PrefixStream: A Balanced, Resilient and Incentive Peer-to-Peer Multicast Algorithm
23
0
0
Texte intégral
(2) INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE. PrefixStream: A Balanced, Resilient and Incentive Peer-to-Peer Multicast Algorithm Anh-Tuan Gai — Laurent Viennot. N° 5514 Mars 2005. N 0249-6399. ISRN INRIA/RR--5514--FR+ENG. Thème COM. apport de recherche.
(3)
(4)
(5) "!#$&%'%
(6) ( *)+,
(7) %.- /&01 2304/(576 8 %' $9 (:;2<=%8 > ? @=A B8CED=FG@HIFGJ KML FGDNPOQ@SRUT JVOQ@=@WGR XY[Z]\_^
(8) `a3bdcfehg1ikjlZ]\_^Pimno\_\
(9) p[q[rsm'tuqoj8i vMwxnzy{^'j}|3gQwxn~,^' tu[nowkj 1^wx^]m8Y[^]wxm8Y4^qG=u['cbtzw8iuuQc Ptzu^Pi ∗†. ∗†. ]'[uu ^m'nuq4ilr [^'w<jxY[^[wxnu4 ^]\¡nu¢\
(10) p[ jlrsm'tuikjlrq[ti{jxwl^Ptz\£nu¢4tum8¤o^jxir q¥tItuwlo^Uilm]tz^ G^'^]wk¦§jlnu¦§G^'^]w ^]qh¨Qrwxnuq[\©^'qQjPª«¬qjlYtjmnoqojx^hj]®h~,^3ikjlwx^]ixi jlY[wx^'^3¢¯^Ptjlp4wl^Pi'°¢¯nuwx~tzw8 1r q4 nQtu ikY[nop[s G^^]±Qp4tu g©4tzstzq4m'^] tz\©nuq[
(11) q[n1 1^]i]®hjlY4^3ixm8Y[^'\©^ikY4nup[s UG^wl^Pikr r^'qQj,jln_q[n1 1^3¢²tzr p4wl^Pi tuq4 UG^'^]wxi ilY[nop[ ©Yt³¨u^rq4m^]qojxr ¨o^jlnm'nhnuG^'w8tjl^oªbtzrq[ g
(12) 4tuil^] ©noq©jlY[^Eik^]\_rq4tu4~,nuwx¤nz¢&eh4 r j8eQjxwl^Ptz\´~Y[rsm8Y tzwljlrstz gtum8Y[r^'¨o^]ijxY[riunQtzsi'®~ ^[wlnonQik^Utuqµtzunowlr jlY[\¡otzjlY[^]wlrq[ jlnou^'jlY[^]w<jlY[^Pik^UjlY[wx^'^¶¢¯^Pt¦ jxp[wx^]i]ªµ«·jxi©\¶tzrq¸tu 1¨tzqQj8tzu^ri
(13) jxnwx^] [p4m^jlY[^ ¢¯nowl~tzw8 1rq[noto µnz¢E^'¨u^]wlgq4nh [^jxn¹jxY[^"i{jxwl^Ptz\ tzq4 1~rs hjxY»º¯^]¨u^]wlgq[n1 1^ p[[notu 4i
(14) toi\pm8Y¼tui
(15) r j_ 1n~q[noto [i8½.ª XY[ri
(16) p[ jlr\¶tjl^ notu µ4tzstzq4m'r q4 rsi_tum8Y[r^'¨o^] jlnou^'jlY[^]w
(17) ~r jlY¥t¹mp4ikjl^'wxrq[¹ixm8Y[^'\©^ tz n~rq[I[r ¦¬ 1r wx^]mjlrnuq4tu¾^'1m8Ytzq[o^]i]ªXY[rsi
(18) wx^¦ ilp[ jxi r qwl^Pikrr ^]q4m^}jlnq4nh [^¢²tzrp[wl^Pi tuq4 ¶jxY[^}Gnoixilr [rr¿j{g©nz¢ 4tzq[rsilY[r q4q[n1 1^PiMjxY4tj 1nq4nzj wx^]ilG^]m.j wx^]m'r 4wln1mr j{gnu¢M^[m8Y4tuq[u^Pi'ªXY[rsi}tzG^'w}4wlno\_nujl^Pi} 1rsi¯y{nor qQjmp4i{jx^'wxr q4tui}nu[Gnoil^] jxnU[wx^'¨hr nop4il g 4wlnonQik^P Y[r^'w8tzw8m8Y[rsm'tu=m' pi{jx^'wxr q[Iixm8Y[^]\_^Pi'ª«¬qojx^'wx^]ikjlrq[ugu® ¨tzwxgQrq[ jxY[^UikrÀ'^¶nu¢mp4i{jx^'w8i<tz n~i jxnµnu[jxtzrq/ 1r ÁG^]wl^]qQjUjlw8tu 1^'¦§nuÁ+iU^'j{~ ^]^'q/ 1^]t³g¼nu1jxr \©rÀ]tjxr noq/tzq4 ¸wx^]ilr r^'q4m'^ jlnµq4nh [^I¢²tzrp[wl^Pi'ª XY4^¶^]wk¢¯nowl\¶tzqm^]inu¢il^'¨o^'w8tzMtu onuwxr¿jxY[\¶i3tuwl^Utuq4tzghÀ'^P ¹tuq4 mnu\©4tuwl^P ~r jlYwx^]ilG^]m.j<jxn jlY[^Pik^ onotui]ª XY[^4wlno4tzQtjlrnuq© 1^]t³g1i=nz¢+jxY[^]il^}tzunowlr jlY4\©iÂtu[G^]tzwMjln<G^~r¿jxY[rqt3¢²tumjlnuw}uªÃEjlnE¢¯wxnu\ jxY[^'nowl^'jlrsm'tuGno1jlr\¶tz§ª Ä"ÅQÆ+ÇxÈÉ Êu G^'^]wk¦§jlnu¦§G^'^]w]®[ikjlwx^]tu\©r q[®h\p[ jlrsm'toi{j. ý ø'÷zþÿËÍóÌu9ùÎzËÍoÏ#û'ÿ'Ð&ó³Ñ'óÒ{Ó]Ô³ Õ{ zÖ³û.Ò{ózÑ.þzԳׯû]ØkøSÙÛù
(19) ³Ú þ Ñ.ÜÝ8ÞÃÖ³Õß³ÕáàÑ.âÃÔ³Ò{ÕlÝ8ÔoÙäã8åPækç.èêéhÕìë+í³Õ{î§ÖÝ{ï'Ù¸ðקÝ8Ö³Ò{Õ.Ù»ñ]ò]óPô1õ.ö]÷uøó ù§ú³øzû4ü â Ö³Ý8Ö³Ò Ý8×9âÃÕ ³×²Ñ ²Õ¬Ø[Ý8ÞÃ×[Ý8ÞÃ×9ß³ÕÂâ ë <Ý8î§îVÕÂß³ÕÂß³Ñ.Ö³Ö kÕ{î ×§Ý .Ý8Þà ∗. †. Unité de recherche INRIA Rocquencourt.
(20)
(21) &= 6 ;2<=%8 > % ¹6 $&%2 %. % ©6%'% , $&%$9
(22) (6 $ ©6 %µ% %. ,2¶2 = %2 tzqiÂm^4tu[r ^]w]®q4nup4iÂm'nuq4ilr 'wxnuq4i ^[wxnu4 Z]\_^ 1^st 1r¿Á+p4ilr noq_ p[q 4p[
(23) 1^4tu±Qp[^'jxi 4tzq4i
(24) p[q ^'qh¨hr wxnuq[q4^'\©^'qQj4tur w 4tzrw¶ 1^owxtuq4 1^ Pm8Y[^'^uª tzq4i©m^ mnoqQjl^hjx^u®Âq[nop4i©m8Y[^'w8m8Y[nuqi. no1jl^]q[rwjlwxnursi<[wxnu[wxr 'j Pi'°<st m8Y4tzwxu^©r st" 1r ÁGp4ilrnuq 1nur j jxwl^¶w 'tzwljlr^ P±Qp[r¿j8tz[^'\©^]qojilp[w ^'q4il^'\
(25) [ ^ 1^]i 4tzrw8i'®P ^,ilm8Y '\¶t 1^, 1r¿Á+p4ilr noq 1nor¿j 'jlwx^¾w ]ilrikjxtuqQjS¢²tum^ st¨unotzjlr r j 1^]i&q[nh^'p4 [i ^j ^]i=tzrwxi 1nor ¨o^'qQj jxwl^rq4mr j Pi mnhnu 'wx^'wPª Mq©4tuwkj8tzqQjM 1p_jlw8t³¨tzrhi '\©rq4tz 1^eh[r¿j.eQjlwx^]tu\±Qp[r[^]q GnoixilZ] 1^ ky Ep4q[^4tzwljlr^u®uq[nup4i=4wlnonQiknoq4i&p4q©tu onuwxr¿jxY[\©^,±Qp[r4nQililZ] 1^ ^]q4il^'\4 ^ 1^Pi=[wlno[wxr 'j ]i ilnup4Y4tzr j ]^]i]ªehnoq_4wlrq4mr4tu[t³¨³tuqQjxtzo^ ^Pi{j¾ [^w P 1p[rwl^st<m8Y4tzwxu^ 1^m8Y4to±op4^,q4nQ^]p4 ©tzp¶ ][r¿j, 1p 4p1 ºVm8Y4tu±Qp[^3q[nh^'p wx^jxwxtuq4il\_^'jtup1jxtuqQj [^ [nuq[q ]^]i±Qp r &^'q wl^ nur j8½ª¾` ^jkjx^<w ]4tzwljlr jlrnuqr ]tz^< 1^t m8Ytzwxu^^]ikjtjkjx^'rqQjl^34tzw p[q[wxn1m^Pililp4i¾ [^Ewx^'owlnop[^]\©^'qQj 1^Pi¾q[nh^]p4 [i,^]wl\©^'jkjxtuqQj ]otz^'\©^]qoj, 1^]i Pm8Y4tzq4u^]i9[r [r wx^]mjlrnuq[q[^]i]ª&«¬Q^'qw Pikp[ jl^ p[q[^ w Pikrsi{j8tzq4m'^¾tzp[34tuq[q[^Pi&^'j stGnoixikr[r r j , 1^¾4tuq[q[rw&^]i q4nQ^]p4 [i}q[^wx^]il^Pm.jxtuqQj}4tuit¶w ]m'r 4wln1mr j [^]i Pm8Y4tzq4u^]i]ª` ^4tz4r ^]w}[wxnup[¨o^ 'Qtz^'\©^'qQj rqQj 'w j [^ m'nuq4ikjlwxp[rwl^ 1^Pi
(26) owlnop[G^]i_q[nh^'p4 1¦· 1rsi²y{nurqoj8i©4tzw©no[nQikr jlrnuq tzp1¼[wln1m'^]ixikp4i_ 1^ wx^'uwxnup4^]\_^]qQj Y4r ]wxtuwxm8Y[rs±Qp[^]i [wxnuGnoi ]i= [tuq4i 1^[w ]m ] 1^]qoj8i=4tz4r ^]wxi]ª Mq_¢²turixtzqQj¨tzwxr ^]wstEjxtur ^ [^]i=uwxnup4^Pi'®noq no1jlr^'qQjp[q"rqQj ]wl^PilixtzqQj}mno\©[wlno\©ri^]qojxwl^< nu1jxr \©rsiltzjlrnuq" 1pI ]tur&^jEt©w ]ilrikjxtuq4m^<tup14tuq[q[^Pi'ª &^]i^]wk¢¯nowl\¶tuq4m^Pi 1^ 1r Á ]wl^]qoj8i tzunuwxr jlY[\©^]iiknoqQj tzqtzghi '^PiU^'j m'nu\©4tzw '^PiU^]q/¢¯nuqm.jlrnuq» 1^]i 4wlno[wlr j ]i3wx^]m8Y[^]wxm8Y ]^]i]ª &^© 'stzrM 1^¶[wxnutzotzjlrnuq [^_ ^'q4il^'\
(27) [ ^¶ 1^Um'^]i<tu onuwxr¿jxY[\©^]iE^]ikj p4q ¢²tom.jx^'p[w±Qp[r9¨tuwlr^E^]qQjlwx^_o®
(28) ^'jE
(29) [^< nu1jxr \¶tu+jlY ]nuwxr±Qp[^oª ìÉ P Ç 4tur wl¦ z¦§tzrw]®h 1r ÁGp4ilrnuq . .
(30) . . . . . . . . ! ) . . $#!. * % .!. -&. '&. +&. /. . . %. %. 1 2!. ) . % . . %. (. $. %. . 43. 1. %. . ) . : . >!. ) . % (&. +0. /. 86. . . ) . . %. , %. ( 5. 6. $ % . 1. % . %. %. =< . ( ,!. (. +0. %. ;.
(31) . . #. $ %. . . . "!. 7 (. . . (. (. 9!.
(32)
(33) !#"$&%'()'&
(34) +*& ,- '(.!/0&213 34150,7698:; 5' % < =>42'( @?A. B. G)
(35) &=2¶ 6¾ %2 XY4ri,4tu^]w[wlnonQik^Pi tuqtu onuwxr¿jxY[\ ¢¯nuw\p4¿jxrm]tuikjikjlwx^]tu\©r q[
(36) r q t_¨u^]wlg©stzwxu^Eixm'tu ^3G^'^'wl¦§jlnz¦·G^'^'w q4^j{~,nuwx¤Gª ^m]tz \
(37) p[ jlrsm'tuikj_ikjlwx^]tu\©r q[¹tzqµtz4[ rsm'tzjlrnuq~Y[^]wl^ tIilnup[w8m^Ursi_ik^]q4 1rq[t n~´nu¢ tum8¤u^'jxi}jln"ttuwlo^qhp[\G^'wnu¢ wx^]m^]r ¨o^'w8i'ª<«¬vÛ\p4¿jxrm]tuikjlrq[ rim^]wkj8tzrq[g jlY[^©\©noikj3^,DUmr^'qQj<~,t³g ¢¯now\p4¿jxrm]tuikj]®GY[n~ ^]¨u^]w jxY[^4p[wx [^'q"nz¢M 1p4[ rsm'tzjlrq[U4tom8¤u^'jxirsi}m'tuwlwxr^] hgrqQjl^'wx\©^] 1rstjx^<wlnop1jl^]wxi ~Y4rm8Y_tzwx^Mnz¢ jx^'qrq4 1^]^]q4 1^]qoj=¢¯wxnu\ÛjlY4^ilnup4wxm'^¾tzq4 jlY[^,wx^]m^]r ¨o^'w8i'ª XY[ri \¶t³g^1[stzrq~Yhg3jlw8tzq4ilr¿j q4^j{~,nuwx¤hi,Y4tuwx [ g¶^]¨u^'wr\©[^'\©^'qQj«¬v¸\p[ jlrsm'toi{jxr q44ª aEq<jxY[^¾nujlY[^]w&Y4tuq4 S®ztzjkjl^]qQjlrnuq<rsi&q[n~m'^'qQjl^]wl^P nuq^]q4 h¦¬ikg1ikjl^'\Ûnuwtz[4 rsm'tzjlrnuq1¦· ^]¨u^]z\p[ jlrsm'toi{j ~Y4^'wx^ÂjlY[^ 4tzwljlrsmr4tuqoj8i9 1p[4 rsm'tzjl^MjxY[^'\¶il^'¨u^PiSjlY4^¾4tom8¤u^j8#i E [F® B[®³u1®oP1®uF G!H·ªb"nQi{j nz¢1jlY4^M^1rsi{jxr q[ tu onuwxr¿jxY[\¶i¾ikjlr 9 [p[[rm]tjl^34tom8¤u^j8i¾tu noq[
(38) tjlwx^'^oJª I}n~ ^]¨u^]w]®Qt¢¯nowl~tzw8 1rq[q[n1 1^3~r¿jxY ilnuq4i ~r Yt³¨u^3jlnUil^'q4 ^]¨u^]wlgUtum8¤u^'j d jlr\©^]i}wl^P±op4r wxr q4©tuq p[[notu 4tuq4 1~rs hjlY d jlr\_^Piuwx^]tzjl^]dwjlY4tuq jlY[^ ikjlwx^]tu\á4tzq 1~r 1jlY9ª=XY[rsi=[wlrq[QiÂt}\¶ty{now 1)r DUm'p[¿j{g~Y[^'q
(39) ¢¯nuwx~,tuwx [^'w8i&\¶t³g<G^,^]q4 _p4il^'w=wl^Pm^]r ¨o^'w8i Yt³¨Qrq[Ut©¨o^'wxgn~Ûp4[ nQtu m'tu4tum'r¿j{goªe1[ r j8ehjlwx^]tzK \ E Hilnu¨u^PijlY4ri}[wlno[^'\#Qg p4ilr q4 rqQjl^'wxrnuwl¦ q4nh [^¦¬ 1ri²y{nurqQjMjlwx^'^Pi ilp4m8Y©jxY4tj,^'¨u^]wlg_q[n1 1^Eri,t¢¯nuwx~tzw8 1^'wMrqUnoq[^jxwl^]^}tzq4 t^]t¢9q4nh [^}drqUnzjxY[^'w8i'ª XY4riEilm8Y[^]\©^tz n~ijln\
(40) p[ jlrsm'tuikjEtUikjlwx^]tu\(~Y4noil^4tzq 1~r 1jlY"rsiEm' nQik^<jxn¶jlY4^\©r q4r \¶tz p[[noto m]tz4tomr j{g nz¢ q4nh [^]i]ª
(41) eh[r¿j.eQjlwx^]tu\drsi< 1^]ilr oq[^] Ijln tu [tu1j3jln ¨tzwxrtu[ ^
(42) q[n1 1^¶m'tu4tum'r¿jxr ^Pi'ª r ÁG^]wl^]qoj ¢¯nowl~tzw8 1^]wxi¾\©t³gUjlYhp4iY4t³¨o^ [r¿Á+^'wx^'qQj 1^'owl^]^]i]ª L4nuwjxY[riwl^Ptuilnuqilnu\©^^hjlw8t¦·p[[noto ¶rsiq[^'^P 1^] jln or ¨o^3il:p DUmr^'qQj,¢¯wl^]^] 1no\ jln_jlY4^ilg1i{jx^'\ ~Y4^'qq4nh [^]imnoqQjlrqQp4nup4il g©^]qojx^'wtzq ^]t³¨o^jlY4^3q4^j{~,nuwx¤Gª XY4^_tu onuwxr¿jxY[\ m'tzqjlYhp4i3nuq4 g"op4tzw8tzqQj{gjlY4tzj3q[n1 1^Pi3~r =p4ik^©tzq¹p[[noto Iwxnup[oY[ g ^P±optzjlnjlY[^ ikjlwx^]tu\ 4tuq4 1~rs hjlY9ªMbInuwx^'n¨u^]w]®Qwx^]mnoq4ikjlwxp4m.jxr noqt¢ jx^'wt_q[n1 1^¢²tur p[wx^m]tzq ^<w8tjxY[^'wrqQjlwxrm]tjl^oª M il^]m'nuq4 1r DUmp[ j{gwx^]ilr [^]irq¹jxY[^¶wx^'rtu[r r j{gInz¢q[n1 1^]i]ª¶«·¢t ¢¯nuwx~,tuwx 1^]w}¢²tur si]®&r jY4tui3jxn"^ wx^'4tom^] _¨o^'wxg
(43) ±Qp[rsm8¤Qg
(44) jlnwx^¦·^]ikjxtu[ rsilYjxY[^¢¯^]^] 1rq[nu¢S [n~q4i{jxwl^Ptz\q[n1 1^]i]ª r¿jxYt<stzwxu^qhp[\G^'w nu¢&4tuwkjxrm'r 4tuqQjxi]®ojxY[rsi ^]¨u^]qojmnop[s UY4tu[^]q ±Qp[r jl^E¢¯wx^]±Qp[^'qQjx goª=X n_\©tu¤u^3wl^Pmnoq4i{jxwlpm.jlrnuq¨u^'wxg_¢²tuikj]® N}rm' ^ E B H tzq9 O+r oÀ]tzP EÃz! H p4ik^Pit¶ilr \©rtuwY[r ^]wxtuwxm8Yhg¶nu¢=m' p4ikjl^]wxijln¶[p[rs "t_ilrq[u^<\p[ jlrsm'toi{jjxwl^]^uª Y4^'qµt"q[n1 1^©¢²tur si]®r j
(45) m]tzqG^Uwl^][stum^P Qgikno\©^UnzjxY[^'wq4nh [^Unz¢r¿j8im' p4ikjl^]w]ª` p4ikjl^'wxrq[ jlYhp4i or ¨o^]i=jxY[^]il^Eixm8Y[^]\_^PiMonQn1 ©wx^]ilr r^'q4m'^jlnq4nh [^¢²tzrp[wl^Pi'®Q[p1j jlY[^E[wx^]il^'q4m'^nz¢9Gn~ ^]wk¢¯p4[¢¯nuwx~tzw8 1^'w8i ~r jlY p[4 nQtu 4tzq4 [~r hjxY
(46) jxn"]jlr\©^]iY[ruY4^'wjlYtzq jlY[^<ikjlwx^]tu\ 4tzq 1~r 1jlY ri}i{jxr &tuixilp[\©^] Sª Q Å S R5T
(47) UVT É Vu ^
(48) j8tzwxu^'j3tUstzwxu^_ilm]tz^
(49) ilg1i{jx^'\ ~Y[^]wl^¢¯nuwx~,tuwx 1rq[Ursi3\¶tu 1^_hg"^'q4 p4ik^]wxi jxY[^'\¶il^'¨u^Pi'ªº²XY[rq[¤©nz¢9twxto 1r nikjlwx^]tu\wx^]m'^'r¨u^P _tuq4 ©¢¯nowl~tzw8 1^]
(50) hg©nuq[^\©r rnuq M e p4il^'w8i=¢¯nuw ^'[tz\©[^uªÃ½ «¬q"jlY4tzjEmnoqQjl^hj3\©tuqhgq[n1 1^Pi\¶t³g Y4t³¨u^tU r\©r¿jx^] "p[4 nQtu "m'tu4tum'r¿j{goª M¨u^]wlg q[n1 1^
(51) ri jxYhp4iwl^P±Qp[r wx^] jln©Y4t³¨o^<t
(52) \©rq[r\©tu9p[[noto m]tz4tomr j{g u jln©4tuwkjxrm'r tjl^rq jlY[^<q[^'j{~ nowl¤+ª r¿jxY jlY[^ ikjlwx^]tu\ 4tzq 1~r 1jlYq[nuwx\¶tzr À]^] jxn ® ilY[nop[ r [^]tzgI^¶toiEm' nQik^
(53) jln tui3nQililr[ ^oªº¯«¬q 1^'^P S® ~,^3jxtuwlo^jtzq tzunowlr jlY[\ê~r jlY p[4 nQtu1 4utzq4 [~r hjxY ^]±Qp4tz+jxn 1 ¢¯nuw^'¨o^'wxg¶q[1n1 1^uªÃ½ b"nowl^]n¨u^]w]®G~ ^©ilp[[Gnoil^jxY4tj<q[n1 1^PiEq4^'^] ¹rq4m^]qojxr ¨o^jxn m'nhnuG^'w8tjl^o°~,^©ilp4il^Pm.j3jlY4tzjtq[n1 1^ ~r jlYuwx^]tzjl^'w,m'tu4tum'r¿j{g_~r +q[nzjrqojx^'q4 Ujln©ikG^'q U\©nuwx^jlYtzqtuqp[4 nQtu u ~Y[^'qr¿jm'tuqU^'qQjx^'w,jlY[^ q4^j{~,nuwx¤ tuq4 "wx^]m^]r ¨o^<jlY4^_ixtz\©^
(54) ikjlwx^]tu\#±Qp4tu r j{g hg ilG^'q4 1rq[nuq[g u ª<ehp4m8Y¹^]Y4t³¨hr now}Y4toi}G^'^]q no4il^'wx¨u^] rXq W ^ ikYtzwxr q[¹tz[[rsm'tjxr noq4i
(55) ~Y[^'wx^U¢¯wx^'^wlrs 1^'w8Yi E [® F Z!Hjl^'q jlnp[[noto nuq4 gr ¢jlY4^'g m]tzq[q4nzjE 1n~q4 nQtu nzjxY[^'wx~ril^u0ª [,r jxX nuwxwl^]qo\j EÃ! H\¶tu 1^tU\©tzy{nuwE[wl^Ptz¤QjlY4wlnop[uY r qIjlY4tzjE 1nu\¶tur q"hg 4p[r s 1rq[¶rq4m^]qojxr ¨o^3jlY[wxnup[oYUjxr¿j¢¯nowjxtzj]ª C. . . <. 16. 0. Ð Ð#Ö]4ç.çPæ_^.
(56) . ' ',- 4. XY[rsiil^' WilY^]Y4t³¨hr now<jlYhp4ir q 1p4m^PijxY[^toililp[\©1jlrnuq jxY4tj
(57) ^'¨u^]wlg¹q[n1 1^U~r tz4[wln³1r\¶tjl^] g or ¨o^jxY[^"iltu\©^ p4[ nQtu u jlnjlY[^"tu[[rm]tjlrnuq&ª¼«¬q¼jlY4tzjUik^]q4ik^ ~,^"tzwx^nhnu¤hr q4¢¯now©t4tutuq4m^P tu onuwxr¿jxY[\ ª M [wxnotu [^'w}ixm^]q4tzwxr n~ nop[ mnuqikrs 1^'wEq[n1 1^]iE~r jlY¨tuwlghrq[Up[[noto Im'tu4tum'r¿jxr ^Pi}~Y4^'wx^ q4nh [^]iilG^'q4 1rq[I\©nowl^Um]tz4tomr j{grqojx^'q4 jxnIwx^]m^]r ¨o^Ut ^'jkjx^'w©i{jxwl^Ptz\¡±Qp4tu r j{guª M 4wl^'jkj{g ikr\©[ ^ ~t³gjln tum8Y[r^'¨o^jlY4ri3~r jlY[rq¹nop[wE¢¯wxtu\_^]~ nowl¤ rsijxn il^j<t [r¿Á+^'wx^'qQjEq4^j{~,nuwx¤¢¯nowE^Ptum8YIp4[ nQtu ¹m't¦ tumr j{guªº &nhnu¤hr q4
(58) tj j{gh[rm]tzG«¬qQjl^'wxq[^'j,mnoq[q[^Pm.jlrnuqi'®Qp4il^'w8i m]tzqU^Ptuilr g
(59) G^3uwxnup[G^] ©p[q 1^'w,jlY4wl^]^}nuw ¢¯nop[w¾ 1r Á+^'wx^'qQj¾p[[noto ¶m'tu4tum'r¿jxr ^Pi'ªÃ½
(60) ` noq4ikrs 1^]wlrq[3jlY[^E¨hr 1^]ni{jxwl^Ptz\©rq[m'toik^o®u\p4¿jxr [^E [^]ixmwxr 1jxr noq m'n1 1r q4 E ! H¾m]tzq^'¨u^]qtu n~ájxn QtjxY[^'w3jlY4^Ui{jxwl^Ptz\¶i3[wlnQtu [m]tuikjl^P "r q ^Ptum8Yq4^j{~,nuwx¤Imnuqikrsi{jx^'qQjlguª 5º Nn1 1^Pi~r jlY"\©nuwx^<p[[noto "m'tztumr j{g¶jxY[^'qItzwljlrsmr4tjx^]irq"\©nuwx^<q[^j{~,nuwx¤1i'ªÃ½UXY[^<tzstzq4m'^] "ixm^¦ qtzwxr n_ri,jxYhp4it_¤u^]g¶nor qQjrq nowx [^'w,jln¶ilnu¨u^EjlY[rsi[wxnoto 1^'wilm'^'q4tuwlrn4Jª L[nowjlY4tzjwl^Ptuilnuq9®QjxY[^4tzG^'w ¢¯n1m'p4ik^PinuqjlY[^<tzstzq4m'^] m'tuil^uª ^Pikrr ^]q4m^¶rsituiln"t \©tzy{nuw<onotzMm'nuq4m'^'wxq[rq[ tuwlo^_ixm'tu ^¶G^'^]wk¦§jlnu¦§G^'^]wikg1ikjl^'\¶iilrq4m^¶\¶tzqhg q4nh [^]i\¶t³g ikr\©[g¢²tur tzq4 I ^Pt³¨u^jlY4^q[^'j{~ nowl¤~r¿jxY[nup1jtzqhg4wl^]¨Qrnupi}tzq4q[nup[qm^'\©^]qojPª Lr q4tu g jxY[^<\¶t1r\©tu9 1^'st³g¶rsit©mstuixikrsm'tu+m'nuq4m'^'wxqrq \p[ jlrsm'toi{jxr q4_^PikG^]m'rtu g¶¢¯now r¨u^<ikjlwx^]tz\©rq[4ª É U+' R¯ &F R É U¾ XY[^\¶tzrq¥rs 1^]tnz¢jlY4ri_4tu^]w
(61) rsijxn¹m'nu\4r q[^nujlY tz[[wxnotom8Y[^]inz¢3eh4 r jk¦ ehjlwx^]tz\:tzq Nrsm^ OGruÀPtz©jln tum8Y[r^'¨o^<nujlY¹unotuinz¢Mwx^]ilr r ^]q4m^
(62) tzq4 ¢¯nowl~tzw8 1rq[z¦·notu 4tutuq4mrq[4ª ^"[wxnuGnoil^"tzq¸tzunuwxr jlY[\ m]tz ^P
(63) jxY4tjm'nu\
(64) [r q4^]i©GnzjlY tu[[wxnotum8Y4^]i_~r¿jxY jlY[^]r w wx^]ilG^]m.jxr ¨o^
(65) G^'q4&^ W[j8i'ªUXY[^©\¶tzrqtu 1¨tuqoj8tzo^nz¢nup4wtu onuwxr¿jxY[\ rsijlY4tzjtzÂq[n1 1^]ip4il^¶tzqp[[noto tzq4 1~rs hjxY^'1tom.jx gU^P±Qp4tzGjln_jxY[^<i{jxwl^Ptz\ 4tuq4 1~rs hjlY tzq UjxY[ri,¢¯^Ptjxp[wl^rsii{jxr S[wx^]il^'wx¨u^P Urq m]tuil^ nu¢Mq[n1 1^ 1^]4tzwljlp4wl^Pi}tzq Itzwxwlr¨tzsi'ªXY[^
(66) r [^]tUnu¢¾mno\[rq[rq[UGnzjlY¹tz[[wxnotom8Y[^]irsi3ikr\©[ ^
(67) [p1jY4tui wx^]±Qp[rwx^] jln< 1^]ilruq¶mno\_4 ^'jl^'gq[^]~ ixm8Y[^]\_^Pi¢¯nuwMq4nh [^mp4i{jx^'wxr q4tuq4 _ 1ri²y{nurqQjÂjlwx^'^m'nuq4ikjlwxp4m.jxr noq jxntum8Y4r ^]¨u^_jlY[rsi
(68) unotuVPª [tuilrm]tz gnup[w_tzunuwxr jlY[\ ¢¯nowl\¶i
(69) mp4i{jx^'w8i<hg¹QtjxY[^'wxr q4 jlnuo^jxY[^'wtu ¾jlY[^ q4nh [^]i_~Y[noil^« ilY4tuwl^ tIur¨u^]q¥[wx&^ W4+ª ^jlY[^]q m'nuq4ikjlwxp4m.j d r qQjx^'wxr nuwl¦¬mp4i{jx^'wl¦· [ri²y{nurqQj<jlwx^'^]i]ª XY4^_m8Y[norm'^
(70) nu¢ QtjlY4^'wxr q[hgI[wx&^ W[Irsi3q4tjxp[wxtu¢¯nuw<tz n~rq[ tzq¹&^ DUmr^'qQj 1rsi{jxwlr[p1jx^] mp4i{jx^'wxr q4 tu onuwxr¿jxY[\ ª I}n~ ^]¨u^'wP®r jMr \©Gnoil^]iÂtq[^]~¥jxwl^]^m'nuq4ikjlwxp4mjlrnuq©tzunuwxr jlY[\m'nu\©4tzwx^] jlne1[ r j8ehjlwx^]tz\ ª b"nowl^]n¨u^]w]®nop[w tu onuwxr¿jxY[\ilnu¨u^Pi=jlY[^}[wlno[^'\´nz¢Sur¨hr q[r q4m'^'qQjlr¨u^jxn
(71) m'nQno^]wxtzjl^o®utzq¶rq[Y[^]wl^]qoj [)r DUmp4¿j{g
(72) nz¢9mno\_4 ^'jl^'g
(73) [^]m^]qQjlw8tzr À]^] _^]^'wl¦Vjxnz¦·^]^'wMilg1i{jx^'\¶i'ª«¬q4ilr [^t<mp4i{jx^'wP®otq[noq1¦§¢¯nuwx~,tuwx 1^]w m]tzqG^ 1^'jl^Pm.jl^P ¥tuq4 4tzq4rilY[^] µQgnzjxY[^'w_\©^'\
(74) ^]wxi]ª 9rq[¤1iG^j{~,^'^]q¥mp4ikjl^]wxi
(75) m'tzq¥^p4ik^P rq GnzjxY 1rwl^Pm.jxr noq4iEº²nuq[^}jlwx^'^E~r +p4ik^Er¿j,r qnuq[^3 1rwl^Pm.jlrnuqtzq4 Utuq[nzjxY[^'w¾jlwx^'^E~r +p4ik^Er¿j,r qjlY[^3nzjxY[^'w [r wx^]mjlrnuq½ª M q[n1 1^}no\©r¿jljlrq[<jln¢¯nuwx~,tuwx _rqQjl^'wl¦¬mp4i{jx^'w¾jlw8t DUmm'tuqUG^E 1^'jl^]mjl^P Utzq4 U4tzq[rsilY[^] ©hg jxY[^<nzjxY[^'wm' pi{jx^'wq[n1 1^Pi'ª "Å ÈÉ É Ê Å { XY[^qhp[\
(76) ^]wMnz¢+q[n1 1^PiÂ~r 4G^ 1^]q[nzjx^] ©hg ª=XY[^}ilnup[w8m^rsiMtzq©^'Qjx^'wxq4tz q4nh [^3wx^'rstz[g©¢¯p[wxq[rilY[rq[_jlY[^<tum8¤u^'jxi ~r¿jxY"t
(77) tzq4 1~rs hjxY 1 º jxY[^ilnunp[w8m^ 1n©q[nzj 1p4[ rsm'tzjl^4tom8¤o¦ ^'jxi8½.ª M i~,^ilp[[Gnoil^<jlY4tzj3tu q[n1 1^]i}ur¨u^tu[[wxn³hr\¶tjx^'g¶jlY[^_iltu\©^p[[noto 4tzq4 [~r hjxY"¢¯nuw}jlY[^ \
(78) p[ jlrsm'tuikjlrq[tu[[rm]tjlrnuq&®u~,^~r Gilr\_4 g_ikp[4nQik^jxY4tj,tz[q[n1 1^]i¾Y4t³¨u^jxY[^}ixtz\©^p[[noto ©m'tztum.¦ r j{g u ≥ 1 ªMX n¶tzq4tu ghÀ'^< 1^]t³g1i]®1~ ^p4il^3jlY[^¢¯nu n~rq[_\_n1 1^]9nz¢jlw8tzqik\©rsililr noq9°=t©4tum8¤o^jwl^P±op4r wx^]i tUjlr\©^ T jxnG^
(79) ^]\_r jkjx^] ¹tzq4 Ijlw8tzq4ilr¿j8i}tUjlr\_^ L rqIjxY[^_q[^j{~,nuwx¤+ªº Y[^]qil^'q 1r q4 i 4tum8¤o^jxi}r q t_wxn~<®hjlY[^<stuikj4tum8¤o^j~r SjxYhp4iG^<wl^Pm^'r¨u^P tz¢ jl^'wEtjxr \©^ ª ½ r jlY"t P Z¤h[r j zip[[notu tzq4 1~rs hjxYtuq4 ]uoU[r jxi4tum8¤o^jxi]® T rsi3j{gh[rsm'tzgI ^Pili3jxY4tziTq +] L\¶i]ª L rsi<Y4tz ¢ nu¢¾jxY[^Ut³¨u^]wxtuu^ wxnup4q4 ¶jxwlrUjxr \©^nuqjlY[^«¬qQjl^]wlq[^'jtuq4 U¨tuwlr^]i¾j{gh[rm]tz g¶G^j{~,^'^]q u
(80) tuq4 I³z\¶i]ªÂXY[rirsiikr\©r stzw jxn¶jlY4^ 9nouv¸\©nh [^' E G!H^[m^]1jjxY4tj3~ ^ilp[[Gnoil^t W[1^] tum8¤u^'j ^]q[zjxY9ª 9n~,^'wGnup4q4 [inoq jlY[^ 6. . . 6. ;. 96. <. 6. Ð .
(81).
(82)
(83) !#"$&%'()'&
(84) +*& ,- '(.!/0&213 34150,7698:; 5' % < =>42'( @?A =>42'( @?A. "$ 4-%2 528- , 5'4 4.&?- . 6 , '( 8 4S . 4%2 & '(;8: - , 4!%%. 6 , '( ,. 8 $& 4 .!,? . . ehrq[u^X wl^]^ O(hd) d 1 h(d + l) 0 eh[r j8eQjxwl^Ptz\ E H O(hd) 1 1/d h(d + l) 1 OGruÀPtz E u! H (m − 1) 1 h((m − 1) + l) 0 ehrq[u^
(85) ` p4i{jx^'w O(m) 1/n (n − 1) + l n−1 ` p4i{jx^'w}X wx^'^ m1 1 +(n(d−−1)/n 1)/m 1/m (h − 1)(d + l) + m + l m −1 vMwx&^ W[4eQjxwl^Ptz\ uz d 1 h(d + l) + m + 2l m−1 Xtz4 ^_u° M qtzghilrsi nu¢9jlY4^3¨tuwlrnup4i G^'^'wl¦§jlnz¦·G^'^'wikjlwx^]tz\©rq[
(86) tu onuwxr¿jxY[\¶i m'nuq4ilrs 1^'wx^] r qjlY[^34tu^]w]ª [^]ilr oq4tjx^]i jlY[^< 1^]uwx^'^Enz¢&¢¯nowl~tzw8 1rq[q4nh [^]i]ª rsi,jlY[^Y[^]r oYQjnu¢ t
(87) jlwx^'^3nz¢= 1^'owl^]^ d ~r jlY n q[n1 1^]i]ª m rsijxY[^mp4ikjl^]wikrÀ'^oª l = L/T hrsi=jxY[dlog ^q[nowlne\¶tzrÀ'^] tzjl^]q4mgr q jlr\©^<¢¯nuw}^'\©r¿jljlrq[d tU4tum8¤o^j]ª M ¨tzp[^]iEtzwx^q[nowl\¶tzrÀ'^] ^]r¿jxY[^'wEr qIqhp[\
(88) ^]wEnu¢Â4tum8¤o^jxinuw}\©^Pilixtzo^]inow}rq jlr\_^¢¯nuw ^]\©r¿jljlrq[Ut_4tum8¤o^j]ª \©rq[r\p[\: 1^'st³g¢¯nuw\
(89) p[¿jxrm]tuikjlrq[t¶tum8¤u^'jjln n q[n1 1^Pim'tuq"^¢¯nup[q r q EPF H·ªXY[^q4nuwx\©tu rÀ'^P stjx^'q4m'g l = L/T ri jlY4^E\¶t1r\¶tzGqQp4\G^'w,nz¢&4tom8¤u^'jxi¾tq[n1 1^m'tzqik^]q4 Urqtwln~ G^¢¯nowl^}jlY[^ W4w8i{j tum8¤u^'jMri¾wl^Pm^]r ¨o^] Sª,º d = l ur¨u^PiMikno\©^wlnop[uY_^]ikjlr\¶tjxr noq¶nz¢+jlY[^Enu1jxr \¶tu 1^]uwx^'^¢¯nuwM¢¯nuwx~,tuwx 1^]wxi]ªÃ½ M ilr \©[^3jlY[^]nuwx^jlrsm'tun~,^'w,nop[q4 nuqUjxY[^3q[nuwx\¶tzr À]^] [^'st³g_rsi EPF H·ª ^3~r 9il^'^EjlY4tzjtjlwx^'^ nu¢ 1^'owl^]^ d tu n~ijln¹tum8Y[r^'¨o^Ut" 1^'st³g 2hd ~Y[rm8Yrsitzj\©noikjhlj{~rsm^Unuq[o^'w<jxY4tzqno1jlr\¶tzM¢¯now ª d=l ^Ip4il^"jlY4riikr\©[ ^\_n1 1^]jxnµtzq4tu ghÀ'^Ituq4 mno\©4tzwx^ jlY[^ [r¿Á+^'wx^'qQjtu onuwxr¿jxY[\¶i_¢¯nuwUG^'^]wk¦ jxnz¦·^]^'w<\
(90) p[¿jxrm]tuikjlrq[4ª In~,^'¨o^'wP®9r q [w8tumjlrsm^o® L \¶t³g¨tzwxgt nzjP® ^PikG^]m'rtu gI¢¯nowt ~ nowls ¹~r 1^ tu[[rm]tjxr noq9ªÛ` p4i{jx^'wxr q4 tu n~i_jlnno1jlr\©r À]^ 1^]t³g1i©~r jlY jlY[rsiUwx^'Qtzw8 Sª «¬q¸nup[wtzunuwxr jlY[\ ® t ¢¯nowl~tzw8 1^]w x il^'q 1r q4
(91) t<4tom8¤u^'j¾jln_tm' p4ikjl^]w YtuiÂjxY[^3 r^]wkj{g_jxn_il^'^]mj¾jlY4^}q[n1 1^ y jxnwx^]tom8Y¶r qjlY[^ m' pi{jx^'wPª«·j}m]tzqjlYhp4im8Y4nQnQik^EjlY4^<q[n1 1^<~r¿jxY"ik\¶tz^]ikjwxnup4q4 Ujxwlr jlr\©^uª M i4tum8¤o^j8i\©t³gtzwxwlr¨u^tjwx^]m^]r ¨o^'w8i,nup1jnu¢nowx 1^]w]®1tuq r\©nowkj8tzqQj\©^]tuilp[wx^ri,jxY[^qhp[\G^'wnu¢ tum8¤u^'j}jxY4tj<q[^]^] jln ^©[p[ÁG^]wl^P rq¹nowx [^'wEjln wl^]nuw8 1^'wEjlY4^©ikjlwx^]tu\ ªXY[rsi[p1Á+^'w<rq4 1^'^P ¹m]tzp4il^]i ilnu\©^ tu [ [r¿jxr noq4tz 1^]t³g jxn¹[st³g jlY4^ ikjlwx^]tu\ ª ^ ~r=y{p4i{jUm'nup[qQj©jlY[^ wx^'nowx 1^]wlrq[ [p[^ jlnjlY[^ tu onuwxr¿jxY[\£m8Y[nQik^]q¢¯nuw<¢¯nowl~tzw8 1rq[tum8¤u^'jxi]ªXY[^y{r jkjx^'w_ 1p[^¶jxnI¨tzwxrtzjlrnuq4inu¢ jxY[^¶jlw8tzqik\©rsililr noq [^'st³g~r =q[nujEG^
(92) rq4m' p4 [^] "rqIjxY[^_m'nup[qQjEtoi}r jriEwlnop[uY4 gjlY[^©ixtz\©^<¢¯nuwtz=tzunuwxr jlY[\¶i]ª Y[^'q ^]qQjl^'wxrq[jlY[^Eq[^j{~,nuwx¤+®zjxY[ri [p1Á+^'w¾jlr\©^}rq4 1p4m'^]i,t<wl^PikGnuqik^jxr \©^¢¯nowMjxY[^}p4il^'wP°9jxY[^jxr \©^3ikY[^EY4tui jxn~tzr j3G^j{~,^'^]qIY[^]w [^]mrsilr noq"jln rsikjl^'qjlnjlY[^©i{jxwl^Ptz\ tzq "jlY4^jxr \©^_~Y[^'qjlY[^©i{jxwl^Ptz\:G^'urq4i jxn©^<[st³gu^P Sª X n}^]¨³tu ptjl^¾jlY[^ wl^] rstz4r r¿j{g3nz¢1jxY[^ 1r¿Á+^'wx^'qQj=tzunuwxr jlY[\¶i]®]~,^ m'nu\©[p1jx^MjlY4^¾~,nuw8i{j9¢²tur p[wx^¾4tom8¤u^'j noixi]ª Y[^]q¥t"q[n1 1^U¢²tzri]®=~ ^Um]tzqµ 1,^ W4q[^¶jxY[^t³¨o^'w8tzu^_4tom8¤u^jnoixitoi<jlY4^t³¨u^]wxtuu^_¢¯wxtom.jxr noqnu¢ tum8¤u^'jxinoikjEhg wx^'\¶tzrq[rq[Uq[n1 1^Pi'ª3XY[riE4tom8¤u^jE nQiliEm'tzq"owl^Ptjx g 1^'G^'q "nuqI~Y4rm8YIq4nh [^¢²tzrsi'ª XY4^~ nowxikj¢²tzr p4wl^4tom8¤u^'j=noixiÂrsiM 1,^ W4q[^] ¶toi=jlY4^4tum8¤o^jÂnoixiÂnu1j8tzrq[^] _rq©jlY[^}~ nowxikjMm'tuil^º¯r§ª ^uªjlY[^ \©nQi{jr\_GnuwljxtuqQj,q[n1 1^3¢²tur si'®hj{gh[rsm'tu g©jlY4^<wlnhnzjnz¢=t
(93) jlwx^'^P½ªÂXY[ri\©^Ptuilp[wl^3rsir \©GnuwljxtzqQj^Pm'tup4ik^ r j^1[wx^]ixil^]i,Y[n~»t¶ilrq[u^q[n1 1^¢²tzr p4wl^\¶t³gr\©4tumjjlY[^<\¶ty{nowlr j{g¶nz¢=q[n1 1^Pi'<ª N}nzjlrsm^jxY4tj}t_¢¯^]~ w8tzq 1nu\ꢲtur p[wx^]irqIt_jlwx^'^<Yt³¨u^ ^Pilir \©4tom.jjxY4tzq jlY4^<¢²tzr p4wl^<nu¢jxY[^wxnhnzj]ª ^tuilnU 1rsilm'p4ixijlY[^ stzwxu^}qQp4\G^'w,nz¢S¢²tzrp[wl^Pi¾m]tuil^
(94) º ¢¯now ^'[tz\©[^E 1p[wxrq[ttzwljlrstz4q4^j{~,nuwx¤
(95) [wx^]tu¤1 1n~q½=~r jlYwl^]otzw8 2. 2. d. Ð Ð#Ö]4ç.çPæ_^.
(96) G. ' ',- 4. jxnjxY[^3tu[r r j{g_jln_wl^Pmn¨u^]w¾ilp4m8Yt [wxtu\©tzjlrsm}ixm^]q4tzwxr nª Lrq4tz go®h~ ^ 1^&Wq[^jxY[^}jxwl^]^}wx^]m'nuq4ikjlwxp4m.jxr noq n¨o^'wxY[^]to ¶tui jlY4^Ejxr \©^<q[^]^] 1^P Ujxn
(97) wx^]tuwlw8tzq4u^jxY[^3jlnuGnunuog©nz¢&jxY[^<ikg1ikjl^]\ ~Y[^'q t
(98) q[n1 1^3¢²tzritzq Ytui=jxn<^wx^'4tom^] 9ª ^~r 4^Pi{jxr \¶tzjl^r j¾hg
(99) mnop[qQjlrq[<Y[n~ \¶tzqhg\©^]ixixtzu^Pi=\p4ikjMG^}ik^]qQj¾ 1p[wxr q[ wx^]m'nuq4ikjlwxp4mjlrnuq9ª M Qtzrq~ ^mnuqikrs 1^'wjlY[^~ nowxikjm'toik^¶~Y[^]wl^UjlY[^\_nQi{j
(100) p[q1¢²t³¨unowxtu[^¶q[n1 1^¶¢²tzrsi'ª XY4ri\©^]toikp4wl^^]ikjlr\¶tjx^]i,jlY4^<wl^Pikr r^'qm^nz¢ jlY[^ixm8Y[^'\©^3jlnUt_q[n1 1^3¢²tur p[wx^uª Xtz[^
(101) or ¨o^]itilp[\©\¶tzwxg nz¢MjxY[^¶tzq4tu g1ilriEnz¢ jlY[^_^]^'wl¦Vjxnz¦·^]^'wi{jxwl^Ptz\©rq[ tu onuwxr¿jxY[\¶iEm'nuq1¦ ilrs 1^'wx^] ¶rqUjxY[^34tzG^'wPªX n_u^jtm'nuq4ilrikjl^]qQj ¨hr ^]~<®QjlY[^tzunowlr jlY[\¶i,tzwx^}ilp[[Gnoil^] ¶jxnp4il^EjlY[^iltu\©^ [^'uwx^'^ d ¢¯nuw¢¯nowl~tzw8 1^'w8i]ªMXY[^\p4¿jxrm]tuikjjlwx^'^m'nuq4ikjlwxp4m.jx^] jlYhp4i~r&Y4t³¨o^3Y4^'ruYQj h = dlog ne ª XY4rijxtz4 ^4tuilrm]tz gikY4n~ijlY4tzj
(102) vMwx&^ W4[ehjlwx^]tz\ tzn~ijlnIYt³¨u^¶¢²toi{jwx^]m'nuq4ikjlwxp4mjlrnuqjlr\©^tzq tzstzq4m'^] p[[noto tjjxY[^m'noikjnz¢il ruYQjlg\_nowl^U [^'st³gjxY4tzqµt"wx^'op[stzw<jxwl^]^Unz¢ 1^]uwx^'^ d ª¼º²XY[^ [^'st³g¥Gnup[q4 /nz¢<vMwx&^ W[4eQjxwl^Ptz\ ritz[[wxn³1r \¶tzjl^'gµj{~rsm^IjlY[^jlY[^]nuwx^jlrsm'tunu[jlr\©tuE 1^]t³g ~Y[^]q e1[ r j8ehjlwx^]tz\(ri~r jlY4r q"t
(103) ¢²tumjlnuw<oª ¢¯wxnu\ no1jlr\¶tz§ª ½ XY[^<tuilrmEjlwx^'^\
(104) p[¿jxrm]tuikjlrq[Utzunowlr jlY4\êp4ik^Pit
(105) jlwx^'^<nz¢= 1^'owl^]^ tzq4 Y[^'ruYQj ª¾eh[r¿j.eQjlwx^]tu\ pik^Pi d jlwx^'^]i
(106) nz¢ 1^]uwx^'^ d ª OGruÀPtz"p4il^]i
(107) mp4ikjl^'w8inu¢}ikrÀ'^ m = Θ(k)d º k rsi_tI4tuhwxtu\_^'jl^]wnz¢jxY[^ tu onuwxr¿jxY[\U½¾tuq4 tjxwl^]^nz¢Â 1^'owl^]^ tzq Y[^]r oYQj <ª I}n~ ^]¨u^'wilnu\©^q[n1 1^]i \¶t³gY4t³¨u^U [^'uwx^'^ Ω(k ) wx^]±Qp[rwlrq[dI=tuqmp[−[1notu (m − 1) logª¹XY4n^≈ikrlog q[o ^ nmp4i{jx^'w
(108) ri_tIikjlp4 1gm]tuil^ tu onuwxr¿jxY[\jlY4tzj p4il^]i r qUjlp[wxq jlwx^'^Pi¾nu¢9Y[^'ruYQj}oªÂXY[^Em' p4ikjl^]w¾jxwl^]^Em'nuq4ilrikjxi¾r qt<jlwx^'^Enz¢&m' p4ikjl^]wxi nu¢ikrÀ'^ m = d º jlY4^Ujlwx^'^Y[^'rnuYQjrsi<jlYhp4i log (n/d) = h − 1½.ª vMwx&^ W4[ehjlwx^]tz\¡p4il^]i 2 ik^'jxinu¢ d rqQjl^]wlrnuwl¦·m' pi{jx^'wl¦· 1rsi²y{nurqojmp4ikjl^'wjxwl^]^]i]ª ì ¶;<=26 d. 2. 2. k. d. d. .
(109)
(110) !"!. XY4^4toikrsmtzw8m8Y[r jl^Pm.jlp4wl^¢¯now}[wxnoto [m'toi{jxr q[Um'nuq4ilrsi{j8irqInuwxotuq[r À]r q4
(111) jxY[^wx^]m'^'r¨hr q[q[n1 1^]i}r qt 5 un ¢G 1^]uwx^'^ d ªXY[^ilnup[w8m^il^'q4 4ijlY[^ikjlwx^]tu\jlnjlY4^,wxnhnzjÂnz¢jlY[^jxwl^]^uª M¨u^]wlgrqQjl^]wlrnuw=q[n1 1^wx^]m^]r ¨o^]i ^Ptum8YUtum8¤u^'j ¢¯wxnu\êr jxitzwx^'qQjtuq4 ¶¢¯nowl~tzw8 [i¾r¿jjln©r jxi d ilnuq4i]ª 9^]tz¢&q[n1 1^]iilr \©[gUwx^]m'^'r¨u^}tum8¤u^'jxi ~r jlY4nup1j¢¯nowl~tzw8 1rq[4ª Lrwxikjq[nujlrsm^¶jxY4tj
(112) jlY[rsiixm8Y[^'\©^Ursiq4nzj4tutuq4m^P r qnop[w
(113) il^'qik^Uilr qm^¶jxY[^^]tz¢q4nh [^]i [nIq[nzj ¢¯nowl~tzw8 ~Y[r^ rqQjl^]wlrnuw_q[n1 1^]i_q[^]^] tzq p[[noto µ4tuq4 1~rs hjlY d ª M i
(114) jxY[^"4tum8¤o^jxi_tzwxwxr ¨hrq[Ijxnt wx^]m'^'r¨u^]w9tzzjlw8t³¨u^]utznuq4jlY[^,iltu\_^ÂtjlY&®]jxY[^'g<tuwl^Âwx^]m'^'r¨u^] 3rqjlY[^ ^'\©rsililr noq<nuw8 1^'wPª 9^'j h = log n G^jxY[^
(115) jlwx^'^Y[^]r oYQj]ªEXY4^[wxnoto [m'toi{j} 1^]t³g rsiGnup[q 1^] Qg ilr qm^tq[n1 1^nu¢ÂjlY[^jlwx^'^ wx^]m'^'r¨u^Pi,t©tum8¤u^'jtzj\©noikj dT + L tz¢ jl^'w}r¿j8i4tzwx^'qQjPªMX&n¶\©rh(dT q[r \©rÀ'+^y{L)r jkjx^'wP®1jlY[^^'\©rixilr noqjxn~,tuwx [i jxY[^©iknoq4iikY[nop[s Iwx^'\¶tzrq"jlY4^©ixtz\©^oªUº²XY[^_¢¯nuwx~tzw8 1^'w8inu¢ tzqhg"tzunowlr jlY[\ ilY[nup4 ¤u^'^]IjxY[ri<toiEt wxp[^¶nz¢jlYhp[\
(116) 9ªÃ½/«·¢~,^¶q[nuwx\¶tzr À]^] ¹jln T = 1 ®&jxY[^U\¶t1r\¶tz¾ 1^]t³g¹ri<jlYhp4i (d + l) ~Y[rm8Y rsiE\_rq[r\©rtu&¢¯now d − = 0 $ª Lrup[wx^r pi{jxwxtzjl^]ijlY[^© 1^]uwx^'^ d ur¨Qrq[Uno1jlr\¶tz= 1^'st³g tui}t ¢¯p4q4m.jxr noqnu¢ l ªÂXlog Y[rsimp4wl¨o^EilY[n~i jlY4tzj,j{gh[rsm'tu+¨³tu p4^]inz¢ l º¯¢¯wlno\ 2 jxn 15½ wx^]±Qp[rwl^Et© 1^]uwx^'^}¢¯wlno\ j4 xn 11 ª Lrup[wx^"r p4ikjlw8tjx^]ijlY[^\©tz1r \¶tz, 1^'st³gnu1j8tzrq[^] ~r jlYµjlY[^jlwx^'^tuwxm8Y[r jl^Pm.jxp[wl^U¢¯nuw¨tuwlrnup4i ¨tu p[^Pi3nz¢ d ª M i<tY4r qQj<nz¢mnu\©4tuwlrsilnuq9®+~,^
(117) Y4t³¨o^_m'nu\©[p1jx^] IjlY[^_jlY4^'nuwx^jxrm]tz=nu1jxr \¶tuM 1^'st³g ¢¯nuw \
(118) p[ jlrsm'tuikjlrq[
(119) nuq[^34tum8¤o^jMjxn n = 10 q[n1 1^]i]ªÂXY[^3^Pi{j,jlY[^]nuwx^jxrm]tz+ilm8Y[^]\©^Emnoq4ilrikjxi r q tzGq[n1 1^]i
(120) 0. -6. 6. d. log n log d. d+l d. 6. Ð .
(121).
(122)
(123) !#"$&%'()'&
(124) +*& ,- '(.!/0&213 34150,7698:; 5' % < =>42'( @?A. 16. optimal degree d=l. 14 12 10 8 6 4 2 0 0. 2. 4. 6. 8. 10. 12. 14. 16. Lrup[wx^o°XY4^Eno1jlr\¶tz+ 1^'owl^]^ d nz¢ t\p[ jlrsm'toi{j jlwx^'^tui,t<¢¯p[qm.jlrnuqnz¢ l = L/T ®ujlY[^3q[nowl\¶tzrÀ'^] stjx^'q4m'guª. ¢¯nowl~tzw8 1rq[¹m'nuqQjlrqhp[nupikg jlY[^ 4tom8¤u^'j©toi_ilnhnuq¸tui
(125) jlY4^'gµwx^]m'^'r¨u^ r¿jtuq4 ¥toi© noq[toi©ikno\_^ q[n1 1^ Ytui}ikjlr q[nujEwx^]m'^'r¨u^] r j EP!Hº²^'¨u^]wlg ^'\©rsililrnuq"rsi}ilp[[Gnoil^] jxnwx^]tum8Y"tq[^'~q[n1 1^³½.ª}«·j<m'tuq jlYhp4i G^ 1&^ W4q4^] ¥toijxY[^il\¶tz ^Pi{j©rq4 1^ i ilp4m8YµjxY4tj a > n ~Y4^'wx^ a rijlY[^ il^]±Qp[^'qm^ [^&W4q[^P µhg tzq4 tzq = · · · = a = 0 ºVik^]^ EP! H ¢¯nowjxY[^ [^jxtur si8½.ª L[nuw a = a +jxY[a^
(126) jlwx^'^ 1^]t³g arsi}= 1oY[g¹oaª _jxr \© x w u n [ p ^PijxY[^no1jlr\¶tz= 1^'st³g¢¯nowEtuqQg 1^]uwx^'^ ª 2 ≤ l ≤ 16 XY4riEikY[n~ijlY4tzj3t W[1^P " 1^'owl^]^m'tzq"or ¨o^unhn1 1^'st³g1i¢¯nowEt©~rs 1^w8tzq[o^<nz¢ l ¨tzp[^Pi'4ª≤XY[drsi≤rsi}8t onhnh
(127) GnurqojM~Y4^'q©jlY4^4tzw8tz\©^jx^'w d Ytui=jxn<^ W[1^P
(128) noq4m^¢¯nowMtz[^'¢¯nuwx^ 1^'4 nghrq[<tE\
(129) p[ jlrsm'tuikjlrq[ q4^j{~,nuwx¤Gª ^q[n~/tzq4tu ghÀ]^jlY4^Ewx^'rtu[r r j{g©nz¢9jxY[^3ixm8Y[^]\_^o#ª L rw8i{jmnoq4ikrs 1^]wMjlY4^3q4nh [^}¢²tur p[wx^}~,nuw8i{jm'tuil^u° r ¢jlY4^wxnhnzj¢²tur si
(130) tu q[n1 1^]i
(131) nQnQik^tz 4tom8¤u^'jxip4qojxr jlY4^Ujlwx^'^ri
(132) wx^'4tur wx^] Sª¹XY[ri
(133) ghr ^] 4i
(134) t"~,nuw8ikj ¢²tur p[wx^Etum8¤u^'j,noixi,nz¢ 1 <ª Nnujlrsm^EjlY4tzjtum8¤u^'j,noixi 1p[^3jln¶ilnowxto 1rsmstum8¤¶nz¢ ¢¯nuwx~,tuwx [r q[riilr \©[g 4wlnonowkjxr noq4tz&jlnUjxY[^©t³¨u^'w8tzo^<qhp[\G^'wnz¢Â¢¯nowl~tzw8 1^]wxi¢¯nuw3wl^Ptum8Y[rq[tq[n1 1^ º¯jlY[rsi3riEjxwlp[^
(135) ¢¯nuwtzqhg ixm8Y[^]\_^³½.ª}XY4^~ nowxikjEm]tuil^<¢¯nuwEwl^Pmnuqi{jxwlp4mjlrnuq jlr\©^
(136) tuotzrq"n1m'm'p[wxi~Y[^'q"jxY[^wxnhnzj¢²tur si]ª ^_m'tuq jxY[^'qµilY[n~êt hd n~ ^]w<nop[q4 noq jlY[^Uqhp[\
(137) ^]wnu¢\©^Pilixtzo^]i^[m8Y4tuq[u^P ¹jlnIwx^'4tur wjlY[^¶jxwl^]^Uhg toililp[\©rq[tzq¸r¿jx^'w8tjxr ¨o^ wx^'tzw8tjlrnuq¼[wxnhm'^]ixi'° jxY[^"wxnQnuj¶ri¶wx^'4tom^] ¼hg¥noq[^"nz¢r¿j8iUilnuq4i"º \©^Pilixtzo^]itzwx^jlY4^'q"q[^Pm^]ixixtzwxg¶jlnUrq1¢¯nowl\(jlY[^
(138) iknoq4inz¢=jxY[^ilnuqItzq jxY[^ilnup[w8m^³½.®4jlY[^q4^'~wldnhnu+jr1i jxY[^'q¶wx^'4tom^]
(139) hgnoq[^nz¢Sr jxiMilnuq4i¾tzq4 ©iln<nuq¶tznuq[<t4tzjlY_¢¯wxnu\jxY[^wxnhnzj]ª M ¢²toi{jx^'wMixm8Y[^'\©^mnop[s m'nuq4ilrsi{jÂrq_ 1rwx^]m.jx g_ik^] ^Pm.jxr q[<t3Gnzjkjxnu\q4nh [^¢¯nuwÂwx^'[stum'r q[EjlY4^wlnhnzjPª I}n~ ^]¨u^'wP®³jlY4riÂ~,nup4
(140) r \©[g to [ 1r jlrnuq4tu4jxnuGnunuog
(141) \¶tzrqQjl^]q4tzq4m'^uª nurq[jxY[ri,~r jlY[nop1jtzqhg¶mnuq 4rmj,~Y4^'qil^'¨o^'w8tzq[n1 1^]i¾¢²tzr+ri q4nzjEnoh¨Qrnupi'ª M q¹tu onuwxr¿jxY[\(¢¯nuw Wq4 1rq[q4nh [^]iE~r¿jxY¹il4tzwx^m'tu4tum'r¿j{g ~,nup[s jlY4^'qG^
(142) tnQililr[ ^ ilnup1jxr noq9ªMeh[r¿j.eQjlwx^]tu\ p4il^]iilp4m8Y t
(143) \©^Pm8Y4tzq[rsil\ ~r¿jxY"tzotur q t O(hd) Gnup4q4 º²il^'^eh^]mjlrnuqI[ª Bu½ª i. i. i−1. i−l−1. 0. . −1. Ð Ð#Ö]4ç.çPæ_^. i. −l. .
(144) Z. ' ',- 4. 200. 1.5*(optimal delay) tree delay d=4 tree delay d=6 tree delay d=8. 180 160 140 120 100 80 60 40 20 0. 2. 4. 6. 8. 10. 12. 14. 16. L rup4wl^1°ÂXY[^<\¶tzhr\¶tz9 1^]t³g¶no1jxtur q4^] ~r¿jxY jlY[^jxwl^]^tuwxm8Y4r¿jx^]m.jxp[wx^3toit¢¯p4q4m.jxr noq nu¢ . d. ª. !"!. ^©m'tz0 &;8A%2 3&¶tuwxnup["nu¢¾q[n1 1^]iE¤hq[n~rq[^Ptum8Y"nzjxY[^'wPª M ilr \©[^©ilm8Y[^]\©^¢¯nuw3[wxnoto [m'toi{jxr q[Ut tum8¤u^'jMr qUt<m' pi{jx^'w¾m'nuq4ilrikjxiMr qUor ¨hrq[^]tom8Y_tum8¤u^'jÂjlnnoq[^q[n1 1^~Y4rm8Y©jxY[^'q©¢¯nowl~tzw8 [i=r j 1rwl^Pm.jlg jxn¶tzSnzjlY4^'wq[n1 1^Pi'ªMXY[^ilnup4wxm'^3m]tzq m8Y[nhnoil^E^Ptum8Y q[n1 1^<r q jxp[wlq¢¯nuwtom'm'nu\©[rilY[rq[_jlY[rsijxtoik¤+ª N}nzjlrsm^,jxY4tjÂjxY[riÂixm8Y[^]\_^rsi=p[q1¢¯^Ptuilr [^,¢¯nuwMtEtuwlo^ qhp[\
(145) ^]wÂnz¢Gq[n1 1^]i]ª I}n~ ^]¨u^]w]®³r jMri=4tutuq4m^P rq nup[w<il^'q4il^uª M Mq4nh [^]i3¢¯nuwx~tzw8 Inuq4^_tum8¤u^'j<n¨u^'w n jln jlY[^ n − 1 nzjlY4^'w<q[n1 1^Pi'®9wx^]±Qp[rwxr q[ tzq p4[ nQtu nz¢ ≤ 1 ª
(146) XY[^¶ 1^]t³g"rsinop[q4 1^P hg (n − 1)T + L ª_XY[^©4tum8¤o^jxiE\¶t³g"Y4t³¨u^
(147) jln G^ wx^'nowx [^'wx^] ©jxY[wlnop[uY t_~r q 1n~änu¢ n − 1 4tom8¤u^j8i'ª XY[^ tu 1¨tuqoj8tzo^¶nz¢jlY4ri_ilm8Y4^'\©^rsir jxi
(148) wl^] rstz4r r¿j{g+°¶tz¾q4nh [^U¢²tzrp[wl^PiG^'rq[¹ilgh\©\_^'jlwxrmu®=jlY[^ ~,nuw8ikjÂm]tuil^,¢¯nuwMtq[n1 1^¢²tur p[wx^m'tzq_nuq4 g_tÁ+^]m.jMnoq[^4tom8¤u^jÂn¨o^'w n p4qojxr 4jlY[^ [^jl^Pm.jxr noq_nu¢jxY[^q[n1 1^ [^]tjxY9ª XY4^~ nowxikj¢²tzr p4wl^<4tom8¤u^'j nQilirsijxYQpi ªb"nuwx^'n¨o^'wP®Qr ¢Mt©q[n1 1^^]t³¨o^]i jlY[^q[^j{~,nuwx¤+®1jlY[^ wx^]m'nuq4ikjlwxp4mjlrnuqIn¨o^'wxY[^]to "ikr\©[ g¹mnuqikrsi{j8i}rqr q1¢¯nowl\©rq[jlY[^¶ilnup[w8m^oª<«¬q1¢¯nuwx\©r q[ nzjxY[^'wq[n1 1^Pi3ri ^]ixip[wxu^]qojPªÂXY[^iknop[w8m^m'tzq [ruogo¦·4tom8¤
(149) jxY[^<rq1¢¯nuwx\¶tjlrnuq rq tum8¤u^'jxi,r j}ik^]wl¨o^]i,tzjl^]wnuq9ª n−1 n. 1 n. . !. e1[ r jxikjlwx^]tu\ E H}rsi©4tuil^] ¼nuq¸t ik^'j©nu¢ rqQjl^]wlrnuwl¦§q4nh [^¦¬ 1ri²y{nurqQjjxwl^]^]i]ª ¾tom8Y¼q4nh 1^ G^'nuq[Qi_jln noq[^<jxwl^]^
(150) tuiEtzqIrqQjl^]wlrnuwEq[n1 1^
(151) tuq4 "rq"jlY[d^ d − 1 nzjlY4^'w8i}tuiEtU^]tz¢Mq[n1 1^uª/L rup4wl^ BUr p4ikjlw8tjl^Pi}tuq ^'[tz\©[^nz¢ eh4 r j8eQjxwl^Ptz\êtzw8m8Y[r jl^Pm.jlp4wl^oª XY[^E4tuilrm}tz[[wxnotom8Y¶mnuqikrsi{j8iMrqUp4ilr q4<jlwx^'^PiMnz¢& [^'uwx^'^ d ª I}n~ ^]¨u^]w]®[t¶ixm8Y[^'\©^<rsi[wxnuGnoil^] jxnUtu [tu1jjlY4^ 1^'owl^]^nz¢Â^]tom8Y q4nh [^<jln¶r jxi}p[[notu "m]tz4tomr j{guª «¬q nop[w3¢¯wxtu\©^'~,nuwx¤~Y[^]wl^¶tu =q[n1 1^PiY4t³¨u^_iltu\_^_p[[noto m]tz4tomr j{gu®&eh[r j8eQjxwl^Ptz\d~,nup[s Ipik^©wx^'up4tuw jxwl^]^]inu¢ 1^]uwx^'^<mnoil^}jxn d ª XY[rsiixm8Y[^'\©^<rsi4tutuq4m^P ilr qm^<^]tom8Y q[n1 1^¢¯nuwx~,tuwx 4i noq[^4tum8¤o^jn¨o^'w jln¶r jxi iknoq4irq jlY[^ jxwl^]^~Y[^]wl^
(152) r¿j<rsiEtuqrqQjl^'wxrnuw}q4nh [^uª M jlwx^'^Pi}Y4t³¨hrq[Y4^'ruYQj h = log n ®+jldY4^_ 1^]t³g d rsi3nop[q4 1^P 0. d. Ð .
(153).
(154)
(155) !#"$&%'()'&
(156) +*& ,- '(.!/0&213 34150,7698:; 5' % < =>42'( @?A. . S. 1. 4. 2. 4. 3. 5. 5. 6. 6. 1. 2. 3. Lrup[wx ^ B[°
(157) e1[ r j8ehjlwx^]tz\ º j{~,n r qQjx^'wxr nowk¦·q[n1 1^¦¬ 1rsi¯y{nor qQj3jlwx^'^Pi'°<jxY[^U^]t³¨o^]i3nz¢nuq[^©jxwl^]^Utzwx^©r qQjl^]wlrnuw q4nh [^]inz¢jlY4^<nzjlY4^'w8ix½ª. hg + L) ª r jlY¶jxY[^e1[ r j8ehjlwx^]tz\êixm8Y[^'\©^o®onoq[^4tom8¤u^j n¨u^'w d tuwlwxr¨u^]i=~r jlY tilY[nuwljl^]w 1^]t³g+° jxY[^h(dT 4tom8¤u^'jwl^Pm^'r¨u^P hgjlY[^jlwx^'^<~Y[^]wl^jxY[^q[n1 1^rsirqQjl^]wlrnuwPª X n¶wl^]nuw8 1^'wtum8¤u^'jxi]®4t©q[n1 1^\¶t³g q4^'^] jlY4^tu [ 1r jlrnuqtzS[p1Á+^'wxrq[¶nz¢nuq[^4tom8¤u^jPª ` noq4m^]wlq[rq[wx^'rstz[r r j{gu®ujlY[^3tzp1jxY[nuw8i¾tuwlop[^jlYtje1[ r j8ehjlwx^]tz\êm]tzq¶uwx^]tzjlg
(158) G^'q4&^ W[j ¢¯wlno\ìjx^]m8Y1¦ q4r±Qp[^PiEil[r¿jljlrq[jxY[^©i{jxwl^Ptz\:r qQjxn d ikp41¦·ikjlwx^]tu\¶iº²m]tz ^P ikjlwxr G^]i8½ilp4m8Y"jxY4tj nhnQikrq[noq[^
(159) ikjlwxr^ Ytui¾t\©r q[now r\©4tumjEªsº²XY[^]g©[wlnonQik^¢¯nuw,^[tz\©[^jln
(160) p4il^}\p4¿jxr [^ 1^]ixmwxr [jlrnuqUmn1 1rq[¢¯nuw¾¨hrs 1^'n tuq4 _^'w8tuilp[wx^m'n1 1r q4E¢¯nowMwx^'rtu[ ^ [rikjlwxr 4p1jlrnuq©nz¢9 [tzjxt4ª ½ M qhg
(161) tuwxm8Y[r jl^Pm.jxp[wl^4toik^P _nuq¶ik^]¨u^]wxtuhjlwx^'^]i \¶t³g G^'q[,^ W[j¢¯wlno\dikp4m8Yilm8Y4^'\©^uª ^Ey{p4i{jtuq4tzghÀ'^jxY[^©4tzwx^Gnuq4^©tu onuwxr¿jxY[\ ª<XY[^©~ nowxikj3m]tuil^ ¢¯now}q[n1 1^¢²tzr p4wl^n1m]mp[w8i~Y[^]q"nuq[^
(162) nz¢=jlY4^ d wlnhnzj8i¢²tzrsi'ª}XY4riEur¨u^Pit¶~,nuw8i{j¢²tur p[wx^4tom8¤u^jE nQili nu¢ tuitu 9q4nh [^]i~r SjxY[^'q wx^]m'^'r¨u^<tz9i{jxwlrG^]i[p1jEnuq[^oª=X n¶wx^'4tur wt
(163) jlwx^'^o®4tz+jlY[^ilnuqinz¢jlY[^ ¢²tur 1/d rq[Uq[n1 1^\
(164) p4ikj}wl^'¦§rq4il^'wljjlY[^]\¶ik^] ¨o^]irq"jlY4^<jlwx^'^oª tum8Y"nz¢=jxY[^ ilnuqi\p4ikj}jxYhp4iG^'wl¢¯nuwx\(t vÂtoi{jxwlg"nhnu¤hp[~Y4rm8Ywl^P±Qp[r wx^]i3tz4[wln³1r\¶tjl^] g h \©^]ixixtzu^Pi'ª ¾tum8Ydnuq[^¶m]tzq Wq4 ¹t q[^]~ì4tuwl^]qQj jxY[rsi~t³guª In~,^'¨o^'wP®hjlY[^
(165) [wxnhm'^]ixi\¶t³gG^\©nowl^<rqQjlwxrm]tjl^~Y[^'q"jxY[^q4^'~4tzwx^'qQj}Ytui^'hYtzp4ikjl^P r jxi p[[noto ¶m'tu4tum'r¿j{g º¯r ¢&r j Y4toi tu wx^]to 1g d ilnuq4i8½.ª M [p4ilY1¦¬ 1n~q [wln1m'^]ixi¾m'tuq©jlY[^]qG^}r jl^]wxtzjlr¨u^'g G^'wl¢¯nuwx\©^] jln¶wx^{y{^Pm.jnoq[^m8Y[r noq[^<t³go^'w 1^]^'G^'wrq jlY[^jlwx^'^uª,XY[rsi[wxnhm'^]ixim'tuq tuotur q u^]q[^'w8tjx^ \©^]ixiltuu^]i]ªÂehnu\©^Em8Y4r s U\¶t³g
(166) jlY[^]qG^]mno\©^Enowl[YtzqUtzq ¶Y4t³¨u^}jl+n W4q4 t4tzwx^'qQj,r q¶jxY[^ik4tuwl^ O(h) m]tz4tomr j{gowlnop[9ª M jlY[^
(167) q[n1 1^]iE~r jlYil4tzwx^<p[[noto Im'tu4tum'r¿j{g tzwx^\©^'\
(168) ^]wEnu¢ÂtikG^]m'rtu9jxwl^]^<¢¯nuw jxY4tj<[p4wlGnoil^uª M qhgInowl[YtzqIjxYhp4i<ik^]q4 [i<tuqtuqQg1m]tuikjE\©^]ixiltuu^
(169) jln jlY4^©il4tuwl^©m'tu4tum'r¿j{g"owlnop[hg G^'wl¢¯nuwx\©r q4t LÂe©r¤u^}il^]tuwxm8Y©rq¶jlY[^}jlwx^'^p4qojxr +t<q[n1 1^Etum.jxr q4tuiMtuqUrqojx^'wxr nowMq[n1 1^¢¯nowMjxY[^}wxr oYQj ikjlwxr^
(170) riE¢¯nup4q4 Sª<XY[^©mnu\©[^1r j{g nz¢MjxY[rituqQg1m]tuikjEilm8Y4^'\©^rsi3Y4tzw8 jln^]ikjlr\¶tjl^oª In~,^'¨u^]w]®jlY4ri owlnop[^]r¿jxY[^'w¨o^'wxgik\¶tu 9º²r¿¢9tz1q[n1 1^Pi=Y4t³¨u^ 1^'owl^]^ d½nuwMt3q[n1 1^~r [4wlno4tz[g<G^ ¢¯nop[q4 _rq O(h) ® jxY[^_Y[^'ruYQjEnu¢MjlY4^jxwl^]^
(171) r ¢MjlY4^
(172) owlnop[Irsi}stzwxu^oª<`,toik^Pi}~r jlYtzq Ω(n) il^]tuwxm8YIil^'^]\ ¨u^'wxg p[q[r ¤o^'guª XY4^3n¨o^'w8tzSmnu\©[^1r j{gUnz¢wl^]4tzw8tjxr noqrq"m'tuil^3nz¢=nuq[^q[n1 1^¢²tur p[wx^3rsi,jlYhp4i O(hd) ª ,0. 90. . Ð Ð#Ö]4ç.çPæ_^.
(173) P . . ' ',- 4 . N}rm'9 ^ E B H tzq O+r oÀ]tz EÃz1® ]!H p4ik^Ut"ilr\_rstzwY[r^'w8tzw8m8Y[rsm'tu=m' pi{jx^'wxr q["ixm8Y[^'\©^oª ^UY4t³¨u^¶m8Y[nQik^]q jxnI 1rsilm'p4ili+O+r oÀ]tz ~Y[rsm8Y r qmp4 1^]i^'jkjl^]w 1^Pilm'wlr1jlrnuqtuq4 tzq4tu g1ilrinu¢,r jxi<\
(174) p[ jlrsm'tuikj<jlwx^'^Um'nuq1¦ ikjlwxp4mjlrnuq9ª OGruÀPtzpik^Pi<tst³gu^]wl^P I\
(175) p[¿jxrm]tuikjjlwx^'^©~Y[^'wx^©q[n1 1^]i<tuwl^¶tuwlw8tzq[o^] "rqQjln"t Y[r^'w8tzw8m8YQg nu¢ mp4ikjl^]wxi3nz¢,ikrÀ'^ m ∈ [k, 3k] ª M q[n1 1^©G^'nuq[Qijxn"tj\_nQi{jnuq4^_m' p4ikjl^]w<tjtzqhg t³go^'wtzq4 ¹tz q4nh [^]iE^] noq[oi}jlnt³go^'w ªE«·¢,tUq[n1 1^_Y[ruY[^Pi{j3t³go^'w}rsi ®+r jtuilnUG^'nuq[Qijxn^]¨u^'wxg t³go^'w¢¯wxnu\ jxn i tzq Ir j3rsiEtmp4ikjl^'w3Y[0^Ptu "rqst³gu^]wxi¢¯wlno\ 0 jln i − 1i 7ª I^Ptu [iErq[Y[^'wxr jtu jlY[^©tu [\_rq[rsi{jxwxtzjlr¨u0^ ¢¯p4q4m.jxr noq4i}^'[m^'[jjlY[^
(176) wl^PikGnuqikr[r r j{gnu¢=¢¯nuwx~,tuwx 1rq[©jxY[^
(177) [tzjxt©jxnUnzjxY[^'wEq[n1 1^]i]ª Nnoq1¦·Y[^]to q[n1 1^]i nu¢Mtmp4ikjl^]wEtjEt³go^'w i ¢¯nuwx~,tuwx 4tom8¤u^'jxijxntz jlY[^
(178) q[nuq1¦·Y[^Ptu \©^'\G^'w8inu¢¾ikno\©^nz¢ÂjxY[^
(179) m' p4ikjl^]wxi tzjt³go^'w ªEº I}^]to h¦§q4nh [^]inu¢=m' p4ikjl^]wxi}tjst³gu^'w G^'nuq4©jlnUt¶mp4ikjl^]w}tjst³gu^]w tzq jxYhp4i wx^]m'^'r¨u^©jxiY[−^1tum8¤u^'jxi¢¯wlno\ tY[r oY[^'w
(180) ^]¨u^]VªÃ½«{ 1^Ptzi go−®^P1tum8Yµq4nh [^U¢¯nuwx~tzw8 [i3jlntmnoq4ikijxtzqQjqhp[\_¦ G^'wnu¢ mp4ikjl^'w8i]®Gghr^'s 1rq[t O(k) 1^'owl^]^u\ª In~,^'¨o^'w3ikno\_^
(181) q[n1 1^]i3\¶t³g Y4tz4^]qIjln Y4t³¨o^
(182) t [^'uwx^'^ <ª Lr op[wl^©r p4ikjlw8tjl^P$ i OGruÀ]tu itzw8m8Y[r¿jx^]mjlp[wx^uª d = O(k ) * . 2. 1. 2. 1. 2. 3. 3. head. 4. S. 4. s. 4. s. non−head. L rup4wl^4°O+r oÀ]tz. 5. 6. 5. 7. 6. 7. S : server. i M w8m8Y[r jl^Pm.jlp4wl^ ª M i}jlY[^_\¶t1r \¶tu OGrÀ]tuUG^'wl¢¯nuwx\©tuq4m^Pi}tuwl^ilr\_rstzwEjlntUjlwx^'^
(183) nz¢¾ 1^]uwx^'^ [^'uwx^'^rsi (m − 1) ®ojlY[rsi¾ 1^]t³g
(184) ri¾nuq[g_nop[q4 1^P ©Qg h((m −d 1)= mT +−L)1 =[p1O(k) jMjxY[^Et³¨o^'w8tzu^,^1G^]mjl^] [^'st³grsi ª"XY[^U\¶t1r\¶tzMwx^]±Qp[rwl^P p[[notu rsi − 1) tzq4 jxY[^U[wxnzjxn1mnu¾ri q4nzj}4tutuq4h((m m^P r qI− no1)T p[w}il+^'q4L)il^uª«·¢ÂjxY[^wxnQnuj¢²tzrsi'®4jlY[^
(185) 4tum8¤o^jnoixiriE(m tzQtzrq 0ª In~,^'¨u^]w]®[jlY[^wx^]m'nuq1¦ ikjlwxp4mjlrnuq jlr\©^nz¢OGruÀPtz©rsi¨u^]wlg ikY[nowkjPª,XY4^tzp1jxY[nuw8inu¢ O+r oÀ]tz¶m'tur \:1t O(k ) wx^]m'nuq4ikjlwxp4m.jxr noq n¨o^'wxY[^]to E u!H·®+jlY[^_\¶tzrqIjl^]wl\ rsi 1p[^
(186) jlnjlY[^_wx^¦¬mnuq4q[^]mjlrnuqInu¢MjlY[^ d ilnuq4iEnz¢MjxY[^
(187) ¢¯tur rq[q4nh [^uª I}n~ ^]¨u^]w]®4tU^'jkjl^]wEGnup4q4 "rsinu[jxtzrq[^P ~Y[^'qm'nup[qQjxr q[nuq[gjxY[^qhp[\
(188) ^]w}nu¢=\©^Pilixtzo^]iwx^]±Qp[rwl^P ¢¯now<wl^Pmnoq4i{jxwlpm.jlrnuq&ª Y4^'qt q[n1 1^ x ¢²tzri]®9jxY[^Ump4ikjl^]wY[^]to nu¢,^Ptum8Y mp4ikjl^'w<~Y4noil^_q4nuq1¦·Y[^]to \©^]\G^'w8i ~Y4^'wx^Ewx^]m'^'r¨Qrq[
(189) jlY[^<ikjlwx^]tu\ ¢¯wlno\ x rsiwx^]ilnoq4ikr[^}¢¯now W4q4 1rq[¶tq4^'~ätzwx^'qQj]ª=XY[rsiri Gnoixilr [^}G^]m]tzp4il^ x ikY4nup[s ¶nuq4 g_¢¯nuwx~tzw8 _jln
(190) m' pi{jx^'w8iMr j 1nh^Pi¾q[nuj G^'nuq[jln_tum'm'nuw8 1rq[<jln OGruÀ]tu tuwxm8Y4r¿jx^]m.jxp[wx^
(191) mnoq4ikjlw8tzrqoj8i'ªXY4ri34toikrsm'tu g wl^P±op4r wx^]i − 1) \©^]ixixtzu^Pi}ilr qm^ x ~tuiE¢¯^]^] 1rq[ tj \©nQi{j m−1 mp4i{jx^'w8i'ª,º§aEq[^,\©^]ixiltuu^,^]wÂmp4i{jx^'w=jxnErq12(m ¢¯nuwx\ájxY[^Y[^]to [p4i=nuq4^ \©^]ixixtzu^ jln3rq1¢¯nuwx\ 2. . 2. 2. 2. Ð .
(192).
(193)
(194) !#"$&%'()'&
(195) +*& ,- '(.!/0&213 34150,7698:; 5' % < =>42'( @?A. o. jxY[^3q[^'~ 4tuwl^]qQj G^'wmp4ikjl^'wPªÃ½ M q[^'~/m' pi{jx^'w,Y[^]to ¶¢¯nuwtzjlY[^mp4ikjl^'w8i nz¢ x ri 1^Pikruq4tzjl^P ¶r qjlY[^ n~,^]ikj^'¨o^'[mp4ikjl^]wnu¢ x ª «·¢Stmp4ikjl^'w=G^]m'nu\©^]ijxnQn<il\¶tzV®zr jMrsi=\_^]wlo^] ~r¿jxY
(196) jxY[^il\©tu ^]ikjÂmp4i{jx^'w nu¢+jlY[^3iltu\_^}t³go^'wPª XY[rsi¾tuotzrq¶wx^]±Qp[rwl^Pi \©^]ixixtzu^Pi=[p1j,r¿j 1nh^]iMq4nzj r\©4tumj¾wx^]mnoq4ikjlwxp4m.jxr noq jxr \©^ilrq4m^Ur j
(197) m]tzqG^ 1nuq4^Ut¢ jl^]wwx^'4tuwxtzO(m) jlrnuq9ª XY[rsiilY[nup[s wxtzjlY[^]wG^mnoq4ikrs 1^]wl^P toijlnono noug \¶tur qQjl^]q4tzqm^uª
(198) /^ W4w8i{jr qQjxwln1 1p4m'^3t
(199) 4toikrsmEm' pi{jx^'w,jlwx^'^<ixm8Y[^'\©^uªÂXY[rsitzw8m8Y[r jl^]mjlp[wx^}rsit_ikr\©[ ^q[n¨o^'G\p[ jlrsm'toi{j tuwxm8Y4r¿jx^]m.jxp[wx^r q[Y4^'wx^'qQjlg
(200) rqQjl^]wl^Pi{jxr q[ª&«·j,ri tzsiknt<onhnh ©rqQjlwxn1 1p4m.jxr noq©jlnv¾wl,^ W[4eQjlwx^]tu\ì~Y[rsm8YUm'tuq G^¨hr ^]~ ^P toitp[q4r noq nu¢m' p4ikjl^]w,jlwx^'^]i]ª ` p4i{jx^'w8itzq4 jlwx^'^r q[¤1ituwl^E¢¯nuwx\©^] jlY[wxnup[oYUjxY[^<p4il^3nu¢ t© 1rsikjlwxr [p[jl^] Y4toikYQj8tz[^uª. Lrup[wx^1° M. . mp4ikjl^]wjlwx^'^~r jlY. . d=2. tuq4 . m=5. ^ m]tz &)8A% 3, 5t jlwx^'^¶nz¢ 1^]uwx^'^ d ~Y4^'wx^¶q[n1 1^]i
(201) tzwl^©wx^'[stum'^] hg¹ 1rsi²y{nurqoj_mp4i{jx^'w8inz¢ m G^'^]wxi]ª M G^'^]w ¤hq[n~i tz4jxY[^}\©^'\
(202) ^]wxi nz¢9r jxi,mp4ikjl^]w]®Qr¿j8i,4tzwx^'qQj m' p4ikjl^]w,tuq4 ©r jxiiknoqUmp4ikjl^'w8i]ª M q4nh [^ jxYhp4i=¤hq[n~i m(d+2) m'nuqQjxtom.jxi[p[jMq[n1 1^]i¢¯nowl~tzw8 <nuq4 g<jxn d+m−1 q[n1 1^PiÂt3ur¨u^'q
(203) 4tum8¤o^jPª Y4^'q¹tq[n1 1^_wl^Pm^'r¨u^Pi}t4tum8¤o^j3 [r wx^]mjlg¢¯wxnu\ tq[n1 1^
(204) nu¢¾r jxi34tzwx^'qQjEm' pi{jx^'wP®Gr j3¢¯nuwx~,tuwx [i}r¿j3jln noq[^q4nh [^
(205) G^'w<ilnuqm' p4ikjl^]w<tzq4 jxY[^'q¹jln tz=nzjlY4^'w3\_^]\G^'w8i3nz¢¾r jximp4ikjl^]w]ª Lr op[wx^_r pi{jxwxtzjl^]i jxY[^m' p4ikjl^]w<jlwx^'^Utuwxm8Y4r¿jx^]m.jxp[wx^uªX n"4tutuq4m^©jxY[^Unotu ¹nz¢¢¯nowl~tzw8 1rq[4®9^Ptum8Y G^'^'wnz¢t"mp4ikjl^'wri il^'^]mjl^P Irqjxp[wlq tuit¢¯nuwx~tzw8 1^'wPª M ikr\©[ ^©~t³g jln"tum8Y[r^'¨o^jxY[rirsi3jln"il^'q4 IjlY[^ ijxY4tom8¤u^j3jln jxY[^<q[n1 1^rq Gnoilr jlrnuq i \©n1 1p[n m r q jlY4^mp4i{jx^'wrikjnz¢=q[n1 1^]i]ª ` p4ikjl^'w
(206) jlwx^'^^]wk¢¯nowl\¶tzqm^]i
Documents relatifs
C'est aussi le résidant pas chez leurs parents fréquentent deux fois parativement à la province, les étudiants de Nanterre ne lement ce moindre attachement à la ville
In this paper, we study the performance of an enhanced channel estimation technique combining estimation using an autocorrelation based method and the Expectation-
Selon Laeven et Valencia (2012) , le coût budgétaire de la crise bancaire s’est respectivement élevé à 44 et 41 points de PIB en Islande et en Irlande, ce qui place ces deux
Dans ce travail, nous comparerons les entreprises coopératives, détenues par leurs membres, dont le produit risqué est la ressource critique apportée et dont l’objectif est
À cet effet, un nombre considérable de recherches démontre cliniquement que les enfants de parents souffrant de problème de santé mentale sont plus à risque d’un retard dans leur
usual route to school and provide us with some details about their travel routine (e.g., schedule, mode of transportation, people accompanying them, etc.); 3) recent interventions
La question de l’extension des limites de Paris jusqu’à cette ligne avait été discutée mais ne fut tranchée que par un décret impérial du 9 janvier 1859 qui décidait de
