CBOC performances using software receiver

(1)

HAL Id: hal-01021986

https://hal-enac.archives-ouvertes.fr/hal-01021986

Submitted on 20 Nov 2014

HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access archive for the deposit and dissemination of sci- entific research documents, whether they are pub- lished or not. The documents may come from teaching and research institutions in France or abroad, or from public or private research centers.

L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non, émanant des établissements d’enseignement et de recherche français ou étrangers, des laboratoires publics ou privés.

CBOC performances using software receiver

Géraldine Artaud, Lionel Ries, J Dantepal, Jean-Luc Issler, T Grelier, Antoine Delatour, Olivier Julien, Christophe Macabiau

To cite this version:

Géraldine Artaud, Lionel Ries, J Dantepal, Jean-Luc Issler, T Grelier, et al.. CBOC performances using software receiver. GNSS Signal 2007, 2nd Workshop on GNSS Signals and Signals Processing, Apr 2007, Noordwijk, Netherlands. �hal-01021986�

(2)

! "" #$ %& !'( (!'( #)

* ! +# ,* () -* . !( -,* )) ( * ( ( * .( !"+ * -+ ( * / 0 +

! "

#

$

%%

.

! " #"$$$

% & ' ( ) ( * ( #"+

) ( *& , (

& $ * ) , ( - ,

) , & " , ( . ( , / ( ( ( (0

( , , &

' ( ( , * , ( & ' (

( ( , ( ( ) ( , & ' (

) ) ( (

12 &

,

' ) ( * 3

4& " & "

& = _'( + _'(

) & _'( " - ) #"+ &

$ ( * ) 5 ( & ')

647 647 ) ) ( ( & '

( ( * ( ( & *

* " ) ( ( * ) 8 3

{ }

{

⁻

}

+

= +

&

) '(

'(

(

) '(

'(

( + *

,

*

{

⁻ ⁻

}

= +

&

) '(

'(

(

'(

(

* + -

,

*

' ) ( 3

( ) { }

{

−

}

= +

− +

+

= +

−

=

−

. / ) '(

'(

(

. / ) '(

'(

/ ( ( '(

) '(

'(

( /

( '(

) '(

'(

( /

( '(

9 9

:

(3)

) ; ;

; ) / )

= +

2 ( = 4 )= &

3 /</ ( ( 3 /-= &

2 * ( >

= )= 3

/< -= &

$ , ( * ( , 3 ( , *

( ? ( , ( ( * , @ :

( ( ( ( , &

' ( 5 ) , ( ,

( ,

( , & ') ( 3 ( , )

) ( ) A5

( , ) ) )

* ( , &

' ( * ( , - (

( & $ (

: (0 ) '

& B ( ( ' '

3 ( ,

( *- ( &

' ( ( 2 &

' * ( , ( , 5 (0 ( &

B +# ( ( (0 , ( , * : C 3

( )

(

( ) ( )

)

( )

+ ( )

− ×

= −

=

4 DD D 4 DD

4 D 6 D

&

4

4 4

0 (/

1/

(

1 1 0 1 1

*,

3 2 ,

2

2 3 ,

2

σ 2 C

) ₁ +%% )

0 (

*- (

, ( ) (

34 #"+ ,

2D1

( ( ( , , ( ( ( (

( .E *- ( .E

2 D D

(

( ( ( ) ( ( (

.E *- ( .E &

B - * ) F A5 ) ( ) C 3

BOC(1,1) BOC(6,1) PRN Gene

P

E-L E-L

P

Sig I&D

I&D

DP Discri

LP Filter NCO

* 12 31 /& /' !(/!+ (

(4)

( ) ( )

−

=

− ₁ ₁

1 2 & " " "

2 D

D 4 π 6

( )

= −

= ₍

( "& " " "

2DD

π π

( )

^& ^" ^"

2_1/ _1/

−

= D 4

G

( ) ^& ^" ^"

2_(/ _(/

−

= 4

DD H

( )

+

×

−

=

−

4 4

6

&

4

"

&

3 ,

"

&

"

&

"

3 ,

"

&

(/

0 1/

( 1 0 1 1

*,

π π

π σ

+ ( , ( ( ) ( ,

) . 3

% / ( ( I J3 { } ( )

( )

( + −)

−

+ +

=

9 9 4

9 9

9 9 / ( '(

"

/ ( '(

"

/ ( '(

"

>

• # ( , 3

{ }

;

;& " )& " )& "

"

&

"

&

"

&

"

&₁ = _1/ = ₍ = _(/ = _'( + _'( + _'( _'( 4

• ( , 3

"

&

"

&

"

&₁ = _1/ = _'(

{ }

K '( & " )& "

( '(

"

&

"

&₍ = _(/ = × = _'( + _'( _'(

• ' ( , 3

"

&

"

&

"

&

"

&

'(

1/

'(

1

=

{ }

K '( & " )& "

( '(

"

&_(/ = × = _'( + _'( _'(

{ }

K '( )& " & "

( '(

"

&₍ = × = _'( + _'( _'(

' 5 #"+ , * 6 3

(

'( =

4"

"

4"

"

&

π π π

π

) LE :

' 5 #"+ ( ( , * ( 2

) ( M 2 3

'( =

'(

4"

"

4"

"

&

π π

π π π

π

( (

) LE & C

' ( . ( ( , ) ( & ' * ,

( , ( &

(5)

- 44,

" , @ 55 ) ( , , * N!"& $ (

) ( ( ( *

, , ) ( , / ( ( & ' @ 55 "O ( ,

P - Q ) (

, ) , &

' @ 55 "O ( , ( @ 55 )))&M 55 & ) BN"$

& $ ( ( 5 ( (0 & ' * ( ( (

, * . ( ) N"" & ' ( , ( (

) $2 ( * 12 8 & ' (

( , (8 (0 ? ( 12

* ( (

' , *

( ( , ,

( #" $$2&

R ( ( . *

& ! ( ( (

#1N (

" ) , &

' ! ( ,

( ) C4> (

&4 : A5 ( *

( & ' ( (

- 0- &

' ( (

&

' 12 1. 2

B B + ( , & ' -

1 1 ) - (

4 &

' "O ( , ( (8 (0 (

) (8 (0 * ( . ( , & 2

( * (0 & $ ( +%% 2%% 2#%% #%% (0

2 : & ' (0 ( ( ( * ( , ? * ( (

) : ( , / ( ( &

* 2 !( !( 5"#(

(6)

* 62 /& /' !(/!+ (

' ( , +%% ( ( + -# ( ( 5 * ) &

B M , * ( & O

M ( ( ( ) 3

( )

1 1 - 1 S

$

S - S S

$ -

$

$ ++#N

ε ε δ

ε δ − +

+ =

= + 6

) 1 ( ( * ( 1 ( (

( &

B - ( ( , - ) * /

0 ( ( ( . C 3 ¹

( )

ε = −αε )

C −

α = & ' ( ( )

< 4

δ ) 4 = (

3 2 _'( _'(

( ) ε

=

ε

&

' ( ( * ( , ( 8 * *

*3

• 2 ( , 3

( )

(

^; ^; ^;^;

)

3 9 9

;

; 3 ;

9 9

;

; 3 ;

9 9

'(

) ( '( )

) )

( '( )

) )

( '( )

α α

+

− + +

+ +

− +

• 2 ? ( , 3

( )

3 9

9

3 9

9

3 9

9

'(

( '(

'( ) ( '(

α

α α

− + + −

− +

G

(7)

• 2 ' ( , 3

( )

3 9 9

'(

( '( ) ( '( ) ( '( )

α α α

− + + −

− +

H

,

" , ) ( , ) ( & ' ) *

( , ( * ( , & ' (

, ( ( &

B , ( * ( (

&

' ( ( ( , , C6T ,

640 & ' ( ( ( , ( ( G ( ) (

* C : ) 1 * & ' ) ( , ) - 4 )

( , * ( , * C 4 &

" , ) ) ( 3 ) 44 A5 C

*- ( 4& 6 ( +%% ) A5 ) : #%% ) 6A5

* 2%% ) 6A5& B N , , ( 6 66 -A5 6&

(. " " 5 " 6 .

B - ) , & ' ( ) ) -

(0 ( ( 8 * A5 ) (

( & $ ) H A5 ) & $ *

, & B ( ( (0

( ( ( - ( 4& 6 ( C ) H A5

) , ( & 2 6 ( 1 " ( (0 (

) &

-100 -90 -80 -70 -60 -50

-20 -15 -10 -5 0 5 10 15 20

Offset with respect to the carrier [MHz]

Power spectral Density(dBW-Hz)

-100 -90 -80 -70 -60 -50

-20 -15 -10 -5 0 5 10 15 20

Offset with respect to the carrier [MHz]

Power spectral Density(dBW-Hz)

* 2 "$( ) (/! #( ) !7 "8 93 1 1:11; # /" ) #( (# 8 " ! ( # 8 !( ) 0 #$ #!')

(8)

0.15 0.2 0.25 0.3 0.35 0.4

2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

RMS code tracking error (m)

front-end bandwidth one sided [MHz]

RMS tracking code error for Tint=4ms and chip spacing=0.125chip BOC(1,1) CBOC(6,1,2/11,'+/-) CBOC(6,1,1/11,'-')

* 2 /"#( ! /& ( " 8+ /! " "8 8 " ! ( # 0 #$ #!'

( / ( '(7 89 7 '(

2 1 " ( (0 )

( , * ( , ' ( , ( , - ) H A5 )

&

' ( ( , ( , < - ) (

( ) ? ( ' ( , 8 )

4&G & # ( , ( , - ( &C )

< - ( ' ( , 4& &

< - , , 6 ( , C&: '

( , 4&G ) ( , * ( , & ( -

, , :&6 ( , &> ' ( , (

) ( , * ( , &

(9)

RMS code tracking Error

front-end filter bandwidth 8MHz one sided

0,01 0,1 1 10

25 30 35 40 45 50 55

C/No

CBOC(6,1,2/11,+/-) / CBOC CBOC(6,1,1/11,-) / CBOC CBOC(6,1,2/11,+/-) / TM61 CBOC(6,1,1/11,-) / TM61 CBOC(6,1,2/11,+/-) / BOC(1,1) CBOC(6,1,1/11,-) / BOC(1,1) BOC(1,1) / BOC(1,1)

32 /"#( ! /& ( " 5(!( 8" 91 1; ) # ) (/( <(# 07 (/( <(

31 (/( <( 91 1; (/( <( 8 " ! ( # 8 !( 0 #$ #!' = >? " ( ) #(#

(10)

RMS code tracking Error in presence of multipath front-end filter bandwidth 8MHz one sided

0,1 1 10

25 30 35 40 45 50 55

C/No

2 /"#( ! /& ( " 5(!( 8" 91 1; ) # ) (/( <(# 07 (/( <(

31 (/( <( 91 1; (/( <( 8 " ! ( # 8 !( 0 #$ #!' = >? " ( ) #(# + 0 5+ ! !' ( < " 5( !

2 G 1 " ( (0 ) ( *

2 H ( (0 &

' ( , *- ( ( ,

( & 2 ) ) N ( ( '

( , 1 " (0 &

(11)

Mean code tracking Error in presence of multipath front-end filter bandwidth 8MHz one sided

0,5 1 1,5 2 2,5 3

25 30 35 40 45 50 55

C/No

Mean code tracking error (m)

=2 ( /"#( ! /& ( " 5(!( 8" 91 1; ) # ) (/( <(# 07 (/( <(

31 (/( <( 91 1; (/( <( 8 " ! ( # 8 !( 0 #$ #!' = >? " ( ) #(# + 0 5+ ! !' ( < " 5( !

'(

$ , ( ( 5 ) ( , *

& ' * ( , ) ) 8 ) A5

&

1 >& $ 1 " ( (0

( ( (0 ( , * ( ,

( , * ( , &

( * - ( , *

( , . 4&C <- ( , * ( , 4&H

& ' ( 3 ( (0

1 " (0 , ) N ( &

(12)

RMS and mean code tracking Error in presence of multipath front-end filter badwidth 2MHz one sided

0,1 1 10

25 30 35 40 45 50 55

C/No

CBOC(6,1,2/11,+/-) / BOC(1,1) CBOC(6,1,2/11,+/-) / BOC(1,1) Multipath CBOC(6,1,1/11,-) / BOC(1,1) CBOC(6,1,1/11,-) / BOC(1,1) Multipath

BOC(1,1) / BOC(1,1) BOC(1,1) / BOC(1,1) Multipath

Mean Error CBOC(6,1,2/11,+/-) / BOC(1,1) Mean Error CBOC(6,1,1/11,-) / BOC(1,1) Mean Error BOC(1,1) / BOC(1,1)

@2 /"#( ! /& ( " 5(!( 8" 91 1; ) # ) (/( <(# 07 91 1; (/( <(

8 " ! ( # 8 !( 0 #$ #!' >? " ( ) #(# !'( 5 " )( # + 0 5+ ! !' ( < " 5( !

A

B ( * ) ) ( 12 &

N!" , 8 ) & $ (

. 12 ( & ' 12 ( 5 (

N!"/ 5 ( ( * ( * ( @ 55 )

( , &

Flexible signal generator

Propagation channel emulator

Broadband digitizer

High capacity data recorder Flexible signal generator

Propagation channel emulator

Broadband digitizer

High capacity data recorder

* 1 2 0" !" 7B) (C+ 5( !)

+ (0 , * * 8 ( / ,

& ' ) ( &

(13)

. D

' * ( ( * 3 5

% " ( , ( (0 & $

, ( , ( ( ( ' ( , ) ( , ( ( ,

( . * 0 ( (0 , ( ( *

( & , , ( ) ( ,

( &

2 ) 0 ( ( ( 12 (

( &

A &O& B, -1 5 @&-B& O "& # B&1& ) @&$&1& $ @&-%& 5 @&O& A * &@& %

% %&"& 1 @&@& L * B&%& " '&B& P 3 ' N ) 5 "

1 ( B%$%! % " #" % Q # ( $!!! $ N #%BN" 44 U C- G B 44 "

+ R"B&

B, -1 5 @&B& O "& A &O& 1 * !& @ & ( & 1 %& + % B&

% 8 %& $ @&-% P U B $ Q 2 N!" O 0 "

" # ( - : ( 44 $B" $ B " ' 2 ( &

: @ & ( & 1 %& $ @&-%& P - # ( "

!. ' - . ' " Q $ N N"" @ * 44G&

C @ & P+ % 2 1 ( , ' (0 % Q ,. * . * / " &

: ; " ( ; :(& 2 / # ##$

6 @& O& 5 P' #" 5 Q # (& $ N ' ( ( & :>-

CH >>>