• Aucun résultat trouvé

Comparison of XL and Gröbner basis algorithms over Finite Fields

N/A
N/A
Protected

Academic year: 2021

Partager "Comparison of XL and Gröbner basis algorithms over Finite Fields"

Copied!
30
0
0

Texte intégral

(1)Comparison of XL and Gröbner basis algorithms over Finite Fields Jean-Charles Faugère, Gwénolé Ars. To cite this version: Jean-Charles Faugère, Gwénolé Ars. Comparison of XL and Gröbner basis algorithms over Finite Fields. [Research Report] RR-5251, INRIA. 2004, pp.26. �inria-00070747�. HAL Id: inria-00070747 https://hal.inria.fr/inria-00070747 Submitted on 19 May 2006. HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access archive for the deposit and dissemination of scientific research documents, whether they are published or not. The documents may come from teaching and research institutions in France or abroad, or from public or private research centers.. L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non, émanant des établissements d’enseignement et de recherche français ou étrangers, des laboratoires publics ou privés..

(2) INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE. Comparison of XL and Gröbner basis algorithms over Finite Fields Jean-Charles Faugère — Gwénolé Ars. N° 5251 Juillet 2004. ISSN 0249-6399. ISRN INRIA/RR--5251--FR+ENG. THÈME 2. apport de recherche.

(3)

(4) 

(5)  

(6)  ! "  # "$#% & ('*)+ ,.-! / # ('* / #0$# 132543678:9;43<>=?2A@CBD43E

(7) FHGI<>25JLK MONP:Q 6&RH= QTS <U@WV X!Y[Z>\:]^_a`cb>d[ef] gihkjAeilef]>g ]m.lnogpl#qrgtsvu5\w3hkgiepxAqr] yDz{ho|}]m{s~€ƒ‚*~€ „nk [ 3hkz†m0‡[] z†]Ul(Y[]z(l(Y[]ˆd3‰;ŠA^kŠ[‹W_Œkq[eigigf]mƒ^oŽkŽk _^k: rnojA]>s ‘W’

(8) “>”•—–[˜k”k™ X!Y[epsš ›no 3]zœl#hA\: ›noz{]>s m{Y[]ƒ‚žnogijkhAz†efm†Y[\ Ÿ0efm†Y¡`cz†¢Aw[d[]z:wrnAsveps£nogijkhkz{efm†Y[\¤¦¥§] ] ¨ [ginkefd©m†Y[]giefd[ª©w›]m}Ÿ«]>]d©c‚¬l#hk\£ [q[m{n—m{efhAd©z{]>s†q[gfm£nkdr‡`cz{¢kw[dr]z:wrnks†eis:Ÿ0efm†Ym†Y[]Ÿ­]gig¯®°ª5d[h—Ÿ0d drhom†eihkd±ho²!³£®}`cz†¢Aw[d[]zcwrnAsveps¤£X!Y[]>d§Ÿ­]œl#hk\£ rnkz†]šm†Yr]>s†]£nkgfjAhkz{e¯m{Y[\œscefd§m}Ÿ«hlnAsv]Us´ceidµm{Y[]£¶r]gp‡[s ·

(9) ¸nkdr‡©·

(10) ¹CŸ0e¯m{Y¡º¼»½;¤¡¾rhkz:m†Yr]¶r]gp‡·¸k¿«Ÿ«]YrnLÀA]C [z{h—Àk]U‡Ám{Yrn—mœef²cc‚¬d[]]U‡[s:m†hÁl#hA\£ [qm†] 3hkgiu5d[hk\£epnog­Ÿ0e¯m{Y‡]>jkz{]]W³Âm†hµm†]z{\£efd›n—m†]A¿&m†Y[]Ÿ0Y[hAgf]T`cz†¢Aw[d[]>zwrnAsvepseps:l#hk\£ [q[m{n—m{]>‡©Ÿ0e¯m{Y[hkqm ]¨[l#]]U‡eid[jµm{Y[]T‡]jAz†]>]³Ã¤©¥±]TYrnLÀk]s}m{qr‡ei]>‡©m†Y[]Tc‚žnkgfjAhkz{e¯m{Y[\Änodr‡ÆÅ

(11) ÇnkgfjAhkz{e¯m{Y[\ÄhkdÆsv]>\£e¯® z{]jAq[gpnoz0sv]UxIq[]drl]>s!eidIm†z{h5‡[qrl#]U‡Ceidz†]> ›hAzvmÈi‹Êɰ¤O¥±]svYrh—ŸËm{Yrn—m0m{Y[]sveiÌ] hk²

(12) \œnom†z{e¯¨l#hkd›s}m{z†qrl#m†]U‡Ww5u c‚Teps;Y5q[jk]lhk\£ rnoz{]>‡šm{hÍm†Y[]hAd[]>sOho²ÎÅ*ÇA¤;~5h m†Yr].l#hA\: rgf]¨5efm}uhk²Îƒ‚Teps;Ÿ­hkz†m†Y:m†YrnkdÏÅ*Ç.nogijkhkz{efm†Y[\ hAd£m†Y[]Usv]csvusvm†]>\£s>¤;¾[hAzDm†Yr]¶r]>gi‡£· ¹ ¿IŸ«]ƒefdIm†z{h‡qrl].nodÏ]>\q[gpn—m{]>‡ÏnkgfjAhkz{e¯m{Y[\q›sveid[j:`cz{¢kwrd[]z«wrnks†eis lhk\£ [qm(n—m{efhAdm†hcYrnLÀA]«ncl#hk\£ rnkz†eps†hkd w3]#m}Ÿ­]]dšƒ‚nod›‡š`cz{¢kw[d[]>z*w›nks†eis>¤¥±]«Y›nLÀk]­ [z†h—ÀA]>‡cm{Yrn—m&m†Yreis nkgfjAhkz{e¯m{Y[\Ÿ0eigig3nkgfŸ!nLus&z†]Unkl(Yœn gih—Ÿ«]>zO‡]jAz†]>]0²ÐhkzOefdIm†]>z†\£]U‡einom†] 3hkgiu5d[hk\£epnogps;m{Yrnodœc‚µnogijkhAz†efm†Yr\¤ €Ñsvm†qr‡u¦hAds†]\£e¯®°z{]jkqrginkzsv]UxIq[]drl]>s:svYrh—Ÿs m†Y›n—mœÅ Ç nogiŸ­nLusYrnks:nÃw3]#m†m†]z£w3]YrnLÀ5eihkzm†Yrnkd©ƒ‚ nkgfjAhkz{e¯m{Y[\Ò]>s† 3]>l#epnogigiuϟ0Y[]dÓeps0d[]Unoz!²Ðz{hk\,½;¤ ÔTÕIÖH×{ØÙ •—Ú

(13) “k™ ƒ‚nogijkhAz†efm†Y[\¿LÛep‡[‡]>dš¾

(14) ef]>gi‡ÜOxIqrn—m{efhAdrs­ÝÞÛ.¾

(15) Ü«ß#¿oàTq[gfm†eiÀ—noz{einom†]D 3hkgiu5d[hk\£epnogI]>xIqrn—® m{efhAdrs>¿`cz{¢kwrd[]z!wrnAsv]Us¿€gijk]>w[z(noeplcá«z{uI [m{nod›nogiu5s†eps¿rá«hk\£ [q[m†]z0€.gfjA]w[z(n[¿[~5]>\:ef®°z†]>jkq[gpnoz!~5]>xIq[]>drl#]Us¤ âDñ ã5å›äÐòÞå3ó(ôöæ#õøç{÷&ã[î>è&ê

(16) étãäëî>êÁê ìÎí*é

(17) îLç(ï*å3ðìtç{äÐí

(18) étäëê ù ã5äÐå3æ0ú;û

(19) ê&ç(ï

(20) å›ðìç(ïüLý þ#õ}òöÿöý ÷ Détõ}üLüLõ}ÿ . . Unité de recherche INRIA Rocquencourt Domaine de Voluceau, Rocquencourt, BP 105, 78153 Le Chesnay Cedex (France) Téléphone : +33 1 39 63 55 11 — Télécopie : +33 1 39 63 53 30.

(21)  & # * $}$#%

(22) Ê'*)+ ­'«0 Ò 0 Ò 

(23)  ! Ñ W Ñ$#0 ­ * C 

(24)  “  ™ á«]D rnk [ei]z*lhk\£ rnkz†]&g  nkgfjAhkz{e¯m{Y[\˝c‚Wnoq[¨cnogijkhAz†efm†Yr\:]Ust‡]Ol>nogpl#q[gI‡]DwrnAsv]«‡]«`cz{¢kw[d[]>z>¤ .hkqrs.]#¨ [gieixIq[hAdrs0gi]gief]>dÃ]dIm†z{] gi]>sz{b>s†q[gfm{nom{shAwm†]>d5qrs0 rnkz.ƒ‚¼]#mƒgi]>s.wrnks†]>s.‡]š`cz{¢kw[d[]> z œ rnkzvm{efz ‡[]ƒgpnd[hkm†eihkdÏwref]>d®°lhkd[d5q[]c‡]ͳ£®?w›nks†]ƒ‡] `cz†¢Aw[d[]>z>¤

(25) yDq[eps­d[hkqrs­l#hA\£ rnoz{hkdrs«l#]Us«nkgfjAhkz{e¯m{Y[\£]>sO‡rnodrs ‡[]q¨§l>nks:´Ísvq[z gi]£l#hkz{ rsƒ· ¸ ]#m‡[nkdrsÍgi]£lhkz{ rs.· ¹ Ÿ0e¯m{Y±ºW» ½;¤šy&hAq[zͪk]œl#hAz† rs.· ¸ ¿td[hkq›s nLÀkhkd›s rz†hAq[Àk]>ztxAqr]DsveAƒ‚Ïn!w3]>s†hkeid ‡q rnoz(no\£Zm†z{]D³ 3hkqrztm†]>z†\£eid[]zU¿Lnogihkz(sHq[d wrnks†]D‡]«`cz{¢kwrd[]ztlhk\£ [giZ#m†] s†]z(nc‡b#m{]z{\:eid[b0s{nodrs&‡b> rnks{sv]>z&gf]0‡]>jkz{b!³ 3hkq[z;gi]>s;l>nogpl#q[gps¤ hAqrs;nLÀkhAdrsbm†qr‡[efb0g  nkgfjAhkz{e¯m{Y[\£]  ]m g  nogijkhAz†efm†Y[\£]:Å Ç s†q[zÍgf]Uscs†b>xIq[]>drl#]UsÍsv]>\:ef®°z†b>jkq[giefZ>z†]UseidIm†z{h5‡[q[e¯m{]>s͇[nkdrscgf]£z(no [ 3hkz†m ƒ„ }€ÑÈf‹É?¤ .hkqrs;nLÀAhkdrs

(26) [z{hkqrÀkb0xIq[]!gincm(noeigfgi]0‡]>s;\œnom†z{eil]>s;l#hAdrsvm†z{q[e¯m{]>s& rnkz;ƒ‚]Us}m; [giqrs;jAz{nkdr‡]0xIq[]0l#]gigi]>sD‡] Å

(27) Ço¤&y;noz«l#hkd›svbUxAqr]dIm>¿Aginlhk\£ [gi]#¨efm†b.‡].ƒ‚T]Us}mO rgfqrsO\œnoq[À—noeps†].xIq[].l#]>gfgi].‡]ƒÅ*Çs†q[z­l#]>s«svusvm†Z>\:]Us¤ y&hAq[z;gf]lhkz{ rs

(28) ·

(29) ¹L¿Ad[hkq›sDnLÀkhAdrs

(30) efdIm†z{h‡q[efmDq[dœnogijkhAz†efm†Y[\£]!gibjkZ>z†]>\£]dIm;\:h‡ef¶rb‡]0w›nks†]!‡[].`cz†¢Aw[d[]z 3hkqrz ›]>z†\£]mvm†z{]gpnÏl#hA\£ rnoz(noepsvhAdt¤ .hkqrsƒnLÀkhkd›s! [z†hAq[Àkb xIq[]l]#mƒnkgfjAhkz{e¯m{Y[\£]n—m†m†]eidImm†hAq—|}hkqrz{s0qrd rgfqrswrnksš‡]jAz†bœ 3hkqrzgf]Us 3hkgiu5d[hk\£]>sefdIm{]z{\:bU‡epnoeiz†]Us xAqr]Ïg  nogijkhAz†efm†Yr\:]œc‚D"¤ !d[]Wb#m†q›‡]Cs†q[zgi]>s s†b>xIq[]>drl#]Uss†]\£e¯®°z{bjkqrgfepnoeiz†]Us nT\£hkdIm†z{bWxIq[]WÅ

(31) ÇWnLÀ—nke¯mm{hkq—|}hAq[z(s q[d¼\£]eigigf]>q[zšlhk\£ ›hAzvm{]\£]dImšxIq[] g nogijkhkz{efm†Y[\£]!ƒ‚§sv 3b>leinkgf]>\:]>dImDgfhAz{s{xIq[]0gf]ƒsvusvm†Z\£]#n Í 3]eid[] rgfqrs«$‡  b>xIqrn—m{efhAdrsDxIq[].‡[]À—noz{einkw[gf]Us¤ %Ù ”U“ × '˜ & “¦™ €.gfjAhkz{e¯m{Y[\£]ϝƒ‚O¿y&hkgiu5)d (k\£]>s\q[gfm†eiÀ—noz{efbUs+¿ *!nks†]>s‡[]C`cz†¢Aw[d[]>z>¿Dá«z†u5 m(nodrnkgfus†] nkgfjAbw[z{epxAqr]k¿rá­nogpl#q[gt¾rhkz{\£]g?¿[svbUxAqr]drl]>s0s†]\£e¯®°z{bjkqrgfeiZz{]>s>¤.

(32) 

(33)     "!. #. š ' &œ D'

(34) # ~]Àk]>z{nkg«lz†u5 m{hAs†u5svm†]>\œslnkd©w3]Cw3hkeigi]>‡©‡[h—Ÿ0dÁm†h¦svhAgfÀ5eid[jµn§\q[gfm†eiÀ—noz{einom†]C]>xIqrn—m{efhAdrs:svusvm†]\ hAd n¶›d[e¯m{]϶r]>gi‡ÁnAsۃ¾*Ü"Èf‹LŠUÉ«hAzd[hkdrgfeid[]>nkz ¶rgfm†]>zjk]>d[]z(n—m{hkz(s:È oÉ?¤T€­mšÜOq[z†hlz†u5 mš^kŽkŽkŽr¿&á«hAq[zvm{hkeps¿ %Ígiei\:h—ÀH¿Hy;n—m(noz{efdµnkdr‡§~Yrno\£eizcY›nLÀk]eidIm†z{h5‡[qrl#]U‡Ãƒ‚ÆnogijkhAz†efm†Yr\ m{hnomvm(nkl(ªm†Y[]Usv]£l#z{u5 m†hIsvusvm†]>\£s Ÿ0efm†Ygiefdr]>noznkgfjA]w[z(n\£]m†Y[h‡[s>¤O~5]ÀA]z(nogps­ rno 3]z(s0s}m{qr‡uWm†Y[]nkgfjAhkz{e¯m{Y[\'È &¿Î‹>¿‹>ށ¿t‹ &>ɰ¤ ¥ efm†YÁnsvusvm†]) \ (*+-,/.1020202.3(45+-,[¿ÎŸ0Y[]>z†6] (798¦· ¹ : ; *<.1020102. ;>=@? ¿tnodr‡±nW ›noz(no\£]#m{]zͳT¿tƒ‚ nkgfjAhkz{e¯m{Y[\,m{z†ei]>s0m†hœ¶rd›‡ÃnœwrnAsveps0ho²&m{Y[]· ¹ ÀA]>l#m†hkzƒsv rnAl#B] A9CD+FEHGB(7I JLK

(35) 8MEONP.1020202.vLÓ Q nkdrR‡ G58 · ¹ : ; *.1020102. ;>=O? svTm SOU1VWXGB(7XYZ [³ QÏsvhm{Yrn—mnkd§q[drefÀ—noz{epn—m†]£ 3hkgiu5d[hk\£epnog;w3]gihkd[jIs.m{hTe¯mU¤Ï€gig;m†Yreis hA ›]>z{nom†eihkdrsƒnoz{]š‡hAd[]Ÿ0efm†Y±giefd[]Unozcnogijk]wrz{nr¤cX!Y[]>dµc‚nkgfjAhkz{e¯m{Y[\Ñs†hkgiÀk]Usm{Y[epsƒ 3hkgiu5d[hk\£epnog

(36) efdµm†Y[] ¶›d[e¯m{]϶r]>gi‡t¿&s†q[wrsvm†efm†q[m†]>sm†Yr]WsvhAgfq[m†eihkdÁeidÁm†Y[]Wefd[efm†epnog!s†u5svm†]>\ nkdr‡¦z{] 3]>n—m(s m{Y[]Ï [z{hl#]>s{s>¤€­mšm†Y[] ]>dr‡Î¿[c‚¦nogijkhkz{efm†Y[\Ò¶›dr‡[s0nœs†hkgiqm†eihkdho²*m†Y[]s†us}m{]\¤ `cz{¢kw[dr]z£wrnks†]>sšho²Ínodei‡]Unog0lnkdw3]qrs†]>‡Ám{hÁsvei\£ [gfef²Ðu©s†hkgiÀ5efd[j±svusvm†]>\£s>¤©€`cz{¢kw[d[]>z£wrnks†eis epsnd[]>Ÿ²Þnk\£efgiuµhk²­ 3hkgiu5d[hk\£epnogps‡]#¶›d[efdrjm†Y[]Ïs{no\£]Ïs†u5svm†]>\ Ÿ0efm†Y¼s†hk\£]£ [z{hk 3]z†m†ei]>s>¤W¾[hAz m†Yrnom>¿ Ÿ­]£d[]]U‡Ãm{hefdIm†z{h‡qrl]£n\£hkdrhk\£einkg&hkz(‡]z{efdrjr¤ \ƒ^e ]3]>z†]>dAmnkgfjAhkz{e¯m{Y[\œsÍl#hk\£ [q[m†]:m†Y[eps wrnAsveps:´Ím†Y[] ¶›z{svmDnogijkhkz{efm†Y[\ eps

(37) m†Yr] *­qrl(Y5w›]>z†jA]z&nogijkhkz{efm†Y[\,È _Lɰ¿om{Y[eisOnogijkhkz{efm†Y[\l(YrhIhIsv]Us&nƒ ›noeiz;ho²H]gi]\£]dIm{sDho²3n jA]d[]>z{nom†hAzH²Þno\£efgiuÍho²5m†Yr]Oep‡]>nkgö¿—l#hAdrs†ei‡]>z†]U‡ ns† ›]Ul#epnogk 3hkgiu5d[hk\£epnogAho²m†Yreis rnoeiz«ÝÐm†Y[a] `D®? 3hkgiu5d[hk\£epnogps{ß nkdr‡z{]>‡[qrl#]Us*efmDw5uÍm†Y[]­²Þnk\:eigiuk¤ °²›m{Y[eis&z{]>‡[qrlÊm{efhAdeps&d[hom;Ì]>z†h›¿—Ÿ«]!nk‡r‡m{Y[eis&z{]>‡[qrlÊm{efhAdm†hcm{Y[]­²Þno\£efgiu nkdr‡±z†]> ›]Un—m m{Y[]Ï [z{hl#]>s{s>¤W¾[hAzÍm†Y[epsnkgfjAhkz{e¯m{Y[\¿t\£hAsvmho²­m†Y[]Ïm†ei\:]œepss† 3]dImefd¼lhk\£ [qm{efdrjTÌ]z{hr¤ *c¤ *­qrl(Y5w3]z{jk]>z0efdIm†z{h‡qrl]>s0l#z{efm†]z{epnm{hWnLÀkhAei‡s†hk\£] l#hk\£ [q[m{n—m{efhAdm†hÏÌ>]z{hra ¤ \𤛂*noÌ>nkz{‡C [z{]>s†]dIm†]U‡ ei[d bP#CÈfH‹ #LÉnod[hkm†Y[]>z!\:]m†Y[h‡Wm†hœl#hA\£ [qm†]`cz{¢kw[dr]z!wrnks†eps«Ÿ0efm†Ygiefd[]Unoz0nogijk]>w[z(n[´

(38) Y[] l#hkd›svep‡]z{]>‡Ïm†Y[] · ¹ Àk]>l#m†hAzsv rnAl#T] A9C¬‡]¶rd[]>‡Tnkw›h—ÀA] nodr‡l#hA\£ [qm†]U‡Ã`Ínoqrs{s†einkdCÜDgiei\:eidrnom†eihkdThkdTn£giefdr]>noz0w›nks†eis0hk² AcC m†hT¶rd›‡¦m†Y[]`cz†¢Aw[d[]>zwrnks†epsͲÐhkz:nóÄgpnoz{jk]œ]drhkq[jAYt¤TX!Y[]Ïgpnksvm:nogijkhAz†efm†Yr\ [z{]>s†]dIm†]U‡±eism†Y[] Å

(39) ÇWnkgfjAhkz{e¯m{Y[\¿m{Y[epsšnkgfjAhkz{e¯m{Y[\ YrnAsnT\£hAz†]Ï 3h—Ÿ­]z†²Ðq[gOl#z{efm†]z{eihkdÁeidÁhkz(‡]zšd[homm{hµs† ›]>dre‡ dP,@fhk² m{Y[]cm†ei\£]l#hk\£ [q[m†eid[jšÌ>]z{hr¤;X!Y[eps0nogijkhAz†efm†Y[\ÒY›nks­d[h£z†]U‡qrl#m†eihkdÏm{h£Ì]z{hš²Ðhkz!z{nkdr‡hA\,svusvm†]\œs>¤;¥§] rz†]Usv]>dAmn:\œn—m{z†ef¨WÀk]>z{s†eihkdWhk²m{Y[eis.nogijkhkz{efm†Y[\¤ °mDeps&‡he gÏlq[g¯m;m{h l#hk\£ rnkz†]«ƒ‚l#hA\£ [qm{nom†eihkd:z†]Usvqrg¯m;nodr‡:nÍ`cz†¢Aw[d[]z&wrnAsveps>¤*¾

(40) efz(svm&c‚nogijkhkz{efm†Y[\ ‡[hI]Us

(41) d[hom;eidAm{z†h‡q›l#]­\:hAd[hk\£epnoghAz{‡]>z†eid[j›¤ *­qm;Ÿ«]­YrnLÀk]­ [z{h—Àk]U‡Ím†Yrnom;e¯²Hƒ‚nogijkhAz†efm†Yr\ m{]z{\£efdrnom†]Us¿ efmŸ0eigfg

(42) nogpsvh:m†]>z†\£eidrn—m{] Ÿ0e¯m{YÃn£gf]¨eilhkjkz(no rY[eilƒhkz(‡]>z†eid[jr¤DàÃhkz{]h—Àk]>z­nAs!m†Yr]nogijkhkz{efm†Y[\,c‚ÁYrnAs!m†Y[] ›noz(no\£]#m{]z³T¿.m{Y[]±Ÿ«]>gfgf®?ª5d[h—Ÿ0dËd[hom{efhAdËho²£³£®}`cz†¢Aw[d[]zCwrnks†epsnkgfgih—ŸsWm†hÆq[dr‡]>z{svm{nkdr‡ m{Y[]¦gfeid[ª w3]#m}Ÿ­]]>d`cz{¢kwrd[]z0wrnAsveps0nod›‡Cc‚D¤›~h:Ÿ­]Ͷrdr‡Cm{Yrn—mc‚Ál#hk\£ [q[m†]>s0m†Y[]‡]>Y[hk\£hAjk]drefÌUn—m†eihkdCho²

(43) m†Y[] ³œ®ø`cz{¢kw[dr]z!wrnks†eps!ho²m{Y[] Y[hA\:hAjk]>d[efÌ>]>‡s}m(noz†m†eid[j£svusvm†]\¤ ~5hAgfÀ5eid[j¦svusvm†]\œsšŸ0e¯m{YÆs†hkgiqm{efhAdrs:efd©m†Y[]¶rd[efm†]C¶r]>gi‡©· ¹ eidIm†z{h‡qrl#]Us:d[]Ÿ, 3hkgiu5d[hk\£epnogpsŸ0efm†Y ‡[]jkz{]]œºCefd±m{Y[]Ws†u5svm†]>\œs lnogigi]>‡§m†Y[]£¶›]gp‡§]UxIqrn—m{efhAdrsÏÝ  ¹9i ±ßʤWX!Y[]>z†]²Ðhkz{]k¿*e¯²0ºWeps ÀA]z{uÃY[eijkYt¿ m{Y[]>s†].z{]gpn—m{efhAdrsDŸ0eigig3drhom«w3]cqrsv]U‡Î¤D~5hŸ­]ƒl>nodœYrnLÀA]m}Ÿ­h‡^e ]3]>z†]>dIm«w3]YrnLÀ5eihkz(sDeid϶rd[efm†].¶r]gp‡[s>¿5gfefmvm{gf] ¶›d[e¯m{]¶r]>gi‡Cnks«Å ¸ ²Ðhkz«Ÿ0Y[eil(YÏm†Y[]ƒqrsv]ƒho²Îm{Y[].¶›]gp‡œ]>xIqrnom†eihkdrsOeis«Àk]>z†u:ef\£ 3hkz†m{nkdAm­nodr‡£¶›d[e¯m{].¶›]gp‡ÏÅ ¹ Ÿ0efm†YTºšÀk]>z†uœgpnoz{jk]A¤

(44) €.dr‡Ÿ«] YrnLÀA].m{hœ‡eisvm†eid[jAq[eis†Yw›hkm†YTlnAsv]Us¤ ¾rhkzCm†Y[]§¶rd[efm†]§¶r]gp‡ Å

(45) ¸k¿.Ÿ«]§YrnLÀk]à rz†h—ÀA]>‡Æm†Y›n—m²ÐhkzCnsvusvm†]>\hk² 3hkgiuIdrhk\£einkgis>¿0ef²m†Y[]±ƒ‚ nkgfjAhkz{e¯m{Y[\ ¶›dr‡[snµsvhAgfqm{efhAdÁŸ0e¯m{Y¼nT rnkz{nk\:]m†]>zÀ—nogiq[]W³T¿

(46) m†Yr]dÁm{Y[]ϟ0Y[hAgf]C`cz{¢kwrd[]zw›nks†eis Ÿ0efm†Y *­qrl(Y5w3]z{jk]>z£nkgfjAhkz{e¯m{Y[\ÄepsÏl#hA\: rqm†]U‡Ÿ0efm†YrhkqmW]¨[l#]]U‡eid[j±m†Y[]ǁ]>jkz{]]T³ ²Ðhkz£m{Y[]TefdIm{]z{\:]U‡epn—m†] 3hkgiu5d[hk\£epnogps¤£àThAz†]>h—Àk]zU¿HŸ«]Ïsvm†q›‡uTm†Yr]œƒ‚ nogijkhAz†efm†Yr\hkd¦sv]>\:ef®°z†]>jkq[gpnoz s†]>xIq[]d›l#]>sceidIm†z{h5‡[qrl#]U‡ w5uœm{Y[]Íz†]> ›hAzvm Èi‹Êɰ¤D€ˆl#hkdo|}]>lÊm{q[z{]ceps­m†Y›n—mTn j}z(nodr‡[hk\ kcs†u5svm†]>\,eps0n:s†]\£ef®?z{]jAq[gpnoz!sv]UxAqr]drl]k¤;¾[hAz!n s†]\£ef®?z{]jAq[gpnozs†]>xIq[]>drl#]Dhk²[Ó ]UxIqrn—m{efhAdrshk²r‡]jAz†]>a] Sƒhkd½œÀ—noz{epnow[gi]>s>¿Le¯m&sv]>]\œstm{Yrn—m*m†Y[]!‡]>jkz{]]O³ˆhk² $. é*éÑülnmom .

(47) . P2  . m{Y[]. ›noz(no\£]#m{]zOdr]]>‡[]>‡œ²ÐhAzOc‚§nkgfjAhkz{e¯m{Y[\ eps­nogi\:hIs}m«m†Y[]Ís{no\£].nksOm†Yr]c‡]>jkz{]]hk²Îm†Y[]c 3hkgiuIdrhk\£einkgis eidTm{Y[]š\œnom†z{e¯¨Ãl#hAdrsvm†z{qrlÊm{]>‡Tw5uTÅ Ç nogijkhAz†efm†Yr\¤ *­qm.m{Y[]:lhk\£ [gi]#¨efm}uhk²;m†Y[]Usv]šm}Ÿ­hW4 nogijkhAz†efm†Y[= \œs.eis s† 3]>l#ef¶r]U‡¦wIu±= m{Y[]Ws†efÌ>]Who²!m{Y[]W\œn—m{z†ef¨Î´šc‚ËnkgfjAhkz{e¯m{Y[\ lz†]Un—m†]Us \œn—m{z†epl#= ]UsŸ0efm†Y 7

(48) * C z{h—ŸsOnkdr‡ l#hAgfq[\£drs>¿IŸ0Y[]z{]>nAsOÅ Ç lz†]Un—m†]UsOs{xIqrnoz{]\œn—m{z†epl#]UsOŸ0efm†Y lhkgiq[\£drs¤

(49) ¥±]clhk\£ [gi]#m†] m{Y[epsOsvm†qr‡uš hkC dœ jA]d[]>z†epl!svusvm†]\œs;Ÿ0efm†YÏnl#hk\£ rnkz†eps†hkdhk²Îƒ‚ÃnkgfjAhkz{e¯m{Y[\ noC d› ‡ *­qrl(Y5w3]z{jk]>zDnogijkhkz{efm†Y[\ ²ÐhAzƒnCl#z{uI [m†hAs†us}m{]\Û.¾

(50) ܤξ[hAzm{Y[eiscl#z{u5 m†hIsvusvm†]>\¿Î`cz{¢kw[d[]>z.wrnAsveps.nkgfjAhkz{e¯m{Y[\ ¶rdr‡[scnWsvm†z{qrlÊm{q[z{] eidCm†Y[]Í\qrg¯m{efÀ—noz{epn—m†]Ís†u5svm†]>\œs­nkdr‡Cd[]ÀA]z!]#¨[l#]>]>‡[s!nšgfh—Ÿ ‡]jAz†]>]k¿5Ÿ0Y[]z{]>nAs¿I²ÐhAz«m{Y[]͝ƒ‚¦nogijkhAz†efm†Yr\¿ m{Y[]‡]>jkz{]]Ísv]>]\œs­m†hÏsvm†eigfgefdrlz†]Unks†]ƒŸ0efm†Ym{Y[] d5q[\w3]z0hk²

(51) À—noz{epnow[gi]>s­½;¤ X!Y[]ƒsv]Ul#hkd›‡¶›]gp‡œs}m{qr‡ei]>‡£eps;m†Yr]0¶r]gp‡:· ¹ ¿IŸ0efm†YϺcÀk]>z†ugpnoz{jk]0lhk\£ rnoz{]>‡šm{h ½;¤ ød£m{Y[eps;¶r]>gi‡Î¿AŸ«] ‡[h:drhom0m{nkªk] eidIm†hœnkl>l#hkqrdAm!m{Y[] ¶r]>gi‡]>xIqrnom†eihkdrs>¤D€.sƒ‚Á‡h5]>sd[hom.lhk\£ [qm{]n:lhk\£ [gi]#m{]`cz†¢Aw[d[]z w›nks†eis>¿oŸ­]lnod£‡]Us†lz†eiw›]nkd£]\qrginom†]>‡:nogijkhAz†efm†Yr\ ho²Hƒ‚qrs†eid[j`cz†¢Aw[d[]>z;wrnks†eis;lhk\£ [qm(n—m{efhAdt¤*¥ efm†Y m{Y[eps

(52) nkgfjAhkz{e¯m{Y[\¿LŸ«]« [z†h—ÀA];m†Y›n—m&Ÿ«]­nogiŸ­nLustz{]>nAl(Yn.gih—Ÿ­]z*‡[]jkz{]]Dm†Yrnkdƒ‚O¤—€.s

(53) efd·*¸o¿—Ÿ­]OeidIm†z{h‡qrl#] m{Y[]drhom†eihkdµho²Os†]\£e¯®°z{]jkqrginkzsv]UxAqr]drl]>s>¤ƒ¾[hAzm{Y[]>s†]šs†us}m{]\œs¿›m†Yr]šq[drefÀ—noz{epn—m†] ›hAgfu5d[hA\:epnog*Ÿ0efgig&w›] lhk\£ [qm{]>‡Cn—m!ginAs}mU¿IŸ­]ƒs†Y[h—Ÿ c‚§nkgfjAhkz{e¯m{Y[\ m†]z{\£efd›n—m†]UsD²ÐhAz0n‡]>jkz{]].YrefjAY[]z«m†Yrnkd`cz{¢kw[dr]z­wrnks†eis nkgfjAhkz{e¯m{Y[\œs͟0e¯m{YÁ n \ƒ„‚ hkz(‡]zU¤WàThAz†]>h—Àk]zU4 ¿H²Ðhkz½ +,Ó§¿*m†Y[]œqrd[efÀ—nkz†epn—m{]œ ›hAgfu5d[hA\:epnogOŸ0efgigDYrnLÀA] nAs.‡]>jkz{]] m{Y[] *«]>ÌhAqmƒw3hkq[d›‡Î¿HŸ0Y[eil(Yµei!s SU1V WX(7 YʤÍX!Y[eiscsvm†qr‡uTs†Y[h—Ÿs0m{Yrn—mcm†Yr]šnogijkhAz†efm†Yr\£s w›nks†]>‡ÃhAd¦`cz{¢kwrd[]zcwrnks†eps l#hk\£ [q[m{n—m{efhAdµŸ0efm†7Y * \ƒ„.‚¡hkz(‡]zÍnogiŸ­nLusƒYrnLÀk]£nCw›]mvm†]>z w›]>YrnLÀ5efhAzcm†Yrnkd c‚µnkgfjAhkz{e¯m{Y[\ ]>s† ›]Ul#epnogigfu:Ÿ0Y[]dCÓeis«d[]>nkzD²Ðz{hk\ ½ÃhAdÏjk]>d[]z{eil.svusvm†]\œs>¤;€dr‡WhkdWnšl#z{uI [m†hAs†us}m{]\ w›nks†]>‡£hkdCÛ.¾

(54) Ü¿5Ÿ«].]#¨ ›]>z†ei\£]dIm{nkgfgiuš¶rdr‡Wnw›]mvm†]>z«w3]Y›nLÀIeihkz«ho² *­qrl(Y5w3]z{jk]z«nogijkhkz{efm†Y[\ l#hk\£ rnkz†]U‡ m{h£ƒ‚ÁnogijkhAz†efm†Yr\¤ ødTm{Y[]šs†]>l#m†eihkd¼‹A¿›Ÿ­] [z{]>s†]dIm.Yrh—Ÿ¬m†hWs†hkgiÀk]\šq[gfm†eiÀLnkz†epn—m{]s†u5svm†]>\œshkdörd[efm†]¶›]gp‡Ãnodr‡ÃefdIm†z{ho® ‡[qrl#]W`cz{¢kw[dr]zÍwrnks†eps¤ .]#¨5m>¿ efd±m{Y[]Ws†]>lÊm{efhAd¦^[¿Ÿ­]£ [z†]Usv]>dIm s†hk\£]œnogijkhAz†efm†Yr\£sc²ÐhAz`cz†¢Aw[d[]>z wrnks†eis lhk\£ [qm(n—m{efhAdt¤;X!Y[]ƒ‡]Us†lz†ei m{efhAdrsOhk²*Å

(55) ǃnkgfjAhkz{e¯m{Y[\Ònodr‡W~]\£e¯®°z{]jkqrginkzv®øsv]UxIq[]drl]>sDnkz†]ƒ‡hkd[]ceidCs†]>lÊ® m{efhAd #:nodr‡WŸ«]ceidAm{z†h‡q›l#]ƒm†Y[]͝ƒ‚±nogijkhAz†efm†Yr\Òefdsv]UlÊm†eihkdCšŸ0efm†YC¶rz(s}m!z{]\œnoz{ªsDhkdWm†Y[eps0nogijkhAz†efm†Yr\¤ ~]>lÊm{efhAd¦ŠC]¨5 rginkefdrscm{Y[]£gfeid[ª§w›]m}Ÿ«]>]d§m†Y[]œc‚Ælhk\£ [qm(n—m{efhAd±nkdr‡Á`cz†¢Aw[d[]zÍwrnAsvepsÍl#hA\: rqm{nom†eihkdt¤ €.dr‡Cm†Y[]>dt¿rŸ­] jkeiÀk] n:m{Y[]hAz†]m†eplnogtnkdr‡]#¨ 3]z{ef\£]dIm(noglhk\£ rnoz{epsvhAdWhkdm{Y[]‡]jAz†]>]Íhkdm†Y[]šsv 3]>le¯¶›l ¶›]gp‡W·¸Íeidm†Y[]s†]>l#m†eihkdšm†Y[]>dhAdm†Y[]Ͷr]>gi‡W·

(56) ¹ceids†]>l#m†eihkd &5¤ $œ Î'*+ Ò C ('

(57) 0$#'  & º " # $Ê-œ #C% % ødm{Y[eis0s†]>l#m†eihkdt¿rŸ«]Í]#¨ [gpnoeidY[h—Ÿ m{h£s†hkgiÀk] s†us}m{]\œs!ho²

(58) \q[gfm†eiÀ—noz{einom†]Í]>xIqrnom†eihkdrs!hAdW¶rdre¯m{]Ͷr]gp‡[s>¤ *+ ( * W  * .2010202. 6=/Y + , = ¤ , ‚]#)m ( 4 w3]n£svusvm†]>\,ho²&Ó \qrg¯m{efÀ—noz{epn—m†]Í]UxAq›n—m†eihkd›s«hAdW· ¹ +¤ ( 4 W  * .201020. 6=/Y +. .0/.. ,. 13246587:9;4=<?>A@CBD@)7%<?E4. ‚]#m0qrs‡[]d[hkm†]Íw5u `*¹GF =Wm†Yr] z†eid[j£ho²

(59) ›hAgfu5d[hA\:epnogps­·

(60) ¹ :  * .1020201. 6= = ? ¤ °meps ei\£ ›hAzvm(nodIm m†hThAwrsv]>z†ÀA]m{Yrn—m m{Y[]Ws†]#mhk²­]UxAq›n—m†eihkd›sH( 4 eps ]>xIq[eiÀ—nogi]dIm m†hÃnkd5uÃhom{Y[]zs†]#m V * W  * .1020102. 6="Y +JIKILI@+ VDM@W  * .201020.  =/Y + ,:²ÐhAz0Ÿ0Y[epl(Y E2V * .1020202. VDMOQjA]d[]>z{nom†]>s«m{Y[]s{no\£]Íei‡]Unog N§nks E(P*<.102010.3(4QA¤T~5hµs†hkgiÀ5efdrjT\q[gfm†eiÀ—noz{einom†]œ]>xIqrnom†eihkdrslnodÁw3]W‡hAd[]Ïw5uµjAefÀ5eid[jÃnTd[]>Ÿ ²Þno\£efgiu m{Yrn—mšjk]dr]z(n—m†]Uscm†Y[]Cs†nk\:]Wei‡]UnogOs†hm†Y›n—mm{Y[eis²Þno\£eigfu±s†nom†eps}¶›]>ss† ›]Ul#epnog­l#hkd›‡e¯m{efhAdrs>¤ *­qmšs†hkgiÀ5efdrj äÐí

(61) étäëê.

(62) 

(63)     "!. Š. s†us}m{]\œs­Ÿ0e¯m{YCep‡]UnogÎjkeiÀk]ƒqrs0nogig3m†Y[] s†hkgiqm†eihkd›s«hk²m{Y[] svusvm†]\"efdWm†Y[]nkgfjA]w[z(noepll#gihAs†q[z{]ƒhk²· ¹ ¤D¾[hkz lz†u5 m{hkjAz{nk [Y[eplƒnk [ [gieil>n—m†eihkd›s¿Ÿ­] hkd[giuWŸ!nodIm.s†hkgiqm†eihkd›s!efdm{Y[] ¶r]>gi‡C· ¹ ¿rnodr‡d[hkm.eidCm{Y[]nkgfjA]w[z(noepl lgfhIsvqrz†]A¤

(64) €ƒs!· ¹ eisn¶rd[efm†]Ͷ›]gp‡Î¿[Ÿ­]cY›= nLÀk]Ísvei\£ [gf] nkgfjA]w[z(noepl.z{]gpn—m{efhAdrs­hkdCm†Y[]ÍÀ—noz{epnow[gi]>s 67&Ÿ0Y[epl(Y ‡[]>s{l#z{efw3]Í]#¨[nkl#m†giuœm†Y[] ]>gf]>\£]dIm{s!hk²*· ¹ ¤DX!Yr]>s†]cz{]gpn—m{efhAdrs!noz{]cm†Y[]Ͷr]>gi‡C]>xIqrnom†eihkdrsÍ´ Õ ” ÞÙ¡X!Yr]ƒ¶›]gp‡C]UxIqrn—m{efhAdrs  `*¹F =e BE * ¹ i  * .2010201.  = ¹ i 6=>Q. ~5h›¿;efdhkz(‡]zm†hµgiei\:efm:m†Y[]svhAgfq[m†eihkdÁeid¼· ¹ ¿;Ÿ­]C‡[hµd[hkm:svm†qr‡u¦m{Y[]Wep‡]Uno

(65) g X(P*.2020102.(4 efed ` = wrqmÏm†Yr]Ãei‡[]>nog X( * .2010202.( 4 .  * ¹ i  ¹ * i .201020.  = ¹ i 6¹ =i ʤˆXh¼s†ei\: rgfef²Ðu©m{Y[]Ãd[hkm{nom†eihkdt¿0Ÿ­]ǁ]drhom†] C¹ F =¼m{Y[]z†eid[j±·*¹ :  * .1020201. 6= ?  *  * .201020.  = 6= ʤ X!Y[]>dŸ­]hkd[giu¼l#hAdrs†ei‡]>zœnodÆei‡]Unog  + X( * .2010201.3( 4 ­ef d C¹ F =lhkz{z†]Usv 3hkd›‡efdrjm{h£m†Y[] ep‡]>nkg X( * .2010201.3( 4 .) * ¹ i  * .201020.  = ¹ i 6= !eid `*¹ F =H¤ ød§ [z{nAlÊm{eil]k¿3e¯²Dm{Y[]šl>noz(‡eidrnog

(66) ºœho²OÅ&¹ eps.ÀA]z{uCgpnoz{jk]šl#hk\£ rnkz†]U‡m†hC½;¿3Ÿ­]š‡[hWd[hkmƒqrs†]m{Y[]¶›]gp‡ ]UxIqrn—m{efhAdrs0²ÐhAzƒs†hkgiÀIeid[jWs†us}m{]\œs>¤¥§]š [z{]#²Ð]zƒm†hCl#hk\£ [q[m†]dr]Ÿˆjk]>d[]z(n—m{hkz(s¿›nksÍ`cz†¢Aw[d[]z.wrnks†]>s>¿›hk² (P*<.1020102.3(4 ­eid ` ¹ F = w3]>l>noqrs†]cm†Y[epslhk\£ [qm(n—m†eihkdsvm†hk ›s!hkdTn£‡]jAz†]>]c³Ñgih—Ÿ«]>z«m{YrnodTº5¤ ~5hšŸ«]ƒYrnLÀk]ƒ‡eisvm†eid[jAq[eis†Y[]U‡œm}Ÿ­hef\£ 3hkz†m{nkdAm{]ƒl>nks†]>s>´m{Y[].¶›]gp‡£· ¸ ÝÞefdsv]UlÊm{efhAdWAßDŸ0Y[]z{]m{Y[].¶›]gp‡ ]UxIqrn—m{efhAdrs!noz{]cÀA]z{uœef\£ 3hkz†m{nkdAm.nkdr‡Wm†Y[]Ͷr]>gi‡C· ¹ ÝÐeids†]>l#m†eihkd &oß­Ÿ0efm†YTº » ½;¤ .0/.  >7 !A< 47:4. ¥±] z{]#²Ð]z!m{hÈ _oÉβÐhkz‡]m{noeigps0hkdT`cz†¢Aw[d[]>z­w›nks†]>s>¤ ¥ efm†Y£q[d[eiÀ—noz{einom†]­ ›hAgfu5d[hA\£einkgis>¿L¶rdr‡eid[j nƒd[]Ÿjk]dr]z(n—m†hAzhk²3nodšei‡[]>nogs† rnodrd[]>‡šw5u" X(P*.2020102.(4# eps­‡hkd[]ƒŸ0e¯m{YÏm{Y[]ƒÜOqrl#giei‡[]>nod€gijkhAz†efm†Y[\¤;X*hjk]>d[]z(nogieiÌ]0m{Y[]ƒÜOqrl#giei‡[]>nodC€gijkhkz{efm†Y[\ hkdC\q[gfm†eiÀ—noz{e¯® nom†]Í 3hkgiuIdrhk\£einkgis>¿Ÿ­]cdr]]>‡Cm{h£‡[]#¶rd[]n:\£hkdrhk\£einkgÎhkz(‡]z{eid[jr´ Õ ” ÞÙ %$ \£hAd[hk= \£epnog;hkz(‡]>z†eid[ej  ` ¹ F = 6 2^  '& en 22)( !6!  ' +*-, . + W . *.201020. . = Y 8/ ,TL /0& [L     @1,2/2 43 n65> H722T 2^  98 ( :*& <; >

(67) =L8>/ = n+*@? AB& <;?CAEDF, 6"GaIH  P2 O:8 J3<2 4K6>>2!L5K Gn2 M( nB!6!   2 /<6!6 9 !6 ND@. –. Õ ‚t]m +*nodr‡ <;Cw›]Ím}Ÿ­h£\:hAd[hk\£epnogps¤ S X!Y[]‚t]¨eilhkjkz(no rY[eilƒhkz(‡]>z>´&¥±]s†nLu :*T <;e¯²U@K 8 ENP.102010.v½ QO.WVYX . 7T[Z>7Dnodr‡ J]\"^ K. .C_ +%Z _ ¤ ] \c„‚ÁhAz{‡]>z>´;¥±]s{nLu +*>` <;e¯²cI . I@+ =7 * . 7aT I Z IO+ =7 * Z>7;hkzI . I@+ I Z I[nod›‡ S X!Y[ U@Ka8 EONP.201020.†½ Q s>¤ m>¤ . 7 ^[Z 7 nodr‡ J>K^b\. . _ +Z _ ¤ S X!Y[] ]giei\:eidrnom†eihkdhkz(‡]z :  * .1020201.  M ? ¿ :  M ? * .1020201. 6= ? ´;¥§]s{nLuœm{Yrn—mÓ + Ó>c&Ód#e±Óf+ Ófc Ó df ef²ƒnod›‡Áhkd[giu±e¯².>Ó c[`ÒÓ fc hkzCÝÞÓ cM+ >Ó fc nod›‡ÁÓ d'`ÒÓ fd ߟ0e¯m{Y¼Ó>c©ÝÐz{]>s† t¤±Ódoß ‡] 3]d›‡[s0hkdrgfuÏhAd  7 ¿ N Z K Zhg±ÝÐz{]>s† ; _ i¿ gj^ K Z½ß#¤ ‚]#mqrs0eidIm†z{h‡qrl#] s†hk\£] ‡]#¶›d[e¯m{efhAdrs>´ Õ ” ÞÙ kD 2 @mlonR6!6>!   P2 6^2 (>. V 8jCG¹ F = >]pH 

(68) 5/IK>! 'J OP )RQ"& :. é*éÑülnmom .

(69) . P2   W. ( Y  n9^O  ! )( (o,  WX( Y

(70)  /c^PO! >!  )(a( > WX( Y +  . nB 3@2H

(71) !22  

(72) M(c(m lan   n22   + E2VO*<.102010. V1Q )(BL P   2    :`cz†¢Aw[d[]>z­w›nks†eis ( J ( 8 U@Ka8 EONP.201020. VQ G 72[ /   WVP7 Y 3H P  W ( YJ.  . W,. ¬z{]>‡q›l#]>‡CwrnAsveps( #5nIK!    P  <Å9(  G72[ / 8 D  WY +DN#(  8Å" 8  D  T 8T Å ,  Ó ! >!   )( , ( 8TÅ

(73) .  W ( YB 3H P.ÓR 4A  F    0'( i  # 4A   F $ 

(74) G 0 V  /a`D®° ›hAgfu5d[hA\:epnog )(a(M> V  `! WX(>. V"Y +" #     L .     ¥±]:‡[hkd  mcY›nLÀk] m{Y[]šqrd[eixIq[]>d[]>s{sƒho²Dm{Y[]£`cz{¢kwrd[]zƒwrnks†eis>¤ ødòÞnkl#m>¿Hef² Òepscn`cz†¢Aw[d[]>z.wrnAsveps.hk² Nnod›‡ (M80% ¿ '&LE<( QepscnogpsvhWnC`cz†¢Aw[d[]zƒwrnks†eps¤ƒ¥§]šz†]Ulnogig*s†hk\£]šwrnks†eil [z†hA ›]>zvm{ef]Ushk²«`cz†¢Aw[d[]z w›nks†eis!eid  ¹ F = ¤ ( • Ù Q Ù “  ” ÞÙ    2i*+ ) , L P )( C¹ F =e"& 6!6!     @ . , >  a +'  /2 B

(75)  P2>2 <+ )(m

(76) . / "   , nB 72

(77)  P2>2 <-"  + E/.10324.P.1020201.    * 3 0 2   * Q  ( W52..2010202.62   * Y a / nIK 2 "   M(  / 4K< 2! (. =4. Ï· =¹ .  + ENPQ  (  /2 BT 2 "  L F7 nB 33 7 2. + E2V * 1. 020201. V  Q ( NR  3 P2>2 c3o( R N  (c>  IKB ( (  @5n  K-+ )   )( ` ! W V 7 . V _ Y K8  #pH2 @. \7,.  2 + 

(78)   < )( N ( [n:9  ! >X   P2 :  * .1020102.  M ? , :  M ? * .1020102. 6= ? 8   /6  n23  5/"2   D@  n;=<T·&¹ :  M ? * .120 0201. 6= ?   e

(79)   R3R)( N>< ·

(80) ¹ :  M ? * .2020102.  = ? . X!Y[]£gpnksvmc rz†hA ›hIsvefm†eihkdÃ]¨ [ginkefd›sƒYrh—Ÿ¬m†hl#hk\£ [q[m†]£ ›hAgfu5d[hA\£einkgisc‡] 3]d›‡efdrjhAd§s†]ÀA]z(nogpsÀ—noz{e¯® kn w[gi]>s M ? *.1020102.  = Ÿ0efm†Y¦`cz†¢Aw[d[]>zƒwrnAsveps>¤€.scŸ«]:YrnLÀA]d[h—Ÿ¬m{Y[]šdrhom†eihkd§ho²­`cz{¢kwrd[]zcwrnks†]>s>¿HŸ«] Ÿ0eigigsv]>]Íefdm†Yr] d[]#¨5msv]UlÊm{efhAd‡e^]H]z{]dIm.nogijkhAz†efm†Y[\œs­Y[h—ŸËm†hœl#hA\: rqm†] efm>¤. äÐí

(81) étäëê.

(82) 

(83)     "!. &.  & C!   # ,$#% & ('*)+ Ñ *­]²Ðhkz{] [z†]Usv]>dIm†eid[jœm†Yr]ƒ‚nogijkhkz{efm†Y[\¿rŸ­]Ÿ0eigfg*efdre¯m{einkgfgiuTlnoz{z{uÏhkqmÍsvhA\£] z†]Ulnogigpshkdm{Y[]lhk\£ [q® m(n—m{efhAd¼ho²ƒ`cz{¢kw[dr]z  swrnks†]>swIu±m{Y[] *­qrl(Y5w3]z{jk]>znogijkhAz†efm†Y[\È #[¿

(84) oɰ¤±¾rhkz£nogig« [z{h5ho²Þsšnodr‡¦²Ðqrzvm{Y[]z ‡[]#m{nkefgps>¿Ÿ«]Íz{]#²Ð]z!m{hTÈ _—É?¤ /.. 7  .

(85) .   5

(86) A9. !7  07  <?E. !X Yr] *­qrl(Y5w3]z{jk]>z

(87) €.gfjAhkz{e¯m{Y[\ˆeis;n jvjk]>d[]z(nogiefÌUn—m{efhAd@kDho²rm{Y[]!ÜDqrlgfep‡]>nkd:€.gfjAhkz{e¯m{Y[\¬m†hcm{Y[]0\q[gfm†eiÀ—noz{e¯® nom†].l>nks†]k¿AŸ0Y[]z{]!m†Y[]9`D®? 3hkgiu5d[hk\£epnog›eisOqrsv]U‡:m†h\œnom{l(Y£m†Yr]gf]Unk‡eid[j \£hkdrhk\£einkgrhk²3m}Ÿ­h 3hkgiuIdrhk\£einkgis ²Ðz{hk\ÄÅ + E<(*<.201020.(4QA¤ °²m{Y[]z†]U‡qrlÊm{efhAd¼ho².m†Y[]z{]>s†q[g¯m:eis:d[hAd[Ì]>z†h›¿&m†Y[]>dŸ­]CnA‡[‡¼efm£m†h§m†Y[] ]UxIqrn—m{efhAdrs­ho²;Å£¤  

(88) ˜ H’ Õ •  Õ • i“£‘ & Ù •  ”  ™   Q*” ´  Å^nk+ dWXhk( z(* ‡.1]02z0202.3( 4 Y­gfepsvmho²* 3hkgiu5d[hk\£epnogps  *J” Q"” ´  nœ`cz{¢kw[dr]z!wrnks†eps­²Ðhkz Ɵ0e¯m{YT Å  £¤ ‹A¤  +ËÅ£¤D¾*eidr‡nogigHm†Yr] ›hIs†s†efwrgf]Í rnkefz(s!ho²

(89) ›hAgfu5d[hA\:epnogps!ho² £¤ ^[¤á«YrhIhIsv]n£ ›noeiz WX(>. V"Y0nkdr‡z†]U‡qrl] m†Y[B] `$!WX(>. V/Y­w5uWm{Y[] ²Þnk\:eigiu £¤ °²&m†Y[]z{]>‡[qrlÊm{efhAd epsOnÍdrhkd£Ì]>z†h 3hkgiu5d[hk\£epnog?¿Ank‡r‡m{Y[epsD 3hkgiuIdrhk\£einkgm†8h žnkdr‡£l#hAdrsvep‡]>z;m†Y[].d[]ŸÆ ›hIs†s†eiw[gf] ›noeiz{s0‡]¶rd[]U‡Ww5uWefm>¤ #r¤­z{] 3]>nom!m†Y[] [z{]À5eihkqrs­ 3hkeidImq[dIm†eigtŸ«]ÍYrnLÀA] nš 3hAs{s†efw[gi]Í rnoeiz0ho²

(90) ›hAgfu5d[hA\£einkgis>¤ X!Y[]Ís†]gi]>lÊm{efhAdWhk²tm†Y[]Í rnkefz WX(7 .3( YDeps­Àk]z{u£ef\£ 3hkz†m{nkdAm­²Ðhkz­m{Y[]ƒ2] gÏl#ei]drluk¤;€¬l#gpnks{sveplnkg›svm†z(n—m†]>jku eps­m†hÏl(YrhIhIsv]Ín: rnoeiBz WX(7 .( _ Y­Ÿ0Y[hAs†] _ ÊÓ WX(7 .3( _ Y­eps0\£efdref\œnog?¤ ¾rqm†Y[]>z†\£hAz†]Wm†Y[]\£hAsvmš]¨5 3]d›sveiÀk]Chk 3]z(n—m†eihkd©efd©m†Y[]nogijkhAz†efm†Y[\ epsm{Y[]z†]U‡qrlÊm{efhAd©hk²m†Y[] `D® 3hkgiu5d[hk\£epnogps!\£h5‡[q[gfhœÅ£¤O¾rhkz†m†q[d›n—m†]>gfuA¿ *c¤ *­qrl(Y5w›]>z†jA]zÍÈ —É*‡]>Àk]gihk 3]>‡Cm}Ÿ­hœl#z{e¯m{]z{ein²Ðhkz.‡[]#m†]UlÊm{efd[j Žo®?z{]>‡[qrlÊm{efhAdrs!nš rz†eihkz{eö¤  

(91) ˜ H’ Õ •  Õ • i"“ !•  ” Õ • ÞÙ   ™ ‚t]#m  .{º 8 CG¹ F =Τ °² #ÊÓ W W >Y.  Wöº Y Y[+  W>Y  Wöº Y m†Y[]>Rd `$!W .{º Y­Ÿ0efgigtw3] z†]U‡qrl]ƒm{hœÌ]>z†h:w5 u E  .†Oº QA¤  

(92) ˜ H’ Õ •  Õ • i"“ !•  ” Õ • ÞÙ $ ™ °²}¿;Ÿ0Y[]d©lhkdrs†ep‡]z{efdrjm†Y[]C rnoeiz E( 7 .( _ QA¿DnodÁ]>gf]>\£]dIm ( Mhk²0m†Y[] wrnks†ep-s  ‡he ]H]z{]dIm²Ðz{hk\ ( 7 nkdr ‡ ( _ ]¨eisvm{ss†qrl(Ym†Y›n—m #ÊÓ W W ( 7 Y.  W ( _ Y Y!epsn£\šq[g¯m{ef rgf] ho²  WX( M YÏnkdr‡ `! WX(7 .( M YÏnkdr‡ `$!WX( _ .( M YœY›nLÀIeid[j¼nkgfz{]>nA‡u©w3]]>d l#hkd›svep‡]z{]>‡t¿«m{Y[]d `$!WX(7.3( _ Y­Ÿ0eigigtz†]U‡qrl]ƒm{hœÌ]>z†h:w5uœm†Y[] ]>gf]>\£]dIm{snkgfz{]>nA‡uÏl#hA\£ [qm†]U‡Î¤ X!Y[]Usv]Ím}Ÿ­hÏl#z{efm†]z{epnm(noªA]nk‡À—nodIm(nojk]Íhk²

(93) w3]eid[jœgih5l>nogOÝÞ]k¤ jr¤«hkd[] d[]>]>‡[sm†hœ]¨nk\£efd[]Ím{Y[]gi]>nA‡efdrj m{]z{\œs{ßw[qm&m†Yr]unkz†]­d[hom& 3]z†²Ð]>lÊmU´\£hAsvm;ho/² `O®? 3hkgiu5d[hk\£epnogps

(94) svm†eigigIz{]>‡[qrl#]­m†hcÌ]>z†h›¤*¾rhkz

(95) \:hAz†]!‡]m{noeigps¿ z{]#²Ð]>z!m†hÈ _—É. é*éÑülnmom .

(96) b. P2   /.  .  >7 !A< 47:4 <?>)@.  < )4 4 <?>. .   ><

(97) 5  . E 9. >. \š¤H‚noÌUnoz(‡WeidTm{Y[]noz†m†epl#gi]>sÈfH‹ #LÉ

(98) nkdr‡¦Èi‹U^UÉ&jAnLÀA]ÍnÏz†]>ginom†eihkdrs†Y[ei w3]#m}Ÿ­]]>dm†Y[]š\£]#m†Yrh5‡Ãho²&m†Y[]:l#hA\š® r qm{nom†eihkdœho²t`c=z{¢kw[d[]>zDwrnAsv]UsDnodr‡:m{Y[]hAd[]0wrnks†]>‡£hAdÏ`Ínoqrs{svepnod£ÜDgiei\:eidrnom†eihkdrsOefdÏs†hk\£]\œn—m{z†epl#]Us

(99) ²Ðhkz m{Y[]s†u5svm†]>\ ( 4 ¤ X!Y[]\£nom†z{eil]>sƒl#hkd›svep‡]z{]>‡nkz†]Ím{Y[]l#gpnks{s†eilÍ\œn—m{z†epl#]Us0drnk\:]U‡TàÃnkl>noq[gpnLuÃÈi‹—ɰ¤‚t]m.qrsƒl#hkd›svep‡]z n\£hAd[hk\£epnog;hkz(‡]>"z & nkdr‡¦nod¦eidAm{]jA]z³T¿*m†Yr]Wsv]m{s hk²­ 3hkgiu5d[hk\£epnogps  7 F C nTs†q[w5Àk]UlÊm†hAzsv ›nkl#]œhk² E<G 8  ¹ F = I SOU2V W GBY Z SOU2V WX(7XYQI¿!²Ðhkz K[8 ENP.102010.vL Ó QA¿!nodr‡  CÑnÁs†q[w5Àk]>l#m†hAzÏsv rnAl#]ho² E<G 8  ¹ F = I SOU2V W GBY Z¡[ ³ Qœ¤ ~5hœŸ­] lnkdlhkdrs†ei‡[]z­m†Y[]ͲÐhAgfgih—Ÿ0eid[j£gfeid[]>nkzno [ rgfeplnom†eihkdµ´ i (C F 4

(100)  * F CW VO *.1IL02IK02I 0 VP 4 Y 4 F C i V6+  47

(101) C * VP7X(7 . X!Y[] àÃnAlnkq[ginLu£\œn—m{z†ef¨  C F4   eis­ [z{]>leis†]giu£m†Y[]cm{z{nkdrsv 3hAs†]>‡W\œn—m†z{ef¨Ïho²*s†qrl(Ynm{z{nkdrs}²ÐhAz†\œno®. m{efhAdWhAdœm†Y[]cwrnAsveps«‡[]>s{l#z{efw3]cnkw›h—ÀA]k¤°²*Ÿ­].Ÿ!nodImOm{h:lhk\£ [qm{]ƒn£`cz†¢Aw[d[]z«wrnks†epsD²ÐhAz!nkdÏhkz(‡]>z & ¿5Ÿ«] l(YrhIhIsv]  7 F C©nodri ‡  C¦m†Y[]!giefdr]>noz

(102) Àk]UlÊm{hkz&sv rnAl#]Us*s† rnodrd[]>‡z†]Usv 3]>l#m†eiÀk]giuÍw5u E>Ó !\£hAd[hk\£epnogÎho²o ¹GF = I SOU1VWÞ Ó Y Zž³ SU1V WX(7 YQœnodre‡ E>Ó 0\:hAd[hk\£epnogÎhk²  G¹ F = I SU1V WÐÓ 3Y Z¬[³ QA¤€.dr‡ÃŸ­]:d[]]U‡Tm†hs†hkz†m m{Y[]­gfeid[]>nkz*w›nks†eisho²  C¦Ÿ0efm†Ym†Y[]­\£hkd[hA\:epnogIhkz(‡]>z†eid[jr¤*X!Y[]d:nƒ`Ínoq›s†s†einkd ]gief\£eidrn—m{efhAdšlhkz{z†]Usv 3hkdr‡rs m{hœnšz{]>‡[qrlÊm{efhAdC²ÐhAz!m†Y[] \£hAd[hk\£epnogHhkz(‡]z{eid[jr¤ ødšhom†Yr]z

(103) Ÿ«hAz{‡[s>¿Um†Y[eps

(104) \œn—m†z{ef¨ l>nodšw›]!l#hAdrs}m{z†q›lÊm†]U‡nks²Ðhkgigih—ŸsO´tŸ0z{efm†]!‡h—Ÿ0dY[hAz†eiÌhAdAm(nogigfuÍnogigIm†Y[] \£hAd[hk\£epnogpsDŸ0efm†YC‡[]jkz{]].gfh—Ÿ­]zOm†YrnkdW³T¿5hkz(‡]z{]>‡£w5u:m†Yr].\£hkd[hA\£einkg›hAz{‡]>z & ÝÐm†Y[]ƒ¶rz(s}m­hkd[]eps«m†Y[] gpnoz{jk]Us}mhAd[]Uß#¤.Û]>drl#]š]>nAl(Ylhkgiq[\£dÃepseidr‡]#¨]U‡Tw5unW\:hAd[hk\£epnogthk²O‡]jAz†]>]n—mci \:hIs}mc³T¤.àTq[gfm†ei [giu ]Unkl(6Y (7}¿ Ka8LEN.202010.vLÓ Qw5unod5uš\:hAd[hk\£epnogÓ DŸ0e¯m{Yœn ‡]jAz†]>]­gih—Ÿ­]z

(105) m†Yrnkdœ³ SU1V WX(7 YÊ¿Ankdr‡:Ÿ0z†efm†] m{Y[]šlh5] gÏl#ei]dIm{s.ho²DÓ  ( 7 efdÃm†Y[]:l#hkgiq[\£drs.ho²;m†Yr]eizƒl#hAz†z{]>s† 3hkdr‡eid[jœ\£hkdrhk\£einkgö¿rm†Y5qrsc‡]#¶›d[]šnœz{h—Ÿ hk²m{Y[] \œn—m†z{ef¨WŸ0Y[epl(Yl>nodw›] eidr‡]¨]>‡w5uÏÓ  ( 7 ¤ Ó *`Ó ¸ `Æ$Ó # 01020`Ó   ¸ `ÆÓ   * `Ó  ! *,++ Ó f* ( 7&% ! > 02010 Ó ¸f ( 7(' 02010   C F4   + > Ó>f (7() 02010 # . ILIKI. ". ILIKI. -. ¥±]ƒnkz†]hAd[giušeidIm†]z{]>svm†]U‡£efdÏm†Y[]ƒef\œnojA]0ho² ( C F 4 ¿5d[hom{])NAÓ W ( C F4 YʤD~5hŸ­].l#hA\£ [qm†]cn`Ínoq›s†s†einkd ]>gfei\£efd›n—m†eihkdhkdm{Y[]cm†Y[] z{h—Ÿs­ho²

(106) m†Y[] \œn—m{z†ef¨  C F4   m†h:¶rd›‡n:giefdr]>noz0w›nks†eis!hk² NAÓ W ( C F4 Yʤ ¾rhkzÏm{Y[]µgpn—m†m†]>z>¿0Ÿ­]µ\šqrs}m‡]#¶rdr]§nÁw3hkq[d›‡ hkd m{Y[]µ‡]>jkz{]]µ³ svhÁm{Yrn—mWm†Y[]§gfeid[]>nkzWwrnAsvepsÏhk² NAÓ WX( C F  4 Ytepsnkgis†h.n.`cz{¢kwrd[]z*wrnks†eisho²5m†Yr]Oep‡]>nkgö¤

(107) X!Y[eis* [z{hkw[gi]\žeps*s†q[\£\œnoz{efÌ>]>‡ÍŸ0efm†Y m{Y[]D²ÐhAgfgih—Ÿ0efdrj m{Y[]hAz†]>\´ .  Õ5Ù • Õ    C 6  P )(L G¹ F = 2>2  [ K 5/IK>! ' (P*.2010202.( = M(P P   5 S"*<.1020102.S = "!  /   N Lp12 EH !6n > ,  Y ,  P'm( #G @2[ / 2a)( 2 "X / M ( nT4 K< !Tmlan Y

(108)  P2>2 <2 (   nP23 3 5/"26  T62! 5 " BG  ϳ Z S@2* S ¸ 020203S = . äÐí

(109) étäëê.

(110) 

(111)     "!

(112)  P2>2 <2 (  c P2 B62! 5 " BG  œ³ Z S"*0 S. ¸. _ IKIKI. 0eS = i. ½. 0N.  $#%

(113) ('

(114) )  *+ [

(115) 0%#$# Ñ  0­0 ødÃm†Y[epsƒs†]>l#m†eihkdt¿3Ÿ­]Ÿ0eigfg

(116) [z{]>s†]dImm†Yr]šnogijkhAz†efm†Yr\ÑÅ Ç Èi‹k‹#É&nkdr‡ rnoz†m†epl#qrginkz†giuÅ Ç eid§nÏ\£nom†z{e¯¨²Þnks†Y® eihkdÆÈi‹ÊÉ?¤£X!Y[]œnogijkhAz†efm†Yr\\£nom†z{e¯¨5®øÅ Ç lhkdrsvm†z{qrlÊm(sc\£nom†z{eil]>sceidrl#z{]\£]dIm(nogigfuTeid±m†Y[]œ‡]>jkz{]]£nodr‡µm†Y[] d5q[\šw›]>zƒhk²O 3hkgiuIdrhk\£einkgis>¿Înodr‡Ãqrsv]Uscgfeid[]>nkzcnkgfjA]w[z(n[¤Í¾[hAz.m{Y[epscs†]>l#m†eihkdt¿HŸ­]šŸ0eigig

(117) q›sv]m†Y[]£d[hkm{n—m{efhAd eidIm†z{h‡qrl#]U‡WeidTsv]UlÊm{efhAd^[¤ ^[¤ . .

(118) /..  .

(119)  . E<?>< 5. >. ¥±]Y›nLÀk]s†]]>dÃefd§sv]UlÊm†eihkdµ^[¤ ^[¿rm{Yrn—mcŸ«]:noz{]hkdrgfueidAm{]z{]>svm†]U‡efd NAÓ WX( C F 4 Y!²ÐhAz  7 F Cˆnod›i ‡  Cžm†Y[] gieid[]>nkztÀk]UlÊm†hAzs† rnkl]>sts† rnodrd[]>‡Íz{]>s† ›]UlÊm{efÀA]giu.w5u EUÓ 0\£hkdrhk\£einkgÎho² ¹GF = I SOU1VWÞÓY ZƳ SOU1VW (7 YQ nkdr‡ E>Ó 0\£hkd[hA\:epnogHhko²  ¹ F = IBSU1V WÐÓ Y Z [³ QA¤Ã~5hµŸ«]£m{z†u§m†hÃ]¨[l#giqr‡]Ï]>gf]>\:]>dIm{shk²!m†Y[]ϪA]z{d[]g hk² ( C F 4 ¿3‡]d[hkm†]U‡ LU@W ( C F4 Yʤ­Xh£ [z{]>‡eplÊm]>gf]>\£]dIm{s0eid  U"WX( C F 4 Y#¿rŸ­] efdIm†z{h‡qrl]nodhkz(‡]z0hAd m{Y[]z†h—Ÿ ´œ‚t]Rm WXG * .2010202.3G 4 Yšnodr‡ W * .1020102.  4 Yw›]Cm}Ÿ«h§]gi]\£]dIm(shk²  * F C IKIKI  4 F C ¤¦¥§] s{nLLu WXG * .2010201.G 4 Y ^FW * .1020202.  4 Y0efa² U@K 8eEONP.102020.†Ó Q:s¤ m>¤ 7W G 7 Y& 7W 7 Y!nodr‡ J\."KW^[\RZ Ó ./G _ + _ + ,r¤&X!Yreis«hkz(‡]z­epsOd[hkm!nm†hkm{nkg›hAz{‡]>z†eid[jhAd  * F C IKIKI  4 F C ¤ *­qmU¿I²Ðhkz­]#¨[no\£ [gi]k¿ ²ÐhAzDm{Y[]ƒl>nod[hAd[eil>nog›wrnks†ei9s EOW 020201.,n.vÓ  .  .102020YÊ¿5Ÿ0efm†YÏÓ  \£hkdrhk\£einkg QI¿khk²  * F C ILIKI  4 F C ¿Aefm­epsOn m{hom(nog[hAz{‡]>z†eid[j›¤

(120) ~5hnkgfg›]gi]\£]dIm{sOlnod£w3]ƒ‡]Ul#hA\: 3hAs†]>‡:eidœnodœhkz(‡]>z†]U‡giefdr]>nozOwrnks†eis>¤ °²3m{Y[epsD]gi]\£]>dAm eps eid  U"WX( C F 4 YÊ¿&nTsv/q gœlef]>dIml#hkd›‡e¯m{efhAd§epsÍm{hT]#¨[l#giqr‡]£m{Y[]œY[eijkY[]>z ]gi]\£]dImho²­m†Yr]Ïwrnks†eps¤ÏX!Y[] dr]Ÿ wrnks†epss}m{efgig«lhkdIm{nkefd›snTs†q[ [ [gi]\£]dIm(noz{uµÀk]UlÊm{hkzs† rnkl]œho²  U"WX( C F 4 Ynodr‡¦efm{sef\œnojA]Ïepssvm†eigfg NAÓ WX(  YÊ ¤ *­qmƒe¯²DŸ­]Ÿ!nodIm0m†h  5e @  P2 ‡q[z{eid[jœm†Yr]l#hA\: rqm{nom†eihkdt¿›m†Y[]hkd[giuC]>gf]>\£]dIm{nkz†u hA ›]>z{noC m†eiF hk4 dà 3hAs{s†efw[gi]epsƒm†Y[]œnA‡[‡efm†eihkdµŸ0efm†Y§gfh—Ÿ­]zc]gi]\£]>dAm(s¤X!Y5qrsƒ²ÐhAzƒm{Y[]œ`Ínoqrs{svepnodµ]gief\£eidrn—m{efhAd hAdµm{Y[]œ\œn—m{z†ef¨   C F4   ¿m†Y[]£]gi]\£]>dAm(noz{uÃhk 3]z(n—m{efhAdrschkd¦nz†h—Ÿnkz†]£hAd[gfu§svei\£ [gfef¶›l>n—m†eihkd›sƒŸ0efm†Y rz†]>ÀIeihkq›s«z{h—Ÿs>¤ àThAz†]>h—Àk]>z>¿onkd:]>gf]>\£]dImOho² LU"W ( C  * F 4 Y&jkeiÀk]Us;sv]>Àk]z(nog]>gf]>\£]dIm{s;eid  U"WX( C F 4 Y#¤D~5h Ÿ«]ƒs}m{qr‡u m{Y[]àÃnAlnoqrginLu\œnom†z{e¯¨   C F 4 ,  eidrlz†]>\:]>dIm{nogigiuefd£m{Y[]‡]>jkz{]]0³Ònodr‡£lhkdrsvm†z{qrlÊm&m{Y[]Àk]UlÊm{hkzDs† rnkl]  * F C IKILI  4 F CÒ²Ðz{hk\n±wrnks†eis£hk²  * F C  * IKILI  4 F C  *l#hk\£ [q[m†]>‡Æn—²ëm{]zœm{Y[]µ`Ínoq›s†s†einkd ]>gfei\£efd›n—m†eihkd¤ ødr‡[]]>‡t¿km{Y[].wrnAsveps;hk² 7 F C¡eis«l#hk\£ 3hAs†]>‡:w5um{Y[].w›nks†eis;hk²  7 F C  *nodr‡£]>gf]>\£]dIm{s;Ÿ0efm†Y ‡[]jkz{]] ³Ÿ0Y[epl(YTlnkdw3] Ÿ0z{e¯m†m†]dÃnAs  G Ÿ0efm†Y G efd 7 F C *o¤«X!Y5qrs>¿rnod]gi]\£]>dAm W G *.1020202.G 4 Y hk²  * F C ILIKI  4 F Ceps«s†hÍm†Yrnom«]¨5epsvm{s­nodœ_ q[d[epxIq[] _W*<.102010. T4 Y;eid  * F C  * IKILI  4 F C  *«Ÿ0efm†Y B7;‡efÀ5ep‡]>s G 7&²ÐhAznogig Ka8LENP.102010.vL Ó QA¤ €.d§hkm†Y[]>z i [z†hAw[gi]\eps.m{h [z†]>Àk]>dAmÍ]gi]\£]>dAm(scho!² LU@W ( C F4 Y.Ÿ0Yreil(Y¦noz{]šeps{svq[]U‡T²Ðz{hk\ nCm†z{eiÀIepnog z{]gpn—m{efhAd ( V V/(L+D,r¤ƒ¾[hAzm{Y[eisƒhkz(‡]>z>¿rm†Y[]:i \œn—m†z{ef¨   C F7   ¿3²ÐhAcz KL^ Ó eps.hAd[gfum{Y[]¶rz(svm.z†h—Ÿs hk²   C F4   ¤~hµŸ­]CŸ!nodIm_  m{h±* nLÀAhkep‡ V/( _ ( _ V + ,òÐhA0z \T)NCnkdrM‡ VÁi eid NAÓ W ( C  * F _  * Y#¤©€.s ( V¦lnkdÁw›]ϟ0z{efmvm†]>d©nks G 7 (7†¿&Ÿ«]χ]U‡qrl]œm†Yrnomm{Y[]Ïz{]gpn—m†eihkd V/( ( VM+ ,Ãlhkz{z†]Usv 3hkdr‡rs m{h _ ( C F4 W i G *.1020202. i G _  *. 7V .* ,/.102010 YB+5,[¿*eö¤ ]kL¤ W i G *.1020202. i G _  *. V.,/.1_ 02010 Y _ 8"LU"W ( C F4 Y#¤CX!Y[] YrefjAY[]z«]gi]\£]dIm«hk²Îm†Y[]cwrnAsvepsDeidœm†Yr]c‡]Ul#hA\: 3hAs†efm†eihkdœho²Îm{Y[epsO]>gf]>\:]>dIm«YrnAsDm{Y[eis­s†Yrno 3] W$#@.201020.%#@.3G _ . ,n.201020YšŸ0efm†Y WXG _ YR+ 7WV/Yʤ ødhkm†Y[]>zœŸ«hAz{‡rs¿DŸ­]T‡h±d[homWlhkdrs†ei‡[]z:m†Y[]]>gf]>\:]>dIm{sœs†h§m{Yrn—m é*éÑülnmom .

(121) ‹UŽ. P2  . 7W G Y­eis!z{]>‡[qrl#]U‡Ww5 u     ¤DX!Yrn—m0\£]>nkdrs­m†Yrnom>¿²ÐhAzn£‡]jAz†]>]c³T¿[m†Y[]lhk\£ [qm(n—m†eihkdeps0‡hkd[] eidrlz†]>\:_ ]>dIm{nogigiuœhkdm†Y[] d5q[\šC w›F _]>z0* ho²

(122) ›hAgfu5d[hA\:epnogps>¤.   

(123) 5  .

(124) /. @)7:4 -. >. X*h£z†]Usvqr\:]cm{Y[eis]#¨ [gpnodrnom†eihkdt¿5Ÿ­]lnod [z{]>s†]dIm!m†Y[]nkgfjAhkz{e¯m{Y[\ ²Ðhkzn£s†us}m{]\)W (P*.102010.3(4 Y!s†hšm{Yrn—m SOU1VW (7XY + S . ´ Å

(125) Ç )– & Ù •  ”  ™ Ü;¨]Ul#qm{]Ím†Y[]ͲÐhAgfgih—Ÿ0efdrj£svm†]> rs>´ ‹A¤ Jo ”  – &  –” öiÙ  ™ á«hkdrs†ei‡[]zHm†Yr]Dwrnks†eps EOW N.,n.202010Y.1020102.1W 02010.,n.2NP.3,/.102020 Y.2010202.HW 010202.3,/.1NHYQ ²ÐhAz  * F  IKILI  4 F  ¤Oá«hkd›s}m{z†qrl#mDm†Yr].\œn—m{z†ef¨     F 7 ,  nodr‡£m{Y[]dW ›]>zv²ÐhAz†\ nš`Ínkqrs}® s†epnodœ]giei\:eidrnom†eihkdϟ0efm†YChkd[giu:s†ei\: rgfef¶›lnom†eihkdϟ0efm†YW [z†]>À5efhAqrsDz{h—Ÿs¤*¥§]ƒhkwm(noeidWn\œnom†z{e¯¨     F 4 ,  ¤ ^[¤ ! Ù  “>”• 

(126) ˜o” ÞÙ  ™ ~5qr [ ›hIsv]  * F C ILIKI  4 F Cžnodr‡   C F4   lhk\£ [qm{]>‡Î¤0á«hkdrsvm†z{qrlÊm nÃwrnks†eis²Ðhkz  * F C ? * IKILI  4 F C ? *š²Ðz{hk\  * F C ILIKI  4 F C s†hTm{Yrn—m£nodÁ]gi]\£]>dAm W 020102. #".G _ .,n.202010YÎs{n—m{eisv¶r]>‡ G _ eisÎdrhomz{]>‡q›l#eiw[gf];w5u  C F _ ,  *  nodr‡ƒm{Y[]D\œn—m{z†ef¨   C ? *  F 4  ²Ðz{hk\  C  ,*  F 7  ¤ #r¤ – *“U“  – ¼Õ &    –” ÞÙ  ™ y&]z†²Ðhkz{\ n`Ínkqrs{svepnod£]giei\:eidrnom†eihkdœhkdWz†h—Ÿs&Ÿ0efm†YÏhAd[giu:s†ef\:® rgfef¶›lnom†eihkdŸ0e¯m{Y [z†]>À5efhAqrs!z†h—Ÿs>¤ ›¤

(127) CÕ Q Õ –”k™ z†]> ›]Un—m!m†Yr]s}m{] T^š²Ðhkz³  ³ 0N qrdAm{efgYrnLÀ5efd[j£nœ`cz†¢Aw[d[]>z0wrnks†eis>¤ ødC²Þnkl#m>¿[Ÿ­]͇h£d[hom0d[]>]>‡Cm†h£ªk]>] nogigHm†Y[] wrnAsveps­ho²  * F C ILIKI  4 F CËnks!Ÿ­]Ílhkdrsvm†z{qrl#m   C *  F 4  ²Ðz{hk\  C F 4 ,  w[qmm{Y[]œ²Ðhkz{\ hk²«m{Y[]Ï]>gf]>\:]>dIm{s W$#@.201020.%#@.3G _ .3,/.201020Y Ÿ0Y[eil(Y¦epsl(Yrnkz{nAlÊm†]>z†eiÌ]U?‡Ãw5u WWXG _ Y.3( _ Y#¿r‡]drhom†]cm{Y[]sveijkd›n—m†qrz†]Ího²*m†Y[] z{h—ŸËhk²   C ? *  F 4  ¤ X!Y[]͇]>jkz{]]ƒ³"ho²Îm{Y[] sveijkdrnom†q[z{]>sOz†]Unkl(Y[]U‡:m†h£l#hA\: rqm†]Ínš`cz{¢kw[dr]z­wrnks†]>s«eisOm†Yr]Ís{no\£].m†YrnkdWeid s†]>l#m†eihkdT^¤ ^+¤ *­qmeidCm{Y[] \œn—m{z†ef¨   C F4   ¿[nkgfgt 3hkgiu5d[hk\£epnogps!lnodYrnLÀA]Ín:gih—Ÿ«]>z0‡]jAz†]>].m{YrnodT³T¤ ød£m{Y[]¶r]>gi‡:· ¸ ¿A༤ *!noz(‡]#mU¿AŒ›¤ ფI¾rnkq[jkZ>z†]0nod›‡ *ƒ¤5~nogiÀ5uWÈi‹#É3YrnLÀk]!eidAm{z†h‡q›l#]>‡œnÍdr]Ÿ l#z{e¯m{]z{efhAd m{hÏnLÀkhAei‡Wz†]>ginom†eihkdrs (7 (7 + (7;‡]U‡qrl#]U‡C²Ðz†hA\,m†Yr]¾[z{¢kw3]d[eiqrs0no r [gfeplnom†eihkdt¤ ødsvm†]> Ã^/¿ G _ ‡h5]Us0d[hom Y›nLÀk]ƒm†hœw3] z†]U‡qrl#eiw[gi]ÍwIu  C F _ ,  *  ¤  . . . . . . . . . . . .

(128) /

(129). 1 7:9.  F 7 AE < . . .  47 7 > 7:4. ødšm†Yr]0z†]> ›hAzvm!Èf‹É?¿km†Y[]0nkqm†Y[hAz{s

(130) eidIm†z{h5‡[qrl#]U‡m{Y[]0d[hom{efhAdšhk²3s†]\£ef®?z{]jAq[ginkz

(131) s†]>xIq[]>drl#]Us

(132) ²Ðhkz;h—ÀA]z(‡]#¶rdr]>‡ s†us}m{]\œs>¤

(133) ¥±]ÍYrnLÀk]A¿5efdTs†]>lÊm{efhAdµ‹A¤f‹A¿[‡eisvm†eid[jAq[eis†Y[]U‡Ïm}Ÿ­hšei\£ ›hAzvm(nodImlnAsv]UsO²ÐhAz­¶rd[efm†]Ͷr]>gi‡[s>¿5·*¸Ínod›‡ ·&¹L¤ ødTm†Y[]š¶r]>gi‡Ã·*¸o¿HŸ­]YrnL= ÀA]nWlz†efm†]>z†eihkdµ‡[]>‡qrl]>‡²Ðz{hk\Ñm{Y[]:¾rz†¢Aw›]>d[eiqrsƒnk [ [gieil>n—m{efhAdt¤°²«Ÿ«]:noz{] eidIm†]>z†]Us}m{]>‡±w5uµnTsvusvm†]>\ ( 4 hkdÁn¶r]gp‡§·

(134) ¹L¿

(135) Ÿ0e¯m{Y¼º»a½;¿*eö¤ ]k¤ºeis ÀA]z{uÃY[eijkYÁl#hA\£ rnoz{]>‡µm†hT½;¤ X!Yr]dÃm{Y[]šm†z{efÀ5epnog&z†]>ginom†eihkdÃeps{svq[]U‡T²Ðz{hk\Ñm†Yr]£¾rz†¢Aw›]>d[eiqrsÍno [ [giepln—m{efhAdß0eigfg&d[hkmcw3]£z†]Unkl(Y[]U‡T‡q[z{efd[j lhk\£ [qm(n—m{efhAdnkdr‡Cnkgfg*l#hk\£ [q[m{n—m{efhAd‡[hkd[]Íepssvei\£efgpnoz­m{hÏl#hk\£ [q[m{n—m{efhAdChAd c¤ Õ ” ÞÙ  .

(136). . äÐí

(137) étäëê.

(138) ‹A‹. 

(139)     "!. TÙ  Ù  Õ

(140) Õ5Ù 

(141) “­“ Õ  Ð× • Õ  &ޖ•“ Õ  Õ  ˜ Õ ™   (*<.201020.(4Fc 2 ,Kn-23c)(

(142) Ó /! 3O3 @ 5/IK>! ' 8   ( ›Ó !6!   )(9(7M, SU1V WÐÓ Y +SOU1VW (7XY D ,

(143) > e+ (P*<.1020201.3(4# J ' n§‡[]jkz{]]©ho²œz†]>jkq[gpnoz{efm}u M(" M / ! !   P  S 2 nRE 7WX( Y I ( 8 9.SOU2V WX( Y + SnQ M n@ 2 IK  / 2 )( !6>! ' M(    SD! ¹F = ,RP2>  ³ G@WNaYY  ( * .201020.( 4  £Y[hA\:hAjk]>d[]hAqrs.s†]\£e;z{]jkqrginkzƒs†]>xIq[]d›l#]:hkd÷

(144) ¸[ ( ( TK 8 EONP.201020.†Ó Q ,  (RVP7 (7 + , % G¹ F =7 X(P*.2010202.(7 * eSOU2V WVP7X(7 Y%^ ³G"WN YM /2VP7 + ,   ¹ F =i (P*H.1020201.3(7 *.3(7 J ( * .201020.( 4  ÏY[hk\£hAjk]dr]hkq›s sv]>\:eOz†]>jkq[gpnoz s†]>xIq[]d›l#]£hkd  (W( KB8 EONP.201020.†Ó Q ,  (RV 7 ( 7 + , %CG¹ F =  X( * .2010202.( 7 * eSOU2V WV 7 ( 7 Y%^ ³ G WN YM /2V 7 + ,  C¹ F =  ( * .1020201.3( 7 * .3( 7 J ‘ 

(145) Õ “ Õ  Ð× • Õ  &ޖ[•±“ Õ   Õ  ˜ Õ ™  2 (P*H.1020201.3(4 3 L ,Kn-2 )(:Ó 5nIK!  ' , >

(146).  9 + . ( * .102010.3( 4 J   ( 7   / /! 32> @ 5/  )(B^ XO P P M(c( 7 (*<.201020.(4- .s†]\£ez{]jkqrginkz&s†]>xIq[]>drl#] (a( *  .202010.3( 4    /! 32> @ 2!  H   "^ 2 ,Kn- 23  /‡]jAz†]>]šhk²«z{]jAq[ginkz†efm}u )(W   /    )(  6"^  K )(B X( *  .201020.( 4  , P2> . ³ G ¥ efm†Yœm{Y[eps«s†]>xIq[]>drl#]0hk²t ›hAgfu5d[hA\:epnogps>¿om†Yr]\œn—m†z{ef¨:jA]d[]>z{nom†]>‡:w5u£Å Ç nogijkhkz{efm†Y[\ YrnksDn ²Ðq[gfg3z(nod[ª ²ÐhAz!m†Y[]‡[]jkz{]T] SB^¡³   I¤;e?¤ ]k¤i¿[m†Yr] ef\œnojA]Ího²m{Y[]wrnAsveps!ho²  * F  ILIKI  4 F ÍjA]d[]>z{nom†]>‡Ww5uCÅ Ç eis n:wrnAsveps!ho² NkÓ WX(  F 4  Yʤ X!Y[eps0\£]>nkdrs­m†Y›n—m>¿5²ÐhAzsv]>\£e¯®°z†]>jkq[gpnoz!s†]>xIq[]d›l#]>s>¿5m†Yr] dIqr\w3]z0ho²

(147) z†h—Ÿs 4 F = W S@Y­ho²

(148) m†Y[] \œnom†z{e¯¨ eidm†Y[]Y[hA\:hAjk]>d[]hAqrsl>nks†]k¿;²ÐhAz S^ѳ G ¿Oeps£ªIdrh—Ÿ0dt¿Onod›i ‡¼eps£jkeiÀki ]dw5u¼nµz{i ]>lq[z†z{]d›l#]ϲÐhAz†\šq[gpn. 4 F = W S@Y+

(149) 4A * F =W S@Y70 EUÓ  \£hkdrhk\£einkgOhk²0‡[]jkz{]] S S 4 Q 4 F = WXS S 4 Y Ÿ0efm†Y¼eid[efm†epnog lhkdr‡[e¯m{efhAdr s 4 F = WXSOYa+ ,še¯²&Ó Z ,: hA

(150) z S"^RÓ K°½ W SOU2V WX(6MY IMg Z©LÓ QA¤;X!Y[]>dm†Y[]Íd5q[\w3]z0hk²*z{h—ŸsOhk² n:\œn—m{z†ef¨Ï²ÐhAz!m†Y[]n g£dr]Íl>nks†]Íeis  * 4 F = WXS fYʤ X!Y[]c‡]jAz†]>]³  cl#hAz†z{]>s† ›hAdr‡[s

(151) m{hm†Yr].‡]jAz†]>9] SŸ0Yr]dœŸ­]Ÿ0efgigrY›nLÀk]0\£hkz{]0z†h—Ÿs;m†YrnkdÏl#hkgiq[\£drs ²ÐhAzm{Y[]WY[hA\£hkjk]>d[]hAqrs rnkzvm:ho²0gpnoz{jk]>svmš‡]>jkz{]]A¤ °m:eps m{Y[]W\£eid[ef\œnkg­‡]>jkz{]]Ws†hTm{Yri n—m 4 F = WXSOY T EU Ó 0\£hkd[hA\£einkgÎho²

(152) ‡[]jkz{]T] SnQ0 °²rŸ­]­lhkdrs†ep‡]z*m†Y[]!s†]z{ef]Us ( WX Ya+  . W 4 F = W S@Y EUÓ 

(153) \:hAd[ho® \£epnog

(154) ho²O‡]>jkz{]] S/QY X  ¿Hm†Y[]£‡]jAz†]>]³   :epsƒjkeiÀk]Ÿ0Yr]dT* m{Y[d]: lh5] gÏl#ei]dImƒhk²Dm†Yr*eisc dsv]>' z† ei]>sƒeps.d[]>jAnom†eiÀk]k¤ m{Y[]W]¨ [z†]Us†s†eihkdÁho² (¼²ÐhAz:xIqrnA‡z(n—m†eplœ]UxAq›n—m†eihkd›sepsW´ * ? ? d '  ²ÐhAz· ¸ nod›‡ *G d   ²Ðhkzš· ¹ ¿;Ÿ0efm†Y º » ½;¤ àThAz†]>h—Àk]>z>¿[eidTm{Y[]šnkzvm{eilgf]ÏÈi‹Êɰ¿3m†Y[]:noqm{Y[hkz(sYrnLÀA] \œnk‡]:nÏl#hAd—|}]>l#m†q[z{]Àk]>z†ef¶r]U‡hkdÃ\œnod5ul#hA\š® rqm†]>z0]#¨ ›]>z†ei\£]dIm{s>´ ! Ù UÕ ˜o” • R Õ  ^2>2 2c26,Kn22M( 5/IK>! ' 2!  H  6"^ J X!Y[]χ[]jkz{]]œ³ GÏepsÍm†Y[]œ\£eid[ei\£nkgO‡]>jkz{]]£z†]Unkl(Y[]U‡T²ÐhAznÃ`cz†¢Aw[d[]zÍwrnAsveps l#hA\£ [qm{nom†eihkdt¤C¾[hkz ]¨[no\£ [gi]k¿o²ÐhAz;m†Yr] *­qrl(Y5w›]>z†jA]zDnogijkhAz†efm†Yr\¿Al#hkd›svep‡]z«nÍ\:i hAd[hk\£epnog[Ó OŸ0efm†Yχ]>jkz{]]³ G i N0Ÿ0Y[epl(Y ‡[hI]UsÍd[homnk [ ›]UnozÍeid E W ( Y I ( 8+9.SOU2V WX( Y+ ³    NQI¤:X!Y[]>dµ²ÐhAz  _ Ó  nod›‡  7 Ó  ¿Îm†Y[]>z†] é*éÑülnmom .

(155) ‹L^. P2  . epscV _ nkdr‡[VP7Oefdµm†Y[]£`cz†¢Aw[d[]zƒwrnks†eps.l#hA\£ [qm†]U‡Ãs†hÏm†Y›n—m 7WV _ Yƒnodr‡ 7WVP7 Yƒ‡eiÀ5ei‡]šz†]Usv 3]>l#m†eiÀk]>gfu  _  Ó nodr‡ 67ÞÓ¤~5hm†Y[]6`O®? 3hkgiu5d[hk\£epnog;ho²TWVP7 . V _ YcŸ0eigfgOw›]Wsvm†q›‡ef]U‡¦nodr‡±Ÿ­]:Y›nLÀk]£Ó‡[efÀ5ep‡]>s #ÊÓ W WV _ Y. 7WVP7XY Yʤ­~5h:m†Y[]‡]>jkz{]]cho²;l#hA\: rqm{nom†eihkdho²m{Y[] `D®° ›hAgfu5d[hA\£einkgÎeisnom0gf]Unksvm0³G5¤  ) $#%

(156) ('

(157) ) )/. 7. A< 4.     >   . E7. . X!YreisÍs†q[wrs†]>lÊm{efhAd§z{]#²Ð]>z{s.m†hm{Y[]£ rno 3]z£È Ё¿ bLɰ¤:‚]#m³ w›]:m†Yr]: ›noz(no\£]#m{]zcho²«c‚¡nogijkhkz{efm†Y[\¤X!Y[] rz†hAw[gf]>\ eis«m†hš¶rdr‡n—m!gi]>nksvm«hAd[]ÍsvhAgfqm{efhAd +FW *<.1020202.

(158) = Y 8C· =¹ ho²*n:s†u5svm†]>\ ( =4 ¤&‚]#m0w3] ©m†Y[] ep‡]UnogÎjk]>d[]z(n—m{]>‡WwIu E<(P*<.2020102.(4TQI¤ Õ  )– & Ù •  ”  Ü;¨]Ul#qm{]Ím†Y[]ͲÐhAgfgih—Ÿ0efdrj£svm†]> rs>´ .   ‹A¤ % &ޔ  Q"& Ö ™ `c]d[]>z{nom†] nogigHm†Yr] [z†h‡q›lÊm{Ts W _M *  7 Y0'( 7 8BƟ0e¯m{<Y g Z¡³ i SOU1VW ( 7 Y#¤ ^[¤ a

(159) Õ –•  kÕ ™ á«hkdrs†ei‡[]z.]Unkl(Y\£hkd[hA\£einkgeidTm†Y[] 67Dho²D‡]>jkz{]6] Z˳ nksnWd[]Ÿ¬À—noz{einkw[gi] nkdr‡C ›]>zv²ÐhAz†\ `Ínkqrs{svepnod]gief\£eidrn—m{efhAdChAdm†Y[] ]UxAq›n—m†eihkd›s«hAwm{nkefdr]>‡efd±‹k¤ X!Yr]chAz{‡[]z{efd[jšhkdCm†Y[]Í\£hkdrhk\£einkgis­\šqrs}mw3] svq›l(YWm{Yrn—mnogigHm†]>z†\œs!l#hAdIm{noeid[eid[j:hkd[]ÍÀ—noz{e¯® nkw[gi]£Ýös†nLu  *ß!noz{]ƒ]>gfei\£efd›n—m†]U‡ginAs}mU¤ #r¤ Ù &  Õ ™ €ƒs†s†q[\£]Om{Yrn—m;svm†] £^u5ei]gp‡[s

(160) n—m&gf]Unksvm

Références

Documents relatifs

Dans le cadre du LabEx RESSOURCES21, les premiers groupes de métaux sur lesquels un accent a été mis sont les suivants : les métaux de la filière photovoltaïque

Dans le cas a), l’´el´ement passif stocke l’´energie cr´e´ee par le moteur durant la phase d’actionnement et la restitue pendant la phase de rappel. C’est un m´ecanisme qui

Les résultats de l’étude de niveau pour un processus respectant un modèle AR(2) avec l’innovation d’un modèle GARCH(1,1) sont présentés dans les tableaux 4.3 et 4.4..

En réalité, son auto- rité repose sur un contrôle communautaire et une hiérarchie politique : dans les prisons et les camps, les comités de détention sont mis en place par

À cet effet, un nombre considérable de recherches démontre cliniquement que les enfants de parents souffrant de problème de santé mentale sont plus à risque d’un retard dans leur

usual route to school and provide us with some details about their travel routine (e.g., schedule, mode of transportation, people accompanying them, etc.); 3) recent interventions

L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non, émanant des

In this way, we derive two simple models for large strain viscoelasticity: the first one referred to as a Convolution Integral Model (CIM) is a solid extension of the K-BKZ model,