Dialectics and experimental biology

,

t

PI'S

'/$

1'K

0"

lit

Fa

·

·it·

n'

·m····

"',~<, ,<.;'

I .,

!

, ,I t

Ph.L.

OIl

C

'

,: ','. . ",:'

'a"

_{. . "}

'liP'

_{' . '}

'

f~'(l'n" t.'~' _.W;',(-.

IV

105

ll~

128

..

, ·1-· .~ "'.,

'*

1

1'111611

PART

l:xperlmontal b1ology

hila

suoh 1hor.·1, tlonvinolng

,'lat;ttl.0a'tona, aa

1ft ••

4101U. .' 'loulttae. aa4

iJl4usrtW1.

;\-ha' 'bo •• men

who ...

·.th

• .,.,

",1,1n'8"_t04

in

b101t;)Q

have

failed

"0

make a crl"te&l

afh"llyde

of

l i .

prlno1,pl ••• ·

-'Io'hiDg

1"

Mote

.":rt,k1!lS

1il

'I'h18dienoe

t11.an

~h.

O'ontl'afJ'

_ '

. .

en. tbe

b~1111(lnt

filetll. 1·:·1lll1tJ.

8ndoare

bestowed

tlpOA

Gb ••

r'.· ion

&ad

.,xpertJleat".

,&Btl

'h.~llmo,t

oom:ple".

negle.t ot

O~)·uttt'n

1n

r~tiJ~ud"O

the dst1n1.tton

and

U • •

01

the

."ono.~'.

1ft 'ant.

·of

wh10b

thfl ..

estllt8

041

.Xp~~·fI"d..

-(1)

It la,

l\.ft:t'h~l

••• , 'hie

Y$'ry

COUUtHu1

eu:b8'il'tltum

of

b1ol.oEa'

_tell

tb:roUl'h

~1rd_

11&8

laid

all

e:!halln1..

cla1.

to

our

lil081c~11,lY

enough.

ohl!~~'10ft~

of

the

ne-l'

tOJ'a1

of

faa" ...

.

rlaltam, suoh

a8

r.rn_.

pr~'l._,

1, '.oal

~)ogJ1tlYl_.

h .•

"·9

gl"en

IlOJt@

t11' :.

"to

'he:rlyillg .p:l.llcll)l ••

ot

exPel.'-:~l

. .

alal

blot • •

,baa

1boae

*0

01a1a

\0 pull_a

knoWler1 __

~ ~ ....

p~1J1&:rlrl1 fo~

1'. owa

sQ

.• ,

and

they

hay. indeed made

ill,.

" .•

,

••

" eontl'iDt1"'".ona.

"!'he

1~,~"&Jl

18

UIl4er

the

lapre· ••

ton

that

th

. . .

101118

ot

matt~:rl#:ill_

aate'he

only

Oft8a

t~t,YOtlr.d

by

oU% '

'~~,~-,' ".~~

,

~" v

'1,"

. '{~\i ~ ~~~.:.J"~--~. Vl~. ffH",' . . ~ £#~'};'1,.,'

l'

A f l t: . v ~![;}f --<" _.-.1.,'1:_ . ... l? (1tr ~111~~" , ("1" ,) 't~a

til",,!· ,~,:.~<'4 • • ' .. ,n~

wh,:l

I

8e" for

1,.

us.

e't~'«t11,aa 'i~,JtI.

the kind

of

krlr!fW'l

$(18

8

we

&011'.

111

bl010' '.

Yhflzte

i .

a

co'

of

p21

nr.;.lple

a

tll>OU

Wl11Gb ..

11 .o'dera

biologl.'.~.e.

.uGh

a...p:r1~y

ot

$:XIJ~rlello..

'he

ftYelf

p~oYl.loaal

ch,Ua81,er

of tiei'1111'i,()na

andot

i:t

01

'ltlrr-11Iatl"ua.

'.he need

'0 , •• ,

tl.{~a1n

&l'l!1

~g;(iln

pl'inclpl ••

whiob

ne'.t~1' t~',f$,rtd

to;,

'l~(~

til t1.ate

1;1"tl1h. In

oth.r

WO,J'dtJ,

f!xpfJrlmftntr.i

bl~)l:

1.

not ••

r~17

a qa ••

'

,tor

OOllolua1ona.

I't

mUll'

f(#tJVe:

8i,tlon

It.

Y4-zyprlnc1Plee.

llowf.~ve:r.

the

.. lI8dl, . . .

'I. lhe 0.11 'he

ttu1'. ot

li.t.'-

8Jl(l

'Ar(1

all the

getler'A11ea:'lon.

proy1f1S..cnal

1'.

tire of

a

dttf

ere:rlt

ord8J'.

the

1,.','8"

18

t&kelt

tzzoa a

btl

of prlntilpl •• whloh .e

call

'. !he

former

18

cb\).~n

twom

a

bodyot

p~lnolple.uJ'lYH.,'

by •.

xper1ment:lal

illY~8tlE~~,t1()n

and

pU,2e11hifJ1H:tTlcal

f~Q\1nd.

aa

~!'at'*,lW8fl"

ot

:p~a" ,f~J.c'.

which

wotlltl 'be plau.llJle fOJl

th,~

tlltwra,

'h

would

My.~tbol.a.

b.

Of~l, dltt.~e1:1t o~de.%

than

thoee

01

,t'h.$

mf:J'ttodolQ~1ca1

kind.

J~OJ' ",h.tf)~lrr81;;~l.t~

'0

ihe

Vf!l~y

bleAt

'''''l _ _ ~i~ "

'XI)~t~l_n~al 'b~o~oQJ

wb,ftre,(,8

ihe latter

00&1'

~)l'\

the

JlfAiYl!

!!.

2Jta>loI19:~!1 ~no'4._

• • •

('Ih •

•

L@t,us

.tAP 8fi

_h.'

'he.e m8ih{)dolog1c,

pZ'irlO1.pl.'.

ae

,.u..

1)0..

l'

follow

'hat

_he'flrf~

'0 "

exte:nded, ".

all

t1

e14. ot'knt7'lf1 • • •

'

It

'he

01010'

n

1.

to

k1.1011

jus"

what

have

some i,dea

on

"tli.

,p%r:)bl.(im.~>l

thflr

edge he

aQ<1111 ..

e. ia

'll.Yt'~*,y UGh~tY.l)G

o.A?

,.ol(t'no~t ~l:r

'1'

i$

melffl17

at

l'tl7'

~)t ~;i mo~e f~neral

scbeu.

'0

Whloh l '

1'1118

lomedetlnlta

relat1()D.

But

l ' 1.

(~81)Gc1all,1 th.o:~ltthc~llo b'101.o{~tm't "'\0

tth()Uld

kooW

'll&

Wl1ill'rf'J

of

t,he

kn,oW1ft(l~r!~~ h~, &Qr1l11J"~'. th.TOl!f~ _~d-tl "l . . . ~V"

the

:r~~{ltl,1.1'~ '~l

to"Z a

f~01"11'let

~

Who

uade~'alt

•• llhe

lnVt!!fff1

tJ'tf.t10tl

of

nl~l'tl%~1.1 ~pl18n.omt.tna

18

'ha'

he

.Etflery~

tor

1't1maf~lt

a

1

lo8rt1

of.~ndwh1oh

3rt,.,.

o.ft

>

11osophloal

dotlb'.

It

1S-11011 nf~08.8tlry.

hOWflYft'l',to

be

a

aotlpt!,,, ,

1t

1,8

OOOt' • •

~ay

to

o-@11ev'e in

'.o;1enoe,

'11.8.1;

18

to

e.,. 1n

de'e:tlt1.,n1 • • 1na.n.

abI0111",

Re08391lZ)' "~'la,'tlQ.

under ..

lying

the

~pll.n

...

na pltOper

to

'l1,Y1n!

be1 •••

llU) • •

11

~l.

to

all

o'b~;r

bei._;

but

l ' 1. neoes.a:ry

a~

"he

1I8J.i

.188

"0

be

'har'

1, fJoftylnoed

'hat ".

htl".

'his

%tlf:t'tion

(Hl1.y

in

a

.anner

mf) ••

O~

1 .•••

aJ)l)1'o%.l.atl~~.

anti

illat

tbe

'lleorl ••

whloh

1f~po._,.,ue

tar

fro.

7eprflHiGX:tt1ng

UD.Ql1anl&eable

'ru~th

••

then

W'$

oo·n.t.ruot

a

'Mrf~l

--IT

tn

oU.r

lfcleno$s.

theaol,e

'bi'l!

of .111oh . . are

ce:t'aln,

1*

"h.l~ t~11

tbelMt"1eorlo11

us,

abeclute1y

ap8.:kintt,t~~1_. ' f l t 1 li2e ()f.l!y p~~t:rtla.l

f:U\d.

prov1--aloQ,al

tltu1hm:,

Which

~~e

neO·f!I

3ary'

tor

119. tr~1

steps

onwl\lob

8;lmp17 the

aG'Wi1

eta'. of

Ola

E;D0W184p,

and

GOn_quen11v

they:

lat.'

lI.alfled w1'

lb..

,'owthotN1enoe,

aDd . .

• \lCtb

mop of'

••

e,.

,be:

.Qlen._

~ltft

1 •••

adY'WlGe4

1n

'hell'

8:"1"t10-.

1

₍₁₎

,'.~

tllO

Yo:rk

. f

Bei"nard.

_{t , .}

emlne.'

O.'holl0 . .

18'nt181

LOllia

i'a.'eu~

had ' , .

h ,:, •• , . .

t:ra:aloa. He

oon.l4ere,

t,

th..o." 111

nattnato·oapl.'.,

&a4

profouM

w07k ."

••

!ttl"en

OD

t11:.

prlno1pl ••

ote:X)Mrl ••

nta'tou.

Jle

pJle41.'o4

;'hat

"as.

Ute1188

In

the ••

1.'.'1,tl.

t'leld

1fou14

be.

ve",

• • •

' .. '(1) . . . .

Oa'b01;10

DtolO

:t ••

l1 ••

ihe 111))118 ....

'1 . . . of

.~1la1'4'.

Ia'b'Ottuetl . .

,

Oou1d

b. • •

,l(ten,d

this ,.tllod

teall

Ital48'

t,t

Dot,

.1'

no"noee he l"ea11n

the

OOll.l

q ...

ot 'he, ..

'~al1.a"io.

ot

t:he hYllQ'thot;1-..4eduot'tYe

"'bodT noe.

he

lmoW.U-'D

h1e

,.ot.'noe

ft,'_

in

w1th

_he

old., phll!oao:pllY

~0l-8Q4.4

. ' a t l l t " f

'Is Df)ttheloalo

.t

'ke ..

1ea'1

in , n .

Goanla', wt'h Wha$ 18 'odq oall.

'waill

t:loDal

1,; , . ,

The

O'tt1hol'10

_ie10s1e, 11aa

,aQo1he ..

prrOblaq

in

tindi.

_'OM

to ana ...

'

the"

~u

•• ;'lon.

o~'11.'

tfha'

a118weJ'8

-,

w&u14 he

:r.eoe,.,.trom

the tea.har of

$0)'01&.-10

!>hl1oaophrf

Is the

lal'er

au.tttalettll,

dqua111wd

wtththe . . . .

4,

of

ex'ptlrlil,8n'al b1010?

lou14

heao'

t.~

the

mo.'

ParS

C~_

"hi. aethod

la

an

att,.pt ••

his

."._;1Gh . .

e.8

'0

be

(1)

a.

88,. • •

4,

Int;:roclu,

,Ion

11

"I"

'da1&

d,.ol.e

~

i

:r

~n_t.l.,(:8alll'S'.

e"

:t11,a).

i~'.lr11J,;

ItJ.6;,

p.6).

c.

B.~dt

Int7Gduotlon

t1iQ ••

(llel,a.graY.)

,P,a:rla,

1:137;

,.t

~

t""

,':t, , ' . . ' ' , 1.;"." 'kif ~" . . '1' , U I \ f

tr;£J~tn.d

in

~'htlo~,oJ)hy, hiiY~

"'

'OWll

'he

,fiJl<~ftte.r

11 ..•

'1$

on

1'1\0

•.

a'erl~11

\0

h.u1~~.'(1

1n

i~tl'$rm.1nlns

tbtt

I1trtu.:r~l

of

thet::

k·ne ...

'1"· "'Q" a

r

~10ll

•.

~1

"ttlJ1fllrlf!str1c'

the, 'e%m 'knowle4ge' to things

0'. ,,4' <iii. ·~'h··1'~~·~~ ~~~~~·a1· ,t~~ ·'~4~$-··,?t.1"~·. ",,~"'l<!.rlllW.t'!i ~'~4A ~"~l ~,."" ;t~,~ (". (&iWkC~;i$ g.'!'';;¥;;;' "'~Ji;. U

t

V Q'!.l'l';l! A K;iII ~ {,'j v1<it ~ ,ilJI~ ... ~11

kno

adiM

of

Y~lryi

,de

e, 's

of

u:nQeTta1'o_y.

tbi.

t. anA of

tho

OGa1lOli

am

1;Ui11olot speech

1!~1

1;0

lOll DO

oae.

1.

8nt1t184 '0

410'*1'.,

and

an

a.utllor

O~

081.1

.',a'e1ch

tl_ge

1\8

has

hi.$~,[~lt 4)ho9~n

'0

tnll .... If

t

know • •

e~ln.

'''0

be

oerttrtln

ot·,

the

"erm

18

of

11"1.

ll$e ",0

'bose lIbo

w'l.1Ib

'0

b8

un,iog-11.'10.

!

therefore

et(~r

thd fto·Mer

~\eK~J1i1l{~;

And

. , 01ll1U8

11111

~.oo

1"

uAOrtrta1n

knowledge.

,

It will

ll;}tO$

n(foo.s~;~%1 IG~

U.

'0

fo.+mulail.

a.

gener~

d~tl.1

'Ion,

of

know'le.

()as-

p:rooedlue

will

De

10

SpfJ,:Gttr

a pa:rtlot4al'

oolle.tlon of

:Mor4

or

1., ••

1I'1dely

i:::!~4 .~::,.ld

of

tl.

~~::It lrl~e

an

8xpifI'.~

"'01r'k

a

dltttc~

'ty

whlC'ltv11,l

onl1

lrlOr$l-i~J ;;:~.$

he

re!l~Q.a

on.

Ttlt..

1M

If

0

not

.irt:?ly

·Qec:"ulr.;~} !!d~11 '\~'Oll do~}.

not

~1»~xte W.ll~,lt 1\-6

means

by

1.:'ht1o

acl,b:~r

, but

mo=ce

:pr~lcl $~17~:e.:g;~ IIfi

he

it~~jl

10.,1

tlyptt".

ft~tdB

_a

1:;ueat1Ql1

UlJOtl

0:le1:\ 1fill

'~1,.n.d

$\iC

V'0Jr1'

mo;rnlJ1ng 4114

1:ruth

011\1,

t·~i,X" roaob11~

Qonclu_l\J't\,$.·.

J;¥.'

.i7.~"1

dI't

w111

n(l~

bene<teeeatty for

Uti

"0'

for~iitJ;lia.tH' ,~

5_r1 ... ,

d. •.

t1ni't1(,n

oi~'

kao ...

IE'!:

••.• S1.1t

it

,~

aze

lett· in

Qo!1f\lslat1

ttfbotli

1\"1t~' lL.ilr/.l@,d~

lajh~\"'.

Gall . .

};e

eltJu

a~boul

$olttn:"t!lck:l:)'\tledie1

fh,3

&Yotclanoe

.1' ....

,1\

'\d~ma,Qsl l~$ue.

lea

•••

lBa

J'~it~~l"

in

*u'l')en~,

.nd

If'

&11

k'~l." '~

116ft

01

the

"J"

;hfJ

analy._

in

'hi.

Wtl:-k.

we

wou14

oonaide-fthis 1t)!18!'al1Q,ealis"

,philosophy ' ••

11,,:~ounded.

IU:-

.8

l '

nanda,

h1e

OOtlll"1l1oD

1.

a

"1.'1118

ho,.'.

!'h.Y91oal

801.f

. . .

,,

he

f!4H,o'r1'bG8

1'\t8

41 .. 1 ••

'14.~.,

n1al«t<otlc'.

aa

't!t(f

<"

tlD • •

'na84

l '

1 • •

tl'J)$

of

kllowled"e

$088

tir(f!n~r,~111mr.:tt1on

would

&miND'

.0

1daal1<8& aad

ul,l.at_l,

to

d.1.aleo"loal

J.la:t$~·l&l!_1

'\t.,~~. .~~ f,l:e~.~fA"l' ~ _{V~ff fI:t*w ~··~U~~ ft,.~iijj'f' ~ ~,,-.~}

.,'

.1~1:"!1 Oil~'1 ... ~l. _{-9. -4.':. 4 ilt7Jt-~ £}

-

-~~4.1.· ~A:~~~4 .. ~ .~~ ~. ''\~.M .~.< _{q .. ~~3'~-.. u~ t:~~Ii'~il~'A ..t: •• ; VJJ.~,;'· .,·JKI ,,~!:."!,,~"£: _SI· ,.'}

thJJnat~

of},)

8lealsoi.,lloe.

we

eo in

QO.~il·8t.i

dlaapefrmeut

allout

the

,~·:tr101pl

••

h.

ahou14 lnvo

'0

~ran.'

hi.

pMral1aatlon.

on

"be .'11$1: hlxnd. "e

.~JlU·.t'

hlaall&lys18

'0

81 'u.a't$ -hi. type

of

kao1ll

in

Ota

tJ&.Mral...

~.

_aD.

40..

muohwt

'h

a\l4e.

.

rD~.~d

••

aa.aly·sia

of

"he

e,e;r1llenitllutho4

1n

b1010gy.

t.),~'t.. ... a f t .... ' .;84 .... ' • . ' ·.'k ... · .. : .... 1 . _.... k .•.

_.'{;1t.'

\ ...

~.,~

.. ,

f t ..;,.·~b41A .Alc ... \<tW ~.,. nA ~ ~.... • rl\t ...

,A.

'~U'i"~·~.~' .:~sl • U .. . ~~ 'Uv f#~~."';' ~$. ll', 4·,.v~Vlij:l.f:.y ~lj U W:I~I'q._ Ii&.~ ~

1·11

C

r

U161 .• ,.

but _

m&1j.llo.~lt8

so-

li1f~r\orloal

tao'..

The

tlf'd

1.

tbe

abtoJl'ptl.on

of

}:)h11.8'.

by

of

flatat!

'by ••

taph,..t •••

~~:e

u-.

_no'

JI.re:17refe7~tq

_••

lif)

f

and

~h1s"hola.'1.

tollow.s-a,

but

to

.~ller

aohol ..

_'l ••

It1Ol\a,s

Fo_oa.

Va .•

qUes.

Sua1*8:s.

whose.tltlcD.of chattoe,

.()y.ement,

and

tlMl0·;!\l~

••

matle

phllo-.

"ophy

of Da'ure

aupe-rf1u.ous

~l.a d1.tltla~

mot_e.'

t()pl\110fJo!~ ()ti'li~'U!t~, aoool"'di~)

10

\flfi~1ah'l~fl

eJ:':j'>ilrl11l8ntal

80i.,IID(1 • •

u .

_'an, .:I'I8n&1.O'l1o,I

.~1:11lQ

••

phy

01

i1.!:ltl,lrtli

ll*or

aa

{<'f~' . A ' au"

o· , ..

~:,._.~" v _ . - . • . ' .'C ~::i . < : , ' , _ " . " , ' "

(2)

:ft.

noma.lI,,l4

P:rl-..

x.t~

}'byld.04'J1'Wl1

AI'111.,

L1b.

I,

~~'l

. .

l)~l~o

'1dt!t.1Jtt

Y.(lxl~1~1lii,)!r(\~1

'5

(~Ji!l;lim~~ !;l~'o~m.1UJ11

so"

2

~

,;

, t1$.1~ 11lqUttt1t~ abl~'tr _~ . • >-;" F~. ::'. ".'. *¥ _', .. ~ .'.~.,-.- lr~.' .':-.' . . . . _.;

.

il:' '"A?

lone.

" ! f . r . .if- ~~.undo oon(lld.~r(lt1on8J1 • . • ' . . • • . . • ".", : . . , ... ~~~. " -." _ .

;; ~el

t

~ nl.~~u%tl~

JIll»"

*:l,fl,1atl~

.tI.uMllm

qU!l1>J.quaa

"0110 r~;~

'il,

()n~.J.

fit

V~~ ~~,

l)¥,).ll

e{f~

t

1.

Onettl i,-·;·t,d. ~lQ·rJ;jll!:l, ~e<1

1n.

" ll;ttrllll.

T,er'10

ot.1n31<le:t;;tt1crn{i;U

.fnolt

~i.pl'11ct.m(1O

OfltlliahJMIOfk{l .•

1l:~ff\\l a$ fJjffJO

18 •

aJ~ l~ii"ll W:~£, ~~

t

J~JJ 1:1 ~!alrWlt

dlfi{~n~l1lSJ\do

(lUi

d .11

's'm'l . lmi oat,

~l\l.s:gt.ol.1.

i~rl

••

i.~~i' oorutldi.r1~t\10

.on'i . .

~t

....

in

11~:.to

&le

a'nitla.

Te~tla

.,1*0

Qonatdera'lo

oontl.8'u 1n

11.b2'1. quo.

, .. ,. . 4 ", . ~. 41;. /~ .~ .~ ... "'. ...

l'

'l. . ' "'~ ~ <;"'fI1!<' ... ~" . , . '<,Llill'si ,~ ,.' ;~,. .

••

;rr~ &):. v tlf~ i;~nl.aJ.,

Qua

e " 4f' A~Jltr~ ~ . . . . ~.a_¥--.La "1.~ro·

oO'''tl14e:rf'l'ta

oontt.'*wln. liotJts,

quo. ecrl'bl"

de

quittueda.\I,

\l.\I~~.· p.~'in$tlt oOf!¥{tWiii'.·~l:t.

T¥.,l

q4(1

otmia

ard

ta,

".1

tld gl~a ~~.n·ua

.or\w,

".1

.tt~.

ad

OtIft.la

yty~ntla.:4

(1)

!he lIohola,tl0. then.

hfiYi!

tor'

._t\lrlea.

been

It.1f1,n~

ttl

A, u.lli: ••

:rM ••

~ted

1'rom

the

.ouorettoft

.tftUlt".~

•.

~1'

neD

we

d,,, hn1feweh a

oonoeptton

at

phi,l ••

ophy

of

n~,'tlH.

It 1.

be.m:~

.fI

l\t;\ve a

fal ••

no'loa

of

&b.tr~'loft

\)0_

1 •

• •

ta"l1'l

... an,d,.

1'l1

'!)bl1o~O'phy

.t

1Ut"'lr~. ,~le'fte1.1fln 1(1~,~:u,1_.

~.- iit!l. -. . '\," ... ~ .. ;,-. . • • . • · . • '\~t·

'-,

.. ,;.

#~ .. -~1tl.~;·'\""'·rJJ'~l·'.~ ~~:I!" T'\..'

l'

1···. A~A""''' a 4t !,~"jt,.' '-":t*.""A".. 1'.

d

~m ~ _~:tIjJ_ it A. ,'*'~ .~~ ~ ~~~f'{ f;U_V" "t{tt:,i~"lai';i;r~' . ""'QJ ~~.~1!:1l. ,£t.fl>J~.i + . . ~ ~..,}i-Jl'JI

.#."

~.I,~

"'lj5\

~ ,,~~

".

g

:really'

the

If)

olll

outo . . .

()f

thls

p~oee

•• , .era

.OllO:r~t'l.on

1.

d.~lY.4

lrO);1)

10' .

tlfil

~1})~1ft:ra~1ol1

l¥f

Mtt£:l8.a

01

an itb(ltrA~o'C

41&1.0-tl0,.1

VlfWiImi&D_'i.

'10 GO'118,ide%pl1.11o.ophy

at

ll4St"u:re .11.;1 tl

QrJJlch of

••

1tk~

.

_1.10...an4$y~tn

1ft

p~J,lo't1.c~

''0

'~~H;~oh. 11t~"t\pbl~1os

\l$tore

vl'tiloeol)hy

of

Wllllr:e 11

11\

t~lO~ _~11d<ettli~J"10 proO~4"

:low

1t l-s

"%'U.

'hat

80me

authora

ll~lV8

maintained the

ti9ft " ' "

. .

n J)h11oaoJJ

of

t l a · .

and

tlffti!l;)hyal0$,

l)ut

of 'lhe

ft)ftI8J'

they

h~~ye

1<>

.'al·11.'

~iel'.lY

$lte·

fir.t

part

llU1i.de

111)

of

gene-Jfallti~.

011

th8 }l:t.inol"o::t

mi!)~btl.

'bol •

~a"

1.

t:re'll,te4

1n

l100k

II

of

thtl

i?byet ••

i .•

pa.rally

oYt,rlooke4,. ruv.l81y

\h., antlly.i.

10

A8

to.

Bo()k Il

t

of

i\r1,~to'tl~'. l~llY$lolt "l\+~$~t S~iJtt~!.'

AU.'t'lors

~"*.t~.' '.if

'h

.... · ..

>F',"l.,.,.A

....

···,;!l,· 11,'::'.r .. ::.~.~ •. ··.

d,

... ··

·it., ~, .•.. I: ... ~ .... , .. i.U'*. A.-1ft . . fk.~ ..a

·l

l

t··,

t ..

~'4'''' '1","*·i'''' 'f~l" ~~W' ('\ ,?f":MrA* 4l A,'!A .

,;·",v V r 't#-~v ~'f;,~.a ~~ -~ .... ~"'J 'QI',J" "U:'';:~ ~..1..4 .' V:~"'~. ~ V'. " ... ~fi,il'" ,?i;.;;f <,tt .. ,# ~;W"')\' ~ " ,"~-l'"

Logic

to 'be ll-rtorand

I~otJt$Y1Gr ~AtM11tlc.,.

11\8

111;.)()rtant

t!eel1on

of 'be

PtJrlh.Tia~"l.,

on natle

lit-tid Y~i;r»l~u'a

beetl

rat}lu~r

thoroughly

na , . • •

'.4.

~"'. Dlal~1.'lQ8

prope!'

fit

ihe toP108,9..d

'h.treal1 ••

OD.

;!ot'bl ." h".e been

·r.4u_4

\0

a

fe"

fle .

191'b1.

l:l.n~'

in

moat

t~~xt-b.ok~.

Ie

'* '-

any

Wt)l::uSe",

'hen.

tb·at.

we

]ltlV~ .t~:\11ed

10 . .

~ th;l~

the. hY'1)o'h.,too-.dtt4\lo·'lve

laetbott

a:Jr!~)lt.d

in.

faod.r-T.llutlibomatlos

rmd. 1 n 'he eXllttrtaefttul&el,

en

G..

111

Jtt~ ~tll !/ .

dt·al

&G"I

1 ofll ;

J:\ru'~

.11a't

r

Tll~r.

ls

a

oOlmeQtlotlbtt·t'ft~n

t'be

M:~le.t _~

of

conG,.,~t1on 111

,

of

1 ...

'0.

:~"1'

l'

1s

lt8we

ap'flro3ch

mt<.'.u~~ll ~b~:11lSl.

i.n

"11at

thay

h8Y'~~'

trOt§!

ftlatt~r.

thai our

d.1.oottttJeO{t'flOlIftSQI

f.l80Gltll")'

laor.

~)Jl.d mo~e

dlal".'ical.

La'

tI,.

OClI181d,.2'

a

oonor~'. o·~\

••

t

'tiUi'

ot

defitil tton

111 .pllil~).oph7

of

;i:~",t\ae.

n

18

aot

lI{t,\tar

~(':l*i,d,a;r(Jfl

itt

1"~; lr~J~~if"~l~~ll£Miti{l/J 'bu..~ x,ltjJ(~:f

. l

•••

fl~.f (lr cr%g;i~i

••

d,

vlPJ,t"crl

~Ji

11

tJlaftl:

[rem

tllt!'

~l~;<rt

-eil

tl(~A

"J\}",ltlltl

3*'

;~JtQ·'u.

llJ,

u's

O(j~'~<J~t~ '~)h:".t,u1 QI~ r1:~<rr(tct

"' :011

&\4P;>08't

tiiJllfl lr~ a~Jt)~O~l(.n:q

.$('._

W

lJ

~*

c

....

l.·'llC·

..•

'~""-.' ~.. .. ' .. «, -. - . . " . . ... ~

the

.~,'bx)tJology

of

e~'l)i};l*l.U!n".fll

"ienoe

do,e" lr<",oognlae

a

t\ltl4~UI~n'r:\.1

prlncl£)le

U,tillally

~l • •

oclated

with

}(fl.n_,

A

llXtSltJ

•

hayf'~ tOUJ7lO

''bJl,Y./he:e

sot.en ••

'ha<I p:t()~1:,!,6.i~etl

ih(t

t:;"rl'hBttt

_t 'h~

ml

1\&1 b,ut

r£;'tt::;~lne,t.t .t'rOttt tW.tl1%tiJ th~,t

wh1db

tbJt

ttlln€l

h~i.6 ~:)U,

'it 'i"'~" fll ~ ,5'lil ~ 1'.," __ ~i~ ,I'. (

"t)'

~,~;j\.~~ (;,J..';~Jliltl~ ,,, , ""J

001lll8111,1ft&

on

t:h8

J:w.tl~)t~~Tior'

A11fuytlca

of

ilr1~lto\'le (1:~)

ThOll..

."0..

'he

41ttere110$

D*,iwean

~i{;!"alll\1.'l...

tOtP-C't

and

·3cl.!~dta4

\flaen

ed

'!

!l11a:tfttlo1l8

d,1&l

~otlca

••

t

de

ct'lftlmn1oU8

~t

10:0&

ot

~,)htloBoph,la.

p1"1l1a •.

l}h11oflOl)hla

l'f"imaen18

s;~J'(18

QJ.")tns!unlw.,

quia

81us

o011.altlflrntl0

~;~t

.'1rol),

l!)$,aarf:'.

oomr2Ullea,

_1110et

ciron,

Ol!llia

f,;~flln

%fl'W'81lnt

'tl~bf~tnt:~t:~t:)titir1 r~;~'tto,

(1)

i\.1i!&i1'f\i~t()n,.

fb.el.";ihtlosopl17

of

thG,)h:y~to~:~l

1:)0181\088.

''';'f

y-

l;f:t

1

d ""'~

-1-

~o

r~ _ -.. --.;)

t ; .

,(~;~,~, ~;, 7 ~

(2) I - lngton,

all.cit ••

P.

(3)

h:dd1Jl':C

11,

.

Me,

Ir1118

}In.'',

{''f~!vl1H\t It)l~t,,

1).201.'

(~)

St.

'Tb,,,)fI&8,In

Po

'51 ,

A~.

ute.

t

Lin. I,

le..

20.

15

logl_iUl'~~Lt

.s'tde

()P,~~'~11c.nlfbtl)\J r~:'.>t1(\n.1.,

1

0110&

~'1.~

.71"

(itt

ht

11,

qll~~,~ Ctl~m>.Jntl,

1

t:t

$.lWl" o~·:'!ni ....

s, tdea'

tIft

i~,'(Jrltl ()rl~,

bUS

:fflti()i:li~, qU~1G

.ftd

Q}1l11flWl

~.

se

l\~~t)t~!n'.

NOll

~~~'~~I1~ i~.t;(~., q,llOd lOt·~1cl.l

(.1

t ·de

t~~~uli. r*~·bui1 OOltltiUn1bu9,

s!Qu\

4e eu,1)ieo'1a.

<ion-- .

$1.

d

..•.

~~'

.. _

..

e.

1~1.1c~1~~!.~. s.~ .~!ut .if~bl.0'11~.-. .YllOJ~·l_uml

emllf,olr.J)"tlc}lltlll,

iW~lQt~1,o~~,ttu;mJ tl~lt

allquid

hu1tl&~od

•

l-?aJfl

aut(j~l l()glca~lQua4!t

Mf.*%o11strrtttYa

eli,

eta1

oiroa

oom,m·un...l

,$11ttOtles

"t~1tilfiiiturdoc.ndo·

taaell,

uattl

dJa!l~)n,"r~~h'i.l~. eGteJltl~\e

non est

in

l)r'oo,.d.ndo ex

hi.

cOf~~lmibu;! ·1flt~~T'rtl{)1:1lb\lB

,11d

,Hk,11qald

oa'telldand,\l.

rllt

r$.~bu

••

q.\1~\. ~UJ'l'

flubiaota

altUlm 801entlsJ'Uli.

:~.d 'l\~). d1J\1~Q'1ct;t

ftlDli,

Quia

.xoer~u.ni

1)U8

l;nt'{l~ftl.'

1

(In:i ttllt

proo_di

t

.t-\'t

gu.e.ndo

..

dtal.,tlol1.

~~4

oa

(luae

,.llnt

,"11arut1

:;;~c1,:Grll1tlr

. . .

• 1Ye- 8irl',

p~

.

a .

"t~.oil:~a-. ~l:,xl

••

t~

..

tl!n

ad

GOmfmBia·.

!.Jlout

ar

,Gtrt,Q,tu:t

qllododlum

e~t

in

Goao~1,i

••

1.\)111J

iJl q\1ifl: .tI~

[,mer"

ti'X

nno

qtlod

eon.-"r

m\;rl

a

SUD:'

8170¥i

idem.

l~~.t

ergo

dift,19:at1ca

de

(IOw.lltl111 bug

nrff).

fjt~)

l:llm

flui

ap<i" rtr·fl.o\

~,'

in

,t

*~n

t

1.

one ...

com:tffUfte.

l"iit1on,1t1!

(~uode;," COt~UmlM

\oi1 logloeA'

i

•• d

etl:~.

quta

e1,:r";(l

·eom:rtttlnl,&

:r~~rla ~~i,r'~.HfntdtU7.

{lua,., .

tie

I!tU'\eli tUll~~l'la&r

'0·tl't'ittrt

Giro'a

~~f,'~'ii\!:t~4~. _fitc~~"~. f~,!".~·~~,~.,~~~,A fJ:~t~'U.tti.f.iIr.~~ t\j~'''i'W n1-o···.~

~~.F·:!i:/'d,hiUQ~ oIii,\ .fr'"\.~~~t .. iJ.,'f!~~ ¥-¥;iIt. "{/, ~~#U1'Jo-,JIi, 6liM~1I",'ii·U. '/if '-;I f.H •• !t". ~ ", ~,~

j,)l'il'lCipi{\

COi~i;:'~U11ial

{l'llll Yilr11?tG

J!1"1nOitltOlftUl

ooremaiUtl eSl

man1Xtt.1tllft%

Q()plt1oJlr).

\¥f~rt1l1no:nm

OO!ltntlll1U.t

'It

en'll. {',

ltOfl

ert'la,t(~tlul

fl"

1)#'l1"t18.,.

e"

8

ill

l11ua.-ODvlo'utJly to

an'loill~ltf' r~$~lli

t",

lUl,f! tf) ~10Y~ troT't1 r~Hr'n'~J-l

OOJlstruct.

ttl

'h1l1gl.

A.~lfi

til

thi~ r~!¥.1)~.'m.a18.0tl

••

(tU·tel's

froftl

t)o'th

ite· ...

'.1.8 and

:oellQll.'~&'1.Ye l~

.

a.In "he

tll'nIn,trotitt011on

to 'he

Ort'lq\18 of

Pta.

it.aeon, xant ...

'\0 ld8:fltlty·M8ta.:ph181oflwl"h

ni,al~Q~io..

_{If . . .}

n

_{were "he}

O?::l, • • • fUld 81ru~8r

_h,e

OCH101tlsi<)na of

lie"l~Jhy.l

• • •

anno'

b ..

"i;,:rlflett

in,

an

6%l)t'~}r_lltftl

lla.nne:r.

hieta.--dial . .

"10 ••

OVf~rloJ)1t'lns

the

t~lO' .~hat

• Ime _ _

4

on

fire'

1rrteil1i

t

ltUJ,

Vi

th-out.

.10ll "he

tQIm~r ~;~ ltOflfitlll •••

and

h

f

_l111r!{1

_friftll

the

~rld

1n.t.f!ntlo11M

'h~ 1f'tI!\t • •

ot

,11::r8..

heaf~,l.

Q·oniu.._

l~;OI·l.

with

T

KW1'

13~":.

that 1f

,ul."otl.·.

lAPO

lla.1-. .

alMd.

ltMhtl,ftt~~dJ

1...

1.

\)i\WI:au..

'h..intl.

t. tbe:reln

tU\oond1

"10ne4

an4

.Ati71''bt~1~~lt''iGi' ~md

'

.~to·. t~~

",",0

1YIlft.

o.f

'heo.ret1cu

k'

.. ,

wh10b

"1'd."~:rr~l~.t.!J1

,DI1II&

,'bels-

o1oj.o"

'h~'x

fir_'

1,11

a.n ••

tlrftly'

Ptl!r'~ ,t~1:t.lilon" tblr~'

second

~~:}"t

le~t

1Jl .

:r1

an.d to 'h41.

~x'*nt

tb:A'

tb.'

otbt!r

sou.rces

of

kno'~?l~J

,'h.&D'lb,tt:tftt\80n,

pe~ml'

l '

"0

do

tJO •

•

a..h.-m~tl0.tftJ~~

'be

f,lo",.'.tl(:)'~

,t

• • • •

1011.

'he

hUII,it/Ul "~'·~i.son O~l.tl r~:ic:&'llfht~Ul t'ol10,·.~~d

l,n 'he

c~an7

of

'h~1t (1~~kJlt

,"

ilUre.

w~,

.,f

,:;~Q18'AeG.

au.

OM

e d ,

flO'

It.tl

1llat l '

.f~.jus't ~l.

oasl' tor

J.tf;1th..-IIAl1.·.

as

,to.

Leo'

'elrlft1o.l1

the

reaSOft

kHl. '0

~litend

onl7

'0.

1'1111.,

t·~

flad.

ow ",'ex-"

'0

open ttlr i.self

'h~. ·~td

","

~

"

1

a~~,l

...

et,

r~'h~r, ~ba'

fAa'l:lttaa'l ••

waa ,

1

1'.

wq!or

.11

101\1

\1 . .

, ••

peo1,a.l~1

wlth

•

tan ••

fUld'h~'

tbls

ohJt~l\~,:~e

Wt:.\8

,1\.

ett_

,.fa

r~

. .

l11'SG1\ . , .

1,0>

0 ••

JIaft

fllOlla, * 0

eouoelY84

'h.

hap

idea

'R

'ft&l

3;£t.

whloh

'l\eJ-ewtla (

no

10

",,~

,

J1.,~8Ott to~

)).81ag

: . 1 _

&,8

'e

'he

Sift

-.eAto toll •• ,.

~lu'ld.o .'h~IHlrtatn ~ay

01 flClf.!lUM

watt

0"a-4

'~~~.4

f07.&11

\111 ••

aDd

'f . .

lntliU.'.

"

,daa~... '~. hl.'~,

of

'b~..

111'.11e.aa1 .,9YQ111,10" .

• , 1'%'''.'

48a1

1M7..1.,fJo~t~$:ftt

,hall

'he

41800Y$1'1

of _ .

r _ .

~oW1!1

(J.p.

of

,'Od Hepe. ..

'he 11t.'017

of

thl.

a&ll

80

h~d ~:be,'4 fO~'llae

'0

41aooY'e:r

'lltt

rou'."...

~

haY.

Dot...

40Wft 10 U' in,

'.'tail.

..y~;~%

..

Ml ••

a.

.e

trf

l

\d1.";i,on

1.h:ate

mt.

_{1,&81"'1\1, ••}

aAlllnc

a'

ihe'_e

, _ "b.

, ; ,

8CoY~rQ

of

the

tIOtlt

eSav;18

el

••

ent. of

ute

4e.ou.tJil!\.''l0l1.

Whlch,

tollo ... 1t1i1

:~~:;~

p::;:;.:rm~~;:e

no:'

.:!~t,.; :~

.'.r ••

'.4

ill

'he fir, ._,

o,t the __ ,

'n.4fWl1

d1eooyel'f)4t

was title to

";pal'

e'd:ri.,e"

tmPO:rt'fll\' ',.

tM

~a'h..

,

•. a:'"ola1l.,

~lld

. •

aft

.~t1ye4 fQ!,

that

re,fi,lIoa

traa

0011,,10&.

ftstl.ra"" one

eo

4S1lonet.rated

"hI 1.·0081 ••

t.rlaag\e,

(Wb€)

11&:1

,~.,or

80me

~'b.l'

:p8lrtlOD.

)tltJ'Uok

a gHat

11

,I,

tor

11"

tOlm,d,'h:l~

1\

.~l.

llcrt

"o

•• eary

to

attach

on ••

!,lt1;o . .

,

be ... lna

tlgurf~t

.r

eyen

'0

(my

T

'",.,, '; "',

tl~.~.~~. \t~Ofi,""

th,l ,"

,~~~~',:tott\i

ot

.t'91~:'loe.

anIJlP

i,;,TOpt.

f~10

foSt an

5~nyc.n'tal(1s.

tl)

ell.uly

ih.1'

prfloe,t'~uye

tall.

ta;!lrifJrth.

b.~{)j,~d,:i ni;~

of

w'lin:'

it.'rl

,,\o'l~Ga;ll

II

d,1a,l!z~~c'1.o~J.

'Hllt 11\

tb~ l~:10't't.~r c(~rUl~~ltifH1"

knoW1ttdp

~>u:'%u1rt!d 'ltlfOU!:~h '<bt"~,rjlic~ltlo:n

otd.1ttlftct1cl

:r~at~tttl

"t't',; ..

J~ ~ ~ ~ 'f!' l' ~l'''1ee'd "

.

, ' ,

.,v", "', , . " ,~ • '

flfld111t$

firs.'

'p:r1n.cl,pl0.

A

!1:f::H,th.1AUI1

$

1

t~ k~o4,

not,

'b,c{:~tlle

the

m1nd

_J

)()fJ,1

"_1",

tif.ut

!t~ltll*'~ bt~Ctl.tl;.l~:!

it

tftny

brtt;~:lt~~d

'by

f:txpaT1011C~.

0'1'

'oeO'?:iuse

~Xpt~!ti.tlOQO\'lnt1~. i'.~rbe

4 Bi\m

of

;:\rl~110'ttll.an

d.i.~lfJ"'iG.

1.

th()~;ifortl

'the

V{~ry' .Qn'~nry

'If

l'an," ••

of tIle

~:<itl;J~riM}lttlrkl ;~Joli!~n.O$4

ahow.

thel~

'0'

bit

d.1j,~1~,1,:~Q'lQ!~1

in

'11s

,~,ri.z!t:ot.l1~\ .~ruJ

••

T~'i,'baJ"'ban 111

'he

I(an'l,&t1.

J~8y~7th.l

••••

'~Ht .tlb~t{\itl,O~t (J~' 1¥~8.i:l'·

t

ap1!~o.'lt10

poei'loft.,

hr~

.•

been maintained.

'by

ooat~~hit'UlOruY' n~utho:r9

l)·o"h

idatl1ls".

and

( ''II;; )

l'

-l'll;f:}

.~ t)U

,t

i 1>1 ,(a'f;

,t 1 tude

l~)~11

c h

:6 ~'l

t

f~,rt Hllti'l

h ::';

)()-tbfhl4Jli

o'n

th~~ otl1(~r 'bXl ~d, 'lJlt!

etln

t~:5.,k. I

t:ct,Qt'

,

,$i~rly,;}otl~,ctl C~", ,::~!~~'~

'pc

:J~:lt;'ly ~lll.r~'n,l.

lllf.;:11'\,$

nJl

ln~611¥~o',u.al 1'\',; Vtc) l,

t

{1.~~:~:~,t l'ltJ.t J!H~rt~ ~1:1 VI; '!'~,~"it; .t'~.

It

\'''';',Jt!I',. "i>'~,i"th~"'~';'" n"""'1"'~"Jl. d'~~"f '4i *'" :m.""li"("t'~ ";1,."'"<I"lf'1;fi';W;t~ "~'i",';l '''l,.,~~

",,!J,;t,.;;,,_ ~~i}''w~,i~~:;\ ¥'~" '}i.t ~~ ~i;)1,"""" ,~:i.i#i(;;;",k-" 1" "i":~i·.4l-1,>ij.; .. ;';~'l:''''i ~;, t t.:;Ln,J,\ ~ ~( .... ",,,'

1)£11"""1~,'1'lr tr.~;!>d

1t·

~l&lf .fr~)l~

,1,\e

OP'l:t:re$a,iOl"l

of:

l-,",~'t.!~,~~ w. _{~--:.>f'Y(' . . .-.p ~} 1',',. _1~"",Y. :if~"... 'f'~, {*~lf~~~ ~ ~,t4t n'l ",t.v. '\'''If'i,

't,·

'h ;\;i\'~n "'i{tI) 1: 1-~ -P" ,+t. -11 ,. '\':.-~- .~-~. -w -. f:;1t Jtt .~~. . _:.»f.~~ 4. ~ J 'i1 ... -14-.<4 w·~,.r}' If ,.(c w- ~ .. "t~;;

• •

It"

_{'t._.#} tlfc ~~'f1l; ~(4 _{J~$~~~' ~":~~"'~i» i f} • ~~~"1 _{~.~. ~ ~l;iI~.;,f ~~ it~.~'1.{.} i;fi ,~~ ~~~ '~"¥~J;"'It:'''l~\~ ~:~'tp I ' .,; 'li-'Ul'Mr'I'1,~, .. 0,', 'i·r ~

,~t.-..:fL-~ .• eO\~ q . . . ,; t! f~.. qt.~J.;,." \f L!.:\, ,., 3:"t~:: OOt~cfJ.

,alOl:lt;.t..

It, teal'

free

to

~1:u.ti{)1pute

:rf!~fkl1

'1"

l '

a

"~~_.. ,:~) {1\'1"~~ ~11 (H1,

t",

'to

~;'i!f'\ ~ _{'<';J~$,J i~.i.; .\.i~~,)t i~,} A.",." m 6 : A t . . ~ ~.t. t:t."'.U, ~,~ ~ ~I A An\.... 1('0 Y"'T~ ,.":)

'r ,,"

'~~\l"lA '

, __ v QJ1. t;" "";ltp<~ i'?.$ ~ ~;;~t;;.(;i, ~&.",;.,"V ~ ~:~ It..te ':': .i'~f4, ,(l~ '\11' .. "", ;, •

to

r~laJrtlr~e

tbe

~~o:eld

R.,t

lei-·ttlt

in

t}1ou(~htt

to

l£,l

with it.,

u'!ld.wi:'h

1te~lf. Y~~or hypothf~a1f1

.t _04. '3 _{Q {~ <t~'¥~"} ~ ri1h"'f...~. _\.J 'fA.'" _{~ QW';l,jlllL.,;} ~A~'H"f{tl ~l!'t _{~w ~}

.h'

_{V<, ,}

"'A.w,."

_{JI;. ,.j.\t~ ~}

it,

_•

v

_{, . (f~,',}

"",,\til,

_{• , . , , . , . , ,}

n

".filii

11 _{.<h .tt,,}:} e~ "·'1"'''''' _{"1,'#" .,.}

11a.k~

..

be1t.v~,fiC'1(jll. ~jnd, p{l~tr·y.

I'n 'the

[111'\}..

l'fb{~tl

olil

~1t'tti

iltd,s'

,(r~ct,31 hs.v~ a~lt;l~$)ti

to

'b~

l1"Ct;;,spted

{)llfiaQe Vr~ltte t 'f;()

're

jU1~;t :t~lC',

f,lnd

b~~Of.)m()

capabl

f) otbt11n~;l ",0 S,t

wl'loee

~Ll~lti#;~3t tOll!1

u:~~ mOJl'~iljljJOr"nmt

·thll:n

t.bet:r :

~ll'~

tftxl

~ltj,!;lc~. ~vhat­

.'fer

ihf~y

tlay b.

i l l

retl11

ty ,

they

rlre

no

1

ol\t~r

'" in

"11~!~in~it

buts

C;{11i1

not

Detl'f.~ttxed

itietiS

". h

~y

c

~m

O{l

L{lOVi,d ab~~)u'ta;nd,

'r:)

1.

",'tY

~d Tf

t

t

h.

1:~tJ

t,

1.

i

kit

~'~.~ 1'T% "'t.>8 ~~ -

';"1

.l~" ""';' '~l ;.1t,,~ 'h'~", tl1 f!!I!&"'.6 AU e1Ii IU' ',n "'l!

t

i

A n

-~~.~.!~ ".' :t..ts t~:l ';~'i f !l"-:':J,~ '~~~;::.- - t. ~ (~·>~4 ;.~ 1#. ~-:J4:, ~ .·~,~il\ ~ Jt;~ .~<~ a: ,4 ,p: g ~" .. ;tt~.t~. ~11.'.

, 1

on

"en.1

nf'~

t,h3

'oon.118,r

1

~'fl l)."_{~n ~l;rh~;l

t

"her~

nl

1m

(or .etllf4s)and

*f.fh.'tft

Wtl-)

tl.linkn:bo~,lt

t

t ..

it

fj;.nr:tbl~g

um

to,',', .

't,'

h~l~,'

1t

,f,), \;

~f~

r.

,~~,;,nf;~!j,·",

" :,.,

i

t

h,. r . ! , ,,,flo

1

t

i

9' 'II,

<'lnd

QO.

f~4:

\ 'J,

i~)~~n "'>.~1

6"

'l~, ~11l" ')"l~:~ ~

it1l: ttM.a

x~n""

1

i'~

ll,*" ,r:,

~'I

t

\1,t'1, t

t"'h

.t'" __ .lI'Jt

t~~,.,4~~'" ,A, ~# \,1~"'H¥ nt, .!'·'V'.9 . .t." ... "q;'lf'.,ll~ ~~'t,'" ')~"it.d .. ".,., ' .. .i f .. ~l', ... l¥·" },;'LJ.. e

l)t}:;;1ft

;~1131 ~s) & '1'(1f

cloan

~e'

t,

0 '~Jfr

()rlCI ()

'm~,k~

t

t

{,t

b

~

'r ,

_ " ( . . . . J~ . .

a.nd, "tle 'titf1r

f

,t

h~lr'l

t"t

t;#l;'i4.

II

1 )

(1)

'.C.~iJ.

£ikthill&l'.

qY,PlYlll~<~3.r9. ~3'udj.e8 ill tl:t9

History,

~ ~

:tt"J:'$

~ft~,lt

t ...

aannGUlla8

(I fi.

no",

11

b(tril

t

1

OIl,

ae l'JrotQWld

p0;rnf!:Ptl

8".

th"

two

P!t~V1,OU1~ on'~ ?A!;.

It

iU..

~t

'the..

1.!t,l,1t

f,bl·'~ ~ f th(!HI~ ~l1r~

'b'b.

~r-~lrl

t

1.

co--P

.1G~t~

t1btJolut •••

nlft'r*!!t 1~1

:no.

l<,nlt

OT :'i t~')ol

thrrt

.erY.~

''',e,

1.t.l1~!ot,tir':(€i~~Pt 1,h~) 1nte~11t)ct

tt3f!lf

t,a1 ,.

in.entivtl

Ol~1t}11}O".,nQ,8.

The

un1v'~"J~~f1l1gat1()ft

of. the

h!fl'Q'b~tl!~I,

,uCilv,(t

mf~t~'od.f

in.

1

t_~l1

bToad-••

' I1gulflcR}rt1oIl,

1~ th~~

1.0

o'ill

1,kluatr;l,t1ofl

of

It.,

An

o:r4ert.~r$.u '~tt\1)QY1~

lAnd

r~li~t.'t1ve.

yt

~~lill:s,'.$

Q,oof)::dl

11

t~) Qtj:f~tfl.:)Olld

tel

t'\t,

relnt

lonr)

,ltsooyere,d

by

1ft

litt

t

tone

$"~~r

fiOr0'

ri"h

~rnd

l)rototm(i,.

It

Z8t:UlW(t

1

~~ ;litl

t

fly'

(~llflJl&~1~

n,;"

':;ifl1fJ.f10yer

neo •• ulT.

(tY@fl :l"~l

V(j'ry

10un<tll·tl()n~,.

1,)og'10.

il

o,o11tt,c1iio,tl

o:,~ r1ftt1~l

fOrJ1tll$:l.a,

~~l,~pptt:L:trI'M

longer

~J.

r,n

3,',

1

t"'lsrttt.l

OOtlc}ttptlon

oon£lt:rllot·~d

once

",. Aft:r

,";'il ~,

t'

c n

'1"111.,, '~

1

'lit'

''1

, ".,

1

,*la;'i~~. "i'. ~ - ~~. i! ~ .~c:\ . . . , . ~ t. .. "¥ 'A-~~ ~ 1 -~>l '~a ~ ~ :'tlf\. :~!~ -1'1' ',. f, •. " "~~ >, 'm- - ¥ttl':'"

nn

(~.fi;t ~ ~ 'l,~ , i:;.~".,f,.. ,;... 4i,~, , ' , , ' <~"" ~.il,';;, "W ~,./,,;.,",

'r:..

i\.:!' ! ;1f.;.§ i • t'S ~'." ' , • ' J., i:, " ~ > ",~ \ " ' ,

ail

e

t,tir:f

ll~al.

·f

oundl~:t 1o~.

Th

o\lJ~h' t~n.l e

t ('

ana

t

}lll"ly

be~~a, to

Olll'ld

on

nil\1' ,t~')l:ul(lu;tl{)nt1, ( ) : r t t )

,,:r;O<.i1.ry

:!ec:!~i:t::ft~! :~3!~;, ~t;:.

r:::w

o~ :"~:i:!;{!)

.'1b@~!Q,m::uionaent

o,ttl'1fl

tl~llvf~ ret~.ll_

of

th~

Qlli,~1:81ufl.l peri()~i

Qf

r:~()1tll1Q.en'all~

tht1l

it'b,alldollm~nt

of

tM~lb*l(}lutei ~~rt.dwll(tn

I

e~,,,¥ tn~u~ ~~bH"lldonJ~ent

of

')18 .

lll)~l'31~lt-~J,

X'

r1lt,£:lll

liO"

only

.Pl~.e. '1!:~$.

lJIld

~~;L'i'e7.

but

fciblOlu"

,o*"r'~ltllty

fml! .,.

r

tt'tIJ~y

as

well

Sit:Y

It'

~ ~lb.olllt~!

.:ruth

.oo.~b~\t

remai'ns

t.

'but

:!i,

uul •• raeof

ti1"ot~lr".

a

pl{'iy.f:,~()tmd

tor the

"I '". _h,~'4. t "li~f~'n' -'~ ~ ~-li!.ft _R~<ik "

-.

I

_!

l

1)1

K~~n.tJ

that

th~ ~"QinnOel ht%.?s

111)

fl')fJ~:"'lut~

'f)ri

n,oi·)l'~~.t

"hat

11t,:)tt'tlag

Is (ui.'taln.

P':ro-llt~nt9:q.1

't',,,,

;>"'7

7 ... ;~~~O' .i:.'1(11'.,.... t · : (;;~., •

I

I I .-j

V~:lJli ;'~ll

one

ti!te:r

thl:1}

o~' h{~:r. th,~ gf!rH~:r,~u ro:r~nul<w.

ot •

~r

<t1

rlfll t(~'r't

)';

:i

0}t~lf ~lfli

11:f.1

~~s

t

t~~~{:llt mOT~,:!}

t.:~J.'l,~l lfH)~t'. \~ ,.~lgel ~ ~3F:L1St t

th,e

;~~u;rl erlO$

o,f

11t~,

t

lll',e

hr~s ;:;l,c'tu;~lly CQm{~ '{)'h~;~

pt)t

tlt tf'b~~:rt~

1.

t

0;1'f1

no

lotl$;~r f.iUIOij

1,11t:l

~li~!iJ" ~~c-t

lcjjl ,

ttrft11lhesl

~,,:

th8re

rl:X-

i

£It _

1

onB' tnnfr

1_:;er

11'1

t.!QV~t:l~t~~nt.

f#

(1)

~<10

I,

r ...

m~q

I:q

tl"u~;t l~l\tr:xl;~ t~.nt1QiJ)l~'

••

lilr ~{V~Hl"

1

e!f1:tl" ,~i,

1

'thz}tJ{J,;

h

l '

d 1

f:t

fJ%

ti

t

rt)1tn J,)'!ta

,t

1

:~m

l'

_{~ i., ~;.~ .•. ,t.glt.!f·~_ (~·c,~itt-_} ~ ~ '1 '1i' -"'I; _.~ "'~.,

1",

A.~ ~ ~ ~ 'i';->$~" ~At'

"";

.!Is ,',,<

·t'·,

"h,.

l'

V'

i'

""''1

1· ..

I: fit~~'f.I·l~\1:.4,· , •. ~>r~J..~:¥.~- .i~' w;,·~; ~ ~J/" . t . , j . , ' fig .

oonFt18t*~11' f(}~~ph;1,s18 011 'h.ohi~g:1n~, ~Q:rld,

nmd

abel ••

£~11

In.

1'i$

l),x;~lltlt.

111at

aJ)M\)lut<,~

truth,

1.:f"

n(!Vi-~!,

reach.€l,

(l:'l!l

'be

Ot)ntlrttl

i

'lillJ"

:t~.!,:proi1,ohed.!t(

2)

(1)

~;;;,. j~Y~'nt;'tJlt.

:51010 '

~

et

( 2)

;,} .:::j.'J.

ltal d

~Ul* t ~rl'l~~

f 4A " "" ':l<:: €}. 't"i

»orlt,j)~n. ,i:.r]

7,

j>-'.

Ho'.

'he

~:x!}la~'tlttn

of ,18 ootltl1'ion

by

!~1~'totl~,s ~IrOl'

those

:~!:h,~ I!:t~!:iii:! :!ii~Ol;;;l;:~i:u~:'~~!::'t1"~:U:l!;

of

tnl~)\I,,'

if-n:;,;11es "he

1Io1u"1o:'1 af

tl1~ i'):r~vl{,ur:i d,1fticult1~a.

and

it

1.

not

1:)o~~igle 'Ii;) ~Jn'1.-t! kr~ot

of

tfh,1Ql"1 Oll~ (10f~.

not

kllOW.

llut

'the

d1ftloul

'10!

0\1%

think1n.g

,":{}tnt~

'0

ll,

tk.no\'

in the

tl0

j~:ac'\;

tor in

!10

t

t~Z

a.s

O\l~ thou~_;rlt

11

"'ill

til

,(;C

1.

eu

1

t

1

f'~~!g,

1

t

1

9

in l1ke c,)ae with

th!)!!e

1Iho

~l7rl!

'rJl-alrul;

for in

e1th*flr

CS~$.

it

lalmpoaaible

to

.fO:tW41J'd..

Henge one shDtl1d

have

lllUl"yeY8d

all

.ne

d.lt~f1oul

titee

o.f,!or~'h'l';lndtbotb fOl~ 'th£~ '~)urpc.ul~ .~

have

at

ted. and

becduf~~~

l;H!,opl.e

1Mbn

lnqu1.re

wi

tIl

(>u

t

t1r~t ~tlJit111g

the dlf'tloult1 a

4tr~! lik~~! thO~~~i

who dQ

rlot

kl1.0\¥

wlle:re

'hey

h;,tvt!

~o

i?J

O:~l~.'t, t\",~,.1l1 {1~~'~'c,1l{~~.,,?then1'S~',lttlt)W ~!~}"~n ~r:1,t!'h~r

he

:ua.

,,~'~7t1l:1

t:tlven '1me

toun1i

9n¥,~,t

he

1~

lookintJ

to"!:

or

not· tor

tho

ellO.

1enotclea,l*,

'4)

lUoh

3"

t.!4.€i;!l,uhl1e

'0

hill,

'who

has

tl1'a1

difJcullsod the

dlttlo\lltls8

1t

18

cl(~u.Jrtlr"h~:rt h~ whf.)

haa

he~lrd

a,11 tbe

oontl~nldl

, t I l '

'111)_.

l~".it th8y"'~re th~~

p(ar11tllto

a

(j.'~H3e.

mustoe

1n~% '~)t,tter

poal

t1011

for

ltld,glng.·

It·"

"~1 nat·u~.lll).1i&~;rot;n'lVftt

no'

0

1

'117

of·oQnOl\1~1on~.

but

Q·t

1'.

'1~ry:pr1ne1.pl.g.

(1)

teu:t;1rttve

tl1al(lo'la:

1.

easent1al17

or1t10:'11; l ' 1.

a

o71t·1'Jll{l

bll~le4

:no'

on

~01.1~t1tl·c

knr,wle<tger,

nor on a

Q1 . . .

f~oJ-~lt11l8t'lott

of

prlncl1l1es,

ou't:r':.'ith.tl:!

on

-ha'

Deaoart ••

oillled1te

lJon~.n.·, 'Oft

tbxlt

of

wlt1Qh

."'f'('*11'one

11

~<:~-t'i}l·ftUI~A

'i"'lL

'\lr;,.J:'tWe

tP# ~~~ .-W ~l,:;t-.. \Y~.

(1)

t '1f'n.~U~ttl t~~,.ttn

c

trlq\l\ld

1n'~:t:rof;:'~;.tt.o {~11

to!' ••

' i n

801enl11s

demon:tltZ'·''''·l·ris e' a :.,1

t~r

_e.,

in

ditil.'1c&"

in

diill~}otl0.a

ea1J11lO4

solum

1n'a%'ro~;t1l..u

tie

O()rloluaione . . .

d,

etiam

de

. . .

18$1 .••

de

qU.l'Otla

d.I()ll$tr·~'tor nO'tl itrtf!rr()f~~~l:t.

sftd ea

.wul\ quaetper .•• , nOI¥1.,

yel

pel',

"d~113

pri,l'10it,1a,i)To'ba.tat

_ ,

l'nt.n.~ia'

_'an'u.

_de

_{0't.lnolu,,1.o'ne..}

;~Jed cu~ Gl.;j.m fj;~mon­

.'traY'.rl-', utit,,),'

"t~t,

u'pr

sitton ••

",ad

a11am

Ot)ncluslonea

A,~~fttl!!t'·,.,@>.~-Ai'f:~l'~ • ~.A;M

I'.

l~A~,\t' ll'~.Dl

I

1,"'.

..~ '11ft

-z

t

Q~alV},':'~ ~ r *.Ur~;;lIl.~.rM. " , ...I. !~~~~.~A If'fll i~ ,'. ;;: .. ~. . ' .

U".

G,. •

Ii .... .J ,

' .. _1,80

':t. Pos'· •.

Anal.I.

180.

5,

n.4."

..

,alec~le

ls at

'h~

:I;l,m,,'ltl8

&.

.ad.

ot

·~1J;.f~lml11ut:t1on

as

well.

' e r

ael

ther is

"h~ a~'¥' ot~x!lm1'!ltlt'1on

an

~.tO\lo?np11:11\.­

_at' of

'he

fatUI.

ktadae

~~.~I.tnJ

'lui

OM

which

a

mWi mq

po . . .

,.y.n 1ho

he

h$;t .•

a~)' k.nr»tlad~e.

Fo.:t 1

t

11:

po~~1bl.e

.".n

for

OIM

wiillou'

kJ10wle4

to

hold

alt

eXtlml11~ltioll

of

ODe

who

1. nib

mo~l.

e.

it

lileo

'he latt4

r

_'f

B7~n,t9

hila

point.

!

t&ten no'

t1'OlI

tIling. 'h4'

h~

klto..

or

:tr.Ofl the

.8!;Jeola1

p'l'l.ncl , •• of

'tbe

Slt1' ,

eo'

Utlder

d19:0U)",.1on,

bu.'

iroll

all that

%~\n.p

of

(U)n • • ~l\l~_. rl"[).Qh111{~

'0

"he

,.ct

'whioh

a

man

a&1 ,,'

.

know 91

tb,GU'

kll{)w1~

ihe

thitoryot

,he

.1"bje ....

bu. whtClb

i t

be

tioea

no'

know,

he

111bOUtl(i

'Q

be

l~plt')rflnt

of

'h.

theory.

~lo

then

clearly

the

31'1

ar

:a~lnlI:~1

does

no'

oo ••

tsl

iD

,'owl.rimitof

allY

t.iefln113

8ubjf:~O'.

)'llor

thil

~fnl_.

'-0,

11 de_l. w1

tJY1tr111

1

tlngl.

foY

€tv~~ry

'theory'

ot

llny1hl

employ- alae

certaln

Qowaonl):rlt"tol1)llJa.

tienee

."·~r,-'-·:, .1Jlalud,1~

eVifn

·~&t8ur8J' tua~

••

u_ in

8,

Wf1Y

of

" alec'""t. and the

p~ao'io.ot ~x

. .

1n1n~ to~

f.l11

undert~:dte

to

10118

esten' a

rOllin

,rtal

of

·'b,ofJ.wbo

prtlfe ••

1o

kll,t,,,

thinge.

~1Iba't

••

'rYe.

tbet.

'l~er(~

1$

'he

g'e~ltJ:rf~ll pr'1!ull])l~*~J

for

they

know 'b ••• of

'b~'1is.lv

•• ju.' aa

.ell

£1;8

th~

••

ient!.".

e".,D

if

1ft

_l'l'

'11$1

fl!,iy

'he, • •

m

'0

the

la:tt*,r'o

tIO wildly

ti,1

tl'rq

fJ"o.

th_.~\l.l,

.11811

are

el1f~ Z:lJ,£ed

i'n :r

f~

tll

ti1Alt

1. on ;

for

'h.y

.'~~J.t~

a bant'

rl8 L~tJ:t.UT.

l'tl

'11~ 8£lm(! tt~sk

'with.

'w;t\ioh

dial"'10

i l CoftOt!:rned.

of •••

1ana11y;

~lnd

he 1,

a 41aleetlcian

whQ

~Xt~,mln

••

07

,he

help

g.:! &

theory

of

;rt~~1.8on1ng,. fit

"

But

tile

fJr,11anGl}1,i~'tti~:)tl

"hrOl,titb

111'~)Q-h~.1. tiXld

tel11;,:i;\1

V~

rlJ'rt

101 ..

p(';ttlou

lli~;.

no

finiAll

'*1'

'l,ll

1,'.1£. In,

tb@11

'Jlt!

m.i'llti

;ftatnlrtina

eno.h.all1ed,

\1ftl~l.$

'We

(Jlat_

ttl~'t t1."

no

1 * do

llfl!

fall

baok

ln'o

lhl

$

Il'f~\.

01

relu.int(

tomoV'~,

011

10w ...

4

truth. The

8'l\4

we

hSY't£f1.n

Yl~. 1,18Qc~~1','h1ng b$t"t~r

ilbJln hjr:,,()1h$.11,

'llOUgb

we

~_n8't.r r~(J~oil

11.

Iiowetrt<lr.

1th~

.;-1\lt»o.%.

ife

h,:~fI,y~,ua:rt ~~u,o,tGd tl';~V$ l.'b"'·lo~.uI17

l!ftjee'M any

de:f1alteaaJ):·fS.

The

41al ••

t1cal

fa{)V~~HHtln'h&8

ftfl'ilen

baflk

\l'pOrl

i

'ftl.li.

and

1be fH.dom

'0

Ct'tt~JtNe1

haebb$come

a

joy

t;f.18~ Q.Q llJ1,eel"",~1,nI1 ~. 011

ita firs'

prll\(J1t)1~1.

'II. It'Z;P'fir-turl,al

k%lowle" G.

.1nce

as

&uoh it lm})11 ••

" do.,.steaa,lrt

all i.pert ••

t,

klno.

at

knowledge.

The yer!

pltl:ftlll11

of flr.t

p~ltlOi,pltJ.

and

of

~ed.1~.l~'ll

••

lmperteetloa.

fbi.

a};tllll •• both

to fir ...

princl,r>lea 1n

the

lilt1

~to'ell&ll

flea...

au.d to

ftli'

Wtt

call

'OdfiY

'he

tnota

of

fJ~i.ft

•••

dl.1ohrt8

thato! 'he

ele:phwlttg

trunk.

.It

18

n40e8~s~~

tortI.

\0

£70.

Otlr •• lve. from

£'M?fltr1V(}'nnea:8"

1.1"

9()

[;).,1: i~gth18

1.

1)1,~'a~lible.

10

}tDOW

"1\1'

the

elep'h~m' h~l.

a

t:runlt

w(;nll<l

be

better

'ban 'ok'Jl-oW

0111y

'h,~l."

he

htl-a

ODS.

,,~'ati f~n1

te.ndency

tOWf.t%ci

tbe ",'

thrt)U

up ••

tt

1

ng

1.2"8

W4~~a" lila Tk". tit ~~

1.

f{f •

lion

U8*-11

t

In

T!r!::~Ol~t

:r

IG

.?\l~

1110 It();:iY •

(1 )

'In. ti'!e

1

ntro-··duotion he

eat ••

All ,:

',~ ~:~.

,.',

~u<~>:~ ~

,;.

~ ~.

. "

A~ (.~

•

it'l~\1

a nus.

•

'Ut'

$liif~(1!r::t:J ' lln;;"~.\l'\m·~nt(il,.

{ t

1aal()n

~yen

of

biQl:. I'

ts

utterly

vain

'OR;Q ••

~ltltlft

'hrou.gb

I

"ltle

dforo.ifiUlrl ••

t

a:r4

lrldepen~'nt

of

'11.

=1::1~-:~~=,:::'

,,:1'''h.

a!::~e!:=

•• '

whlCh

'ft18Rve ad:mt

"h~i,'

Ot)

j~o"fI

al'-e

~~l)J)~tlrf~,!lO.1

'lull'

o~

'M1r con.truetlon

'0 •

aubi •• ',

"9

t,.e

(1

ontiftl

~Qd

&'f$41ett't

i~~O\1.d.. ~~.I"Oll:i.ll.y P1rftJ)~l""d..

by

}tall"

\0

'. a

th.

8tlleD

o,f 'he

wh .

I)

fta'tll%tll

aCienoe.

Itant

-.t'htJ8ubj$O', man,

oY(~r M;i~fh"511nd

cbj,ne,

~D(!

41.o,,~~$4

_the

fll

i~Lr~en'~ll

I4>rlnol;ple.

a,ooordl1~g

to

.hlGh

c:'oj&ot.

A:ttl''b~l11tllI)

b:r

0\1%

!l(in{!."

(2)

",

...

lfhl1_

th1.

poaittoli

1. JJu.tlM·.ptHlble

ltl

,1

tt!

gen~~ral

I:ty ,1

t

~lo'uall, de\lO'~lbe8

a

tYl),(!I

ofkl'10~~lottg;e

all

.l'·'ssut'll~!d

1.2. '

(1) J.

YOll

ue:ltull.

rh"Gr:.'10,~ilBlo1oir;y.

N.Y ••

1:1~2(~.