الآنا والآخر، انفتاح وانغلاق نموذجان: "على الحماميّ" و"مالك بن نبي".

Texte intégral

(1)2013L02W"#‫א! א‬. M?WOW7!8 ،\S]‫

(2) ^א‬1‫א‬،‫אא‬ K?a5 b#??M E D`‫א‬ 9/ . '- /0 $ 21; e %8

(3) :

(4) '; "!"

(5) =

(6) "!L" b *

(7) - +$ ) ?j

(8) _ F! 6P $ &' *

(9) . G

(10) %" &' SG

(11) L!W ) ( +$ G G *

(12) ! D 0 .

(13) !S V0 & fG

(14) ( P B= Ff"

(15) # ( 0 p

(16) !

(17) ?

(18) ( Vi S + "+

(19) ?

(20) G ( . #5 ( .# / +$

(21) = &' " 6 % 5

(22) S )( -G+

(23)

(24) %W >=6 &' P

(25) =n(

(26) jG S' @ %

(27) S - +$ S' 0 %

(28) A 5 + = +

(29) < < H 4 A )+ )) "5$" b

(30) % .% # ?% + ! +T 6 0 ?% 0 =' .(( U f ) 8 .)C. %" 7

(31)

(32)

(33) @ ( F!0 % .V= ! 0 6 +T "5+ " RL+ }%"

(34)

(35) ( F!0 V( 8%"

(36) n( -V( . N W F!0 @ " *= ? B= L% ' =' ` G

(37) @ &' b ( "A 1"

(38) _(. +$

(39) > R S N 7 " _ V= *5 0 +$ ) i( %

(40) S'

(41) 6 0 ? ` G S

(42) % -2 # (

(43) 103.

(44) 2013L02W"#‫א! א‬. 0 ?@" ` G n( N= .&

(45) B0

(46) R S `S .L5

(47) ! i 6

(48) % -

(49) 3L

(50) _( +$ !! i( 6 3L 0 &' "Maurice Merleau Ponty") ". P !" & k3 " *= 6 )

(51) ?G 3L !W R ?G ' .

(52) rq _% +$ &' L

(53) +$ 0 ) ! R F

(54) 6

(55) %" .G 3L >=6 & v ;

(56) _c7 ;

(57) .

(58) L 3L >=6 6 ( *! @ 0 =' /@

(59) ( 0 # 3L 3L *% =n( .3L >=6 (

(60) %

(61) ?G 3L 0 -$ #! S

(62) S 3L 0 A 1 #! ` G 0 " *= &

(63) 2! B 0 *5( - R . 6

(64) .Vv ; Vf

(65) ; -V

(66) % > K &' < e3 " "J . G O * @ R3

(67) k3 ( 0 #G S &' ?8% ( 0 P ( ' +$ i G

(68) 3L !_ 5% ( ( d= V"G k@i

(69) : F( 7 > +$ =6 .!

(70)

(71) 0 " 0 !!

(72) 0 !0 &'

(73) 3 *= >=6 ' 5 -2 S 6

(74) . G %

(75) 2

(76) S N=

(77) ?( k

(78)

(79) 0

(80)

(81) 3L >=6

(82) @

(83) k3

(84) S

(85)

(86) -*5 RG %

(87) . E A 0 "; / 1" b

(88) % 0 .i

(89) o5_ 5_ @+

(90) L S *_( -V= 6 P ( V= 6 0 3 .i

(91) ( j !. 104.

(92) 2013L02W"#‫א! א‬. F (!

(93) V

(94) #! 0 @ k3 ( n ?5

(95) 3 % N S .V

(96) ?5

(97) &! =

(98) O

(99) ( V ?5

(100) 3 -

(101) 2

(102) >8 B= % k!i) F@

(103) ( *S +$ N!

(104) % .

(105) ! G ?% ( ! > 50 2

(106) 0 *3 "

(107)

(108) .6 ( 0 G >=6 ? ( > 50 @0 *! 6 V G 0 N S - +$ V!" 7% G B . +$ G @ )/ ":J : 4" :

(109) 6 i

(110) ?L+

(111) V O 0 0 * g 5T

(112) =6 #!z

(113) + 3. (2). ") @ " :J "F=< u @c U ". (2). ") :. (

(114) ! F ( 0 &' P i 3 % 7 : ; 0 %

(115) 1 . ( *! L5 6 S. %!

(116) P * 3 -!" +

(117) G 2 G3S

(118) ) i

(119) i #. *% 2 % S % 8 0 G+ .

(120) ?) RG ( V(

(121) ?% ./8!

(122) Q"% %( ( "1945 . * 0 6 ( ( g%

(123) i% i

(124) ' 3 ! "@c U " *% -"1942

(125) / " 1941 $ " 4" *% =' ."1947

(126) 5%0 # ?

(127) !

(128) A

(129) ! " L:

(130) : #g% 4 .i"D

(131) b P ( ;. 105.

(132) 2013L02W"#‫א! א‬. % %

(133) R P % > !" /@( #

(134) _( 5 0 3 N=( ?G ='

(135) _( - &' 2

(136) S .a ! S' =

(137) V: j !

(138) 6 2

(139)

(140)

(141) -"1949 ( 3 ") )/" 6 ?) #% % =' 6 #

(142) > +) =6 H i0 "% ?( -"1973 ! ") @ " ( F

(143) ) 0 0 u

(144)

(145) ?) &

(146) (

(147) /G 3 k

(148) u l

(149) P b

(150)

(151)

(152) ?%

(153) %" ! :=

(154) < 2 :") )/" :* : 4" ! Roman ) "

(155) < 4 !A

(156) " :J R ;

(157)

(158) @ ?

(159) =6 < . 50 S =' -+ &

(160) *! ( % (nord Africain 6 !( . (

(161) %

(162)

(163)

(164)

(165) ` W ( B= ` %=

(166) @ < % ' . &'

(167) !!) %

(168) *3 ( ! ( A( % 0 &' &! 3 ) G U =6 R !

(169) !

(170) & d A > @!( U V=

(171) % -B & p

(172) !

(173) Rp% /@" l % ' .!

(174) .6 @ O " 6 %D @ 6 * : pi

(175) 9g ( -@

(176) ! ?G0

(177) " 4"J( - = ( K

(178) 7G

(179) v

(180) ; *

(181) >=6 -? 6 U ( ?G" = + N= .

(182) L!W *L

(183) (

(184)

(185) *L

(186) + S > (Germinaison)"08 :1 "S = + ?LP (

(187) * &

(188) :6 @0 0

(189). 106.

(190) 2013L02W"#‫א! א‬. *G ? =6 U O)

(191) @) = !

(192) 0 .F()

(193) ! ( -L+

(194) @ AG 0 S' #% &_ -* F

(195) 0 ( <" !

(196)

(197)

(198) ! V_% -N V

(199) LP ? " # (

(200) 0 * 6 G ) B

(201) % V &'

(202) #% 2 . 3

(203) .V 2L!S >si9

(204)

(205) ? 0 & V( % .F U =6 5 R G 5 "@ " ! B 0 & (# "

(206) ;Q " &' "A "

(207) % %

(208) ( &

(209) 5 G

(210) o - ! A D

(211) .i =6

(212) (' ?

(213) = ' ( ?@" k3 ( – 6

(214) n( - U = %= &' #%

(215)

(216) 3 '- ? 0 &'

(217) *% ! " !! & j ; : !

(218) + *% *

(219) %

(220)

(221) .(Algérie française) .$ % 0 6 = %" %D 6

(222) @

(223) *5L5 =

(224) ) '- s ) :L5

(225) + *"D

(226) >=6

(227) % F ? !

(228) + " :J (" '- s ) ")/ @" :J ( " < :J (

(229) ;Q ) ) I (A ) * !

(230)

(231) ") ( A) &7 (

(232) 1+ ') %7 V@ %

(233) S VE 0

(234) -U..7 & (F$ ) + *

(235) &'

(236) % 6 .V6

(237) N6 <

(238) { k@+ *f" S Vn( -2L+j V (

(239) G

(240) 3 = ? )

(241) 3

(242) %

(243) +! !"0 = N0 +! 0 ( G " 107.

(244) 2013L02W"#‫א! א‬. + 3 4

(245) ' @ 1 5 + )) :? - +$ (

(246) ( < C ) 2 ' O `

(247) ' 3 4 .?/ ) 6 '3 ; "3'. / + C @' 2

(248) $ (3). ((.P C1 c C : $Q 5 $ 4 .

(249)

(250) ; .V @ ! 0 3 % " ( 07" #% B=( "Celui qui écrivit la cité de dieu avait commencé par oublier la sienne".

(251)

(252)

(253) *" O S'

(254) L ( 5 ' )( .<

(255) S

(256) ` B0 }

(257)

(258) V

(259)

(260) ( # S <

(261) S G!

(262)

(263) *

(264) !

(265) ) ! . (' ( %

(266) V 0 k ! /!

(267) S Vi ` = -T P" ? ( #g% ?+ " 4" 6 6 P"

(268) 8%

(269)

(270) =' & T *$ l -S G ?GG

(271)

(272) .6

(273) V e}+ ; V " & @ Q=

(274) 6

(275) kG V

(276)

(277) 0 k@ 3 %

(278) G N!

(279)

(280) ?8% ) V' . " 2

(281)

(282) ?3 ( V!

(283) K F

(284) . G

(285) ! " !

(286) L "! 6 Q V!!' "A M " >

(287) =+_ S #6=

(288) S

(289) L% S V " ?!

(290) R S

(291) ( k@

(292) >=6 ?5

(293) ( 0 V g3

(294) =n( .

(295) .?G" V

(296)

(297) 5 l G

(298) 3 ( -

(299) > "!0

(300) 5% "A M " % A U E L V57 : B 6_ & N6 -!

(301) %

(302) ) &' 108.

(303) 2013L02W"#‫א! א‬. ?3 k

(304)

(305) &' SG ; A / " 14 =

(306) A

(307) L!W - ! " ! ( *(L+

(308) G

(309)

(310) L!W P 5 L!W .

(311) ) 5 % &' (L+ ? "G # 2"+ ?

(312) & -U 2

(313) @ B 6) =6 V6= ( ` ( C G( - V7 : _ "A M " > +;

(314) _" B 6) ' CJ 2 6 ;$ 5 + C4 @ =+ 0

(315) U ^ 4 2C1 @ 4 (/; :L3 V M " "/ < . 0$ ;

(316) ?c3^ @ @ / Af7h ) 5C I 1

(317) '3

(318) = ' 0 >C1 "A 3/ )

(319) < H 4 0 !/ A+ [ # 0+= 3 4 .?$= ?$= C< ? / ( !? H 4 0 " L. " -" ! 5_ - 4 .(4)((

(320) 0+= 5 3< ; I

(321) ; . U "!" A p

(322) B # ( 3 "

(323) -"

(324) %( D N

(325) V

(326) b +) *( 5 & /"

(327) !.

(328) < + &' V@" b 6 fille d’Ariane(5)" ; " 5

(329) V ! .

(330) & !S &' 7

(331) *

(332)

(333) 6

(334) A

(335) QLG' & e ! " !S Q

(336) $ ") P" k . $ ?; > ) #. #% F 8: 9 /G; 0 V%

(337)

(338) ( %" G ? -? . + k

(339) *

(340) 3 3 Q ) B @ !3

(341) V( !

(342) - ? V%! B= !

(343) 6 =6 ( #G; 0 &'

(344)

(345) F ( V !

(346) O

(347) &' @ .V 5_

(348) ! *3 k

(349)

(350). 109.

(351) 2013L02W"#‫א! א‬. -N 6

(352) & ! 0 N B= ) =6 ( +$ A

(353) _( .! ( 0 ! 0 0 ! 0

(354) %0 2!. +T ?% & #! G "G ! " !! e+ %

(355) :

(356) ( 0 .%

(357)

(358) ?! ?% ?

(359) ! • ( W 6) G+ 5!S

(360)

(361) P

(362) 2' • .R+

(363)

(364) .VG ( %" 0 O V(!

(365) !0 *% /

(366) • . G (

(367) V%

(368) # ? •

(369) ?% 3

(370) • 2

(371) 6L% "+ A" "% 8" @0 6 +$ 5 = N0

(372)

(373) ' .?G) ( 3L S R 60 F .O ) ( ?@(0 & 6 0 ?0

(374) 2

(375) ! ( 20

(376) S =' ! " " 0 k !

(377) 0 b 6 =%6 . 1 + N=% K (

(378) !S @ V

(379) R p +; ? 0 (

(380) S

(381) - (' ( V!(

(382) "8-" }P ! ( ( 0 ; ! ( 6 - (0 60 &

(383)

(384)

(385) .% %" F

(386) 6

(387) "P-^ f "A " V; : 7 B= Torcuato "+" #) 6 @0 V' ! +$ % 3 0 ( >=

(388) L & % B= ! B %! @

(389) !

(390) # % V% !

(391) #) =6 2 ( .

(392) %) ( S "( ; &= " ( S V %

(393) 6 0

(394) 0 ."

(395) ;O" 110.

(396) 2013L02W"#‫א! א‬. RD

(397) 0 #% ( *"D

(398) 2

(399) !) * ?L+

(400) %_ .A A

(401) L!W ( 5 ( k

(402) !

(403) ( 5 k

(404) . 6P

(405) & 3 ( -

(406) !S *!

(407)

(408) & @

(409) P; ( .? !! ` -G0

(410) @ ) ` ?L !S f %g ) - #% ( "+

(411)

(412) V= *3 =" ( B

(413) &

(414) !S ! V 0 k FL S <=

(415) V( b B= " $ ?;" (" ) N= ( ! V_% -

(416) .B A @ ( 5 <

(417) #!)

(418) ?z V"}+

(419) ( %" ?0

(420) /(% % V0 /@ ( )) :? ( *A G+ E b ' ! & +! >=6 B C H f/ c)+ I P- I ; C3 H "/$ 8 4 1 ( " .0U 7 " " ) .(6). (( -3 . H @3 ?

(421) ( ? ?

(422) K R3

(423) >=6 *! # &' R 5 ( N ( !

(424)

(425) (

(426) > %() ? 0

(427) o (+)) :? ( V

(428) ( V B= "); " + " !

(429) A+ ) ? !9+ )# ) )/ C$ 1 C1 "^f H$ .(# )

(430) '; $

(431) $ $ A ; :+ H/ ) F @ H

(432)

(433) #/ H 4

(434) $ =

(435) #/ (+ ) F; L )=f 8 (+ C1 + .@ 1 b 1 ) I H/ 0 + 5 + ) A8 A (# ) 0'$ 5 + .(7). (( $8

(436) 7 ) ?;<$. 111.

(437) 2013L02W"#‫א! א‬. " ?3 F F G = N0

(438) ") )/" % )# )7 A $ ? (+ %C ^ $f $ O)) :" 2A `$G 2A H 4 2A<$ < &=

(439) @ C "< "-/ 2A = ) @ ( 20< ?';O 2A 7 A + .(8)(() ; =+ $. > 0 @

(440) V+ +(S ( 7 S V0 Vi P *"

(441) j 60 F

(442) %

(443)

(444) ? U =6 ( @

(445) *

(446) ' & e ( ? -

(447) "G +$ B S V% .) @ % " 5 ? N!

(448) & k

(449) -

(450) ) ?+ V

(451)

(452) % +$ =6 ?+ " .

(453) *

(454) ( " K

(455) G) :I# 2 > P ( "

(456) ` ! n( ") @ " &' !

(457) A _( &' F G ( V ?5

(458) B= L!W 6 ?G) &' ` S' j L(

(459) "" 14" < +; B= F V' -(G W k !

(460) %

(461) )

(462) -@" &' =

(463) V - W O ( V+ " ! ?

(464) ! k N6 & 0 7 3 l 7

(465) N= . &' ! .(

(466)

(467) ) (

(468) + " N

(469) 3.

(470) + ! B= (% ( +$ A

(471) _( L!W ( -Vi }W G 0 S' 6=

(472) *"+ '

(473) !

(474) -F+ ( ? + ?%_ &!

(475) @ (

(476) ! i F ( S

(477) l #%

(478) ( "3' ($ 5 AV+ 0 )) :? V'

(479) B= #6=

(480)

(481) ?% 5 >C1 " 0 5 $ ) 2+ (...)

(482) I= 9/ H 4. 112.

(483) 2013L02W"#‫א! א‬. .(( Q 8 (+ H/ T / 6 &

(484) 5F 8 ($ "< .82 :e -N. ! ( 55

(485) 6 ! %

(486) %" ( 7 S V'

(487) %

(488) 0 5$ G 5 0 ( 4)) :? v=' V% < 5= ) 07

(489) M 1 C1 A+ 2Z 6. 8. 0 $ +

(490) ; < 37 A )3 " .0 $/

(491) $$ F 04 ;$ 8

(492) $ $ "/ ...7

(493) < < ...A 3 . .107 :e -N ((

(494) ;

(495) Q

(496) +

(497) :

(498) : ) - +$ <'

(499) 6 f@

(500) :

(501) : ( B0 ! !!) *"+ ) .D * G S' l n( b! W

(502) -i@ 3 *

(503) W .' ` S' !{ eL+ S i0 b #% j '

(504) L!W

(505) D ` G 6 >=6

(506) V' P

(507) +$( ( 2! 5

(508)

(509) F

(510) # 6 .O(

(511) ( V

(512) ! ( 0 ( S

(513) !

(514) % V_%

(515) L!W @

(516) > @! .+/

(517) ; 2+$/ ; i 8 + &' *

(518)

(519) &' " -?

(520) %

(521) K > + B= ) F % ( ! - =

(522)

(523) B # + 0 v=' .

(524) ) W P & - ) ?

(525)

(526) S ?G" ( *G+ % 0 & G V0 G+ -( G

(527) & 9U 5 6$ % U + " )) :L3 &' V! ( Q G

(528) < 3 5 c / c

(529) 2

(530) + 0 W H/ ) ( .

(531)

(532) ) C/ A=; "= 1 113.

(533) 2013L02W"#‫א! א‬. 0# H 2- + ) W 3 7 )

(534) / ) A:

(535) $

(536) 5/#

(537) < < )3 u 6 f %C )$ M .25 2 24 :e -N -((@C . ( ( V

(538) ) G ?

(539) % ! 3 V!" RD

(540) ? G R ? -b +0 G3 -

(541) ! 6 :G3p & V!. "+ 4 3 "< )

(542) Y 4)) :? ( - 2 +0 -? & *% 0 c =$ I )

(543) Q )

(544) < 5+ 2

(545) < c)/; u

(546) /

(547) k = + 8 E F; @ 1

(548) < F; H 4

(549) 7O 2 c < .24:e -N -((

(550) ) (+

(551) 23 6 0 #!) V _ k

(552) >=6 V

(553) - W

(554) 3 N 0 ! " ?

(555) 0 & k N S B= .(

(556) V% ( %" ?!

(557)

(558) &' R G ) % ( ( !" R P ' i 0 i=

(559) ?L+

(560) 7

(561) 0 S' ! " 6 L

(562) ! @

(563)

(564) ?) RG >=6 ( 0 %D

(565) -? !

(566) &' k3 &'

(567) D ( d = "+ G 6 %" & a ! b! *! .

(568)

(569) ?% !

(570) (

(571) }%

(572) f

(573) &' -?" ;

(574) K B= ") @ "

(575) "+ # ' ! " Luat clairert :J( L’eure et loir ( " :

(576) :

(577) i( & !

(578) + ! " * ! ?p3

(579) ;! & i0 ! ( &' . 3 5 " 1942 RG (

(580) 0 ( ? - .(Dreux) : * (Vichy) ") " ' /G

(581) ( ?

(582) V. 114.

(583) 2013L02W"#‫א! א‬.

(584) (+ 5 ( V'

(585) ( V L U =6 R"G ( V7! 0 &' &! V

(586) ! 3 ! " * +

(587) % 0 % V) ! " V

(588) 3' 250 5 H 3 N= %(. (9). - 5. .@0 > %( (

(589) ! ( 5 ?

(590)

(591) 0 H V0 &' S 3 ") @ " 6 %

(592) ' 5 ) ? -F + "!( F

(593) *= %" V ) S - 3 k 3 V 3 -( 5

(594) B. `

(595) * 8%

(596)

(597) %

(598) P0 *( G . F 0 V_

(599)

(600) B

(601) `

(602) B0 % . %" >3S

(603)

(604) *!%

(605)

(606) %" V(

(607) k

(608) N= F 9 (9 . P !! L!W

(609) 0 ! ?

(610) /g"( -* 5

(611) > % S ! " 6

(612) -?L@ D

(613) =

(614) ? V"G 8 "9

(615) 6

(616) 0 S > 6 ( 6

(617) # + &' ( ? 6 + R+ ._ S _ B= i6 ` ' + % :T3

(618) "

(619) "

(620) G0 !0

(621) -* 1902 ! "

(622)

(623) " . 1.

(624) ( ? . 6 ( * l &' V !0 *6=

(625) .V!

(626) % ? "N

(627) "

(628) ) k

(629) & . V /

(630) !

(631) "! P &

(632) % " # &'

(633) R 5 ( N

(634) ) "0 0 :

(635)

(636) *G+ & R %!

(637) &' +T k

(638) "2 +

(639) )" > (i0 ." + ( ! 5 O ( ?

(640) !S * ! V S

(641) "V

(642) 6" #%

(643) &' @ 6 &' ? 1946 =

(644) -( U f ; % F %

(645) -1949! !% ( ( ( 0 &'

(646)

(647)

(648) .?)

(649) L!W

(650) D

(651) ( N %

(652) S .T V! k - F !3

(653) 1905 ! &' V3 G0 0 k

(654) 6 (! -*! k 0 1925 ! < + .! " !

(655) 115. 2.

(656) 2013L02W"#‫א! א‬

(657) ( G (0

(658) %

(659) ?

(660) ( ( V *% ! ( ! ( #% k

(661) ` 5' 1928 !

(662) ( @ VG

(663)

(664) ? ! 3 .-1927

(665) FS S0 ? .

(666) ! ( &' 1930 ! (! .

(667)

(668) %

(669) b F( .*! >=6 ?5

(670)

(671) > /

(672) ! % V0 S' -3 *! ( ! ( N

(673)

(674) .

(675) !

(676) % < + (%!L) !

(677)

(678) :

(679) ! " * ! V! -! (

(680) < ! ( (

(681) 3W + - %" (

(682) .< 01K V% G_( -

(683) L!W @3 ( #% RD ` 5 -

(684) 3

(685) !L "

(686) V( Q B= -1948 (

(687) 73 ; 5 1946 ! L' 6 &' ? .)$O " ) +

(688) /+ -1954)$O "

(689) < O 0+ #%( - % P N6 1954 ! ( !

(690) 5 - O 0 &' ?L ! .b +) V

(691) 0 * .1956

(692) $ ! ? ! & -%

(693)

(694) ( d G

(695) % B= d

(696) ( .< 1 5+C -V %=

(697) %

(698) >=6 d -% dK "

(699) 1967 # % . 1973 %0 31 ( . ( !! L!W !!D

(700)

(701) ( " &' -?" ;

(702) K B= " N

(703) "

(704) "+ !

(705) + ! " * ! ?p3

(706) ;! ! " Luat-clairert :J L’eure-et-loir. 3 5 1942RG (

(707) 0 ( ? - :

(708) :

(709) i( & .(Dreux) : J (Vichy)"(" ' /G

(710) ( ?

(711) V & i0 ! ( &' . 3 Ali El Hammami, IDRIS, entreprise nationale du livre, Alger, 1988, p:22. 4 Ali El Hammami, IDRIS, p :144-145 b

(712) < + 0 k ! S 6

(713) ( ; dA 0 B !0 5 ." 0" Vg

(714) >' Vv 60 + ! S'. 6 Ali El Hammami, IDRIS, entreprise nationale du.livre, Alger, 1988, p, 388. .

(715)

(716) -V!" 7. 8 FRANTZ (Fanon): Les damnés de la terre, préface de Jean-Paul Sartre, p : 280.. 9 Belaid Abane: Benbella-Kafi-Bennabi contre Abane. Les raisons occultes de la haine, Koukou éditions, Mars 2012. 116.

(717)