How to use Rosen’s normalised equilibrium to enforce a socially desirable Pareto efficient solution

(1)

HAL Id: hal-02822274

https://hal.inrae.fr/hal-02822274

Preprint submitted on 6 Jun 2020

HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access archive for the deposit and dissemination of sci- entific research documents, whether they are pub- lished or not. The documents may come from teaching and research institutions in France or abroad, or from public or private research centers.

L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non, émanant des établissements d’enseignement et de recherche français ou étrangers, des laboratoires publics ou privés.

How to use Rosen’s normalised equilibrium to enforce a socially desirable Pareto eﬀicient solution

Jacek B. Krawczyk, Mabel Tidball

To cite this version:

Jacek B. Krawczyk, Mabel Tidball. How to use Rosen’s normalised equilibrium to enforce a socially desirable Pareto eﬀicient solution. 2009. �hal-02822274�

(2)

« How to use Rosen’s normalised equilibrium to enforce a socially desirable

Pareto efficient solution »

Jacek B. KRAWCZYK

Mabel TIDBALL

DR n°2009-20

(3)

'(*)! +,)#.- /0#12$34 56*70 78 )%9:;<%

=?>A@CBEDGFIH7J3KL>NM;@COCPDQ RS>UT7BNVXW Y[Z0T\>AVV[]

^`_badcNegf<hAc

ikjml#nporq.sutrjwvxyqzsu{|rxL{sunpo*}Nsuo ~Xrsl%"x9v.jw(|rxL{.npvjwusjpjwq!{.gxL{Xlwn(orqz{.vx(suorsorx9l#np

ujkpnEndtkl#v.jwxL{j#t3zn(so{Cklwnp

j#{s{spjx(pjwo{.qw}sqq.ndlwsxLu3trjwqzsvxLrjL3ortrsEsutr|gx(

jpj#qnL!np|N{

|N{q2{gx{ypj#orjwv.xL{j{rj;l#nporq{vxLsorj#tx(np|ro{nL/{rjjd{j#v.ogxLsu{lwx(oj

lwn(

|E{jwtx(qx+x(v.j{nj# lwsujwo{q.npu|N{sunpo¡n(¢{.rjx(pjwo{.qw£Aznpso{|N{.susu{xEssq.xL{sunpo

vznprj#"¡¤n¥~jpjwv#}/pj#orjwvzsl¦xLu(}\x+x(v.j{nj# lwsujwo{q.npu|N{sunposq9ornL{x(oj#§C|rsusrvzs|r

ijqz|rppj#qz{{.rjv.jw(|rxL{.npvml¦x(ulw|rxL{j#q2x©¨¢xLq.Eªnpqzjwolwnp|

jwtdlwn(orqz{.vx(suoC{jw§C|rsusurv.su|r

«

n(vxG¬zpj#orjwv.x(suq.jwtN¨x(q.®jw§C|rsusrvzs|r,¯xLort®|rqzjwq{rjlwnp|

j#tEl#nporqz{.vx(suo{,°x((vx(or(j

y|r{s

sujwv+{.n±²npv.y|NxL{.jXxm{.rv.jwxL{¦}C|rortNjwv~Xrsl%{rjx(pj#o{q~Xs

x¦x³d´%µ%¶·¥¸¹´.³"¨¢xLq.

x(j(º¢o©j#§C|rsusrvzs|r»n(0{NsqXx(j±~Xs

npqzq.sNu l#npsorl#strjm~Xsu{.{.rjy+x(v.j{nj# lwsujwo{

q.n(|N{.snpo*7ikj2²nEl#|rqn(o©q.s{|gx{sn(orq!~Xrjwo3{.rjl#nporq{vxLso{q¢x(v.j2qxL{.|rvx{jwt3x(ort©j4Nx(suorj(}

|rortNjwvm~Xrsl%lwnpoNtrsu{.snporqmx xL{l%j#{~7jwjwox(oj#§C|rsusrvzs|r¼x(ortxx(vzj#{nq.n(|N{.snpo&suq

npq.qzsruj(yijsuu|rqz{.vxL{.jynp|rvb½goNtrsor(q2|Nq.soN"xInEtrj#²npvmxkµ%¶¥¶¾z³(¿ÁÀÂ(Ã[¿¶À

v.n(rj#"}?suo

~Xrsul%I½rv.qw£Nn(|N{

|E{qXtrj

jwoNtn(ojwx(l%In({NjwvXx(ort;~XNjwv.j±{.rj±np|N{

|N{!uj#pj#qXx(vzjbs

npv

{%xLoC{X²npv/{.rjmv.j#p|rx{npv#

Ä"ÅÆ*ÇÈÊÉLË1Ì(Í0Înp|

ujwtlwnpoNqz{v.x(so{.qwÏdpjworj#vx(usqzjwt¨¢xLq.jw§C|rsusrvzs|rÏp+x(v.j{nmj# l#sjwo{\q.n

|E{sn(o

ÐAÑbÒÍÊÎ/ÓE}Î!ÔE}ÊÕmÔ

ÖØ×1ÙÛÚÜÝÞÙàß/áâÙäã#åÞçæèÙäÜ²éXÝ4êNëåzìäìàÙàâîí4ÜÝâCïîëåìàìàÙäâîíÜ[Ý#âCïðåzñ&òpåzß4ìÛß4âLó

ô[õ

âæèÜ[ÙäÜ[ö¥Ü+ð+ß%ÜÙäÝ#âß4ìCó¥å÷åzÚçøîåzÞÚçøîååâ±ù1íÞÝâîÝ#úÙàåï¥ûEù1ümýUþEù\ïü±ÝâwÜÿLåzìäìàÙäåzÞzïÞßâÚØå

(4)

!rj2x(su nL+{.rsq

x

j#v!sq{~7n(²nput*suv.q{¦}E~7j±~/xLoC{X{.ny²npv.y|NxL{.j¢q.|E l#sj#oC{l#nportrs{sn(orqw}

|rortNjwv+~XNsl%x{~7nL

x¦pj#vl#nporl¦x¦(j!x(j~Xs{yl#np|

ujwtlwnporq{v.x(so{q+gx(qx(oyjw§C|rsusurv.su|r

xmx±ªXnpq.j#o

«

qzjwj! Á¯{.gxL{sq\x(uq.n2xmx(vzj#{.nLn

{sx(Eq.npu|N{sunpon(*xmlwj#o{vxLsqzjwt

v.n(rj#"

"

j#lwnportNup}7~j~/x(o{{nksuu|rqz{.vxL{.j,{rsuqvzjwqz|ru{ x(ogx(Eqzsorxq{dsqzjwtv.j¦xLusu²j;px(j

~Xrj#v.jm{~nlwnp

j#{s{spj

x¦pjwvzql#npo{vzsr|N{.j±{nx

|rrusl±pndnEtA

ikj7x(vzj\suo{jwvzjwq{jwtsomq.s{|gx{sn(orqw}îsom~Xrsul%xXv.j#p|rx{npv*~x(o{q{nlwnpo{.v.npl#np

j#{.su{.supj

x(pj#o{qq.n±{rxL{0{NjwsvUzn(so{l#v.jwxL{j#tj4E{.jwvzogx(s{yq.xL{suqz½gj#q\l#nporq{vxLso{q#!rjXlwnpoNqz{v.x(so{.q

l¦xLo;Ujs

npq.j#t,npo

npu|N{.snpo

«$#%'&(%

}djwsu{z{j#t,xlwu|rqz{.jwv\n(

|r

suqw}pqzjwj

#%'&(%

})+* Un(v

-,! 0npv±"{rj#v.x(pj#orjwv.xL{n(v.qw}?qzjwj

#%'&(%

}./ Á¯4}?npvbnpo3{.rjx(np|ro{±n(\qznpj

|rrsulpndndt

s10(jm{v.x(orq

npv{%xL{.snpol¦x

x(lws{"n(v¢rnpq

su{x(Uj#trqw}Ax¦(xLsxLrj±{n,xunElwx(

n

|rxL{.snpoA2!rj

²npvzj#v¢lwn(orlwj#v.ox3ÀA´43Â(Ãè¿65(´©j4d{jwvzogx(usu{p}~Xrsl%&oNjwjwtNqb{n;jyv.j#qz{.v.sl{j#t*ÏA{NjyxL{z{j#vbx(vzj

s

npq.j#tn(o"x¸g¶87¿ÁÃè¿65(´ j4E{.jwvzogx(s{;{rxL{Xgx(q!{nq.xL{suqzÁIx9jpj#1tNjwjwjwtorj#lwjwqzqx(vp

º¢uq.nr}

v.nprujwq0so(npudsoN¢lwn(

j#{.su{sunpo²n(v<xbq.lwx(v.l#j!v.jwqznp|rvzlwj!ysuortrj

jwoNtrjwo{\n

jwv

xL{.npv.q{gx{trj

j#ort;npoq.npjjw(sq.xL{sunpo

«

s90Lj

v.suLxL{.j!½gq.rj#v.jwo;n

j#vxL{.sor2npo;x±½gqzrjwv

npvso{.jwv.oNj#{7|rq.j#v.qunpppsuor±so{nxmq.jwvpj#vw}rqzjwj

#%'&(%

}:Ó! Á¯0lwx(o,j¢xLogx(udqzjwt,|Nq.soN2{.rjq.x(j

²vxLj~npv;0 x(q/²npv/{.rjmjd{j#v.ogxLsu{

v.npNjwqXx(ort {.d|Nq¢x(vzjmn(suo{jwvzjwq{{.n|rqw

ox(u0{rn(q.jl¦x(qzjwq{.rjmzn(so{mv.j#qz{vzsl{sn(orqxLv.js10(jw3{njq.xL{|rv.xL{j#t* !rsuq2s(C{

jjwl¦xL|rq.j9xLpjwo{q#£UsuortrsEsutr|gx(uu,n

{su,xL?q.npu|N{sunporqXsus{/{rjx(np|ro{¢nL<{rj

npqzsu{.supj

jd{.jwv.orx(s{p}Njwlwx(|rqzjborn({!j#s{.{.sor2orjwpxL{spj¢j4d{jwvzogx(usu{sql#npqz{.u(}EnpvUj#l¦x(|rqzj¢{Njblwnpod

{j#qz{.jwtv.j#q.np|rvzlwj#qx(v.j/qzl¦x(vzlwjL<¨n({.sl#j7{rxL{0sg{rj#v.j~x(q<xbqzx(l<0mnpoy{.rj/lwn(orqz{.vx(suoC{.qw}({.rjwvzj

~7np|rtjk¬orn

v.npNjw;²npvb{.rjv.jw(|rxL{.npvw9o{Nsq

x

jwv#}1~7j9~Xsu<x(q.qz|rj{.gxL{m{Nj

v.j#p|rxL{npvXsuqtNj¦x(usor~Xsu{.{.rj&¬zsuo{jwvzjwq{soNplwx(q.jn(0q.xL{|NvxL{.jwt3l#nporqz{.vx(suorqx(ort"~Xsuq.rj#q

{n=0Corn¥~ rn¥~ {nyx

r

n(vz{sunpo9{rjv.j#q

nporq.sursusu{y²n(v{.rj¢l#nporq{vxLso{q#£dq.xL{suqzèx(l{sunpo,xLnpoN

{NjxLpjwo{q#

ortrsEsutr|gx(Cuj#pj#q+n(rnp|E{

|N{.q

«

x(ortysuo

|N{.q%¯*{gxL{+pj#orjwv.xL{j\{rj7trjwqzsv.j#t9x(np|ro{+n(r{Nj

jd{.jwv.orx(s{lwx(o9Ujlwnp

|N{.jwtx(q<x¢x(vzj#{n±j lwsj#o{q.npu|N{sunpo{.n¢{rj/x(pjwo{.qw£znpsuo{0|N{.ss{

xEssqx{sn(o

v.n(rj#"2!rjv.j#p|rx{npvXsp{|rq.jx(o3xLv.rs{vxLvz ~7jws(C{?>A@

«CBED

î¯!{.n

gx(x(orl#jb{rj2x(pj#o{qw£Ê|N{.susu{²|rorl{sn(orqXnpv!q.j#j0>k{rxL{,xEsusuq.jwq7{rjmq.|N"

¤n¥~7j#pj#vw}Êpj#orjwvzsl¦xLu(}dx9x(vzj#{n9j lwsj#o{!q.npu|N{sunpo,suqornL{Xx(o;j#§d|Nssurv.su|r rj#orlwj±ornL{

q.j#uçjwoN²npvzlwsuorr}GFg´ÀAµ%´,n(

vznprj#,x{sl|rq.j±suoIx9lwnp

j{s{su(j¢j#oCdsuv.nporjwo{wij±q.|Nppjwq{

{Njvzjwp|rxL{n(v0l¦x(ulw|rxL{j#q\xªXnpq.j#ol#np|

ujwtEçlwnpoNqz{v.x(so{\jw§C|rsusurv.su|r

«

¨¢x(qz,orn(v.x(suq.jwtg¯}

q.j#j

#8%-&H%

}I! npvJ-,! }

«

n(vx¬pjworj#vx(usqzjwtr¨¢xLq.j#§C|rsusrvzs|r`x(q?{Nsq?{

jn(Njw§C|rsusrvzs|r suq

l¦xLj#tsuo

#8%-&(%

}(/K ¯+xLorty|rqzjwq{.rjl#np|

ujwtEçlwnporq{v.x(so{°1xLpvx(oNpj7|ru{.s

usjwvU{n¢²npvzy|rxL{j

x{.rv.jwxL{¦}r|Nortrjwv7~Xrsl% {Nj±x(pj#oC{.q~Xsu

x¦xI³d´%µ%¶·î¸¹´.³&¨¢xLq. x(j(º¢o jw§C|rsusurv.su|r

n(+{rsuq!x(jm~Xsu

npqzq.suru l#npsoNlwstNjb~Xsu{I{Njtrj#q.suv.jwt"xLv.j#{.nLj lwsj#o{¢qznp|N{.snpoA\çq.nr}

{Nj+x(v.j{nq.npu|N{sunpo;~XsuAj2x(l%rsjpj#t3x(qx¨¢x(qz"j#§C|rsusrvzs|r rjwoNlwj2q.jwj#oN²npv.l#sorN

o3{rj

x

jwvw}U~jyj4Nx(suorj(}U|rortrj#vb~Xrsl%&l#nportrs{sunporqbx,xL{.l%3j#{~7jwjwo{Nnpq.j{~7n

q.n(|N{.snporqsuq

npq.qzsruj(!Nsq\sq{rjsuorjXn(?v.j#q.jwx(v.l% q{%x(v{jwtsoLMN ¤jwvzj(}C~jb(jworj#vx(usq.j

{Njv.j#q.|r{q0n(N{%x(suorjwtso2{rjx(Un¥(j

x

jwv1²npvxLoyjwodsvznporjwo{%x(

vznprj#"ijsu|rq{v.xL{j

np|rv ½goNtrsor(q"|rqzsorxndtrjw¢²n(v"x µ%¶¥¶¾z³(¿ÁÀÂ(Ã[¿¶À¡¸¾%¶POw¹´RQ so ~Xrsl%`½gv.qw£!np|E{

|N{.q

trj

j#ort"n(ojwx(l%In({NjwvXx(ort ~Xrj#v.j±{Nj±np|N{

|N{XjpjwuqXx(v.j±su

npv{%x(o{²n(v{rj±vzjwp|NxL{.npvw

!rjndtrjwl#nporq.sutrjwvzjwtysuo2{.rsq

x

j#v+suq1tNj#{j#v.sorsuqz{.slx(ortsoN²n(v.xL{sunpo±sq¬zqEj#{z

v.sulwr1ikjorn({.sl#j/{gxL{\qzrnp|rut,x(on(U{rj#q.jx(q.qz|r

{sunporqUjXornL{7q.xL{suqz½gj#t*}C{rjXv.j#p|rxL{npv

sp{x(qzq.s(o

jwogx({;²|rorl{sunporqX{gxL{X~Xsu

vznp

{{.rjx(pjwo{.q{.n

vznEtr|Nlwj2jd{j#v.ogx(usu{

x(np|ro{q7{gxL{xLv.jbtrsTSAj#v.j#oC{!²vznp j

j#l#{.jwt©{rj±vzjwp|rxL{n(v!x(ort suo pjworj#vx(Aorn({!n

{s

(5)

jwlwn(jysuortrsEsutr|gx(uuIn

{sx([±¤n¥~7j#pj#vw}1q.|rl%{v.x(trsuor

vznprj# qz|rv

x(q.qzjwqm{rj9qzlwn

j

n(1{rsuq

x jwv#

i gxL{²npunî~Xq2sqx©rvzsj!np|N{.soNjnL!~XgxL{{.rsq

x

jwvlwnpo{x(sorq#©o " jwl#{.snpoUKE}~7j

trj#q.lwvzsjx;ndtrjwso3~Xrsul%{~7nL½gv. n(|N{

|E{q2x(v.j9l#nEn(v.trsuogxL{j#t&x;v.j#p|rx{npv#!rsuq

n({spjwqnp|rv9q.jwx(v.l%¡²npv9x&x

j#{~7jwjwo®xL{.jwvznLj l#sj#oC{qznp|E{sn(orq9x(ort¡l#np

j#{.su{.supj

jw§C|rsusurv.sxN*o " jwl#{.snpoNqVXx(oNt=Mr}¥~7j7tNj#pj#n

{Nj\qznp|E{sn(o2l#nporl#j

{.q1²npv*{.rjlwndnpv.tNsogxL{.snpo

vznprj#xLortIv.j#dsuq.jb{Nj±,xL{.rjwxL{.slwq\orj#jwtrj#t²npv7{rj±|roNs§C|rjwoNjwq.qn(j#§d|Nssurv.su|r+ij

trjpjwun

{rj qz|N lwsujwo{lwnpoNtrsu{.snporq2²npv{.rj;x

£qyjEsq{j#orlwjIso

"

jwl#{.snpoW*dij x

N

u

{Njwq.jlwnportNsu{sunporqX{n,{.rjn({.suLxL{suorjNx(

jso " jwl{sn(o&ÓN?!NjylwnpoNlw|Ntrsorv.j#,x(v;0Cq

q.|Nx(v.suq.j0n(|rv*½gortrsuorpq#}î~XNsl%2sorl#|rtrj0xXqznEl#snLçjwl#npornpsl+so{j#v

vzj#{%x{sn(o±n(E{.rj<v.j#q.|r{q#

X Y ZJ[\]_^ `a Lbc]dbef

!rj±xL{NjwxL{sulwqnL+{.rj±ndtrj#Utrj#q.l#v.sjwtjwn¥~`sq7{%xP0LjwoI²v.npg! !Nj±so{j#v

vzj#{%xî

{sunporqXx(oNt"suoC{.|rsu{.snpoNq/x(vzj2n(|rv.q#

hji;k

^ lnmoeprq

Înporqzstrj#v{~7nblwnp

j#{s{spj7x(pjwo{.q~Xrnpqzj!np|N{

|N{q<xLv.jJs)tvu

B

x(oNtws(xyu

B

}(v.jwq

j#l#{.supj#u(

z©x(suo{%x(suorsorm{Nj±np|N{

|N{q/suqj4

jwoNq.su(j(Ïg{Njblwnpq{/²|rorl{sunpo;n({Nj¢½gv.q{Xx(pj#o{!sq s xt

K

xLort

s xx

n(+{.rjmq.j#lwnportA

!rj3vzj#pj#oC|rjn(±{rj½gv.q{Ix(pj#o{ l¦x(o®nporu j©l#v.j¦x{jwt |Nq.soNk{rj©q.jwl#nport x((jwo{¦£q

np|N{

|N{

«

¸g¶87¿ÁÃè¿65(´Ijd{.jwv.orx(s{r¯Xx(ortA}suo{.rsql¦xLq.j(}su{j#§d|rx(qs)t{s(x¥!¤n¥~7j#(jwvw}{rjpndnEtrq

vznEtr|Nlwjwty{rjXqzjwlwn(ort;x((jwo{¬zq.|ISUjwvz2~XNjwo;xLv.jX|N{susuq.jwt99{.rj!½gv.q{xLpjwo{

«

ÀA´43Â(Ãè¿65(´

jd{.jwv.orx(s{r¯qznr}r{Nj2vzj#(jwoC|rjnL+{.rjmq.jwl#nport©x(pjwo{sqe|s)t{s(x¥

o©xLrq.j#orlwj2n(0vzjwp|NxL{.snpo*}C{Nj2|Nors§C|rjmjw§C|rsusurv.su|r»nL+{.rj2¨¢x(qzEÎnp|Nv.orn({xLj

,xî

}~

N

t «

sU¯ |

K s x t

s)t{s(x

,xî

}R

N

x «

sU¯ |s

xx

|Us)t{s(x

t «

sU¯ s)tvu

B

x «

sU¯ s(x_u

B

-

«

¥¯

¬

x¦pjwtN,x(npory{.rj2x(pj#oC{.qXsq

«CB

}B

¯4

¤n¥~7j#pj#vw}!x(so{x(sorsuor3qznpj

npqzsu{spjIlwn(yrsorxL{sunpon(¢j#(jwuqas)tyx(orts(x,x¦j

s

npvz{x(o{²n(v{Njv.j#p|rxL{npv#cz"xL{rj#,x{slwx(p}r{.rjvzjwp|rxL{n(vx¦~x(o{b{.rjnp|E{

|N{.q

{nq.xL{suqzÁ «

sU¯s)t

s(xJ|u

B2 «

K(¯

!rv.n(|rprnp|E{{.rsq

x

j#vw}g~Xrjwo

(

«

sU¯

D(

D

K9x(vzjmorn({j

uslws{,trj½gorj#t&x(qXso

«

¥¯

{Nj#;~XsuAjmx(qzq.|rjwtlwnpo{.soC|rnp|rqXsuoIx(Ax(v.p|Nj#oC{.qXx(ortIlwn(orl¦x¦pj2sos

!rjmlwnpn(o

(6)

lwn(orqz{.vx(suoC{

«{

¯~XsuU{NjwoUj2x(qzq.|rjwtq.|rl%{gx{{.rjmlwnpoNqz{v.x(so{Xqzj#{

sL@Lg

«

s)t

D

s(x4¯Ís)tvu BED

s(x

«

sU¯ju BID

«

sU¯ju

BE «

p¯

sq!l#npopj4A}lwunpq.j#t©xLortIUnp|Nortrjwt"q.|rNq.j#{n(+ª x

!rj

vznprj# nLXrn¥~ {.n&jwo{sulwj,{.rj x((jwo{qy{.n3qxL{.sqÁkl#nporqz{.vx(suo{

«

Kp¯mUn(sq2trn¥~Xo

so{.n{~7nq.|r

v.nprujwqwÍ

xN!i gx{qzrnp|rutIUj±{Nj2uj#(jwq!nLs)t/x(orts(x

*!i gx{qzrnp|rut {rjmv.j#p|rxL{npvtrn{.nsortr|Nlwj±{rj

x¦pjwvzq!{nl%rnEn(q.j±{rj#q.j2jpjwuq<

v.suj r(}d{.rjj#(jwuq.s)tx(ortas(x/l¦x(ojj#qz{%xLrsuq.rj#t;x(q\x+x(v.j{n2j# lwsujwo{/qznp|E{sn(oxLort

s

ujwjwo{j#t x(q!ªXnpq.j#o

«

¨¢xLq.Iornpvz,x(usqzjwtÊ¯<jw§C|rsusNv.s|N"1o {rj±vzjwqz{XnL1{.rsq

x jwv/~7j

qz{.|rtN{rj,xL{.rjwxL{.sl¦xLl#nportrs{sunporq{gxL{

t

«{

¯4}

x

«¡

¯\x(ort

«{

¯\oNjwjwt;{.nyqx{sqÁ²n(v7{Nj

xLv.j#{.n,xLort©ªXnpqzjwoq.npu|N{sunporq{.nj4Nsuqz{x(oNt"l#npsorl#strjL

hji¢h £¥¤

c¦pe(§beHp*crfc¦¨{m

¤ a f ¤ o¨

¤

cH©e¨çcH¨{m

¤ a

1n,²nEl#|rqxL{.{.jwo{sunpo"~7jyq.|Nppjwq{¢{.gxL{¢{.rjyxLUn¥pj,x{rj#,xL{.slwx(

vznprj#l¦x(o3rx¥(j{Nj

²npun¥~Xsorq.ndlwsnjwl#npornpslnpv.supsoA

Înporqzstrj#v±x;vx(suorj#{~7npvª0©nî~XoNjwt&&x

|rrsul½gvz xLortx

vzsuLxL{j2½gv.¼v.j#q

nporqzsruj

²npv!vznpusoryq{ndl<0 x(ortI{v.x(orq

npv{%xL{.snpoA

°?j#{s)t!j±{rj±{n(orogx(pjmn(1{Njpndndtrq/{v.x(orq

npv{jwtI{Nv.np|r({.rjmorj#{~7npvª0ÊÏj{2s(x¢j

{Nj!jwoN({9n(Ê{.rj/{v.x(l<0Cq\n¥~Xorj#ty{.rj/{v.x(l<0Cqw£n¥~Xorj#vw!rjXvzj#pj#oC|rjnL{.rj/{v.x(orq

npv{%x

{sunpo ½gv.»sq

vzn

n(vz{sunpogx(Ê{n{Njm{.nporogxLpjmx(ortI{n9{Njm{.vx(l<0Cq#£ujworL{«:t{s)t¬s(x¥

ox(rqzjworl#j/n(x¢trsuq.l#np|ro{

vzsl#j7²npv+q.|

jwvØxLv.pj{v.x(sorq#}

jwvzgx

q0tN|rj7{.n±x(oysu

jwv²jwl#{

qz{xL{jn(\{Nj{.vx(l<0Cqw}+x v.jwx(q.nporx(rjx

N

v.n¦EsxL{sunpo&n(\{rjl#npqz{m²|rorl{sunpo{.n {rj9{v.x(orqØ

npvz{xL{sunpo½rv. ,x¦j|

>t{s

xt

K

Íy{.rj,npvzj(nEndtrqm{n©{.vx(orq

n(vz{¦}1{rjn(v.jgx(v.tE~/x(vzj

orj#jwtrqX{nj2x(suoC{x(soNjwt*

oIrv.suj#Ø}E{.rj±n

jwv.xL{npvn({rj±vznpusor2qz{.nEl<0gx(q/Lx(v.sx(ruj¢v.jpj#od|Nj=«:t¢s)t{s(xx(oNtl#npqz{.q

|

>t{s xt

K

~Xrnpqzjl#npyrsuogxL{sunpoIx

r

v.n¦EsxL{j#q/{rj±½gvz"£q v.nL½r{

t «

sU¯

!rj

|rrusl\½gv. n

j#vxL{.sor{rj/{.vx(l<0Cq<sq

x(styx¢½NEjwtx(n(|ro{¦}(~Xrsul%sq0orn(v.x(suq.jwt

{n=®wj#v.nr!rjlwnpq{q/nL?,xLso{%x(suorsoNb{rj{vxLl<0dqxL{7j#(jw(s(x!sq«Hxªs)t{s(x

>xªs xx «

~Xrjwvzj¢{Nj

½gvzqz{±{j#v. sqbn({sLxL{j#t3©{Nj9trjwq{v.|Nl#{sunpol¦x(|Nq.jwt3{n(orogx(pj=s)t.¯¤jwoNlwj

x «

sU¯?

|y>rx¯s

xx

|°«Hxªs)t{s(x¥

gnpvqznEl#sx(Êv.jwx(q.n(orqw}d{rjb(nî(jwvzorj#o{/~/xLoC{.q/{v.x(orq

npv{%xL{.snpox(l#{.sudsu{a±Ht¢s)t

±¬xªs(x/{.n

jxLUn¥pjmuj#pj#r² !rsq!lwx(o"j±~Xv.s{.{j#ox(q2±(t$s)t

±Ex;s(xJ|W² u B

!rjIx(n¥pj

vzn¥Esutrjwqn({.suLxL{.snpo&²npvndtrjw

«

î¯}

«

Kp¯}sok~Xrsul%>t³>x³«:t

«Hxv´±Htµ±Exv¶² ·p

¸ ¹ º] _be[»

¤j#v.jL}Ê~7j

v.n

npq.j±{.gxL{¢x+x(v.j{nj# lwsujwo{bqznp|N{.snpo lwx(o©j2v.j¦xLsqzjwtx(qxl#np|

ujwtlwnpod

qz{.vx(suo{qXjw§C|rsusNv.s|N"

(7)

¼2i;k ½ ¤ ¤

ij~Xsu?jwq{%x(rusqz&xqznp|N{.snpoI{n,q.|r

v.nprujw

«

xEÛ¯4}

xLpjMºÀ

%Á#%

}Ul#np

|N{j2~XgxL{bn(|N{

|E{

jpj#q!{rjmvzjwp|rxL{n(v/,x¦~/x(o{{rj2x((jwo{q!{n

vznEtN|rlwjL

Înporqzstrj#vndtrjw

«

î¯}

«

Kp¯

!rjv.j#p|rx{npvsq¢{

sul¦x(uuso{j#v.j#qz{j#tsuox x(vzj#{.nj lwsj#o{mq.npu|N{sunpo¶ÂsÃÅÄPÂs)t D Âs(x<Æ

À

%Á#%

}rqz|rl%"{.gxL{

s

(

«

s)t D Âs(x4¯jÇ

(

« Âs)t

D Âs(x¯{rj#o

)È¥

«

s)t D Âs(x¯jÉ

È¥

« Âs)t D Âs(x%¯

D K «

M¯

ç_>·@

«ÊBID

î¯±x(ort

t «

s)t D

¯mx(ort

t

«{9D

s(x¯mx(v.jlwn(orl¦x¦pjL}trs1SUjwvzjwo{sx(rjx(oNtÃsµ@

{Njwo

Â

s Ä s)tÂ

D Âs(x Æ `x(v.\x

}ËÌ

N>

t «

sU¯

« _|U>0¯

x «

sU¯

«

*(¯

1nyqz{.v.jwqzq{rxL{ÍÂstrj

j#ortrq/n(o>~7j~Xsug~Xv.s{jÂs «

>0¯

Ä Âs)t

«

>0¯

D Âs(x

«

>0¯

Æ

¨n({sulwjX{gx{{Nj

xLv.pj#vy>\}g{rj2x(vzpjwv!{.rj

x¦(nPSknL{Nj½gvzqz{

x¦pj#vw/ijlwx(o©q.x¥I{.gxL{?> suqx,xLv.psuogx(

vx{jmn(+q.|rrq{s{|N{.snpoIj#{~7jwjwo{rj±{~7n

x¦pjwvzqw£

x¦(nPSAq#

ç{rj#v.j9sq¢orn

x(v{sulw|rx(v¢vzj¦x(qznpo3²npv¢{.rjyv.j#p|rxL{npv{n

v.j#²j#v±nporjyq

j#lws½glyLx(|rjn(

>7}Eq.npdsor{.rj¢²npun¥~XsoN

vznprujw ~Xstrj#su(jwv\{rjI¬Uj#qz{ÎÂ>x(ort;{NjbUj#qz{Xnp|E{

|N{

x(sv

Ä Âs)t

« Â>+¯

D Âs(x

« Â>¯ Æ

Â

>Ï6xLv.x

ÐPË!ÑÓÒªÔ tCÕ

>

« Âs)t

«

>0¯

D Âs(x

«

>¯.¯

«

|>0¯

« Âs)t

«

>0¯

D Âs(x

«

>0¯.¯

«

Óp¯

o`{.rsq

x

jwv;~7jxLq.q.|Nj&{rxL{;{Njvzjwp|NxL{.npv,suq so{j#v.jwq{j#t6ornL{InporusogÂ> xLort

{Njl#npv.vzjwq

nportNsornp|N{

|N{qx(ort

x¦pn!SAqr|N{¢x(qznso {rjm²|ru?x(v.v.x¦In(<+x(v.j{nj# lwsujwo{

q.n(|N{.snporq Ä s)tÂ

«

>0¯

D Âs(x

«

>¯ Æ x(ortI{rjmlwn(v.v.j#q

nportrsuor

x¦pnPSUq

(

« Âs)t

«

>¯

D Âs(x

«

>0¯z¯

D¦

D

KE

¼2i¢h Ö

mJ©e§eq{pro hm

¤

adcNegf.¨

¤

cNa×pØ_©e¨;q¡¨_be(¨f

ªXnpq.j#oµN 7so{vznEtr|Nlwjwt µ%¶·î¸¹´.³µ%¶ÀI7Ãè¾zÂ(¿ÁÀgÃÙ7I´ªÚw·d¿Á¹¿ÊOw¾4¿Á·EQ

«

Î!ÎjÛ\¯}x(qznÜ0Corn¥~Xox(qw3d´ÀHÝ

´¾zÂ(¹¿97¥´.³Þ±ÂN7<F®´ªÚw·d¿Á¹¿ÊOw¾4¿Á·EQ

«

qzjwj

#%'&(%

}c-! !n(v8KN Á¯²n(vyx(jwqy~Xs{lwn(orqz{.vx(suoC{.q9so{Nj

lwn(yrsoNjwt¡qz{.vxL{.jw(¡q

x(lwjIn(bx(x(pj#oC{.qw oqz|rl%®px(j#qw}{rjIvzjwp|rxL{n(vyq.j#j0Cq;x&q.n

|E{sn(o{rxL{ylwx(oUj,x(trn

{jwtlwnp

j#{s{spj

x¦pj#v.q9x(oNtp|gx(v.x(o{jwj#qylwn(

uj#{.snpon(

lwn(orqz{.vx(suoC{.q<{gxL{tNj

jwortnpo9{rjx(l{sn(orq<|rortrj#vz{xP0(j#o,x(Nx(pj#oC{.qwgnpv<Nsqz{.npvzn({rsuq

q.n(|N{.snpo l#nporlwj

{¢x(ortIjNx(

j#qXn(|Nq.j2q.jwjº/8! [}r-M! }ß*N [}rßàN x(ortá+K

ikj~Xsu0j

unpsu{±{.rj,Î!ÎjÛ

npusu{sulwnLçjwl#npornpslx

r

j¦x([âborl#j{.rjv.jw(|rxL{.npv±jwq{%x(d

suq.rj#q<xbtrj#q.svzjwtÎ!ÎjÛ

«

j

xLsorj#t9Uj#n¥~¯}p{.rj/jw§C|rsusurv.su|rSs

j#j#oC{xL{sunpo2sq0q{vxLsp{z

²npv~/x(vzt*r!rj7j#§C|rsusrvzs|räãmx(v.|rqzE{ã±|rNoE¢1|rl<0(j#vy|Nu{s

sujwvzq*x(qzq.ndlwsx{jwt±~Xs{m{rjAznpsuoC{

lwn(orqz{.vx(suoC{.q¢orj#jwt3{.n;Uj|rq.j#tx(q

jworx(u{I{%xî©v.xL{j#q²npvX{Njlwn(orqz{.vx(suoC{.qw£Esunpx{sn(o"xLort

{Nj

x¦pj#v.qXgx¦pj±{nx(un¥~ ²npv/{Njwq.j

jwogxLu{sujwq/suo {rj#sv

x¦pn!SAq#!Njwo"{.rj

x¥(jwvzqX~Xsu

¬

x¦Ex³d´%µ%¶·¥¸¹´.³x(jb~Xrnpqzjmq.npu|N{sunpoIsq/{Nj2tNjwq.suv.j#t"j#§d|Nssurv.su|r

ã±orn¥~XjwtNpjb{gx{XxÎ!ÎjÛ®jEsuqz{qXxLort sqb·dÀg¿ÊÚw·g´ sqlwv.|NlwsxLU²npv\{rjmx(n¥pj±j#oC{.sl#jwjwo{

jwl%gx(oNsq. ç{;qz|N lwjwq;{.nkq.x¥ {rxL{~Xs{rn(|N{{.rj©j#§C|rsusrvzs|r |Nors§C|rj#orjwqzqw}X{rj{%x

jSUjwl{spjwoNjwq.qlwnp|Nt&orn({mjjwq{%x(rusqzrjwt*y¤n¥~jpj#vw}suo&pjwoNjwvxL}*{Njwv.jsuq±x

j{rnpv.x;n(

jw§C|rsusurv.sx~Xrjwoå¦¶¿ÁÀgÃmx(l#{.snpoNq!n(+{.rj

x¦(jwv.qx(vzj±v.jwq{vzsl#{.jwt*

ªn(q.jwo×N \x(un¥~Xqb²npvmx trsqzlwvzssogxL{.npvz{vzj¦xL{.j#o{mn(

x¦pjwvzq±{rvznp|rp{rjsuoC{.v.nL

tr|rl{sunpo¡n(æ´¿T3NFdÃÙ7Uç

Ç

BIDH

è

D

K}<~Xsu{.¡~XNsl%{rj vzjwp|NxL{.npvyl¦xLox

r

vxLsq.j jwx(l%

(8)

x(pj#o{¦£q

x¦(nPS }g²v.npxdsuj#~

npsuoC{XnL{Nj2l#npy|rors{r¯4Jâ±oI{Nj2nL{rj#vrx(ort*}g{Nj

~7jws(C{.qNjw

lwn(oC{.v.np/~XNsl%®j#§C|rsusrvzs|r sqjwq{%x(NsqzrjwtAA!rsuqsuq9q.nUj#l¦x(|rqzj(}/(supj#o

q.|E l#sj#oC{¢lwnpoNl¦x¦dsu{n(0{.rj

x¦(nPSAq#}AxLo©jw§C|rsusurv.su|r{rxL{¢l#npv.vzjwq

npoNtrq{.n;x

x(vz{.slw|Nx(v

çÏé'ç!t

D

çxª /sqy|roNs§C|rj(

«

ij orn({sulwj,{.gxL{npoNj n(X{rj# x¥kUj;{.rjIxLv.j#{.nj# lwsujwo{

q.n(|N{.snpo Ä s)tÂ

«

>¯

D Âs(x

«

>0¯ Æ Û¯

!rj;x(sov.n(jn(/{Nj,~j#spNqsolwnpo{.v.npusoNI{.rj x((jwo{q#£+jwgx¦dsn(|rvsuq2{.gxL{{.rj#

l¦xLondtrsÁ3{rjÍãmx(v.|rqzE{ã±|rNoE¢1|rl<0(j#v9y|r{s

sj#v.qmx(oNtx(tz|rq{{.rj{xvxL{.jwqyxLnpoN

x¥(jwvzq0{nmjwo{sulwj/{.rjw {nml%rndnpq.jXx(l{sunporq{.gxL{jwx(ty{nmxbtNjwq.suv.j#tj#§d|Nssurv.su|r np|N{.lwnpj(

jwun¥~~j\~Xsuv.j#dsuj#~{Nj7xL{NjwxL{sulwqn(ÊÎ!ÎjÛx(ortsu{.q1su

jwjwo{xL{sunpo*}¥soNlw|Ntrsor

{Nj2|Nors§C|rj#orjwqzq¢lwn(ortrsu{.snpoNqwÏE²n(v!trj#{x(suq!q.jwjº/8! [}r-M! ?npv=ßà

ê ëäìÜ»Vbebîí ï LbeLbe»»Wð[]beé»Ví»

beï ]\.ñ

ij3~Xsx(trn

{ {rj&usu{.jwvx{|rvzj©v.j#q.|r{q;{.n¡{.rj3{~7nL

jwvzq.npo x(j

«

î¯~Xsu{. nporjznpsuoC{

lwn(orqz{.vx(suoC{

«

Kp¯gnpv{.rj

v.ndn(²qXq.j#jº8N

ò i;k £¥¤

creHmoó©bhAcIm7e¦ô¼eHprl f<eHõXa

!rj2q.npu|N{sunpo;{nxLj

«

î¯7~Xsu{.I{.rjznpso{Xl#nporqz{.vx(suo{

«

Kp¯lwx(o"j±~Xv.s{.{j#ox(q

sGöJ6jw§C|rsuT÷{øÙù

}úû

ø

ËÌ

t « sU¯

D x «

sU¯

D «

Ô(¯

~Xrsul%"j¦x(oNqX{.gxL{

H

«s ö ¯ D¯

D

K9q.xL{suqzÁ

(

«

sGö4¯ ,x

÷{øÙù

} úû

ø

ËÌ

(

«Ùü

¡ý

sGö È¥

¯

D_

·

D K «

,p¯

~Xrj#v.j

ü

ªý

s

È¥

«Êü

D s È¥

¯!trj#orn({j#qbxlwnpujwl{sunpoIn(<x(l{sunporq!~Xrjwo"{rj

ç{.©xLpjwo{I¬Ø{v.sujwqz

ü

~XNsjb{.rjmn({Njwvx(pj#oC{suq

x¦dsorws È¥

D¯

D

Kd

º/{s

ö

orn

x¥(jwv;lwx(o s

vznî(j"{.rjwsuv,n¥~Xo

x¦pnPSGC xk|rorsuxL{.jwv.x(l%rx(orpj3suo rsuq

«

n(vyrjwv¯qz{.vxL{.jw((}~XNsl%0(j#j

q9{Nj lwnpyNsorj#tpjwl{npvsuoá þª x

opj#orjwv.x(}<{Nj

qz{.vxL{.jw(qzj#{ sqx(q.qz|rjwtx©l#npopj4A}<l#npqzjwtxLortknp|rortNjwtqz|rrq.j{9n(!ª x

xLortÃ

« s)t

D

s(x4¯IÍ.s)tvu BID

s(x?u BED

s)t

s(x?u´²

}Êx(qXso

«

¯4

ÿ xLj

«

Ôp¯7qzgx(UUj±lwx(ujwtIx"µ%¶·¥¸¹´.³Iµ%¶ÀI7Ãè¾.Â(¿ÁÀgÃ67_3ÂPQ,´

«

xyx9ªXnpq.j#o*}rq.j#jº8N Á¯4!rj

µ%¶·¥¸¹¿ÁÀ¬3vzj#²j#v.qb{n{rjyèx(l{¢{.gxL{±npoNj

x¦(jwvw£qmx(l{sn(o&x!SUjwl#{.qb~XgxL{b{.rjyn({.rjwv

x¦pj#v.q#£

x(l{sn(orq/l¦xLoj(<o {.rj±q

jwl#sx(*lwx(q.j±~Xrj#v.jeg´ t x À

%Á#%

}rj¦xLl%

x¦pj#vw£qxLl#{sunpo;suq

soNtrsudstN|gx(lwnporq{v.x(sorj#t*}N{.rjmx(j±sq!qxLst {ngx¦pj·dÀAµ%¶·î¸¹´.³l#nporq{vxLso{q#

ç0jwx(l%

x¥(nPS²|rorl{sn(o

H

sq!y|Nu{s

sujwt;;~7jwsup{_ç

Ç B

sGö

«

çp¯ jw§C|rs÷{øÙù

úûËÌ

ç!t

t «

sU¯

D

çx

x «

sU¯

ÍD «

àp¯

~Xrj#v.jç -ç!t

D

çx¯ @ª x

_âb|rvx(s:suq{.n,j4rxLsuorj±~XrjwoLs

ö «

çp¯/l¦xLo3,x{l%äÂs «

>0¯/²npvx

pspjwoÜ>U@

«ÊBID

î¯

(9)

ò

i¢h ¤ ¤

ij0Corn¥~²vznpn/8N

t

{.gxL{1x(o2jw§C|rsusurv.su|r6j4Esqz{.q1x(ort2sq|rorsu§d|Nj\sE{.rjx(j<sq\³(¿èÂ83d¶ÀÂ(¹Á¹

7Ãè¾¿µÃè¹ µ%¶ÀAµ.ÂP5(´

«

¯

!rj!jwl#npornpsl\so{.jwv

v.j#{xL{sunponL

sq§C|rs{j7q.s

uj(1º®x(j{gxL{0sq

}LsuqnpoNj

sob~XNsl%mj¦x(l%

x¥(jwvgx(q?npvzj0lwnpo{.v.nppn¥(jwvrsq?n¥~Xo

x¦pn!S9{gx(o±{.rj<n({Njwv

x¥(jwvzq1rx¥(j

n¥pj#v±su{¦e!Nsq±sqbx,trjwqzsvzjwt*}x(oNt&vxL{.rjwv±l#npnpo*}Ê²j¦x{|rvzj9n(\,x(o"jwl#npornpslndtrjwuqw

«

¬q.nEn({.rC¯px(j,sq

suX{.rj q.nLçl¦x(uj#t

q.j#|rtrnL¤j#q.q.sx(o

«À

%Á#%

px(l#nprsxLonL

qzjw|rtNnLpv.x(trsujwo{¦}q.j#j

#8%-&H%

}J/8! <npvº/

B

¯¢²npvb{Nsq±pspjwox(j9sq±oNjwxL{.su(j

trj½gorsu{.j(

ÅCÈÊÉÅ 4ÀÂ3ÂPQ,´æ<¿ÁÃ6F·EÀAµ%¶·¥¸¹´.³&µ%¶ÀI7Ãè¾zÂ(¿ÁÀgÃÙ7 !¿!yÃ6Fg´2å¦¶¿ÁÀgÃ¸NÂ" C¶$#%!4·EÀAµÃè¿¶À

& «s D

çp¯±¿97Õ " Î%!¦¶¾c7¥¶NQ,´çwÇ

B

Ã6Fg´À&ÃÙFg´¾´9´('p¿97Ã67Â,·EÀg¿ÊÚw·g´eÞ±ÂN7<F3´ªÚw·E¿Á¹¿ÊOw¾4¿Á·¬Q*)

i rjwo{Nj9lwnporq{v.x(so{qmxLv.j"µ%¶·¥¸¹´.³(}A{Njwv.jxLv.j9orn qz|rl%(|gx(vxLoC{.jwj#qw}1x(ortx;q

jwl#sx(

{

jmn(jw§C|rsusNv.s|N |rqz{j2tNj#½gorj#t*

gnpv!{gxL{

|Nv

npq.jL}UxLq.q.|Njm{gx{{.rj2lwnporq{v.x(so{q.j{y sqXtrj½gorjwt{rvznp|rp

«

Kp¯4

«

o

pj#orjwv.x(}: orj#jwtrq±{.n Uj9trj½gorj#tk&x lwn(j#l#{.snpo"n(7²|Norl#{.snporq¢lwnporlwx¦pj²|rorl#{.snpoNqw}?q.j#j

/8! ?npv-à! 1x(oNt"qz|rl%"{.gxL{!{Nj2l#nporq{vxLso{§d|rx(s½gl¦xL{.snpo,lwnportNsu{sunporqXx(vzj±qxL{.sq½gjwt*à¯

ÕbjwornL{j{.rj/lwn(orqz{.vx(suoC{0q.gx(tNnî~

vzslwj\pj#l#{n(v0²npv

x¦pjwv

,+

ö u B

V!rjwoA} s ö

@}

sq;x6µ%¶·î¸¹´.³µ%¶ÀI7Ãè¾.Â(¿ÁÀgÃ´ªÚw·E¿Á¹¿ÊOw¾4¿Á·¬Q

npso{ s2x(ort npoNusumsu{,qxL{.sq½gjwq;{.rj3²npun¥~Xsor

ãmx(v.|Nq.E¢ãm|NroE¢1|rl<0Ljwv¢l#nportrs{sunporqwÍ

«

sGö%¯éu

B « B ¯

+ ö « s ö ¯è

B « î¯

(

«

sGö%¯éu

(

«Êü

ªý

sGö¯

+(ö

«Ùü

ªý

sGö%¯

«

Kp¯

²npvXx(u

D.-

xLort~XNjwv.j

ü

;ý

«

Ôp¯

!rjyxLUn¥pj2lwn(ortrsu{.snpoNqj#qz{x(rsuq."xqznp|N{.snpo {.n

«

Ôp¯X|NortrjwvX{Njx(tNn

rsusu{x(oNt"§C|gx(usu½glwxL{sunpo x(qzq.|r

{.snporq#0ikj±oNn({sulwjb{rxL{XlwnpoNtrsu{.snporq

« B

¯ç

«

Kp¯7trj½gorjes

ö

x(qxypj#l#{n(vn(+ornpoIsu

vzn¥(xLrjbq{v.xL{j#psj#qss

ö

@}Nrjworl#j¨x(q.A

o9pjwoNjwvxL}L{.rj/y|Nu{s

sujwvzq

x

+)t1xLort,+Hx0~XsCornL{0jv.j#xL{.jwt{.nbj¦xLl%9n({rj#vw<¤n¥~jpjwv#}

~7j¢q.rx(gl#nporq.sutrjwvx2q

j#lwsx((0dsuort,nL*jw§C|rsusurv.su|r"}L~Xrsl%l¦x(o;vzj gj#l#{\{rjtrs1SUjwvzjwo{7j#(jwuq

n(x((jwo{v.j#q

nporq.sursusu{&²npv2{rj,lwnporq{v.x(so{9q.xL{suqzèx(l{sn(o

«

j4

v.jwqzq.j#tk{.rj,(jwl#{.npv ç(¯

x(ortsq!|Nors§C|rjL

/ Å10324654èÈ72%89¢À ´ªÚw·d¿Á¹¿ÊOw¾4¿Á·EQ¸g¶¿ÁÀgÃvs ö ¿97IÂ;:X¶87¥´À=<CÞmÂN7<FkÀA¶¾QÂ(¹¿97¥´.³ >.?´ªÚw·d¿Á¹¿ÊOÝ

¾4¿Á·EQ ¸g¶¿ÁÀgÃ!¿!@A!¦¶¾=7¥¶NQ,´5(´%µÃ¶¾<7cç Ç

B

Â(À³B+

ö u B

µ%¶À³(¿ÁÃ[¿¶ÀI7C<$DE ?NÝF<$D"GH?I³d´Ã´¾Q9¿ÁÀA´

s ö

Â(À³;Â(¾´e7wÂ(Ãè¿976I/´.³J!¦¶¾

+(ö

+ ö

ç «

8¯

!¦¶¾y´.Âdµ<F

)LK

M

ùìÛæèÝXæ[ååONQP(R@SEÝÞTNUFSCêÝÞæ[Ýú/å<ß4ÿÿîìäÙÛÚß4Ü[ÙàÝâæ;

V

þ*øîåéñ?ÙäìàìXW(å<ãå.ÚÜ[Ý#ÞæAÙäêEÜøîåÞå0ñUåzÞ[å0ú/ÝÞå<ÚØÝ#öîÿîìàåzó¢ÚØÝâLæ²ÜÞßÙäâwÜæUÜÝXæ[ß4Ü[ÙÛæ²êé

Y[Z

ð1ÝÞú/ßìäÙÛæß%Ü[ÙàÝâ]\±ú/åzß4âLæ\ÙàâÜøîÙÛæÚÝâwÜ[å_^¦Ü\Ü[øLß%ÜOWLÝÜ[øÿîìàßé#åÞçæ<êß#ÚØåÜ[øîåbæ[ßú/å¢ÚÝâæèÜ[Þçß4ÙàâwÜ7æèøLßó¥Ý%ñ

ÿîÞÙàÚåa`bÙêcbadeP¦ÝÞbgfhP#ï¦Ü[øîå3iLÞæèÜ?ÿîìàßé#åÞ.jæ*ÚÝâæèÜ[Þçß4ÙàâwÜ?æ[øß#ó¥Ý%ñIÿîÞÙàÚå0Ùàæ

`b

k

ëåÚÝöîìÛóbæ[ßé/Üøß%Ül`pÖ0ßÞ[åÜ[øå

Z

ÝmWon²åzÚÜÙäã#å(\æèøLßó¥Ý%ñIÿÞ[ÙÛÚØå.æ*ñ?øîÙäìàå`pÖ

p

ß4ÞåÜ[øîå

Z

æèöoWon²åzÚÜÙäã#å(\7Ýâîå.æ¡

(10)

N

{sunpo*

¨n¥~m}~jXlwx(oj#{z{j#v<|rortrj#v.qz{x(ort{rj!vznpj!n(Ê{.rj!~j#sp{q.ç

çAx(ox(pj#oC{w£äq<~7jwsup{Jç

«

qzjwj

«

à¯.¯sq+pv.jwxL{j#v+{rx(o{Nnpq.j/nLÊrsq

«

npv1rjwv¯+lwn(

j#{.su{n(v.qw}î{Njwo9rsuq

«

n(vrj#v%¯+°x((vx(or(j

y|r{s

sujwv.qx(v.jXujwq.qzjworj#t*}dv.jwxL{spj/{.nm{.rjlwnp

j{s{npvzqw£V!rsuqjwx(orq<{gx{\{.rjX,xLv.psuogx(

lwn(qz{mn(<{.rj9lwnpoNqz{v.x(so{w£äqbdsn(xL{.snposqbun¥~j#v¢²npv¢{.rsq±xLpjwo{b{.gx(o3²npv¢{.rjwsuvblwn(

j#{.su{n(vw

xLvx

Nvx(qzsorr}d{rjpjwl{npv2ç2{j#q\|rq!n(Nnî~ {.rj±v.j#p|rx{npv\gx(q/tNsqz{.v.sur|N{j#t;{rj¢r|rv.tNjwo

n(1{rjml#nporqz{.vx(suo{qw£gq.xL{suqzèx(l{sunpoIx(npor9{rj2x((jwo{q#

!rjm~npvztrsoNnL{Njm²n(n¥~Xsuor{Njwnpvzjwlwvz|rlwsx(A²npv!l#np|

ujwtEçlwnpoNqz{v.x(so{x(jwq!suqXx

rs{Xqz{vznporpj#v!{gx(oIsuoá/8! [}rqzjwjÍäÔN [

ÅCÈÊÉÅ rqs´ÃmÃ6Fg´æ´¿T3NFdÃ[¿ÁÀ¬3utç@wv O´º3(¿65(´ÀAæFg´¾´xv ¿97Âµ%¶ÀH5(´(' 7·IOR7¥´Ã¶$!

:

x

)s´ÃçNt

t « s D

tçp¯

çNt

x «s D tçp¯O´³(¿èÂ83d¶ÀÂ(¹Á¹ a7Ã[¾4¿µÃè¹ "µ%¶ÀAµ.ÂP5(´¶ÀÃ6Fg´µ%¶ÀH5(´('º7¥´Ã

Â(À³7·gµ<FÃ6FNÂ(ÃÃ6Fg´zyÂ(¾4·¥7<F¬Ý{y2· FdÀHÝ}|r·gµ ~´¾wQ9·d¹Ã[¿à¸¹¿´¾¯7;´('p¿97Ã{)|)Fg´ÀA!¦¶¾Ã6Fg´aæ´¿T3NFdÃè¿ÁÀ¬3

t

ç1ÃÙFg´¾´2¿97Â,·dÀg¿ÊÚw·Ê´:¶87¥´À<CÞ±ÂN7<FIÀA¶¾QÂ(¹¿97¥´.³m?;´ªÚw·d¿Á¹¿ÊOw¾4¿Á·EQ ¸g¶¿ÁÀgÃ{)

on({.rjwv2~npvztrqw}su!x"x(jsuq

²npvxI²j¦x(qzsrujtNsqz{.v.sur|N{sunpon(/{.rj,l#nporqz{.vx(suo{

qx{sqèx(l#{.snpov.j#q

nporqzsrsusu{.sj#qw}?{rj#o{rjx(j

npqzq.j#q.q.j#qx"|rorsu§C|rj,l#np|

ujwtl#nporqz{.vx(suo{

jw§C|rsusurv.su|r ²n(v!j¦x(l%q.|rl%"trsq{vzsr|N{.snpoA

ò i$¼ L¤

m\eghpVlnp

¤

v.npNjw

«

*Û¯4}

x(pj=Mr!o

x(v{sulw|rx(vw}r~7jj4

x(suo

rn¥~ q

j#lws½gln(|N{

|E{uj#(jwq#}sorl#|rtrsuor;{Nnpq.jtrj#q.svzjwt&{rjv.j#p|rxL{npv#}?l¦x(oj9,x(tNj

n

{.sx(U²n(v/{rj2x(pj#o{qw

o " j#l#{sunpoUEÁK ~jj#oC{.snpoNjwtxk³d´%µ%¶·î¸¹´.³ x(j{.gxL{2{rjx(pj#oC{.q

x¦kxÁ{jwvm{Nj

v.j#p|rxL{npvgxLq7nEtNsu½gj#t{.rjwsuv

x¦(nPSAq#!rj¢tNjwlwn(|

suor2jwx(orq{gxL{\{Nj

x¥(jwvzq7trj#lwsutrj

|

npo3{Njwsv¢x(l#{.snpoNq~Xsu{.rnp|N{{rjj

sulws{c0Corn¥~Xj#trpjynpo3{.rjyl#npnpo"lwnporq{v.x(so{¦±od

qz{.j¦x(tA}r{rj#sv

x¦(nPSAq!l#npo{%x(suo

j#ogx(u{²|rorl{sunporq/²npv{.rj±lwn(npo;l#nporqz{.vx(suo{!Esunpx{sn(o*

!rj

jwogxLu{I²|rorl{sn(orqJ

« + ö D ç D

sU¯

DH

n

D

{Nj°1xLpvx(oNpj<y|r{s

dsnpxL{sunpo,{.jwv.

« +(ö

D ç D

sU¯

+ ö

ç

,xî

«CBID

| « sU¯z¯

«

MC¯

~Xrj#v.j+

ö

sq/{.rjm°x(pvxLorpj±y|r{s

sujwv/xLq.q.ndlwsxL{j#t ~Xsu{ {.rjmlwnporq{v.x(so{x(ort ç sq

x¦pj#v

£q!~j#sp{.{rxL{Xtrj#½rorjwqX{rj#sv!vzjwq

nporqzsrsus{²npv/{.rjmlwnpoNqz{v.x(so{.qw£gqx{sqèx(l#{.snpoA

¤j#orlwjL}+s\{.rjy~7jws(C{±²n(v

x¦pj#v

sq#}*²npv±jNx(

jç

Ç x(ort&{Nj~7jwsup{±²npvb{Nj

n({.rjwv

x¦pj#v!sq?(}E{Njwo {rj¢v.jwq

n(orq.sursusu{n(

x¥(jwv

²n(v7{Nj±lwnporq{v.x(so{q#£Nq.xL{suqzèx(l{sn(o

sq!ujwqzq.jwoNjwt*

!rj

x¦pj#v.q#£

x¦pnPS²|rorl{sunporqw}Nq.nndtrsu½rjwt*}d~XsAUj

«

sU¯

(

«

sU¯|u

«

+(ö D ç D

sU¯

«

¥Ó¯

õ

êgÜ[øîå\ñUåzÙäí#ø#Üçæb/ñUåzÞ[å0ÙÛó¥åâwÜÙàÚzß4ìNQP(P_(_P$SEÜ[øîåzâbÜ[øîå7ÿLåzâß4ìäÜ²éXÜåÞú êÝ#Þ1ÚØÝ#âæèÜ[Þçß4Ùàâ#Ü<ÙÛæ*Ü[øå7æß4ú/å

êÝÞ?å.ßÚçø¢ÿîìÛßéåÞ

p

` Ö _Pd` Ö ú!ß ^

Ro

M

V

P.