HAL Id: hal-00342874
https://hal.archives-ouvertes.fr/hal-00342874v2
Submitted on 26 Mar 2016
HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access archive for the deposit and dissemination of sci- entific research documents, whether they are pub- lished or not. The documents may come from teaching and research institutions in France or abroad, or from public or private research centers.
L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non, émanant des établissements d’enseignement et de recherche français ou étrangers, des laboratoires publics ou privés.
Distributed under a Creative Commons Attribution - ShareAlike| 4.0 International License
Dynamics and Stability of a Two Degree of Freedom Oscillator With an Elastic Stop
Madeleine Pascal
To cite this version:
Madeleine Pascal. Dynamics and Stability of a Two Degree of Freedom Oscillator With an Elastic
Stop. Journal of Computational and Nonlinear Dynamics, American Society of Mechanical Engineers
(ASME), 2005, 1 (1), pp.94-102. �10.1115/1.1961873�. �hal-00342874v2�
Madeleine Pascal
Laboratoire Systèmes Complexes, Université d’Evry Val d’Essonne et CNRS FRE 2494, 40 rue du Pelvoux, 91020 Evry cedex, France e-mail: mpascal@iup.univ-evry.fr
Dynamics and Stability of a Two Degree of Freedom Oscillator With an Elastic Stop
A two degree of freedom oscillator with a colliding component is considered. The aim of the study is to investigate the dynamic behavior of the system when the stiffness obstacle changes to a finite value to an infinite one. Several cases are considered. First, in the case of rigid impact and without external excitation, a family of periodic solutions are found in analytical form. In the case of soft impact, with a finite time duration of the shock, and no external excitation, the existence of periodic solutions, with an arbitrary value of the period, is proved. Periodic motions are also obtained when the system is submitted to harmonic excitation, in both cases of rigid or soft impact. The stability of these periodic motions is investigated for these four cases.
Keywords: Nonlinear Vibrations, Two Degree of Freedom Oscillator, Rigid and Soft Impact, Periodic Motion, Stability, Forced and Unforced System
1 Introduction
Vibrating systems with clearance between the moving parts are frequently encountered in technical applications. These systems with impacts are strongly nonlinear; they are usually modeled as a spring-mass system with amplitude constraint. Such systems have been the subject of several investigations, mainly in the simplest case of a one degree of freedom system
关1–4
兴and more seldom for multidegree of freedom systems
关5–8
兴. On the other hand, the system behavior during the contact between the moving parts can be described as rigid impact, usually associated with a restitution coefficient, or modeled as soft impact, with a finite time duration of the shock. Several other parameters like damping, external ex- citation, influence the behavior of the system.
The work is the continuation of a previous paper
关9
兴, in which a two degree of freedom oscillator is considered. The nonlinearity in this case comes from the presence of two fixed stops limiting the motion of one mass. Assuming no damping and no external excitation, the behavior of the system is investigated when the obstacles stiffness changes from a finite value to an infinite one. In both cases, a family of symmetrical periodic solutions, with two impacts per period, is obtained in analytical form.
In the present paper, a two degree of freedom system in the presence of one fixed obstacle is considered. Assuming that no damping occurs, we investigate four cases: Unforced system with rigid impact, unforced system with soft impact, forced system
共with harmonic excitation
兲with rigid impact and, at last, forced system with soft impact. In all cases, periodic solutions are found and stability results of these particular motions are obtained.
2 Problem Formulation
The system under consideration
共Fig. 1
兲is a generalization of the double oscillator investigated in the paper
关9
兴. It consists of two masses m
1and m
2connected by linear springs of stiffness k
1and k
2. The displacement z
1of the mass m
1is limited by the presence of a fixed stop. When z
1is greater than the clearance, a contact of the first mass with the stop occurs; this contact gives rise to a restoring force associated to a spring stiffness k
3. The mathematical model of the system is given by:
Mz¨ + Kz = F + P cos
共t +
兲, z =
共z
1,z
2兲t, F =
冉0 f
共z
1兲冊,
共
1
兲f
共z
1兲=
再− 0 k
3共z
1− 1
兲z z
11⬎⬍1 1
冎, M =
冉m 0
1m 0
2冊,
K =
冉− k k
11k
1− + k
1k
2冊P =
共PP12兲and
are the amplitude and the phase angle of the har- monic excitation.
3 Unforced System
Let us consider the system without external excitation
共P = 0
兲. 3.1 Rigid Impact. When the stiffness obstacle k
3tends to infinity, a rigid impact of the first mass against the stop occurs.
Starting from initial positions z
0=
共1y兲and initial velocities z˙
0=
共wu兲共u
⬎0
兲, corresponding to a contact of the first mass against the stop, assuming a perfect elastic impact, the new positions z
cand the new velocities z˙
cafter the shock are obtained by:
冉
z z˙
cc冊=
冉0 I E 0
冊冉z z˙
00冊, I =
冉1 0 0 1
冊, E =
冉− 1 0 0 1
冊 共2
兲After the impact, the system performs a free motion defined by:
冉
z z˙
冊= C
共t
兲冉z z˙
cc冊, C
共t
兲=
冉⌫⌫13共共t t
兲兲 ⌫⌫21共共t t
兲兲冊,
⌫i=
⌳B
i共t
兲⌳−1共
i = 1,2,3
兲 共3
兲⌳
=
冉1
1 1
2冊, B
1共t
兲=
冉C 0
1共t
兲0 C
2共t
兲冊,
B
2共t
兲= 冢 S
10
共1t
兲S
20
共2t
兲冣 ,
共4
兲B
3共t
兲=B ˙
1共
t
兲, C
i共t
兲= cos
it, S
i共t
兲= sin
it
共i= 1, 2
兲.
In these formulas,
共1,
2兲are the roots of the characteristic equation:
⌬共2兲⬅det
共K− M
2兲= 0 while
⌿i=
共1i兲are defined by
共K −M
i2兲⌿i= 0
共i= 1 , 2
兲.
The following properties for the
⌫imatrices hold:
⌫12共
t
兲−
⌫2共t
兲⌫3共t
兲= I,
⌫i共t
兲⌫j共t
兲=
⌫j共t
兲⌫i共t
兲for i, j = 1,2,3
共5
兲Moreover, the coefficients C
ij共t
兲of the 4 by 4 matrix C
共t
兲satisfy the property:
C
ij共t
兲= C
i−2,j−2共t
兲,
共i, j = 3,4
兲 共6
兲Let us investigate if for a set of initial conditions Z
0=
共zz˙00兲, z
0=
共1y兲, z˙
0=
共u⬎w0兲, it is possible to obtain a periodic solution of pe- riod T, with one impact per period.
The free motion performed by the system after the rigid impact finishes at time t=T when z
1共T
兲= 1 and z˙
1共T
兲⬎0. Let us denote by Z
f=
共zz˙ff兲the positions and the velocities reached by the system at t=T.
The condition to obtain such a periodic motion is given by:
Z
f⬅C
共T
兲Z
c= Z
0, Z
c= H
0Z
0, H
0=
冉0 I E 0
冊 共7
兲Let us introduce the position Z
sreached by the system from the initial position Z
0after a backward motion of duration T: Z
s=C
共−T
兲Z
0. The condition
共7
兲is equivalent to: Z
s=Z
c.
It results for the determination of the four scalar parameters
共y , u, w , T
兲the four scalar equations:
共
− H
0+ C
共− T
兲兲Z
0= 0, Z
0=
共1, y, u,w
兲tor equivalently:
共⌫1
− I
兲z
0−
⌫2z˙
0= 0
−
⌫3z
0+
共⌫1− E
兲z˙
0= 0
⌫i=
⌫i共T
兲 共i = 1,2,3
兲 共8
兲Taking into account the properties
共5
兲of the
⌫imatrices, the sys- tem
共8
兲leads to:
z
0=
共⌫1− I
兲−1⌫2z˙
0共
9
兲 共E + I
兲z˙
0= 0
The last equation of
共9
兲reduces to w= 0. From the first one, y and u are obtained in terms of the period:
y =
共2t
2−
1t
1兲1222
t
2−
11t
1, u =
共1−
2兲12t
1t
222
t
2−
11t
1,
t
i= tan
冉2
iT
冊 共i = 1,2
兲 共10
兲In case of rigid impact, a family of periodic solutions is obtained for which the initial conditions are defined in terms of the period and the initial velocity w of the nonimpacting mass is zero. For these particular motions, the conditions giving the positions and the velocities after the shock can be formulated by:
z
c= z
0, z˙
c= − z˙
0 共11
兲These results are similar to the results obtained in Ref.
关9
兴. The system considered in this previous paper is a symmetrical system with respect to the position z
1of the first mass and it can be
expected that the obtained results are due to this property. But it is not the real explanation because the system investigated now is not symmetrical.
3.2 Soft Impact. Let us assume that the stiffness obstacle is bounded. The mathematical model of the system is given by:
For z
1⬍1
Mz¨ + Kz = 0
共12
兲For z
1⬎1
Mz¨ + K
1z = K
3K
1=
冉k
1− + k
1k
3k
1− + k
1k
2冊K
3=
冉k 0
3冊 共13
兲Let us assume that the initial conditions are given by: Z
0=
共1 ,y, u, w
兲tu
⬎0.
A periodic solution is defined in two steps:
– For 0
艋t
艋, z
1⬎1, the system is defined by the motion equations
共13
兲. The time duration
of this constraint motion is defined by the condition:
z
1共兲= 1
共14
兲Let us denote by Z
c=Z
共兲=
共1 ,y
c, u
c, w
c兲tthe value of the parameters at the end of shock, with the condition u
C⬍0.
– For
艋t
艋+T, a free motion obtained from Eqs.
共12
兲and initial conditions Z
coccurs. This motion finishes when z
1共+T
兲= 1. Let us denote by Z
f=Z
共+T
兲=
共1 ,y
f,u
f, w
f兲tthe value of the parameters at the end of free motion
共u
f⬎0
兲. The condition to obtain a periodic orbit of period
+T is given by
Z
f= Z
0 共15
兲The piecewise linear systems
共12
兲and
共13
兲give the two parts of the motion in analytical form.
– For 0
艋t
艋, the constraint motion is deduced from a modal analysis of system
共13
兲:
Z
共t
兲= H
共t
兲共Z
0− d
兲+ d, d =
共d
1, d
2,0,0
兲td
1= k
3共k
1+ k
2兲k
1k
2+ k
3共k
1+ k
3兲, d
2= k
3k
1k
1k
2+ k
3共k
1+ k
2兲 共16
兲H
共t
兲=
冉H H
13共共t t
兲兲H H
21共共t t
兲兲冊, H
i共t
兲=
⌺G
i共t
兲⌺−1共
i = 1,2,3
兲,
⌺=
冉1
1 1
2冊 共17
兲G
1共t
兲=
冉c
10
共t
兲c
20
共t
兲冊, G
2= 冢 s
10
共1t
兲s
20
共2t
兲冣 , G
3= G ˙
1,
共
18
兲c
i共t
兲= cos
共it
兲, s
i共t
兲= sin
共it
兲,
共i = 1,2
兲In these formulas,
1,
2,
⌽1=
共11兲,
⌽2=
共12兲define the char- acteristic frequencies and the eigenvectors of the constraint
Fig. 1 Double oscillator
system
共13
兲. For the H
imatrices, the properties
共5
兲obtained for the
⌫imatrices hold, together with the property H
ij共t
兲=H
i−2,j−2共t
兲,
共i, j= 3,4
兲for the coefficients H
ij共t
兲of the ma- trix H
共t
兲.
– For
艋t
艋+T, the free motion is obtained from Z
共t
兲=C
共t
−
兲Z
cwhere the matrix C is defined by formulas
共3
兲and
共4
兲and Z
c=H
共兲共Z
0−d
兲+d.
Let us introduce the positions and the velocities Z
s=
共z
1s, z
2s, z˙
1s, z˙
2s兲tof the system after a backward motion of dura- tion T from the initial position Z
0. The condition
共15
兲of period- icity is reformulated as
Z
s⬅C
共− T
兲Z
0= Z
c 共19
兲Z
c=
冉z z˙
cc冊=
冉H
1H
共z
30共− z
0d −
0兲d +
0兲H +
2H z˙
01z˙ +
0d
0冊, d
0=
共d
1,d
2兲tZ
s=
冉z z˙
ss冊=
冉−
⌫⌫1z
30z
0− +
⌫⌫2z˙
10z˙
0冊, H
i= H
i共兲,
⌫i=
⌫i共T
兲共
i = 1,2,3
兲 共20
兲The condition
共19
兲is equivalent to
X
1= X
2, Y
1= Y
2 共21
兲X
1⬅z
c− z
0=
共H
1− I
兲共z
0− d
0兲+ H
2z˙
0, X
2⬅z
s− z
0=
共⌫1− I
兲z
0−
⌫2z˙
0Y
1⬅z˙
c+ z˙
0= H
3共z
0− d
0兲+
共H
1+ I
兲z˙
0, Y
2⬅z˙
s+ z˙
0= −
⌫3z
0+
共⌫1+ I
兲z˙
0 共22
兲From the properties
共5
兲of
⌫iand H
i, we deduce:
Y
i= P
iX
i 共i = 1,2
兲P
1= H
2−1共H
1+ I
兲, P
2= −
⌫2−1共⌫1
+ I
兲 共23
兲The condition
共21
兲leads to
X
1= X
2, P
1X
1= P
2X
2 共24
兲Two possible cases of periodic solutions can be deduced from
共24
兲, namely:
X
1= X
2= 0 or X
1= X
2, det
共P
1− P
2兲= 0
共25
兲3.3 Existence of Periodic Motions (Soft Impact). Let us dis- cuss the first conditions
共25
兲. In this case, from
共22
兲, we deduce:
z
c= z
0, z˙
c= − z˙
0 共26
兲The condition
共14
兲is fulfilled and the initial conditions are ob- tained from the equations:
共
H
1− I
兲共z
0− d
0兲+ H
2z˙
0= 0
共⌫1
− I
兲z
0−
⌫2z˙
0= 0
共27
兲This system provides four scalar equations for the determination of the five parameters
共y, u, w,
, T
兲. It results that, as in the case of rigid impact, T and hence the period can be chosen arbitrarily.
Moreover, the conditions
共11
兲and
共26
兲obtained at the end of the shock are the same for both rigid and soft impacts. From
共27
兲, we deduce:
z˙
0= − H
2−1共H
1− I
兲共z
0− d
0兲关⌫1
− I +
⌫2H
2−1共H
1− I
兲兴z
0=
⌫2H
2−1共H
1− I
兲d
0 共28
兲The last equation
共28
兲, after the elimination of y, provides a rela- tion F
共, T
兲= 0 between the time duration
of the shock and the
time duration T of the free motion.
-The other case X
1= X
2, det
共P
1− P
2兲= 0 leads to no solution
共see Appendix A
兲.
In both cases
共soft or rigid impact
兲, a family of periodic mo- tions is obtained, with an arbitrary value of the period. Moreover, the conditions
共26
兲obtained at the end of the shock for soft impact are consistent with Newton rules of rigid impact
共11
兲with a res- titution coefficient equal to one, i.e., with assumption of ideal elastic impact. This rather remarkable result has already been ob- tained for the symmetrical system of Ref.
关9
兴.
4 Forced System
Let us assume that the two masses are subjected to harmonic external excitations of period 2
/
, constant amplitudes P
1, P
2and constant phase angle
. From the results obtained in the pre- vious paragraph, where a family of periodic orbits is found with an arbitrary value of the period, it can be expected that for the forced system, periodic solutions of period 2
/
exist.
4.1 Rigid Impact. Let us investigate the case of rigid impact.
Starting from the initial conditions Z
0=
共1 ,y , u, w
兲t 共u
⬎0
兲, the conditions Z
c=
共1 ,y
c, u
c, w
c兲tafter the shock are obtained from
共2
兲and the free motion performed by the system is given by:
z =
⌫1共t
兲共z
0− R cos
兲+
⌫2共t
兲共z˙
c+ R
sin
兲+ R cos
共t +
兲z˙ =
⌫3共t
兲共z
0− R cos
兲+
⌫1共t
兲共z˙
c+ R
sin
兲− R
sin
共t +
兲共
29
兲where R =
共R
1, R
2兲tis the amplitude of the response defined by:
R
1= A
1+ A
2, R
2=
1A
1+
2A
2A
i= P
1+
iP
2共i2
−
2兲共m
1+
i2m
2兲,
共i = 1,2
兲 共30
兲The free motion finishes at time t =T when z
1共T
兲= 1, z˙
1共T
兲⬎0. Let us denote by Z
f=
共z
f, z˙
f兲tthe positions and the velocities reached by the system at this time. The condition to obtain a periodic motion of period T is:
Z
f= Z
0or :
z
0=
⌫1共T
兲共z
0− R cos
兲+
⌫2共T
兲共z˙
c+ R
sin
兲+ R cos
共T +
兲z˙
0=
⌫3共T
兲共z
0− R cos
兲+
⌫1共T
兲共z˙
c+ R
sin
兲− R
sin
共T +
兲z˙
c= Ez˙
0 共31
兲Let us assume that T = 2
/
,
= 0, z˙
c= −z˙
0. A periodic motion of period 2
/
is obtained if the initial conditions Z
0=
共1 ,y, u, 0
兲tare defined by the system:
共⌫1
− I
兲共z
0− R
兲−
⌫2z˙
0= 0
共32
兲⌫3共
z
0− R
兲−
共⌫1+ I
兲z˙
0= 0
⌫i
=
⌫i共2
/
兲,
共i = 1,2,3
兲Taking into account the properties
共5
兲of the
⌫imatrices, this system reduces to
z˙
0=
⌫2−1共⌫1
− I
兲共z
0− R
兲 共33
兲and the corresponding values of y and u are obtained:
y = R
2+
共2t
2−
1t
1兲1222
t
2−
11t
1 共1 − R
1兲,
共34
兲u =
共1 − R
1兲共1−
2兲12t
1t
222
t
2−
11t
1, t
i= tan
冉i冊 共i = 1,2
兲Remark: In more general cases, the impact is described by a
restitution coefficient r
共0
⬍r
⬍1
兲. The initial conditions and the phase angle related to a periodic solution of period 2
/
can also be obtained in analytical form
关10
兴. A similar solution has been studied in paper
关6
兴.
4.2 Soft Impact. When the stiffness obstacle is bounded, the motion equations of the system are given by:
Mz¨ + K
1z = K
3+ P cos
共t +
兲z
1⬎1
Mz¨ + Kz = P cos
共t +
兲z
1⬍1
共35
兲From the initial condition Z
0=
共1 , y, u, w
兲t共u
⬎0
兲, the solution is defined in two parts:
– For 0
⬍t
⬍, z
1⬎1, the solution is given by:
z = H
1共t
兲共z
0− d
0− Q cos
兲+ H
2共t
兲共z˙
0+ Q
sin
兲+ d
0+ Q cos
共t +
兲z˙ = H
3共t
兲共z
0− d
0− Q cos
兲+ H
1共t
兲共z˙
0+ Q
sin
兲− Q
sin
共t +
兲 共36
兲Q=
共Q
1, Q
2兲tis the response amplitude defined by:
Q
1= P
1共1 +
22兲+ P
2共1+
2兲 共12−
2兲共m
1+ m
212兲,
共
37
兲Q
2= P
1共1+
2兲+ P
2共1 +
12兲共22
−
2兲共m
2+ m
122兲The time duration
of this motion is obtained from the con- dition z
1共兲= 1. Let us denote Z
c=
共1 ,y
c, u
c, w
c兲tthe value of the parameters at t=
共u
c⬍0
兲.
– For
⬍t
⬍+T, the motion of the system is defined by:
z =
⌫1共t −
兲共z
c− R cos
兲+
⌫2共t −
兲共z˙
c+ R
sin
兲+ R cos
共t +
兲z˙ =
⌫3共t −
兲共z
c− R cos
兲+
⌫1共t −
兲共z˙
c+ R
sin
兲− R
sin
共t +
兲 共38
兲where R=
共R
1, R
2兲tis defined by
共30
兲and
=
+
. This motion finishes at time t=
+T when z
1共+T
兲= 1, z˙
1共+T
兲⬎
0. If Z
f=
共z
f, z˙
f兲tdenote the positions and the velocities reached by the system at this time, the condition to obtain a periodic motion of period
+T is Z
f=Z
0. Let us assume that
+T = 2
/
,
= −
/ 2. At the end of the first part of the motion
共t=
兲, the positions and the velocities are given by:
z
c= H
1共z
0− d
0− Q cos
˜
0兲+ H
2共z˙
0− Q
sin
˜
0兲+ d
0+ Q cos
˜
0z˙
c= H
3共z
0− d
0− Q cos
˜
0兲+ H
1共z˙
0− Q
sin
˜
0兲− Q
sin
˜
0
˜
0=
/2, H
i= H
i共兲 共i = 1,2,3
兲 共39
兲At the end of the second part of the motion
共t= 2
/
兲, we obtain:
z
f=
⌫1共z
c− R cos
˜
0兲+
⌫2共z˙
c+ R
sin
˜
0兲+ R cos
˜
0z˙
f=
⌫3共z
c− R cos
˜
0兲+
⌫1共z˙
c+ R
sin
˜
0兲+ R
sin
˜
0⌫i
=
⌫i共2
/
−
兲 共i = 1,2,3
兲 共40
兲The conditions of periodicity are reformulated as:
X ˜
1
= X ˜
2
, Y ˜
1
= Y ˜
2 共
41
兲X ˜
1⬅
z
c− z
0=
共H
1− I
兲共z
0− d
0− Q cos
˜
0兲+ H
2共z˙
0− Q
sin
˜
0兲Y ˜
1⬅
z˙
c+ z˙
0= H
3共z
0− d
0− Q cos
˜
0兲+
共H
1+ I
兲共z˙
0− Q
sin
˜
0兲 共42
兲X ˜
2⬅
z
s− z
0=
共⌫1− I
兲共z
0− R cos
˜
0兲−
⌫2共z˙
0− R
sin
˜
0兲Y ˜
2⬅
z˙
s+ z˙
0= −
⌫3共z
0− R cos
˜
0兲+
共⌫1+ I
兲共z˙
0− R
sin
˜
0兲Z
s=
共z
s, z˙
s兲t= C
共− T
兲Z
0 共43
兲As in the case of an unforced system taking into account the properties of the H
iand
⌫imatrices, the solution of system
共41
兲is given by:
X ˜
1
= X ˜
2
= 0, ˜ Y
1
= Y ˜
2
= 0
共44
兲We deduce for the forced system the existence of a periodic mo- tion of period 2
/
for which the conditions at the end of the shock are z
c=z
0, z˙
c= −z˙
0. The time duration
of the shock and the initial conditions
共y , u, w
兲are obtained from the first part of sys- tem
共44
兲:
z˙
0= Q
sin
˜
0− H
2−1共H
1− I
兲共z
0− d
0− Q cos
˜
0兲 关⌫2−1共⌫1− I
兲+ H
2−1共H
1− I
兲兴z
0=
共Q − R
兲sin
˜
0+
⌫2−1共⌫1− I
兲R cos
˜
0+ H
2−1共H
1− I
兲共d
0+ Q cos
˜
0兲 共45
兲These formulas give the relations
共28
兲when Q=R = 0
共unforced system
兲.
5 Stability of Periodic Motions (Rigid Impact) 5.1 Unforced System. Let us consider a periodic motion of period T related to initial conditions z
00=
共y10兲, z˙
00=
共u00兲, where z
00, z˙
00are defined by:
共⌫1
− I
兲z
00−
⌫2z˙
00= 0
⌫i=
⌫i共T
兲−
⌫3z
00+
共⌫1− E
兲z˙
00= 0
共46
兲Let us consider the perturbed motion defined by a set of new initial conditions
z
0= z
00+ dz
0z˙
0= z˙
00+ dz˙
0where dz
0=
冉0 y
冊, dz˙
0=
冉w u
冊 共47
兲This motion is defined for t
⬎0, by:
z =
⌫1共t
兲z
0+
⌫2共t
兲Ez˙
0z˙ =
⌫3共t
兲z
0+
⌫1共t
兲Ez˙
0This motion ends at t=T +dT, when z
1共T +dT
兲= 1 and z˙
1共T +dT
兲⬎
0. Let us denote by z
f, z˙
fthe positions and the velocities of the system at this time.
z
f=
⌫1共T + dT
兲z
0+
⌫2共T + dT
兲Ez˙
0z˙
f=
⌫3共T + dT
兲z
0+
⌫1共T + dT
兲Ez˙
0Assuming small perturbations dz
0, dz˙
0of the initial conditions, dz
f= z
f− z
00=
⌫1dz
0+
⌫2Edz˙
0+ L
1dT
dz˙
f= z˙
f− z˙
00=
⌫3dz
0+
⌫1Edz˙
0+ L
2dT
共48
兲L
1=
⌫˙
1
z
00+
⌫˙
2