عسر القراءة والكتابة -دراسة مسحية تحليلية-

- ^{4il-ilr5 4t ..*}

^â*,,13.1

- ^{L.ES!13 Ëcl;$l )*.s}

,",lli3 _i.14t!l

C}lr.

^.l

(

_+t.;1tt

) ' .*"*

.c.xt+ç é,t',".lg

4r.Lî

: oe--il"c

oLl_.pll

g. l»c dlLll

^hÀ

,J:t4

'-'e ^{? +.à}

g+

^U,',

; ,15!l-l

^a*-r.ll

J(ÉJJ.

.rJt

,rr:lt ,6j d ^**: ,!l§ll3 icl-fI oL3trJl3

r-i-1TJl3 u,".,,Tt,

fi$till d.,=$

^l+,a-lr+

,

++l:+ ,-Àl:À*+ al^-i.lt

: .;TK

^J-J-Jü

-l:L d

,'i.-l _ôLl=p3

c5_9cr;

:6blt .1j..lt -

.Ll§ll3 âelJ'ill JÉ,e ,Jr.o+s.li ,js

,''1-,

_{c.:Ll_;r3}

ô:s+ ,d§ll

JJÊ..11

-

.qEsll: ôcl-fll

J.,-

^crt+-i

#

,'L-t

C.rLl-,lr:

èq-+ :Ôltill

_JJââll

-

.qESIl: âelJÉll _»s

6)c

or Résumé:

Dans cet article

^le

chercheur expose ^quelques

études qui ont pour thème la dyslexie

-

dysorthographie. A dessein

de

cladfier quelques concepts

qui

sont en rappott

direct avec ce

^trouble,

L' enchaînement comme suit:

1"'axe consacré aux études qui ont pour thème le diagnostic ^de la dyslexie

-

dysor-thographie.

Zéme axe consacré aux ^études

qui ont pour thèrne

^les principales

causes de

^la

dyslexie

-

dysorthographie.

3 ème axe consacré aux études

qui ont pour

^thème

l'élaboration des programmes thérapeutiques destinés aux

enfants dyslexiques -

ôl^l-:ÀY

^t+1'.-,

J§ll crtt:,a:^ll _.1.

^q..BSJlJ ËelJill

-!^,e

^Jrü+

hÀ €k:

r.jr-iÀ"iü ^{LI|S^TJJ} ,qllSll3 Ëel.,;Ëll crl+ll-;»

é rlJJl3

^ô$*Ull

r+ ê

^C

^*1, i,-tÀ .dt-,Jr _6:l-,13 ./

^Ë-j3J

5!t çs:tl

.-rl-/,.aYl .Ilj+ll -,

!t

^*

-

r.xt+ç ,i,t _J! L.§ ^o+"t ffyt p3l'J3 q,,hll

i$.

Ë _-

I ''rtii c».Ül Cr.. ^.i

- itu-.4p* i-ll

_ L.ti(ltt ôrl.,,JÂll .}.c

.ii

,+Sk"

ai,â,

_k;cf3.t3 l.6itr.u.*

.

_{à. JJ} i.§rr

ot

_{_9*--Jl}

elli

OYL;^

qs:

.J-».,

"itt

drtu,,..-ll

ir _-$ll

^eiÀl»

^qEslll

^ËelJËll

u+Js J ^,:t-,,3t

^d-'lnj

-ÊjJ

"ttÀ!l ^gr

^{q.uJl ,.J}

^CH!

.-'.,..,'r'3

1J,àJ"JU

ü*^tl"ll ô;É

_{alÀxl g,.r}

.k+= d dtü

^C

tJü

Jss ,r4*tdll Êd$r.*

& ^{i+ af.}

crJ§ll

diir-ill

_{r-1 ;,5,;} ^{aJiSllJ ôetJill}

_{;*,c ç:3 ü. ,Jütÿ! JiSll}

_uJ

f$l ^J,.ÿl

,u*J:.dJl AlEl

ù.,s3: ,{+tj+ll

4*,Jr"Jl+ ËI'3ll

JU}": 1}*- ,J

cJa ;rl-i:-,Yt+ élli_9 e1"^'1.:^ 4:;;.)-ÇJ

+-;À.li ^{cjitr^} _C-3 i

'isi:ll

C :r+

Ldl++"':l-É-lr i"Esllr ôel;Âll _(J,,JJ$

ôJt

^cl_n _{ê.JJll +;:++lt: ç+,irll} ^èl-Éll

.U<+ ,liSU

â.it-ll

â+Jl,il

dtih.ll 1r-i,

^,La_Xc,

_UEjr.tiJ

à+t-ll

é ^pl,ill ôt+r",-,J:=,1971 Kirck. S

(élJÉ

ùr.-) ^dLci

^§.Â

:La

_{O*-,L-i c.U-l:..}

*;e eitr.j*.-ll 4§. ^{iir. I}

.4r'5L"1

,lA gL;.'.- -

.1grtsÎ

a!r3 crtr_r,,.,.-

-

élli * ^p*:

^,teJt+--l

^âr.',.-ll t:r

ç;.".1

irXll ^éll.l

^t

$

^r

^ài.

^.rl

al

4SlJl

_çJr*ll crLr.r**-

cl

^La_»r_l f«+!l

,Ir+, _.,-,lJJl

_JÀ'Till

drti.-l:. {.r.i

pÎ

,,.l,"

ee,all çill ^{L1ill lrÀ .,,t*} er--J"ll ^4*"ol lth: ,q.;rK!13

UFÉ,i,: _E lt+^

d

^üi=l+ll3 u",-./.rll ç+1 ^{c*+ tÀld} t*"àl3 to-.r=l:

crl.,llJl

.dl3(ll_r

jlJÂll .-Jl

_{e).c_l}

:,r:YlS

k $

^{_,r_11* â:)E}

Gir

^élhr .ql§ll_, âelJill _J,,"s cJi+ri"i,i

d ^É*+

^{ôl*,l-;.r :qfuIl .Urs*tt}

-

.ql§lts

ËelJill

;."e ç!-Ï

.,s ^dr.=+

ûl*,l;r :ojtIl

_JüÈdl

-

.ql§ll:

6elJill ;,.,c

6)c ^,J

^drr.+

^ùLl.;.r

:&lt3ll JJÊ.ll

-

JJI§i -4h*.,

-

^{r.yLre aLr.,p}

^ir.§

ipt-t+yt l_r!d13,-J.ry e§.

,"ftü _cX.r$

C).o ^.i

-

^{ÂJiilrl 1;r*. i*|.,p}

-

^{Lti§lll Érl.jÉll r..o}

C

^{dr=l+Jl ù-â-,1,l} i:rLl.;.l3 d:r o:+

ir"

_-,1-l-

Ji

^{4L^àlJ}

L

*

es

_,rJe3

.kl I'*Jl Lul .:lJl _3l

:

_{_1-elJl}

"*J

^cJ:Lü

ê ^L#,

ôrl.;É!l

J.e

^uÊiL.*i3

çr, rirr;ll &lJl§

_1,$t

ôLrlJJl :qblt

.lsâ-r!l :L.trs$3

:4#ll

^crt*,lJ§l

-

ⁱ

(1994)

:uô§l

^rr{Jr

L*J LIY - I

Éhi.E 19J /+-üS.ll

j-r;ll _{*J' -iJdl} ottÀi j§ _JJ

+-l-.plt crÀra

é

^,

^à.

^.JS

*1.*B k§l-Ê

ortt ,:t43r.^tt

rjr-.il e$Il3;_

¹³¹¹³ _cj-rTt

.-i.-lt .^Jr;-!iJl:

,â,.rr§^!l

j-r-jl

_{cr+ ç-r.-+tt} ^{j#^ill3} ,àeJ,^..*lt

otr,.-Tl _iJ#

^'u*üll

+rls"ll

^âlSll .,.I,c

üFIl: ^,t{-it!

^{âJ.+ yl â^lS}

_:l ^ti:-

ütS

ol*r j-r-il

^}+-l

.9!- ,/

4+J:S^ll a-lSS

* ^.iJ,:ll

^{,r-l,e ;;.rill3} ,(tÀU,.J leiLr el*

"r) [,r-f

l.ral

L l. I

^.loi _'1t5it

_C..tt, ^â§-*ll

^a.lsll

çjEll

^dbl=jll

,& i-l"ill:

,4i"=I

e$-l

^dJTl

^,il+ll

^u,*ËJ

,rljJ ^L+*

r.1" üJS3i 6ety _-;t-üÀl

c§ é-l .æ>.ll

LJïti:J

,çJ,4ll j#"tll3 ç,-,Jl

jÊJ"tJl :La3 Ul;Ëll .rl.r,:-,Yl

crl-i4-

_,-;a'4

L..1 ^{:LI. BII}

4J."Lll

^a.| üS.ll

j:.-jl _*Jr .i-Fll ôl-lk LIUI i.,.Àll olj,§l /.U:S"I L

^Kll _.,Jo ^{ü-ysll'9 e6.s.é}

q§l _.Jt üFll:

^{,a!iti, er-elLlt}

.i!l

.âSJ,"ll i-lSll ,ritt*ll LJlIJllr

, \,it-i.

^{e+-Éil| a-Kll}

hJJ ^,übJl

,nl

lq.S (328):

r,J:yt

, i.-ll

_ù^ âr;^h

P2Al

^{u," â-,TJJI ++o}

crlrs

c1,jùo

_"û,c, u"ô ç3hir.\tl e,I3ll

.

à.^ll g,.

ir.^$

(3441J

;lill ^{. a. ll}

^.ia

iJS cl^ ,.*l-1. i9ji.*,0 ^clSJ .r=l:

. à' _Jiüil d+- .LJill ^;S. ltl'i^, 4$lql crl:;^hl çlSll e"3"Jl â-8.

cr"-ilr^ll

ll1c ùilS-l .4$l3.it QJl+

^â-,-,1r.

+rl5Jt', ^{t t^"-}

-

r.xl+" éti+ ^Âr.l+ q"t û+y l*$., q,llyt Âl+.

I

,.rrut 6;.dl C),o ^.i

-

^i1l;lri

i,;r*

i*l3r

-

L.Esllt ôrl..fll y.c

4+..J1

,/

1+,!:._l a*,Jr^ll ê;,..

dr;. u. _çJhi,)l

^ô!l.:ll3

dHl: ^j3Tl

^,

;'

^tl

u*Jh.ll â+s,"'1"ô

LS.4"'r

é ç.ll oJl çrt;!Yl3

o-cLn3=.Yl q9:1."^ll_9

.éJrll

_cgrsj

d

^Éss.l3 â*,,p"J 4+r^ll ü^ (J"Jh^ _e..',j :

tllill

_,lav z.itjill 1'p ^â-,1-lrll

'ia o§

c-rl.;L

,

^à. _^i

,f

^{OUS r§ J-9ful . à. ll rJfi^§}

^{J a*Jr$}

^o-.pLî

-

¹

cJ-lsll

2J^ d ^\3r*-

^Or+

^d3!l

^{, à. ll}

^{crl\t§ J}

^{ç1 ,}

er.*^ll

^{'u*d -ltn:l}

élllo

J

^d,+ü

^t

^S

^.ôjJl

.pü

"Jr

³ⁱ

o3.-ll u"+ ,rt s

^{3T o3'^-ll}

"r+ i+ _Ct

,-ilJÊJl)

39","^ll 'u$ _elk+l .Jr!t .-i.-tt

^cJtl.o$ ül§J

4++

_cJ# ^tJ#,S, E3tii âJ$ll qd ,Jrÿt

.-Ltt

^{ôl-]3^E}

_i»l

^{lJ#s Ert^$ éluÀ} _6,1, (S.S9 ^o-.pâ

ç.;!*^!l

.(16.23

"-,1r§ ,r-ù*^tt eitl;r-,|) ^{:J.JiS^ll}

j:.-/

_.r-l,c

_{' tyill}

_.,l,È

Lul

1.6-'-J ,-i3JÊll _{e*,-l ct*+} ç-».411 ^''J*.:ll

g

^{,...r'.-Î ,(0/o67}

:

_tr-,-rll)

-i-r»ll _i-,J u# çæ+ll j#"ill Js

^,(o/n51

: l;-Jl) _êlill

Ê'r,^r3 ô.r.ill

leJ'" $ -i:-r-ll ü# çJ,-+ll -,+af u^ ,..r',-i etill

e-,;*a3 âÀ'i,ll

k

^,.J

.di.-û.Jl3 Llt^-iLll

6^

^o/o40

j _O'ttrl

rÂ

djfol ..i.-ll ^{,:lr;^$}

_6rl ^+-JrSt

ar*-ü -

^Z

.at^lSll

i*,J

^ü#

çxJt

^{j,*l,üll Oi Lr*üs}

^,ç-»-+ll j#"ill JtIil ^crl.rÿ

*tà[c,

^{+l*èll-9 Ë}

_u.-i]l

^crls-.pJl

-l"iJ J ^i*,lJJl

^cr;,61i

-

³

i).

^,§)3ll

^, if. ^ll

^{*1.:;^$}

,Je .+,*1 ^lrtLri ËjClJ

u-rS-ll3 e.*Jl3 i»Ji:ll g,"

,-r*-i ^l*[Lrl dLi"]l k .à] .i-l-r-ll ]+t _OÎ: ,Qiti dr.l#l

^LfJ

etrs.§

Llsll ,jle .iJdl

^i-lte+

cl

^eJBllJ

d$l: ^{cjrlt u-;.-tl}

^{c,hJ^E}

a-KI

"Jr .iJ,ltl

_,sls

;Jrill

_ü:'..,jsl

ri

â3)[:]l

,-i:Â--ll

c.l\t^F, _L,Î

qi+

^hÀ3

.4§+

aiti,

,-iJÈll

I+t ,È

^{âJàill ü+.iS, ü1 ,JS}

ir;i:.

jlj+ll _{-, !L*}

-

ryl+ otry ir.q;,:FLir.ll _{f-É'lll -Jrÿ} fu+.

{

,"ïEr ô$ll Cy...i ^{_ iit-jr-1 i.,-} ".. ^Ll.,,ir.l _ LEsllr 6rl.jÉll .y,o

.

à. ll ilhr§ _,JÊ ^{.rr..-l a-KI} _lsl. .iJ'ill

_üi ^:,*,lJJl

ôJéÎ -

⁴

-iÉl

^ül-à

^èll3l3 .jtlll

^s9:É.,*

,+ ^Li

^{.6.r-;iia A.ISI}

_"Jt .iJ'll _cl

cjrÿl

.,jl+Jl i

^a-fSff

^{*Jt .iJÉlf}

^g,"

^.'-.-1

.6UÂi. a-lSll _,,.l,c

ér.J (y'

^{l*âLir 4+-Js^ll a^KIl J+-l}

;:rk"

_OI ^4*,lJJl

':-6Li -

⁵

.r.l,c

...,"-1 i-lte-ll oil

^g13

âi)ill .-i.il| _iÈÂ:I ^i*.'ilI+ _c*-lk+ ,.+'-l

.eJ$t u

çil3ll

, i.

ll

ol+"§ )ca ^,

o:15!l

, i'

^tt _{Or cJrït}

_' i'

ll crlq^$

.r-l,c t*iurr 4+-üS"ll

i-lsll l+-l

Él-,ll**.-rr,-1 gi ^{a-,t*pt crJe.Ll}

-

⁶

6»

^,ta-ih.,

^â.Kll

^cJ:lr ;-,13,,-il1

.ifÿl .l+t : _,ra

^âDt3ll

si.i,-ll

^cJq.S

ot-r--!t

L.,1 ,a-!-.n.ll

ùSll 6

^cl-:11-r

^{Cdl C+lr^}

^.,Jc

.iJ,ll eü3;.ll

Lr-,1

.la-itq

â^IÉ!l

clilr âj,.all Lt-;

^efu3§.ll

loj:.f

^â-iSll

_cjill

^AiJ'-àll

-i!l ^Ia.;

,â-!Sll os

;Sl;Jl .i:-r-ll

_.,.\"

-iJdll

^{,a.i.ln â-lsll} -.;c.I ùJ3sll

iJ[e

LJJ Gâ-l$l

qi ^{ii3.r^ll}

^si3J,=ll

,] ^{.iJ,l1 ,qit4 gli]':}

^4l ç1ll

.,Jtét _*Jc

t<*^.,* gLo,..,-,

U él ^Â+Jill

^Lt., '|a.itq :-lSIl

clilr

^;r'"ll

c,l-i<" ";,-1 .r' d$l

^itJ.il.

^I "J" ;-Flt J ^a.Jr$

^o-,;gUî

-

^Z

éIh ,rtÊ ç".Js!l

r- ^{JJ r;+J}

^{d'§+-ll-9 .AUU ,-iJô.-ll}

^crl\l

^h

^*Jt .i-":ll

aL,i..*ll

â"$l

4-+tll)

dH:

^cJrït

^O*i;l

^{.,le ËJJË.ll} ;plJill qiS _O1 :J ,;-;ÇJl

.+BS lC Lt4rârJ ^e drLu..-,pi

ql t-lt*tt

elhl

,-'-.-ii

_C

eS, (--r

¹⁴¹¹

fb

^,J+

..iJill

d,t"-i$J

"§l tr"+^tt

60/o14 (-11411) 4.1t ,;EIl

r-i.-ll âijâi çl

^,o:U+tt

j+Jl

_,slÊ

_{iF):il çl-r§}

_ôÎ

C ^ôF+ll ee ^us3

d"" ^,I*J ,j

^ajLi

ÿ ^{e.ju oli}

^{i-,;r.i.- c.rl.u3}

C ^{(l.r+l) 4+Jd}

^A-lSJl

ird)J

^,,,j-.;r:

üfu oi J! ^èJ-+ll

^c.,3Lf

^tÂ

câ.l-eiS^ll at^lSll

.Jr ^.jJdll

.,Jl4ll dlJJl ôltk-

_,rJr

_.trlt

^,

i.

^ll

rl

^{le r,rl 4Ërih:+Yl}

^âI.-rll

+llJ

-, ^.*L*

-

{}l;e ^,:,ls,} i*l+ {pU.+yt pjrlll3 ^crJ.§l Âly

."dii _uÉrll C)L..î

-

^{lrt t-':}

i**.

Ll_!

-

^{tLiStls 6rl;Â11 3"e}

'!i*"1

drlJl+J

^gl\J "l",ll

ùEi! ùl

^ù...tSll

^,#=l

_Alli3

d.-,+L|

8

i axl ^{*Jr .iJ,ill: ,4üir}

^.-rjiS.Jl

.i!l

^j+-l-r

g-r.-;I j*lôlll tJ^*

^!l

J) çUt ^{, à. ll g;} :lr;

Y3

,,llïl

^,

^à.

^tl

C ^,t ïf ^,

i..^rl g..

:lr; _ébJl

.,llEll si.-ll

(1994) ,

p1ll*! Àl ^{.p'q.^,,} Lt1-

2

1,,:I

cJ.,-e*.-l Ëj*^.ll

1§jLJt -.ptt.ll

^.y:,

^.

^à.i(ll

!J

i-,|-;-rll

oira

d,1. (28)

,ôEYl dr

⁽¹¹¹⁾ ÊeL

)it

(139)

â-lJJl â!o ,.,i^..',3

_,4,61d11 :qlEll d.rl3§l é^t+ll

.riiul3..L:ll d

d.rL_or.-a

ô. ô3ltJ g;$l

_1§-rll

(1978 ,CL^- é_,, .^-1 ^.rl.lcl) _;j,.= ll ^çlS$l u^Li.

-

(1981 ^r Myklenust

cr-§L

rlrcJ) .\., ^l',ll _-».li:

r-r,l+^-

a!*3ll

ol.r.,.-l

ËjÉ,".11

1§JLII ôYt+-ll

_i1c,

^,

à.ïSI ,J+Î ,_r. ^clll_l

r ^:

^o.ltIt

^4+jt

^.,1e

^4$ul

élÂJl ,é-.;sll _,i*lslf; .4+él

,i-ërJ':^ll

âilll

,o*^^.,!l

ell;:)l

.dl,ü+Yl

_çr4À*Tll

, ê

^L"

dlsl

cr".;6Li

Jé§t

^crL+_rr

ôtt*,Jt

_ù#

_4Sl.

-,! âIÿ.:

crli

_cljJs rJ+_, Êre

_

¹

.â.".Àll

t".t

_i'1+

4§rtJl

_{_.pl}.ll}

d

^&Uyl

^{c.Ç_! ott*ri.,}

cjtüî *§;.r ^r:lÀ-r3L _{dH UL,} -l

^âly.r

,rli _ciry

^r_»-9

-

²

.q,+-À+tll

élJJl

,++-êl

r.i d

^Lrbiij4ll

Ët$l çJr

^uJJlJl

é:+ll ^{oia ciot+} rir ,ù:ll drtJJ*l l§ÂJl ,ll!: Jl _f r.*.r

â;lll:

.*-^^.,J1

cll'lr)l çJ*i d ^Uî,p_xlt

^ruj,,:Jl

ç3i ^oL)l dtitl _Cf*J

ctt^L:.lt

oç,.!t _Jtul dL-l ^*ilsà

^{l!-,,tj^lt}

jj$l

_-,

_it

* _{= rrt*o} otr3 ir.§

t"t

^i'Jl lrhllr ^+hyt it+.

,:+!il _ûgall CY.â.

-

^{Â.1tjlrl i.s*.}

i*ll -

^{L.t:slll irl.;Êll -ro} ,,IÊ ^{ü*ür+ll qr.il â-,lJàll} fL"3Âl 6,'as^

4§Jul

_{-,1lt.Lll -rLf,ijl}

-

³

.,fj.rll _6r.tt uiliril-r .ptL^ll

^oia

qiliii

_{Y3 rl*9i-} .r=

,!Jt

^d1c

_CJI ^{*!-5*.= -lÉ+}

Êl-3ÀYl ^Ë-,13

É+

^4-,lJJl

'"',oJÎ

^ri3

-jii cl. le-tit L-,.l,,lill

ol-.»ti

ét-o ^V ,;-,4^iX-Jl ijJ,ll _6-l;çll rÇ

.ê"i-ll3

;;,-,!13 r;Â!J

a;L; 1pLht,

^i*"i1

1994

; ;t'&i" 4*

^{*'t',;r

_-

³

Cdll

c-rlaj*..a

çJi ^rJ.)Sl ,Jt -iJ':ll C ^{â*,lJJl '"irÀ}

cri,ÉSr ^,C.*3Jl

ûtr3n---; al.$-rll .l"l3rJt{ üJ.lJl _ç,e3

^qgrr

^iÉ;r-3

.4"'51r3+Yl

âL-*Jt d,r*-;r3tl+,i*ltÂll ^{g* â-J,-3 J'.o (100)} ar açll

AL-*JI d ^Ci3ll

d.rt-rj*-.a;

4t$-*ll ,J^l3,ll

ül.r,r'''l

Ai-Ul

^gg

^r:'i*t

.(1989

,çrl.É;êl -;J slscj) ,qÉlsr)l '"t

., .,

, tê

^{t.or3'le i*'lJ'rll} _6-ütl ^crl:

ô1r.3**.,a1Al.üJ"Il ,j"lJ,ll ül"$J

d

^fu,t

^-=l

^âIÿr

^dli

^{,.3:-rg ly+y Ê)"}

-

¹

d"'I d+.

_çri ^/,luLll _ee-15;

ü:jr+

ix§l du"LIl

$)i: ^er§3 d.tl-i^ _ü*

_Cnll

.rih.$J

J"ilti

ee+=

d!

^ixÈll ix"t"X

ôl+j ôtt-j.

_c*.-r ç*;»:"ll â.iîll

pca ^j+,ll+

(-}"t,=yl

cj.l:t iF

^JS

çf ^ô-rJ

^53É

^Y :

2

ü#

^{rt+T g,o a1}

!S* L3 .o-,|;Jl A{il! ^cll§: q},y .i:-.,Ell:

_u"ü!l+

Éllâ*Ji^J ,..r;jl

_,.d

üJt+

a-rll OU^l'

ll ipi

âc-9,";-

drh-rr dilÀ-i^

.J.àsll d ^üJt

^J

^asll

O*^1,-ll +»15

aéJ,"-

crt.i-lr

,J.t" i

^(0.05) q93i."r

$t 4$t _',!

^â§r.r

sli _cl:y

^r+-r.,

-

³

.JÉ$l

U+.lr-ll:

^.+-,rll

,J ^O:U+

Ur$t üJ^Ir

ll gl ^\l

^l''llJ

_Êul

_{UJi àDt*lt}

'

J"b'll

,.J O:U'*

.r,l§l -' ^l*t'-

-

<yl.,s É,I-Je;r.t+ 4PL.by fJ*!l., ^{q,hyt fu+.}

,-rut _63rll C)[- ^.î

-

^itiJt

l4p* Ll+r-

L.tisllr irl.;É!l .pc,

1993

: dU ^{æS" Jjrr.r}

^,qPÉ.,

Lr.

ôLÂUU â*,1;.r

-

⁴

iüXlI

6jÉ^^ll â+,.-Ài,ll cJiail.

rll

_.rJo

"rr:lt

^,tilJ

Jj

^{â*,l-pll eÂ.u}

611_,/l ,

t.

^tl

_{o! t.*n}

_FTls h$13 (5s)

g* a.i'll

^,',1(.*

,C;'ll

*1.r3,'.^- ç3.r

:ql[ill c,tr§l

_{alrri.,rl ..r-9} .oels")l

. i. ll ,.J,.-ll3 t#-"Jl âilll çjrL ir ^Js ç!

^,€'.-*LTü

J§il -

(oSUr

^J.rcJ)

'6lél

dùls"i'^

â'it! -

(CL- é;

^."-1

^Jæi)

.-.1;r.-.ll etS§l _-,!-üÀl

-

,_,[iiJl àie

ùJl ^qo

.rlæ,!),rJ_eU

AL]X

' :ê

^1-

_C i-,lJil îfl;

5itr t''e"il _:6.5tiill

ç:i dlitll

^'3!C*

of-ir*al3

^{Ë-1jr.4 JçLJ}

^4+J*-ll

g.5»:r" _ù]

-

¹

;-,p,!t t-: _feilyi

_ru+t-,.1

i: ^.srLt+fl f*!Lt ^{DlÀ ô" crLrr,-I}

roc.l"3;,Yl _,-St-Éll crl-r3r,,o

ô"

lÀL"il

ùr* ;ar .,-itijl

^âoL+s A-,-r'r^ll3

.

rrjll-r,llillr

oletr':Yl3 Llt+Àll3

.i-r+ .rl*)K r,'

^â.rËtill

^ai,lJùll ir

^LE

./ ^{4St^l}

^4Iÿr

^crli

^r.3-l}

d,\r - 2

^.

3rc_e ,6;À;.Jl

*

_{33»:iJlr OLI|}

u

-,i_!i"Yl .q'lt'iiYl

üljû/l frc:

^+pLoi+yt

dÊ ùà

,J"ült+

ffi:,fl;+Yl

^cll-,;oll

_frcr ,tl-lj,..*ll

_cI^.:

.u:

AJ"$-"^ll _dl^.3 .A.Eihll â3o

É _+rilJl

^r

^ir.'

_J cU"iill Lt,a

.r.:

_o"üll

lt"à

^{r à-."}

,

.U"iilt+ âÂll

J i'n=,"i.LlJlq i.-ul

CrLs*^-lt .-5eJ,jÊeÂ1,Ée,'r+:lJl A-sJ^+- i1;; éllr:

I w tP J .J a'r !P J, rw

.ll.+yt s:

eljù.iYl

r+.J

^eùEX ols3r;.^Il _{r-u+ câ:y.r+,e}

;Sj+J -, !L*

-

uliÊ ^.:f.Jl i-l+ i:pt 3i.yl ç3hll3.,.l,r5lt iJ;.

:

,:$U ggsllg)ta iilJlrl Âià,- ^â-13.r

-

^{L.l5ltl3 ôrl3il. I ..pc}

:4#i$l

^ét*,lJr$

-

^qr

:(Stanovich and

Keith I

^l9g7) 'o!<J

'obl, JiE

_' ^â*''l-p

-

¹

ela.rr..rr33

Ëel;$ 4t"C

^d.i+JE

-ll ,+ ^.-iJ,3ll C ^i*'lJJl

^c'd':r

(68)

.,lc

â-,lJJl Alio

ô!;^il ^eÔtr3Jl

^orÀ Ü. ,.il.tri

él

drYLIl U''iti''ïiJ

.ËelJËll

d

C-: d,rtr;aa Ê*itl ,sll:3l.Yl

e$I ^ü'-ll+

^l+"8

L-,^

ü,lu4 ).it ^{(17) q.s3} é

-,!-r--:)l

cr)':L'o drÀ:-t+ :fEJl

ir

^{4$J.-ll ËelJill ôt+Jr,â}

ir

^ô3,,ti

)ü (15): 'i:Fl-Jl

^{'ocl-,fll ér1'r3*'a}

.i+Jl ,:lyl 33r.;"

(Christina ^{Van et} al 1993)

:ipijs

Crtâ

rul 'ut i*"l;'l -

²

6BSII ^{J*yüll3 Êel-.ftl}

d

^{eri:Il 19r..}

^{Lr éi-5ll} C ^{i*'lJJl *ira}

.il§,il1 ëljl ^ü,-ll

^+à13

ir

^4+J

^drlJi-

^dJ'3

^él" -b

^e«+lt:

1t"i-Yl3 ôl+J',é .:;r=i: ë$ü l,-1, ir". Êa;.t"

^éll§-r

'lirb ^(ll') U ^1+ll

^d'ilill

â§1

.

^a,l*+ _fc!-lfir^

1-}t. ,:"

^él!i3

^.1pl-;$

^ai-Jl

+tç ,t'

ÊJdll dù[S^i'r

-j.u ,Jo ol-jirYl3

_u^JJi^ll

^{g* ic ."+.} ,lr§'J e ^{',r.'ltUt +Jsll}

^uÉ

.\»l3l oYid

^ôe3-ÉJl3 âer".*Jl â'rtJl _uPl+L

t$-É él: ^{+vt!l ajJl}

41 ^+gt

-=)

^{4.Iÿ.r c.Ji l^ârJÀ élLiÀ}

J ,+ i*'lJJl eU' o-lii

^:6..58:ll

_'

â,i.-5u"llr ,L,:À.3.,*ll u*iJtiJt êJi+ ^{,#Ê a*JJJI}

.éo:*

^d''l+-È

^{Ôll--É^}

lsrS _,l,alif ^drL.J',é

çsl

^rJt'üTf

^ùl

^e'à31

"u-

^ofi3ll:

^3La-Yl ir

^tJS

,l

.i,j*rLJl

$)t:tl+

^{tu-ltL t4JJ} ËJl,l,)l ürLJl _et{4ll

e*'+ çi )+-J

^dÊi

jj+ll

-, !L*

-

^{(J',l,ae ,:fr,1l ir.t+ (fLil.$ p*Jl3 çlrït}

ily

,"fti: _ggrll

CY.. ^.l

-

^{i*!t-, is..,..}

Lll -

a+tisltr irl.;ÂJl .r,c :L.Esll3 ô*l.;Êtl _J,{,'s

u.iÂ..ii

_çr,

drl+,;ll

oL,..l.;§l

,§ dJilll ,-l-É.il

,''-rlL1 c,l_lln

,fl

el*.l.;Jl3

,3l-+ll

_,-!11Jl

Éj,ll ,:È

o.à

hÀ

r,-*i.ii ^crl:ls ôLlJJl ,io _ù] :dêl J ^urli-:

^,LESlls

^ôcl;il|

-:*ç

:.jYlS Ç!$ ;.r

^:.$-r

§l:^

U. ^,JlJL.àYl l_,rl$il â:=t+ll

cJ..l.i."l (1994

^:ei-.pJl

+'-,,

^{t+_,r) 4*,1-,1r}

é -

¹

ôlJk*ll c++ _çl3llr

^cJJTI

ôlej+lt

u"::i;

,rljÊj

â,.!^,,

rJ ùrS! ^Ëelê

,t;!t

U"ri:J

.ç;»^4ll

j*yüll-9 _{,ç-^^,Jl -lJ*o:ll}

La3;et;il

rlr,i*,YLr

â.-tll

uJiS^ll

.illl I+J

_q+", ,"_üS.ll j_r_rll .,Jc

.iJ,ll ol_;Ç

a-l§Ul â.".Àlt

,éÇ.Jl cd

+;S.lt LKll ,+ ,-ilillr

^rËrs.§

^â.lsll è ^,-iJÂillr

^,4itt+

.i§-*ll

a-"KIl

,jl+ll ^dl,,lJtr ,laih"

⁴⁺ üs"ll LlsJt

Lu3

YJtr: élb 6tS

(199a :ur#r

_{n$t_»J}

Àl .+"

^{,l'*., â.-l_,p)} _,s,

-

²

ed.rl_.;,Éi^ll

uà'+ t*+à-,

^4$Ldll

pl,lll crtr.pj 6jri..ll 4sÀJl

_{_.pl-E} Il

ç--r.ill

cl J-,ll_r é..;..!.|*

.i*Bl:

^{a+él_l a!_J.j^ll}

^â;lll:

qF* ^..J1 éllJrytS

4t$-*ll

_d^l,*Jl

é,]:Ei .ii (1

994

:sl.:a^â^-rrr) â*,t;r

", -'î*''

.+sls.l+yt

aLll irx ^(,J _fdlt

^oL.r-.

_"l

Àl .È:r

^{J o.os-o3} _{o.cE_l} ^{.l^s.} 6t*Ul.:) a*,t.p

,',. . i

_rJ*=

!+

⁴

.rl,All cr113*.-

ç3i

^\yXJJ r-..-À-T,ll 1,.5L-Àll ^éIB,r.l!

k

^l-Snl

^(9319r

_Ct-

"J" .iJ,ll C (1997 :,'U(J .UilrJ,iE-)

â-,1;r

driu_r -

⁵

oil u çJtü q,lll ÉyLrll u:+S3

^elaqrsJ3

^{Ëelê 4+rCl}

^crtr3*.-ll

dr

ù3rlt+

&rll ^cjtitYl

^+.ls3

é

^_;l.r=:Yl crY.rl.r-o

plr-i-L,

(ôLJ,,,.-ll

.4*ir _rÎ i!F-t- !*gl+r ù. ôJ,lq a§l jtüïl:

_1$

* iel_j oL3*,-

.1rl.;J -, ^r*L."

-

r.xt+c otry in q {+"Ll+!l esLll.l +ltyt ^fu+"

cati: _6sSl 6].a ^.

-

^iJJrt

^is*.

^i-l.1r

-

^L.t4llr ôrl.fll .rc,

"Jr

k+LÀnl (1993

:iJrJiiJ

_6ls lrr"'*US) â*,1-,p dJjSJ

L+ -

⁶

.a!,,:ll o1,13,,,-

ç:i it ^dfjtTl

^t{-$:.1}

él

dDls^î^ll3

al';3n'-ll *i ^+lâ:

gt3rTl ^,JFaÉ.i,: crà'ei'J

.pl ^cr[l-;.ll

^..1.

fill

^hÀ

ùÿ ^{.p[:' g'3}

l,c,tll

drl+_.,---Jl ge

ll.r

^CIl.:a _Ui

_{Ci^ri , $),:ll}

LrJ ielJiill

-,..,r1 4+t-ÉI ,i-"lSll ,-jJ,ü)

i ^fi+J,.é f6r ^fuJêll

^6elJill

^{çr di+JF'-}

:la;^ icl-,f!l

j_r-!l _.,lc .iJdll crl;Ç

,ç_,1'^4ll

'ï*"illr q',Jl

^ju*.:ll er-i.:-ll ,alLàyl

üjillj

^e6.r,a.§

_',

^I<ll (Jle ^,-iJrnJlJ

,a.it,

.-.r3iS^ll

.i-Fll

^I+-)

.y':

^{+J:S^ll}

it ^{*ll JC.:llr ,la.ih.}

â,.ris.ll a.lSll ^J+-.1:

,él;.Jl ,s t*jill a-KI

_.,IÈ

ar-*ll)

_o-à

*lr3*"- r5: ^ai.LJl

^ËelJÂll

^{oi ot.-r,.- kr.: .(+§JJl}

^â'lsll

g*,l

ü-,Jl

_,rJc

ol.-er,-J

dst

i^ y';Jl oL:".- _JJi JEtll é$

^t"S

'(f*rlt, .ost"i=)l3

ç."ii]l

J,l,pJl -, ^{;rr- -}

-

o"!e ^,sLr.! irr§

ist

i+yt pSLll3.,.l.ritl

lly

."ïqi ôrillC)l,o.i

-

^irlt-'t

ip*

Ll.p

-

^Llisll3 ôr|.fl|..,l.,c

:4*a)tÂ

tê

^l-+

^I:i,-i

ü1 UIS"J

é+, L^

pç;.rl gs§l

dlüTl fL,-

^ü# +ESII: ËelJill

-xç

^,-rl

rt:l

_J,iü+

-

¹

.-ta olr-r.-

' r '

..u.ll al,*ll o1-r3*,-

ç,ei ditïl _6^+ ùl -

²

i'ru,'rr. _L!' u,u''+

.q*sr-, 6erJÂ,

,J ,,..,'

ê*,J

q,u

"*ir

,.r.,1

Îq: ,;ll ^{*t^lsll}

^j,*,,ü

uf A:-

^{cJ3Tl ,}

i. ^tl +.)i ^q+ -

³

.üjJl _{,Jô .,Ic} U ,l

^{dr q.-ll L,"s+}

_ç{ll1

3i ojr,.-ll

ç;»4ll ^{j#^ill} g

^{,-.,*,.-Ï eôLISll}

_{f-J i»l} fJ,-jl

^{''#,3ll ,i)}

-

⁴

-",J

i;r+

ç:r^+lt 't*dl

₆₁₃

,êtill

Ëj'^ÀJ âr.iJl

k -J ci3!l _1-t

_i»t

.j:»ll

_uJ+

_ç-r,-+ll

_**.:11

6 ^{.-r'.^-i} _CJI ,;-J

^âr.ï,ll

^t*o-J _-i:-r*ll

i

.dL..i^llJ

ù-irJl

k+*^à.5l

6r.,i,ll3 üJJ$ll ^drLJX.cJ

+l*tll:

ÉJ+,-i.ll drlsJÊll

J+-l ül

⁵

cr.l

..Jl

^J+-l

_{,-* âiXll} ,-iriJl iü ,Je

^.,,,,o1

^l*îLrl

;j,oell3 6 ^qS*Jl,

.i:>ll .!+t _cl" .r-.-l

^leit

^if Lj^-i.ll k+.à9 -ir>ll ^J+t ui-l

^,la.itq

.l*it

^rl

Llt-it"ll

^te

t

^a3rl

üJÉ,il _iF)Ll

,slÊ ....l,*ii ^ai.l,j+

ç;S"Jl ,-iJ-ll I"u

;-lt<+ _Cl

-

⁶

\Jr _{ul çi,+}

^{liÀJ r6.rs.§ A"KII}

.Jr .iJrill ^e:k+

^{c.r. êJEIJ}

o:tilt, jrll

IJI..üSJ ùT d§ ^â.r;ii.o a..KJl .,.l,c

.iJJl

_,rJc ^{i-.pil| I ,+-üSl -\â a3)ill}

^üJÂJl

.â!+

aitl .i!l

^Lt_2

p

;_pill

d5Jtt -, ^t u-

-

urt1e Él^.1l ir.t+ f*oUryt

f$llr

çtsyt Âl+.

,.tÈr i,$!l c)L. ^e{i,'§ ÂF.- ^Â-13.1

-

^{aqESIi3 6r}.,fl1 .;,o}

,JrTl ,

;. tl \l")[i .,lc

^,-,.,'-1

^,iUJl

^{cd LISI|}

,Jt ^.iJ,3ll

^ù)

-

⁷

,+ ^.iJ,3ll

^6!À &ll3l3 ,n,,[ill .9 ü.".]l

*Jr tl

^{cô.r ]ri^ â.lSI}

_,rJt .iFll

Cl.

.,jl+*ll

d ^a.§ ,È "i-r-fl u

.+,,.-1 ôr ri:. ^{â^l$l}

I+-l

_,,s

Lrr*- il+yt

^eJ|Sllr

d$l: ^{cj-fl| '} i' tl +Jl3 q+ -

⁸

i.1.

dJYl ei.-ll ii): ,JÊ .J'-1 ;tk^ll

^ora

_üJr ^leiLit

^{LrÊS^ll}

^i-KIl

.dJtill ,

i.

-lf

rr _çjLIl ^{, à. I ir)3 ,ilÊJ}

^c,r.ilïl

^'

^{a' -ll}

\^)3

"J' .iJdl

^ôl-j,.e+

,-,;1 .r' #Ul ^JiilJl ,È

^{;-1$l ù)}

-

⁹

ç1

,;u+ll

JiJ-:ll ,sle

\Jrll

^{,.+J§ ô1} J,! ^Ôr*+ll

etr ^us,

^.â:)3ll

^ürÂ.-ll

cje,l

OI

+lli

_..1.

r.,iu drli 6Jii.â

d,rl'*J

JJ (q+.tt) t1;*:t al$

^âij?S

çJJs

iJSa ajî

C ^ô.=ill

^o-,1l,i,1

^t

^{S e âr.3§^ll crt}

^{lsll ,JÈ} ,-iJ"ll

^lt*I"o

.etSl

Ji,À3ll

d-;k- &

^,lrYt

^si,-ll

^{L;) ehi'J A.l3-}

^l$r)l 4LJ"ll

ir*o)j

I+-l: çy;ll ^j,*Él]r

33^,.*tt j'ii"3 ^ôlJt{+J

iû3ll Ott!

O)

-

¹⁰

,J_il| ,

r. ^tl g* rl"r;jé!+*ll i ^iXlt _"J' ^{-iJJlr 4itl+}

^{,-r üS^ll}

.i!l

eJ$ ü.-lt _.r{ ;tïl ^{. a.}

^{!l g^}

^rl.r;

^Y3

^{.r/$l si.-Jl Jj}

JllilJ -,

!t

^-

-

ol,|f ati3 ir.§ _lfU+yt fsLtls.J.tyt il+.

+!U oH$ C)...1

-

^iilJ.J

iar*

Lf.,p

-

^tti$,ls 6rl.;Êll..,y,o

:4{ti§ll

Ërl;§l

_J-*e

ïl+*i

^,,râ

^{êrrlll c,lSLü.ll}

ert*,I-;rll :o.Lïll JJrÂll

: Lyll

ot*.l3.r!l

-

^T

(2000)

:,r$i r$ld i'gl Lty - ^f

,Jii.-JL âLLll

ËJShll

tLÉtl .9r.

i1o ü,i,SIl

C ^4-,lJil

^c.rÂr-t

Jé§l çn

^(f

3a) rcj^

^{ô+14§r lrJ.§ (236) ,1.}

a+I dr:isi

^r§3

,o^,.:Kll

é

ç*,t*,Tl

ËI,jll

^4*iEll

âitll g. _;EJl ü,-ll \i)j ^{g* dil-i)l æ}

^(102):

ir

sa-l â*,lJrtl ^Ëh'ls

ALIJI

i-,Sl.rlï

.,,UL

.,-!e A-,IJJ,

:Ï,:JFl

.â3-1jl rl.ro!

ç;+ (0.05)

$I,r éJi.". r.c $L-.1 ^iJl:

,fu-;à r3ç'3 ,rJc _6':E:ll ^crl'r

4+J.-+ll d.c+ll,â+Lilll Êts+ll

dr

^dS

of

^Cr*+rul:

,l,all crt;j,,"- _ç-ei \"XIl

ja3 rfs:lJl id:ll *ry _CllJ

^:'ilSll

^{4+JJlj a;rül} _{itLill ft+ll}

^,aplSJl

çl ir

41rLJl +È)llll df$

aLÜ

ËJshll +*l't _-, ^Ëct§ ie-ri,"r

ttü-:l or,; u icl§

qg-ei.-.)

F d**i .,lc

^{4-,lJJl cr§Î} S-r .Â;*,lt

Syl

_1.,

p,:ll ot4jn--

.C':ll crl-r3"*o J+,,ü

d

^{(âLLJI ËJSlIl}

^tJ'ti:

(1997\: ô*.r r..i r"* i!..â"

i.-,,l-;.r

-

²

aLill crL3*.-; ât$J"ll

^1J3+Jt

J.l3,lt *i _"Jt ^.iJ':ll C

^c.,À-

d$jSi .(ôUylJ -léIl)

g*+ rl-r-rrll

ühl

.4"tihûr)l

âLlll _{+;.)'j .s.l}

alrri.J é:

(ç-il.$,,.Yl

ëljt

^,

i. ll

_,"é

;\rS: ^{hJ^§} (196)

_{c.l^ 4+Jl}

:qlBll

c.,'tr§l Jjics,o .rlæJ)

.Crlll

crl.r3,r,o

ç:$ ^1§:Ul "1..:t'

:'tl .r!L -

(1994 ^{e .:l3c}

.:.*Î

,Ct*

Àl ù*

"»ljglt -, ^iru".

-

sr.t+c

otry;r.§

l+"t +yt e+trlll d.ryt ^Âl+.

'"tlil o+ll C)*a.

-

^{i*ljtrl i:p*. Ll_»}

-

^{irlislls ôrliÉll y"e}

(1978 ,C1^-

é-l ^."-1

^rhcJ) .-,13.-^ll elS§l Jt$Àl

-

-!-Ël

^{r+e .rl.rcJ)}

^.6-j*fu çst"-i§Yl

q,.ct"3=Yl ^q9 qi,.*ll

u"liù. -

(1995 ^(LJ,-i3,ll (c,=utt

rtuj) .+rTl

^4fo+lr _c}l+L

-

ç.:LJ§Vl3 çel-3+Yl ^19-ü..*lL ,l,alt crL3*,.-

!t$-ll _,Jc

_AJUtll

d$

.ditü LlJt arÉl

^4si+llr

:â,.r.irÿ drl*.l-.1.rll

- ^ç

:(Vellutino and Frank 1996) ^é§lJà ,Ji*:J*l*â

i,"11-1

âel-fll

û1{J,-.,.â ç:.rJ

+*:p-ll

^{ô}+eJJCl i.àJ''-}

C ^4*,lJJl

^crÂsa

o.à

)i.t (118) g,. i-,|;.rll t+p c.,i:S: - ^{6)*ll -.,è,.J} P ^ilJ§l - a+I Jyl

_,=-˧

.;cl_fll ol .:L,3*- dr

^ü3,lt

r o..

çJhÊr)l ^cJ3Tl ü,-11

,ç-rl iel-;ill crLr.r!.,jUs ailt ^dU§l

_-)*p.l

^{r.., ôJtÀs t.-tÀ t-+ts}

âelJill

c.rl-r3*.- '1-,i:

gg$l

oY3a

i1c 1;-1.,ïl ^4#JËJl crL.*.-ll

^.-.r;.,i

ol.1tSiYl

.istr.l

^1++x _îa;$

,rle

^,r.rS1

_oJt .l**tl

4Jj ^,",1. _Jü

t

^{4*,lJ.rll o:o} güEi

oqï

:6dEill

crl-r.,,.-ll â+jx

l*,Ü LU

U4

ü1..àll

ct-.fll

"ga

^.s.!

^+$l+ll

cr)S...^ï cj

.düIl

q9J ^{4J^*irÂll}

:(Willems _et at 1996) Og-nig i"t*l+.,

i*,1$

-2

dr J!

^a..-lÀ

^+*r-r*,IA

^{crl4jn-^- .r:+:} a+tS^l dr=+

C

^{â*,1-2rll c-rÀ.ra}

dJ^.i,J

.a*tKU _/,,:ll ol5n*- ge

il53',.,^

J$d

^(JSSll eéll-,pYl ,'l+:iYl)

âL-*ll i;,)r3

^rdrlr:-,

_ê+- u

^.J§Î

* ^{6^^}

^fut'a=fl

âLy _iÊE

4-,lJJl

.jlj1$ -, ^:rt *

-

r.xlrp ^,-:,tr.;o ir.§ lpU+yt pjürl3 çhll

ily

I

I'

,"rgr ô#ll C),o ^.i

-

^4;l;lri

i;r*

^Ll;.r

-

L.Eslll ôrl;Éll .;.,c

+^)Er

^côl

sb (10J 09)

_drr{

1$^jll *-lu'Î 6:l:Ë ^cl..

4J"e!l 4,'ihi')l

é.:r- ^(13r

^{11) c»,}

^{t" t!^jll} *J-'i 6-i-» ü," ËiE^ll

^{+Sl.lil)l aLJ^ll '}

*l! ^iil,ryl+

^{,-rL.Jl3 4+-,êll Ëel_!ll_e}

ai.lJl ^ârljll+

^4,.-1À drl-,)tnil _dË+I":

ir

^JS

æ ^uSlJt

^,I'3!l

otlrn-4

â.-1À crl-.rL$ly 1J+^-e

-4;."il ^ÔlJL:il

.j.:ll: ^éllJr)l

^{, olnj-ÿl}

:

r pl,:ll ^crL3*-'o tLÉ-ll

.rlt ^,.1.

^:6dlsJl

.-,S$l-r

éllJiyl ,

^o§jYl

olLc

drtJlJt^àl

-

.â-r.,,;ra:

4+!

dr)S.i,.

- ^.f:rll

^+1,»!*;l

- :Llisl

^ôrl;Él'l _{J'^"e +l+*i os}

es$

^e,l.rtji

_slll

cil*,,lJJl _{(,.!È éJtr$l}

.eb

..1"

ql ^,"J. _-f L3

crLl-.;rll gn a^cj,";J

"+l ü*ul cr-rll ^tt"

,J"lJrJl 6elJËll -I..Ê

.JtpÎ ir

^ù1

^{,'!i..1 dr[-l}tl}

g." âcar";^ etta

J ^g-+

,.gtt.-")

Llr

^{c.-.6ü "34,}

.çL;o)l3

,4:;c1^i-)15

,§rTl3

,1ill,-ilYlr ,iit -^-ll 6elJÂ$

e iW

^dJYl*

^{ë^+}

^r,+ âSii.i"

jhl:' clt

_OI ⁽¹⁹⁹⁷ :ü",= r^=i .r.o.^

LÈml

^,glt\(,

,u#H:

eç.tL.o:§)i3

,oelJ+ll

_é-ri,.*ll

Éli§l ^e+-

cl" ^ful5ll3

c.)1.

_{6r"+ a;r! +,li'll}

uplylt .f+ ^r:-.::

rrl3Jl e1ts-'

,J d$-'$l

ç93['"0

.drYul _{6,r^+ c;rl .,lt} ^ôYl

,JÈ.à)l _*Jt

^AJtll

.ÈliYl

^r-F.::

_'JiUl

l-»S l;3.r

.+$.r! Ç!-,i

^r-r+J dU,§g crJÀÎ ^c.rl*,l3r elt'u ₆₁ Vi

rilÀ 61;ct ü+Yl3 ,qrL.i§lYl

J.lCl

^c"ül+

J,! qEsll:

ËelJill ..1*- JJçL

.J

ôJShJl

1*!'L: Ëel§

_,J,.:ll

ol,-e",-

(2000

:n+]j rSlyJ +J; ^*t-r5

^{r'rl^r-.;}

ell-;.rll

,,l,:iYl) oa alE d.l:o ,JÊ

⁽¹⁹⁹⁶

:-r"U*)

_-,rS-,1

Op .,! ^'4Lut oJstl3 .+§lt$l crl;$t O+ _6i: ^{l<I.+. ,*s çt+-Tt oiÀs}

^(JS§ltr

J3lj+!l'd,ù-

-

^{(J{l+c c,tr; ir.§} ilÊt i.Jl _esl,Jls +ll$ if+'

,''ltij r*rll Cl,. ^.i

-

^idt3lrr

!s*. i*ty -

LEsJll 6rl-Éll _.p,g

rÀ â.-lJl

^âel_,$l

;.-

^-,a-.,*,i

_*1

^..1"

,j

^(teeO

^clilyr

^{,+ÉrJl+J i.-l-,p}

."Phonological Cause" "q,++Jôll',33.-ll,,,i.jil :i".OLi

.;tr.rTt

^,.,-,..J1 _-9,r

qEsll:ËelJtll

^{-^"c}

ç!*,1

ani ⁶¹

- ^t

.A+*

_{dl].i1 .*j'U}

,.'"rill

^;§-1

ll ç§,ll ^6L$t

^,11

-

²

çr.6:l-É ^{ql§ll: ôelê}

A'.,-..),ll e-lJ+ll

,.t,.

^{,i#J,3 ôJii}

J -

³

.L;g 90

J

^{60 gsr}

^L

:iÀS*"ll

cj.l.Fll.9 qLsllg ôrl;§tl

y^c

,

jrLo

r'111'orr+r^ll

aô[Jl

z,t.-zû LÈ

È

^oLl_.pll

ir +rrll

^cr,.l!

^ril

'=-. V.. J. J J v J

up*

e+él:

,â-ul.LJl ,-rl,.üSl GJI-.S â.Ln-*ll ,J^l-rll:

i<+ .x

^{âJ§llJ ËelJ,iJl}

dr ü _6. ^ùilS

4l+,ll

.J*l: ..r-^i

^ae+

cl _-rl-jll - ^{dlS^ll ËLxllr}

^sJt"i

@e Maistre)

(f9S8f,e"! çr)-r

(Borel Maisonny) (1953

,l.9jr

^r.Jlty)

*li

_çl-r1

cr!l;À.-l lJ ^qlisll:

^{ôelJill r."c}

^çl 't:l

^{L e io .JS c.,,;-.1Î}

^e,;-

4'i.lS^ll

++l!: f ,."rll

Lrl

irll .,Ji.". .,lc çl ^J-':l

^,fuJ- +r.1-)

ç+J

^L]1.-i

ir é

^drL*l,p

"'' ^{li' Ls.(dl}

...J'^-J|J

êJl cr.:,".,J"cJE,i',i"t-jll

â.Dtc .:_n:

.r{

@arnsley) (1970 o1*', _,rt): (Hildreth) (1954

O!*) d:

^.tESJt3

^ôcl-!I

^r-i-.üStr

,jl{ ^t $

^LJirtll r3rJ'": fu-rJl

:*i-f-ll i»

^4++-1.

(te6S _{cË-r+_r}

ûr"t) ^éll§:

⁽¹⁹⁵⁷ gr"jJlÀ)

dr G

^drLl_,p

^crh

_{-21§t g*ü}

ËelJill

ul-üSl

_{6§t.'a3 Jt*J drJ^J} ^{4+-Éll .-rl,,ËSl} _crj3.,.

c;i

^{âDl.c ryç3,rJc}

)

⁽¹⁹⁷¹ O-:*tl3)3 (Popp) (1964

Ç$) ü"

^{g§ â-,1.p cq1 r§3 hÀ}

^.LtSllr

.â,tsJlr Ëel_.;rilt,

.jtill ËL§]l

^{AÔl.c (1973}

cls-r-l:

_{ç_r_»]:} ^(Watson

-r,1,§l -, ^;rt *,- _r.rl+p o[l.,p

iu§

_4"t rryt _ÊJ'ldlJ

'.+hiJl il+i

,"ttii ôJJIC>l,. ^.i _ ^{:rtjt-i â.q,.,..} Lf;.r _ qUsttl ôrl.,fll _.,;r.,.p

a3LJ- §E

U

3 ^crLl'pll

_".16J

a,:l-,p:-l .}yi ^{g^} dl.LI

^g-.,1g3

êry| ,rJ'

^{+Esll-r ôcl-fll}

*- ^-,tJ *1

^,r"

J

^t-..tS,

^tsl.f a>,'.ll ^cjtitil' dh

^d+- (Troubles istrumentaux d'origine fonctionnelte

) .-p§l

^{' , '+' "lf} ,5 gl.r;S^ll _6.li^,,a *-lc

otj:t:l

^{g^} :"13S3

âcly -l-s

^e6;rl

^Cr.

Jrsr.""Yl

fL'

.(CXt

_{-1Él, ,5JU-i}

- ^,;tS.

^{++y-r âr-J-.à. 6u;. Ë-;3*a}

^{,ui- 1$§}

^ql"eIl

:L.ts!13

ôrl.;ill suo ç)c *p

^rlrr1ll

ols§ .jll

crL,,l.1rll

:&ltill

_JJÂâll

:iu...,pll êt-,lJ.tll

-

ⁱ

(2007\:cXlii

_4.rJl

g)l,a

^à,*,1.1.r

-

¹

CJË"

^Lf

§j - ^{qr+)c e^br}

^-*"'E

.s-

A^àJ"-

C ^4*,lJJl

^cr,,,,

y.c,Jc,=,li:ll ,i ^4,+)e titils

^4*Sfl1

- ^q."$

^{i#-Éll ôrtÈj}

^.,lÊ

^r,ü+

JT.j,.tP

Êet+-üS^

ei--, ^{ùÀ ù^}

^élll3 4r'il§.,)l

âLJ^ll i:,)j ^{crJ tlisJl: ôeljl}

4-lJJl

c+-=J

.(o$"jil'a +lS.lt

^{4,ü+llr â*ÉbJl}

^Ér"Jl it *)

^LJ*Y

_+lrïl

Ël'3ll u. ^{eJ$ , à'} ll _\;")E rr ^ôiF§r h*^I: (120) k ^{lrÊ tu;c}

"J"

rüg3tSi^3 ùf3f3l.,i^ ü1icJ,a+i

C

^{dr^-,,iJ 4Sl3,it}

QJh ôJ$il ^.çil§ü)l

.1*-,J* _{csJi.!l_,} 1t+1,à t."Ât.uJ

:

l*.,l3rll crl3ri

' :qltill dJJ§l ,rlc

^rLacYl

é

^{4-,lJJl o-:a} é"ri-3 ^,J-J ,1"

J$

J§J

6.;. g,.Ê

^élJiJ

^(i.êClJ

^{4,Élfill ta.;c:.+}

:el-)-ll -

¹

.OL:ùJI

L,jF",jS..

çrt,= ^i.:Lc! té$,- .t:-É _ü^ éiJl

^.:r1 drl-;LiÂl A-lll"+

-

²

:a,;lEll

ol-jSiYLl yVt ,;t+,

.t<.r!û: lai.r.- d-DLt'.

+lli$l -, ^;*t *

-

r-rtrc .:,t _Js erJ+ 4pLLJl e$lll +tlyt i't+.

I

,'rur _4;rJl

C).. ^.l

-

^4+Ltrt

is*

^4-l+r

-

^{LEslts ôrl.fll .;r.,e}

Marie de maistre ^'

ji-L _6r

g_,ttJ'J iJ.-"sll ôJJ'.-ll Jl.,ii|

-

Mira

Stamback

'é!t,3-

l;l1."

J

^4+$t+ll

_Jl5I -

Marie de maistre

"ii-L _çs

_ç-,1L

^' J

^{i,rilS^ll Alfult}

_J§Àl -

.K- ABC ( .;r,-lt âL'L ) .;U;lt

^4+-9,11

Jt$l -

#;lt ^{gr ail$l}

^â:.Jl

iÈi

^{19J IESJI: ËelJill g;ri.*,.}

AS _l§il -

.(e.,=Ut .rl.:cJ

g*

",a): .ilsi+Yl

tê t" C ^{i*,lJ$l ,',. l{}

^:6Jt3ill

4tcr.;.lt

^iLrL. _.! crlt*_9i" ^ga;

1;tt^j ^{âIÿr cJi}

r3-l-ts

!r: -

.ric ,i.-l-;rll

6

^;rôn

^Jl

^u{Jlni.

^yl \f _çu$ ,r$ll ,} ^ahU:tl:

^a*U*Jl

.4-,lJ.ll

qf

_frÀi..*ll agy.yll

qr§,ll

_6.tjJ+ll

iJ'l! ^d.$

^{L^ ,(0.05) 4§,.r a; ,L"^}

tê ^Lq,',,oJJ Él _e).c d ^+§;rtt -

â;."iJl 4i9-Éll _-,13r

!.a1 .,Jc

+S'Ut

-

.': _{.dl§Il: et;rtt}

qlL=ll A-,lJJl ü, ËL".Ji."^

45).c 6.ol: Êr.i

^'o_yJ,2t

-

.qESIlr ;elJill _{_.p"c ç_e3} q!ih:',)l

aL-*ll

i'q+LI Ê*"qi t.J-j

ir

AL-)"JI

'- i

^{ôc^I,-ll +*-.r§}

^6Jr

^.rlr,c,!

-

.4r- J^lJl

^4-riJSJ

^,JlJt

^{àYl hÀ}

(1997):irÉ{r t ⁺ⁱ C*É A,,/;l -

²

,.'liill

_,.+

ç.y/ + çr§j 6.b:

-rpL &_x-

I

^{i-,l_pll crà.u}

ir",;rll

,J^lCl ùLl ùÀ u.

4$hiiYl AL-)^lt

iÈ: ^glJ -l*jll

^crLr_r.-

"lc

hJ^l:

(230)

^l.ێl$

t;c ,+ ^â*,llll

^c+-r=J

.otr3*.-Jl

^,glli

,1r,

fu"lSll

.ih3l)l _eLilt

_u,.

u*lJlj

^&JEll ùbü.-ll

i§i

ü^

iirBr

l.to)El

-rljpJl -, ^{lrt *}

-

rylc ^{,rLr.! ir.Lr 4pL.l+yl pShJl,g} _-J§l i,ty

q§i _{oÉ$l C.),4} ^{iilctJ 4+à*} l*l;r

-

^L.lsl3

frtif

.;,c

:4JEll

dJJ§l

_'''l^'L

(e,=f*ff

S-)) ^.Cdl o!-.,,''

LJ,,IL

-

r+c

çlê ^r;c

^{rlrcJ) .âJ*,}-I}

çrL'"'i§!l

ç.ct."3... Yl 193l'",oll

U"!L -

(cfu-l:t rsiL'" ^t

^Àl

.çrLÀ-i

6.E* - tê ^L _C

^a-,lJJl

'"1'o; :ftsll

âeJr.+-ll gt+-,t.r drtt-,JË^

4;

^aS"

^{L-sJ iIÿr crli}

^r!:-.1l

^r-»: -

ür,Jl i

^(0.05)

^4IIr

^{cg .:,.*}

ric rç:t''i-;)l et'-/.

^t

ol! l+:

J$

{#iJ*ll cJst ll

^,â-,_.1ül

^,i-)*Tl

(4-"ii _\lâ.Blt+

A"-lÂllj ,y';ll

c.rL;*,"-f

ilt",Jl

_'J,'Àill

JÈj

LlJl

^drtÀl+Yl+ A*-l3ll d.l[.rro

I é

^{(0.01) â§tl}

g3l'*" $e

^É1Pl-i+Yl

t . ,çu+ll (}!Éll ctJ ^{Étr.,,-ll ë"+l}

ü""11

çlsll ej.+-ll

^{l§,e ,i-,1-pll}

,r

.â-,1!l ;,r*"'Jl ç:t'i-,l)l et'JJ.l

^{4+lets +Sil}

t+

': té

^L+

"'=iJ

.4*-À"ill c-Dls,,*ll

e). ^{,,l ,fUdl}

^{:ti,-.l)l -,13r q^al}

^.Jt

^+SLü

-

ç-rl

^+$lshYl

^âLJ,.ll iil)jl ^{l'5)e qtti-i} el:

^{Ê14^âi}

Ëv;a

.alr.:11

cr!3s.- cjitll

-ys

1,#t

_f&rl

^âL-*ll

^{,r qF-à}

ùi^t"ll trU$

_G'l;r1

^rlrel -

.4{+l} ê

dùls,î,"t| Ey+

+-r-

^r5Je

d"rll:

_'qF

lCl èr* *

(1994) ^:ct+!+ ++rJl ^r+e

r.{r. bd ^â*J1-

³

t;,-*r,i':

^â-,1-p (t+-S*;St;

ilJill ^t'-ll,

JJ§ a*'lJJl

f:-::' ^-l:*

,ê ^L _{,jci.l J,!} .,,*ü

çâ3 "1p)-e

di+ll -' !r'*

-

^{u.tac Éf'J i"l+ l+PLllTl pjhll3} '.,.lrill iJy