Computing the Mean of Geometric Features Application to the Mean Rotation
20
0
0
Texte intégral
(2) INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE. Computing the mean of geometric features Application to the mean rotation Xavier Pennec. N˚ 3371 March 1998 THÈME 3. ISSN 0249-6399. apport de recherche.
(3)
(4)
(5)
(6) !" # $%& " '
(7) (
(8) " " '
(9) )+*-, .0/-1324/-5656/-798 :;=< >@?AB CEDGFH? IHJLK'FHMONPDQ;=NP>@>R?TSE>RJLKU;VMODV?XW MY>RJLZP? [ W]\VNLDVDV^ ? [ W_K NLDVD]JLMO[`[`JLDVK ? [ abI`NXcd?'Ffehg=MY\]JXiVI`? j4JLgVgkNPIlF\=?Il? KU;V? I`KU;V?mD]noAPAGprq B sQJLI`KU;tqvuPuLwB qyx@gVJLZP? [ 3z {6|'}v~]L}G :;=?-iV? [lFHMONPD ?RMYDGP? [lF`MYZGJ!FH?MODFH;VMO[JXIlFHMOK O?@MY[ ;VJXFMY["FH;V?@>@?yJXDXJLOiV?@NLJ[`?'FNL ZP? NL>R?'FHIlMYK"?yJXF`iVI`? [JXDV\+;=N KyJLD ?K NL>Rg=i=FH?MOFUQ?iV[`?JL[4J@ZPiVMO\VMYD=Z?TVJX>Rg=Y?NPDV?NL FH;V?>@NP[lF [lF`iV\VMO? \+FE9gk?NX ? JXFHiVIl? [MOD+K NP>@gVi=FH? IrMO[`MONPDQJLDV\I`NPkNLF`MYK [ API`NLFHJXFHMONPDV[ :;=?iV[li]JLF`? KU;VD=MY-iV? [NPD3gkNPMYDGF`[K NLDV[`MO[lFNX>@MYDVMO>@MY MYD=ZFH;V? O?yJX[lFlS¡[`-i]JLIl?K I`M¢FH? IlMYNLD£Wr ;VMOKU;ZPM¢P? [ FH;V?]JXIl9K ? D-F`? I W FH;V?¤ ? MOZP;GFH? \¥O?yJL[dFlSE[l-i]JLI`? [+NLI3FH;V?¦[liV> NL3§¨[l9iVJLI`? \_©sQJL;]JLYJLDVNLVMY[\VMO[lFHJLDVK ? [ ªfD=NLIlFHi=D]JXFH? OLW F`;V? [l?FH? KU;VDVMO-iV? [Il? ¢tNPDtF`;V?@P? K'FHNPI[`g]JXK ?R[lFHIliVK F`iVI`?NLgkNPMODGFH[JXDV\ZL? DV? IHJLOMY MYD=Z FH;V? >«\VMOI`? K'FH¢"FHN4NLFH;V? IFErgk? [ NLr?yJXF`iVI`? [ K NPiVO\O?yJL\"FHN4g]JLI`JL\VNyr? [¬ak® uGp!¯0o°]NPIMODV[dFUJLDVK ?LWXK NP>@gVi=F`MYD=Z FH;V?]JLIl9K ? DGFH? I NLhI`NXFUJXF`MYNPD=[iV[lMYDVZI`NLFHJXFHMONPD¤>RJXF`I`MOK ? [ W£iVDVM¢F -i]J!FH? IlDVMONPDV[ NPIfI`NLFHJXFHMONPDP? K'FHNPIl[±ZPM¢P? [ FH;VIl? ?\VM¢²³? I`? DGF4I`? [`iV¢FH[ ?gVI`? [`? D-FMYD´FH;VMO[JLIlF`MYK Y?+JF`;VNPIlNPiVZP;´ZP? D=? IHJXYMOyJXF`MYNLDµNL4FH;V?FH;=I`? ?+JLkNvP?K I`M¢FH? I`MONPDV[RFHNt;VNXS >@NPZP? D=? NPiV[@jMO? >RJLDVDVMYJLD¶>RJLDVM¢NPO\V[FH;VJXF·I`? ONPDV¢NLD¸MYDGFHIlMYD=[`MOK KU;]JLIHJXK FH? I`MO[lF`MYK [RNX4F`;V?3>RJLDVM¢NPO\£ :;V?·DV? K ? [l[HJLId¦K NLDV\VM¢FHMONPD¦NPIfF`;V?>@?yJLDIlNLFUJXF`MYNLD£W³MODV\V? g? DV\V? DGF`O¦\=? I`M¢P? \MOD¶¬¹? D]uLxX¯ºW³MY[±NPrFUJLMODV? \ ;V? Il?JX[Jg]JLIdFHMOK iVYJLI"KyJX[`?RNLJ ZP? DV? I`JLbNPI`>iV»Jr@?JLY[lN+g=I`NPgkNP[`?RJLDtMOD-F`I`MODV[`MOKZLIHJL\VMO? DGF\V? [`K ? DGF JLOZPNPI`M¢FH;=>¼F`N NP=FHJLMYD+FH;V?>@MODVMO>iV>½NLbFH;V?K IlMOF`? I`MONPDV["JXDV\¤[`;=N ¾;VNv FHN3? [lF`MY>RJXF`?FH;V?iVDVK ? IlFHJLMYDGFE NLoF`;V?I`? [`iV¢FHMODVZ3? [lF`MY>RJXF`MYNPD³:;V? [`?·JLOZPNPIlMOF`;V>@[gVIlNvP?F`Nk?DVNLFfNPDV¢+JLK K iVIHJ!FH?VirF±JLO[`N? ¿RK MO? DGFy K NP>@gVirFUJXF`MYNPD=[bJLI`?NPDV¢A4FHN ÀF`MY>@? [bYNPD=ZP? I NPI6IlNLFUJXF`MYNLDV[ F`;]JLDNPI gNLMYDGFH[ 6:;V?JXK K i=IHJLK'gVIl? \VMOK F`MYNLD NL FH;V?"I`? [`iV¢FH[4MO[ M¢FH;=MYDqÁ3W= ;VMOKU;QMO[f-iVM¢FH?"I`? >RJLI`Â!JLVO?L :;=?[lF`I`MOÂ-MYDVZ[`MO>RMOYJLI`M¢FENXVFH;V?JLOZPNPIlMOF`;V>@[ Ã!? ;]JyrMONPI NPI ZL? DV? IHJL-?yJXF`iVI`? [oJLD=\NPI gNLMYDGFH[ [lF`I`? [l[`? [ FH;V?¦XJLOMY\=MOFEÄNXNPi=IJLgVgVIlNGJLKU;ÅiV[`MODVZÆj4MO? >RJLD=DVM»JXDÇZP? NP>@? F`IlÅJLD=\ÈO? F`[iV[JLDGFHMOK MOg]JXFH?¦F`;]JXFNLF`;V? I [lFHJXFHMO[lF`MYK JL I`? [liV¢FH[fJLDV\JLOZPNPI`M¢FH;=>R[K NPiVO\+k?"ZP? DV? IHJLOMO ? \FHN@>RJLDVM¢NPO\V[MYDFH;VMO[IHJL>@?' NPIlÂ_ É+ÊG˳ÌlÍÎ ~!Ï |X >R? JLD?yJXF`iVI`?XW]>R? JLDI`NLFHJXFHMONPD£W=i=[`MONPD£W_jMY? >JXDVDVMYJLD+ZL? NP>@? F`Il Ð ÑÒ ÓÑÔÕ!Ö׺ØTÙÚdÛÜkÝ]ÑÞ Ôß Ó ÜÕXà'á!â±ã ÑäoÕÔ ×0Û0åæXçèåéàTê9Ñëá ÛºÚdêìêåìí'Úlá!çèÚbîràTï Unité de recherche INRIA Sophia Antipolis 2004, route des Lucioles, B.P. 93, 06902 Sophia Antipolis Cedex (France) Téléphone : 04 92 38 77 77 - International : +33 4 92 38 77 77 — Fax : 04 92 38 77 65 - International : +33 4 92 38 77 65.
(10) ¾& & &
(11)
(12) 6 ' # R# $%& ±
(13) # # " " '
(14) # >@N
(15) L|? DV D=?3
(16) \£ ùiVD ? NLDViV[`[? >D=NPViVO?3[\VMODG?RFH^ gVI`Il? MY[l>@[`NPM¢FHD=M¢P[·? \][JLZPDV^ [NL>RK ?'^'F·FHIlJLMYId-FHiVMOK ? O[? ? +FYK J+NL>R-iV>@? ? [lF`D-MYFNPDYJ[`K iVJLM¢XYK JLiVDGOFH? ?¤I· 9 i³ÃNP? iV[lFl[S¡K gV?3I`? -DViVDV?NPDV»J [ K NP>@>@?3MOYOiV[dFHIHJ!FHMONPD¸0ùiVD \=? [FE9gk? [\V?gVI`MO>@MOF`MOL? [·O?gVOiV[i=F`MYOMO[`^3? D9MY[lMYNPD¸gVJLINPIl\VMOD]JXFH? iVI?'F·? D I`NPkNLF`MY-iV?XO? [4I`NXFUJXF`MYNPD=[AP ? [ F`? KU;VD=MY-iV? [6iV[liV? OY? [ gkNPiVIO? [ gkNPMOD-F`[ K NPDV[lMOF`? DGF >@MODVMO>RMO[`? I O?bK IlMOF`< Il?\V? [ >RNLMYDV\=I`? [ K JLI`Il^ [ W!K ? -iVM-\VNPDVDV?Y?h]JXIl9K ? D-F`I`?XWPY? [6>@NPMODV\VIl? [ KyJLIlI`^ [ gkNPDV\V^ I`^ [ NPi»J[`NP>@>@?\=? [ \VMY[dFUJLD=K ? [6\V?sQJL;]JLYJLDVNLVMY[ §0JLiKyJLIlI`^y©'+sQJLO;V? i=I`? i=[`? >@? D-F WhK ? [FH? KU;=DVMY-iV? [·I`? gNP[l? DGF[liVIYJ+[dFHIliVK F`iVI`?\£Ã? [`g]JXK ?L? K F`NPI`MO? \V? [ gNLMYDGFH[f? FfDVNPiV[fJyPNPD=[\V^èc R>@NPDGFHIl^-iV?Y? iVIZL^ DV^ IHJLOMY[`JXFHMONPD+;]JXFHM¢P? R\³ÃìJLirFHI`? [fFE9gk? [\=?gVIlMY>@M¢FHM¢P? [ K NPD=\ViVM¢ F ¦\V? [g]JXIHJL\VNyr? [ a JLI@?'r? >@gVO?LWO?KyJLOK iV\=iµ]JLId9K ? DGF`I`?\V?I`NLFHJXFHMONPDV[@? D´i=F`MYOMY[`JLDGFO? [ >RJXFHIlMYK ? [Q\=?IlNLFUJXF`MYNLD£W O? [9iVJXFH? I`DVMONPDV[+iVDVM¢FUJLMOI`? [+NPiÈO?tL? K F`? iVIQI`NLFHJXFHMONPDÅ\VNPDVD=?tF`I`NPMO[+Il^ [liVOFHJXFH[ \VM¢²³^ I`? DGF`[ NPiV[gVI`^ [`? D-F`NPDV[·\]JXDV[K ? FJLIlF`MYK Y?iVDV?ZL^ DV^ IHJLOMY[`JXFHMONPD IlMYZLNPiVI`? iV[`?JLiK JL[\=?XJLI`MO^ F`^ [I`MO? >RJLDrS DVMO? DVDV? [ ;VNP>@NPZP< DV? [ \=? [F`I`NPMO[K I`M¢FH< Il? [ ^'PN99i=^ [ K M SE\=? [`[liV[ ?'F`FH?QZP? DV? IHJLOMO[HJXF`MYNPDÄIl? gkNP[`?Q[`iVIKyJ!S IHJLK'FH^ I`MO[lFHMO-iV? ["MODGFHI`MODV[l< -iV? ["\V?»JXJLIlMY^'FH^K NPDV[lMY\V^ I`^ ?L ? [ K NPDV\VM¢FHMONPDV[±DV^ K ^ [`[HJXMYIl? ["KyJLI`JLK F`^ IlMY[`JLDGF±»J I`NLFHJXFHMONPD´>@NL? DVD=?LW\V^ IlMOL^ ? [3MYD=\V^ gk? DV\=? >@>@? DGF \]JLD=[Q¬¹? DVuPxL¯ºW[`NPDGFMYK M4NL=FH? D9i=? [K NP>@>@?QiVDÆKyJL[ g]JLIdFHMOK iVOMY? I@\V? »J¤NPIl>iVO? ZP^ DV^ I`JLY?X NLiV[·gVI`NLgNP[lNPDV[·^ ZGJLO? >@? DGFRiVD´JLOZPNPI`M¢FH;=>R? \=? \V? [lK ? DGF`?Q\V? ZPIHJX\VMY? DGF±MYDGF`I`MODV[`< 9i=? »JRLJXI`MO^ FH^gNLiVINPrFH? D=MYIfY?>RMODVMO>iV>½\V? [K I`M¢FH< I`? [ ? FDVNPiV[ >@NPDGF`I`NPDV[fK NP>S >@? DGF? [lF`MY>@? I¨ÃMODVK ? IlF`MOF`iV\V?[liVI"DVNLF`I`?R? [lF`MY>RJXF`MYNLDIl^ [`i=OFHJLDGFH?L ? [JLOZPNPI`M¢FH;=>R? [JXgVg]JLI`JLMY[l[`? D-FDVNPD [`? iVY? >@? DGF±gVIl^ K MO[4>JXMY[fJLiV[l[`M ? ¿RKyJXK ? [fgViV[lMY[l9i³ÃMOY[DV?g=I`? D=DV? DGF -iV? A RÀ@NPMO[4g=YiV[4\V?"FH? >Rg=[fgkNPiVI Y? [IlNLFUJXF`MYNLDV[f-iV?gNLiVIY? [gkNPMYDGF`[ JgVIl^ \VMOK F`MYNLD¤\£Ã¹MYDVK ? IdFHM¢FHiV\V?? [dF K NLI`I`? K F` ? @>RNLMYDV[f\V?RqÁ gVI`< [ W K ?-iVM? [dFf^ ZGJLO? >@? DGFfI`? >JXI`-i]JLVO?L J[lMY>@MO»JXI`M¢FH^I`JLgVg]JLDGF`? ? DGFHIl?±Y?fK NP>@gkNPIlF`? >@? DGF\V?K ? [JXYZPNLI`M¢FH;V>@? [gNPi=I\V? [gVI`MO>@MOF`MOL? [ZP^ DV^'S IHJLO? [±?'F±gkNPiVI O? [ gkNPMODGFH[±[`NLiVYMOZPDV?·YJXJLOMY\=MOF`^·\V?DVNLF`I`?·JXgVgVI`N9KU;V?F`;V^ NPIlMY-iV?·irFHMOYMO[HJLDGF"YJZP^ NP>@^ FHIlMY? I`MO? >RJLDVD=MY? DVDV?t? FDVNPiV[gk? Il>R?'F\£ÃìJXD-F`MYK MYgk? IYJ¸ZP^ DV^ IHJLOMO[HJXF`MYNPDÈ\£ÃJLi=F`I`? [Il^ [`i=OFHJXFH[? FJXYZPNLI`M¢FH;V>@? [ [lFHJXFHMO[lF`MY-iV? [ JLir3LJXI`MO^ FH^ [? Di=FHMOYMO[HJXD-FfO?> >R?KyJX\VI`? «Î }v| Ì " !
(17) | gVI`MO>@MOF`MOL?>@NvP? DVDV?LWkI`NXFUJXF`MYNPD >@NvP? DVDV?XWkiV[lMYNLD£W]ZP? NL>R?'FHIlMY?I`MO? >RJLDVD=MY? DVDV?.
(18) @
(19)
(20) ®[l[`iV>@?·FH;]J!F ?·;]JyP?·J3[l? F±NLh>@? JL[`iVIl? [+*-,.0/@NXbFH;V?[`JL>@?gkNPMYDGF1,JLD=\¤FH;]JXFf ? JLDGF F`N3NP=FHJLMYD J ?'F`FH? I ? [dFHMO>RJXFH?X:;V?·iV[li]JL6 Jy¦MY[ F`N KU;VN9NP[`?·FH;=?]JLIdrK ? DGFH? 3I ,52 4 796 8 . ,.b ;VMYKU;tMO[ FH;V?·O?yJL[dFlS [`-i]JLIl? [f? [lF`MY>RJXF`MYNLDQNL FH;V?>@?yJLDLJXYiV?X N "W_M¢6 ?;VJvL?J@K NP D :]\V? D=K ?XJLOiV<? ;=. NPDQ? JLKU;Q>@? JL[`iVIl?LW ?tK NL>Rg=i=FH?¦FH;=? ? MOZP;GFH? \]JLId9K ? DGF`? I W ;=MYKU;È>@MYDVMO>@MY ? [FH;V?¦ ? MOZP;GFH? \ÇY? JL[lFdSE[l9iVJLI`? [+K I`M¢FH? IlMYNLD >? ,A@+4 ;=.0BDC ,.FEG,HC IyQC¡ ?3;VJvL?J+K NXJLIlM»JXDVK ?3>RJXF`I`M K JMLNDLON±\V? [`K IlMY=MYDVZ¤F`;V?3iVD=K ? IdFUJLMODGFE NL ?yJLKU;>R? JL8 [`i=. I`?LW FH;V? D ?;VJvL?RF`N+>@MODVMO>RMO ?RFH;V?R[`i=> NL[l9iVJLI`? [·sQJL;VJL»JXDVNPVMO[\=MY[dFUJLDVK ? [ >? ,A@P4 ? ,.QEK,A@RSBTJMLON
(21) LON ? ,.QEK,A@' 8 . ®fYVF`;V? [l?fF`? KU;VDVMO-iV? [JLI`? ? Y_Â-DVNv D JLD=\JLIl?f? JL[l·F`NMO>@gVO? >@? DGFy UfNv ? L? I WrZP? NL>R?'FHIlMYK4>@Nr\V? Y[ NL_FH;V?Il?yJLr NPIlY\@NLëF`? D·O?yJL\·F`N±K NPDV[lMY\=? Ih>@NPI`?K NP>@gVY?T·?yJ!FHiVIl? [bOMYÂX?4OMODV? [W¬ V"IlM»u X!¯0WGgV»JXDV? [ W9NLI`MO? DGFH? \ gNLMYDGFH[¬¹°r® uLxX¯ NPIIHJX>R? [¬¹ab:uGp!¯0:;V?gVIlNPVO? > ?FHJLKUÂ-Y?MYDFH;=MY[fJLIlF`MYK Y?"MO[f;=N ¥FHN@ZP? D=? IHJXYMO ?FH;V? gVI`?'9MYNPi=[ >@? FH;=Nr\V[4NPI4ZP? DV? I`MOKZP? NP>@? F`I`MOK?yJ!FHiVIl? [ :;VMO[ gVIlNPVO? >¼MO[fDVNXF [`N?yJL[dk ?;]JyP?[l;VNv D MYDȬ¹a®uGp!¯F`;]JXF·ZL? NP>@? F`I`MOK?yJ!FHiVIl? [·ZP? DV? I`JLY¢ \=N¦DVNLF·k? ONPDVZ¤F`NJQP? K'FHNPI·[lg]JLK ? Vi=F·I`JXFH;V? IFHN¦J >RJLDVM¢NPY\3JLDV\3FH;VJXFM¢FMODV\Vi=K ? [gVJLIHJL\=Nvr? [MO ?F`IlRFHNi=[`?F`;V? [lFHJLDV\]JXI`\F`? KU;VDVMO-iV? [NPDgNPMODGFH[ MOF`; FH;V? >°]NPI MODV[lFHJLDVK ?LW ?@K JLD¦I`? gVI`? [`? DGFJ A!Sè IlNLFUJ!FHMONPD¦G¦MOF`[±>RJXFHIlM¢Z YW³FH;V?·K NPI`Il? [lgNPD=\VMYD=Z+iVD=MOF -i]JXFH? I`DVMONPDV\[ [^]NPIF`;V?IlNLFUJ!FHMONPDL? K F`NP+I _`4ba Bdc6Qªf[`MODVZQF`;V?3]JXIl9K ? D-F`? IF`NQK NP>@gVi=FH?FH;V?>R? JLD£W ?NP=FUJXMYD ? MOF`;V? +I Y 4 796 8 . Y9.EeW ] 4 716 8 . ]f.NPgI _ 4 716 8 . _h.¡:;V?F`;VI`? ?3I`? [`iV¢FH[K NPIlI`? [lgNLDV\FHN \VM¢²³? I`? DGFfI`NLFHJXFHMONPDVj[ iT °]IlNP> J>J!FH;V? >J!FHMOKyJL4gNLMYDGFNL9MO? "WJLONPg? IHJXF`MYNLDV[R ?Q\=f? :]DV?+NPD¶?yJXF`iVI`? [[`;=NPiVO\I`? O¶NPD MYDGF`I`MODV[`MOKKU;VJLIHJLK'FH? I`MO[lFHMOK [ NL-FH;=?b>JXDVMONLY\JLDV\"DVNXFNPD±FH;V?oL? K'FHNPI gVIlNPg? IlF`MY? [ NXr[lNP>@?hg]JLIlF`MYK iVYJLIKU;]JLIdFy s+NPIl? NvP? I WbFH;V? I`?3MO[ZP? DV? I`JLOOJ+FHI`JLDV[dNPI`>RJXF`MYNPDZPI`NPi=g¸JLK F`MYD=Z¤NPD FH;=?>RJLDVM¢NPO\ FH;]JXF>@Nr\V? Y[FH;V? gNL[`[`MOVO?"MY>RJLZP? 9MO? ¥gNPMODGFH[JLD=Q\ kXNPIF`;V?±[`iV9cd? K F4>@NvP? >R? DGFMOD FH;V?±MO>RJLZP? [ h®DG NPgk? I`JXFHMONPD [`;=NPiVO\ ?MODGXJLI`MYJLDGFhNPFI lEK NvXJLI`MYJLDGnF m M¢FH;@I`? [`gk? K FhF`N FH;V?JXK FHMONPD@NL]F`;VMY[bZLI`NPiVg³o°]NPIoMODV[lFHJLDVK ?LWGFH;V?]JLIl9K ? DGFH? I NL gNLMYDGFH[MO[MOD-XJLIlM»JXD-Fi=DV\V? IF`;V?±JLK'FHMONPDNL I`MOZPMO\ NPIJX¿RDV? F`IHJLDV[dNPI`>RJXF`MYNLDV[ H o ? ,.
(22) @p4 o9,.EbCED FH;V?K JL[`?4NLZP? NP>@?'FHI`MOK?yJXF`iVI`? [ W-FH;V? [`?4\V? [lMY\=? IHJ!FUJJLI`?>i=KU;>@NPI`?\VM¢¿RK iV¢FhFHN>@? 8 ? F W9JLDV\@ 8 ?;]JyP?FHN FUJLÂX? J"YN9NPÂ@JXF-iVM¢FH?f\V? ? g3I`? [`iV¢FH[MYD\VMO²? Il? DGFHMYJLkZP? NL>R?'FHId@MYDNPI`\V? IF`N;VJvL? JLDMYD=[`MOZP;GFNL ;]JXFJLI`? FH;V?·MODGFHIlMYDV[lMYKRKU;]JLI`JLK F`? IlMY[dFHMOK ["NLhFH;V?·>RJLD=MONPO\¦ ?@K JLDiV[`?X:;VMO["MY[ F`;V?·NPrcd? K F"NL[`? K FHMONPD q ;VMOKU; [`iV>@>RJLIlMY ? [3FH;=?+FH;=? NPIdÆ\=? P? YNLg? \ÈMOD«¬¹a ? D]uPxX¯0ÇCEDµ[`? K'FHMONPDÅA=W ?¤MODGP? [dFHMOZGJXF`?QFH;V?+Y? JL[lFdSE[l9iVJLI`? [ >@MYDVMO>@MY JXFHMONPD¤NX6FH;=?jMY? >RJLDVDVMYJLDQ\=MY[dFUJLDVK ?JLD=\+ ?[`;=N ¥FH;]JXFfM¢FfK JLDQk?[`NP¢P? \¤? ¿RK MO? DGF`OL4:;=? D£W ?ZP? DV? IHJLOMO ?F`;VMO[JLOZPNPIlMOF`;V> FHNFH;V?R ? MYZP;GF`? \¸O?yJL[dFlSE[l-i]JLI`? [·JLDV\FH;V?3sQJL;]JLYJLDVNLVMY[K IlMOF`? IlMYNPD=[MYD [`? K FHMONPDRÀV6CEDF`;V?YJL[lFb[l? K'FHMONPD£WG ?JXD]JL¢r ?JLDV\·K NP>@g]JLI`?F`;V?FH;=I`? ?JLYZLNPI`M¢FH;V>@[bMODFH? I`>@[bNLJLK K iVIHJXK NL FH;V?"? [dFHMO>RJXFH? \Q>@?yJLD³W_JLK K iVIHJLK'NL FH;V? MYIiVDVK ? IdFUJLMODGFE+? [lF`MY>RJXF`MYNPD+JLDV\K NP>@gVi=FUJ!FHMONPDF`MY>@?X r s 6 !± # ?hIl? 9MY?' ¸MODF`;VMY[ [`? K F`MYNPD[`NL>R?]JL[lMYKJLD=\\V? ? gk? I DVNLF`MYNLDV[ NLVjMO? >RJLDVDVMYJLDZP? NP>@?'FHIlL :;=MY[ [l9DGFH;V? [`MO[ JX[fMODV[`g=MYIl? \QGW¬ trgVM»pLu=W]KU;VJLg£uX¯0W W¬ u±OM»vw qv¯ JLDV\t¬ JLIHvu q¯º (. wyxnz. ). {}|~9| | . CEDÆF`;V?ZP? NP>@?'FHI`MOKIHJL>@? NPIlÂkWNPDV?[`gk? K M:]? [FH;=?[dFHIliVK F`iVI`?+NL J>RJLDVM¢NPO\G -´JK !
(23) $ j ! ´:;VMO[MO[JK NLD-F`MYD-iVNLiV[K NPYO? K'FHMONPDµNX \VNLFRgVIlNr\=iVK F`[NPD¶FH;=?FHJLDVZP? DGF[lg]JLK ?+JXFR?yJXKU;µgkNPMYDGF á0åØ'í ÛáfäàT Ø árÚk!Û Ø'æ!×0HÚÛ$0× !Û-Ø'áí'DÛ å³Ø FÛ á!Ø hàTà'!êS×0àUÚkÛºÚdáàU׺ØTÛºá×0Û=åìåWØ'Ú á'à'Úlá!áb¨â"×0Ú`Ø'â4Û!ÛºàTåìÚ áÛ0åìØ'$$Û Oá ÈpÚ%$OØ áAÆêìnÚ !TåGá!£å¹$Û Ûá!Ø'Ú hbÛ !àTàTàÛ0׺Û0ÚlÚ_׺×0׺Wå áyÚdåìáåéØ'àTØ á êG$× oÖ׺åToàTØ'êìïáTå dêìØ'Ú ÚlÛ1â Pà1¡ $Û áÚ å
(24) ÛOh¤!àU Ø ÛºÚdØ'׺×0á$Û åØ Ø áí'¡4Ø'áXã àTØ êj×0ÚlØ àU'Ûº×0Údåé×`çèÕGÚç0-å9ØyØfí 0Údåáá!Úlíf׺à'Û!êêTÚ Ó Ó%á¢S£ £#¤#¥.
(25) . À. . NLF`;V?Q>RJLDVM¢NPO\£Ä:;-iV[ WM¢ ?QK NLDV[`MO\V? IJK iVIlL?QNPD´FH;V?+>JXDVMONLY\£W ?+KyJLDÆK NP>@gVi=F`?¤JXF?yJXKU; gNLMYDGFMOF`["MYDV[dFUJLDGFHJLDV? NLiV[[lg? ? \P? K FHNLIJLD=\M¢FH[±DVNLI`>WFH;V?@MODV[lFHJLDGFUJLDV? NPiV[[`gk? ? \£: NK NP>@gVirFH?@FH;V? Y? DVZLF`; NLF`;V?K iVIlL?LWo ?3KyJLDgVI`N9K ? ? \¶JL[iV[li]JL-MOD-F`? ZPI`JXFHMODVZFH;VMO[XJLOiV?JXYNPD=Z+FH;=?K i=IlP?XQ:;V? \VMO[lFUJXDVK ?k? FE ? ? D@FE N±gkNPMYDGF`[oNLkJK NPDVDV? K FH? \Rj4MO? >RJLDVD=M»JLD·>RJLD=MONPO\MO[6FH;=?>@MYDVMO>i=> O? DVZLF`;·JL>@NPDVZ FH;V?@K iVIlL? [cdNPMODVMYD=ZF`;V? [l?@gNPMODGFH[ :;V?@K iVIdP? [Il?yJLOMY MYD=ZF`;VMO[>@MODVMO>iV> NLI"JLDGQFE N+gkNPMOD-F`[±NLFH;V? >RJLDVM¢NPY\3JLI`?fKyJLOY? \ ZP? N9\V? [`MOK [ h:;V?KyJLOK iVOiV[NL³LJXI`MYJXFHMONPDV[[`;VNv [FH;VJXFZL? N9\V? [lMYK [JLI`?4FH;V?f[`NPOi=FHMONPDV[ NL6JR[dr[dFH? > NL6[l? K NPDV\QNLI`\V? I4\=MO²? Il? DGFHMYJL? -i]J!FHMONPDV[4\V? gk? DV\=MYDVZNPD FH;V?jMY? >RJLDVDVMYJLD>R?'FHIlMYKX CED3F`;VMO[JLIlF`MYK Y?XW= ?±JL[`[liV>@?±FH;]JXFFH;V?>JXDVMONLY\ MO[ % ' ! WrM¨¹?LbFH;]J!FFH;=? \Vf? :VDVMOF`MYNLD \VNP>RJLMOD+NX6JXY£ZL? N9\V? [lMYK [fK JLD?"?'9F`? DV\V? \+F` N 4:;VMO[>R? JLDV[FH;VJXFFH;V?">RJLDVM¢NPO\;]JL[DVN@NLiVDV\]JLId DVNPI"JLDG¦[lMYD=ZPiVYJLI"gNPMODGF±FH;]J!F± ?RKyJLDIl?yJLKU;tMYDJ :]DVM¢FH?·FHMO>@?L·®f[JXDtMO>@gNLIlFUJXD-F"K NPDV[l? -iV? D=K ?LW FH;V? UfNPgr SèjMYDVNv SE?j4;]JX> FH;=? NPIl? > [dFUJXF`? [FH;]J!FFH;V? I`?JL¢ Jy9[f?TrMY[dFJ!FY? JL[lF4NPDV?±>@MODVMO>RMO MODVZZP? N9\V? [lMYK ?'FE ? ? DÄJXD-FE NtgNLMYDGFH[@NLfFH;V? >RJLD=MONPO\¥§¨M¨?X¶ ;=MYKU;ÆY? DVZLFH;´MO[@F`;V?\VMO[lFUJXDVK ??'FE ? ? D´FH;V? FE N gNLMYDGFH[H©' x. w. v. Tx M x. xy. γ t. 0. u y. °6MOZPiVI`?qP
(26) "!#" %$& (' $*)+," -'/.0 1320)45 67'8$#9:7; I. γ y. M. 9:<1=+ >?#9:#" (@A BCD8E( -)9F'HGI 1KJ )4ALNMO E" )# P*<E8)=QR$ 9:81K )S B7D8E( -)9F'HTU 1WVX)4 LZY#O\[]^"'8_`+ + '7C B^9a &b -)c16d`< 6<1)# 7$C9e)b1f^CE( )=K" CE#c "!#" g$& *[ hjiakNlZ7 CR!8)1('(+ E('%'m 9: n+o"!j .p 9:q'm B9a *+ !f" <&r+o('<+,c 6RBs$#)=C#" n+t &?Q $K 1 6g1=+ 'm E8g & )="!3 6#Qu+ 'HE8)="'v#9DC81w[. bÎ Ê } ¨ !b } V~v} °]I`NP> FH;V?3F`;V? NLIl NXf[l? K NPDV\´NPI`\V? I·\VM¢²³? I`? DGF`M»JL? -i]JXF`MYNPD=[ Wh ?Â-DVNv F`;]JXF FH;V? I`? ?TrMOF`[NPDV? JXDV\ NPDV¢RNPDV? ZP? Nr\=? [`MOK [dFUJLIdFHMODVZ@JXFJZPM¢P? D ? JXFHiVIl? MOF`;JZPM¢P? D3FUJLDVZL? DGFP? K F`NPI :;VMO[±JLOYNv [F`N3\V? L? ONPg¤FH;=?>RJLDVM¢NPY\QMYDQF`;V?FHJLDVZP? DGF±[`g]JXK ?·JLONPDVZRFH;V?ZP? N9\V? [lMYK [@§F`;VMODVÂ+NXbI`NPOOMYDVZ JR[lgV;V? I`?JXYNPD=ZRM¢FH[FUJXDVZP? DGF4gVYJLDV?JXF4J@ZPMOL? D+gNPMODGFT©T:;V?ZP? Nr\V? [`MOK [fZPNPMODVZ·FH;VIlNPiVZP;FH;VMO[4gNPMODGFfJLI`? FHI`JLDV[lNLI`>@? \3MODGFHN[lFHI`JLMOZP;GFOMYD=? [JXDV\RF`;V?\=MY[dFUJLDVK ? JLONPDVZ"FH;=? [`?fZP? N9\V? [`MOK [JXI`?4K NPDV[l? IdP? \t§¨JXFY? JL[lFMYD J3DV? MOZP;-kNPI`;VN9N9\¤NL ©'±:;V?iVDVK F`MYNLD¤FH;]JXF >JXgV[FHN?yJLKU;¦P? K F`NPIFH;=?K NPIlI`? [`gkNPDV\VMODVZ gkNPMYDGF±NLD¤FH;V? >RJLDVM¢NPY\MO[4K JLOY? \F`;V? B~f $
(27) :;=MY[·>RJLg¸MO[·\Vf? :VDV? \´MYD F`;V?3 ;VNPO?FHJLDVZP? D-F@[lg]JLK ? M §¨[`MODVK ?3FH;V? >RJLDVM¢NPO\¸MY[·ZL? N9\V? [lMYK JLY¢ K NP>@gVO? F`?v©3Vi=FM¢F MO[NLDV?'SºFHNXS¡NPDV?¤NPD=OµYN9KyJLO¢ÅJLI`NLiVDV\ÄFH;V?¦NLI`MOZPMYD³ C¡ ?ONrNP´NPIF`;V?¦>RJ!rMY>RJL \VNP>RJLMOD ;V? I`?3FH;=MY[>JXg MY[NPDV?'SºFHNXS¡NPDV?XW ? :]DV\ NLi=FF`;]JXFMOFMY[·J[lFHJLIdS¡[`;]JLgk? \\VNP>RJLMOD¸\V? OMY>@M¢FH? \ G¤JRK NPDGFHMOD-iVNPiV[±K iVIlL? > M KyJLOO? \¤FH;=? ! $
(28) " % m - v' f:;=?MY>RJLZL?NL > M GFH;V??'rgNLDV? DGFHMYJL >RJLgQMO[FH;V?K i=F4ONrK iV<[ M NL gkNPMYDGF jNPiVZP;=OLWVFH;VMO[fMO[FH;V?[`?'FNX6gkNPMOD-F`[4 ;=? I`?[`?'P? IHJL >@MYDVMO>@MY MYD=Z ZP? N9\V? [`MOK [[lFHJLIlF`MYDVZIlNP> >@? ?'(F v D3FH;=?±[`gV;V? I`c? I ?v @NPIMYDV[dFUJLD=K ?LWVF`;V? K i=FYN9K i=[NL JgNLMYDGF MY[ MOF`[4JLDGFHMOgN9\]JL£gkNPMODGFJXDV\F`;V?±FUJLD=ZP? DGFHMYJLK i=F4YN9K iV[MO[FH;V?"K MOI`K Y?"NL IHJX\VMYi=g[ o :;=??'rgkNPDV? D-F`M»JX>RJLg M¢FH;VMODF`;VMY[\VNP>RJLMOD I`? JLOMY ? [·JKU;]JLIlFKyJLOO? \ 3B~f
(29)
(30) M S j C¡F K NvP? I`[JLO=FH;=?>RJLDVM¢NPY\@?T=K ? g=FhF`;V?K irFhYN9K iV[bNXkF`;V?\V?'P? YNPg=>R? DGFgkNPMOD-F WP ;VMOKU;;]JX[hJ D9i=YV>@? JL[`iVIl?L ã Ø ×0Ú6Ö׺ÚlçdTå 0ÚdTê 'Õy!Û Úhç vÛ êìØvç £å £!Û ÚhçèêìfØ $×ºÚ Ø r!Û Tå 0ÚèÛ ¡ ÑÒ ÓÑÔ xSy]z { N{ |.
(31) ? F E ?FH;V?I`? gVI`? [`? DGFHJXFHMONPD¦NL MODQFH;=MY[4KU;]JLIdFy:;V? DQMOF`[\VMO[lFHJLDVK ?FHNRFH;V?NPI`MOZPMODQMO[¸\VMO[lF ? @y4 . C C M. . wyx0w. . o:;VMO[KU;VJLIlFMY[[`NL>R? ;VNv ÄFH;V?ylè>@NP[dFOMODV?yJLIm4KU;]JLIdFNLFH;V?4>RJLDVM¢NPO\R M¢FH;3Il? [lg? K FFHNF`;V? ?yJXF`iVI`?. ~ ~
(32) 9 9| . V ~| { } Ê }v~|¨ Nv "W[`MODVK ?· ?@JLI`? NPIlÂ-MYDVZ M¢FH;¤? JXFHiVIl? [±NPD¤ ;=MYKU;JLK F`[±JFHI`JLDV[dNPI`>RJXF`MYNPD ZPI`NLiVg3FH;]J!F>@Nr\=? O[FH;V?gNP[l[`MOVO?±MY>RJLZP?49MY?' ¥gkNPMOD-F`[ WVM¢FMO[D]J!FHiVI`JLkF`NKU;VN9NP[`?"JXD3MYDGXJLIlM»JLDGFjMO? >RJLDrS DVMYJLD+>@?'FHI`MOK§F`;V?"?'rMY[dFH? DVK ?K NPDV\=MOF`MYNPD=[JLIl?±\V? FHJLMOY? \QMOD¬¹a ? D]uPxL¯ ©'h:;VMO[ JyPWkJLO³F`;V?">R? JL[`i=I`? >@? D-F`[ ]JL[l? \NLD\VMO[lFHJLDVK ?JLIl?·MYD=\V? gk? DV\=? DGFNLFH;=?RMO>RJLZP?@I`?'? Il? DVK ?IHJX>R?·NLI"F`;V?·FHI`JLDV[lNLI`>RJXFHMONPDNLFH;V? MY>RJLZL?LQ\=MY[dF ? @p4 \VMY[dF ? @' ?'F k?hJgkNPMODGF NL-FH;V?b>RJLDVM¢NPO\±FH;]JXF³ ?hKyJXYLF`;V?bNPIlMYZPMOD££ ?hKyJLO j TS S j FH;=?b?'rgNLDV? DGFHMYJL KU;]JLIdF±JXF4FH;V?NPI`MOZPMOD+NPIFH;=?MODGLJXI`MYJLDGF >@? F`I`MOK·JLDV\ ?\V? DVNXFH?G FH;V?I`? gVI`? [`? DGFHJXFHMONPD¦NL MOD+F`;VMY[ KU;]JLIdFyo®f[`[`i=>RMODVZ"FH;]J!Fo ?;VJvL?KU;VNP[`? DJXD·NPIlF`;VNXSED=NPI`>RJLrK N9NPI`\VMOD]JXF`?[l9[dFH? >WGFH;=?\VMY[dFUJLD=K ? MOF`;·FH;V? NPI`MOZPMODMO[ \VMY[dF ? B @p4 C C Nv "WLO? F Y ?yJ lEgVYJLK ? >R? DGF6iVDVK'FHMONP D mHWLM¨?XoJFHIHJXDV[lNPIl>RJXFHMONPD[`iVKU;F`;]JXF Y +4 f:;V?\VMO[lFHJLDVK ??'FE ? ? DtJLDGFE N gkNPMODGFH[MO[ \VMO[lF ? @ 4 \=MY[d F Y "!$#&% ('4 C) Y * "!$#&% C DV?"KyJLDP? I`M¢ë FH;]JXFF`;VMO[NLI`>i=»J@MY[MODV\V? g? DV\V? DGFNL F`;V?"KU;VNPMOK ?NL FH;V?"gVYJLK ? >@? DGFfi=DVK F`MYNPD³ xSy]zb Î { NÊ { } |¨ !b } V~v}3 { Ï fÊ y]zb Î { wÊ { } | ! z r} Î } } Ê ~ zbÎ | { }| :;V?gVI`?'9MYNPi=[NPI`>iVYJR[l;VNv [ FH;]J!F±FH;V?·P? K F`NPI ? Y * "!$#&% @MY[±F`;V?@I`? g=I`? [l? DGFUJ!FHMONPDNX MODtJLD?'rgkNPDV? DGF`M»JLhKU;]JXIlFJXF ? JXFHiVIl? ·:;V? K N9NPI`\=MYD]J!FH?h[l9[lF`? >NL9FH;VMO[ KU;]JLIdF MO[ NPIlF`;VNXSED=NPI`>RJLXVi=F MOF \V? g? DV\V[ NPD"FH;V?hKU;VNP[l? DgV»JXK ? >@? D-F iVDVK'FHMONPD£ C¡F MY[ NLëFH? D>@NPIl?hMYDGFH? I`? [lFHMODVZ4FHN4iV[`?hFH;V?hDVNLDrSENPIdFH;VNLZPNPD]JLLK N9NPI`\VMOD]JXF`?h[l9[lF`? >MYD=\ViVE K ? \G±FH;=?g=I`MODVK MOg]JL KU;]JLIdFyW_ ;VMYKU;QMY[fMYDV\=M)? 4 gk? DV\V? DGF±NL6F`;V?g=»JLK ? >@? DGFfiVDVK F`MYNLD£FH;=MY[4MY[4FH;V?"P? K F`NPI f 4,+ ? Y * @jB ? Y * "!$#&% ,A@'W * MY[F`;V<? ;PJLK NP=M»JLDNL FH;V?±F`IHJLDV[l»J!FHMONPDNL F`;V?"NPI`MOZPMOD+MOD FH;V?"gVIlMYD=K MOg]JL KU;]JLIdFy ;V? Il-? + ? M * @p4/.10 . 2&* 3M6 * 55 M8* 7:9 °]IlNP> JgVIHJLK'FHMOKyJL5 gNLMYDGFNL9MO? "WVFH;=MY[>@?yJXDV[FH;]J!F ?±K JLD lEF`IHJLD=[`YJXFHj? mF`;V? ONrK JL³K JLYK iVYJXFHMONPDV[NPD gNLMYDGFH[E F`NFH;V?±g=I`MODVK MOg]JL£KU;VJLIlFNL NLiVI>RJLDVM¢NPO\GI`? g=»JLK MYD=Z =E , 4 , E = M¢FH; fE JLDV\ ,<> E? MOF`; @ BA M * ? ? @ 4C M * ? + ? M * @) "!$#&%!BD @T+°]NPIMODV[lFHJLDVK ?XW6FH;=?? >@gVMOI`MOKyJXK NvXJLIlM»JLD=K ?>RJXF`I`M t MOF`; I`? [`gk? K FFHN¤J gNLMYDGF W]k? K NP>@? [¬a ? D]uLxL¯º 7 7 JFG E G E ? @p4 H fEI J B fEI J R 4 + ? Y * @ BLK H Y * !O#&% .P\B Y * "!$#&% .P RRQ BO+ ? Y * @ R §dq© c .7 c .7 {. 6. 6NM. M. @z } Î |0 Î zbÊ ~=}| Î5{ | CED¨JLK'FyWP ?;]JyL?f[l;VNv DFH;VJXF>RNL[lFNL³F`;V?MYDGF`? I`? [lF`MYDVZNPg? IHJXF`MYNLDV[hNPD\=? FH? IdS >@MYDVMO[lF`MYKJLDV\iVDVK ? IlFHJLMYDZP? NL>R?'FHIlMYK?yJXF`iVI`? [ K JLDk??TrgVI`? [`[`? \·MYDFH;V?gVIlMYDVK MYgVJL-KU;]JLIlF NLrFH;V?>RJLDVM¢NPY\ MOF`; NPDV¢FH;V?R? NPgk? I`JXFHMONPDV[" ?;]JyP?MYDGFHIlNr\=iVK ? \£Q°]IlNP> J+K NP>@gVi=FHJXFHMONPD]JLgkNPMYDGFNL9MO? "W6F`;VMY[ >@?yJLDV[FH;VJXFFH;V?"NPD=O NLg? IHJXF`MYNPD=[ ?;]JyP?"FHN@MY>@gVO? >@M)? 4 D-FfNPI?yJXKU* ;4 FE9gk?NL ?yJ!FHiVIl?JXI`? } } Ê ]L} | Î { Î S }v~ { | S¡Î ~ =} | Î { ? 4 @o M¢FH;RM¢FH[ ;PJLK NP=M»JLD=<[ .10 .2U3 2 * JLDVV\ .W0 . 2OM3 * 2 WrJXDV\ *} } XÊ z !] Ê wÊ { } S { L} | Î { T M * M¢FH;tMOF`N [ ;PJXK NPVMYJLXD .1.0 2&M *ZY @eoP? Il;VMOZP;V? I"Y?'P? hNPgk? I`JXFHMONPDKyJXDtk?@?'rgVIl? [`[l? \¸JX["JK NP>=MYD]J!FHMONPDNL FH;V? [`?@NPDV? ["JLDV\¤F`;9i=[K JLD¦k?·MY>@gVO? >@? DGF`? \MODV\V? g? DV\V? D-F`ONXF`;V?·K NLDV[`MO\V? Il? \FE9g?·NLh? JXFHiVIl?L: N [`MO>@gVYM¢ëiVIlF`;V? I4K NP>@gVirFUJXF`MYNPD=[ W_ ?KyJLDQJL\V\+F`NRF`;V? [l?·JXF`NP>@MYKNPgk? IHJ!FHMONPDV[FH;VN? ;PJLK NLVM»JXDQNL FH;V?FH;V? FHI`JLDV[`YJXF`MYNPDNL FH;V?"NPIlMYZLMY[D + ? M * @T wyx]\. ^`_<ba~. dc feSfeS| . :;V?hKyJL[l?hNLrAP´IlNLFUJ!FHMONPDV[£MO[ MYDGFH? I`? [lFHMODVZfJL[M¢FNPI`>@[DVNLF NLDVO J>JXDVMONLY\"Vi=F JXY[lNF`;V?oFHI`JLDV[dNPI`>RJXF`MYNPD ZPI`NLiVg hgji U4? DVK ?LW]FH;=MY[MO[4MO>@gVOMYK MOF`OJLD;VNP>@NPZL? DV? NPiV[>RJLDVM¢NPY\+JL[FH;=?ZLI`NPiVgJLK'FH[NPDMOF`[`? Oèh®D Ó Ó%á ¢S£ £#¤#¥.
(33) x. . YM DGXJLIlM»JLDGF>R?'FHIlMYK[`;VNPi=Y\? DV[liVI`?F`;]JXFÄ\=MY[dF ? Y 6 Y I @4 \=MY[dF ? Y IR BTY 6 @T Uf? DVK ? ?K JLDN9K i=[NPD \=MY[dF ? Y @'oC¡FMY[ ? YkÂ-DVNv DFH;VJXFyYÇKyJLD3k?4KU;]JLIHJXK FH? I`MO ? \ -JLDJLDVZPO?9aJLIlNPiVDV\3JLD3J!rMO[c §¨iVD=MOF P? K FHNLIU©'W]F`;V?JLDVZPO?"? MYDVZ@D-iVONPIFH;V?"MO\V? DGF`MOFEL C¡F6FHiVIlDV[bNPi=FbF`;]JXFoF`;V?MYDGXJLIlM»JLDGFjMY? >RJLDVDVMYJLD@\VMO[lFUJXDVK ?NP0D hgjihMO[+\VMO[lF ? Y Y @p4 a ? Y1R BWY @§[`? ? ¬¹®fOFHwPx=W³a ? DVuPxX¯ ©'±:;V?ZL? N9\V? [lMYK [±[lFUJXIlFHMODVZ3IlNP> FH;V?MO\V? D-F`MOFE+NPIfF`;VMO[±>R?'FHIlMYK·6 JXI`?I ? @ 4 I Y ? a 6 -B c @ JLDV\¸FH;=??TrgNPD=? DGFHMYJL>RJLg´JXF·MO\V? DGF`MOFE¶MO[FH;V?IlNLFUJXF`MYNLD P? K'FHNPI _ 4 a%BWc ®[· ?;]JyP? Y ? c @ 4 Y ? Eg c@'W³F`;V?K irF"YN9K iV[NLbFH;V?MY\V? DGFHM¢FE¦MY[fFH;V?[l? F"NLhIl
(34) ? ]? K F`MYNPDIlNLFUJXF`MYNLDV[ ^ U4? DVK ?LW£FH;=?\Vf? :VDVMOF`MYNLD i \VNP>RJLMODNXF`;V?gVI`MODVK MOg]JL]KU;VJLIlFMO[hF`;V?NPgk? DR]JLO ? F@To°]I`NP> JK NP>@gVi=FHJXFHMONPD]JL=gNPMODGFNL9MO? "W- ? iV[`?F`;V?K YNP[l? \]JLO F`N3I`? gVI`? [`? D-FJXY I`NLFHJXFHMONPDV[fVi=F ?·;]JyP?F`N3I`? >R? >k? I F`;]JXF±[dr>@>@? F`I`MOK·gNLMYDGFH[ JLI`?"MO\V? DGF`M :]? \¤JXFF`;V?"NLiVDV\]JLId NL FH;V?"\VNL>JXMYD£p _^4 HBWc _S4 EgHBdc6 t9MYDVK ?¤FH;V? g i MY[ J ZLI`NPiVg³WF`;V?¦JLK'FHMONPDÄMO[FH;V?QK NP>@gkNP[`M¢FHMONPDÈJLDV\F`;V?¤gVYJLK ? >@? DGF iVDVK'FHMONPDÅMY[ iVDVMO-iV? ¢\V?'FH? I`>@MYD=? \£¤F`;VMY[MY[RFH;V?+MY\=? DGFHM¢FE«§ 34 _L©'ÄC¡^ Y ? _ @@JLDV}\ _ ? Y^@\V? DVNLF`?+FH;=?Q>RJLgVgVMODVZP[ ?'FE ? ? DI`NLFHJXFHMONPD·P? K FHNLI`[JLDV\@>RJXFHIlMYK ? [ W-F`;V?4JLK F`MYNLDRMOH[ _ I _ 6 4 _ I _ 6 4 _ ? Y ? _ I @jBTY ? _ 6 @@TH UfNv ? L? I W ?DVNLF`?F`;]JXFFH;=?\V? I`M¢XJXFHM¢P? [QKyJXD¥k?t>@NPIl?[lMY>@gV¢ÈK NP>@gVirFH? \ÇiV[`MODVZ´FH;V?tK NP>@gkNP[`M¢FHMONPDÇNLiVD=MOF -i]JXFH? I`DVMONPDV[§¨? -i]JXFHMONPDV[fJLIl?±ZPMOL? D+MYD¬a ? D]uLxL¯ JLDV\¬ab:uGp¯ë©T # R
(35)
(36)
(37) #£
(38) # #£ V :;V? O?yJL[dFlSE[l-i]JLI`? [@K I`M¢FH? I`MONPD¸MO[·?yJL[lMY¢ ZP? DV? I`JLOMY ? \¸FHN¦JXD->@? FHIlMYK [lg]JLK ?JLDV\ M¢FH[·>@MODVMY>iV>(K NPI`Il?'S [`gkNPDV\V[@FHNFH;=?+? >Rg=MYIlMYK JL>R? JLDÆXJLOiV?MODJ¦P? K'FHNPIR[`gVJLK ?X:;VMO[NP=[`? IdXJXFHMONPD´MY[@FH;V?]JL[lMY[RNLfFH;V? FH;V? NPIlNXo?'rgk? K'FUJXF`MYNPDNPIIHJXDV\VNP> XJLIlM»JXVY? [fMOD>R?'FHIlMYK[`g]JXK ? [fgVI`NLgNP[l? \G°_Il^ KU;V?'F·§[`? ?¬¹a®uGp!¯ ©' CED+NLiVIKyJL[l?LWV ?K JLDZPNRi=IlFH;=? IFH;VJLDVÂ-[4F`N·FH;V?"MOD-XJLIlM»JXD-F4\VMO[lFHJLDVK ?JLD=\ IlMOF`?M¢Fy > ? @p4 B H \VMO[lF ? B .
(39) @ I 4 B H \VMO[lF ? Y * "!$#&% . @ I . .. ~ ~ Î ~ kÊ L} Î ~ Nv "W FH;VJLDVÂ-[F`N+F`;V?ZLNrN9\g=I`NPgk? IdFHMO? [NLFH;=?gVIlMYD=K MOg]JLKU;]JLIlF W M¢FFHiVIlDV[NPirFF`;]JXF FH;VMO[ K I`M¢FH? IlMYNLD¦KyJLD¦k??T=g=I`? [l[`? \ JL[JK YJL[`[lMYK JLo[liV>½NXh[`-i]JLIl?·NLbP? K FHNLI DVNPIl>R[ ? F .e4 Y * "!$#&% . ?±F`;V?lè? IlI`NPIL? K'FHNPIm"MYDFH;=?g=I`MODVK MOg]JLKU;]JXIlFyh:;V?K IlMOF`? IlMYNPDk? K NL>R? [ x. > ? @p4 . . B H. .. C . C I. ?"DVNXFH?±FH;]J!FFH;VMO[?'rgVI`? [`[lMYNPDQMY[NPDV¢3F`I`iV?"MODF`;V?"gVI`MODVK MOg]JLKU;VJLIlF : N>@MODVMO>RMO ?FH;V?K I`M¢FH? I`MONPD¦JLD=\¤\V? F`? Il>RMODV?F`;V?i=DVK ? IlFUJXMYDGFEQJXFF`;V?>@MODVMO>iV>W³ ? MOY DV? ? \QFHN K NP>@gVirFH?MOF`F[ :]Il[lF JLDV\[`? K NPD=\\V? IlMOXJXF`MOL? [ b°]I`NP>ÈFH;V?JXFHNL>RMOKhNPgk? IHJ!FHMONPDV[ WXJLDV\iV[lMYDVZ4FH;V?K NL ">R!$#&% gkM NP[lMOF`MYNPD I`iVO?NPIf\VMO²? Il? DGFHMYJLO[ W ?·KyJLDK NL>Rg=i=FH?F`;V?? IlI`NPIfP? K'FHNPjI .JLDV\¦M¢FH[ ;PJXK NPVMYJLDV[ .. M ** 4 . 2 !Y . M * 3 * WJLDV\ "!$#&% M "!$#&% . * Y * 4 . 2 ! Y "!$#&3 % * B . 2 ! Y 2 Y B . 2 Y ! Y WXC¡rFH;V?hiVD=K ? IdFUJLMODGFENL=F`;V?h>R? JL[`i=I`? >@? D-F`[ .9MY[ I`? gVI`? [`? DGF`? \G±FH;=?K NvLJXI`MYJLDVK ? >R. JXFHIlM¢3 . J 2 !Y G E " G#E " WVFH. ;V!?"iV.D=K ? IdFUJLMODGFENL FH;V?"? IlI`NPIL? K F`NPIMY[[lMY>@gV¢k Ê ~| =}*| kÊ | ÎTS }} (. ? "!$#&% .@ R Jh$E N $E Ne4&% . B J G E " G E " B'% . 4 % Y * BTJ . . . % % % Ê P~|ë} Ê ~| Î { rt MYD=K ?"FH;V?"K IlMOF`? IlMYNPDMO[ > 4 > R H .R % )G+ 4 * % 4 . % % ,. G. N G NB %. ? Y * "!$#&% %. . . .. .D@ R. 6 R BU .ºWVFH;V?P:]Il[lF4\V? IlMOXJXF`MOL?MO[ I 8 . . BU .. ÑÒ ÓÑÔ.
(40) ? ZPY? K F`MYDVZFH;=?oFH? Il>¥MOD B MOF`;"I`? [lg? K F FHNF`;V?oFH? I`>@[ MYD I MODF`;V?b[`? K NPDV\\V? I`M¢LJ!FHM¢P? [§[`? ?4¬WVsÈw=qPW [`? K FHMONPD+ÀVép¯ë©TW= ?NP=FHJLMOD£ 4 % ) H % . R B % . JXDV\ % ) . % . R % . % % % % CEDF`;VMO[og]JLIdFHMOK iVYJLIoK JL[`?XW- ?K JLD@?'rgVONPMOFo[`NP>@?gVIlNPg? IlF`MY? [bNL]FH;V?MYDGXJLI`MYJLDGFh>@? F`I`MOKFHN NPrFUJLMOD·>@NPI`? [`MO>@gVY?"NPIl>iVYJL[§¨\V?'FUJLMOO[fMODt¬a ? D]uPxL¯ ©'b?";]JyP?L 7 ) 4 E + ? Y * @ ! R % H . X J V D \ 4 ceBO+ ? Y * @ "! R % BO+ ? Y * @ "!$#&% JLD=\ % ) . 4 E + ? Y * @ "! R % !§ qP© .7 %. \<xnz. 6 9 cS
(41) TeS~LcS| Afe=| -e ~ ~ b ~ . e
(42) cS~. ®mDV? K ? [l[HJLId¦K NPD=\VMOF`MYNLDNLI `F N ?·J3>@MODVMO>iV> NXF`;V?K I`M¢FH? IlMYNLDtMO[ FH;VJXF FH;=?\V? IlMOXJXF`MOL? «) MO[±D-iVO0 CED+NLiVIKyJL[l?LWVFH;=MY[ZPM¢P? [ H. .. .4 4 H. .. ? Y * !O#&%. . .D@. C¡F>@?yJXDV[F`;]JXF"FH;V?>@?yJLDXJLOiV?JLDV\tFH;V?]JLIl9K ? DGFH? IK NPIlI`? [`gkNPDV\ B~f $
(43) S j 1 FH;=? JLIl?±NLF`;D9i=Y¨ °]NPII`NLFHJXFHMONPDV[ WVFH;VMO[DV? K ? [`[`JLIlK NPDV\VM¢FHMONPDKyJLD? IlMOFlFH? D£ H H _ 2 "!$#&% _h.4 P N I _ ? Y 2 R BWY9.
(44) @p4 . . :;VMO[4K NPDV\VM¢FHMONPD3 JL[MODV\V? gk? D=\V? DGFH¢\V? I`M¢P? \§NLII`NXFUJXF`MYNPD=[NPDV¢=©MYD¬¹? DVuPxL¯£iV[lMYD=ZFH;V? JLZPI`JLDVZPMYJLD NPI`>iVYJXFHMONPDµNX FH;V?+Y? JL[lFdSE[l9iVJLI`? [NPg=F`MY>@MOyJXF`MYNLDgVI`NLVY? > U4Nv ?'P? I W;V?QiV[l? [JLDJLg=gVI`NyrMY>RJXF`MYNLD NLF`;VMY[DV? K ? [l[HJLId K NLDV\VM¢FHMONPDFHN+NP=FHJLMYDJQ[`NLYi=F`MYNLD£CED K NPDGF`IHJL[dFyW6 ?gVIlNPgkNP[`?MYDF`;V?D=?'9F[l? K F`MYNLD JLD¶MYDGF`I`MODV[`MOKJLDV\¶ZP? D=? I`MOK ZPI`JL\VMO? DGF@\V? [lK ? D-FJLOZPNPIlMOF`;V> F`N :]DV\ÆJ¤[`NPOi=F`MYNPD¶NLF`;V? ?'=JLK'F@K I`M¢FH? I`MONPD£ CEDĬ £j t=u q¯0W Il? 9MY?' ? \¸NPg=F`MY>RJLJLDV\[`iV9SENPg=F`MY>RJLJLOZPNPIlMOF`;V>@[F`N+K NP>@gVi=FH?RFH;V?R>@MYD=MY>iV>NXNLF`;V? I I`NLFHJXFHMONPD¦iV[lMYNPDtK IlMOF`? IlMYNPD=[ UfNv ? L? I W MOFH;=? [`?@[lNPYirFHMONPDV[JLI`?@iV[li]JLOO¤K ONP[`? \tF`NNLiVI±MYDFH;=?·KyJL[l?NL J[`>RJLO6? I`IlNPI W_FH;V?'QK JLD¤\VM¢²? I [lMYZPD=M :]K JLDGFH¢+NLIYJLI`ZP? I\V?'9M»JXF`MYNLDV[ "sNPI`? NL? I W³FH;V?'¤JXI`?YMO>@MOF`? \¤FHN I`NLFHJXFHMONPDV[4JLD=\K JLDVDVNXFfk?"?yJL[lMY¢ ZP? DV? I`JLOMY ? \+F`NNXFH;V? IFErgk? [4NL ?yJXF`iVI`? [ \<x0w. . ~ ~ e p c=| e . cSp|~ e. ?'r? g]F JL D=k[`MO?fNPD¸JXDR§I`? ? [l>@F`MY>R? >JXkF`MY? NPID@FHNL;]kJXFHF;= ??">R;]? JyJLPD@?"FH?yN@JXF`I`iV? I`gV?X»JXK ? E @ BA Y * ? ? @ P. >. 4 >? @L>. HE j TS SE j WP ?;]JyP?FH;=?NPYONv MYD=Z: Jy9YNPI = > ? = G @ BA Y * ? ? `@ ©' ) R B E? > E? R B B E? > C E? C i P §0AG© . :;V?>RMODVMO>iV> NX F`;VMY[4JLg=gVI`NyrMY>RJXF`? \+K I`M¢FH? I`MONPDMY[ZPM¢P? D+NPI M. M. E? 4 E !O#&% B ) j4? gNLIlFHMODVZ3F`;V?XJLYi=? [±NLh? 9iVJXFHMONPDƧ!qP©TW³ ?+]: DV\¤FH;=?P? Id¤[lMY>@gVO?·NPI`>iV»Jr E? 4C+ ? Y * @ B&7 6 B 8 .7 7 6 .E Uf? DVK ?XW_F`;V?">@MYDVMO>i=> NL F`;V?JLgVgVIlNy=MO>RJXFH? \QK I`M¢FH? IlMYNLD+MO[I`?yJXYMO ? \+NPI. Ó Ó%á¢S£ £#¤#¥. 4. E @p4. @ A Y* ? ? . Y* M. E + ? Y * @ " !$#&% B ? P`4 Y * K c. B H. 7. .7 6. Q ..
(45) w. . Nv "WX ?KyJLDNP=FUJXMYDJf>i=KU;·?'F`FH? I6? [lFHMO>RJXFHMONPDNXVFH;V?FHI`JLDV[lNLI`>RJXFHMONPD-M¢FH? IHJXF`MYDVZfFH;V?gVI`?'rMONPiV[ LJ OZPNPI`M¢FH;=>®[fJLDQMODVM¢FHMYJL ? [dFHMO>J!FH?LW_ ?K JLDQKU;VN9NP[l?JLDG ? JXFHiVIl? . MOoDVNLFH;=MYDVZR? O[`?MY[4ZPM¢P? D£ ? F- ?±F`;V?"? [lF`MY>RJXF`MYNLD+NL FH;=?"F`IHJLD=[lNPIl>J!FHMONPDQJ!F[lFH? g h:;V?"DV?T9F? [lFHMO>RJXFHMONPDMY[ 7 E Q Y* "!$ #&% .P §¨À-© 6 4 @ BA Y* ? ? @4 Y * K c H .7. 6 M EC ? CNLhFH;V?·JX\XcdiV[lF`>@? DGF"P? K'FHNPI±k? K NP>@? [±FHN9N3[l>JXY . : ;=?·gVI`N9K ? [`[±MO [±[lFHNLgVg? \¦ ;V? DFH;V?DVNPI`> § ?i=[`?4 # 6 W= ;VMOKU;QMO[JXY>@NP[dFFH;V?"D-iV>@? IlMYKgVI`? K MO[`MONPDQNL FH;=?>RJLKU;=MYDV?y©NLI ;V? DFH;V?"D-iV>k? I NL MOF`? I`JXFHMONPDV[k? K NP>@? [F`NrN;=MYZP;³abI`JLK F`MYK JLY¢PWr ?±NP=[`? IdP? F`;]JXFF`;VMY[JXYZPNLI`M¢FH;V> JL¢ Jy9[K NPDGL? I`ZL? [MYD JLkNPi=F M¢FH? I`JXFHMONPDV[4NPIfJLDGFE9gk?NL6?yJXF`iVI`? [ 4CEDQFH;V?KyJL[l?NLogNPMODGFH[ WkF`;V?? 9iVJXFHMONPD¤MO[[lMY>@gVOM :V? \¤FHN 6 . ,.EWr ;VMYKU;+ZPM¢P? [FH;=?VJLIl9K ? DGFH? IfMYDNPD=O NLDV?"MOF`? IHJ!FHMONPDIlNP> JXD-3[lFUJXIlFHMODVZRgNLMYDGFy = 6 4 7 8 \<x]\. ^. Se | feS| -e ~
(46) ~Lc Se | e fe. 9~ e. ||,
(47) 9. ?;]JyL?+NPrFUJLMODV? \´JLkNvP? FH;=?F`IHJLD=[lNPIl>J!FHMONPD¶>RMODVMO>@MY MYDVZFH;=?K I`M¢FH? I`MONPD´NLIFH;V? NP=[`? IdP? \µ\]JXFHJ= >RNvJX "FH? W³\+[lMY>@D=K ?y?JXDF`;VX?JLO\ViVJX?"FUJK NPJLi=I`Y?\+K NP?±IlI`[liVYMOgrZPFH;G? FH\¦¢G\VM¢²³DV? NPI`MO[`? ?3DGF4§¨Il? I`NPgV>Il? [`FH? ;VDG?"FH? ?T\VJXGK FfFHNP;VDV? ?LMYoIfK Nv?"XJLDVI`NvMYJL «DVK -?i]JL>RDGJXFHF`M¢ëI`3M ]F`©T;VWk?"F`;VKU?;]JL? DV[lF`ZPM¢? S MYDFH;=?[dFUJXF`?±P? K'FHNPI M¢FH;I`? [lg? K F4FHN·FH;=?KU;VJLDVZP?"MODF`;V?"\]JXFUJr ?'F@iV[RJL[`[liV>@?NPIF`;V? >@NP>@? DGFRFH;]JXF@kNLF`;¶F`;V? \]JXFHJJLDV\¶FH;V?[lFHJXFH?JXI`? P? K FHNLI`[ ? F
(48) R 4 ? R B#B#B R @k?F`;V?P? K'FHNPIRNLNPV[`? IlL? \Ä\]JXFHJµ§ëFH;V? L? K F`NPINX JLO? IlI`NPI·P? K F`NPI`[H©JLDV\ FH;=?K NPI`Il?'S [`gk 6 NPDV\VMODV ZR7 >@?yJLD XJLOiV?R§ ?";]JyP?JL\V\V? \;V? Il? FH;V?±;]J!FH[FHN@[dFHI`? [`[FH;=?±\VMO²? Il? DVK ?k? FE ? ? DQ= JXK FHiVJLJLDV\ gNXFH? DGF`M»JL >@?yJX[`iVIl? >@? DGFH[H©':;=?>@MODVMY>iV> = ?
(49) @ NL F`;V?K I`M¢FH? I`MONPDNPI4J@\VJXFUJ·P? K FHNLI
(50) MO[4KU;]JLIHJXK FH? IdS MY ? \tG ) 4 .. R P 4 ?'F JLDV\ + 54 .. . k?FH;V?XJLOiV? ["NLhF`;V?·[`? K NPDV\tNPIl\V? I±\V? I`M¢XJXFHM¢P? [ NLbFH;=?K IlMOF`? I`MONPM D¦J!FFH;=?·JLK F`i]JL XJLYi=? [ ?
(51) = @T^ trMODVK ? = >@MODVMO>RMO ? [ FH;V?K I`M¢FH? I`MONPD¤NPI4FH;V?\]JXFUJ
(52) Wk ? ;]JyP? ) ?
(53) = @H4 JLDV\+J·:6Jy9YNLI4?Trg]JLDV[lMYNPDQJLI`NLiVDV\ FH;V? [`?"XJLYi=? [4ZPMOL? [ ) ?
(54) = @H4 + B ?
(55) E
(56) @L> B ? = E = @L> ? C = E = C I @L> ? C
(57) E
(58) C I @. eb9iVJXFHMODVZF`N@ ? IlNVWV ?NL=FUJLMOD+J@[l? K NPDV\QNLI`\V? IJLgVgVIlNvrMO>RJXFHMONPDQNX6Il? YJXFHMONPD?'FE ? ? DQF`;V?"[lFHJXFH? 4 E. . J 4 ?? = E. =. =. :;-iV[ W]FH;=?K NvLJXI`MYJLDVK ?NL = MO[ . E =. . . !O#&% B + B ?
(59). @ B ? =. E. =. E. . @ >
(60) L. @ R @p4 . ?C
(61) E. .
(62). CI@. B . "!$#&% B + BTJ + R . "!$#&%. ®[l[`iV>@MODVZFH;VJXFfJLYNLiVI >R? JL[`i= I`? >@? D-F`[±JLIl?MODV\V? g? DV\V? DGF Wk ?;]JyL?+J ¥4 fCE® V JLDV\ ?KyJXD[lMY>@gVOM¢ë +BJ! + R FHN@NP=FHJLMYD³ ) . ) R Q B "!$#&%. =. ? J BhB#B&J @. §© CED NLiVIKyJX[`?LWVF`;V? \]J!FUJ·JLDV\3F`;V?±[lFHJXFH? JLI`? D=NLFP? K F`NPI`[ W]Vi=F?yJ!FHiVE Il? [MODJ·j4MO? >RJLDVD=M»JLD>RJLDVM¢NPO\£ CEDR¨JXK FyWX ?KyJXD\VN F`;V?[HJL>@?\V? I`M¢XJXFHMONPDR-I`? gV»JXK MODVZ ? = E= @ MOF`; B 4 + ? Y *$ @jB ? Y *$ !O#&% ,A@6JLDV\ ?
(63) E
(64) @ MOF`;3J±[`NL>R? ;VNv Ä[`MO>@MYYJLIh?'rgVIl? [l[`MONPD£C¡FbFHiVIlDV[NLi=FbFH;]J!FbFH;V?4\V?f:VDVMOF`MYNLDNLkFH;=?4K NvLJXI`MYJLDVK ?4MO[KU;VJLDVZP? \ JLK K NPI`\=MYDVZLO§? -i]JXF`MYNPDtq©JLD=\F`;]JXF :]D]JXY¢ DVNLF`;VMODVZMO[KU;]JLDVZL? \QMOD? -i]JXF`MYNLD¸§ ©' ÑÒ ÓÑÔ J"# # 4. . "!$#&% B K H. BTJ B % . % . $ " $ " % . %.
(65) | { } ˸TÎ S } } Ê ! Ê ]| } Ì | V~ Ê Ê { ! Ê ªf[`MODVZF`;V?XJLOiV? [NLF`;V? \V? I`M¢XJXFHM¢P? [4ZLMOL? DMYD { Ê ~v}v? ? -i]JXF`MYNLD¸§!qL©'W= ?"NP=FUJXMYD£ J"# # 4. + ? Y $. J @jB * 8 . $ N $ N BU+ ? Y $ @ R c I ,. C¡ JXYF`;V? >@?yJL[liVI`? [JLIl? MY\=? DGFHMOKyJLO¢¶\VMY[dFHIlMYVirFH? \ÆNPV[l? IlXJXF`MYNLDV[@NLfF`;V? [HJX>R?I`JLDV\VNP> ?yJXF`iVI`?§ëFH;V? Y? JL[lFdSE[l9iVJLI`? [? [dFHMO>J!FHMONPDMO[NPgrFHMO>JX]NPDV¢MODF`;VMO[K JL[`?y©'W- ?fKyJLD? [lF`MY>RJXF`P? J $ N $ N6iV[lMYDVZFH;V?4I`? [`MO\Vi]JLO[ ? "!$#&% .
(66) @ B ? "!$#&% .D@ R §0xG© J"# # + ? Y $ @ B K 8 . Y $ ? Y $ Q BU+ ? Y $ @ R c c E @ \<x. . ^`_<ba~ | e. c e feS| . ?;]JyP?gVYNXF`FH? \MOD:]ZLiVI`?¤§!qP©FH;=?>@?yJXD¸JLDV\]JLIl9K ? DGFH? INL XIlNLFUJXF`MYNLDV[I`JLDV\VNL>R¢t\VMO[lFHIlMY=i=FH? \ JLI`NLiVDV\FH;V? lde6=JLK'nF m±IlNLFUJ!FHMONPD§ M¢FH;[lFH\³\=? kx X@\=? ZVW]ALx@\=? ZJLDV\tqvw·\V? ZJLONPDVZ·FH;V?P_GW_ JLD=\ _ J!r? [H©'±jNLFUJ!FHMONPDV[fJLI`?I`? g=I`? [l? DGFH? \-FH;=? MOII`NXFUJXF`MYNPDP? K FHNLI gVI`N!cd? K F`? \¦NPD+FH;V? ? _ _ @gVYJLDV?X:;V? ?'9FH? I`MONPI K MYIlK O?I`? gVI`? [`? D-F`[ FH;V?I`NPDGF`MY? IfNL6FH;V?\Vf? :]D=MOF`MYNPDQ\VNP>RJLMOD¶j§ Cj_QC94 a+4 ©'4eb[lFHMO>RJXFHMONPDV[ JLI`? I`? gVI`? [`? DGF`? \Æ M¢FH;¸F`;V? MOIgVIlNXcd? K'FH? \¶iVD=K ? IdFUJLMODGFE¸? OOMYgV[lNPMO\µJXF
(67) I 4
(68) ¤MYD¶ZPIl? P:;V? YJLIlZP? I? YOMOgV[`? [ I`? gVI`? [`? DGFF`;V?\=MY[lg? I`[`MONPD3NX£\]JXFHJJLIlNPiVDV\RFH;V?4>@?yJLDRXJLYi=?·§¨M¨¹?L6F`;V?gVIlNXcd? K'FH? \3iVDVK ? IlFHJLMOD-FE? OOMYgV[lNPMO\ NL FH;V?"? [dFHMO>RJXFH? Z\ J $ $ JXF
(69) I 4 P©' CEDFH;V?fgVI`MODVK MOg]JLkKU;]JLIdF"§Y?'ëFNL :VZPiVI`P? qP©bF`;V?VJLIl9K ? DGFH? IKyJLDVD=NLFFHJLÂL? MODGFHN·JXK K NLiVDGFFH;=<? lEIlNPDGFHMO? I ? ²? K'nF m+§I`NLFHJXFHMONPD¤P? K F`NPI`[ _ 4 HBdc¶JLDV\ E _JLI`?·MO\V? DGF`MYK JLhJLDV\I`NXFUJXF`MYNPD=[ P? K'FHNPIl[JXI`NPiVD=\F`;V? > JLI`? K ONP[`?tI`NXFUJXF`MYNPD=[U©' ±DÅFH;=?¦K NPDGFHI`JLIlLWFH;=?t>@? JLDÇIlNLFUJ!FHMONPDÄ[`? ? >@[F`N¶?tJLDÈJLK K iVI`JXFH?? [dFHMO>RJXFHMONPD£ UfNv ? P? I WkMOFMY[\VM¢¿RK iV¢FFHN·[HJy3 ;=MYKU;? [dFHMO>J!FHMONPD+MO[FH;=?±? [lF4MO ?"\VNPD£Ã FÂ-DVNv ¥FH;=?±?'=JLK F4IlNLFUJXF`MYNLD£ :;V?I`MOZP;GF >@? F`;VNr\ÄF`N rMO[`iVJLYMO ?¦F`;V?¦\VMO[`gk? I`[lMYNLDÈNX\VJXFUJ¸JLIlNPiVDV\F`;V?¦>@?yJLDÄXJLOiV?¦MO[FHN¸iV[l?¦FH;V? ?'rgkNPDV? DGF`M»JLbKU;VJLIlFK ? DGFH? Il? \tNPD¦FH;VMO[">@?yJLD¦XJLOiV?D§ :]ZLiVI`? q3NPD¦FH;=?·I`MOZP;GFT©'CEDtF`;VMO[±KU;]JLIlF"NLDVOLWFH;V? ]JLIdrK ? DGFH? I±NLbFH;=?\]JXFHJK NLI`I`? [`gkNPDV\V[ F`NFH;=?>@?yJLD¤XJLOiV?X?KyJLD¦[l? ?F`;]JXFIHJLDV\=NP>¼I`NLFHJXFHMONPDV[JLI`? ? YZLI`NPiVgk? \JXI`NPiVD=\3FH;V?±>@?yJXD3LJXYiV?R§ë ?±[l;VNv ¥;=? I`? F`;V?±[`? K F`MYNPDNL F`;V? I`NXFUJXF`MYNPD3L? K'FHNPI]JXYk MOF`; FH;V?">RJ!rMO>JX \=MY[lg? I`[`MONPD£W] ;VMOKU;+ JL[DVNLFF`;V?"KyJL[l?MODFH;V?"gVIlMYDVK MYgVJLKU;]JLIdFT©' Exact Mean Bary. Mean Exact. °6MOZPiVI`? r. q
(70) bS" j 1 PC 9CE8# -#9)49e 1)=Q 9:)# m " B+ )="'R 9e)=^1p BCBs# CE( K)= +,W 6 $9+oE+,$C & E C 9: E8#" -#9e810 9e)=^1 !#"
(71) $% '&)()*6[h0iakNlZ,+s# CE( C1X9a 1)=Q 9e)# n+ )="' +,S 6gE#C 9F E8# -#9:810)= # 63Q7" K9e)# n+ )="'- +o[t*[ , ./ 0*6[. Ó Ó%á¢S£ £#¤#¥.
(72) q-X. . #
(73) Ä
(74)
(75) X± # ?·;VJvL?@\V? L? ONPg? \t M¢FH;¦F`;V?·Y? JL[lFdSE[l9iVJLI`?@K IlMOF`? IlMYNPDtJ ;VNLY?NPIl>RJLYMO[`>%FHN NPrFUJLMOD¦FH;V?>@MODVMO>iV> NLJK I`M¢FH? I`MONPDÆNLDÆJ¤>RJLD=MONPO\ÆJLDV\¶? [dFHMO>J!FH? FH;V?iVD=K ? IdFUJLMODGFE¶NLFH;V?Il? [`i=OF ?KyJXD´D=N ?yJL[lMY¢ ZP? D=? IHJXYMO ?±FH;=MY[4JLD]JXO9[`MO[FHN·NLF`;V? IK I`M¢FH? I`MONPDV[[`iVKU;+JL[ ? MOZP;GFH? \+O?yJL[dFlS¡[`-i]JLIl? [fJLDV\3FH;=?sQJL;]JLYJLDVNLVMY[ \VMO[lFUJXDVK ?X . ~| e ~ ~ e
(76) 9 cS~ ®[l[`iV>@MODVZ FH;]JXFf ?;]JyP?·JK NPDS:]\=? DVK ?LJXYiV? ;=.oNLD¤?yJLKU;¦>@? JL[`iVIl? E. W ?K JLDQFUJXÂL?M¢F MODGFHN JLK K NPi=D-F xnz. . MYDFH;=?" ? MOZP;GFH? \QO?yJL[dFlS¡[`-i]JLIl?K I`M¢FH? IlMYNLD£ H. > ? @p4 . .. ;=.0Bv\=MY[dF ? B .
(77) @ I 4 . H. .. ;=.!B
(78) C . C I. :;V?>@? F`;VNr\@MO[oI`MOZPNPIlNPiV[lO[`MO>RMOYJLI6FHN F`;V?O?yJL[dFlSE[l-i]JLI`?K JL[`?XW-JLDV\·NPD=OFH;V?\=? I`M¢XJXFHM¢P? [JLI`?KU;VJLDVZPMODVZV ?";]JyL?MODV\V? ? \£ )G4 E + ? Y * @ "! R % H. . .. ;=.!B& .. 4. K H. ;=. Q BU+ ? Y * @ "! R % UB + ? Y * @ "!$#&% .. %. ). . % . 4 Ep;=. BO+ ? Y * @ "! R %. ªf[lMYDVZ@FH;=? [`?DV?' «\V? IlMOXJXF`MOL? [ W_ ?NP=FUJXMYD FH;=?"NLYONv MYDVZRZPI`JL\VMO? DGF4\V? [lK ? DGF? -i]JXF`MYNPD³ . 6 4. . Y * . ;=.!B 8 .. JLDV\FH;V?"iVD=K ? IdFUJLMODGFEJXFFH;V?">@MODVMY>iV> MO[4ZLMOL? D- J. # #. 4. + ? Y $. Y* !O #&% . P. M ;S. 8 .. @ B * 8 ? . ; .I BTJ $ N $ N BO+ ? Y $ @ R ;=.@ I , 8. ª4[`i]JXY¢PW9FH;V?4 ? MYZP;GF`? \ O?yJL[dFlSE[l-i]JLI`?fK IlMOF`? I`MONPD3MO[i=[`? \ M¢£ ?Â-DVNv ÅFH;]J!FJLO_I`? [`MO\Vi]JLkP? K'FHNPIl[;]JyP? FH;V?[HJL>@?§Vi=F·iVD=Â9D=N D]©K NvXJLI`MYJLDVK ?3>RJXFHIlM¢ J iVg FH;=?3[`K JLY?¨JLK F`NPI`[;S.¡ R J 4;=.!BJ $E N $E NH¦CEDF`;VMY[ KyJL[l?LAW J«KyJLDk?? [lF`MY>RJXF`? \I`NP> FH;V?"I`? [`MO\Vi]JLL? K F`NPI`[G J 4 7 6 6F8 ;=.0B . B . W]JLDV\ F`;V?"iVDVK ? IlFHJLMYDGFE NL FH;V?">@?yJLD?yJ!FHiVIl?k? K NP>@? [ J x0w. +~. p. # #. 4. + ? Y $ @ BLK. ?. J . 8. ;=.D@. e
(79) h{G|~9|. Q UB + ? Y$. @R 4. + ? Y $ @jBLK. ;=.0B .!B .R . ? c 8 E @ ? ;S.D@ 8. Q OB + ? Y$. @R. 9 91| |e ~. : N"JXYONv Æ\=MO²? Il? DGFJLDV\·DVNLDMY[lNLFHIlNPgVMOKK NvXJLI`MYJLDVK ?>RJXFHIlMYK ? [oNPI \VM¢²³? I`? DGFh>@?yJX[`iVIl? [ WG ?KyJXD·>RMODVMO>@MY ? FH;V?·[liV> NXbFH;V?§[`-i]JLIl? \_©±sQJX;]JLYJLDVNPVMO[±\VMO[lFHJLDVK ? [± MOF`;F`;V?>@?yJXDXJLOiV?XCEDNPi=IIHJL>@?' NPIlÂ_W£FH;V? sQJL;]JX»JLD=NPVMO[f\VMO[lFHJLDVK ? I ? @k? FE ? ? D¦J\:=r? \Q? JXFHiVIl? JLD=\QJ@IHJLD=\VNP> NPD=? MY[4\V? :]DV? \QMYDFH;V? ?'rgkNPDV? DGF`M»JL KU;]JXIlFfJXFFH;=?I`JLDV\VNL> ?yJXF`iVI`?X . I ? @p4. M * !O#&% '. R BU+ ? M * @ R BJFE E BO+ ? M * @jB G G M. Y * "!$#&% P. ÑÒ ÓÑÔ.
(80) ÅMOF`; FH;VMO[NPI`>iVYJXFHMONPD£W=F`;V?sQJL;VJL»JXDVNPVMO[\VMO[lFUJXDVK ?"MO[MYDGXJLI`MYJLDGF M¢FH;I`? [lg? K FF`N@F`;V?±ZPIlNPiVgJLK'FHMONPD£ I ? @<4 I ? @T ?;]JyP?·MOD¦g]JLIlF`MYK iVYJLI I ? @<4 I ? @ ;V? I`? 4 Y * !O#&% MO[ FH;V? [HJL>@?? IlI`NPIL? K F`NPIfJL[?'NPI`?JLD=\F`;V?"K I`M¢FH? I`MONPD>Jy k?± I`M¢F`F`? D > ? @p4 . H. I ? n .D@H4. .. . . H. .. .R B J $ "!$N #&$ % N &B .. :;-iV[ WXF`;V?JLYZLNPI`M¢FH;V>¥MY[FH;=?[`JL>@?hF`;]JLD"NPIFH;V?hO?yJL[dFlS¡[`-i]JLIl? [ WLVi=F FH;V?h\V? I`M¢XJXFHM¢P? [6NL9FH;V?hK I`M¢FH? IlMYNLD JLI`?"\VM¢²? I`? DGFyh:;V?^:]I`[dFf\=? I`M¢XJXFHM¢P?MO[ ) 4+* %. R. >. 4. % ,. H. .R % B J !ON #&% N &B . $ $ . % . trMO>RMOYJLI`¢PW]FH;=?[l? K NPDV\Q\=? I`M¢XJXFHM¢P? [fK JLD?JLgVg=I`NyrMY>RJXF`? \-k 4 % ) H % . R BTJ $ "!$N #&$ % N B % . JXDV\ % ) . % . % % % . . .R % B J "!$N #&% N $ $ % . Nv "WhFH;V?: Jv9ONPI@?'rg]JLD=[`MONPD´NLIFH;V? K I`M¢FH? IlMYNLDÆMO[·FH;V? [`JL>@?LWJXDV\¸FH;V? ?'PNPOi=FHMONPD´NPIFH;=?ZLIHJL\VMO? DGF V\ ? [lK ? D-FMO[[dFHMOY=ZPMOL? DRG·? -i]JXF`MYNLD¤§À-©' ?K JLD@iV[`?FH;=?[HJL>@?[lFHJLIlF`MYDVZ±XJLOiV?JLDV\@[dFHNPgVg=MYDVZ"K I`M¢FH? IlMYNLD JL[k? NPIl?LabIHJXK FHMOKyJXY¢PWo ? ;]JyP? NP=[`? IdP? \ÆJ+K NPDGP? I`ZP? DVK ?MOD¸JLkNPi=F3q MOF`? I`JXFHMONPDV[ ;=? D¶[lFHJLIlF`MYDVZ I`NP> MY\V? DGFHM¢FEJLDV\MYDJLkNPi=F MOF`? I`JXFHMONPDV[ ;V? D+[dFUJLIdFHMODVZRIlNP> F`;V?"Y? JL[lFdSE[l9iVJLI`? [f[lNPYirFHMONPD£ °]NPI±F`;V?iVD=K ? IdFUJLMODGFENXFH;=?[`NLYi=F`MYNLD£W ?3I`? gVYJLK ?RFH;V?@XJLYi=? [NL JLD=\ .. * MODGFHN¤? -i]JXFHMONPD§ © JLDV\ ?NP=FHJLMOD+J!ëFH? I[lMY>@gVOM :]KyJXF`MYNLD£ J. . 4. . !O#&%. ;V? Il? "!$#&% YM [FH;=?gU4? [l[`MYJLDQ>RJXF`I`M JXFFH;V?"NPgrFHMO>iV> $%& ' #
(81) CEDÄFH;V?QNLYONv MYDVZ=W ?¦\V? DVNLFH?¦G t·W Ft JXDV\Ès+®1U4® FH;=?QFH;VIl? ?¦gVIl? 9MONPiV[ >@? F`;VNr\=[ ? JLD]JL¢9 ?;V? I`?3FH;=? I`? YJXF`MOL?JLK K iVIHJLK'¸NLF`;V? \VM¢²³? I`? DGFR>@? F`;VNr\=[ WbFH;V?JXK K i=IHJLK' NLFH;=? iVDVK ? IlFHJLMYDGFE NPD¤FH;=?>@?yJLD¤XJLOiV?§ë ;VMYKU;[l;VNPiVO\¦gVI`? \VMOK F±FH;=?·JLV[lNPYirFH?·JLK K iVI`JLK =©TWJLDV\¤F`;V?K NL>Rg=i=FUJXF`MYNLD¤FHMO>R? [ e6=gk? IlMY>@? D-F`[QJXI`?¦gk? IlNLI`>@? \ÄNPII`JL>@? [ W[`? >@M¢SRNPIDVNPDrS¡NPI`MO? DGFH? \ÈI`JL>@? [ WfIlNLFUJXF`MYNLDV[JLDV\ÄgkNPMOD-F`[ °]IHJL>@? [JLIl?@K NP>@gkNP[`? \NLJ gNLMYDGFJLDV\JLDNPIlF`;VNPDVNLI`>RJL6F`I`MO;V? \VIlNPD£@CEDt[`? >@M SENPIlMY? DGFH? \tIHJL>@? [ W FH;V? FHIlMY;V? \VI`NLDµMO[K NP>@gNP[l? \NXFE N\VMOI`? K FHMONPDV[ ? 6 I @ ? E 6 E I @·JLDV\JXDÆNPIlMY? DGFH? \ÆP? K'FHNPI c F`;VMY[ >@Nr\V? Y[F`;V?"\VMO²? Il? DGFHMYJL gVIlNPg? IlF`MY? [4NXoJ·gkNPMYDGFNPD+J·[`iVId¨JLK ?X°_NLIDVNPDNPI`MO? DGF`? \IHJL>@? [ WVFH;V?"DVNLI`>RJL MY[JLO[`NiVD9SENPIlMY? D-F`? \µ
(82) § c E c©'·:;=?R? -i]JXFHMONPDV["DV? ? \V? \F`N MY>@gVO? >@? DGFFH;V?RJXF`NP>@MYK·NLg? IHJXF`MYNPD=["JLI`? ZPM¢P? D+MYD¬¹ah:uPp!¯NPIIHJX>R? [4JLDV\I`NLFHJXFHMONPDV[JLD=\MOD¬a ? D]uPxL¯NLIFH;V?"NLF`;V? Il[ t-FUJXF`MY[dFHMOK [JLI`?@Il?yJLOMY ? \-I`JLDV\VNL>R¢¦KU;VN9NP[lMYDVZ+JLDt?'=JLK'FXJLOiV[ ? MODJ ZPM¢P? DPNLYiV>@?Q§¨iVD=MONPIl> I`NLFHJXFHMONPDµJLDVQ\ kXNLI@F`IHJLD=[`YJXFHMONPDµK NP>@gNLDV? DGFH[H©'È:;V?Q>@? JL[`iVIl? V[ .JLI`?ZP? DV? I`JXFH? \iV[`MODVZ¸J VJXiV[`[lM»JLD DVNPMO[`?4 MOF`;FH;V?4I`? -iV? [dFH? \ K NvLJXI`MYJLDVK ? D^B~f
(83)
(84) Z e D^B~% 6:;VMO[>@? JLDV[F`;]JXF ?"JXI`?i=[`MODVZ@JLD3?TrF`? DV[lMYNLDNX£FH;V<? lèK NL>RgkNP[lMOF`MOL ? mDVNPMO[`? >@N9\V? gVI`NPgkNP[l? \3MOD¬ab:uGp¯º6F`;V? >@?yJX[`iVIl?±MY[ ? J E E 4 + ? M * @) "!$#&%!BTJFGE GE BO+ ? M * @) ! R %0 . 4 M * @ . ;V? Il? @ . MY[4J VJXiV[`[lM»JLD[HJX>Rg=Y?± M¢FH;K NvXJLI`MYJLDVK + Ó Ó%á¢S£ £#¤#¥.
(85) qOq. {G~fe=|p~
(86) . yxnz.
(87) .
(88) c . 9~. p. e. ~e . : ;V?@JLV[lNPOi=FH?·JXK K i=IHJLK'QNLJ>R?'FH;VN9\¦MO[ ZPM¢P? D¦GFH;V?\VMY[dFUJLD=K ?·k? FE ? ? D¦F`;V?I`? [`iV¢F"JLD=\QFH;V??'=JLK F XJLYi=?·§NLIhI`JL>@?fVJL[`? \?yJXF`iVI`? [ W- ?K NP>@gVi=F`?f[l? g]JXIHJXF`? ¢F`;V?fIlNLFUJ!FHMONPDJXDV\F`IHJLDV[l»J!FHMONPDg]JXIlFH[[`MODVK ? FH;V?'¸JLIl?3MOD´\=MO²? Il? DGF@iVDVM¢FH[H©'t®[F`;V? [l?XJLOiV? [@JLI`?XJLId9MYDVZ¤ M¢FH;¸F`;V?3[`?'F@NL4>@?yJL[liVI`? [@JLDV\¶[`MODVK ? ?NPDV¢3 JLDGFFHN@[lF`iV\= FH;=?Il? YJXFHM¢P?JLK K iVI`JLK NX F`;V?±FH;VIl? ?">@? FH;=Nr\V[ W] ?";]JyP?KU;VNP[l? DFH;V?"? IlI`NPINL s+1® U4® JX["F`;V?RI`? ? I`? DVK ?JLDV\ ?RK NP>@gVirFH?@FH;V?RIHJXF`MYNL[ 34 a a ´JLDV\ 34 FHN KU;]JLI`JLK F`? I`MO ?·F`;V?·I`? »JXF`MOL?RJLK K iVIHJLK'¦NL 4 Ft JLDV\ 4¾ Ft:;VMO["IHJXF`MYN MODV\VMOKyJXF`? [" J k? F`F`? I JLK K iVIHJXK NLV>@? F`;VN9\ MOF`;I`? [`gk? K F FHN s+1® U4®µM¢ JLDV\K NPDGP? I`[l? ¢P trMODVK ?FH;V?hFH;VIl? ?JLYZLNPI`M¢FH;V>@[ JLI`?I`? YJXF`? \¦FHN3F`;VI`? ?·\VMO²? Il? DGF";G9gNLF`;V? [l? [NPD¤FH;=?DVNPMO[`?·NPD¤? JXFHi=I`? [ W£ ?·MODGP? [lFHMOZGJXF`?@?yJLKU;¦FE9g?@NL DVNPMO[`?\VMO[lFHIlMY=i=FHMONPD[`? gVJLIHJXF`? ¢P { Ï w Ê zbwÊ { Ï wÊ { }Q { Ï Ï wÊ { } |¨P ! ! Ë ( |¨| }v~ |{ } Ê Ï Ê V| ~ Ê wÊ { }| CED¦FH;V?·K JL[`?·NXClCèm>R? JL[`i=I`?'S >@? DGFH[ W? I`I`NLIP? K'FHNPIl[f[l;]JLIl?"F`;V?"[HJL>@?K NvXJLI`MYJLDVK ?">J!FHI`M JLY£ ? MOZP;GFH[fJLIl?RqJLD=\ Ft¾MO[[lF`I`MOK FH¢ MY\=? DGFHMOKyJLGF`N Fty:;=? I`?MO[ D=N4[lMYZLDVM :VKyJLDGF \VMO²? Il? DVK ?? MOF`;V? I k? FE ? ? DFH;=?Il? [liVOF`[ NX Ft´JLDV\s+1® U4® :;VMO[4 JL[4?'rg? K F`? \Q[lMYD=K ?"FH;V?"KU;]JLI`JLK F`? IlMY JXFHMONPDQNX F`;V?s+1® U4® JLD=\ FtNPg=FHMO>i=>R[4K NLI`I`? [`gkNPDV\V[4M¢ Jh$E N $E Ne4 J . .
(89)
(90). . .
(91)
(92). . . . H. .. Jh$E N $E N BU .4 . JgB H. .. .4 . H. .. .4 . Ï wÊ zbwÊ { Ï wÊ { }¶ { Ï ]| | !¨=~ ! Ë ( |¨| }v~ |¨{ } Ê Ï Ê ]| ~ Ê ÊN{ }| CED¶FH;=?K JL[`?NLCt=¼>R? JL[`i=I`?'S >@? DGFH[ W? I`I`NLIP? K FHNLI`[@;]JyP?3F`;V? [HJL>@? K NXJLIlM»JXDVK ? >RJXF`I`M iVg F`NJ¤Â-DVNv D´[lKyJLO? ¨JLK F`NPI ¤? ;]JyP? KU;VNP[l? DÆF`N[HJL>@gVO? ?yJXF`iVI`? "JLK K NPIl\VMYD=ZtF`NF`;V? K NvXJLIlM»JLD=K ?3Jh E N E N 4 6. BTJ¸:;-iV[ WFH;V? ? MOZP;GFH[JLI`? ;=. 4 `4:;V?>RJXF`I`M Z JMY[FHJLÂL? D¤FHN?\VM»JXZPNPD]JL M¢FH;¤[dFUJLDV\VJLI`\¤\=? 9M»J!FHMONPDV[@§èqPW W q-XG©NPI4gNLMYDGFH[ JLDV\$§ X=A=W Xrìx==W X=ìuP©MYDIHJL\=M»JLDNPIIlNLFUJXF`MYNLDV[NPIFHIlMY;=? \VIlNPDV[ : N¤NPrFUJLMOD I`? YMYJLVO?3[dFUJXF`MY[dFHMOK [ Wo ?3;]JyL?3\VNPDV? q XF`I`MYJLO[NPI?yJLKU;¸D-iV>? INL?yJ!FHiVIl? [·JLD=\ ? gVI`? [`? D-FMOD :]ZPiVIl?§0AG©4F`;V?·>@?yJLD¦XJLOiV?@JLDV\¦F`;V?·[lFHJLDV\]JLIl\\V? 9MYJXFHMONPD NLhFH;V?·Il? YJXFHM¢P?@JXK K i=IHJLK MY? [NL Ft JLDV\ Ft M¢FH;I`? [`gk? K'FfF`Ns1® Uf® {. . . . . Relative error on the LSQ and WLSQ mean point. Relative error on the LSQ and WLSQ mean rotations. (reference : MAHA error −− ISD measurements). (reference : MAHA error. 5.0 Ratio LSQ / MAHA Ratio WLSQ / MAHA. Ratio LSQ / MAHA Ratio WLSQ / MAHA. 4.0. 4.0. Ratio of the rotation errors. Ratio of the mean points errors. −− ISD measurements). 5.0. 3.0. 2.0. 1.0. 3.0. 2.0. 1.0. °6MOZPiVI`?A= Ô 6$Û Ú׺ÚdêéàUÛºåW Úà çdç!׺à ç åT"êÛ0åìÖêåéçdàTÛ0åT'Ú 0Õ ïOÛºvåWÛQ³Ú"ÚÖ×ºØ Ún×00ÚÚdá à ÛVçdÛ$ç!!ڳ׺àT׺Û0ÚnÚM$êÛÚ`àTáå¹Û! סàUÛºåØh%¢EØ Õ×_³àTáÚyÚl!àfà&¨'åìÚÚd×SçèyØfåT$!ÖàTvêìåTÛ0lÚ`àUâÛºåÛ!Ø áÚ ¡ Úlà'áUà'êWÚà'á!âhÛ!Ú Û¡àTá!â!àTסââvÚnyåìàTÛ0åìØ'áØ 0.0 0.0. 20.0. 40.0 Number of features. 60.0. 80.0. 0.0 0.0. 20.0. 40.0 Number of features. 60.0. 80.0. N#& " B+ DW E8E#^9e E )4H 6 Q%" p$#)+o" )=W 6 & 64a * 1X)4H 6 Q7" X9:)# m " B+ )="')=j 6 9+ !f" * ('m B+,Q " 810P "!$#&% 1(')!$#&%+* + 6K9:('8$*8E( ) -,/.0,_`+og 6<E" "'v<)4213#4 Q%" '8^9:#Q7#" -'"[ 5. 7698 CEDGF HI:BJ. :<;>=? @BA. ÑÒ ÓÑÔ.
(93) ? KyJXDÆNP=[`? IdP? FH;VJXF·FH;V? I`?MO[R[dFHMOYD=Nt[lMYZLDVM :VKyJLDGFR\VM¢²³? I`? D=K ??'FE ? ? DÆF`;V?I`? [`iV¢FH[@NL4 Ft LJ DV\¤s+®1U4®W]Vi=F Ft¾K JLD+k?>iVKU;+Y? [`[g=I`? K MY[l? §èqP O? [l[gVIl? K MO[`?MOD+FH;=?>@? JLD+NPINPi=I4?T=JL>@gVY?y©' :;V?K NP>@g]JXI`MO[`NPD¶NLFH;=? :]ZPiVIl?t§0A¤O? ëFT©JXDV\ȧ0A¦I`MOZP;GFT©[lFHIl? [l[`? [@FH;=?3P? Id¸[`MO>@MYYJLI·k? ;]Jy9MONPI@NLFH;V? JLOZPNPI`M¢FH;=>R[NPI"gNLMYDGFH[JLDV\I`NLFHJXFHMONPDV[ CED¨JLK'F ?3JLO[`N+NP=FHJLMYDtP? Il[`MO>RMOYJLIIl? [liVOF`[NPI±FH;=?NLF`;V? I Â-MYDV\=[fNL ?yJ!FHiVIl? [ { Ï w Ê zbwÊ { Ï wÊ { }{ } ( | Ê ~ wÊ { } ! Ë ( |¨| }v~ |{ } Ê Ï Ê ]| ~ Ê NÊ { }| : N+[`MO>iVYJXFH?RFH;V?RKyJX[`? ;=? I`? JLO>R? JL[`i=I`? >@? D-F`[3;]JyP?P? Il´\VM¢²³? I`? DGF¤§¨VirFÂ-DVNv D_©@DVNPMO[`? [ W ?+i=[`?NPI@?yJLKU;Æ>R? JL[`i=I`? >@? D-FFH;V? \VMYJLZPNPD]JX4K NvLJXI`MYJLDVK ?QNL±C`Cè½>R? JL[`i=I`? >@? D-F`[3 ;V? Il?¤?yJXKU;FH? Il> MY[>iV¢FHMOgVOMY? \Ä-ÆJLDµMYDV\=? gk? DV\V? DGF IHJLD=\VNP> [`JL>@gVY? iVDVM¢NPIl>R¢@\VMO[lF`I`MOVi=FH? \k? FE ? ? D XJXDV\+qLo°]NPIb FtWP ?4;]JyP?4iV[`? \F`;V? ? MYZP;GF`[ ;=.4¥\=? F ? Jh E N E N@ 6 ;V? Il? MY[FH;=?\VMO>@? DV[lMYNLD¤NLoF`;V?>RJLD=MONPO\§0ARNLI4gkNPMODGFH[fJLDV\QIlNLFUJ!FHMONPDV[ W_x@NPI IHJL>@?TSE]JL[l? \?yJXF`iVI`? [U©T :;=MY[ FHMO>@?LWLF`;V? Il?MO[ D=N[`MOZPDVM :]K JLDGFo\VM¢²³? I`? DVK ??'FE ? ? DFH;=?Il? YJXFHM¢P?JLK K iVIHJLK'"NL FtJXDV\ FtW Vi=FFH;V?'JLIl?RkNLF`;>iVKU;O? [l[gVIl? K MO[`?@FH;VJLD s1® Uf® CEDtF`;VMY[?'rgk? IlMY>@? DGF W ?NP=[`? IdP? \¸JIl? YJXFHM¢P? MYDVJLK K iVIHJLK'NLoJ¨JLK'FHNPI"qP FHN qrhCED+NXFH;V? I4?Trg? I`MO>R? DGFH[ W_ ?F`NrNP 4 @ BA ? E B I @ M¢FH; iVD=MONPIl> ?'FE ? ? D X±JLDV\qPWGJLD=\ FtÅJLDV\· Ft ? I`?>i=KU;O? [l[JXK K i=IHJXF`?LoCED·FH;=MY[bYJL[lFhK JL[`?XWPFH;V?K NvLJXI`MYJLDVK ? >RJXFHIlMYK ? [NLDR? JXFHiVIl? [\VN;VJvL?>@NPIl?f\VM¢²? I`? DGF lè[lMY ? [ mfJLDV\ FtÈg? IlNPIl>R[ Á¾F`N-q XPÁ¾?'F`F`? IhFH;]JLD Ft . . . . .
(94) cS
(95) . yx0w. -e ~
Documents relatifs
constat, unanime en Colombie, que la résolution des conflits par élimination de “l’opposant” est l’une des caractéristiques de la violence nationale. Première
Automatic test data generation, structural testing, constraint solving techniques, global constraints 1.. Structural testing techniques are widely used in unit or module testing
It is obvious that the steel showed the plastic strain memory effects at each test temperature, in other words, in spite of the hardness of the steel cyclic stress,
Les cités et leur territoire d'influence sont administrées par de puissantes familles, celles de l'aristocratie terrienne et marchande, qui tirent leur légitimité de
L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non, émanant des
In this paper, we have defined the steady-state control problem for MDP, and shown that this question is decidable for (ergodic) MDP in polynomial time, and for labeled MDP
Trois autres échantillons du pool CHAT étaient également gardés au Center for Disease Control et ont été inclus dans cette analyse (CHAT pool 13, CHAT type 1 Wy4B-5, CHAT 1FL)..
Un habitat de La Tène moyenne et finale à Berry-au-Bac au lieu-dit “ Le Chemin de la Pêcherie ” (Aisne).. Jérôme Dubouloz, Michel Plateaux,
