HAL Id: jpa-00247940
https://hal.archives-ouvertes.fr/jpa-00247940
Submitted on 1 Jan 1993
HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access archive for the deposit and dissemination of sci- entific research documents, whether they are pub- lished or not. The documents may come from teaching and research institutions in France or abroad, or from public or private research centers.
L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non, émanant des établissements d’enseignement et de recherche français ou étrangers, des laboratoires publics ou privés.
Sub-layer adequacy in smectic ordering : structural charcterization of new low molar mass liquid-crystalline
siloxanes
Mohammed Ibn-Elhaj, Harry Coles, Daniel Guillon, Antoine Skoulios
To cite this version:
Mohammed Ibn-Elhaj, Harry Coles, Daniel Guillon, Antoine Skoulios. Sub-layer adequacy in smectic
ordering : structural charcterization of new low molar mass liquid-crystalline siloxanes. Journal de
Physique II, EDP Sciences, 1993, 3 (12), pp.1807-1817. �10.1051/jp2:1993231�. �jpa-00247940�
Classification Physics Abstiacts
6i.30
Sub-layer adequacy in smectic ordering
:structural
characterization of
newlow molar
massliquid-crystalline
siloxanes
Mohammed
Ibn-Elhaj('), Harry J.Coles('. *),
DanielGuillon(~)
and AntoineSkoulios
(2)
(')
LiquidCrystal
Group, Physics Department, TheUniversity,
Manche~ter, M13 9PL, Great- Britain(2) Institut de
Physique
et Chimie des Matdriaux deStra~bourg,
6 rue Bou~singault. 67083 Stras-bourg
Cedex, France(Receii>ed J3 July J993, ieceit~ed in final fbini 26 August J993, ace.epted J Septei>i/>er J993)
Abstract. Thi~ paper deal~ with the structural characterization of a new ~eries of smectogen~ the molecules of which contain three distinct parts, a
cyanobiphenyl
aromatic core, a centralparaffin
chain and a ~iloxane endgroup.
Incompatible
with one another. these parts tend to locate themselve~ in three separate sub-layers superposed in apartially
bilayered smectic A structure.Because the siloxane endgroups have an important lateral exten~ion a~
compared
with the other two molecular moieties, the head to head association of the cyano endgroups is ~maller than usual and the smecticlayering
ofthe aromatic core~ clo~er to asingle
layer arrangement. Thi~ beha>,iour illustrates thenecessity
for thesub-layers
to adapt their internal structure so as to beadequate
for superposition.1. Introduction.
The lateral
register
of rod-like molecules in the smectic state mayprofitably
be ~iewed as amicrophase separation
of the aromatic cores from theparaffin
chains in distinctsub-layers alternately superposed [I].
The structure of the smecticphases
is then described in terms oflayer
andsub-layer thicknesses,
of tilt of the molecules with respect to thelayer
normal;, of molecular areas etc. Most of the smectogens considered so far in the literature are two-block in chemical nature, their moleculesbeing composed
ofonly
two types of constituent parts, aromatic cores andparaffin
chains,co~alently
bonded in a rod-like geometry. In structural(+) Author for Correspondence.
studies of such
simple
materials nospecial
consideration of the lateralpacking
of the indi~idual constituents of the moleculeshas, hitherto,
been necessary. The reasonbeing simply
that thehigh flexibility
of theparaffin
chainspermits important
variations of their lateralexpansion, allowing
the aromatic cores a great latitude to arrange insingle
or doublelayers
with molecularareas of 40 and
2012 respectively.
Twoquestions
arisequite naturally
at thispoint. Firstly
what
happens
to the structural behaviour of smecticphases
if the number of distinct andincompatible
parts ischanged
from two to three ?Secondly
what effect does the lateral size of the constituent parts of the molecules have on this structure ? Therefore what factors influence thegeometrical adequacy
of smecticsub-layers
to superpose on top of one another withoutcomplete
alteration of their intemal structural arrangement ?Investigation
of theseproblems
is the aim of the present article.2. Materials.
The
compounds
studied in this work weresynthesized by hydrosilylation
and characterized as described in a separate paper[?].
Their full chemical formula(abbreviated
in thefollowing
to 2 Si-nO-CB) isCH~ CH~
CH~-it-O-I-(CH~)~O ~ ~
CN~H~ ~H~
with n
= 3, 4, 5, 6, 8, 10 and II-
The
thermotropic polymorphism
of thesecompounds
was studiedby
differentialscanning calorimetry
andpolarizing optical microscopy
and revealed the presence of a smecticAmesophase [2].
Thefollowing polymorphic
schemes summarize themesomorphic
behavior of 2 Si-nO-CB.702 °C
n = 3 K - I
/
SmA
39 .c
fi = 4 K-I
IX 7'C
SmA
~
n=5 SmA ~°~ ~ I
n=6 SmA ~~~~ I
~70'C 59 0'C
n = 8 K-- SmA --1
n =
10 K ~~~ ~ SmA ~~~ ~ I
WO'C 734'C
n = I I K-- SmA -1
Usually, liquid crystalline
derivatives ofcyanobiphenyl
contain two distinct parts,namely
acyanobiphenyl
head group or core and a linearalkyl(oxy)
chain, which areincompatible
withone another and segregate in space to form the smectic
layers [1, 3, 4].
Theparticularity
of the 2 Si-nO-CBcompounds
is that the molecules contain three, instead of two, distinct parts, thethird
being
apentamethyldisiloxane moiety.
To check for theamphiphilic
character of thesecompounds, miscibility
tests wereperformed
betweenw-pentenyl cyanobiphenyl
and the pentamer ofdimethylsiloxane (tests
with the dimerproved impracticable
because of itshigh volatility).
The twocompounds
turned out to beincompatible
over a wide concentration range from room temperature up to 150 °C,suggesting
that the siloxanemoiety
of 2 Si-nO-CBshould
probably
also beincompatible
with the aromatic andparaffin
moieties of the molecules.3.
Experiment.
X-ray
diffraction studies were carried out with aGuinier-type focusing
cameraequipped
with abent-quartz
monochromator(I~~~
= 1.54hi
andan INSTEC
hot-stage
± 0.01°C)
used as asample
holder. Powder pattems(samples
in Lindemanncapillaries)
were recorded with an INEL curvedposition-sensitive
detector(exposure
time 30mini
controlledby
a multichannelanalyzer. Experiments
were conductedby stepwise heating
thesamples (temperature
steps of about 5°C)
from room temperature up to theclearing point.
Atypical X-ray
pattern recorded is shown infigure1.
1500 2000 2500 3000 3500
Channels
Fig. I.
Typical example
of X-ray diffraction pattern smectic A pha~e of 2 Si-I lO-CB at 40 °C.Dilatometry
measurements wereperformed
with a home-made dilatometer described elsewhere[5], providing
thespecific
volume of thespecimens
with an accuracy of 10-4 Thechange
in volume was studied as a function oftemperature,
uponstepwise heating
orcooling (steps
of 0.I °C every 2mini
in the temperature range from 25 °C up to 90 °C. For the volumemeasurements to be
meaningfull,
thesamples
must first becarefully degased (several heating
and
cooling cycles
under vacuum, from thelow-temperature crystal
orliquid crystal
to thehigh-temperature
very fluidisotropic liquid). Typical examples
of volume i,s. temperaturecurves recorded are shown in
figures
4 and 5.4. Results and discussion.
4.I X-RAY DIFFRACTION. The
X-ray patterns
recorded are inperfect
agreement with theprevious optical
observations[2] describing
themesophases
of 2 Si-nO-CB as smectic A innature.
They
contain indeed onesharp Bragg
reflection in thesmall-angle region, correspond-
ing
to the smecticlayering.
In thewide-angle region they
also contain one diffuse band,corresponding
to theliquid-like
conformation of theparaffin
chains and to the disordered lateral arrangement of the aromatic cores in the smecticlayers
(~ 4.6hi,
andone much more
diffuse band (as
clearly
confirmedusing photographic
film) at about6.31,
whichprobably corresponds
to theliquid
like arrangement of the siloxane moieties[6, 7].
The ~mectic
period
measured at 30 °C for all thecompounds
isgiven
in table I,along
with thecorresponding
molecularlengths
estimated from molecularmodelling (Sybyl
softwarefrom
Tripos).
The ~mecticperiod
increases with the molecularlength
asexpected,
but moreinterestingly,
it iscomprised
of between one and two molecularlengths (d/L l.7),
which when combined with the re~ults of thedilatometry
measurements (seebelow)
indicates apartial bilayered
arrangement(A~)
for the smecticlayers and, therefore,
a certaindegree
of head to head association of the molecule~through
their cyanoendgroups [8].
As illustratedby figure
2, for thetypical example
of the n=
I
compound,
the smecticperiod clearly
decreasesas a function of
increasing
temperature,showing
thetendency
of the head to head a~sociation to decrease. Theexperimental
data that will be used below are summarized infigure
3.Table I. -Sniec.tic
period
at 30 °C(d)
arid molecularlengths
(measuredby
mofec.iifar siniifc~tioniisifig S_i'bj'f sofiv~aie fi.oni Tiipos),
L,of'2
Si-nO-CB.n
d(I) L(I)
d/L4 34.4 21.3 1.62
5 36.4 22.6 1.61
6 39.4 23.8 1.66
8 42.6 26.2 1.63
10 49.6 28.7 1.73
II 51.1 30.0 1.70
51
50
~
~9
~
48
30 40 50 60 70 80
T
(oc)
Fig.
2. Typical variation of the ~mecticperiod
with temperaturesample
2 Si-I lO-CB.40
36
30 40 50 60 70
T
(°C)
Fig.
3. Smecticperiod
of 2 Si-50-CB (downtriangle),
? Si-80-CB (up triangle) and 2 Si-I lO-CB(square)
as a function of temperature.4.2 DILATOMETRY.- Dilatometric measurements were carried out
only
on those fourcompounds (n
= 3, 5,
8, 11)
which were available in sufficientquantities. Figures
4 and 5 illustrate thespecific
case ofcompounds
n=
3 and n
=
it. The first shows the first order transition between the
low-temperature crystal
and thehigh-temperature isotropic liquid,
characterized
by
a marked volumejump
and a ;tronghysteresis
uponcooling.
The same type of transition takesplace
also for the othercompounds
where the melt is a smecticphase.
It isuseful to note the
perfect reversibility
of the temperaturedependence
of thespecific
volume in theisotropic (or smectic)
melt, and also the occurrence of asecondary
first orderpolymorphic
transition in the
crystalline
state of the n=
3
compound
uponheating.
On the other hand,figure
5 shows the first order transition between the smectic and theisotropic liquid
; the400
390
m a
L 380 ~~
l a~~°
~E 370
~
8 ~
> ~
360
20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90
T (°C)
Fig. 4. Evolution of the molar volume of 2 Si-30-CB with
increasing
and decreasing temperature.540
Iso~ope
.
530
j O
~E 520
Smectic E
d
>
~o
20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90
T
(°C)
Fig. 5. Evolution of the molar volume of 2 Si-I lO-CB with increasing and decreasing temperature.
reversible volume
jump
measured at the transition is rather small lfb),
as is usual for this transition.In the range of
stability
of the smectic andisotropic liquid phases,
the molar volume varieslinearly
with temperatureaccording
toequation
:V(T)
=
Vo(I
+aT),
where
Vo
is the molar volume at 0 °C and a the relative thermalexpansion
coefficient.Using
alinear
regression
fit method, the values ofVo
and a were calculated forcompounds
n =
5, 8, and II
(compound
n=
3 was not considered further as it does not show a smectic
phase
above roomtemperature). Inspection
of table IIclearly
shows the lineardependence
of the molar volumes on the spacerlength
both in the smectic and theisotropic
state. With the reasonableassumption
ofadditivity
of thepartial
molar volumes of the constituent parts of the molecules, it is easy to calculate thepartial
molar volume of themethylene
groups(Vc~~/cm~
mol~')
as a function of temperatureVc~~
= 15.6 + 1.63 x 10~ ~ T for the smectic andVc~,
=
16. I + 1.61 x 10~ ~ T for the
isotropic phases
Table II. Values
of
the molar volume at 0°C(Vo)
and relative thermale~<pansion
coejfiicient (a) of
2 Si-nO-CB in the smecticA andisotropic liquid phases.
n
Vo (cm~
mol~ 'a x 104
(°C-'
)sA
IsA
5 399.0 399.6 7.7 7.9
8 445.4 446.4 8.0 8.
II 492.6 494.2 8.1 8.3
These are in
good
agreement with thosegiven
in the literature forparaffin
chains in a disordered conformation[9].
4.3 STRUCTURAL MODEL. The smecticA structure of the 2Si-nO-CB
compounds
wassuggested
above to bepartially bilayered
(A~),
since itsBragg period
was found to lie betweenone and two molecular
lengths (L
~ d~ 2 L
[3, 10].
For the sake ofclarity,
it is useful to recallbriefly
the structural model that describes this type oflayering
in the case of the well- knownalkoxy-cyanobiphenyls [8].
In this model(Fig. 6),
the smecticlayers
are forrnedby
anintimate
binary
mixture ofsingle
moleculespointing
up anddown,
and ofpairs
of molecules(dimers)
associatedthrough
their terminal cyano groups. The value of the smecticperiod
reflects
quite clearly
thisdegree
of association of the molecules, I.e. the fractionr of molecules dimerized
d m 2
(V/« )/(2
z = 2 L'/(2
rflfiJi~flf~ ~~/0~i~i
i~'~~fijiifil ~~~
~~~~h~
~jfij@/
Fig.
6. Molecular model of the smectic A~ mesophase (from Ref. [4]).In this
equation,
« and L' are the cross-sectional area of the aromatic cores and thelength
of thesingle
molecules in themesophase
(see Ref.[8]).
It is usefuladding
that with this model, the average molecular area of theparaffin
tails issm
(2 ~)«.
The situation in the present
work, although fundamentally
the same, is morecomplex.
Indeed, the
polyphilic
molecules arecomposed
of three distinct partsincompatible
with one another andconsequently they
tend to segregate in three separatesuperposed sub-layers.
As aresult,
theparaffin
chains situated in the centre of themolecules,
canonly
arrange themselves insingle layers,
whereas the terminal(aromatic
orsiloxane)
parts arecapable
offorming
eithersingle
or doublelayers,
oreventually partially bilayered
structures(Fig. 7).
Thequestion
nowis to decide whether the three types of
segregated sublayer
can superpose themselves in a smectic structure withoutspecial constraints,
due to the fact that theirrespective
molecularareas are not all
compatible
with one another(stacking
«adequacy
» of thesublayers).
Themolecular area
(«~~)
of the aromatic coresstanding upright
in thelayers
is of about 2212,
that(«~~~)
of the disorderedparaffin
chains may vary from ?0 up to over 4012 depending
upon theconformation,
and that(«~~j)
of the short,nearly globular
inshape,
siloxane moieties islarge,
around4312 [1Ii.
In thesimple
case of the two-block smectogens, the lateral molecularcoverage of the surfaces is
imposed by
the aromatic cores and iscomprised
between«~r and 2 «~~
depending
upon thesingle-
ordouble-layered arrangement
of the cores in thesublayers.
Such a coverage is of coursecompatible
with the naturalspreading
of the disorderedal b)
Fig. 7. - Different type~ of arrangement of the three distinct parts of the
:
la) bothand siloxane parts are arranged in double ayer~,
(b) the
aromatic part~ are arranged in single layers theflexible
paraffin
chains, ascurrently
observed inthermotropic
andlyotropic liquid crystals.
In thecomplex
ca~e of the three-block smectogens considered in the present work, thesignificant
bulkiness of the siloxane moieties poses a serious
problem
ofpacking.
Forinstance,
with the siloxane moietiesarranged
insingle layers,
the molecular coverage of the surfaces is 2 «,~~ =861~,
which is toolarge
andhardly compatible
with the lateralspreading
of the(rather short)
paraffin
chains and alsototally
inconsistent with theupright arrangement
of therigid
aromatic cores insingle
or doublelayers.
To consider this
point
further and to describe the detailed molecular structure of these~mectic A
phases
it is useful to calculate, from theexperimental
data, notonly
the smecticperiod,
but also the molecular coverage of the smecticlayers.
Because of the mutualincompatibility
of their con~tituent parts, the three-block molecules mustpile
up inlayers, pointing alternately
up and down(Fig. 8)
; as a result of the two-sided symmetry of the smectic[aye>,
their molecular coveragecorresponds
to the areaoccupied
in the smecticplane~ by
twomolecules :
S=2V/Nd
where N is
Avogadro's
number.Knowing
the values of the molar volume V(Tab. II)
and the~mectic
period
d(Fig. 3),
it is easy to calculate S as a function oftemperature
for the threecompounds analyzed
: n = 5, 8, and 11(Fig. 9).
In~pection
offigure
9 shows that the calculated molecular coverage S ranges from about 32 up to 3912.
The~e values ~uggest thefollowing
commentsregarding
the molecularpacking
in each one of the threesublayers
of the smectic structure(Fig. 8). Concerning
theparaffin
sub-layers,
the S values are inperfect
agreement with what i~ known of the lateralexpansion
ofparaffin
chains in a disordered conformation and are therefore consistent with thesingle-
layered
arrangementproposed. Concerning
the aromaticsublayers,
the S values are betweenFig. 8. Schematic
representation
of the smectic A layers of 2 Si-nO-CB. The central part of the smecticlayers
is arbitrarily chosen to be formed of the aromaticsublayers,
with the aromatic cores (rectangles) arranged in apartially
bilayered structure. This central part isfringed
with the disorderedparaffin
chains (waxy lines) arranged in single layers. The siloxane moieties (ellipses) are located within distinctsublayers
in adouble-layered
arrangement, some of thembeing squeezed
out into theparaffin
sublayers.~w
w
w ~
w ~
w ~
"
a a
as a m
$~f a "
~' a a "
l/l m
m
~ m
m m
33
.
"
m
32
20 30 40 50 60 70 80
T
(oc)
Fig. 9. Temperature dependence of the molecular area of ? Si-50-CB (down
triangle).
2 Si-80-CB (up triangle) and 2 Si-I lO-CB (square).«~, and 2 «~~ with «~, of about 22
l~,
andclearly
indicate apartially bilayered
arrangement with a fraction of cores dimerizedjr
= 2S/«~~)
in the range from 0.25 to 0.50. This would be consistent with the lack of strong second orhigher
order 00 L reflections in theX-ray
diffraction pattern,
figure
I, because of the diffusescattering
interface. As for the siloxanesublayers,
the S values,significantly
smaller than the size(~431~)
of the siloxaneendgroups,
suggest for these groups adouble-layered
arrangement, with some of themsqueezed
out into theneighbouring paraffin sublayers.
A crudeextrapolation
of S ton =
0 at 40 °C
(Fig. 10),
shows the molecular coverage to attain a value of about 4212,
that isthe
expected
value for the lateralpacking
area of the siloxaneendgroups
when all of them areforced to be located into their
specific sublayers.
This extreme situationcorresponds
to the arrangement of the aromatic cores insingle layers
and therefore to the total absence of association of the cyanoendgroups.
It is worthnoting
in this context thedepression
ofr as a function of
increasing temperature,
in agreement withprevious
observations onalkoxy- cyanobiphenyls [8]. Apparently,
there exists a strongcompetition
between thetendency
of the cyanoendgroups
to associatepairwise,
and thus to decreaseS,
and thetendency
of the siloxaneendgroups
to segregate into distinctlayers,
and thus tobring
about theopposite
effect.42
40
~
38
~~$
~
36
34
0 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 II 12
n
Fig, 10. Evolution of the molecular area S with the number of carbon atoms In) at 40 °C.
Interestingly,
the r values of the aromatic cores found here are smaller than the valuesusually
measured withalkoxy-cyanobiphenyls (r
=
0.5
[8]
). This demonstrates theimportant
steric role of the siloxaneendgroups which,
with atendency
to segregate into distinct sub-layers
asrequired by
theamphiphilic character,
contribute to the lateralexpansion
of thelayers
and
consequently
to an increase of the molecular coverage S.Figure
I illustrates thiseffect, showing
the strongdependence
of r upon thelength
of theparaffin
chains. Indeed, the thinner theparaffin sublayers,
the less room for the siloxaneendgroups
to « dissolve »therein,
and themore the siloxane
endgroups
are located into their nominalsub-layers.
5. Conclusion.
The present work deals with the
mesomorphic
behaviour of a new class of three-block smectogens the molecules of which contain acyanobiphenyl
aromatic core, a centralparaffin
chain and a siloxane
endgroup.
It describes the smectic A structure observed asresulting
in thesuperposition
of threeseparate sublayers
formed of the three molecularmoieties,
andgives
them
~ m
m
0. m
m
~ m
0.
a
~
a "
b~ ~
~
m
~
~
~
"
w
' , w
w ~
w
0.25 .
.
30 40 50 60 70 80
T
(°C)
Fig.
I I.Temperature dependence
of thedegree
of association of the cyanoendgroups
for 2 Si-50-CB (down triangle), 2 Si-80-CB (up triangle) and 2 Si-I lO-CB(square).
degree
of head to head association of the moleculesthrough
the cyanoendgroups
as a function of temperature andlength
of theparaffin
spacer. The main conclusion drawn is related with the«
adequacy
» of thesublayers
to superpose. The molecular moieties in thesublayers being covalently
bonded with oneanother,
their surface coverage must beexactly
the same in all threesublayers. Now,
the siloxaneendgroups
arelaterally
bulkier than the aromatic cores. Asa result, the headwise association of the cyano
endgroups
is smaller thanusually
observed, and the smecticlayering
of the aromatic cores closer to asingle-layered
arrangement. The lateralspreading
of thelayers
so obtainedpermits
the propersuperposition
of thesublayers.
Acknowledgments.
The authors wish to thank Dow
Coming, Barry (UK),
forsupporting
this work, JoannaNewton for use of her siloxane
samples
and Benoit Heinrich for his assistanceduring
thedilatometry experiments.
References
[1] Guillon D, and Skoulios A., Mol. Ciyst. Liq. C>.yst. 165 (1988) 317.
[2] Newton J., Coles H., Hodge P. and Hannington J., J. Mats. Chem., submitted.
[3] Hardouin F., Levelut A. M., Achard M. F., Mauzac M, and Sigaud G., J. Chini. Phys. 80 (1983) 53, and references therein.
[4] Hardouin F.,
Sigaud
G., Keller P., Richard H., Tinh Nguyen Huu, Mauzac M. and Achard F., Liq.Ciyst. 2 (1989) 463, and references therein.
[5] Heinrich B., Guillon D. and Skoulios A., in preparation.
[6] Diele S., Oelsner S., Kushchel F., Hiscen B.,
Ringsdorf
H. and Zentel R., Makroni(Jl. Cheat. 188 (1987) 1993.[7] Tinh Nguyen Huu, Achard M. F., Hardouin F., Mauzac M., Richard H. and Sigaud G., Liq. Ciysi.
3 (1990) 385.
[8] Guillon D, and Skoulios A., Mol.
Ciysi.
Liq.Ciyst.
91 (1983) 341 ; J.Phys.
Fiance 45 (1984) 607.[9] Guillon D., Skoulios A. and Benattar J. J., J. Phys. Fiance 47 (1986) 133.
[10] Prost J, and Barois P., J. Chim. Phys. 80 (1983) 67.
[I ii Boyer R. F, and Miller R. L., Rubber Chem. Technol. St (1978) 718.