Modeling Issues and Solutions: Building a Taxonomy from a Biology Textbook

(1)

**!"#$%&'()*++,$+)-'#)."%,/&"'+0))**

1,&%#&'()-)2-3"'"45)67"4)-)1&"%"(5)2$3/8""9)

!"#$%&'()*#+*,*-^./#0123#$%)2*)1⁴/#!3-'*5#617-*38'%39^:/#;(3%,#<2%=-2'(^4#

.>*?%'&@*3&#18#<1@?=&*'#+)(*3)*#%3-#A3B(3**'(3B/#C3(D*'E(&,#%&#F=88%71/#GH/#C+!#

4+IJ#J3&*'3%&(13%7/#K*371#$%'L/#<!/#C+!M#^:N'*@13&#C3(13#O(B2#+)2117#>(E&'()&/#<!/#C+!#

**:)) *'/7"#,;/&"')**

P='#&%EL#(E#&1#)'*%&*#%#&%Q131@,#8'1@#%3#!$#

%LRORJ\ WH[WERRN·V JORVVDU\ WHUPV >@ IRU 3URMHFW+DOR>@3URMHFW+DOR·VJRDOLVWREXLOG

%# '*%E13(3B# E,E&*@# )%?%R7*# 18# %3E5*'(3B#

31D*7# S=*E&(13E# %3-# E17D(3B# %-D%3)*-#

?'1R7*@E# (3# %# R'1%-# '%3B*# 18# E)(*3&(8()#

-(E)(?7(3*E"# J3# E=??1'&# 18# &2(E# B1%7/# &2*#

'*E=7&(3B# &%Q131@,# (E# &1# R*# =E*-# %E# %#

81=3-%&(13#81'#&'%3E7%&(3B#?%EE%B*E#5(&2(3#&2*#

R(171B,# &*Q&R11L# (3&1# 71B()%7# 81'@=7%E# 13#

52()2#%#'*%E13(3B#E,E&*@#5(77#1?*'%&*"#

J3# 1'-*'# &1# R11&E&'%?# 1='# &%EL/# 5*#

(@?1'&*-#T4UVV#B71EE%',#&*'@E#%3-#-*8(3(&(13#

E&'(3BE#8'1@#WKHWH[WERRN·V*7*)&'13()#B71EE%',#

(3&1#<177%R1'%&(D*#$'1&WBW#(3#PXY#81'@%&/#%E#

)7%EE*E# %3-# )1@@*3&# E&'(3BE"# P='# &*%@#

)13E(E&*-#18#R(171B(E&E#%3-#ZI#E?*)(%7(E&E"#X*#

&11L# %3# (&*'%&(D*# %??'1%)2/# 52*'*# &2*#

R(171B(E&E# 18# 1='# &*%@# %&&*@?&*-# (3(&(%7#

)7%EE(8()%&(13E/# '*E&'()&*-# &1# &2*# !"#$%&!!'()*

'*7%&(13/# %3-# 5*'*# *3)1='%B*-# &1# %--#

%--(&(13%7# )7%EE*E# 52*3# &2*,# -**@*-# (&#

%??'1?'(%&*"# !E# &2*,# ?'1)**-*-/# @1-*7(3B#

(EE=*E# 5*'*# (-*3&(8(*-# %3-# -(E)=EE*-# -='(3B#

51'LB'1=?# E*EE(13E"# [2*# (EE=*E# %3-# &2*#

E17=&(13E# &2%&# 5*'*# (@?7*@*3&*-# %'*# %E#

817715E"#

<)) =$+,%/+)

<>:)?'/&/5@="%$)A&;B"/"45) J3(&(%77,#&2*#R(171B(E&E#18#1='#

&*%@# *3)1-*-# )7%EE*E# 81'#

1'B%3()# @17*)=7*E# R1&2# 13#

&2*# R%E(E# 18# &2*('# E&'=)&='*#

%3-# 13# &2*# R%E(E# 18# &2*('#

8=3)&(13# \E**# N(B='*# .]"# N1'#

(3E&%3)*/# ?'1&*(3E# %3-#

E&*'1(-E#%'*#-*8(3*-#R,#&2*('#

)2*@()%7# )1@?1E(&(13"# J3#

)13&'%E&/#21'@13*E#%'*#-*8(3*-#R,#&2*#8=3)&(13#

&2*,# ?*'81'@/# %3-# &2*'*# (E# 1D*'7%?# R*&5**3#

./$7"&## %3-#C"74"'$/# ("*"# E1@*# 21'@13*E#

%'*#E&*'1(-E#52(7*#1&2*'E#%'*#?'1&*(3E"##

!E#%#E17=&(13/#5*#-*8(3*#21'@13*E#%E#'17*E#

&2%&# )*'&%(3# )2*@()%7E# ?7%,"# O15*D*'/#

./$7"&#DC"74"'$# '*@%(3E# %# )7%EE# (3# &2*#

&%Q131@,/# 52()2# '*?'*E*3&E# %# =E*8=7# )7%EE# 18#

ELRORJLVWV· LQWXLWLYH WKLQNLQJ# \E**# N(B='*E# 4#

%3-#:]"##

) )

)

<><)E&''-$-')F%-++&6&;-/&"') [2*# R(171B(E&E# 18# 1='# &*%@#

5%3&*-# &1# )7%EE(8,# &2*#

-(88*'*3&# L(3B-1@E# =3-*'#

&2*# )7%EE# G&'(#"4) \E**#

N(B='*# U]>) O15*D*'/# &2*'*#

%'*#^#(3E&%3)*E#18#G&'(#"4)

\(3# &2*# )13&*Q&# 18# %# C"+"_

R%E*-#&*Q&R11L]"##

!E# %# E17=&(13/# 5*#

'*?'*E*3&# Y(33%*%3# &%Q1_

31@,# =3-*'# 1'B%3(E@/# %3-#

=E*-#)1@@13#A3B7(E2#3%@*E#

81'# E(@?7()(&,# \E**# N(B='*# ^]"# N1'# *Q%@?7*/#

´&RZLVDQ$QLPDOµLVFOHDUHUWKDQ´&RZLVDQ

$QLPDOLDµ)

#

!"#$%&'()!"#$%&!

'(#))*+*,#-*./!.+!

0-&1.*2)!#/2!

3.14./&)!

!"#$%&'*)!'(#))*+*,#-*./!.+!

3.14./&!5.(&)!

!"#$%&'+)!!'(#))*+*,#-*./!.+!

0-&1.*2)!6#)&2!./!

7.(&,8(#1!0-18,-81&!

!"#$%&',)!"#$%&!

'(#))*+*,#-*./!.+!

9*/:2.4)!

,&%2,QWHUQDWLRQDO&RQIHUHQFHRQ%LRPHGLFDO2QWRORJ\

-XO\ā%XIIDOR1<86$

(2)

!"# $%&'(&)*+# ,'-)('.'(&"/# 0'# 1*(# *22# &3'#

4*&)(5(*.'2# 1+*""'"# *"# )("&*(1'"# %-# &3'),#

1+*"")-)1*&)%(#6()&#7"''#8)96,'#:;<#8%,#'=*.$+'/#

!"#$%&#%# )"# *(# )("&*(1'# %-#'#"()*$/# *(2#

+,*-)%.%/)"# *(# )("&*(1'# %-#0,1&2$<# !"# >'&#

*(%&3',#*$$,%*13#7(%&#$)1&6,'2;/#0'#1*(#&,'*&#

1+*"")-)1*&)%(# 6()&"# *"# .'&*51+*""'"<# 8%,#

'=*.$+'/# +,*-)%.3# )"# *(# )("&*(1'# %-# &3'#

.'&*51+*""# 0,1&2$/# *(2# !"#$%&# )"# *(#

)("&*(1'#%-#&3'#.'&*51+*""/'#"()*$<##

4<5/6".#.170-*8399/:#8,*.*$1/

?3'# @)%+%9)"&"# %-# %6,# &'*.# 0*(&'2# &%# 1+*"")->#

;#(,.<=#8-*98*>3# 6(2',# &3'# "6@1+*""#

?38,"*&*(1/7"''#8)96,'#A;<#?3'>#*+"%#0*(&'2#

&%# 1+*"")-># ?38,"*&*(1# 6(2',# &3'# "6@1+*""#

B(C6),><# ?3'"'# &0%# 6"'"# %-# &3'# &',.#

¶7HFKQRORJ\· UHIHU WR

&0%# 2)--','(&#"'("'"<#

?3'# 9+%""*,>#

2'-)()&)%(# -%,#

7HFKQRORJ\ LV ´7KH

*$$+)1*&)%(# %-#

"1)'(&)-)1# D(%0+'29'#

-%,#*#"$'1)-)1#$6,$%"'/#%-&'(#)(E%+E)(9#)(26"&,>#

%,# 1%..',1'# @6&# *+"%# )(1+62)(9# 6"'"# )(# @*")1#

UHVHDUFKµ#

F6,# "%+6&)%(# )(# &3)"# 1*"'# 0*"# &%# ,'-*1&%,#

&3'#&*=%(%.>#7"''#8)96,'"#G#*(2#H;<#I'#(%&'2#

&3*&# "%.'# &',."# %-# &3'# 9+%""*,># *,'#

SRO\VHPRXV'HILQLWLRQVLQFOXGLQJ´J#DOVRµZ','#

*# 1+'*,# )(2)1*&%,# %-# &3)"<# 8%,# '=*.$+'/# I)+2#

?>$'# )"#´!(# )(2)E)26*+# 0)&3# &3'# $3'(%&>$'#

.%"&# 1%..%(+>#

%@"',E'2# )(# (*&6,*+#

$%$6+*&)%("J#%&9*/,'-',"#

&%# &3'# $3'(%&>$'#

LWVHOIµ#

!

4@A/+&%99#B1#"(/!-3%9/*B/C393%-8,/

?3'# )()&)*+# &'(2'(1># 0*"# &%# 1+*"")-># *,'*"# %-#

,'"'*,13#7'<9<#D3"3.#89/#!"%.*$1/#68*&*(1;#

6(2',#E"F2#-1<#!,'*"#%-#,'"'*,13#*,'#1%.$+'=#

"%1)*+# '(&)&)'"/# )(E%+E)(9# ,'"'*,13# *1&)E)&)'"#

*(2# '261*&)%(*+# )("&)&6&)%("# 1%("&)&6&'2# %-#

2'$*,&.'(&"/#-*16+&>#.'.@',"/#$,%9,*."#*(2#

16,,)16+*<# K%0'E',/# &3'# 2'-)()&)%("# %-# &3'#

&',."#-%,#'*13#*,'*#%-#,'"'*,13#)"#$,'-)='2#@>#

´&3'# "1)'(&)-)1# "&62># %-µ<# L)E'(# &3'#

1%..)&.'(&# &%# $,%1'""'"/# &3'),# 1+*"")-)1*&)%(#

6(2',#E"F2#-1#)"#*$$,%$,)*&'<##

4@G/H2I8&%997H2I>-*8399/:#8,*.*$1/

?3','#0*"#*#"&,%(9#)()&)*+#&'(2'(1>#&%#6"'#&3'#

3)',*,13># &%# %,9*()M'# "6@5$*,&"# %,# "6@5

$,%1'""'"# 7"''# 8)96,'# NO;<# 8%,# '=*.$+'#

?3&*>,%9'#)"#*#"6@1+*""#%-#=#.*9#9/#)("&'*2#%-#

*#"6@5$,%1'""<#

#

F6,# "%+6&)%(# 0*"# &%#

.%E'# $*,&"# %,# "6@5

$,%1'""'"# &%# *$$,%$,)*&'#

+%1*&)%("# 03'('E',# &3'>#

*,'# -%6(2# 7"''# 8)96,'# NN;<#

P6,)(9# 0%,D9,%6$#

"'"")%("/# 0'# ,')(-%,1'2#

3%0#&%#6"'#&3'#"6@1+*""#%-#

,'+*&)%("3)$#1%(")"&'(&+><#/

**5/ +"8&29#"9/**

B()&)*++>/# &3'# @)%+%9)"&"# %-# %6,# &'*.# ,'+)'2# %(#

$,)%,#D(%0+'29'#*(2#2'-)()&)%("#-%,#%,9*()M)(9#

&3'# 1+*""# 3)',*,13>/# *(2# &3'# 1+*""'"# 0','#

WUHDWHG DV RUJDQL]DWLRQDO ´EXFNHWVµ F(&%+%9)1*+#$,)(1)$+'"#0','#)&',*&)E'+>#*$$+)'2#

&%# )2'(&)-># .%2'+)(9# )""6'"# *(2# $,%E)2'# *#

-%6(2*&)%(#-%,#&3'#&*=%(%.>#@6)+2)(9#$,%1'""<#

!"#$%&'()!"#$%%&'&($)&*+!

*'!,-.$+&%/%!

!"#$%&'*)!!0-1$)/1+)!*'!

"#$%%&'&($)&*+!2+&)%!

!"#$%&'+)!3$451!

"#$%%&'&($)&*+!

*'!01(6+*#*.7!

!"#$%&'()!"#$%%&'&($)&*+!*'!

,-*(.%%.%!

!"#$%&',)!

"#$%%&'&($)&*+!*'!

8-)&'$()%!

/

!"#$%&'-.)!3$451!

"#$%%&'&($)&*+!*'!

9-*(1%%1%!

!"#$%&'--)' :1'$()*-&+.!*'!

9-*(1%%1%!

!"#$%&'/)!"#$%%&'&($)&*+!

*'!9-*(1%%1%!

(3)

!"#$%& "'((')*+,& #-*.& /%'0$..& "'%& .$1$%2(&

)'%3,%'4/&.$..*'+.5&#-$&6*'(',*.#.&-27&2&840-&

6$##$%& .$+.$& "'%& #-$.$& #9/$.& '"& 8'7$(*+,&

*..4$.5& 2+7& -$+0$& )$%$& 8'%$& $""$0#*1$& *+&

0'+#*+4*+,& #-$& #2:'+'89& 64*(7*+,& /%'0$..;&

<-$.$& ($..'+.& 2+7& %$.4(#*+,& #2:'+'89& 02+&

-$(/&$85$EHWWHUDQVZHU´:KDWLVµTXHVWLRQV;&

=4%#-$%8'%$5& #-$.$& ($..'+.& 02+& 6$& 2//(*$7& #'&

'#-$%& '+#'(',*$.5& 2(#-'4,-& *#& 829& 7$/$+7& '+&

)-2#&"'%82(*.8&*.&4.$7&>$;,;5&"'%&7$2(*+,&)*#-&

8$#2?0(2..$.@;&

!"#$%&'()*(+($,-.

<-*.&)'%3&)2.&"4+7$7&69&A4(02+&B+0/.&

0(1(2($"(-.

C;& D2+$& E;& F$$0$5& G*.2&!;& H%%95& I*0-2$(&G;&J2*+5&

K#$1$+& !;& L2..$%82+5& M$#$%& A;& I*+'%.395&

F'6$%#& E;& D203.'+;& >NOCO@& J28/6$((& E*'(',95&

M$2%.'+&M46(*.-*+,;&&

N;&& P4++*+,&Q;&$#;&2(;&>NOCO@&M%'R$0#&S2('&H/72#$&²&

M%',%$..& <')2%7& Q*,*#2(& !%*.#'#($5& !B&

I2,2T*+$5&=2((&NOCO5&UU?VW;!

!

&