Publisher’s version / Version de l'éditeur:
Technical Note (National Research Council of Canada. Division of Building Research), 1964-10-01
READ THESE TERMS AND CONDITIONS CAREFULLY BEFORE USING THIS WEBSITE. https://nrc-publications.canada.ca/eng/copyright
Vous avez des questions? Nous pouvons vous aider. Pour communiquer directement avec un auteur, consultez la
première page de la revue dans laquelle son article a été publié afin de trouver ses coordonnées. Si vous n’arrivez pas à les repérer, communiquez avec nous à PublicationsArchive-ArchivesPublications@nrc-cnrc.gc.ca.
Questions? Contact the NRC Publications Archive team at
PublicationsArchive-ArchivesPublications@nrc-cnrc.gc.ca. If you wish to email the authors directly, please see the first page of the publication for their contact information.
NRC Publications Archive
Archives des publications du CNRC
For the publisher’s version, please access the DOI link below./ Pour consulter la version de l’éditeur, utilisez le lien DOI ci-dessous.
https://doi.org/10.4224/20386634
Access and use of this website and the material on it are subject to the Terms and Conditions set forth at
Restoration of Lower Fort Garry, Manitoba: Foundations of Factor's Residence
Hamilton, J. J.
https://publications-cnrc.canada.ca/fra/droits
L’accès à ce site Web et l’utilisation de son contenu sont assujettis aux conditions présentées dans le site
LISEZ CES CONDITIONS ATTENTIVEMENT AVANT D’UTILISER CE SITE WEB.
NRC Publications Record / Notice d'Archives des publications de CNRC:
https://nrc-publications.canada.ca/eng/view/object/?id=cd10e527-2cec-4278-9fe5-854900abde4d https://publications-cnrc.canada.ca/fra/voir/objet/?id=cd10e527-2cec-4278-9fe5-854900abde4d
NATIONAL RESEARCH COUNCIL OF CANADA
DIVISION OF BUILDING RESEARCH
'Jr
EClHIN II CAlL
NOTlE
RESTRICTED CIRCULATION
セ
セi
PREPARED BY J. J. Hamilton CHECKED BY G. O. H. APPROyED By R. F. L.
.2AI!.. October 1964
PREPARED FOR National Historic Sites Division, Department of Northern
Affairs and National Resources
SUBJECT
RESTORATION OF LOWER FORT GARRY, MANITOBA
RESTORATION OF LO\'lER FORT GARRY" MANITOBA FOUNDATIONS OF FACTOR'S RESIDENCE
by J.J. Hamilton
In response to a request from the National Parks Branch" Department of Northern Affairs and Nat20na.l Resources, the writer met in Saskatoon with Mr. Peter John Stokes, Con-sulting Restoration Architect to the National Historic Sites Division on August 24"
1964.
Mr. Stokes described the nature of foundation problems at the site and stressed the importance of preserving as much of the original construction as possible. In addition" available soils maps of the area (1) and a report on a foundation investigation for the new museum building in the fort (2) were studied and a visit was made to the site on September 29,1964.
This report includes a brief review of soil conditions at the site" general comments on performance of existing foundations" and specific suggestions for improve-ments to the main residence baseimprove-ments.Soil Conditions
The site is located in the grass-woodland transition soil zone of central Manitoba, on the west side of the Red River" nineteen miles north of Winnipeg. The agricultural
soils appear to be black earths with degrading black earths and are formed on calcareous glacial drift. They are mapped
(1) as Red River clay which has usually developed on lacustrine
2
soils mapping in the vicinity of the Fort might place the soils in the Semple or Lakeland Associations. The Semple Association comprises degrading black earth and associated soils within the grey-black transition zone on a thin mantle of lacustrine sediments, ranging from
6
to15
inches in depth, that rests on till or eroded till. The Lakeland soils are weakly developed calcic blackearth-like soils and associates that have been developed on calcareous silty or fine sandy lacustrine and flood plain sediments, overlying calcareous till substrate.The hummochy appearance of the ground surface of these soils in their virgin state is due to the formation of polygonal rifts in which have developed broad tongued intrusions of surface clay into the calcareous subsoil. It is believed that frost action has played a part in the formation of this patterned ground.
The foundation engineering investigation for the new Museum Building (2) revealed an olive brown clayey silt from the one foot to three foot depths over appoximately
15
teet of stiff brown clayey silt with numerous silt pockets and lime-stone fragments up to tour inches maximum size; in turn, over-lying a layer of dense sandy silt with numerous limestonefragments up to a maximum size ot eight inches, of light brown color and unknown thickness. In addition to the borings made in the above cited investigation. another boring was made in the south west corner ot the basement under the west wing ot
3
the main residence at the time of our visit on September
29.
This boring confirmed the horizontal stratification of thesubsoil drift in the area.
In ァ・ョ・イ。ャセ the soils encountered at usual foundation depths are of fair bearing capacity. moderate to slight
swell-ing 」ィ。イ。」エ・イゥウエゥ」ウセ low permeability and medium to high
poten-tial frost susceptibility. They are not expected to exhibit the high volume change potential due to swelling and shrinking characteristics of the heavier clay soils of the Lake Agassiz deposits further to the south. However. problems due to frost action and seepage of ground water would be expected to be more serious here than in the heavier clays.
Performance of Foundations
Examination of existing structures at the fort. some of which have stood for more than 130 ケ・。イウセ and are among the oldest buildings in m。ョゥエッ「。セ provides interesting information about foundation performance on these subsoils. The good verti-cal and horizontal allignment of the massive stone walls
around the fッイエセ in spite of the growth of fairly large trees in the immediate vicinity of the walls. gives further evidence of the low shrinkage characteristics of these subsoils and their reasonably high bearing capacity. In addition to the polygonal micro relief of the topography mentioned above. most of the damage to unheated buildings in the fort could be attributed to frost action. The cracked floor slab in the penitenti&r1
--
4
and asylum bUilding and the cracking of the walls of the south-WQst bastion are evidences of probable frost heaving and/or the loss of bearing strength upon thawing of frozen soils.
Main emphasis in our examinations at the site was given to the basement of the main residence building, where considerable distortion of the load bearing masonry walls and serious humidity problems ,are evident.
Differential settlement of the load bearing wall in the southwest side of the original residence to the extent of approximately one inch per foot run has taken place. Apparently this settlement has developed slowly over a relatively. long
period of time, as there are no indications of abrupt movements as would cause masonry shear failures. The greatest settlement has occurred at the north end of the area way, between the
original residence and the more recent southwest wing. Near this point a massive chimney and base of a tormer bake oven or hearth rise from the basement floor. Under the weight ot the
wall and chimney, the footings in the area were probably not adequately proportioned for equal settlement. A tormer outside stair-well, which gave access to this basement area from the west side, could have contributed to the settlement problem. Frost action beneath the stair-well would tend to aggrevate the problem and heat flow from the fireplace could well have aided the loss of soil moisture.
As basement areas have not been fully utilized tor . a number of ケ・。イウセ their humidity problems have increased. Abandonment of open fireplaces, with their relatively high
5
-ventilation ratel resulting from chimney draftl and the more
recent use of electric space heaters without adequate provision for air change has aggrevated the humidity problems. Insula-tion of the subfloor above has also contributed to lower winter basement temperatures and a reduction of air exchange within the building. Frost action beneath the basement floor slabsl
increased permeability of the masonry foundations due to mortar deterioration, and increased moisture in the surrounding soil due to lawn and garden watering" have probably all contributed to greater migration of soil moisture into the basements. At the time of our visitl a clothes washer and dryer combination had recently been installed and was not yet vented to the outside. Approximately thirty pounds of moisture is put into the air during clothes washing and drying for an average family of four (3)" and it is essential that this be exhausted outside.
Improvements could be made in grading around the residence to insure good surface drainage away from the build-ing. Along the southwest side of the addition, west of the veranda, an eavestrough downspout spills onto a depressed side-walk which will pond water and may flood the window wells
during spring runoff or heavy rainfall.
Suggested Improvements
1. Reconstruction of Foundations
In generall the foundation walls of the residence building appear to be quite stable and have nQt suffered signi-ficant movement in recent times. Reconstruction
ot
only those6
-areas which are most serious11 distorted upon foundations ade-quately proportioned to minimize future settlements should be entirely satisfactory.
2. Heating of Basements
Keeping basement areas at above freezing temperatures throughout the winter should eliminate further frost action
damage and reduce the rate of deterioration of floors and walls.
3.
waterproofing Basement Walls and FloorsIn order to reduce the seepage of ground water through the walls and floor it would be desirable to excavate a trench along the outside of the wallsl to point the mortar joints, and to waterproof the exterior surfaces. When floor slabs are
replaced in the basementl a waterproofing membrane of four mil
polyethylene film or equivalent should be placed under the new slab.
4.
Subsoil dイ。ゥョ。セ・Drain tilesl installed on the outside of the wall near
its base, will SUbstantially reduce the hydrostatic pressure acting on the walls and floor slabs. An alternate location for the tile system would be under the floor slab at its perimeter inside the basement. The tiles should drain to a sump equipped with an automatic pump, or to a storm or combined sewer through a valve which will prevent back-up into the subsoil drainage system. Provision should be made to drain window wells into the tile system.
5.
Surface DrainageAttention should be given to surface grading and
- - - ; - - - -M M セ
7
handling of roof drainage to avoid concentrated spillage or roof runoff and ponding of water near the building.
6. Humidity Control in Basements
In addition to the above mentioned improvements, it is recommended that changes be made to increase the ventilation rate in the basement. The present heating arrangements" employ-ing electric space heaters" do not provide for the required air exchange to reduce humidity. Heating the basement space may increase the length of time during which seepage can take place" resulting in a greater total moisture gain to the basement.
The amount of condensation forming on cool surfaces, such as water pipes and uninsu1ated wall areas above grade" may also be greater. Insulation of these areas will help to reduce
condensation on them and heat losses during the heating season. It is suggested that eXisting chimneys might be utilized with little or no alteration to achieve the desired ventilation. The use of a centrally located chimney as an exhaust" with the chimneys near the extremities of the building as outside-air inlets, would result in reasonably good air circulation, pro-viding doors or other vents through the basement partitions were kept open. Heaters placed at the base or the inflow chimneys to warm the incoming air" and possibly a small fan or heater in the outflow chimney to aid the natural chimney effect, could achieve the desired results with a minimum of alteration to the existing building.
8
-REFERENCES
1. eィイQQ」ィセ wNaNセ E.A. Poyser, L.E. Pratt, and J.H. Ellis.
Report of Reconnaissance Soil Survey of Winnipeg and
Morris Map Sheet Areas. Soils Report No.5. october
1953. Manitoba Soil Survey.
2. b。イ。」ッウセ Manantz and Mindess. Soil and Foundation
Investigation, Proposed Museum bオゥャ、ゥョァセ Lower Fort Garry, Manitoba. November
1962.
Winnipeg, Manitoba. 3. ASHRAE Guide and Data Book"1963.
Published by theAmerican Society of Heating" Refrigerating and Air-Conditioning Engineers. Pase
637.
e
-e
LO
1::1:)
foセtCARRV
r" セNG IH セnoiBGLケ c:;::J 159 TBGMセᆬᆪOゥGQイイ -:..
NLセ 130 r--'!,zti
I , L __ J riS;-l-'"".---('" " Dセ,.
....-...
, [r.iiJ C] r-: ruU
tKセ
y ャBGM⦅セ L...J fat. セBBBDGunl tV' ... AtCt:/l:JrHT ...⦅NBGセ IU,...----
-, GBMMMMMセ In f / / ( j l f WA H. CI":4RMt.ANOS 141 ••セPゥャWXᆪllN $IrE"
'tt' LJ イMセ , , 120: :...J8
°25 I"tJSr.$T'tJ#"'"='"'1
-.!L'! J.ow>t£mfl,'-"""HE.OONr)NtIr" AND OFlfENS
t:U,H,UOWAllAHO
rNrr«D n:>#7
セ
Pl..ANaGaoセ IIV Av&U1'Tヲセイg セBWj 5HO";Lーrcsセnイ ..JAlOセQZGmQヲNア
8lPL.DlIW!:iS. PAJ..IS.4tH"J.セQイ
セイC XvOセdイャvエ[sNセイ」スaNTcNイnoiyn OndotイᆪoセOnセNイ /N
locBtセunNウ aGエiojcaイセッ IIY[エセaャNイセッ ;-".e:U:UVi/ts.
4V11.DlAtiエZGセNhNABncセo INHxイッNbセai セVセQ fセ セNウiヲェaGs I!)F
c[GMfセNイ r,ACTl.'R .;tIlEKANOEIZcGBnセOsイセセ inoGuiアL[セ ッイセセッ
nエGヲiセr Lk$TRICr .AND r;oV£RNO,Q OF ASS'/N/80/A.
/N/lJ.U. .DI'ft'rtl.lAlt;HousE AND..$TO.OEJエZッKヲpエN⦅ctセo OnOiQセYN
jBGnセqviyoOnエ[ ;VALl."'IVDrt/WEtO I'J#S71()NS COMP/..ETeD
L£;vr;rN o,rEAt:""WALセ OncャNuセn\[ 8ArnCNrセTqBGt sas:/'r b/.JTANCFNOCjOoセ aャGt[vセen IVA.l.LS A80UTTsッセLイ
A,t2rAjGyセイnin r""JUS APPJ/N),J(/MArELセ 4J-.A&RES.
1 __: 't' {24
•-14"i--;;;s"T>INO'AIV TJi'NITY
, _OfHERL' 6Y DOMIN/ON
/!N
t;;OY'Ai-COA1M,(SS.lON£.<i!, wヲmyセsGN No $.IMPSOIV -セ A''-G•.5./87/ "'-"*!OX. '/000. セ -セ NOセセセ P"lL'-SEN7 I.I!' siOpLエZosᆪサfセDゥW[[ッイt - 1140 セ 0/' 4I/R.lAL.セセo qr i セ C\ NウエZQセBieセs qc⦅BGeNlZAセセAG J !
l
ゥGセpイ。OLNOアn セG MA H B GイarLKヲセanos 144 ,trAY /91'8 セmGーOmGゥ (f.QOI/NO 145セ
NNBオセセ
セ セ
.-セ⦅⦅⦅⦅⦅
セ⦅G⦅dsLセセ⦅t⦅GB
.,.,
-
セッ
セ NNNMMセセBGGGGGGGGGGG
.->- _ _=-
セlイBGヲnイウN
セiiG
\ ' ' .セet
:;;::;; . I...
セ
..
セMMZ[[M⦅
-==- _ \
--.!!..
e d < JJ i 1/ e rセセセ
""-_
!'t4yll..-..
QャPGセMMセ
-
- - --
- - - -MMMMセMZZZZZMMMM
----:::
セ セ セ
.⦅セ
III.BBGカセ
IセMMM
=---=:: _._,... . '"⦅tセ
....⦅ァセ
" _ 'NセッセセセオN⦅MBLᄋ^L
-'
Pth.LL'DDOWNI_セN⦅N⦅NMNM
"'"t._. _.. '17I _ «,_7" .OセL
w·セ
.. AIOLff __
t""ir"',
イMセセBGB
, - , . . . : ' .'_·_--'t·,;,:j."::::.•
N⦅MMAZセセ
..LLセ
119 ' ,... \,.,,' ·
,-,.NMᄋ[セエセ
L ' ...i..
ZセN[Z[
...
セ
• ,
,.-""'
".",..
J LBセB
. !'セセ
, •.セMN
:.. (7; t .J 1l0i Kr rT' ,..., ,"" • C 'ᆪセuNld
__ャッNセMMBG OOWNaNNセセ
_.:,'Af7 I'セLN
116 i .,,----"Co II : I ;llr - "_[]llj{ -" I . ' i -'----1-- ,..'! \ ! . i I \ I . i6 I I 0 < 0 ' \ ! 105セ セセセキ。
I セ IU \ 6 L iiiセMM \ . __ pr£WAI" セlBBセo r .- _ .__._._._.'_._ "1セャGセBBGB yry<4 \ I ⦅NセBWゥGMGMMGMG L._ !l
P'_'_,-=:=:_'KlZ-.. I i セaBRャᄋBヲャゥ[wNキjセ[]GM]GMセ . r I . . I L . __._.--.-.ji セiv • GセM..
lセ⦅j-e
e
.e
LO'
EI:)
foセtCARRV
131 f" セ
..
INO/"'... セ]ェ 139 4;1.L'K/NTT -セ 130 1i> roo, • I pSi I I ...._ ... 1 r - - , L!.tIJ C'J イGセ f!7 : i,. 11セ
y r-_.. '-.,J*
ro.fC'Nr <V" {セ ,a・セdイjyt - .1 ID ,...---, "----_...J 122 H • Cイ[TrBBNエNセゥカッNウ 14\ H/(jHWA lJ0lP8ru. セtᆪ JJ r-' セョNZ I • L... ヲGセ. .
.
:20:
,.
.
,", __ .J.
8
D25 I"I2S73 1't:J.<1 , lTT'NrJl1/vy 11 ; ⦅h、Aエtセs _ j 'I: ?/ftR£11'1 IWD, UlRN£'ODNOI'ItK AND OTIf£J1S CL/M6.rO WAll AND L"1tf1'£IO'ro nJ#7 E' セ d AOR7N.t./M/T .t.OT. /S/. ,.... .srANOREW,s セイn liBmOイセot / ,srC.t.t:"4?L'NTS
,;CIt.AN MADr IN AV'f;U:FrJ9M7CshoセNL fjエcGcDセャvイ IN(J'OPMrn
4/f,hUNM:iS,,q"USAOa;o'n:
iBャZnゥGmセNッ QQHLOOエNdッGnHェsGNイイciセqセ .s-"'O#¥NセBGdoイイfoᆪOnイsG "AI
LDC"AT/DNJ'Cvoj」セセo 8i"mセNaゥLョセo FgANJf':$.
8t1'LDlI"tIf:jcセBBGGZMncセd "'vocGイッXセp /8,$/.r.QOhtfcᆪセs o. t,;"H/,t'F F;lCnJR[Cセexanoesz chrOセtGイNincOyNエヲLqヲェセ GV"..QEO
,lNyr.<1 OIST.<1IC!; ANO t;OYC'RNOQ ()/'A5S/I"'80I.<,
,I)'OオNウNiILエゥiセBゥNセ セf "''''OJ7DQE-S &r;JIt'?Pt.CrEO. /NOTセYN
JUNROVNDIIV(j N.4I..l. ANDイッjGyセセ 8,q.sn'ONScompセヲtヲo
L£/rIfirH"orEACHセal L ,',..,Cl.UIVNY SA.$"noNSセX、エャt Sa.:( Fr
oONウtNTncセ /1'fJ'IOELLセイQGvᆪセQGイi BGNaセls Adaur'-5o.FT ARI!'AWITHIN J'Y4lL5 APPROXIMA7o'l"4r. A&/i'fS,
e SCALe orセ_...__so
]NNN[[]]o]Zャセooセ]]セセ]]Z[
100-
.---'
, 'r' "'''セNMMセ
y, 7J e rセセセ
_ _ 'セ
...---'" -4'セ
.
0<.0.n"eセ]]Mセセセセ
-::セ セNM : pNウdエQwnQャ^ャBGセᄋZ[セ i セLNLLLL ..., : __ ..⦅セセQZNMZZZVエャ
:"i4 .. -';P[[L[Nア[Z[ゥNZゥM[[G[ゥHIiセᆪヲt;
lJ \ ! - 't' CrA-•-14'£セ[ウイG (NOlAN TJiWITY" _Ot:" /'I,£8t:" 4YO"AlINION
/:N tiQyrセqGmG COMM"s,s'IONt""fl \ Wt:"MY,1"S.M.,s/MASbN " AtJ(;..s./67/ A __PWla.r,'IODD, " ,MrヲNセQGT _=1:"'7 II.P. -l IClo
li
Sl/PR7S£OPDS/TiO,y -セQTP or81/1fi11At.セno OF : -SOl.011:,(>5oセ ⦅NiヲAzlセゥ{NjNUエ J EXFYOl"7/0N MA.
4OVNDAR>' ,tIN/!' 4L"7'W/!'o'M
sQGセno[[^イキD ANDSrClo'A1I!';'Y7'...セ|QiV I \ H 15 C rAR,+fI.ANOS \44 - GtエQNヲijZkOセGB
/NOIAN Ot,H,PIM; (j.QOI/NO
. 14!
tAll'O «,t14P7M£NT
I(VDSOIIIS {MYセ。hfGaivy
LOWER.
FORT GARRY
POINTS OF INTEREST
Numilers correspond with those shown on the plan of Lower Fort Garry.
tィゥセ plan and notes thereon are taken from the book "Lower Fort Garry" (a history of the Slonc Fort) by Rohert Watson, published in 1928 by the hオ、セッョGウ Ray Company; cloth, 76 pagcs, RZセ illustrations 。ョ\Qーセ。ョN Price One Dollar.
OUTSIDE THE FORT 101. Lime house (frame).
102. Vegetahle garden of penitentiary. 103. Hay yard for cattle.
104. Cattle yard. lOi,. Ox stable (stone). lOG. Horse stable (stone). 107. Cattle stable. 108. Cow stable.
109. Prisoners' root house. 110. Old pathway to Selkirk. 111. Pathway to the river. 112. Stableman's house. 113. Path to cattle yard.
114. Penitentiary stockade.
] 15. Entrance gate to prisoner's yard.
11fl. pイゥウッョセイウG icc house.
1] 7. Old fashioned turnstile.
118. Stone marking the boundary line between the parishes of St. Andrew's (south) and St. Clement's (north).
119. Seat by the Red river.
120. Steps leading down to the river landing.
121. 'Pathway to York hoats' usual landing heach.
122. Men's house and canteen. 123. Blacksmith's shop (log). ]24. Farm manager's house (log). 125. Engineer Abell's cottage (stone). 126. Grain flailing building (log). 127. Root house (log).
128. Beer cellar (log). 129. Store (log). 130. Malt kiln (stone). 131. Grist mill.
132. Saw mill (log)
133. Dwelling and brewery (log). 134. The creek.
135. The spring well.
136. Landing place for the Company's steamers Polly, Colville, Chief C0111missioner, etc.
137. Lime kilns (stone).
138. Miller's dwelling house (log). 139. Indian camping ground.
140. Supposed position of burial ground. of soldiers of Wolseley Expedition, 1870.
141. Hudson's Bay Company farm lands. 142. Scene of First Indian Treaty, 1870. 143. Western post marking dividing line between the parishes of St. Andrew's and St. Clement's.
144. Hudson's Bay Company farm lands. 145. Indian camping ground.
Burial grounds: The burial grounds for \ the men of the Lower Fort were at St. An-drew's church (Church of England) four miles south, and at Little Britain (Presby-terian) about a mile south, also at St. Clement's (Church of England) about two miles north.
2;'). Founc1ations of an old stable.
2(i. The residence. The dwelling for a time of Sir George Simpson, Governor of Rupert's land.
2i and 28. Old cannon. 29. The hell.
ao and 31. Sundial.
ZセRN Former position of the Company's flagpole.
ZセZセN Old gateway of inner enclosure.
I!\SJDE THE FORT
4. North gateway.
!i. Wooden house, used hy dセN Young, the prison doctor.
Ii. Prisoners' yard.
7. Penitentiary and asylum.
X. The remains of the oven huilt hy the lInsoners.
0. Small ga1eway het.ween hastion and stockade.
10. Northeast hastion. This has always heen used as a powder magazine.
II. Old storehouse (frame building). This huilding lodged the soldiers of the Wolseley Expedition of 1870.
12. Guard room and sergeants' mess, huilt 1RiO for soldiers of W olseley Ex.peclition.
iZセ ancl 14. East gate pillars.
!;'). The stone deep in the ground in the
centre of this gateway was placed there In
QXhZセN
Iii. Southeast bastion-ice house. 17. Position of old tethering posts.
18. The part of the south wall which Riel, Lepine and O'Donohue, with their followers, clamheren oyer at midnight in 1870.
In. The Hudson's Bay Company second retail store and fur loft.
20. Founc1ations of another store.
21. Old site of the Lower Fort Garry bell.
22. Foundations of meat warehouse. Re-111(l\'ed 1882.
2:J. FlagstafT.
24. Southwest hastion, washhouse and cook hou se.
I. Present entrance to Lower Fort Garry.
2. Originally men's house, soldiers' canteen in IRiO. Latcr women's asylum.
ZセN Northwest hnstion--CorA)Jany's hake-house.