A NNALES DE L ’I. H. P., SECTION A
R. L ANGEVIN
W. M. O LIVA
J. C. F. DE O LIVEIRA
Retarded functional differential equations with white noise perturbations
Annales de l’I. H. P., section A, tome 55, n
o2 (1991), p. 671-687
<http://www.numdam.org/item?id=AIHPA_1991__55_2_671_0>
© Gauthier-Villars, 1991, tous droits réservés.
L’accès aux archives de la revue « Annales de l’I. H. P., section A » implique l’accord avec les conditions générales d’utilisation (http://www.numdam.
org/conditions). Toute utilisation commerciale ou impression systématique est constitutive d’une infraction pénale. Toute copie ou impression de ce fichier doit contenir la présente mention de copyright.
Article numérisé dans le cadre du programme Numérisation de documents anciens mathématiques
http://www.numdam.org/
671
Retarded functional differential equations with white
noise perturbations
R. LANGEVIN
W. M. OLIVA J. C. F. DE OLIVEIRA Universidade de Sao Paulo, I.M.E., Caixa Postal 20570 (Ag. Iguatemi),
CEP 05508, Sao Paulo, Brazil
Universite de Bourgogne, Departement de Mathematiques,
21004 Dijon Cedex, France
Ann. Henri Poincaré,
Vol. 55, n° 2, 1991, Physique , théorique ,
ABSTRACT. - Given a retarded functional differential
equation,
a stableequilibrium point
and a boundedneighbourhood
contained in its basin ofattraction,
oneperturbs
the differentialequation
with small white noise and states alarge
deviationresult, namely,
solutionsstarting
in theneigh-
bourhood very
likely
escape from it. The end of theescaping path
can bedescribed. The
Euler-Lagrange equation corresponding
to the extremalsof the action-functional presents
delay
and advance in time. Anexample
is
completely
studied.RESUME. 2014 Soit un
voisinage
borne d’unpoint d’equilibre
stable d’uneequation
differentielle avec retard contenu dans Ie bassin d’attraction dece
point d’equilibre.
Nous montrons un resultat degrandes
deviationsconcernant les
perturbations
de1’equation
avec retard par unpetit
bruitblanc. Nous decrivons la fin du chemin de sortie
probable
duvoisinage.
C’est la solution d’une
equation
avec retard et avance.Annales de l’Institut Henri Poincaré - Physique théorique - 0246-0211
Vol. 55/91/02/671/17/$3,70/(c) Gauthier-Villars
0. INTRODUCTION
It is well known that small random
perturbations
canproduce large
deviations in the behavior of the
trajectories
of a deterministicdynamical
system. Infact~
let us consider as theunperturbed dynamical
system anordinary
differentialequation given by
and the
perturbed
systemgiven by
},
is the Brownian motion in !R"starting
from0,
thatis, (0.2)
is aperturbation
of(0.1)
with a white noise. Givenany ~>0
and denoteby X~(t, p)
the solution of(0.2) satisfying Xt (0, p) = po Suppose
is a bounded domain and 0~D is anasymptotically
stableequilibrium (constant solution) of(0.1).
Freidlin and Wentzel considered the action functional associated to(o . 1 ):
defined 0 for of all
absolutely
continuousfunctions 03B3:[ - T, 0]
suchL 2 { - T, 0].
For each (p E IRnthey
introduced the so-called o
quasipotential o I relatively
toand o
proved
othat,
if V(p)
has its minimum in aunique point
then
for any where
Here,
Pdenotes the
probability
measure.In the same authors have
developed
atheory
oflarge
deviationsfor Gaussian processes with values in Hilbert spaces; Azencott
{Az]
alsoconsidered processes with values in Banach spaces. As a
general
referenceon
large
deviations we can mention the bookby
Deuschel and Stroock[D-S], 1989.
In the present paper, we consider a small stochastic
perturbation
of aretarded functional differential
equation.
This kind ofequation
defines adynamical
system in a Banach space but the solutions have adescription
in [R" with many self intersections. The
perturbation
is made with a whitenoise in
but,
since thedynamical
system defines asemigroup
in asuitable Banach space, the deviations will be measured with the distance of the
(not locally compact)
considered space. Thatis,
the solutionsAnnales de l’Institut Henri Poincaré - Physique theorique
RETARDED FUNCTIONAL DIFFERENTIAL EQUATIONS 673
starting
in aneighbourhood
contained in the basin of attraction of anasymptotically
stableequilibrium point,
verylikely
escape from theneigh- bourhood, generalizing
the Freidlin and Wentzel ideas. We will see that theEuler-Lagrange equations,
whichgives
thepoints
of theaction
functional,
turns out to be a functional differentialequation
withadvance and
delay
in time. We were able to compute the minimum onthe
boundary
of a suitable domain of thequ.siotential
for the case ofthe linear
equation j~ 2014x(~-~).
I. PRELIMINARIES AND STATEMENT OF THE MAIN RESULT
Let C be the Banach space of all continuous
paths
p:[- 1, 0]
-4 Rn withrespect to the
- 1 ~ e ~ O}, I
is theEuclidean norm in For a continuous function
~:[~- 1,
--4~~, A>0,
and a real number t inwrite xt
to denote the elementin C
given by then,
the functionis continuous.
We call retarded functional differential
equation
a relation of the formwhere/:
C --+ is a continuous function[Ha]).
For technical reasons, we will suppose
continuously
differentia- bte and thatis
finite,
whereEquation (1.0)
defines the solution ftow2014onCby
where x is the solution of
(1.0)
in[0,
+oo)
which starts in (p, ~i. e,,or x
(B)
= p(0),
for all ein {- 1, 0].
We knowthat )) (t) :
C ~ C is continu-ously differentiable, 03C6(t+s)=03C6(t)03C6(s)
forall t, ))(())= identity
of Cand also that for any fixed cp in
C,
andany 03C8
inC,
Vo!.55,n°2-1991.
Let W1,2 be the subset of all functions
(p:[-l,0]-~" absolutely
continuous on
[20141, 0]
such that03C6~L2
i. e.With respect to the norm
W1,2 is a Hilbert space and the inclusion W1, 2 ~ C is continuous. We know that
W1,2
is invariant under the flow((()(~))~o
and that~ (~):
W1, 2 ~ W 1, 2 remainscontinuously
differentiable.Later,
we will suppose that the function(p=0
in C is anequilibrium point
ofequation ( 1. 0),
thatis,/(0)=0,
which attracts its smallneighbour-
hoods. We assume that there exist
positive
constants K and a suchfor all ~0 and all cp in a
sufficiently
smallneighbourhood
of o. The above estimate is obtained(see [Ha]) by
consider-ing
the linearized variationalequation
about~=0:~(/)=/~(0)~.
Let
(Q, ff, [P)
be aprobability
space and letw (t) : SZ ~ ~0,
be theBrownian motion in tR".
Let us consider the
perturbed
stochastic differentialequation
A solution of this
equation through
cp E C at time t == 0 is a continuous random variablew),
t~-1,
w~03A9 such that(with probability one)
for all6e[2014l, 0]
and such that for all~0,
wehave
also with
probability
one.We know
that,
for each cp EC,
there exists one andonly
one solutionof
equation (l, E) through
cp defined for all We will prove that:I.1. PROPOSITION. - Given an interval
[0, T]
and afunction
cp EC, then, during
the time interval[0, T],
the solution XE(t) of’ equation (1, E) through
cp at time t = 0 very
likely follows
the solutionof equation ( 1 . 0) through
cpat time t = 0; more
precisely, for any 03B4> o,
l’Institut Henri Poincaré - Physique theorique
675
RETARDED b FUNCTIONAL DIFFERENTIAL EQUATIONS
or,
equivalently,
where , the
subscript
(p indicates that the considered solutions start at (p.Proo.f’. -
It is easy to see thatso, Gronwall’s
inequality implies
thatUsing
the classicalinequality (see [F - W 1]):
we find that
for
appropriate
constantsC1, C2, D1
andD2;
this lastinequality clearly implies
the conclusion of ourproposition.
In order to estimate the
probability
that a solutionX~
of theequation ( 1, 8) belongs
to aneighourhood
of a fixedT 1 _ t _ T 2 },
weintroduce the action functional associated to the random processes
X~
anda
quasipotential extending
Freidlin and Wentzell’s construction for pertur- bed vector fields[see F-W 1].
In a similar way as Freidlin and Wentzell do for vector
fields,
let us define the action functional associated to the processesX~ by:
for
T2], which, when/=0,
reduces to the usual action func- tional associated to the Brownian motion.Without loss of
generality,
we can assume that eitherT 1 == 0
andT2 > 0
or and
T 1 o.
Let us denote
by
PT the distance between two continuous functions xand y in C [ - 1, T]:
and, T],
let us define:Vol. 55, n° 2-1991.
Let us state, without
proof,
astraightforward
extension af a theoremof Freidlin and Wentzell
[F-W1],
which will be used several times:1.2. THEOREM. - Let XE
(03C6)
be a solutionof
theperturbed equation (1 , E).
Then, given
T>1, 03B4>0, 03B2>0
ands0>0
we have:(a)
There exists Q such thatfor
all E E(0, Eo)
theinequality T] such that 03B30=03C6
§(b)
There exists8o>0
1 suchthat for
all~e[0, soJ
and allc~ ~ W ~ ~ 2,
we haveThe
quasipotential
ofequation (1.0)
with respect to theorigin
0 inis, by definition,
the functionalIt is clear that V
(0, p)
~ 0 for all cp E W1, 2 and that V(0, p)
is continuous in poMoreover,
if 0 is anequilibrium
ofequation (1, 0),
thenV(0, 0)==0 and,
sinceextending
backwards yby
zero does not increase theaction,
one can assume
T
1 == - oo .The name
quasipotential
comes from the fact that forgradient
systems inx (t) = - grad U (x (t)),
with 0 as an attractor, thequasipotential
istwice the
potential U,
if we stay in the basin of the attractor.The
following theorem,
as in the non retarded case, studies the exit from a bounded domain D contained in the basin of anattracting equili-
brium.
Since,
under ourhypotheses,
the solution operator of the retarded functional differentialequation
iscompact,
one can extend eachstep
usedby
in theproof.
Theextension, although
notcompletely standard,
can be done in a natural way and we will ommit the details.
Let the nonretarded case, it can be shown to be almost
surely
finite and moreover, we have:1.3. THEOREM. - Let 0 be an
asymptotically
stableequilibrium
tion
( 1, 0)
and let bounded connected openneighbourhood of 0,
the
closure of
which03B40-neighbourhood Dõo
contained in the basin suppose also that D andDõo
arestrictly contracted by the flow of
thenanperturbed
system, that is, andsuppose, moreover, that there
unique point
3Dminimizing
thequasipotential
V(0, p)
on aD.for
> 0 and any we have:Annales de ’ l’Institut Henri Poincaré - Physique " theorique "
677
RETARDED FUNCTIONAL DIFFERENTIAL EQUATIONS
II. THE ACTION FUNCTIONAL
From now on, we will restrict ourselves to random
perturbations
ofequations
of thefollowing
type:where
f :
isgiven by
We suppose that F:~"x~-~~ and
g : ~n ---~ f~n
are bounded C1 1functions with bounded derivatives and that a :
[0, 1] 2014~
!? is of class C2.The
perturbed equation
isThe
corresponding
action functional isWe want to minimize S on the
following
class:where " (p and 0
(p
are "given
functions.It is clear that we have to assume
T ~
1.11.1. PROPOSITION. 2014 4 necessary
condition for 03B3~M to
, minimize S onthat y
satisfies
thefollowing
?Euler-Lagrange equation:
where
(the
star indicates the matrixtransposition).
Recall that tp and 03B3T=
cp
and observe that theequation
above which is retarded and advanced intime, is,
as a matter offact,
a second orderintegro-differential equation.
Inspite
of the fact that we do not know apriori
that y has first and second derivatives in[0, T -1],
we remark thatVol. 55, n° 2-1991.
the function
H(y)(~)
isabsolutely
continuous in[0,T-1]
and~ H (y (.)) E L2 [0, T - 1].
Later on we will showthat y
isC2
in[0, T - 1].
~
Let
[0, T - 1]
such thatA (0) = /! (T - 1) = 0
and put/! (6) = 0, 8E[ -1,0],
andh(t)=0, t~[T-1, T].
We know that if03B3~M
is a local minimum for S then for all /! as above.cIA
Let us make
explicit
this condition:Since
ho
==hT
= 0 and afterusing integration by
parts andinverting
theintegrals
we obtain thefollowing expression:
Since /! is
arbitrary,
the result follows fromDu-Bois-Reymond’s
lemma[A])
which says that if 0:[a, ~]
-~ M" is continuous and ifP
D*(t) /! (/)
dt= 0 for all C1 functions /!:[a, ~]
-~ f~n such that Jathen C is constant on
[a, b].
We have
then,
for allT -1 ] :
Since the
integrand belongs
to T -1],
it follows thatH* (y) (t)
isabsolutely
continuous on[0, T -1].
If we transpose theexpression
obtainedafter
computing
the derivative of the lastequality
we get thefollowing Euler-Lagrange equation
which holds for y, almosteverywhere
inl’Institut Henri Poincaré - Physique theorique
RETARDED FUNCTIONAL DIFFERENTIAL EQUATIONS 679
as claimed.
Let us now consider the existence of an absolute minimum for S in the class which will
imply
the existence of solution for theequation (2. 4)
with
boundary
condition andLet and a
minimizing
sequence ofelements in that
is, S (y m)
as m oo . Without loss ofgenerality
we may assume
11.2. PROPOSITION. - There
subsequence,
alsodenoted by
which converges
uniformly in [0, T -1] to a function 03B3~M
suchthat S
(y)
== ~.Proof . -
The idea is to show that ~~l is compact in C[0, T]
and that Sis lower semi-continuous on ~.
We start
observing
that there exist constants a andP
such that a > 0 andThis
implies
thatand then
By
the Arzela-Ascoli’sTheorem,
there exists asubsequence
of(yj
whichconverges
uniformly
to a functionyeC[0, T -1];
extend y to[-1, T] by yo
=(p andYT==9.
It is easy to show that y isabsolutely
continuous in[0,T-1].
..To prove
YEL2[0,T-l] ]
take~e(0,T-l)
and choose /!>0 smallenough
such that[t, ~+/!]c:[0, T -1 ] .
Using again Cauchy-Schwarz inequality
we haveVol. 55, n° 2-1991.
If we
integrate
between 0 and(T - 1 2014 ~)
andby
inversion in the orderof
integration
one obtainsand since the last term is bounded
by B2,
we pass to the limit as m 00and see
that,
for all T T -" 1 and h > 0sufficiently small,
we haveSince y
isabsolutely
continuous in[0,T20141],
we use Fatou’s theorem and obtainBut 1; T - 1
arbitrary implies
andA standard argument shows now that
~m
convergesweakly
toy
on[0, T - 1],
in the sensethat,
for each we have lim whereIt is easy now to prove that the absolute
minimum ~
of S is achievediny.
III. EXAMPLE
Let us
apply
theforegoing
results to theproblem
of exit from a domain attracted to0,
in the case of thedynamical
system definedby
the scalarlinear retarded differential difference
equation:
We know
[Ha]
that the condition0~-
is a necessary and sufficient condition to ensure that 0 is anasymptotically
stableequilibrium
ofequation (3.0);
infact,
this condition isequivalent
to assume that allroots of the characteristic
equation verify
Re~0.Annales de Henri Poincare - Physique . théorique .
681
RETARDED FUNCTIONAL DIFFERENTIAL EQUATIONS
The action functional
corresponding
toequation (3.0)
isgiven by
and the
Euler-Lagrange equations
for the extremals of S aregiven by
We will compute the
quasipotential
ofequation (3.1)
withrespect
to theorigin.
As noted
before,
we may suppose thatEquation (3.2.2)
is an advanced difference-differentialequation,
whichbecomes a retarded
equation by performing
thechange
ofindependent
variable t ~-t.
Therefore, by [B-T], given 03C8
eL2 [ - b, 0], and 03BE~ [R,
we can solve(3.2.2)
to find aunique
function H :(2014
oo,b]
-+ IR which satisfies:1)
H(~
+9) = B)/ (8)
for almost all ee [ - b, 0]; 2)
H(0)
=~; 3)
H isabsolutely
continuous on
(2014
oo,0], and, 4)
for almost all t in(2014
oo,0], H (t)
= H~t
+b).
With
H = H (t, ~, t~r~
sodetermined,
we solveequation (3.2.1)
in(-oo,0]
with initial conditiony~=0.
We get a functiony:(2014oo,+~]-~[R
which isabsolutely
continuouson (-
oo,0].
Of course, y
depends upon B)/
and~;
the relationsallow us determine
B)/ and ç uniquely
as functions of po Infact,
from the variation of constants formula[Ha],
we havewhere X is the fundamental solution:
Given 03C8~L2,
letJ (t)
be the solution ofwhere
BJ/
is definedby ~ (o) _ ~ ( - b - 8)
for allOe[-~0].
It is easy to see that
([Ha],
p.22, formula 6.2):
and that
Vol. 55, n° 2-1991.
By equation (3 . 2 . 1)
we have for t E[
-b, 0]:
or
Define the function
~(8), 6e[-~0], by
Then,
we can writeequation (3.4)
asLetting
t = 0 inequation (3 . 4),
we getSince a
(0)
>0,
we can solveequation (3 . 7) for ç
so thatequation (3 . 6)
can be written as
where
We now compute the function
~(8).
It follows from the definition that
Therefore, ~(8)= 2014~(9).
Since~(-~)= 1/2,
we haveAnnales de l’Institut Henri Poincare - Physique theorique .
683
RETARDED FUNCTIONAL DIFFERENTIAL EQUATIONS
Also,
the kernel K(8, u)
has theexpression
Equation (3 . 8)
now becomes the Volterraequation
Which has a
unique
solution for eachWe now compute the
quasipotential
relative to theorigin.
From what has been
proved above,
thequasipotential
V(cp)
isgiven by
where
y (t) = x ( - t), x (t) being
the solution ofIn
fact,
Yb = cp andy - 00 = 0
and y satisfies the variationalequations (3 . 2 . 1 )
and
(3.2.2).
We have
Vol.55,n°2-1991.
Let j~: W1,2 --+ W1,2 be the linear operator defined
by
for all 8 E
[
-b, 0] .
It is clear that
and
Recall that the
inner product
in W1,2 isgiven by
for all (p,
B)/
in W1,2.A straitforward 0
computation
shows that:PROPOSITION III. 1. - The
operator d defined
above issymmetric
andfor
all (p in W1,2.Let m be the infimum of
V (cp)
over the unitsphere ~ 03C6~1,2
= 1. Thenfor all cp E W1,2.
THEOREM III . 2. -
7/~e(0,7T/2),
theProo~ f : -
We know that mbelongs
to the spectrum (J(A)
ofA; therefore,
it suffices to prove
that o(A)
is contained in(0, oo)
or,equivalently,
thatthe resolvent set
p (A)
of A contains the interval( - oo,0].
Let À be a real
number, ~, -_ 0,
and let us solve theequation
for tp in
W 1 ~ 2, where ~
is an~given
element in W 1 ~2.Let us write 1- 2 À
= I
where J.l E0 1
and make thechange
of variableN~ ~ ~ ~
gp
W2 ~2~+~)~
Annales de l’Institut Henri Poincare - Physique theorique
685
RETARDED FUNCTIONAL DIFFERENTIAL EQUATIONS
Then,
the aboveequation
isequivalent
to the systemSince
we
have, by
the variation of parameters method:~ (8) _ (cl + c (9)) cos ~, (8 + b) + (c2 + d (8)) (3.11)
where c 1 and c2 are constants to be determined and
c (8)
andd (9)
arefunctions
given by
and
Taking (3. 11)
into(3.10)
we arrive to the systemin c1 and
c2given by
Let D be the determinant of the coefficients of C1 and C2.
Then, D=D( )=2 2+(1- 2) cos b-( + 3) sin b.
Let us prove that for any D>O. Since then
cos b
> cosb> 0 and 0sin
& sin&;
thereforeLetting
1: be the tangent we can writeD ~~,
where2 1 + "(2
and it is easy to see that
g (i) = (1- i2)2
andSince 0 i
1,
we seeimmediately
that for anyTherefore,
we can solve(3.12) uniquely
for c 1 and c2and, with ç given by (3 .11 ),
we get aunique
solution cp of(~ - ~, I)
cp = cp, for anyB)/
EW1,2,
and any
~~0, depending linearly
andcontinuously
onB)/,
which proves thatp(j~)~(2014 oo, 0].
This finishes theproof.
Vol. 55, n° 2-1991.
From Theorem III.
2,
we conclude that/V
is a hilbertian norm inW1,2,
which isequivalent
to theprevious
one.If we take D as the open ball with respect to the norm
JV,
with centerc and radius
R,
where c and R arepositive
constants,c R,
thenTheorem 1.3 can be
applied
to theperturbed
system .if0~7c/2.
To show that
fact,
we must prove that the absolute minimum of/V((p)
on is achievedonly
at onepoint,
namely,
In
fact,
we have:then
where ( , )>y
denotes the innerproduct
associated toV;
thereforeand
theinequality
is strict if which proves that the minimum ofjV
on aD occursonly at(po.
As a final
remark,
we note that the method we have used can beapplied
to many other systems, for
example,
to the scalar linearintegro-differential equation
with a
(t)
= e - ~r- r~
-1,
t E[0, r].
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
The authors thank CAPES and COFECUB for
supporting
this work.[A] N. T. AKIEZER, The Calculus of Variations, Blaisdell Publishing Co., 1962.
[Az] R. AZENCOTT, Lect. Notes Math., Springer, No 774, 1978.
Annales de l’Institut Henri Poincaré - Physique theorique
RETARDED FUNCTIONAL DIFFERENTIAL EQUATIONS 687
[B-T] J. G. BORISOVIC and A. S. TURBABIN, On the Cauchy Problem for Linear Homo- geneous Differential Equations with Retarded Argument, Dokl. Akad. Nauk S.S.S.R., Vol. 4, 1969.
[D-S] J. D. DEUSCHEL and D. W. STROOCK, Large Deviations, Ac. Press, 1989.
[F-W1] M. I. FREIDLIN and A. D. WENTZELL, Random Perturbations of Dynamical Systems, Springer-Verlag, 1985.
[F-W2] M. J. FREIDLIN and A. D. WENTZELL, Fluctuations in Dynamical Systems Under
the Action of Random Perturbations, Moskva Nauka, 1979.
[Ha] J. K. HALE, Theory of Functional Differential Equations, Springer-Verlag, 1977.
( Manuscript received August 16, 1990;
revised version received April 5, 1991.)
Vol. 55, n° 2-1991.