HAL Id: jpa-00212482
https://hal.archives-ouvertes.fr/jpa-00212482
Submitted on 1 Jan 1990
HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access
archive for the deposit and dissemination of
sci-entific research documents, whether they are
pub-lished or not. The documents may come from
teaching and research institutions in France or
abroad, or from public or private research centers.
L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est
destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents
scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non,
émanant des établissements d’enseignement et de
recherche français ou étrangers, des laboratoires
publics ou privés.
Microstructure of halato telechelic polymers bearing
group IVb metal carboxylate end-groups
Jean-René Regnard, Pierre Lagarde, Claudine E. Williams, Gilberto Vlaic,
Pascal Charlier, Robert J. Jérome
To cite this version:
Microstructure of halato telechelic
polymers bearing group
IVb
metal
carboxylate end-groups
Jean-René
Regnard
(1,*),
PierreLagarde
(1),
Claudine E. Williams(1),
GilbertoVlaic (2),
Pascal Charlier(3)
and Robert J. Jérome(3)
(1)
LURE(Laboratoire
pour l’Utilisation duRayonnement Electromagnétique),
CNRS-CEA-MEN,
University
of Paris-Sud, 91405Orsay,
France(2)
Dipartimento
di Scienze Chimiche, Universita diCagliari,
09124,Cagliari, Italy
(3)
MacromolecularChemistry
andOrganic catalysis Laboratory, University
ofLiège,
SartTilman, B6, 4000
Liège, Belgium
(Received in
Februarv
1 st, 1990,accepted
onApril
26,1990)
Résumé. 2014 On a
analysé,
parspectroscopie
EXAFS, la structure locale desagrégats
d’ionomèrescarboxylato-téléchéliques
neutralisés par un excès de zirconium. Laprésence
de liaisons Zr-O-Zrexplique
lagrande
stabilité du matériau aux solvantspolaires. L’augmentation
du nombre de voisins zirconium avec laquantité d’agent
de neutralisationindique
une croissance desagrégats
avec le taux de neutralisation. On propose un modèlecompatible
avec lespropriétés mécaniques
de ces matériaux.Abstract. 2014 The local structure within the ionic aggregates of a
carboxylato-telechelic
ionomer neutralized with an excess of zirconium has beeninvestigated by
EXAFS spectroscopy. Thepresence of non-ionic Zr-O-Zr intramolecular bonds
explains
the greatstability
of the material towardspolar compounds.
The number of Zrneighbours
in the aggregates has been found toincrease with the total amount of zirconium in the
sample.
A model consistent with theunique
mechanicalproperties
of theresulting
material isproposed.
Classification
Physics
Abstracts 61.40K - 81.20SIntroduction.
Ionomers are materials in which ion
pairs, randomly spaced along
anonpolar polymeric
backbone,
associate into microdomainsresponsible
for a thermoreversible network[1-4].
Halato-telechelic
polymers (HTP’s)
form a class of model ionomers sincethey
consist of short chainsselectively
terminatedby
a salt group which may be either a neutralizedacidic,
aneutralized basic or a
quaternized
amino group[5-8].
The networkjunction points
are nowsituated at the chain ends and thus
separated
by
a well-defined characteristic distance.Both the
quantitative
fonctionalization of acarboxy-telechelic polymer
and thecomplete
neutralization of the acid
end-groups
arekey
parameters
for the contribution of all chainsegments
to theload-bearing
capability
of the material. Ahighly
controlled method for neutralization of thesecarboxy-telechelic
polymer
has beenreported using
stoichiometricamounts of very reactive alkaline or alkaline-earth metal alcoxides
[5].
Thistechnique
requires
that the alcohol formed as abyproduct
iscompletely
eliminated in order todisplace
the reaction
equilibrium
and also to avoid the ionpair
solvation. The related metalcarboxylates
promote
the formation ofhighly interacting
ionpairs [5,
7,
8].
Provided thechain
length
isuniform,
there iscomplete microphase separation
between the chainsegments
and the ionic groups which areincorporated
intomultiplets [9].
These domains aresurrounded
by
a volume from which other ionic domains areexcluded,
andarranged
in aliquid-like
manner in space. In thesematerials,
there is no evidence for ionic clusters aspostulated
in the more classical ionomers[9].
However the contribution of the ionicaggregates
asphysical
cross-links andfillers,
although important,
is not sufficient to accountfor the small-strain tensile moduli of
carboxy-telechelic polyisoprenes
and the modulusenhancement has been attributed to
entanglements
in the form ofinterlocking loops
formed when both ends of a telechelic chain are located in the sameaggregate
[10].
It has also beenshown that the ionic microdomains in materials with a
higher
modulus are moreordered,
asshown
by
ExtendedX-ray
Absorption
Fine StructureSpectroscopy (EXAFS).
It is indeed observed that metal a,«carboxylato polyisoprenes
are able to strain-harden more as thecoordination number of the metal atom increases. Furthermore the
degree
of local orderstrongly
depends
on the neutralizationpathway,
all other conditionsbeing
identical[11, 12].
So,
when an a,«carboxylic
acidpolybutadiene (PBD)
isquantitatively
neutralizedby
Zn insuch a way that no
byproduct
which could solvate the ionpairs
isproduced,
ahighly
orderedstructure is observed. A coordination of shell of five Zn atoms at 3.22 A is indeed
reported
whichdisappears
when the Zncarboxylate
ionpairs
are formed in the presence of asolvating
agent.
An exactdescription
of the conditions of neutralization is thereforemandatory
forcomplete sample
characterization.On the other
hand,
when telechelics are neutralized with tetravalent transitionmetals,
theresulting
material hasunique properties
related to the different nature of themetal-carboxylate
bond. Indeed in contrast to alkaline and alkaline-earthmetals,
elements such astitanium and zirconium form bonds which are
mainly
covalent and theirdipolar
interaction isnoticably
weaker. Across-linking
effect is observedonly
when an excess of alkoxide groups isused in the neutralization
steps
andsubsequently hydrolyzed
[13,
14],
an observation whichled to believe that the network is stabilized
by carboxylato-metal-oxohydroxide
groups[8,
14].
Theresulting
material contains smallinorganic
domains and shows agreat
stability
towards
polar compounds,
which contrasts with that of alcaline telechelics. Indeed nostructural
change
is seenby small-angle-neutron scattering
when Ti-PBD has been immersedin deuterated water whereas an increase in the domain size
corresponding
tohydration
of themetal
by
D20
is observed for Na-PBD[15].
The nature of the tetravalent metal also influences the mechanical
properties. Dynamic
mechanical measurements have shown thatoxy-Zr-carboxylates
formbigger although
less stableaggregates
than the Ticounterparts
and that a,lù-carboxylic
acid PBD exhibits a morecomplex
viscoelastic behaviour when neutralizedby
Zr instead of Ti. This has beententatively
attributed to thenonequilibrium aggregation
of theoxymetal carboxylates and/or
to the occurrence of at least two different
thermally
activated processes in the Zrcontaining
polymer [14].
The surfacecomposition
of theionomer,
asanalysed by
ESCA,
is alsodifférent : for Ti-PBD the surface
layer
contains no Ti and is followedby
alarge
concentration
gradient
towards the bulk whereas theZr-containing
domains tend to beupon the
hydrolysis
of the metal alkoxide groups used in excess[16].
EXAFSspectroscopy
of an a,«carboxylic
acid PBD neutralized with an excess of Tiisopropoxide (400
and 600%)
inthe presence of water has also confirmed the existence of Ti-O-Ti intermolecular bonds and has shown that the
majority
of the Ti atoms are included in dimer and trimer units. Twodifferent Ti-O bond
lengths
have thus been measured[17].
Since the Zr behaviour contrasts in some
aspect
with that ofTi,
it is of interest toprobe
the local environment around Zr atoms in order to compare the microstructure within theaggregates
ofoxy-Ti
andoxy-Zr
carboxylates.
For this purpose, EXAFSspectroscopy
has been used toprovide
adescription
of the short range order around Zr in terms oftype
and number ofneighbours,
distances and thermal and static disorder in these distances.Experimental.
SAMPLE PREPARATION. - The
samples investigated
were obtainedby
neutralization withzirconium
isopropoxide
of adicarboxylic
acidpolybutadiene (Hycar
CTNB 2000 X156),
commercialized
by
BFGoodrich,
of molecular characteristics as follows :Mn
= 4600 ;
MW/Mn
=1.8 ;
functionality
= 2.01 andcis/trans/vinyl
ratio =20/65/15.
A five wt % solutionof the
carboxy-telechelic polybutadiene
wasprepared
in toluenepreviously
driedby
refluxing
over calciumhydride.
Thepolymer
was then driedby
three successiveazeotropic
distillations of toluene and anappropriate
amount of Zrisopropoxide (0.1
molL-1
1solution in
toluene)
was added to the final 5 wt % solution of the
polymer.
Zr alkoxide was used in the stoichiometric ratio but also in various excess to thecarboxylic
acidend-groups. Samples
calledZR 1,
ZR2,
ZR4 and ZR6correspond
to analkoxide/acid
molar ratio of1,
2,
4 and6,
i.e. to a
degree
of neutralization of100,
200,
400 et 600%,
respectively.
The neutralization reaction was driven tocompletion by azeotropic
distillation of theisopropanol
formed as areaction
byproduct.
When ca. 20 % of the toluene volume was distilled off under reducedpressure, it was
replaced by
fresh solvent and a further distillation run was carried out. After three distillation runs, the 20 % of distilled toluene wasreplaced by
toluene saturatedby
water in order tohydrolyze
the unreacted Zr alkoxide functions.Again
three distillation runs were achieved under theseparticular
conditions. Toluene wasfinally
distilled offcompletely
and the
polymer
was dried to constantweight
under vacuum at 65 °C. It was molded at 120 °C(150 °C
forZR6)
into disks whose thickness wasadjusted
toget
the bestsignal-to-noise
ratio in the EXAFSexperiment (absorption
coefficient times thickness on the order of2).
THE EXAFS TECHNIQUE, EXPERIMENTAL AND DATA ANALYSIS. - All
samples
were studiedin air and at room
temperature
on the EXAFS 1 station at LURE-DCI. Thestorage
ring
was run at 1.85 GeV withpositron
currents of about 250 mA. Forscanning
the energy rangearound the Zr
K-edge
at17 998 eV,
a Si 331 channel cut monochromator was used. The EXAFSspectra
were recorded in the transmission mode at 2 eV intervals over the energy range 17 800-18 800 eVusing
two ionization chambers filled with argon. Each datapoint
wascollected for 2 seconds and each
complete
spectrum
was measured 5 times for thehighest
Zr-content(ZR4
andZR6)
and 7 times for the lowest concentrations(ZR2
andZR 1 ).
Theexperimental amplitude
andphase
functions for the Zr-Opair
were obtained from the cubicperovskite
BaZr03
(dzr-o =
2.095Á,
N (O )
=6).
where u o is the smooth atomic like contribution above the
edge
and u B thebackground
originating
frompre-edge absorption
processes.For a
K-edge,
thesimple back-scattering theory gives
therelationship
between the EXAFSsignal X (k )
and the structuralparameters
[18] :
where Ri
is the average distance whichseparates
theabsorbing
atom from theNi
neighbouring
atomsdefining
the ithshell,
with a r.m.s.deviation 0- i ; exp (-
2 o-2i k2)
is aneffective
Debye-Waller
factorresulting
from the statistical and thermal distortion of theequilibrium
structure.Fi(k) and ~ i (k)
are theamplitude
ofback-scattering
and the totalphase
shift,
respectively,
characteristic of the selected(absorbing atom)/(back scattering
shelli) pair,
and A(k )
is thephotoelectron
mean freepath.
Data
processing
was carried out on aVÀX
730computer
according
to a standardprocedure [19]
that isonly briefly
summarized hère :uB is
extrapolated
from thepre-edge
region
fitted with a Victoreen function(ILB x
=CA 3
+ DA4)
and then subtracted from theexperimental data. u 0 (k)
is obtained froma
smoothing procedure (200 iterations)
of the EXAFS oscillationsstarting
50 eV above theedge.
The slow residual oscillationsof X (k)
are then eliminatedby
a multi-iterative processwhich affects
only
the very small R-values(typically R
1Á)
of the modulus of the Fouriertransform.
Eo
wasarbitrarily
chosen as the inflectionpoint
of the ZrK-edge
in the selected modelcompound BaZr03 (Eo
= 18 006eV).
The reduced data for the modelcompound
and theionomers are shown in
figure
1. Thek3 multiplied
spectra
were then Fourier transformed inthe domain
[51, 680]
eV afterapplication
of aHanning
window,
yielding
the moduli1 FT
1
shown infigure
2. The main feature of these radial distribution functions(RDF)
is thepresence of two distinct
peaks
for eachionomer,
attributed to Zr-O and Zr-Zr atompairs,
whose intensities vary
systematically
with Zr-content without muchchange
in position
[20].
Thebroadning
of the firstpeak
forsample
ZR 1 could not bereasonably explained.
Results and discussion
Provided that the
Fi(k)
and Oi(k)
functions areknown,
the structuralparameters
Ni, Ri
and ai can be determined for agiven compound.
We use asemi-empirical approach :
the first
peak
ofBaZr03
was Fourier filtered and theexperimental phase
function wasextracted on the basis of its well characterized
crystallographic
structure(each
Zr is surroundedby
6 oxygen atoms at the distance of 2.095Â).
Subsequently,
the filteredsignal
was fitted
using experimental phase
and theoretical[21] amplitude
functions to evaluate the À and aparameters
ofequation (3) (N being
fixed at6.0). Finally
we calculated theexperimental amplitude
not convoluted with theDebye-Waller
term, but still convoluted with the mean freepath
term. Theexperimental
functions were then transferred to the back-transformed firstpeak
of the fourionomers,
and the structuralparameters
of the first shellwere obtained
by
a least squarefitting
of the data in the interval between 70 and 600 eV.During
thefit,
a variation of k was allowed to take into account anyapproximation
in chemicaltransferability
ofamplitude
andphase
functions. Theadjusted
wave vector is k’ =( k 2 +
0.2624 DE0)1/2 .
The best fits arereported
infigure
3 and the calculated structuralparameters
are listed in Table I.The first
important
conclusion is that it isimpossible
to fit the data withonly
one Zr-OFig. 1. - Experimental
EXAFSX (E)
vs. E for the four zirconium-neutralized a, (J)car-boxypolybutadiene samples
labeled ZRI, ZR2,ZR4,
ZR6 and for the modelcompound BaZr03.
NoteFig.
2. -Fig.
3. - Fit(full line)
of the Fourier filtered firstpeak (dotted line)
for the ZR 1 and ZR4 ionomers.Table 1. - Parameters
of
thefirst
coordination shellsplit
in 2 subshells noted a andb for
theintroduced. It is
interpreted
asshowing
the existence of 2types
of Zr-O bonds. The total numberof oxygen
atoms is constant for allsamples
with an average value of 6.0 ± 0.5 butthey
are not distributed
equally
between the 2 subshells : in the inner subshells at 2.10À,
the number increases with thedegree
of neutralization up to 400%,
whereas it decreases in theouter subshell at 2.25
Á.
Thesamples containing
aproportion
of 2 or 3 Zr per chain(ZR4
andZR6)
have almost the same local structure of oxygen atoms.Attempts
to fit the back-Fourier-transformed secondpeak (Zr-Zr pairs)
of the ionomerRDF with
amplitude
andphase
shifts extracted fromtetragonal yttrium-stabilized Zr02 [22]
as a model
compound
were unsuccessful. Hence for the secondshell,
acomparison
within theseries of
samples
was carried out and two differentanalyses
of the data wereperformed.
First we used the methodproposed by Sayers et
al.[23].
If it is assumed that the Zr-Zr distances aresimilar in the four
ionomers,
then the ratio between theenvelopes
A(k )
of the EXAFSsignal,
relative to the second shell of twosamples i and j
is :A
plot
of In should be linear andgive
the ratio of the coordination numbers andthe u 2
values. As
anexample
of thisprocedure, figure
4 shows theplot
of In(A41AI)
as afunction of
k 2.
Asatisfactory
linear behaviour was obtained for all combinations and theresults are noted as « Method 1 » in table II. The second method uses one of the
samples
as areference
compound :
theexperimental phase
andamplitude
for the Zr-Zr atompair
arecalculated
by backtransforming
the secondpeak
of the ZR 1sample
Fouriertransform,
arbitrarily setting
N = 1 and R = 3.5À (a
reasonable value fromFig. 2).
Then the fit of theback Fourier transform of the second
peak
of the other ionomers was achieved with thesefunctions. An
example
of these fits is shown infigure
5. Asreported
in tableII,
both methodsgive
results ingood
agreement.
Note that on average, each Zr atom is surroundedby
anFig.
4. - Ratio of the EXAFSFig.
5. - Fit(full line)
of the Fourier filtered second peak (dotted line) for the ZR6 ionomer.Table II. - Evolution
of
the relative coordinationnumber,
theeffective Debye- Waller factor
and the Zr-Zr distance in the Zr-neutralized HTPcompared
tosample
ZRI.increasing
number of Zrneighbours
in the second shell when the total amount of Zr in theionomer
increases,
but with ahigher degree
of disorder. We believe that this is due to anincreasing
static disorder from ZR 1 to ZR6. Lowtemperature
investigations
areplanned
toelucidate this
point ; they
will bereported
in aforthcoming
paper. It isinteresting
to remark here that a casualglance
at the moduli of the Fourier transforms(Fig. 2)
would hint theopposite
conclusion since theintensity
of the secondpeak
decreased withincreasing
ion-content. The conclusion that the average number of Zr
neighbours
increases issupported by
thechemistry
of thesystem.
Indeed thehydrolysis
of anincreasing
amount of unreacted zirconium alkoxides should lead to a more extended network of Zr-O-Zr bonds asConclusions
Three main conclusions can be drawn from this
experimental investigation.
First twotypes
of Zr-O bonds exist in theaggregates
of a, wcarboxylic
acidpolybutadiene
neutralized at and abovestoichiometry
with Zrisopropoxide
followedby
thehydrolysis
of the unreactedalkoxide groups.
Indeed,
two coordination shells have been found around each Zr atom at2.10 and 2.25 ± 0.02
À,
that one canreasonably assign
to Zr-O-Zr andZr-carboxylate
(-COOZr ) and/or
Zr-OHbonds,
respectively.
This observation is consistent with thechemistry
involved in the neutralization process(Eqs. (4)
and(5)).
It also confirms the results of the ESCAanalysis
of octanoic acid neutralized with various amounts of Zr alkoxide followedby hydrolysis
of the unreactedfunctions
[16].
TheO1
1 core levelpeak,
that isunimodal when the octanoic acid is neutralized at
stoichiometry,
showsclearly
twocomponents
when an excess of Zr alkoxide is used. The extrapeak
has been assessed to the Zr-O-Zr bonds(Eq. (5)).
Note that the same conclusion has been reached when thecarboxy-telechelic PBD was neutralized with an excess of Ti
isopropoxide
in the presence of water[17] ;
two O-Ti distances were also measuredby
EXAFSspectroscopy.
Second,
when the amountof neutralizing
agent
increases fromstoichiometry (ZR 1 )
to a sixfold molar excess
(ZR6),
the relativeproportion
of oxygen atoms inoxy-bridges (first
oxygensubshell)
increases whereas the total number of oxygen stays constant. This observationmeans
that,
whatever theOR/COOH
molarratio,
each Zr involved in acarboxylato-oxohydroxide
aggregate
is surroundedby approximately
the same number of nearneighbour
oxygen atoms, which can be
expressed
asThe main
change
in the local structure of theend-group
aggregates
aspromoted by
anincreasing departure
fromstoichiometry
has to be found in the relativeproportion
of oxygenatoms in the two subshells. That the
population
of oxygen atoms inoxy-bridges
(R
= 2.1À )
increases at the expense of thosecontributing
tocarboxylate and/or
hydroxyde
groups when the excess of
hydrolyzable
Zr alkoxideincreases,
means that thecross-linking
ofPBD extremities
gets
more efficient.Finally
this trend issupported by
resultsconcerning
the third shellpopulated by
anincreasing
number of Zr atoms when the total amount of Zr in thesample
increases(Table II).
It is thuslikely
that the size of theaggregates
increases.However,
as the basic unitgrows in
size,
it becomes more disordered as shownby
thelarge Debye-Waller
factor. It isdifficult at this
point
to devise a more detailed model of the actual structure.As
already pointed
out,qualitatively
similar results are obtained when a,«carboxylic
acidPBD is neutralized to 400 and 600 %
by
Tiisopropoxide [17].
The total numberof
oxygenatoms is however smaller
(4.4 compared
to6)
and a dimer of Ti has beenproposed
as thebasic
entity
whose characteristics are constant in the range of the molar excess used(400
to600
%).
In that case, the coordination number of Ti is close to one(0.8)
and the short rangeorder is
high.
The results
reported
in thisstudy
are consistent withprevious
viscoelastic measurements,and
particularly
with thesteady-flow viscosity
of a 10g . dl -1
solution
of a,w-carboxylic
acidPBD neutralized with Zr alkoxide
[15].
A viscous solution is observed at thestoichiometry
of the neutralization reaction.ultimately
an elasticgel
is formed. Thischange
in the solutionviscosity
canonly
be accountedfor
by
a more efficientcross-linking
of PBD. It is also worthrecalling
that the bulk a, «carboxylic
acid PBD neutralized with a fourfold excess of Ti or Zralkoxide,
exhibits arubber-like
plateau
in the viscoelastic measurements but the modulus ishigher
for Zr than for Ti[ 15].
Thus,
at a constantdegree
of neutralization(i.e.
400%),
the mean number of chain endsattached to an
aggregate
ofoxohydroxide
metalcarboxylate
ishigher
for Zr. This is inqualitative
agreement with the EXAFS observations which conclude to ahigher
coordinationnumber of Zr
compared
toTi,
all other conditionsbeing kept
constant.References
[1]
EISENBERG A. and KING M.,Ion-Containing Polymers, Polymer Physics
Ed. Stein R., Vol. 2(Academic
Press, NewYork)
1977.[2] MCKNIGHT W. T. and EARNEST T. E., J.
Polym.
Sci. Macromol. Rev. 16(1981)
41.[3]
LONGWORTH R.,Developments
in IonicPolymers
1,Applied
Science(London)
1983, Ch. 3.[4]
FITZGERALD J. J. and WEISS R. A., J. Macromol. Sci. Macromol. Rev. C28(1988).
[5]
BROZE G., JÉROME R. and TEYSSIÉPh.,
Macromolecules 15(1982)
920 and 1300 ; 16(1983)
996 and 1771.[6]
BROZE G., JÉROME R., TEYSSIÉ Ph. and MARCO C., J.Polym.
Sci.Polym. Phys.
Ed. 21(1983)
2205.
[7]
JÉRÔME R., BROZE G. and TEYSSIÉ Ph., Microdomains inPolymer
Solutions, Ed. P. Dubin(Plenum,
NewYork)
1985,p. 243.
[8]
JÉRÔME R. and BROZE G., Rubb. Chem. Technol. 58(1985)
223.[9]
WILLIAMS C. E., RUSSELL T. P., JÉRÔME R. and HORRION J., Macromolecules 19(1986)
2877.[10]
REGISTER R. A., FOUCART M., JÉRÔME R., DING Y. S. and COOPER S. L., Macromolecules 21(1988)
1009.[11]
JÉRÔME R., VLAIC G. and WILLIAMS C. E., J.Phys.
Lett. France 44(1983)
L-717.[12]
VLAIC G., WILLIAMS C. E., JÉRÔME R., TANT M. R. and WILKES G. L.,Polymer
29(1988)
173.[13]
BROZE G., JÉRÔME R. and TEYSSIÉ Ph., J.Polym.
Sci.,Polym.
Lett. Ed. 21(1983)
237.[14]
BROZE G., JÉRÔME R., TEYSSIÉ Ph. and MARCO C., Macromolecules 18(1985)
1376.[15]
JÉRÔME R., TEIXEIRA J. and WILLIAMS C. E.,unpublished
results.[16]
JÉRÔME R., TEYSSIÉ Ph., PIREAUX J. J. and VERBIST J. J.,Appl. Surf.
Sci. 27(1986)
93.[17]
VLAIC G., WILLIAMS C. E. and JÉRÔME R.,Polymer
28(1987)
1566 ;and CHARLIER P., CORRIAS A., JÉRÔME R., REGNARD J. R., VLAIC G. and WILLIAMS C. E.,
Nuovo Cimento, to be
published (Proceedings
of the 2ndEuropean
International Conference onProgress
inX-ray Synchrotron
Radiation Research,1989).
[18]
STERN E. A., SAYERS D. E. and LYTLE F. W.,Phys.
Rev. B 11 (1975) 4836.[19]
LAGARDE P., RayonnementSynchrotron
dans le domaine des rayons X,Proceedings
of theAussois summer school,
Septembre
1986, Editions du CNRS, Paris(1987).
[20]
Note that the features below the firstpeak
have not been taken into account sincethey
should have nophysical
significance
for alight
back-scatterer like oxygen ; theshouldering
could be due toa low