteinizing
hormone in the fowl(Harvey
etal.,
1983). They
alsoappeared
to have aninhibitory
effect on theestrogen-induced vitellogenin
synthesis
in the chickembryo
liver(Elbrecht
andLazier,
1985).
However,
a minimal level ofthyroid
hormones may be necessary for a chicken to exhibit a normal response to an
estrogen
challenge,
as shown in the obese strain of WhiteLeghorn
showing
inheritedhypothyroi-dism
(Schjeide
et al.,
1986).
Sex-linked dwarf cockerels have a T3deficiency,
but appea-red to be as sensitive as their normal half-brothers in response to aninjection
of17p-estradiol
(5 mg/kg)
at 7 weeks of age: theplasma
level oftriglycerides
reached amaximum 28 h after the
injection,
with a mean(± SEM)
of 5.88 ± 0.94g/l
in dwarfs ascompared
to 1.95 ± 0.72g/i
in untreated dwarfs and a mean of 7.19 t 0.28g/i
in normalsas
compared
to 1.96 ± 0.58g/i
in untreated normals(Tixier-Boichard, unpublished
results).
The
changes
inthyroid
metabolism due to the dwarf gene are noteasily
related to the effects of the gene onlaying
traits,
indicating
that therelationships
betweenthyroid
hor-mones and steroid hormones
during reproduction
should be further studied in the dwarf hen.Lower
IGF-I production
A
possible
role of IGF-I in thereproductive
function has notyet
beeninvestigated
in the chicken. Inmammals,
some studiessuggest
an IGF-I involvement in thereproductive
function,
as for instance thesynergism
with FollicleStimulating
Hormone to inducereceptors
forLuteinizing
Hormone in cultured ratgranulosa
cells(Adashi
et al.,
1985).
The
plasma
level of IGF-I has been found to be reduced in dwarfpullets
aged
15 and 18 8weeks
(Huybrechts
et al.,
1987)
but there are no data at an older age.Until now, the effects of the sex-linked dwarf gene on
reproduction
andmainly
onovu-lation rate appear
complex
and may involve severalregulation
pathways
that cannot beeasily
related to the marked modifications observed at a young age.Conclusions and further
approaches
The studies of the sex-linked dwarf mutation in
growing
chicks tend to favour the idea that theprimary
effect of the gene is connected with thereceptor
protein
forgrowth
hor-mone, from direct
experimental
evidence,
or with thereceptor
forT4,
from indirectexperi-mental
evidence.
Further
physiological investigations
areneeded,
including
in vitro studies of T4uptake
and GHbinding
in the liver as well as in vivo studies of GH and IGF-I effects in the dwarf. From anotherpoint
ofview,
moleculargenetics
can offer a new tool to test thehypothesis
of an abnormal GH hormone or GHreceptor
in the dwarf. The gene for chicken GH has been cloned(Souza
etal.,
1984)
and could be used as aprobe
to detect a structural dif-ference of the GH gene between dwarf and normalchicks,
according
to the method of restrictionfragment
length polymorphism.
This difference should not be connected with theantigenic
properties
of thehormone,
since it isnormally
recognized
with the usualpre-sented
by
Leung
et al.(1984b) , showing
no difference between the DNA from dwarf ornormal birds. The rabbit gene for the
growth
hormonereceptor
has now been cloned(D.W. Leung
etal.,
1987)
and couldprovide
aninteresting
tool to compare the dwarf tothe normal genome.
However,
the mutation may be connected withonly
apart
of the gene, the size of which is unknown. Since the entireprobe
may not be able to detect asmall
difference,
a modified or anincomplete probe
could then be useful. One canspe-culate on a mutation of that gene that could affect the sequence involved in the
binding
of the hormone to itsreceptor.
If this sequence could beidentified,
it wouldhelp
inestabli-shing
a&dquo;specialized&dquo; probe
to be used in the dwarfssuspected
of aGH-binding
defect.These considerations are
speculative,
but are aimed atshowing
that bothphysiology
andmolecular
genetics
could nowplay a
part
inelucidating
the nature of the dwarf mutation.References
Adashi E.Y., Resnick C.E., Svoboda M.E. & Van Wick J.J.
(1985)
Somatomedin-C enhances induc-tion ofluteinizing
hormone receptors by follicle-stimulating hormone in cultured ratgranulosa
cells.Endocrinology
116, 2369-2374Bowen S.J.,
Huybrechts
L.M., Marsh J.A. & Scanes C.G.(1987)
Influence oftriiodothyronine
andgrowth
hormone ongrowth
of dwarf and normal chickens: interactions of hormones and genotype.Comp.
Biochem.Physiol. 86A,137-142
Buonomo F.C., Lauterio TJ., Baile C.A. &
Daughaday
W.H.(1987)
Effects of insulin-likegrowth
fac-tor I
(IGF-I)
ongrowth hormone-releasing
factor(GRF)
andthyrotrophin-releasing
hormone(TRH)
stimulation of
growth
hormone(GH)
secretion in the domestic fowl(Gallus domesticus).
Gen.Comp.
EndocrinoL 66, 274-279Burch W.M., Weir S. & Van Wick J.J.
(1986) Embryonic
chickcartilage produces
its ownsomatome-din-like
peptide
to stimulatecartilage growth
in vitro.Endocrinology
119, 1370-1376Burghelle-Mayeur
C.(1988)
Influence dugene
du nanisme(dw)
sur le métabolismelipidique
de lapoule pondeuse.
These de Doctorat, ENSIA Universit6s Paris Vil et Paris XiCalabotta D.F.,
Cherry
J.A.,Siegel
P.B. &Gregory
E.M. (1983) Lipogenesis andlipolysis
in normaland dwarf chickens from lines selected for
high
and low bodyweight.
Poult. Sci. 62, 1830-1837Campbell
R.M. & Scanes C.G. (1985) Lipolytic activity ofpurified
andbacterially-derived growth
hor-mone on chicken
adipose
tissue in vitro. Proc. Soc.Exp.
Biol. Med.180, 513-517 7Campbell
R.M. & Scanes C.G.(1987)
Growth hormone inhibition ofglucagon-
and cAMP-inducedlipolysis by
chickenadipose
tissue in vitro. Proc. Soc.Exp.
Biol. Med.184, 456-460’
Carsia R.V. & Weber H.
(1986) Genetic-dependent
alterations in adrenal stress response and adre-nocortical cell function ot the domestic fowl(Gallus domesticus).
Proc. Soc.Exp.
Biol. Med.183, 99-105Decuypere
E. & Kuhn E.R.(1984)
Effect offasting
andfeeding
time on arcadian rhythms of serumthyroid
hormone concentrations,glucose,
liver monodeiodinaseactivity
and rectal temperature ingrowing
chickens. Dom. Mim. Endocrinol. 1, 251-262Decuypere
E., Kuhn E.R.,Clijmans
B., Nouwen E.J. & Michels M.(1982)
Prenatalperipheral
mono-deiodination in the chickembryo.
Gen.Comp.
Endocrinol., 47,15-17 7Decuypere
E., Rudas P., Huybrechts L.,Mongin
P. & Kuhn E.R.(1986) Endocrinological
effects of the sex-linked dwarf gene. 11. Effect on tissue monodeiodinationactivity.
7thEuropean Poultry
Conference, Paris, 24-28
August
1986, 2, 955-959 .Decuypere
E.,Buyse
J., Scanes C.G.,Huybrechts
L. & Kuhn E.R.(1987)
Effects ofhyper-
orhypo-thyroid
status ongrowth, adiposity
and levels ofgrowth
hormone, somatomedin-C andthyroid
meta-bolism in broiler chickens.Reprod.
Nutr. Dev. 27(2B),
555-565Demame Y., M6rat R & Pihet A.
(1984) Composition
deslipides
de l’o3uf chez despoules Leghorn
normales et naines. G6n6t. S61. Evol.16, 211-220Elbrecht A. & Lazier C.B. (1985) Selective
inhibitory
effects ofthyroid
hormones on estrogen-induced protein synthesis in chickembryo
liver. Can. J. Biochem. Cell. Biol. 63, 1206-1211 1Fekkes D., Hennemann G. & Visser T.
(1982)
Evidence for asingle
enzyme in rat livercatalysing
thedeiodination of the
tyrosyl
and thephenolic ring
ofiodothyronines.
Biochem. J. 201, 673-676Gharbi J. & Torresani J.
(1979) High affinity thyroxine binding
topurified
rat liverplasma
mem-branes. Biochem.Biophys.
Res. Commun. 88, 170-177Grandhi R.R. & Brown R.G.
(1975a) Thyroid
metabolism in the recessive sex-linked dwarf femalechicken. I.
Age
relatedchanges
inthyroid
hormones levels. Poult Sci. 54, 488-493Grandhi R.R. & Brown R.G.
(1975b) Thyroid
metabolism in the recessive sex-linked dwarf female chicken. 111. The influence of exogenousthyroid
hormones inglycogen
metabolism. Poult Sci. 54,499-502
Grandhi R.R., Brown R.G., Reinhart B.S. & Summer I.D. (1975)
Thyroid
metabolism in the recessivesex-linked dwarf female chicken. IV. The influence of exogenous
thyroid
hormones on amino-aciduptake by plasma
and tissues. Poult Sci. 54, 503-509Guillaume J.
(1976)
Thedwarfing
gene dw : its effects on anatomy, physiology, nutrition, manage-ment. Itsapplication
inpoultry industry.
World Poult Sci. J. 32, 285-303Guler H.P., Zimmerman D., Wetzel J.C., Zapf J. & Froesch E.R. (1987) Insulin-like
growth
factor I(IGF I)
but not humangrowth
hormone is effective inaccelerating growth
rate ofmini-poodles. The
EndocrineSociety
60th AnnualMeeting,
June 10-12, 1987,Indianapolis,
abstr. No.1 00, pp.1 1Hall T.R.,
Cheung
A. &Harvey
J.(1987)
Somebiological
activities of recombinant DNA-derivedgrowth
hormone onplasma
metabolite concentrations in domestic fowl.Comp.
Biochem.Physiol.
86A, 29-34
Harvey
S.(1983) Thyroid
hormones inhibitgrowth
hormone secretion in domestic fowl(Gallus
domesdcus).
J. Endocrinol. 98, 129-135 .Harvey
S., Sterling R.J. & Klandorf H.(1983)
Concentrations oftri-iodothyronine, growth
hormoneand
luteinizing
hormone in theplasma
of thyroidectomised fowl. Gen.Comp.
Endocrinol. 50, 275-281Harvey
S., Scanes C.G. & Marsh J.A.(1984)
Stimulation ofgrowth
hormone secretion in dwarf chic-kensby
thyrotrophin-releasing
hormone(TRH)
or humanpancreatic growth-hormone-releasing
fac-tor(hp GRF).
Gen.Comp.
EndocrinoL 55, 493-497Harvey
S., Scanes C.G.& Klandorf H.(1988) Thyrotrophin-releasing
hormone inducesgrowth
hor-mone secretion in adult
hypothyroid
fowl. Gen.Comp.
EndocrinoL 69, 233-237Hoshino S. & Suzuki M.
(1982)
Immunochemical determination ofpituitary growth
hormone separa-tedby polyacrylamide
discgel
electrophoresis
in normal and dwarf chickens. Poult Sci. 61, 813-815 5Hoshino S., Wakita M., Suzuki M. & Yamamoto K.
(1982) Changes
in a somatomedin-like factor andimmunoassayable growth
hormoneduring growth
of normal and dwarfpullets
and cockerels. Poult. Sci. 61, 777-784Hoshino S., Suzuki M., Wakita M. &
Kobayashi
Y.(1984)
Stimulation ofgrowth
hormone release indwarf and normal chickens
by
thyrotrophin releasing hormone (TRH) or humanpancreatic growth
hormone
releasing
factor(hpGRF).
J. Steroid Biochem. 20, 1550(abstr.)
Hoshino A., Suzuki M.,
Kakegawa
J., Wakita M. &Kobayashi
Y(1986) Thyroid
hormone response tothyrotrophin releasing
hormone(TRH)
in the sex-linked dwarf chicken. EndocrinoLJapon.
33,675-682
Hutt F B. (1959) Sex-linked dwarfism in the fowl. J. Hered. 50, 209-221
Huybrechts L.M., King D.B.,
Lauterio T.J., Marsh J. & Scanes C.G.(1985a)
Plasma concentrations of somatomedin-C inhypophysectomised,
dwarf and intactgrowing
domestic fowl as determinedby
heterologue radioimmunoassay.
J. EndocrinoL 104, 233-239Huybrechts
L.M.,Decuypere E.,
Kfhn E.R., Lauterio T.J., Scanes-C.G. &Mongin
P.(1985b)
Growthhormone secretory response to
thyrotropin releasing
hormone in normal and dwarf chickens.Reprod.
Nutr. Dev. 25, 641-645Huybrechts
L.M., Kuhn E.R.,Decuypere E.,
M6rat R & Scanes C.G.(1987)
Plasma concentrationsof
growth
hormone and somatomedin-C in dwarf and normal chickens.Reprod.
Nutr. Dev. 27, 547-553Huybrechts L.M., Michielsen R., Darras V.M.,
Berghman
L.R.,Decuypere
E. & Kuhn E.R. (1988)Effect of a methimazole induced
hypothyroidism
on agrowth
hormone induced insulin-likegrowth
factor I response in normal and sex-linked dwarf chickens. Med. Sci. Res. 16, 85-86Krenning E.P.,
Docter R., Bernard H.F., Visser T.J. & Hennemann G.(1978)
Activetransport
oftri-iodothyronine (T3)
into isolated rat liver cells. FEBS Lett. 91, 113-116 6Krenning
E.P., Docter R., Bernard H.F., Visser T.J., Hennemann G.(1981)
Characteristics of activetransport of
thyroid
hormone into rathepatocytes.
Biochem.Biophys.
Acta 676, 314-320Krenning
E.P., Docter R., Bernard H.F., Visser T.J. & Hennemann G.(1982)
Decreased transport ofthyroxine (T4),
3,3’,5 tri-iodothyronine(T3)
and 3,3’,5’, tri-iodothyronine(rT3)
into rathepatocytes
inprimary
culture due to a decrease of cellular ATP content and variousdrugs.
FEBS Lett. 140,229-233
Kuhn E.R.,
Decuypere
E., Hemschoote K.,Berghman
L. & Paulussen J.(1983) Antagonism
ofserum tri-iodothyronine changes after
injections
ofprolactin
in the domestic fowl before and afterhatching.
J. Endocrinol. 99, 401-407Kuhn E.R.,
Huybrechts
L.M.,Decuypere
E. & M6rat P. (1986) Endocrinological effects of sex-linkeddwarf gene. 3. Prolactin and
growth
hormone fail to increase the liver T4-5’-monodeiodinaseactivity
in the sex-linked dwarf chick
embryo.
7thEuropean Poultry
Conference, Paris, 24-28August
1986, 2,965-969Kiihn E.R.,
Decuypere E.,
lqbal
A.,Luysterborgh
D. & Michielsen R. (1988) Thyrotrophic andper-ipheral
activities ofthyrotrophin
andthyrotrophin-releasing
hormone in the chickembryo
and adult chicken. Horm. Metab. Res. 20, 158-162Lam S.K., Harvey S. & Hall T.R.
(1986)
In vitro release oftri-iodothyronine
andthyroxine
fromthy-roid
glands
of the domestic fowl(Gallus
domesticus). Gen.Comp.
Endoainol. 63,178-185Lauterio T.J.,
Decuypere
E. & Scanes C.G.(1986) Growth, protein synthesis
andplasma
concentra-tions ofgrowth hormone, thyroxine
andtri-iodothyronine
in dwarf, control andgrowth
selectedstrains of
broiler-type
domestic fowl.Comp.
Biochem.Physiol.
83A, 627-632Leenstra F R., Van
Middiekoop
J.H.,Verfijken
P.F.G. &Abplanalp
H. (1986) Influence of the sex-linkeddwarfing
gene dw on yolk and eggproduction
in normal andsuperovulafing laying
hens. Arch.Gefliigelkd.
50, 65-68Leung
D.W.,Spencer S.A.,
Cachianes G., Hammonds R.G., Collins C., Henzel N.J., Barnard R.,Waters M.J. & Wood W.J.
(1987)
Growth hormone receptor and serumbinding protein: purification,
cloning
andexpression.
Nature 330, 537-543Leung
F.C.,Taylor
J.E. & Van Iderstine A.(1984a)
Effects of dietarythyroid
hormones ongrowth
and serum T3, T4 andgrowth
hormone in sex-linked dwarf chickens. Proa Soc.Bip.
Biol. Med. 177,77-81
Leung
F.C., Gillett J., Lilburn M.S. &Kopchick
J.(1984b) Analysis
ofgrowth
hormone receptors and genes in sex-linked dwarf chichens. J. Steroid Biochem. 20, 1557Leung
F.C.,Styles
W.J., Rosenblum C.I., Lilburn M.S, & Marsh J.A.(1987)
Diminishedhepatic
growth
hormone receptorbinding
in sex-linked dwarf broiler andLeghorn
chickens. Proc. Soc.Exp.
Biol. Med. 184, 234-238
Marsh J.A., Gause W.C., Sandhu S. & Scanes C.G.
(1984a)
Enhancedgrowth
and immunedeve-lopment
in dwarf chickens treated with mammaliangrowth
hormone andthyroxine.
Proc. Soc.Exp.
Biol. Med. 175, 351-360
Marsh J.A., Lauterio TJ. & Scanes C.G.
(1984b) Effects
oftri-iodothyronine
treatements onbody
and organ
growth
and the development of immune function in dwarf chicken. Proc. Soc.Exp.
Biol.Med.177, 82-91
Mathews L.S., Norstedt G. & Palmiter R.D.