Reverse Automatic Differentiation for Optimum Design: from Adjoint State Assembly to Gradient Computation
37
0
0
Texte intégral
(2) INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE. REVERSE AUTOMATIC DIFFERENTIATION FOR OPTIMUM DESIGN: FROM ADJOINT STATE ASSEMBLY TO GRADIENT COMPUTATION F. Courty — A. Dervieux — B. Koobus — L. Hascoet. N° 4363 Janvier 2002. ISSN 0249-6399. ISRN INRIA/RR--4363--FR+ENG. ` THEME 1. apport de recherche.
(3)
(4)
(5)
(6)
(7)
(8)
(9) !#"$%
(10) &'() ( * . +, -/.10 !& 2
(11) + *
(12) 314651798;:=<?>@AB4DCFEG:IHKJLEM8ON @DPQ46R,7K79S;8;TU@DVW46XQYZT\[G7KEM< ]_^a=` b1a1ceuwdgvjxzfQy a=h ija=]kMvtlnxGmo{s|~aI} pqijrsitp a=` b1a\i a=p i fk {{ZxMv p_sa v a }?^ a v}?^ a OMM$dMkG | a vM dgM { kza\i ª (xG^ vO=i =x y©xM| | $k]_ ^ « a{ lsp p | |b£v | k kz| p |¤ x a\ i²xz| M| ¡ v aI{Mvja v xMv it¬sa6 ^ a=b b v x s| i1a¢e}Ia=| li p }Ix vjb£|¬ ka=p|~¯}D¤¥®¥|§¦i | a sv $a=Gp p ^ | kza pxG|v v x aI¨a vp v x ija p ^ |~b av xkMsy©ax°| G±wpKa b1xMaI¬ p p^k x ¬ | pMa a,v r k k v aMG p£]_itrs^ ija pt a\kMb b | a\r i xz Ol{k vjx ³v kMk b£i6kzp p x a |¦ aµa ´ v a\Ma\p M| kp£pta ±²| kGr ·x ¶_a=lsiwp¸b£b1ka=Gb r | r a { a=a=¹nl kMa\Gb1p a=} Gk pj~}i£l b£ kzkp |r x iIa ° pº]_r ^{s| |~iW} k sa\ r b£| k { k i¨v b»k l a }?n^¾xn xMa={ii¨iI b1]_a=^ b a=xM1v ±r¾a ijp{xMvtv xGkz{¡Mx ait a²]_p x ^s|k iW{{sb1 r»aIp k^sx v aIi a | v i¥ija²l¡ita\|§¦ a ªv xGa=v Gp p | ^ ka p |x }µ$x b ¼ ¬{ rlsp | | ptsa v kzxzp | x p^ ½a kM y©x| Gp_itpkzpta¿kM( v k | a=Gp v a kpta=(p x p ^ a»« { p | b£k ¤ a=i | M {vjxM¬s a=bQ |~ÀF} i=ÁG°sÂ9ÊÃÄÆk ÅZ| avÇÉ©Ën p xMÌ ka=lsi=p ° x }Ib£x b kzp {|} v a= i|i ¦ |~¬sa v a a\MÈ¡p x | k±Wp °|x k °y©xMxM| { Gp p=| °sb1 k v ki ^ | a=k G{ p aa=i | G° }Ix b { lspkzp |x k ¡È l | osrskb»É. Unit´e de recherche INRIA Sophia Antipolis 2004, route des Lucioles, BP 93, 06902 Sophia Antipolis Cedex (France) T´el´ephone : +33 4 92 38 77 77 — T´el´ecopie : +33 4 92 38 77 65.
(13) .·
(14) .
(15) &.
(16) + /)
(17) + %
(18) -.· ) ( )
(19) $" . t , -/. &! .© ³ &'Q
(20) &. . !& 2 {Zx xGÁnl ¬ v
(21) v a\h i |ÁBxvq l vÊ v a x la²| i_itrsija h p }=a\` vtb1| awx ki ` y© x ls| Mp p;|| iy©kzxlp| |x {FvtxGs¬sa La=` k b1¤a|L` | ¦v a« h v {a=Gp | p b»| kzlp |b x }¤ ¢a=} i ls| pGx b1 kOp a| ¹nb lsxaWvsa=a F} | Gb M{ x a sv ita a | { Gav a b1v vIijaI` ap ° }Ix ls pjpta=a\ln m$a=$a a=i a=h { i k } l(a£¡b l,a\h b itrsxij|~p v a\aMb»Æa¨Ê kx li¨aµMm pq{sxaÆ| p b£x ki a a a¨ k k| ip¿ita¹nlsa¸aI´ x kp v a a { vtx sva=kb1b£a\b1l a a | a | p | a=k ¡{kv Ga\h p_ita\p Ma=pjai ax l i x b{¡vt¬xGv {¡a=x lni m x } kiW~}ll s a i | |§¦aa hh {v a=a=Gp | kkMp G|pjx iD a=|pwGa\ a v { ijak v p¼ |{ } k l vW| a| psv a h sv ka\pi |x ¬Zx ½Ql }µ¹n a=l i |w{ }Ixk v k i x b£a h | b1ik a ¬s¬ a=a\i=k l ¤ }Ixkl i{ } b a x} |kMiIi ° vaQkMb | a=a\h Gb p xM{Z|v x al v²w a aIpj{ptvjaFxM¬b·La\` aIh b1p ^a¥x a « a={ ijp p£| b£lskp |K| ¤ isaIha\a i | {ZMx l v1} k ~} l a v aµ´ } k } a\b»a\Gp1laIh pkzp»kM y©x| Gp»a=p1l¡ Å¡\µÃ Án |¦ v | |x x | xG{ | | |x ªxMv } | È | nlb a h vt| ¹nlsa°nÊ¥k | a v Éta hËGp a=xGGÌ p a=kzi=p°Da h }I$x l kM lsa=p b1b1a=Gkp p }µ¹nx lsb a{¡° v a\ijpi |b¬ a\iiIkz°p kM y©xs| Ga pI°s v b1k a=| i=a\°OMb·p a h k ¹nlsa¸sa=i l sa=i.
(22)
(23)
(24)
(25)
(26) "!$#%!& '(
(27) ) . . , +-/.10325476'-890+ |¢ xMy©]_x{ | p^ G| b£pKijk rn ijy©sxpta\|a=b£i | Gi k v xa6 ija=|rsx ptitp pj| sa=}µb£ex bi_bxGv x a6 vtskx a ¡|W a=b ^ xG¬ v ar { {Zu xM|k { v l p | kk 9v ¤¥kx b |§¦ x vta sxMv _a= Ga=p^ s| k xM;| v: aI¹na vlikzkp |¡x {i=v v a\< ituwa\k¤ v:}?^ > ^ a v i ± } xGvjÌG^ | s xx r ^ x aqaq} kM |v vWa }G}µp p6x|x a=¹nl xzk p p }^ ae|x ita\b1 i |a\p i | | | pºr b xz^ p p a¨^ {¡aevt« x itppkzpj}b£a_k xzk vt| k ^ G¬p a | ip sa=a a=sa\vjrÆ»| kp x=»| ? aµm ¸¬ kWa=siij^ a\a=i i;} a=p GpDavt| k |~v a p6| } p p |x kzx p pp x^ a pp ^ }µa ax iji}Ip x k Glp k vjx} p |° x ¬ ijrFp k p l^ a x|p b b {{ k ls|~}µp °;| | p s Q lpQ^ } ap p |x}µa x¾b p ^{sa a=xMlptv a£a=p bQita\° i a\p| kp | a i| pºitprpx kzxzpji ao xMpsM^ a aÆa1kijipjkkp b1pta1kMa G rk vjr¾| |k p ¬sa= a ka»vjs±| ita a\| p ,^$ itkzv rsp a=iji pt{ a=a ab£} pi xkMi¥sa p ^ | aosa\ k | b1vj| ija=a=(i |p x v kxi {Zp x ^ ijaa= }µx ijrsMitp pjvta=xMbQ a } p xGv @ | p ^ p ^ aok y©xM| GpWk {¡{vtx k }?^ °9±a1aIa= x r,p x i xM Ma | x¸} a ¬ | | {v k ^} p |} aqy©p xM^ | a uw ¤ :·| i | i }Iv aIp | ija=¸kMoi x a\ x ok }Ix b { lspja v °Mp ^ a v ak v aqpº± x kpjl v k Ë ±²<jc k> rsp ix p a vjl| Ma¥Fp ^p a¿aWkk y©x| MGp Bp uwA ¤ : k¡(p ^ a=Qp x | i }Iv aIp | ija | p=° xMv ° x ? Qp ^ a¿kM y©x| Gp x p ^ a¿ | i }=v a=p | ita\(ijpjkptaWijrnijpta\bQ < ( > p C ^ kºp ½¡{s| Di ¶_>|~lsÌ pa xGrF{ p{¡p ^ |vtx kx F Dp | << ( >>_| ¬ iea£b k xGv | a¨pj} p a\ a1kijb r xMp xv a }µk |xx | b kz{sxpj Gaaµm,< ^ ¬ p r^ k}IEv x b <tc |{ > k ±vt| i^ x a\o ± | p | p ^| ^ i¨v l | ª xG| v a v a=pj,k Ì ? a=|U¦ ¬sa i v xa\ a } ra\i } ¼ ª¬ xMr v aI m|v ka b } p |x a (p kx ¡p ^ a xG{ p | sb a=iW| ikzkMp $|x aI mkÌ a p¨v sa=a k l¡kzp p ao k a\Mp=°Kk¡$p a a a¸k k aosa=i a\Mp H l v p ^ a v ° ªxGvW¬¡x p ^BxM{ p |x i=° p ^ aosaIMa xM{ b1a=Gp | $a\s | sa=a v p | b1aob1kr ¬ a¸a\ xMv b x li= ]_^ a=Bp ^ a ^xM{ a x kM(kMlsp x b£kzp |~} |¦ a v a\Mp | kp |x | xG{ p |x I< >6| i x ;{ k v kb x lGp | b {ZxMv pjkM } aM ¤¥|¦ ]OJ a vx a\M| kp r| k i²p |¹nx lsQx a=i ijxp | x xpº± k | vi_a¨xzit kp |¡ it±p x xa v a=ikp x |l¡}¨p kz^¤¥ptaaW|§¦ |kMiijv l a | b x| {ijvj|a=xx i a¥| p p v | ^ a| pºr(}µx i |xz pº|¬sp±² |x k v aexi M| Qa=s± a ^sv k|~}?p ^|x kM ( ¢^ lsp x b1kpta\ kM(]_p ^ ^ k a Ga ªMxMroRTv S±pºR9± MVk UTv RX b WDb LYsx QZa\sRIi a }Ix ¢eb ls{ p lspjb£a=iÆkzp p ^ a {vtx a a=l G} p p kxp p Q^ aFk a¥k k}µ xMk ¬| kMk aex p k ¡{krvjx° v kMkMb»b&a p r | b1p a= ai1K9k,LM" N | OPa\M Q x | |v p a ^ } a¿p |x ijx pj,kzpjMaWa } p k xM^ vjv | °k ¬s7[\ ^saM]_x ^ ` <bp a ^ }µ>a xM[a }I¬¿x | ¢Gp {¡vj{sx ]_ r ^ ^| sk| Qi_k¸p ^ a | b1 ªxM{¡a=v xM±| i k |x v d,| c6b °x p s^s}?a | ^ ie a\ijka=xM¡v ii | pp |xF }=| }µ}pºxr b v b»{ llsijptp a1¬ p aW^ a1vja=xM ij¬ k a= li kz| ppj|a= ^ d | pºcr pl¡i b1| sa\Fip | M| saIa=pBp a1|¦ ± a v a\ a¸} a\iIk° ¬ lsp¿kM x p¥a v r,i¥itaIp´ k}µ| a=GpI°KGkMp i¨° bÆ| l k } bp=° ªxMa»v k k v lkp kz^ pja a»vekM k v a£nll¡b itp¬ a p v kMc6 ° b x x p¿ska {¡ i_{sk |~v } a k ¬s}?^s a1x itp a\x, k v Ma¸i } k a£b x sa i¿kMi¨p ^sx itaok vt| i | s | kza vjx srskb |~} i¥± ^ a\$Ê¥k | a v ÉtËGp xGÌ a\i ]_^ a v aIM} a xMv vita¨b x a >f }Ix b ]_{ ^sls| pja=v i²p ^ v a {vtx | l } p v²xz }µx p ^ a¨¬sp | v k¡|i x {Zx ijxza= F^k }µxG| ¬s| kM xz xz ^ k {vtx }µ xGv ¬sk| bp | b1a=i | pk1^ a v J,Ma a= ªxGxGo^ v Makab£| p b£p | i_k°p ^ |^a¿` <Ve g<bic a khYpjj l> \ v b£k kpjsa aQ}?i ^ k aI|?Zpj¹nl v lsita¨p1i²pk xok{{}Ix|~sb} a\kk{ p |lsx pj aWb px^ a¿p ^kMka p y©xv a=| GpIa v ijaop b a x ssaQa\i p x p p ^s| a¿i M{k vtxG¬s a=kbQl °skk ¡| i ij}Ip l¡v kz pj| aIM r È¡v x a ± | a=kMi ijxija=¾b p ¬s^ a r$v kaIa v iji a£x a|§¦ v a°Kv kMa=G p | kxMp ¬n|xy a } p xz| a p ^ al¡ }I} x p b |x {s k aI pjaoa= i k | bÆ ll kzp kz|xp |x $¢ei xziÆ pºk ±²vk a\v ija¸l ij p l | xzpj a° p ^| n| iÉ |§¦ a v a=Gp | kzp |x °p ^ aqk y©x| MpDijrsitpja=b | i | Gp vjx l } a\ | ¸k¨p v kMi { k v a=GpO±²krO¶_lspkzp6p ^ aeikb1a²p | b1a° *. m%monprq9s"t"s.
(28) . L M R9M"S R
(29) LBL(UOiUVLYR. bp£^ kMa(Mb£rFkMaIijmni p | v Mk a({lvtijxGa ¬sxa= b£itip xMk v vtkz| MijaÆaUijl ¶ }?^x p k^·i{p vj^ xMa ¬s| a= b£}Iv i1a=kMbÆita\l ijp }µx ¬ b aF{i xMaI m M| a=pº r ¬xz r p pt^ a=a1 |i x xl lsi£p k|x U·k a xG|vt} | kzp pt^ a b)^ kk¡¡ b£kM |{ l kp |x i= x ^ v v | x {{s v v |¦ v | |x x ^ x v_{ v xz ^ x ±²p ^ k a¿v ¢a1k p y©^ xpk| p¿Ma pkitiitrsitp a\ijbptka=pt¬sb aI M7a rv a\<tci i_| > p pl^ k aok °ijkMpjkzr Qpja£p aI^a=¹na\a Flkzijp paW^ |x a» liWita ka v¡a\MEbÆp l< k(ijp pe> plQ^ ijaaWp p}µ^x p |iji p a¿v pºa\l± i | } plij|kb£x k |k , a k º{sp¿k| akM} ijpaiji a=xzb 6¬sp{ vja=xaÆi ix v kb p©r É p ^ kzpqi x a\ip ^ a¿kM y©x| Gp²ijrsitpja=bQ ]_^s| | ^ {Zx| xz ^ {v xMvÌ {vjxM{Zx }Ivj|{ |x x 9^x ^ |¦ v pjp a^ v a b£v iaIxzia v ijpi6a^ p aÆb aqkx itsy©pa¿xMk| lG ip_| sa\¹G£l¡Gp kzp ^ p a|x Fp kMa a\ !xzit Fa\Gp ¢e^ pals± p x lb£ } kz p p |@B|x }¥a ¤¥k |§¦ sa a v vja=| Gijka²p |p kkW| p |a x a=Q}i kp xnx¬ p a xM ¬ pk | sa=± p ¬ rFaek {{sa r a\| M p {¡^ | ^ ^ |¦ v | |x xGxM |^ ~{ x xG{ ^ vtx | kMkMij ijy©a=x@Bb | Ga ¬spDa\it| srsb 1ijptpa\^ b(ka i v ]_a\a¸i ^ | p a\lkk p¿| pp xzv a\ a(b1p ^ k a¿| ¡kMi6a p y©a\x xG| kp G{p²kz{sp ij pjr»kBptk,a¿p ¼ijb£rsitkzpjp a=vjb | m ¬ v laI pqa= !½W x i ±xp_ px£a v;¬ |al | xGFv p p ^a va aIp vtxWx a ls| pjp a | sv kzaWp ptaei axMp x | k sls£?p mspsa\^ a= ai {Zx| GpI°¡b£k ÌM| s1p ^ a v a=i | lk kM | i ^ @Ba¿p ^ l¡i {vjxM{Zx ija¿k }µ kii xz i xM lp |x Fk xGvt| p ^ b£i_li | sokoi | b {s| ? a=UMk }µxG¬s| k ]_^| iqi | b {| ? a= ¬¡Mkvt| }Ia xMÈ ¬sr(| kk kxz rspta\ij a=aI m | ijpji | | lijp vj| k i x pº±k v aM ]_^ a¨k }I} l v k } r¸k¡oaµ´ }I| a\ } r x p ^| i_k {{vjx k }?^o| i xG{ }p |©b ·|}IËGx a=a } } b1±aIv p a ^s|x G p vjx ªx xMv l }k^ a1{{sp ^ r{ao|{si ¯|~^ } k p { ^ |aax xMv {aIxMp |a b v ^sit| aF|ijkb p xM|{xx B| aUb |p x x sap D^ a¾{vj xM^s|¬s¦ x a a=v bQa\G x p |©kz¯^ p |Ënx a } y©x(x ¨| ±w{ a k v {k v a= a ijqa=G¬sxnp xGx { l xiIv piËn^xa a ls xMp |{ x p Æ| b1 k k a=KGxG{pvt|vjp kzxM^ pj¬sba= ia=b ªxG,v xzi p xMËG a¸ a | } ks e p ^]_a_^skk|p i y©| iqxM| Gxp6sitp aWrsij± ipta\| pb ^sxp klsb pq k}µa\Gx $r b b1b£{s aIkzaIp pp vt| | m(Uijp pp ^ xGa v pk{vta1axs} kMa=ËG ia iK} p Gxh p¥p {^ kMvtaijxGij{¡xMa=x¬nb ity a\a i²} r p p | ^Maa l¡ } p |x k v kM | a=Gpwa= k lkzp |x ËGa } {v a=ija=Gpji_k a=±nlb1a vj|~} k | lijp v kzp |x i=. #%$ &('*) 0'-8 + 8,-&-890+.'7.10/10)2+ xG]_{ ^p | || i_b ij|vta ix } kzp p ||x x } | {¡iq^ vtxGaI¬s a\| x bQpt}Ia\v H;p |~x v ijp p6^ ±wa¿a s{Z|a\xGi |p }=vjvtx |~{ p l |x} a_ ? p xz^ a p }µ^ x a¿Gp | |§G¦ l a xv a=l}=Gvti6p_|~¬i it^ pjk a { { a i v xM| G{ p | |xMb M| a=ikzp ª|xMx ^sv x i {xvj xM ¬| | s a\^£b(k£ i y©]_^ x^k| {a\ a ±a Gp l a²p aq i aIpta_ijpjkM Mp6kM k r»±wa_sa\i a²k¥ kM a\Gpb1aIp 1± p kM GpI ". 35476. 8:9<;>=2?A@CB2D!;FEG@7?H9. B a=b aÆij ªpjxMk v v p_k ± k| p b ^ |kor b xz ex s a ¤ K{ vjxxM=¬sI a=a=bQi | ºp ± }µ^sx |~}?^i | ijp pj^ i a | ,È¡x i xM± | | i¿sob kx Fsa i ^ a\k { a ¬ r$| Gp^ a av ijaJ: I l xG {a vp | b a=¹n|l kzkp p ||x x i={ vjxM¶²¬ r É | G^ a v{ijv aJI }µxM| { p | b | }Ikzvjp |~|{ x £|x ±waWb1|a=_kM¬ op ^ ªkzxMp_v p ^ a ªxMv bÆl kzp {|x vj{Z| i²x p ^ kp ^ x kMx xM{ p | b| | kv p |x {vj{xMvj¬xM ¬s a=bQ° ]_¬ ^lsp ÈZpH;x | a ± b a | x s ita aQD|si¿a=ib x x sa p v kzpja ± rv }µxzx ²b aM}µ{°x aImBkk¡i¾ita\pij^i} b1a |xa=b1Ga=p i ^¾l | iW ^ k ijavj| °6k p¬s akz|p ]_^ { a¸k v Ma xG} b1a a=p ijv a r v | iW^¡avta\{sx b(|~} pj^ a= ^ | a ¡c° aIp¿kM lsp aIpWk a itpkGp¨ita p °Ok¡¾p a¸b»a\ k k p kM¾ k r,p ls p a @. KML/mNKPO.
(30)
(31)
(32)
(33)
(34) "!$#%!& '(
(35) ) h. 0.5 y= γ (x). 0 -2. | Ml v a£cZA ]_^ a¿ xI= aWb x sa O{vtxG¬s a=b. -1. 0. 1. 2. 3. 4. H. xGv : | kvjptxMa\{ i xz p ^ a»l ] {{: a v¨: ¬¡x lu*k {¡v rMvtxy Dk} vj| kzp |x ¡ie> k vjx l¡Fp ^s| i ªxMv bÆl kzp |x ^ ka ¬ aIa\¾ijpjl | a\ | kM l a=k ¶²f É ¢ef a p=<Vg cTj g§cIj xx ¢^ p }I^ }µxGa¨xG¬nv k y ¬ | i}s}µ¸|| ijpixk¿xMp± v¨^ ^sa }µ|~x }? ª^xMv sb£ a k? }| ia=b |ix p x^ 6aWxM { x,x p b£| ¬b£k k | (}µi| x ^ M|k p { vt|axM < H;p ^ | Za xM| c v >^$r°°ZkMv p ^ a { p}I}xx G± p vjx^x|}?^Qk }µJ,vtxG| vjk xMv ¬v a= i a {¡{|x iev k }µ| i lkÆ } kp | x ls^ a ijiaIb p pxnxzx a p ^ kMMb a a x | ib»p i |a=¬sp a vja |} }Ik x G p xitvjpxb£ i k l| | i¨pk il xz¬ Q ijpaIp ^pa {s a£ kb xz b
(36) <V° g ij|a=b $cT|j pt±a\ p P¬ > r( a=]Kpi ^ x a a a=\kp¥}?]p ^ < a| >} l v a M}µaGxG<Lvjaijv aIa=a i it{¡a H;x rM| ¡°Wp iqc ka > kM(p ^ a ¬Zx l¡k v r xz ± ^s|~}?^ | iqk i x a= x pta= ¬ r OaIpqli | Gp vjx l } a A A !
(37) < "# $Z>&%(' <tc > < *)_>,+%(' < -)_> ]/. <10D< )_> % 0 e 32-435 e > 76"8 ±x ^ p a ^ v a9a 0D| <s)_a { >9a\| iKsp a=^ Ga p²{¡ v k a\vjij| ik l ¬sv aa=i xz( aQ) kM ° <Lp \ ^ °skkp | i ?r 0 f e <3) 2-4*$5 e %Wk {f hrv < a=):i }Ivj|~; ¬ a\): < {>>v = a=) iij
(38) l >/v aq> ° M)#a=sa ¬ v a k | s r¥k}µx bl { } lsp pt|xa\ vjx bk {¡v a\i }=vt|~¬ a\(i ^ k { aM ]_^ a xG{ p | b | kzp |x {vjxM¬ a\b p xo¬ a¿i xM Ma= | i_± vj| ptpta\;A H;| ¡ A@ | ? il }?^ p ^ kBp < A@ > ] "b CED"| F#G < > < ( > ± |p ^ < > ] < -) < >> <L > kM(± ^ a v a ) < >D| i_p ^ a¿i x lsp |x xz p ^ a¿ijpjkptaWa=¹nlkp |x v a kpta\ p x p ^ a }µx Gp vjx ki ªxMx ±qTi A H < *) < > > ] < > ± ^ ava H < *)_> ] IKJ < )_> ; IML < )_> ; ¶ x l¡k v r }µx | p |x i <h > a \ I. m%monprq9s"t"s. I.
(39) . L M R9M"S R
(40) LBL(UOiUVLYR. | Q± ^s|~}?^ A.
(41) ] .
(42)
(43) ; < )_> ] ) )_> <L > J < ] 5 L. ;5 ^ v | ^ | ^ xs}µ| }Ix {¡x ªxx | ^ x a\sa v± rMa ° a p ^ a i»{vp a=iaFil sv a=a¥¡i | pºra\° ¬ raIpA p a(Ma pºr b sa=Gpi ± sla*kM \ ° p a(p pk < > ] 0D< )_> ] < % c > g % c < ; > j ± ^ a v a | iWc f Z ! #" "%$'& ( &)" 354 3. D!?. ?. 2=2B ;. ;| Gl v a A Ê xMI= aWb1a=i ^ ± | p ^ 1a v p |} a=i ]_^ a£b1
(44) a=i ^,
(45) >D| i¥xz b£kM^ sa }Ixx p vj| kMs a=}i= |x ºp¨itpxk =v Ipji vtx b%x k v xGv | p ^sx x ? k p vj| ¬ kMsMl kp |x F± | p ^¾}IxnxMv | É ¡kzpta\i=< a \ p a ijpjkMMptÉ ija p ( a¥Ma b»a=p r aDa sa\ r d] cM HZxMv kGrÆ*, + | Ma=*- + }µx Gp vjx < * . ] c 0/l> °M±aesa vt| ak¿b1a=i ^¸x ¸k¿k }I}IxMv |x nÉ |~Ì a_b x sa< H;| ¡ (> °Gp ^ kzp | i ¬ r(i | | s£a v p |} a=i²k x s£Ma v p |~} k 9| a=iBA 1 .3254 c TfTfBf /56" \ *8 7:9 ] *:; 1 254 c BfTfBf / ` 6 \ *, + ]=< + \ *8 7>9 ; <jc % < + > \ *
(46) <@? > ^{Zaxv| a / | | i»p^ ^ a,nl|~b v ¬ } a v1|x xz ¥{¡xM| Gpji | | a |~x v a } p |x vj| ¬s| · p { ^ a v | Gpta v kv { g }µ | j ° | / ` | i1^ p ^ a,v nl|} b ¬ a v»x x ©$| ijppGvj^ pj|a£i¬ lsijpa=|¹nx p lsa a °K\ ±wa v aa {p v a=ij a=°Gp kM¬ rU< p +^ a£i»akU} p xGBv sÉA k xz k | ab»a\k i |kx b1D aIC pja <Ei C a r /F/ U` p> p a(^ a a }µxnp xGv k | kptsa=ai x}Ix p ^ vja¿xb1{ a=i v ^ ]_^ aWv b1a=i ^(}IxGxGv | kpta\i A k v a¥p ^ liqsa ? sa\ ¬ 5r <E? > ki_kM ] aIm {s|~}µ| p l } p |x xz p ^ a Gp k kMb1aIpta ]Ox |x | i }Iv v aI p || a»p ^x a È lnm | ¬ k k } a H} ° ±> a1k {{s r¾k(a v ptaIm } a\Mpja v a=$l { ± | ? | ptaIÉ x lb1a ªxGv É b»l @Bkzp a¿sFa=< x a ptar ¬Hr GD(< b1> a\p ^ a¿kMFita=p lxzk x a sa=i i < ] a v p |} a=i > p ^ kzpqk v a¨sa | ^G¬ZxMv i xz Z° ¬ r p ^ a } a ¬Zx l¡k v r£kii xs}µ| kzpja=1± | p ^ x sa Z° ¬ r IJI +LK ] I#I +NM IJI K ° ¬ r '% cp ^ a x lpº±k v {Zx| MI#p | I + » xGv b£k H. KML/mNKPO.
(47) .
(48)
(49)
(50)
(51) "!$#%!& '(
(52) ) . Ma } p xMv p x IJI + k ¬ r '% +LK ] . '% c 6 8 @Ba xM¬ pk | Qp ^ a ? | pjaµÉ x lb1a ªxMv bÆl kzp |x ;A . A. +LK K0+ +LK < A. ¬¡x lk v r }µx ¡ | p |x i < > K + ]_^ a l } p |x H sa { a=¡i x ijpjkpta¸ k vj| k ¬s a ) p ^vjx ls ^ p ^ aopº± 7x ?Zv itpW k vj| k ¬s a=i ) k¡ ) K0+ xz p ^ a¨a a=b1a=Gpjk v r | Gpta v É } a ZÈ lnm kM a { a=i x op ^ a¨b1a\i ^(}µxnxMv | kzpja A p ^vtx ls+L K ^ p ^ a | G}Ipt}Ia=xM v v kz| pta\ x xGv b£k i '% v +LK <J A > ]_^ a )| +LK kM ) K0+ k v a x | svja=| k v aImsp v k |{Zx x kzp |x ¡| i vjx b ] } a ¤ i ¸| kM| v xk ]_kF^ ¢ ¸¬{ pkM| k1 kMpº| r { Ka |a=}a k ¼ ¬ a¿®¨k Ë {{sv O| ½a\È sxGa=v kMiI° x| aµp=ms ^ pja=sa\,p vp È kMsMl {k| p | iqkMi ^s|~ }?^¿g | j |§¦ v b| ¬spt a > i a²l ± s Wa a=b1a\Mpk r lnm ip a k Ka=a lnmÆi ptp sC < ± i a a=Gp k a @Ba } kM p ^ a= xM¬ pjk | (p ^ a¿ijpjkptaWi xM lp |x | pja v kzp | a r vjx bk | sa=k vt| ita\ | b {s|~}µ| p_p | b1a¿ks kM }µ| s A C ; H ` < ) > )
(53) ] % H < ) > <jc > C± x l | iD p ^ ¬ aqa }µ x | kzb» aWx k£k Ê b£aI±_kpixi6 b1| kptpa vjv | kmp °|x kM 1 ªxM± v ^ i a=x1 p | s^ a_p H | b1< )_aeit> pja] { vtx ±qi | ? | pta rM°G¢ xMvj| p ^ b <jc > }Ix s]_a ^ |x©a¨Mija=pta=n^skMl |~|}?s° ^ a¿±wv a¿k l}µijxM a¿¬| p kM ^ vj aÆx H i | ` b < ^) {s| ? >Da=|i_} k¼i ^s{ ||k¦ p ^ | v k it p r xM| v ?Zkzv M|ijx ap©É b£xMxzv kzs p a vtv^ | ½¸m Mk? kv }µ xG|¬sxMi_| v k Qx p_v b1lkij}=p a=} vj | m v | (p
(54) ^ È xza }Ip x ^ ¬ b a»{ itlspkzpj}aptav a\± ¹n^l|kz}?^p l¸ija=± i }µx ijpjka=iGl p p} i a kb lp a=i a¨| aµmitpjk a=kMpw x Oa | a\Ga=kp v²kzp| Gpta vj{Zxp kzpja a= x ijsp©É a\Ti A sa k l kzpja lnm k k a H
(55) < A -) > + ] < ) + *) K '% +LK < A > > ; ¬Zx l¡k v r }µx | p |x i f <jcc > KC + ]_^ a | sa=k vt| ita\ | b {s|}I| pqp | b1a¿kMs k }I| s1p ^ a=Q± vt| pta\Ti A <jc ( >
(56) ] < H
(57) > ` < ) ;>
(58) )
(59) ] ) % C ;
(60) H < -) >f <jc= > @Ba v a a v p x g j ªxMv k v a } a=Gp²saIpk | a\ sa\i }=vt|~{ p |x xz p ^ a ?Zv itptÉ xGv a v k }µxM¬| kM
(61) w« { a v kp xMv
(62) } {¡v }µx | |x v ]_^ Ì x¸| | | x x | } {vtxG{ v | ^ {¡v }µx | pk |x p iq| sk¸iqk itrsijpta=a bdA ¡ p sa kM i_p C pji¹nlki ɺ kz k b ¡k a a p a\iI°¡p a a ¡ É <jcI > ] ! ;
(63) | i6a\ki | rÆ| i vjx| a=| »± v | p ^£|x }µx > b {]_ ^a=pta {xMv v6{}µx k v p | |k |x }µx Gv¥a v v | a\ } xa± | p ^ |~kWv } k }µxG¬s||s| ^Gpja ¬Zv xMkzv p |x {3 {< vj| x5 g| j °M±|a_x k {{s r pkF^ b»a_itl p xMp v É kz Ma xz 9pt| a pji6k p x n É kM | i ^sa | s¥aa=Gp vj| a\i p | i6sk a ¦ xGv a k a=¬si a B]_kF^| i v a=a il p¿ pjsi a | » k¨i x lsk p |x 1itm p v b£kptkza=p rW¾li k| ¡s H < *) >. +. ]. < ) -) '%. C
(64). >> ;. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
(65) . . . . . . . . . "!. . # . . . m%monprq9s"t"s. . $%. &. .
(66) ?. L M R9M"S R
(67) LBL(UOiUVLYR. k]_^v a=| i kMi }Ix x b k {s¬s aIa¨pta\b»i_a\p b ^ xMa¿v sroa=iti p}IxMvj|v { kzp |a¨x k¡xz( p b»^ la }?È¡^ x ±b xGi vxMa¨ MaIa ´ v }I| a\Gpp ^ kzpqkMQaµm {s|}I| p x a @Ba }µx i | sa v x ±k Q UTMR RL WC YO L ML R9W ± | p ^ /&v a=k { k v kb1a=pta v iBA . . GA . . < > %(' > +%(' < % > < % ,. 7. A . 7. . %(' +%('. ± ^ a v aW p ^ a1/F / | b1`L a\i |x x p ^ aÆijpjkpta¿ k vt| k ¬s a | i ªx l v p | b1a=iep ^ aÆnlb ¬ a vqx x a=i< ] a v p |} a=i > ] ]_^ a¿ | i }Iv aIpja¥ k vt| kGp xz < (>D| i²± vj| pjpta=,A H;| ¡ A@ | Qk£il ¬ ijaIp xz 7 ijl }?^ p ^ kzpB< A@ > ] b | < >f <jcYh > CEDEFG ± | p ^ kMk | ; A < > ] < -) < >> <jc= > ± ^ a v a ) < >D| i²p ^ a¿i xM lsp |x x p ^ a¿ijpjkzpja¨a=¹nlkzp |x ; A H < *) < > > ] <jc > | Gp vj@Bx a l }xMaW¬ itkMa (v MkMa1 y©p x^ | kzGpÆpq±witpa kzpt} aMk°¯kk F{¡{sk rBx ±qk i}?^ p xk | ± vtv | lptaW a p ^ ªxG3a v L p ^ a( WG O |§¦ MaGv a=UGip U| k R9p W|x kMi xz ªxZ°Ox ±±q^Bi A |}?^ a=kMiWp x H < *)_> ] <Lijpjkzpja >
(68) . . . . H < I ) < -)_>> e I . . . . ` < > ] I < -)_> % I. . . I H < -)_> I. I ) < -)_> I<. ]. ]. . Lk y©x| Mpqijpjkpta >. jc ?. < >. xM{ p | b£k | pºr > ^s| |~i¨}¨it¤¥rsij|§¦ pta=bQv °9±| a ^s|x | ^| ^ pta\{s ª|x l v aI| m {¡v \a ij} i | x i ¬ a } klijaÆp ^ aIr,± |;¬ a1aI k lkzpja=¾p ^vjx ls ^ © ¾ p x ¢lsp b£kzp a a=Gp kzp °ki²aIm k a= UËGa 6 . <. KML/mNKPO.
(69)
(70)
(71)
(72)
(73) "!$#%!& '(
(74) ) . © | p | k | kzp |x ;A @ 7-) . . . @. Ë xM l) p |x
(75) xz itpkzptaWa\< ¹nlkz> p |x ;A ]. . x b { lpjkzp |x xz 9 < ÊeaI± b1a=i ^. . & . . . . . -)
(76) Y> ]/. . . <0 .
(77) %. 0 e 32-435 e > 76 . . < ªxGx vb p { ^l| i=pjkz°p i |xMx Ma¨xzp ^ p a ^ aWÇ Iv Åk | a\oMpIÂ xz= =Á A E ` > < . .
(78) . H . k ita. .
(79) ]. . . >. . % ` < ; >. ] a=ijpTA
(80) 9% ]Ov lsa : . . . . . | Ml v aWrA ¤ a\i }=vt|~{ p |x xz p ^ a,¼jk y©x| Mp_k xMvj| p ^ b£½ H. 354. . B. "% #$ " (& " 9. . 7;. . . . D. $ &)" =. ?. ª ©xG v H;i | x¡xG {s | | |si6 sap ^ ^{sa|} ptxzxMa\ { »p |p b ^ va | }µk}Ix p x |x ij pj{ kG{p6vj| xMij¬pta a\{ b ^ v <jkMcY v h | a\> G| p]_b1^ aIap ^svx a=£ijp ± xz| p ^ p k^ a y©xM{ | Gk pI{ °Ma kv i6aµk mvka b a | vsa=a= i } a_p ^ k aB ±xMvjk| r p ^ |b aIa s»p a¿i pº±²k a b lsp s¸p aW k a\Mp ` . m%monprq9s"t"s.
(81) c. L M R9M"S R
(82) LBL(UOiUVLYR. + 8+ 7 ' .10)2 &-8T0C+. . )C). # ). *. . 0 21) 0. 4-/0+ & -8T6. 8 ) . ) +D-8 . Gx¢{ lsp p | xb b£x | kzkzp^ p |~|}1x vxMv } {¡¢ vtxG ¬s xM a\vjb£x| p ^iIx b @Bv|}»a {¤^v |a ¦ a a v v a=p G^ p a | kz| p G|ptx a Ev a=< ij¢¿pta\ ¤ v >qa\k| i¨sa v aIpjp p x | sp ,^ a b xMkvpta£a\itkMp }IBxb a } xGp v |a1x ± xz| s a k r¾v p |~l}µij a=a=iC g | Z j kM(¢Æp ¤ p { a a v ab a=| pjGi¥p_ b |§¦ a v a=Gp k| kp |x r5 g hixj ML PMOWCU ¥¶²rFp ^ kpI° ±wa1b»a\k,p ^ kzp¥kU¢Æ ¤ 9p xnx pjk Ì a\ieki | x { lp k¿i x } l |vjx } a {vjx v kb >:< 2 pºr {s |~} k ]_r ^ |
(83) ¤ xnx > p ^ kzpIv °n | Ma=okM¸k v Mx lb1vj} a=Gpa 2? 7 ° >_}Ix{bvjx { lsv pja=i pi¢Æ^ b1kz¤ p=a °;°O k l¡| }= }µa=xG p v p |^ sa(Q\k p] v x G^l± b1< ^sa a=|~}?G^ p aKa ° vj}I| x kzb p | { Ma»lsa=pji¨¢Æa=ki» v ia xZ}µb»p x a(b s{ Mala=vjpt|sa= a kp k| pt©a\¾a=iqi p koxz^ a sa=^ ª±x i]_x ± ^ l |a sv Za Ga °k <±w
(84) v aoa£ij± aI|M1a v ? k v ijp WG{LYvQZa\R9itU a\kGxb p p ^ a K9LM"N OPMQ WGLBQ RL K L N IN RGN U (LPN RK QZOWGR O U L K (R N RGN MR9U9R (RWDLPMRGVLPW R v aIMa v ita²b x a°± ^|}?^»| i;± ^ kzp6±a²aIa=»p x¿}Ix b { lspja_k y©xM| Gpji= H| k r° ±| b a¨{± vjx | a=i b1^sxa\M± p ^s} xkM± ¬ p ^sa¿| iklv aIp xb£a v kija¨pta=b x sa } k ¬ aW kijp r | b {vtx Ma= | Fk£i { a }I| ? }¥} kija°kM ^x ± p ^| i . . . . . . . . . . D$. " $N" 0 )( &)" $ " (& ]_v ^ a xz ¢Æ ¤ {|vtv x } l |} x a=i¥kFQ} MxGR v L 2 O Q 7R9M S}IO x SiRI{ ° | aMWk ^ {vjx |~v v kM} b/|x p ^ kz pI° vt| M| a=,| kM 7 2 k Glb1a=Gp ]_^s| ieb x kMsa | i_k¯i x b1aIa p | p b1a=³i v a a a p vjv a=([a p x kMi²p ^ a3° Q Mb R lsWDpja=LYi¸QZpRI aU a p k sa kzp Ma l¡^ } p l| |x {siIkM b»ua\v Ga pj}µk | it a r °ZrM ¢Æ°zk G¤ } r |x{| svja\x M p v | kM?| b a=i 0 }I}?x ^ }Ib x b { ^ ls{Zpjx a ijvqa={vjxzx k¨v kMitb£a\¹Gil± a=| p } ^ a k xz 9}I| x b ijp {¡v lx i} | p p ||x x i xz K b£.)kz2 p ^ g§a=c b£f f kzjZp k|} ¡k p kzp b a=b1a=Gpjiek l¡ p ^ ° iqil p kp ^] ^ + * ^
(85) * fTfBf * ^
(86) ± ^ a H v vta¥x a\b k }?p ^ ^ a ^ K }?^ | i²k | p ^ aWv l a aa=°b1kMa=G pk ± v vjr | p | ls } p |x ªxMv| b p ^{sa¿ a=b1sa a\vjM| pjka=p | ¬ aDr < | Mk ij}Ip xMv l¬s}| kp (|x b£kzK p vj | m >Dx °s±aWa=pTA ^` ^ ! ?#" ;FD K9LM"N OPMQ7WGLBQ R Da > G[\ ] ^` < a [a H -476. %D =. 9<;-= ?;%$ 8'&. . ;F9. (?AD!?. . 7;. . . !. ^` <ba >. [a
(87). ]. . < ^` * ^ * ^ * Tf fBf * ^ <ba >> f < ^`
(88) * !^
(89) * ! fBfT f * ^
(90) < a > >
(91) f=fTfTf ! ! f < ^
(92) ` < a > > f. jc. < >. ]OxÆ}µx b >{ >sl f pta D[\ ^ ] ^}I` x <ba > {;[a °Gp ^ a ªxMv ±k v £b x sae> >sf a=a=iwp x»}µx x1b x { lptaep |^ ab£kp vj| m 6a } p xMv6{vjx l } p ] < ^
(93) ` <ba [a °¡p \a b lspja$[a ] < ^ ` * ^
(94) <ba [a
(95) °kFi (l¡Mp. . . [\ ] [a ] < ^ ` * ^.
(96) * ^. . . * fTfTf * ^
(97) <ba > >f [a
(98) f ! ^
(99) <a > ^ * fBfTf * ^
(100) <ba >. p ^ a ±w?Za v xMitp ¬ ij| a vijp va(l p} ^ p |kx pC a xz | i10£p °Z^ kMa FxMvjb| xG| v ka¨ Mk a=vsMa lv b1k a=roGp=p °D^ kzp ^p a\ ¿| i1p ^ a| | i_Gptp a^ v a b1| Ga=pja | kzv b»pja(a\ k| kz lsptaWaF k k pjlsa av k pta v aµmsa } lsp |x x K °¡±aÆijaIaWp ^ kzpqp ^ aÆk ¬¡x Ma {vtxs} a=ii K v a\¹Gl |v a=i_p ^ a | Gpta v b1a= | kzpjaW k lsa=i xz p ^ a !. !. KML/mNKPO.
(101) cMc.
(102)
(103)
(104)
(105) "!$#%!& '(
(106) ) . aI| iemsaijp} vlk p | | x ^ p ªxzxM v 0±k | v (p p ^ xoaD| bUTO{sWG a=RCb1LPa=MGQZpIRT° M ¬ | Qr ±| G^spta|~}?vt^ a=kp ^ aI| sr( k | v pea ± }Ix| p b ^ { p ls^ pja a=xGvt¬| r | 0£k aµ]_ms^ a a } v lsa p ª|xGx v a¥xp ^ | 0£i {¡vt]_xs^ } a\l¡ijiIi ° p| ^ ija p v ªlxGv} ±²p |kx v , |¦k£a sv a\a Gvt| p | kzkzpp ||Mx a | xz ijp 0 v l |} ip |k x {vt[ x pv ^kbkp 0£| b[ ° {sxG ¬a=b1pjk a=| Ga=pji ^ vj` x b 0 ¬ r | ija v p | s ¬ a ªxMv aÆa=k }?^ ]_> ^ a ªxMv ±^ k K v x1b^ x v²s^ a }Ix b { ^ lspja=ik y©x|| sa=k v^ K }Ix b ¬| kp |x ^ xzv p | ^ a VL | W vU}µx x p¬s^ | a¨k |x }µxM¬xz| kM»^ b£kzp vt| m x}I^x ` < ^a ` <bwa «¥> xz]K p xoa }Ix b p> { a ls^pjaÆ|}?kM^£p ^v | i°npk |~a¨y©v xMk| G pqvj±x M| pp ^ p p / kz^ pa ±w ªxGa¨v } s±²aIk a\|v x Fb a xzx a saM^ i²°Zk± ªxMaWv sp a\^ k lv i¥sa=b |§a=¦ Fv px(kzp }µ| x b { l{ptp a¿vjx a p ^ v a / R9U ]_^l| i b£} ki ¬ a¿^¹n` < l a | pt°Ma¨± aµm { a=i a=| ¹na l ªxMa\v²i; k v ia¥i r k lsa=aµi msxa N ls/ p ]_i ^ Da Mp R9Sa RTMVU9RX±WGk LBQ»R | i_k1a ±²a=Gkp r¸kp ptx a= i x a¨ p ^ kMkbQpI . . . . " $N" 0 )(. ! ? ?F?AD ?9<;-= ?;%$ 8'& ;F9 IMR9SR9MVUTRlWDLYQZR PMOZQ R a \ e ^` e < a >f \ \ ? ^ 3OZQTL 'WGLBQ R H : F< > -4. 3. (?ND ?. &)"% $ "% (& ;. ]_^ 2 a 7 xz ¢Æ} xG¤ v {vj2x l } a=i¸}Ik x { L°^ | a{ vjx k {} vjx v kMf bp ^> kpI°^s |~}?| ^Ua=|*k* x k v Ml¡b» a\Gx p | p ^ ° aop ^ p kzv kMp¨si ak{Z¡x Uija=a=ki¥kox si aµ} Ék ka vp }µx b ¾{Z«¥x si a| pja } kMv °a=ilp ^s b pI| ° Ì$xzls pjxza=± i^sp |~}?k^ a i¿±k,a ±}µax l | b p^ { p \ls| septa»,^ p`bM<^ aa a1} p° xMv± v¿k x | a\M\ p=°Oi¨p ]_k ^ ^sa i | iv a=a=b i¹nl lx kspji a p x| i i x b1 a=vtp x | b»b a\i ¹nv a l ka pv|v x a\ otp cx ki²kp^ Fa k pja v p v kMi {Zx µi | p |x (±wa xM¬ pjk | ;A ^` e < a > f \ ]. < ^` e < a > > f < ^
(107) ` e * ^
(108) < a > > f fBfTf f < ^` e * ^
(109) * ^ f\ f !. . !. * fBfTf * ^
(110) < a > >. z. < >. ]OxB}Ix { >f ¬ } vt| } xGvÆ{vjx } v x }?^ }?^ { v ^ b£kp vj| m Db£b kzp lsvt| pjm a {^vj`x e ¡< a l } p\ iI°°skp ^¡a v =a aa kMv ijla¥ija(b b£x skzaWp ijm pjk 6v pji²a p pxo}µx b { lslpta pi£k a(i bÆl a\k a p kM.
(111) * ^ * fBfTf * ^
(112) < a > >f \ \
(113) ] < ^ ` e
(114) * ^ * fBfTf * ^
(115) < a > >f \ . \ ] < ^ `e * ^. p ^ a= | p }µx b { lspta\i kMQ]_i ^sx£| iwx Qp | b»lGaMp °n|±w ^a ` xMe < ¬ a ij>a f v \Ga_] p \^
(116) kzpw] p ^s< ^| i
(117) ` e {¡<bavtxs> }>a\f \ iji v a\¹nl |v a=ip ^ a | Gpja v b»a\ | kzpta k lsa=i xz p ^ aeaµmsa } lsp |x x }?0 ^ | |»p ^ v (a Si|RTMVUTRLPMQZ RTM xz ^ p ^ a |vv }µx b |~v{ lpjkzp |]_x ^s| ¬ r | 0£{s6«¥| a_v ±{ kr¿p x¿^ k}I¡x a_{ p ^s| i || x iDp x¿xv a }µx b }?^ { lspta a\| l¡k } v p |x Gpta°D| ± b1^sa=|~ }?v ^¯kzpj| aUi» aImk { lsa\a¾i^ ± | a a= | v a=}µx¹n}µxbl { a\{lpjkzp |x xi b x Gx¯a a\v i vija arvj|°6a=kk ptx a=p ^ ^ a v b ±²k^ r lsp| kzi1p v p x i itp|v xMv a a=k¬k p ^^^ Ka v ªGx aIptMa a v b1ita ¬a=| kijp ptv a l } a\p |ijx^ l pi=i1 ]_kMi£^sx | p i |a=i²r aµmk { a a=i | ba | lQpta=b1 a=°b i xMv kroi1i { p k } aMaI p ]_aI^ a aQv a p | i²a=kb ± xM{ p a=| b£k a\ ¹Gp lv kMsa=a x¦ r·p x¸p ¬ aa l]_ ^ a aIv pºaI±MaIa a=v it(a¥p b a=x ijaWa pºxz± p ±²^ a¿krn¢¿i= ¤ p xnx % ! | b {s a=b1a\Mpi x a¨il }?^ p v ksa xz¦ ]_^ a v a=a v ija |§¦ a v a=Gp | kzpja= {vtx v kb v l¡i v a } l v i | a r x | pji } k p v a=a : k }?^ il ¬vjx lsp | sa | i²k k | k ¬s a ¬Zx p ^(| !. . m%monprq9s"t"s. !. !. !. !.
(118) c. L M R9M"S R
(119) LBL(UOiUVLYR. || pji |§^ ¦ a v a=Gp | | kptvta=x ª|xGv b | k| | pj|i ¦ xGvtv | | | k n ªxMv b( ªxMv ]_^ aq ||¦ a v a=|§¦Gp | v kzpja=1| aµmsa } ls ªxGp v |x | ik }?}?^ ^s| a=|¦a\v ¬ r | } k É vjsx^ »lp p | sa¥aQb1ijpjk | k v pi v ¬ lsr¯p saI| mna a } lsp pj| i²vj| $ ¬sp ^ a a a\xMG¤ vjp | kzvt| pt|a\k w| ^s|ijbQp v l x ©} p} |x p iwi= °D± a | p ^a=GkMp kz pja=| p |x k bQ it°n}?p a=^oxMk v } kza | xa ijp a\v lMp} ¬p kvj|xptx a\ i pp | kza p} ijk kM ia | pjMipja x b1nɺa= |¦ kzapjaev a\ Mk p | kk pta\»a=i=Ma v i |l x s »]_p ^s| i i² ªxGi v ±²É k k v »a\ ij±K9aILaM"{1N O| i MQ ªxMU"N x R±wR Z°a\ na\¬ k r»p ^ aXk MR9p SRTMVkÆU9R il U"N RVR lnZ°É p¤ ^ l kzvjp | }I,x b p ^ { a lspjv a=aIi¥Ma p v^ ita a£{it±vjx aIa l { } ° pjpi¥^ ± a | |p M^ pja a\v k b1}?^¾a= | |kzijpjp a1v l } k p |lsx a\ i¿ iWijp xMk v }µa=xM ¬|¬ kMa U ªxMb£v a kz^ p kvj| m9B° k| $v a¸p ^ la ita\v aI a @ v ija^ a\xG v sp a ^ v a v aIM¬a vjv x itait| ±aIa {ov a\} k }?^ a\ik } k | p x } kÆ il |¬vjx lsp || saM° |^sp | v a\it| p xMv a=| ip |^ a¨itp|kz¦ pja v xz | k vt| k ¬ ª xMa\iv (UH; | R K9LPMR^spx ^| i il lp sa¨±kMi k a\°¡kM p k i pqkzMk °Gp i_p b1a pjiq a a=Gp kzpja= bQ ¡ ¸i ±qi A. A. x. A. : execution of x in its original form. x. B. D. B. D. D. D. B. x. B. x. C. C. C. C. : forward sweep of differentiated x : reverse sweep of differentiated x. x. : differentiated x. C. ;| Ml v aDA RTSiRTMVUTR WGLBQ R L 3O ML ZMOW O MRR U (LN =U LMO R MR VLW ! O L MO QZRVL pk^ aea a | i¦ a } vjp x ixzi rp ^{| iwvjxMpj{Zk }xMp v | p ¹n|xls¡a k x op x k¿pi^ b1a»k s a } { k p ^¾ p xzv aIap ^ a «¥}sk a } kp voaIaMa=° kikM| r ,}?p ^ ^ a a»}?Ì kMb p ^ x klpGp p ^ xa kMv b a }µx x lb Gp { lxz pjkzijp p |xGx v É | i² ¤vjx ii {s r | {vjxzxM {ZxM^ v p |x ¡{¡k vt xGp ¬sx p ^ a¿ijxz¹n lk xGv a v xz p ^sv | iq}µx sa { { p ^ |x v x¦ ^ v v x xz ¤ ^ ki²p > ^ a=iaÆ]_k^ ptsa v kM ªMxMpp v kzMa=a ija ^x ;v aI/ pl a\v b£ | is | ^ ijp x v ska } a v k I a k x b| sa=kls| vqpjk}µ{p x vjxMb £¬ ¬sp| ¬skM ksp |a x xGv i=xz°s ^ p p }µ^ xa a aI| | Ma=a i vtit| xa¥ b p ^ aÆa k }µxG¢Æ¬s| kMÌ k^` < xn| a i1xMÌ i } kzk G k k a v | É1a kkp lsa¥x a\l ± v°;{ p a=^k av p |^s} | l ^sk c6vD| °s{^ p vjptxMa\a¬s a=aI{ bQMk a °nv pijit|l¡ka¥b1 b b£sa k svtvt|a | kza\i p | ¬ a\ri :xk ¹nlr¸kp |± ·|x p pi ^ a(<jc a\? ¹G> l¡i kzË sp | |a x } ¡aqsi»Zp k ^
(120) {a O{ aIa\l¡p_k vl} i_p p |x xpk ¬ k aa aIxm } p a v kM a=Gi p{¡x } itkMa\i x| kzMpjk a=}Ii xM ª¬sxM| v k¡p ^ i a xv a=H a vp ij| b1aqa=b i_x Msa Ca } p < xM/)v i_| i k v kaWv k ai °Gx k xGD x c ]} kMc > | ]_kz^pja=a i=^s° |¬ r ^ss| a ^? pt a=| p |x {¡ vtx xz l p } ^ pjai v aIMa ]Ov xita¥b x a¿k vj|¬Z x ax v {{vjx }?^Q| x {{s ¤ | ^ v v x xQ}µx { ^ ªx v ^^ | ^sv | ^ilpjv a=b£¸b£aImk x {¡v a\aij° i |^x l i k |v i : ¹n} lk kzp |x v iip <j|~c} k ? > @$r,^ a¨¢¿k v a x ,x ±p a xx | sa=¿a p x ija¿xMsv ba\i }=vt|~aƬ } a¥p kM v | bb ª{xGlsvjv x pta»a\xGp b1v aa=GpDlp xx p| Gpta a v b1a=a=a | ijkaÆpta¨b k s als° a=i=p kzp a=l a=i¨ kijp k rFp a¸kb lGp b1a=b rUsa a=iijk r ijp ka H. . . . . . . . . -4. 8. ( & & &. =;. . & $'&)". G= ?NB ? G=. &. *;F9<B. "!$ " )& 7;. ]_{ ^ aqb1H k | ¸il | ¬vjx l}µp | | sa_|p ?Z^ }_kpD{¡vt±x aqvbÆlijp | |¦ a v xsa\G} p |¬ kzpta |v £p ^ ^sa | v a=vjx a v ij| a_b }Ix x sa | | iDp ^ xza vjx lsp |v a_ p ^ }=k} p }µx |bÆÉ kMijlsijpta=a\b i ¬s rO®¥xni xMs{ Æi i x ·a=Gb1p a=i ^ a\Mp | p | ka\b£iI b ¢ s{¡¥{s |~} kk p |x l k x r° p p ^ a i v aIlsa vp ijsaoa b x si a itp px i p ^xita=ija a x k s il vtx lsa=pi|i sMa=ai KML/mNKPO.
(121) c\.
(122)
(123)
(124)
(125) "!$#%!& '(
(126) ) . a=kMv ip x k^ (aµmsp v^a\| b»a r k ¬ v }Ia x }µx ilbxMv { p |x^ xz b1^ a\b xG^ v roi { k } a¨vj p x | itp xMv a | Gpta v } b1a= ^| kxpt a¨ k lsa=i=«¥ k @Ba¨ab1va=a\i b£a=k i=v°sÌ p p ^ iqkzp²b£p k^ r a=ijaWa kib1ita\a¿b b¬s r axnpxG{ ki Q^ ±ka k|p_p a a¿{ a=l¡ssa\a Gp r | pjsa ¸v kzijp rn|xijpt¡a\iIb © kMx p ^ a v ± xGv ¡iI°np ^ aIr }I{x l }µ | ¬ |a v l }?| ^ { | k v k a xQ HZ| xMv {pvj^x a=ijaWpº^ ± x¸v a=kMi xMx v iI° }µ x aIpel¡i } { k | x p ^ a=xb
(127) ^
(128) É xnv xM{ i=v ]_^ a x v a¿k v ªxMaWv¥ita=xnxGa {v k iË x a b1a»k k v a1a=Usa=ptai }Ivj| ¬ a=¹n lsa\¬ i¥r p vj|b a=±kM Ì a¿g phj °a¸kb1 xa=pb ^ a vr x sa»¡±ijlkMb i {pvjxM{Z x ija= p ¬ a r7k aIx a ijkaÆ b ° J,sa xG^ kb£b£k iI| ° |kMGp Qvj]_x ¶ ^s|l | i } }?a\^s xz}? ^| g | jg P j @B° g ?vaÆj k | v aWx xM| ^ ¸p x } lijaÆ^ k¸sa= ªxG±v pja }?^
(129)
(130) | ¹nlsxnaMxM°Z{ i { a^ }µ| ?Z} k r(sv a= v | ija= v ªxGv
(131) |¦
(132) É vxnxM{ i=| °¡k|¡x x p ^ a i;xnxGpta { | i_ a=¹n¹nlsl a | k a a=a=Gi p²p Æx p k£ba xMk v a p;}µp x b kpI{ ° k } p k ªxMGv r bQ°É ki_i ^sx°z±qp a_x itp(kp ^ ¡a k ªxMx a=±a | ij aw? Ml a v aZa=A Gp kzp .
(133) LYQ LYQ .
(134) LYQ LYQ . . ^pv a ]_?v ^ Ga£l v aox pjp kz^ { pk|p¿x p ^ a LBQ ªxM v ±²v a k {¡v v Ba\itij^a\±MpvaIiqa ª{BpxG^ v xa v a\aI^ k M}?a ^ v| it|a¿pta ijv v ±kaIp a|x {¾| }µxMLBvQv a=i {¡ x | i | | sb£xM¸v b1p a=x | kzvLYpjQ a Ær «¥ ªxMsa| x ±} kMa=U it¬ | a=r a x| pj i aIMa itaoij±aIa k< ¬ ptr a v k D ¢k } iqp xMk v }µ¯x ¡°ZitLYa\i Q|¹G la a= xz °} ap kM^°sap ¯^| xnpiqxMb£{;a > kMa |{ aol pkp a|x Gptv aa=b1l } a\a= i_k ptv a(kijp k |~} lk a=i1roitp p ^ a¿a=k¯b k x l¡a Mlp ijxa= b1b£a=b b1xGa=v r kl¡ptita a\r {¡x vtx ]_v ^sk}?| bQ^ip°v kk| ¡³i ªxMp^sv ^s| b£| i kzpv |a\x |x l }} a=ki¸ v b1¬ a¨a=b k ªxM{xMv{v r| a=}I x |x ¬ril^ b kM{p | |x x ¸{kMva=ik }? ª^3xMv
(135) a=
(136) ªijÉ xGaIxnva=xM {¸ | ok x p ^±a aIv aa=v°wa v ±wijx aeaF ± |¦ x x al v a\ {Mvjp{x | v ka pt| a\a v pl¡i¿b»± |a p ^ kp ^s| iÆa»p pv ki¨i ªpjxMa=v b£kzl¡p i¨|x p k]_i ^s| i»b£skzaIp Ma xM { b1© a\Mpp i | i {sa\itkMa\Gsp a\ | bQ¯° p ^ a( aµ ms p ! Bv a a=ka=iji¨a° ¬ p lsp | i» x ap xk¸k| p |^ k| a ¬s^ aÆkM x ±W| s ©,xz p i^ xnl a1x¬ vjb1x a\ls| kp ^G| p a| b1} ak °9 ±wi a| 1 {vjxM {Z%x ij aÆ ! k { < k K v p H| k |v ¡ b1 x > a }?]_^| k^ | xi | }µkx p |b|x |¬s | sx|a\ ip k^ ^{¡a {s{|~vj} xnxMk} vp a=Ì |ix iI ° x x¬ kMitp ¬a\^ a aI^ m kijp ° sk a= k M a¿ ! kiqp b»l }?± ^ pki {Z (Ox ii QD|¬sWG aWO p x p ^ aÆO
(137) kM L lsrp U?x b£«¥kzpl |~} p xnkxM i]_p ^s| ieb k i x b b a¨| p| b a¥| ± a=iqp ^ a vj| i a Ìoxr b£kM |{ l kp |x (a vvtxGv i=. . -4. . !>" ?NB#"JE%$&" " ?NB. " (& ;.
(138) . ?. . ('>@0 " $ ;. D. . . 8. _] ^ a| ªxx1x ±x | ^s v }?^ a ¤ }?ÌM| itxnp xv a | a\i x Qp ^ aÆlija zx p ^ a a\ki rop p a ¢¿ Zp i= m%monprq9s"t"s. ( & & &. = ;. . . & $'&)". 2=2?NB ? G=. &. *;F9<B. "%$)". F¢¿ ¤ Zp Gx xM k x ± aIMa v ° | p_p v kMi {Zx ija=i. % ! .
(139) c=. L M R9M"S R
(140) LBL(UOiUVLYR. = Á} ¨
(141)
(142) O^ ¡\vj x ªÁ | ªÅ Åx |¦ =vÅ· K| Å K Ì KÁn}?^ x ^ OnlaIpob ¬lai v²xzk
(143)
(144) É xnxM{ i=p a x sa lxzp s± a,^s|~p }?^ <Lp ^ aWa p a=^sG|~p v kzpjx a°_ai aI>Wp | i_a=i ^sx ±q*p aUsaµmsp ? G l v aºp I} x G pjk | i¸k ª ª
(145) . . . . ]. . !! LBQ # $" !! # ". ¬Z} x ]_| a=x ^ i a xz? 'v
(146) ij
(147) p6É itxnpjxMa ¬{1{ vji x| i| MCk p | x WGijO a { k O v kzMpta»R Oij(l P¬¡M Ovt
(148) x lsL p | sLa=K *i=) (uwR=+v LP a M $}µ | ij a > rO ° |Ma=k^ L }? P^5M{O
(149) {¡W1
(150) vtÉ xG°xn{p xGx vt{ | aImsbÆp lv } kijp} p ¬
(151) a
(152) v É v xna {sxM{ k i6} a\kM1¬ ]_rFp ^^ ka } kk aI± pp ix l kMk¬ vjsxx a=lsp ± ^ p |a isv l a¥sbÆaI±³llsijijp p l s¬¬¡avta¨x < slsaMa p Z?| s&a%$a='<La°s ¡k¡ % ' | pi (x
(153) r -}µx,+G pj"a=. Gpji+± | i² p k > kxn xMH;{ | °n± k ^s rMx kz° itpjpa a ^s¬Z| i;xk sita r k}µx | iGl¿v a=b1ila=l G¬} pjvja=i=x o lspp x| skaa bxG»vtl| ij| p ¬k ;a1
(154)
(155) É a ? xnsxGa\{ ° ]_± ^s| | p i ^ ?Zp v ^ ijp_a¸itk pj{¡a {{QvtxGa={kvj¡| ki²ptp aÆx k p v ^ Ga lb1{¡vta=x G pjv i=k° b kM | l| ijpjpi v kz¬Zptx a\s r ¬ | roipaI^ ma k } ªpx rFx p± ^ | a s ¬Zx? sGrl v xa p ^ a 9( Â /O O0Ç * (
(156) + $ . ]. . . . . !1 2344
(157) )56 !1. * (
(158) $)56+ $ "
(159) 23 44
(160) *,+ "$. 56 ) # $ " # * (
(161) *,+ ". 56+ $ LBQ # #. ]_xM^ { a¾vj=itx Áa }µ8x | 7 itx pja { :|¦ | 9oi v ÇKkMls p \x| b1Án Ák;;p |~\}
(162) Á$ < ÁG© \Áp x ^ a$Å ¢¿Ç ¤ | Á^;OwÅp xGxM =/KÁ¾¬ vj\ x Án | ! ª 9 ° &x v>?saU} \bÆv Ål| > ij\p @x }kM * p ^ aB¬ b p lsp sa,p a a\Mp kpta °Dk s ± p k il lsp sa\i a l i Ma r k a= r. . x | | ? a\ pI © KML/mNKPO.
(163)
(164)
(165)
(166)
(167) "!$#%!& '(
(168) ) . cih. { k v p |~v} l ^ k v °k p ^ a
(169) ) kM
(170) *,+ "$. bÆl¡itp ¬ a x kMsa=° ¬ lspk i x k il ¬vjx lsp | a=i } k a\ l¡sfqa a } p k a= bQp ^ kzpqkM ¢¿ ¤ ¡p xnxM9{ a vt ªxMv b£i_k£sa { a=a= } a¨kMk rsi | ip ^ kpqsaIpja v b | sa\iI° ªxGv a=k }?^ k vj| É xs|k ¬s}=} a=l x i=v ° iI°±x p ^ ^ aIa\p ¸^ akv¨| |k p¿xvt| k k } ¬s^ pj laqk bÆ r¾l¡¤ itsp a ¬ { xnaqa\xs a ?i ^ sx a=¾£xGp p ^xMx¿a ^s|x {1Ì lsp p¿^ ae ^|¦ a a vjv}µ| a=x Gkzpp || kzMv pa|%x @¾| ^ k a=vj¸| k i ¬sx b1a=i=a { } |k x k,a=1s^ ia l { ¬a\vjx sls}?a=^Up | s} xr a |? pjiWi x lsp p { xlskMpjsiÆa=b1k}Gr$p sa p { v a=ao¢¿ vtx | Bpa=|k }?^$° xzp ²vja£| | pj¬spi | { b£lspk iI a\^si¥|]_p^s^ | ia a\kxGiji¨va p x }Ikx plG±a1kMkMi{ pjija=l|Bbx sap { a=¾¡sp a=kzp¨}I| a\a\iIk °;k¡ k ]_r ^ a\p y llijp }a k a\ ij¢¿ik ¤ ro s| ¨a p ^ akzp v a=a¥a v ijk a6b k x sa=aMi_°k ¡| | s_ p ^ awb1a=kMb b1a r xz p ^ ailp xGb {Wvtp x ls p | saDp x |¦ a v a\Gp | kzpta < ^ a v a
(171) r> °kM(p ^ a¿kMb1a x p ^ a | { lspq |¦ a v a=Gp | kzp |x ( k vt| k ¬s a=i< ^ a v a
(172) r> ©i | sa ! °p ^s| i | iqi | b {s r k }?^| a=a= ¬ rop ^ aWpº± x1 ªxx ± | s | sa\i xz 6}µx b£b1kMBi A 4 4 4 ) 4
(173) $ 4 3 2 4 3 4 3
(174) 4 24 . ±]_^s^ |~aw}?^F|§¦ }Iva a=v ka=GptaWp | k£kptsa=¨aI± il ?¡¬ vja x lsp | 4 a=2i=4° } k p a\^ k p
(175) }µx G% pk |° i²
(176) p ^ a¿ |§¦ ) a v % a= Gkp | kz pja= F
(177) il *¬,+vj x "ls. p | s% a\ iI°j k v a6i Ì aIp }?^ a= |v £p ^ v aesaµmsx p ? Ml v a ^s]_x ^ a=r x xM¬ aIH;r | : }? ! ^ ip k } p | ¹n¬lsvjx a ªxM| v ijp }µxGx v k|aJI v a xz}µ x b { ªxMlsv pjkp |v x ¿ p v kMs{¸a x ª¦ xM|¸x p ^ a ¬ aIr M¬a kvjx itv a¥aIb| a v ija¸a °it
(178) ±ki²aI a i { ,±q) Ê x p |~ } ao p
(179) ¡^ kz¡*p» , p ^sk | i»pjk } % p ^s| |¹n}?ils^ l a | b l{p | sa=^ ai v} k ª¡xM ii¿v itp px¬ i p ^| a k Ì xMvj| ±²| x¡k k o ^ Mit±a v aI|i ¦ a |x v i x| ±wp a\^ a ". ° ± i}Ilx sa lp sa=i b»lijpp a a a a a=£p p a¥ a a\Mp kpta\ k. m%monprq9s"t"s.
(180) c\ ]. L M R9M"S R
(181) LBL(UOiUVLYR. . . .
(182) % + !!.
(183) )5+ 2*3 44 !!.
(184) )5 % + $ 2*3 44 !!.
(185) )5 % + " LMR 23 4$4
(186) *,+ ". 56 fBfTf # $ " "
(187) R9U LPMR 23 4$4
(188) *,+ ". 5 % 6 ) fTfBf # $ " #
(189) *, ". 5 % + LBQ LBQ # #. _] |§^ ¦ aev p =^Á | v | ij¨|ptx a Á {¸x| i ÅZkz
(190)
(191) GkÁUxn| oxM/O{ k¿ÁUb£Ák·n| l k ªÁ p v¸|kMÇi ¬s ªxMÁnv b1\Áx£k {p |xªvts ª xM°Mv pÅ ^ kp Å^ a=kM
(192)
(193) Ã iwªvÅ p xÅOp ^ ª xMa v | b {|vjx x a\x °Mb xM}Iv xMae{ aI´ xz}µ | a=G^ pI° M a=sa ]_a v ^a=kGaÆptpa\a= kzipit?¡a\ a } a xz4 p É2 ^ 4 a¿ p v °Gi=kij
(194) ¡kºi r p ªxGvi_ b£k4 kz p 2|x4 i k | iqaep p ^ kz p_aa\k }?^Qb| pja p v kza=p ij|a¥x p xkM pi ^ a b1
(195)
(196) kÉ p xnxM{ i b»l(itkp ¬ a ªr xMx ±wp a\ a || b£b1x a= | | kzpja r x ¬ r | pj]_i ^v aIa v ij^ aeij} ±wa= a { x ]_^ ^s| xGi²vtk| b | x lGvtpx ip xX| ?Zv ij p
(197) l*ij,+a p ^ a¥5epº| ± x»v xnxMx { i |
(198) x |)^ 5 % ^ ° "$. kMb1Gijpa i }?xs^ }µkWk| kzi pj| sa=ib(a ]_LPsM^saR_| i kMa= ka=¡1iwR9pp Ux a Lp M^ R k a } {k p vj x iI °p v kMka bQi p Ì^ a=a¿p }?kk ^ vja\v k rsls¬ ip a p s^ x a kz±Wpq°G±± a ^v |a¨}?^(k | i²xs}± ki ^ pta\kza\pb ±w ªxGa¨Mv a=±²p ^sk°z| Giqk pta\ijposxG¨vp ax1± I xMv p¬a=ijpjp k pxM| ;v aa A . . . KML/mNKPO.
(199)
(200)
(201)
(202)
(203) "!$#%!& '(
(204) ) ]. 9Â O OÇ0. (/. . c. (.
Documents relatifs
« La prophétie, ou interprétation et conférence des Écritures se fera par les ministres du Colloque, en l’assemblée où chacun dira la tête découverte ce que Dieu lui
AMC PAPI : Spécificités du contexte torrentiel – Rapport de Phase 1 Page 18 sur 46 Dans le cas des laves torrentielles, on peut résumer les conditions nécessaires au
Gillard, “Combinaison de la DG-FDTD avec un mod` ele de substitution pour un calcul de dosim´ etrie locale dans un probl` eme variable et fortement multi-´ echelle”, dans 18`
Le jugement porté par les femmes lettrées sur leurs soigneurs doit donc être nuancé en fonction de la personnalité de chacune, de la gravité de la maladie,
3.3 Processus d’alimentation d'entrepôt de données : Nous devons extraire, transformer et charger les données à partir des sources précédemment citées, dans l'entrepôt de
6.5 Test results for Column Generation model when adding multiple improving columns per job at each iteration in case of modified benchmarks (scale /10), different initial solutions
« On ne fait pas que des psychothérapies en clinique/…/On en parlait encore ce matin : est-ce qu’on a le temps de faire des psychothérapies, parce qu’on voit les gens
L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non, émanant des
