HAL Id: jpa-00212560
https://hal.archives-ouvertes.fr/jpa-00212560
Submitted on 1 Jan 1990
HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access
archive for the deposit and dissemination of
sci-entific research documents, whether they are
pub-lished or not. The documents may come from
teaching and research institutions in France or
abroad, or from public or private research centers.
L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est
destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents
scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non,
émanant des établissements d’enseignement et de
recherche français ou étrangers, des laboratoires
publics ou privés.
Disorder induced adsorption of polymers
A. Baumgärtner, W. Renz
To cite this version:
2641
LE
JOURNAL
DE
PHYSIQUE
Disorder induced
adsorption
of
polymers
A.Baumgärtner
and W. RenzInstitut für
Festkörperforschung, Forschungszentrum
Jülich, D-5170 Jülich, F.R.G.(Reçeived
17 August 1990,accepted
23 August1990)
Abstract. 2014 The
competition
betweenadsorption
andentropic repulsion
of asingle self-avoiding
polymer trapped
inquenched
mediaconsisting
ofparallel, adsorbing
rods distributed at random in theperpendicular plane
are studiedby
simulations andanalytical
arguments. The chainundergoes
anadsorption
transition at finite temperature which is not observed in aregular
medium. Below and above the transition temperature, the chain is
essentially
stretchedparallel
tothe rods and shrunk in lateral directions with exponents 03BD~ = 0, 03BD~ = 1 for the
corresponding
components of the radius of
gyration.
Thesephenomena
are based on two different mechanisms,localization
by adsorption
at low temperatures and localizationby entropic repulsion
athigh
temperatures. The present model is the first where theentropic
localization occurs atarbitrary
strength
of self-avoidance.Analytical
arguments suggest, in agreement with our data, that thechain
obeys approximately
conventionalself-avoiding
behavior at the criticaladsorption
temperature. We expect that both
phenomena,
disorder inducedadsorption
andentropic
localization, can be tested
experimentally.
J.
Phys.
France 51(1990)
2641-2651 1 er DÉCEMBRE 1990,Classification
Physics
Abstracts _05.40 - 36.20 - 64.60
1. Introduction.
Flexible
polymers
chains withgradual
self-avoidance(SA) [1-13]
and strict SA[14-17] trapped
inquenched
random media have attracted much attention veryrecently.
These models arebelieved to be relevant for
problems involving polymers
ingels (filtration, chromatography,
catalysis
or extraction from porousrocks).
Furthermore,
there areapplications
inreaction-diffusion
systems
[6]
andnon-equilibrium
surfaceroughening [5].
The theoretical interest has increased since these models can serve asprototype systems
exhibiting
features of moregeneral
systems
withquenched
disorder.For ideal chains
(no
SA)
it has been shown[1,
2, 5,
6]
that the chain size shrinks forM>0,
whereu 2 =P 0 V2
measures thestrength
of thedisorder,
p o and vdenoting
theconcentration of the obstacles and the
scattering strength
of an obstaclerespectively.
This is aconsequence of the
entropic repulsion,
which causes the chain to usedensity
fluctuations ofthe disorder and to
preferentially
stay
inregions
of low obstacledensity.
It should be noted that the similarproblem
of a random walk of asingle particle
in disordered media(«
ant in alabyrinth »
[18],
is different from a random walk chain in the same media since differentensembles are considered
[ 1-7].
Theequilibrium configuration
of such a chain isstrongly
collapsed
foru2/
(4 - d)JN
1,
and forspatial
dimension d = 3 the mean square end-to-enddistance (R2)
obeys
thescaling
relation[1,
2]
where f
and N denote the Kuhnsegment
length
and the number ofsegments
in thechain,
respectively.
Thescaling
functionf (x) -
const for x ..,c 1whereas
f (x) - x- 2
for x > 1. Hence the size of the chainbecomes,
foru 2
Ùk >
1,
independent
of chainlength
NWe call this the
« entropic
localization of a random walk » inanalogy
to the Anderson localization of aquantum
particle.
This has been discovered firstby
Monte Carlo simulations[1]
]
and has been discussedintensively
later[2-13].
Inparticular, simple
arguments
asintroduced
by
M. E. Fisher(estimate
of theFlory-exponent
vF =3 / (d +
2 ))
andby
Imry
andMa
(Ising
model with aquenched
randomfield)
have beendeveloped [5, 6] leading
to thesame results as variational calculations
[2]
and the use of the results from theAnderson-localization
problem [6].
So
far,
theentropic
localization has notyet
been examinedexperimentally, although
someconjectures concerning
itsobservability
inpolymer networks [11]
]
and at thecoil-globule
transition in porous solids[10, 12]
have been made. Inparticular,
there has beengiven
evidence[3,
10,
12] that,
forsufficiently
weakSA,
the disorder-induced localization should survive. Aregime
where such weak SA isusually
realized is near a8-point.
There the influence of disorder reduces toshifting
the 9-transition towardshigher
temperatures
(the
SA-side of thetransition) According
to ourknowledge,
thequestion
ifquenched
disorderchanges
the tricritical behavior at the0-point
has not been examined up to now.In this work we
provide
the firstpolymer
modelsystem
where theentropic
localization ispresent
atarbitrary strength
of self-avoidance. Weexpect
it torepresent
anexperimentally
realizable situation.
Moreover,
thesystem
under consideration exhibits a criticaladsorption
transition which is caused
solely by
thequenched
disordered structure of thepolymer’s
environment.The main idea to assure the
independence
onSA-strength
of thephenomenon
is tostudy
ananisotropic
system,
where localization of the chain takesplace
in d’ - d dimensions and simultaneousunfolding according
to the SA-constraint isexpected
in theremaining
d - d’ dimensions. Anappropriate
choice of such a model environment is a disordered arrayof
long parallel
rods,
and hence d =3,
d’ = 2(Fig. 1).
As a consequence, weexpect
ingeneral anisotropic
chainconfigurations
with !To validate the model in a realistic situation one has to make sure that the
lengths
of the rodsare not
significantly
shorter than thelength
of thefully
extendedpolymer
chains.The second
important ingredient
in our model is assume the obstacles to beadsorbing,
which is a common situation in manyexperimental
systems.
Simultaneous presence of disorder andadsorption provides
thefollowing competition :
at lowtemperatures
the chain likes to adsorb on the rods and thus favoursregions
ofhigh density
of obstacles wherethey
can
get
localized. In contrast, athigh
temperatures
the chain isexpected
to movefreely
Fig.
1. - Sketch of twotypical
configurations
of apolymer trapped
amongrandomly
distributedparallel
rods.annihilate to lowest order and the chain is
expected
to behaveapproximately
like aconventional SAW.
These
questions
andpredictions
will be worked out in the rest of the paper, which isorganized
as follows : a lattice and continuum version of the model is defined in section 2.Section 3
presents
results from a Monte Carlo simulation.Analytical
arguments,
developed
in section4,
explain
the main resultsgiven
in section 3. Section 5 contains the summary and conclusions.2. The model and simulation
technique.
We consider a
single polymer
chain in ananisotropic
mediumconsisting
of Minfinitely long
parallel
hard rods of cross-sectiona2 pointing
in the z direction. In theperpendicular xy-plane
the rods are distributed at random with a concentration p o =
Ma2/L 2 where
L denotes thelinear dimension of the
system.
The rods areimpenetrable
andadsorbing
with a short rangeattractive
potential
ofstrengths 00
and range a. Thepolymer
chain is modelledby
aself-avoiding
walk(SAW)
where each self-intersection costs the free energykB
Tw. Forw = 0 the chain is Gaussian whereas it is
strictly self-avoiding
for w - oo .We are interested in the behavior of the
system
at small and intermediate rod-concen-trations far frompercolation
thresholds. In thisregime,
weexpect
the same results for chains with small but finite self-intersectionprobability ps, = exp (- w ), w large,
as forstrictly
SAW’s.
Furthermore,
in a continuum version of the model we can use the limitwhere
ruz) = (r 1- (s), z (s) )
denotes thespatial
coordinate of themonomer s and 6
=1 /kB
T.The first term accounts for a free Gaussian random walk in d
dimensions,
the second termcounts the number of self-intersections and the third term sums up the disorder
potential
Ualong
the chain. Thedisorder-averaged
potentials ((/)
is anarbitrary
constant whereas the correlations arewith
6 a d’
denoting
a d’ = d -1 = 2 dimensional smoothed-out delta function of width a. Hereu2 = po v2(T)
containsentropic
andenergetic
contributions from hard-corerepulsion
andshort-range
attraction of the rods. This will be further discussed in section 4.For the Monte Carlo simulation we used a lattice version of the above model on a cubic
lattice with lattice constant a. The rods are
represented by
columns of sites not accessible tothe
polymer
and p o is theoccupation probability.
Forp 0 -- 1 - p c =
0.41,
the space inbetween the rods is
percolated
in thexy-plane,
i.e. it forms an infinite network ofempty
space, and hence the
polymer
can movethrough
the wholesystem.
As thepolymer
model wetook that of Domb and
Joyce [19, 20]
on the cubic lattice. Each chain conformation has astatistical
weight
where nj
is the number of times the chain visits the latticesite j
and the sum runs over the fullspace. An
adsorption
energy4>0 >-
0 is attributed to each nearestneighbor
contact between arod and a chain
segment. Hence,
the lowest energy state of a chain adsorbed on rods is thestraight
conformation surroundedby
threeadjacent
rods,
where the chain has E = 3 Ncontacts.
(The
exponentially
rare case where the chain wastrapped
by
fouradjacent
rods wasruled
out.)
Ensembles of chain conformations are
generated by randomly applying kink-jump
andreptation algorithms during
the simulations(for
details see e.g.[21]).
Chain conformationsare selected
according
to theMetropolis
scheme : the new conformation isaccepted
ifexp
[ (Eola -
Enew) 4>O/kB
T]
>- 7], where 0 - 7] 1 is a random number. Since0 0
is theonly
energy scale in our
model,
we henceforth measure thetemperature
in units of4>O/kB.
For all simulations we took w =1,
whichyields
on the average about 10percent
self-intersections ofthe chain. Without
disorder,
theSAW-exponent v
= 0.588 is wellrecovered,
even for shortchains,
N . 20. We usedperiodic boundary
conditions in the xand y
directions. The linear dimension of the basic cell is L _150,
which is muchlarger
than the distances travelledby
thepolymer
chainduring
the simulations. Without loss ofgenerality,
we considerp = 1 -
p o =
0.7,
disregarding possible peculiar
effects at thepercolation
threshold.We took ensemble averages over chain conformations at different realizations of the random media. We have limited the number of realizations to
10,
and havecarefully analyzed
thecorresponding
fluctuations of the mean square radius ofgyration.
This is discussed in thenext section.
3. Results from Monte Carlo simulations.
Before
discussing
the effects of disorder on thethermodynamics
of ourpolymer
model,
wefirst
present,
serving
as a referencesystem,
the behavior of thepolymer
model embedded in aregular
matrix,
where the rods are distributedperiodically
on a 2 x 2 sublattice in thexy-plane
with p o = 1 - p = 0.25. The results for normalized lateral mean square radius ofrods,
E/N,
as a function oftemperature
T aredepicted
infigure
2. Asexpected,
theadsorption
transition,
where S, -->
const., occurs at T = 0. AtT =i=
0 one observesSi -
NPF.
The energy is a continuous function of T andyields
no evidence for an inflectionpoint
except
very close to T = 0.Fig.
2.- Polymer
amongperiodically
distributed rods : normalizedperpendicular
component of themean square radius
of gyration
,S1
versus temperature T for chainlengths
N = 80(A)
N = 140(0),
and normalizedadsorption
energyE(e).
This situation has to be
compared
to the case where the matrix is disordered. The results forSi
andE/N
arepresented
infigures
3 and4a,
respectively.
The differences ascompared
tofigure
2 aresignificant.
Thespecific
heatC,
estimated from the thermal fluctuations of theenergy
E/N
isdepicted
infigure
4b for N = 140 for several realizations of the disorder. Itsdisorder average exhibits a maximum at
Tc, ;:-
2.6indicating
the appearance of aphase
transition. For
temperatures
7"Tc1
chains of N « 300 arestrongly
adsorbed such thatS1
isindependent
of N,
and511 ’-
N. This is also demonstrated for T =2.0,
as anexample,
for various chainlengths
N infigures
5 and 6. The chainconfigurations
arestrongly
unfolded andlaterally collapsed
withexponents
for the
corresponding
components
of the radius ofgyration.
Theadsorption preferentially
takesplace
inregions
ofhigh
obstacledensity.
Due to finite size effects weexpect
Tel
2.6 for N -> 00.Fig.
3. -Fig.
4.- (a) Adsorption
energy per monomer,E/N,
versus temperature for various chainlengths
N.(b)
FluctuationC,
of the energyE/N
versus temperature for N = 140. Each datapoint
at onetemperature
corresponds
to aparticular
realization of the disordered arrangements of rods.Fig.
5. -Perpendicular
component of the radius ofgyration,
S$
versus chainlength
Je at varioustemperatures T.
Fig.
6. - Parallel component of the radius ofgyration,
Su2
versus chainlength
N at various temperaturesAt
high
temperatures,again
thepolymer
chain is shrunk in thexy-plane
such thatS1
isindependent
of N and511 ’"
N,
which isdepicted
infigures
5 and6,
respectively,
for T = 7.0 and T =00. This effect is observed for alltemperatures
T >Te2 = 3.6,
whereTe2
is estimated from the maximum ofSl (cf. Fig. 3).
In this case, theadsorption
energy is very small(E/N
= 0.36 for T =oo),
which indicates a different mechanism for theshrinkage
than that at low
temperatures.
Infact,
athigh
temperatures
theentropy
loss due to the presence of obstacles causes this lateralcollapse
which is a 2-dimensionalanalogy
of thelocalization of random walks in disordered
quenched
environments observedrecently
in Monte Carlo simulations of random-walk chainstrapped
in three dimensionalpercolated
media
[1, 7].
In thepresent
case, this localization effect isimposed
to the chainonly
perpendicular
to the rods due to their disorderedarrangements
in thexy-plane.
It isimportant
to note, that the
presently
considered case of apolymer
amonghard,
parallel
rodsis,
to ourknowledge,
the firstexample
where the localization effect is observed for chains with full self-avoidance. It seems conceivable that thepresent
situationmight
have anexperimental
realization. In summary,
according
tofigures
5 and 6 one observes athigh
temperature
Due to finite size effects we
expect
Te2
3.6 for N - 00. Since thehigh
temperature
compression
is apurely
entropic effect,
it is stillpossible
thatTe2 =i= Tel
even ifonly
onepeak
in the fluctuations of the energy is seen, cf.
figure
4b.Since our
interpretation
of the lateralcompression, P-L = 0,
isindependent
of theSA-induced chain
unfolding
in the z-directionleading
to v
i =1,
the samephenomena
should beobserved in a 2-dimensional model without SA. We have tested this
prediction by simulating
arandom-walk chain
(w
=0)
on the square lattice amongrandomly
distributedadsorbing
obstacles of concentration po = 1 -
p =
0.3,
at varioustemperatures.
The results forsi,
depicted
infigure
7,
are very similar to our 3-dimensional model(Fig. 3) :
si
is almostindependent
of N attemperatures
T :Tel
and T >Te2
and exhibits a maximum nearT = 2.9.
The most
prominent
feature offigures
3 and7,
the appearance of a Ndependent
maximumof
si
at intermediatetemperatures
close to theadsorption
transitionTel
is more difficult toexplain.
Since this effect is observed in two and in threedimensions,
we must conclude thatFig.
7. -Perpendicular
component of the radius ofgyration,
si
versus temperature T for various chainlengths
N of apolymer
without self-avoidance amongrandomly
distributed hard squares in twoSA is not of
primary importance
for thesephenomena.
Rather a subtle balance betweenattraction,
leading
at lowtemperatures
to theadsorption
of the chain onto therods,
and therepulsion
between chain androds,
leading
to localization athigh
temperatures,
seems to beresponsible
for the emergence of conventional SA behavior at intermediatetemperature
between twocompressed
states at low andhigh
temperatures.
We come back to a morequantitative explanation
of thispoint
in section 4.This
picture
issupported by
thetemperature
dependence
of Sf
asdepicted
infigure
5. Oneobserves,
starting
at T = ao, withdecreasing
temperatures
anincreasing
range ofN,
whereSi
seems toapproach
SA behavior -N2 J’P.
Of course, from the data we cannot exclude otherexponents
close to vF.Also,
from our data is not clear whether there is at all atemperature
where v #
0 for N --+ oo, which wouldcorrespond
toTel:> Te2’
On the other hand we can,especially
for the 3-dimensionalsituation,
not exclude that there is a finitetemperature
window
Tel
TTe2
withS1. ,....,
NvF
In the next section we willgive
ananalytical
argument
for the existence of a
single
criticaltemperature
where
repulsion
and attraction are balanced such thatand v =
1/2
in d = 2 areexpected
from the lowest orderapproximation.
4.
Analytical
arguments.
Here we will
give
someanalytical
estimates which allow a morequantitative understanding
ofthe
phenomena
discussed sofar,
especially
the localization and simultaneous chainunfolding
by
self-avoidance(SA)
in presence of disorder(Eqs. (5))
and the occurrence of a maximum infigures
3 and 7 withapproximately
free behavior(Eq. (6)).
This will be done in twosteps.
Starting
from thescaling properties
of the Hamiltonian(Eqs.
(3))
we willgeneralize
Flory-Imry-Ma
type arguments
for thepresent
anisotropic
model. Two different versions of the disorder term in thesearguments
have beenproposed
for theisotropic
situationindependently
by
Edwards and Chen(henceforth
EC[3])
on one hand andby
Cates and Ball[5]
andNattermann and one of the
present
authors[6] (henceforth CBNR)
on the other hand. In asecond
step
thetemperature
dependence
of the disorder correlation(Eq. (3b))
will be derived in anapproximative
schemeleading
to a mean-fieldtype
formula foru 2( T),
which exhibitsexactly
one zero at T =Tc.
The basic idea of these
arguments
is to estimate thesaddle-point
of thepartition
functionexp ( -
f3 F) = L
exp (-
/377) by using scaling properties.
For oursystem,
the free energy isconfig. estimated as
The first and second term on the r.h.s. of
equation (7)
describe thestretching
andcompression
of a Gaussian random walk where we havegeneralized
the commonexpression
(see
e.g.[22])
to ouranisotropic
situation.(It
is easy to show that thelongitudinal
forth term there are the above-mentioned two versions of the disorder contribution.
Extremizing
F withrespect
toRp
we obtainExtremizing
F with respect toR,
andinserting
equation (8)
we obtainBefore
discussing
equation
(9)
for the 3-dimensional case we mention that for a 2-dimensionalrandom walk without SA
( w
=0)
the first term inequation (9)
becomes irrelevant for Nu oo at u # 0 and we obtain the localization result v 1 - 0 with the sameamplitude
forboth EC and CBNR in
agreement
with[3,
5,
6]
Now we retum to the discussion of
equation (9).
Without disorder(u
=0)
the first and thirdterm balance for N - oo and the usual
Flory-result
for SAWsis
recovered,
inagreement
withequations (6)
whenanticipating u (Tc)
= 0 as shown below.The
Flory-solution, equation (11),
isspoiled by
either of the disorder-terms as soon asu #= 0
if N -+ 00.Furthermore,
the solutionRJ.. = Rc, equation (10), only
survives forw :: ur 3.
In ourmodel,
this condition isonly
fulfilled at very lowtemperatures
where theadsorption
becomes sostrong
thatR,
= a, aregime
which ishardly
accessible to the Monte Carlo method. Forstrong
SA,
which we are interestedin,
SA is relevant onall length
scalesstarting
from lattice constant whereas disorder is irrelevant for R «R,
and thereforeW >-
ur 3. Consequently
theonly
solution in presence of disorder comes frombalancing
thethird and fourth terms in
equation (9)
whichyields together
withequation (8)
the resultfor both EC and CBNR with similar
amplitudes (see Eqs. (2))
Al. = w2/f5 u3
andA
p= f4u2/w
for(CBNR)
andA 1 -
( / fu 3) i /2
andA
= fu
for(EC).
With the resultequation (12)
we havegiven
asimple qualitatively
correctexplanation
of the simulational resultequation (5).
Of course, itmight
be worthwhile tostudy
theprefactors
in detail insubsequent
work.Now we consider the second
point,
thetemperature
dependence
ofu 2.
Thepotential
U(r1 )
acting
on apolymer
segment
atposition
r1 isrepresented by
a sum over thepositions
ri
ofscattering
sources(obstacles)
times the interactionpotential 0
(r 1 - r i ).
8 e
contains atemperature-independent
hard-corerepulsive
and atemperature-dependent short-range
attractive
part
withamplitudes
v o and v= 4>O/kB T,
respectively.
Thesimplest
way toproceed
at thispoint
is to assume a Gaussianprobability-distribution
for thescattering
strengths
of the sources, butaltematively
one obtains the same result as a lowest orderAfter
performing
theintegration,
e.g. forand
taking
the limit a --+ 0 we obtainequation (3b)
withwhere we have
neglected higher
corrections.Independent
of thespecific potential
used for thederivation,
equation
(14)
represents
a feature which isgenerally expected :
Forsimple
potentials
with one formparameter,
as in our case, there isexactly
one zeroM(7c)
= 0. This isbasically
ourargument
forequation (6a)
and for the appearance of a maximum infigures
3 and 7. Fromequations (10)
and(14)
we havewith
A o
=Tfluo
andT,
=Ûlluo.
Qualitatively,
the mean-fieldtype
result,
equation (15),
describes very well the observed behavior. In order to demonstrate
this,
we have fitted our2-dimensional data with
u ( T) given
inequation (14).
The curves shown infigure 7
for finitechain
length
N are obtained on the basis of thescaling
function[2]
where
Rc( T)
isgiven
inequation (15).
All three curves areproduced using
asingle
set ofparameters
uo,Mi,
f.
Of course near the criticalpoint Tc
fluctuations willmodify
the criticalbehavior,
which iscertainly
aninteresting subject
for future work. The situationright
at the criticalpoint
will be consideredanalytically
in aseparate
paper in detail.5.
Summary
and conclusions.In the
present
work,
we have considered a modelsystem
consisting
of aself-avoiding polymer
chain
trapped
in aquenched
disordered array ofparallel adsorbing
hard rods. The model hasbeen studied
by
means of Monte Carlo simulations andby analytical
arguments.
It is demonstrated that the chain exhibits an
adsorption
transition at finitetemperature,
which is not observed if thearrangement
of the rods isperiodic.
Below and above the transitionpoint,
thepolymer
chain isessentially
stretchedparallel
to the rods and shrunk inperpendicular
direction such that thecorresponding
components
of the radius ofgyration
arevll = 1
and v 1 -
0,
respectively.
It isargued
andsupported by Flory-Imry-Ma
type
arguments
that the twophenomena
at low andhigh
temperatures
are based on two different mechanisms : at lowtemperatures
the localization of thepolymer by
adsorption
on the rods isdominating,
whereas athigh
temperatures
the localizationby entropic repulsion,
in formalanalogy
to the Anderson localization ofquantum systems,
isprevailing.
Thepresent
modelseems to be the first one where the
entropic
localization ispresent
atarbitrary strength
of self-avoidance. The existence of a criticaltemperature
where the twocompeting
mechanismscompensate
eachother,
issupported by analytical
arguments.
Moreoverthey
suggest,
inagreement
with the Monte Carlodata,
that thepolymer
chain resumes conventionalself-avoiding
characteristicswith VII
=V 1.
%.-- 3/5.
be tested
experimentally.
Wesuggest
that also in othergeometries
the samephenomena
canbe
observed,
aslong
asthey
providè
all the necessaryingredients,
disorder,
adsorption
andanisotropy.
Agood
candidate is alayered
structure(lateral
dimension d’ =1)
whichmight
beexperimentally
realizable,
e.g. as a disordered stack of porous sheets.In this context, a remark
concerning
thethermodynamic
limit seems suitable : effects whichmight
occur inexponentially large
systems,
such as Lifshitz tails[24]
or slow cross-overbehavior at
marginality [25],
are not considered here. Infact,
they
are very difficult to find in Monte Carlo simulations as well as in realphysical
systems
[24, 25].
The critical
properties
of theadsorption
transition have notyet
been examined.Also,
the characteristics of thechain
configurations
atT,
are notyet
knownexactly.
The latterpoint
will be considered in detail elsewhere.In the
present
work,
the diffusion of thepolymer
chain has not beenconsidered,
since theapplied
Monte Carlotechnique (combination
ofkink-jump
andreptation algorithm)
does notprovide
a realisticdynamics. Recently,
the diffusion of chains has been studied in a similar(athermal)
disordered medium withoutadsorption [26],
where anomalous diffusion has beenobserved,
butentropic
localization was notdetected,
probably
because the chains were tooshort.
References