Original article
Diurnal flight activity of African bees Apis mellifera
adansonii in different seasons and zones of Ghana
J Woyke
FAO
Representative,
Accra andTechnology Consultancy
Center of theUniversity,
Kumasi, Ghana * (Received 30 May 1991;accepted
8 December 1991)Summary —
The number ofApis
mellifera adansonii worker beesreturning
to the hiveduring
5min was counted every 0.5-1.0 h throughout the day. The investigations were conducted during the
dry and rainy
season in 3 zones of Ghana. The pattern offlight activity
in different zones did not dif- fermuch
within each season. However, it differedgreatly
between seasons. In therainy
dearth sea-son, a
single peak
offoraging activity
occurredduring
themorning.
Twopeaks
offoraging activity
occurred during the honey flow, winter dry season; one shortly after sunrise and the other shortly be- fore sunset. The presence of the second
evening peak
isexplained by
nectaravailability.
Apis
mellifera adansonli / flightactivity
/tropical
climate / AfricaINTRODUCTION
It is
important
to know the diurnalflight
ac-tivity
ofhoney
bees in different areas andthroughout
the seasons. Someapiary
op- erations should be conductedduring high flight activity
and othersduring
low activi-ty. Woyke (1989)
found ahigh
correlation betweenflight activity
andstinging
behav-ior of African bees.
The
pattern
of diurnalflight activity
isgenerally cone-shaped,
with apeak
around noon. This was true for A m
ligusti- ca, A
mcaucasica,
A m scutellata and theirhybrids
in Brazil(Lengler, 1984),
forA mellifera in India
(Verma
and Dulta,1986).
A mligustica
in Korea(Lee
etal,
1987)
and Canada(Szabo, 1980)
and forA m litorea and A m monticola in
Kenya (Mbaya, 1985). According
to Kerr et al(1970)
theflight activity
of Italian bees in Brazil washighest
between 8.30 and 10.30 h and that of African bees and theirhybrids
between 14.30 and 15.30 h. WhileGary (1967)
found abell-shaped
curve forflight activity
of A mellifera in atemperate
area, he found an
U-shaped pattern
ofdaily flight
in anirrigated
desert area. Heexplained
thispattern by high temperature
and lowhumidity.
Silva and deJong (1990) presented
a3-peak pattern
offlight activity
at 7, 14 and 16 h for Africanized bees in Brazil. Fletcher(1978) reported
apeak
offoraging activity prior
to 5h,
at* Present address:
Agricultural
University, Bee Division, SGGW, Nowoursynowska 166, 02-766 Warsaw, Polandfirst
light
as characteristic of the African bee A m scutellata inNatal,
South Africa.In this
study
diurnalforaging activity
ofA mellifera adansonii in different areas and
seasons was
investigated.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
The
investigations
were conducted in 1986/1987 in 3 environmentally different zones of Ghana: the south coastal savanna zone in Ac- cra, the central deciduous forest zone in Kumasi and the northern dry savanna zone in Tamale.
The investigations were conducted during the dry season (December-February) and the rainy
season
(June-July).
The same bee colonieswere observed during both seasons in 2 zones.
Observations in Tamale were conducted only
during
the rainy season.To determine
foraging
activity, the number of worker beesreturning
to the hiveduring
a 5-min period was counted.Special
preparatory exer- cise was made to count bees at their maximalflight
activity of 1.0-2.5 thousand per 5 min.Three persons counted simultaneously return-
ing
bees per 5 or per 10, till all 3 results weresimilar. The counts were repeated every 1 h
starting
from 5.30 till 18.30 h. However, at the time whenrapid changes
inflight
activity oc- curred,returning
foragers were counted every 15-30 min. Thus,approximately
30 counts perday
were made. However, the curves infigures
4-10 are based on 13 data
points,
eachplotted
at the full hour. Some other data served to verify
the full hour records,
especially
at the maximumflight.
Other records are mentioned in the text.The counts were
repeated
over 10 differentdays.
Numbers of workersreturning
withpollen
loads within the 5-min
periods
were also deter-mined in some cases.
At the full hour, temperature was recorded,
and also relative
humidity during
the dry sea-son. In Kumasi, the
experimental
beecolony
No4 was
weighed
atweekly
intervals, as were 2 others. The amount of brood was measured every 3 weeks in 3 colonies,including
the ex-perimental
one. In other localities, the amount of brood wasjudged
by the number of combs oc-cupied by
the brood.Hours of daily sunrise and sunset in Ghana
were available to the author. The sun rose and
set on June 21 at 5.56 h and 18.24 h and on De- cember 21 at 6.20 h and 17.52 h
respectively.
RESULTS
Start and end of
flight activity
During
thenight
worker bees form a small cluster outside the hive entrance(fig 1). In
the summer
rainy
season(July)
somebees start
walking
out of the cluster at 5.00-5.10h, crawling
on the front wall ofthe hive
(fig 2).
Some of thecrawling
beestake
flight
at 5.15 h ie 45 min before sun-rise,
when it is still dark.Returning
bees donot
fly directly
to the entrance, but land onthe front wall of the hive and then walk to the entrance
(fig 3).
Some bees even landon the
edge
of the roof.Returning foragers
are
guided
to the entranceby fanning
beeswith released scent
glands.
In the mean-time it
begins
toget
a littlelighter.
It is pos- sible to read written records at 5.30, ap-proximately
30 min before sunrise. The cluster outside the entrancedisintegrates by
5.45 h, and the beesfly
out and returnto the hive
directly
from/to the entrance oralighting
board. At 5.30-5.45 hreturning
bees become visible and it is
possible
tocount them.
In the
evening,
sunset occurs about18.25 h. The bees cease
flying
at 18.35 h.The latest bees land on the front wall of the hive and walk to the entrances. At this
time,
the bees start to form a cluster out- side the entrance. It is difficult to read writ- ten records at 18.45h,
andby
18.55 h it istoo dark to read.
In the winter
dry
season(December- February),
all thephenomena
occurredabout 15 min later in the
morning
andabout 15 min earlier in the
evening.
One can assume that in the darkness or
low
light intensity,
the bees are not able toland or start the
flight directly
to/from the entrance.Orientation
flight
Orientation
flight
of different colonies wasrecorded 20 times in different localities.
Worker bees started this
flight
between 15and 16
h,
and mostfrequently
at 15 h. Inmost cases, the
flight
lasted about 30 min.At this
time,
the drones also started tofly.
They
continued theirflights
till 17 h.Summer
rainy
dearth seasonDuring
the summerrainy
season, thesky
is
mostly cloudy,
andfrequent
rains occur.Therefore the
temperature
is not veryhigh.
During
theinvestigation period,
ie Juneand
July,
thetemperature
was very similar in all 3 localities: at 6 h 22-23°C,
at 12-14h it rose to 29.5-30.5
°C,
and at 18 h itdropped
to 26-28 °C(fig 4).
Theamplitude
between the lowest and
highest tempera-
ture was about 7 °C.
The summer
rainy
season is the dearthperiod
for the bees.Very
fewplants
areflowering.
The bees had to eat theirhoney
reserves to fulfill their
energetic
needs. Dur-ing
theinvestigation period,
bee colonies lost 1-2kg
of their totalweight
per week.The workers collected
pollen
from Zea mais andbrought
homeenormously large pollen
loads. This
protein
source enabled broodrearing
to be maintained. On June 5, 1986, 15 combs werepresent
incolony
No 4 inKumasi. Brood
occupied
34 700 cells in 10 combs, and on June 26, 39 900 cells also in 10 combs.However,
onJuly 17,
theamount of brood
dropped
to 17 300 cells in8 combs. Colonies
investigated
in Tamaleand Accra were of similar
strength.
The
patterns
offlight activity
for 2 con-secutive
days,
12 and 13June,
were very similar in Kumasi. Therefore averages for bothdays
arepresented
infigure
5. Onthose
days,
it waspossible
to start count-ing flying
workers at 5.30h, approximately
23 min before sunrise. At this time 745 workers/5 min returned to the hive
(not
in-dicated in
figure 5).
Thehighest activity
of2 400 workers/5 min occurred at 6.00
h, just
at sunrise.Later, foraging activity
de-creased
quite rapidly
andby
11.0 h therate
dropped
to 550 workers/5 min return-ing
to the hive.Decreasing activity
contin-ued
practically
till the end of theday. Some higher activity
was noticed between 15.30- 16.30, when an orientationflight
tookplace.
At 18.00h,
340 workers/5 min re-turned to the hive. The last count could be made at 18.30
h,
8 min after sunset, when 35 workers/5 min returned.Eleven
days
later,patterns
offlight
ac-tivities on 2 consecutive
days,
June 23 and 24, were also similar to each other. On bothdays,
with theexception
of the morn-ing peak
at 6.00 h(average
750 workers/5min),
ahigher peak
of an average of 1 163 workers/5 min was noticed at 9.00 h(fig 6).
Afterwards,
foraging
decreased until theevening.
Ten
days later,
theearly morning peak
at 6.00 h was no
longer present
in thenorthern savanna zone in
Tamale,
whenonly
270 workers/5 min returned to the hive(fig 7).
Thehighest activity
of 950workers/5
min
had moved to 9.00h,
similarto that observed earlier in Kumasi. Low ac-
tivity
of about 200 workers/5 min continuedfrom 11.30 till the
evening.
The 16.00 hcount was not conducted because an or-
ientation
flight
occurred between 15.30 and 16.00h,
and it wasimpossible
tocount the workers
during
theirregular flights.
About 1 month later
(July, 22),
in thecoastal savanna zone in
Accra,
thehighest activity
of 2 400 workers/5 min tookplace
at
sunrise,
at 6.02 h. This number was re-duced to 465 workers/5 min
only
1 h later(fig 8).
Some increase(750
workers/5min)
was noticed at 9.00
h,
butgenerally
lowvariable
activity
continued till the end of theday.
The lowestactivity
occurred between 14.00-16.00h,
andagain
aslight
increaseof 500-645 workers/5 min was noticed be- tween 17.00-18.00
h,
30 min before sun-set. At sunset at 18.26
h,
290 workers/5min
returned,
andflight stopped by
18.35 h.
Winter
dry honey
flow seasonDuring
the winterdry
season,investiga-
tions were conducted in 2 localities
only:
atKumasi and Accra. The
temperature (fig 4)
and RH differed in each
place.
InJanuary,
the
temperature
in Kumasi at 6 hdropped
to
20 °C,
and was the lowestduring
thewhole
investigation period.
At 12-14 h thetemperature
rose in bothplaces
to33 °C,
anddropped
in theevening
to 28-28.5 °C.In the deciduous forest zone in Kumasi the
amplitude
was muchhigher (13 °C)
thannear the ocean in Accra
(7 °C).
Later on inthe season, the
temperature
at 14 h rosein
February
to 36.5 °C. RH inAccra,
on Dec 27 was 100% at 6h;
itdropped
to64% at 13 h and rose to 91% at 18 h. In
Kumasi,
RH inJanuary
andFebruary
wasalso 100% at 6 h.
Sometimes, during
thecool
wind,
theharmattan,
thehumidity
condensed into
fog,
and waterdropped
from the leaves. At 13 h RH
dropped
to45-58%,
and at 18 h it rose to 52-60%.The winter
dry
season is thehoney
flowperiod.
The nectar flow starts inOctober,
when bee colonies may even
gain
5kg
per week.During
theinvestigation period
inAccra
(December),
Neem tree Azadirachta indica was one of the mostimportant
hon-ey
plants,
as waskapok
Ceibapentandra
in Kumasi
(January). During
theflight
in-vestigation period,
bee coloniesgained
inKumasi 1-2
kg
per week. InKumasi,
8brood combs were found in
colony
No 4, inthe 3-week check intervals from Dec 4 to Jan 15 and 7 combs on Feb 5. A similar number of brood combs was found in other colonies. It should be noted that the colo- nies were weaker in the second half of the
honey
flowperiod
than in the dearthperiod
in June.
It was
possible
to startcounting
beesreturning
to the hive in Accraduring
thewinter season
(Dec 27)
at 5.50 h when236 workers/5 min returned
(fig 9).
Themorning peak
of 865 workers/5 min oc-curred at 6.15
h,
10 min before sunrise.Flight activity
decreasedrapidly
till 7h,
whenonly
134 workers/5 min returned.Low
flight activity
continued till 14 h. After-noon
flight activity
started to increase at 15.00 h and reached apeak
of 1 210workers/5 min at 17.00 h. It was
already getting
dark at sunset, at 18.00h,
whenonly
230 workers/5 min landed on the front wall of the hive.By
18.20 h the cluster out- side the entrance had formed andonly
12workers/5 min landed on the front wall of the hive.
Two weeks
later,
thepatterns
offlight activity
for 2 consecutivedays,
Jan 12 and13 were similar in Kumasi. The averages
(fig 10)
show that themorning peak
of1 450 workers/5 min also occurred at 6.15 h. At 9.00 h
flight activity
almoststopped. However,
1 h later apeak
of1 082 workers/5 min was noticed. Low ac-
tivity
continuedthroughout
theday.
The af-ternoon
flight activity
started to increase at17.00 h and reached a
high peak
of 2 700 workers/5 min at sunsettime,
at 18.00 h.Flight stopped
at 18.30h,
about 30 min af-ter sunset. It was too dark to read
by
18.35 h. About 1 month later
(8 Feb),
thehighest morning flight activity
of 1 400workers/5 min
again
occurred at 6.15 h(fig 11). Between
8.00-16.00 hforaging
activi-ty
was low: 20-300 workers/5 min. An af- ternoonpeak
of 1 300 workers/5 min oc-curred at 18.00
h,
at sunset.At the end of December and
beginning
of
January,
theevening peaks
offlight
ac-tivity
in bothplaces (Accra
andKumasi)
were much
higher
than themorning
ones(figs 9, 10).
One monthlater,
themorning peak
washigher
than theevening
one(fig 11). Later
on in the season themorning peak
increased up to 2 400 workers/5 min and theevening
onedisappeared during
the
rainy
season(fig 5).
DISCUSSION
This
study
constitutes the firstreport
of thepattern
ofhoneybee flight activity
in differ- ent zones of the samecountry.
BothGary (1967)
and Fletcher(1978) reported flight activity
at dawn and dusk.However,
thephenomenon
that bees start tofly
and landin low
light intensity
not from/to the en-trance but from/to the front wall of the hive
was
previously
unknown.Compared
to themost
frequent
cone- orbell-shaped pattern
of
flight activity reported
for different Euro- pean and African bee races(Lengler,
1984;Mbaya,
1985; Lee etal,
1987; Ver-ma and
Dulta,
1986,1988),
or Africanized bees in Brazil(Kerr
etal, 1970)
thepattern
offlight activity
of A m adansonii in Ghanawas different. The
dry
seasonpattern
with theearly morning
and theevening peaks
was similar to that described
by Gary (1967)
for A mligustica
inirrigated
desert.This
suggests
thatflight activity
may some- timesdepend
more on the environmental conditions than on the race of the bees.Nevertheless,
differentpatterns
offlight
ac-tivity
have been recorded for different beeraces
foraging
in the same conditions(Kerr
et
al, 1970). Only
oneearly morning peak
of
flight activity
at 6 h was not recorded be- fore thepresent study.
CONCLUSIONS
The
pattern
offlight activity
in very differentzones but in the same season did not differ much.
However,
thepattern
differedgreat- ly during
different seasons.Only
anearly morning peak
occurredduring
therainy
dearth
period
at thebeginning
of the sum-mer
rainy
season. Tendays later,
themorning peak
had shifted to 9.00 h. This occurred in the deciduous forest zone aswell as in the northern savanna zone.
Probably
the bees learned that the nectar remained available later in theday
in therainy
seasoncompared
to thedry
season.Two
peaks
offoraging activity,
oneearly
inthe
morning
and the other late in the eve-ning
occurredduring
thehoney
flow winterdry
season. Theevening peak
offlight
ac-tivity
washighest
at thebeginning
of theseason, and one month later the
morning peak
washigher. Probably,
with theprogress of the
dry
season, more nectarwas available in the
morning
than in theevening,
due todrying during
theday.
For-aging activity during midday,
at the warmperiod
of theday
wasalways
low.One can propose the
following hypothe-
sis. African
honey
bees startsearching
fornectar
early
in themorning.
This results in theearly morning peak. Prolonged rainy
season
delays
themorning peak.
When lit-tle or no nectar is
available,
lowforaging activity
continues till theevening. During
the
dry honey
flow season, lowforaging
occurs
during
the hotperiod
of theday.
However,
in theevening,
when thetemper-
ature is lower and the
humidity higher,
an-other
peak
offoraging activity
occurs atsunset.
Résumé — Activité de vol diurne de l’abeille
africaine, Apis
mellifera adan-sonii,
au Ghana en diversesrégions
età diverses saisons. Il est
important
deconnaître l’activité de vol diurne des abeilles en divers lieux et diverses sai-
sons. Certains travaux
apicoles
doiventêtre effectués
lorsque
l’activité devol
estélevée,
d’autreslorsqu’elle
est faible. Uneforte corrélation a été trouvée entre l’activi- té de vol et la
propension
àpiquer
desabeilles africaines
(Woyke, 1989).
Les re-cherches ont été faites au Ghana dans 3
zones différentes : la savane de la côte Sud à Accra, la forêt de feuillus dans le Centre à Kumasi et la savane sèche du Nord à
Tamale, pendant
la saison sèche(décembre-février), période
demiellées,
etpendant
la saison despluies (juin-juillet), dépourvue
de miellées. On a déterminé l’activité de vol encomptant
durant 5 min le nombre d’ouvrières rentrant à la ruche à des intervalles de 30-60 minpendant
10j.
Tôt le matin et tard le soir les ouvrières
quittent
laruche,
pas par le trou de vol mais par laparoi
arrière. Pour une même saison l’activité de vol n’a pasbeaucoup
varié d’une
région
à l’autre. Par contre, la différence entre les saisons a été nette. Unseul
pic
à 6 h est observépendant
lapé-
riode de disette au début de la saison des
pluies (fig 5).
Dixjours plus tard,
lepic
d’activité matinale s’est
déplacé
à 9 h(fig 6),
que ce soit en forêt de feuillus ou dans la savane du Nord(fig 7).
Les abeilles ont vraisemblablementappris
que,pendant
lasaison des
pluies,
le nectar ne sèche pas aussi vite que durant la saison sèche. Enhiver, période
sèche et demiellées,
l’activi- té debutinage présente
2pics.
L’un a lieupeu de
temps après
le lever dusoleil,
entre 6 h et 6 h 15, l’autre peu de
temps
avant le
coucher,
entre 17 h et 18 h(fig 9).
Au début de la saison
sèche,
lepic
du soirest le
plus
fort(fig 10),
alorsqu’un
moisplus
tard c’est lepic
du matin(fig 11).
II estprobable qu’il
y aplus
de nectardisponible
le matin que le soir en raison du dessè- chement au cours de la
journée.
Apis
mellifera adansonii / activité de vol / climattropical / Afrique
Zusammenfassung —
Dietägliche Flug-
aktivität der afrikanischen
Honigbienen, Apis
melliferaadansonii,
zu verschiede-nen Jahreszeiten und in verschiedenen Zonen von Ghana. Es ist
wichtig,
dietäg-
liche
Flugaktivität
derHonigbienen
in un-terschiedlichen Gebieten während der ge- samten Saison zu kennen. Manche imker- liche
Eingriffe
sollten zur Zeit hoher Aktivi- tät und andere währendgeringer
Aktivitäterfolgen. Woyke (1989)
stellte eine enge Korrelation zwischenFlugaktivität
undStechverhalten bei Afrikanischen Bienen fest. Die
Untersuchungen
wurden in drei verschiedenen Zonen von Ghanadurchge-
führt: südliche Savannenzone an der Küste bei
Accra;
zentrale Laubwaldzone inKumasi;
nördliche Trockensavanne in Tamale. DieBeobachtungen
wurdensowohl während der trockenen Tracht-
periode (Dezember-Februar)
wie in dertrachtlosen
Regenzeit (Juni-Juli) durchge-
führt. Um die
Flugaktivität
zuerfassen,
wurde die Zahl der zum Volk heimkehren- denFlugbienen
an zehn verschiedenenTagen
den ganzenTag
über in Intervallenvon 30-60 Minuten fünf Minuten
lang
ge- zählt. Am frühenMorgen
undspäten
Abend
fliegen
die Bienen nicht vomFlug-
loch aus, sondern von der Stirnwand des Bienenstockes. Das Muster der
Flugaktivi-
tät in den verschiedenen Zonen war wäh- rend derselben Jahreszeit kaum verschie- den. Zwischen den Jahreszeiten
hingegen gab
es deutliche Unterschiede. Während der trachtlosen Zeit zuBeginn
der som-merlichen
Regenzeit gab
es nur einen ein-zigen Gipfel
um 6.00 h(Abb 5).
ZehnTage später
war derMorgengipfel
der Trachtak-tivität auf 9.00 h verschoben
(Abb 6).
Diesfand sowohl in der Laubwaldzone wie auch in der nördlichen Savannenzone statt
(Abb 7).
Wahrscheinlich lernten dieBienen,
daßder Nektar während der
Regenzeit
nicht soschnell vertrocknet wie während der Trockenzeit. Zwei
Gipfel
vonTrachtflügen
waren während der Tracht in der winterli- chen Trockenzeit zu beobachten. Einer fand
gleich
nachSonnenaufgang,
zwi-schen 6.00-6.15 h statt, der andere kurz
vor
Sonnenuntergang
zwischen 17.00-18.00 h
(Abb 9).
ZuBeginn
der Trocken- zeit war derAbendgipfel
derFlugaktivität
am höchsten
(Abb 10),
aber einen Monatspäter
war derMorgengipfel
höher(Abb 11).
Wahrscheinlich war amMorgen
wegen des Austrocknens
tagsüber
mehrNektar vorhanden als am Abend.
Apis
mellifera adansonii /Flugaktivität
/Tropenklima
/ AfrikaREFERENCES
Fletcher DJ (1978) The African bee, Apis mellif-
era adansonii, in Africa. Annu Rev Entomol 23, 151-171
Gary
NE (1967) Diurnal variations in the intensi- ty offlight
activity fromhoneybee
colonies.J Apic Res 6, 65-68
Kerr EW, Goncalves LS, Blotta LF, Maciel HB
(1970) Biologia comparada
entre as abelhasItalianas
(Apis
melliferaligustica)
Africanas(Apis
mellifera adansonii) e suas hibridas.I
Congr
BrasilApicult, Florianopolis,
151-185Lee ML, Choi SY, Cho YH (1987) Diurnal activi- ty of honeybees
(Apis mellifera)
at the hiveentrance. Korean
J Apic
2, 27-42 (in Korean) Lengler S (1984)Compartamento
delinhagens
de abelhas (Apis mellifera) quanto a sua ac- tividade de voo. Cien Cult 39, 1606-1608 Mbaya JSK (1985) The distribution of African
honeybees in
Kenya
and some aspects oftheir behaviour. Proc 3rd Int Conf Apic Trop Climates, Nairobi. Int Bee Res Assoc, 56-60 Silva M, De
Jong
D (1990) Diurnalflight
activityof Africanized and
European
honey bees.Apiacta
25, 78-80Szabo TJ (1980) Effect of weather factors on
honeybee flight activity and colony weight
gain. J Apic
Res 19, 164-171Verma LR, Dulta PC (1986)
Foraging
behaviourof
Apis
cerana indica andApis
mellifera inpollinating apple
flowers. J Apic Res 25, 197- 201Woyke
J (1989)Biology
and management of Af-rican honeybees
(Apis
melliferaadansonii)
inAfrica. XXXII Int