" 10 000 permis pour réussir " Evaluation quantitative

HAL Id: halshs-00746026

https://halshs.archives-ouvertes.fr/halshs-00746026

HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access archive for the deposit and dissemination of sci-entific research documents, whether they are pub-lished or not. The documents may come from teaching and research institutions in France or abroad, or from public or private research centers.

L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non, émanant des établissements d’enseignement et de recherche français ou étrangers, des laboratoires publics ou privés.

” 10 000 permis pour réussir ” Evaluation quantitative

Yannick l’Horty, Emmanuel Duguet, Sophie Kaltenmark, Pascale Petit

To cite this version:

Yannick l’Horty, Emmanuel Duguet, Sophie Kaltenmark, Pascale Petit. ” 10 000 permis pour réussir ” Evaluation quantitative. 2011. �halshs-00746026�

RAPPORT DE RECHERCHE

N° 2011 - 7

« 10 000 permis pour réussir »

Evaluation quantitative

1

1

1

Y

L’H

,

E

D

,

S

K

,

P

P

www.tepp.eu

1

231453617189AB1

1

1

1

21341444156789A15BC717DCAA971E11

FC9B1C9961

1

1

1

768967A17DACA11

1

1

1

1

CDEEF11

DE11

6 !F1"DED1

#D$D1#F

#%D&1

1

E1 % E$1 '1 E1 E$DFE1 (1 D1 4F$$DFD1 '1 D1 )E$$*1 E$1 %+F $1 E1 %%1 E$1 1 %,D1 $1 --$1 (1 . %FEDFE1 /19010001 )$1 1 %$$F111 DE%1 D1 1 2E($1 (. %FEDFE1 1 D1 2E$$1 E1 DEDFD1 D,1 343561 1 %$E1 (E1 (EE1 $1 %$D$1 (. FDFE1 (1 D1 F71 E+81 $DF$F+1 D 7$1($1)E$6191$DF1(E1E+81%% !EF+1+F1D1%%1%DF$%1D 7$1(19:001 )E$1 D135616-$1E1D,F11DF1A099611

1

. %FEDFE1E$F$1'1  $1'19010001)E$1E1(F--F%1(FE$FE1;1F$$$1 (1%ED$1($$1E1 DFF DFE1-FEDEF71$FEF-FDF,*1(1(1(190001<*11E1 D DEE1 $EEDF$%1 11 1(1 D$$1$1 F$1(1E(F615= ('1($1--$1$1FE$FE1$FD1($1)E$1+F1D7(E1>1D1 F$1(1E(F1 '1 DEF1 (1 (% DE*1 ($1 %$D$1 $E1 DE($1 $1 $1 !DE$1 (D%(1 '1  F11$1D1+DF%1($1 F$1 %$61&)1(1%,DDFE1$1(1$1D,1 %F$FE1$1(F--%E$1--$1$11(,EF1($1)E$611

1

$1 %,DD$1 (EEE1 E1 E$&1 (%+F $1 (1 !!1 %EF$1 D1 $FE1 (1 D1 -%(%DFE1(1!!1/13D,DF*1 F11#FF+$1#&F+$111(145361?231E1@189ABA1 +F1 %EF1 $ 1 D&DF$1 DDE1 1 D.1 (1 !!1 ED1  F1 1 %,DDFE1 ($1 FF+$1 &F+$*1 1 FE$F1 (1 $E(D1 356=64236*1 +F1 $1 1 D(1 -DEBDF$1 ($1 %($1 DFE1 1 ( FEFE*1 $F%%1 (1  1 356*1 E1 ($1 D($1 E(FD.1 (1 D!%1 1 E@91 E(FD1 ($1 %($1 123 45661 D1 -%(%DFE1 (1 !!1 3##1 $1 +DE(1 '1 1 E1 E,1 EF%1 (1 45361 D&%F$%1 ( F$1 )DE,F1 A44:1 +F1 %EF1 9801 !!$1 F$$$1 (1 C1 D&DF$*1 3D931 (1 DEF,$F%1 #DF$=$1 4%F1 1 EDE1 D1 FD%*1 1 4E1(($1(1 F11$1%+F $13E6*1(1DEF,$F%1(1#DF$1A*14#511#1 (1DEF,$F%1(,1FD1($$EE*1G59561(1DEF,$F%1(1EDE$61DE$11E$&*1D1 %$E1 % E$1 %DE1 $1 %F$%E1 (1  1 (1 !!1 4631 +F1 $1 D1 D-1(1!!1(13##1DF$%1D1$FE1(146141 1(1!!1D1 1 &)1(%(1$1&$D$1'1D7$1'1 F11E1 DFF1$1 &7$1$ DFD.1(1 (F$DE1 !$F+1E1 F11$1 $EE$1?17819A1B3CA7C1964A611

1

DE$11D(1(11%,DDFE*13561642361D1 F$1E1!D1E$&1(1D11 ($1 (EE%$1 1 $1 !!$1 E1 (F1 1 1 1 --E1 $1 DFE$1 %E%F+$1 E%$$DF$1 '1 %,DDFE61 41 =DFDE1 E$1 $1 D D1 1 1 F1E1(1%DF$1E1 %DFE1(%,DDFE1(1DE(1E,1+F1EE1 EFE19010001)E$*1$111FF1% FDFE11(DE1AB1F$*11 E1 $ DE1 $1 F7$1 (1 $FEF-FF%1 E-$1 D.1 F$1 $DE(D($1 FEEDFED.*1 +F1 F $E1 (1 $F,1 E1 1 (%,DDFE1 F.1 D-FE1 (1 (F1($1$$1$DF$F+$1-FD&$1(1F D1(1. %FE61

9E(FE11

2314567789A1361BA4C871DA1EFD684A1BA6914A98416A18CBF493EA19F69A1B3498E684A136B471DA71A6A71A1 D88E6951D87A498F1F641EA71A6A71BA61F61B371D8BC5719F6917A1B377A1EFCCA1781A138A18A361DA1 F4C398F1 88983A1 DF3891 D3393A1 DA1 3A641 361 BA4C871 DA1 EFD684A1 1377A41 7F1 BA4C8711 EA791 456778416A15B4A6A19 5F48!6A1A1EFDA1DA1314F69A1A916A15B4A6A1B4398!6A131EFD689A13619A4CA1D61 B34EF6471EF"9A6#1DA1F4C398F1!6817593A1A1B6717F6A917641B671D6A135A1$131739873E98F1D3F841 764CF951 31 D88E6951 89487!6A1 DA1 EA99A1 76EEA778F1 D5B4A6A71 487!65A71 73F69A1 EAA1 DA1 D87BF7A41 D6A1F6AA1E3B3E8951DA1CF88951369FFCA1!681B671A791EA49885A1B341%9391&A99A13B9896DA1A641F64A1 DA71 BA47BAE98A71 BA47FAA71 A91 B4FA778FAA71 !681 E 3A91 31 DFA1 BF641 EA71 A6A71 'F1 7A6ACA91AA1A641BA4CA91D534841A1EA4EA1B (78!6A1DA1A6414AE A4E A1DACBF81C3871AEF4A1AA1A641 369F487A1)1B459AD4A1)1DA1F6A36#1ACBF871BF641A7!6A7131BF77A778F1D61BA4C871A7914A!687A1$6*DA)1 DA1 EA71 AA971 BF789871 7641 A71 E 3EA71 D3EE5DA41 )1 ACBF81 A91 7641 31 !638951 DA71 ACBF871 FEE6B571 31 D59A98F1D61BA4C871A91A13891DA1BF6F841D87BF7A41D615 8E6A1BA691A#A4EA41367781DA71AA971B68773971 D8954398F17FE83A1A13F48739131B487A1D369FFC8A1EA1!681BA691CFD88A41DA1FC4A6#137BAE971DA131 8A1DA71A6A71A641457A361DA17FE8388951A6471F878471A6471E F8#1DA1FACA91A9E1

1

2A1 EF94379A1 A791 377A+1 43BB391 A94A1 3CBA641 A91 31 D8A478951 DA71 AA971 BF9A98A71 D61 BA4C871 DA1 EFD684A17641A71B34EF6471DA1EA71A6A71A9137AEA1D55CA971DA1B4A6A17641314538951DA1EA71AA971 D371A71596DA71A#87939A712A71434A7194336#13BB8!6571EF73E4571)1EA19(BA1DA1!6A798F1F917649F6915951 45387571 36#1 %9397*,871 A91 A1 7F91 B371 E8571 7641 A71 A6A71 A1 D88E6951 D87A498F1 &A791 EA1 !681 3891 895491 DA1 536398F1 DA1 FB54398F1 1-.1...1 BA4C871 BF641 456778411 DF91 FA91 A791 D3BBF49A41 DA71 55CA971 DA1 CA764A1 7641 A71 AA971 D61 BA4C871 DA1 EFD684A1 7641 A71 B34EF6471 DA71 A6A71 A1 D88E6951 D87A498F11

1

2FB54398F1 1-.1...1 BA4C871 BF641 456778411 31 EF787951 )1 B4FBF7A41 6A1 76A98F1 A91 61 D87BF78981 D3EEFCB3ACA91)1DA71A6A71A1D88E6951D87A498F1A91DF488A1CFDA79A1BF641A7138DA41)1B377A41 A641BA4C871DA1EFD684A12A71A#B548CA939A64717F91DA71C8778F71FE3A71DA71EFAE98895719A4489F483A71 A91DA71369F*5EFA71377FE8398A71/173891D6A1A#B548CA9398F1DA1BF495A1398F3A1!6819A79A1D854A9A71 CFD389571 DA1 83EACA91 A91 D3EEFCB3ACA91 A91 A1 536A1 A71 457693971DA1 C384A1 !63989398A1 BF641 F841 8CB3E91 4A3981 DA1 F9A98F1 D61 BA4C871 7641 A1 B34EF6471 DA71 A6A71 558E8391 DA1 38DA1 76BB5CA9384A1 B341 43BBF491 )1 EA6#1 !681 A1 558E8A91 B3710CA764A41 A71 AA9711 ,A1 536398F1 !6389398A1A79153ACA91AAE965A1BF641D59A4C8A41A71C59 FDA71A91A71B349A3483971A71B671A8E3EA71 0CA764A41A1B4FEA7767111 1 2536398F1!63989398A1EF7879A1)1CA764A41A71AA971DA71A#B548CA9398F717641A71943AE9F84A717FE83A71 A91B4FA778FAA71DA71A6A71231838951A7918A1DA1E 84A41A71AA971D61D87BF78981EA79*)*D84A1D61FA91 CF59384A1A91DA71CA764A71D3EEFCB3ACA912A1CF9391DA13176A98F13F65A1)1E 3!6A1A6A1A91 A1 4A79A1 )1 E 34A1 BF641 A71 A6A71 D84A1 7AF1 A71 A#B548CA939A6471 0DA1 !6A!6A71 EA938A71 )1 61 C3#8C6C1 DA1 -...1 A64F711 DA1 CCA1 !6A1 A71 CFD389571 DA1 3EEFCB3ACA91 &A493871 A#B548CA939A6471 4A98AA91 DA71 F4C6A71 D3EEFCB3ACA91 89A781 A91 D3694A71 DA71 D87BF789871 B671 593571D371A19ACB7121EA493871A#B548CA939A6471B45B34A91B6717B5E88!6ACA915B4A6A19 5F48!6A1D61 BA4C871 DA1 EFD684A1 D3694A71 5B4A6A1 B4398!6A1 A9E1 2536398F1 BA691 73D3B9A41 )1 EA71 D854A9A71 FB98F71B487A71B341A71BF49A6471DA1B4FA971A91A1A714ACA91B371A1E367A1/1A173891B371F1B671DA1 EFCB34A41A711BA4F4C3EA711DA19A1F619A1A#B548CA939A6471D61BF891DA16A1DA1314567789A1361BA4C871 1

2A1B457A9143BBF491DFA1A71B4AC8A471457693971DA1EA99A1536398F1/1A#BF89A16A1A!69A179398798!6A1 36B471D615E 398F1DA1A6A71!6817F91D371A1D87BF78981A1EFCB34391DA133F17(795C398!6A1A71 A6A71 !681 F91 4A361 38DA1 F61 4F6BA1 9A791 )1 EA6#1 !681 A1 F91 B371 4A361 A91 !681 F91 A71 CCA71 E343E9548798!6A71F7A43A71A91F1F7A43A71F614F6BA195CF812A!69A1315951453875A1D5691C381

4.--1 7F891 DF6+A1 CF871 3B471 A945A1 DA71 A6A71 D371 A1 D87BF7898-_{1 36B471 D61 5E 398F1 DA1 -5451}

A6A711 1

231B4AC84A1B3498A1D6143BBF4914AB4AD1DA7155CA971 D5)1EF6710877671DA7143BBF4971B45E5DA9711!681 D5E48A91 A71 AA971 399AD671 D61 BA4C871 DA1 EFD684A1 7641 A71 B34EF6471 DA71 A6A71 A1 B4F9FEFA1 DA1 A#B548CA9398F1A91DA17F1536398F1A1D54F6ACA91AAE981DA1A#B548CA9398F1231DA6#8CA1B3498A1 DFA1A71457693971877671DA1536398F1D61D87BF78981 111 1 12345678937A3BCADEF73 'F671B457A9F71A1B4AC8A418A61A71596DA71A#87939A717641A718A71A94A13EE71361BA4C871DA1EFD684A1 A913EE71)1ACBF81637161DA6#8CA19ACB71F671B457A9F71A1D54F6ACA91DA1A#B548CA9398F1A91 A1B4F9FEFA1DA1536398F1,A194F878CA17AE98F15488A131!638951D614F6BA195CF811 3 7B3F73E5F8737A3337BE338538E3F73CA8F7379A5A73

/1 A#879A1 B371 54893ACA91 D596DA1 DA1 4554AEA1 7641 A71 AA971 D61 BA4C871 DA1 EFD684A1 7641 3EE71 )1 ACBF81BF641A71A6A7188983ACA915F8571DA1ACBF817F69AF87161EA49381FC4A1DA194336#136#1 %9397*,871CA99A91A13391AA913F43A1D613891DA1D87BF7A41D61CF(A1DA19437BF491D3713EE71)1 ACBF81 83B 3A1 A91 88EA1 04..411 CF94A91 !6A1 A1 3891 DA1 BF775DA41 6A1 F8964A1 BA4CA91 D3EE4F994A1 A71 E 3EA71D94A1A1ACBF81C387153ACA91A1FC4A1D A64A71943385A71637161CCA14A8794A1A71 94336#145387571B341:104..411A91;64A(1A91<46EA104..=1187879A917641AA913F43A1D3F8413EE71)1 6A1 F8964A1 F61 DA1 BF775DA41 6A1 F8964A1 BF641 A71 558E8384A71 D61 4AA61 C88C6C1 DFE1 BF641 A71 BA47FA71 BF9A98AACA91 A71 B671 5F85A71 DA1 ACBF81 F641 :1 !681 7A1 EFEA94A1 7641 384A1 C594FBF8938A1 DA1 2F71 $AA71 A1 3891 DA1 BF775DA41 6A1 F8964A1 36CA9A43891 DA1 >?1 31 B4F388951 DA1 94F6A4161ACBF81BF641A71558E8384A71D614AA61C88C6C1;64A(1A91<46EA1F91B671F81A91CF94A91 !6A13EE71)1615 8E6A1F694A1A13891DA1BA4CA994A1DA17F49841D614AA61C88C6C1BA4CA91)1EA6#1D5)1A1 ACBF81 DA1 94F6A41 DA71 ACBF871 C8A6#1 B3(571 1 %81 :1 A91 @8A41 04..=11 D5CF94A91 !6A1 A1 C3!6A1 D3EE71)1615 8E6A1B4851A791613E9A641C3A641A#B8!6391A71C36387A71BA4F4C3EA717641A1C34E 51 D61943381B3498E684ACA91BF641A71 3893971DA71!63498A471A71B671D53F487571DA1384A1C594FBF8938A1 DA12F71$AA711

1

637131EF9868951DA1EA7194336#1!68187879A917641AA91BF78981DA1558E8A41D61CF(A1DA19437BF491 7641 3EE71 )1 ACBF81 F1 BA691 E89A41 A71 94336#1 DA1 A3B33931 04..C11 F61 DF+A41 E68A(1 A91 83B 3A1 04..C11F641A7194F871384A71C594FBF8938A71DA1<F79F12F71$AA71A91F31G43E87EF1A3B3393194F6A1 !661 CA8A641 3EE71 36#1 EA94A71 DACBF81 B341 9437BF491 B68E1 BF641 EA6#1 !681 F91 B371 DA1 F8964A71 36CA9A1 31 B4F388951 D94A1 A1 ACBF81 38781 !6A1 A1 FC4A1 D A64A71 943385A71 DF+A41 E68A(1 A91 83B 3A1!6391)1A6#133(7A91A71AA971D6A1A#9A78F1D6A18A1A44F8384A1D61EA94A1DACBF871 D(3C8!6A1 67!6A1 DA71!63498A471 AE3571 A91 D53F487571 /71 94F6A91 61AA91BF78981 A91 7888E3981 7641 ACBF81DA1EA71!63498A4711

1

2A71434A7194336#1!681A1G43EA178954A77A91)1EA19(BA1DA1!6A798F17F91D38A6471BF641A77A98A1EA6#1 DA71 CAC4A71 DA1 F94A1 5!68BA1 DA1 4AE A4E A1 %1 CF887391 DA71 7F64EA71 3DC88794398A71 A# 36798A71 F671 3F71 CF9451 !6A1 A1 BF64EA93A1 D5!68BACA91 A1 369FCF8A1 D371 6A1 EFCC6A1 33891 61 8CB3E917888E39817641731D645A1D61E C3A193913618A361398F310666A91;F634D12DF49(14..>11 !6A1/A*DA*G43EA1FH1F1D87BF7A1D8F4C398F71D59385A717641A719ACB71DA19437BF4971DFC8E8A*943381 0666A912DF49(1A91F34814..>11EF84C39138781314A398F194F65A1B341<46A91A912A76A64104..I117641DA71 DF5A71DA!69A134138A6471D3716A1596DA1453875A1)138DA1D6A1C59 FDFF8A1DA19A7981F671 CF94F71!638E A416A1F49A1CF889518943*458F3A1D3716112334125267849AB136CA9A1A71E 3EA71 D94A188951)161A94A98A1DAC36E A1BF641A71A6A7143E88A710666A912DF49(166134!6A91A9891

1 _{&FCCA1A71A945A71D371A1D87BF78981F91A618A61DA18138A414.-.1)1817AB9AC4A14.-.131D645A1DA175F641D371A1}

D87BF78981361CFCA91DA1A!69A1759AD1DA1J1CF871BF641A1DA48A41A6A1A9451817AB9AC4A1)1-=1CF871BF641A1B4AC8A41 A6A1A9451A138A414.-.1

F34814.-.11&A99A1596DA17641DF5A71A#B548CA93A71EFCB34A13EE7136#1A94A98A1DAC36E A17641A71 CCA71F4A71DACBF81DA1E3D8D3971B34389ACA9178C8384A71)1A#EAB98F1D613891!68717F919896384A71F61 F1D61BA4C871$11

1

@387136E61DA1EA7194336#1A791E8517641A71A6A71DF488A1CFDA79A1F61A1D88E6951D87A498F1F641 EA71 B68E71 B3498E68A471 37AEA1 DA1 BA4C871 DA1 EFD684A1 BA691 EF79896A41 6A1 B687739A1 34484A1 )1 31 CF88951 !681 BA691 8C89A41 3EE71 )1 ACBF81 B671 F49ACA91 !6A1 BF641 D3694A71 B68E71 6A1 764E4F991 81 A#879A1 D371 EA1 E 3CB1 DA1 4AE A4E A1 36E6A1 596DA1 CF887391 6A1 3BB4FE A1 DA#B548CA9398F1 EF945A1EA1!6814AD1)131F8719471F48831A91A1CCA19ACB71377A+1A#BF439F84A131B457A9A1596DA1 1

1

73EAEE73F73CA8F73

2A#B548CA9398F11-.1...1BA4C871BF6414567784113159513E5A1B341A1GFD71D%#B548CA9398F1BF64131 KA6A77A1D64391 5951 4..>1 7F671 31 F4CA1D613BBA1)1 B4FA91 DA79851)1 A7ACA1 DA71 7946E964A71 A1 EF93E913AE1DA71A6A71A1D88E6951D87A498F1BF641A641B4FBF7A41DA1EF794684A1DA71B4FA9718F3971 D3EEFCB3ACA91A91DA176A98F1381DA1A7138DA41)1B377A41A641BA4C871DA1EFD684A1=51DF778A471F91 5951 4A9A671 B341 A1 64(1 A91 F91 3891 FA91 D6A1 EF943E96387398F1 2A71 BF49A6471 DA1 B4FA971 7F91 BF641 A77A98A1DA71C8778F71FE3A71F61DA71EFAE98895719A4489F483A71A1EF93E913AE1DA71C8778F71FE3A71 38781 !6A1 !6A!6A71 369F*5EFA71 377FE8398A71 2A71 B4FA971 EF64A91 61 FC4A1 DA1 A6A71 3483A1 DA1 !6A!6A71 D8+38A71 )1 B678A6471 EA938A71 F641 536398F1 81 31 5951 D5E8D51 DA1 D87986A41 A71 1BA98971 BF49A64711 DF91 A1 B4FA91 EFEA4A1 CF871 DA1 -..1 A6A71 A91 A71 14F71 BF49A64711 !681 EFEA4A91 361 CF871-..1A6A71/1(1313619F931C.114F71BF49A64711A914511BA98971BF49A647112536398F1!63989398A1 0A913539F84A11A1EFEA4A1!6A1A71C.114F71BF49A64711!6815D4A91B671DA1-=.17946E964A71D854A9A71 7641A7ACA1D619A4489F84A14333871C594FBF89381

1

$B471 6A1 B 37A1 DA1 B45B34398F1 DA1 A#B548CA9398F1 A71 A6A71 F91 EFCCAE51 )1 4A94A41 D371 A1 D87BF78981)1B349841DA18138A414.-.10E1A1E3AD48A41D593851D371A193A361-11,1A6A1A791B4FBF751 B3417F14554A91!681A791D3713143DA1C3F48951DA71E3716194338A6417FE831D3716A1C8778F1FE3A1 A1 4ACB877391 61 DF778A41 68!6A1 D87E48B98F1 )1 38DA1 D61 789A1 A#943A91 EF361 7B5E88!6ACA91 BF641 A#B548CA9398F1 231 9F938951 DA71 A6A71 558E8384A71 BF9A98A71 B457A9571 B341 A71 A#B548CA939A6471 4ACB891EA1DF778A41DA1E3D8D3964A168!6A1!681EF98A91A7ACA1DA718F4C398F714A!687A71BA4CA99391 DA15488A41317896398F17FE83A1A917FE8F*B4FA778FAA1D61A6A12A71DF778A4717F91EA94387571A9194389571 79398798!6ACA91381DA1D5E484A1A1B4F81DA71E3D8D3971A91D5E349A41A71E3D8D3964A7139(B8!6A710A19A4CA1 DA1D8793EA1)1ACBF81DA14A77F64EA71DA18A361DA1D8BCAL112A#943A91A7916988751)131F871)1DA71871 DA1A798F1DA1A#B548CA9398F1A91)1DA71871D536398F1 1 783 23!75F73F7379CB75AAE537A3F73C8AE53

 37A1B45B3439F84A1  37A1 DA945A1 DA71 A6A71 D371 A1 D87BF78981 4AC84A1 A!69A1 79398798!6A1 36B471 DA71A6A71 %!69A1 79398798!6A1 36B471 DA71 7946E964A71 FAEFDA1 A!69A1 79398798!6A1 36B471 DA71A6A71 %951 4..>1 )1 D5EAC4A14..>1 &FEAB98F1 D61 B4F9FEFA1 A91 DA1 A#943A91

K38A41 4.-.1 )1 7AB9AC4A14.-.1 &F7989698F1 DA71 4F6BA71 9A791 A91 95CF81 G813481MD5691C381 4.--1 FAB9AC4A14.--1 'FAC4A14.--1 1 1

2A71 7946E964A71 7F91 4A945A71 B4F4A778ACA91 D371 A1 D87BF78981 EFCCA1 8D8!6A1 A1 43B 8!6A1 -1 2A71 14F71BF49A647117F91A94571B67143B8DACA91A915938A919F671AAE98ACA913E9871A16814.-.1

1

0 10 20 30 40 50 60 janv ier févr ier mar s avril mai juin _juillet _août sept em bre octo bre

Porteurs dans l'évaluation aléatoire Autres porteurs

Ensemble

1

2A716#1DA945A71DA71A6A71D371A#B548CA9398F1F91A6#13677815951B4F4A77871231A94A1DA945A1 !681 31 5951 EF78D545A1 D371 536398F1 A791 DA1 6891 CF871 361 9F931 2A71 B4AC8A471 DF778A471 F91 5951 A4A87945718138A414.-.1A91A71DA48A471DF778A471EF78D54571D371536398F1F915951A4A879457181 7AB9AC4A14.-.12A143B 8!6A1414A79896A131E 4FFF8A1DA71A945A71D371A#B548CA9398F1231CF89851 DA71A6A715938A914A94571A1C3812A71A945A71F91EF9865136*DA)1DA17AB9AC4A14.-.1C3871AA71F91 B6715951EF78D545A71D371536398F1!63989398A11

1

2A1 B48E8BA1 DA1 536398F1 A791 DA1 EFCB34A41 B34C81 DA71 A6A71 36#1 E343E9548798!6A71 78C8384A71 61 14F6BA1 9A7911 ENA79*)*D84A1 61 A7ACA1 DA1 A6A71 !681 F91 558E8A41 DA1 3E98F1 076A98F1 A91 3EEFCB3ACA917B5E88!6A1A1E3715E 539113AE16114F6BA195CF811DA1A6A71!681A1F91B371A1 558E8A41 &A71 A6A71 D61 14F6BA1 95CF811 F91 53CF871 3EE71 36#1 3694A71 D87BF789871 A#8793971 DF4A71 A91 D5)1 D371 A71 9A4489F84A71 0!6A1 F1 3BBAA1 A71 CA764A71 DA1 1D4F891 EFCC6111 &A1 1D4F891 EFCC611 348A1 EF78D543ACA91 D61 D5B349ACA91 )1 3694A1 0A#879AEA1 F61 F1 D6A1 38DA1 D371 A1 E3D4A1 D61 G$K1 D6A1 F647A1 458F3A1 EFCC63A1 F61 89A4EFCC63A11 A91 D61 A6A1 )1 3694A1 0A1 FE98F1 D61 !6F98A913C8831 DA1 A#879AEA1 F61 B371 D61 &/O/F11 /1 A1 73891 A1 36E61 E371 DA#E64A1 A1 A6A1 D38DA71 5543A71 DF91 81 3643891 D4F891 C3871 68!6ACA91 DA1 3E98F1 7B5E88!6A1 83E5A1 B341 A1 GFD71D%#B548CA9398F1BF64131KA6A77A1381DA1BF6F8418DA988A417F1AA91AA1A1DF89194A1FE94F(5A1 !636#1A6A71D614F6BA19A791'F9F71!66A18F4C398F17B5E88!6A17641A71D87BF789871DA1D4F891EFCC61 3194A1EFAE95A1D371A1E3D4A1DA1A!69A136B471DA717946E964A71!681364318A61A17AB9AC4A14.--1 1

"D#873%2345AC73F73678573F5379CB75AAE53F73657337A7B73$55C73%& &'3 0 1000 2000 3000 4000 5000 6000 7000 8000 9000 10000 janv ier févr ier mar s avril mai juin juill et août sept em bre octo bre Dossiers validés RANDOM TEST Petits porteurs 1 23AE9398F1DA71A6A71D37161F613694A14F6BA1A791AAE965A1B3419843A13617F491&A791A17A61CF(A1 DF91 F1 D87BF7A1 BF641 94A1 7"41 !6A1 A71 DA6#1 4F6BA71 38A91 31 CCA1 EFCBF7898F1 A91 7F8A91 8A1 EFCB343A7102DF49(1A91A98914.--11&A1E F8#13539F84A1DA71A6A71!681A94A91D371A1D87BF78981315951 453875176416A1B548FDA1DA151CF871A94A18138A41A91817AB9AC4A14.-.1&FE49ACA91BF64173F841 !6A71 A6A71 BF644F91 558E8A41 D61 D87BF78981 A71 7946E964A71 4ACB877A91 A1 8A1 A1 DF778A41 68!6A1 D87E48B98F1 BF641 E 3!6A1 A6A1 E3D8D391 361 B4F43CCA1 &A1 7F91 DFE1 A71 A#B548CA939A6471 !681 D58877A91 31 879A1 DA71 A6A71 588A71 361 D87BF78981 6871 D371 61 D5381 DA1 CF871 D6A1 7AC38A1 53639A641DFA136#17946E964A71A145769391D619843A13617F491P1AE367857383#8A71E5A3383 FEA(1 A91 61 A6A1 7641 !6394A1 31 B371 3EE71 361 B4F43CCA1 081 3BB3498A91 3F471 361 14F6BA1 95CF8111

1

2A1 B4F9FEFA1 B45F891 A7689A1 DA1 45387A41 DA6#1 A!69A71 955B F8!6A71 36B471 D61 5E 398F1 DA71 A6A71)1-41CF871B6871)1-51CF87126A131A618A61D5691C3814.--13694A1A791B4F43CC5A1A1FAC4A1 4.--17F671A71A6A711E3D8D39711F91DFE1B3498A1DA1A#B548CA9398F1!6871558E8A91F61F1DA1 38DA17B5E88!6A1

1

7F671 A71 A6A71 E3D8D3971 7F91 8F4C571 361 CFCA91 DA1 31 73878A1 DA1 A641 DF778A41 D87E48B98F1 7641 A#943A91D613891!6871A17F91B3717"471DA1558E8A41D61D87BF789810B48E8BA1D61EF7A9ACA915E384511 E68717F8A91D371A114F6BA19A7911F61A114F6BA195CF8113B4719843A13617F49181A641315951DAC3D51 D3EEAB9A41A#B8E89ACA91DA145BFD4A136#1A!69A71955B F8!6A71B456A71B341A1B4F9FEFA1

1

F8161A6A1A791D371A114F6BA195CF811A71A#B548CA939A64717A17F91A3571)1A1B371E A4E A41)1 EFCBA7A417F17939691A1681FE94F(391DA7138DA71A#EAB98FAA71DF91A1558E8A438A91B371A713694A71 A6A71!681A17F91B371D371A1D87BF78981&A71A6A71A1BA6A915C34A41!636#1D87BF789871DA11D4F891 EFCC611A91EA1BAD3919F69A131D645A1DA1536398F12A#BF89398F1DA1A!69A179398798!6A1B6871EAA1 DA1A!69A136B471DA71BF49A6471BA4CA99A91DA1A15488A41A91DA1B4AD4A131CA764A1DA71D854AEA71DA1 94389ACA91A94A1A71A6A71D614F6BA19A791A91EA6#1D614F6BA195CF81 1 1 $19894A1A#EAB98FA1A91D371A1E371FH161A#B548CA939A641EF78D4A1!681A7918D87BA73A1!661A6A1 4A94A1D371A1B4F43CCA1A91558E8A1DA138DA1361BA4C871DA1EFD684A1BF641DA714387F71!68198AA91)1 7F1 879F84A1 BA47FAA1 )1 731 7896398F1 F61 )1 7F1 B4FA91 A1 A6A1 A791 895451 361 B4F43CCA1 A91

15E 3BBA113619843A13617F491&A99A1BF77888951D5FCC5A1FQA41A7917948E9ACA918C895A1A91CF985A12A71 A#B548CA939A6471D87BF7A91361C3#8C6C1D61FQA41BF641C.1DF778A471B4FBF757123E98398F1D61FQA417A1 3891F471DA187E48B98F1A18A1B341A183871D6178CBA1F69F1D3713BB8E398F1955C398!6A1C3871AA1 A1BA69194A1389A1!6A1B3412CB7DB25B7EB3DFCCB1B341B4FA91B4533ACA918DA9885A1

1

$1 31 81 D61 CF871 DA1 7AB9AC4A1 4.-.1 81 (1 33891 361 9F931 5-4-1 DF778A471 38D571 D371 A#B548CA9398F1 34C81EA71DF778A471J-IC15938A91D371536398F13539F84A1DF91=C=.10R=>1?11D371A14F6BA19A791A91 -J>C1 044-?11 D371 A1 4F6BA1 95CF81 2A71 DF778A471 F1 EF78D54571 D371 536398F1 5938A91 7F891 DA71 DF778A471 877671 DA71 1BA98971 BF49A64711 0>IC11 7F891 DA71 3E98398F71 DA1 FQA41 0C=11 2A71 FQA471 F91 DFE1 83ACA914AB457A951!6A1.I?1DA1A7ACA1DA71DF778A47138D571111

3

E(3F736785737A3#8AC3F73ACBE53

2A1 B48E8BA1 DA1 536398F13539F84A1 A791 DA1 EF79896A41 A71 DA6#1 4F6BA71B341 9843A1 361 7F491DA1 33F1)1 589A41 9F691 83871 DA1 EFCBF7898F1 )1 31 F871 7641 A71 3483A71 F7A43A71 A91 7641 EAA71 !681 A1 7F91 B371 F7A43A71@CA178131B4F388951D615E 398F13A44391A791A#94CACA9138A1EFCB9A19A61DA131 938A1DA71DA6#14F6BA719A791A9195CF8181A791B46DA91DA15488A41!6A1A71DA6#14F6BA71F918A131CCA1 EFCBF7898F1A#1BF791EA79*)*D84A1A71CCA71E343E9548798!6A71A1CF(AA1&A31BA4CA91367781DA1B45E87A41 79398798!6ACA91 A1 B4F81 DA71 A6A71 !681 7F91 D371 A#B548CA9398F1 A91 DA1 D5E484A1 A6471 B48E8B3A71 E343E9548798!6A717FE8F*D5CF43B 8!6A71

1

2A1B4F819(BA1DA71A6A71A791A1768391P1S51A1CF(AA1DA14-1371B371F619471BA61D8BC510A71T1 F91 B371 A1 <3E11 B371 F61 BA61 DA#B548AEA1 B4FA778FAA1 5A451 361 DFC8E8A1 B34A931 0BF641 6A1 34A1CF8985113AE1DA1947138A714AA671F61DA138A718A36#1D3FE398F7176881B341614554A91A1 C8778F1 FE3A1 3AE1 DA1 434A71 F98F71 9 5F48!6A71 F61 B4398!6A71 DA1 31 EFD689A1 2A71 DA6#1 DA484A71 3483A717F91A71B671D88E8A71)1CA764A41A917F91B3498E684ACA91 5954FA711

1

'F6713F71B61EF7939A41!6A13145B349898F1DA718D88D6713617A81DA71DA6#14F6BA71593891!637818DA98!6A1 2A71 !6A!6A71 D854AEA71 4AA5A71 4A79A91 C88CA71 %A71 A1 7F91 B371 767EAB98A71 D86AEA41 A71 457693971 DA1 536398F1 F641 A1 CF94A41 A91 3B471 3F841 E3E651 9F69A71 A71 CF(AA71 BF641 E 3!6A1 E395F48A109438951U195CF811F131AAE96517(795C398!6ACA91DA719A7971DA1D854AEA71DA1EA71CF(AA71 7F69A71 A71 CF(AA71 4A9A6A71 7F91 EFF4CA71 )1  (BF9 7A1 6A1 DF1 7AF1 3!6AA1 81 (1 31 B371 DA1 D854AEA17888E398A1A94A1A71A6A71D614F6BA19A791A91EA6#1D614F6BA195CF81

11237B73C8AA3F73C8AE53

6371 EA99A1DA6#8CA1B3498A1 F671B457A9F71 A71 457693971DA1 A#BF89398F1DA1 A!69A1 955B F8!6A1 453875A1 A1 CF(AA1 6A1 35A1 3B471 A945A1 D371 A1 D87BF78981 36B471 D61 5E 398F1 DA1 -5451 A6A71 2A1 E343E94A1 A#B548CA931 DA1 F71 DF5A71 4AD1 A#BF89398F1 79398798!6A1 DA1 A!69A1 B3498E684ACA91 78CBA1 /173891 DA1 4AE A4E A41 DA1 33F1 7(795C398!6A1 DA71 D854AEA71 79398798!6ACA91 7888E398A71A94A1A14F6BA19A7910A71A6A71!681F91558E851DA138DA17B5E88!6A11A91A14F6BA195CF81 0!681F91A613EE71!6361D4F891EFCC61FE311&FCB9A19A61D61B4F9FEFA1!681A791A194A131CF8D4A1 D854AEA1A7913994863A1)1AA91E36731D6194389ACA91EA79*)*D84A1)131D854AEA1A94A1AA91E36731DA1 3176A98F1A91DA13EEFCB3ACA91A91EA681D61D4F891EFCC617371!6A1F17F891AEF4A1A1CA764A1)1 EA1793DA1DA1536398F1DA1D87986A41A71AA9714A7BAE9871DA71DA6#1FA971CF59384A71A91F1CF59384A71 D61D87BF78981D38DA711 1

25E 398F17A1EFCBF7A1DA1DA6#17F67*5E 398F71P1-...18D88D671D614F6BA19A791A9154518D88D671D61 4F6BA1 95CF81 &A71 -5451 8D88D671 F91 45BFD61 )1 61 CCA1 !6A798F384A1 DA1 -=1 C869A71 !681 EF64A1 !6394A143DA714648!6A71P1317896398F1D61A6A14A398ACA91361BA4C871DA1EFD684A121A71EFD898F71DA1 FACA9121317896398F1B4FA778FAA1A9183E84A121317896398F1BA47FAA1A913C883A1D61A6A1F641 E 3E6A1DA71!6A798F71A7145BF7A71CF(AA71F915951E3E65A71A91DA719A7971F915951AAE96571381DA1 73F841 781 A71 D854AEA71 DA1 CF(AA71 5938A91 79398798!6ACA91 7888E398A71 A94A1 A1 4F6BA1 9A791 A91 A1 4F6BA195CF81A917AF1!6A1A71A6A71F91F9A671 F61F1A1BA4C871DA1EFD684A1&A71DA6#1A945A71 BA4CA99A91DA1D87986A41AA91D6194389ACA91038DA17B5E88!6A1V176A98FW3EEFCB3ACA911A91AA91 B4FB4A1D61BA4C871DA1EFD684A1 1 F7337838537((7A3BEA5A38373A893F7383893F((C75A73C7873F837B3F73 E5F873

34C81 A71 A6A71 !681 F91 558E851 DA1 38DA1 7B5E88!6A1 F1 D5FC4A1 4=41 9896384A71 D61 BA4C871 EF94A1 JI51F19896384A71$617A81D614F6BA195CF81F14AEA7A1--C19896384A71BF641J-=1F19896384A712A1936#1 DF9A98F1 D61 BA4C871 DA1 EFD684A1 A791 DFE1 DA1 4=41 ?1 D371 A1 4F6BA1 9A791 EF94A1 -CR1 ?1 D371 A1 4F6BA195CF81/1348A138781D6178CBA1361DF6A1A94A1A71A6A7138D571A91A713694A71&A99A1D854AEA1 A791 7888E398A1 A91 BA691 DFE1 94A1 3994865A1 )1 8CB3E91 E36731 DA1 A#B548CA9398F1P1 F1 BA691 D84A1 !6A1 A#B548CA9398F131C698B851B341DA6#1A71E 3EA71DF9A8417F1BA4C871DA1EFD684A161313B471A945A1 D371A1D87BF789811

1

2A1CCA19(BA1DA1EFCB34387F1BA69194A1AAE9651A1D5EFCBF7391E 3E6A1DA71593BA7176EEA778A71D61 B34EF6471D61A6A1!681B377A17F1BA4C871P187E48B98F1D3716A1369F*5EFA1F9A98F1D61EFDA1F9A98F1 D61 BA4C871 3E!687898F1 D61 5 8E6A1 'F671 EF7939F71 DA71 D854AEA71 8CBF4939A71 A91 7888E398A71 )1 E 3E6A1 DA71 593BA71 DA1 EA1 B34EF6471 093A361 411 :1 F7A4A1 !6A1 551 ?1 DA71 A6A71 D61 4F6BA1 9A791 D5E34A91 94A1 3E96AACA91 87E48971 D371 6A1 369F1 5EFA1 A91 RJ-=1 ?1 DA1 EA6#1 D61 4F6BA1 95CF81 2A71 A6A713EEFCB3571A9176A98F5717F91=C1?1)13F841F9A61A641EFDA193D871!6A1A7195CF8717F91 CI41?1)13F841F9A61%81A71D59ADA6471D6A1F8964A17F91-RC1?1E A+1A7176A98F571A91>>1?1 E A+1A7195CF8711 3 783%33E)7E53F73678573F5373FCE87B75A3F837B3F73E5F8733 06131A1CF(AA13B471A945A1D371A1D87BF789813

1 ;4F6BA19A791 ;4F6BA195CF81 6854AEA1

/7E48B98F1D3716A1369F1 5EFA1 551?1 RJ-=1?1 14.51 &FDA1F9A61 =C1?1 CI41?1 -551 A4C871F9A61 4=41?1 -CR1?1 --R1 687BF7898F1D6A1F8964A1 -RC1?1 >>1?1 RI1 1

671 F1 4ACF9A1 A1 3CF91 D61 B34EF6471 !681 EFD6891 )1 F9A98F1 D61 BA4C871 DA1 EFD684A1 B671 31 D854AEA1A7915A5A1A94A1A71DA6#14F6BA71287E48B98F1D3716A1369F*5EFA1EF79896A13964AACA91

6A1593BA1D5E878A1A91D87E48C839A168715E3491D8C86A1A94A1A71DA6#14F6BA71C3871BA4D64A19F691361 F1 D61 B4FEA77671 D3BB4A98773A1 2A1 93A361 C1 D5938A1 A71 457693971 A1 E3E6391 A71 B4FBF498F71 )1 E 3!6A1593BA1D61B34EF6471BF641EA6#1!681F91B37751593BA1B45E5DA9A1341A#ACBA1B34C81EA6#1!681 F91B371A61A1EFDA1JI41?1DA71A6A71D614F6BA19A7917F9187E48971D3716A1369F*5EFA1EF94A1=.1?1 7A6ACA91BF641A14F6BA195CF811

1

34C81EA6#1!681F91F9A61A1EFDA131B3491DA1EA6#1!681F91F9A61D71A1B4AC8A41A77381A79131CCA1 D371 A71 4F6BA71 A91 81 A1 31 DA1 CCA1 BF641 EA6#1 !681 F91 F9A61 )1 31 DA6#8CA1 9A9398A1 FA6A1 31 B4FBF498F1DA1EA6#1!681F91F9A61A1EFDA1)13194F878CA19A9398A1A9136*DA)1A7917888E398ACA91B671 F49A1D371A14F6BA19A791:1A1D5D68431!6A13176A98F1A913EEFCB3ACA91A13E889A91B371A71 E 3EA71DF9A841A1EFDA1F47!6F1A1B377A1C38713E889A91A13891DA1A14AB377A41781F1A1439A11 1 783*334((7A3F733875AE537A3F73EB)57B75A383AA8F7333BEAC33 06131A1CF(AA13B471A945A1D371A1D87BF789813

3 7A3 CBE53 +((C7573 ,A8F75A3 E23A#873 -37A3 -3 CBE53 $1B37751A91F9A61A1EFDA1 =C.?1 CI4?1 -55?1 5->1 ....1 >>-1 54I1

!EF735E53EA75833 1 1 1 1 1 1 1

/7E4891D3716A1369F15EFA1 JI4?1 =..?1 4I4?1 54-1 ....1 IRR1 =I41

F81F681P1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1

&FDA1BF64131B4AC84A1F871 =4C?1 =IR?1 *4C?1 .=J1 .=R>I>1 CIR1 4J-1 &FDA1BF64131DA6#8CA1F871 -=R?1 -RR?1 *-.?1 .CC1 .JC5-R1 CIR1 4J-1 &FDA194F871F871A91B671 -4J?1 II?1 5C?1 C5.1 ....-=1 CIR1 4J-1 'A1B377A1B371A1EFDA1 ->I?1 4II?1 *=.?1 -I51 .-CJ551 CIR1 4J-1

!EF73EA75833 1 1 1 1 1 1 1

$1F9A61A1BA4C871 IJR?1 I.-?1 J=?1 4.J1 ..C54I1 =4=1 4541

7B35E53EA75833 1 1 1 1 1 1 1

%194381DA14AB377A41 5JR?1 5-J?1 R.?1 -RJ1 ..>IR>1 4J=1 -R>1 'FC4A19F931DN A64A71 4C=1 4C51 *.I1 .441 .54=4-1 4J=1 -R>1 'FC4A1DN A64A71B3417AC38A1 4C1 ->1 .C1 -4.1 .445>J1 4J=1 -R>1

7B3EA75833 1 1 1 1 1 1 1

11111D61B4AC8A41EF6B1 R4I?1 =5I?1 I.?1 .J41 .IJ4I=1 4=.1 --C1

11111D61DA6#8CA1EF6B1 4I5?1 C.-?1 *=C?1 -.I1 .C..CR1 4=.1 --C1 1111194F871F871A91B671 -45?1 --=?1 -C?1 .C=1 .J4I-C1 4=.1 --C1 'FC4A19F931DN A64A71 C451 C-I1 -I1 .JJ1 .IC>5C1 4=.1 --C1 'FC4A1DN A64A71B3417AC38A1 CJ1 I-1 *.I1 -441 .44CJR1 4=.1 --C1 &F"91D61BA4C871 R54I1 -.I5=1 *CRR-1 =C51 ....1 4=.1 --C1 687BF7A1DN6A1F8964A1 RI5?1 J4R?1 *J5?1 -=.1 .-CC-C1 4=.1 --C1

+E73F8573EA8733 1 1 1 1 1 1 1

$13E A95131F8964A1 J.I?1 R>=?1 .>?1 .-I1 .5>.C.1 -R41 541

'FC4A1QC1B3417AC38A1 -R541 -=RR1 --R1 .I-1 .R54IC1 -R41 541

'FC4A1DA1BF8971 R4I1 R4.1 ..=1 .4R1 .J>5C.1 -R41 541

$EE8DA91DA1F8964A1 --J?1 5=?1 C4?1 .5.1 .I4CRC1 -R41 541

F64851A136A1P1D854AEA717888E398A71)1=1?1A1A491P1)1-.1?1F17648571P1F17888E3981

1

7F6F6471 B34C81 A71 A6A71 !681 F91 F9A61 A1 EFDA1 A1 3891 DA1 558E8A41 DA1 31 76A98F1 A91 DA1 3EEFCB3ACA91 36CA9A1 7A78ACA91 A71 E 3EA71 DF9A841 A1 BA4C871 2A1 936#1 DA1 76EE71 361 BA4C871A791DA1IJR1?1BF641A71A6A713EEFCB3571EF94A1I.-1?1BF641A713694A712F47!68715E F6A91 )15B4A6A1B4398!6A1A71A6A713EEFCB3571314AB377A9161BA61B67145!6ACCA91!6A1A71A6A71D61 4F6BA195CF81

1

,A1 D854AEA1 8954A7739A1 EFEA4A1 A1 EF"91 D61 BA4C871 2A71 A6A71 3EEFCB3571 D5E34A91 !6A1 A1 4A79A1)1E 34A1A791A1CF(AA1DA1R54I1X1EA1!681CF94A1!6A13176A98F1!681A791D61BA61CF871DA1 -...1X1A1EF64A1B371319F938951D61EF"91D61BA4C871F81DA1)12A71A6A71F13EEFCB3571F91!6391)1

A6#1614A79A1)1E 34A1DA1-.I51X1EA1!6817888A1!6871A173E!6899A91B371F1B671DA1319F938951D61EF"91 D61BA4C8712A71CA764A71DA1D4F891EFCC613EEA778A71FE3ACA91BA4CA99A91D35A41A1EF"91D61BA4C871 BF641EA71A6A71A1D88E6951D87A498F1231D854AEA1A791DA1CRR-.1X1A91A7918A185A1)1615E3491D371A1 CF93971DA7138DA71A475A71B687!6A1A1FC4A1D A64A71DA1EFD689A1A791A1CCA1A1CF(AA1D371A71 DA6#1 4F6BA71 &A31 7888A1 !6A1 9F671 A71 AA971 BF789871 !6A1 F671 AF71 DA1 CA994A1 A1 58DAEA1 EF44A7BFDA9136#1AA971DA1EA915E3491DA1CRR-.1X1A91)1EA6#1DA71CA64A71D3EEFCB3ACA911

1

34C81EA6#1!681D87BF7A91D6A1F8964A181(136E6A1D854AEA1764131B3491DA1EA6#1!681F913E A95A17641 A1 FC4A1 DA1 BF8971 7641 A1 FC4A1 DA1 Q8FC94A71 B34EF64671 A1 CF(AA1 E 3!6A1 7AC38A1 A91 7641 31 45!6AEA1 DA71 3EE8DA971 DA1 31 4F69A1 F6A98F1 A91 3EEFCB3ACA91 A#A4EA91 DFE1 36E61 AA91 E3673176419F671EA7137BAE97111

1 3

+737((7A383373F8AE5EB737A3833BEAC3CF75A773F73678573

8A34DF71 C389A391 31 7896398F1 D61 FACA91BF641 A71DA6#14F6BA712A193A361I1B377A1A14A6A1 6A175AE98F1DA713483A71!681D5E48A91317896398F1DA1FACA91DA71A6A71:1EF7939A1!681(131A1 5543136E6A1D854AEA17888E398A1A94A1A71DA6#14F6BA7173617641A71!6A798F71!681BF49A91764131 7896398F1DA1FACA912A71A6A71!681F91558E851DA13176A98F1A91DA13EEFCB3ACA91 389A91 B671 45!6ACCA91 61 FACA91 8D5BAD391 A91 F91 D5C5351 F61 ACC5351 CF871 45!6ACCA91 361 EF6471DA71DF6+A1DA48A471CF871B45E5D391A!69A11 3 783.334((7A3F733875AE537A3F73EB)57B75A3837B3F73E5F873833 A8AE53F73E)7B75A3 06131A1CF(AA13B471A945A1D371A1D87BF789813 O3483A1DA1EF94A1 7A791 0'V>>-11 75CF81

0'V54I11 6854AEA1 F96DA91 4F1&4898!6A1

$A1 44C1 44I1 ..1 .I.1 .R>.C.1

2FACA918D5BAD391 ==>?1 IC5?1 -4-?1 =-J1 ....1 $BB349ACA91 =>>?1 R.5?1 *.>?1 .CJ1 .J.5R=1 O8917A61 ---?1 -CR?1 *4=?1 -R.1 .-.>4-1 $1DA71A3971 -=J?1 -I4?1 -=?1 .>41 .C=5.C1 $1D5C53511 -=R?1 4C5?1 *5-?1 ICC1 .....-1 F64851A136A1P1D854AEA717888E398A71)1=1?1A1A491P1)1-.1?1F17648571P1F17888E3981 3 1 &A71D854AEA71A1DF8A91B37194A1C3189A4B4595A71%A71A17F91B37185A713613891F61F1D3F841A61A1 BA4C871EFCCA1A1CF94A91A7193A36#11=1A91R1FH1F91D87986A91A71A6A71D371A71DA6#1E371DA1 864A1/1(1318A16A1D854AEA179398798!6ACA917888E398A10EFFA1DA1D4F89A1DA7193A36#1=1A91R117641 A71 EFD898F71 DA1 FACA91 !6A1 A71 A6A71 38A91 F61 F1 A641 BA4C871 DA1 EFD684A1 :1 EF7939A1 E384ACA91 6A1 CF8D4A1 B4FBF498F1 DA71 8D88D671 D61 4F6BA1 DA1 94389ACA91 )1 84A1 D371 61 FACA91 8D5BAD391 !6871 38A91 F61 F1 A1 BA4C871 %1 EF94AB3498A1 871 7F91 B671 FC4A6#1 !6A1 A6471 FCFF6A71)184A1E A+1A6471B34A971&A1A791DFE1B37161AA91D61BA4C871EA79161AA91D61EF6BA1 76A98F*3EEFCB3ACA91 2A#B548CA9398F1 31 A61 61 AA91 7641 A1 3891 D 389A41 D371 61 FACA91 8D5BAD391%A1313F48751369FFC8A14578DA98AA1DA71A6A711

1

783/33031A723E83A877B75A3F53853E)7B75A35FC75F5A333433

3 "E873A7A3 "E873ACBE53 4F31E4898!6A1

5833 3 3 1 7B3 //6/373 . 68373 ..-C=1 -E537B3 /.69373 .%6:373 Y...-1 4F31E4898!6A1 .5RRJ1 .5-.41 1 1 1 1 1 -E563D7237375A3 3 3 1 7B3 *968:373 /%6%373 ..4=R1

-E537B3 .&6;:373 .969*373 ....I1

4F31E4898!6A1 .JR.41 .R=4=1 1

1

&A1387391F13643891B61BA7A41!6A1A71A6A71D614F6BA19A79136438A91A616A1B671F49A1B4FBA78F1)1 D5C53A41 B687!6871 7F91 B671 FC4A6#1 )1 FEE6BA41 61 FACA91 8D5BAD391 C3871 A71 E 84A71 95CF8A91DA18A47A1&A17F91C38A79ACA91A7195CF871!681F91A1B671D5C5351361EF6471DA71-41 DA48A471CF871$1F6A36181A173891B371D61AA91D61B3773A1D61BA4C871EFCCA1A1CF94A1A193A361 R1 C3871 8A1 D61 AA91 DA1 A#B548CA9398F1 F641 BA4EAF841 31 76A98F1 A91 558E8A41 DA1 3EEFCB3ACA91 A71 A6A71 A1 DF8A91 B371 E 3A41 DA1 C8778F1 FE3A1 A91 DF8A91 DACA64A41 A1 BF7898F1D3EE5DA41)1A641369F*5EFA16A71D5C53ACA971DA1B4F#8C89517F91A873A3A71C3871DA71 CF8895714578DA98AA71B671F8938A717F918EFCB398A713AE1A1C3898A1DA138DA1BF641A71A6A71!681 A1558E8A91&A791BF64!6F81A#B548CA9398F131B618C89A4131B4FBA78F1)131CF889514578DA98AA1DA71 A6A71BAD39131D645A1DA131B45B34398F1DA1A641BA4C871DA1EFD684A12A1C3898A1DA187E48B98F1D371 A641369F*5EFA1A71ACBE A1DA1D5C53A41D61CF871DA1B34984194FB1F81DA1A641369F*5EFA1238DA1F6A1 3F471EFCCA1614A81361D5C53ACA911 1 78383303<72=E83FCBC5)C3E837BBC5)C383E83F73 %3F7573BE33343

3 "E873A7A3 "E873ACBE53 4F31E4898!6A1

7B3 *69373 %*6& 373 ..C.>1 -E537B3 86.373 %*69:373 ....C1 4F31E4898!6A1 .CCRJ1 .54-R1 1 1 &FCCA91A71A6A71558E8384A71DA138DA17B5E88!6A1BA6A9*871)131F8713F841)131F8716A1CF88951 4578DA98AA1B67138A1A916A1B487A1D8D5BAD3EA14578DA98AA1B6718CBF4939A1Z1&FCCA91BA69*F1 D5EF 389A41D3393A17371D5C53A41D3393A1Z1,A145BF7A14578DA1D37131CF889514578DA98AA1 DA71B34A971FAF1/7AA1A1936#136A1DA1CF889514578DA98AA1A791DA1>1?1A1G43EA1C594FBF8938A1 & 3!6A1 35A1 81 A791 DFE1 B4F3A1 !6A84F1 61 C53A1 7641 D8#1 !6899A1 7F1 FACA91 BF641 D5C53A412A71A6A71!681558E8A91DA13176A98F1A91DA13EEFCB3ACA91768438A916A1BA49A1 8CBF4939A1787176838A91A6471B34A971D371EA71D5C53ACA971C3871EA1A791B371A1E371DA1EA6#1!681 F91 B371 4A361 38DA1 /1 A791 DFE1 B4F3A1 !6A1 A71 D5C53ACA971 DA71 B34A971 B4FF!6A91 31 D5EF 389398F1DA71A3971!681A1D5C53A91B371A91EF7A4A913BB349ACA91DA71B34A971361CF871 BAD391A19ACB71DA1A641B3773A1DA1BA4C871DA1EFD684A11 1 F81A#B548CA9398F131B371DAA917641A19(BA1DA1FACA91A14A3E A1A13891DA1456778417F1BA4C871 A791377FE851BF7898ACA913613891DA14578DA41A1C387F1B6991!6A13BB349ACA916371A193A361J1F1 F891DA71D854AEA717888E398A71A94A1A71A6A713AE1A917371BA4C871!687138A91F61F1558E851DA1 38DA1 361 BA4C871 2A71 8D88D671 9896384A71 D61 BA4C871 7F91 A36EF6B1 B671 FC4A6#1 )1 84A1 A1 C387F1 !6A1 3BB349ACA91 @3871 EA99A1 EF445398F1 A791 4387AC3ACA91 B371 A1 78A1 D6A1 E36738951 :1 EFCB34A1 8E81 DA71 BFB6398F71 D854A9A71 :1 31 EA99A1 F871 61 AA91 D61 BA4C871 A91 F1 B671 DA1 A#B548CA9398F1%9391DF5A13138A1B4FBF498F1DA1D5C53ACA917641A71DF6+A1DA48A471CF871F1 A1BA691B371D84A1!6A1EA791A1BA4C871!6813F487A1ACC53ACA91A1C387F1C3871B69918A47A1&A1 7F91A71A6A71 389391A1C387F1!6815B4F6A91A1B671315EA778951DA1B377A41A1BA4C871&AE81A791851 3613891!6A1EA71A6A71 389A91D371DA71+FA71B6991A#EA945A71A91B4F3ACA914643A710A91F1D371 A71EA94A71643871DA77A4871B341A71457A36#1DA19437BF491A11EFCC611 1 783;3303+53#873A>73F73E)7B75A3DA72=E833343

3 "E873A7A3 "E873ACBE53 4F31E4898!6A1

?E53 3 3 1

7B3 /&6&&373 .968373 .>CJ>1

-E537B3 **6;&373 **6:/373 .>I>J1

4F31E4898!6A1 Y...-1 ...-41 1

1 1 1 1

<A7B75A3 3 3 1

-E537B3 8%6;373 8 6:373 .J45.1

4F31E4898!6A1 ....-1 ..4-R1 1

1

1

3F7((7A375E7377A73833A8AE53F7BE33

2A1 B3773A1 D61 BA4C871 DA1 EFD684A1 BA691 94A1 3778C851 )1 6A1 F4C398F1 B4FA778FAA1 A91 F1 BA691 787B84A41DA7194336#1D536398F17641A71AA971DA131F4C398F1BF641A1D87E69A41A71AA9717641ACBF81 &A71 94336#1 CA99A91 A158DAEA1 94F871 9(BA71 DAA971 D8798E971 D371 A1 9ACB71P1 AA91 A#*39A1 03391 31 F4C398F11AA91DA1FEQ*810BAD39131F4C398F11A91AA91A#*BF79103B4711341A#ACBA161A6A1!681 B45B34A1 5B4A6A1 9 5F48!6A1 F61 B4398!6A1 D61 BA4C871 DA1 EFD684A1 A791 FD51 )1 45D684A1 7A71 AF4971 DA1 4AE A4E A1 DACBF81 $1 EF94348F1 F9A98F1 D61 BA4C871 BA691 36CA9A41 31 CF98398F1 D61 A6A1 A91 89A78951DA17A71AF4971DA14AE A4E A1DACBF81%19 5F48A1A71AA9718CC5D83971D6A1F4C398F1A17F91 B3715EA77384ACA91A71CCA71!6A1A71AA971B7EFD91

1

6371A1E371DA1A#B548CA9398F1F1A1EF7939A1B371DAA911F93A1DA138DA1DF91558E8A1A71A6A71 817641A71E 3EA71D3EE5DA41)161ACBF8181764131!638951DA71ACBF871FEE6B5719AA1!6AA1BA69194A1 3BB4FE 5A1361943A471D6173384A1D619(BA1DA1EF94391DA1943381D617939691DACBF81F61AEF4A1D61CF9391 DA71 4AA671 DA1 4ACB3EACA91 6371 A1 93A361 51 !681 4AB4AD1 9F671 EA71 55CA971 36E6A1 D854AEA1 7888E398A15CA4A1764136E6189AC1A94A1A14F6BA19A791A91A14F6BA195CF811

783:334((7A3F733875AE537A3F73EB)57B75A3837B3F73E5F873 06131A1CF(AA13B471A945A1D371A1D87BF789813

O3483A1DA1EF94A1 7A791 0'V>>-11

75CF81

0'V54I11 6854AEA1 F96DA91 4F1&4898!6A1

A4EAB98F14AA671P1 1 1 1 1 1

F3384A1 I->?1 C>4?1 4J?1 --R1 .4IR>.1

/DAC89571E C3A1 -I5?1 -I-?1 .5?1 .IR1 .RI5--1

&/O/F1 -C.?1 -C5?1 *.5?1 .=-1 .R--4>1

&'$F%$1A91F647A1 =.?1 =J?1 *.J?1 .R41 .=CRJI1

8F$1 --4?1 --.?1 .4?1 .--1 .>-==R1

34A971 55?1 -.-?1 *-C?1 .>I1 .CI55R1

$FE398F71FACA91 4.-?1 44>?1 *4>?1 -IJ1 .-I-..1

$694A71 I5?1 =4?1 *.I?1 .CR1 .J-RIJ1

$1BA4361614AA61 J5=?1 JJ-?1 -I?1 .JI1 .IR-541

@F9391D614AA6103AE1.11 =4R1 =441 I1 .-51 .5=I>51

F939691P1 1 1 1 1 1

F334851 C.-?1 C--?1 *-.?1 .IR1 .RIR4C1

8AE A4E A1ACBF81 I54?1 IJ5?1 .I?1 .-51 .5=5>=1

GF4C398F1 -II?1 -=.?1 *.R?1 .CJ1 .J--IR1

/3E981 JC?1 R-?1 -4?1 -.41 .C.R=J1

%CBF81P1 1 1 1 1 1

68E1 -I5?1 -I.?1 .>?1 .=C1 .=>=RC1

4851 -C=?1 -R.?1 *4=?1 -I>1 .-CRI.1

/3E981 J-R?1 J..?1 -R?1 .JR1 .II>JJ1

&F1P1 1 1 1 1 1

:648A41 -4>?1 -4J?1 .4?1 .--1 .>-4CI1

%CF(51 -RR?1 -JJ?1 *--?1 .R.1 .=I5CR1

/3E981 J.I?1 R>=?1 .>?1 .I-1 .RJ55.1

&F94391DA1943381P1 1 1 1 1 1

&F943918D59A4C851 5-?1 >R?1 *-=?1 --C1 .4=>..1

&F94391EF6491 4-=?1 4.>?1 .R?1 .C41 .JIJ=51

/3E981 J.I?1 R>=?1 .>?1 .I-1 .RJ55.1

3

F64136939131D59A98F1D61BA4C871DA1EFD684A1A7918A1377FE85A1BF7898ACA91A917888E398ACA91)1DA1 FC4A6#1 8D8E39A6471 8571 )1 ACBF81 EFCCA1 B341 A#ACBA1 A1 3891 DA1 BA4EAF841 F61 F1 61 73384A1 2A1 CF871B45E5D391A!69A1A718D88D6719896384A71D61BA4C871DA1EFD684A17F9134ACA91B671FC4A6#1)1 3F841BA43616173384A1!6A1A718D88D671F19896384A71093A361>11@387181A173891B3718E81D61AA91DA1 38DA1361B3773A1D61BA4C871B687!6A1EA91AA91A791A1CCA1BF641A71DA6#14F6BA7138D571A91F138D571 2A1 BA4C871 A791377FE851BF7898ACA913613891DA1 9F6E A41 61 73384A1 7371!6A1 F1B6877A1593841 61 8A1 E36731 A94A1 A71 DA6#1 55CA971 /1 7A1 BA691 !6A1 EA1 7F891 A1 3891 DA1 D87BF7A41 D61 BA4C871 !681 BA4CA99A1 D36CA9A417A71E 3EA71DA1BA4EAF8416173384A1/17A1BA691367781!6A1EA17F891A13891DA1BA4EAF84161 73384A1!6813E889A13EE71361BA4C871B34EA1!681BA4CA91DA1AA4131EF94389A183E84A1851361B38ACA91 D614A79A1)1E 34A11

1

78393303<72=E837@838537373BE3F75733343

3 "E873A7A3 "E873ACBE53 4F31E4898!6A1

7B3 .:6&%373 .:6;&373 .>.J>1 -E537B3 *:6;;373 *;6 373 .=-I51 4F31E4898!6A1 ...>51 ..->-1 1 1 1 1 1

F81 F1 4A34DA1 31 B3491 DA71 A6A71 !681 8D8!6A91 !6871 FEE6BA91 61 ACBF81 F1 F98A91 53ACA91 DA71 D854AEA717AF1!68717F919896384A71F61F1D61BA4C871DA1EFD684A1093A361-.11@3871EA99A1F87*E8131

D854AEA1A7917888E398A1!6A1BF641A71A6A71!681F91B371595138D571:1BA691(1F841)1F6A36161 AA91DA1FEQ*8185136#1CFD389571DA1A#B548CA9398F12A71A6A71!681F91595138D5717F91B671FC4A6#1 )1B377A41A641BA4C871A91F91DFE1)1EF64919A4CA1CF871DA19ACB71BF6414A94F6A4161ACBF81!6A1A71A6A71 !681F91B371595138D57136*DA)1D61D4F891EFCC61&A91AA91A1DA43891B371BA47879A41F471DA1317AEFDA1 A!69A1 1

F3877391 DA1 31 4AE A4E A1 DACBF81 F1 F7A4A1 6A1 B671 43DA1 B4FBF498F1 DA1 A6A71 A1 4AE A4E A1 DACBF81B34C81EA6#1!681F91B371A1BA4C87131D854AEA13AE1EA6#1!681F91A1BA4C871593919F69AF871 7888E398A1 !6361 7A681 DA1 -.1 ?1 EA1 !681 A791 EF 54A91 B687!6871 7F91 CF871 FC4A6#1 )1 A#A4EA41 61 ACBF811

1

783 &3303A87737A3EA73A8AE53E(7E557733343

3 "E873A7A3 "E873ACBE53 4F31E4898!6A1

4537BE3 3 3 1

7B3 **6**373 .&6; 373 .-JIJ1

-E537B3 %:6.:373 %96*;373 .J.R41

4F31E4898!6A1 .-IIJ1 ..-=I1 1

1 1 1 1

B7D7D738537BE3 3 3 1

7B3 .*68/373 .&6; 373 .R..=1

-E537B3 /&2&&373 .96&9373 .J45C1

4F31E4898!6A1 ..5-C1 ..>JR1 1

1

8A34DF71)1B457A91317896398F1DA718D88D671A1ACBF812A193A361--1DFA13145B349898F1DA71A6A71 7AF1A19(BA1DA1EF94391F641A71&6/1F1EF7939A16A1D854AEA1BF7898A17A6ACA91BF641A719896384A71 D61 BA4C871 D371 A1 4F6BA1 95CF81 ,A1 89A4B459398F1 A791 !681 A#879A1 61 AA91 BF78981 D61 BA4C871 7641 31 B4F388951DA194F6A4161ACBF81A1&6/1C3871!6A1EA91AA91A791EFCBA751B341A1FEQ*81DA718D88D671DA1 4F6BA19A791/17A4318954A77391DA15488A41F471DA1317AEFDA1A!69A1781EA91AA91A791C389A61:1A1 EF7939A1 B371 DA1 9AA71 D854AEA71 BF641 A71 &661 :1 BA691 A1 D5D684A1 !6A1 AA91 DA1 FEQ*81 7A#A4EA1 CF871BF641A719896384A71D61BA4C871!681F91595138D5712A71EF943971)1D645A1D59A4C85A17F91B6713E8A71)1 D5E4FE A41 !6A1 A71 &6/1 A91 DAC3DA91 DFE1 CF871 D89A78951 DA1 4AE A4E A1 BF641 A71 DAC3DA6471 DACBF81F641A1943381A189548C181A#879A1B371DA1D854AEA17888E398A1A94A14F6BA19A791A914F6BA1 95CF81813617A81D614F6BA195CF81FA671A719896384A71D61BA4C871D614F6BA19A7917F917888E398ACA91 B671FC4A6#1)194338A41A189548C1:1BA691(1F841)136778161AA91DA1FEQ*812A71A6A7138D571F91D61 D"145D684A1A6414AE A4E A1DACBF81BF641C8A6#1B45B34A41A1B3773A1DA1A641BA4C871DA1EFD684A18717A1 7F91D848571D3393A1)1EF64919A4CA1A47189548C1!681D6A1B3491BA4CA9161CA8A6413679ACA91A94A1 F4C398F1A91ACBF81A91D3694A1B349145D6891A71EF"971DA14AE A4E A1

1 1

783 3303A8737A373A>73F73EA73E5AA3F73A33343

3 "E873A7A3 "E873ACBE53 4F31E4898!6A1

!+13 3 3 1 7B3 ;6 .373 /6&.373 ..-JJ1 -E537B3 :6.%373 :68;373 .5R=.1 4F31E4898!6A1 .=4.-1 ..C4-1 1 1 1 1 1 !++3 3 3 1 7B3 /6&:373 86: 373 .RJI.1

-E537B3 .6*&373 86&:373 .CICI1

4F31E4898!6A1 .JR4>1 .5I=.1 1

1 1 1 1

15ACB3 3 3 1

7B3 :6;*373 /6* 373 .4=J=1

-E537B3 .6& 373 *6%%373 .I-R>1

4F31E4898!6A1 ...C=1 .4R-C1 1

1

%1F694A131D645A1D61EF94391DA1943381A791B671F6A1BF641A71A6A719896384A71D61BA4C871A91!681F915951 38D5714A398ACA91)1EA6#1!681F91B371A641BA4C871DA1EFD684A1EA1!6813877A17654A41!6A1A1BA4C871 43FA1 31 D645A1 DA71 EF943971 093A361 -411 &ABAD391 EA99A1 EF7939398F1 A791 )1 63EA41 E341 8E81 A71 5E 398F714A79A91BA98971053CF87176B548A6471)1C.11,1A#3CA1B6713BB4FFD817A431BF778A1F471 DA131DA6#8CA1A!69A1

1

783 %3303A87737A33F8C73F7373E5AA333$753BE'343

3 "E873A7A3 "E873ACBE53 4F31E4898!6A1

7B3 86:3 /6&/33 .-ICR1

-E537B3 /6*;33 /6% 33 .JJ.C1

4F31E4898!6A1 ..RRC1 .5=>R1 1

1

2A713694A713483A71!681D5E48A91317896398F1DACBF81A91A71E343E9548798!6A71DA1314AE A4E A1DACBF81 A1F91B3713BB343994A1DA1D854AEA717888E398A71A94A1A71A6A71!681F91558E851DA138DA1A91EA6#1 !681A1F91B371558E8511

1

+737((7A3EA(3835AC)AE53E73F73678573

231 DA484A1 B3498A1 D61 !6A798F384A1 593891 EF73E45A1 36#1 4A398F71 7FE83A71 DA71 A6A71 A91 )1 A641 8954398F1 7FE83A1 /1 (1 31 8E81 367781 DA71 457693971 8954A773971 !681 C5489A438A91 D94A1 3BB4FFD871 :1 EF7939A1B341A#ACBA16A1D854AEA17888E398A1D37131B3498E8B398F15AE9F43A1DA71A6A717AF1!6871 F91595138D571F61F12A1936#1DA1B3498E8B398F1A791DA1=I1BF891B6715A51BF641A71A6A71!681F915951 38D571 /1 73891 8E81 DA71 5AE98F71 458F3A71 DA1 4.-.1 @3 A64A67ACA91 F1 A1 BA691 D59A4C8A41 781 EA91 5E3491A791D61)161764E4F991DA1B3498E8B398F1DA131B3491DA71A6A71!681F914A36138DA1F61)16A1CF8D4A1 B3498E8B398F1DA71A6A71!681A1F91B371558E85134138A6471F1A194F6A1B371DA1D854AEA717641 A71EFCBF49ACA971DA1B3498E8B398F1377FE8398A11

1

Tableau 13 : Effet de l’aide à l’obtention du permis O3483A1DA1EF94A1 7A791

0'V>>-11

75CF81

0'V54I11 6854AEA1 F96DA91 4F1E4898!6A1 3498E8B398F15AE98F1 IIJ?1 C>C?1 =I?1 4C41 ..4.II1

@AC4A1377FE8398F1 -=-?1 -IJ?1 .=?1 .4J1 .J5JJ>1

F64851A136A1P1D854AEA717888E398A71)1=1?1A1A491P1)1-.1?1F17648571P1F17888E3981

1 1

,A1 !6A798F1 BF493891 7641 A71 4A398F71 DA1 EF6BA1 7641 A1 3891 !6A1 A71 A6A71 45!6A9A91 !6A!661 361 CFCA91 DA1 A!69A1 A91 781 F681 7871 8A91 A7ACA1 2A71 457693971 7F91 4ABF49571 D371 A1 93A361 -I1 F641A71DA6#189AC71AA91D61BA4C871A791B371A1CCA1BF641A71A6A71!681F91595138D571A91EA6#1!681A1 F91B3715951:1EF7939A1!6A1A71A6A71!6817F9138D571D5E34A91CF871DA14A398F1DA1EF6BA13AE1F61

7371 EF 389398F1 F47!6871 F91 B371 AEF4A1 A1 BA4C871 ,A1 89A4B459398F1 7A43891 61 AA91 DA1 FEQ* 81C3948CF831P131C87A1A1EF6BA1A7918CC5D839ACA914A934D5A1B341A13891DA17684A161B4F43CCA1DA1 F4C398F1A#8A391B6871AA1A7913F4875A16A1F871!6A1A1A6A17F4913AE176EE71D61B4F43CCA11 1 783 .3303CC#875A72=E83#87#885375373BEB75A637A33E86372=E83F5373BDB73 E)7B75A3#8737AA737E55733343

3 "E873A7A3 "E873ACBE53 4F31E4898!6A1

4537AE53 3 3 1 7B3 8&6; 373 /:6. 373 .RJ5I1 -E537B3 /*6%:373 /:6 *373 ..R4J1 4F31E4898!6A1 ..I.41 .>=RC1 1 1 1 1 1 +5373BDB73E)7B75A3 3 3 1 7B3 .%6.:373 .&69 3733 .54>=1 -E537B3 * 6883733 .%6:%3733 ...-.1 4F31E4898!6A1 ..-R51 .JJ-.1 1 1 1 1 !E58E53

$61 9F931 F1 EF7939A1 )1 31 F871 DA71 AA971 D61 D87BF78981 D38DA1 7B5E88!6A1 A91 DA71 AA971 D61 BA4C871 DA1 EFD684A1 7641 DA1 FC4A6#1 37BAE971 DA1 31 8A1 BA47FAA1 B4FA778FAA1 A91 7FE83A1 DA71 A6A71 A1 D88E6951D87A498F12A1D87BF78981D38DA1B4FD6891DA71AA97194717888E3987176413EE7136#1369F*5EFA7131 4567789A1361EFDA1314567789A1361BA4C871A917641A13891DA1D87BF7A41D615 8E6A12AA91A791DFE1BF789817641 3B9896DA1 )1 31 CF88951 DA71 A6A71 F641 A71 3694A71 37BAE971 A71 AA971 A1 7F91 B371 68F!6A71 23BB4A98773A1 DA1 31 EFD689A1 73BB34A9A1 )1 6A1 54893A1 F4C398F1 B4FA778FAA1 A91 D371 A1 E371 B457A91EA99A1F4C398F1A7917688A1B341DA71A6A71 A1D88E6951D87A498F1%19 5F48A1A71AA971D6A1 F4C398F1 A1 7F91 B371 A71 CCA71 3391 0AA91 B7 AC9B11 BAD391 0AA91 DA1 5F14C11 A91 3B471 0AA91 B7

EFD911 %1 33(7391 A71 457693971 D6A1 A!69A1 79398798!6A1 453875A1 A1 CF(AA1 DF6+A1 CF871 3B471

A945A1DA71A6A71D371A#B548CA9398F1A714576939717ACA91F3ACA91DFC8571B341DA71AA971 DA1 2FEQ*81 341 A#ACBA1 A1 9ACB71 B37751 D371 3BB4A98773A1 D61 BA4C871 DA1 EFD684A1 31 B371 5951 EF73E451)14AE A4E A4161ACBF81F616A13694A1F4C398F11

1

&A71 457693971 B38DA91 BF641 45A#3C8A41 DA1 33F1 B671 EFCB9A1 A91 B671 3BB4FFD8A1 A71 AA971 D61 D87BF78981D38DA13AE1D3393A1DA14AE619ACBF4A1A91A1EF94391B341A71CA764A71D3EEFCB3ACA91 AAE98ACA91 453875A71 B341 A71 7946E964A1 361 EF93E91 DA71 A6A71 &A791 FA91 DA71 DA6#1 A!69A71 B4F43CC571D8E81814.--11

EE)D73 1

<%878$'61 K*@1 04..=11 [G3E889A41 3EE71 DA71 A6A71 361 BA4C871 DA1 EFD684A1P1 596DA1 A91 B4FBF7898F7\1 AEEF397

EA35B6BC9A43B1--=1B11

1

<:,;$861 K1 6,;,%71 %1 2D:87]1 ]1 A91 F$8/1 G1 04..>11 441 596DA71 458F3A71 7641 A71 E 3EA71 D61 7F49841 D61 E C3A1F126BC9D792BD7B75A71

1

<8,'%71 &1 A91 2%F,%,81 K*]1 04..I11 [2A1 F939691 8578DA98A1 3AE9A*9*81 31 6645A1 DA1 & C3A1Z1 ,A1 A798C398F1 C8E4F*5EFFC5948!6A17641DF5A71433387A777B82B71FCF642B7==0C17

1

6,;,%71 %1 ;:,K$861 $1 A91 2D:87]1 04..511 [2A71 85389571 9A4489F483A71 DN3EE71 )1 NACBF81 P1 ,A1 A#BF4398F1 )1 B349841DA17F64EA713DC88794398A71A# 36798A7\11FCF64B7B979A94D942B1^I-=*I-R1-J*II1

1

6,;,%71 %1 2D:87]1 ]1 A91 F$8/1 G1 04..>11 [FF49841 D61 E C3A1 A1 /A1 DA1 G43EA1 P1 D87B3489571 9A4489F483A71 7B39831C87C39E 1A917545398F\1B82B71FCF642B1R.0I11

3

6,;,%71 %1 2D:87]1 ]1 D61 $8E,%71 21 %7/71 1 A91 F$8/1 G104.-.111 1G369*81 94A1 CF8A1 BF641 3EE5DA41 )1 61

ACBF81Z12A71 A7A8ACA971 D6A1 A#B548CA9398F1 A1 458F1 B34878AA11183BBF491 BF641 $AEA1 398F3A1 BF64131&F 578F1FFE83A1A91%38951DA71E 3EA710$&F5116FE6CA91DA14AE A4E A1DA1%%%1,8A478951D%4(1 O31D%77FA1

3

A$_$<$7$1 @1 04..C11 [KF1 $EEA771 31 %CBF(CA91 3CF1 2FB*FQ8AD1 $69FA771 _F4QA471 81 ,F1 CA94FBF89371 $4A37\1C843FCCB6BC97AC75ACC4C71C=1BB1-R=-*-RR51

1

D:2`%81 D1 E,/;2%]1 K1 A91 8$D$%21 F1 04..C11 [68E1 7437BF491 3D1 9 A1 FB39831 687948698F1 F1 @8F489(1 %CBF(CA9P1 %8DAEA1 4FC1 31 '396431 %#BA48CA9\1 F23CA57 F!7 F541"7 CA5"D4D7 AC7 #ACAB6BC91 441 BB1 CR=* C5J1

1

;,82%]1 71 A91 <8,&%1 61 04..=11 [7 A1 AAE971 F1 E341 3EEA771 F1 ACBF(CA91 F69EFCA71 F41 BA34A1 4AE8B8A97\1

F23CA57F!7$3%AC71FCF64171=510411BB14=.*4J41 1

2D:87]1 ]1 A91 %7/71 1 04.--111 1%36398F1 3539F84A1 A91 A#B548CA9398F71 7FE83A71118A6A1 433387A1

D%EFFC8A1)1B343994A1 1

:';1104..411[&341:BA47 8B13D1_A34A*9F*_F4Q\1 F23CA57F!7F541"7CA5"D4D7AC7#ACAB6BC914-10411BB1 4C>*4=41

1

8$D$%21F1A918/&%12104..411[&341:BA47 8B1%CBF(CA913D1%3487\1 F23CA57F!7$3%AC71FCF641D1=41BB1 -.>*-C.1

TEPP Rapports de Recherche 2011

11-1. Les effets du lieu de résidence sur l’accès à l’emploi: Une expérience contrôlée sur des jeunes qualifiés en Ile-de-France

Yannick L’Horty, Emmanuel Duguet, Loïc du Parquet, Pascale Petit, Florent Sari

11-2. Comment développer les emplois favorables à la biodiversité en Ile-De-France ? Jean de Beir, Céline Emond, Yannick L’Horty, Laëtitia Tuffery

11-3. Être mobile pour trouver un emploi ?Les enseignements d’une expérimentation en région parisienne

Loïc du Parquet, Emmanuel Duguet, Yannick L’Horty, Pascale Petit, Florent Sari

11-4. Ce que font les villes pour les ménages pauvres. Résultats d’une enquête nationale sur les communes de plus de 20 000 habitants

Denis Anne, Céline Emond, Yannick L’Horty

11-5. Discriminations à l’embauche des jeunes franciliens et intersectionalité du sexe et de l’origine: Les résultats d’un testing

Pascale PETIT, Emmanuel DUGUET, Yannick L’HORTY, Loïc du PARQUET, Florent SARI

11-6. Les effets du bénévolat sur l’accès à l’emploi. Une expérience contrôlée sur des jeunes qualifiés d’Ile-de-France

Jonathan Bougard, Thomas Brodaty, Céline Emond, Yannick L’Horty, Loïc du Parquet et Pascale Petit

La Fédération TEPP

La Fédération de recherche CNRS Travail, Emploi et Politiques Publiques (TEPP, FR n°3126) réunit des centres de recherche en économie et sociologie :

• Le Centre d'Etudes des Politiques Economiques de l'université d'Evry, EPEE, Université d’Evry Val d’Essonne

• Le Centre Pierre Naville, CPN, Université d’Evry Val d’Essonne

• Le Centre de Recherche en Economie et Management, CREM, Université de Caen Basse Normandie et Université de Rennes 1

• L'Equipe de Recherche sur les Marchés, l'Emploi et la Simulation, ERMES, Université deParis II Panthéon-Assas

• L'Equipe de Recherche sur l'Utilisation des Données Temporelles en Economie, ERUDITE, Université de Paris-Est Créteil et Université de Paris-Est Marne-la-Vallée

• Le Groupe d'Analyse des Itinéraires et des Niveaux Salariaux, GAINS, Université du Maine

La Fédération TEPP rassemble 150 chercheurs et enseignants-chercheurs, 140 doctorants et 40 chercheurs associés, qui étudient les mutations du travail et de l'emploi en relation avec les choix des entreprises et analysent les politiques publiques en mobilisant les nouvelles méthodes d'évaluation.