Publisher’s version / Version de l'éditeur:
21st International Conference on Port and Ocean Engineering under Arctic Condition 2011 (Proceedings), p. 112, 2012-01
READ THESE TERMS AND CONDITIONS CAREFULLY BEFORE USING THIS WEBSITE. https://nrc-publications.canada.ca/eng/copyright
Vous avez des questions? Nous pouvons vous aider. Pour communiquer directement avec un auteur, consultez la première page de la revue dans laquelle son article a été publié afin de trouver ses coordonnées. Si vous n’arrivez pas à les repérer, communiquez avec nous à PublicationsArchive-ArchivesPublications@nrc-cnrc.gc.ca.
Questions? Contact the NRC Publications Archive team at
PublicationsArchive-ArchivesPublications@nrc-cnrc.gc.ca. If you wish to email the authors directly, please see the first page of the publication for their contact information.
NRC Publications Archive
Archives des publications du CNRC
This publication could be one of several versions: author’s original, accepted manuscript or the publisher’s version. / La version de cette publication peut être l’une des suivantes : la version prépublication de l’auteur, la version acceptée du manuscrit ou la version de l’éditeur.
Access and use of this website and the material on it are subject to the Terms and Conditions set forth at
Performance measurements of the effect of simulator training on
novice operators in simulated ice conditions
Power MacDonald, Stephanie; MacKinnon, Scott; Simões Ré, Antonio;
Power, Jonathan
https://publications-cnrc.canada.ca/fra/droits
L’accès à ce site Web et l’utilisation de son contenu sont assujettis aux conditions présentées dans le site LISEZ CES CONDITIONS ATTENTIVEMENT AVANT D’UTILISER CE SITE WEB.
NRC Publications Record / Notice d'Archives des publications de CNRC:
https://nrc-publications.canada.ca/eng/view/object/?id=47029146-9a04-4be0-a3ca-ab7f525ddd99 https://publications-cnrc.canada.ca/fra/voir/objet/?id=47029146-9a04-4be0-a3ca-ab7f525ddd99
! " ## " " # $ % & & '# " ( # # " # & # " ' ) ' % " % " " ) $ % " " ! ' " # % ! " * + # " , ! *- " " " ) ! " % " " " # " ( # + !" #$ ! " . ) " " " "/ " ## "
) " ) " ,& & 001- & ## "
+ % " % 2 " # ## " " % + " " ( " " ( % " # ( ) " " ( " % " " ) " " % ! ! " * + # " , ! *- # " # ) 3 ! * " 4 " " # " % # 0 , 115-" " % ) " ## ,&) 151- 60 " " ) #
# " " # " + # # ,7 - ) " + " , + 008- # ,9 :- ,3 ; * 00<- ) $ " 7 ) " # # " , 005- $) " # ) " ) % ) " # # # " " % $ # ) ,= % 186- $# " ,&"" % 005- + ' " " , 00 -" " % " # 9 # % . " ! " ,9 .!- % + # ) # ,9 181- & " " ( '# " + ( ,: 001- " " " " " " # , # 11>- " ) " ) + # % # '# , 00<-3 "" " ) # " " " " ,? ) 115- " # # ,!. 7 - # + ) # ) " # ' , " % % -) + ,@ 008- ! 9 .' = " " " # ) # % " ( # # ( # % " " % ## % # # % " % " ( # ,33611 # 6 00<- ! # # ' $) " # ' % " " %& ' # ( )* ! 3 3 . ? 9 " " ## 1 " # #
7 !. 7 " # # # 7 # ( ) ! # 7 # % " " # ' # # % " A # % " % # ! * " , " " " !. 7 -# # % " A # % " # ! * " A # % $ ) " " ' # # % " A # B % ) " " % " % " # $ % @ ! " ,@ !- # ) # " A # B ! ,2 " - C ## ) : + @ , % -2 " / 2 " / % ! " # $ 2 $ + # 0 0 9 ! % ) 60 ! ) + " % # # ) ## " ) + " % " " # # " # + ,2 " B- D ) E # F 0
2 " B/ ! $ $ # ! ) % !. 7 ,? # - F & ## 0 # ) % % ' # 6 # # : " B # # % !. 7 ,2 " >-/ # # " ) % ) # # !. 7 ) % " $ ) " ) % ) # 2 " >/ ! 3 F ! !. 7 "
. # # # ' " % " / G G . G . G % G % ! % 4 # # 7 # % ' ! # % " " # $ + # 4 # ) ) ) % % " ) % % : % " " : & ( ,:& -!. 7 # ,H I J-# % " ) # " ,A7 - ' " # " " 2 ) # # " % + !. 7 ! % % 7 # % ( ' " '# " " !% ( % " # $ " # $ " ! ( % " & & ! H ,7 008-% 3 % % '# :& ) " 4 3 $ ! # # % : % # % ' " # 2 # " " ,! ) -, " - # $ % ) . # # " % ' " # ! # ) % % % " " ) % # .' " + " % " % # " A 3! ## " # " . " " # # # # " # ,2 " 6- ! " # + % # # ' )
2 " 6/ .' # 7 $2 ) / 3 . 3. ! " # " " # F % ' " 7 # # ' " % ' " ! # ) % " % # # '# " ( ! ) / 7 2 / , -) # . . * . . *
! * 7 , - 5> 66, &'(- 6< >>, )& (- 5 0,)&* - 5> 86,+& ,- 5> 8 ,(&*-. 5B B,/&*'. ! * ! , - 5B 0<,'& )- 51 B>,)(&/ - 5> 11,+&'(- 1B 8,('& '- 5< <8,*&,-. 5B <B, -&-,. ! * K 7 , - 5> 1<, &),- 56 66,)&+)- 5B <5,+&,(- 56 < , -&-*- 55 56,*&-/- 5 <B,,&)+-! * K <B,,&)+-! , - < >B,'&/-- 58 1B, )&, - <> B1, -&-*- 8 0, +& /- < 01, (&)(- 51 1,
&')-7 , - 51 55,*&' - 58 >,*&-/- 50 1B,'&('- 58 88,,& - 5> 1B,(&')- 55 B0,,&*). ! , - < B8, '&')- <B , &/*- <0 0, +& - << 8>, B >8- 51 >,,&)/- <0 8B, -&,(.
! ) / 7 7 ; 2 7 " ) A # ) ! * ! * K B5 > B5 + ,-. 8 1 ,-. < < 81
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
# ) 2 ' # # # % ' " ' ) ' " , D E 2 " 6- % & " " ) # " " % ) % " " % " , 065 00 - # ) " " " # % ) ) % ! % '# " " " " " $ % " # " # ! # ) " " % '# " % # ) "$ # #" + , # 11>-# # " ) % " " ) N $B 7 ! " N ! % # # " # $ + , 00>- # " # # " # " # # # '# % " ) # # " " # " # A % ) + $ " " # + # ) # # F '# ) " # : " " , 00>- # # % " " # % ) % '# " + % " ! " 7 ! " N " # " ## " " $ # ' " " ,# " - % " # " # # $ " # ! # F % # ) " # ) " " $ % " ($ ! " ! " " " $ % " % " " " " $ % , 00 - ! # " % " % " !. 7 & " ! * + % " " # " ) ' % ' # " 4 '#
) # " ) % 2 " % # '# " " 5" 3(&#)%&" ! " + ## ! # ! " 9 = 3 3 : # # % ) @ ! "
&+& &" &
" & 001 &
&) : ; * 3 151 Q.
" " Q 0 % 1 % 2 B ##
B16$B1<
&"" % 3 ? + & 9 3 : 4 & ; * 005 Q@
3 ! " # '# " R . + Q 1 3 4 " % B ## 688 ? ) 7 115 Q! # # " Q 4 5 %& ? + 3 ## <<$86 ? ) " ; 3 00< Q? " $ / % + %Q ! 6 ! > ## <B # @ A + ? : " ? A ; ? 3 11> Q: " # # OQ 7 1 <B ## 1B : : ++ * 3 ; 001 Q2 " Q ! 8 " 0 > ## B06$B > 9 .' 00< 94 4 1 ! 6 1 33 611 9 .' , = " -9 = 181 Q9 # % / . . # "Q % 4 0 ## <B
" 4 00 & 1 " : 4 " 4 = " " 4 1<8 Q ! " * + # " , ! *- 1<8 ) ( Q " 4 = " " 4 1<> Q , & - 1<> ) ( Q " 4 = "
+ & . $* @ = & ; = S 9 008 Q& .
# " ! " : " + + 7 % ) 7 ) / & 7 Q 6%5 % "% 7 4 ## <6 $<6> = % : A " = 9 9 : ; 3 186 Q ! " 7 + / ! " ? $ S Q 5 % "% B0 ## $ < 7 +$ & " 3 ; = ) : ? 008 Q. # % + " + # % Q ! 8 " 1 ## 16$ B 3 & 3 ; * : 00< Q % @ . : . Q 2 ; >1 ## 60<$6 < + 3 . = ; & ' & 00> Q # " # " # Q 6 "% 2 "% > ## B>8$B6 7 9 =S & * + ; 2 $! 005 Q. '# # ) + # " "/ # # 4 " Q " % 0 ## B8B$ B88 @ ? ? 3 ; 7 & 008 Q. ! " " Q 7 . " ## B