A congestion control model for multicast overlay networks and its performance

A Congestion Control Model for Multicast Overlay Networks and its Performance

Guillaume Urvoy-Keller

Institut Eurecom 2229, route des Crêtes 06904 Sophia-Antipolis, France

urvoy@eurecom.fr

Ernst W. Biersack

Institut Eurecom 2229, route des Crêtes 06904 Sophia-Antipolis, France

erbi@eurecom.fr

ABSTRACT

!"#%$!&('*)$!+, !-+. /0+, ! .12

+,1$43'5564789#"$:1;1<"$!1&=+,> ?; #8+,):#& !+@A

7B -= CD+"781.+,E )/ E):+FBGH,)788+,E++,E=7)$!+, C

-0+(#% !+, CI)+, ! J+,* !8I2) C$!+*K+8+,E:L12$C !-K+, ! M$!<K"$1:#

+,E+K-NEO1<K"$!1&P:0+,.1?P9#2QE:KGR$C !7H !+#SI)2T"GU

-?90++1/KF;E1<"$!1&('5R#20-7=+,E:5#9I:K-N?

$!91IA+V."W-" !<K"*1:#W":#"X C+YY-E:1 CZ -0 +, $

$!91:[ . >-E8I -NEX14+,E57\)$!+, !-K+.#% !+, CI)+, !+,F

Y-0 $!-")$!+Q+,EG+,E )/ E2)+ HQ7\)$!+, !-K+G, !14[H.

)$C C:1-")"-78+,E9#]I#X ^+,E:78K_2$C)5 $!/

I2F`"$C !7= C &P9)78" !-1$=0,)2$!+L#781:+,K+Y+,E:K+*+,E

+,E )/ E):+G" 7B -Q (1<$! &Z'5a !L $!78K+b C#2

":#"+X H+,E*9):7IA"X 0-" !<[5E C$!G1(+,EL":#9V+

:#Z'5c[>+,E:+,E )/ E2)+L#20-"0*$!/1 !+,E:7H !- $!$&J !+,E

+,E*9)7\IAL -" !<K"FZ.E2 !(,)2$!+8 !XG-"$!0 * C#9 !-+, !1

+,E+1<"$!1&]+V. ?5 7)2$!+, !-K+#% !+, CI)+, ! Q1TA"B78

de .A 781:-0#<1 +K/1<">:K+, !<"#%V+1,:#X7\)$!+, !-+

#9 !+, CI):+, !1F

Keywords

.1:/K+, ! f. +, $['*)2$!+, !-0+[hg<"$!1&*i+,> ?A[

1. INTRODUCTION

j51-NE CB7)2$!+, !-K+- /0+, ! (-1+, $9EA9-")#78 C$!&

18$!1&"0#8+, 7= !, ! ^-NE780E"5K-NEH-" !<K">-NE9

+,Ek9)7\I".1:$!1&";+,)I:-" CI+=lm2[onqp #H (+,Ek !,)1

.rs !":#9$C C]lt2[Au0v pVF.w9 )-"I#, C/ $!"+B7\)$!+, !-+

-0 /+, !1-1+, $Hlx[;yqp #G CQ:1+, !-")2$!1* !+A"178 -

E40-" !<0#\$!z++"+, !1Ll{2[1| pVFzj0-"+,$!&HkE:1 C+, )^l|1pE

1<"}+,E:K+8+,E"] !8" !1):8A"U 781:-X #R-1$! I C$C !+,&

I$!7~. !+,E1)2-I0#G, C/ $!"K+8"#%V+ V"#7\)$!+, !-+

-0 /+, !1R-0 +, $€Bk<K"Y1H+,E:(-K8.E:Q+,E:8IAK++,$!"-N?

I # !#+,E]1:# ):#9V+, CR+, !7B8+*+,E(#% CT""+=-0" !<"

1[5 }1<"K/[5+,EL78L1:#W+,E:L+,1:7H !, ! J#2"$!1&9X+

+,E*#9 CTA"+]- !<"( X $!&Q,)2Id-0+8+b$C !/1E+(< 1 !+, !1:[

Permission to make digital or hard copies of all or part of this work for personal or classroom use is granted without fee provided that copies are not made or distributed for profit or commercial advantage and that copies bear this notice and the full citation on the first page. To copy otherwise, to republish, to post on servers or to redistribute to lists, requires prior specific permission and/or a fee.

Copyright 2002 ACM 1-58113-619-6 ...

^‚

5.00.

+,EGƒ!„:…V†9‡ˆ1„ ‰z‡ƒ†Š]‹LŒH‡9!ƒŽs"‹0ƒk0‘q0Ž†9’L“9‘"1…V‘"‹0‘!ŽC”9‘8ƒ!„:‘]Žs’2•

–

‘1…N0‘=†Šƒ!„:‘!†ˆ9‹9…"Žsƒ—„:ŒO†Šƒ!„:‘H’:‡2ŒH˜‘ …†ŠŒ=‡9!ƒŽ‹ƒ…V‘"‘1Ž

–

‘ …F

™ !<K"W+,E:8$C !7= !+#W- $!1I2 C$C s+,&Q1:#9V+ V"#R3.n1.6'5[

1<"$!1&(:+V. ?.157)2$!+, !-K+#+8#9 !+, CI):+, !1Q TA1* C

+"+, C/Y1$!+":K+, !<FWg<K"$!1&Q7\)$!+, !-+(#9 !+, CI2)+, ! J "

+0kK@1$C$!1€>š:, !#+,E.:+V. ?H-0"+ C(9)7\IA5 A1<K"

$!1&]9#20 #"$!1&#AF.E#2K+8IA+,>"LK# de-"+1<"$!1&

9#2. !5+, 7= !++#* C^8+ ,1:#9 > #]$C C?o=7B :"5),

C/G.€A›5Q1<"$!1&G9#œ0-" !<08#2K+2[4I)TA"8+,E(#2K+2[

#=1. #+,E#+1= !+;7)2$!+, C$! )+/1 C:/$C C2?>+ > #

+,Eœ" !/1E9IA C/Y# .+,71<$! &:9#FX›ž+H 51<K"

$!1&]9#20[4.E"L1/ !Ÿ# C]+,0$C C?9=K,E2 !14[A < !#

7)2$!+, !-K+=1. #9 C:/"< !-X+,E:K+):08 $!&G+,E8)2#"$!& C:/

)2 !-K+@1):+, C/-0 I C$C !+, > +,E:>šU+"+;3,)2A +12+, !<K

7)2$!+, !-K+8 )+, C:/L !\+H )2 C0#:6"FDw):-EQ W1<$! &D#% !+, C

I):+, !1:+V. ?f/ K+,$!&r, !7H2$C C¡L+,E*7)2$!+, !-K+(- /+, !1

-1+, $;21I2$!7X€HšU+# ;A"U 7= C/L D"#%V+ V"#-

/0+, ! Q-1+, $;IA+V."D+,E:B )-( #G+,E=- !<"[1<K"

$!1&L'5¢):0)2 !-+H-1:/K+, ! W-1+, $;IA+,>"D#1d-+

1<"$!1&*9#20F8šL-0+[:, C-(+,E:H1<"$!1&*9#2)8.R+

+, 7= !++,E:#+(+,E <K"$!1&*'5 C$C$zIA.@ !"#9$!&F

š+7B C+,) !+, !<"$!&Y0< !#2"++,E+1<"$!1&L'5¢,E )$!#L"

,)$!+œ C}GE !/ E"X+,E21):/1E2):+X, C:-0b !+8#-1)2$!L+,E]K+*

+, 7= !, !1R1<K"+,E=#9 CTA"+\I -NEH ;+,E8#9 !+, CI2)+, !

+,F^š+ !H+,E:( Id0-+, !<X +,E2 ! A"œ+L ):1+, C&Y+,Eœ"

178 - !7=1<78+ h1<"$!1&*'5R1:#X+8<1 $C)+H+,E:

##9 !+, ! $>+ /K\0 )2 C7B"+ C1 <K"$!1&]9#2KF

.E +, !-$! !1/12 !Ÿ0#Lk1$C$!1€>š*0-+, ! bn%[..""

"++,E8>n Z'Z789#2$k)#LI&>E C+,0 )Zl|1p;+/K+,E:

. !+,E81)2@g<"$!1&H'5b789#"$F>šUH0-+, ! (|[1. C+,9#%)-5+,E:

78K_$C)1$!/"I2[.E !-NEX.K@)#= Cl| p+789#2$A.n1Q'

#Y.E !-NEY1< !#208+,E:(+91$.+X $!&9ŸX+,E:Xg<$! &'5F

=):(($C C:18-")"-(78+,E9#GI#Q D+,E]7B_2$C)

$!/K"Ir+-1$!-")2$!K+Y+,E*+,E )/ E2)+*1IAK+,E+,EL.n1S1:#

g<$! &X'5¢789#"$F

š8-0+, ! ({[.;2+42"$C !7H C:1&œ9)78" !-0 $:,)$!+;+,E:K+

#78 +,+H+,E+5+,E:Bg<$! &X'5R789#2$#9+5, !/ C¡

-1+,$!&L,)2TAH]+,E )/ E):+H#20/ #+, !1Y1 C-"K, C:/L9)7=

IA"H1k0-" !<F=QE2 C$!(+,E=,)$!+ B I+ C#G1789#9

"K+=, !ŸH:+V. ?[z+,E&L :K+.1+,E&*IA-1):(+,E&*-1

,A1:#X+=, !+,)+, !1:.E:"+,E:.n1Q'Q789#"$A !1$C#&

T-+#(I&]+,E9)7IA" z-" !<K"l|1p,F£)2+,E"781[:K.

AK#Q+Gl| pV[.8-1:, !#"X]E1<9&V+ C$!#< !-]$!1SK+,E:

+,E *$C !/1E+,V+ C$!#O3_A1:"+, !1$s6* FQ.E2 !B-NE !-L:1I2$!

)8+b C"œ+,E:(IA"E < !1X +,E:^g<"$!1&Q'5S789#"$518

$! /K"9)7\IAH - !<"F.E\0,)2$!+1\7= !, C/L, C-

CQ1)2H-:1 ![;+,E:œg<"$!1&'Z789#2$.,E1*, !/ C

-0" !<"F

£4 C $C$!&[z.- -"$C)#2= C0-+, ! F

2. E2E AND OVERLAY MODELS

. C$C$4¡+.20"+5+,E:.n1R'5R789#"$F5g)5 Id0-+, !<

!++(789#2$;+,E:H#20+ C$!H >.5-1:/K+, ! f- +,1$53+

$!0+:K+4 C(¡++/K16 I2)+;+ I+ Cœ78 C/ )$:,)$!+@U

.¡_9#9,, !Ÿ0. C#21Q-1+, $+,E:K+4789#"$!;.L-12-+, !18 C

+0#&8++FhG5. C$C$z+,E:"œ_2$!1 CL+,Eg<"$!1&8'5Y789#"$F

›8G+,.1?Q+ $!/K&[.X,)78LGE78K/"1):X+,

.E" $C$z-" !<K" K+5+,E:$!1:9# #*E:1<K78#9 !,

+1:-0œs7+,E:B )-FL.E !=K,):7=+, ! }" I$!=)=+*)

X, !7=$!]7B9#2"$>.E:=, C/ $!X C# O, !ŸH !):#L1H $C$;"

-0" !<"L.E"Z>n  '5 !X- , !#"#A[=.E !-NEJ/1X !+,E

+,EX™ $!+12 (- -"$C), ! Z+,E+H+,E:X. C:#1ž, !ŸX,E:1)2$!#QIA

+, ! $;++,E#9 !+ -K7O+,E: )-=l{ pVF£:1.1?91

, !7H2$C !-" !+V&[A..K,):7B B)2$C !7= !+#(I:1:#. !#2+,E^ (+,E.+,)2

+,E:#"$!1&9 ;K-N?91.$!#2/K78"+1:/1$C !/ CI$KF

2.1 E2E MCC

.E=>n '5P789#"$ !#" !-+#G CD£4 !/ )*uFc›$C$9#2

1G7)$!+, !-+L-1:1I2$!Y$!/K-&R9#Y3 )+"6"FO.E:b !X

/1$! I $. C:#1ž:1780+" ] #G-?9+f !8"+HI&G+,E

1)2-0]12$!& C-0 !8 >:K-N?o+ E1<8IA"D-" !<K#

I&W $C$c+,E:L-" !<K"G30 )2 !<1 $!+,$&[H+,E !*780 *+,E+( $C$H+,E

K-N?91.$!#2/K78"+ 5-?9+ E:1<HIA"L-0" !<#LI&

+,EH )-=, C-H.H,)78=1L)2$C !7= !+#I:1:#. !#2+,ED +,E

0<":K+,EA6"F

Receivers Source

W e W e W e W e

!#"$!&%(''

2.2 Overlay MCC

.E]#+1 C$!]1+,E:X <K"$!1&Q'O789#"$5 (20"+#Y C

¡/ )n%F;g<K"$!1&:9#; k$!-0#8.E::<K">+,E:.#9 !+, CI):+, !1

+,0œU ?H TZ3 FKF+,E:(1)2-8 !81$!G1Q1<"$!1&G9#16"FL›$C$

+,EL1<"$!1&Q:9#*. !+,E}_9-"+, ! Z1H+,E:X )-G1YŽ’Ž“9‘

+,E=+,> ?AF8.E=):-0+, ! $C !+,&Q15+,E:B <K"$!1&b9#]-0 IA

0 $C !Ÿ#Q):, C/Y" +X78-E C:* C+ $C$!#K# dV)2-+8+L+,E

1):+L+Y.E !-NE !+( !*-12-+#RU (-" !< C/R1:#:#9 C:/

#+-?90+F.š+"78#9 !+5:9#kI+,.0"(1<"$!1&=9#k1

$!0/-0&b9#2083 )+"6"[4.E !-NEf- IA81#% C &L )+"+,E+

1\+57)2$!+, !-0+-1:1I2$!F.E:)2 !-K+- -+, ! IA+V."

+V.H#1d-+1<K"$!1&]9#2.)5=¡_9#%V, !ŸH. C:#1P-0 +, $

. !+,EQ 7B+")+* FDE !8. C#21 - +,1$ !BR†9’9ˆ9‘ƒŽ†9’

9#2.E"(+,E+,.1?8+,E(IA+V."X+,E+,> <K"$!1&8:9#

/0+-0 /+#AF

. . .

. .

. . .

.

Wc o W f o

Legacy node Legacy node

Wc o ink W f o W f o W f o

. . . . . .

oc oc

1 k

W f o W f o

W o c

Legacy node

ic

oc b l(ic)

. . .

. . . . . .

Next Overlay Node

Current Overlay Node

"-./$0213546%(''87:9-;01

Y#-1)2$!Y+,EG1):+/K C/rI -NEX H Z1<K"$!1&R:9#[

+,E" !5=I)2T"H3< C+,):1$ > $s6kA" )+,2)+F=< ><"1[<K"

Cz+,E: Id-0+, !< !>+I21?(+,E=ƒŽCˆ1„:ƒA- )$C C:/8 C#%)-#(I&8+,E:

>n M'5P789#"$[;.8> ++]"<K*($!9(- )$C C:/G C

+,E="H+,E:K+ C>œI -E 8 + ;+,E=#9 !+, CI2)+, ! W+,

/0++9L- /+0#G HK788+, !78X3 FF8U $C$!H+9*7):-EYI-?

CY1. #9 C/*:K-N?o+6"[4+,E81)2-(,E )$!#GIA-078(1. H

!+F›MI-?92,)(78-E:12 !7~ !+,E9)78 #+ &KF=£ +,E !

)2AK[. $!&f¡_9#Z. C:#1 3> *

?

6(- +,1$IA+,>"

+,E8 )+,2)+I2)TA"H 51Y1<K"$!1&b9#2(1:#G !+ C):+I2)TA"1€

£:18:K-N?o+R+LIA*-0 !#r C++,E:X )+,2)+8I2)TA"[.-?90+

: *

?

7)+E1<IA0"L7H !++#]K7ž1$C$+,E )+,2)+F>wo)-NE

. C#21Q-1+, $ !kA@5†5B8- +,1$:7B-NE !7O, C:-0+,Ek C2)+

I)2TA8K#21:+ !+\U .1#% C/*+8+X+,E:(-1:,)7=+, ! Q+0

+>+,E:1):+,):+.I)2T"F..EDC:1-1+, $7B-NE !7 IA+,>"

+,E )+,2)+I)2T"1:#L+,E C2)+I)2TA#9&K+.:K+:,)

+,E+H+,E:8I-?92,)L. C$C$5-EQ+,E* )-€œ. , !#2"X+V.

1<"$!1&=9#k.E"5+,E:;¡2+53)2+,K7(6@1<K"$!1&=:9#5+, ,

7= !+4-?9+;+5+,E:>- #H 1:#H+,Ek:K+,E=I+,.0"8+,E.+V.

1<"$!1&89#2; !k:K+k-0 /+#AF5gœ+,E:5+,E".E #A[21: )+,

/1 C:/I -NEX z+,E5- #(1<"$!1&=9#25 !@E !/ E$!&(- /0+# F

šU^+,E2 !5-K+,E: C):+5I2)TA" ;+,E-1:#X1<"$!1&]9#=. C$C$

I)2 C$!#Y)G12 !#9$!&Q !+. C$C$.+1Y1. #9 C:/*-?90+9

5+,E )+,2)+.I2)TA"c- 0,A #% C/L+H+,E:-1:/K+#*I -NE

E $!#+*

?

-?9+F

X":,)8(I:K-N?9,)])Y+X+,E:81)2-0[+,EEC:1M1:#

-1:/K+, ! X-1+, $78-E:12 !7O7):+4IA>- )2$!0# F>+,E !2)

AK[4+,EH, !Ÿ=1.+,E C2):+I)2TAH ; D1<"$!1&*9#2H !$C !7=

!+#Q+F+*

,

:K-N?o+( #r+,E*1<K"$!1&f9#* $!&Q"#28I-?

^-?9:1.$!#/78+.E:L+,E !< C/]-?90+.- XIA-12 !#

C+L $C$ )+,2)+=I)2TAFLš5*:K-N?o+H- Y+I]-0 !#Y C+

1$C$.1):+,)+\I)2T"[;+,E:= C):+I2)TA"B+ ++(¡2$C$>)2D #G

K-N?91.$!#2/K78"+8. C$C$;IA8"+I-?+*+,E)2+,71<$! &

9#FZw C:-*)+F

*

,

:K-N?o+L3+,E:L78K_ !7\)7 9)7\IA*1

1):++1:#9 C/œ-?90+67B &HIA C^+, , !+kIA+V."^+,.1<$! &

9#[5.(7\)+=IAX I$!L+G+1 *

,

:K-N?o+= C}+,E:( C2):+

I)TA"+B <K !#*-?9+5$!F

E1< C+,9#9):-0#L8- )$C C:/X+,E:K+K,)20+,E+5+,E

I-?9,)2(-1L21:K/K+]1$C$;+,E:H.1&*+(+,E=1)2-0F.E

K78+" *

?

- +,1$!5+,E:5$!<"$h h- )2$C C/L3,A#X zI:K-N?9

,)16"€H+,E:$! /K"B+,E:8<11$C):( *

?

[A+,E8.1?9"H+,E8-1)2

$C C/2F5rE" +*

?

!. C¡2 !+=15 $C$h <K"$!1&8:9#[:+,E" !.

I-?9,)2B #L+,E:-0" !<" -K7=$!+"$!&L#- )$!# F

› -7H2$!+D< !~ c Z1<$! &#9 !+, CI):+, !1O+,* !]"

+#* CL¡:/1)2|F

W c o

W c o W c o

W c o W c o

W c o Source

Receivers

./$021354 % '' 7 9;01

2.3 Implementation of Overlay MCC Model

QE2 C$!.+,E; Id-+, !<K. +,E@ A4 !+.#781:+,K+.+,E:K+4+,E

g<K"$!1&Y'5M789#2$.1):+,A 78B+,E:8>n J'M789#"$; C

+78. AA 781:-0[:.51$!8. +>+\A1 C+5 )+k !+., !7=$C !-"

!+V&L . !7H2$!7B"++, !14F(.E=I:K, !-8 "+, !1:81.+,E81<$! &

12$C !-K+, ! Q1#2- CIA#L CL¡:/1)2{F5A ^ !<1 $;1=

-?90+[A+,E:H 2$C !-0+, ! W# )"):0=+,E:K-N?o+ $!&* C>+,E:" !

K+$!+1:80=,-H CQ-ED )+/ C/LI2)TA"1Fœg+,E:". ![

+,E.12$C !-+, !1X+ $C$![.E2 !-E=0,)2$!+4 CB+,E:>.* C-7H C:/12

$C !-K+, ! W+(#2-= !+K#2<K"+, !#Y. C#21[z":,) C/*212

K/K+, ! D 4I-?9,)2KF

Application layer

TCP layer new packet

connection

incoming TCP outgoing TCP connections

W o f

W o send

c

If free space in each bufferplace then copy

else wait

7107 329 9 ./$021354 % ''

7:9-;01

3. MAX-PLUS ANALYSIS

.):.+ 78_$C):$C C:0 5 )+, !1:>+789#"$+,E:kI"

E < !1H ;+,E1<"$!1&L'5F2.E=7B_( A+, ! D#":K+#LI&

!.):#( C:+0#L h+,E:),) $K#2#9 !+, ! D #*+,EK#2#9 !+, ! D#"

+#8I&r !k):0#œ C+K#]1z+,E:.),):1$A7\)$!+, C$C !-+, s F>+,E

"+, !1:( (#"¡:#Y C, !#2! "$#&%(') +*-, /.10*. !+,EW+,E:

-1<"+, !1Q /.2435'&/.468793;:- "$#&% FHš+5 !+, !/1E+,

.1#G+(,E O+,E+H3< "$#&% [ [6k !*-K787):+K+, !<87H C C/

. !+,EZ+,E:*U $C$!1. C:/W78+,E78K+, !- $ A+, !€Q-7B7\)++, !<

!+,&K[A#% !+, CI):+, !< s+,&K[4K9-" !+, !< s+,& #* !#2+, !+,&L"$!7B"+F<"

= ' /. !+,E: !#"+, !+V&G"$!078"+ ;+,E

"+, !1Q #L+,E:

>

'Rv5 !+,E:; !#2"+, !+V&8"$!7B"+k1R1A"K+, ! X, C:-0 /.

3'+3

#Lv13'?3@67A3B:C "$#&%KF

Dz+.):. C+,9#9):-B+,E:1$C$!1 C/*++, !14€

EFHG

"

6JIK:MLC6ONP:QL(€z"< !-H+, !78H -?9+RNa+/I.E:"

I,[2#"A:#9 C:/(1*+,E-0 +_9+[ !.\9# +,E:H3 C2):+51

)+,2)+6I)TA"1;8/ !<K"L9#2F

ETS

G"

6JI:!LC6UNV:!L(€+, !78 C:+1+=.E"L-?9+RN $!0 <K

I.E"I,[A#2"":#9 C/G1+,E:8-0 +_9+[A !(:9#8 c+,E:

3 C2)+ )+,2)+6I)TA"18/1 !<"9#2F

ETW

€;9):7IA"1; )+,2)+I)2T"K+0-EL1<"$!1&*9#2KF

E

I<3€ C2):+5I2)TA"c ;-")"+ <K"$!1&]9#2KF

ETX

3YI<316"€$!/K-&]9#\):+,07 +CI<3F

ETZ

3H[9€4?9V+,E )+,2)+.I2)TA"c ;-")"+ <K"$!1&]9#2KF

E

I

[

€ C2):+HI2)TA"B 5_9+1<"$!1&G9#2(-1,A1:#9 C:/

+

Z

3[%F

šY1)2H789#"$;.H,)78[z#9 !#QkE C+,1)l|1p,[+,E:K++,E:

I)2TA\ CQ0-EG1):+"H1= C¡2 !+FXšUD+,E"H.1#2[z+,E"8 !

*:K-N?o+$! CQ+,Eœ+V. ?AFœšUQK-NE9#2[h-NE#9)2$C C/Y !

£;š£hgž #Q+,E:(-"K=+,H\(-("YI&+,E:8-?9+B 51)2B'

, !1] !;789#"$!#(I&*Ž’“9‘e‰‘1’:“9‘’ƒ2‹9’:“…V‹9’:“9†9ŒP< !-5+, !78

FHG

"

3.E2 !-E#=:K+. C:-"$C)#] )") C:/X+, !786"F

.E=+, !78.E"=-?9+5$!1<=9#2 C+,E:H1<"$!1&X#% !,

+, CI):+, !1Y+, !-7H2)+#L.1$C$!1€

E

.E:]9,+,Eœ )+,2)+kI)2TA5 z-")"+; <K"$!1&=9#2":#

:K-N?o+^N K89 }= !+8E=9-0#R:K-N?o+CN8Zu[

21< !##+,E:K+k !+.E:K0-" !<0#]-?9+/Nž7`+,E: C2)+

I2)TA"B #+,E:8. C#21`- +,1$.1$C$! 5:K-N?o+_N~+]IA

"+F5w98.5E:1<K€

S * ,8`

"

'P3

S * ,8`

"badc S G,

" S

Gfe

`

"badgh

i

6

F * ,Y`

"

E

.E:= C):+I)2T"CI<31.+,E8-")"+1<"$!1&*9#2B":#

:K-N?o+_Na+(K-NE1):+,):+I)TA"K91YK !+E521

-#H:K-N?o+jN Bu[ < !##(+,E++,E@):+,07M$!/K-&

:9#

X

3YIO3q6 E:K@1. ##=-?90+$NO #8+,E: !;+4$!0+

\s,:K- CK-NE^ )+,2)+I)2T"1F5w98.E1<€

S G,

"

'P3

S G,

"akc

Slnm

G

,po

" S * ,rq

"bakg

h

s

!tutut

S * ,Yv

"badg

h

s 6

E

›P$!/K-&(:9#;I4:#-?9+/NaK59 LK. !+E.21

-#:K-N?o+_N uH #Y+,E=< ! )=9#2CI uHE:K

> ##*:K-N?o+/NbF>w98.E <K€

G"

'P3

G

akc

" G"akc 6d

G"

1$!/"I- IA(_9+"#20#Y+*78K+, !-8.E"8+,E87)2$!+, C$C !-

+, !1 ;+V.=7B+, !-5 !#"¡:#*I&(+,E\)$!€

3 6

G '78_

[ 3

G

[ [ 6

#"¡:+,.,-" ! $h78+, !-0€D !>+,E:78+, !_=¡$C$!#L. !+,E

=

0<"&9.E"=1:# k !+,E: !#2+, !+,&L78K+, !_]¡$C$!#G. !+,E

>

+,E

#9 !/K $H1:#

=

<K"&9.E:FJ™ !<"}+,E:#"¡2 !+, ! L+,E"

E $!#A€4' # 'j6B7kF

w C:-0.+,E:;-1Ak1:+,E;78_$C):1$!/"I+5- IA;_9+"##

+B78+, !-0[A.-1- $!-)2$!K+8+,E:+,E )/ E):+1;+,E:1<$! &

'5G7B9#2"$I&+,E.78_$C):$C C ;-")"-FjD4+4)4K#21:+

+,E1$C$! . C/]+K+, ! €

E

€++1$49)7\I"149#25 C8/ !<K"+ $!/K&F

E €78K_ !7\)7 1H+,E:L. C#21~, !Ÿ0

*

,

1:#

*

?

3 C

+"785 z:K-N?o+6"F

E

"4'M3

S c" 6 tutut

6

S

"

6"F

E

" I$!9-N?X<K-+ . !+,EL+, !

" 6

"badc 6

tut t

"bakgkc F

.E"z[

' 3> 6 tutHt

6 >

! "# $

%<G

"

'&

6 = 6

tutut 6=

! "# $

m gCakc

o

%<G

"

'&

6

" ' ( "

"bakc U RN*)Qv

3u16

.E"+( "f !HI2$!9-?L78K+, !_*#"¡:#LK. $C$!15€

( "'

,---. / "

tut t 0+"

tut t

FFF FFF FFF

FFF FF F FFF

tutHt

132

22222

4

;-E(I2$!9-?( C5( "G !5= ) 78+, !_( h#% !7B":, !1

76

[

.E" / "M1:#80+"ž-0- )+]1(+,EL"< !-+, !78( #R+,E

. C#21 C:1 -1+, $c78-E:12 !7 ,A-0+, !<"$!&FZ›5R1:1$!&9, !

, !7H C$! H+(l|1pA781&8IA- !0#* )+. +,E:-1+,Eg<$! &

'5O789#2$5#20-" CIA#W IA1<X #Q+,E:(/:" !-X+"78H / "

1:#0 " - LI- $!-")$!+0#GKU $C$!15€

E 3/

".6

G

€.,)7 >"< !-IA0+,.L:9#:9œ #-I@:K-N?o+

Na3 C:-$C):#9 C:/X+,E:5:9#/I4 #;9o6@ C+,E !k+,EL0_ !+1:#

v8+,E". !F;.E:4€

3/ " 6 G

'R78_<>=

[@?BADCFE F [" 6

=BG

3Vn6

.E:"

G

2++,E0+. z:9#.IA+V."X:9#H9

#-I,FšUœ+,E0_ !+IA+V."L9#_I@1:#9[

rG !

^7=+,&(+5 #Y3

/

";6

G

! ) $h+

= F

E

3I0 " 6 G

€.š9 !.:9#.E )+/ C/(+, \(-.K+-12

+, $!;3+,E21):/1E(5 C# Q780-NE !7(64+,E. )+/1 C:/+,1

¡:- z +,E"59#2+9

CX+,E#9 !+, CI2)+, !Y+,0[9+,E"L.

. C$C$5- $C$9XBKJ,-1+, $C$C C/f9#LG1:#9

!+J,12

-+1DL83#% CTA"+.7O !+k20#2-0 .E2 !-E( !k !+k

"+.:9#16"F£: c_97H2$![: CD+,E=-K=1;+,E:H>n '5

789#"$[412$!&L+,E$!1<H ;+,E8+,(3-" !<K"6 H-12

+, $C$C C/b9# #GE <K8(-7B78 Q1:-0+ 1[z.E2 !-EY !

+,E:9K+.:9#F5.E:Q3I0+".6 !5+,E:H78_ !7)7a1< $C$

< !-H+, !78. 5-?9+/N~3 C:-$C):#9 CA/*+,E9#2RI@1:#>9o6"F

.E:"

3I0+"56

G

'R78_;< =

[@?BADCIMNE F [" 6

=@G

6 3|o6

.E:"O9

!H+,E8 -+181k9#2;9FBšUH9B !\+X-

+, $C$C C/]9#215+,E"_ !+5:+,E*I+,.0"(:9#H9

#-I,[43I0+">6

G

! ) $h+

= F

.E $C$!1. C:/(+,E 07~l—up41$C$!15):5<K"&8K, C$!&L+\)+,E:

78K_$C) 781$C !7a+B-7=)+=+,E+,E21):/1E2)+ I+ C# €

PQSRTVUVR W uFXXŽƒ!„HŽYŽY“5‘1…

–

Ž"‘;ƒŽŒH‘qDZƒ—„:‘>Œ=‹9ƒ…Ž"‘z3( " 6 "[

‹9…,‘>‹C†ŽYŽY“5‹9’:“ƒ!„:Ž—ŽŒ.‰A!Ž‘;ƒ!„:‘.‘D\9Ž—ƒ‘1’:‘4†Š $C !7 ":]^`_FaBb_

" '

c8d

‹!‘“]ƒ!„:‘egfK‹"‰z‡2’:†

–

‘D\0‰†9’:‘1’:ƒihBŽƒ!„œ‰z…V†9˜"‹9˜1Ž—!ŽsƒjfklY

c

"†9…•

…,‘‰†9’:“ƒ†*ƒ!„:‘8Žs’

–

‘ …0‘=†Š8ƒ!„:‘8‹3fŒ.‰zƒ†9ƒŽƒ!„:…,†9‡Kˆ „ ‰z‡ƒ†ŠHƒ—„:‘

†9’:’:‘ ƒŽ†9’mY

<onqprnL"20"+L+,E:78K+, !_R:17 #2¡2#MKn n'

78K_

G 3 6 G

FDE(,)7=+, ! Z 5 !#"+, !-1$H"< !-*+, !7B8 !

+,) $, C-+,E-1:, !#"#L7)$!+, !-+, ! X !K,):7B#*+

IA( C+K#2&Y+K+*. !+,EQ¡:_90#R. C:#1a, !Ÿ0F<1.<K"1[;+,E:

C#2"":#"-( >+,E:< !-8+, !785 !+5(-"$!11F<"[+,E:

"< !-X+, !7881(- , !#2#R+*IA8 C#2A"#2"+8187B+,E"

78K+, !- $;+,K-+ I C$C !+,&F

.E ?+]+,EH IA1<B+,E:17*[A(, !7=$!8$C C:1-")"-

I#81(; ):K+, ! L3uq64781&\IA;):#B+-K7=2)+5+,E:>+,E21):/1E2

):+; A+,E.1<$! &H'5Y789#2$F>&\-)2, !<K-07=):+K+, ! X

" .;-1( I+ C(+,E$Dz& ):1<8_ "+3+,Ek C<"51A+,E:

+,E )/ E2)+6

c

'S$C !7 ":]^s_Fa b _

"

1=$!1/(" )/ EW<1 $C)8

NbFhE" !5H+,#"V TLIA+V."X+,E--)2K-&( +,E0+, !78

+, ! 1:#L+,E+, !78 ) C#+8+, !78K+=+,E+,E )/ E2)+F5G

-E:9K!N ' n vvKvb CW1)2(-0 $!-")$!+, !1:[.E2 !-EW.H,)\œ-" !"+

+GE1<789+,E}-")2<K*1:#+,E )/ E):+L<1 $C)X !+,EZ7B $C$

-12¡#2:-H C+"<1 $!83$!5+,E

ut

. !+,E^8x

vt

I I C$C !+,&6"F

4. NUMERICAL RESULTS

8-E:9K88E:K78/K":0 )\I C:1&L+,H+ A1$!/& >#":+,E

w' FYšQ+,E !]+1A $!K/&[>+,E:* 8¡<X <K"$!1&G9#2L3 C

-"$C)#% C/8+,E5 )- !+"$C06; (+,E.:K+,E]s7M+,E5 )-+1&

- !<"1F1.0+,.R+V.L1<"$!1&Y9#2(+,E"*1*+V.*$!/K-&

9#2F^G80_97= C*+,E8 C C)::-X +,E= $C$!1. C/G:0+,.1?

7B+"1L+,E+,E21):/1E2)+€

E

i)7\I"1;-+, !<K-" !<K"[

E

r C#21O, !Ÿ [ *

,

[1:#: *

? [

. /0+, ! X#%)5++,E.-"K+, \(-. !789#"$!#(5 #2K7

"< !-H#"$!1&*+5K-NEL9#F

w ! -+,E:L, !7)2$!K+, ! G1*-K7=):+K+, ! $C$s&<"&Q_A2

, !<K[k>\9-):H Y+V. ?H 57B9#2"K+(, !Ÿ( !+,ED)2Q+X|9n

-"$C !"+F5i+[9E1.<1[:+,E+5+,E:$!/K !+,E7= !-8#-"K=1;+,E:

+,E )/ E2)+. I"<K#= Cl|1p9 !k1$C#&=+, !-0 I$!1$!.+,E

|9n*-$C !"+FY(- , !#2(*E:0 <9&V+1 C$"< !-X+, !78(#% !+, CI)

+, ! Z1:#Q):+,E!. ):##1+Y#9 !+, CI2)+, ! O. !+,EZ780

x

'Mu=1:#L-09&\(-" !"+1;<1 !+, !1Q ) $;+LuvKvL3Iy;'Pv

t

|K||K|2[

z

'M|

6

u0vu{[| 'žu

t

6"FcE= I I C$C !+,&Q#":, !+V&bs)2-+, ! D

+,EIA ):## +B#% !+, CI):+, !D !/1 !<"I&:€

}43

S 6 ' ym~

uQ3Iym

z 6 ~ | S a m c€

~ o

65.E"y>

S  z t

.E:0 ^ ), C:/(=E1<9&V+ C$;"< !-0#% !+, CI):+, ! !+V.

1$!# FB£4 C+[ !+ !.$C$C?91.R+,E+789#"$C C:/+,E8_A1:"+, !1$

+,H\(-81:#GE !/ E$!&Y<1 & C/L$! 5(3F/2F;> ):##Q +o6"[41

7B .12 !+Hl p,Fhw%0- # [, C-. !+4 !@9)78" !-0 $C$!&8#9 \(-")$!+

+(1I:+1 CY,)$!+ cœ$!1/"9)7IA"1k0-" !<83 &Yu0vvKv

+Xuv8vKvv96"[):, C/( XE:1<9&V+ C$;#9 !+, CI):+, !1Q $C$!15+87B9#2"$

3K+\$!0+(+LG-0"+ CW_9+"#6=+,E:(IA"E1< ! X c+,E:Xg<$! &

'5M789#"$> !+,Ef]$! /K"89)7\I"81.- !<"F^šU#20# [h

+,E5/ 1)28I-7Bk$! /K"1[9+,E.21I:1I2 C$C !+V&*+,E+;#% CTA"+.,)I2

+,08 c+,E:X#% !+, CI)+, 1P+,> ?Q_" !"-G#9 CTA"+*-12

/K+, ! D-1:#9 !+, ! IA-K785E2 !/1E:"1F, C:/(1LE:1<9&X+ C$4$!1

0,)2$!+8 C-$C !"+*_" !"-" C:/W<"&D#% CTA"+*-1:#9 !+, ! L

+,E" CL+,E*7 +,EG1)2-D #P+,E9)*1$C$! +Q+,*+,E

g<K"$!1&8'5r789#"$[-"+, C/H- #% !+, !1:, !7= C$! +H+,E:5-K

1;=$! /K"+V. ?AF

@¡+41I:+1 C=9)78" !-0 $:,)$!+41>n L'5b7B9#2"$F;

0 Cœ£4 !/ ) +,E+;+,E.+,E21):/1E2)+U ;>n Y'5Y789#"$:#"

-5K.+,E:59):7IA"14- !<". C-"0F5šU(K-+[kE C

+,0 )Ql| p41<#*¡++,E+.1_A "+, !1$C$&#% !+, CI)+#Y"

< !-0=+, !780[A+,E:#-"K\ !521A +, !1:1$.+H$!/A3 6..E" !

+,E9)7\IA 0-" !<F

0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35

0.4 0.45 0.5 0.55 0.6 0.65 0.7 0.75 0.8 0.85

Number of Receivers

Throughput

W ^e =50 W ^e =15

- !D" !&% '' 7 9;01K9C 535/443 15;0 /5

7:

.-07= ;+,E:;1<"$!1&1:#H+,E:;>n L'5b7B9#2"$[o.7\)+

-E97812 C/ s)2$;. C#21Z, !ŸF.E1<+,E K78+"

[ *

?

[: #: *

, € -1+, $!+,E\9)7\I"1.1):++1:#9 C:/

-?90+œ C}+,E:(:0+,.1?A[ *

?

- +,1$!*+,E]$!<K"$1-1)2$C C:/

I+,.0"8I -NE; A+,E.'Y+,[K #

*

,

-0 +, $!>+,E:k9)7=

I" 1):++1:#9 C/]-?9+. CLHI21:-E*IA0+,.L+,>=1<$! &

9#FRL.1+=+-7H:1L+,E:X+,E21):/1E2):+(A"178 -

15IA+,EQ'5O789#2$!= H+,E(78(9):7IA"B 1):++1:#9 C:/

-?90+1LK-NEX:K+,EL7`+,E:1)2-0+8=/1 !<"L0-" !<1F5šU

>k#"+5+,E:;++1$#2:+,E(1:+,E.+,;w=[1+,E"B+,E:; $C$!1. C:/

0 ):K+, ! D7\)+.E:1$!# € ' wop *

,

3{96

£:1+,E:Bg<"$!1&L'5789#2$[A.=. C$C$;_9K7= C8+,.B-[

#"A:#9 C:/D Q+,E8<1 $C)*1#+*

?

IA C:/L¡2 !+( C¡2 !+FL£

+,E=¡2 !+(-K[."+,)2$!+1+,E8#9 CTA""+8<11$C):

1# *

?

[A78"$!&DE" *

? ' u[ *

?

'& *

,

# *

? ' u0v

6

*

,

F>wo C-H+,E:"H +,E9#20=3+,>=$!/K-&]9#1:#L+,E

1<K"$!1&*:9#= !+"$C06IA0+,.+,.(#1dK-"+1<"$!1&*9#2K[4.

-E95+,E:57= C !781$A- /0+, ! L. C#21W+IA.1A, !Ÿ# *

,

'|2[

, C- * |81:9#2 ! $!.1&9 !#9$!F

IAY0" CM£4 !/1)2QmY1L#9 CTA""+<1 $C)L +*

,

E"J+,E:

)+,):+=I)TA"(, !Ÿ08 $C$1<$! &:9#81*,)78#Q+*IA

C¡2 !+F5.E:+,E )/ E):++ &951$!78+- + +5 #* !. C:#"

A"#"+=15+,E=9):7IA"B >-" !<K"F*£ *

? ' .R[z*-K7=

$!+#20- )2$C C/] !5K-NE !<0#* #*+,E"5 !I:K-N?9,)=+

+,E]1)2-0F*£ H C:+1:-K[@ C+,E"(9--")=L-0 /+, !1R CQ

,)I:+,K[+,E:B )+,2)+I2)TA"B +,E:81<K"$!1&b9#2H CQ-NE /K8

+,E+.,)I:+,0. C$C$A¡2$C$A)] C¡2 !+"$!&Y3>K,):7B C¡2 !+\I)TA"06

#*+,E )-. C$C$4<K"IA0-781.11F;£: 5+,E !0 z[

.-1:, !#"¡2 !+=<11$C):1A *

?

C+,E+5 ;+,E ! "1F

0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35

0.5 0.55 0.6 0.65 0.7 0.75 0.8 0.85 0.9 0.95

Number of Receivers

Throughput

W ^o c =10 W ^o

c =3

- ./$021354% ' '87 9;01K9; 535/413 15;0

/5M27 w ' *

? ' .

Dz+.):.#"¡:H+,E‰‘1…—Š†9…ŒH‹9’:"‘Ž’:1…,‘‹0‘K.+,E:K+, !8 h+,E:

+,E )/ E2)+8 +,E(g<$! &D'M789#"$>+L+,E:B+,E21):/1E2):+

>+,E8.n1P'5P7B9#2"$FBGH,)788+,E++,E8<1 $C)(

!-0 $!-")$!+#. C; ):K+, ! W3{96"F

0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35

0.6 0.7 0.8 0.9 1 1.1 1.2 1.3 1.4 1.5 1.6 1.7 1.8 1.9 2

Number of Receivers

Performance Increase

W ^o f =30 W ^o

f =3 W ^o

f =1

-0 927 3A5 597 3 9 9^ 535/-4 3 15;

0/5!27 Fw'

*

,

'|

8= C¡/ )*y(+,E: !7=-+H >+,E8<1 $C)]1# *

?

D+,E:

A"U 781:- z+,E1<"$!1&8'5Q789#2$F.£:1 *

?

'+ *

,

[9+,E:

1<"$!1&('5r789#"$z/ !<K5=+,E )/ E):+.A"U 781:-+,E+; !

, !7= C$!1*+X+,E:B œU H+,E]>n Z'5M789#2$F*£:1 +*

? ' u[

+,E-0 )2$C C/8 z+,E5#% CTA"+kI -NEk !;+,E:5+, !/1E++kAK, CI2$!

Y1:#+,EY+,E )/ E2)+L B1<"$!1&Z' 789#"$H !]IA"$!1

E #A[A++, C:/ *

? ' u0v

6

*

,

1$C$!1+8-E !<8B, !/ C¡:-1+

" 7B -\ C-"KFEA"U 781:-1 *

?

'Muv

6 *

,

!, !7= C$! B+8+,E \U *

? ' .RF>E !0,)2$!+5 !7= !, C/2[

K !+#781:+,K++,E:K+1<$! &L'5R !2K-+, !-1$C$!&GK, CI2$!

, C-(.’:Žƒ‘ C2)+\I)TA"H CYK-NED1<"$!1&L:9#= !,)\(-" !"+

+7B ?9+,E:5+,E )/ E2)+.A"178 - $!78K+ C#"A"#2+1

+,E9)7\IA 0-" !<F

< ><"1[z+,E8#20- )2$C C/Y15+,E:B#% CTA"+=I -NEH 5+,E

1<K"$!1&R'5 !(1I:+1 C:#Z+(+,EL_A" HG$!1/"^+, !78

0 )2 C#RU B+,E:(I:K-N?9,)G+*K-NEW+,E*1)2-KF1D4+=)

#"+LI&6;kH4[Huo

w=[5 B 1<K"$!1&R:9#G !+

#9 !+ -57Z+,E:> )-F;.E:"z[1 ;+,E.1<"$!1&H'5G789#"$[

578K_ !7\)7M14u0v

6

*

, 6

:K-N?o+4:0#2+;IA."+AIA"1k+,E

1)2-0=IA-K78 > H ;+,E=-1:/K+, ! f9--") C:/LK+#"+,E

1].E"K.+,E2 !;9):7IA". ! 'Kw

6 *

,

CX+,E:5>n Q'5

7B9#2"$FO.EL+, !78L (I-?92,)Y+G0-E+,EG1)2-L !

E !/ E+k CX+,E.1<"$!1&8'5Y789#"$A.E"(-0 /+, !1L9--")

_9+X+Y+,E:*0-" !<1FO£: X+,E !*.1+]-0[HuvY+, !7B*781

-?90+#(+IA"+k)#2"+,E1<$! &('5r7B9#2"$z)2+, C$

+,EI-?92,)=K-NE+,E:1)2-KF

£:1 *

,

'a| #Q|9n*-" !<K"[5G+,E )/ E):+8 C-"L1

1IA )+ v t

!; I"<K#]1.+,E51<"$!1&8'5f CX-K5 AE:0 <9&

+1 C$!#M"< !-0Y+, !783G£4 !/1)2fy6"FO.E:LA"U 781:- C2

-81I:<#GU +,E81<$! &789#"$; !78 C$!&G#9)]+(+,E

0<"5+,E )/ E2)+5#2/1#+, !1L z+,E.>n Q'5f7B9#2"$ !+,E

C-"K, C:/Y9)7\I"X 0-" !<FWšUW+,E"(.1#2[>.E2 C$!L+,E

" 7B -8 >+,E81<"$!1&L'5P789#"$ !+, !/ C¡- +,$!&

1TA-+0#\I&1 C:-"0k CB+,E:;9):7IA"h -" !<K"[9+,E@A

7B -1.+,E5.n1Y'5r789#"$A#-"0.#9+, !-0 $C$!&] CX-K

1+,EE1<9&(+ C$!#L"< !-0=+, !780Fk£ 5+,E>n W'Q789#"$[

-?90++,):-?LK++,E=-1:/K+#L:9#8. C$C$;#%)-H+,E:H1<"1$C$

+,E )/ E):+(, C-(+,E:( )-(+ H":#9 C/G:K-N?o+H<"f+

+,E.:1+k1A+,..E"5+,E: !- /+, !14FšUB+,E:51<$! &

'5P7B9#2"$[z+,E8 )+,2)+I)2TA/ !<(+,E\-0 &C:_ CI C$C

!+V&G+L+1$!"+X+, , !"+8-1:/K+, ! W CQ<1 & C/b +B 5+,E

#9 !+, CI):+, !1R+,0. !+,E:1):+#20/ #+, !1Y CL+,E )/ E):+F

5. CONCLUSIONS

.E8+,E21):/1E2)+]#/1#+, ! } 5>n J'M. !+,EY C-"K,

C/*9)7\IA81.-" !<K"H.¡+=,E1.GI&DkE:1 C+, )l| pVF

<1.<1[%8-1)2+7B,).;21A#X+=<"+5,)-NE

H+,E )/ E2)+5#2/1#+, !14F5 AK\1<"$z'5r7B9#2"$

U 1<K"$!1&:+V. ?z+,E:K+4781?9z+,E:;+,E )/ E2)+4A"178 -

1X7\)$!+, !-+D, ! O C#2"":#"+W (+,EY9):7IA"Q1("

-0" !<"FšUX:1+, !-")2$!11[

E

.21A(*.s !":#9$!&7\)$!+, !-+H-1:/K+, ! W-12

+, $o789#2$9 z1<"$!1&+,> ?4+,E+z-7I C:;.. C#21.

I:K#-1:/K+, ! (-0 +, $9I+,.0"H#1d-0"+41<$! &9#

. !+,EZY. C:#1I# C:1 - +,1$H78-E:12 !7 C, !#

-EW1<"$!1&r9#F.E:C:1 #R-1:/K+, ! Z-0 +, $

C+"-0++H $C$!1MI:K-N?9,)=+=0-E+,E:1)2-0F

E

. 781$C !Ÿ+,E51<"$!1&H'Y789#"$A< !+ $C C:1

-")"-=0 ):K+, ! [4.E !-NED $C$!15):+=)=+,E 0+, C

- $z,)$!+7 +,E:H78K_$C)=1$!/"I*+(-K7=2)+8+,E

+,E21):/1E2)+ h8'R, !15=):-0+, ! h+,E:9)7=

IA"H15+,E:8-0" !<"[;+,E8. C:#1 #GI)2TA8, !ŸK[k1:#

+,E:< !-=+, !7B#% !+, CI):+, !zF

.E*2"$C !7H C:1&¢,)$!+L I+ C#Z,E:1~+,E+( X1<$! &

178 -L H1<K"$!1&R'5ž<9F;.n1ž'5[k>L*+,E+81

|9nY-" !<K" #P21A"$!&Z-NEMI2)TA"D, !Ÿ+,EY1<"$!1&

'5ž& !"$!#* v t

!7= <K78"+F}E]U-+8+,E+H (1<K"

$!1&Y'5M+,E:(+,E )/ E2)+87B\):1TA-+0#fI&+,Eœ9)7IA"

0-" !< !5#%)H+8=E !/ E#/ 1;#20- )2$C C/L ;+,E#9 C

"+@I -NE[E !-ELIA*K-NE !<K# [ CL+,E5-" !.

-1:, !#"#A[4. !+,E.’:Žƒ‘•,0Ž1‘I)2T" C+,E1<"$!1&]9#F

›4):+,)5. ?A[K.k C+:#8+0_9+":#A[9" !+,E";9):7B" !- $C$!&(1

$!&9+, !-0 $C$s&[.+,E=,)$!+=1I:+1 C:0#fE"8+X+,E:B-81.$! /K"

/ 1)2œ, !ŸF;.E:5781d >-E:1$C$!":/K. C$C$:IA5+¡:#B )+k.E+,E:

+,E]K78 )+( 5I)2TAL3 B ) !< 1$!"+,$!&9[. B )(-E:078[;+,E:

+, !/ E+, B+,E::C:1~-1+, $s6* C:-X+,E:D/ )J, !Ÿ

C-"0FML781&r0_A-+X+,E:K+œ CH>*-1+, C9):Y+D_:1:#

+,E8, !Ÿ*15+,E=I2 C &D+,.=E1<89-")#Y14[h+,E:=I)TA"

 ) C78"+H7= !/1E+=<K"+,) $C$!&G C-"Kœ)9IA1)2#20# FXgD+,E:

+,E"E # [9 CA>k-1:, !#"5 )2 !+5789#"K+1<K"$!1&\+,> ?A[

1&. !+,EBkY+:z A31<"$!1&6 9#20[9. !+,EH78 &-"$C !"+;-

-+#L+80-E":#9:9#*3 C1)2c, !7\)$!+, !1:[>- , !#2#

$!&*1:-$C !"+A""#%9#2q6"[A.-1LE:1A+8781 C+ CD+,E:

!-.21A"+, !.1:1)2>-E:7BFk:K+.<K"+,):1$C$!&(+,E:K++,E:"

_ !+H(+,#"V TYIA0+,.Y+,E=$!<K"$.1k$C ! I C$C +V&Y 5+,EH"

< !- #8+,E:.9)7\I".1A-"$C !"+FšU(1)2>"< !-5789#"$[..1 !7

+41< !#% C/8"< !-5+,E:K+4 !L !"#9$!&8 B-EHI21:-E(

+,E+, #]+,E+; !. $!=s)2$C$!&("$C ! I$!F5›-1: )"- h+,E:

$!++.-1:+,1 C+k !;+,E:K+k+,E5 <K"$!1&\+V. ?B7\)+;,$! W#21.

C-K ;=$!1:/X- /+, !1G CL +51;+,E:#9 !+, CI2)+, ! W+,KF

£:1H<"&*$!1/81:#LE2 !/1E2$!&D-++"0#Y/ 1)2[4K788K+,E:"H1

$C)+, ! $C C?9E2 !"1-NE&X #L/ 1)2 C:/[::0#L+=IA C<K+, !/K+#

+H78 C+1 C\E !/ EX$!<"$h z"$C ! I C$C +V&L. !+,E:1):+.K-" C¡-" C:/X+,E:

1<"1$C$I:1:#. !#2+,EzF

Acknowledgments

.E2 !51-NE^.5,)2A1+#LI&*š+"$;.1A K+, ! zF

6. REFERENCES

l!u"pc£.F9.K--"$C$C [h™=FA.1E:"z[A™=Fg$!#"1[A # 2F,F)#9+[

f’"„:…V†9’:Ž1‹9ƒŽ—†9’8‹9’“ ehŽ’:‘‹9…"ŽsƒjfBZz‹9’cˆ9‘1˜1…,‹.Š0†9…

Ž—01…,‘1ƒ‘

–

‘1’:ƒf 0ƒ‘1Œ\[9r C$!0&[uxKx9n%F

lnqp 2F9.&K"5+5 $F![HJeš7=1<#. /0+, ! D. +,1$41š

'*)2$!+, !-0+5, C/&7= !-D41&"FL[Aš>…,†1BY

[9i1<K7\I"Hn1vvvF

l| pc›=F>E C+,0 )z[A£.F>--$C$C [ #LF !K+[Jš7H:K-+5

i+V. ?!"$!1&#"; !+, !1Y1L'*)$!+, !-+Hw9, !1:

"178 -H !+,E.$C C?oH. /+, !1Q. +,1$L2[%$†

‹"‰9‰‘"‹9…5Ž’'&()*+$…,‹9’20‹91ƒŽ†9’25†9’#c‘ ƒB†9…V”9Ž’9ˆ[9n1vvon%F

l{ p\wF, 2F™ $!+12 > ##-8F.-8F:w9 I [+JV£2)2#78"+1$

gI:< K+, ! '*)$!+, !-+H.1:/K+, ! D. +,1$4 C+,E

šU+"+FL[zšU>…,†1BY†Š&(/1020*3546 6[94FxxKv87:u0vvKv2[

i:9; ?A[w9›=['L -EYuxKxxF

l pcPF™ /]0+1$F—[Jg^+,E:1 C$! ;"I^£4 C$!(wo !Ÿ0

!+, CI):+, !FL2[@šU>…,†1BY†Š;6•ƒ!„!‘1…ƒ†9’<h†9’Š‘1…,‘1’:‘

†9’†9ŒHŒ=‡’:Ž‹9ƒŽ†9’ Z*†9’:ƒ…,†iZ;‹9’“#†9Œ.‰z‡2ƒŽ’9ˆ[g-0+ IA"

n vKv2uF

lm p\wF'L-1. :K[="=F. -1I:14[A1:#X'YF>";++"$C [

J,j5- !<"V#9 !<"1Dz1&"#L'*)$!+, !-K+FL2[hšU.&?20)3!3

6 @[92zF4uKu1yA7u|Kv2[A›)/ )+=u0xxKm2F

lyqpRDkFj !Ÿ0Ÿ2[J:/K78--€;›M.@ !:#9$!&Lw C:/1$!"Vj5+

'*)2$!+, !-0+H. /+, !1Q.1+, $;w9-E:7BL2[šU>…,†1BY†Š

3B>&?10)3#3C4 [w%+9-?9E $!7*[zw9.#"z[:›)/ )+

. /+, !1D1+, $z /D41&K"#*'*)$!+, !-K++

4 ,"DL[:š>…,†1BY†Š&()* &(/1020*3546 [94F

xxKm87:u0vvK|2[zw9 L£ -" !-2[z.›H[cw%›H[:'L1-NEDuxxKt2F

lx1p 2Fr !#78"1:#L'YF0< #%$!&K[J,;_9+":#9 C/

k )+, !12I#D. /+, !1Q.1+, $+B'*)2$!+, !-K+

›2$C !-0+, ! FL2[@šU.&?20)3!3 k[o›)/ )+n1vvuF

. /+, !1Q. +,1$.35£'556"€2+9-0 $

wo-" C¡-+, !1L2[;[Aš+":0+ 5 +[i1<07\IAn1vvuF