Sociological Analysis of the W3C Standardization Process XML Warehouse Meets Sociology

Sociological Analysis of the W3C Standardization Process

XML Warehouse Meets Sociology

François-Xavier DUDOUET

Laboratoire d’Analyse des Systèmes Politiques Univ. Paris X, 200, av. de la République, 92001 Nanterre

Cedex, FRANCE tel : (33) 1 40 97 76 52 [email protected]

Ioana MANOLESCU

Projet GEMO INRIA Futurs 10, r. J. Monod, 91893 Orsay

Cedex, FRANCE tel: (33) 1 72 92 59 20 [email protected]

Benjamin NGUYEN

Laboratoire PRiSM Univ. Versailles St-Quentin

43, av. des Etats-Unis, 78000 Versailles, FRANCE

tel: (33) 1 39 25 40 49 [email protected]

Pierre SENELLART

Projet GEMO, INRIA Futurs and École normale

supérieure 45, r. d’Ulm, 75230 Paris

Cedex 05, FRANCE tel: (33) 1 72 92 59 29

[email protected]

! "##$!!%&'(##)+*!,--!&)!.)!/1032546+!$7(

(!'+$89!)+)!:+;9<=>%)+)+)+:!&+?@A!$CB>)!/D!E7F!G

@$!+'$!IH)!J-!')++&9KL7M-!')C-!)N@OO&"QP#9N)+$)!)!:9B+!$

)!)+& R)(NSAN%+$T(+BU%)+9)!)+:!@'V)T@AC$!BSNO@+!$'$H;W);

-')++&X RA@9$S(!BY7F!GZ0#[3A!+B7M)+'\C:^]')+AN-_K`a!

)+*!+B#)!/a)!A!,;--!')++&.!!bP#++B#/+&9K+/)C'P#&)+c`a9!)!)!:9B

dIe;fgT;J'9*!$hi9++)+j/)!Pk@)!&)+)C:;@& VB+9!

@$!+'$!IH)!)+/#V7(Y&@A!3&'A; l(!)++)+N)+P#9

+$c-C)!&+K!7L-N)!-!)'#Pm&)+$n,)#IB+HLN#@+!$'$H;W);

-')++&X o(!!'+$p)C.CcA_'+:+.)+/qp@+P#r@A%A+$d032Y4ag&)!+;s

"#9')!AN%CKt7O!)C$!AN&VP#)+$N9C:u+!$v+AB+:p9-N-!@);+&Y)+/

+w032Y4x"L;@);A_@s +!$y%!)+"Qp-)!$!A&s5:!T*++A!+r+$!$$

N/)!'P#W);1Kz`1/);@P#9)!An%9$Y)Y)+$!A%{Y-!@P#C;B

%)C&)+)!:+&;_+!+IBs%,)+/1!l0R[A!+BR|+!$@$!H+&)+#-N)!9;&WK

S}~+€aq‚bƒt„%€t…}†c‡Zˆ#‰bŠ_€t‹1~#Œ€1…N‹1ƒt„'R~;‚bƒt…

Ž+KZ‘_’+“+”•s–p•!—_˜i™bš+›t•sœs”’!;•C–.‘“;”š—1“š+žXŸ%<G)+P#-A++p9-N-C&9)!N

+$c )!&);)!:9B_K

¡w€t†#€aƒ_},¢3Y€tƒ1£¤…

¥,¦N-N9'Pm;s&)+_ +§LANP#+L¨t+%)!'& N n$!+$NIH9)!_K

© €«ªq¬‚ƒ_‡L…

­a)+9 _&+!+ ^ «);9)+)+:+B! V7O)+'$®7M$!y7+(jGq)CN%)+APc

 n9N$!+$H9)! ¯032Y4 ¯0{[3A|B°7O)+'\!!:±]3')+A-N ²7(

7O9')+An@:K

³´

µ+¶

·SŒ¸

µ · ¶

¹3+%+'&"#)+'\@)!&+{@&!N9;$m)Y9);_@AN#$B+H

*Cs|vCA!++I!T)+/S!/)+'P#9)CN Y@;+*+++)y!J)+-T)C/!

-+&A+q@;%+'&º"{)+'\.-'/)+'P#9$tKN`o!Anb+IBC@b)C/ t%WBN C!

A!+P#-)+B;+$j-C)!-!A&)+j»y:C*++i:!+)+:!+-!N9+^9'J"#)+AN$

@svsAN'.9)+n@ANI!:V&+N%ANm$!9! 1()!P#!@|B¼$&; a$!+-N9N$C;s

%A*!&BNb+!$.@A!$!b+!$¼@$!+'$)+)+PcL$!9&)+Xo"#!&(!)+

P!@AN@^9N$S-!'$%m^9P#-N)9BsPmCc/:+AN!/);.:!*;+½P#

-+)+$tK+¾y%);99q'9+!@¿"L)!A!$.%%AN#sBs-C)+N!@!)+.!b@;%+'&

)!-!Àd'%A!Á;ÂND&)!'+9)!?(&"{++?P#Pm:!9)!?+!$

+P#-)+B!P#9!3Yp:!*CY+'9;g' b*++$&.C;PÃ);6!V$!9p.;

9)!+%$JC;yX%AC&"ÀCB;-)9!!@s9K3¾Ä$!9+(!!')!/V'9+*+;s

N/)!'P#W);VL.-N@)CANL)C);/)!3p%)C&3@C@ a(CA!qIq)9

NS)+NB)!!Kq¾#C)+N9pP#-N)+C¼!:!+$!++.)!/p%)++.%&+!9;

@s@+'9Å+'j/+&;rI)!r/;&hs@*!9"R&Æ$CANC:Ç++*!W"R& M!

%&++@OT9(NJ)i$C'9&!ivCA!!)+_x)!$N9)Z)!(+

!/)!P#9)!m/)!Pw*;9"{-);+|oCt9+#!)+t(3!%%;&%$m)+!+"{%!K

`o+$!I)!C;BN t$&c:C&C;@N:.u%)++q%&;C;l+\!!b!/)!Py)!/

*C%:J+:!!AP#(Y)!/V(N+'!+!$¤-CN)9)C&)!-+B!!:wAN%+/A

!/)!P#9)!«KcÈA+Y!)+"L$&BN& P#)+'+!$JP#)!'!A!PJ+%*;I!

!*!)+*Cu@)!P#.7+(V9!)+)!:9BNÆ,;p&)CN%!v+AN9N&! ,'9P#+!$);A_

+P#)+A+^)+/Y!/)!P#9)!y$!)C&ANP#++!:J*!9')!AN½NA!PJ+%*;I!

/)!PD(!A_'!!&5)TA!IA!@; .$!A_BT)+Y/)!P&)+¤;Pm)!*+;$

)C!!! b5NV/)+'PÇ)+/§c`«2Y4q ,032Y4q b+!$5­tÉ3¨O$C)!&ANPm;s|9K1¨t)!

N@9N&! lNW)+L+!$C+'!9)C!+{)+':CH;&)+_.+u:C+$!A+B

-A!(%!!:/)!P&)+T)!!NK¾=@"=]L)+)!:+S!P#WO)C/N

A!P#()+/7M+(-N9:!;A!$

europa.eu.int

d!º¥qA!')+-+VÊLN);

)C//&;6"{(_%+gS)!!JP#)CN N)!%TA!$!+

gouv.fr

d¨¿+!

:C);*C'!PCz%;g9's|P#9+$p9qË!ÌÌ_KÌÌ!Ìn 1+!$º!)N%A!$!+

.gov

d|ÊR :!)+*!@!Pc9!q%s% 1N&AN$C!:L4¿(N+B¼)+/bGq)+:+'!X$mN

Ím9)!!+n|IA!3)+/1§{+I!ga9qÎ;ÏnKËNÌ!Ì1KÌNÌ!Ì1K

7O%)+.%&+!@;%+S)+A$O+B(N9N9/c/')!Ph7;(

$&p@)!'9:!.$p+!+BN'l)!)+% 1!!'+'c&A'++IB¼C)+q+*+;+(!

)!%)+c%9;s|XK3 «);PmM%9;s||$)^A%Y:!@r-!A-N)!%

$&(;%EP#9N9:!PCÐ@BN|P.ÁdÉ3Èb2O _%gD)>@)+'¯

!/)!P#9)!«Ka§{)+"L*!9X q%A&Y$&p)+W)!5mBs-C9IBu$!)!C.(!B

Pm;CAN9u_@;|)!T)CY)+-CB;r-!!@/@);PD@@+)@A%A+

$&(;%S/)+'Pm .@C7+(T$!)!&AP#9!p/)+'P#9$!)!)+p/I.N

B;-&+B.'+9)!C;1ÉÈ2M _AN%$1K!¨aA!'P#)C'; 1%AN&ÉLÈb2M _'

-)+)!BO%A!$½)CM%)+c%9++ÑpC;+$N& L%&YNWB^$)^!)s

%AC-N-!)C,!#!'++qC+)!:!9N9Bc)+/q*++)!AN%)CA!'&!X «$c$)#!)s

!%%|N.%&9!@qº!P);$!:.+!$V&)!C-C)Cp)+/bN+%c*CB

%-C;&/3--!&9)!9K

`o!V;As!)!%);/RNº-!+-!+#&)!P#V/')+Px"L)V/$N&Æq%)+93%9+!

+!$$&+(!!@#P#9N9:!PC'KNÒAN:C);+1,)m(!'$C:!!L:;+-#(C"{9;

!!%V"{)+'$N& (CB^9N9B+H!:5Y!+9$nº);/.@)!&)!)C:;@N)!A!:C^

9)+N&'9.9¦N+P#-<NNp@)!&)!)!:+9IBs%L)+/.s|+(!%NPmC

)C/¿7FNG5¹;&)CP#P#+!$&)+tK!`a!L&);&L);/1,)+-3b$!A){)+A

-|-!9)!SO5¨¿+!:C);*C'!PCr'%-!)!N%)+'9$-N@)|ÓWWR)CN

+!+BN%)!/L@$!+$NIH9)!Y-C')+;&%+#VCu9')!/!/)!PcW);

`oCN)+)+:+BÏ+ÌNŸÆb!)+"L;*++' ,"{V%pº"{$!.':+p)+/+-!-W);_

+!$m-N)!&%(3W¦N_')+n,)!/_!o"#)+'\N ;b$Cs@@(N9$c. W)!#Ô1K

`o!c@AC$!Bc)+/bN/)+'P#W);º+&N!)C)+:+BcP#+':+!:c)+1)+-NL/)!

)+$NWBsÑ@)!9)!)+:!@'$¤+P#+n$!)CP#+T*!;@BA!9¦N-)+'$1K

`o!À'A&!%h);/x!N)C*;9*!Å!)!)C:;!j$-$Nh)!Õ

"L$;%-!@+$O+$!)!-s)+_ l"{O$C;-C;C$nº)!N9'9)!:+N)+!.

@+$!+$tK4¿9^A@s%½&^@)CP#P#+!$&)+n@AN&ZsMN)!%

%-+\!!:N m+ ¤@9N$C;$_Y)+&NWB+;$C)!-++$(+BO

"#)+'$+"{$NSAN%V)!!$AN@.&)!P#PmAN!IBK§#&;/)!_ "{"#

)C!B.An@L9'P )c@/b)p@AN&+&N!&+¿$)+A!PC9K

`o!.)!.)+/c%)+)!)+:!@p@+N$C;$r%9!:(N)+$;%A!.!z!

7OFCGy)+(N*+)!AN9<¿%A!9Y(!)!$C!#9'p9)+N&+N9$^9(N)+AC!An@+(!B

+$O+&!%%(!BO)!/7M9(;&!)!)C:;!.)½N:+'+&;@c-)!&'(N

A!P(!+%KjÊ{$!+X|9N$!N: ! -C')!&!X%+?)!/Q9);PP#A!&9)!N

+&N!9#&*+s% L9N$O|9N$!+'$-C')+$NA!W)!.AN%9/ANL/)Cc++B

)C':+;CH9)!Jd'9$PmO)CY&)!'-!)C9)!!gV"#J/);9AN)!7(

+&N!)C)+:+BNK¤ AÄAN!$%;C$N:Àh!v+AIB A_'+/A!y/)+Z!

@$!+'$!IH)!Y(!)C$+BY|%/ b+{&+V;+$)VP#-')+*!$V)!(NW9

9¦_-!9!+$#-)!&+$NAC';9K

`o!VN+$/)+¼@)!&9LBN@)!/'`¿ b)9"#*!9X b:!)+!m"{+L(!9B;)!!$

@$!+'$!r'@!:¯(!)!$!s%Æh+*+;¯P#'Ó&)+À)+P#-+& Ç%A& ;

2)N%)+/| 5@y!':»@)!&)!)!:+@S)i9N9B+Hy+++%)+nU);

Êc@&Í#9P#!X%+:+#();+'$bd'+!)!A:+#!+A!P#(%b;c|1!c/)+

)9"¤_F!ŸgXK

`o!V7OF!GZ-!AN(Cº"{)!\!:5:!)!A!--N9:!!&;-sAV9);PP#A!&9)!N

!+'9&)!¤(C"#9;J$!//+++V-!+)+-N! m9$; m$+&

N9+%)+_X º-N)!%I)!N+!$J$+'W);_ !+Kc`o!!'

7O9(Nr(N+%$N/)+'P#W)+V')!AC'&!C/)CPJ!.')!&)!)!:+@l()+A!1!

!+'9&)!Nm(NW"{+9^9&)!XR);/.:+*!9u-)!&!&&K1.-!+&A9

9!'.)!/++(!)!@&!:.'`O@+!$'$_% " # $%$&c@c(9);P:!

-'9*!CuP#+_)+/YC@&)!J(!9"R9+¤-!+&-C%W9'$

+')+A!$!O:!)+(N+ #+!$"#)+'\!!:T$//'9!.P#½H)!!!XÆm

+'&*!+$p&)C+9!qlB!-!&+B¼-!A(!%N9$.7;(.-C;:+!9K!2)!;)+*!9X

"#!+ ! -!+&-C8$!) P#9k-C+BN%B )Ck9+!$

+;9)+N/;+!9s% b"#9N)9+);/R!YPm9:Y)+#+)+/+'9N&

+'R\.+!$ºB!-!9IBc-!A(!'$.)C!m7M9(¼%)+B#+/+"#9'$N9K

¾J%)!&9¿@C@¿@AC$!B+!:L{@+!$@$NH+&)+c-!@);9;&,P#A_@t;$C;-s

)T!S%A&)!y(+B¤$*!9)!-C!:J+!$yAn@:T&)!Pm-!A!'H++$¤$!9

P:CPC3)+)!& %!+CNvCA!!.%A!;PA!+s@*!9"R

+$N/)!'P#W);9)+9&)!(!+)+P#Y-)9"#';&m)5--!'+!$5!

%+%H;)!/_!L&)!-NA9K

³´%³

¡T‚b}b¢|…

¨a')+PÅ)+AN$NAC;L*+9"L-!)!sR)C!.+-!-W)! bu:C);+º&;(!

$*+$!+$.+)#"{)9+:;)C!&< ' ())* #*+"-,,./ /0 /$

1 #+!$T2 $3/$4567#8 9;:=< 14>7 ?

@ A,3K

¨a')+PT!L$N9LP:!9Pc9!a*!9"{-);+| C"#;Pwt!|+(!@N:!

@svsAN'+P#9!'/)!q$!9;vsAN%I)!N a|)+'+:+! _+!$.+!+B!%b)!)+ n)

(yAN%+$i(CB»@)!&+'9C@+\!C:i+$!*!9!:!J)+/Y!T7+(!Ñ

'P$!)!Ab-N)9++9¿)+/a/)C'P#&)+1KN`a)LCb+!$_ C"{#-!@);-)!%!

+'&+%A!'L/)!q%A!9#);)C C(N+%$#)!m'+$!B{+*+++(!7;(R)+)!&

P)+$N9& 1$p:+AN9:!!XÆ1'9b;.(C;:#$NW+(!!@c!'+9'!+Ñ

B'-&-!@)|ÓWWCB' b+!IWAN@R@-;&/BL9':+9|,;+%3)+/aAN%3+!$

:C)!)+$¤%A!--!)!¼/)!ºN+$N6)!/!O%)+9)+)+:!' L!N9A!!)!'%Ñ

9¦_-!+m$!!'9'(N+lN9PpK_`t,)+)!¿%!)CA!$(NLW¦N_'(!! (;%$

)CL7M+(c@+!$@$n% $#AC)+P#9$L)3N:+'+&+@t-N)!&%(&¦C'K

¨a')+PxCu%)+);)+:!&+b-N)+s3);/*C&"c 1!.)!(XÓW+%*!!L9'"L)!/)!$_K

¨a'@| ,!+!+BN@PAN@3$!+P#)!N@@."L)!\N!:Nm);/.7F!G

@$!+'$!IH)!O:+')+A-N& lAN-N)!*+$N:Ns9&AC;R)+)!º)

-+&-!9NY-C')+;&º+!$!/A!+!YI);AC)+P!KED{C)+"{!:

"#!)5-N99-!9!+!$^)9"j$N9%)+_+;\C;5;9$nR)V(NW9

A!$X@+!$C:#)!/1#'A&!%%;9N$/AN'L)+/1!)+_')!|APc !+!$

P)+'L:!@IBL!LC+'!9t-!+!)!P#9N)+1K¾m$!*!|%$;,3@;%A!I

)C/cA!)+C')!;$SN$C*!$A!+#C9*!;& lCV"#+*+:^)+/LNV7(

 «9);$!IBs "LS"{)!A!$¤\NW¦N$¤9N9Bs%P#&N)+$_Y-C'*!)+An@B

+-!-+$)N.!|9(N%!Pc9!)!/+9'!9)!C;b'9:!A!9)!VdK:Kt/)!

$AN:&)C+')+Î+Ï+Ÿ' )!.&*!*C)!TFŸg% )!5-N)!&!%p)+/L'`

@+$!+$NH+)+n C+!$¼@+3)9"OCBL9'B{)+*!9&K

³a´HG ‚q}b‡#£y}by}†#‡y‹a‚,†{~!ƒ_„%‰ˆ{~!„%‚†#…

`o!L"#)+'\"{#@;-C)!q)+.N9'#-)C+$!+$.9)!!:mCc/)!)+"L!:.-C1K

7O/)+A_@;$w);U!S-N)!9;&5);/.!@+(!@N!:!0#[3A!+B7F!G

¹+)+P#P$!9)!d)^(V&%A!+$^*++BM')C);g%K7V-!9\!+$Y0L[3AB

$A!) @+*+;@V/;%)+X9KL¨tX|| m!T@+N$!+$H;9)+J-N')+9;&!!

%-C;CN9$^)!*++LB!+X% b;$N)9"j)s%)VNV+!$_ 9N9(NN:V

%)+9)+)+:!)S'!@)!);*CV/Ar(!)+"{-!')C&s%9K3 _9)+N$CBN lN

+vCA!++&Y"#0{[LA!+B)!/#!Y9)!P#-!AC+¼%&;s||º!*C);*+;$

-)!*+$;,$N)+P!r'%-!+&/3\!)9"{;$C:!)3!3-')'Ó&9&%K

7N9*!c-@/)+'Pm;$9q9N9B!%)+p-NA!(LP#+:c@

)C/C.7FNGw032Y4[3A+B."#)+'\!!:V:+')+AN-NÆoL@zL+9!*C$V9

http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-qt-comments

K>7 *!

$;%:+N9$O%Wc)!/++!|!:)+-C+!$O$P#9n%)CN/)CN

%)+9)+)+:!&;b+!+BN'L)!/bCL|| %A!9VsW<t$!*C$NA!+L-!)N|!:p)!

!p@ a3)!@:;+!IH9)!N& o$N%9AN&')!)!-!;LW!KÈ!%$p)C.C

9)+N&+-+AN9pP#)!$C; L"LO9¦!'W.!SP#+:@Ñ5)+C;C5T

$&(;%! 1+!$p-'/)+'PZc-!@;P#C;|B¼$!9c9N9BN'An@!:¼@9q)!/

vCA!+!,$#{%P#-N:!'9-N!&+)!)+'K

`o!yP#+x)+!(!AC)!x)+/)!A!"#)+'\ZOJ'9/W)!Z);ZN)9"

%)+9)+)+:!'V$)+P#-A++u@&';%+9'&N9XV9O9)+9(N)+'9!

+!$-N)!$A!9¼@-N9/m;-C-N&)+.)!)++!$pP&!)!$NR);/,7O($NW

+!+BN%& «).9);P-!P#+C!m@$)+C9'*+9"Rl+!$p@W|&+

+!+BN%9KLÒ3Au+-!-)!9T!)!*!W;5)!*++.!O@W)+/..

%)+9)+)+:+B#'+%+'&_ (!B#AN%!:7M+(L;&!)!)C:;!9C;+$#)!R032Y4q

+!$Á(+B?-!')!*+$C: $&(s@+r@B;Ä)!)+Â)D+!+B;H+QNA!Pm;

+++%);_msm&+-+A+$YYPm!:V|{&)!+Cz+*+++(!.)!N

7+(_K `1!j%9)!!$h&)!+'(CA!);h)!/)+ANU"{)!\hJi:C;C;

+C9&A!'; l(!!'+$)+O$!+'$N.%A!9Y!L02Y4q a0# 4o ,+!$YP)!@

P#-);|;CBm0{[LA!+BC «/)!q7+(c$!9{Pm;C;:++P#++a)!)+1)c(C{A_@;$

(CB @)!&+Y@9!@9);9&:J$yB+H!:T7+(!r(N+%$J$NW

%)+A!&K

³a´HI ·Tƒ_b}b†R„KJ¿},~s„%‚,†

`o!9&"{3@+$^+/)!)+"#&K +%)+LM('+/IBY'+*;&"cRN

@9+$Ä"{)+'\N JÀQ/+$D)!/i$&=+9:!)!À9N$Õ7;(

"L+')+An@!: j9N$²Á?/$²)+/=%)+)!)+:!+Ç@A!$!B?)!/

@+$!+$NH+)+c(!)C$!+9K

7S"{p+@);$A!9; y +&)!TF_ m!S)+N9-CY9'A!9;)SN

-|AC+ @A!$!B )C/hNÄ0#[3A!+B @9N$!+$H;9)! !9h"{

A!$\!K_ ;%)+m¼$!'9(N+b)!A!')CA+)+#m)!$N9a)LP#)!$C;_+!$

vCA!+B^)!A!p@-/u-)!(!P.&K ;%)+ÏY-s%9!.%)CP#V&¦_P-!

vCA!+!m$Y';%AC|R"{)!(+;$5$NA!@!:V)!A!mB!%% +"#q!

!+-!@;P#C;|Bº@)!)C)!:!9qC9'-!'99)CNÆ«N#/A!%);9)+)+:!&+

@A$+BV#(!9B+)!!$!V'9)+-N.)!/b!R-!+-N9&Kt _W)!Ëp$!!%&'(;{N

:C'T'&+%ANT)!/5¤')C&)!)!:+@Ñ$&wP#+!+:;+P#++V)!)+

$@*++$»/')+P )+A&¦_-!+'+!yyS"#)+'\_K.7y/!'Z"#

9)+N&An@)+_Å$D-N9X%-!+%*;!h/)!j/ACANÀ9)+9(N)+'W);?+!$

@;%+'&LN/+$_K

G´

NM%OOPMpŒRQ ·S

©

G´&³ Q €a‰w¬}qƒ_€"S#‚,ˆc…!„@†R

`o!+;++$CBT(!+J)+p)+/."#)+'\T)+!)!-!);/$NW

"L+')+An@!: _P$)!.+!$.s+:+'&)+p)+/$&.FNF!Ÿ%KC7M#+/+a)

P&'H+$²*;&"c% x+!$²);/ÅPm)+$N)+)!:+; ;C$?)!)!Õ/)+

9)!N@'A%:=&!X%9;w$!9j"L;@);A_@sWK§#)"L+*!X S9!!'

+&N!)C)+:!!#)C!BV$!+"L!:+B^v+AN9!/;(Cp$&! u:++!+'9

!+:++X,)!a/)C&|9K

VCu&!@p)!/l!V&)!@AN%)+Y)!/u%)+)+)+:!&+b"L;+);A_@s ¿!

+--!')++&kQ'9$N&;IB $!//+'C'Kj`t &)C!9-!=)+/

*) /!!(N9+^C)!$!A&+$^OÎŸL+!$SF!Ÿ%Ka4oW#AN#:C*+p

@;-C$Y)+*!+*!9"»)+/NL!9"i--!')++«KN¾i9)+!Cq"L;+);[email protected]

"#9')!AN%)+/¼vCA!+*!N/)!'P#W)+%A!!p@)!&)!)!:+9#$!9

NW!!b!)L'*;+_P#9N+P#W&+_-)!+&'!:#P#W);$1K9¹z+-!@++!:

NV+W)+_(!9"L+^-|-C|)+mN9#9¦N+%#)!+#$)+!#)9

+$S)S!/)+'P#9)CO&.&+O(!-')+;&@+$OO+:+A.Ò4_¾­

+--!')++&tKÒ3L)+!@;BN CCb/)C'P#&)+_ _v!A!IL)+/+*!9(N

/')+Ph*!@)+An.@)!A!@;)CY!"{+(n b!:+BY!9+')+:!)CAN& +!$

9+c)+B#(!L!+:!9+$#(CB{AN%!:#{@+P#r'|A&A+$#$&3P#)C$!+'K97M

$+*+;)C-!+$#.F!ŸaP#9N)+$);)!:9B{/)!1C3$;%:+$#&)!N@AN%)+c)+/

&)!+Cq"#@);A_@p/)C&An@+$p)!/)+)!$%\N 1

b-!')'ÓW;%FÔ!Ÿ

(!'+$#)+mNb¾L&*!02^4V$!+*;+);-P#9!t-9/)C'PyF_Ï+Ÿ%K

G9!;l)V!+%\^)!/L9+*+C:Y/)!@P#&)+Y/')+PxC.7;(5;

NGb'&"#+'9KqO)!AC.;%+ "{$)!)+#"L;s#)'&'+*!% $$!

-+:+s)+/º!½7O(T(A+p'W'+*!'-9/!/)+'P#9)!T/)CA!N$w);

-A!(l"{(-!+:+!-N9!_)+;&;C$N9'$!H+&)+tK

G3´G Œ}~!}„@†{~+€aqƒ1}~+„X‚,†i}b†#‡ O

É#W C+:!)!k@B!@PD)!// !²-!)N&@(CIB²) v!AC;B

9+)C:;+!+)!A+!$x$!@'(!AC;$x$!9i')!AC'&!;/!9By"L;

9)!+$SSM@:+$!9(;%CK{`1N5&;&%9+{9'C+&A^)+/#

$9YC+:+'&)+O@BNPÅ)+P-!'%! ( YF!Ÿ#)+//9'N:6!

!+:+'9+$T$!99(N+%O*+9"Å)O!OA_@;% L$O'9.)!/

-,,.*;

"#!P#\#!.&)!!W)!(!9"L+p!$N*C$!A$C.@)!A!'&!+!$

NP#+$!&)+&Kb¹3+%+'&O!.++Y!!.-)!$!A&;$O@+*!@#$!9

!+:+'9)Cy-N')9)B!-!!Od+P#)!C:J!+PD"#¤&IÉ#%9)xF/NŸ^+!$

]L9'.nÌCŸg% t%)+P#);/o"RC.C;*+(!+m'9n@/+@$.C)c$!A_'9

-')+$A!&d'+%-N9&*CB! ,N'D{+DL)+)u&)CP#-!+'&*+p%!)!-C-N!:p-)+9

FF!Ÿb;$.mÈb2=É3ÈEY-!')+$A!&z%AC9g&Kt _A!9u@B!@;P)CA!$p%)+*+

%)CP#c)C/!c-)!(!;P3/9+$p(+Bc@)!&)C)!:+@q%+\!N:m).&¦_-!)+I

$*++'%c$&¼%)+A!&K«§{)9"#*!9X «!9B.N9*!¼%9*!@$!%$*+;s:C;9K

¨a'@| {"{'!:½"R+-!-X6V:++!+'BO*++B+$!)+A_V+!$O+')+'r

-')+V!%\NÆb)+C'!' b)!A!L"#)+'\N ,"#9\NV$*++++:+V)!/!

+9&;-s)+/3$!+'$7(p$C/)CP&'d'.-!+&A90L2Y4agb)

+AC)!P#9O!5P#A&!V-C)NX%(!!-)C&s&6);/.$&9¦!'9&)!_K

 «9)!!$BC ¿!9Bp+.)!'+++$VP#+Bu)+V')!!+b$!9; ¿"{!m!

*C;B.NWAc)!/,7;($N)+9A!P#++|'!v+A'!!+!$:#02Y4Kn`1N$NIBs

%A&u@B!@9P¼@#B;-&+B/4 A+* «&& «!9B./)+9AN);

N5//9!#W¦n+&AC)!)+/#9);P-!&¦Ov!A!+'!)!+':+V$N@(NAs$

$9#%)!A!'&!% _$:!*!LIL)+b!)¼@A-!-N)+a/);, /$p@;:C;

"#!+LL)+N&+-+'b'++*;++a)LN#%)+)+)+:!&+a@AN$+B'$N9/!+$NÆ

N:!V&'AN&L)+'$!+L)YP#+\!.!V$!9p+!+B!%v+A';

@;+*+++¿/)+a{%)++t@A!$!BK

G3´I

RO3ˆ#€1ƒªT¢X},†R,ˆc}bq€a…}†#‡y‡#},~!}q‰L}b…N€1…

`o)YP#+!-CAN&02Y4T$N)+ACPc9!& ,N03­t9OnF!Ÿm$V0R C4J+Ÿ

+!:!A!+:+!.!+*!Y(C;9"#$N9BYAn@+$^YV&)!C¦CR)+/L+-!-W);

$+*+;)C-!Pc9! "{' !Q/)CANhh)!Ä/!|»9¦!'W)!À+!$

'_@/)CP&)+#)!/1'9*!9BR%Pm1*+)!ANPms,)+/a$!9!K

`o!/'@6vCA!+BT;C:!A!+:+-)!-!)N@+$¤/)+0324i!O$&+(!!'

9)!P#P#A!IBT"#;02^4ar[4=Î&NŸ%Km0{254¿r[4j"L!(!!'+$J);w"L)

%P#-!p)+9-!9<t-NW'Y$6)V(NP#&!+$Y9:!+n|032Y4

$)+AP#C| «$N 1/);b++&.P#9&.+N&)CA!!+'9$n «L|c)CA+-!AC¿$

)x(Ny9);_@'A!W9$tKVGq)!%;Ç%-C')»)+(&Ó&9&r)!9!$jv!AC;B

!L0L[4^v!AC;Bc+!:CA!+:!ËNŸab!$-$!++IBR-C')!-!)N@+$_K!¨t!+BN

![LA!Ip;C:!A!+:!TÎNÎWŸp/)!Pc6O(!!@5)!/.O9A!'++p7F!G

@+$!+$NH+;$º032Y4OvCA!+B.+!:CA!+:;! «0#[3A!+BV_Ô!Ÿ%KDL"{+I3NËNŸ,

!i+9'!@O&)!P#-C9yP#-+P#++W);x)!/!y9N:+A:!yd"#

@;%-!+&_)!+!:!A!+:++Ñ/9A!'+b&t&1P#+g&K

¾La;%L02^4MvsAN9Bc9N:+A:!+!+*;m(N9)!P#m!-A+|z)L!L7F!G

02^4ÇvCA!+B |9N$!+'$CH9)!ÆAN& m!S0{[LA!+BU+!:!A!+:+JÔNŸ

()+')+"R /)!P +?)C/jPKT¾L?¦_&+++Ç@;%)+AN9 /)!

A!$X|+!$:p0L[LA!+BV'Î1NŸ%K_7.'IBp)!0{[LA!+BpV)!A!"{)+'\

/)+ÀID¦-N!X%*+ -C)+"{+' Ã"{& )9"RD9);Pm-N&¦ 032Y4

Pm;C-A!W)+_X 9N$m/)+'N&@!%N:L+&9-!+&3!,R|9N$C;@$_K

 «*!9'5-!')9)9B!-!!9N$JN$CAn@'-N)!$!A&9A!''9!IBT;)+"=)

@)C'h0L2Y4 $N)+9A!Pc9!Ã+!$Àv+A;BÅ!+P>A_'!:Å0L[{AC;BNÆ

9)+P#-N@_'*!c@q-)!*+$!+$p)C.Cc-:!)+/b!R7MFG"L)!\N:

:C)CA!-V)!0{[LA!+B^tÏ+Ÿ%Kº!"#)+'\N ¿"{$N).!)sq9+P#-+b)p(!A$

+03254O$NW.P#+!+:++P#++{BN|+PcÆa@&% 1"{V')9" )9" %A!9p

@B!@9PÇ9);A$(NVs:C'&$YYp:!9N+)+)!+9!WA!'+ ,)V(N

A_@;$(+B¼@)!&;t%&++@'+!+B+H;:7M+(#$!)C&ANP#++'&K¾LCB30L[LA!+B!r

9)+P#-N++¿P#+!+:++P#++¿@BNPT/It+)3Nb9'&+%ANK

G´

3‚q‹a„'‚b¢'‚oªw},†c‡J‡#},~s}b‰L}q…€5ˆR…€

2)!$!+p')!&)!)!:9B#"L;b(!)!&1N;C$#)!/_NÎFGb++AB{$+:

"Lp9':+.P#)CA!!');/3|9@9$K¨¿)+b¥qPmÉ{AC'\NC;P. 1)+N

)C/!/)+ANC$N:/&C;%p)+/.%)!&)+)!:9BC l!^A_@^)!/.@9@;º"{!

9;&%9Bi)x!+(!%Ç@)!9)!)+:+Bi!i@&NKº¨t)!O!PÁN

%)+9)+)+:!&;-CN9N)+P#+);h')+AN$»(»|A$!$j!w>

$4N)9{!+ / 0 «Kq`tC@)+)!$Y)+-N-!)'I)!V)N

-+*;+Cp--!')!9TW.&Pm; R"{!/+*+)!'9$$!+)+)!:9BO)!*++

9¦N-@P#9!&)+tKbÉ{A\NC;PÕ$N9/!!.%);9+{/9&#!*

-4

.& ? P .$& . *) $ 3&+) $ 1

3 1 .,.

*-4

,./* $ *,./ & ! R|Î9Ë!Ÿ%K

¨a)+cn|9N&! @:+)!ANº-N+&+& )+(n%9'*++!Y)C/#&*!L$A+;& l)!

+*++^@AN&$!V@u%)++/W|WKt7!+V!$*!$CA!+L9);+(N)+'W.V

@+$!+$NH+)+u-C')+;&l"#!&."#$9+P#!cA_%);/,C@!9

/)+P#)+_b)!/a-!+)!-!; &B'L)P#9'+B#"{IC:c%-!+/&9)!N&

(A+;x+%)x-!+9-NWC:»jy"L$NW@P#!+$j+9'W)!

-)!&!&:+)!*++'!+$#(sBR')s"{c%9t)!/1'A!+9K

O)+'$)AN!$C;|;\CM@++/Y+!+B!%)+/¼%)+/+%|& l)+N

PmAn|'9;%$!y+YN9O-C'+&)!!9*++$x$!+;& 5'A&xsUP#)!+

ÓWA!$:;+P#++')!b)+P#P)+p%_%L'ACnWKt CW@&+¿@;+%)+N:¼%C)!A!$

(DAn@+$ )Á$!@N:+A% -X%)+h9¦N-N9'9N&?/')!P :!)C(!+

$!+!;9Ky +!/BÀ;@+(!@N!:ÀÀ@)!&+y/+%»P#+_

*C'/B!!:.Iz@W&+B_K¨t)!@&! «"R)+P#+:!))p&A!'&VP#)+'

)C/++.P#_ C#'A&$!#9Lb!:!!+#!L!,!+mN

9)+AN+Bs%$!KaGb)!r)!&9AN'9N&)+/b"{)Y@)!&+b/&m\IB¼Pm;9nl!9

!+'#.9¦_-!9NW);.9)!!W:#)+N)R!L)+!+XKC¨t)!N@9N&!

ÉLAN@\!N9PE;x%!)+"LÅ!9 'A$!x"Ls !)+Tx-N+'%)+N9)!

-_|Bs&)+)!:+&;av!ACs@)+n (A+{%)+)C)+:!+_-!+!)!P#9N)+&)!!W;$

)L:!)!(!+_+&)!!)!Pmb@$N+$c@)!&+_s+:+'&)+.'ÎÔCŸXK

 «N&NÎF &++ABC oÉ{A'\!P"mP#9N)+$)+)!:9Bu;(C;9V"#

$*C)+-+$_Kc`a!W!|pP#-)+9!pX%A!!5'S99!IB / /$

/$4"&M+!$ )

? $ *4qKlÉ{+*+;)C-!+$U%&TÎF!ËNÌ L;%

+-!-)!9!!L$+"Lu*C')!A#$!*C$NA!+b$NW);@$N9b).9¦N(!I

@9)!N%!-Ð|A&A!ՐÏ!Ÿ' FŸxdNW"{)C\D%);9)!)+:+B+gX J')!9+

-)!-!+;y¤%-!+&/T%)+V)!C/:CA!'9)! .)!5)¤(A!$wN

B;-)+)!:9BY)!/LY%);993:!')+A-^d/+%)+'LIBs%@g.oÎ&Ÿ%KaÒLVN)+N

$N S/W)+'9T+!+BN%i9)NX%! +:!Ç9P#)!A!C| )!/J-!+X')C!+

!/)!P#9)!dX@9¦n L-')+/;&%)!N R;$A!9&)+n #@+9B;g_Ÿ.$TÔ!Ÿ

9"{)!@\p--!')C*++BpC;-/A!.$N'9);*C'!:c@;9)!NP#)C!:

+:C3A!P#(X,)!/t-)C-!K

Í9*!!+!&.;%5;-C-N)!9!!./9V!'PmW);_WKz`a!5/'@

)C!Y ,E $'Kq`aCs@VPcW!)C$N.$!+9"{I^%)+&B9\N9^+#

"#!)CNKL`a!+;/)+'.V$!//&A#)S@*C^!$N*C$!A#(*C)+

N)!AC:!.!+P.Kn`aCc%+&)!!$.)!!=1 $'K_`a)c(Cc-!@);9;&%9$n n!

$9LN+$_,)L(!#v+AC/+$_KN`1AN& NvCA!+9*+LN/)+'P#9)Cc'A&;

-+'%);*!&"RU)!x&A!+^/+&!)+9)+ANs$Z/);WKº`o!!'

P&!)!$NS+'T9(NU)J!:!C:+CY:;)+(N9Y$+B!!+P#& º(!AC69y)9

$!'9(3L!$*+$!AN9 "tP#-!+&a)!mN9PpK.`t!'$P#I&)+

NWt;%PcW!)!$b$!)LN)9¿&+-+AN #$P#+N%)+1KR`1)+NB

-)!&%(N¤@;-C';%++&)+»)C/ @)!&+Y/+%^Sy%!+-N%!)+%Kc

-)!&%(N)#&)!Pm-N9'L;IBN'b1P#

"{I#+!)+,&tP#

(A+at,*!9B{$//9A!1)#&¦_-!R!+P#-);@t9*!)+AC)!«K

x)+!@s|| 6);A+!+BN'O)C/Y7(Z$N)+ACP#+!S9-!A!':yW)+

!+'9&)!N5;)+"R5())$C/B$!*!$NAC;V$-!+&A9

)!-!& a+!$V)p-'9&9c:!)!(C;,;C;IBs%9Kt`a!+!+B!%)+/b"{'

P;&@+:!; )9"mÕ v+A9*C?!'-!@&9)!N Z(!!%$N+Â!

vCA!++W*;y+9'-9&)Ci(9$i(CB¤JAN%:!J)+/^$&+(!!'

P&!)!$N9K«¨¿C;IBN 1!+!+B!%L)+/P#a;9$n% a!9A!'B.)+'$N9'$

(CBjxPmj$NP_@)!N ½+)+"#yAN )h!:+:!+SP#r(;%$

+*!)+A+);m)!/_N&)+X'Ñ&+9'+%);_WK

2@6 PNFŸ#!!.@A$!+$5N"LBV!9{-)!-!V&L)!!9"R

:C')+AN-N& b*C"L!:6;%V;ºuC"x!'9&)!Y$Y9);PmPcA!W);

P$AP.Kb§Ru"{)+'\O!*!)+*+!º!$*!9)!-!Pm;s¼)+/Y)!)+{+P#$

ÍW| +N ,'+-!'+%C:!-N99-!9)CY)+/{-C;)+-pu$@A&')!N

+$Ç9¦!'W:jy$&x/)!P !x&"cJ:+')+AN-Ã7M9(Ç-C;:C!K

§#)9"#*!9X !;C;IBs%;$//+++p/)!&An6;)!A'9<3!S

P!BÀ+9'!$DÀ/I+N:Õ'AN@"#)++BÀ!/);@P#9)!À+!$

$N9!/B;:j%-!+P#P#+X% 5"#! "RxA!$CB»i$C//+++O-N@);(+Pc

+P#IBN `y@$!+$NIH)!_Kb2)s@P#-!)C++IBs )!A!--!')++&

(!'+$S);½0324o %Pr|@@AN%A!'+$O$!9Pc)+$ "LN&ºP#AN&

P)+'3+-!-)!-!'&3/)+)+AN19':!W¿--!&9)!mdX +%)!cÏ«Kng&K

G3´

3‚‹t„%‚¢X‚bb„X‹1}b¢3…+~+ˆR‡L„%€a…p‚,†i…+~!}†c‡L}bƒt‡L„J}~!„'‚b†

ÒL!h)+A$=!@\Å"{CB @)!&+T@+!!J+'xC+';@+$Å(+BÃ!

@$!+'$!IH)!p-C')!&!X9Kt n;C$N+$.N9:!)9&)+nl;*+;B#+&N!9

+$Å';%+*!9$Å)Åh%P#+TNACPc(!+y)+/J¦-N99KuÍm;*++s%

@$!+'$Nw$!)xN)9O)!CB»$C;+"LxCN&;&%ACsWKÉR9/!!:

+&N!9R@$!+$nº.9%)Y&)+)N%:Y/'Pc+!$)+ANs';m"#!&

"#.)+!)!!½9!)!)!:9BN L"LN9T;5O++V9);)+Pc+!$

-)+I9YP#-+%XK¼`1½P#&B¤9¦N-9J"L+BN s)+(_'+'*++$J(+B!

Ò¥G,É P#9!B^@+!$'$_$!)!Pm!9:!º|`SP#+\NW| ,+'p!)s!

(!Y/')+PD9!+V-!)!Cu)!/V*+W"?CnŸV$ZËCŸXKc ) m!

vCA!!@)CNS)!/

n ')

9N$L

) ^@$!+$nS@¤+$!)!-s$

(+&)!P#Y&@AN&'Ka¾#N@"L+N:5;%Yv!ACs|)+n!v+A!m!VA_'Y)+/

%)C&a'99N&)!)+9K

É#+%-!JNyP#-!)!+!9¤)+/ANC$N9X@+!$N!:JC @+!$'$H;W);

-')++&X «/&"¤%)+9¿%9;C!b!+*+#$$!'+&%$mb)!-!{%)#/9&KN`a!

"#)+'\Nl$!!'9'($._Ô!Ÿa+N$+Ÿq|A$+BL3P#-!+%¿)+/|+!$'$Nb

9)!P#-!+!!&K^`aCiP#)N|O+$!*!9N9$j'+%A!'T)+x!i+9'&)+N9

@$!+'$!IH)!T-!@);9!X5N9*!(!+)!(s+N9$(!B!O )!&\!)!P

G9!/)!,Ò3':++NH+&)+N91¹z!@;9'ºÎ9Ì!Ÿ' 1FÌ!Ÿa$.FtΟ@K+§{)+"L*!9X

Nl|`V|+!$'$!IH;W)+#-)!+&'!,'P#*!+@B{A!9¦N-)+'9$pNŸ%<

Ò:!+!@9)!y/)!Y¥9);)+PcG)+r)+-N+9)!y9N$JÉL*!9)!-!Pm;sXK

http://www.oecd.org

$/+$4 ! & )#,. $&C)T@)!+

%&+%Ÿ $; $* & &+JeH * #

4)1 $P) 3 /$

%+/ 3 +

,E 4 + (/ & &

*?#/0,

/)

$4>* $*+e;f +* )

/ (& &>, ** / .,.//

/ , *1

$4 *)3

) $4 *1

),.N + //;, *1N) /&$

/) ) & *4 / 1

/

ÒAN#@A$+BY#9V+P#-+)V/,!L:!-_ a(CBp&¦_-!)N@:.

+%)!' +N$ Pm;9!+!@P. "{! C±7MFCG

@+$!+$NH+)+c)+/10{[AN9BNK

I´ O¡ MVÃ O µ

5

µ · ¶

!#%W)!N o"{.+@);$A!9.,.&)!!9+-+|+&'+B.V)+'$!+

)p9);Pm-N+N9N$./N9:;)CR)!/b!VA!$CBs a(!ACq/X@"Lpb(!B

Pm)+*!W!:^)CA!.!+'+@#)!NY@+!$'$CH;W);5)C-! l(!)+/@);P

!#')C&)!)!:+1$#&)!P#-A+q@&{-C)!!t)C/t*!9"cK

I´&³

Q SLª¤…+~+ˆ#‡lªU~S#€ Q I

++&9*!B+"L!+'!K_`tCb& c/9&| Cb$C;/N:L9!++W;@!<

)c(LA'!+$)9"L;@$N,"{)!$ t%)L&1N)!%"{I{9)+Pc-!AC+

+!$VPc9+N)!/L)+!+%C:YPcWBY$N%9AN&$Y)+P#PA!W! +!$

!7M)+'$L7$!l7M+(#G)+_')!A!PTLC{&+++¿)+/1C,NW"{)C\1K

¾L@)!A!$ F!̲)!/6NS7F!Gh¹39);PmPc9N$!9)!N9¤(T'+9¤!

//3.')/+!,CB#9;9'B#$/{@K!K @9N$!+$H3*C;);A_

!@-N9&'h)!/xC@!9®/!KT§#)9"{+*++X UÅ"#!)!Q-)C&s&Ã)!/

@+$!+$NH+)+.3@)!P#9"{!9a*!:!ACNK+¥b*;+L!L-!+)+-NLLNC+

)C/L!V-)!&!&X l)+AN:C^9(N)5&V:;P#-%u)C/3!V)!*++'

-&A!'+ _!+$.l"{9B3)L&)!P#-+!+!$m

-4 )$$

?{'Î +Ÿ' #+!$

!º¼"{&cV)+')!A!:C$P#9N)+$);)+:!&+#@AN$sB^)+/3!V7F!G

@+$!+$NH+)+p-!')+9;&9);//;WK+ÈzAC¿aAn|+(+B#$N+/!N:#)+A

)C(XÓ&9&|WK¥o9S7FNGj%-/&)!^-!@)!$!A%c)!/^:!)!AC-O)!/

!$*+$!A9$

/C? #-,K

7N9*!c9!)N@+.)p@A$+B.Pc)+'%-!+&/9Bm!m0{[AN9B#7)!\N:

]')!A!-_ _/)+3@;*+++¿@;+%)+nWK¨tX|q)+/a; _c9!Bc%)+)!)+:!+¿@A$+BN

IP#-);|Ca)!+*+9¦-N9|#)!/aNm/+$ºNWo&++!+B;H+N

%)+P&Pc+,;&!1&%A!!9N$%'*!;bC9'-!'W+'b$#'/9'+;9K

`o!3+A+N)+ "b+v+AC+!+,"{I#0L[3ABL-N)+s+$LCo)+-N)+A!t!

@+*+++XKc`1T%)+$N +!$JPc)+'-!')+/)!A!$'+;%)+_ #V!9.N

0L[LA!+B"{)+'\C:^$!@/#.)9"Ç*!9B^&)'V)^V'9)!PmP#+!$NW)!

@9ANV_Ô!Ÿ%K#m!++/)!'V-!)X%(!V/)+#Anm)Y*+9"xN"L)!\N:

:C)CA!-"!'A& ,+!$YN)+(Ó%+%*+s& ,$V!)N@p)!/!$*+$CAN99K

ÈbBi+!+B9H;C:yC½"{)!\N:y:+')CA!-n /')+P 'S(!+:;!N:J)¤I|

+&+*!P#++' ,"#u9'V+(!)5&)!*+;m;Y%A&)Cnm&L&)!A!$

+%c@A#)+!9¦!%K

I´HG

PSR€!ˆ#€aƒCª¤…!~+}b†R‡L}bƒt‡L„KJ¿}~!„%‚†i…!‹a€«†R€

ÒNP#9BuP#:!!.NW{@9N$!+$_#+p$'&"L^AC-YY9)N@;$5')+)!Pc

/A!3)!/L()+'N:5-N9)!-!\C:Y()+A!L*!-$Y)!-!9Ka|mC)"jI

@+B.;\Cs-+&! {7M'+#N$!%&A_%%)+p')C);PL-!+&\N9$."#

/*" u )+AN$5"#\V-5)V2OKXK`bK^)+'$!+L)

Pm;Wx"R?yCs@Q&¦_-!+& J$?'-$À)+A+;&h!)CA!X

++*!9"{N:®Pc ½Å)+'$!+w)j+!+B9H;xÇ|+!$'$CH;W)!

-)!&!&#

V/9& o!!@c$@A&')!N)!!IB¼'++Bpd)!!)!b"{&B;+9'gb9\N

!x/);@Pk)+//Z)j/+&xP#+&!:NWKY`a!i@;@O)+/N P#!

$%A&');_Å9'À!+$?*+ * !/$'Kyf$/11*=;Q+%)

$+I{"L);5VP#!:Y%KŽ&AN@{\!V*+V$N%9AN&')!N& %)+P#

+P#+=9'D-!'*+9! Z$?;@="#N!+$D)Q"#);@\!!:D:!)!A!-

-+&-!++|& Â(NAs )+XÁ@ -A!(+ =@AN&E+DC /N9

@;&)CP#P#+!$&)+n% )+u+N@"L+|6)v!ACs|)+n&p)+AC%$!+'VP&B

$+%t)!¦-N9|WK

`o!An% 5i@JNW"{y@y+'+@$x»Ux/&Ov+A

+9&s%%(CV*+NÔNŸ%K¾3C.%! ,"Lp"#3/!$)#)+B^b!

-+&-!++|& «(NAso+').91!-!A(!+P#++'+!$.'+9&)CNbNW

NWB3"#1!+*+3;$ !$A!'!:L;%3;@t/)!A!oB;+XWK

ÒLA!.@AC$!B^/)+A%;.)C!Y-A!(V+P#+-)!@;$)!5N0L[{AC;B

9)!P#P#++.P#+N:S@ m$!A!:N!@c/)!A!ºB;+X9<b()+A!¼Ï«KÌNÌ!Ì

+P#+&#9O(CY$N*C$!+$!)VN++$N& b(+B^$C+'PmN!:V"#!&

+P#+3+N@"L+;9.)+WKNÒLA!:+)!ab)(A!$.* # H

*) /VP)+$N9{)!$N9#)@)+'V+!$^-)!&!&d(!BYAN%!:

0#[AN9BgtNb/)C'P#&)+&)!-NAN9K

I3´I 3‚‹t„%‚¢X‚bb„X‹1}b¢3}q#Lƒ_‚}b‹)Si‚#~Sc€ Q I

`o!T%);99u@AC$!BT)+/U|9N$C;@$!H9)C¤-!@);9!XP#A_@p_|"R9

%+9P#:+B^%P#-Yv+A;@)CN9<_7N)V+. ) $pN*+)!*+;$

7OC.@!+ ( " 67!9 $, ^$)!9BMC;*+

(9"{++ +9 )+!+ Q7NW /$Q$N)D&B?-!BD?

)C':+;CH9)!

¾mN@"{+:8!!@ v+A;@)!N ')!A!$ $N9" >-!@P#C;B

%)C&)+)!:+&;Pm;-V)!/b!p@9N$C;$H9)Cu-C')+!X9Ka`a!.-A!'-!)N@p)+/

NZ+-!-)!9Åw)h&¦_-!)N%x!\_y(!9"#+Å$!*+$NA!+& M!

)C':+;CH9)!mNWB5|9N$5/)+X oCu&)C+W¦N3p"LN9!9Bp+%| a+!$

N9S/)!(XÓW+%*+!½"{Ii'!@-N9&Y)¤J:!*++»|9N$C;@$_K¨¿)+

n|+!9; «#+'+%)+.(NW"L;9."#)N$!*!$A!+b9c(L!/9''$

(CBY!Y)+C9!#)+/#VP#+!:Y' 9N$5NV')+;.-C&B!9$^(CBV!

N$C*+$A!+l"{.q)C':+;CH9)!3d9);@-N)+'W)+_b)!9+$!+P#9g

9+u(C.¦C'9&9$p/')+Py!m7MFGS"{+(p-!+:!+9K!¾y)+'-!)C9)!!ÑL:+)!9

P:!+(J)J'+AN%¤W¦n@N:J9!N)+);:sB¤)yP#-NP#++T9"

@$!+'$_K¿`o!!'Vv+AN+@)!L$NW+PcC.)+N&+-+AN93'A!WANp)+/

N$!99(N+%)L({@9tAN-_K

3´ ;M Mu ·Œ· O^·¡

`o!%&)!.$;%&'(!!)!A!bP&C)!$!)!);:sBc/);,c@)!+a+!+BN%3)+/

NR7MF!G-A!(L&)!P#Pm;s|bP#+N:m@XK+7L-N@;%C¿)CA!+-N-C')+;&

/)!$CJP);$!:y+!$Z&¦+%);ZdX +%); ¿KÎWgX V)!;:+T+!$

vCA!+B+!:dX «W)!½tKNgX /;!:+N$S!Pm;scd' _W)!1KF!g&K

¾m/;l!!@p$!9+r)C'+++$VP#9N)+$_;C$.)+)!AN%+$pV)+AN-!@)XÓ%+%|

"#)!A+N)+P#-+P#+++BR%)!&)+)!:+&+)!)+,c «&)!LtKaK

3´%³

…p},ˆ#~;‚£y},~;„%‹}q…VL‚q……!„%‰¢X€

T)!$)9¦N-)!p*++B+:!v+AN++;5)!/p!/)!P#9)!N m.

9'&+#)O$!!@:!P#9);$)+)+:+B"LN&+$N!!AP#

!+'*+++)+s6-!)N%%(!!K§{)9"#*!9X NA!Pm;S!-A+c+!$S/;9$N(C;&\

9+#d;$c@N)+A$!ga(3A_'+$L)A!3+!$#+!@&LNL@Bs@+P.K

! "$#%'&(*)!%+,- /.102"#%$##%435067068

B:F"N4F,N7BEAU;SVN7:FBK>/BA"FWF";XF"GBYA2;?KN4;O,;RN4?K@OVAZF=Q[ED\Q5BHN,?2F"BQXN,:]@

ACF,@:5Q@>"Q_^ :F"NF,[`,aBO,@bFN,;:A/G5N,H_Q5N4@R>"@PcN,:edfN,R=5>/B_ghjikBl@>/B

N7:FB>"BA"F"BQmN7:mN4Q5B:FN4S7[N4:JRn@?LF,;>ZAKopFGBqN7:Q5N4rN,Q=5@O"AlF,GJ@bFYH5;ACF

PIBEALAC@RBEAs;:tF,G5BP@N7O4N,:5RuO4N"ACF/hJ^ @?LG(@K=F,G5;>G@A@K:(=:5N,v=B94wuD@:Q

S"N7>ZACF/DPN,QQJO4Bx@K:JQyO4@ACF-:@PB5hz1:j@*?bF,;>1?@K:xGJ@KrB(PI=JOF"N,HO7B(B`,Pt@N7O

@QQ5>"BA6A2BAbhfdf=5>7FGB>/P;>/BD@K:x@?bF,;>-?K@:\G5@rBtP=5O4F,N,H5O4Bt>/;O4BA{M|N4F"GN,:

Q5N4S"S"B>/BK:F}N7:JACF,N4F"=FN7;:A2DWB5hR5h~5B€@]=J:N,rBK>6A/NF,[‚H>/;SBALA2;>}@:Q_@

?K;:AC=JOF,@:F-S,;>s@<?;PtH@:[hƒyB*ALA2@RB*A1@>/B<H;5A"F"B*Q\S7>/;PX@:\B`,Pt@N7O

@QQ5>"BA6AL„…M†B\?L@HF"=J>"BFG5B\Q@KF,BED@=F"G;>6DA2=~ˆ‡2B?2FZD@:QyF,BK‰F;S1B@?G

PIBEALAC@RBJh-Š!G5NAP;QJBKOuN,A‹F,GJBWA"F"@>,F"N,:RyH5;*N7:F;St;*=5>t@:5@O4[JACNA2„{F,GJB

>CB*A2=OFŒ;StF"GBVA2;?N7@O<A2?N4B:FN"A"F"Axv=B>N7B*AjP@L[VO7B@QpF;pN,QB:F"N,S4[N4:5R

;EF,GJBK>-N4:FB>CB*ACFN4:5R<B:FNF,N,BA1@:5Q(>/BKO,@bFN,;:A/G5N,H5A-ŽZM|BtB‰BPIHJO4N7S,[IFGN"AN,:

'B?bF,N,;:\5h‘’2hf“s:?BIFGB<?L;:?BKHF,=5@OP;QB*O”NAsBA"F"@~5O,N,A2GBQJD!M1B•1–6—

Q5@LF"@˜AC;=>C?B*Ap;SyN,:EFB>CB*ACF\F;™B:FNF"N,B*Aš@:Q›>/BO7@KF,N,;:JA2GN,HJAš;S\FGNA

PI;QBOD@:Qœ,5–ž1F"GJBsQ@KF@1A/;=>/?BAN4:F,;;=5>!M|@>/BG5;=ACB5h

dfN7R=>/B†‘‹A2G;M†A{@Q5N,@R>@P›;S”F,GJBH5>";?LBALA=JA2BQ<N4:ŸF,GJB?K@*A2B;S ;=5>

PI@*N7O4N,:5R`O4N"ACF…@HH5O4N,?K@LF"N,;:fh! ¡;:EFB:F¡N"A-BK‰F">/@?bFBKQ(S">/;PX@tP@N,O4N7:JR<O7N,ACF

@>"?GN,rBtN,:@uS"=O7O[Œ@K=F,;PI@F,N7?sM†@b[JDN,:EF;t@ŒACBPN,`"ACF>"=J?2F"=J>"BQ<PBA2A2@RB

M1@>/BG5;=ACB5h<9:S";>/P@KF,N7;:X¢BHFyN,:›F,G5NAšM1@*>"BG;=5A2B}N4:5?O4=5QBAšF,GJB

F"G>/B@QWACF,>/=5?2F=>CB‹;S-F"GB\P@N,O4N7:JRxO4N"ACF|Ž"M1GN,?KGPIBEA2A2@RB‹@:JACM1B>6AIF";

M1GJN7?LGJ’”@EA”M1BO4O$@AF,G5B1@*=EFG;>2DQ5@LF"B*DAC=J~6‡bB?2F$@:5QS"=O7O5FBK‰Ff;S!B*@K?GB`

PI@*N7O"hXz1QJQN4FN7;:J@KO,O4[D€@K:J;KF"GJBK>£M1@>BG;=JA2B¤N,A¥~=5N,OF_F;¦ACF;>/B

N7:S";>"P@KFN4;:<@~;=F @?LF,;>6A;SF,GJB1P@N7O4N,:5RO,N,ACF@*:QtF,GJBKN,> N7:AZFNF,=F,N7;:JAKh

ŠTGNAN7:S";*>CP@KFN4;:?K;PBA S"N,>/ACFfS">/;PF"GB1P@N7O,N,:R|O7NAZF$NF/A2BO,S2o:5@PIBEA”N,:

F"GBx K&x-S"N,BKO,Qy?@K:~5B\=JA2BQyF,;xN7QJBK:F,N7S7[§@K?LF";*>2A6„N4:A"F"N4F"=FN7;*:AI@>/B

N7QB:FN7S,N7B*QlS,>/;P¦F"GBXQ5;P@N,:X:5@PtB*A¨N,:]B`"P@N4OW@Q5Q>/BALA/BA@:Q

BK‰JH5BQ5NFN7;:A©Pt@?GN,:BA¦Ž"ª-«*)¬S"N4BO,Q’Lh£ŠfGNA©?L;=O7Qc~JB

?K;PHJO7BPB:F"BQ~[x;F"GB>N,:S;>/PI@F,N7;:AC;=>/?KB*ALD”S";*>IN4:AZF@:?KB(S,;=J:Q

;:XF,G5B™iW;*>CO,Q›iVN4Q5B™iWB~]Ž"­†Š'ƒx®_;>y¯sƒx®°Q5@LF"@}QBEAC?>CN4~JN4:5R

PI@*N7O4N,:5RO4N"ACFH;JAZFB>/ALDG5;*PtB\H@RBEAt;S1F,G5B\P;>"BxN4PH5;>"F@K:F1@?2F;>/ALD

N7:JACFNF"=F,N7;:JATMB~A/NFB*A2’/D5=JA2N7:RsM>@HH5B>2AKh

,±f² /%7,sJ+!¡³<#.!f02|K0L "* C4<*020L8

ŠTGB<?;:F,B*:F;*S{F,GJBA2BtF,M1;tM†@K>/BG5;=A2BAsNA{FGB\´">/@bMŒ´Q@KF"@*„!M1BuP@K[

B:>CN,?LGxNFM†NF"GxBK‰F>"@N4:JS7;>/P@bFN,;:\;:\@?2F;>6A1@:QjN4:AZFNF,=F"N4;:JAKh$ŠGNA

N7:S";>"P@KFN4;:tNAR@LFGB*>CBQ~[|S"BLF"?GN7:RN4:5S,;>CP@LF"N,;:uS7>/;PFG5BiWB~D~[

M1>/@HH5N4:JR<A2HB?LN,S"N4?1­Šƒj®§H5@RBEAN7:F;†¯-ƒx®h® BLF =JAACF">BALA”F"G@KFfFGNA

H5>";?LBQ=5>/BuN,AIA/BPN7`@K=F,;P@KF,N,?hfŠ!G5BŒAC[ACF,B*P›RB:B>/@bFB*AsH>C;*H5;A2N4F,N7;:JALD

@:Q†FG5B*A2B-:5BBQ1F";1~B1P@:5=@O,O[?L;:S"N7>PIB*Q'h

µ¶"·

¸V¹£º£»¼*½¾¿ÀÁ¿”ÂÛÄsÅuÁf¾Æ{ÇCÂÀ

iWBG5@rBI?G;JACB:tF;t>/BH5>"BA2B:F$;=>”?;:F"B:FfM1@*>CBG5;*=ACBN4:¯1ƒx® DS7;>

F"GB1S,;O7O4;M|N7:R>"B@*A2;:ALo

•

¯-ƒy®k>"BH>/BA2B:FZA{ÈÉ2•Ê4Ë"ÈÌÍÎÏÌ,ÎEÍÉLž<N,:5S,;>"Pt@LFN7;:D'N,:tM|G5N4?G ACF,>/=5?2F=>/BQ™QJ@KF,@Ž/BhRhS";*>jB*@K?G™PBA6A2@KRB*DŸB`"P@KN,OAy@K:JQ

QJ@bFBA2’$?K@:~B1PN‰B*Q†M|N4F,Gt>"@KMVFBb‰JFfŽCPBA6A2@KRB-~5;Q[’Lh

•

¯1ƒx®kN"AJœ4ÉÊ5œ4Éo5:JBbM˜N7:S";>"Pu@bFN,;:<?K@:(~B@QQJBKQ<@KF$MN4O7O

~[1@QQJN4:5R1:JBbMqBO4BPB:FZA”;>@KF4F>/N4~5=F"BEA

•

¯1ƒx®°N,ApN7:F,B:Q5BQ F;›~BUFGBUO,@:R=@RB ;S§FGBiWB~JD Pu@K¢JN4:5R(NF{A2=N4F@K~JO4BŸF,;<F"GJBtM1>/NFN7:R(;S”͈–2——É2ÍLȆS";>iWB~

HJ@RBA ;> ;KF"GJBK>$Q5@KF,@-S";=:5Q;:IF,GJB{ikB~h

•

zXPt@N7O,N4:5R(O7N,ACF…G5@*AI@:\N,:GJBK>/B:F…́ÍÉLÉÈLÌ4ÍLÎ5Ï*Ì4ÎÍLÉuŽ"PBALAC@*RB z›NA{F"GJBt?LGJN7O4Q(;SPBALAC@*RB N,S @:AZM|B>6AF";|z1’2D5MGN,?LG

>/Bv=5N4>/BA @s:JBACFBQI>/BH5>/B*A2BK:F"@LF"N4;:S";>/P@KF$A2=?GI@EAT¯-ƒj®…h

•

¯1ƒx®˜>"BP@N4:A<Èʕ — œ7É\F;y=:5QB>/ACF@:5Qh;?N7;*O7;RNAZFZAŸ?@:

R>/@A2H<FGBBK‰FB:F¡@K:JQtF,G5B¢5N4:JQ<;SFGBIN,:5S,;>"Pt@LFN7;:(ACF;>/BQ

N,:1F"GJB{M|@>"BG;=JA2BA5‡L=JACFf~[|>/BK@QN,:R†F,GJB{¯-ƒx®xQ@KF,@5h

ŠTGB>/BS";>/B*D!S";> F"GJN,As@K:JQ<P@:[<A2N,PN7O4@*>@HH5O4N,?@bFN7;*:A2D¯sƒx®N"A@>/B@KO

ACF"BH S";>"M1@*>CQ S,;>xv=5@:FNF"@KF,N,rBA/;?LN7;O,;RN,?L@O<@:@O4[A2N,ALD1M1GJN7?LG G5@*A

F">/@Q5N4F,N7;:@O4O4[£~B*BK:£?K@>/>"N,BQ_;=F N,: FGBe?L;:F,B‰F};S™>BO7@LFN7;:J@KO

Q5@KF,@~@A/BAKh ŠfG5B(?LG5;N,?KB(;S¯sƒx®V:J@bF=>C@*O4O[(O,BK@*Q5A1F,;\=JA2N4:5R<¯|=B*>7[

NFZACBO,Sy@*Ap@:XN4:FB>C>/;R@LF"N,;:XO7@:5R*=5@RBoF"GJB™BL‰H>/BALA2N4rB H;EM|B>;S

¯s=JBK>"[x@O,O7;KMIAIF,G5B(S";>/P=5O4@KFN4;:j;*SsF,G5B(?K;*PIHJO7BL‰kv=B>"N,BA1F"G@KFM|B

:5BBQŽ6A/BB<BK?LF,N,;:‹5h‘’/D@:5Q(NFA-QB*?LO7@>/@KF,N7rB:@KF,=5>/BP@¢BANF P=J?LG

B@ACN,B>TF;1=JA2BF"G@:@OFB>":J@bFN7r*B1O4@:R=@*RBAA2=?G@AT¯†®TŠh

µ-¶

¿ ¼¿Ç/¼*Á¾ÇC†À¿”ÂuÙÁf¾!ǛÁ'Â1¼

z]:5=Pt~B>1;*S1H>C@?LF"N4?@KO-N,ALA2=BAI>/B*v=N,>"BQFGB=JA2B<;S-@K=F,;PI@F,N7?u@:Q

A2BPN7`,@=F";*Pt@LF"N,?S"N4O4F"B>/N7:R1@:QuBK:J>"N7?GPB:F2o

•

ŠGBt:@PB;S@:tN4:ACF,NF=F"N,;:uPI@[@HH5B@>M>"N4F7F,B*:tN,:tP@:[

QJN7S,S"B>"B*:EF‚M1@[AKh›iWB QBr*N"A/BQ¦RB:B>N7?mH@F4F"B>:A F,;

>/B?L;R:JNBWF"G@KFx´65=J:pƒWN4?>/;AC[EACF,BPuA§9:5?h4´\NA§F,GJBA/@PB

N,:A"F"N4F,=FN4;:›@Ap´65=J:'´x@*:QX´"ƒ@A2A2@?KG=ACBKF,FAj9":AZFNF,=F"B ;S

ŠB?KG:5;*O7;RK[˜ŽZƒx9ZŠ!’L´WN,AšFG5B}A2@PB™@*AU´"ƒx9ZŠ”´Lhtdf=5>,F"GJBK>

N,Q5B:F,N,S"N,?L@KF,N7;:<?L@:<~JBQ;:BPt@:5=@O4O4[Ž/B5hRhF;=5:Q5B>6ACF,@:Q

FG5@LFt´/?B>CNACB*:EF6h?L;P<´N"At@ikB~WA/NFB(~B*O7;:JRN,:R\F,;y´"ƒ@>¢

® ;*RN,? ;>"HJ;>/@KF,N,;:´/’2h

•

z€H5B>6A2;:y?@K:xGJ@KrB‹A2BKrB>C@*OQN,S"S,B>/BK:F-B`,PI@*N7O@QQJ>"BA2A2B*AL„

N,Q5B:F,N,S"N,?L@KF,N7;:;*S<H5B>2A2;*:AP=JACFF"G=A(~5ByQ;:By;:WF,G5BN7>

:J@PBALD @:Qj:J;KF|;:FG5BN7>-@QQ5>"BEA2A2BA1Ž"@ALA/=5PN,:R<FG@FF,M1;

HJB>/A2;:AšQ;™:J;KF‹G5@rBVF"GB A2@PB:5@PB’Lh1dN4>6ACF‹:@*PIB*ALD

;HF"N,;:J@KOPN,QQ5O4B:@PB1@:Q<O4@AZFT:@*PIB|@>"BBb‰JF,>/@?2F"B*QtS,>C;P

FG5BmS"=O7O‚:@*PIB QBA2?L>/N4HF"N4;:JD]PI@*¢N,:5R HJ;ALA2N4~5O4B FGB

@ALA/N7PN,O7@LFN7;:u;S´"dfN7>6A"F@PBs® @*ACFt@PtB´ @:Q´7®T@ACFt@PtB*D

d$N7>ZACF@KPuB´ S,;>N,:5ACF@:5?LB5h

•

ŠGB>/Bp?L@*:U~B ´/G;O4BEAK´\N4:F"GJBšF,GJ>"B@Q¨ACF">"=J?2F"=J>"BV;StFGB Pu@KN,O7N4:JRtO,N,ACF Ž/O7;EACF B`"P@N7OA2D?L;>C>=5HF"BQ<P@KN,OfG5B@Q5B>6Abh4h4h’ S";>

MGN,?KGS,@¢B1PBA2A2@RBAP=JACFf~5B-@QQ5BQ!h

µ-¶7µ

W½! ZÁ"™Á!Â|¼¿¾Æ}»J½Ç/½/½À¡Ç#f¿-¼½½$6»

ŠTGB(Q@KF,@t@=F,;PI@F,N7?L@O,O[(?L;O4O7B*?2F"BQ<M|N7O4O¡~Bu?K;*PtHO7BPtB:F,B*Q~[<P;>"B

v=@O,NF"@KF,N,rB1Q@KF@1A/;=>/?BALDJA2=?G@A”N,:F"B*>"rN4BKMALDF"B*?LG5:N7?L@*OQ5;?=PtB:FALD

;=FZA2N4Q5B>ZA&%›A/=5>"rBL[JALDN4:n;>"Q5B>™F";_=:JQB*>/ACF"@:5Q_GJ;KMcN,:Q5N4rN,Q=J@KO

ACF">"@F"BRN4BAH5@>"F"N4?N7H@KF,B-F,;†F,GJBsO,@>CRB> HN,?2F=>/B5h9":QJN7rN,Q=5@O"A N7:Jr;O4rBKQuN4:

F"GJB\A"F"@:QJ@K>/QN'*@LF"N,;:xH5>";?LBALAQ;\:5;KF|;:JO[x>"BH>/BA2B*:EF¡F"GJB<rN,BKM1H;N,:EF

;S\FGBN7>N4:A"F"N4F"=FN4;:5AL„tFGB[™@OA2;UG@r*BpF"GBN,>x;KM:}Bb‰HB*>7F"NACB @:Q

~5BO4N,BKSZA‹M†GN,?LGN,PH5@?bFuF"GBN4>‡2=JQRPB:FŒ@:Q ACF"@LFBKPuBK:FAKh(-B*A2N4Q5B*ALD

H5B>/A2;*:5@O>"BO,@bFN7;*:ACGJN4HA1Ž/~;EF,GxS,>/N7B:5QJA2GN7H‹@:Q\@:N7P;JACN4F,[’-N4:5S,O7=JBK:J?LB

F"GJB<QB*?LN"A2N4;:\P@¢N,:5R(H>/;?BA6AKh! ¡O7B*@K>/O4[D A2=5?LG‹>CBO,@KF,N7;:JA2GN7HJA1@>CBu:5;KF

>CB*?L;>Q5BQWN7:yFGByP@KN,O,N4:5RyO,N,ACF6h”dfN,:5@O7O4[ED…FG5BxN4Q5B:FN4S"N,?L@KFN4;:W;*StGN7R*G

ACF"@LF"=AšN4:JQN7rN,Q5=@O,AyMNFG›>/BK?;R:N'*BKQ›@*=EFG;>"NF,[};:™FGBVF"B?LGJ:N7?@KO

A2=5~6‡bB?LF-N"A:5;KF|ACF>"@N,RGF,S;>,M1@>/Qh¡Š!GNAtACF@bF=JAIN,AI;*S7F,B:\N,PH5O4N,?LNFZD@:Q

@OF,GJ;=5R*GNFŒN"A\¢J:;M|:~[WF"GJBVACHJBK?N7@O,N"A"F/A\¢:5;KM†O4BQ5RB*@K~JO4BWN7:pFGB

S"N7BO,QDN4FfP@K[|>CBPt@N,:IGJN4Q5QB:1F;1@:;=FZACN,QB>Lh

9":VRB:B>/@O"D{FGByGJN7B>/@K>/?GE[šACF,>/=5?2F=>/N,:RyF"GBVAZF@:5Q@>/QN'@KFN4;:A/;?KN4@O

A2H@*?LBN"Ay?;:JS7N,>/PIB*QU~[FGB¨v=@O4N4F"@LF"N,rB@*:@*O[EA2N,Ay;SF"GB@*?2F";>/A&%

H5B>C?LB*HEFN,;:!h

)¶

*¸,+-*/.,0¹1*32,435,4608792

)¶;:

¿ ¼¿¿fÄ1ÅÇ/»5Ç/¼Ç6½”Â

“s=J><BK‰JH5B>CN,PBK:F"@LFN4;:VQ5B@OFuM1N4F,GšFGB

[email protected]

PI@*N7O4N,:5R€O,N"A"FMGN7?LG_NA™F,G5B]i=< ¤H=J~O7N,?]O4NACF S7;>˜AC=5~PuNF7FN4:5R

?K;PPuBK:FA§;*:šFGBjHJ>/;H5;A2BQy¯-=B>"[D¯u®TŠ¨‘h>W@:5Qy¯@?f@KFGy‘fh>

>CB?;PtPB:5Q@KFN4;:JAKhJz Pu@KN,O4N,:5R(O7N,ACF…@>"?GN,rBtM1@EA†;*~F@KN,:BQ\S">";P F,GJB

H5=~5O4N,?™P@N4O,N7:RXO7NAZFšA2BK>/rB>p@:JACM|B>"N,:5R F";›B`,Pt@N,O,AšF";

public-qt- [email protected]

@:QpF"GB: ?L;:rB>7FBQpF";W@6A1:JN‰V•BC

S";>/P@KF/h$Š!G5BuPI@*N4O7N,:RO4NACF¡?L;:F@N4:5BQxED‘8D(PBALAC@R*BAs@KF FGB1FN7PB;S

BK‰F">/@?bF,N,;:'h

zF?B>/O-A2?L>CN,HFM@*A†M>"N4F,F,B:\F";\?L;:rB>7F-F,G5N,At@>/?LG5N,rB<N7:F;ŸFG5Bt¯-ƒx®

w1@KF@ƒ;QJBKO1QBA/?K>/N4~JBKQN7:k'B?bF,N,;:HG!h,gh Š!GJN,A<AC?>"N,HF-=JA2BA†FGBI?$B>CO

JW#4%/CK.#)MLG8NPO-P;Q=O,BŸF;\~5=N,O7Q\F,GJBŸFG>CB@QACF,>/=5?2F=>CB*D~@ACB*Q

;:RQL@*PIN,BTS¡@bMN4:AC¢JN7A F"G>/B@Q5N4:JR_@KO,R;>/NF"GJPUL,E<PO/hxzI?2F;>6A›@:Q

N7:JACFNF"=F,N7;:JA{N,:S";>"Pt@LFN7;:tM|B>/B@KOA2;tR*B:5B>/@bFBQ<~[F"GJN,A1AC?>"N,HF/hf5;PB

@?2F";>/A\MB>CBV:;F(Bb‰JF">"@*?2F"BQJD1MGB: NFM|@A\N,PH5;ALA2N4~JO7ByF,;VBK‰F">/@?bF

@=F";Pu@bFN,?L@O4O[Œ@<S7=JO4O:@PBtS>C;*P FGBIVK&xV<S"N,BO7QhfŠ!GJN,A{M|@A{F,GJB

?K@*A2BD5S;>N,:AZF@:?BD5;S$@s:=5P~JBK>;S$A2H@PuAKh

iW>/@KHJHB>6A†S;>{­IŠ'ƒx®V@:Q¯1­†Š'ƒx®yMB~HJ@KRB*A1Ž";:O4[<@*r@N,O4@~O7BF";

i=<5 XPBKPu~B>/A2’tQJBA2?L>/N,~N7:RjFG5BxO4NACF;SPIB*PI~B>ZAŸ;S-F"GJB¯-=5B>"[

i=<5 ¤M;>/¢N7:R£R>;=H M|B>/Be@*O"A/; M|>/NF4FB:JDN7:£;>CQB>›F,;£@QQ

N7:S";>"P@KFN4;:\@~;=EF…PtBP~5B>2A2GN,H\N,:F"GBt¯-=B>7[(M1;*>C¢JN4:5R(R>/;=H(F";

F"GB1@?bF,;>6ATM|@>"B*G;=ACB5h

)¶"·

¹q½Ã1ÁW#XÄ1ÅÁf¾fÇCÁ$»¿ ÂÛ¾!Áf»ÅBC¼*»

“s:J?KBF"GB-Q5@LF"@-NA”BK‰F>C@?LF"BQ@?L?K;>"QJN4:5RsF;sFGB1?L;:?BHF=@*OQ@F"@-P;QBO

N7:F;†FGBPIBEA2A2@RB*ALD5>/BACHJBK?LF,N,rBO4[JD5@?2F;>”¯-ƒx®\M1@*>CBG5;*=ACBEA2D5M1B-RBKFf@

S"N7>ZACF<O,BKrBO<;S<N7:S";>"P@KFN4;:;:pFG5N,A\QJ@KF,@y~[W@H5HO[EN4:5RW;=J>t¯=P

R>@HG5N,?L@OIF;;O3L,K‘YO<;:šFGBy¯sƒx®˜Q;?L=JPIB*:EFZAbhdf;><N,:5ACF,@*:?BD{F,GJB

R>@HG5N,?L@O™>"B*H>/BA/B:F"@LFN7;:qQ5B>CN4rBQ£~[_¯†5=5P S">/;PcF"GJB€@?bF,;>

M1@>/BG5;=ACB1N,AQBHN,?2F"B*QIN,:1dfN7R=>/BZ<h

!Z[f]\t*#.f4#%!06'&<&‹#b3J+! /.# 0 ³u#.0LK8

¯=P^LE‘8OX?K;*PtH=F,BA€@£ACF">=5?2F=5>"@OXA/=5PP@>"[_;S™F,G5Be¯-ƒx®

Q5;?=PIB*:FD”@:5Q‹@(A2BbF…;S-A2N,PHO7B(ACF,@KFN,ACFN4?AKh5df;>N,:JACF"@:5?LBDfN7:<dN4R=>/B

<D!F"GB>B@>/Bt‘W_EGxN,:5ACFNF=EFN,;:\BO7BPtB:FALD!B*@K?G;S M1GJN4?KG(G5@*As@KF¡O,B@ACF

gD@:Qy@F1P;JAZF@G:@*PIB*ALD”@EAIN,:QJN7?L@F,BQx~E[‹F,G5Bx´gEoGf´O4@~BO;:§F,GJB

BQRB-~BKF,M1BB:1F"GJBsN,:JACF,NF=F"N,;::5;*Q5B-@:QIN4FZA”?GN,O,QIO,@~5BO7BQt:@PBh

¯s=JBK>"[Œv=5B>/N7B*ALDM†GN,?LG<M1B>/BIHJ>";?KB*ALACB*Q<~[1F,GJB1N¯}AZ[JACF,B*PFL‘fEO2h

^@?G]v=5B>"[›~>/N7:RJApN,:S";>/P@KF,N7;: F"GJ@bFx?@:}~5B =JA2BQUF;™r@O7N,Q@KF,B

BK‰N,ACFN4:5RG[H;F,G5BEACNAj@:5QS";*>CP=O,@KF,BW:5BKM°;:BEAbhŠfG5BVAC;?LN,;O4;R*N7?@KO

N7:F,B>/H>/BLF"@F,N7;:u;S!F,GJBs>/B*A2=O4FZA”@HH5B@>/AN4:Œ5B?2FN7;:uh<'h

dN,>/ACFZD@\?K;*PIHJO7BLFB\O7N,ACF|;S1N,:5ACF,N4F=EFN,;:AN"ABb‰JF">"@*?2F"BQxS,>/;PXF"GJB@?bF;>

M@K>/BG5;=JA2ByF,G5>";=JRG@Wv=B>7[h^T@?KGVN4:A"F"N4F=EFN4;:pNAŸF,GJB:pP@:5=@O,O[

@:5:;F,@KF,BQMNF"Gu;:B-;S'FG5B-S";O,O4;M1N,:R1F4[HBAKojS;>9Š?K;*PtH@:N7B*ALD

S";> @*?L@QBPN7? N7:JACFNF"=FN7;:ALD S";>c:5;KF`"S,;>`"H5>";S,NF

;>/R@*:N@KFN4;:5AXA2=?KG_@*A™F"GBXzI  ƒkDkFGB i=<J  BKF,?h"D

S";>

H5>/;rN4Q5B>6Aj;SŸ9,:F"B>/:BKF(@?L?BALAx@:QUB*PI@N,O<ŽCQ=JByF";WF,G5BWBL‰5F>"@?2FN7;*:

H5>/;?BKQJ=>/B*D†M|BW?K;*O7O4B?LF,BQ v=JNF,BW@WO,;F<;S(A2=J?LGH5>";rN,QB>6A2DuACN,PIHJO[

~5B?L@=JA2B‚@K?LF,;>2AXA2B:Q£BK`"P@N4OA S">;Pc@*?L?K;=:FA GJ;ACF,BQ£~[lFGB

H5>/;rN4Q5B>6A2’/DxS";>tHB>ZA2;:@O-Q;PI@*N4:y:5@*PIB*ALD@:Q

S";>

F"GJB\>"BP@N4:JN7:RA2NF,BEAtŽC@~5;*=F†! ‹’2hŠfGNAIF,[H;O4;RK[§N"At>/B`,N7:6‡LB?2FBQxN4:

F"GJBjM|@>"BG;=JA2BD1@O7O,;KM|N7:JRW=5A<F";W=ACByN4FuS";><S,=5>7FG5B>tN,:F"B*>">/;R*@KF,N7;:h

ŠTGB:JDFGBs:J=Pu~B>;SN,:JACF,NF=F"N,;:A”S";> B@?LGIF4[EHB-M1@*A?L;PIHJ=F"BQ!h

ŠTGB\:J@KF,=5>@O1v=BAZFN7;*:jM;=JO4QjFG5B:y~JBF";x?L;PH=FBF,G5B(:5=P~5B>;S

PtB*ALAC@RB*A HB>}@K?LF";*>U~JBKO,;:JRN7:JR]F,;lB*@K?GlF4[HB];SN4:AZFNF=F"N4;:JAKh

­;KMBrBK>6DFGNAN,A{:;F>/B@O4O4[=A/BS"=O~B?L@=JA2B1@:u@K?LF;>P@L[~BO4;:R1F,;

Pt@:[xN,:JACF,NF=F"N,;:A6D{H;F,B:FN7@O7O4[x;SuA/BrB>"@*O{F,[HBAbhƒ;>/B;rB>6D

D

"#I@:Q

;>/R@:N@KF"N4;:JA{M|BK>/B1:J;KF ?L;:JA2N7QB>BQtN,:F"B>BAZFN7:R

S";>!F"GBA/;?LN7;O,;RN,?L@O@:5@O4[A2NAbh

ŠTGB>/BS";>/B*DIM1BW>/BS"N7:BQ ;=5>(?L@KFBKR;>/N@KF,N7;:~[VQJBKrN,A2N,:RV@VA2BLF(;S

N7:F,B>/BACF,N,:5R<E+Z,%40D'M|G5B>/BtB@?GH>/;S7N,O7Bu?L;:5A2NAZFZAs;S-gD5‘fD;>P;>"B

F7[HBAt;*SIN4:ACF,NF=F"N,;:Abh$1=B>7[ g<Ž"~JBKO,;M1’1?;PH5=FBA JÍ<ɖÏ$–Ï*Ì7Í

Ì%$ɗT͝Ê7œ,ɞÉbÍÊ&EÉLžÍ• Ì$ÉÊ'ÈÌ7Ê4Ì,ÎÌ7Ê,'5È($É ÉKœ,')È-Ì4!o

let $actors:=doc("actors_info.xml")/actors_info/actors let $institutions:=doc("actors_info.xml")/actors_info/institutions let $functions:=doc("actors_info.xml")/actors_info/functions let $ac:=element actor_categories{

for $a in $actors/*

let $c:=distinct-values(

for $f in $functions/*[@actor_id=$a/@id and @institution_id !='xquery']

let $i:=$institutions/*[@id=$f/@institution_id]

where $i/@category='org' or $i/@category='corp' or $i/@category='univ' return $i/@category)

return element actor { $a/@id,

attribute category {string-join((for $t in $c order by $t return string($t)),'_')}

} }

return element actor_categories { for $t in distinct-values($ac/*/@category) let $a:=( for $actor in $ac/*[@category=$t]

return <actor>{$actor/@id}</actor>) order by $t

return <category cat="{$t}">{$a}</category>

}

-=B*>Z[ŒgoLz1?LF,;>2A >/BKR>";=H5BQt~[|N7:JACFNF,=F,N7;:?L@KFBKR;>/N,BA

iWBtGJ@KrBuBKO,N7PN,:@KF,BQ<F"GBt¯Bs=JBK>"[tM|;>"¢5N,:R<R>";=5H(NF/A2BO7S S">/;P™FGB

´";>"R@K:JN'@F"N4;:´?K@F,BR;>7[h*BBHN,:RxN4FsM†;=5O4QVA/¢5BLM€;=>|@:@O[EA2N,ALD

ACN,:?BtN4F M;=JO4Q@>"F,N,S"N4?N7@O7O4[<~;@*ACF”FG5Bu;>/R@:JN@LF"N,;:ACH@>"F,N,?KN4HJ@bFN7;*:

@A2BQx;:(F"GNA†?@LF"BR;>/N'@KFN4;:JD”Ì$É+'ΕB5É2Í<\•|É2ÈLȖ)É2ÈuʁÈLȈÎ5ÉLžH-,

–5ÏÌ7ÍLȝÉK–Ï$¡— ÍLÊ,œ,ÉN"A ;~F@KN,:5BQ~[|@HH5O[N,:R1=B>7[|‘tŽ/~BO4;M|’bo

let $threads:=doc("public-qt/public-qt.xml")/threads let $actors:=doc("actors_info.xml")/actors_info/actors let $ac:=doc("actor_categories.xml")/actor_categories return element messages_count {

for $t in $ac/category let $c:=sum(

for $ac in $t/actor/@id let $a:=$actors/actor[@id=$ac]

return count($threads//message[@author=$a/emails/email]) )

return <count category="{$t/@cat}">{$c}</count>

}

-=5B>"[s‘$o#=5P~JBK>;SfPtB*ALAC@R*BA”S";>@?LF";>6A ;SfB@?KGN,:JACF"NF=F"N,;:

?L@KFBKR;>/N,BA

“{FG5B><v=B*>CN4BEAIM1B\HJBK>/S";*>CPBQ?L;:?B>C:xF"GBxQBHF"G;S1F,G5>"B*@QJALD@:Q

F"GBN,>1O,BK:JRKF"GxN,:xPIBEA2A2@RB*At~[h ŠfG5B(>CBH5@>"F"NFN,;:x;SFG>/B@QJAI~[<FG5BN7>

O7B:5RKFGN"A¡A2G;EM|:tN4:1d$N7R*=5>"BZGfh

Number of threads by length in messages

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 to 35

!/.fWK.*#)<),0L "0f /703%,K$ /.8

iWBW:5;F"N,?LByF"GJ@bFŒ@WO7@*>"RBW:=JP~B*><;SF"G>/B@QJA?K;:JA2N,ACFu;S‡L=5ACFu;:JB

PIBEALAC@RBVŽ/:;p@:JACM|B>"’Lh [VN4:A2HB?2FN7:RWF"GBWPuBALA/@RBAFGB*PtA2BO,rBA

@:QWN7:FB>"rN7BLM|N7:JRyH@>7FN7?LN,H5@:FA<;S1F"GB\iV;>/¢WR>/;=5HJD{M|Bx?K;*:5?LO,=QJB

F"G@KFFG5B*A2BsPBA6A2@KRBA @K>/B|A2HO7N4FfN7:S";*=5>>/;=RGO4[1BEvE=J@KOf?LO,@ALA2B*AKo

gh H@P Ž"PBALAC@R*BA”?;PH5O,BbFBO[|=5:>/BO4@KFBKQ1F;sFG5BF";HJN4?K’

‘$h ƒBA6A2@RBA O7BS7FMNFG5;=Ff@:@K:AZMB>Lh

<fh ƒBA6A2@RBA1@:AZM†BK>/BQJD~5=FM|GB>/BIFGBt@:JACM|B>M1@EAsH5;ACF,B*Q

@A @s:JBbM PtB*ALAC@*RBDQJ=BsF,;1F,G5B-=ACB*>"A?LG5;N,?LB5h

G$h ƒBA6A2@RBA@:ACM|BK>/BQJD~=FfM1GJBK>/BsFGBI@:A"MB>@HH5B@>6A”@A @

:JBbM PBALAC@R*B1Q=5BF";1P@N4O,B>”Ž/PN,A2`"’"?;:S"N4R=>/@KF,N,;:h

ŠTGBHJ>"BA/B:?KB;*Sš´>/BK@O/´\:;`,@:JACM1B>‹PIBEA2A2@RBEAjŽ"?O7@*ALA§‘J’\?@:~JB

BK‰JH5O4@N,:BQ@AS,;O7O4;M†AKo

@5h ƒ;JAZF‹;SŸFGBA2BVPIB*ALA2@RB*Aj>/BS"B>F;W® @ACF( @O,OIiW;>"¢JN4:5R

w|>C@*SF N"hBJh>CB*A2=5OFT;SH=5~O,N4?s>"B*rN7BMH>/;?BA2AL„F"GBK[|@>"BsF,@*¢B*:

@AtN,:H5=F1~[\FGB(i21]@:QQ5;x:;EF|:5BBQxF";x~B\BK‰JH5O,N4?NF,O4[

@:JACM|B>"BQh

~fh ;PBt;S F,G5BP›@>"BH;5A"F"BQ<S,>C;P H5@*>7F"N,?LN,H@*:EFZAN,:IFG5Bsik;>/¢

1->C;=HWN4F/A/BO4S/D@:QšF,GJBjQNA2?L=A6A2N7;:P@K[x?;:F,N,:5=B\;:jF,GJB

H5>N7r@LF"B P@N4O,N7:R™O,NAZFxŽ"FG=A2D<;=EFZA2N4Q5BFGB A2?L;HB ;S‹;=5>

@:@O4[A2N,A2’Lh

F,;<>CB*HO4[tF;t@O,OTF,GJB?K;PPuBK:FA

BA2HB?LN,@O4O4[uBQNF;>/N7@O ;:5B*A

N4:JQN7rN4Q5=@O,O[h

zIP;:R™F"GB O7;*:5RB>xF"G>/B@QJALDŒM|B :5;KFN7?LBFG5@LF\‘X@:Q!<5`,PBALAC@*RB

F"GJ>"B@QA@>"Buv=5NFB-N7PH5;*>ZF@:F„FG>/B@QO7B:5RF"GP@K[|>CB@?G<5JD~J=EF$S,>C;P

g&<pF;<JpPBALA/@RBA6D†F,GJBK>/ByNA1‡L=JACFt;*:5BjFG>/BK@QVN,:šF,GJBy>/BA2HB?2FN,rB

?K@KF,B*R;>Z[JhfŠGN"A-?K;>/>/B*A2H;:QAF";tFGBtS"@?2F¡F,G5@LFF,GJBtP@N,O4N7:R(O4N"ACF¡NAsS";>

ϝ•-•1É'J́ÈbDŸM|GN,?G›;S7F,B:›>/B*v=N7>BUHJ=:5?2F=5@O\@:JACM1B*>/ALDŸ@*:Q›>/@>/BO[

[N7BO,QIO,B:5RKFG[|Bb‰?KG@:RB*AKh

iVBG@rB@O,A2; S";O,O7;KM|BQFGBVBr;O4=F"N4;:JDIN,:F"N,PBDt;S<FGBVB`"P@N7O

@Q5Q>/BALA/BA;S@1S"BM@?bF,;>6AbhJŠfG5B*A2B1v=B*>"N7B*ALD5@:5Q@KO,O;F"GB>$Q5;?=PIB*:EFZA

@:5Quv=5B>/N7B*A”M1B-=A/BQJD5?L@:~5B-S7;=:5Q@KF$L >8O2h

)¶ ½ fÇ2½$6½ÀÇ!¿-Ç/Â1¼*Á¾W 1¾fÁ'¼¿ ¼Ç/½Â

ŠTGB(S7N,>6AZF{ACF"BH\;S-A2;?N7;O,;RN,?L@O@:@O[A2N,A†?;:JA2N,ACF/As;*SN7QB:FN4S7[N4:5RtFGB

N7:AZFNF,=F"N4;:JAN4:5r;O,rBQN,:†FGBsPuBALA/@RBA ;:†FGBsHJ=~5O,N4?sP@N7O,N7:R1O,NAZF6h

zI:\@:5@O4[JACNA1;SB*`7Pu@KN,O@QQJ>"BA2A2BEA†;*Ss=JA2B>2A1HJ;ACF"N4:JR;*:§F,GJBtP@N4O,N7:R

O7NAZF¡A/G5;M†A”F"G@KF$P;5ACF$;S!FGB*P™?L;PB1S">/;P9/Š(K&($#E,0oE< xhŠGB

:5BK‰F¡Pt;ACF¡>/BH5>"BA2B:F,B*QR>";=H?;:F"@N7:JAsB`"P@N4O @Q5Q>/BA2A2B*AsG;JAZFBKQ(@bF

r@*>"N7;*=Ae9,:FBK>/:BKF€H>/;rN7QB>ZALDUM1GJN4?KG¬Q5;¬:;F]R*N7rBq=Al=ACBS=O

N7:JS7;>/P@bFN7;*:_@~;=FFGB€;>R@:5N@KF,N,;:5A›;SFG5BN7>};KM:B>/AKo6<EG xh

1«E02, 73 B`,Pt@N7O£@Q5Q>/BALA/BA >"BH>/BACB*:EF g;D ‹„eN7:QJBKHJBK:JQB*:EF

ŽCS>"BBO4@:?BK’19Špf5+"0L02,$#E%,0tPu@K¢JB=H ‹D!MGN7O,B-D _;S-BK`"P@N,O,A

?K;PBsS>";PU:;:`"H5>;S,N4FE# b# /40h

iVBG@rB(@:@O4[&*BQF"GJB<:=5P~5B>s;S@?2F;>/ALD@:QFG5B<PBALA2@RBA1F,G5BL[

N"ALA/=5BQD!S";*>s@uR>;=H(;SA2BrB:\H>/;S"N,O4BAbhikBt;~F"@N7:JBKQ<FGB<S,;O7O4;M|N7:R

Q5NAZF>CN4~J=F"N,;:!o

?$>";S"N4O,B @?LF,;>ZA JH;JA"F"BQPuALACRJALh

 ;*PIHJ@K:JN7B*A g< ‘WD8_N

A1:N,rBK>6ACN4FN4BA <8N ggb‘

“->/R@:N@LF"N,;:A <8< g;N

 ;PuH@*:N,B*A A|:N7rB>6ACN4F"N,BA < E<‘

 ;PH@:N7BA “s>/R@:N@LFN7;:A ‘J‘ g&>JE‘

A|:5N,rB>/A2N4F,N7B*A “s>/R@*:N*@bFN7;*:A D <PD

;:uA/H5B?LN,S7N,BQ D D8_!g

K 6#% [ [ ±

d>/;P F"GNAQ5N,ACF>"N7~J=F"N4;:DM|BA2BB-F"G@KF$S">";P™@~5;*=F <P> >tHJB;H5O4B|G@*rN7:R

H5;ACFBKQ(@LF O7B*@ACF ;:BPt@N7O$;:tFGBO7NAZFZDg;DP><@>/BI?;:J:B*?2F"BQtF;@bFTO4B@ACF

@ ?;PtH@:[h¨Š!GBA2B_S"N,>/ACFX>/BA2=O4F/A€A2G;McF"GJ@bFX?;PH5@:5N,B*A @*>"B

Q5;PuN4:5@LF"N,:RjFG5BxN4:ACF,N4F"=FN7;*:5@O1O7@*:QAC?@KHJBh{Š!G5BN7>uBK‰F">BPBO[rN"A/N7~JO4B

Q5;PuN4:5@LF"N,;:_N,:eF,B>/PtA›;S @?2F;>6A HJ>"BA/B:F N7:eFGB]P@N4O,N7:R€O7N,ACF

G5N,RG5O4N,RGEFZA F,G5BmN7:F,B>"BACF‚;S£AC=J?LG¦?K;*PIHJ@K:JN7B*AnN4:©FGB¬i=< 

ACF"@:5Q@>/QN'@F"N4;:\H>/;?LBA2AKh$ŠGN"A1?@K:\~JB<Bb‰HO7@N4:JBKQx~[tFGB<N4PtH@?2F…;S

i,<  >/B?L;PPIB*:QJ@bFN,;:c;: F,G5B A2=??BALA ;S¬@©FBK?G:5;O4;RK[

?K;PPB>"?N4@O7N*BQ}~E[¨@?K;*PIHJ@K:[DIF,GJ=JA§FG5BVBK?;:5;*PIN,?WN,:EFB>"BEAZF‹;S

?K;PH@:N7BA N7:1FGBsPu@K¢JN4:5R1;Sf>CB?;PPtB:5Q@KFN4;:JAKh

ŠTGB€A2B?;:5Q°AZFBH€;S ;=5> @:5@O[JA/N"A™NAUF,;€rBK>/N4S7[€N,SWF,G5BXO7@>/RB

H5@>7FN,?LN7H@KFN4;:<;S ?L;PH5@:[uBPHO7;[BB*A{NA{>/BS,O,BK?LF"BQ<N4:IFG5B|r;O7=PB;S

F"GJBKN,>xH5;ACF,N,:5RAyN,:UF,GJBP@N4O,N7:R O7NAZF(FG5>"B@QALh<ŠfG5=JALDIM1B :5BBQUF,;

Š!GJBj@=F,GJ;>6AŸ@*>"ByR>/@LF"B*S7=JOsF";x®N,@PRs=JN7:WŽ7i <5 ›O,N4@N,A2;:yS,;>†FGB

¯-=5B>"[\M1;>"¢JN7:RxR>";=H5’S";>uGNAIB‰5HJO4@:@KFN4;:JA;SFGB‹PIB*ALA2@RB*A

O4BS7FM|NFG;=F$@K:@:JACM|B>Lh

F";sFGB1r@>N7;=JA”=ACB>HJ>/;S"N4O,BAbh

iWG5B:t@*:5@O[ N,:R1F"GJBsQNACF,>CN,~=F,N,;:I;*SP@N4O"A H5;ACFBQI~[1=ACB>ZAS7;>B@?G

N7:FB>"BA"F"N,:ReH5>;S,N,O7B*DkM†BeA/BB]F,G5@LFpFGB]?;PtPB>C?N4@OV?L;PIHJ@K:JN4BA2

Q5;PN,:5@LF"N,;:™NAy?L;:S"N7>PtBQ!h1df>/;P¥FGB‘8NPN P@N4O"A\M1BV@:@O4[&*BQD

G5‘P<‚Ž#_fg ’}?K;PB€S">/;PcHB;HJO4B€?K;:J:B?2F"B*QlF;e@KF O4B@*ACF;:JB

?K;PHJ@:[h<“-: FGB™?;:F,>/@>Z[D@K?@Q5BPtN4?*AšŽ/N4:5QN,rN4Q5=@OAš?L;::5B?bF,B*Q

M1N4F"G¤=5:N,rBK>6ACN4FN7B*An~=F_:;F€MNF"G ?L;PHJ@K:JN4BAC’£G5@rB @ O,;KM

H5@>ZFN4?N7H@KF,N,;:W>"@KF,N,:5R5o$<VPBALA2@RBAt;:y@rBK>/@R*B\H5;ACFBQy~[§@K:@?bF,;>

M1N4F"G ´A1:JN7rB*>/A2NF4[´]H>/;S"N,O4BDU@:5Q DnS";>›F"GJBn´A1:JN4rB>/A2NF,[£@:Q

“s>/R@K:JN@LFN7;:f´ H5>";S"N4O,BDM|G5N4?GtNAO7;MpMGB:?;PH5@>/BQ1M1N4F,Gt@-RO4;~@O

@rB>"@*RB;Sg H;JAZFN7:RJAjHB>\N,:Q5N4rN,Q=J@KODI@*:Q @: @rBK>/@RBV;S<‘8>

H5;ACF,N,:5RAHB> N7:QJN4rN,Q=5@O'M†NF"Gu@Ÿ´ ;PH5@:[J´H>/;S"N,O4B5hz>"B1@?K@Q5BPtN4?*A

O7B*ALAN,:EFB>"BEAZFBQpN4:WFG5BWA"F"@:5Q@>/QN@KF"N4;:WH>/;?LBA2ALDF"G@:WN,:Q5N4rN,Q=J@KOA

?K;:J:B?2F"B*Q§F,;x?L;PH@:N7BA1zI>BF,G5BL[\Pu;>/BH>/BA/B:F1N4:xH5>/N4r@LF"B<O,N"A"F

d=>"F,G5B> @K:J@KO4[JACNA”;:1FGB|H>/N4r@KF,B-O7NACFM|;=O,Q@:JACM1B>fF"GNAv=BA"F"N,;:fh

z1:5;KFG5B>nN,:EFB>CBEAZFN7:R¦;~ACB>/r@F,N7;:¦NA F"GJ@bF_FGB©P;JAZF£@?bFN4rB

H5@>ZFN4?N7H@:FZAkF;F"GJBUP@N7O,N,:R}O7N,ACF§G5@rB @PN4‰JBQ H5>/;S"N,O4BDIM|G5N4?G

S"=>ZFGB>"Pu;>/B™N4:5?LO,=5QBAV@™?L;PH@*:[}@S"S,N7O,N4@KFN4;:'hŸŠ!GBUPu;ACFx@?bFN4rB

H5@>ZFN4?N7H@:FZA @>/B©F"G;JACB¦M|G5;A2B H5>/;S"N,O4B N"A ´/ ;PH@*:N,BA

A1:JN7rB*>/A2NF,N,BAL´<ŽgWH5;ACF,N,:5REAŸHJBK>uH5B>2A2;*:5’t@*:QyFG;JACB\MNFGWH5>";S"N4O,B

´/ ;PH@*:N,BA1@:5Q(“s>/R@:JN@LFN7;:Ab´-ŽG _ŸH;JACF,N7:RJAsHJBK>-HB>/A2;:J’bh'Š!G5B*A2B

S"N7>ZACF>/B*A2=5OFZA?K;:JS7N,>/PUF,GJB1;~5A2B>/r@bFN7;*:A”P@QB-N7:@1H>/BrN,;=AACF,=5Q[|;:

F"GBWN,:F,B>/:@KF,N,;:5@Ou>"BR=JO7@LFN7;:VH5>;?LBEALA L"g*EO2o”FGBWP;ACFu@?2F"N,rBD-@K:JQ

;S4FB:¦P;JACF_N,:SO7=B:FN7@O_@?2F;>6A¥N,:©>/BR=O,@KF,N,;:ZAZF@:Q5@>/QN*@bFN4;:

H5>";?LBALA/BAs@>"BF"GJ;A2Bt~BO,;:JRN7:R<F,;(A2BrB>@O A2;?N7@O ?L;:EFBL‰5FZA{Ž6AC=J?LG<@A

?K;PHJ@:N7B*AŸ@*:QW=J:N7rB>2A2NFN,BA2’/D-BA2HB?LN,@O4O4[jM†GB*:W;:5BxA/=5?LG?K;:F"BL‰5F

N7:r;O,rB*ApB?L;:;PN7? N4:FB>CB*ACFZApŽ"B5hR5hŒ@™?;PH5@:[’2hiWB ?@O4OxA2=?G

N7:Q5N,rN,Q=5@O"AÉ,_–ÏÌ,ÍLș~B?L@*=5A2B™FGBK[X@>CB›@LFyFG5B}N7:F,B>/S7@*?LB™;S

Q5N4S"S"B>/BK:F-A2;?N,@KO@>/BK:J@ALD@:Qx~>CN4QJRB(?L;PP=5:N4F,N7BEA|M|G5N4?GM|B>/B<:;EF

Q5N4>/B?2FO[|?L;::JBK?LFBKQfh

IBrB>"F,G5BO7BA6ALDM†BI:;FN4?KBQŸF4M†;t¢N7:QA{;S PN‰BKQuH5>";S"N4O,B1N,:QJN7r*N7Q=5@OAKo

F"G;JACB G5@rN7:R˜A2BKrB>C@*O\@KSS"N4O7N,@LF"N,;:Ay–Ì(Ì%$ɚȈ–•|ÉpÌ,ʕÉV@K:JQUF,GJ;A2B

@S7SN7O4N,@KF,BQF;‹A2=??LBA6A2N7rB<N,:A"F"N4F,=F,N,;:JA†–Jœ7' )\Ì$ÉIÌ,Ê4•1Éhdf;>N7:JACF@K:J?LBD

;:B@?LF,;>”NA?;:5:B?2FBQIF,;F4M;rB>"[O,@K>/RBuA/;S4F,M1@>/B1?L;>/H;>"@KF,N,;:JA

@:Q !6D”@:5Q‹;:5B<=:5N,rB>ZA2NF4[#"shJz:¯Bs=JBK>"[(v=B>7[(;:<F"GB<P@N7O,N4:5R

O7NAZF-@>/?LGJN4rB(?@K:xBK‰F>C@?LF@O4O@Q5Q>/BA2A2B*A1@ALAC;?LN,@KF,BQF;<F"GNA†@?LF";>6DN,:

F"GB€;>"Q5B>™;SF"GB€B`"P@N7O,ALDyFG=A2DWÊ%'£Ì4Ê4•|É]Íˆž5É2Íhx ;PH5@>/N4:5R

A2=??LBALA/N7rBW@*QQJ>/BALA/BA\@O4O7;MuA\QBF"B?bF,N,:5RV@Q5Q>/BALA\?G@*:RB*AKh9":pF,GJB

?K@*A2B›;SW;=>A2@PHO,B›@K?LF";*>2DM|B™QJBbFBK?LFBKQXBK‰J@?2FO[}F4M;›@KQJQ>CB*ALA

?KG@:RBALDS">/;P$sF,; " ŽC=ACN,:R@:@*O7=P:5=JAsB`PI@N,O”@*Q5Q>/BALA/’s@:5Q(@

S"BbMXPu;:F,GA1O7@LF"B>1S,>/;P%"pF;&!LhiWBu?K@:(?K;:J?LO7=JQBIFG@F”FG5N,A1@?bF,;>

G5@*A\A2=?K?BALA/N7rBO[~BB:W?K;::5B?LF,BQWŽ/H>/;~J@K~JO[@*AŸ@*:WBKPuHO,;K[B*BK’F";

F7M|;rB>"[(N7PH5;*>ZF,@*:F?L;PH5@:5N4BEALD!@:QGJBtNAs;>M1@*A1?L;::JBK?LFBKQ<MNFG

@:<N7PH;>7F@:F”9Š`,;>CN4B*:EFBQ<=:5N4rB>ZA2NF7[hƒ;>"BtS,>/Bv=B*:F,O4[D5M1B|:5;KFN7?LB*Q

F"GBX;EF,GJB>V¢5N,:Q€;SVPIN‰BQXH5>/;S"N4O,B›N7:QJN4rN,Q=5@O"ALDxA/N7P=5OF@:B;=ACO4[

@S7SN7O4N,@KF,BQ1F;sF7M|;1QJN7S,S"B>CB*:EFfF4[HBA ;Sf;>"R@K:JN'@F,N7;:JAKh

d=>"F,G5B>uvE=JBK>/N,BA1QJBKrBO4;HPB:F¡M1;=O7Q‹PI@*¢B(AC[AZFBKPu@bFN7?uQN"ACF,N,:?bFN4;:

~5BLF7M|BB:IFG5B*A2BsF7M|;¢5N4:JQI;S'É,\–ÏÌ4Í2Èh“|:B|A2G5;*=5O4Qt:;F,BDF"G@KFMG@KF

N"A<N7PH;>"F,@:FtN,A<:5;Ft:B?LBEA2A2@>7[kA2N,P=O4F@K:JBK;=JA@S"S7N,O,N7@LF"N,;:D{~=F|@O,A2;

ȝÏ*Ê7–œ'É̝Í(È-žÉ &*ÉKœ46— ÉKžQ5=>/N,:R†A2=??BALA/N7rB-@KS"SN4O7N,@bFN,;:ALh

ŠTGNAsBK‰J@PHO7BuN"A-@O4>/B@KQ[u@IrB>"[tN,:F"B*>"BAZFN,:Ru;=EFH5=F¡S,;>…A2;?N4;O,;RN,ACF6o

NFuH5B>/PNFAF,;WN,QB*:F,N,S7[W;:JByH;F,B:F,N,@OtN4PtH;>7F@:Fu@?2F";><S,;>tQ5BBHB>

>CB*A2B@>/?LG!h

s=J@KO,NF@LF"N,rB¬@K:J@KO4[JA/N"AeŽ"N,:F,B*>"rN7BLMuAl@*:Q¬F"BL‰5FY@:5@O[EA2N"A/’‚A2G;=O,Q

?K;:F,N7:J=B\;=>ŒAZF=Q[ED{N4:;>/QB>1F;jr*B>"N,S7[\FGB‹>CB@O-N7:S"O,=B:?KB‹;S)É,

–5ÏÌ7ÍLÈ-N,:IFGBP@N7O,N7:RO,N"A"F2hd$=>ZFGB> @:@O[JA2N,A;:IFG5B|PIBEA2A2@RB-F"G>/BK@*Q

ACF,>C=J?2F"=>/B(ŽZM|G5;‹@A2¢JA<v=5B*ACF,N7;:JA1@:Q\M1G;(N"A1@:JACM|B>"N,:5R<F"GBP’M1N,O7O

;EFGB>-¢5N4:5QJA1;SN7:S";>"Pu@bFN4;:D AC=J?KG‹@As@*?bF,;>/A2S,=5:?bFN4;:JALD!?K;*PtH@:N7B*A2

N7:F,B>/BACFAW@:Q›@?LF,;>ZA2s:JBbF,M1;>"¢AšŽ"F,GJBUHB>ZA2;:@O‹@K:JQ™H>/;S"BA6A2N7;:J@KO

?K;::5B?bF,N,;:JA”~5BLF,M1BB*:†F,GJBP’2h

-¶

5=.9 04 *6 4=.,*R7F5M*32,*3.,0W

4 7 7º 7. 4 * 7 0 5Vº

0 *32,460 4

d>/;P_;=J>‡L;N,:F1M|;>"¢WN7:yFGN"A<H5>;2‡2B*?bFD{M|BxG@rByO4B*@K>/:5BQW@A2BbF†;S

O7BA6A2;:AM|G5N,?LGtMB?K>7[AZF@O4O7NBN4:t@RB:B>N7?-@>/?LG5NFB?2F=>/B1S;> @A2;*?KN,@KO

A2?KN4B:FN"A"F"A-Q5@LF"@uPI@*:@*RBPB:FF,;;O/h$Š!GN"A@>/?LG5NFB?2F=>/BNA{;=F"O,N4:5BQ(N4:

dN,R=5>B5h

zn:5B?KB*ALA2@K>"[ N7:HJ=EF<F;pFGBšF;;OtNAF"GBVA2BLF<;S<?K;*:5?LBHFZA‹FG@KF<@*>"B

>CB*O4Br@:FVF";]FGB A2;?KN4@*OW@:@O[JA2N,AL„§FGBACBX?;:5?LBHFZAUŽ/BhR5h\@?LF,;>/ALD

N7:AZFNF,=F"N4;:JALD1PIBEALAC@RBEA§BLF?h’\@K>/BWB*ACF"@~5O4NA2GBQ~[yFGBVAC;?LN,;O7;RNAZFZA

H5>/N4;>!F";|@?2F"=J@KOQJ@KF,@1@?v=JN,A2NF,N,;:'h9,QJBK@*O7O[JDF"GBA2B|ACGJ;=5O,Q~B1QBAC?>/N4~5BQ

rN,@t@u?K;*:5rN,rN,@O N7:FBK>/S"@?KBu@AsN,: L<POZ„'F"GBK[Œ?K@:(~5BIFGB:‹ACB>/N4@O,NBQ(N4:

@:j¯-ƒx® S";>"Pt@LF|ŽZF>"@:JA2H@>/B:F-F";\FGB§A2?LN7B:FN,ACF"’@:QACF,;>/BKQxN,:§FGB

¯1ƒx®\Q@KF@K~J@A2Bh

ŠTGB‹A2?KN4B*:EFNAZF|PI=JACFFG5B:A2N7:RO4B;=F-iWB~jQJ@bF@‹A2;=5>/?LBA1F";\O4;@QxN4:

F"GJBŸF;;O,„”F,G5B*A2B@*>"BB‰F>/@K?LFBKQ\@*:Q‹O7;@Q5BQ\rN7@tM|>/@KHJHB*>sŽ"iWB~\QJ@KF,@

@?v=JN,A2NF,N,;:’Pu;Q5=O,BALD$A2G;M|:<@KFFGBt~;F4F";P›;Sd$N7R=J>"Bu'hŠGBQJ@KF,@

Pt@L[x>/Bv=5N4>/B\?O4B@K:JN7:Rx@:QySN7OFB>"N,:R5D @A†M|B\G@rB‹A2BB:xN7:5B?2FN7;*:

Gh<hŠfG=A2DF"GBnF,;;O1P=JACF1~JB\B@AC[\F,;yBL‰5F,B*:QxMNFGj:JBbMYS"N4O4F"B>/N7:R

?K@H@~N,O7NFN,BALDH5B>CG@HJA=:5QB>fF"GB1S,;>CP ;Sf=A2B>/`7QJBS,N7:BQS"=:5?2FN,;:ALh

“1:?KBnF,G5BqQ5@LF"@¬NAeO7;@Q5BQDUFG5B¬A2;?N,;O7;RNAZFZAeM1N,O4O]ACF@>ZFY~[

~5>/;KM†A2N7:R,RBKF4F"N,:R@?v=@N,:F"BQtF,;IF,GJN,AQ@F"@*„M1B-N,O7O4=AZF>C@LFBQ1F,G5B-=ACB|;S

¯u5=5P!LE‘8O/D@*:QF,G5B>/Bs@>/B-P@:[1;FGB*>/ALD5A2=J?LGI@EAT¯-ƒy®T5H[ L,g&O2h

T!)!]\t!4#.f4 C*K /|+"1#02"#%0LK,Kf /40L 40)f#E 6#

&‹#f#JE&(Kf /%78

-@A2BQW;:jFGN"At¢J:;EM|O,BKQJRB\;SsFGB§A2;=>/?LBA6D…F,GJB\A2?LN,B:F"N,ACF-?@:WAZF@>ZF

v=B>"[N,:RF"GJBKP<h¯-=5B>"[}v=5B>CN,B*AyN7:}RB:B>/@KODt@:Q N7: H@>7FN,?L=5O,@K>

F"GJ;A2Bt=JA2BQ(N4:\;=J>@K:J@O[JACNALD'FBK:JQŸF;<~B(v=5NFBt?;PH5O,Bb‰$hz™M1@K[Œ;=EF

;S1FGN"A<?K;*PtHO7BL‰N4F4[N"AtF;yS";>/P=5O4@F,Bj'ɟȈʁ•$—œ,ÉÎJÉ2Í,–Ì1–yÌ4Ê4•1É*D

•–Ì7ÉLÍLÊ,–œ7ÊKÉ_F"GB ¯-ƒx® Q;?K=PB:F]N4FYH>/;QJ=?KBA6D &ÊÈΖ5œ,ÊÉ NFZD

S";>"Pt=O,@bFBW@:;F,G5B>\v=B*>Z[VBLF?h|Š!GJBW@K=F,G5;>\;*StF"GNA§HJ@KHJBK><M|NF,GV@

A2;?LN,@O™A2?N4B:?BA ~J@K?¢R>C;*=5:Q S,;=:5Q£NF™Pu=?KG‚B@ACN,B>UF;eNA2A2=B

¯s=JBK>/N4BA ~5@*A2BKQu;:uA2BrB>@ON7:F,B>"PuBKQJN4@>"[1>/B*A2=O4FZAbhdf=5>,F"GB>/P;>/BDEFGB

rB*>7[m:@F"=>/Bn;S€GNAeM1;>"¢ NAlBK‰JHJO7;>/@LF";>7[ @K:JQ P=OFN4`/ACF,@RBJo

A2;?LN,;O,;RN"A"F/AS";>"P=5O,@bFB(G[*H5;KFGBACBALDM1GJN4?KG\FGBK[\@LF,F"BPtHF-rB>"N,S7[(~[

v=B>"[N,:RpFG5BVQ@F,@~@A2Bh ?$;A2N4F,N7rBWŽ";>(:B*R@KFN4rB’\>"BEAC=5O4FA\:5@LF"=J>"@O,O[

O7B@QtGJN7P F,;tS,;>"Pt=O,@bFB1;F"GB> G[H;F"GBA/BA2„S";>FG5N,A>"B@*A2;:5DF,GJB{¯-ƒx®

Q5@KF,@~@A/BPI=JACF$Pt@¢5B1N4F$B@AC[|F";P@KF,B>/N4@O,NB-F"GB>"BA/=5O4Ff;S@|v=B>7[@*A

@>/BS7N,:5BQ™QJ;?=PB:FZDIF"; ~B@QQJBKQ F";pFGBpQJ@bF@~@A/BpS";*>jS,=5>,F"GJBK>

G5BO7H;S!@-R>/@KHJGN,?L@O5F;;OA/=5?LG@A¯(¡^=L_EO2h

dN4:J@KO,O[EDtA/;?LN7;O,;RN,?L@O@:@O[EA2N,A\>"Bv=5N4>/BA‹AZF@KF,N"ACF,N,?@KO1F;;*O"A6DIA/=5?LGV@A

A2H>/B@QJA2G5BBKFALD5@:Q<R>/@H5GtHJ>";Q=5?2FN7;:F";;OA2DN,:t;>/Q5B>F";¡‡L=5QRB1;S!F,GJB

ACF,@KF"N,ACFN4?@Oy?L;>">/BO4@KFN4;:]~BKF4MBB: F4M;}S"@?2FZApBKF,?h(5=5?LG›F;;*O"Ap@>/B

=AC=J@KO,O4[WN4:5?O4=5QBQV@*A=FN4O7N4F,N,BAN,:Wr@>"N,;=5A<;HB>"@KFN4:5RkAC[ACF,BPuA<Ž/B5hRh

“sS"SN7?LB;:tiWN,:Q5;KMuA@:5Qt“-H5B:<“-S"S7N,?B1;:I®TN7:=‰J’6„5N,:EFB>"S@?LN7:RF,G5BP

A2PI;;KFGO[<M|N4F"GFGBtQJ@bF@tP@:J@KRBPIB*:EF¡F,;;OM|;=O,Q(~5Btr*B>7[(GBO4H5S=O/h

iWB<ACF>"BALAF,G5@KF…AC=J?KG<F,;;OAs@>/Bt=JA2BQ\~[tF;Q@K[*A-A2;?KN,;O,;R[u>CB*A2B@>/?LGD

~5=FN4:u;=5>$?L@A2BDF,GJBsrB>"[1HJ>";Q=J?2F"N,;:u;S'FG5B-:=5P~5B>6A”;:1M1GJN4?KG1FGBK[

@HH5O[ >CBEvE=JN4>/BA§F,GJBpH>/BKrN,;=Ax=JA2@KRBW;S(ACBPN,`"ACF>"=J?2F"=J>"BQŽ"F,G5@LF<NALD

¯sƒ®’QJ@bF@~@A/BAbh

¶

=729yº

0872 5=2= + *3.

+/*6 4H0=*

ŠTGB€ACF,=JQ[€H5>"BEACB:FBQ]G5B*>"B NAU?L;:Q5=?LF"BQ€H>CN,P@>"N,O[X~J@ACB*Q];:

H5=~5O4N,?KO[¨@r@N,O4@~O7B N7:S";>/P@KFN4;:™;: F"GBW¯s=B>"[¨AZF@:Q5@>/QN*@bFN4;:

H5>";?LBALALoK­†Š'ƒx®\iWB~H5@RB*A@:5QH5=~5O4N,?O[`7@*>C?LGJN4rBQPI@*N4O7N,:R1O7NAZFZAKh

“s~JrN7;=JA2O[JD!FG5BtN4:F"B>/H>CBF,@KF"N4;:(@K:JQ@*:@*O[JA2N,A1?L;=O,Q~B<N4PuH>/;rBQ~[

=ACN,:RtF,G5BH5>N7r@F"BP@N4O,N7:R<O4NACF ;S”FGB1¯s=B>,[tM|;>¢5N4:5RuR>";=HHLGPG8O/D

;:<M|G5N4?GŸFGBIi=<J QN"A2?L=A2A2N,;:A-;:<F,G5BŒACF,@:Q5@>/Q<NFZACBO,SF"@¢5BHO,@?LB5h

­1;M|BrB>6D{M|ByS"BBO1?;:JS7N,Q5B:F1FG@KF1FGBj>/B*A2=OFZAŸ;~F@KN,:5BQW~[=JA2N4:5R

H5=~5O4N,?tN,:S";>"Pt@LF"N4;:\@*>"B<~;EF,G(N,:F,B>/B*ACF,N7:JR<@K:JQ>/B*A2HB*?2F"S"=O F,;<H5>/N4r@K?L[

H5;O,N7?LN,B*AKhIikBG5@rB?L;:EF@?2FBKQ F"GJBpi=< £A/;O,N4?NF,N,:5RF,G5B >"N7RGF(F";

N7:?O7=Q5B N4:™;=>j@*:@*O[EA2N"AjF,GJBPBA2A2@RBAyS>C;*P¥FGNAyO,N,ACF/D@K:JQU@>/B

?K=>/>/BK:F,O[-M@NFN4:5R1S;>F,G5B->CB*A2H;:5A2Bh

ƒy;>"B‹RB:B>"@O,O[JDF"GB\N,ALA/=5B(;S-?L>/BQB:F"N,@O"A1F";\@??KB*ALAI@(A2BLF-;SiWB*~

Q5;?=PIB*:FA1Ž/N7:?O7=Q5N4:JR<@>"?GN7rB*QPBALA/@RBt~J;@>/QJA2’N"A-;>"F"G;R;:@OF";

;=>u@HH5>/;@?LGfo ;=>uH5=>/H;JA/ByN,AtF";kA2=HJH;>,F/D@:QpH>/;rN4Q5B(F";;O,A<S7;>

A2;?KN,@O!@:5@O[EA2NA”;:1F,G5B-~5@*A2N"A ;S@-RN4rB:IikBK~uQ@F,@ACBKF6h

9":tFGBI:JB@>S"=F,=5>"BDM†B1HO7@:F";N,:?KO4=JQBN4:u;=>¡@K:J@KO4[JACNAKoKFGB1B`"P@N7OA

S">";PlFGB\H5>"N,r@bFB¯Bs=JBK>"[‹Pt@N7O4N,:5R‹O4N"ACF-Ž/@~5;=Fug&>h> >P>xPBA2A2@RBA2’6D

F"GBji <5  ikBK~VH5@*RBAO4NACF,N7:JRyF,G5BH>/Br*N7;=A@:QV?K=>/>"B:F¯-=5B>"[

M1;>/¢N7:RyR>/;=JHWPIBPt~B>ZALD{@AtM|BO4O@AtF"GJB\­Š'ƒx® `,~5@EACBQPIBBKFN4:5R

@:Q¨FBO7B?L;:S"B>/B:?KBV:;EF,BEALDIH;JAZFBQ ;:pFGByi <5 ‚ACN4FBh…z1?L?KBA6AF";

F"GBA2B Q5;*?K=JPIB:FAVN"Ap>/B*ACF">N7?LF,BQ›F,;Ui=<J  PBPt~B>/AL„<RBbF,FN4:5RUF,GJB

H5B>CPNA2A2N,;:tF;t=A/BIF,GJBKP™MN4O,OB:@~O,B1=A”F;@:@O[E*BsF,G5B|N7:FB>"@?2FN7;*:A

~5BLF7M|BB: i=<J ©M1;>/¢N7:R_R>";=H PBP~B>6A M|GN7?G£A2G@HBQ F,GJB

Q5BS"N7:N4F,N7;:;S!FGBsO,@:R=@RB5h

z1H5HO[EN4:5R£;=5>›F,;;OUF; ;F"GB>›i=< ¦M1;>"¢JN7:R£R>/;=HqACN4FBA NA

F"B?KG:JN7?L@O,O[uA2HJBK@¢N,:RtA"F">/@N7R*GFS7;>7M@>/QJD5@K:JQ†FGBAC;?LN,;O4;R*N7?@KOfPBbFG5;*Q

?K;=JO4Q~B1FG5BuAC@PB5h­|;EM|BrB*>/D!H;F"B:F,N,@O=JA2B> ?;PPt=:5NFN7B*ALD5NALAC=5B*ALD

H5O4@K[*B>6A2D @K:JQ\N4:FBK>/@?bFN4;:JA†H@KF4FB>":AsP@K[<~JBtrB*>7[(QN7S"S,B>"B*:EF…S";>6DA2@L[JD

F"GB ikB~e ¡;:FBK:FWz1??LBA6A2N7~N,O7NF,[]iW;*>C¢JN4:5R€R>/;=JH LG5‘8O/DjM|G5N4?G

S";?=5A2BEA¨;*:]P@¢N7:R›F"GB™iWB*~]@K??BALA/N7~O,B™F";›@O7Ox>/BR@>/QO7BA6Ap;S

Q5N,A2@~N,O4NFN7B*ALD<@K:JQ™F,G5Bpƒ@KF,G ƒj®YM1;>/¢N7:R R>";=H LG g;OM†GN,?LG™NA

Q5BQ5N4?@KF,BQjF;\F,G5B\N,:?KO4=A2N4;:y;SP@bFG5BP@KFN4?K@OsBL‰H>/B*ALA2N4;:JAtN4:\iWB*~

H5@RB*ALD@:QFG5=JA1rB>"[(Q5;P@N,:`/ACHJBK?N,S7N,?h$Š!GJ=JALDT@‹AC;?LN,@O@:5@O4[JACNAs;S

F"GBA2BWQN,S7S"B*>"B:F(R>/;=5HJA\NA§O,N,¢B*O[WF";VG5N4RGO7N,RGF<QN7SS7B>/B:FuF7[*H5B*A;S

@?2F";>/ALDN7:FB>"@?2FN,;:A BKF,?h

ƒy;>"BRB:B>"@O,O[JD{FGBjF;;*O†M†ByG@rBxQ5BrBKO,;HBQW?L;=O,QW~By=JA2BQyF";

@?v=N,>CB}@K:JQ›;>/R@:NBpFG5B Q@KF,@ ?;:F@KN,:BQ›N,:™@:[}Pt@N7O,N4:5R}O4N"ACF

@>"?GN,rBKQ;:jFGB(iWB~JD@KO,O7;M1N,:5R\F,G5=JAtF,;\@:@O4[&*B<F"GB(N7:FB>"@?2FN7;*:A

F"@¢5N,:RUHJO4@?LB~JBbF,M1B*BK: F"GJBH@>7FN7?LN,H@:FAKhuŠ!GJN"AxN4:5?LO,=5QBAxBhRhsF,GJB

® N4:5=‰›¢JBK>/:BO(P@N7O4N,:R O7NAZFZDt@>/?LG5N4rBQ™@KF LG8>PODŸP@N7O,N4:5R O,N,ACF/AxS7;>

r@>/N7;*=A®N,:=‰ QN"ACF,>/N,~=F,N7;:JAŽ/BhR'h¡w1B~N,@K: @K:JQša…BKQ­1@KF,’6DsS;>tF,GJB

97^^ ^šAZF@:Q5@>CQN@LFN4;:tM|;>/¢N,:R<R>/;=5HJAL<W_EO¡BbF?h“F"GB>¡S";>/BACB*BK@~O,B

@HH5O4N,?K@LF"N,;:AšP@L[™N,:5?LO,=Q5BpFGB@:@O[JA/N"Ay;S\BL‰?LGJ@:RBAjM|NFGN7:}@