Stålmarck's Algorithm in Coq: A Three-Level Approach
24
0
0
Texte intégral
(2) INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE. Stålmarck’s Algorithm in Coq: A Three-Level Approach Laurent Théry. N° 4353 January 2002. ISSN 0249-6399. ISRN INRIA/RR--4353--FR+ENG. THÈME 2. apport de recherche.
(3)
(4)
(5)
(6)
(7) !"$#% &'( )*),+.-/)10
(8) )2354 4(
(9)
(10) 6 27 8:9 ;=<?>A@CB$DEF; G H1IKJ LM
(11) NOQPSR TKUVMXWZY\[FUZ]UVM W M^_]`aWb]dc.WfehgiLj:Y\WZUbkFc.M l6mnYaoM^*pqMLrLrM s2`atKt:Y\mu^2vwMXmnM ]IKM mn]IKMxTzy {F|?}a|~OF`aTic.`\mugCN\\FNONat.`\[\M=e. K\\ TKM6Y\i^uIKM,LY?e^Md]dUZMT?^qLrMd^nIKYwv^uY]IKM ]UK`*j:YiY\WZM `aTXt.muYFtY?ehUV^uUZY\TUbeq`^n`\cw^uYFWVYF[\gUZe ( ^naWZL$`am]z e `aWZ[\YFmuUV^uIKLH1IKUbet`at:MmmuM tYFmh^eqYFT~euY\LrMMdwtM muUZLrMT?^ne UZT~UZT?^uM [\m`^uUZTK[_^uIKUbe`aWZ[\Y\mnUV^uIKL UZT.euUZvKM^nIKM~,Ywk$^nIKMYFmuM LtKmnY\MmUZT`ren`M 1`g\ ¡¢?£z¤n¥¦ § \ ^n\WVL$`am]z e1`\WV[FY\mnU^nIKL¨?j:YiY\WZM `\TCYFmuL~cKWZ`\M\¨wen`^uUbeh©`ajKUZWZU^gF¨,Yik. Unité de recherche INRIA Sophia Antipolis 2004, route des Lucioles, BP 93, 06902 Sophia Antipolis Cedex (France) Téléphone : +33 4 92 38 77 77 — Télécopie : +33 4 92 38 77 65.
(12) - h d
(13) ) )
(14) C "$#% C)
(15) 4 4( $ 6C) d (d0
(16) )* .
(17) T.M2vwM e6LrR^uIKYwvwM=eWVM=e6tKWZc.e6Md] `\]dM=e tYFcKm \R muUV©.M meuUKcKT.M,YFmuL~cKWZM*jYiY\WZRM TKTKM1M eh^ cKTKM ^`acw^nY\WZY\[FUVM2M=e^1W `\WV[FY\mnU^nIKLrM_vwM ^n\WVL$`am]zi,MSmn`\tKt:Y\mu^,tKmnY\t:YFeuM2Md^1R`\WVcKMvwU:R muM T?^uM e,LrRd^nIKYwvwM e vf UZT?^uR[Fmn`a^uUZY\T vwM
(18) ]dM^*`\WV[FY\mnU^nIKLrM~W UVT?^uR muUZMc.m2vwcehgweh^uJLrMXvwMXtKmnMc.\M
(19) ,Yik: "¦ = ¤ `aWZ[\YFmuUV^uI.LMvwM ^aWZL$`am]:¨?YFmuL~cKWVMj:YiY\WZRMT.TKM\¨Ken`^nUZeh©`aj.UVWZU^nR\¨,Ywk.
(20)
(21)
(22) "!#%$ &. |. ' (*),+.-0/213).45-6(. l muYiUZTK[(t.muYFtM mh^nUVM=e_YFmuL$`\WVWZgY\T L$`\]IKUZTKMUZeXeh^uUZWVW `(^nUVLrM7 ]dYFT.eucKLrUVTK[`\]d^uUZiU^gFfHqYUZT.]dmnM `FehM~^uIKM t.muYwvwc.]d^uUZiU^gF¨ALYFmuM`\cw^uYFL$`^uUZY\T/euIKY\cKWbv jMC`FvKvwM=vAqH1IKM muM$`amnM$vwU:M muM TF^
(23) 1`gwe^uYt:MmuY\mnL ^uI.UZe `FvKvwUV^uUZY\Tf 8 T^nIKUbe t.`\tM m, M_t.muM=ehM TF^1ehYFLrM_YafYFcKmMdwtM muUZLrMT?^ne,UZTUVT?^nM[\m`^nUVT.[`
(24) tKmnYiYaftKmnYw]dM=vwcKmnM j`\euM v Y\T ^aWZLr`\mn]z eX`aWZ[\YFmuUV^uIK: L 9<;=
(25) | = UZT.euUZvwM^uIKM ,Ywk tKmuYFMm>9 ?
(26) = ^aWZLr`\mn]z eX`aWZ[\YFmuUV^uIKL UZe
(27) ` ^`acw^nY\WZY\[Fg ]IKM=]\Mm=,PSUZ\M T ` j:Y?YFWVM=`aT tKmnY\t:YFeuUV^uUZY\T ^uI.`a^ ]Y\T?^n`\UVT.eC`amnUZ`\jKWVM=e¨ U^]IKM ]weUVX^uI.UZe t.muYFtY?ehUV^uUZY\TUbe^umncKMY\m*`aWZWztY?eueuUZjKWVMS`aWZcKM eY\UV^ne1`amnUZ`\jKWZM e 8 T?^uM [\m`^nUVTK[ehc]I(`aT `aWZ[\YFmuUV^uIKLUZT(` t.muYFMmLr`\\M=e1U^2t:YFenehUZjKWZMS^uY$`acw^nY\L$`^nMtKmuYiY\ e1Ya euY\LrMcKTKUZ\M mnen`aWZWZgkFc`aT?^uUV©.M v(YFmuL~cKWZ`\M\ H1IKMSLrYFeh^1vKUVmnM ]d^ 1`g^uYtM mhYFmuL ^uI.UZe1UZT?^uM[Fmn`a^uUZY\T$Ube,^uYrehUZLrtKWVg`FvKA v @CB @ D euY\LrMSUVLrtKWZM 7 LrM TF^`^nUVYFTXYaw^uI.M,`aWZ[\YFmuUV^uI.L ^uY_^uIKM,\M muTKM WaYaw^nIKM t.muYFMm= c.]I
(28) `\T
(29) Mdi^uM T.euUVYFT
(30) ]`aTXj:M ^nmuYFcKjKWZM euY\LrM\ 8 6^nIKMUVLrtKWZMLrMT?^`^uUZY\T UZeUVT]dY\mnmnM ] ^=¨. M
(31) L$`gUVT?^umnYwvwc.]MX^uIKM Y\mnML$e_^uI.`a^S`amnM
(32) TKY\^`aWZUbvA 8 T^ucKmnTf¨ ^nIKM euM^uIKM Y\mnML$eX]`\T j:M$c.euM v ^uYtKmnY\M`aTig tKmnY\t:YFeuUV^uUZY\T euUZT.]dFM EHGJI.KMLCGONQPRGTSUK5UZeX`\WV 1`gwe `r`\WVUbv(^uIKM Y\mnMLKH1IKM
(33) eh^n`aTvK`amv`aT.eu ,M m^uYr^uI.UZe_tKmuYFjKWZMLUbe1^uY$cehM @ V0@ WX
(34) 9 Y
(35) =`\T.v tKmnY\MS^uIKM ]Y\mnmuM=] ^nTKM ene_Y\,^nIKM$UZLt.WVM LM T?^n`^nUVYFT/UVT.euUbvwM^uIKM$tKmnY\M mtKmuUZY\mUV^neXUZT?^uM [\m`^uUZY\Tqzl muYiUZTK[C^nIKM]dYFZm 7 mnM ]d^uTKM=eue Y\z`SmnM `\euY\T`ajKWZM UZLrtKWVM LrMT?^n`a^uUZY\TrYa ^n\WVL$`am]z e`\WV[FY\mnU^nIKLxUZet:YFeneuUVjKWZM*`aT.vI.`Fe`aWZmuM=`\vwg j:MM TvwY\TKMUZT`~t.muM ?UZY\ce, Y\mn[ 9 \
(36) = 8 T ehgweh^uML$e WVUZ\MX,Yik:¨i`aTC`\W^nMmnT.`^nUVFM2 1`g~Ube ^nYMit.muM=eue ^uIKM]dYFLt.cw^n`a^uUZY\TvwUZmuM=] ^nWVgrUZT.ehUbvwM^uIKM t.muYFMm= 8 T^nI.`^1]`\euM2^nIKMStKmuYFjKWZML YaA©.TvwUVT.[`tKmuYiY\zUbe,^um`aT.euWb`^uM=vrUVT?^nY~`aTCM k?cKUZ`\WVM T?^1eugiTF^`\]d^uUb] t.muYFjKWVM L] 8 ^6Ubef^nIKMTtY?eueuUZjKWVM,^uYc.euM]Y\LrtKcw^`^uUZY\T^uYehYFWVFM ^nIKMeugiT?^n`\]d^uUb] tKmnY\j.WVM L H1IKUbe UZe^nIKMeuY 7 ] `aWZWVM=v W^6
(37) _` @ba
(38) @ c dedf C] 9 {.¨n
(39) | =
(40) gKY\WZWZY *UVTK[_^uIKUbe WVUZTKMF¨ ,M[\M^vwYFcKjKWZM,j:MT.Md©K^= gUZme^=¨^uIKMMdi^uM T.euUVYFT Ube1vwY\T.M f @ D euYU^*Ubeen`Mjig]dYFT.eh^umnc.] ^nUVYFTf M ]Y\T.vA¨iUVq^nIKMXehgweh^uMLmnM ]Y\mvKe`tKmnYiYaqYFjwoM ]d^ ¨ *I`^ Y\cKWbvjMmuM=]dYFmnvwM=vUVTr^nI.`^,] `\euM2Ube `XeuUVTK[FWVM2cKT.] ^nUVYFT]`\WVW FH1IKUbe LrM=`aT.e ^uI.`a^ ^uIKMSehiU hM_Yaz^uIKM t.muYiYaAYFjwoM ]d^,Ube UZT.vwMt:MTvwMT?^1YaA^uI.M`\]d^uc.`\W`\LYFcKT?^,Y\A]Y\LrtKcw^`^nUVYFT$^uI.`a^,Ube T.MM vKM vr^nY
(41) M eh^n`\jKWVUbeuI ^nIKMXtKmnY\t:YFeuU^nUVYFTf g UZT.`aWZWVg`$Wb`\eh^_t:YFenehUZjKUZWVUV^gCUbe*^nYtM mhYFmuL5`$LrUV j:Md^ MM TMdi^uM muT.`\Wq`aTvUVT?^uM muT`aWfUZT?^uM[Fmn`a^uUZY\Tf H1I.M,UbvwM `Ubeq^nYXehM t.`am`^nM6^uIKM*euM `\mn]IXYFm6`_tKmnYiYa¨ ^uI.`a^6UZe c.euc.`aWZWZg
(42) ]dtK,c 7 UZTF^nMT.euUZ\M\¨=mnY\L']IKM=]iUVTK[_^uIKM t.muYiYa?H1IKMeuM `\mn]I$UbevwY\TKMMdi^uM muT`aWZWVgtKmnYivKc.]dUZTK[`
(43) ^um`\]dMFFH1IKUbe ^um`\]dM_UZe ^uIKM T(]IKM=]\M=vrUVT?^uM muT`aWZWVg jig$^nIKMXtKmnY\M m 8 T/^nIKUZet.`at:Mm ,Mt.muM=ehM TF^X^nIKM euM$^nIKmuM MvwUbe^nUVT.]d^~`at.tKmuY?`\]IKM=eX`aT.v/euIKY IKY t.mn`F] ^uUb]`\W6^uI.Mg `\muM1YFm ^nIKM_UZT?^uM [\m`^uUZY\TrY\ ^naWZL$`am]z e `\WV[FY\mnU^nIKLFH1IKMt.`at:Mm,UZe,e^nmuc] ^uc.muM=v`\e Y\WZWVY 2e j M2©.me^ [FUVFM
(44) `aTY\M muiUZM Y\^uIKM`\WV[FY\mnU^nIKL.H1IKM T ,MXtKmnM euMT?^_`$]Mmu^uUV©.M vUZLrtKWVM LrMT?^n`a^uUZY\T ^uI.`a^]`\TjM cehM=v `\e~` j.`FehMCY\m
(45) ^nIKM(^uIKmnMM `atKtKmnYF`F]IKM e k g UZT.`aWZWVg/ M(]Y\Lrt.`amnM$^nIKM(vwU zMmnMT?^`\tKtKmnYF`\]I.M eXYFT eh^n`\T.vK`\mnvCMdK`aLrtKWZM e*`\T.vvwmn` ehYFLMX]Y\T.]WVc.euUZY\T.e l. monqpsrut5v#-#+f4`).n2w. T ^uIKUbeehM=] ^nUVYFT M~[FUVFM~` kFc.UZ]Y\M muiUZM Ya ^n\WVL$`am]z eS`aWZ[\YFmuUV^uI.L x LYFmuM]dYFLt.WVM^uMUVT?^umnY7 Kv c.] ^nUVYFT ]`\T j:MYFcKT.v UZTy9i; |= j M]Y\T.euUZvKMmSjYiY\WZM `\TY\mnLc.WZ`\M\x^uY\LrUb]
(46) j:YiY\WZM `aT Y\mnLcKWb`aM`amnM ]Y\Lrt:YFeuM v Ya1^uI.M(]dYFT.eh^n`aT?^e{z}| ^umncKM~X`aT.vy}| `aWbehM~
(47) `aTv3`ehM^Ya2`amnUb`ajKWZM e> Z
(48) j MC`aWbeuY I`\Mr^uI.McKT.`\mug ]dY\Te^nmuc.]d^uYFm{P|TKM [F`^nUVYFTf~`aTv ^uIKMj.UVT.`\mug ]dYFT.e^nmuc] ^uYFmne| ]dY\TaocKT.] ^nUVYFTf~ ¨# 8. *:,%].
(49) {. b D. | vwUbeocKT] ^uUZY\ T ~ ¨ U|UZLrtKWVUb]`a^uUZY\fT ~d ¨ |M=kFc.UV`aWZMT]d%M ~d, x j:YiY\WZM `aTCY\mnLcKWb`
(50) Ube1`
(51) MWZW 7 Y\mnLrM v$MwtKmuM=5e 7 ue UZY\T]dY\Lrt:YFeuM v(Ya6]dYFT.e^`aT?^ne ¨w`amnUZ`\jKWZM e1`aT.v]Y\T.eh^umnc.] ^nY\me,g.Y\m*MdK`\Lt.WVMF¨i^uIKMYFWVWZY *UVT.[~YFmuL~cKWb` Ube*`jYiYFWVM=`aT MdwtKmnM enehUZY\T ]dY\T?^`aUZTKUVT.[~YFcKm*`amnUZ`\jKWZM e
(52) ¨,F¨.X`\T.v Z
(53) . X . Z. ZX
(54) o . o . ^naWZL$`am]z e,`aWZ[\Y\mnUV^uIKL Ube,`^n`\cw^uYFWVYF[\gr]IKM ]FMm=FH1IKUbeLM=`aT.e,^nI.`^1U^*]IKM=]ie,UV`XYFmuL~cKWZ`UZe`aWZUbv |^umncKM%~ Y\m*`\T?g$`FeueuUV[FTKLrMT?^,Y\qUV^ne`amnUZ`\jKWVM=eiH1IKMStKmnMiUVYFc.e,MdK`aLrtKWZMUbe`
(55) ^`acw^nY\WZY\[\gFx_TCMw`\LrtKWVM Y\`(Y\mnLc.WZ`C^uI.`a^
(56) UZeT.Ya^
(57) `(^n`acK^uY\WZY\[FgUZe
(58) ¨feuUZT.]dM>
(59) z`\T.vQ UVTi`aWZUZv.`^uM=eS^uIKM YFmuL~cKWb`K H1IKM `aWZ[\YFmuUV^uIKL vwYiM eTKYa^ Y\mn vKUVmnM ]d^uWZg YFT/^uIKMCY\mnLcKWb`jKcw^Y\T ` vKMmnUVFM v Y\mn L `WZUZeh^~Y\ W df @ iHYr]dY\Te^nmuc.]d^ ^nIKUZe1vK`a^n` 7 eh^umnc.] ^ncKmnM_ M2©.me^1c.euM e @`amnUZ`\jKWVM2^uYr]`atK^ucKmnMT.M[F`a^uUZY\Tf¨ieuY P_UZe
(60) muM tKmuM=ehM T?^uM v/`F e 0 H1IKMT3 MC`\eneuUV[FT TKM `\muUb`aj.WVM=eS^uY `\WVW6^nIKMCeucK,j 7 MdwtKmnM enehUZY\TeYa1^uIKM YFmuL~cKWbo ` | ehc.,j 7 MwtKmuM=eueuUZY\T.eeh^n`amu^uUZTK[ *UV^uI/TKM[?`^nUVYFT `\muMrI.`\T.vwWZM v jig euUV[FTKM v `amnUZ`\jKWVM=Ce ~d gKYFm
(61) Y\cKm MK`aLrtKWZMS MI.`\ M X
(62) . . . . !. T . . #$. . #". . . H1I.UZe1[FUVFM e1c.e^nIKMY\WZWVY *UZTK[rWZUZeh^*Ya,X^nmuUZtKWZMd^e-
(63) &
(64) /.. 3
(65) 25.. 0 .. 8 .. 6 .. ; .. : .. . (+(. 01 3
(66) 2 76 8 : ;
(67) F 1
(68) A . . X
(69) A . . &%. . (*). . X o . #'. . . 34e +9, =<. *>c +?, =@. CB . H1I.MS`\WVcKMXY\q^nIKMY\mnLcKWb`UZe^nIKMX`aWZcKMXYaR
(70) #
(71) a H1IKMS`aWZ[\YFmuUV^uIKL `\] ]dcKL~cKWb`^uM=e UZTwY\mnL$`^nUVYFTC`aj:Y\cw^,^uIKMmuM=eht:M ]d^uUZ\M`\WVc.M e Y\A^uIKMvwU:M muM T?^,`amnU 7 `\jKWZM e g.Y\mSM `F]I iUVTv Y\ ^umnUVt.WVM^ne ¨z^uIKM muMUZe` ehM^XYa mncKWZM e^uI.`a^
(72) vwM en]dmnUVj:M eIKY 'T.M "UZTwYFmuL$`^nUVYFT ] `aTj:M
(73) [F`\UVTKM=vAc g.Y\m2Mw`\LrtKWVMF¨K[\UZ\M T ^uIKMX^nmuUZtKWZMd2^ . EDF 7Gi¨.`$©.mneh^2mncKWVM
(74) en`gwe^uI.`a^_UV s I.Y\WbvKe¨: MY\jK^n`aUZT^ YCTKM 'M k?c.`a^uUZY\T.2e EDH I07G z~ x2TKY\^uIKM mmucKWZM
(75) YFm_^nIKMreu`\LM^umnUVt.WVM^Sen`gie ^nI.`^rUV2 EDJ z5IKY\WbvKe ¨YFTKM(T.M M=kFc`^uUZY\y T 7GUbe[?`aUZTKM vf H1IKM=ehM mncKWVM=e~] `aT jMehM MT `Fe~` 1`gCY\6tKmuYFt.`a[?`^nUVTK[rUZTwY\mnL$`^nUVYFTff x_tKtM T.vwUV[ xx[\UZ\M=e1^uIKM]dYFLt.WVM^uMeuMd^_Y\ muc.WVM=e1Y\m_^uIKM^umnUVtKWZMd^ . D o G H1IKM2`\WV[FY\mnU^nIKL' Y\mnwejig
(76) mnMdcK^n`^nUVYFTf
(77) 8 ^ `\eneucKLrM e ^uI`^6^uI.M1Y\mnLcKWb`SUZe `\WZeuM*`aT.v^umnUZM e^nYSmnM `F]I `]Y\T?^um`\vKUZ]d^uUZY\Tf¨AU M(`aT3M k?c.`a^uUZY\T ^uI`^UbeXUZLt:YFeneuUVjKWZM$^nY eu`a^uUbeA g K L0*Y\Fm zM ~ T3Y\cKm MK`aLrtKWZM\¨F^uIKMtKmnY\t.`\[F`a^uUZY\T`aWZY\T.M_Ubeeucw]dUZMT?^^uYM eh^n`\jKWVUbeuI^uI`^^uIKMSY\mnLc.WZ`UZe1`^n`acK^uY\WZY\[Fg\ j M N+O NCP.
(78) }.
(79)
(80) "!#%$. eh^n`\mh^* *UV^uI ^uI.M
(81) e^`^uM *IKM muM
(82) &
(83) " `aTv(`\tKtKWZg$^uIKMYFWVWZY *UZTK[rtKmuYFt.`a[?`^nUVYFT
(84) #
(85) .
(86) 2. 76K. 0.
(87) . . F. : z ;K z K z. . z z z z z. #4CI C9 CI C? CI +<,CI BCI +@,CI =>.CI. ^ @ ^ @ ^ @ ^ @ ^ @ ^ @ ^ @ . @. 0 z. @.
(88) z : z. @. z. @.
(89) 32 8K z ; z. . 76K z. @. F z. @. 8 z. @. 1H I.MWb`\eh^XM k?c.`a^uUZY\T UbeX`]dYFTF^nmn`FvwUb] ^uUZY\T ehUZT.]M MriTKY x^uI`^J8 mnY\L^nIKMehM=]dYFT.v WZUVT.M\ x2T `\W^nMmnT.`^nUVFMX `gC^uYCeuMM
(90) ^uIKUbe_t.muYFt.`a[?`^uUZY\T Ube2^nY\M Mt^uI.MmnMtKmnM euMT?^n`a^uUZY\T Ya6^nIKMXY\mnLc.WZ``\T.v ^uY L$`\mu~M `\]I$`\muUb`ajKWZM* *UV^uIUV^ne,`aWZcKM_`aTv$`^ *IKUb]ICeh^uM t$YaA^uI.M2tKmnY\t.`\[F`^nUVYFTrU^ I`\e j:MM TC`\eneuUV[FTKM vA g.Y\m,MdK`aLrtKWZ2 M 6 LrM=`aT.e ^uI.`a^ ^nIKM_`amnUb`ajKWZM 6e 6 I.`Fe j:MM TC`\enehUZ[\T.M v^uI.M_`aWZcKM2^nmuc.M`^ ^uIKMehM=]dYFT.v eh^uM t(Y\^nIKMXtKmnY\t.`\[F`a^uUZY\T Z
(91)
(92) . . . ! . ! . . . $. (. . X
(93) . " . " . X
(94)
(95) o
(96) . . . . . . (+( ). %. . . (. )(. X ! o " . . '. . . Y?e^Ya ^uIKM^uUZLM
(97) ^uIKM
(98) t.muYFt.`a[?`^uUZY\T `aWZY\TKMXUbe2T.Ya^eucw]dUZMT?^*^uYC[\Md^_`C]dY\T?^nmn`FvwUZ]d^uUZY\T`aT.v]Y\, T7 ] WVcvwM\%x ehUZLrtKWZM `g_^uY_]Y\LrtKWZMd^nM tKmnY\t.`\[F`^nUVYFT_UbeA^nY_`aWZWVY /]`FehM eutKWZU^u^uUZTK[.]j IKMT.M\M mftKmnY\t.`\[F`a^uUZY\T I`\eTKYa^1mnM `\]I.M vC`]dYFT?^um`\vwUb] ^nUVYFTf¨\^nIKMmnMX`amnM2^ Y~t:YFeneuUVjKUZWZU^nUVM=e,8 `aWZW^nIKM`amnUZ`\jKWVM=e1`amnM`\eneuUV[FTKM vA¨ ^nIKMY\mnLc.WZ`Ube1TKYa^_`~^n`\cw^uYFWVYF[\gCeuUZT.]dM MSI`\MSY\cKTv `\T `FeueuUZ[\TKLrMT?^1^uI`^2L$`aFM e1UV^* `aWbehMF ^uI,7 M mu *UbeuM2 ,M_tKUZ]rYFTKM2`amnUZ`\jKWZqM T.Ya^,gFMd^,`FeueuUZ[\TKM=v$`aT.v]muM=`^nM*^ ,YjKmn`\T.]IKM=e T^uIKM_©.mneh^,j.mn`\T.]I M`\v.v ^nIKMTKM M k?c.`^nUVYFT z `aT.v/YFT ^uIKMCeuM ]Y\T.v jKm`aT]I ^nIKMM k?c.`a^uUZY\T `\T.v ,M UV^uM mn`a^uM^uIKMXen`aLrMStKmuYw]M ene | tKmnY\t.`\[F`^nUVYFT S]`FehbM 7 eutKWZU^u^uUZTK[ ~ YFT(j:Ya^nI(j.mn`\T.]IKM e iH1IKUZe1LrM^uIKYwv([\UZ\M e ce*`aT MdwM ]cw^uUZY\T(^uI.`a^*WVYiY\we1WZUVFMX`~j.UVT.`\mugr^nmuM MX`\e*vwM tKUZ]d^uM=vCUZT gUZ[\c.mu> M ;\ UZT.]dMS^uI.MmnMSUbe2`©.TKUV^uM TicKL~jM mY\ `amnUZ`\jKWZM e ¨.UV^uMm`^nUVT.[CtKmnY\t.`\[F`a^uUZY\T`aT.v ]`FehMeutKWZU^u^uUZTK[(^uMmnLrUVT`^uM=e 8 ,`\WVWjKm`aT.]I.M e2Y\ ^nIKMXMdwtKWZY\m`^nUVYFTCM T.vKe1 *UV^uI`r]dY\T?^nmn`FvwUZ]d^uUZY\Tf¨wYFcKm1UVT.U^nUZ`\WAY\mnLcKWb`UZe*`~^`acw^nY\WZY\[\gF H1IKM*YFmuUZ[\UZT.`\WFUbvwM `SUZT ^n\WVL$`am]z e`\WV[FY\mnU^nIKLxUZe ^nYLr`\\M1c.euM1YaUZT?^uM mneuM ]d^uUZY\TUVTY\mvwMm ^nY`FY\Ubv ] `\euM1MdwtKWZYFeuUVYFTf\H1IKUbe6Ube vwY\T.M*UVTr^nIKM @ F> { , @^uI.`a^ UZe vwMtKUb] ^nM vrUZM T g UV[FcKmuM_NK j IKM T`atKtKWZgiUVT.[ ^nIKMXmncKWVM MXe^nUVWZWf]dmnM `a^uMS^ ,YjKm`aT.]I.M e*`aTvCt:MmuY\mnL^uI.MSt.muYFt.`a[?`^uUZY\T(jKcw^2UZT.eh^uM `FvCY\jKm`aT]IKUVT.[ `\[F`\UVT ,MLrMmn[\M ^nIKM^ ,Y3j.mn`\T.]IKM ejig ]Y\T.euUbvwMmnUVT.[ `3eh^n`a^uM^uI`^C]dYFT?^n`aUZT.e$`\WVW*^nIKMM k?c.`a^uUZY\T.e ^nI.`^
(99) `\muM~`\WVUbv UVT jY\^uI jKm`aT.]IKM={e | %~dH 8 ,j:Ya^uI jKm`aT.]I.M eS[\UZ\M`(]Y\T?^um`\vwUb] ^nUVYFTf¨:^uIKM mnM eucKWV^ YaA^nIKM_UZT?^uM mneuM ]d^uUZY\TrUZe`
(100) ]Y\T?^um`\vwUb] ^nUVYFTf 8 fYFTKWVgY\T.M_jKm`aT.]IrtKmnYwvwc.]M e `]dY\T?^nmn`FvwUZ]d^uUZY\Tf¨\^uIKM mnM eucKWV^SY\ ^uI.MUZT?^uM mneuM ]d^uUZY\T Ube^uIKMrmnM eucKWV^SY\,Ya^nIKMmSjKm`aT.]Iq 8 T/`aTig]`FehMF¨zU,^uIKMrTKM "e^`^nMUbeSTKYa^ ]Y\T?^um`\vKUZ]d^uY\mng\¨=UV^ ]dY\T?^`aUZT.e`^6WVM=`\eh^^uIKM1UZTKU^nUZ`\W.eh^n`^nM | !" ~d
(101) 8 ^nIKUZe UVT.]WVcehUZY\TUZe6eh^umnUb] q^ | !#$ ~ MI.`\MS[F`\UVT.M v(UVTwYFmuL$`a^uUZY\Tf H1IKM$vwUZWZMLrL$`CmncKWZM~UbeSU^nMm`^uM=v YFT `aWZW`amnUZ`\jKWVM=e2^nUVWZW `C]Y\T?^um`\vKUZ]d^uUZY\T UbeSmuM=`\]IKM=vY\mTKY LrY\mnM UZTwYFmuL$`^nUVYFT(Ube1[F`\UVT.M vAKH1IKUbe1[\UZ\M=e1c.e*`aTMiM=]dcw^nUVYFTC^nI.`^2WZYiY\weWVUZ\M g UZ[\cKmnMX|KKH1IKUbe*tKmnYw]dM ene1]`\T. *:,%].
(102) b D Y. T. S. vi =T. vi =. S1. S2. Propagation. Propagation S4. T. vj =. vk = T. T. S3 vj = T. vk =. S5. S6. S7. S8. Propagation. Propagation. Propagation. Propagation. S10. S11. .... .... S12. ....
(103) . S. T. S9. .... vi =T. vi =. S1. S2. Propagation S3. Propagation. ∩. S4. S’. !"!$#%#&
(104) ('). N+O NCP.
(105) ,.
(106)
(107) "!#%$. vi = T. vi =. T. v=T. vj =. T. vk = T. vk =. T. j. N '
(108) ! "!$#%#&
(109) ')!. j:MT.M eh^uM vffx^SpqMFMW6¨:UV $ M]`\WVWq^uIKM~tKmnY\t.`\[F`^nUVYFT `a ^uM m_^nIKMjKm`aT]IKUVT.[`\e2UZT[g UV[FcKmnM~Nw¨ Y\^uIKM mu *UbeuM M mnM ]dc.mneuUVFMWZgS] `aWZW\^nIKMtKmuYw]M ene`a^ pfM \M WA4` ^uM mq^nIKMjKmn`\T.]IKUZTK[.H1IKM,TKUZ]M,t.muYFtM mh^g Y\ ^aWZL$`am]: e1`aWZ[\YFmuUV^uIKL UZe^nI.`^_pqM\M WqN~UZe*eucw]dUZMT?^*^uY$vwM^uM=] ^_LrYFeh^1^n`\cw^uYFWVYF[\UZM e . p +f4 q4Z(2v ru(. 4Zw
(110) tZpkwpk(*),r).4Z-6(. H1I.MUZLrtKWZMLrMT?^n`a^uUZY\T~^uI.`a^6 ,M1`amnM,[FY\UZTK[^uYSc.ehMYFm6Y\cKmUZTF^nM[Fmn`a^uUZY\T
(111) Ube6`euWZUV[FIF^nWVg~vwU zMmnMT?^6\M mneuUZY\T Y\*^uIKM UZLt.WVM LM T?^n`^nUVYFT vwM=eu]muUZjM=v3UZTO9 \= H1IKUbeUZLrtKWZMLrMT?^n`a^uUZY\T 1`\e~Y\T.WVg MdwM ]cw^n`\jKWZMCY\cK^neuUZvwM ,Ywkrc.euUZTK[^nIKMMdi^um`\]d^uUZY\TLrM=]I.`aTKUbeuL 9<; ;= _MmnM MS `\TF^,^uYrj:M`\jKWZM_^nY]Y\Lrt.`amnM2^nIKMXvwU:M muM TF^ `\tKtKmnYF`F]IKM eYa6UZT?^uM[Fmn`a^uUZTK[r^uI.M`aWZ[\YFmuUV^uIKL Y$^uIKMUVLrtKWZMLrMT?^`^uUZY\T euIKYFcKWZvj:M
(112) MiM=]dcw^`ajKWZM
(113) j:Ya^nI UZT.euUZvKM Y\cw^ehUbvwM,Yik:zHqY [\M^_^nIKUZe ¨z ,M~ `\]M^ YCL$`\UVT t.muYFjKWVM L$e g UVme^Ya`aWZW ¨^uIKMrWb`aTK[Fc.`a[FM Y\S,Ywk/UZetKcKmnMWZg cKT.]d^uUZY\T.`\W Y TKY euUbvwM 7 M zM ]d^~Ube`\WVWZY M vA M ]Y\T.vA¨ cKT] ^uUZY\Te~L~c.eh^r]Y\TwYFmuL ^nYC`$FMmng(eh^umnUZ]d^`aT.vWZUZLUV^uM=v ]dmnUV^uMmnUZY\TYa^nMmnLUZT.`a^uUZY\Tff 8 T^uIKMY\WZWVY *UZTK[$ M
(114) MdwtKWb`aUZTIKY ^uIKM=ehM `Feht:M ]d^ne1I.`FMj:MM TI.`aT.vKWVM=vA .
(115) q\. . . ¦ . ¢ . ¢ : =w ¦ . xe2UV^Ube2c.euc.`\WVWZgC^nIKM] `\euM\¨euUZ[\TKM=v`\muUb`aj.WVM=e2`amnMXUVLrtKWZMLrM TF^nM vcehUZTK[UZT?^uM[FMme-c Ube2mnMtKmnM euMT?^uM=v ij g ,`aTv 06jig .H1IKMXUZT?^uM [\MmH4XI.`\e2`$eut:M ]dUb`aW e^`^nc.e2`aTvUZe*cehM=v ^uY$mnMtKmnM euMT?^ z | `aTv 4 mnMt.muM=ehM TF^e* ~ 8 T ,Ywk ,M_c.ehM_^uIKMjKUZT.`amngrmuM tKmuM=ehM T?^n`^nUVYFTrYafTicKLj:Mme FH1IKUbe,]Y\mnmuM=eht:Y\TvKe^uY^uIKM ^git:M d,
(116) a
(117) @* *IKY?ehMvwM©.TKUV^uUZY\TUZe*^uIKMYFWVWZY *UVT.[ . *:,%].
(118) b D ?. .
(119) ! " #%$ &(')
(120) * #+ ,-'.
(121) * # / , 0. ]`\TjM
(122) UZT?^uM mutKmnMd^nM v`FJe ;\5¨ 4 1 671328 `\e 9w9¨ 4 1;:<132;8 `Fe <K ¨ 4 1=6 4 1 6>1?2;838 `Fe>C`\T.veuYY\Tf:HqY [FMd^*Y\c.m2ehUZ[\TKM=vC`\muUb`ajKWZM e ¨i ,Moc.eh^_TKM M vC^uY`FvKv(`reuUV[FTC^nY$Y\cKm d.W a@2Y\jwoM=] ^e- 132. .
(123) A@CB- D " E%FHGJIKML ,-'N@OB * E%FHPQSRTKML ,-'N@OB. ^nmuUZtKWZMd^2Ube1muM tKmnM euMT?^uM=vC`\e*`reuMd^2Y\q^uI.muM M
(124) ehUZ[\TKM=vC`\muUb`ajKWZM e1`\T.v`~j.UVT.`\mug$YFtM mn`a^uUZY\T . x. .
(125) U@C VW O X ! " Y E%QSZ%IJ[\ @C]^X V_;`'N@OBa'N@OBb'c@OBb'N@C 3VW . *I.MmnM. Cd%
(126) feRd. Ube*`aT MTicKLrMm`^nMS^g?t:M
(127) ]dYFT?^n`aUZTKUZTK[r`aWZWA^uIKMXWZY\[FUZ] `aWA]dYFTKTKM=] ^uYFmne . x ]dMT?^nmn`\W UZLt.WVM LM T?^n`^nUVYFT UbeueucKMUbe
(128) IKY ^nY mnMtKmnM euMT?^X^uI.M(eh^n`^nMCY\^nIKM(`\WV[FY\mnU^nIKL¨qU MC^uIKM ue Md^rYaM k?c.`^nUVYFT.e^uI.`a^r`\muM(`\WVUbv `a^r` [\UZ\M T LrY\LrMT?^= T ^uIKUberehM^Y\_M k?c.`a^uUZY\T.e ¨ ,M `\T?^^uY j:Mr`ajKWZM
(129) ^nY(vwM=]dUbvwMk?cKUb]iWVgUV ^ YCehUZ[\T.M v`amnUb`ajKWZM e`amnMM k?c.`\W gKYFm_^nIKUbe McehM^uIKMreu`\LrM~vK`a^n`
(130) 7 eh^umnc.]d^ucKmnM `\erUZT ^uIKM cKTKUZY\T,7 ©.T.v `aWZ[\YFmuUV^uI.L 9<;N=_j.cw^C *UV^uIKYFcw^(`aWZUb`\euUVTK[uj M `\enehYw]dUb`^nMC^nY M `F]I `\muUb`ajKWZM^uI.MehL$`\WVWZM eh^_`amnUZ`\jKWZM^uY *IKUb]IUV^_UZe_M k?c.`\W :pfMd^c.e*^`a\M~`aTMdK`aLrtKWZM
(131) *UV^uI }`\muUb`ajKWZM e `\T.v ^uIKMrYFWVWZY *UVT.[ euMd^XYa1M k?c.`a^uUZY\T.`e g9 M<cI#< M 4 I3> I?3hFH j MrI.`\M~^uI.MrY\WZWVY *UZTK[ WVUbe^
(132) Y\ `FeueuYw]dUb`^nUVYFT.-e =g 41 4 I&9 4eI&< 4eI#> >cI&? >=hFiHq Y`\muUb`aj.WVM=e `amnM_M=k?c.`aWzUVq^uI.Mg$t:Y\UZTF^^uY ^nIKM~en`aLrM~MWZMLrMT?^neLrYwvwcKWZY(`aT MWZMLrMT?^n`\mug mncKWVMYa,euUV[FT.e H1IKM`\enehYw]dUb`^nUVYFTWVUbeh^S`aWZY\T.MvwYiM eTKYa^ ]Y\T?^n`\UVT MT.Y\cK[FI UZTwYFmuL$`^nUVYFT ^uYj:MC`ajKWZMr^uY `FvKv TKM M=kFc`^uUZY\TeH j MC`aWbeuY T.MM v ^nY \M Mt3ehYFLrM iUZT.v(Yaj`\]$t:Y\UZTF^nMm*UZTwY\mnL$`^nUVYFT i *IKUZ]I `amnUZ`\jKWZM e1`amnMt:Y\UZT?^uUZTK[~^uY$`[\UZ\MT(`amnUZ`\jKWVMF UVT]dM ,M vKY$TKYa^_`\WVWZY `\WVUb`\euUVT.[.¨w`amnUZ`\jKWZM e*`amnMXMUV^uI.Mm2t:Y\UZT?^uM v(^nY$Y\m2t:Y\UZT?^*^uY.H1IKUZe_LrM `aTe1^uI.`a^*^uIKMj.`\] t:Y\UZT?^uM m*UVTwYFmuL$`a^uUZY\T(] `aT jMXFMtw^*UZT ^uIKMX]dYFmumnM eut:Y\T.vwUZTK[©.MWbv Yaq^nIKMX`amnUZ`\jKWZM e,^uI.`a^_`amnMt:Y\UZT?^uM=v ^nY. 8 T YFcKmSMdK`aLrtKWZM M~I`\i M g4 kj 9.I-<%lWI9 4eI&< 4eI#> mj ?JlWI? > h? n_Y 'U, ,M `\T?^ ^nY `\vKv YFm
(133) MdK`aLrtKWZMr^uI.MM k?c.`a^uUZY\T 0\qH1I.`\TKwe^uY^nIKMC`\eneuYi]UZ`a^uUZY\T WVUbeh^
(134) ,M$[FMd^
(135) ^nI.`J^ UbeSLrUVTKUZL$`aW6`aTv^uI` ^ 0t:Y\UZT?^neS^nY 0
(136) Y `FvKvwUZTK[C^nIKMM k?c.`^nUVYFQ T I0~UbeM=k?cKUV`\WVM TF^S^uY `FvKvwUZTKQ [ J 0
(137) 6HY vwY ^uIKUbe~ ,M(TKMM=v/^uY ]I.`aTK[FM$^uI.M `FeueuYw]dUb`^uUZY\T3WZUbe^rehY ^uI.`a{^ tYFUVT?^ne^uY 0
(138) `aTv `aWZW ^uIKM`amnUZ`\jKWZM e_^uI.`a^S MmnMt:Y\UZT?^uUZTK[C^nY rTKY xt:Y\UZT?^^uY
(139) AH1IKUbe[\UZ\M e_c.e^uIKMrTKM `FeueuYw]dUb`^nUVYFTCWZUZeh^ ;g4K o j 9.I-<cI-A>cI 1?TlI&91 4eI#< 4 I3> 4eI? 4%h?. HY(UZLrtKWZMLrMT?^
(140) `\enehYw]UZ`a^uUZY\TWZUZeh^neSUZT/,Ywk:¨: Mc.ehM~cKT.]d^uUZY\T.`\W6`amnmn`gwe f x_e`\mum`gwe*L$`g T.Ya^XjM UZTKUV^uUb`aWZUZeuM vf¨w ,M©.meh^1T.MM v(^nYrvKMd©.TKM
(141) `~^git:M^uYrI.`aTvwWVMXc.TKUVT.U^nUZ`\WVUbehM=vC`\WVcKM=e- .
(142) p_;fHqsr t< ? vuf w " t 'c{_;3fqU| } xTyXz [ Cb *~ y R%[ X{; _ 3fqA|5}. UV^uI ^nIKUZeXvKMd©.TKUV^uUZY\Tqs¨ %=(mnMtKmnM euMT?^ne`\T cKTKUZTKUV^uUb`aWZUZeuM v `aWZcKM$`aT" v 3T; Gf*muM tKmuM=ehM T?^ne^uIKM UZTKUV^uUb`aWZUZeuM v(`aWZcKM
(143) `Ya^g?t:MJG
(144) H1IKMXTKMdi^_eh^uM t(Ube1^uY$vwM©.TKMXjKUZT.`\mug$^nmuM M e j. N+O NCP.
(145)
(146)
(147) "!#%$. . \.
(148) @Jr t< ? vuf D " { @ | } E z ZJ\ X * E x ZJI%QH\ { _;fqU|5}'c{ @&O | }'N{ @ | }'c{ @& |5}. . . . j M$c.euMr^uIKMCjKUVT`amng muM tKmnM euMT?^n`a^uUZY\T Ya1Y\cKmX`amnUb`ajKWZM eS^nYUVLrtKWZMLrMT?^YFcKmcKT.]d^uUZY\T.`\W,`\mum`gwezHqY ©T.v(^uIKMX`aWZcKMYa6`aT UZT.vwMd ,Mc.euMU^e*jKUZT.`amngmnMtKmnM euMT?^`^uUZY\T(`\e*`rt.`a^uI UVT ^uI.M^umnMM7. . @ @
(149) ( r t M ! M{,@%@ t(} @ u= # / { E x Z%EI% QSz \#ZT\" } "!"! "{ ~ y R[ | } * $&% }D"! {,@@&
(150) ( | &%' % } * { #%$ % } { E x Z%IJQH\ * { #+ % } { E x Z%IJQH\ ( % % }D") {,@%@
(151) ( | % % % }. {_;q. t-}3 ". Ms0. UVLrUZWZ`\muWZg MvKMd©.TKM^nIKMXcKtzvK`^nMXYa`aT`amnmn`g`FeY\WZWVY 2e . @ @ C r t ? ! M{,@@ t(}5@
(152) u )tb' {,@%@ t(} "+*-,T Jt/. "! { E x Z%I%QH\ | { x ySz [ | " }-{ E z ZJ\ | }-{ E0 z ZJ\ |5}&} # / E z ZJ\0 * % 1 % 2 { D } ) " { x # / E Z%I%QH\ E x ZJI%QH\ | { xTyXz [ | " } %1 %2 }&} * { #%$ % } "! E z ZJ\0 { E x Z%I%QH\ | { ~ y R[ |5}-{,@@&C | { E0 z ZJ\ |5} 0% " }-{ E0 z ZJ\ |5}&} * { #%$ % }9{ E x Z%I%QH\43 %1 %2 }^"! { E x Z%I%QH\ | 3 {,@@C | %1 % " } %2 } * { #+ % } "! E z ZJ\0 { E x Z%I%QH\ | { ~ y R[ |5}-{ E z ZJ\0 |5}-{,@%@C | { E z ZJ\0 |5} 0% " }&} * { #+ % }9{ E x Z%I%QH\43 5%16&%2 }^"! { E x Z%I%QH\ | 3 &%1 {,@@&OC | 5%20% " }&} Ms0. 1H I.M_c.euMY\AcKT.]d^uUZY\T.`\Wz`\mum`gwe6I.`Fe,`~]dYFeh^,UZT$^nMmnLYafMd]UVM T.]dgFiH1I.M`\] ]dM=eue,Yaq`\TMWZMLrMT?^1UVTC^uIKM `\mum`gUZeTKY\^1]Y\T.eh^n`\TF^1jKcw^*WZUVT.M `am^nY^nIKMWVM TK[a^nICYaq^uIKMUZT.vwMd(UVT(U^e1jKUVT`amngmnMt.muM=ehM TF^`^nUVYFTf?H1I.UZe Ube^uI.MXtKmuUihMS^nY$t.`g$Y\m*j:MUZTK[rtKcKmnMWZg$cKT] ^uUZY\T`aW . 87 9 ¢ w ¦ . . x_WVW cKT.]d^uUZY\T.e^nI.`^]`aT/j:MCvwM©.TKM v/UZT ,Ywk Lce^
(153) ^nMmnLrUVT.`a^uMF 8 T3Y\mvwMm^nYjM(`ajKWZMr^uYM `\WVc`^uM ^nIKM euMrcKT.]d^uUZY\T.eUVTehUbvwM ,Ywk:¨f M$Lc.eh^c.euM$^uI.M g U/]dY\Te^nmuc.]d^uYFmXY\TKWZg\ H1IKUZe]dY\Te^nmuc.]d^uYFmXI.`\e
(154) ` FMmng(mnM eh^umnUb] ^uM=v ]dmnUV^uMmnUZY\T^uY(MT.eucKmnM
(155) ^nMmnLUZT.`a^uUZY\T :Y\TKMeht:M ]U©:]~`\mu[FcKLrMT?^_Ya6^nIKM~cKT.] ^nUVYFT L~c.e^ eh^umnUb] ^uWZgCvwM=]dmnM `FehMSUVTeu<U h MSUZT`aWZWz^uIKMXmnM ]cKmehUZ\M]`\WVWbe;:Md©.T.UVTK[rc.T.] ^nUVYFT.e2euY^nIKMg ]dY\TKY\mnL ^uYr^uI.UZe ]muUV^uM muUZY\T(]`aT(jMtKmnY\j.WVM Lr`a^uUb]_euY\LrMd^nUVLrMF g.Y\m1MdK`\Lt.WVMSUVT(Y\cKm*vwM \M WVYFtKLrMT?^, MT.MM v^uYrj:MS`\jKWVM ^nYC`at.tM T.v ^ ,Y$YFmnvKMmnM v(WVUbe^ef j MI.`\M
(156) `\T `amnjKU^nmn`\mugr^git:M G
(157) ¨:Y\T *IKUb]I `cKT.]d^uUZY\T ! Ya^gitM G G =< ?> UZe,``\UVWb`aj.WVM^uY~]dY\Lrt.`\muM1^ YXMWZMLrM TF^e Y\H G¨\U MFc >A@B DC% (E;FHG=LrM `\T.(e JIKC T.MS Y\c.WZv(T.`^ncKm`aWZWVg *mnUV^uMS^uIKM ded @ ScKT.]d^uUZY\T`\e . 4,CTMCq L. *:,%]. NM. V O. rWV 3{&V
(158) CDt(}. M{&V O t(} u . {&V O^t(} ".
(159) ;=. b D. 1 2 . "!"! 12 1 2 } "! " "#33 ! " { ,CTMCq L 1 2 }&} ) 3 { C, TMCq;L 1 2 }&} RMQHI. *. RMQI { y RML }o{ y RML. {&V } { y RML \TE K[ " * { y RML IJL [ " M. *. Ms0. `\muTw[FcKY\Lrmu^uMc.T?T.^2`^n^nI.MWZ`g~^^neIK^nUbmue*c.vw]d^uMdcK©.mT.`aUWZ^nWZUVg YFTCvwM=Ube]dmnTKM Y\`F^1ehM=`Fe*]] *MIKtwUZ^nWVM M~vUVTjigC^nIK,MYwYak$^uI.ehUZMT.m_]UVM_^UZTCUZeY\Y\T.TKMWZg(mnM ^u]IKcKMmneuehUZM=\]dM_Y\T] `avWZWY\UVTK^MFUb e, ^uYCIKM^uIK©.M mmueM^. UbeTKYa^`(ehUZTK[FWVM`\mu[FcKLrMT?^_Y\6^uIKMcKT.] ^nUVYFT^uI`^SvKM ]dmnM `FehM=e_`a^_M `F]ImuM=]dcKmehUZ\M
(160) ] `aWZW zHYY\M mn]Y\LrM ^nIKUbetKmnY\j.WVM L ¨ MCTKM M v3^nY vwM©.TKM(WVYw]`\WVWZg3` mnM ]cKmneuUZ\MrcKT.]d^uUZY\T ^uI.`a^I.`\T.vwWZM e~Y\TKMCt.`amu^~Y\2^uIKM mnM ]cKmehUZY\TfwH1IKUbe1Ube2vwY\T.MScehUZTK[^uIKM ]Y\LrL$`aT.v
(161) `
(162) $ " , M ! , M " # $ 1 2 . . {&V Ow| }'c{&V
(163) C!| };'. *. RQI { y M } { y RML R L. &{ V } { y M \TEK[ " R L * I%L [ " ". 2. 6. M. * 1 2 ?{&V O!| }.. ! 2 1 ! " 1 3 2 ! #" 3 ! " { , M 1 2 }&} % ! & ' (*) , O ! , O " # {&V
(164) C!| };'N{&V OD| }a " * ,+ M{&V OD| }. $-+/ 1 "! RQI * { y RML/. + }^") {&V 0" . } { y RL " { , M 1 + }&} \TE K%[ ") *% I%L [ "! { y RML1. { , O + }&} . RMQI. *. {&V
(165) Cw| }a ". " " } " D. M. ) 2} 43 { 5. 0. T ^uIKUbeWb`\eh^~vwM©.TKUV^uUZY\T j:Ya^nI3cKT.]d^uUZY\T.e 798;: `aT.v$ 798 < I.`\M$^nIKMUZm~©.mneh^~`\mu[FcKLrMT?^~vwM=]dmnM `\euUZTK[ eh^umnc.]d^ucKm`aWZWVg$UZT ^uIKMXmnM ]cKmehUZ\M]`\WVW H1IKUbecKT.] ^nUVYFT ded @ CUbe`\] ^nc.`aWZWZg ^nIKM(YFTKWZg/vKMd©.TKUV^uUZY\T *IKMmnM^nIKM eh^umnc.]d^ucKm`aW`amn[\cKLrMT?^Y\ ^nMmnLrUVT.`a^uUZY\T$ 1`\e tKmuYFjKWZML$`^nUZ]\e gKYFm ^uI.MYFMm`aWZWK`aWZ[\Y\mnUV^uIKL¨©.TvwUVT.[~`
(166) euUVLrtKWZM`\mu[FcKLrMT?^ Y\:^nMmnLrU 7 T`^uUZY\TUbe6kFc.U^nM1vKUVmnM ]d^
(167) 8 z ,MWVYiYF`^^uI.M1vKU zMmnMT?^ e^nMt.e6vKM en]dmnUVj:M v~UVT M=] ^nUVYFTrNS`aWZW?^uIKM*UV^uM mn`a^uUZY\T.e `\muMrvwYFTKMr^uUZWVW TKYTKM UVTKY\mnLr`a^uUZY\T UZe[?`aUZTKM vf> =,cK^
(168) U UbeS^uI.M$T?c.Lj:MmXYa1`amnUZ`\jKWZM e ¨^nIKMmnM$ *UZWVW T.M\M m,j:MLrY\mnM_^nI.`aT UV^uMm`^nUVYFT.e Y`\WVW:^uI.M euMc.T.] ^nUVYFT.e1`amnMSvwM©.TKM=vCmnM ]cKmneuUZ\MWZgY\T`aTCUZT?^uM [\Mm ^nI.`^2Ube1UZTKU^nUZ`\WVWZg(euMd^1^nY 6 8. N+O NCP.
(169)
(170)
(171) "!#%$. ; ;.
(172). / ¢ ¦ H1I.M`aWZ[\YFmuUV^uIKL Y\mnie*vKUVmnM ]d^uWZg YFTjYiYFWVM=`aTMdwtKmnM eneuUVYFT.eKH1I.M euM
(173) MdwtKmnM enehUZY\Te2`amnMvwM©.TKM v`Fe*YFW 7 WZY 2e . . . .
(174) C?@J X ! " ,-' C3@ ~ C3@. ' C3@ ~
(175) X V_` ' C?@ ' C3@ y [ . . . . . . *I.MmnM %
(176) feRd Ube1^uI.M^g?t:MYa ^uIKMXj:YiY\WZM `\T ]Y\TKTKM=] ^nY\me- .
(177) X V_;; D " R X V_; X V_ $HE X V_; + z Z X V_. . T ^nIKM euMXMdwtKmnM enehUZY\Te¨i MXI.`\MXvwM©.TKM v`rtKmnM vKUZ] `^uM ,`
(178) <CeD ^nI.`^UVT.vKUZ] `^uM=e*UV`rj:YiY\WZM `aT Md 7 t.muM=eueuUVYFT/UZe~`^n`\cw^uYFWVYF[\g\H1IKM(`\WV[FY\mnU^nIKL UZT ,Ywk UbevKMd©.TKM=v3jig ^nIKM$cKT] ^uUZY\T , k8 ^eX^git:MCUbe- q;, 9' C3@`' {,@&t(@C@&,A } X V {&V O-@OB(} qH1IKM©.meh^
(179) UVT?^uM [\M mSUZT.vwUb]`a^uM=eX *I.`^XUbe^uI.M$WVM \MW6Y\ T.M eh^uUZTK[.¨U MF=UVUV^6UZeeuMd^ ^uY_ M[\Md^Y\T.WVgXtKmnY\t`a[F`a^uUZY\Tf¨=ehM^^n{Y ;,^uI.M1vKUVWZMLrL$`_mncKWZM,YFTYFTKM,`\muUb`ajKWZM\ H1I.M
(180) ehM=]dY\Tv(`\mu[FcKLrMT?^Ube1^nIKMXjYiYFWVM=`aTMdwtKmnM enehUZY\TqiH1I.MXmuM=ehcKWV^*UZe_]dY\Lrt:YFeuM v(Ya6|MWZMLrMT?^ne .H1IKM ©mneh^YFTKMUbe2^nIKM~©.T.`aW`\eneuYi]UZ`a^uUZY\TWZUZeh^ zH1IKMrehM=]dYFT.vY\T.MUbe`CjYiY\WZM `\T^uI`^UZT.vwUb]`a^uM=e_UV MI.`FM mnM `F]IKM vC`]Y\T?^um`\vKUZ]d^uUZY\TfwH1IKMS^uI.UVmvCYFTKMSUZe^nIKMXWVUbeh^1Y\`amnUb`ajKWZM e, *IKUb]I(`aWZcKM=e1I.`\MSjM MT LrYivKU 7 ©M v jig$^uIKMXMwM ]dcK^uUZY\TfKH1IKM
(181) ]Y\mnmuM=] ^nTKM ene Y\^nIKM
(182) `aWZ[\YFmuUV^uI.LUZe2eh^n`a^uM=vCjig$^nIKMY\WZWVY *UZTK[^uI.MY\mnM L ? !H #"c@ %q @O@%$ & q;, . & # C 3@.. {,@ %q } { @ ? }D"! {, MfV (' * { ) , V }D") @ 3 . }. Mw0. 8 ^uI.Mj:YiY\WZM `\T ^nI.`^XUbeXmuM^ucKmnTKM=v Ube^umncKM^uIKM T/ ,M$]`\T ]Y\T.]WVc.vKM~^nI.`^
(183) YFcKmMdwtKmnM enehUZY\T UZeX`(^`ac,7 ^nY\WZY\[Fg\8 ,TKY\^ ¨f Mr]`aT.TKYa^
(184) en`g `aTig?^uIKUZTK[.j M]`\T M `\WVc`^uM~^uI.UZec.T.] ^nUVYFT vwUZmnM ] ^nWVg UVT.euUbvwMC,Yik: YCYFmSMK`aLrtKWZMUV, M `\TF^S^uY]IKM=]U,^uIKMrMit.muM=eueuUVYFT[ +* P UbeX`^`acw^nY\WZY\[\gF¨z ,MMT?^uM m^uIKM YFWVWZY *UZTK[]Y\LrL$`aT.v(UZT ,Ywk . ,.-./.021.3 4657.8.9;:<=1/6>96>@?BA7<DCE?GFH3I.9JC
(185) AK?BLK?BM6C2MNPOOQ?BFR?BLS?TM6C2MNPOOOOO23U ?T8AH:5#09WVYX;VHO[Z\YX;9
(186) <.I^] Z28A
(187) 7H9R_`X#330. H `aj.WVF M ;SeuIKY 2e,IKY ^uI.M`\WV[FY\mnU^nIKL muc.T.eUVT?^uM muT`aWZWVg`\T.vM?^nMmnT.`aWZWZgYFT(eh^n`\T.vK`amv$Mw`\LrtKWVM=ewH1IKM L$`F]IKUVT.M MI`\MSc.ehM=vCUbe1` ,a}a I.hSl,67 WZUZT?cKCL$`\]IKUZTKM\,g.Y\m1M `F]ICMdK`\Lt.WVM M[FUVFM_^nIKMTKM eh^uM=v WZMFMW:Yaf^nIKMSY\mnLcKWb`K¨F^uI.MTicKL~jM mY\qUV^ne1]dYFTKTKM ]d^uYFmne ¨a^nIKMT?c.Lj:MmYaqUV^ne1`amnUb`ajKWZM e ¨a^nIKMS^uUZLM`aTv eut.`F]dM
(188) mnM k?cKUZmuM=v^uY(MdwM ]cw^uM~^uI.MMdi^nmn`F] ^uM=v `aWZ[\YFmuUV^uI.L ¨.^uIKM~^uUZLrM`\T.v eut.`F]dM
(189) mnM k?cKUZmuM=v^uY(MdwM ]cw^uM ^nIKM
(190) `aWZ[\YFmuUV^uI.LUVT.euUbvwM~,Ywk H1IKM=ehM1j:MT.]I.Lr`\muweeuIKY 3©.me^^nI.`^6Y\c.m UZLrtKWZMLrMT?^n`a^uUZY\TUZeT.Ya^6\M mugXM$]UVM T?^ aH1IKM1Mdi^nmn`F] ^uM=v FMmehUZY\TUbefUZT`1 `F] ^uYFmqY\ ;=\*euWVY Mmf^uI.`\T^uIKM]dY\LrLrMm]dUb`aWFtKmnYivKc.] ^vKM\M WVYFtM=vjigSl6mnY\M mqHM ]IKTKYFW 7 YF[\gF c.m6IKMcKmnUbe^nUZ] eq^nY
(191) ehM WVM=] ^ vwUZWVM LrLr`S`amnUb`ajKWZM e`amnM\MmngXT.`\UVFM1`\T.v]dY\c.WZv~jM*Wb`amn[\M WVgUZLrtKmuYFM vA *:,%].
(192) ;N. b D
(193) #%. $ "!$
(194) '
(195) !$. !)
(196) e e ? "!5' $ " !$' $ " !Z' $ !)
(197) e % ' b
(198)
(199) ' &
(200)
(201) ) ( !)
(202) ] 0 . . . % . .
(203) % !. . . 0 + 0 ", ' b )
(204) # "0 + . "!). .
(205) # .
(206) # . )"% . "!) " 0 + .% . !. . . . . . . . . . # . % . . % . ] % ] ! ! . . /10 . % %. '
(207) $" '
(208) " '5
(209) '5
(210) . #%
(211) #%
(212) $ #%0 #J0 b # %0 # J0 ! # %0 # J0 # %0 ] # 0 # %0 # J0
(213) b # %0 # J0 ! # %0 J # %0 b b # %0 # 0 # %0 # J 0 % # %0 b * # b0 # %0 # 0 # %0 # 0 # # %0 # 0 ] # 0 # ] %0 # 0 ] #J%% 0 ]% # %0 % %# # 0 % %# # # 0 # - %# # % 0 - %# # bM0 # 0 %# . c ) 2 !#&
(214) '3, . . -. -. . . M ]dYFT.vA¨?^uI.MSM `aWZc.`^nUVYFTCUZT.ehUbvwM,YwkrUZe1M \M T(euWVY Mm1`aT.vCmuM=k?cKUVmnM e`~ `aUZm*`aLrY\cKT?^1Ya LM LrY\mng\ j M `\muMSY\T.WVgC`\jKWZM^uYrmuc.T(^nIKM
(215) euLr`\WVWZM eh^2pfM \MWfNMw`\LrtKWVMFKH1IKMYa^nIKMm*YFTKM e*`\muMY\cK^neuUZvwMYFcKm*muM=`\]If 54 6. ¢ 3 .a . g.muYFL^uI.M
(216) `aWZ[\Y\mnUV^uIKLUZT.euUZvwM~,Ywk:¨wUV^2UZe*t:YFeneuUVjKWZMS^uY$vwM muUZ\MX`~^n`F] ^uUb]afgKY\m^nIKUZe ¨K MXTKMM=v^nYr©.WZWA^uIKM [?`atj:Md^ MM T jYiYFWVM=`aTY\mnLc.WZ`\M`aT.v tKmuYFtY?ehUV^uUZY\Te:H1IKUZeUbevwYFTKMcehUZTK[$^nIKMeh^n`\T.vK`\mnv ^ Y7 WVM \M W `\tKtKmnYF`F]If j MS©.me^*vwMd©TKMX`^nmn`\T.euWZ`a^uUZY\T$cKT] ^uUZY\T mnY\LYFcKm1jYiY\WZM `\TCMit.muM=eueuUVYFT.e ^uY^uIKMtKmnY\t:Y7 euUV^uUZY\T.e fH1IKUbeS^um`aT.euWZ`a^uUZY\T ^n`aFM eX`FeS` t.`\mn`\LrMd^uM mX`Cc.T.] ^nUVYFT ^nI.`^
(217) UZT?^uM mutKmnMd^ejYiYFWVM=`aT `\muUb`ajKWZM e `Fe1tKmnY\t:YFeuU^nUVYFT.e. C3@M7w@,Cr ).
(218) 9'87 @&O- # C?@Hu 97 @&C " { }^") { ) } * { ~ % }D"!;:D{ C3@M7w@,C ) % } * { ~ y [ R %1 %2 }^"! { C3@?7 @&C ) %1 }=< { C?@?%7w@,C ) %2 } * { ~ y [$E %1 %2 }D"! { C3@?7 @&C ) %1 } >A{ C?@?%7w@,C ) %2 }. N+O NCP.
(219) ;=|.
(220)
(221) "!#%$ 3S
(222) 3
(223). . U S
(224) 8
(225) S
(226) 8 S 8
(227) >S
(228) 8 ! . ¢ q§ n_Y X¨Kc.euUVT.[$^uIKMMdK]dWZc.vwM=v 7 LrUbvKvwWZM`\e_`aT`wUZY\L¨KUV^_UZe_tY?eueuUZjKWVM^nYCeuIKY ^nI.`^U `aTMwtKmuM=eueuUZY\T UZe `~^`acw^nY\WZY\[\gF¨iU^e1^um`aT.euWb`^uUZY\T `\e*`tKmnY\t:YFeuU^nUVYFT(Ube^umncKMF.H1IKUbe1UZe*[FUVFMT jig$^uIKMYFWVWZY *UZTK[^nIKMYFmuM L ? !H #" C3@?7 @&C , f V ('3 & ) H-'87 @&C .{ ) #/ } & H C3@.S{H, f V ('. } N{. C3@?7. @&O. )pH}. H1I.M,M?^nmn`]dYFT.vwUV^uUZY\TM "$#fz]Y\LrM eqmuYFLxY\cKm MT]dYwvwUZTK[.¨= ,MI.`FM6^uYSMT.eucKmnM ^nI.`^
(229) UZe UZTF^nMmntKmnMd^uM=v `Fe @ x ^`\] ^nUZ& ] %')(*,+-3]`\T(T.Y j:M
(230) vwMmnUVFM vA,¨ 8 ^2 Y\mnwe1`\eY\WZWZY 2e 8 ^*©.me^*^`aFM e^uI.M
(231) ]dcKmnmuM T?^[FYF`aW `\T.v^um`aTeYFmuL$e6UV^UZT?^uY`
(232) jYiY\WZM `\T$M k?cKUZ`aWZMT?^ 8 Tr^uIKUbe ^um`aT.ehY\mnL$`^uUZY\TrUV^,FMMte `
(233) vK`a^n` 7 eh^umnc.] ^ncKmnM ^nI.`^,Lr`\t.e^nIKM2j:Y?YFWVM=`aTr`amnUZ`\jKWZM e ^uY
(234) ^uIKM UVm`\] ^nc.`aW.`\WVc.M2`\e `Xt.muYFtY?ehUV^uUZY\Tf
(235) 8 ^ ^uIKM T$jKcKUZWZvKe,`XtKmnYiYa ^nMmnL cehUZTK[X^nIKUZe,j:Y?YFWVM=`aTrMdwtKmnM eneuUVYFTr`\T.v^uI.M2^uI.MY\mnML$e ,!#
(236) @ b `aT. v .uB df / d ,`
(237) <CeD pqMd^*c.e2euMMIKY U^2 Y\mnweUVTtKm`\]d^uUb]dM\,YFT.euUZvwM m^uIKMYFWVWZY *UVT.[[FYF`\=W 69 7!:A.9438./.0507<] 0 21. H9.3A94 8.96>
(238) 8 _ ? / _98A635 O /;:=<?>/ ]. 67. x_tKtKWZgiUVTK[^nIKM@%'(*,+-3. ^`\] ^nUZ]SM T.vKe1^nIKMXtKmnY?Y\ . 8.96>
(239) 8 A38./.50 07<] 7X68A99256A63-9ICB 3. 8.96>
(240) 8 AD9I^]. M
(241) ]`\T vKUZeutKWb`g$^uIKMXt.muYiYa^uM muL. j. .AH:<68 8.96>
(242) 8^] 8.96>
(243) 8JZ E / 9_ 8.A.35GF ?B,.M5.=A 663 8.A.35G6./
(244) 7.86303H2I ?T2A JAA.2/ I=K928 8 ?T=A JAA./2IG39828 ?TA=JAA./2I,L<#:
(245) 828 E V_5H3.>:
(246) 8H:-.92F=6A
(247) 7H9#O@?TM6C2MNPO[/#OOL ?BF63I.9WCAE?BLR?TM6C MNPOOQ?GFR?BLK?BM6C2MNPOOOO ?TA
(248) 7<H1.3AA.G9 M
(249) 8
(250) ? 3E ? 3 CHOO ?BFH3I.9WC
(251) AS?BLR?BM6C2MNPOOQ?BFK?GLR?TM6C2MNPOOOOOO _ ? / 9_ 8A635 O=/ :=<?>/ 8. ^SUZeS]dYFLrtY?ehM=vYa,`\T `atKtKWZUb]`^nUVYFT Ya6^nIKM
(252) ^nIKMYFmuM LN.uB df / d ,`
(253) <CeD fH1IKM
(254) ©.meh^S`amn[\c.LM T?^ bU e~^uIKML$`at.tKUVT.[ cKT] ^uUZY\T mnY\L j:Y?YFWVM=`aT `\muUb`aj.WVM=e
(255) ^nY t.muYFtY?ehUV^uUZY\T.e R8 ^rUbe[\UZ\M T jig ` WZYiY\7 cKt c.T.] ^nUVYFT UZT.euUZvKM ` t`amu^uUb]dcKWb`am`\mum`g | DO @ P/ ~ H1IKUZeC`amnmn`g/Ube$jKcKUZW^ `\eY\WZWZY 2e#g UZmneh^ ¨ `\T M Lrtw^g`amnmn`grUbe1]dmnM `^nM vA| DQcP/ ~ ^uI`^*[\UZ\M=e ^nIKMUVT?^uM mut.muM^n`^nUVYFT @,^uYr`aWZW^nIKM`amnUZ`\jKWVM=e M ]dYFT.vA¨^uIKM,`\WVc.-M UZe `\enehYw]UZ`a^uM v^nY2^uI.M `amnUZ`\jKWZM 4 1=671?2;8 | D @ R/ ~d=H1I.M,euM ]dYFT.vX`amn[\c.LM T?^ Y\S .uB d 2/ d ,<CD Ube` tKmnY?Y\_^nI.`^[ "$#f
(256) IKY\WbvKe UVT]dM T "$#c
(257) M `\WVc`^uM=e^uY @d¨ : ¨ ^nIKMtKmuYiY\ Ya @d¨zUbe_[FUVFMTfzH1IKM
(258) ^nIKUZmnv `amn[\cKLrMT?^SUZe_^uIKMj:Y?YFWVM=`aT MwtKmuM=eueuUZY\Tf gUZT.`\WVWZg ^uIKMWZ`Fe^ `\mu[FcKLrMT?^AUZeq`1tKmuYiY\F^nI.`^f^nIKM j:YiY\WZM `aTMit.muM=eueuUVYFTUbef`^`acw^nY\WZY\[\gFdH1IKUbefUbeA[\UZ\M Tjig`aTX`atKt.muYFtKmuUb`^nM `\tKtKWZUZ] `^nUVYFT(Y\q^uI.M^uIKM Y\mnML ,!u @ *UV^uI`TKM=e^nM v WVM \M WAYa N~`\T.vC^uIKMXj:YiY\WZM `aT MdwtKmnM eneuUVYFTf 8. *:,%].
(259) ; {. b D monqp p 6. pkt.
(260)
(261) 2+.-#ru3fn. H `aj.WV> M ;ehIKY 2e,^nI.`^*c.euUVT.[rvKUVmnM ]d^uWZg$^uIKMX`\WV[FY\mnU^nIKLUVTehUbvwM,Ywk]`\TKTKYa^1j:M
(262) `~mnM `FehYFT.`aj.WVMSehYFWVcw^nUVYFT YFm~UZT?^uM [\m`^uUZTK[^nIKM`aWZ[\Y\mnUV^uIKLH1IKMCt:MmuY\mnL$`aT.]MCYa*^nIKM tKmuYF[\m`aLrLrUVT.[ WZ`\TK[\c`a[\MCUVT.euUbvwM,Ywk j:MUZTK[~WVUZLrU^nM vA¨? ,MTKMM=vr^uYmuM=vwc.]dMS`\e Lc.]IC`Fe t:YFenehUZjKWZM*^uI.M]dYFLrtKcw^n`a^uUZY\TCvKY\TKM2UZT.euUZvKM,Ywk:?H1IKM j`\euUZ]XUbvwM=`Ya6^nIKUbeeuM ]d^uUZY\T Ube2^nY(vwM©.TKM`TKY\^uUZY\TYa MwM ]dcK^uUZY\T^nmn`F]dMX^nI.`^X]dYFTF^`aUZT.e2UZTwYFmuL$`^nUVYFT ^nI.`^ ] `aTjM*cehM=v~`FeIKUVT?^e^uYXmnMtKWb`gXLrY\mnM1Md]dUZMT?^uWZgX^nIKM2eu`\LrM1]Y\LrtKcw^`^nUVYFTf\H1IKM1tKmnYiYat.muYw]dM=eue UbeXeutKWVUV^XUVT ^ Y.AH1IKM$`aWZ[\YFmuUV^uI.LUZemncKT Mdi^uM muT.`\WVWZg `\T.v mnMd^ncKmnT.e`aT MdwM ]cw^uUZY\T ^um`\]M\AH1IKMTq¨A^uIKM ^nmn`F]dM1Ube ]IKM=]\M v~UZTF^nMmnT.`aWZWZgUZT.ehUbvwM*^nIKM2tKmnY\M m H1IKUbe6Wb`\eh^,eh^uMt$euIKY\c.WZvrj:M_`aWZ[\YFmuUV^uI.LUb]`\WVWZg
(263) euUVLrtKWZMm ^nI.`aT mncKTKTKUZTK[r^uI.MXUVTKUV^uUb`aWf`\WV[FY\mnU^nIKL 4 . 9 K ¢ . TYFmnvwM m1^uYr©.[FcKmnMXY\cw^2 *I.`a^_`r[\YiYwv(^um`\]dMX]Y\cKWbv jMXYFm*^uI.M
(264) `aWZ[\Y\mnUV^uIKL¨K MTKMM=v ^uYr©.T.vt.WZ`F]dM e UZT ^uIKM
(265) `\WV[FY\mnU^nIKL *IKM muMc.euMWZM ene*]dYFLt.cw^n`a^uUZY\T Lr`gCjM
(266) `FY\UbvwM vA x ©.me^1UbvwM `~UZe^nY~mnM ]Y\mv$Y\T.WVgr^nIKMXehc.] ]dM=euehcKWA`atKt.WVUb]`a^uUZY\T.e,Ya^uIKMXvwUZWVM LrLr`~mncKWVMF¨iU MX`atKtKWZUb]`
(267) 7 ^nUVYFT.e* *IKM muMX`a ^uMm2^uIKM
(268) UZT?^uM mneuM ]d^uUZY\T TKM UVTKY\mnLr`a^uUZY\TI.`Fe1jM MT[F`\UVT.M vAKH1IKMXY\^uIKM m_`at.tKWVUb]`a^uUZY\T.e vKYT.Ya^_]dYFT?^umnUVjKcK^uMS^uY^uI.M©.T.`aWqmuM=ehcKWV^ KH1I.UZe1[FUVFM e1c.e*`~©.me^2t:YFeneuUVjKWZMXvK`^`^git:MYFm1^uIKM^nmn`F]dM=-e 8. . [ z * * QIT[.
(269) @ ,$C X ! ". 0. [ [ [. ZJ\ Y E L [ Y E zTz Y E. ? &, ? &,. @ $O @ $O9' %@ $O9' @ $C X@OBb' @ $O ' @ $C '. ,. ,. ,. ,. &,$OJ0. @. T ^nIKMSY\WZWVY *UZTK[r ,MmnMdM m1^uY^uIKUbe*FMmehUZY\T `\e^uI.MX\MmeuUVYFTz x_TKYa^nIKMm,UVTwYFmuL$`a^uUZY\T^uI.`a^] `aTrjMmuM=]dYFmnvwM=vUbe *I.UZ]Ir^nmuUZtKWZMd^ne UVTr^nIKM2tKmnY\t`a[F`a^uUZY\TM zM ]d^uUZ\MWZg [?`aUZTCeuY\LrM_UZTwY\mnL$`^nUVYFTfwH1IKM_ `F] ^^uI.`a^ MvwY~T.Ya^1TKMM=v$^uYmnM ]dYFmnv^nIKMMdK`\]d^,mncKWZM_^nI.`^1I.`\ej:MM T `\tKtKWZUVM=v I`\ejM MT tKmnY\M v UVT Y\cKmYFmuL$`aWZUbeu`a^uUZY\T ^ Y mncKWZM e~^uI.`a^`amnM `\tKtKWZUZ] `ajKWZM(YFT ^nIKM eu`\LrM ^nmuUZtKWZMd^e2`aWZ `gwe1[FMTKM mn`a^uMS^uIKM~eu`\LMXUZTwYFmuL$`^nUVYFTfKs*M=]dY\mvwUZTK[r^uI.M^umnUVtKWZMd^[\UZ\M e1ce_`$euM ]dYFT.v tY?5e 7 euUZjKWVMXvK`a^n` 7 eh^umnc.] ^ncKmnFM | \MmeuUVYF T '.~ 8. . @ ,$C X ! " 0 Y E [ S ?@@O& ,$OVW ' @&,$O Y E [ , $O9' %@ ,$O9' @ ,$C Y E [ ?@& Y E [ X@OBb' @ , $O-' @ ,$C-' @&,$OJ0.
(270) [ z ZJ\ * \TEQXZ%IJ[\ * L[ * QIT[ zTz. g UZT.`aWZWZg$Uq MSWVYiY\$`a^,^nIKMj`\euUZ]_Y\t:Mm`^uUZY\Te¨F^uIKMSLrYFeh^MwtM T.ehUZ\MY\TKMSUbe ^nIKM]dY\LrtKcK^n`^nUVYFTCY\f^uIKM ZU T?^uM mneuM ]d^uUZY\T `^^uIKMMTv Ya6^nIKMrvwUVWZMLrL$`mncKWZM\zH1IKMUZTwYFmuL$`^nUVYFT Ya *I.UZ]I T.M 'M=kFc`^uUZY\Te2I.`FM j:MM T([?`aUZTKM vC]`aT(jMXeh^uYFmuM=vUZT^uI.M^nmn`F]dMF Y.¨i *IKMT ]IKM ]iUZTK[~^uIKM^um`\]M\¨iU^*Ube1ehcw]UVM TF^^uYrFMmnUg ^nI.`^~^uIKM=ehM(TKM M k?c.`^nUVYFT.e
(271) I.Y\Wbv3UVT ^uIKM muM=ehc.W^nUVTK[ e^`^uM=eY\*^uIKM(^ Y jKm`aT.]IKM=eeuY MC]`\T `\v.v ^nIKML ^nY^uI.M~UZTKUV^uUb`aWe^`^uM~Ya6^nIKMvKUVWZMLrL$`mncKWZM\ x*vKvwUZTK[^nIKUZeUZTwY\mnL$`^uUZY\T^nY^nIKM^ YtKmnMiUZY\c.e ^nmn`F]dM=e,[FUVFM e*`~^uI.UVmv tY?eueuUVj.UVWZU^A g |\M mneuUZY\ T
(272) ~ . N+O NCP.
(273) ;}.
(274)
(275) "!#%$.
(276) @ ,$C X ! ". . [ z * * QIT[. 0. [ [ [. ZJ\ Y E L [ Y E zTz Y E. ? &, ? &,. @ $O @ $O9' %@ $O9' @ $C X@OBb'N{&V O-@OB-@CB-}' @. ,. ,. `\T.v `YFmh^nIY\TKM |FMmehUZY\T '
(277) ~ . @ ,$C X ! " 0 YY E [ S ?@@O& ,$OVW ' @&,$O E [ , $O9' %@ ,$O9' Y E [ ?@&. .
(278) [ z ZJ\ * \TEQXZ%IJ[\ * L[ * QIT[ zTz. ,. @ $C X O @ b B N ' & { V O O @ B C @ B }' @ [. YE. ,$O-' @&,$O5' @&,$OJ0. ,$O-' @&,$O5' @&,$OJ0. UV^uI`aTig$Y\f^uIKM=ehMS^nmn`F]dM e ¨?U^*Ube ^nIKMT t:YFenehUZjKWZM_^nYrvKMd©.TKMSUZT.ehUbvwM,Ywk$`
(279) c.T.] ^nUVYFT @ e @^nI.`^ FMmnU©M er` ^um`\]dMFu8 ^ne^git:MUZe C?@p' %@ ,$O ' {,@t(@O@ ,i } X V ,H1IKM]dY\mnmnM ] ^nTKM ene~^uIKM Y\mnML `FeueuYw]dUb`^nM v *UV^uI ^nIKMcKT.]d^uUZY\T ^uI.`a^_]IKM ]we,^um`\]M e1Ube^uIKMYFWVWZY *UZTK[ j. ? !H #" $%($H%@ ,$O @O@%$ & 6 C3@. & @&,$O. {($ %($ H%@ ,O$ } { @ ? }D"! {H, f V (' * { ) , V }D"! %@ ?. . }. Mw0. 1H I.UZe^uM ]I.TKUZk?cKM YaX[\M TKMm`^nUVT.[ `3^um`\]MUZe(TKY\^CTKM `\T.v I.`FeC`aWZmnM `\vKg j:MM T c.euM v UZT vwU:M muM TF^ ]Y\T?^uMi^
(280) Y\mMdK`aLrtKWZMCmnM ]MT?^uWZg UVTO9 }= x2T Mi^uMmnT.`\W tKmnY\[Fmn`\L euY\LrMd^nUVLrM e]`\WVWZM v
(281) @~UbecehM=v ^nY [\M TKMm`^nM^uIKMC^um`\]dMFqH1IKMYFmuUZ[\UZT.`\WVUV^g Ya*YFcKm`at.tKmuY?`\]I UZe
(282) ^uI.`a^ MC`amnM$[\YFUVTK[^nY\M muUVg ^nI.`^ YFcKm*Mdi^nMmnT.`aWAtKmnY\[Fmn`\L [\MT.Mm`^uM=e1]dY\mnmnM ] ^1^nmn`F]dM e KH1IKUbe1UZe_vwY\TKMjig©mneh^*LYwvwUVgiUVT.[$Y\cKm*tKmnMiUZY\c.e `\WV[FY\mnU^nIKL euYU^tKmnYivKc.]dM=e^um`\]M e fH1IKM$^gitMCYa1^uIKMCTKM , cKT.]d^uUZY\T3UbeX^nIKMT q;, ' C3@ ' {,@t(@O@ ,A } OXVH {&V
(283) C @OB(} #%@ ,$O KH1I.M^uIKM Y\mnMLY\ ]dYFmumnM ]d^uTKM=euemnML$`aUZT.e1cKT]I.`aTK[FM v ? !H #"c@ %q @O@%$ & q;, . & # C 3@.. {,@ %q { @ ? * { ) , V . Mw0. } }D"! { H, f V (' }^") @ ?. }. =cw^2 MX`aWbehYtKmnY\MY\mnL$`aWZWVg$^nI.`^*^nIKM^um`\]M_^nI.`^2Ube*tKmnYwvwc.]M v(UZe*]Y\mnmuM=] ^ ? !H #"c@ % q @&,$O @O@%$O & q;, . & # C 3@. {,@ % q } { @ ? 9}D"! { 3 }^"!{($%($3 H" %@ ,$O 9} M * { ) , V }^") @ ? . . Mw0. . ^SUZe_^uI.MT t:YFeneuUVjKWZM
(284) ^nYCc.euMX^nIKM~Mi^um`\] ^nM vFMmehUZY\TY\6^uIKUbe`\WV[FY\mnU^nIKL 8. *:,%]. ,. `\e2^uIKMY\m`\]WVMYFm[FMT,7.
(285) b D. ;%Y. M mn`a^uUZTK[^nIKMC^nmn`F]dMF H1IKM L$`aUZT j:MTKM©K^Y\2^uI.UZer|
(286) 7 pfM \M W,`at.tKmuY?`\]I/Ube^nI.`^r MCMTehcKmnM^nI.`^Y\TKWZg ]Y\mnmuM=] ^,^um`\]dM=e,`\muMS[\M TKMm`^nUVT.[. x2WbehYUVT?^nMmu `\]dUZTK[~^uIKMM?^nmn`F] ^nM vt.muYF[\m`aL ^uYrtKWb`g~^nIKMmuYFWVMSYa^uIKM YFmn`F]dWZM2Ubeeh^um`aUZ[\I?^uY\mn `\mnvreuUVT.]M_^nIKM^um`\]dMStKmnYwvwc.]dM=v$jigr^uIKMtKmnY\[Fmn`\L"UbeMdK`\]d^uWZgr^uIKMSY\TKMSTKM M vwM=v jigC^uIKMXc.T.] ^nUVYFT(^nI.`^S]IKM ]we^uI.MX^um`\]M\. gKYFm*^uI.UZe_ ,M1oc.eh^_ *mnYa^nMM WVUZTKM e2Ya ]`aLrWq]YwvwM\.H1I.UZe ] `at.`\jKUZWVUV^g Ya1]`\WVWZUVT.[`\Tig Mdi^um`\]d^uM=v ]YivKM~mnY\L ^uIKM(,Ywk eugwe^nML ]Y\cKWbv/`aWbehY j:M`acw^nY\L$`^nUZ] `aWZWVg [FMTKM mn`a^uM=vCvwcKmnUZTK[^uIKMXtKmnYw]dM=eueYaMdi^nmn`F] ^uUZY\Tq. 87. ¢ 3 .a 8 T `CeuUVLrUZWZ`\m_ 1`gC^nI.`aT UVT M ] ^nUVYFT |. {¨. M~]`\T vwM muUZ\M`^n`F] ^uUb] %')(*(~^uI.`a^c.euM e_^uIKM|
(287) 7 pfM \MW `\tKtKmnYF`F]If 8 ^,t.muYw]dM M vKe UVT.U^nUZ`\WVWZg$`\e6^nIKM2^`\]d^uUb] %')($*,+-3AgUZme^U^,©.T.vKe ^uIKMjYiYFWVM=`aT$M k?cKUZ`aWZMT?^,Y\ ^nIKM*YFmuL~cKWZ`.FH1IKM T$U^1]`\WVWbe6Mdi^nMmnT.`aWZWVg^uIKMMdi^um`\]d^uM=v~t.muYF[\m`aL , ^nI.`^,tKmuYwvwc]dM e,`^um`\]M\j UV^uI ^nIKUbe ^nmn`F]dM_UV^1jKcKUZWZvKe1`tKmuYiY\:^nMmnLc.euUVTK[^uIKM @ C e @tKmnY\[\m`aL 8 f ,MS]dY\TehUbvwMm,^uI.MSen`aLrM2[FYF`aW `Fe1UVT M=] ^nUVYFT |. { 4 . 6. 69 7!:A.9438./.06./GM ] 0 21. H9.3A94 8.96>
(288) 8 _ ? / _98A635 O /;:=<?>/ ] 8.96>
(289) 8 A38./.06./GM ] 37X68A99256A63-9C I B. 67. 8.96>
(290) 8 AD9I^]. _Y 'UV, MvwUbeutKWZ`g^nIKMrtKmnY?Y\6^uM muL¨AUV^L$`\\M eMdwtKWZUb]dUV^X] `aWZW ^uY ^uIKM `\T.v ]dY\T?^`aUZT.e*`~^um`\]dMX]Y\LrtY?ehM=vCY\ `reuUVTK[FWVMS^nmuUZtKWZMd^_`at.tKWVUb]`a^uUZY\T n. @ e @ !u @ . ^uIKM Y\mnML. .AH:<68 8.96>
(291) 8^] 8.96>
(292) 8JZ E / 9_ 8.A.35GF ?B,.M5.=A 663 8.A.35G6./
(293) 7.86303H2I ?T2A JAA.2/ I=K928 8 ?T=A JAA./2IG39828 ?TA=JAA./2I,L<#:
(294) 828 E V_BAF6/8=F=6A7H9#O@?TM6C[MNPO[/HOO!L ?BF63I.9WCAE?BLR?TM6C MNPOOQ?GFR?BLK?BM6C2MNPOOOO ? M 7HG9 MG6A.G/ M913AA.G9 M8 ?BFH3
(295) I.9JCAK?GLK?TM6C MNPOOQ?GFR?BLK?BM6C2MNPOOOO ?B8AH:5#09=8 6A.?/ M9 ? 6AH: 5#098;CAS?TA 8H07!>E?T,M L MNPOOQ?TA 8H07!> ?TM6C2MN!OO T ?TA #:<7!>E?BM6C2MNPOOOOOO 8. H `aj.WVM=e N`aT.vr|[FUVFM,^nIKM2t:MmuY\mnL$`aT.]MUZTr^uM muL Ya:^uUZLrM_`aT.vreut.`\]M*Y\T^uI.M_vwU :M muM TF^ FMmehUZY\TeaH1IKM j:MT.Md©K^2Y\ I.`iUZTK[$`~^um`\]dMj:M ]Y\LrM e2`\WVmnM `Fvwg]dWZM `\m2`^_pqM\M Wu;\.x^pqMFMWqNw¨wUV^_Ube1TKY tY?eueuUVj.WVMS^uY t.muYFM`\WVW6^nIKM$MdK`\Lt.WVM=efH1IKUbeX 1`\eUZLrtY?eueuUVj.WVM$ *UV^uI ^uI.MUVT.U^nUZ`\W `aWZ[\YFmuUV^uIKL TwY\mu^ucKT`^uM WVg ^uIKM j:MT.Md©K^_UZT ^uM muL Ya6eht`\]dMXUbe*TKY\^_ehY$j.UV[c gKYFm1^uIKM
(296) mnMWb`^nUVFMtM mhYFmuL$`aT]dM e1Y\^nIKMvwU zMmnMT?^_iUVTv(Y\ ^nmn`F]dM=e¨i M] `aTehM MS^uI.`a^^nIKMg(`amngrmuYFLY\TKMMw`\LrtKWVMS^nYr`\TKYa^nIKMm=, 8 MWVYiYFLrY\mnMSeutM=]dUV©]`\WVWZg ^nY ^uIKMrMdK`\Lt.WVM=eY\pqM\M W Nw¨z^uI.MLrYFmuMUVTKY\mnLr`a^uUZ\M~^uIKMr^nmn`F]dMUZeS^nIKMrjM^h^nMmXUV^
(297) tM mhYFmuL$e zH1I.UZe ]Y\Tw©muL$e,^uIKM `F] ^*^nI.`^_]Y\LrtKcw^`^uUZY\TeuIKY\cKWbv(jMXLrUZTKUVLrUbehM=v UVT.euUbvwM~,Ywk N+O NCP.
(298) ;,.
(299)
(300) "!#%$
(301) #%. )
(302) . # # # # # # # # # # # #. . . J0 e % J0 ] e J0 "! Z 0 "! $ J0 "! 5 %0 J0
(303) J e 0 ] 0 ] ] J
(304) & )( !J0
(305) % 0 % % J0 %0 + * , JJ0 b J]0 JJ0 b % *%0 b * J0 " . + "% 0 ! J 0 + " .% J %0 . . ). ? ' ' ' . $ $ $. '
(306) !
(307)
(308) 0 )
(309) # 0 " ' )
(310) # "!) 0 )
(311) # "!) ? . . # #. # # # # # #. /10 . #. . # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # #. . . 0 0 ] J ] 0 0 0 0 * J0 0 % 0 J *% J0 %0 %0 %0 0 *%0 *%0 ! 0 % 0 JJ0 %0 J0 . # #. #. #. # # # # # # # # # # # # # #*%0 % J # 0 J # %0 ] # %0 # 0 J # % 0 %% # 0 J # 0 %0 ]0 ] 0 !% %0 0 %0 %0 0 0 % 0 0 ] % %0 % 0 %. . '
(312) #&
(313) '3, #%. . # # # # # # # # # # # # #. . 0 b 0 ] 0 0 0 . 0 % 0 % ] 0 % %0 % % %0 % 0 * 0 0 0 % * 0 %% %0 0 0 * M *b0 b 0 J] 0 . #. # # # . #. . #. # . . # . . A-6(3HtZ1 4Z-6(
(314). H1I.M,©mneh^]Y\T.]WVcehUZY\T~ ,M1]`\Tvwm` /mnY\L ^uI.M euMMwtM muUZLrMT?^neUbe^uI.`a^ ^nIKM1Y\TKWZg
(315) mnM `\WVUbe^nUZ] UVT?^nM[\m`^nUVYFT UbeS^uI.M$Y\TKM~^uI.`a^
(316) ,YFcKWbv c.euMrmuM .M ]d^uUZY\TfHg UZ[\cKmnM e[FUVFMT UZT3H`\jKWZM eF;$`aT.v/N ehIKY "^uI.`a^
(317) `aTig Ya^nIKMm euY\WZcw^nUVYFT UZeWb`amn[\MWZg Y\cw^ 7 t:MmuY\mnLrM vjig ^uIKMMdi^nmn`F] ^uM=v ]dYwvwMFAH1IKUZeSvwYiM eTKY\^]Y\LrM~`Fe`(ehcKmntKmnUZeuM\ j M*`amnM,]Y\Lrt.`amnUZTK[2^nIKM1T.`aUZ\M,UVT?^uM mut.muM^uY\m Yaf,Ywk *U^nI^nIKM1IKUV[FIKWZg 7 Y\tK^uUZLUbeuM v
(318) ]Y\LrtKUZWVM m Y\ ] `aLrW j I`^ Ube6LrY\mnMeucKmntKmuUbeuUVTK[Ube ^uIKM`\] ^nc.`aWw[?`atf g.muYFL'Y\c.m6MdwtM muUZLrMT?^ne ¨UV^,`atKt:M `\mne^nI.`^ YFTKM2ehM=]dYFT.v Y\.mncKTKTKUZTK[^uUZLM | YFm ^uIKM1Mdi^nmn`F] ^uM=v]YivK%M ~qUZe^uI.ML$`aiUZLc.L ]Y\LrtKcw^`^nUVYFT M] `aT[FMd^UVTehUbvwM2,Yik: H1I.UZe1Ube*j.`FvCTKM 2e 8 ^ UbeTKYa^ ]WVM=`am6`^^uI.M*LYFLrMT?^6IKY mnM .M=] ^uUZY\Tr]dYFcKWbvj:M1M zM ] ^nUVFMWZg
(319) c.euM v~UVTC,Ywk: x tKmuYFLrUZeuUVT.[ `\tKtKmnYF`F]IUbef^nIKM YFTKM tKmnM euMT?^nM vUZM T 9<;F¨n
(320) N =F *IKM muM6^nIKM FMmnTKMW\Yaw^uI.M1,Ywkeugwe^nML I.`Fefj:MMT
(321) Y\mnLr`\WViU hM=v `\T.v$tKmnY\M=v$]dYFmumnM ]d^,UZT,YwkU^ehM WwH1IKUbe1]dY\c.WZv$t.muYiUbvwM` `grYafj:YiYa^e^nmn`\tKtKUZTK[
(322) ^nIKMSeugwe^nM L ?^uIKM ]YwvwMYa*^nIKMCt.muYFMmX Y\cKWbv/jM(Y\jw^`aUZTKM v/jig/Mdi^nmn`F] ^uUZTK[ `\WV[FY\mnU^nIKL$eY\mnL$`aWZ<U h M v/UZT.ehUbvwM ,Ywk:R 8 T ^nI.`^_] `\euM\¨w`\v.vwUVT.[ren`M WVgCTKM ]dYwvwMS^uYr^nIKM
(323) eugieh^uM L Y\cKWbvCj:M
(324) eh^um`aUZ[\I?^hYFmu 1`amvA H1IKM~ehM=]dY\Tv(]Y\T.]WVc.euUZY\TUZe*^uI.`a^2^uIKMXLrUV UZT?^uM [\m`^uUZY\T c.euUVT.[~^nmn`F]dM=e*UZe*Y\m*^nIKM^uUZLrM
(325) jM UVT.[$^uIKM j:M eh^r ,M ]`aT3[FMd^=s2M eucKW^e[FUVFMT UZT H `ajKWZM erN `\T.v | ehIKY ^nI.`^Y\WZWVY *UZTK[^nIKUbe`\tKtKmnYF`F]I UV^rUZe t:YFeneuUVjKWZM^nY tKmnY\Mr^`acw^nY\WZY\[FUVM=e
(326) Ya_euUZ[\TKUV©]`\T?^~ehiU hMF j MCI`\MtKmnY\t:YFeuM v3` TKM `\tKtKmnYF`F]I ^nY vwY ^nIKUbe*UVT?^nM[\m`^nUVYFTCjigCvwM \M WVYFtKUVT.[rvKUVmnM ]d^uWZgUVTehUbvwMS^uIKMXt.muYFMm^uIKMXt.muYF[\m`aL ^uI.`a^2UZe2[\MT.Mm`^uUZTK[~^uIKM *:,%].
(327) b D. ;%?
(328) #%. !)
(329) e. . . e " ! 'Z ! $ " ! $' !$ " ! 5' !$ !)
(330) . e '
(331) b
(332) ' &
(333)
(334) )( !)
(335) ]
(336) # + ? ", # 0 ' ] )
(337) # " ) " . % + ? )
Documents relatifs
« On ne fait pas que des psychothérapies en clinique/…/On en parlait encore ce matin : est-ce qu’on a le temps de faire des psychothérapies, parce qu’on voit les gens
L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non, émanant des
AMC PAPI : Spécificités du contexte torrentiel – Rapport de Phase 1 Page 18 sur 46 Dans le cas des laves torrentielles, on peut résumer les conditions nécessaires au
Gillard, “Combinaison de la DG-FDTD avec un mod` ele de substitution pour un calcul de dosim´ etrie locale dans un probl` eme variable et fortement multi-´ echelle”, dans 18`
Le jugement porté par les femmes lettrées sur leurs soigneurs doit donc être nuancé en fonction de la personnalité de chacune, de la gravité de la maladie,
3.3 Processus d’alimentation d'entrepôt de données : Nous devons extraire, transformer et charger les données à partir des sources précédemment citées, dans l'entrepôt de
« La prophétie, ou interprétation et conférence des Écritures se fera par les ministres du Colloque, en l’assemblée où chacun dira la tête découverte ce que Dieu lui
Pendant six ans, jusqu’au premier janvier 1568, le clergé de France doit fournir chaque année au roi l’équivalent de quatre décimes, un million six cent mille livres tournois,
