A distributed algorithm for weighted max-min fairness in MPLS networks

(1)

! "# $%&' !( )*+ ,&(*-'

./0/1234 567876 9/8:;2<76=567>/2078? ;@ A7B=/ C D/E=7FGH

IJKLJMNOPLQRRSTUVNJWNKR XTYNZR[TWSTUVNJWNKR

\]^_`ab_c d/

e2;e;0/16;>/Ef70827gF8/f1E=;2784G8;1347/>/1:/7=48/f

G1hiG76 041276= ;@ 84/ 6/8:;2< 31e1378?jd/ e2/0/6884/ d/7=48 k2;i

e;287;61E l1hil76 e;E73? CdkllH 8418 0Fee;280 1 G767G1E 218/ 2/i

m

F72/G/68 16f 16 ;e87;61E G1h7G1E 218/ 3;60821768 16f 1EE;318/0 6/8i

:;2<g16f:7f84 1G;6=1EE1==2/=18/0g10/f;6 1:/7=48100;3718/f :784

/134 ;6/j nF2 f70827gF8/f 1E=;2784G 1347/>/0 8470 e;E73? @;2 okplkAq

6/8:;2<0 F076= 84/ .qrkist 07=61EE76= e2;8;3;Ej s4/ 1E=;2784G F0/0

e/2iAqk 133;F6876= 76 /134 6;f/ 8; <//e 8213< ;@ 84/ 0818/ 76@;2G1i

87;6 ;@ /134 Aqkj o8 F0/0 1 6;>/E /heE7378 g;88E/6/3< E76< 08218/=? 16f

1 f7u/2/68 3;682;E 123478/38F2/ 76 :4734 :/ Fef18/ 84/ 3;682;E e13</8

76 84/@;2:12f e184jq7GFE187;60 04;: 841884/0/ 8:; /E/G/6807Ge2;>/

0Fg0816871EE? 84/ 3;6>/2=/63/87G/3;Ge12/f 8;84/e2/>7;F01E=;2784G0

f/>/E;e/f 8;1347/>/ 8470e;E73? 76 84/ vsl 3;68/h8j

w xyz{|}~z|y

- &! !&& ! * ! ! ! * - &!& ! !( &$ !

& !&# & !&# &!-&! " * ! ," *(

#& & &* ! $ &!&#&*-&&&&! &

,"&- -& !&#!( ( ! -+!-& ! ,"

#&+ &!-& *&

! (& & ," &- -+ ! !+ -!!&- !-& ! -!

& ! * & - - !& & $& ," & &

& & & !(&&!(&!+ & &&$ !

&& !&!&#!( (&&! (&+&&(

!&!(&&- + !& -!& ¡&- - !&

- ! &&! (&+ --&&( ! !&# !( ( !

- & ! ! *& - !+ & ! -+ &

&&!&#*&-&( &*& & ! * - !

¢

$ (& ( £&&! &$ -& ! ¤ & &!& - &

! !&# !( ( ! -+ -&( & !

! & -+ &!& & & - - ! +

- !&- &!& -& - (&-*&( ! *

& !( * & ! * &&¥* &&! !( & &# & -! !

&-

(2)

*&!&#!( *+!-! !( £&&!!&#-!&!

& -* ! ! &(&&(&&&( &&(-# -! -&&&& &-

-! -#& &*&( ! ( !( -#(

* ! ¤ $ (& ( ( *&( * ! -* ! &

-+ * (-# + * ! &&!&( !

& -!& !(*& &*-& !&&! -&

-&& *! $&&(!( &-!(+& -!$&&!-& **+

*&( &

* $& && ! + (( ! ! & - &!&-#

!# ! ! ! &- -! -#& !( + * ! ( £&&! -! -#&

*(&- &-*&&&(( !(( ! -!&( -+&(+! -

& - !( $& & -!$&&!-& & + - (&&!( !

! & &- ! && * ! &*

!& -! * ! & ( ! & * ! & -* ,"

- &-*& * ! & (&&( " - !&( -&

* &( !& ! ! " & $&& - + &

- + (&-& ! &$&&( ((&( + -! -#&

& - ! #& & &( ! &

-&( ! ," -*( & *&( + #& & !& *& # &

-* ! &&-* &&! *!(&&&$&(&+& &&&!&&$&(

& !( & &!( &( $&& &! -& -!& ! -&

*&( -(& &( -#& !( +(* ! ! &!& (&

& +& -#& + * ! -+ && & &- $&

& -*& & & &- ," ! !&# !

- !+ & &( -#& & ( -(&( !( & &&! !( +& -#&

*--&*+& *

y{ z{||{z|y |z|y |

*! &( (& ! ! & ! !& $ (&( + ! (& &

&(& ! ! & & &( ! $&- &&- &

(& !&( ! " #$ % &'()*+ , -. /0 12 ' / 34 )'5 67896 /:; 7 / + * : 0 ') 1/; 7 : 5 * :<= /; >? , -@ A B C >DE A FGHIIIHJK B @L M .L N > DO A FGHIIIHJK B @P QP R .P QP S .L QL T 24 '+' QU /0 ) 4 ' 2 ' / 34 ) 7 00 *( / 7)'5 2/ ) 4 ) 4 ' ' < '6' : )V

& -!*& && - (& ! ! &&&& !( $ & !

! ," !&# * # &( ! &$ * # ! & -!&

$ (&( + ¤&(& (& ! ! & ," -!&

! ," !&# & W," *& !&-!!&-&( + &

!# X & ," Y $&&!& & !# ! X !( &- ," E

(3)

L A

&&-&( & ! !# ! X

L L

,& & &-- + * &!( ( !# !#

*&( *+ * &( &!&

L

!(

L

& &&$&( &

&¥* &&! !( & & -! ! &- ," E

A

Y &&- $&+

& +&*&&* ," &¥* &&!$& !

!+ !#(&!&-&&(& !#-- + &

L L S A

X - & ! *&( + ( ! -! ," &* & (&& !&

&& ! --& !& ," ! !#

! " $ ' 0 7 = ) 4 7) 7 +7)'&'()*+ F L E A Y K /0 ! /; ) 4 ' ; * << * 2/:3 ) 2 * (* :0 )+7 /: ) 0 7+' 0 7) /0 "'5 # L S L S L $%% E A Y S $%% A X

! & &!& - & ! ! -+ & - &

&- ," E A Y & + QL !+ -+

-& &- ," &! & & ! ! !&# -- +

-&(( !!( ( &- ," * ! !$& ! &

! -+ &( ! &- ," & & + ! -! !

& ! !( ( &- ," *! (( ! & & &(&

! & + -+ (& !&( !( ( &-+ (& $&

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

& ! ! !# & & ! &&&! & $&

-+!( &&!&-# !# (& ! !

*4"O"/ ! " # ()*++ 23!"45$% : 98;<9 ; '7 0/=< '+7)'&'()*+ /0 899 /; 7 : 5 * :<= /; '7( 4 ;<8 4 7 0 ' / ) 4 '+ 7 899 = *)) < ' : '( N </:N 2/ ) 4 +' 06 '() )* *+ 7 +7)' 7 00/ 3: 6' : ) 'P @ 7 < )* / ) 0 9Q H

&-&! &( & ! -*&& &&-,"

--( ! -+ ¢ -&! &( & &

- ! &¥* & ! ! - !-& ( !&!(&(

(4)

! &- ! & & ! -!$&& & -+

¥* -#+ * ( *&( !( +!-!* & !

'$# ./ 3 .1"4 !

*( *&(* !*&&" ! !--!$&+ ! !

* & !&#

& !( " -#& -! ! & ! &&

&&$&( & $ (&( & -& ! & ,"

& $ (&( & -& ! & ,"

&-&( & & && !&# ,"

&

&-# ( & ," &!&-# !#

& ( -+& !& &!( -#&- *& ! & -

*&- &&," !(*(&& !(

&( -

& & ! & & &&! ! & -#&! &-& $ !

-#&&&& *& &!( " -#& ! &( & (

!&( ! & & !&*&

! & -#( &- *& *(& ! ! & "

&&

! &-& $ ! " -#& & !& ! &

! ! * &( &

!+ &£ ! !&# $& &&! (!& ! & (& !

- &$& & - - ! ¡ & # !+

!& & & && $&! -!$&& & !

! & -!& * &&!( !+&-! ¥*& *& ! *

& &# & !( & &- * ! *& * # *

$& & &!-& + ( + ! & *(& &-! ! *

&*&*(&& ! ! !&("&+-!!

$& & ! ! -*&( + & (!& *&&& *& $&

& -&- ! ! ! &!& -+-&! *-&*(&&*&

!&-#( &+$&&-&- ! ! #&& !&!(&

&$&&(( !& &&

-!$&+& - + & &!&-#

!# ! & ! ! $&-! (&+ & -!$&&!-& &

& ! && !# &&!( $ &*&( + &

X "& !# Y "& ," $& ! !# U

& $*&&," V

A

Y #!! !#

s47076@;2G187;6 70;6E? F0/@FE fF276= 84/ /081gE704G/68 ;@ 84/ Aqk ;2 :4/6 84/0/

(5)

J &!&-# !# ( & ," V A Y #!! !# && & ! ! ¢

"& ," &!&-#&( !# &

F V V A Y $ J U K

"&,"!&!&-#&( !# &

F V V A Y $ J U K & $& Y

& & ," V -&( &&&$&( & & ," U

!( ! (( ! &-&(+&!&# (( ! &

! & & & ,"

! -* !# & -! -*&

$*& $& & (( ! & & *! & & ,"

&!&-#&( ! !# -*& 1"4 ! .131.! " "- ( - Y B , U U , U > U , U B C D ! "#$$ U D CDD ! %&'( ) * +

& --& &

--*&! &,"& &!&-#&(! !#

& -*&&&& !( ( ! !# + # ! & -- +&

!# !* & ," $& ! !* & (( ! &

& ," ! &!&-#&( ! &¥* & && !( ( ( $ (&( +

& * & ," & &- ," &!&-#&( ! & &&&

!( ( & -& &- V

A

&*! &

& &-!( -& &

--* &! ," & &!&-#&( !

& !# ! ! -& & $*& -&! ! ¤ !(

- &$&-!$&&!-& & & U ," V &!&-#&( ! !# -*&( + >? V A B U U " , -U

#&+ &&&! & & &+ & &

J U

! !

-&-+& *& & ! (& ! ! & &!&-# -! &!-+&

! " . ("!!13J,3"/ /!!5$ ;') = ' ) 4 ' 0 ') * ; ;<8 0 : *) = *)) < '9 : '( N '5 7) </:N A X 7 : 5 = '(7 < ( @< 7)'57((*+5 /:3 )*% <3 *+ / ) 4 6/ H /0= *)) < ' : '( N 9 (* :0/0 )' : ) /; >? V A B U S U " , -U

(& ! !(& $&( &-+ & ! ! ¢!(&!,"!

&!&-#&( !#* $& &!&-# &&&&&-&

0

(6)

-*&! !#&&!& -&&," !

*( $& &$&(

&*( & &!&-#&(

* &+ &," --*! ! &- ** !(&

& ! ! & #&& -# & & ! ! &-

$& ! ," &- ," V & #&& U H U H -U H J U &( !

& ! ! & -*& & & - & &- ," - &$& &

&- !

& ! & !(& &- ** !# ! &(

Y !( 1"4 ! ' " 0 .2 "4 5e;6 2/3/7e8;@ 1kvs Aqk2/187;6v6fs/2G76187;6CH Fef18/t.CH 5e;6 84/ 2/3/7e8;@ 1.tqr 3 8 5 3 8 5 Fef18/73CH ;2:12f .tqrC7.. t.d D9H Aqk2/187;6v6fs/2G76187;6CH 7@ Aqk 8/2G76187;6 84/6 238 5 23 Fef18/73CH /E0/ 7@ Aqk32/187;6 84/6 3 8 5 3 8 5 8 5 Fef18/73CH Fef18/t.CH 8 5 73 ? 8 5 7@ C ? ! H84/6 D9 " # 1 t. " # ? ;2:12f kvsC7..dt.D9H Fef18/73CH

F0/ vE=;2784G$8;31E3FE18/ 73

7@ %3 4 5 6 84/6 2/e/18

pp08;e0:4/6 g;88E/6/3<i3;60708/63? C0// &/@'H701347/>/f

7( 3 8 5 73 ) 8 5*+ , - 3 . 7@ / 3 / . / 0 7( 3 84/6 l;>/ e @2;G %3 8;3

F0/ vE=;2784G$8; 31E3FE18/ 73

F687E / 3 / . / 17( 3 ;2 %3 56

& *(& -&(*& &-*& &( ! -*&! $*&

U !( J U

(7)

! + ! > U , U B -U B S *( & $&( &- & ! !& ," + *- > , B - B # $$ U > U , U B -U

B &$&( & !&

!(

& + &( ! !& -

!&&( & &--*&( -& &!( &! & &

&+

&!&-# -! &!

!+ & &(&&$ * & & !& &! & &!( !

-#&!(*( !&," & ! !*!&&-& !

" -#& ! * (& & *& *& !# -*& &

&- &( !#& !&*-*&& &&

!# !( *& & !(& (& !&( !

& & &$ * & *! &-& $ ! -#& & &&

&!( " -#& ! &( & ( !&( ! & &

*& !(&

&*-*&& *!&&&$&+," V

A

Y&

& U

! ! !&-!(& ,"& & & U S U S U

* *(& - &-*& ! &-#( !( & & - &

!&-# !# ! !& (&-&&& -!$&&!-& & *! + !

! & !& &- !

'$ O4"2 .1"4 ! !" .1 ! ! L* 4-4/ 3 . /

& " - -& ! &( &-! ! & &

-& ! && !(" -#&*--& $& "

-#&&&&&*& !(&!+&!( && &(!

& !(&&&&&," &!+*(&!-&&& -#&

* * ! -! & +& &&!(&( #&& &+&* (&$&

&+ (&& !& !(& * &!( * !& * &&

! &- ** & - & &- ," V &- U

& &*&!( *!& -#&&! &$*& !,"

-!& ! & ** & & & & ," &

&! & &-& $& !( & && & ," &!+& -&

& ! ! &&

&! & +& & !+ && " -#& & *&(

$&( &-!#&&&($!&&" &&&-!

& *& " !( && &-! &(*-& & $&&( !&&(&(

-&( -&! !& -& &!( &$&+ -&&&

& & $&&( !(*-&( + (&&!( ! & & !

& &

!( * -&& !(*-& &( $&&( !+ & *& & &&

&-! &(*-&&-& ! !&&(&( +& -&*&!+ !&&(

&& & ," &!+ ! & &

~z|y {~z

-& * * ! *&$&(&$&&( &- -+&

(8)

! +

& & (( & ," !& + !& !( & &&-*& &

! +

* !&" -&&*&&-!-& & ! !( "

-+-& "-+-& -! & ( ! -#& ! &

!(& !& & !& &&&!(& !( &-#( !

" -#& ! !(& & && & !& !(& ! & !

&&&-* ! !"-+-& &," &&!( &- & !

&$& $&-," &

& $& & & -& & &&-*& &

& $& -& *! & &! & $& & &&&! & & $&- !(

& - ! $&- -*&( * ! & !

*!(& &( &- ! &

G

C !& + & -&

& &! & $& & &&&! *--& $& & $&- *!(& &(

&- ! & + * * * ! &-& & *

!( - -!$&&!-& &&( & &-!( - * *

-!&*&( ! - -& * !+ #!&(&&

&- !& * ! ! & &¥*& & &( ! & -

& & !&# -! * ! & *& ! * * ! ! &( #&

& + - + && & $& ," *& -!!&-&( ¤ !#

W!( ," $& ! &+ &

Link1

Link0

Link3

Link2

Link6

Link5

Link4

LSP4

LSP2

LSP3

LSP1

LSP0

C 1H of..l. d/7=48 . D9 j $ $ $ j ' ' ' ''j ' ' CgH cc !

& ," && &¥* &&! -! ! &

!( &- !&-," $& !&!&#-! * !

& &$* ! & & *!(& * ( *&( &

& -!$&& & & &( ! &

#&

¢

& ! &&& ! *- &!+ -& & & &

&*- (&! ( !-& *!(& " & &$* ! & &

*!(&* &( ( *&( * * ! &-&& * !

& !

#$!/ 2 / 1.! " & (& &&! $& * ! ! & !*&

-& && -&&( & !(&!(

!( ," & &&-*&( & * ! ( £&&!

(9)

0

20

40

60

80

100

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

35

40

45 Fair rate (MB/s)

Iterations

Evolution of the LSP’s fair rates using Hou’s solution

LSP0

LSP1

LSP2

LSP3

LSP4

0

20

40

60

80

100

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

35 Fair rate (MB/s)

Iterations

Evolution of the LSP’s fair rates using our solution

LSP0

LSP1

LSP2

LSP3

LSP4

C 1H CgH c c ! !

& ! * * ! & &&! & & * !

&* k2/3707;6 ;F0 1E=;2784G nF21E=;2784G 176 j 'j $j' $j j j j $j j j j $j j j j j'$ a] c !! !

& !*& & !!&&(&( + * * ! ! & & &

$&+ * & # &!*& ," &- & &&

&& & & & !" &,"$&&-&(&" !+ &

,"-! !*& -!&& $&(* !(&( " &-&$&+

*&* !( $&*&+&&!-&!(- +&

0

20

40

60

80

100

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

70

80

90 %

Iterations

Minimum and average number of LSPs frozen at each iterations

Min of Hou algo

Mean of Hou algo

Min of our algo

Mean of our algo

cc!! !!

&&&-*&(& * !! & ,"!(

& $& &( & ! * !( $&& &-&!& ," $& &-

& & & &- & ! & & $&&

!(& ! * &-** $&$*&!((*-&!! -+ !-& !

*!- !

(10)

& ! &

" & ," &* * ! #& !+

¢

|y~|y

& &&!&( !$& ( *&( - &$& & &

- ! * ! $ (& -& - &-*& & & $ &

!( ( ! &," --( ! & & -+ £&!

- $& - ! (& & !&# &$ -& $ (& ! !(*-&

+ ! *& ! *&&( - ! (&

* $&-! (&+&&!-&+* !!& *(&

! &-! -#&!( & !& ! !& - &!&-# !#

# ! &+ & * ! & " - && & ( -+

& -& !(& ! ! (&-&& & $&&( &&! ! &

- &-*& & ! ! &&

* **& # -* ! & (&$&&! ** -!$&&!-&

& &&-* ! * ! &$&! & -& &!

&-&! ! *& $&&& -!-&+* !* +*!- !

(&- & & -& &- $& &-& && * +

& - &!!( !+& !$& && !& ! !

& £&$ ," !&#

3J"1!/ # *&( + & *&! &-

"

¤ !( & & ! & ! &-

{y j vsl;2FGs/346731E;GG78//j !! ! /g2F12? j vsl ;2FGp'i.j

$j &jv:fF34/AjD/2=/2&j16sjA7rjq2767>101616f jq:1EE;:j

! &/3/Gg/2$j . $j

j qjD1E;6jDE1634?nj&/E3;F28jA/fF3AjlE;616fjq<7>/jq?684/07016f

2/3;GG/6f187;6 @;276821if;G176 8213 /6=76//276=j s/346731E ./e;28vs.o5l

&/E7>/21gE/ &j567>/2078? ;@ A7B=/9;>/Gg2/ $j

j &jD/280/<10 16f .j1EE1=/2j j k2/6873/ 1EE$j 'j j416=9j;EG7/ 16f &jq7Fj ! ! ! ! vF=F08'j s:/E@84 o68/26187;61E;6@/2/63/ ;6 ;GeF8/2;GGF673187;6 o 'j

j vj 4126?j v6 1E=;2784G @;2 218/ 1EE;3187;6 76 1 e13</8i0:783476= 6/8:;2< :784

@//fg13<j s/346731E ./e;28 lospAqps.i j

j j s4;G10 ;F /62? s/6= q47>/6f21 qj k16:12 16f r71? kj FG12j v =/6/273:/7=48ie2;e;287;61Eg16f:7f84 041276=e;E73?@;2 18G 1g20/2>73/j ! e1=/0 $ j j .j 176 qj 1E?16121G16 .j ;?1E qj 14G? 16f .j r70:1618416j ! ! !! vF=F08 j vsl ;2FGpi $j j jjA/D;Ff/316fDj.1fF6;>73jvF67/f@21G/:;2<@;2G1hiG7616fG76iG1h @1726/00:784 1eeE73187;60j n38;g/2 $$j j tj .;0/6 16f 1Ej ! !! ! 16F12? $j . j