Pi-calculus and LCC, a Space Odyssey
23
0
0
Texte intégral
(2) INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE. Pi-calculus and LCC, a Space Odyssey Sylvain Soliman. N° 4855 Juin 2003. ISSN 0249-6399. ISRN INRIA/RR--4855--FR+ENG. THÈME 2. apport de recherche.
(3)
(4)
(5)
(6) "!# $ %& '$ &( )&*,+.-0/213(%45*6/27-.1 8'9;:=<?> @BADCFE=G;HI>KJMLONPHMQRHI>=J >RSTQRUVJWQ XJZY\[]<B^.LOJMHW_PX> `bacLOde> Sgf LOGhScaiUVHMGhSc>jY klUOm;m.LOacSon;>Fa>=Qi9>RaiQi9;>pG.q%rhsPtOtuAwvOX;HMGx@VyOyPzKA|{=}~mUVNP>=Y. =R ;OO >Tm;a>=Yc>RGhS USaUOGYcJMUVScHMLOGLVS9;>gUPY\[]GQi9acLPG;LOXYmHQRUOJMQRX;JIX0YHMGPSL JMHIG;>jUVaQ LOG0Q X;aac>=GhS QRLOGY\ScaiUVHMGhSbJWUVG;NPXUVNP>=YT6fof' ]UOGnX0Y\>TSc9UVS SaUOGY\JWUSHILPGUVG0n Sc9;>Fa>=Q >=GhSUOn;UOGQ >jYbHMGS9;>FJILPNOHWQRUVJ Yc>R<UOGPSHMQ=Y&LOfofSLgNPHIP>bUVG?UOQ=Q LOXGPSLVS9;>'ac>jYeSacHWQSHILPGKLOm.>RaiUScLPa&HMGBGhScXHSHILPG;HMY\ScHWQZHMG;>=UOa&LONOHWQV 8'9HMY UOJIJML¡lYXYSLx> ¢m;a>=YYKUOYKUx&HIG;>jUVaB&LONPHMQ~Sc9>RLOa[OUG;LVSHILPG£LO'YcmUPQ >YcHI< HMJMUOaScLx¡o9UVSB9UOY a>=QR>RGhScJM[£^0>=>RG¤HMGhScaLnXQ >jn¥^][¦CUO^;^U[¥UVGn§`HScSY?HMG¤< Ln;UVJJILPNOHWQRY= ¨©S?UOJMYcL¨m.>Ra< HSiYBSLua>RJWUS> < LPac>?Q JMLPYc>RJM[ S9;> m;HI©Q=UVJWQ X;JMXYFUVGn¥fofªmUVaiUOn;HINP< YlSc9UVSKm0>=LOm;JM>~90UO>B¡'UVGhS>=nSLQRLO< mUVa> «LPaFU JMLOGN~SHI< >P ¬xh®5¯°B± ²O `bHQRUOJMQRX;JIX0YRQRLOGQRX;aac>=GPSoQ LPGY\ScaiUVHMGPS'm;aLONPaUO<?< HMG;N]JMHIG>=UVa'JMLONPHMQ. Unité de recherche INRIA Rocquencourt Domaine de Voluceau, Rocquencourt, BP 105, 78153 Le Chesnay Cedex (France) Téléphone : +33 1 39 63 55 11 — Télécopie : +33 1 39 63 53 30.
(7) B
(8) §
(9) $ %o \ oZ
(10) LOXYm;aE=Yc>RGhScLPGYX;G>¨ScaiUOn;XQSHILPG3nX m;HIQRUVJWQ XJFUPY\[]GQi9;aLOG>P>RaiYJM>=Y JMUOG;NPUONO>jY JMHMG;E=UOHIa>=YoQRLOGQRX;aca>RGhSiYUP>=QFQ LPGPSaUOHIGhS>=YK,fof';mX;HMYlXScHMJIHWYcLOGYlQR> ScSc>ScaiUOn;XQSHILPG>RSlJI>jYoUUVGQRER>=Y aE=QR>RGhSc>jYn>gJMU YcER<UOGPSHM_hX;>TJILPNOHW_PX>Tn>gfof¤m0LPX;a LP^Sc>=G;HMabX;G;>gac>=m;aE=Yc>RGhSUVScHMLOGn>lJ LPm0E=aUVSc>=X;a n> a>=Y\ScaHWQScHMLOG>RGx&LONOHW_hX;>KZHMG;E=UOHIa>GhScX;HIScHMLOG;GHMY\Sc>P 'f >=QRHZG;LPXYom.>Ra<?>RSTn > ¢m;aHI< >RagQ LO< < >Sc9ERLOaHM> >=GZLPNOHW_hX;>TZHMG;EjUVHMac>PPX;G>TG;LOScHMLOGn >=YcmUPQ >gYcHM<?HMJWUVHMac> ~Q >=JIJM>TaE=QR>R< < >RGhS HMGhScaL]n;X;HS>gm0UVaCUO^;^U[ >RS `HScSY m.LOXa JMUFJMLONOHW_hX;><?Ln;UOJI>P TG;>lUVX;Sca>QRLOGYcE=_hX;>=GQ >'>=Y\S X;G;>'< >RHMJIJM>RXac>oQ LP< m;acE=9;>RG0Y\HMLOG?n>=Y a>RJWUSHILPGY>RGhSca>'m;HI©Q=UVJWQ X;J>RSJMUOG;NPUONO>=Y fofgO_hX;H;LPGhSERScEoYcLOX;< HWY KQ LO< mUOaUOHMYcLOG~n>Rm;XHMYJMLOG;NOSc>=<?m0YR ± j ¯ `HI©Q=UVJWQ X;J2m;aLONPaUO<?<UVScHMLOGQRLOGQRX;aca>RGhS>FUP>=QFQ LOGhSaUOHIGhSc>jYF;JILPNOHW_hX;>JIHMG;E=UOHIa>.
(11)
(12)
(13) !"$#&%'()$ # (. % 8'9> πQRUVJWQ XJIXY'90UOYg^0>jQ LO< >P5YcHMGQ >~HSiYgHMGhScaLnXQSHILPG/. @Vz)0©UY\SUVG0n;UVainmUVaiUOn;HINP< «LPaFYcm0>jQ HI«[]HIG;N QRLOGQRX;aac>=GPS macLQ >jYcYc>=Y= u8'9;>UOYc[]GQi9;aLOG;LPXYKO>=aYcHMLOG¥HIGhSacLnXQR>=n¦^]2[ 1LOXnLP3J . 4t 0©Sc9;LPX;NO9¤HS 9UOY ^.>R>=Gm;aLO>=n~JM>=YY > ¢m;a>=YY\HMO5> . @r 0©]UVJMJIL¡lY UK< LPac>oa>=UOJIHWYeSHMQ^.>R9U]HMLOa «LPabnHWYeSacHM^;XS>=nYc[YeS>R<YUVG0n 90UOYSc9>Ra> «LOa>F^0>=>RGXYc>=nUOY'^UPY\HWY«LOa'S9;LPYc>O]«LPaoHIG0YeSiUVGQR>FHMGSc9;>'deLPHIG;©Q=UVJWQ X;JMX5Y .M{j4@ 0© 8'9;>BScL]LOJWYgXY\>jnScLUVGUOJI[ 6R> Sc9;>jY\>~JMUOG;NOXUONO>jYR;a>R<UOHIGx9;L¡>RP>RaTQR>RGhSc>=ac>jnxUVaLOX;G0nSc9;>~G;LVSHILPG LO«^;HIeeYcHI<~X;JMUVScHMLOGZT¡o9;HMQi9&T^.>RHMG;N¤P>Ra[ LPm0>=aUVScHMLOGUOJ6oHWY G;LVSUVJM¡U[YYUSHMY\,UOQ ScLPac[HIG3Sc>Ra<YLO >R¢m;ac>jYcYcHMG;NBn>jQ JWUVaiUScHMO>=JI[QR>RacSUVHMG9;HMNO9 JI>=O>=J.macLPm0>=a\SHI>jY UO^0LPXS'QRLOGQRX;aac>=GPSm;aL]QR>=YY\>jYR 8'9;>F<UVHMG mX;acm.LPYc>lLOSc9;HWY'UVacScHWQ JM>lHMYbScL~m;aLhHWn>TUBJILPNOHWQRUOJ0Yc>R<UVGhScHWQRYScLBSc9;>UOYc[]GQi9;aLOG;LPXY π©Q=UVJWQ X;JMXYUVG0n S9]XYSc9;>Km.LPYYcHI^;HMJMHSe[ScL XYc>FG>R¡ ScL]LOJWYScL a>=UOYcLOGUV^.LOXSlmacLQ >jYcYc>=Y= 8'9;>=ac>HMY~UxJILPG;NxSaUPnHSHILPG¦LVlQ LP< mUVaHMYcLOG¥^.> Se¡>R>=G¥Sc9;>xf LOGQRX;aca>RGhS?f LPGYeSaUOHIGhS `aLONPaUO<? < HMG;Nx,UO<?HMJM[£LOoJMUOG;NOXUONO>j7Y . 9@ 8:0oUVGn¦n H ;5>Ra>RGhS~UVaHWUVGhSYKLO'Sc9;> π©Q=UVJWQ X;JMX5Y <fof ¡UPY«aLO< Sc9;> ^.>RNPHIGG;HIGNQRLOGYcHMn;>Ra>=n¨UPYFU m;aLQ >=YYFQRUVJWQ XJIXY=59;L¡>RO>=alS9;>?,UOQSFSc90USSc9;>QRLOGY\ScaiUVHMGhSFY\ScLOa>B¡'UOY UOJI¡'U[YKNOaL¡oHMG;Nx< LOG;LOScLOGHMQ=UVJMJI[< UPn>P>Ra[HMGQRLOG]O>=G;HI>=GhS Sc9;> >RGQRLnHIGN¨LVoS9;> < >jYcYUVNP>mUOYYe HMG;N¨macHM< HSHIP>=Y LOoSc9;> LVS9;>Ra~¡ >=JI>J =hGL¡oG¦m;acLQR>=YY QRUOJMQRX;JI3H .I{j)} 0© u8'9;> n;>RO>=JILPm;< >RGhS=HMG¥Sc9;> JMUPYeS n;>=QRUPn>O&LVbS9;>ZHMG;>=UOaBf LOGQRX;aca>RGhSBf LOGY\ScaiUVHMGhSFm0UVaiUOnHMNO< 6fof'TSc9UVS NO>=G;>RaiUVJM H 6=>=YKfofYcHI< m;JM[ ^][UVJMJIL¡oHMG;NQ LPGYeSaUOHIGhSTYc[YeS>R<Yo^UPY\>jn LPG¨ZHMG;>=UOalZLPNOHW Q .I{=r 0%HMGY\Sc>=UPnLVQ JWUOYY\HWQRUOJJILPNOHWQV;NPac>jUSJI[ >R¢]Sc>RG0n;YlS9;>?> ¢m;a>=YY\HMO>Km.L¡ >=aTLOfofg5UPYlG;LPG¨< LOG;LOScLPG;HMQB>RPLOJMXScHMLOGYTLV S9;>?Y\ScLPac>~UVa> m0LhYcYcHM^;JI> S9;aLOX;NP9BS9;>TQ LPGYcX;< mScHMLOG LVZQRLOGY\ScaiUVHMGhSY^][?UPY =BUONO>=GPSiY . @OsOr{O?{ 02 8'9;HWY NO>=G;>RaiUVJM@H 6=USHILPG~UOJIJML¡lYR UPYK¡>Y\90UVJMJ Yc>R>O%«LOa?Ux<BX0Qi9¦<?LPac>G0UScXaUOJb>RG0Q LnHMG;NxLVom;aLQ >=YY Q=UVJWQ X;JMHbJM H =P>«LOa~HIG0YeSiUVGQR>Sc9;> QRUOJMQRX;JMXY;UOY'¡'UOYoUOJIa>=UPn[Y\XNONO>jYeS>=n<?LPac>FS9UVGSc>=G[O>=UOaY'UONOL?HI2G . @V)s 0© π 8'9;>=ac>B9UO> UOJMYcL^0>=>RGxJMLVSiYlLV a>=Yc>=UOaQi9UV^.LOXSoS9;>~%¦^UPY\>jn JMLONPHMQmacLPNOaiUV< < HIG;N < Ln>RJWYlLO QRLOGQRX;aac>=GQ [««LOa HIGY\SUOGQ > .I{j)s 0 UVGn?S9;>Ra>lHWYbUJMLOG;N 9HMY\ScLPac[~ac>=JMUVScHMG;N &UVGn?S9;>Ffof§,UV< HMJI[UOY ¡oHMJMJZ^0>K^acHM?> A[ac>jQRUVJMJM>=nHMGxY\>jQSHILPGx@; !@ B9CGUVJMJM[Sc9>Ra>FHWYoLPG;>< UOHIG¡LOa =u S9;LOX;NP9 HISl¡'UOY'JWUV^.>RJMJI>jn D m;a>RJMHI< HMGUVa[ac>jY\X;JISFY E\'ac>=JMUVScHMG;N n;HIa>=Q ScJM[ S9;>Ba>=n;XQSHILPG¨HIG π ©Q=UVJWQ X;JMXYoUOGnSc9>RLOaHM>=YlLOb&G <0S9US LO HxHMJMJI>=alHIIG . @?{ 0© J Sc>Ra Y\LP<?>'m;a>RJMHM<?HMGUOac[ Yc>=Q ScHMLOG~«LOaHIGhSacLnXQRHIGNgS9;>oG;LOSUSHILPGYXYc>=n~Sc9;aLOXNO9;LPXS%S9;>lUVacScHWQ JM>O S9;>KmUOm0>=aoHMYS9hX0YlUVacScHWQ X;JWUS>=nUVaLOX;G0nSe¡L?>=GQ LnHMG;NhYR KHMaY\S=0¡ >NOHMO>KHMGxY\>jQSHILPGz UYcHI< m;JM>O.Q LP<?m.LPYcHIScHMLOGUOJ6;YcLOX;G0nUOGnQ LP<?mJI>RSc>K>RG0Q LnHMG;N LVSc9;> UPY\[]GQi9acLPG;LOXY πQRUOJMQRX;JMXY'HIGhSLufof,¡oHS9;LOXS?ac>jY\LPa\SHIGNScLu9HINP9;>Ra~LOain>Ra ¨8'9;> HI< m.LPYY\HM^;HMJIHISe[ LOUa>RO>=aYc>>R<~^0>jn;nHMG;NHWYgUOJMYcLnHWYcQRXYY\>jn T8'9;HW'Y C0aY\SgY\Sc>RmUVJMac>jUOn[ NOHMO>=YTacHWYc>KScLUG;>R¡¡'U[LO a>=UPY\LPG;HMG;N¨UV^.LOXS ©Q=UVJWQ X;JMXY'm;aLQ >=YYc>=Y=%GUO< >RJM[SaUOGYcJMUVScHMG;NSc9;>=< HIGhSLufof UOGn¦XYcHIGNxSc9;>=ac> S9;>ScL]LPJMYon>=O>=JILPm0>jπn«LPa'Sc9UVSo«aUO<?>=¡ LPLa =M.M{=y&{O{V0@O)} 0© >S9;>RG§^X;HIJWn¦LPG¦Sc9;HWY~GUSX;aUOJ>RG0Q LnHMG;NxScLuSU =O>HMGhScLuUPQRQ LPX;GhS Sc9>JWUSc>jYeS~O>RaiYcHILPG£LOoSc9;> JMLONPHMQ=UVJoYc>R<UVGhScHWQRY?LOFfoN f . zO)y 0O<LOG;>LVgSc9;>xHMGhSc>=ac>jYeSHIG;N¥m.LOHMGhSYUV^.LOX;S?S9;HWYY\>=<UVGhScHWQRY=b^UPY\>jn LPGSc9;>BGPSX;HIScHMLOG;HWYeSHMQ~ZHMG;>=UOaTZLPNOHWQV;HWYTSc9UVSTHSF<UVGUONO>=YSLQRUOmScXac>KS9;>Ba>=Y\ScaHWQScHMLOGLPm0>=aUVScLOaoLO fof¤Sc9;aLOXNO9U~Y\HM< m;JI>gSc9>RLOa[ LVZe% 8'9;HWY LPm0>=aUVScLPa=P¡o9;HMQi99UOYUVJM¡U[Yb^0>=>RG UBm;aLO^;JM>R< «aLO< S9;> JILPNOHWQRYFY\HWnM> . )s 02&¡UPYT«LPac< >=acJM[HMn>=GhSc H C>=n¡oHS9uS9;> > ¢HWYeS>RGhScHWUVJ _hXUVGhSPH C>=aLVbS9;> X;Gn>=acJM[]HIGN JMLONPHMQO]¡oHS9 G;LOSlQ LO< m;JM> S>RJM[YcUVScHWYe,UPQSLOa[?a>=YcX;JISYK6n> SiUVHMJI>jnHMGYc>=Q ScHMLOG r M{j ©So9UPY'ac>jQ >RGhSJI[^.>R>=G macLPm0LhY\>jn¦ScL¥UOnn¤G;>=¡ LPm0>=aUVScLOaiYBScL¦QRUOmScX;a><?LPac>m;a>=QRHMYc>RJM[¥Sc9;>< >=UOG;HMG;N¥LVTS9;>ac>jYeSacHWQSHILPG LPm0>=aUVScLPa=S9;>B< LhYeSgUPnUVGQR>=nm;aLOm.LPYUVJ&XY\HMG;RN Q "#?S$T.M{=z 025UVGnxUOJIJML¡oHMG;NUm;a>=QRHMYc>BQRUOmScXac> LO S9;>xY\m0UScHWUVJ'G;LOScHMLOGLVga>=Y\ScaHWQScHMLOGHIG m;aLQ >=YY?QRUVJWQ XJI5H . U0© >m;acLPm0LhY\> 9;>Ra> ScL¥XYc>S9;>¨YcUO< > *. + -,
(14) . z. VWVYXZ![?\^]^].
(15) r. ( ) 7 . . . QRLOGY\ScaXQ ScHMLOGXYc>=n «LOaTSc9;> JMLONPHMQ=UVJZYc>R<UVGhSHMQ=YoLVfof SLNOHMO> UQi9UOaUPQS>Ra H 6jUScHMLOG LVSc9;>?Y\m0UScHWUVJ 0G UScXac>FLVSc9;> πQRUOJMQRX;JIX0Y'^h[ UBS9;>RLPac[LO%e%]Sc90UVG!=YScL?S9;>K>RGQRLnHIGN?< >=GPSHILPG;>=nUV^.LO>P 8'9HMY JWUOY\S&m.LOHMGhS%HWYZSLT^.>ba>RJWUSc>jnK¡oHISc9KS9;>b¡LOa=gLO HxHMJIJM>Ra>. @;{?0]¡o9;HMQi9 UOJIa>=UPn[Y\XQ=Q >=>=n>jnHIG~ac>=m;ac>jY\>=GhScHMG;N S9;> π©Q=UVJWQ X;JMXYoUOY'U Sc9;>=LOa[?HMG&]9;L¡>RP>Ra ¡ >g< UOGUVNP>lSL~NPLBLOG>FY\Sc>=m«X;acSc9;>=aSc9UOGSc90US'¡ LPaL= UPY ¡>>=GQ Ln2> # #? !# SL#? S^ #?S SBHMG¦S9;>S9;>RLPac[PHIG Q LOGhSaUPYeSB¡oHISc9XYcHIG;N£Y\>j_hX;>RGhSY >j_hX;HImm0>jn ¡oHISc9xU YcHINPGUSX;ac>P 8'9;HWY&HIG;>jUVa&LONOHWQSc9;>=LOa[§LVFSc9;>¨UPY\[]GQi9acLPG;LOXY QRUVJWQ XJIXY'NPHIP>=Y?XY= HMG ScX;aGZ'G;>=¡#ScL]LPJMY «LPaa>=UPY\LPG;HIGN§UV^.LOXSSc9;>m;aL]QR>=YY\>jYR ]>=Q ScHMLOG t¤YeSiUVacπSYSLn>jYcQRacHM^.>u9;L¡Sc9>=Yc>¨ScL]LPJMYQRUOG ^0> mXSKScL¡LOa =BZSc9;>UOa\SHMQRJI>?HMYKSc9;>=G£QRLOGQRJIXn;>=n£^][uU n;HMYQ XYYcHILPG£UO^0LPXSSc9;>Y\ScaLOG;NJMHI!G =Y^.> Se¡>R>=G QRUOJMQRX;JMXYoUVGn fofgOY\m0UOQ >oUOGn?JIHMG;>=UOaJMLONOHWQVPUVGn UF«>R¡ ¡LOain;Y Q LPGQ >=acG;HMG;NFSc9>o«XScXac>o¡LOa =BUVG0n π m.>RaiYcm0>jQScHMO>jY'HIG Sc9>=Yc> nLO<UVHMGY= , o R ,R o . . .
(16) . . .
(17) . . . . "!$# %'&(')+*,%'*,-'!. &/ "0&-10-'!. >K^;aHI> A[a>=Q=UVJMJ0S9;> Yc[hGhSiU¢ UOGn Yc>R<UOGPSHMQ=Y'LVSc9;> UPY\[]GQi9acLPG;LOXY πQRUVJWQ XJIXY;UPY'NOHMO>=G HMG2. t40O< &> S ^.>~UOGxHIG C0G;HS>~Yc> STLO 7#?i.aiUVG;NP>=nLO>=ao^h[ x, y, z, . . . 0Sc9;>?Q LOGhS> ¢]S\2«ac>=> Y\[]GhSUV¢ LO S 4#?$ #^NHMYS9;>«LOJMJIL¡oHMG;N < π. . 2. P. <@<. 43. x ¯z x(y)P P |P !P (νx)P. 8'9;> HMGhScX;HIScHMO> < >=UOG;HIGN LObSc9>=Yc>?QRLOGY\ScaXQSiYF^0>=HIG;NS9US LOX;Scm;XSiYFSc9;> < >=YYUVNO> LOGSc9;> iQ 90UVG;G;>=J x x(y)P ac>jQ >RHMO>jY U?< >=YYUVNO>FLOGQi9UVGG;>RJ x UOGnS9;>Rx¯Gz> ¢>jQ XS>=YSc9>FmacLQ >jYcY` z¡o9;>=ac> y a>Rmac>jY\>=GPSiY'Sc9>~a>=QR>RHMO>=n< >=YYUVNO>P acXGYlS9;> Se¡LmacLQ >jYcYc>=YlHIG¨m0UVaiUVJMJI>=J6 !P a>Rm;JMHWQRUS>=YlSc9;> macLQ >jYcY P UVGn (νx)P a>=Y\ScaHMQ SY Sc9;> PY|Q LPPm0>LO%S9;>KGUV< > x HMG P >Y\9UOJIJ Yc>R>?HIGSc9>?G> ¢]S Y\>jQScHMLOG0YlS9USSc9>?JWUOY\SFSe¡ LLVS9;>=Yc>Q LPGYeSacX0QScLPaY=.GUV< >RJM[ UVG0n Uν Va>KSc9;>?LOG>=YoS9USUVa>KSc9>~< LPY\SgnH Q X;JISFScL Qi90UVaiUOQS>RaH 6=>KJILPNOHWQRUOJIJM[O TL¡ >=O>=aoSc9;>~ac>jYeSacHW!QSHILPG LPm0>=aUVScLPa ν HWYbQRacX0Q HWUVJ]ScLS9;>l>R¢]mac>jYcYcHI]HISe[ LV.Sc9> π©Q=UVJWQ X;JMXYh>=Ycm0>jQ HWUVJMJI[BUPYSc9>TY\90UVaHIG;NLO.GUO< >=Y Q=UVG ^.>'Y\>=>RGBUPY%UgYeSacXQ ScX;aHMG;NlLVSc9;> m;acLQR>=YY\>jYZHM&G ! =a>RNPHILPGY=RS9;> < LP^;HIJMHISe[FLO;GUV< >jY%UOJIJML¡oHIGN S9;>'deX;< m«aLO<fof ScL πQRUOJMQRX;JMXYoUVGnSc9]XYo«LOaoHMGYeSiUVGQR> UVG>=UPY\[>=GQ LnHMG;N LVSc9> λQRUOJMQRX;JIX0 Y B HISTYc9;LOX;JWnSc9;>=ac>R«LOa>FGLVSo^0>KG>RNOJM>=Q Sc>jn 8'9;>FHMG;m;XSoUVGnac>jYeSacHWQSHILPGQ LOG0YeSacXQ ScLPaY UOGn ^0LOSc9^HIGnSc9;>gGUV< > HMG J Y X0Y\XUOJ65YcX;^Y\ScHIScXSHIG;NUGUO< > y «LOagUGUV< > xx(y)P HIGUm;aL]QR>=(νy)P YY P .[]HI>=JMnHMG;N P [y/x] .<U[ ya>=_hX;PHMac> ScL a>RG0UV< >gYcLO< >F^0LPX;GnG0UV< >=Y ScL UOLPHMnX;GnX;JM[^;HMGnHMG;N >KY\90UVJMJ5n;>RG;LOSc>F^h[ f n(P ) Sc9>Yc> S'LV «a>R>GUO< >=Y'LVSc9>Km;acLQR>=YY P 0n?> CG>=nUOY'XYcXUVJ2 y 8'9;>KLPm0>=aUVScHMLOGUOJZY\>=<UVGhScHWQRY'HWYoNOHMO>=G HMGSc9> YeSe[]JM>KLVSc9;>~f J H . z 0©;¡oHS9 Sc9; > S^
(18)
(19) SL. S^
(20) #? #R;n > CG;>=nUPYSc9;> Yc<UVJMJI>jYeSlQ LPG;NOaX;>=GQ >FLOGm;aL]QR>=YY\>jYRYUSHMY\«[]HIG;N?S9;>K≡acXJI>jY'LVSUV^JI> {O 65. '7. 8. 9. :7. . . ; =<. V. > ?. @>A.
(21) t.
(22)
(23) !"$#&%'()$ # (. e{=Uh e{R^. 6@VUh 6@^. 6@VQj 6@Vn0 ,zP. P |Q≡Q|P P | (Q | R) ≡ (P | Q) | R (νx)P | Q ≡ (νx)(P | Q) (νx)P ≡ (νy)P [y/x] (νx)(νy)P ≡ (νy)(νx)P (νx)P ≡ P !P ≡ P | !P. (x 6∈ f n(Q)) (y 6∈ f n(P )) (x 6∈ f n(P )). 8UV^;JM> { < hScaXQ ScX;aiUVJ%f LPG;NOaX;>RG0Q > 8'9;>SaUOGYcHSHILPG a>RJWUSHILPG −→ HWYSc9;>KJM>=UPYeSo^;HMGUOac[a>RJWUSHILPGYUSHMY\«[]HIGNBS9;>KacXJI>jY'LVSUV^JI> @ \{j P [z/y] 2@O P −→ P ⇒ x(y)PP| x|¯Qz −→ −→ P | Q 6zP P −→ P ⇒ −→ (νx)P ,rh P ≡ P , P −→ Q, Q ≡ Q(νx)P ⇒ P −→ Q 8%UO^;JI> !@ <8&aiUVGYcHIScHMLOG kl>RJWUScHMLOG . 0. 0. 0. 0. 0. . . )+ . 0%' . ) . !. *,%
(24). 0. 0 . % ,- . . !. 0. 0. '8 9>Ra>UOac>Y\>=O>RaiUVJa>=UOYcLOG0Y SL£QRLOGYcHMn;>RaQ LPGYeSaUOHIGhS Y\[Y\Sc>R<Y?^UPY\>jn§LOGJIHMG;>jUVa JILPNOHWQHMGY\Sc>jUOn§LO QRJMUPYcYcHWQRUVJ'JMLONPHMQ HIGSc9>¨YeSXn[§LOKfof#JMUOG;NOXUONO>jYR KHMaY\S='UOY Yc9;L¡oG HIG . @Osl{jyo{O{^0lJMHMG;>=UOaJILPNOHWQ macL]HWn>=YU~,UVHISc9«X;J&JILPNOHWQRUVJ5Yc>R<UVGhScHWQRY SLfof UVNP>RGhSY=]HSoHWYSc9;>=ac>R«LOa>gGUVScX;aiUVJ.SL UPnLOm;S S9;> YcUO< > JMLONPHMQg«LPaTUVNP>RGhSYlUOGn «LOaTQRLOGY\ScaiUVHMGhSY= ]>jQ LOG0n;S9UV!G =Y'SL Sc9;>~YeSiUVGn;UOan SaUOGY\JWUSHILPG LOQRJMUPYcYcHWQRUVJ JMLONPHMQ~HMGPSLJIHMG;>=UOaJILPNOHWQVJMHIG;>jUVaKQ LPGY\ScaiUVHMGPSKYc[]Y\Sc>=<YFUOac> UNO>=G;>RaiUVJM H 6jUSHILPG¨LV'Q JWUOYY\HWQRUOJQRLOGY\ScaiUVHMGhS Yc[YeS>R<Y=oSc9UVS HWYUVG][ QRJMUPYcYcHWQRUVJFQ LPGYeSaUOHIGhS Yc[YeS>R< QRUOG ^.>m;a>=Yc>RGhS>=n UPY U¤JIHMG;>=UOa QRLOGY\ScaiUVHMGhS Yc[YeS>R< 8'9;HIain5HMG¨LOain>RaTScL >=YQRUVm.> «aLO<S9;>B,UPQSgSc9UVSQRLOGY\ScaiUVHMGhSYTQ=UVG¨LPG;JM[ ^.>?UPn;n>jnScL Sc9;> Y\ScLPac>UOJILPG;NxUxQ LO< m;X;SUSHILPG¥HIG¤fof JMUOG;NOX0UVNO>jYRZYc>RP>RaiUVJ UVaHWUVGhSYLOlfofp¡o9;>Ra> Sc9>Q LOG0YeSaUOHIGhSY Q=UVG^0>xQ LPGYcX;< >=n§^][§UPY =§UONO>RGhSiY~UOGn¦S9hX0Y ac>=<?LP>=n£«aLO< S9;>YeSLOa>O9UP>^.>R>=GHMGhScaL]n;XQ >jn ^][ UOaUPY\¡'USUVGn ZHMGQ LPJIG . @Vsoz;^{ 0KLOMa 1>=Y\S=n2> 1 L]>=aUOGn ` UVJWUV< HWn>=YYcH . r 0O<§S9;>=Yc>UOacHWUVGhSY >=G;9UOGQ >Y\HMNOGPH C0Q=UVGhScJM[?Sc9;>F> ¢m;a>=YYcHIP>Tm.L¡ >=a LOfof UVG0nSc9>QRLOGY\ScaiUVHMGhSY UVa>gGUVScX;aiUVJMJM[?< Ln>=JI>jn UPY«LOa<BX;JWUV>FLVJMHIG;>jUVa'JMLONOHWQV GSc9HMYlYc>=Q ScHMLOG¡ >m;a>=Yc>RGhS'Sc9>KUOacHWUVGhSlfof XYc>=nHIIG .M{=y;{P^{ 0© ® j G Sc9HMYom0UVm.>Raj]U Yc> SoLVUVaHMUO^;JM>=Y HMYon>=G;LVS>=n^][ X Y M M I M]Sc9;> Yc> SoLO&«a>R>UVaHMUO^;JI>jYL]Q=Q X;aaHIG;N?HMG U«LOa<BXJMU HMYKn>=G;LVS>=n^][ &UYc>=_hX;>=GQ >?LVUOacHWUV^JI>jYTHWYKn>RGLVSc>jnu^][ n>=G;LVS>=Y S9;> «LOa<BXJMAU A HMG£¡o9HMQi9Sc9;> f«v(A) a>R>LQ=Q X;aac>=GQ >jYFLV UOacHWUV^;JM>=Y ~x 9UP>~^.>R>=G¥ac>=m;~xJMUPQ A[>jnu~t/~^]x[¨] S>Ra<Y ~t ,¡oHS9Sc9;>KXYcXUOJac>=GUV< HMG;N LV%^.LOXGnUOacHWUV^JI>jYRUOLPHMn;HIG;N?UVaHMUO^;JM>QRJMUPY\9>=Yi . . . . VWVYXZ![?\^]^]. .
(25) U. ( ) 7 . . . KLOa~UuY\>RS n>RGLVSc>jYKS9;> Yc> S?LVCG;HISc>Y\>j_PX>RGQR>=Y LOl>RJM>R< >RGhSiY HMG KLOa~UxScaiUVGYcHSHILPG a>RJWUSHILPG ⇒ ⇒S nS>RGLVSc>jYSc9;>SaUOGYcHSHIP>UOGn ac> A> ¢HMO>Q JMLPYcX;ac>LO ⇒ S 8'9;>B>=YY\>=GPSHMUOJ&nH ;.>=ac>=GQ >B^0>RSe¡ >=>RG¨fof3UVG0nufof HWYoS9USFQ LOG0YeSaUOHIGhSYoUOac>«LPac<~X;JWUV>KLV JMHIG>=UVa JMLONPHMQFUVG0nS9USTQRLO< <BXG;HMQ=USHILPG S9;> acX;JM>jQRLOGYcX;< >=Y'HMG«LOa<USHILPGZ ,± ± =R ® R JIHMG;>=UOa Q LOG0YeSaUOHIGhSY\[Y\Sc>=< 3 ! S (C, ` ) ?. ?. . . . . . . . #?S#. . . . C. 7 # S
(26) # !#gJIHMG;>jUVaTQRLOGY\ScaiUVHMGhSY Q
(27) $S N&?# V ) S^ Q #?'&?# Σ $
(28) R SL# $( 7Q $ $ #?S S$ #
(29) $ )# ^
(30) #?
(31) SL -# # # 1 > !## " #? ?
(32) ># S ∃ ! ⊗ 7$
(33) Q? # C × C I #" #? #T $ " !# ! SL ^() O# $# C #M #$) $
(34) Q? # C ? × C O / ) #$/Q ( #% S^
(35) #? `C
(36) T #$ST & #$#$ #? '
(37) S C# ' # # (#
(38) # >$ @?
(39)
(40) )*
(41) 9. C. . . .
(42) . . . . .
(43) . . . . (. . ;. (. . . . . . 9. .
(44). 6 <. . ;. . . . . ;. . . .
(45) . . . ;. . (. /. . 2<. . . 6. . Γ, c ` d ∆ ` c Γ, ∆ ` d. ;8. . . . . . . 6. .
(46) . =<. . (. Γ`c Γ, 1 ` c. `1. Γ, c1 , c2 ` c Γ, c1 ⊗ c2 ` c. Γ ` c1 ∆ ` c2 Γ, ∆ ` c1 ⊗ c2 Γ ` c[t/x] Γ ` ∃x c.
(47) . 1. =<. 6 <. c`c. 2. . Γ, c ` d x 6∈ f v(Γ, d) Γ, ∃x c ` d. 8'9;> Yc[hGhSiU¢xLV fof 9# lHMYFNOHMO>=G¨HMG¨SUO^;JM>?z.¡o9>Ra> k YeSiUVGn;Yg«LPagmUOaUOJIJM>RJQ LP< m0LhY\HIScHMLOGZ « O L aKG;LPG©n;> Sc>=ac< HMG;HWYeSHMQ?Qi9;LOHWQ >P «LPaKUOacHWUV^JI>?9;HWnHIGNUOGn «LPaK^;JML]Q$=]HMG;NUOYL=. ?8'9;> UScLP< HMQ + UONO>=GPSiY p(~x) . . . UVa>BQ=UVJMJI>jn S 4$#^$7∃ lLOa S :$#$
(48) SL#7$ Z¡ →>?UOYY\X<?> Sc9UVSgS9;>?UOacNPX;< >RGhSYTHIG S9;>BYc>=_hX;>=GQ > ~x UOac> UOJIJnHWYeSHIGQ STUVaHMUO^;JM>=Y= 8'9;> ) UONO>=GPSlHMG¨fof3HWYl¡oaHScSc>=Gx¡oHS9uU X;G;HMO>=aYUVJ _hXUOGhSc H C>RaoHMG LPan;>Ra'ScL < U =P>> ¢m;JMHMQRHSoS9;>UOacHWUV^JI>jY'¡o9;HMQi9UVa>^0LPX;GnHMGS9;>KNOXUOanZ ko>jQ X;aiYcHILPGFHWYLP^SUOHIG;>jnF^h[Fn>=QRJMUOaUVScHMLOGY= > <U =O>S9;>XYcXUOJV9][hm.LVS9;>=YcHWY5Sc9UVS&HMGUon;>=Q JWUVaiUSHILPG UVJMJ;S9;>o«a>R>gUOacHWUV^JI>jYL]Q=Q X;aaHIG;NKHMG LQ=Q X;aHMG 8'9>gYc> SbLOn;>=Q JWUVaiUSHILPGY LOUOGfof p(~ macxLP)NOai=UV<An>RG;LOSc>jnu^][ D ZHWYFSc9>Q JMLPYcX;ac>~^][¨AUVaHMUO^;JI>?a>RG~xUO<?HMG;N LVUYc> SKLV'n>=QRJMUOaUVScHMLOGYgNOHMO>=G «LPaTnHWYeSHIG0QSTm;aLQ >jnX;a>FG0UV< >=Y p J S SL D.A HWYlUY\>RSlLVn>jQ JWUVaiUScHMLOG0Y D SLONO>RSc9;>=ao¡oHS9¨UVG HMG;HIScHWUVJ&UONO>=GPS A 6± § P 8'9>lLOm.>RaiUSHILPGUVJYc>R<UOGPSHMQ=Y HWY n > CG;>jn LOGQ LPG CNPX;aUVScHMLOGY¡o9;>Ra>oSc9>TYeSLOa>lHWYbnHWYeSHIGNOX;HWY\9>=n?«aLO< UONO>=GPSiYR J
(49) S ?HMYoUBScaHImJI> (X; c; A) ]¡o9;>=ac> c HWY'U?QRLOGY\ScaiUVHMGhSQ=UVJMJI>jnSc9>Y\ScLPac>P A HWY'UVG UONO>=GPS'LOa H>R< mSe[PUVGn HWYoU?Yc> S'LVUVaHMUO^;JI>jYRQ=UVJMJI>jnSc9> "#?UOacHWUV^;JM>=YLO UOGn 8'9;> LPm0>=aUVScHMLOG∅UOJY\>=< UOGhScHWQRY'HWYoXn?> CG>=nHIGS9;> YeSe[]JM>KLV%Sc9;>~f J H . )z 0&^][U?ScaiUVG0Y\HIScHMLOGcY\[Y\Sc>=<#A¡o9;HWQi9 n;Lh>jYG;LOSbSi U =O>THIGhScL~UOQRQRLOX;GhS Ycm.>=Q H C0QT>RUVJMXUSHILPGYeSaUVSc>=NOHM>=Y= %8'9;> S^
(50)
(51) SL S^
(52) # $# HWYbSc9;> JM>=UPYeS?Q LOGNOaX;>RGQR>YcUVScHWYe«[]HMG;NxSc9>acXJI>jY LV'SiUV^;JM>z; KLOa~QRLOG]O>=G;HM>RGQR>9;>Ra>OUVGn¥XG;JI@H =O>≡HIG .M{O?{ 02 S9;>FJILPNOHWQRUVJ0>=_hX;HMUVJM>RGQR>gLO%Q LPGYeSaUOHIGhSiYHWY GLVS ^X;HIJIS\©HMG HMGS9;>FQRLOG;NPacX>RGQR>O >F¡oacHISc> Γ, ∆, ... «LOa
(53) <. (. 2. . . 2 <. . . +$,. ;. . <. . 8. . . :7. ;.
(54) . ;. <. V. > ?. @>A.
(55)
(56)
(57) !"$#&%'()$ # (. NO>=GPSiY g>=QRJMUOaUVScHMLOGY `bacLPNOaiUV< J. α . A ::= p(~x) | tell(c) | (A k A) | A + A | ∃xA | ∀~x(c → A) D ::= | p(~x) = A | D, D P ::= D.A. ¯ ~± 0 6± ± . . . z 6∈ f v(A) ∃yA ≡ ∃zA[z/y]. . . , . A k B ≡ A, B (X; c; Γ) ≡ (X 0 ; c0 ; Γ0 ) −→ (Y 0 ; d0 ; ∆0 ) ≡ (Y ; d; ∆) (X; c; Γ) −→ (Y ; d; ∆). . . (X; c; tell(d), Γ) −→ (X; c ⊗ d; Γ) c `C d[~t/~y] ⊗ e (X; c; ∀~y (d → A), Γ) −→ (X; e; A[~t/~y], Γ).
(58) . . . ². 8. . y 6∈ X ∪ f v(c, Γ) (X; c; ∃yA, Γ) −→ (X ∪ {y}; c; A, Γ). ± ² % O , ± O ± . (p(~y ) = A) ∈ D (X; c; p(~y ), Γ) −→ (X; c; A, Γ). . (X; c; A + B, Γ) −→ (X; c; A, Γ) (X; c; A + B, Γ) −→ (X; c; B, Γ). 8%UO^;JI>Kz <fof Yc[]GhSU¢UVGn LOm.>RaiUSHILPGUVJYc>R<UVGhScHWQRY= <~X;JIScHWY\>RSYgLVUVNP>RGhSYTHIGuQRLOGC0NOX;aiUSHILPGYR Tf LPG;NOaX;>RG0Q >KHWYl> ¢]S>RGn>jnScL <BX;JIScHWYc> SYgLVUONO>RGhSiYlHMGxSc9;> LP^]hHMLOX0Yl¡'U[ < Γ ≡ Γ H ; Γ = {A , . . . , A } Γ = {A , . . . , A } UVG0n ∀i = 1, . . . , n A ≡ A 8%¡L¥QRLOG C0NOX;aiUSHILPGYUVa>xYcUOHMn S^
(59) # 2 (X; c; Γ) ≡ (X ; c ; Γ ) '¡o9;>=G Sc9;>¨Yc> SiY X UVGn X UOac> >j_PX0UVJ2ZSc9>Q LOG0YeSaUOHIGhSY c UOGn c UVa> C 2>j_hX;HIUOJI>=GPSj&UVGnS9;><BX;JIScHWYc> SYBLVoUVNP>RGhSY Γ UOGn Γ UOac> QRLOG;NPacX>RGhS= '8'9;> SL ^ ac>=JMUVScHMLOG −→ HWYoS9;>BJM>=UPYeSoSaUOGY\HIScHMO>Ka>RJWUSHILPGLOG¨Q LPGCNPX;aUVScHMLOGY YUSHMY\«[]HIGN~S9;>KaX;JI>jY'LV%SUV^JI> z >K¡oHIJMJ&Q=UVJMJ S#'LVU?QRLOG C0NOX;aiUSHILPG (X; c; Γ) Sc9;> QRLOGY\ScaiUVHMGhS ∃Xc 0. 0. ;. 1 <. (. 0. . ;. VWVYXZ![?\^]^]. . n. 0 1. 0 n. 0. 0. i. 0. 0 i. 0 0.
(60) s. ( ) 7 . . . π GS9;HMYgY\>jQSHILPG¡>KNOHMO>KUOG>=GQ LnHMG;NLO%S9;>BUOYc[]GQi9;aLOG;LPXY π©Q=UVJWQ X;JMXY'HMGPSLfofg«LPJIJML¡oHMG;N Sc9;> HWn>jUOYLO . @O)s 02]9;L¡>RP>Ra ¡>TnL GLVS G>R>=n 9>Ra>oScL~ac>jY\LPa\S SL 9;HMNO9;>=abLOain>=a= %Gn>R>jn Sc9>Ra>lHMYUKLPG;>oScL LPG;>~QRLOaac>jY\m.LOG0n>RGQR>K^0>RSe¡ >=>RG π©Q=UVJWQ X;JMXYoUVG0n¨fof LPm0>=aUVScLOaiY'S9USJI>jUOnSL UO>Ra[xY\HM< m;JM>~UVG0n G0UScXaUOJ5ScaiUVGYcJMUVScHMLOGZ G;>Y\9LOX;JWnKG;LOSc>S9US%Sc9;>XYcXUVJhQi9;LOHWQ >bHMY&ScLgXY\>TU 4$ =LOm.>RaiUScLPa«LOa%Sc9>bG;LPG©n;> Sc>=ac< HMG;HWY\< HMG fofgOS9;HWY QRLOX;JWnUVJMJIL¡ UOG>RGQRLnHIGN LV&U QRLOaac>jY\m.LOG0nHIGNKLOm.>RaiUScLPa «LOabSc9;> πQRUVJWQ XJIXYh9;L¡>RP>Raj >=O>=GBS9;>
(61) SL #$'P>RaiY\HMLOG~LV.Sc9;>lQi9LOHWQ >'LOm.>RaiUSLOaLV5fofgVHWY LOGJI&[
(62)
(63) SL #$'UOGn?HMYS9hX0Y G;LVS UO^;JM>'ScLKa>Rm;JMHMQ=US> S9;> Q$ VQi9;LOHWQ >oLO0S9;> ,Yc[]GQi9;aLOG;LPXY πQRUOJMQRX;JIX0YVSc9HMY HWY ¡o9][BLPG;JM[ Sc9>TYeSiUVG nUVain ,n>RSc>=ac< HMG;HMY\ScHWQ= UPY\[]GQi9;aLOGLOXY QRUOJMQRX;JMXY ¡oHMJMJ^.> Sca>=US>=n¦9>Ra> G;> < HINP9PSUVJWYcL¨¡UOGhSBScL£XYc> UuG;LOGY\SUVG0n;UVain¥O>=aYcHILPG¦LVgπfofg%¡oHISc9 Yc[]GQi9;aLOG;LPXY UOGn 9;L¡>RP>Ra Sc9UVS =]HMGnLVn>=QRHMYcHILPGZ^.>=YcHMn>jY'^0>=HIGN?XG;GUSX;aiUVJ,Yc>R>< LPY\S m0UVm.>RaiYTUV^.LOX;SFtellG;LPG©<?LPask G;LVSLOG;HWQKP>RaiY\HMLOGYlLVfof . @Vs5z;{O.r{P^{ 0«l¡LOX;JWnxJM>=UPnScLU,UVHMJMX;ac>?Y\HM< HIJWUVa SL?Sc9UVSl>RGQRLOX;GhSc>=ac>jnHM2G .I{j)} 0Z¡o9;>=GQRLO< mUOacHMG;Nfof ¡oHISc9Sc9> π©Q=UVJWQ X;JMXY 8'9;> >RGQRLnHIGNoLVSc9>< >=YYcUONO>=YZHMYZSc9;> LOG;>YcX;NONP>=Y\Sc>jngHM&G . @V)s 0©LO^SiUVHMG;>=n^][UOn;n;HIG;NgUVJMJO< >=YYcUONO>jY SL?Sc9;> Y\ScLPac>KUVG0na> SacHM>R]HMG;NBS9;>R<^][<USiQi9;HIGN~S9;> Qi9UOG;G;>RJG0UV< >O 8'9;>BScaiUVGYcJWUScHMLOGHWYlNPHIP>RGHIG¨SUV^JI> r0«LPalS9;> l>=ac^aUOGnxQ LPGYeSaUOHIGhSTYc[YeS>R<UVGn¡oHISc9un;>=Q JWU aiUSHILPGY D . 6. '<. <. 1<. 6. 7. 3. [¯ xz] [x(y)P ] [P | Q] [!P ]. tell(msg(x, z)) ∀y(msg(x, y) → [P ]) [P ] k [Q] bangP bangP = [P ] k bangP ∃x([P ]) 3 3. ¡oHISc9. 3. [(νx)P ]. 3. HMG. D. %8 UO^;JM>Fr < 8&aiUVGYcJWUScHMLOG LVSc9;> UPY\[]GQi9acLPG;LOXY πQRUVJWQ XJIXY'HMGhScLfof 8'9;HWYxQ LP< m0LhY\HIScHMLOGUOJTSaUOGYcJMUVScHMLOG HWY^0LOSc9 Y\LPX;Gn3UOGn3QRLO< m;JM> S>£¡oHISc9ªa>=Ycm0>jQSScLSc9;>£Se¡L SaUOGYcHSHILPGYc[YeS>R< Y < ± ± ,± ± ² % j -# P Q Q$# ^( S
(64) π
(65)
(66) S 4$#^$ #^$ P −→ . . ,. . . . . . .
(67) . ;. 2. . !# !# SL# # " X, Γ Q0 ^
(68) ! (∅; 1; [P ]) −→∗ (X; 1; Γ) Q
(69) $ ( !# ^S
(70) # !R ≡!R | R (∅; 1; [Q0]) −→∗ 0 Q (# ≡
(71) Q # $# S^
(72) #? # . . . . <. ;. <. . . . . . 2. . (X; 1; Γ).
(73) ^. (. =<. . ±Z±. > a>=UOYcLOG^][Q=UOYc>KLOGSc9> ac>jnXQ ScHMLOG 'koX;JM>=YB{ UVGnx@ LO%SiUV^;JM>~@?9UP>KHI< < >=n;HMUVSc> QRLOX;GhS>RamUVacSYFHMG¥fofgZG;LOScHMG;NSc9UVSBY\LP<?>PLOb−→ S9;>Qm.LPYY\HM^;JM> aX;JI>jY<U[¨9UO>?SLx^0>UOm;m;JMHI>jn ^.> «LPac>KUOG ;>=O>=G HI%S9;LPYc>Ka>=nXQ ScHMLOGY'QRLOaac>jY\m.LOGnScLG;LOSc9;HMG;N HMG πQRUOJMQRX;JMXY . .
(74) .
(75) X [ "!#!$ X&% ')( *+ ' " , X .-)! ( X *!$ X/ X ' 0 (:X ' !$ X "1 π2 * 11 V. > ?. @>A.
(76) }.
(77)
(78) !"$#&%'()$ # (. a X;JI>'z;VSc9;> ² aX;JI>'G;>=>=n;YSLg^.>lUVmm;JIHM>=nZV¡o9;HWQi9~HWYSc9;>'a>=UPY\LPG ¡ >onLG;>RS NO> S >R¢UPQSJI[ (∅; 1; [Q ]) KLOaoaX;JI>Fr¡>QRUVGYcHI< m;JM[a>R<UVa=?Sc9UVS'< LhYeSoaX;JI>jYLV&SiUV^;JM> @BQRLOaac>jY\m.LOG0nScL~Sc9> n>?CGHSHILPG LO ≡ HMGufofg5> ¢;QR>RmSFacX;JM> z;.9UVGn;JI>jn¨^][Sc9;> ± ² & O , aX;JI>P.¡o9>RGuHISHMYgHIGuSc9;>?aHINP9PS n;HIa>=Q ScHMLOGZLPaoJI>jUOnHMG;N~ScL Sc9> nPH ;5>Ra>RG0Q >^0>RSe¡ >=>RG Q UOGn Q LOSc9;>=ac¡oHWY\>P ± ± ,± ~± = W# P Q Q$#7)^( S
(79) π $
(80)
(81) S :$#? #?$ KLOa. . . 0. . 0. . . ,. . . . . ,. (∅; 1; [P ]) −→∗ (X; 1; Γ) Q. . ;. <. (∅; 1; [Q]) −→∗ (X; 1; Γ). #. 2. . . . .
(82) ^ ( MS^
(83) #?$ !# . <. . P −→∗. ±Z±. ko>jUOYcLOG;HMG;N^][uHMGnXQ ScHMLOG¦LPGS9;>JM>RG;NOSc9¥LVSc9>fofpac>jnXQ ScHMLOGZUVGnSc9>RG¦^][Q=UOYc>LOG£Sc9;> JWUOY\STY\Sc>Rm&¡>KNO> STUOG>RO>=G<?LPac> n;HIa>=Q STQ LOaa>=Ycm0LPGn>RG0Q >FLOGQR>K¡ > GLVScHWQ >S9USTUPYo¡>K9UO>SiU =O>=G T>Ra^;aiUVGnQRLOGY\ScaiUVHMGhS'Yc[YeS>R<]HSoHWY'G;L¡3Y\ScaiUVHMNO9hS\«LPac¡'UVain~ScLQi9;>j$Q =~S9USoLPG;JI[ UB< >=YYUVNO>FY\>=GhSLPG Qi90UVG;G;>=J x ,H6 >O msg(x, z) QRUVG¥>=GPSiUVHMJ Sc9>NOXUOan ∀y(msg(x, y) → A) UVGnSc9]XYBX;G]^;JML]$Q =uSc9;> B;S9USgHbU acXJI> HWY C0ac>jn¡oHS9;LOXSTSc9;>BQRLOaac>jY\m.LOG0nHIGN ; .¡>BnLG;LOSTNO>RS Sc9> ask Y\ScLPac>~QRUVGG;LVST^.>?>R< mSe[;^ B.Sc90US ± ² & O , ¡oHIJMJ^0>~< HI< HW$Q =O>=n^][a>Rm;JMHMQ=USHILP(X; G Y B51;UVG0Γ)nSc9]XY S9USoS9;>KLOGJI[aX;JM>=YoUO<?LPX;GhScHMG;N~ScLU n H ;.>=ac>=GQ >¡oHMJIJZ^.> ² xacXJI>jYR ©SHMY&¡ LPa\S9KG;LVSHMQRHIG;NlSc9UVS&Sc9>Ra>9UO> ^.>R>=GBUScSc>=<?m;SY&UVSUoa>RP>RaiY\>>=GQ LnHMG;N< LOa>Ycm0>jQ H C0QRUOJIJM[O UVS >R<~^0>jn;nHMG;Nfof HIGhScL¨YcLO< > UVaHMUOGhSYLV'S9;> π©Q=UVJWQ X;JMXYY\>=> «LOa HMGY\SUOGQ > . zP4@ 0 «LOa U«XYcHMLOG Q=UVJWQ X;JMXY >=GQ LnHMG;N LO.G0UV< >l>=_hXUVScHMLOGYbUVGn HMG;>=_hXUVScHMLOGY= TL¡ >=O>=aY\XQi9Ua>RP>RaiY\>'>=GQ LnHMG;NhQRUOG LPG;JM[ QRUVm;ScX;a>UYc<UVJMJhm0UVacSLOSc9>lfof¦mUVaiUOn;HINP<^h[Ka>=Y\ScaHWQScHMG;NgSc9;>oQRLOGY\ScaiUVHMGhSnLP<UVHMG «^0UOYcHMQ=UVJMJI[ SL l>Ra^;aiUVGn0¡o9;HWQi9HMYS9;>K<UVHMGn;PH ;5>Ra>RGQR>^0>RSe¡ >=>RGufof UOGn YcLO< >JWUVG;NPXUVNP>=YJI@H =O>K&HIGnU; HxLPac>=LO>=a= Sc9;> LPm0>=aUVScHMLOG LVBfof n;Lh>jYUOJIJML¡YcLO< >¨P>Ra[¤m.L¡ >=a\«XJgQ LPGYcX;< mScHMLOG LO a>=YcLOXaQR>=Y=UPYBHIS?m.>Raask < HSiY UVG ?Q LPGYcX;< mScHMLOGLVoSe¡L«LPa~< LPac> Q LPGY\ScaiUVHMGPSiYRJM>=UPnHIGNx«LOa HMGY\SUOGQ > ScL£ScaHMhHWUVJoYcLOJMXScHMLOG0Y~LOgm;aLO^JI>=< Y YcXQi9 UOY~Sc9;/> M ) !# S$UOY?HSHWY?m0LhYcYcHM^;JI> SL NPaUO^xSe¡L«LOa =YUScLP< HMQ=UVJMJI[P 8'9;>=Yc>BSe¡Lm.LOHMGhSYUVa>~Sc9;>?<UVHMG£UOacNPX;< >RGhSYT«LOa^;HWn;nHMG;N YcXQi9U a>RP>RaiY\>g>RGQRLnHIGN $ ,& ¥ o , , 8'9>Ba>=Q >=GhSTac>jY\XJSiYTQ LPGQ >=acGHIG;N S9;>BJMLONPHMQ=UVJY\>=< UOGhScHWQRYlLOfof ,Q eW . zOy 0%«LPaFn>RSUOHIJWYTUOGnxm;aL]LV,Yi YcX;NPNO>=Y\STS9USFSc9>~>R¢]HWY\Sc>RGhSHMUOJ_hXUOGPSPH C0>RaFLV %¤HWYY\X QRHI>=GPSFScL m;aLOm.>RaJI[>RG0Q Ln>~Sc9;>?ac>jYeSacHWQSHILPG LPm0>=aUVScLPaLOfofgUVGnSc9]XYoSc9UO!G =YScL?Sc9;> UO^0LP>g>=GQ LnHMG;N0Sc9UVSoLVSc9;> πQRUOJMQRX;JIX0Y J JILPG;NFSc9;>'JMHIG;>jYLV.¡o9US HWY nLOG;>'HMG . @?{ 0;«LOaSc9>'Yc[]GQi9;aLOG;LPXY ©Q=UVJWQ X;JMXYO¡>¡oHIJMJSc9]XY n;?> CG;> U~SaUOGY\JWUSHILPGLO%S9;>KUOYc[hG0Qi9;acLPG;LOX0Y πQRUOJMQRX;JIX0Y'm;acLQR>=YY\>jY HMGhScL%πu«LPac<~X;JWUV>O X;a'NPLPUVJ^.>RHMG;N?ScL HWn>=GPSH«[Sc9;>Ka?> A0> ¢HIP>FUOGnScaiUVGYcHSHIP>KQ JMLPYcX;ac>FLV −→ ¡oHISc9Sc9;>K>=GhSUVHMJM<?>=GhSlac>=JMUVScHMLOG ` . . 7.
(84) . ,. . . 7. 7. 8 8. =<. +. 6
(85) (. 5. . '. . . &. '%. &/ "0. 2!. !=-' . !. . *. + . .
(86) . %'&/*. 2%. 8'9>oHMn>jULV5>RGQRLnHIGN ^][ HMY GLVSG;>=¡KO9;L¡>RP>RaHS XY\X0UVJMJI[ a>=YcX;JISY HMGY\LPX;Gn?^;XSbGLVSbQ LP< m;JI>RSc> >=GQ LnHMG;NhYR 8'9;>bm;aLO^JI>=ν<ªJMHM>=∃Y%HIGBSc9;>acHMNO9hS&aX;JM>b«LPa ∃ «^;XS ^.LVS9 JI>R SUVGnKaHMNO9hS&aX;JI>jY%UOac> G;>=QR>=YYcUOac[ VWVYXZ![?\^]^].
(87) {jy. ( ) 7 . . . «LPa'Sc9;> YcLOXGnG;>jYcY'UOYoYc9;L¡oGJMUVSc>=aoHIGJM>R< <U~r0 I{^< Γ ` A[t/x] Γ ` ∃xA. © ¡>¨¡'UVGhSScLHIGhS>Ram;ac>RSSc9HMY UOY πQRUOJMQRX;JMXY'm;aL]QR>=YY\>jYR'¡>¨NO>RSSc90US HI P −→ Q[t/x] S9;>RG ¡o9;HMQi9HWY'LO^]]HILPXYcJI[ ,UOJMYc>O«LPaoHIG0YeSiUVGQR>F¡oHISc9 P −→ (νx)Q TL¡ >=O>Raj¡>BnL G;LVSF¡UOGhSlScLQi9UVG;NP>Sc9;>?JMLONOHWQRYl^h[xUPn;nHMx¯G;zN−→ UYc>=QR(νy)¯ LOGnxm0yUVacSTScLSc9;> Y\>j_hX;>RGhSY SL 9;LOJWnU ^
(88) SL#'UPY'¡UPYonLOG>FHM2G . @;^{ 0 «ScL?SU =O>HIGhSLUOQRQRLOX;GhS'9;HWn;n>RGUVaHWUV^;JM>=Yi TYcHMG;NY\LP< > G>R¡Q LPG;G;>=Q ScHMO>jYK¡ LPX;JWn¦UVJWY\Lx^.> U¨YcLOJMXSHILPGSLuQi9UOaUPQSc>=ac@H 6R>?S9;>a>=Y\ScaHMQ ScHMLOG¥LOm.>RaiUSLO4a B UxNOL]Ln Q=UVGn;HMn;UVSc>l¡LOXJMn?S9;>RG^.>oS9;> $SL#? #^$ LOm.>RaiUSLOaLO .M{=z;]@P4t 02]UOYbXYc>=n HMG . U02]^;XS'UOY ¡>TYc9UVJMJ0Yc>R> S9;>FXY\X0UVJ5LOm.>RaiUSLOaiY LV&F Hu&£UVa>gYcX Q HM>RGhS'UOGnUOJIJML¡ XY ScL?^0>UV^JI>gScL =O>R>=mXYcHMG;N S9;>FScL]LOJWYbLO %¥ScLac>jUOYcLOGUV^.LOXSlS9;> a>=YcX;JIScHMG;NYc>R<UVGhScHWQRYB,Yc>R>K«LPalHIG0YeSiUVGQR&> . @O)} 0&«LPagYcLO< >KXYc> LVS9;>Bm;90UOYc> Yc>R<UOGPSHMQ=Y LV&%ScL~Qi9;>=$Q =~Sc9;>FQ LPaca>=Q ScG;>jYcYLOZm;acLOScLQ LPJMY> ¢m;a>=YY\>jn~HMGfof'¡oHS9;LOX;Sb,UVJMJMHIG;NBHIGhScL S9;>KXYcXUVJ5SaUOm LO%S9;> ∃ >RGQRL]n;HIG;N >R¢]mJMUOHIG;>jnUV^.LO>O >Q=UVG;G;LOSXYc>¨9;>=ac>uU¦ScaiUVGYcJMUVScHMLOG LO XYcHMG;N UOGn ^.>=Q=UVXYc>¨LVBQRLO< m;JM> S>RG;>jYcY a>=UPY\LPGY?Y\HM< HIJWUVa SLS9;LPYc>> ¢m;JWUVHMG;>=n¤«LOa S9;>¨x(y)P Yc>R<UVGhScHWQRY LO∀Ffof(HMG .M{O?{ 02 1'UOYcHWQRUVJMJM[¥Sc9;>xaHINP9hS HM< m;JMHMQ=UScHMLOGxaX;JM>BJM>=UPn;YoSL ? # S#$# )# S$.«LOaTHMGY\SUOGQ >~¡ > 90UO> A, msg(x, y) ` A ⊗ msg(x, y) UOGn Sc9]XY ¡o9;HWQi9LOQ LOXaYc>KnL]>=YoG;LOSgQ LPaca>=Ycm.LOGnScLUOGh[hS9;HIGN HMG π©Q=UVJWQ X;AJMX`Y7 msg(x, K;LPaSc9;y)HWY( ac>jUOmsg(x, YcLOG¨¡>y)YeSHM⊗$Q =uA¡oHS9¥UYc>=Q LPGnLOain>Ra^UPY\>jnxScaiUVG0Y\JWUSHILPGu>RP>RG£HSc9HMY macLP^;JI>=< Q LPX;JWnm;aLO^0UV^;JM[^.>UPLOHWn>=n ¡oHISc9G;LOG;©QRLO< <BXSiUSHIP>gJMLONPHMQFUOY'HM2G . zP)y 02 8'9;>¨Yc>=QRLOGn LPan>=a HMYUOJMYcL¥G;>=QR>=YYcUOac[¥«LPa ! UPY HSHWY¡>RJMJ =]G;L¡oG Sc9UVSSc9;> ! LVK& QRUOG;G;LVS a>RmJIHWQRUVSc>FSc9UVSoLV π©Q=UVJWQ X;JMXY KHMGUVJMJI[PHIST¡LOX;JWn^0>Km.LPYY\HM^;JM>KHIG¨%¦UVJWY\L?SL>RGQRLn> M U 4 O>=aYcHILPG LO%S9;>BQi9;LPHMQR>KLOm.>RaiUSLOaj ¡o9HMQi9 HWY¡o9UVS¡UPYnLOG>oHIG . @^{ 0©h^;XSb¡>lnL G;LOS «>R>=J;Sc90USbHISb¡LOX;JWn?^0>l¡LOacSc9 >R¢]mJMUOHIG;HMG;NKHMG< LOa> n;> SUOHIJWY=;UVGn ¡oHIJMJ5Sc9>Ra> «LOa>YeSHM$Q =¡oHISc9S9;>KUOYc[hG0Qi9;acLPG;LOX0Y πQRUOJMQRX;JIX05Y B>=Ycm0>jQ HWUVJMJI[YcHIG0Q >FSc9;7> :$ Qi9LOHWQ >QRUVG^.>K>R<~^0>jn;n>=nHMGS9;>,n;> Sc>=ac< HMG;HWYeSHMQjoUOYc[]GQi9;aLOG;LPXY πQRUOJMQRX;JMXY'JI@H =O>FS9U4S < ∗. ∗. ∗. 7. <. 8. . 2. 5. . . 6. . . P + Q ::= (νx)(νy) (¯ xy | x(z).P | x(z).Q) ' . . + . *. ). #. 8'9> m;aLQ >jYcYc>=Y~LVgSc9;>xUOYc[]GQi9;aLOG;LPXY πQRUOJMQRX;JMXYoUVa>S9;>RGScaiUVGYcJWUSc>jn¦«LPJIJML¡oHIGN¨Sc9>HMGnX0QScHMO> n;?> CG;HIScHMLOG LVZSiUV^;JM>KtKHMGPSLB«LPac<~X;JWUV>T^X;HIJIS'¡oHS9S9;>TS9;a>R>UScLP<Y rcv msg UVGn loc LV%ac>jY\m.>=Q ScHMO> UOacHISe[z S9;HIainUVaNOX;< >=GPSoHWYoY\>jQ LPGnLPan;>Ra@?UVGn{O 3. . . x ¯z x(y)P P |Q !P (νx)P. . 3. . 3. . . . . . . 3. . . msg(x, z) rcv(x, y, P ) P ⊗ Q !P ∃x(loc(x) ⊗ P ) . . . . . . 3. . . 8%UO^;JI> t!<ZHMG;>=UOalZLONPHMQ ]>=< UOGhScHWQRY . V. > ?. @>A.
(89) {P{.
(90)
(91) !"$#&%'()$ # (. 9;>=ac> UOGn UOac> n?> C0G;>=nXYcHIG;NxYc>=QRLOGnuLOain>RaUOYHMG . @?{ 0T«¡>~XYc>?Sc9;>YUV< > G;LVSiUSHILPG 9>Ra>oScL?^0>FQ rcvLPGY\HWY\Sc>RGh!SjP9;L¡>RP>RaHISoY\9;LPX;JWnG;LVS^0>Q LPG«XYc>=n¡oHISc9Sc9;> D LO&Q LPX;aYc>^ElLPm0>=aUV! ScLOabLV&& GLVSc>jnHMGSc9;> YUV< >¡'U[HIGxUVmm0>=GnHI¢ J ? < rcv(x, y, P ) ⊗ msg(x, z) ` P [z/y] !P a`P ⊗!P. > UVJWY\L HM< m0LhY\>FSc9>«LOJMJIL¡oHMG;N G;LOG;2JMLONPHMQ=UVJ5U¢HILP<M< ∃x(loc(x))a`1 8'9;>jY\>UOac> UVJMJ S9;>U¢HMLO<Yg«LOa<?HMG;NLOXa Y\HM< m;JI>%Sc9;>=LOa[O&UOGn£¡oHS9S9;>UV^.LO>?>RG0Q LnHMG;N S9;>R[¦UOac>>=G;LOXNO9¥ScL>RGQRLn>m;a>=QRHMYc>RJM[Sc9;>UOYc[]GQi9;aLOG;LPXY π©Q=UVJWQ X;JMXYoUPY ¡oHMJIJ'^.> Yc9;L¡oG¦HIG¤Sc9;> «LPJIJML¡oHMG;N?Yc>=Q ScHMLOGY= . '. 9*,-'%. . '%' . !. !. > ¡oHMJMJGCaiY\S «LQ XY~LOG§YcLOX;G0nG;>=YY a>=YcX;JISY=¡o9;HMQi9§UOJS9;LOXNO9¦LV S>RG¤_hX;HISc>ScaHI]HWUVJ2 UVa> Sc9;> <?LhYeS HM< m0LPa\SiUVGhS¡o9;>RGG;>R>jnHIGNSL XYc>x«m;aiUOQ ScHWQRUOJIJM[;'Sc9> Yc>R<UOGPSHMQ=YR.«LPaFHMGY\SUOGQ >~«LOam;aL]HIG;NYcUV«> Se[ macLPm0>=a\SHI>jYF6Y\>=>«LOaoHMGY\SUVG0Q > .I{jy)0Z«LPalU?n;HMYQ XYYcHILPGUO^0LPXS'Sc9;HWYoHWYcYcX;>j -# P Q Q# # ^( S
(92) π $
(93)
(94) S 4$#^$ #?T § P ≡Q. !# . . . . . . P a` Q.
(95) .
(96) 8. ;. 2. . 2. . #. . ±Z±. >Kac>jUOYcLOG^][Q=UOYc>gLPGS9;>acX;JM>=YLO&SUO^;JM>?{PLOX;aSaUOGY\JWUSHILPG^.>RHMG;N ^UOYc>=n LOGSc9UVS'LOHxHMJMJI>=a= ¡>¡oHIJMJ&QRLOGQR>RGhScaiUS>gLPGS9;> nH ;.>=ac>=GQ >jYoUVGn Sc9]XYon;> SUOHIJ&LOG;JM[Sc9>KacX;JM>=Yl@OU~ScL@Vn koXJI>@VUKJM>=UPn;YXYbScL~m;aLO>'Sc90US ¡o9;>=G S9;> ` mUVacSbHWYbLP^SUOHIG;>jn^][?UBJI>R S ∃ ac∃x(loc(x) X;JM>OP«LOJMJML¡ ⊗>jn R)^h[ ⊗U Sa`∃x(loc(x) aHMNO9hS ∃ aX;JM>~«⊗¡oHIRSc9 ⊗t S)Qi9;LPYc>RG SLBx^.6∈> fxn(S) UVGn UV¢HILP< Y= 8'9;> a mUVacS'«LOJMJIL¡lY> ¢;UPQScJM[S9;> YcUO< >FmacL]LVYeSacX0QScXac>P koXJI>@^£JM>=UOnYgX0YFScLm;aLO> S9US ¡o9;>=G 8'9>Bm;aL]LVYeSacX0QScXac>~HMYg> ¢;UOQ ScJM[S9;> Yc∃x(loc(x) UO<?>~UOYFUV^.⊗LOR)a`∃y(loc(y) >O0^;XS t HMYgG;L¡⊗Qi9;R[y/x]) LhY\>=GxScL ^0> x «yLPa 6∈`f UOn(R) Gn y «LPa a koXJI>¨@VQHWY nLOG;>HMG U£YcHI< HMJMUOa?<UOG;G;>RajbX0Y\HMG;NSc9;>¨YUV< > Sc>=Qi9G;HM_hX;>UOYzPQSL¥NO> S UVG0n n;PH ;5>Ra>RGhS=;UOGn Sc9;>=GSc9;> YUV< >FSc>jQi9;G;HW_PX>UPYozOU~ScL NP> SoSc9> loc(x) HIG0Y\HWn> ∃y UOGna>=QRHImacLxQRUOJIJM[O y koXJI>l@VnZHMY UFnHMac>jQS Q LOG0Y\>j_PX>RGQR>bLV.JI>R S ∃ aX;JM>UOGn LO;Sc9;>'G;LPG©JILPNOHWQRUVJ]U¢HMLO< ∃x(loc(x))a`1 . . . . . ]± . . ∗. P −→ Q. !# . . . ± ² % j . . P ` Q. #. . -#.
(97) . P. . Q. Q$# 7# )^( S
(98)
(99) . ;. 2. . . $
(100)
(101) > S 4$#^$ #?T π 2. ±Z±. 1[HMGnX0QScHMLOGLOGS9;>ScaiUVGYcHIScHMLOG P −→ Q 8'9;>K^0UOYc>Q=UOYc> HMY'LP^h]HMLOXYK6U¢HMLO<#aX;JM>j KLOaKS9;>HMGnXQ ScPHMLOGZ−→ ¡ >PmacLQ >=>=n£^][Q=UOYc>?LPG£Sc9;>JWUOY\SKScaiUVG0Y\HIScHMLOG P −→ R −→ Q &G;LOScHMG;N S9US^][~HMGnXQ ScHMLOG9][]m0LOSc9;>jY\HWY¡>TUOJIa>=UPn[B9UP> P ` R UOGn S9USbX0Y\HMG;NKS9;>gQRXS aX;JM>l¡ >TLOG;JM[ G>R>=nScLmacLP>TS9US R −→ Q HM<?mJIHM>=Y R ` Q . . . . ∗. ∗. ∗. . . . . . . VWVYXZ![?\^]^]. . .
(102) {@. ( ) 7 . . . >m;aLO>?Sc90USB^][uHMGnX0QScHMLOG¦LPG£Sc9;>Yc H 6=>LVSc9>m;aLhLO««LOa FS9US BSc9;>^0UOYcHMQ =Q UOYc>lQ LPaca>=Ycm0LPGn;YSL acXJI> {TLV5SUO^;JI>F@PUOGn?Sc9>THMGnXQ ScHMLOGHWYLO^;SUVHM⇒G;>jn ^h[ QRUPRY\>o−→ LPG RQ−→ Q ¡oHISc9 aX;JM>=Y@SL r0 >?n>RSUOHIJ 9;>=ac>BSc9;> aX;JM>=Y~{?UOGn¨r05Sc9;> LVS9;>RaFLOG>=YF^0>=HIGNSacHM]HMUOJUOm;m;JMHMQ=USHILPGYTLO S9;>KHMGnXQ ScHMLOG9][hm.LVS9;>=YcHWYR 8'9;>Q=UOYc>LVacX;JM>x{HWYK>=UPY\HMJI[uLO^SiUVHMG;>=n«aLO< S9;>UVmm;JIHWQRUVScHMLOG£LVSc9;>GLOG©JILPNOHWQRUOJUV¢HILP< «LOa rcv 8'9;>QRUOYc>LVKaX;JI>xr¦HWY S9;>x«LOJMJML¡oHIG;N <x¡ >xG>R>=nSL§m;aLO> Sc9UVS R ` Q =]G;L¡oHMG;N¥S9US UVGn K;aLO< JM>R< <Ur M{ ¡ > NO>RS 7 UOGnuSc9;>YUV< >~«LOa R UOGn≡^]R[,HMGRnX−→ Q ScHMLOGQ9][hm.LVS9;Q>=YcHWYo≡¡ Q>9UP> R ` Q 0¡ >S9;>RG?deXRY\STa`G;>=>=Rn ScLUOm;m;JM[Se¡oHWQ >Sc9>BQ QXS aX;JM>FScL NO>RSoSc9;>K>R¢]m.>=Q Sc>jn a>=YcX;JIS= >¡oHMJIJ G;L¡ SUO$Q =]JM>Sc9>< LOa>Q LO< m;JM> ¢¦Q LP< m;JI>RSc>=G;>=YYKa>=YcX;JSiYRNOHM]HIGNxXYBUxm.>Rac«>=Q SB<USiQi9 ^.> Se¡>R>=GS9;>ScaiUVG0Y\HIScHMLOGac>=JMUVScHMLOGUVGn HISYoJMLONPHMQ=UVJQ LPX;GhSc>RamUOa\Sj >£¡oHIJMJ YeSiUVacS^][ YcLO< >£m;ac>=JIHM< HIG0UVa[ a>R<UOLa =YLPG S9;>¦YeSacXQ ScX;a>£LV S9;>¥m;acL]LO,YLP^SUOHIG;>jn ^][ SaUOGYcJMUVScHMLOGLO πQRUOJMQRX;JMXY'm;aL]QR>=YY\>jYR § ± P ` Q S Q #? !# #?S# 7 S ! ' # . . . 0. 0. 0. 0. . . 0. . * . 10 . . . . % . . !. (. <=. . , . . ;. . < . <. . . "# !# S. . . . <.
(103) . . 2. . . . . 1. . 2 . . # S^SL#? #" ;. +. =<. . ±Z±. &> SlXYlY\SUOa\So¡oHISc9Sc9> QRUOYc>FLVacHMNO9hS . . !.
(104) # #" ∃ S^
(105) @#^ S
(106) 4 # 4#^ S # S^ S^
(107) #? # . . 0. . . '. . 0. . ;. S^
(108) #^> ⊗. . . . 8. #5 7# . <. ∃. Γ, Γ0 ` loc(x) ⊗ ∆ Γ, Γ0 ` ∃x(loc(x) ⊗ ∆). J JIJS9;>~aX;JM>=YUV^.LO> Sc9UVSLPG;> S9USKUVa>BGLVSacHMNO9hS acX;JM>=YFLPG;JI[xUPQSLOG¨S9;>?JI>R SmUOa\SLVbSc9;> cY >=_hX;>=GhS:BUOYbSc9;>=ac>FHWYbG;L Q LPGnHIScHMLOGLPGJM> S'acXJI>jYRhSc9>R[Q ⊗LPX;JWn9UO>g^0>=>RGUVm;m;JMHM>=n^.> «LPac>gSc9>gaHINP9hS 0S9;>Ra>BHWYTSc9]XYUVG;LOSc9;>=aTm;aL]LVLO Sc9;> YcUO< >~Yc>=_hX;>RGhST¡oHISc9uSc9;>?aHINP9PS ⊗ deXYeSKUV^.LO>S9;>?acHMNO9hS ∃ ∃ aX;JM>O KLOa'Sc9>KJI>R SlacX;JM> < Γ, loc(x) ⊗ ∆ ` Γ0 Γ, ∃x(loc(x) ⊗ ∆) ` γ 0. 8'9;>¨YUV< > =]HIGn LOga>=UOYcLOGHIG;N£UVm;mJIHM>=:Y <acX;JM>=Y LPG¤S9;>acHMNO9hSQRUOG^.>xY\¡'UVmm0>jn¤¡oHISc9;LPXSUVG][ SacLPX;^;JM> B5LOGS9;>?JI>R Sg< LOa>BaX;JM>=YTQ=UVG¨^.>~UOm;m;JMHI>jnxLOG¨Sc9;>~JIL¡>RaTYc>=_hX;>=GhSTSc90UVG¨LPGxSc9;>~X;m;m.>RaFLOG;> ,JI>jYcY«a>R>UVaHWUV^;JM>=Yi;UOGnS9]XYoaX;JI>jYSc9UVSTnL G;LVSoSLOXQi9 Sc9> ⊗ QRUOG ^.> Yc¡UOm;m0>jn«a>R>=JI[ScL]L J JIJ]S9;HMYm;aL]LVQ=UVGBUOJMYcLT^.>oY\>=>RGBUPY%UFY\HM< m;JM>QRLOGYc>=_hX;>=GQ > LVUgNO>RG>RaiUVJM H 6=>=nO>=aYcHMLOGKLV«L]QRXYcHIG;N macL]LV,Y .M?{ 0 ∃ UVGn ⊗ 9UP>gS9;> YUV< > $( S (R«LPaoF H¨&¥¡oHISc9xYcLO< >G;LOG;2JMLONPHMQ=UVJU¢HMLO<YR ]± B± = -# P Q Q$# #)^( S
(109) π $
(110)
(111) S 4$#^$ #?. . . . . P ` Q . . . !# . . . ,. . P −→∗ Q.
(112) . 2. 8. 2 /. 2. #. V. > ?. @>A.
(113) {jz.
(114)
(115) !"$#&%'()$ # (. ±Z±. > ac>jUOYcLOGx^][HIGn;XQSHILPGLPGxSc9;>?m;aL]LVbLO THxLOa>Bmac>jQ HWY\>=JI[P.¡> QRUVGuG;LVSHMQR>BS9US HMGSc9>Bm;aL]LVe;S9;> aHINP9hSgY\HWn> LOSc9;>BYc>=_hX;>=GhST¡oHIJMPJUVJM`¡U[QY'^.> LV S9;>K«LOa< R «XYcHIGNJI>=< < Ur z «LPalS9;>~aHMNO9hS ∃ aX;JM>jUOGnSc90USgLPGxSc9>BJM> S¡ >?QRUVG¨UOJI¡'U[Yoa>Rm;JWUOQR>BQ LP<?<UPYl^][ ⊗ UOGnxm;X;SFUVG UVaLOX;G0n HI Sc9>Ra> HMYgU SLNO>RSlSc9>KScaiUVGYcJWUScHMLOGLO Um;acLQR>=YYRS9;>BHMGnX0QScHMLOGS9]XYl<U =P>=Y ∃x Yc>RG0Y\>P LVSc>?S9USK¡>?90Uloc(x) O>~ScLxUVJMJIL¡ Q XSiYLOG£G;LOG©JMLONOHWQRUOJUV¢HILP< YFHMG£Sc9;> m;aL]LV,Y=Z^;XSSc90USKSc9HMY n;Lh>jY'G;LVSlHMG]UVJMHMn;UVSc>FSc9> UV^.LO>Fac>jUOYcLOG;HMG;N KLOa S9;>^0UOYc>QRUPY\>P%HIoSc9;> JMUPYeS~acX;JM>HWYBUOG¤U¢HMLO< S9;>RG¤¡ >NP> S S9;>a>=YcX;JISB^][¥ac > A> ¢HMhHISe[uLO −→ 8'9;>Q=UOYc> LVSc9;>G;LPG©JILPNOHWQRUVJ UV¢]HMLO<YHWY UVJWYcL HM< <?>jnHWUSc> UOYFSc9>R[QRLOaac>jY\m.LOG0nunHMac>jQSJI[¨¡oHISc9 S9;>RHMa πQRUVJWQ XJIXYoQRLOX;GhS>RamUVacS= 8'9;> Q=UOYc>LV&S9;> Q X;SlacX;JM>HMYTnHIa>=Q ScJM[n>=acHMO>jn«aLO<S9;>ScaiUVG0Y\HIScHM]HSe[LO © S9;>Bm;aL]LV>RGnYT¡oHISc9¨UaHMNO9hS ⊗ acXJI>«Sc9UO!G =YoSLJI>=< < Ur z;;S9;>~Q=UOYc−→ >KLVSc9;> HIGYcHWn>BUVG Q∃ RUOG^.>FSca>=US>=n Y\>=mUVaiUS>RJM[ ]¡ >F9UO> P = P ⊗ P S9hX0Y P = P | P UVG0nSc⊗9>YUV< >g«LOa ¡oHISc9 UVG0n ' 1[HIGn;XQSHILPGx9h[]m.LVS9;>=YcHMYT¡ >B9UO> UOGn P −→ Q S9]XYl^][ Q UOm;m;JM[]HIG;N Qa>Rm.>=UVSc>=Qn;JI[aX;JM>=Yl@~LV%SUO^;JI>B@?UOGnu{jU?LVSUV^JI> {P¡ >K−→NP> S PQ | P −→ _h>=n Q |Q 8'9;> Q=UOYc>LV&S9;>KJM> S ⊗ HMY'HM< <?>jnHWUSc>P ©Sc9;>KmacL]LV>RGnY'¡oHS9U?aHINP9hS ∃ aX;JM>Om;a>=QR>=n>jnHM< <?>jnHWUSc>=JI[ ^][U?acHMNO9hS ⊗ aX;JI>P]Sc9UO!G =YScL JM>R< <U?r z;¡>NO> 4S < . . . . . . . . ∗. ∗. . . 1. . 1. . 2. . 1. . ∗. 2. 1. 1. 1. 2. 2. 2. ∗. 2. ∗. 1. 2. Γ ` loc(x) ∆ ` Q1 Γ, ∆ ` ∃x(loc(x) ⊗ Q1 ) . . >NO>RS Sc90US G>=Q >jYcYUVaHMJI[¨>j_hXUVJWY UPYSc9>Ra>HMY G;L¨JMLONOHWQRUOJU¢HMLO< QRLOGQR>RaG;HMG;N >BQ=UVGG;L¡ªXY\>S9;> HMGnXQ ScHMLOGx9][]m0LOSc9;>jY\HWYoLPG ∆loc(x) UOGnG;L¡'U[ScLUPn;ΓnxUVG ∃ HMG«acLPGhSlLVHSj loc(x) UVG0n O U G u n R Q O L G R Q I J X ; n ~ > ] ^ x [ ; G O L c S W H. Q M H ; G N S 9 U S « a O L < V U m ; m I J ] [ M H ; G N c a = > 0 m j > U c S j > n M J x [ c a ; X M J ? >. r O L S O U ; ^ I J > @ H Q R −→ R S9;>RG (νx)R −→ (νx)R _h>jn 8'9;> Q=UOYc>LV&S9;>KJM> S ∃ HMYlHI< < >=nHWUS>O . . ∗. 1. ∗. 0. 0. . & R ¥ o , B ,$ T, π `bacL]HWnHIGN USc9;>=LOa[«LOaoS9;>BUPY\[]GQi9;aLOGLOXY QRUVJWQ XJIXY'HMG¨ZHMG;>jUVaT&LONOHWQKUVJMJML¡lY'XY'ScLXY\> UOJIJ&Sc9;> SL]LOJWYLVo&ScLxa>=UPY\LPGUV^.LOX;S πQRUOJMQRX;JMXY'm;aπL]QR>=YY\>jYR G£Sc9HMY Yc>=Q ScHMLOG£¡ > ¡oHMJIJbNOHMO> > ¢;UV< m;JM>=YLO 9L¡ Sc90USTQRUOG 9>RJMmXGn>RaiY\SUVG0nHIGN~^.> ScSc>RalSc9;>K^.>R9U]HMLOa'LV YcLO< > π©Q=UVJWQ X;JMXYoUVNP>RGhSY= . . . . )+*9*. != @ . )(&. . '8 9> CaiYeSl^UPY\HWQXYc> LV&LONOHWQRYSLa>=UOYcLOGUV^.LOX;STm;aLONOaiUV<YHWYlm;aL]LV Y\>jUVaiQi9Z bGxLPX;aTQ LPGhSc> ¢]Sj;LOG;> Q=UVGG;LOSc>oS9US Sc9;>FQ LP<?mJI>RSc>RG>=YY Sc9>RLOa>R< r rBQ=UVGUVJMJML¡XYbScLBac>jUOYcLOGUV^.LOXS JIHMO>=G;>=YYm;aLOm.>RacScHM>=Y LO π©Q=UVJWQ X;JMXY'm;aLQ >=YYc>=Yl P ` Q HM< m;JMHI>jY P −→ Q hUOGn?Sc9;>gY\LPX;GnG;>jYcYSc9;>=LOa>R< r @UV^.LOXS YU«>RSe[m;aLOm.>RacScHM>=Y P 6` Q HM<?mJIHM>=Y P −→ Q HxLPac>Kmac>jQ HWY\>=JI[P;< U =]HIGN U JWU 6=[XYc>KLVS9;>KG;LOG;2JMLONPHMQ=UVJZU¢HMLO<Y«LOa< HIGN Sc9;>KS9;>RLPac[PU m;aL]LV Yc>=UOaQi9HIIG CaiY\S LOain>RaF H¨% QRUVG¥^.>=QRLO< >ac>jUOYcLOGUO^;JM> «a>=Q=UVJMJ Sc90US=%¡oHS9¦G;LSc9;>=LOa[O- CaY\SKLOain>Ra . . VWVYXZ![?\^]^]. . ∗. . . ∗. . . . .
(116) {=r. ( ) 7 . . . F Hu&xHWYHMG` ]` J f . @Oy)0 8'9;>Ra>TUVa>lUVJMa>=UOn;[BJMLVSYbLV&&HIG;>jUVab&LONPHMQS9;>RLPac>=< m;aLO>=aY UUOHIJWUV^;JM>O >jY\m.>=QRHMUOJIJM[Y\HMGQR>g&9UPYb^.>=QRLO< >F_hX;HISc>Fm.LOm;X;JWUVa'UOYUBYcm.>=Q H C0Q=UScHMLOG JMUOG;NOX0UVNO>. @P@];@]5{:U5{jt)02UVG0n S9;>R[QRUOG ^.>KXYc>=n «LOalU?m;aL]LVYc>=UOaQi9Sc9UVSl¡oHIJMJZXYc>^0LOSc9«LOa¡'UVaina>=UOYcLOGHIG;N~«LOa'S9;>KJM> STYcHMn>KLO S9;>Yc>=_hX;>RGhS,QRLOm][]HIGN S9;> πQRUVJWQ XJIXY'a>=n;XQSHILPGYg^;X;SBUVJWY\L^UP$Q =h¡'UVainxa>=UPY\LPG;HIGN«LPaSc9;>aHINP9hS m0UVacSK6Q LPGQ JMXYcHILPG NPX;HMn;>=nY\>jUVaiQi90 . . . "!= . . . )+*. !$ . . "%. &!. 8'9>Bm;9UPY\>?Y\>=<UVGhScHWQRYgHMYgS9;>BGUVScX;aiUVJm;aLUV^;HMJIHISe[Y\>=< UOGhScHWQRYgLV &HIG;>jUVaFZLONPHMQ .I{=r0© F©S9UPYT^.>R>=G a>=QR>RGhScJM[XYc>=n¨¡oHISc9Sc9>?Ycm0>jQ H C0Q?UVHM< LVbm;aL]HIGNYcUV«> Se[xm;aLOm.>RacScHM>=YgLVfof UONO>RGhSiYT.M{=y {P{VZ@V})0 UOGn HMYlQRX;aac>=GPSJI[Y\ScX0nHI>jnUOYoU?mUVaiUOn;HINP< «LOaoHMGCG;HISc>BY\SUVSc>KYc[]Y\Sc>=<Y'<?Ln>=JQi9;>jQ$=hHMG;N0 gY\HMG;N Sc9;> Y\LPX;GnG>=YYoSc9>RLOa>R<r0 @;.HISHMYFm.LPYY\HM^;JM> ScL XYc>BS9;>?YUV< >BSc>=Qi9G;HM_hX;>?UOYTSc9UVSFX0Y\>jn «LPa?fof UVNP>RGhSY=ScL£m;aLO>YU«>RSe[£macLPm0>=a\SHI>jY ^][§Y\>jUVaiQi9;HMG;N«LOa m;9UPY\>Q LPX;GhSc>Rac©<?Ln>=JMY=¡o9;HWQi9 UO< LOX;GhSYBScL£Y\LP< > =]HIG0n§LVTUO^Y\ScaiUOQS?HIGhS>Ram;ac>RSUVScHMLOGZ £©S?HWY?UVJWY\LLVTQ LPX;aiY\>m.LPYYcHI^;JM> ScLuX0Y\> Sc9;> >=GQ LnHMG;N NOHMO>=G HMGY\>jQScHMLOGxz UVG0nSLXY\>FS9;>RGSc9> fof SL]LOJWYo< >RGhScHMLOG;>jn UO^0LP>O . )( . . :-. . "0 . %1&/ . '8 9>~a>=YcX;JISYFNOHMO>=G¨HIGSc9>~m;a>R]HMLOXYFYc>=QSHILPGUOJIa>=UPn[NOHMO>~YcLO< >?m;aLONOaiUV<>=_hX;HMUVJM>RGQR>~^0UOYc>=nxLPG %¥>=_hX;HMUVJM>RGQR>O9L¡ >=O>RajLOG> QRUVG&0UVJMLOGN~S9;> JMHIG>=YlLO ¡o9US HxHMJMJI>=agUVJMa>=UOn;[nHWnHIG . @{^0©GLVScHWQ > S9US¡>?Q=UVGu>=G;aHMQi9xS9;>Y\[]GhSUV¢xLVS9;>UVNO>=GhSYTScLXY\>~Sc9>~m.L¡ >=agLO & UOGnxS9hX0YgLP^SUOHIG£Y\LP< > C0G;>Rao>j_PXHIUVJM>RG0Q >=Y= ©LOG;>Kn > CG;>j Y < HMYTU?QRLVUVNP>RGhSY= Sj P ` Q} hP i = {Q | Q J JIJML¡oHIGN?QRLVUVNO>=GhSY SL~^.>F<?LPac>gSc90UVG deX0YeS'ScaiUVG0Y\JWUSHILPGLV%UONO>=GPSiYg ^;XSlUVJWY\L~HIG0Q JMXn>FSc9;>. Q LPGYeSiUVGhS=&LOG;>QRUOG£UOJIJML¡S9;>>RaiUOYcHIGN LOYcLO< > mUVacSKLVUm;aLQ >jYc:Y BZSR9;> & LOm.>RaiUSLOaFac>jUVJM H 6=>=Y > Se¡LQi9;>=$Q =Y'US'S9;> YcUO< >gSHI< >P;¡o9;HMJI>S9;> ⊕ LPG;JI[G;>R>jn;YoLOG>gS>=Y\SlLOalUOG;LVS9;>Raj5 R R
(117) & B £ ,& o % o G> LP^de>=Q ScHMO>LOlSc9HMY mUOm0>=a ¡UPY SLX;G0n>RaiYeSiUVGn¤HIG< LOa>n>RSUOHIJWY~Sc9;>LOJWn§m;aLO^JI>=< LVlS9;> >=GQ LnHMG;N¨LOoSc9;> ac>jYeSacHWQSHILPG¦LOm.>RaiUSLOaj%UVG0n¥ScL CGn§YcLO< >¡'U[UOacLPX;Gn¥HIS= HIlm0LhYcYcHI^JI> ¡oHS9;LOX∃S a>=YcLOacScHMG;N?ScL UVJMJSc9;>?Q X;aa>RGhSl¡ LPLa = UVaLOX;Gn^;HMGn>=aY~F .M{=z5@Ot] U0«'HMG¨LOain>Ra'SL^.>BUV^;JM>KSLXYc>KSc9;> m.L¡>Rac«X;J5ScL]LOJWY'LV&b f LP<B^;HMG;HMG;N?UB«LOa<UVJ.>RGQRLnHIGN~LOZSc9;> QRUOJMQRX;JIX0Y'HIGhScL fof UVGnSc9;>UVXS9;LOa Yba>=YcX;JISY'UV^.LOXS S9;>Y\>=< UOGhScHWQRY LVSc9>ga>=Y\ScaHMQ ScHMLOGLPm0>=aUVScLPaπLV%fofHIGhSL~e%¨<UOn>Fm.LPYY\HM^;JM>lScL?nHWYcQRLO>RabSc9;>gSe¡L <UOHIGac>jY\XJSiY'LVSc9;HWYomUOm0>=a:< KHMaY\S=5S9USFSc9;> UOYc[]GQi9;aLOG;LPXY QRUOJMQRX;JIX0Y'HMYg>=UPY\HMJI[>=GQ Ln>jn¨HMGUYcLOXGn¨UVG0nuQ LP< m;JI>RSc>~¡U[ HMGSc9;> Y\SUOGn;UOan fofgS9;>Kac>=O>=aYc>Tπ>=GQ LnHMG;N ^0>=HIGNHI< m.LPYY\HM^;JM>O ]>jQ LPGn;S9USoS9;> CaiY\SlLOain>Ral_hXUOGPSPH C0>Ra Sc9;LPX;NO9HISTnL]>=YoGLVSTNPHIP>n;HIa>=Q ScJM[Sc9> ac>jYeSacHWQSHILPG LPm0>=aUVScLPa=m;aL]HMn;>=YSc9>K<?>jUVGYoScLNP> SlHISlSc9;a∃LOXNO9UY\HM< m;JI> Sc9;>=LOa[^UPY\>jnLPGxLOG;>K<UVHMGxUSLO< LO UOacHISe[LOG> < loc . . . . . . V. > ?. @>A.
(118) {t.
(119)
Documents relatifs
C'est aussi le résidant pas chez leurs parents fréquentent deux fois parativement à la province, les étudiants de Nanterre ne lement ce moindre attachement à la ville
In this paper, we study the performance of an enhanced channel estimation technique combining estimation using an autocorrelation based method and the Expectation-
Dans ce travail, nous comparerons les entreprises coopératives, détenues par leurs membres, dont le produit risqué est la ressource critique apportée et dont l’objectif est
L’indice EMBI a augmenté de 77 points de base entre le point bas de mi-septembre 2007 et fin février, en partie conduit par la hausse de 300 points de base du spread de l’Argentine
À cet effet, un nombre considérable de recherches démontre cliniquement que les enfants de parents souffrant de problème de santé mentale sont plus à risque d’un retard dans leur
usual route to school and provide us with some details about their travel routine (e.g., schedule, mode of transportation, people accompanying them, etc.); 3) recent interventions
La question de l’extension des limites de Paris jusqu’à cette ligne avait été discutée mais ne fut tranchée que par un décret impérial du 9 janvier 1859 qui décidait de
