Distributed Optimization using Virtual and Real Game Strategies for Aerodynamic Design
Texte intégral
(2) INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE. Distributed Optimization using Virtual and Real Game Strategies for Aerodynamic Design Zhili Tang — Jean-Antoine Désidéri — Jacques Périaux. N° 4543 September 2002. ISSN 0249-6399. ISRN INRIA/RR--4543--FR+ENG. THÈME 4. apport de recherche.
(3)
(4)
(5)
(6) !"#%$&'
(7) !)(*)!,+-)(/.01 2 3#)546)875 9:!);<& #) =>@?BAC?DFEHG@IKJMLHNOEPGQSR!GTVUW?BG@NYX Z\["?C]@Z_^V?)J`LWEHa\bc@N_[ deZ\^"?fEHc'g hjilk monpr qnOsOtuzm)k"movlwyn"x6z{t}|_|_~monlzw}|n n"z{t} motyx ztu|~ {| nzWF' x lH|z n3{n"iln"{iln~W p\ p_YqsOn"zn"m)Hn F _q r¡x¢nV _|P£!x¤ztun¥"m)¦ §6v¡|¨lm%~¶©¦ª |_i¡~\x zH{hjn |ilw@ tyz!nVi¡n tu¢|n"~³P{|_tu¹~µz!ºjilxltyn l{i¬| {|_ ¡x_O~¡| ilx n"mov¡r tyn" z{3il9n¬»_v¡n «\{tuvl~l¸nV¢¶{z{|¢_t}l|_xv¡~mrzn| ®|z{lilmzn tuvl|_mrw¯z{_tut¯²"·° x ztyhjtu| il~¶t}¡n¸w}x tun ~¡wumo¢x |_{l±wut}|6zi¡|nmo z{t}mo|¡tux²"z{x6t}z{moz{tut} |_tuvl² ~³n wyx ®´{|w}tu ºv¡~ n wuw¼n v¡z{t¯ilz{nn |_®´|_~¡jz{l{x|_t}~\lz wun | m9®H` ||~¡®z{|_x~¡~\zz¾ x ¿Àtu¹~lx n ~ |_xFzw}t}tu®ÁmozMt}m9²Vx6x6z{t}|_t}mo~¡ tu²"·@x ½¬ztu|nF~)Hv¡n ~ ®´|n {m z{ilx n~!x |tu~P®´|_z{t}{w x t}~\z@x ¢| ®H{n |~¡v¡Sz{z{xt}|_~\~ z ºx¾~µt}ÂOz·Äi/x lÃz iln"t¯n z{n_t}|_vl¹~¡~¡ºx nwe|~¡{tu~\ zxz{wux x| tu ~lv¡nx wu¢nn" xÄlx{x n ty¹@x z{wuxilx )n" x n| tu~\||ztu~P~_n"z«\z{{v¡»6xxx t}z~\tytuz{|x l~wu·Ê nox~ÈzÉ¡|ÅvlPn zx ilzn"n"tyx_®´moÅtuwu|Åz{ilntunVmo¹z{n!lilw}n"nÅmo|~Pxn P~\z{|6z{»_nxn t}~\moz{O"¶n ·zt}ilÆÇ~\| z{|_mo| |_ ¡w}|_v¡x ¢ {tyt}t} ~¡~¡x ¢¢ w tux~lt}¢_®´|n tuwWt}|n"~\z{z{t}mox tu{²"nx ztu|_|m)~l·Mtue~lnt} ®´|ºtuwt}zi9iPx xH®´n"|{m)x {v¡nwux |ztu|z{t}~ mo tu² n n{t} »_n x_ ®´||_ m&t}~¡Ë¢Ì6zÍ9|9λ6xÏtuÐO|Îv¡Ñ6jÒSÓxn z|{| z{ \nVx6~PzMx momtuvlw¯z{t¯{°Àt}Hz|n tu{~_tyx z Ô vl~ n"|~lÕ¡tuzÖ·Mx_i× lwuxØ_n VÙ tu~xFOmomonz{tyÇÚFxi¢_xmrnÇ|z{t}motu² nV|_~lnÙ |6º~){t¯z{n {t}|_~3v¡t}~l¢ tu|~® ®´|_xrm)m9v¡x6w¯z{z{t}t¯|_°À~P|_lt}{~\|6z»O|t lnztu mrOtuo²"x zziltu|n~| ·Mz{sOilv¡n ¡ ·@|_hj~ltyilVnÜ6hÚex_x ~¡i|nV~l«\tyvlt}wuÕPtul|6ºtuvlmÛx|_z{ilvln ~ ~ w}|t}®Á{z{tu~ln"¢Px |_tu~ ®´|tuwuz{j|x z{{ilnn3x ~¡|_xw}vw}Oz{² t}|_n ~ Ox!njÝ|_Þ~¡ßuÎÒSt àB Ì n"á0n |tuw}mowuv¡lvzzx6x6z{z{t}t}~l|_¢~¡ »O·MtusOz{n"v¡»x n"w{x x~ wP âOtu{~ n" xjw\¢\| x ®@mox tun®´|_z{t}{w¼x zln"wu¢t¯ztun"ztu"~l·¢_sOv¡x"~n" {x®´n vl{w | n"\~Ptu¢x ~rmotunV vlnVw}z{tu¢ ~ |~ ãPxn"m z{iln»6x wut t¯zox ~ n ä9 n ~¡ )|®Pz{ilnl{n"n ~\z n"tu¢~omonzi¡| tu~x¡x x wuwun wl|_molvztu~l¢3n"~\»Otu|_~lmon ~\z"· åÄFlæ\zçWtumrè{é)tu²"ê x §6zë tu|¥~ª¹@Fì tuztuzm9{t}¡x wÇvzÆÇn | ~\Fz{|_z{w t}mohjiltu²"n"x6|z{{t}|_¹'~M¹ vlì w}tyn"z{Mt}l«\vlv¡zx6n z{ t}|_@~¡x "¹'x wuw} n"w@|ÆÇtu~\|zmoMl«\vlv¡zx6tu~lz{t}¢¡|_¹'~¡í ¹v¡Úew¯z{xt¯°À|i¶înVx Sz{mot}»_nn ¹ ïFt}zvPx wðñn"x w îx mon3z{{x zn ¢_t}nV ¹lsOiPx Hn3¡x x monz{n {t}²Vx6z{t}|_~. Unité de recherche INRIA Sophia Antipolis 2004, route des Lucioles, BP 93, 06902 Sophia Antipolis Cedex (France) Téléphone : +33 4 92 38 77 77 — Télécopie : +33 4 92 38 77 65.
(8) ; '@) ¼@
(9)
(10) ("))5 5¼ #)5 ¼
(11) (8)
(12) '
(13) !( <)!<Ç ) "1)(! 46@1 9!:9!); 9
(14) z{mo
(15) t}|_ty ~o¥ n" vl| z{nVt} m9zª x wun |ÆÇ~¡ nFnjz{®´{x|_vllt}Pmoz|_n¡z`x x"xlwu| n"l{O||~¡vilxz{nmot}wywutux)«\vl«_wynv¡x{n"¡x tuz«\tu|vlv¡~ nV~l n ne ®´|nÄwf{Ù |m)wux¬v¡z{z{t}wumox i z tytu|_|x ~ tuzn tu |nj~9 vµzm)OP v¡|njw¯z{~\z{t zi ty {|_wuntutul¹n w}tu ~¡n¸n"x¼«\t}{vlnn tFvn ¼~|·@~ M| ~¡Ù vl| t¯zn z{t¯ °° |n"~\3zx x wu¢tu~\|_z{t}"z·i¡Fmr~nV V x Ù |_wutunztumowuxotu{x6 z{ t}v¡|_S~¬z{t}z|_{~ k" {n3|zlv¡xÁ~znV n ¡ x Ù vlz~Ätylv¡{w}| tuk ãP{wCn ¹moon H~\z3|lz{xtun ~¡~¶nx |x ~¡z z{"x3~\x zvln¹¡Ynlze{wy|xolm9wuk mox6n"t¯° mo Ù tyvl~¡x nztu|»6~ x { tuxnlw}xnHx | z{|xtu~\~¡znn_¹ {F xzwuxx t}Á{~ n9 nvl¡|_l~¡w "z{mox ~\n z{~\nz{·@xt}ÆÇ{nnV·|_~È~_z{{|_xmot}~\z{¡n"x @x |_ty~\|_z ~¬z{{xxv¶t¯z nVx@ ¡ x n@wfwfÙÙ |_tu~\zz{tu|mo tuv¡{x6Sz{z{t}t}|_|_~~ {ì x n~PlÇw} vP| ~\¹ z n"x tu~\t}~¡zn"¢" ¹O ntun z~\znz{¢m "~ z{ilx | wuty|x wuz|tu¢_|tu~9«\vl~nVÙ t}'~\z{||~\z vl t}|zm)«_¡v't}Ù~ vlV~¡ nF~¡vl|~lvlnÇ»_n ®´|wuw}{nm)"v¡«\wuv¡x x6ztuz{|t}|_~ ~! x" tu» |"tun~\z nnwu"xx zwyx i tu"| n_° · {tu|n ~\zn"|_zn tuvmo9tuH |nVvl»Oz{tu!{xot¯z{»On Çty w}n n ¡ |_t#l"$w} k"{mon ~\n z{F Ù |_{t¯z{zk tumo{n"tu{x6xz{ t}{|_| ~9 m)\~Pvlx w}zmotuHtu«\|vltu~_nVz Ô n"Ù v¡~¸~l|{~l| Õ¡ã¡t¯wzSÖS ·Ù xÆÇt}wui¡nx·@«\vlnVnj®´|_|_vln mov¡n"" ¹ ®´¡ |_w}x vlk"~¡mr{~ln v¡t}nV~F jÙ¡|n"x vz{et}mow}OnVm tyx x z{zvtuz{|ty«\~¸nVvl mn ·ÇvlMnew}Ù z"tuÚF«\Pvlx|_tut}w}~\itulz"¹·{|_n ì z n"tunmo%ÚetuVx_n|vlv¡iÄ~w}n"x mr tu~¡n"t}z~\t'k"z{x6nzz n"vl|_t}P~\~lze~ |_~l|_tun"«\~{vln"nVz{n H~¡|n xzF~ ~\ z{z`{ox|~¡wumox9||z{~¡n wutuv«\ z{vlt}Ù t}|_nV~le~ ®´|x {vlÙmovlz|~Äx v¡zltu|{~¡| n° z{¡|"Mtu|ã¡t}nVwuwu`w}vPx_Pz{|_{|xz~_x &t z "~\` z{t}x»_vn |_~_nV|zrMvlx n"z{~¡vl{x{x w}Çz"n ¢z"tu3n"l wu¡v¡ xn`)tun vlv¡n ~ {vo |x_" n n°fwyznVn"|vlzv9w "»O tutunn ~'z{vl·¸|n ~Pwy"· w}n vPl'ztun"tun |Mvl~")x vlz{\w}|z{Hx n"z{\ M~P x |nmo~Ptuã¡«\x {vlmonz{n x ~\¢_|zMn ~\wyzjx3n"»6|x ~Pzwut n"t t}{zt¯ °° n zwCÙ nä"xt}z n3wyxrm zi¡| n3P|_vlwuxo |~¡ n z{t}|_~ x~¡jvl~n ~O»Otu|_~l~ln mon"~_z n3"x wyvlwPx x wuw}k"w}n_· z{'ñ i nÇ ê |_n"¦Vv¥ tuèn © "( n v¸w¼¥F |ª |v~\»OzF tulz{wuvlnztun mr|wf¹tyz{{¡t}x6x m9ztux x |wfm~ ¹ Vz«_ty{vPztu{x6{x6t}zlz{tu|t}v |_~P ~ n¹Ø nÙ xwu®´ vl|vl{wun mow V¡¹n x"{«\xv¡w}wux k zwuntu| ~¡tyez{x tul|_v t}_~\¹"z|_nV ¹ ztumon v tu{x6 z{n)t}|_ÚF~xmivl¹¡w}ztuz|x6z nV S¢ztut}n"® ¹.
(16) )à CÒSà Þ Î . . CàÁÍrà VÌ fàBÑ6á¬Þ SàÁá àÁÒ CÞ¡Ì ßÌ6á FÎ{Ì ßMËÌ6Í9Î CÒ{Ì Î àBÎ.
(17) . . . . . . . . . ¦"§ ê ë © ¦ ê æ æ §6¨( ê § (´¨¦ ê ê 'æ £rë ê ¦£ '§ ê ¨l© ¦ ê '¦ *¨( æ ¥ © ê ¥"¦ §6¨ æ ë ¦ *¨( ê ¦ § ê ( 'æOê § ç pPpP·· ê ¥"ì'¦ t¯§6®Á¨x zF¢í¸íæ x6ë tu~lt}mot}motu²"tu²"¦x x z*ztu|tu|~¨~ ( ~ ~ ê n"n"¦ § zêzi¡i¡(nnÆÇÆÇ'||~¡æO~¡ê z§ zçx x tu~\tu~\zz||®M®MÆÇÆÇ|_|_~¡~¡zzx x ~\~\z zì t}x ®Áz ¢¶·3·3···3·3···3·3···3·3·3·3···3·3·· "p ll·· Úeì æ §vln"Bmo©tu¢¨ n ~Ä{( tu"@x x wx (mo{æ |n z{n n æ vlñ¦"{¨nY·¦ ·3·3ê ···3·3···3·3·3·3···3·3···3·3···3·3·3·3···3·3···3·3···3·3···3·3·3·3···3·3···3·3···3·3·3·3···3·3·&·& ll·· p MíÄvln"w}n"iÄFíÄsO|_|6w}»_»n n mon"·3~_·z ·3·3·3···3·3···3·3···3·3·3·3···3·3···3·3···3·3·3·3···3·3···3·3···3·3···3·3·3·3···3·3···3·3···3·3·3·3···3·3·&·& ll·· sOz n ¸|tusO~_tuzF² ns|Mwu»»Øn xw}vP·x6z·3tu|·3~ ··3·3···3·3···3·3·3·3···3·3···3·3···3·3·3·3···3·3···3·3···3·3···3·3·3·3···3·3···3·3···3·3·3·3···3·3·&·&__ ¨l¥ ¨ æ ´¥"¦ § ´¤ ¦ æ ë ê ¦ ·· § ê ¤ ÆÇÆÇ( æ |_|_*~¡~¡¥ zzx x tutu~l~lnnë æ § sOsOtutu~l~l¦¢¢ wuwun3n3ë ç |_|_t}t}~\~\zztutu®´®´||tutuww'ìt}®Áx zF¢íÄíx6tu~ltumotumot}²Vt}²Vx6x6zztu|tu|~~ ··3·3···3·3·3·3···3·3···3·3···3·3·3·3···3·3·&·&__ ·· p hhºº| | °° |_|_t}t}~\~\zztutu®´®´||tutuwwìt}®Áx zF¢íÄíx6tu~ltumrtumrtu²"tu²"x x zztu|tu|~H~Ü ì ·3·x ¢o·3í·3tu·~l·3t}mo·tu²"·3x z·tu|·3~··3·3·3·3···3·3···3·3···3·3·3·3···3·3·&·&. !æ ¥ (Á¦"¥ ·· sÆÇl|_w}~¡t}zz{zt}~¡x ¢ tu~lì n n ã¡s~lt}t}~lz¢_tu|w}n~Ê ·|tu·3~\zj·e·3t}·®´·3|tu·3w ì ··3x ¢o··3í·t}~¡·3t}mo·3tu·²"x6·3z{t}·|_~·3»O·tyxr·3·î·3wu|·3¡x·w'·3F·z·3tumo·t}·3²Vx6·3ztu·|~ ·3·& · íÄíÄÆÇ|_nn~¡zzi¡i¡z|| x tu~l·3·3n ··sO·3·3tu~l··¢_·3·3w}nr·3·3··|_·3·3t}~\··z·3·3··tu®´·3·3|_t}·3·3w ··t}·3·3®Áz3··íÄ·3·3x ···3·3t}mo·3·3tu²"··x6·3·3z{t}|_··~Ä·3·3»O··tux·3·3î··wu·3·3|P·3·3x ··wM·3·3F··z·3·3tumo··t}·3·3²Vx6·3·3ztu··|~ ·3·3·&· _ · p st}· pP~l·¢_w}n |_n"t}~\vlzw}z{jtu| ®´®|_t}Élw {ì|~\zx Ü6¢9ínVx tu~lt}sOmoltuwu²"t¯zx zztutu~l|¢~º»Otut}xrziÄïeh'tuºzv¡|9xw'wyîxØx n mo3n·3s\z·3x6·z{n ·3¢·tun"·3 ··3·3·3·3···3·3·· \\ ·· pPpP·· n"n"vlvlw}w}z{z{jj| | ®®Él{w}|zn"~\z~PÜ x6íztut ~ll¢ wusOnØlÜ wut}zn"zxtu~lj¢9sO¡ºw}t}t}zzz{iÄt}~lh¢9ºÇº|9t}zi¸wyxØhjn"i¡{jn"n·3M·3wu·xØ_·3n · ·3···3·3·3·3···3·3·· \ · h·ºl| · ° |_t}~\n"zvlw}tuz{j®´|| tu®w Élì {|x ~\¢zÜ6ítunV~lx tumrsOtu²"lx wut¯zztuz|tu~ ~l¢»Otuºxot}ziÄnVx h'w'ºî|9x mowyn)xØs\n z{{3x z·3n"·3¢tu·n" ·3···3·3···3·3·3·3···3·3·0·0pp\ · l· n"vlw}z{j| ®w}zn"~Px6ztu~l¢sOlwut}zztu~l¢9ºt}ziÄhºÇ|9wyxØn"{j·3·3··3··3··3·3··3·0p_p %$. !#" ')(. A. ". &. +*. ". <>=?" D. . %$. 2$ ". ". 2$ ". ". 3. 6. 6. 3. @$. +A. @$. +A. E. .B0. ". L3. 4353. 0. 76. 3. %$. +8. %$:9. ". ;. C. D. GE. ?F. K$. $ ". .B0. ". ?F. &JI. 21. -,/.0. ". GEH. %$. ". ". 'NM. E. 2E. 2E 2E. O. 0. P>I ;. 8Q$. (. 'N<. $. RA. S>T. =?". L3. QU. %$ ". 9. '2D. '-&. V E V. C. V. WO. V. WO. '-;. X E. H. X. V. X. X. E. X X. H. X. X. E. X X. Y Y[Z\2]^_]`. -E.
(18) p. 'Ð_à @àÏ¡Ì á . lÎÌ6á Fá ÀÑ àÁáHÎ Sà ÒSà Ì Þ¡Î ÒSàBÌ Þ. . . -. . .
(19) . . . . · hOs zº| x6°zn"¢|_ t}~\z·3·tu·3®´|·tuw_·3·3t}®Áz ·íÄ·3x ··3t}mo·tu·3²"x6·3z{t}·|_~H·3Ü ·ì ·3x ·¢·3íÄ·3t}~l·tumo·3t}·²Vx6·3z{t}·|_~·3ì·nV·3tu·3¢~·»O·3tu·x·3n"·x ·3w\î·3x ·mo·3n ·0p ê © ( '¥ ê O. X. H. M. A. ". %$. ". &NM. 5Y.
(20) )à CÒSà Þ Î . CàÁÍrà VÌ fàBÑ6á¬Þ SàÁá àÁÒ CÞ¡Ì ßÌ6á FÎ{Ì ßMËÌ6Í9Î CÒ{Ì Î àBÎ.
(21) . . . . . . . . . . ) 9
(22) <` Ô moºíÄi¡n"vlnn w¯z@{z{n`t¯º° z{t¯iltyz{inÇ t}tu¡~\|Ozw} tun"~¡t}{n x x_z{WSÈzÙ tu'||_~l~n zPn tumon z t}ºÇ·@²Vn"x6í n z~rtuì |~³n"» n í x~x ì w P n tyÖr nVtyt}9¡ w}¢_tu~ltuxPt}n"~¡n t}m~lx¢*v¡ tuxzmomoHPn|_n zilz|x |~P~¡ t|_ n w}n |_{tu¢~n F j®´¹Ø|xn ~{z| il~¡nºxv i¡zn"n ty{ tun`r¢~z{tuil~³|n ®¡| n" t}n z¢_rn ~lm9zn | tyn"Ç{x ®´zn"vlne{nz{¹|9 |tu~\¢z~l{t}tuãPl"vx z~\tu|zwu~P9ex z{"W|¸n"Szjtu~lz{¢_ilw}n n° ty{z{tun lmw}tu~lHnon x ®´~ |{m9ÜØ|x 3~¡ t}ne~¡tu¢~!wunmo°ÀP|_|_t}ne~\z zi¡ xn"~!t}¢_|_~Å~ln |_ tuz{tumotult}²Vwut}x6~lz{n_t}|_·~¬ ~xPz{il|_nvl~ w}t} z° · hjhji¡i¡nnt}z~lºÇ¢_|9n m9 tux n tu~\~¸z{i¡|x®w}wun wyx~l{¢_n"ty jx|wl®Mx í llì {|_ x_x il{n"n3 tu|_~mrx ¡vvz{|z{m9x zx6tu|z{~¡n xw|nlzHtumrn ~¡tu²"x n)zx tu|~ ~o tu|_~¡¢\wuv x ~lnetu²"x i¡ztux|P~ nP|x mox lmowunnz{t}n z° · tu²"x zetu|mr~¹l|_"~lx ¢wyzvlilwunv¡jm9|x ®~O»6rx z{n"tux i¡ztu~l|tu~¡«\vlnVxÇ~ zi¡x |z~\i¡z{xØ|_»_wPnz{Hiln n n |_~ _ ¹ln"x »~ n wu|HnVn ¹n z{~\ilzen|_t}~Ow}vl»n"ztu{|~ n mrnVn ztu¢il~| mrn z il |C·
(23) ty|_3~Hzn il{ni¡x nPHn z{ilt}n"n~¡mrn)|\xz~ ºt âO ~ln"|6w}¬ºwuv¡n n ¢_ n3·| hj®@zililty3n mo n"nz{tuil¢|~l n"tu)z|n"n"»z{n x {n ¡wuw}¸tyi {n"zn"{tut}zx tul»n9wun3H»n"n""w}|x v¡ t¯zn9 t¯|z¡ n"nVPn"~ vl {n tuzhj{t}il¡nvz~ltu|n \~¡zj"· mo ~r|_x zÇlH |t}lztuv¡|wu~x¹6z{xillnjlmo{|_nxzi¡i9| otyÇ º|Oi¡nV@x6z~l| îrz· wun ~ vl v¡t¯z»\v¡n"w¯wu®Hx3zn |zjz{xilwCnj· t}mo{Hn|_®´n {t¯{z{nt}|_ ~z{||®Wx `|~¡zi¡zn)x × w}tu|O~\|\z{ n" w} · z{ ||vlã¡¡~ w}n zi¡|nez{¢t}mox tu ²"t}x6n"z{~_t}z|_~ | ®¼Ô z{@ilÆn |_ÖSÙu·zM ®´~Ävl~¡z{ilztytuF|~!xlºlt¯{z{|_ixã¡i'~l¹lt}zzn i¡n t x "H~Pn"x n"wuO~¡tyne®´l|{{|m)l vlwun wym-xl·@tuhjilty|wu»¢n x m9tun x~\~\z`!ty`ztuvPmon n" O |_9zx9|× l®wyxzilârn Pl|Ø{¼vÙ\zn |°C®´|_z{t}{mo ntu² mon"`nz{z|i¡| ã¡ ~ v¡zv¡ilx nwuw}P*nVn zO|_i¡¡x~lt¯z¢x n~\z z{| z{v¡ilnn z |Ån"zt}i¡¢_n~9®B»Øxxztyx z{¡i¡w}x6nVzo ·@~hj il nFx |n {mo| l vOz~¡x6x z{mot}|_ty~ x~¡x xwumoltyw}nVx r{n| ®e~lnVz{iln"tyr{{xx l{l¹ {~9|_x_Hn i/tu~lx ¢3{nz{il®´nevl~ ~Ovlmtu~ Pn"Mn| ®B®¼ ¡x{xmr n f· zn"{hj il n n ã¡@~lÆtu~l-¢3z{moilnnz{il¢n"| | mo"nx z{~/)Hzn|t}|_mozltu{mo|6»t}²"n n · O»6x¸tyxx ~¡lx wun"wu\ z ty · x wuewuÄv¡n »6x x wuwuwuv¡¹ x6zz{ilt}~¡ty¢z{nVil«_n9v¡t}{n"n"~¡t}z{ziltu»Ont¯ztu ~O» n"n {{t}t}»6|_x6~*z{t}| »_®en"ex ~¶zi¡n x Ozzx {n {nmo~ln wun"Ån wyx n {¢z{n9|!m9v¡x z {x t¯¼z·YnrzÉ¡i¡|n z{n"il{t}n ¢_n~ ° |t}momon l~Pvz{tun |j~¡xz{n"wlil{~l||_¡w}w}|_n"¢mo "¹Vz· ilnjt}²"n`| ®z{ilty'm9x6z{t} x~3n"~ n zi¡n`monz{il| tumr¡{x_Szty xwºt}zirvl{n"~\z Ô î " n l ~ n { z u t o x u w ¢ _ | } t z ¡ i o m x¡w}¢_| | {v¡t¯z{ iln"m x z~¡{n"| x zi¡z{n 3x3n nz3z | | ®®Çî HFnV|{tutu~\Ö ¢z{~r3 Px_ |_3 t}~\| x!z"H¢_n"n 3t}~r~lx n"z{~Y{ilx n xztuw¯ |z{n"n ~¸{tu~¡|¢x6®Ç~oz{¡t}»_x¡nx_n"z~\|!nz{x¢`lx xF{ | Htu n |~\v¡¡zvl°fnV¢_wux vlzzt tuil|nno~r ~l| n ®Wn"\t}x~z3{ ¢_t}in »O~l·t n"hjv¡{x ilxzwun9tu@|îz{~Yi¡ex6|z ® n"n"i¡~\~ z{t} w Ç|6º®´{|n Ç~il·@ztuKwx ~¡în"®´µ~Än º | |t¯®'z{moi¸zill®´n{n"tux ¡n"zxvl{n"xn"~_Fmozjx n"¡i¡iPx n x ~\~lxzetyztumñn"~¸tyn"®´|t¯z{z{MtuilPn zx |otu¡tux ~lil{¢3t}n w ~\vl{zVon ·e~ z{hjilx nil~ n) nVmo®´|_tunV¢j~oi¡m)x Hv~l|ztytux6~_m8zztu|®B~PtuxØ~_`»_z{|z{|3i¡zx6i¡zjln{|¡| ¡x "tuxxMlt}|t}|_wu®Ht}~¡z¡x tyx wuw}x °w ®Bz{ x_ilSnVnz{x6t}z{¡|_t}~|_|~|nV®W|®H 3|il~¡®´tu|_w z mx n"tu~~\n"~z{z{" i¡·tux6~lhjz`¢¸ilxnvlnjÈmHvtun~/z{zx zxÄzn tuM|wu|~rzi¡ mrxxwM~rnVmoPi¡t}x x ~l{~¡tun m)tu~\z{v¡mñ@m tutu~o~ zî·¸n"em9w}@ztyil@| |_®H¡vlzx ¢i¡iznty|îv¡wuFxnV Swuz tu»|_tumrnj~Ù®´Hzv¡|~¡{n"Sz{z{«\xt}vl~\|_tuz ~oz{n9x|3~ ¢_l{{x n x »t}zn"n"ty~\~\zz° tu~®´|_ ~ m9x6zilz{t}n¬|_~¡¹Ox_zi¡zÄn n"x»n"n3{xx wewy|nVx iltu ¢¹Fi¡w}x/ wyx |_{¢znYt}~ ®´|Oz{ n v¡{m | !®` Æ
(24) "z tumo n · # "x monY¡x_âµx ¢\x tu~µ|~ n"t}¢_~ mo»6xxw}¢_n z|tyilx {lt¯| z{wu ilnrm9®´®´|9|{@m)tu~|_vlwyzz{x6ilxz{nÅt}t}~l|_tux ~Y~l{¢n"®´|_x*3n"| ~¡n®ät¯z{¢_t}{»Otux n t}~\z3tuz{n w}t}¬~\~z®´°À|_¡|xmom9ln x vlztuz||tu~l~l¢¸¹ zxtumr~ n" tu~¡²"m9x t¯zz{x tut}|»O~O~t}z·Ê | ®P zn"iln"nVtun"»6x x6njzx tu»¡i³nVl i¡·|\xxhji¡il®´|nnVv¡x {n nwu|_3t}~\||_z~r~µ»6x x n"{»tu|_xn"t}l~\{xzwun ° w z{|n"® il ~¡n"tu«\t}¢_vl~nty»6x ¡{tuxxlz{w}tunV vlwux x{n¸wu)x |_z~¡zxt n"ztu»n n ¹j®´|Mn xzn {|n"wu x Oz~¡tu»x n"mow}/ty ®´n º n"t}¢_|_~r~¡¡z{{|_xlt}w}~\n"zmÊ ·tu~9ºtuil|_tu~l~li9nVxx v³wyx {i¡¢x n ~OvlnVx m){Hw}tun n tuO~l9t}zn"tyx6w}wuz{t}ln ztyFz{nVv «\ v¡tun"x6jz{t}| |_®~ z "il
(25) n "v¡ "·nh%| $®@x_|x~\~z{¹&|_wPv¡z{ilvln »O|_tuwuoxr®´x |_~ j |sz{xt}wumx_`vli¡m xØ»_nFi¡x ¡Hn|_P |\n"n t}¢_ ~!x)||_® ~ln° z{iln | m9zjx l¢|6l»{|n"~¡i n . BE. O. H. V. F. F. Y Y[Z\2]^_]`.
(26) 'Ð_à @àÏ¡Ì á O. . lÎÌ6á Fá ÀÑ àÁáHÎ Sà ÒSà Ì Þ¡Î ÒSàBÌ Þ. . . -. . .
(27) . . . . tu ~|~Oº»i¡n"tu¢_i9n Åz{il n3n"t}|_¢_~¡~¶z{{|_xw}t}v~\z{z`t}|_{~¡n ¡"· nV n" ~_z{|_n t} ~\z)Oomozn i¡zneil| Õ¡ |6)ºi¡nVxØ«\»v¡n9x6z{x t}wy|_|Ä~¡`P~¡n"n n n ~¶ v¡|~ln wu oOPn{jxx6Øzty{ã¡x n w \rz{ilneãPx ~¡~ x w Mw}nV i¡~¬xzâOi¡ tu {fn ¹¡Hx |~ z"¹'Ox moÆxnz{lilvl| â! x¡~ x ní | | ~¬t |#À¹¡z{xt}m9~ x wMO |~\ez~ {| w n"{z{il|n ~ |_ #À "· ¹ n {t}»_n ®´ |_
(28) m! z il n |~° z{t}~Ov¡vlvl|_v¡»OvlwyxoMvlnw}zn"!x wfnV· «\ v¡{x6nz{®´t}n"|_~¡{ n ¹ z{z{|/|n x»6xw}× z{v¡t}x ¢_zi_nÄz{w}z{Äil nY|vl¢_{lx wun tun ~\|_zztutu!molt}²V{x6n"z{t}n |_~\~ zÔ n he Æ·ÊhjÖilÙ}¹PtynVmo«_v¡nt}z{{iln"| z¹ilnrºil|_tyw}vi z{t}|_îr~ · z{z{|t}il®H|_n x ~{ ·n®´||_hjtu~\ilnz nz{lil {|n|mo¡ w}l|n"mowum nl¹t¯vzt}~ozx6x z{|lt}®|_ z~¡t¯ilz{x nrt}w'|_ ~x |_ z|ze|_t}z{| ~\il®@zFnz{¡ilx tu~¡|_exlmow}w}n"nm0tuzi¡ltu| F{ |n"ltu«\Fwuvln x tum»6lx l¹6wuz{{n ||Ø~\zen"t}»6m9z{x |x wuv¡zziPtux6»z{x6n n`zwu9z{| il®znjºz¢i¡tynrxn3xz{tu~¡iln x n)~\wuz@n"| »6ty®Px wu v¡l|_x6{|z{z t}l|_®´v¡wu~ n ~¡m|S°® ¹ z{z{il|¸niPx x n"H| n On"~¡xt}mo¢_~*tu)l®´vl|_~¡lwuzn tum9|~ ·!¹ en"¢_3xº n9wun"mo{en ~\zziltun|~l~On vl mx6Pz3n"3zi¡| n® n ~ n" tu¢|~¬®wy¡xx zx ¡mox nz{x n ¢_{ x¹lx i~ ¹ |_tu~lwu¸ºÇn"n"w}w`wux zvltu»t}zn"n w} ®´¡n"{ºx_Szty|_ ~¡xwz{tu{~Åxt}~\xn z{| xO~È~¡x Pmon!tyt} mo ln"wun tumo¢~n"¹¼~_z{nv¡ iÅt}~¶x_z{ilz{|!ty)momotun~lz{t}ilmo| tu² n¹lzilvn zo |lx z¢!tumrºtu²"t¯z{x iÅztu|~¶|_~¡ºzt}zx i±tu~_z|~P| ®Çz{ {|x~¡t}~\z{z{x~\tuz wuvPt}®Áz"tu~l·!¢Åzn"ilnn"~\x z l|_vlt}l~\zwutu°f"»6x6x z{{t}ty|_x ~¡l wun z{n" il~lMty«\¡vlnnV¹`n"t}~±~_zºz{ililntyiÈ|_z~¡i¡n!zwux t¯tu®Á~lzn |~¡x n"z| x tu~\Oz~¡xtymrrty{rx6z{tui¡ã¡xnP n9O|_Èztux mo t}vP²Vx6z{z{t}t}~l|_~¢ z{|_ilnn"t}~Pztu»t n3n ®´~¡v¡ ~¡n Sz{xt}~l|_~Y¢wun tyF xwu¡|xmon | |_t¯~ãPn '|¹M{z{nVilnH|ÕP~ |6º8t}~¡¢|_wuw}»_·n rhjilturn"{nrvl~/x {tun3~³zºÇx¸|ãlmon x t}~ wut¯®Áz{xØmoº| P xn¹Çâx ~ tu~¸ zzi¡iltun mox~ln ¢zwuiln| i¡ x_ MÔ z{V|)ÖeHznFilnmo | |_ t}zã¡n ®´vl!~¡ Svlz{t}{|_t}~¡~*¢3PznViln|mot}zn nV3x6z{t}||_mo~¡lÇwu| n®¼¼z¹tumoºi¡nFn tu{~\
(29) n zn"¢ x6ztytu3|~9tu~¡|®'wuv z x6n z{ ne¹ n"Ô «\v¡Öex zziltu|n9~¡tu"~¡· t ~ n"z~¡i¡tun {tu~\n zH{|| z"v¡¹Hz{n3ilnoxow}{t}®Á zx wyx |j~Px z{{x|t}tu~\~_zFz»6ty x { tyn"x xlw¯wuznºz|9t}ziÅxilx_tun »_x ne~Yz{n iltyl ·Mw}tyt}z3"|| ~P tuz{~l{¢xt}z~\ilzFntu~Å |z~\ilznr{||wHzz{i¡t}n mo|tu{² n"¹Oz{ ili¡tyjn {\ntu¹Wn w ºÇ n tyx"3x ~ ~ xx Pl"n x t}zwyx |tu|wu»~¡wun xt}~lwnVxnVx x3|_t}x wut}wu~\¢· zn"lnV«_x vPtyx6)ztunV|«_~!vPx6®´|zjtu|z{~¬ilntu~\»_| wu»O t}n"~l¢!tu»6x6zi¡ztunr»nVH |¹Otul~\vlz{zx®´||_zvlvl~ ~P x6zzn"ilw}n_¹Oxzt}ilty®´|tux w vl|tu®B~\xz nn"«\¹'v¡xx6~ z{ t}|_t¯~ z xz{lnVtux6w}hjt}zzilÄx nr{zl|x t¯lz{ {¡nVxw}ty tu ¢x ~Yztu|\|®´|~¸zF|®´ vl® n ~¡z{Silz{z{x not}tu|_~¸x ~ ¹¼zO|_n"Ht}~\Hn"zn"x|tylx ®Çlwu|wu{ l|_zx_tutu~Ymoi mxiPwvlxPw}zn"t i¡ ¡tuxØ{»O| t}tu|_lv¡"wu t}¹¼~Pn ¡x v{{z n t¯m9 z3n"xtyt}â6¢_~lx ~| ¡· z3w}n3eHtu|_mov¡{x ltuwulw}|6_wu»_¹Hnon zt}moil~¬n"n ¢~\nrn"z~lx n {t}n~Yx zw zºilz||n x*#t "Wwutun ~l{n"n x~\z3º|xØmletuz~¡|Äx6z{t}||_wu~ »n|®Fx z{milnvlw¯z{ t¯t° "H n"ty n"t}~\¡zw}tu~¡{x t¯{z{Än {|tux¬lzºtumrt}ztui ²"x ztut|"H~Ån"ln"~\|_zlºÇwun n"m t}¢_ i_zz{9ilnrx ~ ã¡ z3z{|¶|~¡mrntu~ltytumoz|t}²"nÄm9x zilâ_nn { n"#t "Wvln w}{zn tu~\~lz¢ ®´vlt}z~¡n"ztytux|~x¹nltuv~z3 z|i¡~tu3Õ¡tyâOSzVtu~ ¹O mr| |_®jn"w}|6tu~l»nVn"x @zilnF|_m)ºÇln"t}tu¢_~¡i_x zz`tu|x_~ t}¢_|\~lnV3n ~lz{||zn |motunez t}~*t}z¢_n"n ~ltu|n"~9{xm9w xغoi¡n ~l~¬| zzPilnn vl|t}~¡z{ xn lw}zn x ~ z|rzi¡®´|n{mnVv¡xw¯z{t}n~lz¢|®´® v¡~¡|Swuz{vt}z|_tu~9|~¡moÇxØz{i¡x6wux_zx â){nFt}¢_z~l{t¯tyãHSz wux ~PHnn¹zzzn iljnFz{i¡nVx |~!~ z i¡n|_~l{nn m9ty@xzt}|~ltuvP~l¢rnj|z{~lilnVne@t}~!x {znilz{|n ºmoi¡n z|ilwunF| n"tux zi¡ini¡¡t}x¢_ irne º|_ilz n"~!tu~o Æ|~¡ ±t z{n t}{mot}~ln_¢· x hjwuwPilz{njil¢_n|_|x w\| nV®¡Szziltu»ty@nVÇ¡x tuHm)n vl@w}tyz{ xz~l|n |_t}~\v¡z{wu| ¹\v¡z{il nnx {~lxØ|6º»_¡n wOx_x âl¡|®|\zxi¡tui mO |vlmn w}zvllt}wu°ft}n ~¡H{t}|ty~lx tu¢~\~3zÇ x |_ tumr|®´|_¡tu~\t}vwPzz{°À|x »6zx z{tu{|t}tumo~¡xltu²" w} "nMx z ztu· n"|~9i¡tu~ll®´tu{|_«\|t}vllwy'nwun ºm9i¡t}x "zHi· n"hxe®´x x |{~¡{nm)||v¡~lwuz{tyx t}mozÕ¡tu|tu|6² ~ ºn Mn"xx Ptu» |_|n v z` ®´tuwu~lt¯|_®Á¢jz{mñt}~¡z|¢î»6x x xmotutu®´nÇ||v¡tuhjwu'Çi¡x x n n |{{n{| x ~¡zO|ex~¡w}zx O{mo² n"n x6ty z x zt}z{zn n"motyxlz{· z{~¬|Yx|lOztumrmrmotu² n n z{|tu~¡onÚeÙ )x_|6i¬º~*¢_xzmox {n¢¹Wnzzri¡nrºt¯~¡z{| i/ztun |~¬iP| x ®F~l× ¢_¡nwuxØ| _®Fn OÙWmotymrt}~\n zz{{tu| v¡t}~l ®´n | {mox~x z tu|n"~Èxºi¬t}zli/wyxØziln"n |z{ilzilnn"|{zil n" { ·"¹ "x Úe~lx_~¡| iÄz)nVtumo«_v¡lt}wut}|6¡»_notuvl®´m-vlztuFiln")nVx|~¡ilnn Ù 3º|6ºil~*n ~Äz{xnVx¢_niÄz"·¸lwyxØsOHn"n"" ¹¡t¯ãH |9~¡»Ot}zzx v¡tux~lwÇn x~ O !znVilx nrw`z{O{mox zmrn"¢n z{|tu ® EKH. E V. E. F. F. 5Y.
(30) )à CÒSà Þ Î . CàÁÍrà VÌ fàBÑ6á¬Þ SàÁá àÁÒ CÞ¡Ì ßÌ6á FÎ{Ì ßMËÌ6Í9Î CÒ{Ì Î àBÎ.
(31) . . . . . . . . . H. FÚÃen x{ni¸¹Vz¢_i¡xnmo n" x |_{t}n)~\ztu°fmr»6x ¡{w}tyn"x mrlwun"n~\zznVn ilz~l| ty«\vln n`zlv¡{¬|6»Oxt ~¸n"|xFz{t}moiln"tu²"xx z|tu|~Åz{t}moztu² x6n"z{"n ¹6¢_x ~ ®´ |_ Úex_n"it}¢_î~¸xmovl~ nÇ n"|_3~\z|{t}~llÕ¡vltuzn"z" · t}Hz{nz¢_º|\n | n"~®´z{nVilx6nz{vl{nt}zn tu~ {tyx tyv¡z{~ tuln vz{ n | ~ÕP|tumozjltu~Ävlzxrtu~lm)¢rvlxw}~ zt}° ¢_tut}{»_n"tulwux t}~¡~xnVx o n"ºt}xØ¢_r~·z|oxi¡t}n"»nz{ilnn"«\vltuw}wut}¡tuvlm .0! )( )
(32) !( )4 75% ¼) )870! < 5 ;)(Y# z{nxill nel®´|{{|_v¡n`x_w}n n"imǺ¡nV«_x ilvP{tyâOx6i t}z~¡tu|¢iP~'x|¹j~)t}z`Hx n tuÇn ~ n ilz{n"z{x w}iltuwu|n®´v¡{)|wlvlzn |¢_{ilt}wu»6vl x6moz{ t}m9|_|~x vl{| motu®¡² nzn il~\z{njz{iln nx ¢t}n"|_~~lt}~\n {nz®´x ®´n"wP|{x n"m)¡~¡vlznVwyx6xz{t}|_z ~3 n"®´ |{· {|t}lzz{tut}|m9~9x| w ®W z{n"ilt}ne¢_~x v¡|t}tu~l~_¢ z |_ |vlºhjw t}~¡ilP¢¡non_¹ l¹z{{il®´||n¢_jx nnVn"lx|Fmr | O®Ç¡~¡w}znxilmonzi¡tun nVl{tu{¢|x~ÅH¢rn l z|O{tu|Onn" ä@n º tuv¡iln ~\tynrzi tu| nmozãPi¡nV~ln3xnjw}vlzt}®ÁilznnFz | |_tu~Yz@z{x ®´n vl¢r{~¡m9x6zztutu|| |¡~®·@x x Él{|_nj|\®´Õ¡vlz|6~¡º ®´vlztu~¡x|P~¡z|_tu|v| ~z®Px z{ H~il¹nºx Õ¡tuil|6®´ty|_ºjit}°w ãPz{iln nw ®´vl»6~¡xtyzx tu|l~wun" عl
(33) {xعlxhj~ iln"z{~ iln3liOty xw¼w}|"x6ztu|~ | ® zi¡n3P|_vl~ x_¹lºiltyi!m9xØHn{n l{n"n ~\zn O Ô VÖ.
(34) x~ xriPx ~l¢_ntu~ {n"vlw}z{jtu~ÄxriPx ~l¢_n Ô Ö "$! #&% (') "*! #&%% tu ~vlnoz{ilznF| z{|_ilz`n®´»6vlx ~P{Stux ztuz|tu|~'~ ·Mà 5n {nt}~*¹\z{z{ililnn9vlÕ¡¡|6º{{tu|_w}z{vl+ z rtu|x~¬~ ®´ |_ ,m& ox z{{ilnenv¡i¡n x ~lz{¢| n9 xtu{z|Otu~l ¢tux v¡ztun Åi9z i¡tu{nn"S z{|w}~\Åz{ºt}¡t¯z{vi*ztu|zil~¡n z{z{mon |o|{m9 nVt}WãP|z ¢_i¡x ~lx ztutuz² |x nF~ {zty ilÇn n3t} ~r¡vlx_z{{iltuty~lne¢jzi¡z{ilx nvPHSnzn ·@v¡{hjt}n»6ilx | tyz® tu|~lz~i¡| zn| x6®\xz{zt}lil|_lnÇ~r{|_tyx_vltuwu~\n i!z{xx | j t}v¡ze|tu~\n âz n|zz{H|iln xn{x6z{tytu|~!Vz@¹"z{tu~9il|jn3¢z{li¡|{x v¡n"z'lt¯n t}z~\~¡z¢en"moz{nVilxSnzt}~Ptu~O|Hvl~'®´mo·n"xn {tu|lv¡w}n z|wuvx Ftuz{~\t}|_ztu~~lt}~¢!·hj v¡|il~\tui9ez{x||w'º{z{xØiln"n"P|zi¡{|_~x ¹PzM z`zililznnj|9¢ãPn |6~¡wu»_tux mrn wP{tun~l~¡t}x ~¡lz¢9{tu~ln"n"¢{«\tuv¡ | x6~)z{t}®´®´|_{|~¡|mz{il|nÔ®_z¢ÖSil· xn) Õ¡t}n"|6~_º z ã¡ n"|Ow nV x~l| n)zÇt}~\nVz«_{v¡| t} {njv¡ m)n vlw}zx_tuelwuxn Õ¡||6~º ° z{ilnsOÕ¡v¡|6lºjP°f|\ã¡n nÇw ziP x6|z m9zilx ntu0~ ¢/|6»_n "{x ~l~ t}~¡P¢n3n"º«\v¡{t¯x6zz{zt}n"|_~.~ x_-³ ºiltyi)n O¡nVn"ziln n Hn ~ n ~¡ nÇ|&® x~ ºt¯z{ilt}~ Ô _Ö -1
(35) 23465 hji¡n ~ tu n zn"motu~ln ®´{|m5z{iln3n"«\v¡x ztu|~ Ô p\Ö -78 9- #&% (') - :#&%2% ;65 E. F. . Y Y[Z\2]^_]`. .
(36) 'Ð_à @àÏ¡Ì á V. lÎÌ6á Fá ÀÑ àÁáHÎ Sà ÒSà Ì Þ¡Î ÒSàBÌ Þ. . . . ÚenOz"¹¡t}~\z{| v¡ t}~l¢9xo'x¢x ~l¢_nív¡w¯z{t}lwutun ¹ºni¡xØ»n " ! ' " ! ! ". ! ! -*#
(37) 4% (' . ÆÇi¡|\|\tu~l¢ z{|x zty®´9z{ilnx |tu~_znV«_vPx6ztu|~. -. -*# (' " ! ! . . .
(38) . . . . - :# - :
(39) # 4%% . Ô Ö. -* # ! 7 . . Ô _Ö. . Ô Ö. O. z{ilnã¡zjz{n {m8tyjn wut}motu~¡x6z{n ¹¡x~ ºÇnã¡~ z{i¡x6z ºi¡n {n. " ! . H. ! - : # . ÔÖ Ô º®´hj|_t}i¡3znÅi x lx{n" t}»ØzPxtunV|~\S~Pz{zx x ¢_zw@|onÄÕ¡x |6tu~!ºj°fzxã¡i¡n ¡x w zt¯ zx n"{ »6rÖ9x wu~Otyv¡!vlx6mz{t}~ t}P|_ n"~¡n j H· | n ®~ ~Y n"n"z{~\ilt}z!¢_n9~| ® »6x_x n{)tuxz¹ei¡lºx wun"z t}zÔi _x ÖFz{~!ilty3PnYn x {n"¡n x vlzn"w}zztymox zwiPtu~lx6 n zt"Hz{n"ºiln"nYt¯z{~\il¢_z|ty{x vx wzjn"tuz{n «\il~\v¡nzx z~l| tun |®n ~ ¹ z{xilln)l{x | l{|tytux6~\zzenn"H«\|v¡vlx ~ ztu |x ~ {Ô \Öj|~tuF x t¯z{wyt}|_|~¡xj{¡n"x «\vlztutyx nVw "t#"Wx {n n{®´n vl~\w¼ztym9x wx zn"il«\n"v¡mox zx tu|zty~Ä xx w¼~ z {n"z{x ilznmo n ~\n zz"n"· motu~¡x6z{t}|_~Ä| ®@ziln ÕP»6x|6º tyhjx lil|wunwun"vz|tuH|mon"~¡ l@|vlmoz{t}~Px6n"z{)t}nj|_wu~¡zxi¡x ¢_njwnx¹'|_ zilze|n tu|~\®@zM|xlmo{|tul~llvl¢wuz{n wux6mÊn z{t} iP|_n"~¡xx tu¢w`~Ät}nmoätuw}tytux wun n~¡ ty|_Åmo{||l®jvlw}¢_n zililnt¯wuz_ ·n"|«\½~\vlztu{il»6|n"x wM~rwun zz~\ililzn"n|z{~O|oÅvlz{mx il¡nPln" |_|\| xz® i¬| ®@n"|6zt}»º¢_n"~| z{nV{xx i t}z tu|n"~¡tux¢w ~ x»Ølxl{tyx |_¡xw}ni'¹Hx ~º i¡tu{n"iÅ|_monV«_lv¡vt}z{tun"~l ¢r ztui¡nVnSz3Õ¡|6n ºµ»6x ã¡wuv¡n"x w ztu¹l|P~¸nV||_®Çmr¢nVx t}|_n"~_mrzHen OwuwuÄt}~ltu¢P~ · tu»Ot vPx wuw}Ä»6x {Ot}~¡¢ F~¡ nn"«\v¡x6z{t}|_~ Ô Ötyn"z{xlwutuiln ¹lx ~ t}mol{|6»n"mrn"~\zj"x ~ Pn3m9x n3ºt¯z{ixoi¡x Hn3i¡x ~¡¢n ÔÖ ; º Hi¡·Mn {hjn ilÅn»6tuex {Ptux |\ztut}|ztu~ »n_t}~ ¹Hxz{~ il nmo|\xzjw}w ®´vln ~¡~¡|zvltu|¢_~ i¸zi¡|9n ~z{i¡Px6zFnVz|_ilmrnnVã¡ zF»Øxtyx6z{t}|_~Ätux ~Åx vlx6zn3nVz{t}m9x zn)|® Ô " _Ö ! 5 z{ |)|®Á~¡z®´n"|_Mzw}wum9|6x ºKtux ~\âOz{xr"t}~¡¹¼¡¢x v¡ziv¡i¬|i9® xxzmox!n"n |mrH n"tut¯~lãPz tu"m)x6vlz{n"t}{m |_~n x~\¹ z{zj ilvln n~\¢zztux w'x lx wun)tumrn º~\tuzM~ltu~l tum)¢!x~ovlzilm8PtyntuâO{j~ln"{"n"n"x {x_"wy¹Wilvlznwyilx6 noz{· n ¢ ~ xx |~ t} n" ~_zn ilzÇnem9z|9lxØxØÄ|» P|_n"tno{ l»\{{n tu| |Hwyn"nVx6x Sz{zzt}~¡nn ¢ tuty~\ z |en"x»\~3tynx wuw}|6ººjilx tylwui!nM~lvlnV¡nV¡{xx {nt}wuºt¯z{|_il~Ot}~)»n º{¢ilnVtuÇix z{zilw}nÇnVx |z~¡z{z|x xrtu~\w}|z{ xxw¼nMmo{t}x6~lz{tutum)ã¡v¡n m ·· ~ziltyºxØ_¹"xl{|n vl{n . H. . V. O. V. X. E. 5Y.
(40) )à CÒSà Þ Î . CàÁÍrà VÌ fàBÑ6á¬Þ SàÁá àÁÒ CÞ¡Ì ßÌ6á FÎ{Ì ßMËÌ6Í9Î CÒ{Ì Î àBÎ.
(41) . . . . . . . . X. ! <Ç)!¼ )" "1)( )) )( !': ~ziltyÇn"ztu|~ºnF |~¡t n z{ilnFzºÇ|° tumon ~¡tu|~¡xw¡x tu®´|_t}wPvl~¡ |~¡zx tu~ln |_ztumot}²Vx6z{t}|_~v¡t}~l¢)ziln ãP|_ w}n |\wz¬tun m9 x | wm9vl {|x »~\tun~*z{tu| wWxz{iln z{ il|_nnã¡_®B~¡¹Ox nzil °CãPnOn Õ¡¸w |6ºKzHi¡|nã¡vln x ~ w tu ®´x tu|_j{t}wM¢_¹|6ni¡»· ¢¡n"xP·@~ln ãPn ¢ 3vlOx_{nzil· v¡nw}n"t}~\zn"n"«\v¡~Px x zwtu|H~¡|"vl·~ e x {{vlYmox n~ z{i¡z{x6ilznz{il{n nmoÕ¡| |6z{º n . . 8. . E. B. D. c. É t}¢_vln @ì |m9xt}~ ºt}zi nVtu¢~v¡®Bx_n x ~ |_vzn"H|v¡~ x { 'nz"Ù x{v¡mrn)zi¡x z
(42) , Yx {nzi¡nl{n"{vln_¹ n ~¡t¯z_¹W»n wu|t}z |moH|~ln"~_zetu~*x ~ tunVSztu|~P ¹'z| zx wMn"~ln {¢¬x ~ z{| z{xwMn ~\z{i¡x wuOYHn )v¡~lt¯z»|wuvlmononVHn"ztu»n"w}_¹ hjiln"~¬ziln9zº| ° t}mon ~Ptu|~¡xwvlwun nV«_vPx6ztu|~Pjt}~YÆx znVtyx ~ |O| tu~¡x6z{n"jx {n. . E. 8. ~ z{iln3 xn| ®xrPn"®´nVSz¢_x_ºÇni¡xØ»_n. . ' ' 5 . Ô VÖ EWE. Ô VÖ hji¡n»_n"z| |_~_zx tu~¡Çziln3 |~¡n {»6x6ztu»nF»6x {tuxlw}nV ¹ x~ xnFzi¡n |~O»nVSz{t}»_nÕ¡v!»n"z|_{tu~ ¸x~ tunVSz{t}|_~¡nVHn"ztu»n wu " nãP~ln x®´|_w}wu|6º "¹ $&%% # $&%% " $&%% " . # . ( ' " . Ô "_Ö $ # #. #' " . ! ' !
(43) ) ' ) ' !
(44) ' ) ' ~Ä|_ n z{|9z{n"x zziln|_w}t P|_vl~ x |_~ t}ztu|~Äl{n" tun wu¹PºÇntu~\z{| v¡nz{iln vl{»\tuwut}~lnVx |\|_° ~¡Mt}tuvl~¡«\w}vlx n"znVnV n" ¹O«\¹¼ã¡v¡x ¢_x ~ vlz {tun|¢~¡)n"j~lPtun ~Än"w}x6|6z{ºvln{»Oxilt}wu|6t}z~¡º{n"v¡Çx z{zilvl tu|\{jn |_âO tu ~ mot}~¡nVx | ziY®nVÇmoxiPnV|_xØvli»~nx z{il|z{nvlil~no®´|_ x w}wutuxr|6º®´|_tutut}~l~lw ¢¢)v¡wun®´|_t}~lx tu¢ m ®´|_ |_t}wf~·®´|hj{ilm9nx zw'ºÇm9|°x ltulmotu~ln ~¡¢z{tu|n"~¡ix° w '.
(45)
(46) . #. * ' . E. E. Y Y[Z\2]^_]`.
(47) V . 'Ð_à @àÏ¡Ì á. E. . ºi¡n {n
(48) . '. ¹ ¹ . lÎÌ6á Fá ÀÑ àÁáHÎ Sà ÒSà Ì Þ¡Î ÒSàBÌ Þ. . . ' ' 5 . -. . .
(49) . . . . x~ ' x nÄ |¹ ~OÅ»nVtuSzz{tuil»nn!_Õ¡xv |_lt}ty~ x ~ |x ®~ z{ iln z x t}~P{n"®´|_ztu|m9~±x6z{t}nV|_~H·n"ztu»n wu¹
(50) . Ô p\Ö E. . É tu¢vl{n @x ztyx wW»Otun º | ® o°CzOHnmrnVi ||_®zztuÉ¡ilm9|nrx w z{|\ilnVnzF®´ÕPtuvl¢|6~ ~¡º Slz{xt}{|_|~|_lvl· wun ~ m ~¸ z¢i¡n"n~ln x tux ®´wf|¹¡tuz{wil|nF º|_t}~lze¢P®´¹lvlz{~PilSnztu|x~Ån {|tu \n ~Pã¡x ~lmon tu "xei¡®´x|{wux_w}|6Sºzn"etyt}~Äztyz{ iljno¢tux »n n{| z{ilOn)~¡»6x xmow}vltyn Ô VÖ. ºl¹Mi¡ºtuilin"ty@n x³®´vltu~PoSzxYtu|®´~vl~¡| ®zz{tuil|n`~/ÕP||6®º¶zi¡»Øxn ty¡x ¡nVw}nVvlx{~n z¹Çi¡|nÇHz|ilvln ~ lx {n"{{| vl®l{nH| #t "Wn x{n ~¡ºÇ nÇn!mrHn"n~\zºztu|n n"~l~Èn z{iltu~)nÄxnVSSz{z{t}v¡|_x ~ w ¡xz{nV{x~¡vl{|_n~lxty~e |_xzvlx H{n ¢nz|l~l{tyn"{x tuvl®´|_nt}tuw¼~ tu~ tu~O »{n"x{¢n {n n"v¡t}S¢_z{~!t}|_l~!{|l¡{|w}n"¡m w}n"¹m |_·M ziln3»6xl{tyx6n"z{{t}|_vl~n tu~! z{x il¢9nx |Otun ®´ä9|tu wt}n"i¡~\zjxP|n ® ¡| v¡ n"xr»6x {tux ztu|~!t}~ zi¡n|_zj®´vl~¡ztu|~ Ô _Ö "! '# ºi¡i¡xtuPi¶n_·±tyFxÄo®´t¯vlz9~¡i¡Sz{x_t}9|_~Èx wu| nV®jx z{ il*nH»6n x n {~³tyx6zmotu|n ~¶~\z{tut}~¶|_~lz{n il nOÕ¡$|6º xã¡mrn"w nV |_»6~ x "ty x ¹`lwuzn"ilnÄx |~ z iln"z{rilnzn »6{xm99tyx6z{ t}x|_~/~¬H|nÄ®ex n"tux®´tu|_w}t} w z{m9 {nxxz~\n"t}ozmotuz{|tut}~¡~lmoxtunnVwmoxn nÇlz{ziln il| ln z ~O|vl!®Mm㡺P~liln"t}tuzn i!|® ºÇt "W|_nVn vl{tuw n ¢ ~¡~! nV»6n"«\x "vl¹¼{tut}Px{nnVl w}z{nVx ilÇvPnx n¢z{zn n"il»x6n"n"z{~n o¹Wzt}zi¡|n"nmo{x ÕPlz|6vltu|ºÊz~tu~l·ºÇ¢Ã|_z{vl|6t}mow º nn i¡»_t¯n xØ®V»_ºÇ¹_nnFOz9ºÇ| v¡n"HnrnFtu~lv¡¢r|wutu »~l|n¢~\ zz{ilx|n w z{il|wun »|_nF_z¹i¡zni¡Õ¡n|6Õ¡ºK|6º nV«_n"vP«\x6v¡ztux |z~Ptu|j~¡|~¡x nn3n"tu»~\n"z{9| t}zv¡n"{n x ztu|x~· |~¡zx tu~\zt}~¸v¡i¸x9ºjxØ9z{i¡x6zºÇn3|_~lw} ~ln"n z| 6. E. E@O. 5Y.
(51) )à CÒSà Þ Î . CàÁÍrà VÌ fàBÑ6á¬Þ SàÁá àÁÒ CÞ¡Ì ßÌ6á FÎ{Ì ßMËÌ6Í9Î CÒ{Ì Î àBÎ.
(52) . . . . . . . . . E E. zã¡z"¹lºn nã¡~¡n|_mrn _x |ltyx ~m9x z{tu n"®´| |~O»n"~ltun ~¡ nFtu~ ziln®´|_w}wu|6ºt}~¡¢ n {t}»6x6z{t}|_~¡.
(53) '
(54) ' Ô Ö Ãen {nºÇn3|_~¡t n"jzilnznVx !zx6znÕ¡ |6º3¹lx~ ziln3»6x {tyx6ztu|~ | ®zilnMvlw}n"n"«\v¡x ztu|~¡xn. Ô Ö
(55) '
(56) 465 x_ziln3{n"vlw}z| ® ¹ ¹¡iln ~¡ n Ô Ö ('
(57)
(58) '
(59) ('
(60)
(61) '
(62) »6Fxtyºx6z{nt}|_mo~¡n"x ~_wHz{®´t}||_{~lmn |l®'{zn i¡»Ontu|v¡vlwuwun ¹~lnV«_|6ºvPx6t}z~\tu|z{~P| j ºv¡t¯ z{nilt}z~ ilnz{iln x ¢ |x m9~¡x¢t}ty~ x ~/ m vlw¯z{t}¡w}tun ¹Px ~ tu~_z{n ¢_{x znziln.
(63) !
(64) '
(65) 5 Ô _Ö # h¢_ji¡t nÇwutun~¸®Ázz{i¡ilxtu~ ¡xPt n"nÇ"¹W|t}®¡zz{tyilnPxn"P|6tu| »_n`tynV«_tuvP~ x6ztu| ~rtu{ n"xS~)z{t}|_H~n ¹H zt}il»On"t n n ®´ |{t}~\nz{z{|eilzn)ºãP|F{PzFx tuz{~\"z·n ¢_e{ xwºPnÇx vPzFn| z®Çi¡nn"«\ Fv¡°fx6zz{Ot}|_P~ n Ô \Ö`ty. ! ! Ô VÖ x~ zilnn" |~ t}~\z{n ¢x wW¡xz|® nV«_vPx6ztu|~ Ô _Ö. !
(66) ! ! ! Ô Ö À®`zilnr®Bx Fã¡n"w P|_vl~ x-tyFm9xt}~\z{xt}~¡n ¸ v¡tu~l¢!ziln n"tu¢~¹Wz{iln ~ 5®´|tu~Õ¡|6ºÊºjxØ»n_¹ z{tu~\i¡zx6n"z¢tyx6ozz{tu||/~ xØx ~! !Hn3 º t}zz{n ~ 5¡ ·Kt}®ºn¸ x~³moxân ! 85Å®´|9z{iln¸|vl zÕ¡|6º ºxØ»_n¹Çziln¸xP|6»_n.
(67) ! ! ! Ô _Ö x~ n"«\v¡x6z{t}|_~ Ô \Ö`Hn" |mon". ! ' ! ! Ô 6p\Ö ÆÇ|_~¡n"«\vln ~\z{w}_¹Oziln»6x {tux ztu|~ | ®@|_zj®´vl~¡ztu|~¸ x~!Hn3º{t¯zzn ~. ! ' '
(68) ! ' ! ' ! Ô Ö EKH. E V. E X. E. . Y Y[Z\2]^_]`. . . .
(69) Ø. 'Ð_à @àÏ¡Ì á. E. lÎÌ6á Fá ÀÑ àÁáHÎ Sà ÒSà Ì Þ¡Î ÒSàBÌ Þ. . . . -. . .
(70) . . . . Úe|6º³nVx {{x~l¢njz{ilnz{ilt} x~ ®´|v¡z{i9zn"m9Çt}~zilnFtu¢i\z`i¡x~ t ne|®'x H|6»nn"«\v¡x ztu|~¹\ºnei¡xØ»_n. ! ' ! ! ' ! ' # Ô _Ö. !
(71)
(72) '
(73) ' !
(74)
(75) '
(76) . . . #. . . . O. . . . F~zilnx tu®´|tuwWvl®Bx n! 6¹x"|_ tu~l¢)zilnFÕ¡|6ºã¡n"w P|_vl! ~ x |~ t¯z{t}|_~ 5¡¹OºÇni¡xØ»n 5
(77)
(78) 5 '( 5
(79)
(80)
(81)
(82) 5 ¹P|rzi¡n®´|vlzi!zn"m PVn |monV Ô Ö !
(83) '
(84) " '# .
(85) '
(86) ~\z{| v¡ n Ô \Ö Ô ÖÇt}~\z| Ô V_ÖS¹Oz|o¢_nz. ! ' '
(87) ! ' ! # ' . !
(88)
(89) '
(90) ' !
(91)
(92) '
(93) ' Ô Ö H. E@O. EKH. E. . . . .
(94).
(95). '. . " '
(96)
(97) '
(98)
Documents relatifs
« On ne fait pas que des psychothérapies en clinique/…/On en parlait encore ce matin : est-ce qu’on a le temps de faire des psychothérapies, parce qu’on voit les gens
L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non, émanant des
AMC PAPI : Spécificités du contexte torrentiel – Rapport de Phase 1 Page 18 sur 46 Dans le cas des laves torrentielles, on peut résumer les conditions nécessaires au
Gillard, “Combinaison de la DG-FDTD avec un mod` ele de substitution pour un calcul de dosim´ etrie locale dans un probl` eme variable et fortement multi-´ echelle”, dans 18`
Le jugement porté par les femmes lettrées sur leurs soigneurs doit donc être nuancé en fonction de la personnalité de chacune, de la gravité de la maladie,
3.3 Processus d’alimentation d'entrepôt de données : Nous devons extraire, transformer et charger les données à partir des sources précédemment citées, dans l'entrepôt de
« La prophétie, ou interprétation et conférence des Écritures se fera par les ministres du Colloque, en l’assemblée où chacun dira la tête découverte ce que Dieu lui
Pendant six ans, jusqu’au premier janvier 1568, le clergé de France doit fournir chaque année au roi l’équivalent de quatre décimes, un million six cent mille livres tournois,