• Aucun résultat trouvé

Correction du syndrome de l’énuclée par injection d’hydrogel

N/A
N/A
Protected

Academic year: 2021

Partager "Correction du syndrome de l’énuclée par injection d’hydrogel"

Copied!
128
0
0

Texte intégral

(1)

HAL Id: dumas-01214539

https://dumas.ccsd.cnrs.fr/dumas-01214539

Submitted on 12 Oct 2015

HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access archive for the deposit and dissemination of sci-entific research documents, whether they are pub-lished or not. The documents may come from teaching and research institutions in France or abroad, or from public or private research centers.

L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non, émanant des établissements d’enseignement et de recherche français ou étrangers, des laboratoires publics ou privés.

Correction du syndrome de l’énuclée par injection

d’hydrogel

Élodie Maringe

To cite this version:

Élodie Maringe. Correction du syndrome de l’énuclée par injection d’hydrogel. Médecine humaine et pathologie. 2015. �dumas-01214539�

(2)

! "! #$%&'()!*+,()!-)!*)-)%+.)!)(!-)!/0$1*$%+)!-)!12&).! ! $3345!67"8! ! ! ! !"#$#%&'()%*#%+,&*'-#%+.#!/!%+#%+'0!#()%#1%-#+#0,1#% % % % !

%211)%(+2.!-&!9:.-12*)!-)!';).&%'))!

/$1!+.<)%(+2.!-;0:-12=)'!

! ! />4?53@45!5@!?AB@53B5!CBDEFGB5H53@!E5!6!95C@5HD>5!67"8! ! /I>!! ! )EAJF5!*$1+.=)! ! .45!E5!"7!K4L>F5>!"MNO!P!%'+%0:! ! ! ! /1)9+-).(!-&!<&1:!Q! *A3?F5B>!E5!/>AK5??5B>!*I>R!*&1$+.)! ! ! ! -+1)%()&1!-)!(0)9)!Q! *A3?F5B>!E5!-AR@5B>!$EIF3!1)(2&(! ! ! ! *)*S1)9!-&!<&1:!Q! *IJIH5!E5!/>AK5??5B>!9AEI3T5!*+'$UU2! *A3?F5B>!E5!/>AK5??5B>!/F5>>5!#1)=)1! !

(3)

! 6!

ANNEE UNIVERSITAIRE 2014 - 2015

U.F.R. DE MEDECINE ET DE PHARMACIE DE ROUEN ---

DOYEN : Professeur Pierre FREGER

ASSESSEURS : Professeur Michel GUERBET

Professeur Benoit VEBER Professeur Pascal JOLY

Professeur Stéphane MARRET

I - MEDECINE

PROFESSEURS DES UNIVERSITES – PRATICIENS HOSPITALIERS

Mr Frédéric ANSELME HCN Cardiologie

Mme Isabelle AUQUIT AUCKBUR HCN Chirurgie plastique

Mr Bruno BACHY (surnombre) HCN Chirurgie pédiatrique

Mr Fabrice BAUER HCN Cardiologie

Mme Soumeya BEKRI HCN Biochimie et biologie

moléculaire

Mr Jacques BENICHOU HCN Bio statistiques et

informatique médicale

Mr Jean-Paul BESSOU HCN Chirurgie thoracique et

cardio-vasculaire

Mme Françoise BEURET-BLANQUART HCN Commission E.P.P. D.P.C. Pôle Qualité

(4)

! V!

Mr Guy BONMARCHAND (surnombre) HCN Réanimation médicale

Mr Olivier BOYER UFR Immunologie

Mr Jean-François CAILLARD (surnombre) HCN Médecine et santé au travail

Mr François CARON HCN Maladies infectieuses et

tropicales

Mr Philippe CHASSAGNE HCN Médecine interne (gériatrie)

Mr Vincent COMPERE HCN Anesthésiologie et

réanimation chirurgicale

Mr Antoine CUVELIER HB Pneumologie

Mr Pierre CZERNICHOW HCH Epidémiologie, économie de

la santé

Mr Jean-Nicolas DACHER HCN Radiologie et imagerie

médicale

Mr Stéfan DARMONI HCN Informatique médicale et

techniques de communication

Mr Pierre DECHELOTTE HCN Nutrition

Mme Danièle DEHESDIN (surnombre) HCN Oto-rhino-laryngologie

Mr Frédéric DI FIORE CB Cancérologie

Mr Fabien DOGUET HCN Chirurgie Cardio Vasculaire

Mr Jean DOUCET SJ Thérapeutique - Médecine

interne et gériatrie

Mr Bernard DUBRAY CB Radiothérapie

Mr Philippe DUCROTTE HCN Hépato-gastro-entérologie

Mr Frank DUJARDIN HCN Chirurgie orthopédique -

Traumatologique

Mr Fabrice DUPARC HCN Anatomie - Chirurgie

orthopédique et traumatologique

Mr Eric DURAND HCN Cardiologie

Mr Bertrand DUREUIL HCN Anesthésiologie et

réanimation chirurgicale

Mme Hélène ELTCHANINOFF HCN Cardiologie

(5)

! W!

Mr Pierre FREGER HCN Anatomie - Neurochirurgie

Mr Jean François GEHANNO HCN Médecine et santé au travail

Mr Emmanuel GERARDIN HCN Imagerie médicale

Mme Priscille GERARDIN HCN Pédopsychiatrie

Mr Michel GODIN (surnombre) HB Néphrologie

M. Guillaume GOURCEROL HCN Physiologie

Mr Philippe GRISE (surnombre) HCN Urologie

Mr Olivier GUILLIN HCN Psychiatrie Adultes

Mr Didier HANNEQUIN HCN Neurologie

Mr Fabrice JARDIN CB Hématologie

Mr Luc-Marie JOLY HCN Médecine d’urgence

Mr Pascal JOLY HCN Dermato - Vénéréologie

Mme Annie LAQUERRIERE HCN Anatomie et cytologie

pathologiques

Mr Vincent LAUDENBACH HCN Anesthésie et réanimation

chirurgicale

Mr Xavier LE LOET HCN Rhumatologie

Mr Joël LECHEVALLIER HCN Chirurgie infantile

Mr Hervé LEFEBVRE HB Endocrinologie et maladies

métaboliques

Mr Thierry LEQUERRE HB Rhumatologie

Mr Eric LEREBOURS HCN Nutrition

Mme Anne-Marie LEROI HCN Physiologie

Mr Hervé LEVESQUE HB Médecine interne

Mme Agnès LIARD-ZMUDA HCN Chirurgie Infantile

Mr Pierre Yves LITZLER HCN Chirurgie cardiaque

Mr Bertrand MACE HCN Histologie, embryologie,

cytogénétique

M. David MALTETE HCN Neurologie

Mr Christophe MARGUET HCN Pédiatrie

(6)

! 8!

Mr Jean-Paul MARIE HCN Oto-rhino-laryngologie

Mr Loïc MARPEAU HCN Gynécologie - Obstétrique

Mr Stéphane MARRET HCN Pédiatrie

Mme Véronique MERLE HCN Epidémiologie

Mr Pierre MICHEL HCN Hépato-gastro-entérologie

Mr Bruno MIHOUT(surnombre) HCN Neurologie

Mr Jean-François MUIR HB Pneumologie

Mr Marc MURAINE HCN Ophtalmologie

Mr Philippe MUSETTE HCN Dermatologie - Vénéréologie

Mr Christophe PEILLON HCN Chirurgie générale

Mr Jean-Marc PERON (surnombre) HCN Stomatologie et chirurgie maxillo-faciale

Mr Christian PFISTER HCN Urologie

Mr Jean-Christophe PLANTIER HCN Bactériologie - Virologie

Mr Didier PLISSONNIER HCN Chirurgie vasculaire

Mr Bernard PROUST HCN Médecine légale

Mr François PROUST HCN Neurochirurgie

Mme Nathalie RIVES HCN Biologie du développement et de la

reproduction

Mr Jean-Christophe RICHARD (détachement) HCN Réanimation médicale

- Médecine d’urgence

Mr Horace ROMAN HCN Gynécologie - Obstétrique

Mr Jean-Christophe SABOURIN HCN Anatomie - Pathologie

Mr Guillaume SAVOYE HCN Hépato-gastrologie

Mme Céline SAVOYE–COLLET HCN Imagerie médicale

Mme Pascale SCHNEIDER HCN Pédiatrie

Mr Michel SCOTTE HCN Chirurgie digestive

Mme Fabienne TAMION HCN Thérapeutique

Mr Luc THIBERVILLE HCN Pneumologie

Mr Christian THUILLEZ HB Pharmacologie

(7)

! O!

Mr Jean-Jacques TUECH HCN Chirurgie digestive

Mr Jean-Pierre VANNIER HCN Pédiatrie génétique

Mr Benoît VEBER HCN Anesthésiologie -

Réanimation chirurgicale

Mr Pierre VERA CB Biophysique et traitement de

l’image

Mr Eric VERIN CRMPR Médecine physique et

de réadaptation

Mr Eric VERSPYCK HCN Gynécologie obstétrique

Mr Olivier VITTECOQ HB Rhumatologie

Mr Jacques WEBER HCN Physiologie

MAITRES DE CONFERENCES DES UNIVERSITES – PRATICIENS HOSPITALIERS

Mme Noëlle BARBIER-FREBOURG HCN Bactériologie – Virologie

Mr Jeremy BELLIEN HCN Pharmacologie

Mme Carole BRASSE LAGNEL HCN Biochimie

Mme Valérie BRIDOUX HUYBRECHTS HCN Chirurgie Vasculaire

Mr Gérard BUCHONNET HCN Hématologie

Mme Mireille CASTANET HCN Pédiatrie

Mme Nathalie CHASTAN HCN Physiologie

Mme Sophie CLAEYSSENS HCN Biochimie et biologie

moléculaire

Mr Moïse COEFFIER HCN Nutrition

Mr Stéphane DERREY HCN Neurochirurgie

Mr Manuel ETIENNE HCN Maladies infectieuses et

tropicales

Mr Serge JACQUOT UFR Immunologie

Mr Joël LADNER HCN Epidémiologie, économie de

la santé

(8)

! X!

Mr Thomas MOUREZ HCN Bactériologie

Mr Jean-François MENARD HCN Biophysique

Mme Muriel QUILLARD HCN Biochimie et biologie

moléculaire

Mr Vincent RICHARD UFR Pharmacologie

Mr Mathieu SALAUN HCN Pneumologie

Mme Pascale SAUGIER-VEBER HCN Génétique

Mme Anne-Claire TOBENAS-DUJARDIN HCN Anatomie

Mr Olivier TROST HCN Chirurgie Maxillo

Faciale

PROFESSEURS AGREGES OU CERTIFIES

Mme Dominique LANIEZ UFR Anglais

(9)

! N!

II - PHARMACIE

PROFESSEURS

Mr Thierry BESSON Chimie Thérapeutique

Mr Jean-Jacques BONNET Pharmacologie

Mr Roland CAPRON (PU-PH) Biophysique

Mr Jean COSTENTIN (Professeur émérite) Pharmacologie

Mme Isabelle DUBUS Biochimie

Mr Loïc FAVENNEC (PU-PH) Parasitologie

Mr Jean Pierre GOULLE Toxicologie

Mr Michel GUERBET Toxicologie

Mme Isabelle LEROUX - NICOLLET Physiologie

Mme Christelle MONTEIL Toxicologie

Mme Martine PESTEL-CARON (PU-PH) Microbiologie

Mme Elisabeth SEGUIN Pharmacognosie

Mr Rémi VARIN (PU-PH) Pharmacie clinique

Mr Jean-Marie VAUGEOIS Pharmacologie

Mr Philippe VERITE Chimie analytique

MAITRES DE CONFERENCES

Mme Cécile BARBOT Chimie Générale et Minérale

Mme Dominique BOUCHER Pharmacologie

Mr Frédéric BOUNOURE Pharmacie Galénique

Mr Abdeslam CHAGRAOUI Physiologie

(10)

! M!

Mme Marie Catherine CONCE-CHEMTOB Législation pharmaceutique

et économie de la santé

Mme Elizabeth CHOSSON Botanique

Mme Cécile CORBIERE Biochimie

Mr Eric DITTMAR Biophysique

Mme Nathalie DOURMAP Pharmacologie

Mme Isabelle DUBUC Pharmacologie

Mr Abdelhakim ELOMRI Pharmacognosie

Mr François ESTOUR Chimie Organique

Mr Gilles GARGALA (MCU-PH) Parasitologie

Mme Najla GHARBI Chimie analytique

Mme Marie-Laure GROULT Botanique

Mr Hervé HUE Biophysique et

mathématiques

Mme Laetitia LE GOFF Parasitologie - Immunologie

Mme Hong LU Biologie

Mme Sabine MENAGER Chimie organique

Mr Mohamed SKIBA Pharmacie galénique

Mme Malika SKIBA Pharmacie galénique

Mme Christine THARASSE Chimie thérapeutique

Mr Frédéric ZIEGLER Biochimie

PROFESSEURS ASSOCIES

Mme Cécile GUERARD-DETUNCQ Pharmacie officinale

Mr Jean-François HOUIVET Pharmacie officinale

PROFESSEUR CERTIFIE

Mme Mathilde GUERIN Anglais

ASSISTANT HOSPITALO-UNIVERSITAIRE

(11)

! "7!

ATTACHES TEMPORAIRES D’ENSEIGNEMENT ET DE RECHERCHE

Mr Romy RAZAKANDRAINIBE Parasitologie

(12)

! ""!

LISTE DES RESPONSABLES DES DISCIPLINES PHARMACEUTIQUES

Mme Cécile BARBOT Chimie Générale et minérale

Mr Thierry BESSON Chimie thérapeutique

Mr Roland CAPRON Biophysique

Mr Jean CHASTANG Mathématiques

Mme Marie-Catherine CONCE-CHEMTOB Législation et économie de la

santé

Mme Elisabeth CHOSSON Botanique

Mr Jean-Jacques BONNET Pharmacodynamie

Mme Isabelle DUBUS Biochimie

Mr Loïc FAVENNEC Parasitologie

Mr Michel GUERBET Toxicologie

Mr François ESTOUR Chimie organique

Mme Isabelle LEROUX-NICOLLET Physiologie

Mme Martine PESTEL-CARON Microbiologie

Mme Elisabeth SEGUIN Pharmacognosie

Mr Mohamed SKIBA Pharmacie galénique

(13)

! "6!

III – MEDECINE GENERALE

PROFESSEUR

Mr Jean-Loup HERMIL UFR Médecine générale

PROFESSEURS ASSOCIES A MI-TEMPS

Mr Emmanuel LEFEBVRE UFR Médecine Générale

Mr Alain MERCIER UFR Médecine générale

Mr Philippe NGUYEN THANH UFR Médecine générale

MAITRES DE CONFERENCES ASSOCIES A MI-TEMPS

Mr Pascal BOULET UFR Médecine générale

Mme Elisabeth MAUVIARD UFR Médecine générale

Mme Yveline SEVRIN UFR Médecine générale

(14)

! "V!

ENSEIGNANTS MONO-APPARTENANTS

PROFESSEURS

Mr Serguei FETISSOV (med) Physiologie (ADEN)

Mr Paul MULDER (phar) Sciences du

Médicament

Mme Su RUAN (med) Génie Informatique

MAITRES DE CONFERENCES

Mr Sahil ADRIOUCH (med) Biochimie et biologie

moléculaire (Unité Inserm 905)

Mme Gaëlle BOUGEARD-DENOYELLE (med) Biochimie et biologie

moléculaire (UMR 1079)

Mme Carine CLEREN (phar) Neurosciences

(Néovasc)

Mme Pascaline GAILDRAT (phar) Génétique moléculaire

humaine (UMR 1079)

Mr Nicolas GUEROUT (phar) Neurophysiologie

Mr Antoine OUVRARD-PASCAUD (med) Physiologie (Unité

Inserm 1076)

Mr Frédéric PASQUET Sciences du langage,

orthophonie

Mme Isabelle TOURNIER (phar) Biochimie (UMR 1079)

CHEF DES SERVICES ADMINISTRATIFS : Mme Véronique

DELAFONTAINE

HCN - Hôpital Charles Nicolle HB - Hôpital de BOIS GUILLAUME

CB - Centre Henri Becquerel CHS - Centre Hospitalier Spécialisé du Rouvray CRMPR - Centre Régional de Médecine Physique et de Réadaptation SJ – Saint Julien Rouen

(15)

! "W!

Par délibération en date du 3 mars 1967, la faculté a arrêté que les

opinions émises dans les dissertations qui lui seront présentées doivent

être considérées comme propres à leurs auteurs et qu’elle n’entend

leur donner aucune approbation ni improbation.

(16)

! "8!

(17)

! "O! % % % % % % % % % % % % % % % % /%234%-56789:%-34;69<8%=9%&83>9;;9<8%-58?%-<85649% % % YAB?!H5!KIF@5?!E;ZA335B>!J5!C>4?FJ5>!R5@@5!@Z[?5\! *5>RF!CAB>!LA@>5!JF?CA3FDFEF@4!5@!LA@>5!4RAB@5\! <;IF!4@4!Z5B>5B?5!J5!CABLAF>!ICC>53J>5!P!LA?!R]@4?\! Y5BFEE5^!@>ABL5>!JI3?!R5!@>ILIFE!@AB@5!HI!>5RA33IF??I3R5\! ! !

(18)

! "X! % % % % % % % % % % % % -34;69<8%=9%+3?79<8%/=564%)973<7% % YAB?!H5!KIF@5?!E;ZA335B>!J5!JF>FT5>!R5@@5!@Z[?5\! *5>RF!CAB>!LA@>5!CI@F53R5!5@!LA@>5!4RAB@5!CAB>!H5?!3AHD>5B?5?!IEE45?!5@!L53B5?! JI3?!LA@>5!DB>5IB\! )@>5!IB!DEAR!IL5R!LAB?!4@IF@!@AB_AB>?!B3!HAH53@!J5!CEIF?F>!IEEFI3@!P!EI!KAF?! ICC>53@F??IT5!5@!ZBHAB>\! Y5BFEE5^!@>ABL5>!JI3?!R5!@>ILIFE!@AB@5!HI!>5RA33IF??I3R5\! ! !

(19)

! "N! % % % % % % % % /%234%-56789:%-5@529%=9%&83>9;;9<8%$3=54A9%-6=5BB3%% % YAB?!H5!KIF@5?!E;ZA335B>!J5!_BT5>!R5@@5!@Z[?5\! Y5BFEE5^!@>ABL5>!JI3?!R5!@>ILIFE!HA3!C>AKA3J!>5?C5R@\! ! !

(20)

! "M! % % % % % % % % /%234%-56789:%-34;69<8%=9%&83>9;;9<8%&69889%C89A98% % YAB?!H5!KIF@5?!E;ZA335B>!J5!_BT5>!R5!@>ILIFE\! -I3?!LA@>5!?5>LFR5`!_;IF!Z4?F@4!P!>5_AF3J>5!E5!RIHC!J5?!35B>ARZF>B>TF53?a! Y5BFEE5^!@>ABL5>!FRF`!E5!@4HAFT3IT5!J5!HA3!C>AKA3J!>5?C5R@\! ! !

(21)

! 67!

/%25%>526==9% %

%

/% 29;% D58947;%E! LAB?! b@5?! E5?! J5Bc! b@>5?! E5?! CEB?! RZ5>?! P! HA3! RdB>\! YAB?! b@5?!

?I3?!IBRB3!JAB@5!H5?!HAJ[E5?!P!?BFL>5\!YA@>5!?AB@F53!F3KIFEEFDE5!H;I!KIF@!J5L53F>! EI! K5HH5! GB5! _5! ?BF?! IB_AB>J;ZBF`! _5! 3;IB>IF?! CI?! CB! ILAF>! J5! CEB?! D5EE5! C>5BL5! J;IHAB>\!

!

/% 25% ;F<8%E! ?Fc! I3?! 3AB?! ?4CI>53@`! HIF?! CEB?! E5! @5HC?! CI??5! 5@! CEB?! 3AB?! 3AB?!

>ICC>ARZA3?\!(A3!>4R53@!DA3Z5B>!H5!>5HCEF@!J5!_AF5\!<5!?BF?!@5EE5H53@!KF[>5!J5!@AF`! @B!I?!@AB_AB>?!4@4!B3!HAJ[E5!CAB>!HAF\!

!

/% 25% A854@G2H89%E! @A3! CI>RAB>?! C>AK5??FA335E! 5?@! B3! D5E! 5c5HCE5! CAB>! HAF\!

<;5?C[>5!GB5!@B!5?!KF[>5!J5!HAF\! ! /%I954G&69889%E!E5!CEB?!IL53@B>F5>!J5!EI!KIHFEE5\! % /<J%+9A<6;9K!LMN9437%E%HI!@I3@5!*I>@F35`!HA3!A3RE5!=4>I>J`!HI!RAB?F35!'IB>5`! HA3!RAB?F3!(ZF5>>e`!HI!KFEE5BE5!%ZI>EF35!5@!'ABF?5!E5!D4D4!4RB>5BFE!GB5E!DA3Z5B>! J5!?5!>5@>ABL5>!P!RZIGB5!KAF?`!E5?!ARRI?FA3?!J5L>IF53@!?5!KIF>5!CEB?!K>4GB53@5?\! ! /%25%O9==9G>526==9%E!H5>RF!J5!H;ILAF>!IRR5C@45!IB!?5F3!J5!LA@>5!KIHFEE5\! ! !

(22)

! 6"!

/%29;%526;% % %

09<J%@<%$5647%)3;5689%E!%ZI3@IE`!$H4EF5`!04E[35`!<AfEE5!5@!$B>4EFI`!E5!@5HC?!CI??5`!

3AB?! 4LAEBA3?! RZIRB35! JI3?! J5?! JAHIF35?! JFKK4>53@?! HIF?! 3AB?! ILA3?! ?B! RA3?5>L5>! 3A@>5! IHF@F4! 53@>5! /I>F?`! 1AB53`! *IJ>FJ`! (ABEAB?5! 5@! HbH5! E5! *5cFGB5a! T>gR5! P! 3A?! ?AF>45?hi55jk53J! KFEE5?! GBF! E5! ?A3@! J5! HAF3?! 53! HAF3?a3;5?@!R5!CI?!(ZFDIBE@`!<BEF53`!-IHF53`!=>5T`!/F5>>5!5@!=I?CI>J\! ! /%*<?69%E!lBFD5>A3!5@!HA3!IJAE5?R53R5!3;IB>IF53@!CI?!4@4!E5?!HbH5?!?I3?!@AF\! ! /%$585L%E%GB5!E5!@5HC?!CI??5!LF@5!J5CBF?!R5@@5!KIH5B?5!/"!Am!3AB?!3AB?!?AHH5?! >53RA3@>45?!nDF53!?o>!?B>!E5?!"5>?!>I3T?!J5!E;IHCZFap\!.AB?!35!3AB?!?AHH5?!CEB?! GBF@@45?! _B?GB;P! R5?! @5>>FDE5! ?AB?kRAEE5?! J5! -Wa! /BF?! 3AB?! ILA3?! T>I3JF! B3! C5B! ?4CI>4H53@! 53! @I3@! GB;F3@5>35?\! *IF?! 3AB?! ?AHH5?! AB! IEEA3?! J5L53F>! H4J5RF3?! RAHH5!3AB?!E;ILA3?!@AB_AB>?!>bL4!53?5HDE5!5@!R5!?5>I!P!/I>F?a! ! /%0=M2947649%E!GB5!J5!DA3?!HAH53@?!CI??4?!53?5HDE5!J5CBF?!R5!KIH5Bc!q)+a! <;IF!Zg@5!J5!@5!>5@>ABL5>a!@B!5?!B35!IHF5!@>[?!RZ[>5!CAB>!HAF\! ! IP%97%#=3@69%E!3A?!IHF43AF?!C>4K4>4?\!23!I!@AB_AB>?!?B!?5!>5@>ABL5>!r!'I!C>ARZIF35! KAF?!R5EI!?5>I!C5B@!b@>5!53!S>5@IT35a! ! *3=3%97%/87L<8%E!3A?!T53@FE?!J4_I3@4?`!@AB_AB>?!EI!HIF3!?B>!E5!RdB>\!

(23)

! 66! /%*M45:%!L6O5<=7:%)M26549:%-5?L5:%97%5<%A83<D9%*59449?% % /<J%)3<94456;% % /=9J6;%E!H5>RF!P!EI!35B>ARZF>!r!%;5?@!53?5HDE5!GB5!E;A3!I!5??Be4!E5?!CEg@>5?! JB!J4DB@!J5!E;F3@5>3I@\!%5EI!3;IB>IF@!CI?!4@4!CI>5FE!?I3?!@AF\!(B!H;I?!IB??F!C5>HF?! J5! KIF>5! EI! >53RA3@>5! J5! -5869! 5@! CEB?! @I>J! J5! EI! C5@F@5! $585L\! <;5?C[>5! GB5! E;A3! >5?@5>I!J5?!IHF?!KFJ[E5?\!15?@5^!RAHH5!LAB?!b@5?\!

!

C=389%E! @B! KIF?! C>5?GB5! CI>@F5! J5! EI! KIHFEE5! J5?! ACZ@IEHAa\! (B! 5?! B35! J5?!

C>5HF[>5?!C5>?A335?!JA3@!_;IF!KIF@!EI!RA33IF??I3R5!P!1AB53`!5@!@B!3AB?!I?!@AB@!J5! ?BF@5!@53JB!E5?!D>I?\!15?@5!RAHH5!@B!5?\!

!

&69889% 97% I<=65%E! J5! DA3?! HAH53@?! CI??4?! 53?5HDE5`! C5B@! b@>5! GB5! E5! V"!

J4R5HD>5!C>ARZIF3!?5>I!53RA>5!B35!KAF?!IL5R!LAB?a! !

/<J%$5647G"6=568694;%E% %

'=6N698%E! RAHH53@! 35! CI?! @5! JF>5! H5>RF!r! *A3! F3@5>3I@! 3;IB>IF@! CI?! 4@4! E5!

HbH5!?I3?!@AF\!(B!I?!@AB_AB>?!?B!b@>5!JF?CA3FDE5!5@!J5!DA3?!RA3?5FE?!5@!sI!_B?GB;IB! DAB@!JB!DAB@\!.;5?@!CI?!B35!C4CF@5!GBF!L5B@!r!

(24)

! 6V!

&L6=6DD9%E! E5! CI>>IF3!r! (B! I?! ?B! H5@@>5! J5! EI! RABE5B>! JI3?! R5?! 8! I3345?!

J;F3@5>3I@\!(AB_AB>?!I@@53@FK!5@!IL5R!EI!HIF3!?B>!E5!RdB>\!15?@5!RAHH5!@B!5?\! !

'=6N698%E! @I! T53@FEE5??5! 3;I! J;4TIE! GB5! @I! >FTB5B>\! (B! I?! 4@4! B3! RZ5K! J5!

REF3FGB5!CI@F53@`!DF53L5FEEI3@!5@!@B!5?!B3!IHF!?F3R[>5\!

(25)

! 6W! /%=.MQ<6D9% % ! /%29;%?3G6479849;%E% ! /<J%N69<J%E!2EFLF5>!5@!SIJ!H5>RF!CAB>!LA@>5!JF?CA3FDFEF@4!GBI3J!_;IF!J4DB@4! 5@!GBF!3;I!_IHIF?!KIFEEF!CI>!EI!?BF@5\!04E[35!H5>RF!CAB>!@I!JABR5B>\! !

"M=5%Q! A3! ?;5?@! ?BFLF! @AB@! IB! EA3T! J5! 3A@>5! F3@5>3I@\! 1ILF5! J;ILAF>! _AB4! E5?!

53@>5H5@@5B?5?a! ! /@268%E!GB5EE5!KA>R5!J5!RI>IR@[>5`!_5!?BF?!IJHF>I@FL5!J5!@A3!CI>RAB>?\! ! #769449%E!E5!H5FEE5B>!RAkF3@5>35!GB5!E;A3!CBF??5!>bL5>\!<5!?BF?!Z5B>5B?5!J5! @;ILAF>!RAHH5!IHF\! ! R<6==5<29%E!E5!RZIHCFA3!J5?!ACZ@IEHA\! ! /=9J%E!EI!>5E[L5!J5!EI!35B>AkACZ@IEHAEATF5!5?@!53@>5!@5?!HIF3?a! ! *5<85%E!H5>RF!CAB>!@I!DA335!ZBH5B>!5@!@I!?FHCEFRF@4\! ! !L6O5<=7%E!E5!C>5^!J5?!ACZ@IEHA\!(AB_AB>?!C>b@!P!>53J>5!?5>LFR5!5@!P!KIF>5!EI! Kb@5\!

(26)

! 68! !

S6==652%E!E5!?BC5>!CICI!JB!T>ABC5\!

!

/% =5% 89=HN9%E! %ZEA4`! E5?! CIB?5?! F3KA?! H5! HI3GB5>A3@`! )EAJF5`! HA3! JABDE5`!

A3!3;I!CI?!E5!HbH5!C>43AH!CAB>!>F53a)JABI>J!E5!C>ARZIF3!C>AK5??5B>r!-I3F5E!E5! D4D4!ACZ@IEHA\! ! ! /<J%?L9>;%E% % I<=69%E!@B!5?!CAB>!HAF!B3!5c5HCE5!J5!>FTB5B>!5@!J5!C>AK5??FA33IEF?H5\! ! /=9J%E%@AB_AB>?!P!>5KIF>5!E5!HA3J5\!%5?!JF?RB??FA3?!H5!HI3GB5>A3@\! % /=6?9%E!R;5?@!@AB_AB>?!B3!CEIF?F>!J5!KIF>5!J5!EI!C4JFI@>F5!IL5R!@AF\! ! &988649%E!DF53!CEB?!GB;B35!RZ5K\!lB5!J5!DA3?!HAH53@?!CI>@IT4?!53?5HDE5\! (AB?!E5?!C>A_5@?!JA3@!@B!>bLIF?!?5!>4IEF?53@!B3!P!B3a!_5!?BF?!Z5B>5B?5!CAB>!@AF\! % /%=5%?34;<=7.%E!GB5EE5!4GBFC5!J5!RZARa!@AB_AB>?!EP!CAB>!LA?!KFEE5?\!*ITIEF`!%ZI3@IE`!

'IB>53R5`! .I@ZIEF5`! %I@Z5>F35`! 9ACZF5! 5@! EI! C5@F@5! .I@ZIEF5! LAB?! IEE5^! >45EE5H53@! H5!HI3GB5>\!+HCA??FDE5!J5!>5@>ABL5>!IB@I3@!J5!@53J>5??5\!

(27)

! 6O!

/%=.L3;D67.%E!GB5!J5!KAB?!>F>5?!53@>5!EI!?IEE5!J5!?AF3?!5@!E;AKKFR5a!

!

/<J% 387L3D76;79;%E% H5>RF! P! 9ACZF5`! -I3e`! *I>F5k/IBE5! 5@! 9ACZF5! CAB>! LA@>5!

JF?CA3FDFEF@4!@AB_AB>?!IL5R!E5!?AB>F>5\! !

/<% O=3?%E!@AB_AB>?!J5?!DA3?!HAH53@?!CI>@IT4?!53@>5!E5?!C5@F@?!RA3?5FE?!C5>?A!5@!

E5?!J5>3F5>?!>ITA@?!IB@AB>!J5?!EILIDA?a! !

/<J% ;9?8M75689;%E! Y4>A`! *e>FIH`! *IEFjI`! $3T[E5! @AB_AB>?! ?F! CI@F53@5?! 5@!

JF?CA3FDE5?!CAB>!3AB?\!! ! )9298?692947;%D5876?<=698;%T%E% % /4@8M%E!CAB>!@A3!IFJ5!C>4RF5B?5!CAB>!EI!>4IEF?I@FA3!J5?!?@I@F?@FGB5?\!! ! /<J%3?<=586;79;:%-8%97%-29%+<854@%97%-8%U<94764%E!H5>RF!CAB>!LA@>5!IFJ5!J5?! H5?B>5?!J5?!C>A@Z[?5?\! % %

(28)

! 6X! % % % % % % /%234%2586%+52694% % (5!>53RA3@>5>`!FE!e!I!DF53@]@!"7!I3?!I!4@4!EI!CEB?!D5EE5!RZA?5!GBF!CBF??5!H;I>>FL5>\! <5!35!CAB>>IF?!FHITF35>!HI!LF5!?I3?!@AF\!lB5!J;4@IC5?!J4_P!CI>RAB>B5?!P!@5?! RA@4?a!5@!FE!53!>5?@5!53RA>5!@I3@!P!CI>@IT5>!5@!P!>4IEF?5>\!<;IF!@5EE5H53@!Zg@5!J5! KA3J5>!3A@>5!C>AC>5!C5@F@5!KIHFEE5a! /5>?A335!35!H5!RAHC>53J!IB??F!DF53!GB5!@AF\!(B!5?!EP!P!RZIGB5!F3?@I3@`!IL5R!@AF!EI! LF5!5?@!?F!KIRFE5a!@B!5?!HA3!RIC!IB!_AB>!E5!_AB>\! 15sAF?!FRF!@AB@5!EI!C>5BL5!J5!HA3!IHAB>\! ! !

(29)

! 6N!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

%A>>5R@FA3!JB!?e3J>AH5!J5!E;43BRE45!CI>!

F3_5R@FA3!J;ZeJ>AT5E!

!

!

(30)

! 6M!

+,##-&$"*

* )9298?692947;%VVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVV%WX! $3225689%VVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVV%YZ! ,4783@<?7634%VVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVV%[W! ,K! )5DD9=;%VVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVV%[[! WK! /4573269%VVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVV%[[! WV/%K%-94;<857634;%VVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVV%[\! WVP%K%*9;%D5836;%@9%=.38O679%VVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVV%[X! WV0%K%*9;%O38@;%3<%54A=9;%@9%=.38O679%VVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVV%[]! WV+%K%'86>6?9%547M869<8%3<%O5;9%@9%=.38O679%VVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVV%[Z! WV#%K%$32297%3<%5D9J%38O675689%VVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVV%[Z! WVC%K%'86>6?9;%@9%=.38O679%VVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVV%[Z! WVR%K%&M863;79%38O675689%VVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVV%\^! WV"%K%*9;%85DD387;%6479849;%VVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVV%\W! YK! ,4@6?57634;%@9;%M4<?=M57634;GMN6;?M857634;%VVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVV%\Z! [K%+9;?86D7634%@9;%M4<?=M57634;GMN6;?M857634;%VVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVV%X^! [V/%K%#N6;?M857634%VVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVV%X^! [VP%K%#4<?=M57634%VVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVV%XZ! \K! ,2D=547;%VVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVV%_W! \V/%K%,2D=547;%38O675689;%VVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVV%_W! \VP%K%&837LH;9;%VVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVV%_\! XK! 032D=6?57634;%VVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVV%__!

(31)

! V7! XV/%K%#JD3;67634%97%9J78<;634%@9%=.62D=547%VVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVV%__! XVP%K&73;6;%VVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVV%_`! XV0%K%#?783D634%;<8%?5N67M%543DL75=29%VVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVV%_]! XV+%K%#4783D634%@<%O38@%?6=65689%VVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVV%_]! XV#%K%)M785?7634%@9;%?5N67M;%97%?34785?7<89%@9%>3846J%?34a34?76N5<J%VVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVV%_Z! _K! &86;9%94%?L58A9%@<%;b4@8329%@9%=.M4<?=MM%VVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVV%`Y! _V/%K%,2D=54757634%;3<;GDM863;7M9%VVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVV%`Y! _VP%K*9;%,2D=547;%64785G38O675689;%VVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVV%`\! _V0%K%*5%A89>>9%@9823GA856;;9<;9%9J785G?346Q<9%VVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVV%``! _V+%K%*9;%64a9?7634;%64785G38O675689;%VVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVV%`Z! ,,K! #7<@9%?=646Q<9%VVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVV%Z^! 'Oa9?76>;%@9%=.M7<@9%VVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVV%Z^! -57M869=;%97%-M7L3@9;%VVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVV%Z^! )M;<=757;%VVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVV%Z]! +6;?<;;634%VVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVV%W^_! 034?=<;634%VVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVV%WW]! )M>M894?9;%VVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVV%WWZ! )M;<2M%VVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVV%WY`! !

*

*

(32)

! V"!

.'($,/0%(&,'*

'5!?e3J>AH5!J5!E;43BRE44!?B>LF53@!@>[?!K>4GB5HH53@!JI3?!E5?!?BF@5?!J;B35! 43BRE4I@FA3! AB! J;B35! 4LF?R4>I@FA3`! HbH5! IL5R! B3! FHCEI3@! @43A3F53! J5! LAEBH5! RA>>5R@\! +E! RAHCA>@5! B35! 43ACZ@IEHF5`! B35! DI?RBE5! CA?@4>Ak?BC4>F5B>5! J5! EI! C>A@Z[?5!ARBEIF>5!IL5R!HI_A>I@FA3!JB!R>5Bc!?B?kCIEC4D>IE`!5@!B3!C@A?F?!P!E;A>FTF35! J5!>5@53@F??5H53@?!5?@Z4@FGB5?!5@!C?eRZA?ARFIBc\!

'I!K>4GB53R5!J5!R5!?e3J>AH5!5@!?5?!>4C5>RB@FA3?!?ARFIE5?!34R5??F@53@!B35! @Z4>IC5B@FGB5!IJIC@45!5@!C5>?A33IEF?45!53!KA3R@FA3!J5!?A3!FHCA>@I3R5\!

'I! C>F?5! 53! RZI>T5! REI??FGB5! J5! R5?! CI@F53@?! ?5! KIF@! ZIDF@B5EE5H53@! CI>!E5?! FHCEI3@?! ?AB?! C4>FA?@4?`! E5?! T>5KK5?! J5>HAkT>IF??5B?5?! AB! EFCA?@>BR@B>5?! 5@! E5?! F3_5R@FA3?! J;IRFJ5! ZeIEB>A3FGB5! n"tVp\! %5?! @5RZ3FGB5?! C5BL53@! b@>5?! B@FEF?45?! ?5BE5?!5@!4TIE5H53@!J5!KIsA3!IJJF@FA335EE5!AB!?BRR5??FL5\!

!

'5?!FHCEI3@?!53!ZeJ>AT5E!?A3@!RA33B?!J5CBF?!E5?!I3345?!"MM7!nW`8p!5@!?A3@! B@FEF?4?!CAB>!EI!RA>>5R@FA3!J5?!HFR>ACZ@IEHF5?!?4L[>5?!5@!J5?!I3ACZ@IEHF5?!IL5R! J;I??5^!DA3?!>4?BE@I@?!JI3?!EI!EF@@4>I@B>5\!!

';ZeJ>AT5E! 5?@! B3! HI@4>FIB! ZIB@5H53@! ZeJ>ACZFE5! RAHCA?4! J5! .k LF3eECe>>AEFJA35!5@!J5!H4@ZeE!H4@ZIR>eEI@5\!'u5IB!JB!@F??B!53LF>A33I3@!5?@!JA3R! I@@F>45! CI>! A?HA?5! C5>H5@@I3@! E;IB@Ak5cCI3?FDFEF@4! J5! E;FHCEI3@\! '5?! 5cCI3?5B>?! ?A3@!HF3FHIE5H53@!F3LI?FK?`!KIRFE5?!P!F3?@IEE5>`!5@!DFARAHCI@FDE5?!nOp\!

-FKK4>53@5?!KA>H5?!?A3@!P!3A@>5!JF?CA?F@FA3!IR@B5EE5H53@!JI3?!E5!RIJ>5!J5!EI! R>AF??I3R5!A>DF@IF>5`!CI>HF!5EE5?!E5?!J5HFk?CZ[>5?`!E5?!?CZ[>5?!5@!E5?!C5EE5@?\!)EE5?! CI>@FRFC53@! IBc! JFKK4>53@5?! 4@IC5?! J5! EI! >5RA3?@>BR@FA3! J5! R5?! A>DF@5?!

(33)

! V6! HFR>ACZ@IEH5?`! IB! RAB>?! J5?! "[>5?! I3345?! J5! LF5! T>gR5! IB! RI>IR@[>5! C5B! @>IBHI@F?I3@!J5!R5@@5!RZF>B>TF5!5@!P!?I!>ICFJF@4!J;5c4RB@FA3\!'I!C>AR4JB>5!J5!R5@@5! >4ZIDFEF@I@FA3!5?@!DF53!RAJFKF45!IL5R!RAHH5!C>5HF[>5!4@IC5`!EI!C>F?5!53!RZI>T5!J5! EI!R>AF??I3R5!J5?!CIBCF[>5?!5@!J5?!RBE?!J5!?IR!T>gR5!IBc!J5HFk?CZ[>5?!5cCI3?FL5?! 5@!IL5R!RAHH5!J5BcF[H5!4@IC5`!EI!R>AF??I3R5!A??5B?5!GBF!?5>I!T4>45!CI>!EI!HF?5! 53! CEIR5! J;B35! ?CZ[>5! 5cCI3?FL5! nW`8`Xt"8p\! '5?! C5EE5@?! ?A3@! B@FEF?4?! 53! >4@>Ak ARBEIF>5!IKF3!J5!HI_A>5>!E5!LAEBH5!A>DF@IF>5!nNt"7p\!

%A3R5>3I3@! EI! RA>>5R@FA3! J5?! ?e3J>AH5?! J5! E;43BRE44! IL5R! B3! FHCEI3@! @43A3F53!J5!LAEBH5!RA>>5R@`!IBRB35!4@BJ5!3;4LIEB5!EI!C5>@F353R5!J5!EI!@5RZ3FGB5! J5?! T>IF3?! J;ZeJ>AT5E\! -I3?! R5@@5! F3JFRI@FA3`! E;AD_5R@FK! 3;5?@! CI?! J;F3JBF>5! B35! R>AF??I3R5!A??5B?5!CBF?GB;FE!?;ITF@!E5!CEB?!?ABL53@!J5!RILF@4?!v!HI@B>5?!w!IeI3@!5B! B35! R>AF??I3R5! RAHCE[@5! HIF?! DF53! J5! RAHDE5>! B3! J4KFRF@! LAEBH4@>FGB5! ?4GB5EEIF>5\!

/AB>! R5@@5! @5RZ3FGB5! J;F3_5R@FA3! J5! T>IF3?! J;ZeJ>AT5E`! E5?! ?5BE?! >4?BE@I@?! J4R>F@?! JI3?! EI! EF@@4>I@B>5! 4LIEB53@! EI! RA>>5R@FA3! J5?! 53ACZ@IEHF5?! J5?! RILF@4?! HFR>ACZ@IEH5?! 5@! ?5HDE53@! @>[?! C>AH5@@5B>?! IL5R! @>[?! C5B! J;5KK5@?! ?5RA3JIF>5?! nXt"7`"O`"Xp\!

%5@@5! H4@ZAJ5! J;F3_5R@FA3! J5! T>IF3?! J;ZeJ>AT5E! ?5HDE5! IB! HbH5! @F@>5! GB5! E5?!IB@>5?!@5RZ3FGB5?!J4_P!RA33B5?!5@!B@FEF?45?!53!C>I@FGB5!RAB>I3@5`!RAHC53?5>! B35! C5>@5! J5! LAEBH5! A>DF@IF>5! HAJ4>45! RZ5^! J5?! CI@F53@?! C>4?53@I3@! B3! ?e3J>AH5!J5!E;43BRE44\!

! ';AD_5R@FK!J5!R5!@>ILIFE!5?@!J5!C>4?53@5>!E5?!>4?BE@I@?!J5?!F3_5R@FA3?!J5!

(34)

! VV!

.1* !-22"3)*

41* 5'-(,#&"*

'5?!RILF@4?!A>DF@IF>5?!?A3@!?F@B45?!J5!RZIGB5!R]@4!J5?!KA??5?!3I?IE5?`!53@>5! E;4@IT5! I3@4>F5B>! JB! R>g35! 5@! E5! HI??FK! KIRFIE\! )EE5?! RA3@F53353@! 5@! C>A@[T53@! E5?! A>TI35?!J5!E;ICCI>5FE!J5!EI!LF?FA3`!53!CI>@FRBEF5>!E5?!TEAD5?!ARBEIF>5?!5@!E5?!HB?RE5?! ARBEAHA@5B>?\! %ZIRB35! J5?! A>DF@5?! I! EI! KA>H5! J;B35! Ce>IHFJ5! GBIJ>I3TBEIF>5! JA3@!EI!DI?5!5?@!53!ILI3@!5@!E5!?AHH5@!53!I>>F[>5\!95C@!A?!ICCI>@53I3@!IBc!HI??FK?! KIRFIBc! 5@! R>g3F53?! CI>@FRFC53@! P! ?I! RA3?@F@B@FA3\! 23! J4R>F@! CAB>! RZIGB5! A>DF@5! W! CI>AF?! >4B3F5?! CI>! W! I3TE5?! AB! DA>J?`! B35! DI?5! 5@! B3! ?AHH5@\! -5! 3AHD>5Bc! A>FKFR5?!R>5B?4?!JI3?!E5?!CI>AF?!A??5B?5?!H5@@53@!53!RAHHB3FRI@FA3!E;A>DF@5!5@!E5?! >4TFA3?! LAF?F35?! 5@! C5>H5@@53@! E5! CI??IT5! J5?! I>@[>5?`! J5?! L5F35?! 5@! J5?! 35>K?! J5?@F34?!IB!TEAD5!ARBEIF>5!5@!P!?5?!I335c5?!nKFTB>5!"p\!

(35)

! VW! ! #FTB>5!"!Q!I3I@AHF5!A??5B?5!J5!E;A>DF@5!n"Np!

465*1*7"')0$-(&,')*

-I3?!E5!?53?!I3@4>AkCA?@4>F5B>`!EI!C>AKA3J5B>!J5!E;A>DF@5!5?@!J5!W8 HH!53! HAe5335\!

';A>FKFR5! I3@4>F5B>! AB! DI?5! J5! E;A>DF@5! H5?B>5! W7 HH! J5! EI>T5! CAB>! V8 HH! J5! ZIB@.!

'I!JF?@I3R5!?4CI>I3@!E5?!6!A>DF@5?!5?@!J5!6X!P!VV HH!RZ5^!E;IJBE@5.! '5!LAEBH5!J5!EI!RILF@4!A>DF@IF>5!5?@!5?@FH4!53!HAe5335!J5!6O!P!6N RHV\!

(36)

! V8!

468*1*9")*2-$,&)*/"*3:,$;&("*

!"#"!$%$&'()*$+,-.(*/,(/$),$-0'1)23$3/$04)(5*6/$ (>FI3TBEIF>5!P!DI?5!I3@4>F5B>5`!5EE5!5?@!KA>H45!CI>!6!A?xnKFTB>5!6p!Q! ';A?!K>A3@IE!53!ILI3@! 'I!C5@F@5!IFE5!JB!?CZ43AyJ5!53!I>>F[>5!

)EE5! ?4CI>5! E;A>DF@5! J5! E;4@IT5! I3@4>F5B>! J5! EI! DI?5! JB! R>g35! 5@! JB! ?F3B?! K>A3@IE\! -I3?!?I!CI>@F5!I3@4>F5B>5`!5EE5!C>4?53@5!53!J5ZA>?!EI!KA??5!EIR>eHIE5!Am!?5!EAT5!EI! TEI3J5! EIR>eHIE5! 5@! 53! J5JI3?! EI! KA??5@@5! @>ARZE4IF>5! Am! ?;F3?[>5! EI! @>ARZE45! JB! HB?RE5!ADEFGB5!?BC4>F5B>\!

(37)

! VO! !"#"7$%$&'()*$/86/(2/$),$0'6.('0/$ (>FI3TBEIF>5!P!DI?5!I3@4>F5B>5`!5EE5!5?@!RA3?@F@B45!CI>!V!A?xnKFTB>5!Vp!Q! )3!ZIB@!5@!53!ILI3@`!E;A?!K>A3@IE! )3!ZIB@!5@!53!DI?`!E;A?!^eTAHI@FGB5! )3!I>>F[>5`!EI!T>I3J5!IFE5!JB!?CZ43AyJ5! )EE5!?4CI>5!E;A>DF@5!J5!EI!KA??5!@5HCA>IE5!53!ILI3@!5@!J5!E;4@IT5!HAe53!J5!EI!DI?5! JB!R>g35!53!I>>F[>5\! #FTB>5!V!Q!J5??F3!I3I@AHFGB5!J5!EI!CI>AF!5c@5>35!J5!E;A>DF@5!n"Np! !

(38)

! VX! !"#"$9$%$&'()*$*21.(*/,(/$),$-0'2:;/($3/$04)(5*6/$ (>FI3TBEIF>5!P!DI?5!I3@4>F5B>5`!5EE5!5?@!KA>H45!CI>!V!A?!nKFTB>5!WpxQ! ';A?!^eTAHI@FGB5!53!ILI3@!5@!53!J5ZA>?! '5!HIcFEEIF>5!?BC4>F5B>!53!ILI3@!5@!53!J5JI3?! ';A?!CIEI@F3!53!I>>F[>5! ! )EE5!?4CI>5!E;A>DF@5!JB!?F3B?!HIcFEEIF>5\! #FTB>5!W!Q!J5??F3!I3I@AHFGB5!JB!CEI3RZ5>!J5!E;A>DF@5!n"Np! !

(39)

! VN!

!"#"<$%$&'()*$*26/(2/$),$=.3*'0/$

! lBIJ>FEI@[>5`! 5EE5! 5?@! RA3?@F@B45! CI>! W! A?\! -;ILI3@! 53! I>>F[>5`! R5! ?A3@! E5! HIcFEEIF>5! ?BC4>F5B>`! E;A?! EIR>eHIE`! E;5@ZHAyJ5! 5@! E5! ?CZ43AyJ5! nKFTB>5! 8p\! )EE5! ?4CI>5!E;A>DF@5!J5?!KA??5?!3I?IE5?`!J5?!?F3B?!5@ZHAyJIBc!5@!?CZ43AyJIBc\!

#FTB>5!8!Q!J5??F3!I3I@AHFGB5!J5!EI!CI>AF!F3@5>35!J5!E;A>DF@5!n"Np!

46<*1*9")*;,$/)*,0*-'=3")*/"*3:,$;&("*

'5?! W! CI>AF?! A>DF@IF>5?! ?A3@! >4B3F5?! 53@>5! 5EE5?! CI>! J5?! DA>J?! GBF! E5?! B3F??53@!6!P!6xQ!

SA>J!?BC4>Ak5c@5>35`!C>4?53@I3@!53!I>>F[>5!EI!KF??B>5!A>DF@IF>5!?BC4>F5B>5! SA>J!F3K4>Ak5c@5>35`!C>4?53@I3@!53!I>>F[>5!EI!KF??B>5!A>DF@IF>5!F3K4>F5B>5! SA>J!F3K4>AkF3@5>35`!RAHC>53I3@!53!ILI3@!E;A>FKFR5!JB!RI3IE!EIR>eHAk3I?IE! SA>J!?BC4>AkF3@5>35\!

(40)

! VM!

46>*1*?$&@&%"*-'(A$&"0$*,0*;-)"*/"*3:,$;&("*

'I!DI?5!J5!E;A>DF@5!I!EI!KA>H5!J;B3!GBIJ>FEI@[>5\!9A3!RA3@AB>!ICC5E4!>5DA>J! A>DF@IF>5!5?@!RA3?@F@B4!Q! )3!ZIB@!CI>!E;I>RIJ5!A>DF@IF>5!J5!E;A?!K>A3@IE! )3!J5ZA>?!CI>!E;A?!K>A3@IE!53!ZIB@!5@!E;A?!^eTAHI@FGB5!53!DI?! )3!DI?!CI>!E;A?!^eTAHI@FGB5!53!J5ZA>?!5@!E5!HIcFEEIF>5!?BC4>F5B>!53! J5JI3?! )3!J5JI3?!CI>!EI!R>b@5!EIR>eHIE5!I3@4>F5B>5\! !

46B*1*+,##"(*,0*-2"C*,$;&(-&$"*

+E!>4CA3J!P!E;5c@>4HF@4!F3@5>35!J5!EI!KF??B>5!A>DF@IF>5!?BC4>F5B>5\!&3!C5B!IBk J5??B?!5@!53!J5JI3?!J5!EBF!?5!@>ABL5!E;A>FKFR5!JB!RI3IE!AC@FGB5\!

46D*1*?$&@&%")*/"*3:,$;&("*

!">"!$%$?/$:'2'0$)-6*@,/$

%>5B?4! 53@>5! E5?! J5Bc! >IRF35?! J5! EI! C5@F@5! IFE5! JB! ?CZ43AyJ5`! FE! KIF@! RAHHB3FGB5>!E;A>DF@5!5@!E;4@IT5!I3@4>F5B>!J5!EI!DI?5!J5!R>g35\!+E!EFL>5!CI??IT5!IB! 35>K!AC@FGB5`!53@AB>4!J5!?5?!H43F3T5?!5@!P!E;I>@[>5!ACZ@IEHFGB5\!

(41)

! W7! !">"7$%$?'$1*++,(/$)(5*6'*(/$+,-.(*/,(/$),$1/26/$+-;.2)A3'0/$ 2DEFGB5!53!ZIB@`!53!ILI3@!5@!53!J5ZA>?`!5EE5!KIF@!RAHHB3FGB5>!E;A>DF@5!IL5R!E;4@IT5! HAe53!J5!EI!DI?5!J5!R>g35\!)EE5!EFL>5!CI??IT5!P!J5!3AHD>5Bc!4E4H53@?xQ! '5?!D>I3RZ5?!?BC4>F5B>5!5@!F3K4>F5B>5!JB!35>K!ARBEAHA@5B>!RAHHB3!n+++p! '5!35>K!ARBEAHA@5B>!5c@5>35!nY+p! '5!35>K!CI@Z4@FGB5!n+Yp! '5!35>K!3I?AkRFEFIF>5!

'5?! 35>K?! EIR>eHIE! 5@! K>A3@IE! nD>I3RZ5?! JB! Yp\! %5! ?A3@! J5?! D>I3RZ5?! J5! JFLF?FA3! JB! 35>K! ACZ@IEHFGB5! GBF! 3Iz@! J5! EI! CI>@F5! I3@4>AkF3@5>35! JB! TI3TEFA3!J5!=I??5>!

'5?!L5F35?!ACZ@IEHFGB5?!?BC4>F5B>5!5@!F3K4>F5B>5\!

!">"9$%$?'$1*++,(/$)(5*6'*(/$*21.(*/,(/$),$1/26/$+-;.2)B='8*00'*(/$

)EE5! KIF@! RAHHB3FGB5>! E;A>DF@5! IL5R! EI! KA??5! C@4>eTAkCIEI@F35\! '5?! @>AB?! 5@ZHAyJIBc! I3@4>F5B>! 5@! CA?@4>F5B>`! EFL>53@! CI??IT5! IBc! I>@[>5?! 5@! IBc! 35>K?! 5@ZHAyJIBc`!E5!35>K!I3@4>F5B>!5@!E5!35>K!CA?@4>F5B>\!

46E*1*FA$&,)("*,$;&(-&$"*

%;5?@!B35!H5HD>I35!KFD>5B?5!5@!HF3R5!GBF!@ICF??5!E;53?5HDE5!J5?!CI>AF?!J5! E;A>DF@5\! %5! C4>FA?@5! KA>H5! B3! L4>F@IDE5! ?IR! C4>FA?@4! GBF! EFHF@5! E5! RA3@53B! A>DF@IF>5\!

(42)

! W"!

46G*1*9")*$-22,$()*&'("$'")*

!"C"!$%$?'$D('*++/$)(5*6'*(/$

'I! T>IF??5! A>DF@IF>5! AB! RAB??F35@! IJFC5Bc! J5! E;A>DF@5! >5HCEF@! E5?! 5?CIR5?! F3@>I! 5@! C4>FHB?RBEIF>5?\! )EE5! 5?@! KA>H45! J5! EADBE5?! IJFC5Bc! ?4CI>4?! E5?! B3?! J5?! IB@>5?!CI>!J5!HF3R5?!REAF?A3?!RA3_A3R@FLIE5?\!

!"C"7$%$?/+$=,+:0/+$):,0)=)6/,(+$

'I! HA@FEF@4! JB! TEAD5! ARBEIF>5! 5?@! I??B>45! CI>! O! HB?RE5?! ARBEAHA@5B>?! nKFTB>5! Op`! RAHC>53I3@! W! HB?RE5?! J>AF@?! 5@! 6! HB?RE5?! ADEFGB5?\! %5?! HB?RE5?! KA>H53@!B3!R]35!P!?AHH5@!CA?@4>F5B>!5@!P!DI?5!I3@4>F5B>5\!

#FTB>5!O!Q!E5?!HB?RE5?!ARBEAHA@5B>?!n"Mp!

(43)

! W6!

"#!$%&!'(&)*%&!+,-./&!

+E?!?A3@!IB!3AHD>5!J5!W!Q!J>AF@!H4JFIE`!J>AF@!F3K4>F5B>`!J>AF@!EI@4>IE!5@!J>AF@! ?BC4>F5B>\

'86A649%E! R5?! HB?RE5?! C>53353@! A>FTF35! IB! ?AHH5@! J5! E;A>DF@5! CI>! B3! @53JA3! RAHHB3!ICC5E4!@53JA3!J5!UF33!GBF!?;F3?[>5!?B>!E5!RA>C?!JB!?CZ43AyJ5`!IB!3FL5IB! JB! @BD5>RBE5! ?AB?! AC@FGB5\! %5! @53JA3! ?5! JFLF?5! 53! W! DI3J5E5@@5?`! RZIGB5! HB?RE5! J>AF@! ?;F3?[>5! ?B>! 6! DI3J5E5@@5?! IJ_IR53@5?\! '5! KIF?R5IB! J;A>FTF35! JB! J>AF@! EI@4>IE! C>4?53@5!53!>5TI>J!J5!EI!CA>@FA3!4EI>TF5!J5!EI!K53@5!?CZ43AyJIE5!B3!A>FKFR5!ICC5E4! E;I335IB! J5! UF33! GBF! EFL>5! CI??IT5! IBc! 6! D>I3RZ5?! JB! 35>K! HA@5B>! ARBEIF>5! RAHHB3!n+++p`!IB!35>K!HA@5B>!ARBEIF>5!5c@5>35!nY+p!5@!E5!35>K!3I?IE!nKFTB>5!Xp\!

#FTB>5!X!Q!LB5!J5!KIR5!JB!@53JA3!5@!J5!E;I335IB!J5!UF33!n"Mp! !

(44)

! WV!

!85a97%E!E5?!HB?RE5?!J>AF@?!?5!JF>FT53@!J;I>>F[>5!53!ILI3@`!JI3?!EI!EAT5!CA?@4>F5B>5!

J5!E;A>DF@5\!

!9826456;34%E! ?5! KIF@! ?B>! EI! CI>@F5! I3@4>F5B>5! J5! EI! ?RE4>A@FGB5`! P! C>AcFHF@4! JB!

EFHD5!nKFTB>5!Np\!

#FTB>5!N!Q!EI!?CF>IE5!J5!(FEEIBc`!IL5R!E;F3?5>@FA3!?RE4>IE5!J5?!HB?RE5?!J>AF@?!n"Mp! !

,4498N57634%E! E5! J>AF@! F3K4>F5B>! 5@! E5! J>AF@! H4JFIE! ?A3@! F335>L4?! CI>! EI! D>I3RZ5!

F3K4>F5B>5! JB! +++\! '5! J>AF@! ?BC4>F5B>! CI>! EI! D>I3RZ5! ?BC4>F5B>5! JB! +++! 5@! E5! J>AF@! EI@4>IE!CI>!E5!Y+\!

/?7634%E! E5! J>AF@! ?BC4>F5B>! 5?@! 4E4LI@5B>`! FE! ITF@! 53! ?e35>TF5! IL5R! E5! HB?RE5!

>5E5L5B>!J5!EI!CIBCF[>5!?BC4>F5B>5\%

'5!J>AF@!F3K4>F5B>!5?@!IDIF??5B>`!FE!5?@!I3@ITA3F?@5!JB!J>AF@!?BC4>F5B>\! '5!J>AF@!EI@4>IE!5?@!IDJBR@5B>\!

(45)

! WW!

0#!$%&!'(&)*%&!-0*.1(%&!

9A3@! IB! 3AHD>5! J5! J5Bc`! R>AF?I3@! ADEFGB5H53@! EuIc5! I3@4>AkCA?@4>F5B>! JB! TEAD5! ARBEIF>5\!

*9%2<;?=9%3O=6Q<9%;<DM869<8!

+E!5?@!E5!CEB?!EA3T!J5!@AB?!E5?!HB?RE5?!J5!EuA>DF@5!nKFTB>5!Mp\!

'86A649%E!CI>!B3!RAB>@!@53JA3`!KFc4!53!J5JI3?!5@!IBkJ5??B?!JB!@>AB!AC@FGB5\!

!85a97%E! FE! EA3T5! EuI3TE5! ?BC4>AkF3@5>35! J5! EuA>DF@5`! 5@! JA335! B3! @53JA3! GBF! ?5!

>4KE4RZF@!P!I3TE5!IFTB!JI3?!B35!CABEF5!J5!>4KE5cFA3!KFD>AkRI>@FEITF35B?5`!FHCEI3@45! JI3?!EI!KA??5@@5!@>ARZE4IF>5!JB!K>A3@IE{!CBF?!FE!>5J5LF53@!HB?RBEIF>5`!5@!RA3@AB>35! EI!CI>@F5!?BC4>F5B>5!JB!TEAD5!53!?5!CEIsI3@!?AB?!E5!J>AF@!?BC4>F5B>\!

#FTB>5!M!Q!E5!HB?RE5!ADEFGB5!?BC4>F5B>!n"Mp! !

(46)

! W8!

!9826456;34%E! CI>! B35! CA>@FA3! 4EI>TF5`! ?B>! EI! KIR5! ?BC4>Ak5c@5>35! J5!

E;Z4HF?CZ[>5!CA?@4>F5B>!J5!E;dFE\! ,4498N57634%E!CI>!E5!35>K!@>ARZE4IF>5!n+Yp\! /?7634%E!EA>?GB5!E;dFE!5?@!53!IJJBR@FA3!Q!E5!HB?RE5!ADEFGB5!?BC4>F5B>!5?@!IDIF??5B>`! EA>?GB5!E;dFE!5?@!53!IDJBR@FA3!E5!HB?RE5!ADEFGB5!?BC4>F5B>!5?@!>A@I@5B>!F3@5>35\! ! *9%2<;?=9%3O=6Q<9%64>M869<8% S5IBRABC!CEB?!RAB>@!{!Ru5?@!E5!?5BE!HB?RE5!GBF!35!?5!J4@IRZ5!CI?!JB!KA3J!J5! EuA>DF@5\! '86A649%E!53!J5ZA>?!J5!EuA>FKFR5!A>DF@IF>5!JB!RI3IE!EIR>eHAk3I?IE\! !85a97%E!JF>FT4!53!J5ZA>?!5@!53!I>>F[>5`!CI??I3@!?AB?!E5!J>AF@!F3K4>F5B>\! !9826456;34%E!?B>!EI!KIR5!F3K4>Ak5c@5>35!J5!EuZ4HF?CZ[>5!CA?@4>F5B>!J5!E;dFE\! ,4498N57634%E!CI>!EI!D>I3RZ5!F3K4>F5B>5!JB!35>K!HA@5B>!ARBEIF>5!%AHHB3!n+++p\! /?7634Q! EA>?GB5! E;dFE! 5?@! 53! IJJBR@FA3! E5! HB?RE5! ADEFGB5! F3K4>F5B>! 5?@! 4E4LI@5B>`!

EA>?GB5! E;dFE! 5?@! 53! IDJBR@FA3! E5! HB?RE5! ADEFGB5! F3K4>F5B>! 5?@! >A@I@5B>! 5c@5>35\! %;5?@!E;I3@ITA3F?@5!JB!HB?RE5!ADEFGB5!?BC4>F5B>\!

)#!$%&!2".3%&!'(&)(*".,%&!%/!*"!)"4&(*%!+%!5%3-3!

*9;%A5649;%2<;?<=5689;!

)EE5?! ?;4@IE53@! JuILI3@! 53! I>>F[>5! ?B>! RZIRB3! J5?! HB?RE5?! J5! E;A>DF@5\! %5EE5! JB!>5E5L5B>!J5!EI!CIBCF[>5!?BC4>F5B>5!5?@!>5EF45!P!R5EE5!JB!J>AF@!?BC4>F5B>`!R5!GBF! C5>H5@!EI!?e35>TF5!KA3R@FA335EE5!J5?!J5Bc!HB?RE5?\!%5EE5?!J5?!HB?RE5?!J>AF@?!?A3@! >4B3F5?!53@>5!5EE5?!CI>!J5?!H5HD>I35?!F3@5>kHB?RBEIF>5?!GBF!RAHCE[@53@!E5!R]35!

(47)

! WO! HB?RBEIF>5\! )EE5?! C>4?53@53@! J5?! C>AEA3T5H53@?! A>DF@IF>5?! GBF! ?5! KFc53@! ?B>! E5! >5DA>J!J5!E;A>DF@5!Q!R5!?A3@!E5?!IFE5>A3?!HB?RBEIF>5?\!

!

*5%?5D;<=9%@9%!9434!

)3!RA3@F3BF@4!53!I>>F[>5!IL5R!EI!TIF35!JB!35>K!AC@FGB5`!5EE5!53@AB>5!53!ILI3@! EuZ4HF?CZ[>5! CA?@4>F5B>! J5! E;dFE! 5@! 5?@! ?4CI>45! J5! EI! ?RE4>A@FGB5! CI>! B3! @F??B! R5EEBE5Bc! @>[?! EgRZ5! nEu5?CIR5! J5! (53A3p\! $F3?F! 5?@! >4IEF?45! 53@>5! EI! RIC?BE5! 5@! E5! TEAD5!B35!L4>F@IDE5!I>@FRBEI@FA3!53!>A@BE5!GBF!C5>H5@!E5?!HABL5H53@?!J5!>A@I@FA3! J5! E;dFE\! /EB?! 53! ILI3@`! EI! RIC?BE5! J5! (53A3! ?5! HbE5! IBc! TIF35?! HB?RBEIF>5?! 5@! 53LAF5!J5?!5cCI3?FA3?!I3@4>F5B>5?!IBc!CIBCF[>5?!5@!P!EI!RA3_A3R@FL5!nKFTB>5!"7p\!

!

(48)

! WX!

!"C"9$%$?/$D0)5/$):,0'*(/$

2>TI35! 3ADE5! J5! EI! LF?FA3`! FE! 5?@! C>A@4T4! CI>! EI! RA3_A3R@FL5`! E5?! CIBCF[>5?`! E5?!HB?RE5?!ARBEAHA@5B>?!5@!EI!RILF@4!A>DF@IF>5\! +E!?;ITF@!J;B35!?CZ[>5!J5!O`8!RHV!IL5R!B35!EA3TB5B>!IcFIE5!J5!6V!HH\! (>AF?!@B3FGB5?!E5!RAHCA?53@!J5!J5ZA>?!53!J5JI3?!Q!EI!?RE[>5`!E;BL45!RAHCA?45!CI>! EI!RZA>AyJ5`!E5?!RA>C?!RFEFIF>5?!5@!E;F>F?!5@!53KF3!EI!>4@F35\! 'I!C>AC>F4@4!>4K>IR@FL5!J5!E;dFE!5?@!I??B>45!CI>!E5?!HFEF5Bc!@>I3?CI>53@?!GBF!?A3@! RA3?@F@B4?!J;ILI3@!53!I>>F[>5!CI>!EI!RA>345`!E5!R>F?@IEEF3!5@!E5!LF@>4!nKFTB>5!""p\! #FTB>5!""!Q!RABC5!?ITF@@IE5!JB!TEAD5!ARBEIF>5!n"Mp!

(49)

! WN! !"C"<$%$?'$D0'23/$0':(E='0/$ %u5?@!B35!TEI3J5!53!T>ICC5`!?F@B45!?AB?!E5!>5DA>J!A>DF@IF>5!?BC4>Ak5c@5>35\! 'uIFE5>A3!5c@5>35!JB!HB?RE5!>5E5L5B>!J5!EI!CIBCF[>5!?BC4>F5B>5!EI!JFLF?5!53!J5Bc! CA>@FA3?!F34TIE5?`!EI!CA>@FA3!A>DF@IF>5`!EI!CEB?!LAEBHF35B?5`!GBF!5?@!EAT45!JI3?!EI! KA??5@@5!EIR>eHIE5!J5!EuA?!K>A3@IE!5@!EI!CA>@FA3!CIEC4D>IE5`!?F@B45!JI3?!Eu4CIF??5B>! J5!EI!CIBCF[>5!?BC4>F5B>5`!?AB?!EI!CA>@FA3!A>DF@IF>5!GBu5EE5!>5_AF3@!53!I>>F[>5\!! %ZIGB5!CA>@FA3!CA??[J5!J5?!RI3IBc!5cR>4@5B>?!GBF!?uABL>53@!JI3?!E5!KA3J!JB!RBEk J5k?IR!RA3_A3R@FLIE!?BC4>F5B>\!

'uF335>LI@FA3! J5! EI! TEI3J5! EIR>eHIE5! C>F3RFCIE5! 5?@! I??B>45! CI>! E5! 35>K! EIR>eHIE!GBF!5?@!B35!D>I3RZ5!J5!EuACZ@IEHFGB5!J5!qFEEF?!nY"p\!

'I! TEI3J5! EIR>eHIE5! 5?@! B35! TEI3J5! 5cAR>F35! J5! @eC5! @BDBEAkIRF35Bc! 5@! P! ?@>BR@B>5!EADBEIF>5!nKFTB>5!"6p\!

(50)

! WM!

H1* .'/&%-(&,')*/")*A'0%3A-(&,')IAJ&)%A$-(&,')*

%A3R5>3I3@! B3! dFE! 3A3! KA3R@FA335E`! FE! 5?@! CI>KAF?! 34R5??IF>5! J;53E5L5>! ?A3! RA3@53B! AB! EI! @A@IEF@4! J5! E;dFE! CAB>! JFKK4>53@5?! >IF?A3?`! LF@IE5`! 5?@Z4@FGB5! 5@! I3@IETFGB5\!

'5?!C>F3RFCIE5?!RIB?5?!GB5!E;A3!>53RA3@>5!?A3@!n67pQ!

! 'I! CZ@e?5! JB! TEAD5! P! E;A>FTF35! J5! JABE5B>?! ?CA3@I345?! 5@! J;I@>ACZF5! IL5R! B35!JFHF3B@FA3!JF?T>IRF5B?5!JB!LAEBH5! ! '5!TEIBRAH5!34ALI?RBEIF>5!>4K>IR@IF>5!@>[?!JABEAB>5Bc!5@!F35?@Z4@FGB5! ! '5?!@BH5B>?!nH4EI3AH5!RZA>AyJF53`!>4@F3ADEI?@AH5p! ! '5?!CEIF5?!JB!TEAD5!C5>KA>I3@5?!AB!C434@>I3@5?!IL5R!AB!?I3?!RA>C?!4@>I3T5>! ! '5!J4RAEE5H53@!J5!>4@F35!RZ>A3FGB5! ! '5?!HIEKA>HI@FA3?!RA3T43F@IE5?! ! 'I!C>4L53@FA3!J;B35!ACZ@IEHF5!?eHCI@ZFGB5! ! )3!RI?!J;dFE!F3JAEA>5!5@!53!J5ZA>?!J5!CI@ZAEATF5!@BHA>IE5`!A3!5??IF5>I!IB! HIcFHBH! J5! RA3?5>L5>! E5! TEAD5\! -;B35! CI>@`! A3! C5B@! B@FEF?5>! J5?! HAe53?! J5! >4K5R@FA3!RA?H4@FGB5!RA3?5>LI3@!E5?!@F??B?!ARBEIF>5?`!?F!E5!LAEBH5!5@!E5!@A3B?!?A3@! ?@IDE5?!J5CBF?!J5?!I3345?!5@!53!ID?53R5!J5!?FT35!F3KEIHHI@AF>5`!RAHH5!E5!L5>>5! ?RE4>IE! I??ARF4! AB! 3A3! P! B3! >5RABL>5H53@! RA3_A3R@FLIE\! -;IB@>5! CI>@`! 53! RI?! J;4RZ5R! AB! J;FHCA??FDFEF@4! J5! R5?! @5RZ3FGB5?! A3! C5B@! ILAF>! >5RAB>?! P! B35! 4LF?R4>I@FA3!HF3FHF?I3@!EI!C5>@5!J5!LAEBH5!EA>?GB5!EI!?RE[>5!5?@!F3@IR@5\!-I3?!E5! RI?!RA3@>IF>5`!A3!IB>I!>5RAB>?!P!B35!43BRE4I@FA3\!)3!RI?!J5!CI@ZAEATF5!@BHA>IE5`! E;43BRE4I@FA3!IL5R!I3IEe?5!I3I@AHACI@ZAEATFGB5!5?@!H4JFRAkE4TIE5\!

(51)

! 87!

K1*>")%$&2(&,'*/")*A'0%3A-(&,')IAJ&)%A$-(&,')*

K65*1*BJ&)%A$-(&,'*

%;5?@! E;IDEI@FA3! JB! RA3@53B! ARBEIF>5! 53! TI>JI3@! EI! ?RE[>5`! E5?! HB?RE5?! ARBEAHA@5B>?`! E5! 35>K! AC@FGB5! 5@! 4L53@B5EE5H53@`! EI! CI>@F5! CA?@4>F5B>5! J5! EI! RA>345\! %5@@5! F3@5>L53@FA3! 5?@! >4IEF?45! ?AB?! I35?@Z4?F5! T434>IE5! E5! CEB?! ?ABL53@\! 23! JF?@F3TB5! 6! @5RZ3FGB5?! J;4LF?R4>I@FA3`! R5EE5! >4?4GBI3@! EI! RA>345! 5@! R5EE5! RA3?5>LI3@!EI!RA>345\!

9"F"!$%$FG'26'D/+$

23! >5@>ABL5! HAF3?! J5! HAJFKFRI@FA3?! J5! E;I3I@AHF5! A>DF@IF>5\! '5?! >ICCA>@?! 53@>5! E5?! HB?RE5?`! E5! TEAD5`! E5?! CIBCF[>5?! 5@! E5?! KA>3Fc! J5H5B>53@! F3RZI3T4?`! C5>H5@@I3@! B35! T>I3J5! ?@IDFEF@4! J5! EI! RILF@4\! %5@@5! @5RZ3FGB5! C5>H5@! B35! DA335! HA@FEF@4!J5!EI!C>A@Z[?5`!E5?!HB?RE5?!ARBEAHA@5B>?!>5?@I3@?!I@@IRZ4?!P!EI!?RE[>5\!+E! ?;ITF@!J;B35!C>AR4JB>5!@5RZ3FGB5!?FHCE5!n67p\!

9"F"7$%$H2:)2G.2*/26+$

%5@@5! @5RZ3FGB5! 3;5?@! CI?! 53LF?IT5IDE5! ?F! E;A3! ?B?C5R@5! B35! CI@ZAEATF5! @BHA>IE5`! 5EE5! C5B@! IBTH53@5>! E5! >F?GB5! J;ACZ@IEHF5! ?eHCI@ZFGB5! 5@! 35! C5>H5@! CI?!J;I3IEe?5!I3I@AHACI@ZAEATFGB5!RAHCE[@5!n67p\!

(52)

! 8"! 9"F"9$%$I*11.(/26/+$6/:;2*@,/+$:;*(,(D*:'0/+$ ! 67.&)8,"/.-3!3-3!)-3&%,7"/,.)%!9%:8,;&%!+%!*"!)-,38%<=!/%)>3.1(%!4,.3)%4&! "|p!2BL5>@B>5!J5!EI!RA3_A3R@FL5!?B>!VO7|! 6|p!'FD4>I@FA3!JB!CEI3!@43A3F53! V|p!$DEI@FA3!J5!EI!RA>345!! W|p!$DEI@FA3!J5!@AB@!E5!@F??B!BL4IE! 8|p!$C>[?!IDEI@FA3!J5!EI!RA>345`!J5!C5@F@?!@>IF@?!J5!>5K53J!?A3@!C>I@FGB4?!IB@AB>!J5! ! EuABL5>@B>5!?RE4>IE5!CAB>!C5>H5@@>5!EuF3@>AJBR@FA3!JuB3!HI@4>FIB!F35>@5!?AF@! 53!L5>>5!AB!53!H4@ZIR>eEI@5!J5!KA>H5!ALIEIF>5!AB!>A3J5!J5!@IFEE5!F3K4>F5B>5! AB!4TIE5!P!"N!HH\!$F3?F!EI!?RE[>5!5?@!F3@IR@5!HIF?!IL5R!B35!JFHF3B@FA3!J5?! LAEBH5?!FHCEI3@IDE5?\! O|p!#5>H5@B>5!Z5>H4@FGB5!J5!EI!?RE[>5!CI>!J5?!CAF3@?!J5!LFR>eE!8h7! X|p!#5>H5@B>5!?I3?!@53?FA3!JB!CEI3!@43A3F53!CI>!J5?!CAF3@?!53!&!J5!YFR>eE!8h7! N|p!/BF?!K5>H5@B>5!J5!EI!RA3_A3R@FL5!IC>[?!REFLIT5!JB!CEI3!RA3_A3R@FL5h!@53A3\! ! %5@@5!@5RZ3FGB5!3;5?@!CEB?!B@FEF?45!IR@B5EE5H53@`!RI>!J5CBF?!EuIL[35H53@!J5?! DFAHI@4>FIBc! RAEA3F?IDE5?! A3! C>4K[>5! JuIB@>5?! @5RZ3FGB5?! GBF! C5>H5@@53@! JuFHCEI3@5>!J5?!LAEBH5?!CEB?!FHCA>@I3@?!R5!GBF!JA335!B3!H5FEE5B>!>4?BE@I@!P!EA3T! @5>H5!5@!4LF@5!JILI3@IT5!E5!?e3J>AH5!J5!Eu43BRE44\!

(53)

! 86! 67.&)8,"/.-3!3-3!)-3&%,7"/,.)%!4",!*"!/%)>3.1(%!+%&!0"3+%*%//%&! )EE5!35!RA3?5>L5!CI?!EI!@A@IEF@4!JB!?5TH53@!I3@4>F5B>!J5!E;dFE!n6"p\! +E!?;ITF@!J5!EI!@5RZ3FGB5!GB5!3AB?!B@FEF?A3?!IR@B5EE5H53@!JI3?!E5!?5>LFR5\! ! /N5475A9;% E!IF?45!@5RZ3FGB5H53@!5@!>ICFJ5`!5EE5!C5>H5@!EuF3?5>@FA3!JuFHCEI3@?!J5!

@IFEE5! ?BKKF?I3@5! HbH5! 53! RI?! J5! CZ@e?5! FHCA>@I3@5`! 5@! C5>H5@! E5! 35@@AeIT5! RAHCE5@!J5!EI!?RE[>5!J5?!>4?FJB?!BL4IBc\

,4?34NM46947;% E! >F?GB5! Ju5cCA?F@FA3! JB! HI@4>F5E! CEB?! FHCA>@I3@! GBuIL5R! B35!

@5RZ3FGB5!RA3?5>LI@>FR5\! !92D;%3DM8573689;%E% "|p!/4>F@AHF5!RA3_A3R@FLIE5!EFHDFGB5!?B>!VO7|!nKFTB>5!"V!Ip 6|p!15C4>IT5!J5?!HB?RE5?!J>AF@?!?B>!?AF5!nKFTB>5!"V!Dp! V|p!)c4>[?5!J5!EI!RA>345!!nKFTB>5!"V!Rp! W|p!+3RF?FA3!J5!EI!?RE[>5!53@>5!E5?!HB?RE5?!J>AF@?!?B>!GB5EGB5?!HFEEFH[@>5?! nKFTB>5!"V!Jp! 8|p!-4RAEE5H53@!H4@FRBE5Bc!J5!EuBL45!I3@4>F5B>5!5@!CA?@4>F5B>5!CBF?!4LF?R4>I@FA3! C>AC>5H53@!JF@5!nKFTB>5!"V!5p! O|p!/>AEA3T5H53@!J5?!F3RF?FA3?!?RE4>IE5?!_B?GBuIB!35>K!AC@FGB5!CBF?!F3RF?FA3!

RF>RBEIF>5! J5! EI! ?RE[>5! 53! ILI3@! JB! 35>K! AC@FGB5! CAB>! AD@53F>! W! EIHD5IBc! ?RE4>IBc!C4JFRBE4?!?B>!B3!HB?RE5!J>AF@!nKFTB>5!"V!K!5@!Tp!

X|p!.5@@AeIT5!HF3B@F5Bc!J5!EI!?RE[>5!J5?!>4?FJB?!BL4IBc!?F!34R5??IF>5

N|p!+3?5>@FA3!J5!EuFHCEI3@!IL5R!B35!CF3R5!P!?BR>5!JA3@!EI!@IFEE5!I!4@4!J4@5>HF345!IB! ! C>4IEIDE5!CI>!B3!TIDI>F@!nKFTB>5!"V!Z!5@!Fp!

(54)

! 8V! M|p!#5>H5@B>5!JB!CEI3!?RE4>IE!IB!LFR>eE!8h7!53!RAHH53sI3@!CI>!E5?!EIHD5IBc!

?BC4>F5B>?!5@!F3K4>F5B>?!

"7|p! #5>H5@B>5! J5?! 6! IB@>5?! EIHD5IBc! ?RE4>IBc! GBF! LF53353@! RZ5LIBRZ5>! E5? ! C>4R4J53@?"!'5!JABDE5!>FJ5IB!?RE4>IE!JFHF3B5!E5!>F?GB5!Ju5cCA?F@FA3!

?5RA3JIF>5!J5!EuFHCEI3@!?I3?!>5@53@F??5H53@!?B>!EI!HADFEF@4!nKFTB>5!"V_!5@!jp ""|p!#5>H5@B>5!J5!EI!@53A3!CI>!J5?!CAF3@?!53!&!CI>!JB!LFR>eE!8h7!IC>[?!

F3JFLFJBIEF?I@FA3! 5@! REFLIT5! CI>! F3_5R@FA3! J5! ?4>BH! CZe?FAEATFGB5! JB! CEI3! RA3_A3R@FLIE!

"6|p!#5>H5@B>5!J5!EI!RA3_A3R@FL5!IB!LFR>eE!Oh7!nKFTB>5!"V!E!5@!Hp

"V|p!*F?5!53!CEIR5!JuB3!RA3KA>HI@5B>!_B?GBuP!EI!>4IEF?I@FA3!JuB35!C>A@Z[?5\!

(55)

! 8W! !

I! D!

R! J!

(56)

! 88! ! #FTB>5!"V!Q!E5?!JFKK4>53@5?!4@IC5?!J5!EI! @5RZ3FGB5!J;4LF?R4>I@FA3!CI>!DI3J5E5@@5?! nFHIT5?!F??B5?!J5!EI!?ARF4@4!#%+p! T! H! E! j! _! F! Z!

(57)

! 8O!

67.&)8,"/.-3!)-3&%,7"/,.)%!9)-3&%,7"/.-3!+%!*"!)-,38%<!

/N5475A9;% E! CI?! J5! RFRI@>FR5! I3@4>F5B>5! C>AKA3J5! 5@! JA3R! HAF3?! J5! >F?GB5!

Ju5cCA?F@FA3! J5! EuFHCEI3@! A>DF@IF>5\! +HCEI3@I@FA3! J;B35! DFEE5! J5! CEB?! T>I3J! JFIH[@>5!GB5!EA>?!J;B35!4LF?R4>I@FA3!3A3!RA3?5>LI@>FR5\!

,4?34NM46947;% E! CEB?! JFKKFRFE5! @5RZ3FGB5H53@! 5@! CEB?! EA3TB5\! .5@@AeIT5! BL4IE!

RAHCE5@!CEB?!JFKKFRFE5!P!RA3@>]E5>\!%AEA3F?I@FA3!J5!EI!DFEE5!CEB?!JFKKFRFE5!RI>!EI!?RE[>5! 5?@!EI>T5H53@!RA3?5>L45\!

!92D;% 3DM8573689;% E! IC>[?! C4>F@AHF5! EFHDFGB5`! A3! >4IEF?5! B35! j4>I@5R@AHF5!

EIH5EEIF>5!?B>!@AB@5!EI!RA>345\!

+3F@FIE5H53@`!B35!ABL5>@B>5!?RE4>IE5!4@IF@!>4IEF?45!53!@5HCA>IE!?AB?!E5!J>AF@!EI@4>IE! I??5^! EI>T5! CAB>! C5>H5@@>5! EuF3@>AJBR@FA3! JuB35! DFEE5! RAEA3F?IDE5! AB! 3A3\! -5?! K53b@>5?!J5!?RE[>5!4@IF53@!J4RABC45?!?AB?!RZIGB5!HB?RE5!J>AF@!CAB>!C5>H5@@>5!EI! RAEA3F?I@FA3!J5!EI!DFEE5!EA>?GBuB35!DFEE5!RAEA3F?IDE5!5?@!HF?5!53!CEIR5.

%u5?@! CAB>! R5@@5! >IF?A3! GB5! JuIB@>5?! @5RZ3FGB5?! A3@! 4@4! J4L5EACC45?! CAB>! R5?! HI@4>FIBc! RAEA3F?IDE5?! IKF3! JuIH4EFA>5>! EI! RAEA3F?I@FA3! J5! EI! DFEE5! 5@! JuFHCEI3@5>! J5?!DFEE5?!J5!@AB@!JFIH[@>5\

-5!3A?!_AB>?`!EI!?RE[>5!5?@!F3RF?45!J5!HI3F[>5!RF>RBEIF>5!?B>!VO7|!53!I>>F[>5! J5! E;F3?5>@FA3! J5?! HB?RE5?! J>AF@?! nKFTB>5?! "W! 5@! "8p! 5@! Eu4LF?R4>I@FA3! C>AC>5H53@! JF@5!5?@!C>I@FGB45\!'I!CA>@FA3!?RE4>IE5!CA?@4>F5B>5!5?@!Q!

k?AF@! RA3?5>L45`! R;5?@! EI! @5RZ3FGB5! J5! EI! CABC45! >B??5!Q! F3@>AJBR@FA3! J;B35! DFEE5!P!E;IFJ5!J;B35!CF3R5!P!?BR>5!53@>5!EI!RAGB5!?RE4>IE5!CA?@4>F5B>!5@!E5!?5TH53@! I3@4>F5B>`!C5>H5@@I3@!B35!HAF3?!DA335!RAEA3F?I@FA3!JB!DFAHI@4>FIB!nKFTB>5!"Wp\!

(58)

! 8X! !

!

#FTB>5!"W!Q!95EA3!EI!@5RZ3FGB5! J5!EI!vCABC45w`!HF?5!53!CEIR5!JuB35! DFEE5! 53@>5! EI! RAGB5! RA>34Ak?RE4>IE5! I3@4>F5B>5! HIF3@53B5! 53! CEIR5! CI>! ?5?! HB?RE5?! 5@! EI! RAGB5! ?RE4>IE5! CA?@4>F5B>5!HIF3@53B5!53!CEIR5!CI>! E5!35>K!AC@FGB5!n66p! ! ! ! ! k?AF@!>4?4GB45`!R;5?@!EI!@5RZ3FGB5!JB!CI>IRZB@5!Q!EI!CI>@F5!CA?@4>F5B>5!J5!EI! ?RE[>5!5@!E5!35>K!AC@FGB5!?A3@!?5R@FA334?!5@!53E5L4?`!CBF?!EI!DFEE5!5?@!KFc45!53@>5!E5?! HB?RE5?`!?AB?!EI!RA>345!5@!EI!?RE[>5!>5?@I3@5!n6"`66p!nKFTB>5!"8p\! ! #FTB>5!"8!Q!?5EA3!EI!@5RZ3FGB5!JB!v/I>IRZB@5w`!HF?5!53!CEIR5!JuB35!DFEE5!53!I>>F[>5! J5!EI!RAGB5!RA>34Ak?RE4>IE5!I3@4>F5B>5!53!CI??I3@!53!@5HCA>IE!?BC4>F5B>!P!EuIFJ5! JuB35!CF3R5!P!?BR>5!n66p!! !

(59)

! 8N!

67.&)8,"/.-3!"7%)!83()*8"/.-3!&(,!/"0*%!

)EE5! ?5! >ICC>ARZ5! J5! EI! @5RZ3FGB5! Ju43BRE4I@FA3! J4R>F@5! RFkJ5??AB?\! )EE5! RA3?F?@5!P!C>I@FGB5>!B35!43BRE4I@FA3!CBF?!P!>4IEF?5>!Eu4LF?R4>I@FA3!?B>!@IDE5!CAB>! 53! >4RBC4>5>! EI! ?RE[>5! 5@! 53! 53L5EACC5>! EuFHCEI3@! A>DF@IF>5! IC>[?! ILAF>! C>I@FGB4! E5?!ABL5>@B>5?!34R5??IF>5?!P!EI!DFARAEA3F?I@FA3!nKFTB>5!"Op!n6"p\! #FTB>5!"O!Q!4LF?R4>I@FA3!?B>!@IDE5!nFHIT5?!JB!?5>LFR5p`! Ip >4RBC4>I@FA3!J5!EI!?RE[>5`! Dp RZAFc!J5!E;FHCEI3@!P!E;IFJ5!J;B3!TIDI>F@`! Rp >5HCEF??IT5!J5!EI!DFEE5!?AB?!LFJ5!CI>!J5! E;I35?@Z4?FGB5`! Jp !>5RABL>5H53@!J5!EI!DFEE5!CI>!EI!?RE[>5`! 5p F3?5>@FA3!JI3?!E;A>DF@5!P!E;IFJ5!J;B35!CF3R5!P!?BR>5! ! ! I! 5! J! R! D!

(60)

! 8M!

K68*1*B'0%3A-(&,'*

';43BRE4I@FA3! RA3?F?@5! 53! E;IDEI@FA3! JB! TEAD5! ARBEIF>5! 53! >5?C5R@I3@! E5?! HB?RE5?!ARBEAHA@5B>?`!5@!53!?5R@FA33I3@!53!I>>F[>5!E5!35>K!AC@FGB5!P!JF?@I3R5!JB! C]E5!CA?@4>F5B>!n67p\!

)EE5!?5!C>I@FGB5!E5!CEB?!?ABL53@!?AB?!I35?@Z4?F5!T434>IE5!n6"p\!

/N5475A9;%E!5EE5!C5>H5@!B35!I3IEe?5!I3I@AHACI@ZAEATFGB5!RAHCE[@5!5@!>4JBF@!E5!

>F?GB5!J;ACZ@IEHF5!?eHCI@ZFGB5\!

,4?34NM46947;%E! C5>@5! J5! LAEBH5`! RI>! E5! CEB?! ?ABL53@! EI! ?RE[>5! 3;5?@! CI?!

>4B@FEF?IDE5\!

!92D;%3DM8573689;%E

"|p!/A??FDFEF@4!J5!C>4E5L5>!JB!KI?RFI!5@!J5!EuICA34L>A?5!@5HCA>IE5!CAB>!>5RABL>F>! EuFHCEI3@!RAEA3F?IDE5\!+3RF?FA3!IB!J5??B?!JB!@>ITB?!CAB>!35!CI?!E4?5>!E5?!>IH5IBc! @5>HF3IBc!J5!EI!D>I3RZ5!@5HCA>AkKIRFIE5!JB!35>K!KIRFIE

6|p! /BF?! ZIDFEEIT5! J5! EuFHCEI3@`! ?B@B>5! IB! LFR>eE! 8h7\! 'I! CI>@F5! CA?@4>F5B>5! J5! E;FHCEI3@!JAF@!>5?@5>!J4RABL5>@5!CAB>!KILA>F?5>!?I!RAEA3F?I@FA3

V|p! 23! C>AR[J5! RAHH5! CAB>! Eu4LF?R4>I@FA3! nKFTB>5! "XIp! HIF?! E5?! HB?RE5?! J>AF@?! ?A3@! J4?F3?4>4?! JB! TEAD5! IC>[?! KFcI@FA3! ?B>! 6! D>F3?! J5! LFR>eE! 8h7\! '5?! ADEFGB5?! ?A3@!J4?F3?4>4?!JB!TEAD5!nKFTB>5!"XDp

W|p! )3BRE4I@FA3! C>AC>5H53@! JF@5! 53! RABCI3@! E5! 35>K! AC@FGB5! 53! I>>F[>5\! Y4>FKFRI@FA3!J5!EI!EA3TB5B>!JB!35>K!AC@FGB5!nKFTB>5!"XRp!

8|p!04HA?@I?5!

O|p! +3?5>@FA3! J5! EI! DFEE5! 5@! ?B@B>5! J5?! HB?RE5?`! ?F! EI! DFEE5! 5?@! 53L5EACC45! J;ICA34L>A?5! B35! K53b@>5! 5?@! C>I@FGB45! P! OkN! HH! JB! R53@>5! J5! EI! DFEE5! IKF3! J5!

(61)

! O7! ?B@B>5>!E5?!HB?RE5?\!'5?!HB?RE5?!?A3@!FHCEI3@4?!J5!HI3F[>5!P!L53F>!IB!RA3@IR@!J5! E;FHCEI3@!A>DF@IF>5!5@!KILA>F?5>!EI!LI?RBEI>F?I@FA3!J5!E;FHCEI3@!

X|p!#5>H5@B>5!I3@4>F5B>5!53!6!CEI3?!RAHH5!C>4R4J5HH53@!ILI3@!E;F3?5>@FA3!J;B3! RA3KA>HI@5B>!

#FTB>5! "X!Q! 43BRE4I@FA3`! Ip! JF??5R@FA3! IBc! RF?5IBc! J5! EI! RA3_A3R@FL5`! CAB>?BFLF5! 53! I>>F[>5! _B?GB;P! E;4GBI@5B>! JB! TEAD5`! Dp! C>F?5! J;B3! HB?RE5! J>AF@! IL5R! B3! R>ARZ5@! P! ?@>IDF?H5`! Rp! ?5R@FA3! JB! 35>K! AC@FGB5! IL5R! J5?! RF?5IBc!RAB>D5?!P!DAB@!HAB??5\!&35!@>IR@FA3!5c5>R45!?B>!E5?!HB?RE5?!J>AF@?! C5>H5@!J5!?5R@FA335>!CEB?!KIRFE5H53@!E5!35>K!C>[?!J5!E;IC5c!A>DF@IF>5!n6Vp! ! c5865479%?L68<8A6?5=9%=5%A89>>9%@9823GA856;;9<;9% &35!T>5KK5!J5>HAkT>IF??5B?5!C>4E5L45!JI3?!E5!GBIJ>I3@!?BC4>Ak5c@5>35!J5! EI!K5??5!C5B@!>5HCEIR5>!E;FHCEI3@!IC>[?!43BRE4I@FA3\!%5@@5!@5RZ3FGB5!C>4?53@5!B3! F3@4>b@!EA>?GB5!E;A3!35!JF?CA?5!CI?!J5!@F??B!IB@AEATB5!CAB>!>5RABL>F>!B3!FHCEI3@! DFARAEA3F?IDE5`!3A@IHH53@!RZ5^!E5!@>[?!_5B35!53KI3@\! ! ! I! D! R!

(62)

! O"!

L1* .#23-'()

%

L65*1*.#23-'()*,$;&(-&$")*

! 'A>?! J;B35! 43BRE4I@FA3h4LF?R4>I@FA3`! FE! KIB@! >5HCEIR5>! E5! LAEBH5! ARBEIF>5! J4KFRF@IF>5! CI>! B3! 4GBFLIE53@! ?CZ4>FGB5! RA>>5?CA3JI3@! P! O! H'! 53LF>A3\! 9IRZI3@! GB5!E5!LAEBH5!J5!EI!C>A@Z[?5!ARBEIF>5!>5C>4?53@5!"`8!P!6`8!HE`!E;FHCEI3@!@43A3F53! J5L>I! RAHC53?5>! B3! LAEBH5! IEEI3@! J5! W`8! P! V`8! HE\! '5?! JFKK4>53@?! JFIH[@>5?! JF?CA3FDE5?!C5>H5@@I3@!J5!RAHC53?5>!IB!HF5Bc!E5!LAEBH5!J5!E;dFE!RA>>5?CA3J53@! P!J5?!JFIH[@>5?!IEEI3@!J5!"N!P!6"!HH!nKFTB>5!"Np\!

#FTB>5!"N!Q!RA>>5?CA3JI3R5!53@>5!E5?!JFIH[@>5?!J5?!FHCEI3@?!@43A3F53?!5@!E5?! LAEBH5?!RAHC53?4?!n6Wp!

!

&3! TEAD5! ARBEIF>5! C[?5! X`8! T>IHH5?! 5@! B35! C>A@Z[?5! 53@>5! 6`8! 5@! 8! T>IHH5?!CAB>!J5?!FHCEI3@?!A>DF@IF>5?!53@>5!"N!5@!6"!HH!J5!JFIH[@>5\!';ILI3@IT5! J;B@FEF?5>! J5! T>A?! FHCEI3@?! 5?@! J;B@FEF?5>! B35! C>A@Z[?5! EI! CEB?! E4T[>5! CA??FDE5! 5@! JA3R! J;IH4EFA>5>! EI! @AE4>I3R5! 5@! EI! HADFEF@4\! '5! RZAFc! J5! E;FHCEI3@! J4C53J>I! 4TIE5H53@!J5?!RA3?@I@I@FA3?!C5>!AC4>I@AF>5?!5@!J5!E;I?C5R@!RA3@>AEI@4>IE\!

(63)

! O6! -I3?!EI!HI_A>F@4!J5?!RI?!A3!?;5KKA>R5>I!JA3R!J;FHCEI3@5>!B35!DFEE5!53@>5!"N! 5@! 6"! HH! J5! JFIH[@>5! n68p\23! JF?@F3TB5! 6! @eC5?! J;FHCEI3@?! F3@>IkA>DF@IF>5?! 53! KA3R@FA3!JB!HI@4>FIB!GBF!E5?!RAHCA?5!n67p!Q! k!'5?!FHCEI3@?!F35>@5?!nL5>>5`!?FEFRA35`!/**$\\\\\p! #FTB>5!"M!Q!JFKK4>53@?!@eC5?!J;FHCEI3@?!F3@>Ik@43A3F53?!F35>@5?!n6Wp! ! k!'5?!FHCEI3@?!DFARAEA3F?IDE5?!nZeJ>AceICI@F@5`!IEBHF35`!R4>IHFGB5`! CAEe4@ZeE[35ap!n6Op! #FTB>5!67!Q!J5Bc!@eC5?!J;FHCEI3@?!@43A3F53?!DFARAEA3F?IDE5?!n6Wp! ! !

(64)

! OV! -5! 3AHD>5B?5?! ILI3R45?! A3@! 4@4! >4IEF?45?! RA3R5>3I3@! E5?! HI@4>FIBc! B@FEF?4?\! '5?! "5>?! FHCEI3@?! ?A3@! F3@>AJBF@?! J5CBF?! "NN8! n*BE5?! 5@! IE\! n6Xpp`! FE?! 4@IF53@!RA3?@F@B4?!J5!L5>>5!5@!A3@!>4LAEB@FA334!E5?!?BF@5?!J5?!43BRE4I@FA3?!CBF?!E5?! FHCEI3@?! 53! /**$! nCAEeH5@ZeEH5@IR>eEI@5p! ?A3@! I>>FL4?! JI3?! E5?! I3345?! "MW7! n6Np\! '5?! C>F3RFCIBc! F3RA3L43F53@?! J5! R5?! FHCEI3@?! F35>@5?! 4@IF53@! EI! HFT>I@FA3`! E;5cCA?F@FA3!5@!EI!RA>>5R@FA3!J5!KIFDE5!LAEBH5\!

/BF?! J[?! E5?! I3345?! "MN7`! E;IF>5! J5?! FHCEI3@?! DFARAEA3F?IDE5?! J4DB@5! n6Op\! /I>HF! 5Bc`! A3! >5@>ABL5! E5?! FHCEI3@?! 53! ZeJ>AceICI@F@5! RA>IEEF53! AB! ?e3@Z4@FGB5`! 53!CAEe4@ZeE[35`!53!IEBHF35!5@!53!R4>IHFGB5\!/AB>!R5BckRF`!T>gR5!P!EI!RAEA3F?I@FA3! J5?! CA>5?! J5! E;FHCEI3@! CI>! B3! @F??B! KFD>AkLI?RBEIF>5`! E5! >F?GB5! J;5c@>B?FA3`! J5! HFT>I@FA3!5@!J;F3K5R@FA3!5?@!JFHF3B4!P!EA3T!@5>H5!n67p\!-;IB@>5?!ILI3@IT5?!?A3@!EI! HADFEF@4! J5! EI! C>A@Z[?5! T>gR5! P! EI! KFcI@FA3! J5?! HB?RE5?! J>AF@?! ARBEAHA@5B>?! ?B>! E;FHCEI3@!n6"p!5@!E5!EI>T5!RZAFc!J5!LAEBH5!FHCEI3@IDE5\!

!

$! E;F3L5>?5`! E5?! HI@4>FIBc! F35>@5?! JAFL53@! b@>5! RAHCE[@5H53@! 53@AB>4?! J5! @F??B! IB@AEATB5! IKF3! J;4LF@5>! E5B>! 5c@>B?FA3! HbH5! P! @>[?! EA3T! @5>H5! R5! GBF! LI! >4JBF>5! E5! JFIH[@>5! J5?! ?CZ[>5?! FHCEI3@45?! JI3?! E5?! 4LF?R4>I@FA3?\! %5RF! LI! JFHF3B5>!4TIE5H53@!EI!HA@FEF@4!J5!EI!C>A@Z[?5!RI>!FE?!@>I3?K[>53@!EI!HA@FEF@4!J5!EI! C>A@Z[?5!?5BE5H53@!P!@>IL5>?!B3!HABL5H53@!CI??FK!J5!EI!RILF@4\!%;5?@!CAB>GBAF!FE?! ?A3@! IDI3JA334?! J5CBF?! CEB?! J5! "8! I3?! IB! C>AKF@! J5?! FHCEI3@?! DFARAEA3F?IDE5?\! .4I3HAF3?`!FE?!C5BL53@!@AB@5KAF?!b@>5!RA3?FJ4>4?!RAHH5!B3!RZAFc!ICC>AC>F4!?B>! E5!CEI3!J5!EI!>53@IDFEF@4!RZ5^!J5?!CI@F53@?!P!5?C4>I3R5!J5!LF5!RAB>@5!n}"7!I3?p!GBF! 35!34R5??F@53@!CI?!B35!F3@4T>I@FA3!J;FHCEI3@\!

(65)

! OW! /AB>! KILA>F?5>! EI! C>AEFK4>I@FA3! KFD>AkLI?RBEIF>5`! E5?! FHCEI3@?! DFARAEA3F?IDE5?! JAFL53@! b@>5! EI>T5H53@! ABL5>@?! L5>?! E;I>>F[>5! J5! EI! RILF@4! A>DF@IF>5`!R5!GBF!C5>H5@!J;53!IBTH53@5>!EI!@IFEE5\

'5?! EARIEF?I@FA3?! J5?! FHCEI3@?! ?A3@! P! E;F3@4>F5B>! J5! EI! RIC?BE5! J5! @53A3! AB! 53! I>>F[>5! J5! R5EE5kRF! JI3?! E5! R]35! HB?RBEIF>5\! '5?! ?CZ[>5?! C5BL53@! b@>5! >5RABL5>@5?! CI>! J;IB@>5?! ?@>BR@B>5?! @5E?! GB5! EI! ?RE[>5! AB! JB! KI?RFI! IB@AEATB5! GBF! ?5>L53@!J5!DI>>F[>5!BE@4>F5B>5!CAB>!EI!HFT>I@FA3!5@!E;5c@>B?FA3\!

!

L68*1*F$,(MN)")*

&35! C>A@Z[?5! ARBEIF>5! 5?@! >4IEF?45! JI3?! E5?! W! P! N! ?5HIF35?! IC>[?! EI! RZF>B>TF5\!'I!C>A@Z[?5!FJ4IE5!5?@!>4IEF?45!IBc!JFH53?FA3?!5cIR@5?!J5!E;A>DF@5!IC>[?! GB5!E;dJ[H5!CA?@kAC4>I@AF>5!IF@!JFHF3B4`!CI>!HABEIT5!J5!EI!RILF@4!5@!>4IEF?I@FA3! J;B3!RA3@>5@eC5!5??Ie4!CI>!E5!CI@F53@\!'I!RIC?BE5!F>F5335!5?@!53?BF@5!R53@>45!?B>!E5! RA3@>5@eC5! 5@! EI! C>A@Z[?5! C5B@! b@>5! >4IEF?45! nKFTB>5! 6"p\! '5?! C>A@Z[?5?! ARBEIF>5?! C>4KID>FGB45?! ?A3@! 5?@Z4@FGB5H53@! HAF3?! ?I@F?KIF?I3@5?! 5@! 5EE5?! EFHF@53@! EI! HA@FEF@4!ARBEIF>5\!-5!CEB?`!5EE5?!C5BL53@!>5@53F>!E5?!?4R>4@FA3?!53@>5!EI!C>A@Z[?5!5@! EI!RILF@4\!

(66)

! O8! ! #FTB>5!6"!Q!>4IEF?I@FA3!J;B35!C>A@Z[?5!?B>!H5?B>5!nFHIT5?!JB!?5>LFR5p`! Ip! HAJ[E5?!J5!TIDI>F@?`! Dp! >4IEF?I@FA3!J5!E;5HC>5F3@5!?RE4>IE5!P!E;IFJ5!J;B3!T5E!53!?FEFRA35`! R!~!Jp!5HC>5F3@5!?RE4>IE5!>4IEF?45`! 5p! KA>H5?!J5?!RA3@>5@eC5?!D>B@?`! Kp! I?C5R@!KF3IE!J5?!C>A@Z[?5?\! ! ! I! D! R! J! 5! K!

(67)

! OO!

O1* <,#23&%-(&,')*

n6"p

*

O65*1*BC2,)&(&,'*"(*"C($0)&,'*/"*3:&#23-'(*

-5! KIsA3! C>4RAR5`! P! RIB?5! J;B3! J4KIB@! J5! @5RZ3FGB5`! E5?! FHCEI3@?! C5BL53@! ?;5c@4>FA>F?5>!?;FE?!?A3@!CEIR4?!@>AC!EAF3!53!ILI3@!AB!?F!EI!K5>H5@B>5!J5!EI!RIC?BE5! J5! (53A3! 53! ILI3@! 3;5?@! CI?! ?I@F?KIF?I3@5\! &35! F3K5R@FA3! CA?@AC4>I@AF>5! C5B@! 4TIE5H53@! 53T53J>5>! B35! 5c@4>FA>F?I@FA3\! -5! KIsA3! @I>JFL5`! B35! HIBLIF?5! RFRI@>FR5`!B35!C>A@Z[?5!AB!J5?!RA3KA>HI@5B>?!HIE!@IFEE4?!5@!J5?!CAF3@?!J5!C>5??FA3! 53@>5! E;FHCEI3@! 5@! EI! C>A@Z[?5! C5BL53@! 4TIE5H53@! RA3@>FDB5>! P! E;5c@>B?FA3! J5! E;FHCEI3@\!'5?!FHCEI3@?!5cCA?4?!?A3@!?B_5@?!P!F3K5R@FA3\!SF53!GB5!J5!C5@F@?!J4K5R@?! 53! ILI3@! J;FHCEI3@?! CA>5Bc! CBF??53@! >I>5H53@! ?5! K5>H5>! ?CA3@I34H53@`! EI! CEBCI>@! J5?! 5cCA?F@FA3?! J5L>A3@! b@>5! >5RABL5>@5?! IL5R! J5?! T>5KKA3?! ?RE4>IBc! AB! J5?!@F??B?!IB@AEATB5?!CAB>!KILA>F?5>!B35!TB4>F?A3!RA3_A3R@FLIE5!P!RA3JF@FA3!GB;FE! 3;e!IF@!CI?!J;F3K5R@FA3!n67p\! !

*

*

*

! #FTB>5!66!Q!5c@>B?FA3!J;B3!FHCEI3@!nFHIT5!JB!?5>LFR5p! ! !

Références

Documents relatifs

Un patient nous a été adressé pour rétro et hypoplasie mandibulaire dans le cadre d’un syndrome de Treacher Collins.. Il présentait toutes les caractéristiques morpholo- giques

Nous avons fait une étude rétrospective, prospective sur les améloblastomes des maxillaires dans le service de stomatologie et chirurgie maxillo-faciale du CHU- OS durant une

- Notre étude n’a porté aucun préjudice aux patients inclus dans l’étude, mais a contribué plutôt à une meilleure connaissance de l’améloblastome de la mandibule pour

Mr Pierre FREGER (surnombre) HCN Anatomie - Neurochirurgie Mr Jean François GEHANNO HCN Médecine et santé au travail. Mr Emmanuel GERARDIN HCN

Les rhizalyses sont très banales dans les tumeurs bénignes et elles peuvent se voir également dans certaines tumeurs malignes comme les plasmocytomes malins. Dans le cadre des

La mandibule est également en relation avec le crâne par l’intermédiaire de l’articulation temporo-mandibulaire, articulation bicondylienne à ménisque interposé, située juste en

Il est aussi appelé excréteur terminal. Il correspond à la fusion des canaux excréteurs. Son épithélium est pluristratifié. Il s’abouche dans la cavité buccale en regard de

Cependant, une interprétation isolée de ces tests peut entraîner des erreurs soit par excès soit par défaut dans le diagnostic et la surveillance de cette