Robustness of a routing tree for the Push Tree Problem
Texte intégral
(2) INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE. Robustness of a routing tree for the Push Tree Problem Frédéric Havet. N° 4464 May 2002. ISSN 0249-6399. ISRN INRIA/RR--4464--FR+ENG. THÈME 1. apport de recherche.
(3)
(4)
(5) !"$#% &!')(* ,+ /- .021
(6) 03.547698:<;>=3? @BADCFEHGHIKJMLNOPGQSRUTG*VWOPXUOYVZCFEHGO []\P^S_YG*VW`aQSOZb*^SVcVZG L,QSdedf^S\PVgeGh\PG5biAeGF\ibiAeG'jfkl3l3mnloJp`aQqXrns3s3rtJvuwdDQnx3GO. y z{|F}~eS|S @BAeGa[/RDOPA@\ZGFGde\P^3eGFEbF^Sj2VZQS jDOwGGEwGj2VZO\P^3Ef^nVPAVPADG2VPG jeG\@\ZGFG)Qnjg UAe^S\PVPG5OYV[
(7) QnVPAde\Z^SDGEVKgUG5QnOW VPAVPAeGVP\iQSgUGF^S>OWGFVYGGFjaVZAeGdeROcAQSjDgadeRD
(8) EHGbiADQSje OcE ROcG5gH j jU^3\PEQVZ ^3jgU OcVP\Z eRUVP ^SjQnjDgH\ZG*VZ\P GFQnj W ¡seI*¢£<QtVY^OcVPGdQndDde\P^2QSbiA^S\¤VPAeGW[]RDOcA @\ZGFG[/\Z^SDGE¥¦Q3O,de\Z^Sdf^3OPGg jaVPADG§D\iOcVKOcVPGFd£>Qw¨Yx3^<^<g<©OPdDQSjeje jexVP\ZGFGª7bQnG5g\Z^SRUVZ jexVP\ZGFG5« OBb*^3jDOYVZ\PRb¬VPG5gQnjgVPADGFjVPAeGtde\Z^SeGFE OBOc^33Gg jVZAe OdQn\PVP b*ReQn\VP\ZGFG3
(9) ® jDgU jexHQ\Z^SRUVZ jDxVP\ZGFG OB¯W[
(10) ADQS\ZgeRUV¦VPAeGhOPGb*^3jDgOcVPGdEQqXGKdfGF\P^S\ZEwG5gG5QSOP XS£3VPA<RDOVPADGK gUG5Q O]VZ^ROcGVPAeGt\Z^SRUVZ jDx VZ\PGGQSOQª7OPGFEH «,OYViQneG jU\ZQ3OYVZ\PRb¬VPRD\PGQSjDgVP^dG\c^3\PE°QSgeQSdUVZQnVP ^SjDOVP^biAQnjex3 jex jU^3\PEQVZ ^3j dQVcVZGFj\ZjDVPAeOB OWjDdOc QngUdfGKGFVP\5AD£Gh¦\PG^3OcRUVPVPRD jegexwXVPVZ\ZAeGFGG3 \Z^SDRDOYVZjeGOZO,^S¤Q\Z^SRUVZ jDxVP\ZGFGAeGFjaVZAeGw jU^3\PEQnVP ^Sja\ZG±2ReGOcVZO ge OZQndedfGQS\QVWOP^SEHGtje^UgUGO ²a³2´>µZ¶· }¸{Sº¹ QViQH\PGde bQVP ^Sj£2jDG*VY¦^S\Z»^SdUVZ EH OPQnVP ^Sj¼£e\Z^SDRDOYVZjeGOZO. Unité de recherche INRIA Sophia Antipolis 2004, route des Lucioles, BP 93, 06902 Sophia Antipolis Cedex (France) Téléphone : +33 4 92 38 77 77 — Télécopie : +33 4 92 38 77 65.
(11) )¼ c p (F (,+ . ( Y &
(12) geGo { Qn\Ze\PG% gUG G2VZdDGF \Pje^3GFe\aCGFEHVGogUgUR Gode \P QS^3\PeeCF\ZEHGG OZQqgUQnR j2VdDRDbF^SOj2VPb* ^SGFRDj2\cVVagebiGAeOGFEHNF NFj¼EH°GFj2ViOEH ^UgUQ NF OP^SG% OG gUR bF^SdDEH\P^3dee\Z^SCEHEH GO Gj2VP\ZGGOtgUGRUTEHNbQnje OcEHG5OKgeGHge OcVP\Z DRUVP ^SjogUGH je^S\ZEHQnVP ^Sjob*^SjOc OYViQnj2V df^SRDOZOPGF\t^SRVZ \ZGF\ jU^3\PEQnVP ^Sj¼ ¹ QSjDO, , ¡sDI*¢£3G5OYVde\P^3d^2OcNGRejeGWQSdede\Z^UbiAeGGFjgeGFRUTHN*ViQndfGO]df^SRD\¤G,de\Z^SeCFEHGWgUG Qn\Ze\PGOPQqQnj2V5@^3RUVg QS^3\Zg £qRejK¨Yf^Sj<©QS\PD\PG¤bF^SRe<\iQnj2V¤ª7QSdedfGFN¦QS\Pe\ZG]gUG\P^3RUVZQSxSG5« GOcVb*^3jDOcVP\ZRe V GFV,GhdD\P^3eCEHGKG5OYV,GjDOPRe VZGh\PN5Oc^3R w j3VZNF\Z GRe\WgUGhbFG*VQS\Pe\ZGS/@\P^3ReSG\BRejaQn\Ze\PGhgUGh\Z^SReVZQnx3GG5OYV ¯[
(13) gU bF GEQn O,QOPGb*^3jDgUGhNFVZQndfG!O GFfG5b¬VZReGh7QSbF GFEHGj3V5# ", jDOc RejeG gUNGGOcV$g RUVP OPGF\ Qn\Ze\ZG gebFGFGRe\Z ^SRUbF Vi Qnx3Gb*^3EwEHGw je\ZQ3OYVZ\PRDb*VPRe\ZGª OcGEH Y«WOcVZQSeGG*V$g ^SdfNF\ZGF\KGOKQSgeQSdUVZQnVP ^SjD%O j2VPN\P GFRD\KgUG ¹ QnjDO¦b*G\ZQSdedf^S\PV£SjD^SRDO¤N*VPRgU ^3jDOQ\P^3eRDOcVPGOZOPG,$g RDjQn\Ze\ZGWgUGW\Z^SReVZQnx3G^3\ZO¤gUGWQgU OPdDQn\Z VZ ^3j geGK\ZG±2'R &FVPG5OBGFjab*G\cViQn jDOB'j (hRDgeOgeR\ZNOPGQSR¼ ) · |5{ µ * { LGde bFQnVP ^Sj)gUGgU^3jejeNFG5OF£U^3dUVP EH OZQVZ ^3jgDQnjDOBGOB\ZNOPGQSRUT £2\Z^SDRDOYVZGOZOcG.
(14)
(15) !"
(16) # $%#'&( $% )* +. ,. )0/¤ * je^S\ZEHQnVP ^SjgU OcVP\Z eRUVP ^Sj)^UbFbFRe\iOB jEQnj<XgU fG\PGj2VWb*^Sj2VZG*T<VZO£UeRUVVZAeGh¦QqXUO¦ jAD biA)gU OYVZ\P eRU VZ ^3j OBQSbiAe GF3GgHVZGFjDgVP^wGKQn\Z QnVP ^SjDO^n^3jeXHVY^DQSOP bWEHGbiADQSje OPE2O 1
(17) deROcAQnjDgdeRe /[/RDOPA O QtdD\P^2QSb¬VZ 3GEHG5biADQnje OP3E 1QhOc^3Re\ib*GB^n jU^S\ZEQVP ^SjHOPGFjDgeO/VPAeG, jU^3\PEQVZ ^3jVZ^ª^3\/ jHVZAeG,gU \PG5b¬VZ ^3j ^SZ«¤d^3 j2VZOAeG\PG\PG5±3RDGOcVZO¤^S\VPADQnV¦ jU^S\ZEQVZ ^3jd^2OPOP DXH >^UbFbFRe\ jVZAeGKjeGQS\]RUVZRe\PG3][/Re> O Q\PG5QSb¬VZ 3GhEHGbiADQSje OP4E 1¤AeGjQ\ZG±2ReG5OYV,^UbFbFRe\iOF£fQEHGOZOPQSxSGh OWOPGFj2V,VP^VPAeG jU^3\PEQnVP ^SjaOc^3Re\ib*GS£ QSjDgVPAeGOP^SRe\ib*GK\ZGFde G5OB<XOPGFjDgU jexwVPADGh jU^3\PEQnVP ^SjVP^wVPAeGh\ZG±2ReG5OYVdf^S j2V @BAeGhdDRDOcA)EHGbiAQnje OcE O,dDQn\PVP b*ReQn\ZXRDOcGFRe¼
(18) VPAeGh jU^S\ZEQVZ ^3j O,OcVZQVZ bS]jVPADQnVWbFQ3OcG3£UVPAeG bjUQnj ^3\PVZEAeGFQjVZ ^3jaGADADQSQSOWjDVPgU^Gg GH^UOPGFbFj2QSVWXSVZ^oQS,VPdAD^2GOPOP jU e^SG\ZE\PG5Q±2VZRe ^3GjOcVWbidfAD^SQn jDj3xSViOWGO^3£
(19) jeAeX^¦^3GFjDSb*GG3\£ £
(20) Qn\ZjDGg±2ReQSG5OYViORUVZRe \P¦Gw\Z\ZGGOP±2ReRe VHGOc VZj O jU^3\PEQVZ ^3j VPADQnV O^SRUV^SgeQVZGS'@^ GjDOPRe\PG)VZADQVVPAe OgU^<G5Oje^SVADQndDdGj¼£,Qnj<X jU^3\PEQVZ ^3j RDdfgeQnVPGa ADQqSGVP^ fGde\Z^SdQnx3QnVPG5g VP^ QSWd^2OPOP DG)\ZG±2ReGOcVdf^S j3ViOF @BAe ORedfgDQVPGVP\iQ b O df^nVZGFj2VP QnXBQSOcVPG*RD £GOPdG5b* QnX /Qn\ZxSGtj<ReEfGF\iO^n
(21) Red>geQVZGOQn\ZGOcGj3VVZ^d^3 j2ViO,AeG\PGhADQS\ZgeX QSj<X\ZG±2ReGOcVW^UbFbFRe\iOF@BAeG\PGF^S\ZGS£e /VPAeG\PG5±2ReGOcV,\ZQnVPG O,3GF\ZX^ª\ZGFQVP SGtVZ^VPADGRed>geQVZG\iQVPGq«¬£ V,EQn»3GOBOcGjDOPGVZ^QndedDXVZAeGhdeRe¼EHGbiAQnje OcE) @^OcVPRDgeX)VPAe O,VZ\ZQ3gUG^SofG*VY¦GFGjdeRD
(22) QnjDgdeRDOPAEHGbiADQSje OcE¥WQq3G*VQSjDga oGFjejD je» , ¡sDIS£ W ¢ j3VZ\P^UgURb*GgVPADG[/RDOPA)@\ZGFGh[/\Z^SeGFE VPADQnV^S\ZEReQVZGgfGF^5 1 G*V 68789:096<;=>96<;;¦fGQSjaRejDgU \ZGb¬VZGg)x3\ZQSdeA¼£QSjDg)G*@V ?A9
(23) B; 7C?D9FEG=HI;KJMLGVPAeGGjexnVZA ^S,Qnj<XG5gUxSNG BO7P9
(24) EQ=HR;<ST>N96<;P`a^S\ZGF^SG\£ G*V ?D9UV;@7XWMYZ[Q\^]`_?A9
(25) B;,fGVPADGGjexnVZA ^n,Qnj<X OPReex3\ZQSdeaA U&^Sb 6w c e{ dTf¤} ³<g ³ c } · z * ³ h ie 2 VjklI#N6<mnOP^SRe\ib*Gtje^UgUG oSg:96<;mn! Red>geQVZG\iQVPG p'qTL(m \PG5±2ReGOcVOcGF< V rPs8:N96<;m5 t\ZG±2ReGOcVh\ZQnVPG55O u9FHI;qvL(=AwxHySzr{4| tgOIklI#3}~"6<m -. ..
(26) #o"S4:N9
(27) }~5;mK tl(
(28) #k}Q5+H D0! R xtk 3:N9
(29) }~5;mxwxHNS4r<mR#a
(30) #! p?D9}~5;IM u9FHI;?A9
(31) }G; Z 5+j R+){. @BAeGHOP^SRe\ib*Gje^UgUG oHbF^Sj2VZQS jOQde Gb*Gw^n jU^3\PEQnVP ^SjaVZADQVbiADQSjexSG5O p VZ EHGOtdfGF\KVZ EHGwReje V ," VPG\WGF3GF\ZXbiADQSjexSG3£UVPADGRed>geQVZGga jU^S\ZEQVZ ^3j Olx# tt\Z^SEohVZ^Qnje^UgUG5O, jg:9}~5;]RDOP jex VZAeGG5gUxSG5O, j>9
(32) }~5;ZW`)ReVP bFQ3OYVW ORDOcG5g £DAD biAaEHGQSjDOVZADQVK^SjeX^SjeGRDdfgeQnVPGEHG5OPOZQnx3Gh OOcGj3V ^3GF\/GSGF\ZXwGgUx3GS 9GEwG5QSOPRe\ZGBVPAeGKOc *FG,^S VPAeGWVP\iQ bQSOZOP^<bF QnVPG5gH VZAQEHGOZOPQSxSG,Q3O
(33) VPAeGj<ReEfGF\ VZ^SAeKGFD\ZG* ViO^3\PVPGK EHG±2GRDOHQSVZ>AeVPG^gUp ?AOc9
(34) VZ}Qnj~5b*;ZG b*^3GF\ZGg ¡@BADG)VP^nViQnWQSEH^SRej2V^nhRed>geQnVPG)VP\iQ b)dfGF\VZ EHGRDje V O LG5±2ReGOcVZO,^S\,VZAeG jU^3\PEQVZ ^3jaOYVZ^S\ZGg)Q5V o^UbFbFRe\ u9FHI;¦VP EwG5OWdfGF\WVP EHGReje VQnVje^UgU"G H4Sgrw ¤QSbiA\ZG±2ReG5OYVB\ZGOPRe ViO¦ jQ\ZG±2ReG5OYV¦EHGOZOPQSxSG,VZ^HGhOPGFj2V¦^3GF\VPAeG lI))<dDQnVP3 A } \P^3E HHVP^HQje^UgUG jO}~ AD biAab*^3j2VZQn jDOQSjRed)VZ^geQVZGhb*^Sd<X^SVZAeG jU^S\ZEQVZ ^3j¼]@BAe Oje^UgUGt VPADGFjaOcGjDgeO,Qw\ZGFdeX EHG5OPOZQnx3G¤VZ5^ HRDOP jexKVZAeG,OPQSEHG¦dQVPA£SeRUV]jD^ jw\ZGF3GF\iOcGBgU \PG5b¬VZ ^3j¼@BADGVZ^nViQnDQSEw^3Rej2V/^n>\PG5±3RDGOcV VZ\ZQ bdfGF\BVZ EHGhRejD VW O¦VPADGF\ZG*^S\ZGtG±2RDQS>VP^ W Z"u9FHI;?A9
(35) }G;P Q( .
(36) l. |%{<i . ". OHje^nVZGg j W ¡seI¬¢£]VZAeGa[/RDOPA @\PGGde\Z^SDGE OwGQ3OcX @º 6 ViOcG K OHQVP\ZGFGS jDgUGFG5g £¤G*V ~ 7 9:`=>;,fGQVP\ZGFGH VPA Q)Oc^3Re\ib*Go4S :QnjgoQ\ZG±2ReG5OYVOPG*V"r8:L,GFEH^< jexaQSj2XaG5gUxSG B"S4> \Z^SE8~\ZGOPReV
(37) jHVPADGBVP\ZGFGe\ZGQS»2 jextgU^jH j2VZ^VY¦^hb*^3Ewdf^SjDGFj2VZO£:Y VPADQnV¤b*^Sj2ViQn jDO o3£3Qnjg : Y ¤@BADGFjVPAeG)* ta B jVPAeGhdeROcAVP\ZGFGt O
(38) p W Z u9FHI; 3QnjDgVPADGtVP\iQ bt^SjVPAeGhG5gUxSG HB O"9Bk; 7?D9Bk; 9
(39) BZ; w@BAeGwVZ^nVZQSVP\iQ bOP *F GVPAeGjo O"9F~" ;7WMYZ[ "9
(40) BZ; oGgUGFje^SVPGH<X. VZAeGWQSEw^3Rej2V¤^n>VZ\ZQ bB jVZAeG,^SdeVP EHQSOP^SRUVP ^Sj VZAeG,\ZG±2ReGOcV]Rejb¬VP ^SjHVZADQV¦G,QS\PG,bF^SjDOP gUGF\Z jDx jDGFGgDO¦VP^fGh gUGj2VP §DGg £DGtRDOPGKVPAeGhje^SVZQnVP ^SjDO!!9
(41) ~5;]QnjDg" @BAeG\PGF^S\ZGQqSG*VQnjg oGFjeje je»a , ¢¼OcVPRDge G5gQdDQn\PVP b*RDQS\b*QSOZO^nADGFRe\Z OcVP bFO¤^S\¦VZAeGK[]RDOcA @QSjD\ZGFgG] deVK\Zb*^S^SDjDGjeE Gb*VZOAeVZ AebiAhGRDOP^SOPGReO\ib*QBGtVYje^U^gUOYGVZGFQndjDQSg)deQnde\Z¼^3VZQSAebiGA \ZG±2jhReVPG5AeOYG¤V,§Dje\i^UOYgUVG5OcOFVP¦Gd¼j)£Q5VPAD!GOc
(42) G5 b*@^3jD
(43) g) OYVZ~ GFd¼ O£DVPb*Ae^3GjDOY^3VZdU\PRVP b¬EVPG5Qng dDRDOcAVP\ZGFG ja~¡ O^SeVZQn jeG5g<XOc^3< jexhVPADGde\Z^SDGE jVZAeGK\P^3RUVP jexVZ\PGGS ]Q3biAAeGFRD\P OYVZ b jVPAD O bFQ3OPO¦ OBVPA<RDObiAQn\iQSb¬VZGF\Z Gg2XVPAeGhRDOPGgEHG*VZAe^Ug^S\^SeVZQn je jexwVPAeGt\Z^SRUVZ jDxVZ\PGGS <RbiAAeGRe\P OcVP bFO
(44) Qn\ZGQnVcVP\iQSb*VP SGG5bFQnROcGVPAeGXhxSGjeGF\iQVZGQnj jU\iQSOcVP\ZRDb*VPRe\ZGS£Ae G¦OcVP UQS^ jDx \iQndD gwQSgeQSdUVZQnVP ^SjDOVZ^hbiADQnjex3 jDxVZ\ZQ bdQVcVZGF\ZjDOj W ¢£nVPADG,OcGjDOc VP < VYX^n>Oc^3RUVZ ^3jDO
(45) ^SeVZQn jeG5g jHVPAD O¦QqXVP^biAQnjex3GO/ jRed>geQVZGWQnjgH\PG5±3RDGOcV¤\ZQnVPG5O/¦Q3O] j<SGOcVP x3QnVPG5g <RDded^2OcG,VPADQnV¦Qh\Z^SRUVZ jDx VZ\PGG ~ ADQ3OhfGFGFj%^3UVZQS jeG5g9VPADQnV\PG5OcReVZOt j Qnj%^SdeVP EHQS]^S\hjDGQn\P^SdUVZ EQnª7 VZA Qndede\Z^qTU EQnVP ^Sj \iQVZ $^ #<«WdeRDOPAVZ\PGG^3\KQdDQn\PVP b*RDQS\W\ZG±2ReGOcVKRejDb¬VZ ^3gj u<,^ xS^<^Uga OVZAe OK\Z^SRUVZ jDxVP\ZGFG VPAeG \ZG±2ReG5OYVBRejb¬VP ^Sj) OBEH^<ge §DG5g&% QqSG*VQnjg oGFjeje je»ge OZb*RDOZOPGgHVY¦^wge >GF\ZGFj2VOPbFGFjDQS\P ^3OjVPAeG§D\iOYVB^SjDGS£<VPADGKOPG*VB^n\PG5±3RDGOcV jD^<geGnO r \PGEQn jDO¤RDjDbiADQnjDxSGg¼£<QSjDgQS>\ZG±2ReG5OYV¦\ZQnVPGOBbiADQSjexSGKQnEH^3OcVReje ^S\ZEHX3£<VP68AD7QnV¦ OVPAeGtjeG \ZG±2ReG5OYVBRejb¬VP ^Sj4u('¼OZQVZ Oc§DGO9*)!+-,;u/. u('. 9)K10;
(46) u<¤@BAeGXOPAe^2!*39F~5;4.5# :9<; 3 j%VZAeGOPGb*^3jDg%OPbFGFjDQS\P ^DQ£ r biADQSjexSG5OF@BAe Ob*^S\Z\ZGOPd^3jDgeOKVP^ ,7=)^S>\ 037@?¡@BAeGXoOPAe^ VZVZAD\PGQGOVH1QSgeGFge3 GFjejoxo Q¦OP Gjex3ADQqGSGH\PG5Qn±2j%ReG^3OcdUVVPje E^UgUQnG]\ZbF^SQnRUj VZ ADjDQqxSVZG\PGQ9GHgU\Z^SQS\EQ)QdVP Qnb\PVPGF fb*ReG5b¬QnVH\t^S\Zj%G±2VPReADGGOcVh±2RDReQSjD b*VYVPX9 ^S^Sj¼W£
(47) QQSgD\Z^SgURU jDVZx) jDQx OP jexSGh\PG5±2ReGOcVWje^UgUGEQqX\PG5OcReVW j)VPAe O,\Z^SReVP jexHVP\ZGFGfGbF^SEH jexQn\Ze VP\iQn\Z XDQ3g ª ja\PGQnVP ^SjVP^ VZAeGh^SdeVP EHQS \P^3RUVP jexwVP\ZGFGK^3\BVPAeGhjeG \ZG±2ReG5OYVBRejb¬VP ^Sjf«¬ W^GSGF\\P^3RUVP jex9VP\ZGFG)OcGGFEOVP^%GEH^S\ZG\Z^SDRDOYVVP^o\PGEH^qQS^SWSG\cVZ bFGO j , ¢£] V O bF^Sj_YG5b¬VZRe\PG5gVPADQnV¤ VZAeG,\ZG±2ReG5OYV/Rejb¬VP ^Sj O]GOcVZQSeG,G*Teb*GdUV¤ Bj ASGF\PVP b*G5O/AeG\PG V¦gUG5b*\ZGQ3OcG5Oª7Qnjg EQqX<fGBge OZQndedfGQS\i«¼VPADGF/j C' 9F~";4.M9EDFA)8+ H ;I 3 ADGF\Z%G uKJ O/VPAeGBEH jD EReE je^3<j GF\Z^t\PG5±3RDGOcV \iQVZGt^SGF\BQn VZAeGhje^UgUGO/@BAe O,b*^3j_YGb*VPRe\ZGt¦Q3OdD\P^3Gg V^SC\ A7L)H W ¢ jVPAD OdQndfGF\5£UGtGOcVZQSe OPAVZAe O,b*^3j_YGb*VPRe\ZGK^S\GF3GF\Z$X Ag1 f<d ³<· } ³ N MPO R Ftk 2< R D <5 F# 5$%# &( lI ) 2+P
(48) # Ft I
(49) F!)b Q AlI !
(50) # O SRR " D 4 < xtk jH =TUT2=HV({@W tk 2 x! F# >X " R2R F 4um! xtV
(51) #. 2 t4jYu '
(52) m t e + @u('9
(53) H[Z; \ u9FH]Z;=*^n7P)=UTU=SA {_Q b~ j F# Nlx
(54) +)b!
(55) 3
(56) !5 SRR I F au{& # 2 (m uTJ ;I 3A9F~";`. 9aDbA5c)!+dA 3 p. @BAeG^S\ZGFE¥ItxSGjeGF\iQn *FGO¦Q\PG5OcReV^n\PQnjDgeGe Qn
(57) "W s3sq¢£DAe^dD\P^3GW V^S\¦VPAeGhOPdG5b* Qn¼bQSOPG ADGFj3u J 7 p1
(58) VPADG2VPG jeG\,@\ZGFGtde\Z^SG DGE @BAeGtRedDdG\^3RejDg 9aDFA@f)+-A ;] OVP xSA2Vhg^3jDOc gUG\¤VZAeGhb*XUb*G9o=H =H =UUT=H V =EG=ok; VPA 9o=EQ;QnjDg 9
(59) EQ=H V ;^ntGFjexSVPA'IQnjg H Qn,^nVZAeGF\G5gUxSG5O^ntGFjexSVPAiDj+ H G G*V0u9
(60) H Z ;07 p'Qnjg kmlGkon.
(61)
(62) !"
(63) # $%#'&( $% )* + u('9FH Z ;7L^S\j)$.L^ . AoQnjDg u9FEQ;7u('
(64) 9
(65) E; 7uKJ@BADGwdQVPAV~79o=H G = H =UUT2=H V =EQ; OhQSj ^3dUVP EQn \Z^SRUVZ jDxVZ\PGGK^S\\ZG±2ReGOcVBRejDb*VP ^Sj4<u £DeRUV !3D9F~";G7 9EDFA5c)!+dA H ;a 3 . @BAe OK\PG5OcRD VhOcAD^,O,RDOVPAQVt\PGEw^< jex\ZG±2ReG5OYVKje^UgUGOKADQq3GQOPEQn EHdDQSb*VKADGF\ZGQSOQSgege jex Z\ G±2ReG5OYVje^UgUGOwEQqX9AQqSGQ9gU\ZQSEQVP b^3jeGS%,GjDb*G3£/ G¦QSj3VVP^9RDOcGVPAeG\Z^SRUVZ jexVP\ZGFGQSOQ OcVZQSeGh jU\iQSOcVP\ZRDb*VPRe\ZGt j)Ae biAVPAeG[]RDOcAa@\PGG[/\Z^SeGFE O,OP^SSG5ggeX2jQnEH bQnX3£U V OB7QS\,fG*VcVZGF\ VZ^H^¦SGFRU\ZVGOc ¦VP ¦EGHQVZ¦GWQSVZj2AeVGhVZ\P^G5±2RReOcGGHOcVVZAejeGH^UgU\P^3GhRUOcVPGF VZjeOBxVZVPAD\ZQnGFjGVPQS^OtReQ)jOPgUGFGFEH\ZG OcOcVPVZ EQnDQVPGHGt jUV \ZQ3OYVZ\PRb¬VPRD\PG3£ GH ]jDGFGgVP^ bF^SEHdeRUVZG, V]\P^3E"VZ EHGVZ^hVP EHGS]< jDb*G, V¤ O¤¯[
(66) AQn\igVZ^h§DjDgwVZAeG,^3dUVP EReE \Z^SRUVZ jextVZ\PGGS£3G,EQqX geGb* gUGVP^RDOcGHQnjoQnEH^3OcV^SdeVP EHQS\Z^SReVP jexVZ\PGGde\Z^UgURDbFGga<XOP^SEHGAeGRe\Z OcVP bn ¦RUVh@BAeGF^3\PGE&I EQqXjD^nVGhGFT<VPGFjgUGgVP^QSEH^3OcV^SdUVZ EQS¼\P^3RUVP je3x 1 c } · ]· { | · M |Q@ RC#NJ ) t J L0 F# @! ( D
(67) xt
(68) '
(69) # $%#g& . lx) 2+ xta ~ R#a
(70) #
(71) g! xt
(72) ]' @Ft I
(73) F) Q AlI (!
(74) # @ R2R b! t %H # 2 L"7 uY'9
(75) HR; \ u9FHI;8!k9
(76) ~5;. #[ t ! 3 9F~5; q *3 { c } ·¼· g^SjOc gUGF\VPAeG^S^ jex)VPADGjeG*VY¦^S\Z» VPA jD^<geGao3£i£bE QnjDgVH9 VZAz?D9ok=HR;57 9898 £ ?A9o=EQ;G7 + )3£R?D9FEG=;7 ?A9o=;b7 )3 GFVofGtVPAeGOc^3Re\ZbFGS£pg7L)QnjDg3u9; 7 u ' 9; 7 )7 u9FHI; QSjDgau9ok;b7 (u '9ok;b7 u9FEQ;b7 (u '9FEQ;G7 L57 (u '9FHIP; G*V"~ fGHVP\ZGFGH jDgURDbFGg9<XaVPAeGHVZ\PGGHGgUx3GOj9=o!Z; £Go=EQ,; QnjDgz9FEG=HIP; @BADGFj k9F~5; 7 '!. QSjDg!3A9F~";%7" QSjDg Vt OKGQ3OcXVZ^OPGFGVPADQnV 7#' )QSjDg 3 7 )3,GjDb*G!!9F~" ; . #[ QSjDg$3A9
(77) ~5; q$ 3 . . . W^GSGF\5£/VZAeG)VP\ZGF4G ~ j VPADGQnf^SGde\P^<^S OHSGF\ZX dDQS\cVZ bFReQn\QnjDg OSG\PX RejD »SGX VZ^ G dD\P^UgURDbFGg2XQSjAeGRe\Z OcVP bnjgUGFG5g Vt OKSG\PX)DQ3g^SjoQOPReejDG*VY¦^S\Z»%ªVPADQnVh OVPADGw^3jeGw jDgeRDb*G5g <NX o3£ EQSjD%g Y«* ReV¦RDOPRDQSXAeGFRD\P OYVZ bO¤X< GFgOP^SRUVP ^SjO]VZADQVBxSRDQS\ZQSj2VPGFGQnjQSdede\Z^qT< EQVZ ^3j\ZQnVP ^ ^3jGSG\PXOPReejeGFVY^3\P»> @BAeG\PGF^S\ZGS£ VW¦^SRDg)fG j3VZGF\ZGOcVP jexVZ^^SUViQn ja@BAeGF^3\PGE Ih »3G\ZGOPRe ViO^3\WQnEH^3OcVW^SdUVZ EReE VZ\PGGO¦VZADQVWQS\PGKde\Z^<geRDb*G5g VPAaOP^SEHGtdDQn\PVP b*ReQn\ADGFRe\Z OcVP bn & !' #" ,+ j ^S\igUGF\VP^de\P^3G@BAeG^S\ZGFEvIS£W¦GjDGFGg VPAeG9^S^ jex\PG5OcReVAD biA¡AD^SgeO^3\QSKdDQS \iO^S jDOcVZQSjDb*G5OB^nVZAeG[/RDOPAa@\ZGFGtde\Z^SDGEVPADQnVWQn\ZGt gUGj2VP bFQn GFTeb*GFdeV^S\BVPADGF \\PG5±3RDGOcV¦RDjDb¬VZ ^3j¼ ¸ . /³ 0 21435+ .7698 _Q ;:yqL)O t3) buV xt<u(' j 0 R2R c } · ]· { | · ('*)+ -~ , ³ |~ ( F R R#a
(78) #! Qu('9FHI; .$: u9
(79) HR; !))RH0S4r{n|! I N
(80) ~5m 3D9
(81) ~5;4.!: 9
(82) ~5;{ G*VRDO§D\iOYVdD\P^3GVZADQV VOPR b*G5OtVP^de\P^3G@BAeGF^3\PGEIAeG'j u9
(83) H[Z;7 p/£^S\ ). ^. A> jZ gUGFG5gOcRDded^2OcG]VPADQnVVPADG¦OPG*2V
(84) K^ne j2VPGxSGF\iOOPRDbiAtVZADQGV u9
(85) H[Z;7 < p Oje^SVGFEHdUVYX3®D^S\GSG\PX ^`S=
(86) £G*V H fG¦VPAeG,bF^2OcG5OYV
(87) SG\cVZG*T^SDVZAenG udeRDOPAwVP\ZGFGB^nx ~ ",jDgGFV u fGBVPAeGB\ZG±2ReG5OYV
(88) RejDb*VP ^Sjb*^3 jb* gU jDx VPAOuw^SjaGSG\PX3GF\PVP b*G5OBG*Teb*GdUV H]Z¤QnjgaH]Z ^S\ ^nS>
(89) ADGF\ZG5u 9
(90) H[Z;`7 LQSjDg4u 9FH]Z ;7Mp/tª7¯W^nVPG . Q( . . . .
(91) m. |%{<i . VZADQVK VtEQqXAQndedfGFjaVZADQVH]Z 7 H]Z 3 «VK OGQSOPXVP^OPGFGVPADQnV@~' OQSju ^3dUVP EQnVP\ZGFG3K< jDb*G<u QSjDag uY'gU fG\,^SjeX jVPAeG H]Z £ ^ S
(92) £<VZAeGFja VPAeGh\ZGOPReVBAD^SgeO¦^S\u VP^u(' VZAeGFj 3 9F~";G7c. uJ 9
(93) ~5;4. 9aDFA52)!+ A p ;I *3. G*G*V,VRD%OfjDGW^VZ AeG<b*^39jDoOc= H gU G=\BH]VPAD=UUQnTVu=H9
(94) H V Z ; ;G27 VZGFp/ je£<GF\¦^S\ VZ\P) GGW.f j0^4.c~ A>QSjD gG*V} ZfGVPAeGKdDQVZA_Y^3 je jexoWVP^jH[Z j ~gGQS\PXS£V7 ZV } Z
(95) Qnjg % OBQOPReUVZ\PGGW^SVPADGdeROcAVP\ZGFG3 G*VBRDO¦^<^3»HVP^VPAeGK^2QSgeO^nVPAeG G5gUxSG^n ~¡RDjDgUGF\nu('>QnjDg0u</QnjG5gUxSGKgU^<GOje^nVBfGF^SjexVP^VPAeGVP\ZGFG 9VPAeGj VZO¦^3QSg O^S<< ^3RDOPX VZAeGBOPQSEwG¦RejDgeGFb\ u ' QnjDg u2]<GF
(96) V 7 >9F~5;R>9K;>QnjDgGFV "9 "; 7vY Z !!9B=~5;Q7CY Z ! 3 9B=~5;P U jDbFG u9
(97) HR; 7 poQn VPADGhGgUx3GO¦^n }"ADQq3Gt^2QSag pRejDgeGF\ u<¤@BA<RDO 7Tp?A9K;x "9 5; ªYI5« ®D ^S!\ ^`S- b)=DtQSjD gG5QSbiASG\cVZG*T KS3r' £eG*V &Z9;]fGtVPAeGbF^2OcG5OYV3GF\PVPG*T^nG } ZVZ^ Ea 4j ~ G*V )>. ^ .2A> G*V,RDOW^S\igUGF\BVZAeG3GF\PVP b*GnO E Z =E<Z =UTU=E<ZJ ^n r'OPRDbiAVPADQnV K9 Z9
(98) E<Z ;=H Z ; . 9&Z9FE Z 6 =H]ZA;Z $ G*je!V G)07bFcQSj § jD g9FpOP= GW#±2Re" GZjD b*3 G5u(O'9F^SEQ;;Z3 GF\PVP b*GO^n r'7£ 9 Z = Z =TUU = Z ;j) .@^ . A QSjDg RDjDb¬VZ ^3jDjO uYZZ£ J ).f^ . A>£DOPRDbiAVZADQV1 % ^S\GSGF\ZX ).f^4. AQSjDg ) .'&j.)(9£ Z S4r'+* g )d.,&i.-(o£¤ Z 7 E Z. VZAeGFj^S\HGF3GF\Z/X & ' \,&oVPAeG$j Z 3 S % ^S\GSGF\ZX )d.^B. A QSjDi E Z =E Z =TUT2=E Z. 2£UQnjDg^S\BGF3GF\ZN X ? ' \T?£eOPG*VcVZ jD1x 0 Z 9? ' =&R;VZAeGhOcGFVB^SSG\cVZ bFGO Z 3 VZ2A & ' .3& OcRbi AVZADQV Z 3 7 E Z. 3 £ W54Z76 \ . 398 _ u Z 9;G7 u9
(99) E Z. 3 ;:* J % ^S\GSGF\ZX ).f^4. A x£ W u(Z9 Z ;G75;* \ 9I^ =^ ;Z(£ u(Z 9 Z ;G7 u(Z 9 Z ;G7 u % ^S\,QS4 ).3&j.<( QnjDgQn¼dDQS 5 ®D^S\ ) .3&j.=(o£eG*V > fGtVPADGt^S\ZGOcV¦VZADQV, O¦VPADGhReje ^Sj)^nVPAeGhdDQnVPAD@O ? Z £ ) .1^h. A>£q_Y^3 jD jex ZA9 Z ;/VP ^ H]Z
(100) 4j ~ J *3 9
(101) ~5;G7#R?D9%;+ u ?D9> ;x "9 "; ª rS« oG je^^3UVZQS jRedDdG\f^SRejgeO¤^SA R?D9BK; + W J u ?D9> ;
(102) QnjDg "9 ";
(103) <Xw^3RejDgU jex 9F~5; <XVZAeGtVP\iQ bKRejDgeGF\uw jaOP^SEHGhQndede\Z^SdD\P QVZG,VP\ZGFG5Ob*^3jDOYVZ\PRb¬VPG5g\Z^SE VPAeG5u('^SdUVZ EQn>VZ\PGG~C' G*VB RDG*O¦V ^<~ ^3 »HfVPGAeGKQVP^2\ZQSGFgeGO^S ejVZVZQnAe jeGG5\Zg^SRe\ZVP^S jeE xVZ~ \P'GG<X9~ Q3gegUAe GFjejxVPyQAeGK9o\ZG=H±2Re=GH OcV¦=UTReUjD2b¬=VZH V^3;7jY2biVPADGQS jejeGxS\hG5O]VP\Z\ZGF^SCG E u VPj ^j6wuY' . kmlGkon.
(104)
(105) !"
(106) # $%#'&( $% )* +. VBEQqX^SjeXbiADQnjDxSG,^3\BGgUx3GO^n
(107) AeG\PGVPAeGK^3QSg¦Q3O`p9QnjDgEHQqXgUG5b*\ZGQ3OcG3@BA<RDO !!9
(108) ~ ;4. 3 Tp?D9B ;Z)U jDbF G OQ2VZGF jeGF\VP\ZGFG j 6w£ ?D9 ;.?D9%;P@BA<RDO!!9F~ ;>. 3 p?D9BK;P WGFjDbFG p?D9%;d9 5;7c .1!9F~ ;4.f *3 p?D9BK;P "9 5; .5 3 Fª ,3« G*V ~ GQwVP\ZGFG^3UVZQS jeG5g\P^3XE ~C'¼2X)QSgDgU jDxQOcAD^S\PVPGOcV^S\ZGOcV ' gj 6 b*^3jejeG5b¬VP jex Z VP^ H]Z¦^Sj \ )". ^ . A>B gGQS\PX 7 39F~ ;P G*VhRDOt^2^3»je^ ^n¤VZAeG^3QSgDO^SVZAeGHGgUx3GOt^SK ~ RDjDgUGFn\ uQSjDNg u(' GFV ' GVPADjG 3 9o= = =TUU = V ; <VPGF jeG\VZ\PGG 0j ~ '/Q Bt O¦je^nV j `' B' VZAeGFj 3D9
(109) B=~ ;G7 &k9
(110) B=~ ;P
(111) B O/ C j `' B' £SVPAeGj &9
(112) B=~ ;G7 p/ "WjDgH B5S/`' £SVPAeGj &B=~ qzuTJ OP jDb*%G u9 Z ; q uTJ QSjDg x BS ' F£ B =~ 7 Le
(113) @BA<RDO(£ k9 F~ ;4.f3A9
(114) ~ ;2jp?A9 ' ;49Fp +"uKJ" ;D?D9B` ' ;P ¯W^h£eGFV fGtVPAeGOPAe^3\cVZGOcV¦^3\PG5OYV, 4j ~ bF^SjejDGb¬VZ jDx Z VP^ H]Z
(115) ^3\ )>.5^h. A ¦XgUGF§Dje VP ^Sj¼£ ?A9 ' ; . ?A9 ;P "WjDO g ?D9 ; .T?D9> ; W ZV 9 Z9 Z ;= Z ;Z],GjDb*G3£ V !!9
(116) ~ ;4.5 3 'p?A9> ;'p 9 Z 9 Z ;= Z ; 9
(117) p$+yuTJ<;D?D9 ' ; ªl2« Z G*V]RDO/jD^b*^3jDOP gUG\VPAeG, jDgUGFT &t^3\/Ae bi2A 7 ?A9> ;e W ZV 9 Z 9 Z ;= Z ;eg9)+ H G ;?A9 ' ; OBEH jD EReE)4 .5!!9F~ ;/VZA2RO<0X ]±2RDQVZ ^3jDOtIQnjgl p?D9%;xd"9 5; . .. p 3 . pA 3 7 p J u p J u ?D9> . 3. J $+yuTJ p . ; u A? 9 ' ; ª S«3 ; u 9 Z ¦XgeG*§Dje VP ^Sj£U^S\GSGF\ZX).5^h.fA>£&"9 ";`q W J u 9 9 Z ;= Z Z; £DOc^. . ¯W^. J. . J. V. Z ?D9B` ' ;4. W ZV 39o= Z /; VZA<RDO J. V. Z 9 Z. ;= Z. ª7m3«. u 9 Z 9 Z ; = Z ;4. A]9 5;. V. J. u ?A9 ' ; . u Z 9 Z ;<39ok= Z ; Z J WjDg fGbQnRDOPG3W u(Z9 Z ;"7-2.p/£/GADQqSG4W J uYZ9 Z ; 39 Z =o!;"7 9
(118) ~C';Z JWjDg <X []\P^3d^2Oc VP ^SjhrU£K 9
(119) ~ ' ;h.1 3 9F~ ' P; £qOP jDbFGu Z 9
(120) HRh; . u ' 9FHI;D^S\ GSG\PX,jD^<geG H@BA<RDOF£!W ZV W u Z 9 Z ; 3 9o= Z ; .. ". Q( . ".
(121) u. |%{<i A3. ]@BAeG5OcGKVY¦^H jeG5±2RDQn VZ G5OBxS SG1 . ]±2RDQnVP ^SjDO U£emHQnjDg. . X< Gg. J p p?A9
(122) }j;+ R?D9}j; +. . . J. . J. u D? 9> ; .. . . A p. .. u A? 9> ;. A+. +f) "9 5;. p. 9 5; . W¯ ^8]±2RDQnVP ^SjDOhrQnjDg9uX2 GFg- 3 9
(123) ~5; . KA"2)!+ bQnRDOPG>A5c)!+ H qTLe£U<X0¤±3RQVP ^SjO,D£UGt^SeVZQn j 1 . H . . !3A9
(124) ~5;.. ªn«. u D? 9B ' ;4. A 3. . DbA5c)!+dA. . . . A8. p +yu J 2) 3 u J ; p p. A9)!+. "9 ";G YA9*)!+ H. G. . 3. ª7u3«. ;x H
(125) *3 ¦G*. u J 3 p. , 0/¦ ", sSsn¢ DY g 3je x "e\PQnjgUGhQnjDg g Qn^S\ZGOcV
(126) jDbF\PNEwGj2VZQn VPNtd^3Re\ QS\Pe\ZGhgUGhOYVZGF jeGF\5£/j D 2 x I
(127) Q! xlI#! x )* l 2 F ) ! F#+< R2R 5tk &I )* !+<+j RF F R C_ h & 4_ £fdDQnx3GOKI !, fI uD£ QwL,^<biADGFG3£e®e\iQnjDbFGS£D`aQS rnsSs3se , ¢ ®¦nWQq3G*V/QnjDgw`% 9Gjeje je»>e@BAeGBdeRDOPAVZ\PGGdD\P^3eGE) < ¬£3<ReDEw VcVZGg £
(128) T<VPGjDgUGg SG\ZOP ^Sj^S , ¡sDI*¢ , ¡sDI*¢®¦¦QqSGFVQnjg `%¦ 9Gjeje je»> @BAeG9deRDOPA VP\ZGFG9de\Z^SeGFE)"j ($ - k F# O I+l(e +! 4$!))* ) ) ! F#+<! xt # 2
(129) ¬£UdDQSxSGnO ,DIu ,eI e£2rSsSsDIS . . . . !#". . %$. ). '&. *. 3. #(. ) *+ , -,/. 0 21 %$ 54. kmlGkon.
(130) Unité de recherche INRIA Sophia Antipolis 2004, route des Lucioles - BP 93 - 06902 Sophia Antipolis Cedex (France) Unité de recherche INRIA Lorraine : LORIA, Technopôle de Nancy-Brabois - Campus scientifique 615, rue du Jardin Botanique - BP 101 - 54602 Villers-lès-Nancy Cedex (France) Unité de recherche INRIA Rennes : IRISA, Campus universitaire de Beaulieu - 35042 Rennes Cedex (France) Unité de recherche INRIA Rhône-Alpes : 655, avenue de l’Europe - 38330 Montbonnot-St-Martin (France) Unité de recherche INRIA Rocquencourt : Domaine de Voluceau - Rocquencourt - BP 105 - 78153 Le Chesnay Cedex (France). Éditeur INRIA - Domaine de Voluceau - Rocquencourt, BP 105 - 78153 Le Chesnay Cedex (France).
(131). . ISSN 0249-6399.
(132)
Documents relatifs
« La prophétie, ou interprétation et conférence des Écritures se fera par les ministres du Colloque, en l’assemblée où chacun dira la tête découverte ce que Dieu lui
Pendant six ans, jusqu’au premier janvier 1568, le clergé de France doit fournir chaque année au roi l’équivalent de quatre décimes, un million six cent mille livres tournois,
« On ne fait pas que des psychothérapies en clinique/…/On en parlait encore ce matin : est-ce qu’on a le temps de faire des psychothérapies, parce qu’on voit les gens
L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non, émanant des
AMC PAPI : Spécificités du contexte torrentiel – Rapport de Phase 1 Page 18 sur 46 Dans le cas des laves torrentielles, on peut résumer les conditions nécessaires au
Gillard, “Combinaison de la DG-FDTD avec un mod` ele de substitution pour un calcul de dosim´ etrie locale dans un probl` eme variable et fortement multi-´ echelle”, dans 18`
Le jugement porté par les femmes lettrées sur leurs soigneurs doit donc être nuancé en fonction de la personnalité de chacune, de la gravité de la maladie,
3.3 Processus d’alimentation d'entrepôt de données : Nous devons extraire, transformer et charger les données à partir des sources précédemment citées, dans l'entrepôt de