HAL Id: inria-00000511
https://hal.inria.fr/inria-00000511
Submitted on 26 Oct 2005HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access archive for the deposit and dissemination of sci-entific research documents, whether they are pub-lished or not. The documents may come from teaching and research institutions in France or abroad, or from public or private research centers.
L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non, émanant des établissements d’enseignement et de recherche français ou étrangers, des laboratoires publics ou privés.
Neuronal Spectral Analysis of EEG and Expert
Knowledge Integration for Automatic Classification of
Sleep Stages
Nizar Kerkeni, Frédéric Alexandre, Mohamed Hédi Bedoui, Laurent Bougrain,
Mohamed Dogui
To cite this version:
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
inria-00000511, version 1 - 26 Oct 2005
7 # 6 # 4 4 7" "> # # " " 6#! 7 # 434# .+ . 2# 53 # @ #3 7 # 6" 6" ! 2 34 6>3 65 # 4 " 4 66!4# # " >9 9 $ 4>" 6 2 4"#4# !6 #1#3 " 4 ? # 6 # 426 " # ! 7 " 7 # 3 4 5#49 $ 4>" 6 42 " 4 # # !4!6 #1#3 53 " 6 # 26 "# "B C9 ( 14! 6 " 6344 2 7 53 # ! " '2 # "44#4 " # #"># 1 # "4 7# $ # $ " # $ ! "> # "> #9 ( 4 "> 4 7" # 1>6" 4##4? # ? : ""> " # 71 4#> 4 7# 46 2< 4#> 4#> 4#> % 4#> -" # 2 3 1 "# 46 2 B%C9 4 663 # 14! 6 " 6344 6 4 "# 7 ## # 4#> 4 # 53 # 2 4" 7 " " # 4 42 " "> # 6 "# 3 #1# 4 " 41 6 > 2 6 6 "#4 " # 4>" 649 "> # # 4 " # 4 " 53 54 1"> # 4#" !64 7" 53 #4 77" " 64B-C # 6" "6 "4# 44 # # " 2 7" 4 # 2 6!"#!4 4 7 " > " 663 7%.4 65 6 42 " "># # 4# # 2 34 6> 64##9 ( > !2">+#> # 7 # 66 "> # 46 2 65 64 "4##!#4 # 32" > 9 # 4 > 2 6 2 4"## " 7# 1 !446 2 4#> 4 > " # " ! "> # "> # " : 4 #2 4456 # 1 " 2 # " 1 66 2 4"## " 7 # 46 2 # #! 9 ( 5# " 32" > " # 4##4# 6 # 2!# " # 46 2 4#> 4 ? 66 "4##!# 2 #? ? 665 # 5 4 7# 6" 6 4 "+ :">9 ( 77 !6#3 7# 14! 6 " 6344634 " 41 6 42 #49 4#63 # D! 6#3 7 # 4>" 64 2 " 4 "# D! 6#3 7# 6 # 4!4 " # 4##"> " # 4 62 64? 9 5 4##"> " 2 ! " 4 " #7 #4 ! # 5 "# #4 2 # "# 1 "#4 " 26 # # 4>" 6 "# 2 ## "9 8 " 63 # #" 44 7 # !64 !4 7 14! 6"# 2 ## "# 461 4 "5 1 : 9 " # 4 644 6 !64 5 4 " # 14! 6 # # " 74 2 # !6 ? 1 4 " 4 > 2 6 6 "#4 2 4"# " # 2 34 6> 64>" 64 " " 2 # !6 " # $ 4 4 5 " ( 56 9 " # " # # 62 ( # " 6# ? 1 4 " $ " # 4 # 4 " # 1>6" 4##4 # 5 " 4 746 2 64 > # # 8> ? 1 4 7 # / " 6! "> 46 2 42" 64 " # # ? 1 4 7 / # % 9 "#73"> # 4 # 4# 4 D! 4 6"> # ""> 53 # ! " '2 # " # 4 54 1 # #4!5@ #1 "# 2 ## " 7# 4 !64 "42 44569 ! 62 ? 1 D! " 3 7E # ? : ( # ? 1 D! " 3 7- # E 8#> " 6# ? 1 D! " 3 7.9, # - 8#> % " -26' ( "4 "#46? ? 1 4 8#> 82" 64 D! " 3 7 # - 8#> 0 #'4 2 ? 1 ) "# ? 1 4? # > # 26#! 8#> 8 ?# # 8 ? # # 2 ## " " # < " $ " # 49 " 7 # # # # " 7# 4 " # 4 4 644 77 !6# 2 " "> " # 6" " " #4 '2 " 9 1 # 47 D! "## ## 4 6 "#4 1 62 77 # 53 #7 #49 ( !64 714! 6 " 6344 " 6! 2 # 74!5@ #1#3 7 ' 26 # 2 4" 7# 6# ? 1 4 " # " ,.F 7# # 2 ? " 6 # 4 " 4 " # 65 6">5 #? " 6" "49 4#! 34 ?4# ## # 7 > "#5 #? " 6" "4 "# 4 65 # 3 4 5 !#*,F B,C9 " # " # # 77 !6# 4" # 2 1 !463 ? 4 !6 " #7 > ## # 42 "#53# 4 " 6344 # 65 6 4 " "> # 7E 746 2 2 %.4 2 4 7? !4 7 '2 #? : 4 D! " 1 > 9 $ < 6 # 426 "#"# 4#" .+ . 434# 9
( 1 62 "# 7 !# # 46 2 " 6344434# 4 "#"47 53 # # " 6> 6 2 1 "#4 " # +2 44"> 7 6 > 1 4 # "! 6 2 63> 2 49 &! "#63 2 # 663 66# " ? "! 6 2 63> 2 4 D!22 ? # " !# # 46 2 " 63 6442 ? 7!6B/CBGCBEC9 ( "# 4# 7 # 4 434# 4 " # 46 2 4#! 3 4 1 4 4 " 4"> 7 !6#26 4 "4 "> ? ? " "# "# 4# 2 #"#< + & "4 56 " 4 "# D! 4#47 ">4 " # " 7 " !# # " 6344 434# 6 4"> # 6" " 7 # " ' " # " #4:4H + ( > ? "> "! 5 7# 2 # 4 "# 1 ""> " 2 63> 2 "> " 42 663 # " 7 D! "#73"> " 7 64473"> 66 # 4 2 # 4H + ( "# 4## 1 " ? 14 " 7 "#"!#3 " 46 2 # #! " # #63 54 1 56 14! 663 5!# "63 7# 4>" 62 44">6: # #1#3? # 46? ? 1 4 # 4#! #! 7# 46 2 #9 + ( @ #3 7# !# # " 6344434# 4!44 4 7 " # 14! 6 " 6344 # 7 #4 77" " 64 I ? " # "63 "4"4!4 746 2 4#> 4 6447 # "9 ( !4 "3 4! "# 72 7 " 7# 4 434# 4 4 2 7 2 # # 14! 6 " 63449 " !# # " 6344434# "5 4 5 6: " 44 # " 7#? 2 #4< # 2 # " # # "#4 2 #9 ( # # 2 # 4 2 4"## "4 7 # 2 34 6> 64>" 649 ( 4 2 4"## " !4#5 7 #7!6? # > # # # 4# 4 7# 4>" 6 " !4# : 2 #4 7!" "#6 2 2 # 4 ? 6 5 ">"> 4 267 # " ? # !#> #6444 " # 7 6## # 766? "> 4#2< # # # "#9 ( 4 4 " 2 # 4 2 4 53 # # # "# 6> # 4 ? # 44 # # # "7 # "# # 46 2 4#> 9 "# # 2 #61 6# @ 77 !6#37 # 4 434# 4 "44#4 7 # 7 6"> 7 # 2 34 6> 64>" 649 " # 7 6"> "76! " 4 "4 563# 2 7 " 4 7# 434# 9 0 !4 # "D! 4 7 " 6344 !4 < 26#! " 6344 2 " 6344 42 # 6 " 6344 # B/CB*CB .C9 "> # 4 # "D! 4 # 42 # 6 " 6344? # 4# ! ( "47 ( 4 "63 !4 9 ( 4 "5 '26 " 53# 7 ## ## 14! 6 " 6344 45 4 2 63 " # # # " 7 4 ? 1 4? # 2 # !6 7 D! " 4 ( 56 9 " # # # "# 2 #61 6 4 '26 5 "> 7# # " 6# "D! 4 4!6#">7 # #7 6 "#66> " # "D! 49 "> # 4 # "D! 4 ? ? 66 5 "# 4# " #7 6 ! 6 #? :4 ? # 4!5@ # 7 ! 4#! 3 " ? ? 665 2 4"# " # 766? "> 4 # "9 6 > 63 226 "" ! 2 34 6> 6 7 64 6: $ " 6344 B CB C 4 #4"4 3 1 : 2 #"# 64B %C " 6344 71>6" B -C 46 2 " 6344B ,CB /CB GC #9 4 #? 4 '26 " "# "# ! # "2 ## > 6 7# 42 2 4# 2 # 2 7 " 7 ! " '2 # " " " 4 26 65 6">#4: 5 4 " # 4 # " # 4 2 4"## " " " '2 "## #? 4 5 5 6?9 $ < !6# 3 ) 2# " ) # #! 9
%
&
! '2 "# # !6# 3 ) 2# " ) B EC ? 446 # 4# 4# D! # # 69 "> #7 6 ! 6 #? :4 )4 # "63 # 4#7 D! "#63 !4 ? " 4!2 14 # ""> 4 D! 9 9 ? " # "> !4#5 6 " 5 #? " #? :" 4 7 # 2 4"#"> 42 #1 63 # "2!# " # !#2!# 7# " #? :9 #? " # 63 4 7 " ! "4 4>" # # 4 "2!# " !#2!#4>" 64 " 41 6 "# # " 63 4 7 5# 3 4 "5 " 66? # 26'73# 6# " # # " 5 6 " 5 #? " # "2!# " # !#2!# 63 9 $ " 663 "" #1#3 4 26# 7 " 63 # # 766? "> 63 9 9 " ! " " " 63 4 "" # # " ! " "# " '#63 " ? > # 4 44>" # "" # " >9 9 (? 2 44 7 2!## " # " !#7 4#2 7 2 44"> "4##!#"> # 5 :+2 2 > # " 6 ""> 6> # B *C< + ( 7 ? 2 2 > # " 7 #1#3 7 # "2!# # # !#2!#63 >1"># 2!# !#2!## #" 5 2 ? # # 4 !#2!# ? !4#5 :" ?" 7 ' 26 7 4!2 14 # "">9 ( 4 2 4 " > " 663 4!6#4 " 4! 7 9 + ( 5 :? 2 2 > # " 7 7 # !#2!# 63 # # "2!#63 >1"> # 7 # " 7 ? > # 66? ">7 >65 6 49 ( ? > # 7 # " !6 4 # 7 # 1 3 644 65 :+2 2 > # " 6 ""> 6> # B *C " ? 66" #5 4 5 9 ( 4 #? 2 44 7 2!## " 2 7 7 ' 26 " 6 ""> #5 4 ! "> "3 2 49 ( " 1 6 # " #5 4 4!4 "63 "# 7 ? ? 3 2!## " 7 !#2!# #1#3 " # 4# # # ) 2 7 " 9 (32 663 # 6 ""> 44 4 # "! 5 7 6 ""> # # " 2 4 " 44 " # 4 54 1 # ## 1 6 # " 4 " ! 5 7 > ? ">!2 > " 4 66!4# # " >9%9 " # 4##4# 6 44+ 1 6 # " 7 ? : # 42 44 4 2 # >1 " "! 5 7# 4 " # 6 ""> " 1 6 # " 4#4 4" " 63 663 " 662 4456 6 ""> " 1 6 # "4#4 5# " 7 # ##64# 7 ' 26 # 42 46 " # 2 7 " 7 # " #? : 4 2!# 4 " 1 > 7 66 4! 2 7 " 49 8 1 6 "# " 6 2 # 4 9>9 6 ""> # " # #! 6 # 4# 4 9>9 "! 5 7 " 63 4 7# " #? : 1 # 5 42 7 9 ( '4# 41 6 ! 4# 4# '26 # 4 "4 "4 " # " #? : ? >1 4 # 5 4#> " 6 # " 9 9 # 4 664# 1 6 # " 4 46 # 4 # 7" 6 " #? :9 $ % < )6 ""> !1 9
' (
' #) ( 4 '2 "#!4 " 46 2"> # "> 7 %* 3 4 6 6 !6#9 ( 44!5@ #? 4 44 # # 4 1 J !" # " 6 '26 # "4 7 # 1 !4 834# K " # 8 6!6 42#6 " (!"4 7 # 4!42 " 746 2 4 9 ( 14! 6 " 6344 4? 66 4# 2 # ?"!24 ? # ##4 6#32 # "#9 ' ! ( 2 34 6> 64>" 64 66 # " # 4!5@ # 267 76# ># 4 26">7 D! " 3 7 ,/ " 7" 663 " 4: " 7 # 2# # 46 2 2 63> 2 3 B .C9 ( 4 2 63> 2 3 "# "441 64>" 64 ">? # '2 #: 24 7 4 " 6344 #? $ " $ " " $ >9- 9 ( #? $ 1 # "4 !4 # "# + # 2 6&%+ 67#+ > # " # "# +# 2 6&-+ > #+67# 5 6 6" 4 " >9 9 ! "> # 14! 6 " 6344# '2 #5 44 4 >" 442 63 "# 7 4# 1 # " 7 $9 ( 4 2673 ! ? : ? ? 66 2## 4 1 # " 44">6 " # 7 !# # 6447 # "9 ( ( 56 2 4"#4# # 64 7# "> !# 4 ? 66 4 # 4#! #! # " " 46 2 4#> 4? # # "! 5 7 2 4 # ! # " # 2 "#> 2 # # ( #6( 786 2 F((8 " # 2 "#> 2 # # ( #6( 7 "> F(( 9 ( ((8 2 4"#4 # ! !6# ! # " 74#> 4 % " - " # "# # ! # " 7 # 46 29 ( 4 1 6! 4 5# " 766? "> # 14! 6 " 63442 %.4 2 4 !#53 " '2 #9 A >1 4 " # " 6 "7 # "# # # 61 6! 4 7# 2 "#> 4 7 # 4#> 4 2 # # ((8 F(0+((8 B%C9 2 4 F((8 F(0+((8 F(( ? : /G +++ +++ / 8#> ,- , L . , 8#> %-G %- M,. % 8#> % .G . M . . 8#> - * / M . / %% . # , 1 "# - +++ +++ ((8 .%% (( -" # < 8#> 2 4# "9$ '< 4 26 4 "4 ? ">2 34 6> 64>" 64!4 7 # 14! 6 " 63449 ( 14! 6 " 6344 4 !#2 %.4 2 4 ? 3 6 - 4 264 7 ! ">9 ( 4# 5!# " 7# 4 2 4 "46 24#> 4 4>1 " " # ( 56 9 ( 6# 46 # $ 4>" 6 " # 5!6 ! #5 4 ? 2 4766?4 >9, < + ( 4>" 6 4 !#2 %.42 4 42 " "># # 14! 6 " 6344 2 4H + 2 # " 7 # 4>" 6? 6!6# # 42 # 6 2 ? 53 # (9 " # 5# " 42 #! ? : 2 "63# 7 D! " 4 " 6! " # "# 1 6C.9, % C9 ( 4 "# 1 6 42 " 4 # # 7 6 71 # " 7# 2 34 6> 6? 1 4 6? # "% ? 6 6 " #"># "#"! !4 2 " "# 64 # . 7 D! " 3H + ( 42 #! 4 4!5 1 " 71 2 #4 42 " "> # # 46 2 5 " 4 6# N B.9, - CH( # N C- E CH 62 N CE CH8> N C / CH " # N C / % C 9 5 " ? 6!6# #4 6#1 42 # 62 ? 8) ? 4 D! 6# # # 7# 5 " 42 # 6 2 ? 8) 53# ##642 # 62 ? (8) 9 66# 7!" # " 6# 4 " # 2 # "4" # # 2 34 6> 64>" 64 " 6344 " # 6"> !#53 4 7#? ? ? 1 62 7 # 4 77 #9 ( !4 %.4 2 ? 665 2 4"# " ! #5 4 53# 71 1 6! 4 7# 8)# ? ? 44 # 65 6 2 4"#"> # 46 2 4#> 9 " # 4 @ 2 > < ##2<==???96 97=M: : "=@ 9 # 6 #5 4 ? " # "#> # # 2 4 4 4 1 "# "4 "># 6? "! 5 " # 2 2 #" " ! 4#! 39 " 663 ! 2!4 ? 665 2 4 ? # .. 4 264 4# 5!# "# , 46 2 4#> 4 " # ? : 9 $ * < $ 42 # 6 6">9
* +
* + ( '2 "#? 4 !#!4"> !6#+ 3 ) 2# " ) 9 ( "! 5 7 "2!#" ! "4 7# !4 47' # , 42 " "># # , 1 6! 4 7# 8) 6!6# "# $ 1 # " D! # " 9 ( "! 5 7 !#2!#" ! "4 4 7' # / " ! " 7 46 2 4#> " # " # # ? : 9( "! 5 7# " " ! "4 4 5# " 7# 4#! 3 7 41 6 "7>! # "4 ! "> # # ""> 2 449 ( 5 4#4! 44 # 5# " "> # 1 !4 "7>! # "4 #4# 4 G/F9 ( 4 # 4 5# " ? # " 2 4 53, "2!#" ! "4 / " ! "4 " # " 63 " / !#2!#" ! "49 8 !6# "4 !#53 441 6 # " "#" " 46 # 4#49 ( "7!4 " # ' ( 56 % 4!6# 7# 2# 6" #? : 6447 # " 4 ?4# #< 9 ? : 4#> 4#> - " # 46 2 ? 66 6447 H 9 8#> 4" # >" " # 4 "63 "7!4 ? # # 46 2# "? # 4#> H %9 8#> % 4 46> #63 >" " # 4 "7!4 ? # 4#> -9 4 & % ' + ( & *, . . . , % --. / G . - .F % , . % -'. % . . %* % , % %F ' . * 0- ,*. + ( G . / . / /' --. " # %< & "7!4 " # '9 ( 4 4!6#4 64 2 ! ? # 4 77 " 4 " # "! 61 6! 4 ? # # 4 " $ 1 # " " # 4 ? # # 5" # "4 7 # #? $ 1 # "4 . "2!# 2 # 4 , 2 # 47 1 # "9 ( 5" # " 7 # #? 1 # "4 4 " # : 4>"7 "# 2 1 "## # 61 6 7# ##64! 44? 2 4447 G/F # GGF9 * ! ( > >"# " # 74#> 4#> - " 4 '26 " 53# 7 ## ## 3 ? 66 2 4"# " # # ""> #5 4 " # 4 2 1 4 # >"# "53# "42# 7# 4 56" " # 42 # 661 6 5 #? " 4#> " 9 "42# 7# 2 2 4"## " 7# ? : 4#> #4? 66 >" 5 !4 # 2 4"#4 77 "# 42 # 6 2 4# " 4 2 # # # 4#> 4< # 62 ? 1 4 2 4"# "63 " # ? : 4#> 4 "5 4 " "( 56 9 8#> 4" # >" 5 !4 # 4# 46> #63 2 4"# "# #5 4 " # 4# 4 42 # 6 2 4# " 44#> " ? 4# ">63 2 4"# " # 4 " # "63 '26 "# 54 1 "7!4 "9 8#> % 4 "7!4 ? # 4#> - 5 !4 # 3 1 # 4 42 # 6 2 4# " 9 9 2 " " 7 # 6# ? 1 49 1 " # !6 !4 7 14! 6 6447 # " 4 5 4 " 4!5@ #1 4! 7 4 " # " 5 #? " # 4 #? 4#> 49 " # 4 4!77 "## ## 6# ? 1 4 !23 # ",.F 7# 2 ! # " # 4 # "4#> - "4# 7 4#> %9 4 " " # " ? >1 5 6? # 42 # 6 2 4# " " 46 2 5 " 4 7 4#> % " 4#> -' 264 2 4"# " ! #5 4 >9/ 9 ( 4 " "# 5!# # '26 "? 3# 4 4#> 4 "5 "7!4 7 # 3 65 6 "63 " # 5 44 7 42 # 6 2 4# "9 ( 4 66!4# # " !6 5 4263 7 # "7!4 4#> 464# 5 1 " ? !6 64 "# 5!# # 4## # # 2! 42 # 6 " 6344 4" # 4!77 "## 7!663 77 "# # 5 #? " # 4#> 4 7 46 29 $ 1 < 82 # 6 2 4# " 74#> % " - 2 4"#" # # 5 49
1
( 5@ #1 7 # 4 ? : ? 4 # 1 " ! '2 " " 2 ! "> 4 "+ :"> # 67 46 2 " 63445 4 " #7 6 ! 6 #? :49 " # 4 2 2 ? 2 4"# " 7 ! 4#24 # 5 ## !" 4#" ? ? " 2 ! " '2 #4 " 4 "9 ( 2 4"# "7>! # " >1 4 G/F # 7 > "#7 # "#7 # " 7# / 4#> 4 7 46 2 7 4# # $ "2!# #9 D!1 6"#? :4 " # 6# #! !4"> 7 6447 # " " / 6444 >1 4!6#4 ? 1 3 5 #? "/ " E.F B C9 1 " 7 "B C ? 1 '26 " # # 4> "# 4" # 6? 34 "# ## 4? "> ? "4 !4 " 4! 4 26 6447 # " 4#> 46 2 ? # !#" 4 " 1 "# # ## 4 4!6#4 "63 4 ? # 6 # 7# ( 6"> 2# " ! 4#! 3 " # 4 4!6#4 "# "7!4 "5 #? "4#> 4 D!1 6"# # # 42 # 6 61 69 " # 7 2 # 4 " = # # " 7 # 2 # 44!6#"> 7 # 6"> # "D! 4 6: # # # " 7# > 2 6+ 6 "#4 " # "#> # " 7# # 2 34 6> 64>" 64 > #5 56 # 2 1 # 5# " 4!6#49 #4? #? 4#! 3"> " "> ">? :9 A 64 #3"> # 2 463 !" 4#" ! " '2 #4 " 2 # !6 63 #44#! #! 9 " # 22 4 # # 66 !64 " # D!1 6"# 7 2 #3 2 "# 71 ? 5!# 64 7 # # 42 " # # # 3 263 ? 4 :" ?" # 77 !6#63 "#> # 4#! #! # " :" ?6 > 9 5 "> 4! #32 663 ! " # 4# 4 " " !# # " ! " 62 44">? !6 5 " '# 63 "# 4#"> 2 2 #3 # >1 # ! 2 34 6> 64>" 6 " 6344 434# 49 ( !# 4? 4 # # ": 49 O " 4 1 7J !" # " 6 '26 # "4 7# 1 !4834# K " # 8 6!6 42#6 " (!"4 7 2 !4 "# 5!# " " 444#" " # 46 # " " # #+> # ">!4 7 # 42 2 9 ( 4? :? 42 7 "# 7 ? : 7 8( & 2 @ # 7!" 53 " (!"4 " "1 4# 4 " ? # # 62 7# " > "9 B C 6' " 9 : " 9 " 67 9 " ! 9 9 #7 6 ! 6 #? :4 # '# # :" ?6 > 7 $ ! " ! # " !$%" &$' ""45! : 82 "> ..-9 B C 44# 9 P' " 2 63> 2 D! ! 4 6 " 66 9 9 ( )* * * + ,-2# E 229 **+ .E 44 " **E9 B%C 44# 9 4 Q>64 6P" 634 14! 66 " 66 9 9 ( )* * * + ,-2# E 229 E+ / 44 " **E9 B-C #4 77" 9 " 64 9 9 * . / )* * * 0 " "7 # " 8 1 = " 4 "4##!# */E9 B,C $ 66 O9 9 8#! #! ! 4 6 ! " < " 634 # # "" 66 6 # D! # 2 6>D! " " R# 9 " S#O9 9 ( * 1 , / )* )* 44 " ** 9 B/C 44# 9 P" 634 !# #D! ! 4 6 " 66 9 9 ( )* * * + ,-2# E 229 /+ %% 44 " **E9 BGC 87 9 " 0 " 89 !# # '7 + 6> * .. 46 2 4#>"> 4 ">< 2 4 " ? # 14! 6 " 6344 2 * # 3 * 0 69 % 9 % **/ 229 G+ %%9 BEC > ? 6 9 " $ # " O & 2!# + 444# 86 28#>"> !""" " 0 69 -E 9 .. 229 - + - %9 B*C ( 7# 9 " 634 "! D! ! 4 6 " 66 9 9 ( )* * * + ,-2# E 229 %%+ - 44 " **E9 B .C ) 3O9H 5 #489 " ( 44": 9 1 ? 7 2 # 66"> # "D! 4 7 $ " 6344 % 0 69 E **/ 229 + 9 B C 5 # &9 $ ! 3 O9 9 " > 9 6 # " 2 6> 2 44"> !4"> " ! 6 " #? :49 # 3 * 0 69 % 9 , .. 229 /*-+G. 9
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
B *C ! 6 # 9 9 "#" $9 9 " A 66 4 9O9 ""> "# " 6 2 4"## "4 53 ) 2 > # " " ! 6 # 9 9 &666" O9 9 " # 4 9 * 8 * 9 : * ( ) 44 *EG 229 % E+%/ 9 B .C 2 9 0 9 4 9&9 64" 9 9 " $ O9 4 26 7 # 7 ' "> 7 ># 2 63> 2 ">4 " 3 * 0 69 E ** 229 %* +%*%9
![To cite this document: Lachaud, Frédéric Multi scale analysis of composite structures behavior. (2011) [HDR].]()