Publisher’s version / Version de l'éditeur: DBR Computer Program, 1965-05-01
READ THESE TERMS AND CONDITIONS CAREFULLY BEFORE USING THIS WEBSITE.
https://nrc-publications.canada.ca/eng/copyright
Vous avez des questions? Nous pouvons vous aider. Pour communiquer directement avec un auteur, consultez la
première page de la revue dans laquelle son article a été publié afin de trouver ses coordonnées. Si vous n’arrivez pas à les repérer, communiquez avec nous à PublicationsArchive-ArchivesPublications@nrc-cnrc.gc.ca.
Questions? Contact the NRC Publications Archive team at
PublicationsArchive-ArchivesPublications@nrc-cnrc.gc.ca. If you wish to email the authors directly, please see the first page of the publication for their contact information.
NRC Publications Archive
Archives des publications du CNRC
For the publisher’s version, please access the DOI link below./ Pour consulter la version de l’éditeur, utilisez le lien DOI ci-dessous.
https://doi.org/10.4224/20330779
Access and use of this website and the material on it are subject to the Terms and Conditions set forth at
Calculations of thermal performance of a building and its air
conditioning plant by hybrid computer
Mitalas, G. P.
https://publications-cnrc.canada.ca/fra/droits
L’accès à ce site Web et l’utilisation de son contenu sont assujettis aux conditions présentées dans le site LISEZ CES CONDITIONS ATTENTIVEMENT AVANT D’UTILISER CE SITE WEB.
NRC Publications Record / Notice d'Archives des publications de CNRC:
https://nrc-publications.canada.ca/eng/view/object/?id=4940ea2c-217a-4564-85c4-cbcce09b1ddd https://publications-cnrc.canada.ca/fra/voir/objet/?id=4940ea2c-217a-4564-85c4-cbcce09b1ddd
, ...
•
.,
___ _NATIONAL RESEARCH COUNCIL CANADA
DIVISION OF BUILDING RESEARCH
CALCULATIONS OF THERMAL
PERFORMANCE OF A BUILDING AND ITS AIR CONDITIONING
PLANT BY HYBltiD COMPUTER
/
/ by
G. P. Mitalas
Computer Program No. 21
of the
Division of Building Research
Ottawa
·_·..,.
. セ@
,.
}.CALCULATIONS OF THERMAL PERFORMANCE OF A BUILDING AND ITS AIR CONDITIONING
PLANT BY HYBRID COMPUTER by
G, P. Mitalas
The temperature of the air in an air conditioned room depends on the rate at which heat enters the room, the rate at which heat is removed from the room, and the heat storage capacity of the structure, The calculation of room air temperature or room cooling load is quite involved as the ambient conditions, the characteristics of the cooling plant and the characteristics of the structure must all be considered together, The calculation involves the solution of several equations, both algebraiJZ and differential, that describe the performance of the cooling. ウケウエセュ@ and the structure. These
equations can be solved qui.te readily by an electronic computer. This report describes the way that the NRC computer facilities have been used to make air conditioning design calculations.
Computer Facilities Available
The Analysis Section of the NRC Division of Mechanical Engineering has a Pace analogue computer, a Bendix G-15 digital
computer, and an analogue-digital digital-analogue coupling unit that allows the two computers to be interconnected, ·These machines have been used for air conditioning design calculations. The coupled analogue -digital machine is particularly well suited for this type of calculation because the problem involves algebraic and differential equations. The analogue is best suited for solving ·the differential equations and the digital is superior at algebraic equations. The digital is also used to generate the ambient conditions that are the driving functions for the problem, and the results are recorded in digital form and finally typed by the typewriter associated with the digital machine.
Mathematical Model of the Thermal Eaergy Balance of a Room and an Air Conditioning Plant
The heat interchange within a room, the heat flow.,through
u
a room envelope and the heat interchange between an outside wall and its environment, can be described by a set of linear algebraic
ᄋセᄋᄋᄋ@
t
c .e.
tl l t
and by a set of differential equations:
e.
l =D. e. 1
tD. e.
- D.e.
t-1 1- ttl ttl t t
where
C .. , K, and D. are coefficients
Jt t t
=
= K.I. J J
e.
t
=
room envelope inner surface temperature... (1)
... (2)
(Ref. 1)
=
time dependent variable (i. e. solar radiation, outside air temperature, etc,).The number of equations in a set is governed by the number and the construction of room envelope components. A room thermal ·response can be described by approximately ten differential and ten
linear algebraic equations.
where
The room air temperature is given by:
=
tMR
=
J
(clel
tczez
t ...0
=
room air temperature Q = heat addition or extractiona*
R
=
minimum allowable room air temperature (i.e. stat setting),/)
• . • (3)
(Ref, 1)
thermo-The continuous solution of the above .equations is possible using the three basic analogue circuits given in Figure 1.
. ·,,
3
-The mechanical equipment to control the inside climate in large buildings usually consists of:
(a) chiller
(b) primary air unit
(c) secondary water coils.
Figure 2 is a schematic diagram of this equipment and the
room.
The chiller cooling water outlet temperature, at constant water flows and compressor speed, depends on the cooling water inlet temperature and the outside air wet-bulb temperature, and is given by:
where
8 A A 8 A 8 2 - 8
*
/';. wo=
l + 2 Win+ 3 Win WO8w.
tn 8wo
=
=
=
=
inlet cooling water temperature (• F)
outlet cooling water temperature ( • F)
a and b
=
constants that are functions of the particular chiller design8 セG@
wo
=
minimum allowable outlet cooling water temperature (• F).[)
The maximum heat extraction --per square foot of
nominal face area by the primary air unit at the design air and water flows --is a function of the temperature of the chilled water entering
,
__this unit, Bwo; of the inlet air dry bulb, BoB;· and of the inlet air dew-point, Bop• temperatures. It is given by one of the three following expressions depending on (Bop - Bwol difference:
where where
=
/
/=
c, d, e, f, g and m are constants that are functions of the particular primary air unit design. The temperatures are in • F and Qp is in Btu/hr ft2,
E.
1n
M
a
The enthalpy of the outlet air is given by: E
=
E. .., (Qp)/(M')o 1n a
=
enthalpy of outside air (inlet air to primary air unit) (Btu)/(lb of air)=
mass flow rate of air through primary air unit (lb)/(hr ft2).If it is assumed that the outlet air is saturated, which is a reasonable assumption for a unit with four or more rows of sprayed coils, the outlet air temperature is given by the following equation:
B
oa
=
(-2. 69+
n
3. 51 E o - 0. 0518 E 2 o+
0, 000333 E 3) •F. o The heat extraction by the secondary coils is:where
u
=
=
5
-constant which depends on the particular coil design and water and air flow rates.
inlet water temperature to the secondary coil, oF
9R
=
room air temperature, oFX
=
bypass factor, i.e. the ratio of cooling water flow through the chiller to the cooling water flow through the primary air unit.,
=
water flow rate through t.!J.e primary air unit, (lb)/(hr ftZ)./
The sensible cooling of room air by secondary coils and primary air is:
where
S
=
primary air unit coil nominal face area allocated for this room, ftZ.The cooling water temperature entering the chiller is:
The equations describing the heat balance in the room and the cooling plant must be solved simultaneously because ·of the interdependence of room air temperature and heat extraction by secondary coils. The
solution of this set of equations on a hybrid computer is not a straight-forward operation because of the operational difference of the two computers; the digital computer sample_s the analogue voltages repre-senting 9w in and 9R at the time, ts· Using these sampled values it calculates ( 90a) ts and ( 9wr>· ts but the calculations require a small time interval,. and therefore the values (90a) ts and (9wr> ts are "late".
This diff:cbulty can be overcome by noting that the driving functions are ·periodic with 24-hr period, and that only the periodic steady state
Mセ@
I)
6
-calculated for the time, ts, are stored in the computer memory and held there until the time, ts
+
24 hr. At this time the values are transmitted to the analogue computer.Hybrid Computer
The hybrid computer at the Division of Mechanical Engineering, NRC, used for these calculations is made up of:
(a) a Bendix G-15 digital computer, two magnetic tape units, a typewriter, puncl)ed paper tape reader and punch.
(b) a Pace 131R electronic analogue computer made up basically of 96 amplifiers, 160 potentiom'eters,
4 relay amplifiers,. digit.al vo:Jtmeters and an analogue
/
recorder.
(c) an Epsco addaverter with an 8 D:..A (digital to
analogue) and an 8 A-D (analogue to digital) channel capacity.
The D-A converter accepts lZ binary bits with sign, accuracy± 0. 5 bits or 0. OZ per cent over the working range of ± 10 volts and the time for conversion "" 0. 1 ms.
The A-D converter gives lZ binary bits with sign, accuracy ± Z bits, i.e. 0. 1 per cent and time for conver·sion of 8 channels
"" Z ms.
The interval between the conversions can be controlled by the addaverter clock or by the Bendix G-15.
Operation Procedure
The procedure for the solution of the e.quations describing the room thermal performance and the air conditioning plant can be divided into four major steps:
(1) Preparation of the driving functions
(Z)
Setting up and checking the analogue circuit (3) Solution of the equations on the hybrid computer ( 4) Tabulation of results.7
-Preparation of the Driving Functions
The driving functions are calculated by "A Program to Calculate Design Data for Air Conditioning Calculations". This program is designed to calculate various weather parameters from the basic data, to store these in memory and to punch them on paper tape. The detailed description and operational procedure of this program are given in Ref. 2.
The punched paper tape produced by this program is not directly usable as an input for the "Running Program" which is described in the following sections. The numbers listed on the punched paper tape must be converted to the special format accept-able by the D-A converter. The "Driving Function Conversion Pro-gram" was written to convert the numbers to the r,equired format, to calculate A1, Az, and A3 constfnts and to store these on magnetic tape. The detailed description of this program and its operational procedure are given in Appendix I.
Setting Up and Checking of the Analogue Circuit
The method and the detailed description of how to set up an analogue circuit is given by G. P. Mitalas et al {1). Before this circuit is used, it is desirable to check the circuit and the settings of the
potentiometers. This can be done simply by noting that:
(a) the temperatures of the room envelope and the room air at steady state conditions must be equal to the temperature at the outside surface of the room envelope, when the other inputs are zero; (b) the heat extracted from the room air must be
equal to the solar radiation input to the room, when the heat flow through the room envelope an.d the internal heat sources are zero.
Once these verifications are carried put it is reasonable to assume that the analogue circuit and the potentiometer settings are corre.ct and that the analogue circuit components are functioning correctly.
Procedure for Operating the Hybrid Computer
(1) Mount the magnetic tape containing the driving functions on the magnetic tape unit No. 0.
(Z) Mount a reel of blank magnetic tape on tape unit No, 1.
(3) Set the addaverter controls:
( 4)
(5)
a) channel capacity
=
8b) channel 8 on "Data" channel c) time on clock
=
1. Z sec.Load "Running Program" (the .description of this program and its operational procedure· are given in Appendix II), search the magnetic tape for the required driving functions, and load thi,s set into the computer,
Turn on the analogue recorder and set the
analogue computer in operating mode. This puts the hybrid computer in operation.
(6) The heat extraction from the room air can be varied by:
a) a change in bypass factor, X
b) a change in primary air unit coil nominal face area, S
c) a change in constant, U,
{7) The strip chart record of the analogue voltages indicates if the solution is proceeding satisfactorily, and it also indicates when the periodic steady
state conditions are reached.
(8) When these latter conditions are reached, the results of this calculation, the driving functions used, and the several constap.ts are recorded on the magnetic tape on unit No. 1. The procedure for this is given in Appendix II.
9
-Tabulation of Results
The "Tabulation Program" was written to type the recorded results from the magnetic tape. This program also performs a limited amount of calculations to present the results in a more comprehensive form. The description of this program and its operational procedure are given in Appendix III.
Acknowledgement
The author wishes to acknowledge the assistance of Mr. G. P, Van Blockland of NRC Mechanical Engineering Division, Analysis Section, who prepared the programs described in
Appendices I and II.
References
/
1. Mitalas, G. P,, D. G. Stephenson and D. C, Baxter, Use of' An
Analog Computer for Room Air -conditioning Calculations. Research Paper No, 114 of the Division of Building
Research, Ottawa, December 1960 (NRC 6099).
2. Mitalas, G. P, A Program to Calculate Design Data for Air Conditioning Calculations. National Research Council,
Division of Building Research, DBR Computer Program No. 20, January 1965,
FIGURE 1
ANALOGUE Cl RCU IT FOR THE SOLUTION OF
a) linear algebraic equations
b) Ordinary differential equations
-el.,.l - eH D· l-1
}---:::=::--t
., G)) セcャ@ +9, • +Where
Potentiometer
Relay amplifier
・Lセ・ッ@
e
0=
Ke,
e,
e,
kセ@ 1.e,
<
0e
3=
e.
Summer
e
=
e,
e,
6 ・Lセ・ P@-eo
e,
+e
1. +e3
e,>
0e3
e
3
=
e+
Integrator
t ・セ@=
e7
・Lセ・ッ@-eo
=
J
I e'
+e,
+-e3 ) dt
e+
e7
e.
e3
0 (J 317:1-tIogue
<!:der
Ana
Reco
v
FIGURE 2
Analogue
.,
....
,..
,
セ@Results
Room
' "'I
Secondary
Q"*
Water
Coils
I'
I'
I \ ' /.
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I ,
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
ewi
I
I
I
I II
Digital
Digital
"
Computer
,
Memory
ew&
セ@Cooling
'Tower
r---ew
in
,
...
Chiller
ewr?
'
jbケー。ウウセ@
Valve
--Lセ@'
Ie"s
Primary
eDP
"
Air Plant
fineo
a.
. IDriving
.
Functions
CONVERSION PROGRAM by
G. P. Van Blockland
The driving functions on the punched paper tape
generated by the "Program to Calculate Design Data for Air Con.;. ditioning Calculations" {2) cannot be used directly as an input to the "Running Program", as the numbers for this program must be
specially-scaled machine language numbers. Therefore, this pro-gram was written to perform the following operations:
{a) to read punched paper Mセ。ー・@ prepared by the "Program エッMc。ォセャ。エ・@ Design Data for Air Conditioning Calculations",
{b) to convert these data to machine language numbers and to shift some of these numbers to the 13 least significant bits of the 29 bit word {this is the number format acceptable by the D-A converter).
(c) to arrange the converted numbers in arrays in such a way that they are ・。ウゥセケ@ available for transmission to the D-A converter by the "Running Program 11,
{d) to calculate A l• A2 and A3 coefficients (A's are defined on page 3) to store the con-verted numbers and the coefficients in one file on magnetic tape.
All the input is by punched ーセー・イ@ tape except the pro-vision by which the driving function set number No can be entered by typewriter. The order of the data on punched paper tape is given in Appendix I. The first paper tape channel read is stored in line 06, the second in 07 and the third in
C.d.
I-2
Arithmetic Operations
This program calculates scaled A1, A2 and A3 coefficients.
=
=
=
Locations of Constants 0109 a 1/200 / 0115 b1/200 0127 a2 0114 b2 0132 200 a 3 0135 200 b3 OutputThe converted numbers and A1, A2 and A3 coefficients are· stored in one file on magnetic tape in the following order:
First line = copy of computer memory line 09
Word location Data
96-4t A1/200
97
-4;.';
A2
+
L10-5 2-16
96 97 98 99 No/1000 S/100 Ag/1000 H/10
Second line
=
copy of computer memory line 1096-4t 97-4t 98-4t / 99-4t 96 97 e0p x 1/zoo e0 B x 1/zoo E X 1/100 r 1 x 1/1oo x z-16 Aw/100 No/1000
Third line
=
copy of computer memory line 1196-4t 97 -4t 98-4t 99-4t where t
=
1(1)24. Memory Allocations rTD x 1/1oo x z- 16 ew x 1jzoo x z- 16 eg x 1/zoo x z- 16 rT x 1/soo x z-16Lines 00, 01, 02, 03 and 04 are used for program and word location.
I-4
ZO:OO mask
ZO:Ol 9WB
x
1/100ZO:OZ T for pickup
20:03 T for storing 21:00 number to be extracted 21 :01 scale factor Z2:00 temporary storage 22:01 , temporary storage 22:02 temporar)l" storage / 22:03 temporary storage. Operation Instructions
1. Mount magnetic tape containing driving functions on
mag-netic tape unit No. 0. Position the reading-writing head in the blank tape past the last information block.
2. Load the "Driving Function Conversion Program". Enable
ON, type P; after the first block has been read, compute GO.
3. Mount input data tape (output of the "Program to Calculate Design Data for Air Conditioning Calculations") on photo reader.
4.
Start the program. Enable ON, type@
c£, compute GO.5. Three blocks of paper tape containing the driving functions
will be read, These functions will be converted arid written on magnetic tape.
The program halts automatically as soon as all the input data tape is read and processed.
CJ 6. The driving function set number can be changed by the
(a) compute switch to BP while the computer is in the process of reading punched paper tape (b) when all of the three blocks are read,
com-puter halts
(c) Enable ON, type
®
cf, compute GO. Type No x 1/1000 in seven-decimal digit format,e. g. No
=
5, type 0050000 tab® .
The number No read from the punched paper tape is replaced by the number entered by the typewriter.
/
I-6
FLow ctUiii,T CON.VERSIONr
,}, セL@ j Q_OAセNd@ 3 t3Locks oFI
S 7"0K E tiles t!lo p, /! Dll-r/9 ' A P£ ,_£. IN J.tu E·sr F<>lf I!NP ""' rn.v0-l Plt:kVPlT C OIVV. ヲャセ@ cp 'ff"'z·" NOIIIAt.TI
.,..,.
I
I
/(£ .fi!."T 0 V Of FLOw' PIC}( VP @w
II
-II
cq/VV. To Fl;r<,•pr x z
(I,M
P1c1c vP=oJ
'. ""
u:r tJn.tr rr>ll 1'1<1< VP 2 q.
/"ANY.• TIJ GOセ@ & D PrJr z"'1
'
.
<J·U P!clc V P t3wjJ.I
P!cl( v pIr
/'oN
V"'8T T6
.t:IUJ>Pr {D/111/. 7'qBGセ@
c.P;:)rz"'
6 J,<uI
Cl/l c. llz,,4,. • llj sru.<£
Ir.
i9"' . oJT. IN L II 1.1.1> .PICi;vP L
I
l: u NV'. TO Fl A エセNp@ pr. ^NセV@ ;.N c 11 elf. PIC/c VP .froff& 1/'1. t,,Lor]
rNᆪセ@ I 1 T /i/(No'-.. T I! j T FoR [IVJ)
o . .n ーエ\セ@ UP ゥ^セH[@
1
y
CONV. 14 f'IXI'./) PT /l. 22 .PI<!< up u, R)• R..,, Pte!< VP Sopl
/1, s C()NV', , , セ^BiIHpNj^ヲLᄋ@ "DNt/. T() r,.l!'j) pT()Jar
tMlo t.:>A/1/. To [ZZ[セNiAGNp@ l'r PIC I( VPt.:
FIH'i> PTI
entᆪセ@At.,
t?/ rEs r"''""'
Toセᄋᄋ@
D (J • ... > -12 WRIT!." 1"/l £ <'t:>/Jf PICI< VPJ
,.._,,
I
Wlt!rt" J ヲjlッイセ\NウN@ <>I'N.n.c.
セ@
r - - - OPJ. OF MECHANICAL ENGINEERINGDIGITAL COMPUTER Nセbqhatory@
G -15
D Preparedhy C..v.B.PROGRAM PROBLEM: ( 0 N Vf I( U t? N ell 0 C. II 11M
0
4
I
5
2
6
3
7
iiMlMセ⦅pMQMtMiヲ@
C S D 8
Page_ of _ Date: _ _ _ _ Line (!(}NOTES
I
8 910
11 ャヲMBMGOjGoセェMMjAGoGMGエMヲゥNjN⦅A⦅iOlヲjエjアL[oセuスGャ[⦅LイGNpKMQMjANGAZZZFMGBN@ 0::_:' BBGMMG]セZZ・N⦅BBMA[@ Ad.__ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ --!12
13
14
15
iセMG\@ PQセ@ セBGGMャゥMMMQMBMHjBGMBM エoZZZ⦅oヲNANOMヲMBサIKKKMセRBMMBMUMBMO@ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _--'-1
16
17
IS
19
II I) 17 () !SJ/ RfA 0 TAP>"20
21
22
23
I 7I
I
lq {) (I 2 :i' J I TK24
25
26
27
28
29
32
33
36
37
40
41
44
45
48
49
52
53
56
57
60
61
64
65
68
69
72
73
76
77
80
81
30
34
38
42
46
50
54
58
62
66
70
74
7B
82
31
35
NfJT セエT@ i ) ' / . I" 911 セi@ 7 2 ;r z? n A 1<39
? 0 II
I II
セ@ 0 32 SO 0 ()0 ]I Sfr /?f."ADL43
5'0.nloo
all6i<t f-ifl•T Nc=·oa47
I . . i < ] J 7 0 0 J v /l;tu;v·--r "
51
!I
I
II I
llliAOy55
セセセセWセセセᄋaᆬGQセjM
T
セaQTG。TAセ。MサMセl⦅A⦅QセGMッセャセol⦅ゥ@
_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _-1
59
;,
I
27 oF oRセ@
31 - VUiH:r63
I ッvエZセ@ f."•ow of? OdッセャLッャッャ@I
I67
セL@
I II
i l l 0 I Is I '7J
ICI1/4
1« oiHi?l TRJS
セセセセLセセセセセセVセ^セッセッKGセᄋセᄋGセMセMセlセLセᄋセセセセlセッセW@
____________
セ@
79
I I I QQMMセセMMTMTMMQMセセゥMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMセ@83
7oB4
as
86
87
Tl?88
B9
90
91
92
93
94
95
9.6
uo
U497
Ul
us
98
U2
U6
("I " L I (.)CLY<LII
I 8
-N.R. C.
セ@ OIV. OF MECHANICAL ENGINEERING
-DIGITAL COMPUTER LABORATORY
Page_ of._
' G ·15 D Prepared by t; VB Date:
PROGRAM PROBLEM: CON V. PI{ 0 セᄋ@ Line 00
0
I
2
3
Lp T N
c s
D B.NOTES
4
5
6
1
/0,
..
zo
(J tJO 71) /. __.. Jo.oJ8
9
10
II
22'? /u I no 0 0 /0 012
13
14
15
2a }OI
'Is-
0zc
2 CLR RFjᄋoセ@ I16
17
18
19
us
I,;
7 !z
"
(JO tJ/ IJtJ, a 7 - O f . q '? 7 I20
21
22
23
.:;.,r
QQ Ia R Dzo
"
,
R.M P "" LUD 'I .24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
3 2 1 L un 0 2·0 28 ]1), , . - / I f ' .32
33
34
35
u.o '"''
1:<.< c"
no 2" / <•n...!...,
A ((36
37
38
39
lLr
7Z , uJ " (Jt
7 zr?h
r,
t.
n
.:...;, fl 11.l
40
41
42
43
Ll.w u ub セ@'''
lf NrAR""'
|セ@44
45
46
47
48
49
50
51
hP luo QセN@ 0 0 1.1 \エセ@ "'
-
] /,(}/'
52
53
54
55
17,."
0 w 0 00 Joo ,)( , _, S"56
57
58
59
$'/ w s• SL I 2/ J' tセ@ A TO n .. セ\N\@ \Gセ@ u, ,.., " " p60
61
62
63
su
w 6 J D ' ,I " : 1 ' .,-R A 1"n n(,n セ@ セauN@ A'<64
65
66
67
68
69
70
71
6J61
,,
() 2 0 2? 2o. o 2 - ,111'1.'
72
73
74
75
;(,17J
17.
IJ(J"
2<1s
1<n
セOiヲGL@ 776
77
78
79
7! TIn
0 0:?2911
r,. •. ,
- <>!? 1"'
80
81
82
83
74 セi@ lJ?/ 0 "1,
/VC/1;184
85
86
87
セ@,_
'
88
89
90
91
'-lt lAS" I o, lo I o, 21 S(A'Z£ -'4trv"_,.
2/. 0/92
93
94
95
12"
<z;
17/
17 17, 196
97
98
99
Bセ@ w1.,
,,
I, I ' I '7"/(A .,.. A / r<.<n. ,, "· " •
uo
U1
U2
U3
U4
us
us
'il7 Jq ウセ@ 0 21? zs aョセ@ JDN.R.C.
,...--- OIV. OF MEC ANICAL ENGINEERING H
DIGITAL COMPUTER LABORATORY
P•E• _ ol.
-'
G ·15 D
Prepared byG.v.
8 0 ate:PROGRAM PROBLEM: (IJN V, p 1{0 セN@ line OQ
0
I
2
3
L p TN
c s
0 8
.NOTES4
5
6
7
8
910
11
S'- J9 I" o I Zi J 1 ll R I D I I12
13
14
15
"
"
"'"
0 l 0 2. rLR T D. --,16
17
18
19
u'
lq iセ@ • I I ' J I""'
'
'
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
Ql lo '....
0 2 2 2. 1'1 Maセ@28
29
30
31
"''
'"
I I ' 0 2. 20 A It - 2o.oo32
33
34
35
"
··.1' 6 I '" 0 00 11 / MA<• - 2 1 , .036
37
38
39
l '6b
'" 7 () 1)/l40
41
42
43
].I'I" o
'"'
ol" Z:i' ... Lセa\イャヲNjI@ N' _...., AK44
45
46
47
Ln !uu"
"
Js- コセ@ /IJ-=-..
A/1 I48
49
50
51
u6 U<> iセG@ () Qセ@ In A" _ , 7 7. hi -,52
53
54
55
56
57
58
59
loz
l11
12t>lu•
IH
r, ⦅⦅LNaセ@i
so
61
62
63
12 /J I 10 3 01)12.
0?'./J セ@ Alt OFrttn•uMr64
65
66
S7
lln
O<,l••
"'
0 I A r 7)sa
69
70
71
t6 /"- 2/ 0 2.9 20 A I{ __,. RPNセI@ J72
. 73
74
75
2/ 2'-' 2. () tl 2" 1h " I _:!_. AI?76
77
78
i
79
2" lr"'
""
.n ol ' 2 iセB@11
イエRコNMエセ\^W@ srollt A', l ·80
81
82
83
) 9 .'"
f7 <.<6 0 J' I <I N( iiセ@84
85
86
87
88
89
90
91
NセG@ S"u 1 ... 1o
I'o
2"' }d."' - A If92
93
94
95
セヲL@ $'1 6o 0 0" ).0 S I• <' L セaセ@ セ@96
97
98
99
I"'
6o 62
I
r. 2 oiH ilt IIJ') A 1'1 セ@uo
Ul
U2
U3
r
tッᄋセNMM セセQイセャ@ 'b·''
2'-' 64 o o I H セ@U4
us
us
7""
Au
/oI-<.,.
lA oo 11<.,: -
2 I. o I . MLᄋMMZAセMBGGM .,.--·-.· ·.· .. ·-·I-10
N.R. C.
.----
OIV. OF MECHANICAL ENGINEERING DIGITAL COMPUTER LABORATORYPace_ of._
' Prepared by
G -15 0 G. !(
'
D a I e:PROGRAM PROBLEM: 」セn@ V. PP.Ot;. Lf n e QQ
0
I
2
3
L
p T Nc s
D B
.NOTES4
5
6
7
セsG@ iセ@ tJIJ,,
(..> 2 IJIJ セ@ 2-oS" ....I 1:.
8
9
10
11
I.R"''
6?su
I l l J I TIIATo""s"
(tJNV ro Fl pr"'
"'
12
13
14
15
,.(,hs
II. () l . 22 A I \ - 27.<>/ '<!I16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
I. i I-to 7< 0 20 2'3 Ta - A I(24
25
26
27
'1Ul7s
'11? 0 tiO 2Cf $/<[1, ⦅⦅[NNaセ@ I28
29
30
31
..,.,..
r
lo, セ@ s<> o ·o 6 29h
r
.t.--
___.,q"l
... <> L.セ@
32
33
34
35
'19 ·. Po .l'o • II,II
I セi@ .. N C A II36
37
38
39
;9 Osh;
0 ()' 21 セエGゥャGャ@ Fl! __,. 21. ol Nセ@'bI
040
41
42
43
U.s
? • I fi" " iセ@ 0 ' " 200 I( •44
45
46
47
"'
w I-,'"
I 21 ;JII
I!Idz:e
O/_, イセ@ ('"NV. ro ,<"[. pr48
49
50
51
"'10l.ro
.1'() () 2 8 22 OャイャNMMM^セRNPセ@52
53
54
55
I
I
56
57
58
59
S?o
l;oz
IS?u
0 20 iGセ@ tセ@ セaイャN@I
I
so
61
62
63
:?LJ. l9sIJ?s;
0 0 0 2« Sl< £ L NNZAMiiセ@!:'
64
65
66
67
YS"r
00 til 0 0 ' 2?17
ro'7.-- - Alf7 セ@:":f"
.-68
69
70
71
.o J? I Do lao 0 31I '
I 1\/C A If&.!
72
73
74
75
L/.1I" •
lao 0 00 l/ セf@ __,. 2/.0176
77
78
79
lz
lJ a n 0 0 ' I (2 -IJ" 00 oo X80
81
82
83
CHJ. w Ia 6 S''-' I 2 I"
.,."ll
ro ot . .J"IJ. CoNI/ ro /'"1 Pr84
85
86
87
no
I" 9 t,O 0 l Jl 22 . a w - ? ? n >88
89
90
91
-92
93
94
95
(A(.) 1, ' iセ@ ' I , 2 I111
Tn 11 To ,.., ? '7 '96
97
98
99
n
uo
Ul
U2
U3
U4
U5
us
N,R, C.
DIV OF MECHANICAL ENGINEERING
I
DIGITAL COMPUTER LABORATORY-Pago _ o f _
'
G ·15 D
Prepared by"· 1/. セ@
D a to:
PROGRAM PROBLEM: CUNV. PH o 4. Llno
e.o
0
1
2
3
Lp
T Nc s
DB
.NOTES
4
5
6
7
f!crVKI<J e"KoM lo<.l8
9
10
11
1 7 112 61 0 J 0 3/ _jv_ll_l7e n<E C<>PE セ@.,
I
-12
13 ' 14
15
0/ wセᄋ@ :?7 21 J/ T!!A ' " o.oo<ITI! u•A D セi\@ ;:::
16
17
18
19
70"'
'""'
7 / "' Pセ@ 19 L Bセ@ - I 4 .} I I I I20
21
22
23
71 セL@ 7'""
21 31 _I__&_II TO J M T セ@ ' I '\24
25
26
27
77 I ',,9
'PI 0 IO 14 L;o __, ''""'
; I .I"•
28
29
30
31
91"'
' I! 3 17/ 1.:. 21 31 rxll -row...,.-32
33
.34 ' 35
9),
...
' " Ilxot
lo I IQ.
L /I - r L I 0 I,. I36
37
38
39
.Pt
w''"
171 '""v
.3/ /ff /J 7"n 1./M T40
41
42
43
0 I lo 1 ()O o o I Of tVc = (JP' I44
45
46
47
48
49
50
51
52
53
54
55
56
57
58
.59
60
61
62
63
64
65
66
67
'68
69
.
70
71
72
73
74
75
76
77
78
79
80
81
82
83
84
85
86
87
sa
89
90
91
-92
93
94
95
96
97
98
99
• <uo
Ul
U2
U3
U4
us
us
N.ll. C. OIV, OF MECHANICAL EN I I
,
-DIGITAL COMPUTER セNaboratory@ G NEER NG PaE• _ of._ ' G -15 0 P.repared by <. (/.i3 0 Ite:
PROGRAM PROBLEM: cqiAャNセ@ .. ヲGセッ@fl.
ll n a "' I0
I
2
3
Lp
T Nc s
D8
.NOTES4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
o!J oq /0 l_Qln
20 j} セ@ - ....1.._I,L._{t & ...12
13 . 14
15
It> I I 14 (J lolLs
セBGᄋGlM JL),16
17
18
19
""
15" 1_2 t) t>L 2c ...
_h_{L'
20
21
22
23
1?,,..
t/t l!LJ, ...o.L\, '/?11 J .s.::.Jl. I'24
25
26
27
175/
lp .z (J )'I ) I 1'1 •L T / Pt v I28
29
30
31
..!2_2 loJ lo<' 11121 129 PIV. - A.fl32
33
34
35
..{L4 OS'=
I l.u_ 2? ,q 1'\. セ@ A.t1_' ' ' "
36
37
38
39
07 ot:/ II I D/ lC!c --"-
II
エセ@ / II
40
41
42
43
l£oo
-. 0 'J l.x_; t<2. - . .:! /? p _ZJ"44
45
46
47
⦅lセ@
IZ ;_L _Ll.lX lV
A_K -;> _u t>t>48
49
50
51
52
53
54
55
; / I 7 ;'J 2(} 2J 2o.oi---P IP.55
57
58
59
IP /<f 21 11/?1 2<.e
- ' ? 11. a· I60
61
62
63
J?
I 4 2) IHセ@ 11 lli. • I /.f. I64
65
66
67
.2.11.>/
2 l"'-"
Jl _.M..'.LJ. - ..£.• \1 '68
69
70
71
22 '2 l 2'1:"
; t 2\1 PN.L _.. _!L!1_72
73
74
75
24 2S 26 I 2_i1'¥
;C} It - II _E._76
77
78
79
2!5'
2 7 28 I (1/zc;
c _,.
...
Ar<80
81
82
83
27l.u
I'
'7PI1 V3 3 l84
85
86
87
21?
2q13 c
. In
)J /}!'(--. 2]. d /BB
89
90
91
I 25 Jo 11 Jlf 0 20 / . : 1 . 0 / - /092
93
94
95
J 3S )7 o ol ]'fc _,. /'Ja
96
97
98
99
J.> • IV 1X lc, loz -·N7t;. {)uo
Ul
U2
U3
37st
;s
0.z
'I )/ 1-JL L II PJ.VU4
us
us
I .·· .•. ·.· ... •.:. ' ... ,.N.fl.C.
OIV. OF MECHANICAL ENGINEERING MMMセMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMML@ DIGITAL COMPUTER ABORATORY
G -1 50 PROGRAM PROBLEM:
0
4
8
12
16
20
28
32
35
40
44
48
52
55
50
54
58
72
75
80
84
88
I
5
913
17
21
29
33
37
41
45
49
53
57
51
65
69
73
77
81
85
89
2
6
10
14
18
22
30
34
38
42
45
50
54
58
62
65
70
74
78
82
86
90
92
93
94
95
97
98
UO
Ul
U2
U4
U5
US
3
7
II
15
19
L 2S I 1123
'l';.z SY.67
S783
91
95
_Z_J_99
7SU3
177 P r e p a r e d by ⦅」BMGGGMセBGMGMGjjBMNGMMMMᆳ 'oNv PRO.<i, Pace_or._
Date: _ _ _ _ ll ne Cl!p .
r N Ef-s+o-1-s·f---N_o_T_E_s
______
--j 27 2'1 セQ[V@ 2!?' I
)o J/ I 2.<128 32 3/ VIZ4I
_li I/;v
01.z o
1'<. >"1 P''I
L o 。セ@ セ@ 1D. l]JR.Jt l D --.. 1'1 f1. n_fj_ P cicicicio}jセセセMMセj」セセセセセ」セMセfセセセ\セtッセセセkMMMMMMMセヲLMMMMQ@ 72171 f) 31.zs
I,L6I75-o
126 J I 7 6177o
Jo ZJ? I 2 cT · 2 I _ , . / /). セiN@ z!? セ@ /91}セ@
I
I
J
I 14
-N.R.C.
r---- OIV. OF MECHANICAL ENGINEERING
-DIGITAL COMPUTER LABORATORYPage_ of._
'
G -15 D Prepared IJy G,
v.
B. Date:PROGRAM PROBLEM:
c
fl. fY. 1!:- pxoCj. ll n e a/0
1
2
3
Lp T N
c s
D 8_NOTES
4
5
6
7
7<1 Jio ?! () l2 ᄋセ@ I TIV Z ;91( "\•
セ@8
910
11
..
• 0.,
12
13 . 14
15
J'l 8> q7 012. 2J' <:' F"'" All "'\ I .,Co "'\16
17
18
19
.f'J I"'" •t D 2.<- a !fl. -1"/fl•
"'
20
21
22
23
セ@24
25
26
27
_go
!tq
lqo セッオゥャ@ 'At. .,,1( 'c (! ]/ ]S '2/,()/ - t.J)'
'•
28
29
30
31
no I'" ! "'' 0 " ' Jl A < - PN ' ' セ@ .,
32
33
34
35
"
_\ . $7 I 'U' i 1 j" Jl' 1 01VIPl'36
37
38
39
4S '"' t lo' o lo 31 r< ,..., p Oセ@ セB@40
41
42
43
44
45
46
47
. I
48
49
50
51
52
53
54
55
56
57
58
59
GO
81
62
63
64
65
66
67
sa
69
70
71
.
72
73
74
75
76
77
78
79
80
81
82
83
84
85
86
87
88
89
90
91
-92
93
94
95
96
97
98
99
uo
U1
U2
U3
U4
U5
us
N.R,C.
.---
OtV. OF MECHANICAL EN GINEER G IN DIGITAL COMPUTER t.ABORATORYPage_ of.
-' G ·15 D Prepared by t:!/. t3 Dale:
PROGRAM PROBLEM :
c
0 !:/.v.
PRO 4. Line QJ0
I
2
3
Lp
TN
c s
D8
.NOTES4
5
6
7
tJ!J 02 26"
21 3/ Tlifl ro ppᄋセ@ (8
9
10
II
12
13
14
15
72 Ia :? ]_<£ () OJ <'I () 3 • • ., - • ' · . 716
17
18
19
t/7r
[qq iq J' J lO J I [!IMP IN J J1
' "20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
2<J 26 zS' • ]0 2J' 2o. o 2 - セセセ@セ@
-"
28
29
30
31
]J? 2q J2 0 OJ ).q J•O--=-
A If c I"
32
33
34
35
Rセ@r
OD rof.vv _..fl/(1.
l b 0 0 fl 2? -/2 3't,J'f .. / ""
35
37
38
39
N(l/f? • . 0 3 I 11 n"'
42
43
セ@40
41
?.i'14<116,
Q tl Q 21 ft',4f.t! fBャャ\NイLセ@ _, 21. セセ@"'
44
45
45
47
"·".
, I
I
s/1.'"
....
43
49
50
51
,(_p I LI'?
l1S4 I 21 J I rAA r o "',._.r•-r
52
53
54
55
I
55
57
58
59
7.l w 77 ''f () I l l Jl TX./1 .,._ Q/,;,·,60
61
62
63
77 r / '74.JI
"'JJ'
.22 lfN__,22.oJ I f64
65
66
67
sa
69
70
71
st
187 l?q o 2o 2? 20.n' __..../if?72
73
74
75
I _セ@()'
I 0 " OJ""'
>I< f' l セ@ /9 II76
77
78
79
oar,
I I " a ; o In IJO [ L 2. ,_ - L"'-l
80
81
82
83
10 I I 2 '"
( 0 j I' I Nc A II84
85
85
87
88
89
90
91
Ql( lln Rセ@ .2 0 • .0z __..
.Ll/1_ 0 0 lo92
93
94
95
ow"
2q \ゥォ・\セ@ /1/l OS OJ98
99
In
96
97
0.,.r
"'
I 2 0 0 )f 2S' f OJi'•H ___,. Iff( 1 JL..uo
U1
U2
U3
" セ@ oR IQ IO o ]I )I Oiiセ@ If IfU4
us us
I-16
N.R. C.
r - - - OIV, 0 F M ECHANICAL ENGINEERING
-DIGITAL COMPUTER t.ABORATORY
Pace_ of.
-'
G -15 D Prepared hy
G
v. !J Date:PROGRAM PROBLEM: CJIN
v.
PfiP(< ll n e 0 J0
1
2
3
Lp
Tnセ@
s
D8
.NOTES4
5
G7
,j
tlf 17.1'_ t' (I(/ l / <tAU' ャGBセ\イ@ --" 2/. #II
I
8
910
11
7.?"'
In
sGセ@ I 21 ) I Tl'./1 "• ou-u t'd •</ セN@ "' "'r Iro I oo12
13
14
15
J':>'"
ll.<o IJ I 7"1!1/ ro lJ/L.,
_,'
kJ 11 )(z16
17
18
19
21 lA 2 I 2 2 zJz,
I'll?!' I20
21
22
23
Jtf 2.1' <4 0 2A' 22 l'lr! セ@ ' ' · " " I24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
U.a So QN\セ@ azo
Rセ@ 2o. " ' _.., '"'32
33
34
35
S'• ·S'> Is.!> 0 2 セM Jh£l __:. A !1,T
II
[ 6-J, " __.. ,q"l
36
37
38
39
Nセ@ S' 172 _セ@ 0 0 7 12.1'40
41
42
43
5S' LI
6J
Go • l l Ji IVcAn44
45
46
47
J/0"'
.I'J n I 21 J II
7ff"ro
CaN Y.43
49
50
51
;o!w
3o.'-lo I l l J I'"""'"
,-'
'
52
53
54
55
Jo 43 62 j OJ z• o s. '-' , _::,_? /-1 R'
55
57
58
59
u. l 7.J" .. ..., I IJO 0 lo T " X 260
61
62
63
J(z tlS' '99 I 2 [? 22 J9 r1 __, 22. <>I64
65
66
67
68
69
70
71
5?5? lqoI
<U ,. 2<" 2?-r;.
- AR.72
73
74
75
qz 1'1J jq.l' t' OJ 2<? J/<£1-.--=-
Lアセ@76
77
78
79
<iJ!r
llfJ'In セ@
J
0-?. XX - ; 9 1 f l 40 0<>80
81
82
83
I atf ! ' -I"J' '" 1' .? !/ J/ /)1('4!? I84
85
86
87
...
.,
"'
S'f I 21 j , . b " " セN@ r,t. t> r.88
89
90
91
I
c.
2 14 0-'
.
'.1 J 3 I 2.1 J x-292
93
94
95
J s I" ' /17 ·J OJ 2q Bill< セ@ QQセ@96
97
98
99
9"7 lq I ______., J 7 . , 7 セセNAMn
0 "7 22 22. A"uo
Ul
U2
U3
I,;
U4
us us
07 / , __.... .4R'"
I<+ t' 2o 2J'N.R.C. DIV. OF M CH
-I
DIGITAL computeセ@ LABORATORY Pace_ ar-E ANICAL ENGINEERING ' G -15 D Prepared by
c.
v.B.
Date:PROGRAM PROBLEM : COt!i.V • pNセッ」N@ Ll n e I H
0
1
2
3
Lp
T
Nt
s
D
8
.NOTES
4
5
6
7
14 IS'II
:? _D_l .2_<1 !_!s_n . _.:.. iuセ@%.<