Computation of two-phase flow in steam generator using Domain Decomposition and local zoom methods
27
0
0
Texte intégral
(2)
(3)
(4) ! !" #$" %
(5) & '
(6) & () *'%
(7)
(8) & +'* ,-. ! & #/ 02143657598;:<>=@? AB/#02CD<E:F = GHIHEG L J N K O M Q M S P T R V R N U X W Y P [ U ] Z _ U \ a ^ `. b e c f d h W [ g i P k d k j i Z N K O M h P V l n m _ d p o q J r b. j s JLb Jqt j b t uwj2v tyjx{J z } vn|b x{~}O~x@ U>>K[~wW;U[[ZiK[PS>WNd |6d U[xPScn Z dfzWXMU[mEK ^>7 ^dpN fWa UNt mm^PhWalVUNmnc6d¡XdyjwIJ¢6d^>PhlVdT£mk~¥d d ¤ W;UNce¡pd ¨¦ §ª©V«¬¯®[« °%´±¶Ä[±³Ïf²n¸a»[´´2±¶µaÁ¯±¶·µ¾Å¸º·¯¹nÐQ»Ñ2¼½»I¿µ¾À¿ÂÄ[¾ÅÁ¯·ÒÃÀÄNÑB¸¾±¶»IÏf·¯»Iµº¿¾Å²e·y»I¸µTÆǾ¸±¾»IÈE·Ô¸a±¶ÓYÄ[Ñk¿ÊÑÉ2Õ]±¶Ö·¯Ä[±V·¯´TÄNÎ4¸a»[û´ËÏV»[Ä[̪Ã×ÄOÍV»²¯»I´¿Ê±¶µµ¿Á¯´T±V¾¸ÍVÆDZ¶»Î¨Î¯¼ºµwÄN»I¸a·4±V´B¼º·»[Á¯´ØEÏVÃŵ±¶¸ÄNÄ´Ù ¸¾»I·ÒÏVÃÅÁ¯µa¸a±V´¶Ú ÛÌå»[´_Ä»Iæ[·¯±VÏf´T±VÄN´TÐ[·¯±¶¾ÅÎç·¯Ð_¿¸ÆǾ豸ÁÇÑk´Ñ±4ÕÝénÄ[Ü{ÃÀÄ[¼ ·¯±Ïf±ÒÁ¯µ±¶±OêEÄ4Á¯ÄNÑk¸¾¾»I´p·¯¾ÅÏTµ¶Æ¯ÚrÃűVë¸;ÆÇÙßÞ˱ұ¶Ä[Á¯ÃÅ¿ Ð[»[Ä[´T·¯¾¸·àƯ¿4ÄN²¯Ür²¯én´»IÄ[Ä[µa±¶ÏpÎìƨá;»I»I·í¾À·>²n¸ÃÄNâÒ´TÄ[¼ËÃÀþ±¶¸Ã Æà»[㥴_ä µÕ ±fÙ êEµÁ¯ÁÇé×±¶·Î¯¸»I¾Å¿Ä[ÃÄ[¾¾Å¸a·¯±VµL´TÄNÄ[¸·¯¾»IÎ ·¼ËÙiéE¾â¸ÆÙßµÏfÁÇ»Ié{·¯ÎÇÌS»I»[¿´T¿ Ä[¾Å¾Å·Ç·Qг¿»[±V´º¸ÆÇ·Ç»»I·¯Î{ÏfÜN»I¼º·Ç»[Ìå´»[ØE´Tµ¥¿¼B¾Å·¯¾¸Ð³ÆQ¿»±¶æ[µ±VƯ´TÞÅÄN·¯²nÐDznÚI¾Å°ï·ÇÐk¾Å¸»[Æ ´¢Ñk·Ç»IÑ·ÇÕÔ»îæ[ÜE±V¸´TÆÇÃÅÄN±B²¯Ïf²6»I¾Å¿·ÇÐ Ù ²n¸¾ÅÁ¯¿¸±³ÄN¸¾Å¾µ»I·¯µa¸aÄ[´Ã»I²¯·¯´ÐI»[Ãé6â ñ¶´¿ ±¶ÎnÁ¯µ¾ÏfÍV±¶±Î{¾ÅÚ µª±¶Ä[µ¾ÅÃÅâ¾ŷ¯Ïf´T±¶Ä[µa±¶ÎO¸a»ÄNé×»IÁǸ ðVñ[ñÜòñ[ñ[ñ¿±¶µÆÏf±¶ÃÅÃŵLÄ[·¯ÎO¸Æ¯± Ûwórô ÕÏfÒ»I±V¿Û ¸»IÆDz6·¯»ÁÇÏfÎø¸±VÄN´T¸ÓY·¯¾õ»I¾ÅÑ·¯·ÐìÛ ´±¶Öp¸µÜËÆÇÁ¯±@¾À÷ú¸µÂõqùN»ÄNÑûÏV´Ä[±yÃOÃÅ»EÏföe»IÏV¿»EÄ[ó»I²n¿÷ÆnÄN¾´±V±¶Ïf´TÎD»IÄN¿´T¼ËÏp²nƯ¾¸ÁǾÅÆÝÏV¸Ä[ÄN¸Ãk¸ÆǾ¿Â»I±_·nÁnÏVµVÃÃÀÜ˸Ä[¾µ¸Ð[µÆÇ´T¾Å¾Å±@ÏVÎüÄ[Á¯Ã ÏfµaÌå»I±¶Án·Î-ßaâ±fõqÎÇèE»»I¸VÜ2ÏV¿Ä[¾ÅÄ[ÃQµ4¾À·ÝÑBµÆDZVÏf»îÌå»I±¶¼Ë¿Ïf·{¸ ²nÚ Á¯Û 븻[ÄNÆÇ´¸±Ô´¾»I±¶Ïf·Ýõ¸Ñ ¾Å´T»I±fÛ · Ù µÄ[ÁnÏVÏVøÁǵQ´pÄ[Óå¼BÏfâÒ¾¸Æà»I·]Ư¸¾ÐIÆÇÆý±Q»[ÌåÁ¯´³ÃÀÃûÎǼ+»I¿µa²nÄ[ÄN¾À·Ò¸¾ÀÄ[¼ËþŴT¸±¶Æýµa»IĨÃÅÁÇƯ¸¾¾ÐI»IÆ]·eÖpÏfÚ6»I°%ÆDZV±´±¶Ïf·¯»IÏf·¯±OÏVé×ÃÀÁ¯±VÎǸ߼º±O±V¾Å·ý±¶·àÄ[¸·%ÆDZQ¾À¿ÍV²¯»´»I»î¿æ[±¶Ä[¿·¯±¶Î]·>¸k¸ÆÇ»[±QÌ¢ÌY¸Á¯Æ¯Ãű à ÎÇ»I¿ Ä[¾Å·{Ú þõÑ d Û ÿ Õ KNWa±V¸RÆÇ»Î{ÈÜn¸aõ±¶Ä[»E¿ÊÏVÄ[à É2B±¶·Ç¾±V±V´p´TÄNÄN´T¸aÏT»[Ư´¾ÀÜ×ÏVÄ[öeûEÕÒ»I¿4ÁnܯøÑ2¾Ð[»I´T¿¾ÅÎqÄ[ÜE¾Åë · ¼ºÑ2»N±¶ÙiÏf²n»IƯ¿Ä[µ²×±³»I㪵¾Åß»¾»I¼Ë·Òµ ÕÒ±V¸ÆÇ»EÎDÓYÑkÑkÕàÖpÜ . . . Ûb »[M´UN´±¶PS^ªµa²×UI»II·¯NWίdX¾ÀRp·ÇR ÐQÄ[Á¯¸ÆÇ»[´¶Ú¯ë±¶ÃhÚ ù[ùEÚÀÓYñ>Ö ÇÚ EÚ EÓhÚ [ÕÔùEÚÚÅð E±¶ÜÃÀã¯ÃžÅÄÄNè´TÎ6ÖpÚù[ùEÚÀÓYñ>Ö ÇÚ EÚ EÚ Ú .
(9)
(10)
(11) "!$#&%' "! !" ()"*"+, (-#/. ). 0. 1-243657298;:<>=?'@AB8&<C<D3EF<DGIHI? J9KL3MN2POQ:"R 8;:3S3T298U:"RBMV:7EXWY34=Z8[R :. .
(12)
(13) . \]IWY3J434A^@"3T2`_ aa\.
(14)
(15) . ! "!$#&%&' ( )%+*, -*!.0/1*,23!%& 4/1' *,25*!6%+ 6%&*, -78 69*;:$=<>/?/@7=AB! : CD*;' !#FEG*H*,2I2 69*;:$J%+ 8 )9$K' *, 6MLH ?*!.F ONP*(QR9S!TS*NU' *,2V$ )( )%+*, XWZY1V1(;Q #&%+'[( 6%&*, "%& )9=%&2KV$#\( 6%&*, "*!.]S6 $'^9`_aV' #+[! bH ) !2 c? $ )d )*,e<fbcA6%+66 Ng9 K#&%+hiV%&:Njd ) 0%&ak5*,%+#&%+ lm B]n%+lWDo,WGb;%&2V#\( 6%&*, $g!66 hiV%+6:=.p*,JMq(!#&VSrQ )%+*, g*!.sbctZ u.p*,623! ' J! :6(.p Ov8! !#+vH6%+ WSwx9:%+y'V#+ 6%& a!k$6*,Vl!9i 0k v :%+z5 ' P%& l, *,2 66%+'[!#S( :{9 vH6%+'[!#Z6' !#& m )V$6kV#+ |! :~}!/TS*NgP 696*!Vl,9 ' *,2#+ML %+ ) S!#Du )6V$' )V$6 mML;'^9S! l!kZ ONP )9? ONP*3$9S!6(m+WW steam (secondary fluid). liquid water recirculation. feed water (secondary fluid). 㥾ÐÇÚqðNÚn㯴±¶·¯ÏTÆý·ÁnÏVñ¶ÄN´Ëµa¸a±¶Ä[¿ Ð[±¶·Ç±V´TÄN¸a»[´ÓYµÏTÆDZ¶¿±îÖ Primary fluid. O "%+ :Vu )%\!#PkS!'^il,6*!V :XmF 696*,k$#& 2%&K%&2#&% S :-k v4l (uQO#+%&hiV%+:2%LH )V !* !'^9Xm#+%&(s%+ ? )9Pc@s_JG6*!. ON|!6(mr6 |c?)! :$*! 6 6*aM !#Wi<o,,,AMmrc?)! $:*! 6 6* ! :3Y1kv <uo!, An! $:{Y1kuvKM s!#W<uo,! AMW(J*NPq, mi )9x iV2k5*!.Z:S( ^1 6*? )*!6 .p*,x[('^9' *! i 66*,#5q,*,#+V23?#+%&2%+ 6P )9$S( 6%\!#X *,#&V$ 6%&*, GWSY1Vgl,* !#G%&j )* . %+ ' [! k v OvH%+'[!#+#+v.>(' )*!K )9 )9%&2KV#&( )%+*, Z*,6%&k%+#&% )%& <p2323*,uv$A ! $: :V$' @ )9j 6%&2!m : !#XNg%+ 69 *, ' *, ;.p*,62%& lBl!6%&:$g! : %+ ' [!#&*H'[(#&#+v{ )9K%&2KV$#\( 6%&*, !'' V6!'v<pNg% )9*,V; 0 )9$K' *,2V$ )( )%+*, =d 09%+l,9 6*!#&V$ 6%&*, *!. )9$@Ng9$*,#&?:*!2{!%+ A. k vV%& l2323*!v:%&u )%&kV$ 6 :"S!)(#&#&#g%&2#&23 i )( )%+*, 4*!./?/@7 *H*,22 69*H:g*, ' #&V$ )xN|*,i ^d )%&*! W. ! $:#&*H'[!#. a*!Vl,9#v,mD )9%+S(5%&:%+qH%+: : %& 696{S!u )Wnwx9{ 6 S!u K%&: :$%&'[d ) : )* {k%&.F66 )( )%+*, =*!. 69 ONP*(QO$9S!6TSV%&:8TS*N23*H: #fmS )9 HV$236%&' !#!6Z 'M ) ! :e )9' *!V#&%+ l 6)( 6 l!v!Wwx9$3 ' *! :*, : !#&?Ng%+ 69¡ 69 : ' %&$ 6%&*, ¡*!.| 69 V6:~/?/@7I!$6* !'^9GmH%+#&#+V 6)( 6 :KNg%+ 69 OvH%+'[!#S iV2 %&' !#66V# )W;]%& S!#+#+v!m(%+ 69 )9%+6:BS( [mdN|g )9gCD*H'[!#$/1.p 'M s|*,6 'M )%+*, 8<fC¢/@xA2 )9$*;:BV :B.p*,n 69. £.
(16) * *,2 '*,2V$ ^d )%&*! 0%+ e },/ #&*H'[!#9%&)!'^9%&' !#n2KV$#+ )%+l,6%+:8'*, ) L; ! $:eNP l,%+q! H 6*,2~ iV2 %&'[(#|66V# )B'*, ' 6 %+ l¡ *H*,2 6%&2V#\( 6%&*, ¡*!.g )9$gQR 6VkZ~kV :$#& 6l,%&*, *!.nbct78*H'^,QOVGW. . ?e
(17) . . 2%LH )V?2{(6xTSV;L < A
(18) . l,6qH% Ov¡<>2 A 2%LH )V$6?6Z '%+ S'@ i 69S!#+ive< "! $# A &%('*) )d )V6( ):8#+%&hiV%&: 5' % S'@ )9S(#& v < ! $# A #\( 6 g9[d K< +! $u# A C 666V$6 <>n A 9[( g*,V' {<p . / A -, 6 & % 2. > < ) A 2%LH )V1q,#&*H' %+ Ove<>20 $# A * 6#\( 6%+q,Jq, #+*;'%+ Ov¡<pl !x2%& iVx#+%&hiV%&:Gm$2 $# A 1 ^d )%&'?hiVS(#&%+ Ov< 243 36587 A L 5*!6*,%+ Ov¡<=<?>?@A<gA 9 ;: ;BDC )V$6kV#+ ¢:%zGV%&*, ?'*;My' %& D.p*,G )9$s2%LH 6V6F l!v1hiVS( )%+*, 3<>ilE. $# $# A ONP*(QO$9S!6@ )V$6kV#+ a:$vH S!2%&'1qH%&' *,%+ Ov¡<pil+. $# $# A ;F6C 23% LH )V?: %+ Ov¡<pil+.G M/ A J ONP*(QR9S!.p%&' 6%&*, ~ 6 *,< $# A IH #+ 2 ^!uv~q,*!#&V2<K. / A < 2%LH 6V61q!*,#&V2<K.L/^A <?> -MON $*;:S(#G.pV 'M )%&*! 6 )%&'M ) : hiVS! )% Ov
(19) PRQ . S. =T V UXWYZZ[DI\]s
(20) ^t _` . a. . 6 [q, 6!l,%+ l¡ 692{(6 m2*,2 )V$2 ! : 6l!v4hiVS( )%+*, B.p*, [('^99S(6 >< BaVl,9?! :e|9$ 4<o ,AAMmSNPK6V2 )9$ 2I )*~l! 0{23% LH )V:6'6%&; )%&*! *!. )9? ONP*(QO$9S!6@TS*N@W6*qH%&:: 69S( g )9$@.p*!#&#&*Ng%+ lB!6V2$ )%+*, x9*!#&:Xm . cbdb. . V.>!'P 6 %&*, XmqH%&' *,V$F! : )VkV#& n:%+6%&S( 6%&*, !P l,#&' 6 :B! $:K66V6 6 62g! $ l,#+ ' 6 : %& 69S!#& v k!#\! $' ? hiVSd )%&*! Xm 6!23?$6 6V.p*!x ) !2 ! : #&%+hiV%&:Xm ::$v~qH%&' *,%+ Ov 2*H: #fm. N|l,M . }.
(21) <orA~2{!gkS!#\( ' . : P < : A . <orA. < £ A~23*,2 6V2kS(#\! '. : <
(22) : <uo A 1 1 A < : F6C : . : Z< : * < . . P A : J H AA. <£ A. <>} A~ )9S(#& v kS!#&! '. : K% . : Z< P A % * . < :
(23) <o : . <. A 1 :OBDC % A . A A. <>} A. . J6*,#q,J%& ~m$4! $: q(!6%&!k#+ W O {*,6:P 6*' *!23V; ) Sm L{! : C=%+ 3.pV $' )%+*, *!.| ! :¡mGNP :¡N|( 6 ? )962*;:;v; !23%+' )!k#& WXwx9$ m m m )62 !6*,k$ ^(%& :=k v8 69KVK*!.s~#\(6l,6M ?*!.623% QO23%+6%+'[!#D'#&*,V66 #&( )%+*, m5 Y1kv" (#WJ<uo!, AMWswx9=2*,u ~*!. 6 V :! )9=b;'^9#+%&'^9 )%+ l2*;:#a.p*! ! :e )9:%+. QTSV;LC¢#&#+*,V'^9 QuEG*,#+*! ^!023*H: #.p*, WDwx939$[( 6*,V$6' %+ e 69 )9!#& v hiVSd )%&*! %+#&%+ !: 6*@ 69a6 *,#&V; )%&*! B*!.D! l!v kS!#&! ' ghHV( )%+*, B.p*, )96%+2{!uvTS*N@WGw* q(!#&V( ) )9%+0 )62 mZNPB%& '#&V:$*! 69 1'*,6 #&( )%+*, J!k5*!V$ )9@9 ( aML;'^9S! $l,'*;My' %& 0( : 69?Nj(#&#G 6 25)( 6V6(W. F C BDC J H 1. A 1. ,. F6C. a. ' ' *,:%& lx 6*g 699 v;Z k5*!#&%&'i%+ :*(.; 69TS*N hiVSd )%&*! m[NPV6P/1%&%&'^9#+ XkZ*,V $:;Q !v '*, :% )%+*, s( P )uv3*(.G )9$J:*!2{!%+ 8<>23!6TSV;L{! :3 )9!#& v$AP! $:~_JV23! *, |( s L$% J<> 6VAMWHwx9a*! )9$ 6s6%+: *!.5 )9g:*!2{!%+ !6g%&2Z 62[(k#&sNj!#+#&W c@ 6!#&#v3NP' *, %&:x )92I!:%&!kS( 6%&'?! $: Ng% )9 * 69 !a ) W. . 8
(24). 1{rL [X L1L@ [. 4(6*,!'^9 )94 )( )%+*, S!uv`T*rNk v )6! %& e'*,23$V$ ^( 6%&*, GW0O *,V(;Q #&%+'[( 6%&*, $ mN|e'[( $ l,#+ ' N|[q,¡z5 'M ) WJb;*$m|N|e#&%&2%& ( ) )9= 6%&2 )62 %& hHV( )%+*, <uorA WGwx9 iV2 %&'[(#'^9 2 %&1kS(6 :e*, eV $ )V' 6V6:¡ %+ 6K #+ 2 23M )9*H:<>]Fs7=ANg%+ 69 )%QR#&%& $[!B9 L$!9 :$)!#1#&23 i 6~! $: -|)! $ QO_J%+'^9*,#&*, )%+23 6'^9$ 2!Wnwx9$~ ! : q(!%\!k$#& ? )!!q!(#&V( )9${ *H: WO ' *, )6! m )9"q(!%\!k#+?%&x:M S :=k v #&23 [WZ|*, ' %& l )9$hHV( )%+*, 8'*;My' %& )<L5m Sm msWWW A m¢ 69v¡(6l, )!#+#+v: S $ :-k ve #+ 2 [m¢ML;' $ Ng9%&'^9 %& $*;:S(# S #+:XWwx9Ku )66?( :8 69 2{!#DTSVHL 6 62J!6%& )l,)d ) :kiv S( )WZ Z u.p*,62 )9#&V$23%+ lB*!. )923!6g23( )%L5m6Kc?669* 0!#fW¢<uo ! Aj! : VV $: a%& ) Q l,)d )%&*! .p*,a' *!23V; )%& $l3 )9$ #+ 2 J2{( 66%+' Wwx9K:%zGV%&*, )621!%+23#+%&'%+ #&%+!{ 69~.p6%+' )%+*, *, $¡<>2*,23 )V2{AMWnc@ 6!#&#v,m )9!:;q, 'M )%+*, ! :4:6%. K )62. A 1. . :. . db.
(25) . a. !6ML;#+%&'%+ [W %+ c?669*8 !#Ws<o, AMmXNP{%& $' #&V$: |wg/'*,6 'M )%&*! ¡ 6*%& HQ ' [!K )!k%&#+%+ Ov *(. )9' 6)!#:%+z5 'B!:$q! ' 6%&*, 6'^923(W 1 !'^9= )%+23 6 < *,V$ )% ) 6( )%+*, e )*=*,#+q!~ *, #+%& !' *,V$#& : hiVS( 6%&*, )AMmN|{ 6 K6*,#q,3 69 6%+2{(vKTSV$%&:{ l!v hiVS( 6%&*, =<p.pV#+#+v%&2#&%+' %+ ]Fs7=A 6*l,M P 690 )9S!#+ v3*,V' )62 W5wx9iV mXNPK66*,#q,K 69K 69S!#& v hiVS( 6%&*, e! $: )9 )9K'*,V#+ :23!6Q 23*!23 i 6V2 *, jk v3 69@|9*,%& ;Qc@ 9*K2 )9$*;:XmH6c@ 9*B! : |9! ¡<uo!, AMW JV61' *! Vl ( 6 :~l!)!:%+ P23M )9*H:<fxc7=A ' *! :%+ 6%&*, $ :~k v )9J:%\(l,*, S!# < %+ x% ))( 6%&*, )AMW. 2. a. ,. . 2. . YZ . LW [DL@ .
(26). j! :*! e 69 2{( ) (#\[q,'*, ' $ m¢NP9S[q,:q! #&*!5:! !$#&%&' ( )%+*, Ng% )9 )9aj '*;: QO#+%& ( n*!. ON|!6x' !#&#+ :Kub b5m, g/1gc?)!2*, ( :Bw*!V23%X<uo!, AMm Ng9%&'^98V6a 69 @7 *!. ON|!6(WZO )9%+g!#+%&' ( )%+*, Xm$q! )(#Fc@_0| ^!i0! 6V $ %& l4%&2KV# ^! $ *,V#+v!m|' *!V#&: d q,v ' j 6%&2=%+ 6 6( )%+*, ~k v 69eub b ^!"<>' *!V#&%+ l 56%&*H:A Wb;*mDN|323%+23%+'B=7 V#+ 6%&#+BO 66V'M )%&*! B78V$#+ )%+#&/?( ) <78u78/@Ag(#&%+'[( 6%&*, GmHNg% )9:%&u )%&kV$ 6 :2 2*,v!m*, NP*,Hu ^( 6%&*, M ON|*!6W. a. a.
(27). . a. . . ]S*,F[('^9~c@_0 ^(6m, )9xV$6 ' ! 6 sV ' *,V$#&:3kZ*,V :!6%+ W,wx9g'*,V#+ : k5*!V :S!%&x!6?%+ 69 £ /*!x},/ 6l,%&*, $ W!'^9'*,V#+ :k5*!V :S!uv~%+j: : k v k5*!V :S!uv'*, :% )%&*! OvH5"<f( /1%&%&'^9#+ [mPC¢/@0m0WW+W AMmj4c_03 )!6" S!2 <>*q;%+:%& $l 69:S( ^,Aj! :8! 8*!5)( 6*,g S!2<f!a%& )6Z*,#\d )%&*! Xm; u )6%+' 6%&*, XmGW+WW A W . 6 1*,23%& $.p*!623( )%+*, ML;'^9S! l! mD9$ 6 )9*,Vl,9 69Kub b7!u ) 1 )!6m5[!'^9 c_Js6#\[q!g )!6i *NgsNg9%+'^93:( ^1% :P! :BNg9%&'^9 *, $ %+ 2V *q;%+: ( g[('^9' *!V#&%+ lB%+ 6 6( )%+*, XW. a. a. . ~ _. WB [G r ?Y. . !6%& )6 ):e%& 8 69*!5*! )V$ %+ 6%& ak*,Vl,9 1k v/?/@7' *! ' 6 %+ l{ )9$: !# *!.F $*, 8'*, $.p*,23%+ l l,6%+:<>%+ ' [!%& l 2 698' #&#&g iV2KkZ g%+ 8*,23@S( )%+' V#&!x6 Q l,%&*! g%& :5 : i 6#+v*!. )9@*! 69 a*, ^Ag! : *!.F#&!6l!?2369' #+#&x iV2KkZ WZO ! *! )9$ xNj[v!mNP?Ng%&9 6*l! JBS!)(#&#q! 6%&*, *!. )9c@_0j6*!. ON|!@Ng% )9*!V$ 6%+l, %+ '[! j'^9! l,g! : %& q!*,#+qH%& $l*, #v~623!#&# iV2KkZ j*(.$6*H' 6*, m$ OvH%+'[!#+#+v )9*!6 [q(!%&#&!k#&%& #+*;' !#NP*,Hu ^( 6%&*, e M ON|*!6W¢wn!i%+ l~ )9%+1%& 6*!' '*,V ! : :V )* )93H%+ :*(.x hiVS( 6%&*, $! $:kZ*,V :S(ve' *! :%+ 6%&*, $ mDN|3'^9*H*,6{ S()!#+#& # q,66%+*, *!.¢ )9/1%&%&'^9#+ uQ_JV23! {2 69*H:Xm6 V! 6 6*! %<uo[,, A|( : C¢?w!# Q #&'~<o, A m )*36*,#q,KhiVS( 6%&*, $B<uoAx 6*<f},AMWS!#+6*{V$6K/?/@7 !* !'^9 .p*,a 69 6%+2{(vTSV%&: l!v hiVS( 6%&*, GW. ,. wx9a' *,2V$ )( )%+*, S!#;! #Z%&(:$q,' )%+*, Q:$%+z5V6%+*, 6*,k$#& 2 W,wx9a' *!666Z*, :%+ l. .
(28) %& ).>!'j' *! :%+ 6%&*, $F!jk5*( )9B 666s! :Kq(!%\!k#+ ' *, 6%& iV%+ Ov!W ]S*,n23!nTSV;LB! : 6Z '%+ S'@ 69S!#& v 69%&jNg%+ ). . . # # # . < A. . < A. ! :. % # % DB C # % # # BDC % Ng%+ 69. . . . * . F6C < . A. <> A. b. < ,A. P. <> A. Y1 3' ! $*! )%+' B )9V3*!.P )923!6?TSV;L<p *;:!#Fq(!#&V[A1%& u )[(: *!.Pq,#&*H' %+ Ov=%& hHV( )%+*, < Aj%& *!6:g 6*B.>! 6 )9@23!6xTS*N '*, q(( 6%&*, GWSwx9@'^9*,%&'@*!. 69 k5*!V :S!uv ' *! :%+ 6%&*, $g!' '*,V g.p*,x#&*H'[!#5:%& 'M )%&*! *(.n'^9S()!'M ) %&u )%&'?#+%& . . *,V; 6TS*N. _JV23! %+ $TS*
(29) N. /1%&%&'^9#+ W . wx9 )%&2 6 %&D%& $: Z :$ .p*! !'^9 )!6W(78*, *q, mNPP: !# Ng%+ 69*q! 6#&!%+ l ! : *, $*rq! #\!$%& l@'[(6 Wiw*@%& $' 6 !6gu ^!k%+#&% OvK! $:'*, q,6l, ' (mHNPJ%+ )6*H:V' 6#\dL$( 6%&*, "6*H' 6 *, " )9q(!#+V <> 6666 ! :q(!%\!k#+ )A %+23Z*,6:*, 69 ' *,V$#&:Bk5*,V$ :S!%& W,]S*,¢ )9x*q! 6#&!%+ l1' !6(m(NPx5.p*,2 #+%& !%+ ) 5*!#\( 6%&*, *,:%& 'M |dzG' ^d )%&*! *!.G #&:$s*! 3 )9$a'*,V#+ :k5*!V :S!%& WiJ6(mH*! JV$6 P/?/@7 !g#&*H'[!#56' *, $:%+ 6%&*, < ,!'*,k%\A|%& u )[(: *(.nS( )% )%+*, :~q! 6%&*! *!.Fxc7¡W. 2 . 8
(30). . 1{rL . [X [. ! #"$ . a. a. O 69xkS!'^il,*,V : S #+: *!.5 69Jbc`%&2KV#&( )%+*, XmNPa'^9$*;*,a 69aj jCY1w a 23*H'^,QOVGmj!2S! {! : |*!V'^9 ) ?<uo,! AMWiwx91%& sS! P.p*,62P! ~9S!#.D'vH#+%& : *!.¢$W £ 2 %+ {:%&!2 )|( :~$Wo2 %+ {9%&l,9 W;wx9J%& %&:a%& S#+#& :Ng%+ 69~`9S!Z : )VkZkV $:#&(m ;W £ 2 %& 9%&l,9 [mP%& Ng9%+'^9 6)[q,#& )9$9*! %&23!vTS*N@WgY1 . . b. .
(31) Top subdomain. Middle subdomain. Bottom subdomain. 㥾ÐÇÚ EÚnëƯ´±V±³µÁÇé{ÎÇ»I¿Ä[¾À·¯µr²6ÄN´¸¾¸¾»I· ¿±¶µÆ¯¾Å·ÇÐ
(32). TS*N :%+ )%&kV; )%&*! ¡k!m¢ %& $ 6VkZ3VZ*, #\d ) ! $: *, ${! 6%QRqH%+k)( 6%& l k! !6B 5' )%q,#+v=#+*;' ( ):e( 1 69Bk5*( 6 )*!28m5 )6!%&l!9i ?! :' V$q,:S( ?*!. 69K )VkZ kV :$#&!W. . "
(33) ! #"$ . wx96@S! 6%+ 6%&*, sN|6? )%&:XW]S*,x(#&#G' !6 m 69?:*,23!%& {'[!uq;%+ lB%&P.p*,#&#+*rNg%+ l 69 23 ! TS*N :%+6' )%+*, XW . . wx9s S6u F*, $|%& q!*,#+q! 696j *, *q, #\!$%& lJ6VkZ:*,23!%+ *, .p*, )9s%& '*,2BQ %+ lT*rNU l,%+*, -<p S!2 :kZ*! )*,2{AMm*, .p*,g )9 )6!%&l!9i JS!u <p S!2 :=2%&::$#&A ! $: *, $ .p*!1 )9 )VkZ k5 :$#&V? )9$ L;%+ @TS*N 6l,%&*! <p S!2 :e )*,SAMWXO [!'^9 Vk5:$*,2{(%& )932369%+ l %&? )9kZ K[q!(%&#\(k#&(mG6* )93!6 2k#+v¡%&@ *! ' *! ;Q .p*,23%+ lm @]n%+lW £ W$wx9?S( 6%\!#Z66*,#+V$ )%+*, {*!.¢VkZ:*,23!%& P*, ?( :~ )9 @! %+ ' [! :Xm*K )9?'Vk%+'?6*H*! j*!.¢ 69?23 ! ' #&#Zq,*,#+V230%&j*!.*,: x*(. 69?% )'^9 *!. )9$@ 6VkZk$V :#+!Wwx9@ )*( ^!#X iV2k5a*(.n' #&#+x%&g!*,V : !$m ,,;W. b. Gb.
(34) wx91 ONP**! )9xS!u )%+ 6%&*, $j%& q,*!#+q,1 ONP* 6VkZ:*,23!%+ <> S(23:~ )*, ! :kZ*! 6 6*,2{A ! $:!6%&2%&#&!G'*, %&:6%& $la 69P iV2k5*!.$' #&#&s< ;m !, AX! : )9s' *! $.p*,62%& $l *!. )9$l!#&*,kS(#Gl,%&:Xmk$V$ x )9Mv:%+z5 xk v~ 69@ML;%&u ) ' *!.F*q! 6#&!%+ lW . b. . .
(35)
(36)
(37) . O B[!'^9 ' !6(m,*, j$6*H' 6*,n%&F:Mq,*! 6 :B )*0*, jVk5:$*,2{(%& XW!b;*md )9j hiV%+6 :K 6*! ^(# 2323*!v%&J6[!:*rq! 0 69K*;' 6*, WX]S*,a%& $ ^( ' (m ,{78*~%+J ::e%& 8 69 '[!{*!.P )9 )9$6 36VkZ:*,23!%+ @S! 6%+ 6%&*, XWXC¢%+! )9%+@%&!6*!V :9!#+.|*!.| 69 6*! ^(# 2323*!v'[!!' % Ov[q(!%+#\!k#+.p*,F!#+# )9j'*,2V$ ) FV 6m,6V$ %& $l0 )9P6%+2KV#\d )%&*! %&g *! J! 8[!uv ^!W5O 8' *, )6! mS )96% )VS( 6%&*, %+gNP #+#Dk5M 6 6 gNg9 (6i%& l £ ;m o £ ( : o £ 78*.p*, )9 =*;' 6*, Wj]S*,3 *, *q! 6#&!%+ lVk5:$*,2{(%& m 69 6#\dL$( 6%&*, 3' *Hy' %+ x.p*,P 691'*,V#+ : kZ*,V :S(6%&j%&P hiVS!#5 )*B$W W;wx9?%& ).>!' ' *, $:%+ 6%&*, g(6@!$#&%&:[!'^9¡oB*,V$ 6 g%+ 6 )d )%&*! @< 6%&21 6 )AMW. . 2. . .
(38) "
(39) ! #"$ . J6!m$*, ?' *!23S(6 P )9@/?/@7 V#+ 6jNg%+ )9~ 690.pV#+#G:*!2{!%+ {'*,23$V$ ^( 6%&*, {*, W 9ivH%&'[(#Z2*H: #+! : iV236%+'[!#!)!2 6 P(6g%&: )%&' !#W H%+ l@ #&( )%q,x:%.\Q .p '66*!x*!. o m )9@u )[(:$v )( )@%&x[!'^9 %& ,;o@ 6%&21 6 W. a. P / $#. Three subdomains partition Mass flux. coupling 10 ite. relax. = 0.4. Relative difference norm L2 (log10). −2.5 bottom middle top full domain. −3.5. −4.5 0.0. 400.0 Time Iterations. 800.0. 㪾ÅÐÇÚ6ùEÚ Û »I·æ[±V´Ð[±¶·¯Ïf±QƯ¾Åµa¸a»[´â_»[Ì¥¸ÆDZæÄN´p¾ÅÄNénñ¶µwÌå»[´¸ÆDZ³¸Æ¯´±V±³µÁÇé{ÎÇ»I¿Ä[¾À·¯µº²nÄN´¸¾¸¾»I· wx9.pV#+#:$*,2{(%& 6%&2V#\( 6%&*, :@!*,V :o,,3 6%&2u )0 )*3q, %+.v )9)!2 ' %+ )6%&$mP w!k#+o,Wj|*, 6hiV )#v,mj 69e!2*,V ~*!.@6[q, : )%+238%+ 6 )d )%&*! 3%+ !kZ*,V$ , :$V 6*¡/?/@7 6' *, :$%+ )%+*, %+ lWnwx9$8]%&l,V }e69*Ng )9 #\d )%+q!. .
(40) Three subdomains partition Mass flux boundary values. Relative difference norm L2 (Log 10). −1.0 Neu. bot./middle Dir. bot./middle Neu. middle/top Dir. middle/top. −2.0. −3.0. −4.0. −5.0. −6.0 0.0. 200.0. 400.0 Time iterations. 600.0. 800.0. 㥿¾Ä[ÐǾÀÚ ·¯ÇµwÚ ²nÛ ÄN»I´·¸¾æ[¸±V¾Å»I´Ð[· ±¶·¯Ïf±Æ¯¾Àµa¸a»[´â»[Ì{¸ÆDZBée»IÁn·¯Î¯ÄN´âOæNÄ[ÃÅÁDZ¶µBÓY¿ Ä[µµº¹nÁènÖªÌS»[´º¸ÆDZ2¸ÆÇ´±V±2µÁÇé{ÎÇ»NÙ . :%+z5 '=q!*,#&V; )%&*! *!.. # @ C £ *! ! W. . < )9=hiVS( i 6%+ OvNg%+ 69" )9$=#&*NP ~'*, q, l, $' )d )A. W$J6@ %&| 69?*,V$ 6 x% ) 6( )%+*, { iV2k5g! : )9? $*,62. %&| 69. . ]S*,| )9$'*,V#+ :kZ*,V :S(6%& m*! @69*Nga6%&2%&#&!shHV! )%+ 6%&x*, ]n%&l,V$6 m$kV$ %&a *N )9' *,V$#&%+ l3% ))( 6%&*, iV2KkZ WG]S*,a_JV23! ='*,V#+ :kZ*,V $:S!6%+ m 69 2{(6xTSV;L%+x6#\!' : k v~ )9@u )66 <p6hiVS( 6%&*, A W. . 2. wx9j 6%&2J.p*,j 69?6#+*N| g ^!e< )*,Xm; )VkZ?k5 : 6 l!%&*, As%&1o £ x*, b$0_a#+ )6 b;S(6' £ m £ ,7 W Pv '*,23!6%+6*, ~ 6* 69?*q,)!#+#D' *,2V$ )( )%+*, XmH*, )[q, ! *!.| )9j )%&2 ¢ % )9 %&: i 6%&' !# )%&2 )- iV2KkZ m¢ )9${6Z :;Q V4! : )93S!)(#&#&#y' %+ 'Mv! !*,V : £ ! :-$W 6 5' 6%+q,#+v!WFwx9j *q, 9[(:%+¢!k5*!V$ £ 5X )%&2nu )Xm[ )9Sd ¢%&X[!*, S!k#+!W[R ¢2V DkZ 29S(6% : )9Sd x )9%+gj*q! 69$[!: 2{[v35 S!#+% J )9?'*,23$V$ ^( 6%&*, %.D )9?'*,V#+%& lBZ %&*H: q(!#&V%+ )*H*2V'^9 :' [! :XWaO 69 )VkZ¡k5 :` l,%+*, Xm| 69 /?/@7 ( : 69 .pV#&#:*!2{!%+ '*,2V$ ^d )%&*! !6q, uv%&2%&#&!0Ng%+ 69%& S!u )%&'V#\(1 )9~6!2 6%&2 6 XW |V; g%& ' *! 6hHV$ '*!.%& $' 6 !6: )%&21u ) $a%+ ~ )9?V$ 66[(2 6l,%&*, $ m; 69 ' *,V$#&:~k5*!V :S!uvl, |23*,J6!%+:#+v %&l,9 sq!(#&VP%+ 3 )9$?/?/@7 ' !6(m$60w!k#+o < x( : AMW. . b. .
(41) . |*,2S!6%+ l6*,2 l!#&*,kS(#?hHV! )%+ 6%&*, )9 6%& ML;%+ =!6 ! $:` )9$ q(!6%&!k#+ S #+: )923 #q, %& !'^9 Vk5:$*,2{(%& XmsN|¡'[! hiVS! )%.v )9$ (' ' V$)!'Mv *!. 69 /?/@7 66V# )W |*, ' %& l )9 q(!%\!k$#& mB )9 C £ $*,62 6#\( 6%+q! :%zG6 $' < Ng96 9*,#+:n.p*,Fq(!%\!k#+ n! :B.p:B.p*,F.pV#&#;:*,23!%& 6%&2V#\dQ )%+*, AP%+x2{dL;%+2{!#%+ 69? 6)!%+l,9 gS!u x6l,%&*, ~.p*!j )9?23!6jTV;L ! : 69@6Z ' % S' )9!#& v <>!k5*!V$ o ! $: o[ 6 5' 6%+q,#+v$A! :B%+ K )9g%& $' *,2%& laTS*N l,%+*, .p*,n 69x66V6<f!*,V : o AMm(6 gw!k#+ £ Wi|*, $' %& $l@ 69xl,#+*,kS!#HhiVS! )% )%&. > @ . P . . P . /. . .
(42) * ~ )9$1ML;%+ m; 6916#\( 6%+q!0:%zG6 $' j.p*!| )9023 ! )( )%+'0hiVS!#+%+ Ov,mi )9$123 ! ~q,*!%&: , .p)!'M )%+*, ! $: )9${l !TS*N )( 6~!{#+ 6 )9S( o WO 5' K 6*8 )9${2%LH )V TS*N 6( )(m )9@6#\( 6%+q!?:%+z5 '%+g!6*!V : o[ W. a 6. . P . wn(k#&Bo . a. +# #a%+ !#+#mFNP=' *! 6%+: )96= 6V$#+ )~!{6( )%+.>!'M )*,uvNg% )9"6 l,!6: 6*! !#+vH6%+ *!.a%& :$V 66%\(#xbcBWFO !::% )%+*, Xm%+ B%+K:%+y'V#+ K 6*q(!#+VS( )~ 69 S!u B*!.a )9~T*rN %& u ^!k$%&#&% OvB%& 3 )96 x V#+ 6 W]S*,s%& $ ^( ' (m; )9$15*!%& )|!6*;'%\( 6 :{Ng% )9{ 69123dLiQ %&23!#F #\d )%+q! 2{!TV;L :%+z5 '~!3#+*;' ( ): %+ ¡TS*N 2%L;%& $l l,%+*, @6V$'^9-! :*Ng 66 !2 .p6*,2 )9?TS*N :$%& 66%+kV$ )%+*, ~kS3*,x !x )9@kZ*,%&#+%& l.p6*, W. a 6. . wn(k#& £ . " "
(43) ! #"$ . . wx9K 6V$#+ )0' *, ' %& l3 )9 ONP*~ *! *q, #\!$%& l{6VkZ:*,23!%& $JS( )% )%+*, #+[!: )* 6%+23%+#\!J' *, '#&V%&*, $ *,V$ 6 @%+ 6 )d )%&*! ¡6[q;%+ l }, ¢, ~mjs )%+23B6[q;%+ l
(44) S, mSMy' %& ' v ~W. . . . . b *m *, $a'*, ' )6( )| *N *, )9$a%&2KV$#\( 6%&*, .p ( )V$6 s*!.5 )9g*q,6#\(%& $lVk5:$*(Q ; 2{(%& j' !6(WSR x'[( 8kZ1qH%&NP :8!g! L; 6 %&*, *!. )9$?%+ ))( 6%+q!123M )9*H: V :.p*, *, *q! 6#&!%+ l' !6 WY?V$s 6 |' *,2V$ )( )%+*, s*!.X 69J2*H'^ QRV{Ng% )93 ONP*KVk5:$*(Q 2{(%& xS( )% )%+*, 9S[q,69*Ng )9S( 69@*rq! #\!$%& l%& '6 !6a 69@' *,2V$ )( )%+*, 6*,k$V 6 0! $: 69S( x )9$:$%&6'6S! '%& g%+ ~ )9@*q,6#\(%& $l l,%+*, !@NP[(Zm ]n%&l$W W. . . ]S*,F%& $ ^( ' g! $:'*, ' 6 $%& l? )9$x' *,2V$ )( )%+*, K6*!kV 6 m )9$a*q! 6#&!%+ l?'[(6 !#&#+*NgjVx )* ' *! iq! l,Mq, 8%+.¢ )9$%+ %+ 6%\!#Z6( )%&!#G:%+ 66%&k$V$ )%+*, *!. )9@6Z '%+ S'@ ;Q )9S(#& v(6~:%+6'*, )%& iV*!V ( K 69~6V$k5:*!2{!%+ K%& ).>!'!Wwx9%&K%+B=6Mq,6 ) k5'[!V$6 )9S(#& v=q(!6%&( )%+*, =#+[!:? 6* 2%LH 6V6q! #+*;'%+ Ove! $:¡$6 6V3q(!%\( 6%&*, )9*,Vl,9 )9 : $6%+ Ov*, $ Wa %+ 69` *! *q, #\!$%& l"6VkZ:*,23!%+ 8! 6%+ )%+*, Xm| 69 )!2' *!23V; ^( 6%&*, : V :$ 6#\dL$( 6%&*, <p%& ).>!'' *, $:%+ 6%&*, !$#&%+'[( 6%&*, A )* ' *! iq! l,!WZR.n $*! [mKTS*N %+ q, 6%+*, 8*H' 'V6a! $: 69@' *,2V$ )( )%+*, ~.>!#&#+ W. . . j~L|~ . W
(45) @. . Nj( i 0 )*~Z u.p*,62I )9$K' *,2V$ )( )%+*, *!.s3#+*;' !#¢6VkZ:*,23!%& Ng%+ 693 S 2369 ! :XmP%& )9=6!28 )%+23(m )*V= )9%+{9%+l,9 *,#&V$ 6%&*, %& $.p*,2{d )%&*! %+ *,: 3 )* %& '6 !6j 69a!' 'V)!'MvB*!. )9$x6%&2V#\( 6%&*, *!. )9jNg9*!#&x:*,23!%+ XW(w*@:*,%+ l1 )9%+ m!NP V6|#&*H'[!#i9%+ )(6'^9%+'[!#H2369g<>#+*;' !#i2KV# )%&l!6%&:SAX! : 69xCD*;' !#H/1.p' s|*,6' )%+*, 23M )9*H:XW. o.
(46) 㥾ÐÇÚ EÚnë ¼º»»îæ[±V´TÃÅÄN²¯²n¾À·ÇеÁÇé{ÎÇ»I¿Ä[¾À·¯µr²6ÄN´¸¾¸¾»I·4¿±¶µTƯ¾Å·ÇÐ . . . . . . "
(47) . "
(48)
(49) #"$ " .
(50) # . @N|! J 6*3[!'^9u )[(:$v ^d )@TS*N 6%+2KV#\d )%&*! ~k vB )6! %& a' *!23V; ^( 6%&*, XW |*, hiV 6#+v,mD 69 3(6 6%&2 )62?%& = )9$BkS!#\( ' BhHV( )%+*, WGwx9BV6: 2% %&2#&%+' % a!* !'^9#& !:a )*{#&% 6 )%+ l{*(. )9KhiVS( )%+*, 6 621%+ i 6* ! =*!5)( 6*, S!u =<p#&M. QO9! :46%+:!m%&2#+%&' % A@! :¡*,V6'8! <>%&l,9 uQO9S! $:"%&:(mML;#&%+' % AMW 'M )VS!#+#+v!m¢ 69{23!%+ V5*!6{*(.x )9%+ )%+23 '^9 2~%& )*=*q! 6'*,23 )9$~ *, #+%& ;Q [!B.p ( )V <>6#\dL$( 6%&*, -$6*H' ^A W|7 *,6*rq! m 696*,V$6' )62 %& - )9kS(#\! ' hiVS( 6%&*, $J(6?:5 : 0*!. 69@V i *Ng 8q(!%\!k$#& W. a. o,o.
(51) O )9%+ )6*H:V' : C¢/@I!#+%&' ( )%+*, XmFNP:*- *! ~ )!!%+ )*-!'' *,V$ i 69 6%&2 )62 mS.p*;'V6%+ l*, #+v*! 8 )9$u )[(:$v ^d ) hiVS( 6%&*, a )*6*,#q,(WGa '!mN|6M.p ^!(@%& )*!'' *,V J hiVS( 6%&*, $jNg%+ )9 )9$@.p*!#&#&*Ng%+ l.p*,2 w<pVA $W. . E. wx9xl,* (#;*!.S 69gC¢/@23M )9*H:K%+n )*1#+*;' !#&#v?' *!66' 69j:%+6' 6% :B*,Z )d )*,m(6vH m¢%& q,*,#q,:%& 693 iV2 %&' !#66*,#+V$ )%+*, e*!.x:%&' )% : hHV( )%+*, *! l,%+q! 2369 < A $WZ]S*,aB $L; ::%+6' 6% d )%&*! *!6: mS )9 6*,a' *,2 a96 .p6*,2 )9@S!' :%+6' 6% d )%&*! ¡<>6!' 6 A W. N
(52) N N N. a. j!%&'[(#&#+v!m!NP0: !#ZNg% )9 ON|*:%&' 6M )% ( 6%&*, *!.G )9a*,Z )d )*,w?W '* !60*, $K<p*, )! :S!:*, !m A|%+ ~ )91Ng9*!#&?' *!23V; ^( 6%&*, ~:$*,2{(%& Xm;)[vH m! : K S ?*, (m m5%& = 69 *H*,2 6 l!%&*, <p%&26*q,23 ?%& 69B6!' 6 A mX)[vH W¢c? )!#+#+v,m )9' * !6B:%+6'6 6% ( )%+*, =!#+#&*Ng1( [!uv= iV2 6%+'[!#66*,#+V$ )%+*, XmZkV$ ?23[v%+ )6*dQ :V'#&!6l!0 6*,x%& *,230S! 6%&'V#\!PS!u )x*!.¢ )9$?' *,2V$ )( )%+*, ~:*,23!%+ XW x 69 *,Z*,6% )(md 69j iV2 6%+'[!#;66*,#+V$ )%+*, %+n $9S! ' :BNg%+ 69K )9| j:%+6' 6% d )%&*! XmrkV$ 23*!6| L;5 6%q,!W,J $' !m(N|j*! #+v23v'*,23$V$ )|0S!u F*!.S 69|Ng9*,#+|:*!2{!%+ XWrwx9 6)( 6 l!v%+g 6*3*,#+q! 69@#&*H'[!#G6*,k$#& 2 Ng%+ )9 )9$kZ u 0:%+6'6 6% ( )%+*, ! : #&*H'[!#+#+v ' *,6' )9 )! :S(6: L;666%+*, *(.| )9$3*,Z 6( )*!?%& )9 Ng9*,#+ :*,23!%& XWGw* :* )9%+ mS( 8% ) 6( )%q,?*;' a%+a!#+%& :GW. #. . # . a. . ] *,s! 3:$ ^(%&#&: 66 )( )%+*, {*!.5 )9JC¢/@2 69*;:Gm 6 g )9$0J!'^ikV6'^9 x*,%&l,%+ S!# S S!Z <>0!'^ikV'^9Xmao, A WFO - )9 .p*,#+#&*Ng%& $l=6' )%+*, XmnNP66 i )9$ 2*H:%+ S: C¢/@`23M )9*H: V6:%& )9Kc_0x6*(. ONj!!mZ%& '#&V:$%& lB )9$ *, 8#&%+ [!j.p ( )V$6 !xN|#&#¢!xZ*,6%&k$#&!W. . ! #"$ . #. "
(53). . .
(54) . " . C D k5 )92369(66*H' %&( ):Ng%+ 698 69u ^! :!6:=S!'K:%&' )% ( 6%&*, *!.F 69 l,#&*!kS!#,:*!2{!%+ ! : 69P2 9(66*H' %&( ):Ng% )9@ )9s#&*H'[!#!6*,k$#& 2 <p S $ :%&' )% ( 6%&*, SAMW :~#&M kZa 690kZ*,V $:S!v *(. ( : k5a )9akZ*,V :S(v *!. Wiwx91#+*;' !#S2369 ( :{ )9$0l,#+*,kS!#S2 9 !6a 2k5:: :~.p*!62%& l9$%& 6!6'^9$%&'[(# l,6%+:= 66V'M )V!WXwx9$B%& )6 S!#k5*!V :S!uv%+1l,%q, k v WXCD k5 69 ' * (66P *H: %& '#&V::%+ )9$ *H*,2 l,%+*, *!.$ )9 2 69K! : k5s )9P%& )6 S(# *H: g*!. W. # a
(55) #. . # # # a . a. B. a. wx9K% ) 6( )%q,6*H' 61%+J 69.p*,#+#&*Ng%& $lWSCD kZ 69'^9S()!'M ) %&u )%&'.pV 'M )%&*! *!. ! : 69@%& % )%\(#G!$6*[L;%&23( )%+*, ~*!. )9$*,#&V; )%&*! *, 69@2369 W. a . . "!#. #$ ! $ # N O #. # #. u ^!u xNg%+ )9 ;m l,%q, m% ;mDo,m £ mDWW+W :*6*,2?62*H*! )9%+ lB%+ 6 6( )%+*, |.p*,j 69@l,#&*!kS!#G$6*,k#+ 2 < A *, m ' *!23V; )F )9$%& )6 S!#!k5*,V$ :S!uv0q(!#&V$ D*, m kiv1%& )6Z*,#\( 6%&*, a.p*,X%+ )! ' (m :*6*,2?62*H*! )9%+ lB%+ 6 6( )%+*, |.p*,j 69@#&*H'[!#56*!k#&2 < A `B*, m ' *!23V; )? )9@ 66%+' )%+*, *!. <p'[!#+#& : <>%+ AMm £ A|*, *H: g*!. :M S @ )9@ L; a%&l,9 QR9S! :%&:@k v. . . N . *)+ N#. o £. % # & ( N . N# '$ # N # a # #.
(56) $ # N # B # <&) £ N# AMW !:$:e 69 C¢/@ 6 231 6* 69 6%+l,9 QO9! :S!u @*!.s )9B ' *! :S!uvTS*Nt $ 6l(v kS!#&! ' hHV( )%+*, ( :2*,2 )V$2 kS!#&! ' hHV( )%+*, XWr_J*a' *!66' 6%&*, %&¢Z .p*!62 : *, ~ )9$?666V$6 hiVS( 6%&*, *!.¢ 69|9*,%& !#+l,*,6% )92 < )9@C¢/@ )62 %&j( $ a' *! ;Q )! |:V$6%& $l? )%+23xu ) SAMWHJ6!m u ^! :$P.p*, )9$a'*,V#+K<>m An.p*, )9a $ 6l(v. N. kS!#&! ' ?hiVS( )%+*, 8! : .p*,< . msAP.p*,j 69@23*!23 i 6V2. ,. kS(#\! '? hiVS( 6%&*, GW. j!%&'[(#&#+v )9%+j!#+l,*,6% )92 23[vk5aq;%+NP : #+%&!0' #&!6%&' !#GC¢/@% ) 6( )%+*, s#&*H*,%& Ng9%&'^9 NPa:$* *( 6*,#q,xML$!'M )#vK )9g#+*;' !#! $:3l,#+*,kS!#;6*!k#&23m!kV$ s*, $#+vKZ u.p*,62 .pN`%+ 6 )d )%&*! ?<p 'A|*!.*, $?%+ ))( 6%+q!123M )9*H: )9?VVS!#X iV2 %&' !#5 6 '^9 %+hiV g*!. c@ $%mS S!2 #v~*,V; ) g% ) 6( )%+*, |.p*!g 69@ *, #&%+ [!j 6 23<p 6)! $6%& J'*,2V$ ^rQ )%+*, Ng%+ )9 B623% QO%+23#+%&'%+ s!$6* !'^9SAg( :|*, Vl ( 6 :c@6!:%& x Ov;Z@23M )9*H: .p*,g )9#&%& $[!xuv;u )2 6*!#+qH%& l$WSR 0' ! =kZqH%&MN%& ) 23a*!.'#\!6%+'[!#¢*,V$ 6 a%+ 6 )rQ )%+*, x<p%W !Wr )%+23s%+ 6 )d )%&*! ^AGNg%+ 69KZ 6%+*;:$%&'sV5:( )F*!.S )9$j:.p' '*,6 'M )%&*! q(!#&V .p*,j )9$l!#&*,kS(#G*,k#&2I! :*!. )9$kZ*,V $:S!v{q!(#&Vg.p*!j )9@#&*H'[(#G*, (W. . . P9S[q,P66 6 :K )9$|2KV# )%+#&%+'[( 6%+q,q,66%+*, <p6 hiV )%\(#;*, $A*(.$ )9$j!#+l,*,6% )92 m kV$ sN|a9S[q,0!#&*:$q,#&*,Z :{! ~(::%+ 6%+q!gq! 6%&*! <>!)!#+#&#$*, [AMWiO ~(#&#' !6 mH*, 6#&q!Kc? $ %X )!6 V x.p*,j )9$l,#+*,kS!#5:*,23!%& '*,2V$ ^d )%&*! 8( :6q! 6!#*( )96 .p*,j )9$ *;*!2 6VkZ:*,23!%+ j' *!23V; ^( 6%&*, <p*, @k v 6V$k5:*!2{!%+ AMW / ( ^ ! a.p6*,2 69 *H*,2I6VkZ:*,23!%+ 6* 69l,#&*,k!#X*, ?.p*,x 69$V6Z*,6*!. ? )9 S#&#+%& l *!.j 69~:M.p 'M K' *!66' 6%&*, q(!#+V Wn]S*,#+#&*Ng%& $l 693 OvHZ~*!.x 69{kS(#\! ' hiVS( 6%&*, Gm( )9$j6 i :( ^1(6j5' %+ 'j )9!#& v,m!2{!nTSV;L5mdq,*,#+V23s )9623!#$*,V' *,j 6V!WSwx9 XmSk v~2[! *!.' ! *, %+'[!#56 )%&'M )%&*! @<p.p*!|q(!6%&!k#&^A*,|q,*!#&V2 N|%&l,9 6 :6 u )%&' 6%&*, $s<p.p*,G 69 2{(#,6*,V$6' n( :@666V$6 )AMmNPP 66%+' D )9$ 6:Sd ^ *, 3!#&# $*;:P*(.G )9$Jl,#+*,kS!#$:*,23!%& B2 9{%& $' #&V$: :%& B )9$ *;*,2 6 l!%&*, <>ML;' $ ( 0 69B/1%+6%&'^9$#& a *H:^AMW5wx9K#+*;' !#¢:.p' @' *!66' 6%&*, aq(!#&V1!K' *!23V; ) :8.p*, )9P *H: F*(. )9Pl,#&*!kS!#i2369K%+ ' #+V::%& )9P' *,6' )%+*, K l,%+*, Xm Wdwx96x *H: m %& '#&V:$ :%& mD!B:%&u ^! @*!. )9$B%& )6 S!#k5*!V :S!uv *H: ?k v2*, )9S( *, *,j ONP*{ #+ 2 )WSwx9@MLH ) 6%+*, *!.n 69%&x l,%+*, %&x23! S!l! :k v )9@' *H:@V 6W. a. a . a. . "
(57)
(58) #"$
(59)
(60). "
(61)
(62) #"$ . # &) N#. ) N#. wx9B' *!66' 6%&*, = 6 62 %& < £ AaNg9 £ ^( :1.p*,0 69K 66%+' )%+*, =*, = 69 l,#&*!kS!#:*,23!%+ *!.| )923% LH ) V 35' %+ '{ 69S!#& v<> $*! ): J^A m*(.j )92%LH )V. . . ). 66V6<> *! 6 : )A( : *!. )9¡2%LH )Ve2{! TSV;L <> $*! ): (A %& % )%&!#&#v ' *,2V$ 6 : *, 3 )9 *;*,2 Vk5:$*,2{(%& XWHwx91'*,V )6S!u g*!.D )9$1vH2KkZ*,#&%+'J*!5)( 6*, < £ As%+s 69J S $%+ )a #+ 2 |.p*!62KV#&( )%+*, B*!.D 69J.p*,#+#&*Ng%& $l@ 6 2 <p%& '[!1*!.X 69 :6%. xTSV;L9 vHZ*! )96%+^AMm*, 69@2369 *!. 69@l,#&*!kS!#G:$*,2{(%& . # &) N#. . o}.
(63) . M N : < ) P A % ). A A 1 A. $Q Q Q Q M N : Q. < M N A < :OBDCO % ),A. < :
(64) $Q. . <o. <> A. Q < )!A #\d ) P9 [d [m $Q < % ) )!A u ^( 6 %&'ahiVS!#&% Ov,m Q < % ) ),A 23% L; 6V6g: ;Q 6% Ov,m A 1 Q < % ) ) )!A #\d )%+q!Fq,#&*H' %+ Ov!m =Q 6*,V' )62 %& $' #&V$:%& lj 69s6 u )%&' 6 :. . Ng%+ 69. . q,*,#+V2a 69 2{!#Z6*!V6'!m; 690kZ*,V $:S!v )9$ 623!#STSV;L~! :Gm;Z*,6%&k#v,m )9$166V6 l,)(:%& i s )62 WiR.¢ML;%+ )mH 69%&s#\( s ) 2 %&P.pV $' )%+*, {*(.X )9J6 )%&'M ) :3q!(6%\(k#& <fa m Hm)AMW. ). BDC. *, ' 6 $%& lK 690 *! ~#&%+ [!.p[d )V!m; 69JNP[(H $ 6g#+%& s%& 3 )90q(!#+V P*!. | m;'*,2BQ V$ 6 :=Ng%+ 69 )9$q(!6%&!k#+ g ^!( e( J )9' V6 ?*!V$ )1%+ 6 )d )%&*! <p%W !WS )%+23%+ 6 )rQ )%+*, AMmH! $:~*!.D )9$Jq,*!#&V2J 69 2{!#*,V6' <>V$61*!.D 690 u )6%+' 6 :~q,*!#&V2a 69 2{(# 6*,V$6' [AMW. . "
(65)
(66) #"$
(67)
(68). "
(69) " . #"$ . . # )+ N# . w 9¡' *,6 'M )%+*, ) 2 x < : :`6 u )%&' 6 : £ AMm|Ng% )9 )9e6!23eqH%&*!V6#v q(!6%&!k#& mi%& )9$J S % )a #+ 2 |.p*,2KV#&( )%+*, *!.X )9$J.p*,#+#&*Ng%& l@ $ L $6 6%+*, ¡<>%+ {'[(6 *!. )9@:%+. xTSV;L 9ivHZ*! )9$ 6%+^A. . M N : < ) P A ) < :
(70) $Q <o $Q A Q A 1 J ). R M N : Q : HQ M N : F6C < ). .p6%+' )%+*, ~ ) 6*! m. ! $:. <. . J H Q < % ) ). Ng%+ 694 69 )(23 *( ^( 6%&*, )9S! 4(k5*q,(m. )c ) Q. Q 1 Q A. : M NA ) ),A. . . <uo[ A. )!A%+K )9~ 6*! ^(#P ONP*(QO9!6. j%&x 69@k5*,V$ :S!uv 66 W. FC. wx9NP[(H $ 6?'*, ' 6 $%& l )9 *, 8#&%& $[!j.p ( )V#+%& g*, $#+v %+ 69q(!#+V g*!. m ' *,2V$ 6 :Ng% )9 )9s' V6 i F%+ ))( 6%&*, ?q(!%\!k#+ ! : *! Ng%+ )9 )9P6 )%&'M ) :*, W. o. .
(71) 8
(72). . . 1{rL . [X [. ! #"$ . ?'^9$*;*,? )*B' *!23V; )@ *H*,2 6%+2KV#\d )%&*! {*!.¢ )9$xQR 6Vk50kV :#+?6l,%&*, Gm!kZ*q, )90#\!u P 6Vk506VZ*,u x#\d )!mi*!.D 69@j jCY1w J42*;'^,QOV$~6MqH%&*,V#+v36 Q 6 i 6 :<f/?/@7 ) '[! )AMWD i *Nt 69 ML;%&u ) $' *!.PTV%&:q,*! )%+' #+*;' ( ):%& )9@kV$ :#&?N|!!(W. a. a. gN|! j' *!23S(6x )9JC¢/@ *;*,2 V#+ 61<p: *( ) :{C¢/@xANg% )95*,u QR6*H' 66%+ l <>*,P'^9S!%+ :APEG*;*!2 ' *,2V$ )( )%+*, mi: *! 6 :*! [W Pv5*! QR6*H' 6%& lmiNP123 ! J'*,23$V$ ^( 6%&*, %& @ ONP*1%& :$ Z : ! :6V'' 6%q,x 6 6 md 69s' *,2V$ )( )%+*, *!.s )9Bl,#+*,kS!#:*,23!%& e( :XmX ' *! :XmD )9 '*,23$V$ ^( 6%&*, *!.P 69 *H*,2 VkZ:*,23!%& XW K!#&*{Nj( i 1' *,2S!KC¢/@ *H*,2 6 V#+ 60Ng%+ 69l,#&*!kS!#¢:*,23!%& 86%+2KV#\d )%&*! a( #&*N ! : 9%&l,9S!' @ 6*!#&V$ 6%&*, <p66Z ' 6%+q! #+v:$ *! 6 :8aM.> ! :8aM.orAMW. . 130 cells. 㥾ÐÇÚ EÚ Û »IÄN´Tµ±Ä[·¯În·¯±k¿±¶µÆDZ¶µÓYµa±¶Ïf¸¾Å»I·¯µpÖ. 520 cells. . o. .
(73) . $"". . . *, ' 6 $%& l 69=l,#+*,kS!#a:*,23!%& GmNPV ON|*42 9 Wjwx9 S *, $!m|:$ *! 6 : | )9Bl!#&*,kS(#n' *,!62 9XmX%+1' *,2Z*,6:¡*(. }!},~' #&#&WGwx96! !,~9 L(9 :6!# #+ 2 )a%& )9 *H*,2 l,%+*, XWSwx96' *, $:=*, %&g: *! ):8 69l!#&*,kS(#G S 2369 <> !'^98' #+#X*!.¢ )9@'* !6?%&x#&% x%& %&l,9 A m$ ]n%&lW;$Wwx9$%&j S @2 9 %+x2{(:1*!. £ K' #+#&W. . b. wx92 9=' *! ' 6 %+ l{ )9$ *;*,2 Vk5:$*,2{(%& %&a2{!:$*!.F £ ' #&#&<>% a%&J3S!u *!.n 69@l,#&*!kS!#X:*!2{!%+ ~ S 2369A WSR a%&g 6#&%+' ?*!. )9@%&6xNg%+ )9N|!#&#+ m%+ ' *,2%& $l ! : *,V$ uQO' *!23%+ lB![!mS6 ]n%+lW ;W. $b. . . .
(74)
(75)
(76) . wx9 9 vH6%&' !#2*;:#&?( : )9 iV2 6%+'[!#S!6!23M )61.p*,1 69 %& )6 S!#%+ 6 )d )%+q! 23M )9*H:<>9$ 6(m¢6 '*, :% )%+*, :¡|*! Vl ( 6 : c?)!:%+ AJ!6B%+: )%+'[!#.p*,?!#+# 69 6%+2KV#\d )%&*! W;O S!u )%+' V#&! m$ 69 ^d )%&*! S!v~' 6% )6%\B%+ o .p*,x )9$ #\d )%+q! :%+z5 '@ 6*, W. . P / $#. wx9~kZ*,V :!ve'*, :% )%&*! .p*! 69{l,#+*,kS!#:$*,2{(%& ¡' *,2V$ )( )%+*, !6 )93V6V!# *, WG|*, ' 6 %+ l{ 69 *;*,2 '*,23$V$ ^( 6%&*, $ m )9$ 6K!66Z '%+ S'KkZ*,V $:S!v '*, :% Q )%+*, x.p*,x )9@ L$% )W5/1V$@ 6* 6966 $' K*!.q,*,u )%+' J!'6*,a 69%&g6' 6%&*, XmNPV$6 % )9?/1%&%&'^9#+ 1'*, :% )%+*, J.p*!0 )9B5' % S'B )9!#& ve! $:= )9B23!61TV;L<p%& *H: *!.j )9$3 L$% KV.>!'A m%+ )9$ :S!; )%+q!~/1%+6%&'^9$#& _a V23! < /?_1A?*, m 6 VS!u )6*, %<uo,! AMW. a. ,. a. ]S*, )90C/@' *,2V$ )( )%+*, m, 6902*,2 )V$2 ! :3 69a 6l!v3kS!#&! ' ghHV( )%+*, * 69{l!#&*,kS(#:*,23!%& ¡! :*, 69 *;*!2 VkZ:*,23!%& !6' *!V#&:XW|*, ' 6 $%& l , )9B$6%&23!uv TS*N l!v=kS(#\! 'K hiVSd )%&*! Xm5 69 *H*,2 %& #+ 06%+2{!uvTS*N 6 2BQ 5)( 6V6g( :B )9 *;*,2 *,V$ 6#& n )9623!#;TSVHL!6|' *,V$#& :BNg% )9B )9xl!#&*,kS(#;:*!2{!%+ <f!P%& {/?/@7=AMWiwx9J HV$236%&' !#S!6!23M )6P.p*!s 691C¢/@"'*,23$V$ ^( 6%&*, $|! ' *!V;Q #&%+ l{Z %&*H:-<p 'A $W WZwx9 £ *,V$ 6 1% ) 6( )%+*, J! := #&dL$( )%+*, S()!2 6 iV2KkZ a*!.' *!66' 6 := *H:J%+ 8 )9$l,#+*,kS!#G' *,2V$ )( )%+*, (6 *;:$ <>kV$ mZNP 9S[q,:*, @'*,23$V$ ^( 6%&*, $jNg%+ )9q,)!#¢ iV2KkZ g*!.F'*,6 ' 6 : *H: )AMW. `. . . b . . . . . Z u.p*,62 )9'*,V#+ :@6%+2KV#&( )%+*, Ng%+ )9? ONP*Jc@ %( ^!H¢V%& lajk% QO*;' 6*, ' *,2V$ 6 <fb;V e ) 6%+6 £ m523*H: # £ , £ m £ ,78 A WXwx9BZ u.p*,623! ' ?' *! ;Q ' 6 %+ lB )9j 6%&2?! : )9$2 2*,uv~!@#&%&u ): %+ wn!k$#&@}$W. o.
(77) a 6. . wn(k#&@} . a'[( {:*6*,2g' *,223 ) Wiwx9a2 2*,6%+ V6:~%& B 691C¢/@' !60! :{|9S!%+ : '[!?!J%&2%&#\( W,wx9Mv{:$ $#+v:%+z5 P*!.X 6902 2*,v $ :$ : %& )9J'[!1*!.¢g.o!W R %&K 69)!2~.p*,K )9$j )%+23{' *,2S!%&6*! XW78*!6 *q! mNg% )94S!6!#&#+ #|'*,2BQ V$ )( )%+*, m )9C¢/@ 23M )9*H:-#& !: 6*#&*NP j )%+23(WFJ ' (m%+ %&KZ*,6%&k#+ )* %& '6 !6 #&*H'[(#&#+v 69{(' ' V$)!'Mve*!.P 69' *,2V$ )( )%+*, <> k5#&*NJA0Ng%+ )9$*,V$ @ )*H* 2KV'^9 %& '6 !6? )9$'*, W *, ' 6 $%& lK 69@j` )%+23J6Z :$j.p*,P 691' *!V#&%+ lm )9$?C¢/@ % ))( 6%&*, s*, { 69 | l,#&*!kS!#:*,23!%& {*,P 691VZ:S( 6 x*!.D 691kZ*,V :S(v3' *, :$%+ )%+*, ~*, ~ 69 *;*,2 :*!2{!%+ ' *,u J!k5*!V$ @o *(. 69? )*! )!#¢j )%&2!W ] %&l$W¢ #+*! )@ )9$3'*, q, l, $' 9%+ )*!ve*!.P )932{!TV;L¡q!(6%\(k#&K.p*,@ )9$3l,#+*,kS!# n :*,23!%& C¢/@ ' *,2V$ )( )%+*, g! $: 69@6.p6 ' ' *,2V$ )( )%+*, @<>aM.> ! :8aM.orAMW. . a. k *,V$ £ ' *,6 'M )%+*, 6 jNP (#&%+ :XW |Mv,*, : £ !K*,V$ )j%+ 6 6( )%+*, mi )9$1' *,Q Z 6' )%+*, =q(!#&V$ ?!K )!k%+#&% :XW ? )9$K :e*!. 69B' *,2V$ )( )%+*, XmS )9$B:%&' 6M ) C £ *,2 *(.F )9 6l!v8' *!66' 6%&*, 8%&J!k5*!V$ 1};W ! WGw*{' *!23S(6!m )9$ML;'^9S( l, : 5*NP a%& ~ 69gQR 6VkZk$V :#+ l,%+*, %&g(k5*,V; ( W. a. b. `b. ] %&l$W,?#&*( )F )9$a'*, q,6l, ' J9%&u )*,uvK*!.Z )9 *;*,2 6VkZ:*,23!%+ Kq!(6%\(k#& Wi|#+[!#+v,m n )9' *!23V; ^( 6%&*, '*, q, l, $' ~%+u )*, l,#v(z5 'M ) : k v )96M.p6 92 )*!.P 69 ' *,V$#&:k5*,V$ :S!uvq(!#&V$ W5O =.>!' m5 69Bl,* !#*!. )9$K6#\dL$( 6%&*, 8S!)(23M ) B<>96 $W AP%&s )*BS( )%&!#&#vB:S!2~ )9$ 6?*!6' %+#&#&( )%+*, J<fK#+*rNP Pq!(#&VJ *! x%+ ' [! x: #v )9:S!2%& l AMWPb;*,2!::$%+ )%+*, S!#x 6 6~69$*rNP : )9( ~ )9$=: '6 !6*!.@ 69=' *!V;Q #&%+ lBZ 6%+*;:¡<.p*,x%& $ ^( ' (m ' A|#+[!:$j )*Bk5M 6 )g' *, q,6l, ' 9%&u )*,uv{Ng% )9 %&: )%&' !#X9 vH6%+'[!#D V#+ 6 WZJ*NPq, mS )9$j )%+23g!6?%+ ' [! :XW. . . wx9~ Sl,V$6]n%+lWPo[69*NgB )9$ ' *,6 'M )%+*, S #+:K*!.g 69 C¢/@t' *,2V$ )( )%+*, .p*,m. (Detail). 㥾ÐÇÚ Ú Û »IÄN´Tµa±ÂÄ[·¯Î n ·Ç±³¿±¶µTÆDZ¶µ Ìå»[´¸ÆDZ³ÍV»E»I¿ ÄN´±¶Ä 7. o. b.
(78) Clotaire −Gm− alpha(zoom) =0.5. Relative difference in L2 norm (log10). −1.0 Ref0 Ref1 LDC 450 nodes LDC 750 nodes −2.0. −3.0. −4.0 0.0. 100.0. 200.0 300.0 Outer iterations. 400.0. 500.0. 㪾ÅÐÇÚEÚ6ÕÒÄ[µTµ¹nÁè4Ïf»I·æ[±V´Ð[±¶·¯Ïf±ÂÆn¾Åµa¸a»[´â[ÜÇÐIû[é6Ä[ÃqÎÇ»I¿Ä[¾Å· Zoom MGC −LDC (750 nodes)− alpha(zoom) =0.5. Relative difference in L2 norm (log10). −1.0 Gm Hm Pm Tp. −3.0. −5.0. −7.0. −9.0. −11.0 0.0. 500.0. 1000.0 Outer iterations. 1500.0. 2000.0. 㥾ÐÇÚEÚ¢ÄN´T¾ÅÄNénÃű³Ïf»I·>æ[±V´Ð[±¶·nÏf±QƯ¾Àµa¸a»[´â[ÜÇÍV»E»I¿!ÎÇ»I¿Ä[¾Å· . 66Z ' 6%+q! #+v!mD )9 6l!vehiVS( )%+*, ¡! :e )92*,23 )V2 hiVS( )%+*, "<>'V$ Kd '2 %& %&: )9B2*H'^ QRVA WGwx9B l!v='*,6 ' 6%&*, 8 ) 231!6K#+*;' ( ):( 1 69.p*, )%& *!.| 69gQ )VkZ kV :#+! :e )9 2*,23 )V2 '*,6 'M )%&*! ¡ 6 62@*,V$ 66%&:$ 69! )% Q qH%&k6( )%+*, kS! W 39S[q,~Z u.p*,62 : 6hHV$ )%&!#P'*,2V$ ^d )%&*! .p*! 69{6!23 ) '[!!Wa6V# ) !6@%&2%&#\( mikV$ a*,k qH%&*,V$6#+v3 )9j )%&21%&l, % S'[( i 6#+v3%& '6 !6 W. . . .
(79)
(80) . |*, ' 6 $%& lB*,23Jl,#&*!kS!#ShiVS! )% )%+ m;#&%+!g )91 L;'^9S! l,:5*NP mH )90 ) !2 2{! TS*N6( )(m;WWW+m (#&#i' *,2V$ )( )%+*, l,%+q!j6%+23%+#\!¢66V# )W,]S*,n%+ )! '!m( 69xML;'^9S( l, :. o.
(81) 㪾ÅÐÇÚqðVñÚ6õÑ Û Ïf»[´T´±¶Ïf¸¾»I·¯µ. 5*NP mJ%+ 69C¢/@ '*,2V$ ^d )%&*! Xmj%&#&%&l!9i 6#+v*rq! 6%&23( ): ' *,2S!%&*, ~Ng%+ 69 69aM.o' !6[AMW. <f(k5*,V; ;W . %& . O {.>!'M P 69J%+23$6*q,23 i P*,k$ )!%& $ :3Ng% )9 )9JC¢/@"23M )9*H:{%+P! 6%&' V$#\!#+vK%+ 69 #&*H'[!#q(!6%&( )%+*, {*(. 691q(!6%&!k#+ |%+ { )9$?l,#&*,k!#5:$*,2{(%& XW;Y1 ]n%&lWZo,o,miNP9*N` 69 )9!#& v@:%+ )%&kV; )%&*! @!#&*, $la*,2q! u )%&' !# #&%+ D%+ 69' *,#+:#+ lx.p*,X 69P'* !6P! : S @2 69$ a' *,2V$ )( )%+*, g!#+*, @! :.p*,j 69C/@ ' *,2V$ )( )%+*, XW;O 8S( )%+' V#&! m )9a%&*(QRq(!#+V *(.G )9$J5' %+ '0 69S!#& v %+ 6%+:x )9a' *,6' )%+*, 6 l!%&*, 3!6g'#&*, )* )9g.o 66V# )1 69S! e )9 g.> *, m¢q! ¡%+.P6*,2BV :$ uQR u )%&23( 6%&*, 1!Z[!W wx9@ )9!#& v *! S#+ g' *,2V$ 6 : Ng%+ 69 )9C¢/@ *! *;*,2 *,xl,#+*,kS!#5:*,23!%& ! q,v¡' #+*,6! :¡kZ*! )9e 6 )9$36!23Kq(!%\( 6%&*, $1 )9S! e )9$*,6 *,k uq, :*, ¡ 69 aM.oK66V# )WDY1k q;%+*,V#+v,mZ )9k5M 6 )?! )9' * !6Kl!6%&:866V# )1%+ )9 )uv=*!. )9 *;*,2 m$ 69@k5M 6 )a!61 69 *H*,2 :%+' )%+*, W s9S[q,P5.p*,23:'*,2V$ ^d )%&*! DNg%+ )9 ' *, $:%+ 6%&*, j.p*!j )9@)(231 6 a' !6*, '!W. . a a. :!$ )%q,P/1%&%&'^9#+ _JV23! k5*,V$ :S!uv l,!%& Xm; )9@66V# )a!1q, uv6%+23%+#\!W. G[X. e s
(82). ]n%& !#&#v,mGNP~9S[q, $6*q,: )93y' %+ 'Mv*!.g( -!#&l!*,6% )92 k!6:-*, ! !::% )%+q! q,66%+*, *!.F 69B/1%+6%&'^9$#& uQ_a V23! 2 )9$*;:8%& 69%&2KV#&( )%+*, *!.Pbc ONP*(QO9!6. o.
(83) Clotaire Cold Leg (LDC / ADN) x=R−0.06 m ; y=0.04 m 132000. 131000. 130000. 129000. ldc corrected coarse zoom coarse fine. 128000. 127000. 㪾ÅÐÇÚð[ðNÚeÈE²×±¶ÏV¾ nÏ2±¶·¸Æ¯Ä[òE⨾À·4Ïf»IÃÅΠñVÐ. 6.5. 7.0. 7.5. TS*Ng WF ~ ^!( !:$q(! ^!l!~*!.JS!)(#&#&#&%+62 ! $:$6 '*, :% )%+*, %& $lWR BNP*,HBNg% )9 *q, #\!$%& l8*,@ *, *q! 6#&!%+ l! 6%+ )%+*, ¡! :¡ )93l,#&*,k!#F2 69$%& l8'[! k53 *, ' *, ;.p*,62%& l$Wwx9 6 6 5.p*,23:%+ -%& :$V 66%\(#|' *! i 6MLH ' *, $' #&V$:~ )* )9$ )[q, *!.s~#\(6l,!23*!V 1*!. )%+23%+ 6 6( )%+*, iV2KkZ @( :¡j )%+23(W ' ' *!6:%+ l,#+v!mZ 69 V6V!#g2369' #+#&B iV2KkZ < }, ,! A'[! "k5 !6%+#+v-%+ ' [! :" 6*"o[,$m ,,*, NP*,6iu ^( 6%&*, $ ONP*,6WFwx9%+NP*, %+'*,23$#& 6 :¡Ng%+ )9! -!:!$ ):2 )9$*;:¡ )* .>!' 3! q, )VS!#sq,*,u ) L$6 ' ( 6VkZ:*,23!%+ %+ i 6 u.>!' m#&%&(B )9 :S($ )%q, /1%&%&'^9#+ a_JV23! 2 69*H:-< VS( )6*, $%mDo,! AMmZ! : Ng%+ 69=/?/@7 ' *,2V$ )( )%+*, *!.j$6%&23!uvTSV%+: l!v¡kS!#&! ' (WX2KVu *,V$ )#+%& K 69%& )6 u *(.j' *H: QO#&%+ ! #&%+!j )9$aj *, $<pub b$A )*@S!6!#&#+ #&% s ^!HV%& l? M ON|*,miNg% )9*!V$ ' *H:g6 Q l!%& 6%+ lWia*rNPq! m$ )9%+P'^9$*,%&'J%+ iq!*,#+q! P#&%&2%+ )( )%+*, *, {S()!#+#& #$' *,2V$ )( )%+*, '[!!' % )%& WFw*¡%&#&#+V 6)( 6{ )9$%& 5*!%& [mn 69 2:S!9# B#&[NI!#+#&*Ng )9$8 )%+2{d )%&*! *!.j 69{'*;:S!6!#&#+ #S( ! :*!.| )92{rL$%+2{(#6[('^9S!k#+35 :;QRVXW 3.p*!V : q(!#&Va!6*,V$ : !K 6*{, ! : )*3$mS66Z ' 6%+q! #+v<p: Z :$%& l*!.n 696*,k$#& 2 6% A W$R.DNP?' *,2S!JNg% )9~23!6%+q! #+vS()!#+#& #23!'^9%+ 0' !S!'%+ )%+ mi 69%&|6Z :HQOV q(!#&V?%+x#&*N@mkV; J%+x *!Vl,9.p*,j )9@#&! :(#&%+'[( 6%&*, $ W. a. a. ,. a. a. . a. b. 78*, *q, m$ 691%&2#+ 2 ^( 6%&*, %+Pq,66( )%+#&0 *,Vl!9~ )*K L; 6 :~ 6*K hiVSd )%&*! j' *!V;Q #&%+ l*!| )*K#+*;' !#Z!:S!; )%+q! *H*,2%& l23M )9*H:|.p*!PTS*N6%+2KV#\d )%&*! {!*,V : *!k )dQ ' #+!W|*, ' 6 $%& l 69%&#\( 5*!%& [mDNP{9S[q,{6*q,: )9y'%& $'v *!.g! !::% )%+q! q,66%+*, *!.P *H*,2%& l3!#+l,*,6% )92Ik!6:¡*! = )9BC¢/@ 2 )9$*;:=%+ )9$K6%+2KV#\d )%&*! *!.nbc ONP*(QR9S!@T*rNgWwx9C¢/@' *,2V$ )( )%+*, !#+#&*NgP 69? 9! ' 23 J*(. 69 6*!. ON|! :%+' 6%&*, %+ 69@' *,6' )%+*, 6l,%&*, . . . . 69gk59S[q;%+*,s*!.5 69gq!(6%\(k#&%&k5M ON| ~ 69J V#+ s*!.5 )9a' *,2V$ )( )%+*, FNg% )9 '* !6! : S 2369Xm 69'*,96 $' kZ ONP = )9 *H*,2 VkZ:*,23!%& 66V# )J! : )9l,#&*!kS!#X:*!2{!%+ *, $ g%&x 9S! ' :XW. £ .
(84) wx9gC¢/@' *,2V$ )( )%+*, '*, J< *H*,2U! :Bl,#+*,kS!#i:*!2{!%+ ^A¢%&l, )#v9$%&l,9 69S! 5*! '^9S!%& $ :'*,2V$ ^d )%&*! ! $:Xmr*,k q;%+*,V#+v,m[q! uv'^9 !Z 69S! )9sl,#&*!kS!#,:*!2{!%+ *, ?Ng%+ 69 )9? S @2 9XW wx9%&JN|*,8'*, %& 61%& 3 S @( )23$ J )*~k$6%& $l{2*;:6 = iV2 %&' !# 6*;*!#&a%& 8 69 ' *, 6MLH x*!.D%+ :Vu )%\!#S%&2KV#&( )%+*, *!.¢bc ON|*(QR9S!JTS*NgW]SV$ )V$6a%&26*q,23 ) !6{#\! $ :XWO -S!u )%+' V#&! mDNP~'[! -2 6%&*, 69~:Mq,#&*,2 B*(.a8q,66%+*, -*!. )9 ]#&V;LO ) u.>!' |*!66' 6%&*, 2 69*;:<>]nuxAa.p*,J )9 *;*,2 ' *!23V; ^( 6%&*, mG l!*! B B!#WP<uo[, £ A@*, $l,*! KM !#fWj<o,,} A mn( :4] b23M )9*H:.p*,2KV# )%&l!6%&: 6' *, $:%+ 6%&*, %+ l < P)! :; [mXo ,AMW. a. a. a. dbdb.
(85)
(86)
(87) ?NP*,V#+:8#+%&!J )* )9S! ${ )9]S)(2{( 6*,2?|*,2S! v~.p*,j 69 %+j S S! $' %\(#X6V$5*,u [W. £ o.
(88)
(89)
(90)
(91)
Documents relatifs
Patients - Les patients admissibles à l’étude HOPE devaient être âgés de 55 ans et plus, avoir des antécédents de maladie cardiovasculaire (coronaropathie, accident
Robin onstant boundary ondition as input value for the 2D separated problem, and a mean. value of the Diri hlet boundary ondition as output value, and onversely for the
In this study, we use oxygen isotope ratios (δ 18 O) of Senilia senilis shells from the Saloum Delta in Senegal, to construct the first record of centennial variability of the
1 اذه يفو ،يوغّللا مهثارت ىلع مهدامتعا وه ةيبرغلا ةيوغّللا تاساردلا روطت داز امو لوقي ددصلا " ضاترم كلاملا دبع :" << يف نيعلضتم ريغ مهتماع
Manually created sentiment lexicons are espe- cially useful because they tend to be more accurate than automatically generated ones; they can be used to automatically generate
• The worst case is with a single layer of gypsum board directly attached to the studs of all the walls below. • Adding a second layer of directly attached gypsum board
Analysis of the base-pair degrees of freedom for each step along this path, in addition to free-energy calculations and reduced-coordinate sampling of the different 4WJ
à-dire ne pas porter une atteinte disproportionnée aux intérêts ou aux libertés et droits fondamentaux de la personne concernée par rapport à l’intérêt que l’employeur
