Non-Cooperative Routing in Loss Networks
Texte intégral
(2) INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE. . . .
(3) . . . . . . . . . Eitan ALTMAN — Rachid EL AZOUZI — Vyacheslav ABRAMOV. N° 4405 MARS 2002. ISSN 0249-6399. ISRN INRIA/RR--4405--FR+ENG. THÈME 1. apport de recherche. .
(4)
(5)
(6)
(7) ! "# $% &('*),+-. /10324. 57698;:3+<,=>'@?&A/B.DCFE9G CIHKJ38>L(MN+<,=PORQTSU+WV".DXY:Z.[2E\L7] ^`_badcYeYfhgjiFkmlnemoqpsr3eutvlnwslxtyadcYeml z;{n|q}xeutv~Ds^Fivv ivo |q{ntse({neT_ed{_e
(8) 1Rg~[vi qqRgqo qeTl 1md, qq¡ ^`_be¢boqem{Pltnpb£¤eTl¥{y|qpsty£¤bv£¦A§¤|Rlnl1edtx¨©|{nªslN£¦Aty_e¢«*{o cYem¨©|{nª| «bob|qs¬u|W|qed{o,ty£¤®e Ro cYe¯¨F£¤tn_°lem§²±l_³pblem{ylm´(^¥¨I|ln|q§¦psty£¤|³u|buemstylho {yed|qbln£µsed{yemN¶`ty_e\·vol_9eT¸Rp£¤§¦£¦¹{n£¦pcDº»u|{¬ {yemln|qbs£¦[ty|ty_eDdoqlneZ|q«o[±bb£²tyeWpc¹em{|q«vo qemRtyl ¼@lnpb_½oqlKlned{y®R£µue3{n|,®W£µsed{l¾htn_bo tto ªe {y|qptn£¦3seTu£µl£¦|qblmºNo b[tn_eK¿°oq{y{n|[em¸Rp£¦§¤£¦¹{y£¤pcDº£¦¨F_£µ_{y|qpsty£¤b3semd£¦ln£¦|qblho {ye(tyoqªqem9¹WwDo ®ed{yw9§µo {yqeYWpc¯¹ed{A|q«I£¦bs£¦®W£¦pbo §©pblem{ylm´Z¿°e3ln_|,¨Àty_bo,t(ty_emlneZeT¸pb£¤§¦£¤¹b{n£µoDs|9|qt(«@o §¦§Á£¤Rty|[tn_e ltyoqboq{y«*{o cYed¨I|q{yªsl`| «;|q¬Âd|R|em{yo tn£¦®qe{y|qpsty£¤3o cYeTld´Fvlo\{yemlnp§²tTºb¨Ie¯ln_|,¨tn_bo tvp£µ¸Rpeu¬ bemlyl¯|q«vem¸Rp£¦§¤£¦¹{y£¦o³|q{Ked®ed| «vpsty£¤§¦£¦Ãmo,ty£¤|blKo,tYem¸Rp£¦§¤£¦¹{y£¦o³c\oÄw³«@oq£¤§`em®qed£¤½tn_e[moqlne3| «hl£¦cY§¤e ty|q|q§¦|qw9| «`bo {o §¦§¦ed§;§¦£¤ªslm´Åv|,¨©em®qed{TºN¨IeZl_|,¨Btn_o,t¯ln|qcYe\| «Itn_e\b{n|¹§¤emc\lAs£µlnoqeTo {(£¦Ætn_e moqlne£¦3¨F_£µ_\tn_bev¹boqbs¨F£µWtn_{neT¸pb£¤{yemY¹WwY| «¥oq§¤§u|emutn£¦|qbl©£µlÁty_elyo cYeq´;Çb|q{Áty_elemd£¦oq§moqlne |q«ohboq{yoq§¤§¦ed§s§¦£¤bª(tn||§¤|qwqºq¨©e`|q¹tyo £¦Yl|cKeFlnp{y{n£µln£¤§¤wAln£¦cKb§¤eF¨`oÄw(| «Nl|§¤®W£¦tn_eFeT¸pb£¤§¦£¤¹b{n£¦pc «*|{F¹|qtn_[doleTlI| «>¿°oq{ys{y|q oql`¨Ied§¦§»oqlF·oqln_eT¸pb£¤§¦£¤¹b{n£¦pcD´ È[ÉRÊËyÌ¯Í ,ÎPq¡ ¥|lyl`eutx¨I|q{yªsldºÏoqcKehty_ed|{nwº·voqln_ em¸Rp£¦§¤£¦¹{y£¤pcDº¿Æo {s{y|qem¸Rp£¦§¤£¦¹{y£¤pc!´. Т÷ Ñ*Ñ*ÒPÒPÓ»Ó»ÑÕÑÕÔ°Ô°ÖPÖP×× ØZØZÙÛÙÛÚTÚTÜ Ü ÝÛÝÛÞÛÞÛÞÞßßÓ»Ó»àÛàÛáTáTâUâUã;ã;äÄäÄãxãxå1å1æWæWáTáTççèéèéàÛàÛêéêéãxãxå1å1ÞÛÞÛëÛëÛÙÛÙÛÞÛÞÛÝÝìmìmàÛàÛíÄíÄîÄîÄèðèðï©ï©ÔPÔPñuñuâòâòèéèéí í àÛàÛêéêéèè å1å1óóããäTäTãxãxôôõ,õ,öUöUïïñÄñÄçxçxãã ø;ùú ïèéêµûWüdýdïçÂîÄãxåòê²þPèéñuâUãöx× ñÄãâ× èéê. Unité de recherche INRIA Sophia Antipolis 2004, route des Lucioles, BP 93, 06902 Sophia Antipolis Cedex (France) Téléphone : +33 4 92 38 77 77 — Télécopie : +33 4 92 38 77 65.
(9)
(10) Y !#"$ %& ')(*+ , -!. 0/1 . ¡ ·|pbl;kdtnpbs£¦|ql¢oqblÁuedt©o {ntn£µu§¦e`§¤ev{n|pstyoqqeFo lÁseml¢{nkTleTo ps3r 2em{tyemlÁoqbl;§¦evdos{ye e}xedpsrÆ|q¬Âd|R|km{yo tn£¤«@loÄ®qemYseTl(pblyo ed{l£¦bs£¦®W£¦pbo §¦£¦ltneTld´ 4vempsr°d|qbdedstlAseZln|q§¦pstn£¦|qlAl|Rt d|qbln£µskd{ykmlm¶¯6§ 5 kT¸Rp£¤§¦£¦¹{ne se3·oqln_»ºÁ¸Rp£©d|q{y{neTl|qbÆoqp doql7 5 p |c¯¹{ye\±b£`7 5 o edRtyl¼Õtnem§I¸Rpe eml«*|qp{y£µlnlnedpb{ylseKlned{y®W£¦deT¾v¸pb£Pb{nemedRt(semloÛtn£¦|q³se{y|qptyo eqºeut8§ 5 km¸Rp£¦§¦£¤¹{yeYse¿Æo {s{y|q»º |:9§¦eml3skmd£¦ln£¤|bl\se[{y|qpsto emlYl|RtZ{n£µlnemlYboq{\p tn{yaml\{yoqb |c¯¹{ye[7 5 pblnoqqem{ylY£¦bs£¦®W£¦spbed§µld´ ·v|qpblAcK|Rtn{y|qbl(¸RpeZdeml(kT¸pb£¤§¦£¤¹b{neTl(eYtn|c¯¹edRt¯bol(o l(§¤eTlAdos{yeml(ltyo o {l(se(}xempsr³b|qs¬ d|W|qkd{o,tn£¤«@l\se[{y|qpsto eq´ z>o {Zu|blnkm¸RpedRtTº©|pblYcY|qRtn{y|ql\¸pbe[8§ 5 p£µu£¤tnk9se[6§ 5 km¸Rp£¦§¤£¦¹{ye[, 5 eTlxt oqllno tn£µlx«@oq£²tye<c ;mcKe\oqbl§µoZty|q|q§¦|qq£¦eK§¦o§¦pbl(l£¦cY§¦eYeK§¦£¦edblboq{yoq§¤§¦ad§¦emlmºeut(6§ 5 psty£¤§¦£µlno tn£¦|qÆseml §¦£¦edblI, 5 emltIoqlIp£µ¸Rpeb|q3b§¤pblm>´ =©ededbbo Rtmºs|pbl©cK|Rtn{y|qblI¸Rpehdeb{n|¹§¤amcYes£µlo {@o ?d¸po b §¦eml¹boqbse3oqlylnoqtyemlsedc\o skdeTl¯boq{§¦emlKu|edrW£¦|qlln|qRt§¦eml<c ;dcYemlm´Æz1|p{K§¤eDdolseTl¯§¦£¦edbl o {o §¦§¤am§¤eTldºW|pbl`|q¹styed|bl`pecYkuty_|sseAln£¤cY§¦e(|p{F{ykmln|qpbs{yev§¦eml{n|¹§¦adcYeml`se(6§ 5 kT¸Rp£¤§¦£¦¹{ne(se ·oqln_edtvse(¿Æo {s{n|»´ AÀÍ T Ë C B . ¡ iFkTleTo ps r 2Yed{ntneTldºWty_kd|{n£¦e(semlP}xempsrNºkm¸Rp£¦§¤£¦¹{ye(seA·vol_»ºskT¸Rp£¤§¦£¦¹{neAeh¿Æo {s{y|q»´.
(11) Ë -
(12) - -3È . >$ ·v|qs¬u|W|em{yo tn£¦®qeF{y|qpsty£¤¯_boql©§¤|¯¹edem3ltnpbs£¦em3¹|qtn_£¤\ty_e«*{yoqcKem¨©|{nª| «¥{y|oW¬òtn{oZFoql¢¨©em§¤§ olh£¤tn_eK«*{o cYed¨I|q{yª|q«¢tyed§¦emu|cYc¯p£µdo tn£¦|q9beutx¨I|q{yªWlm´¯Wpb_«*{yoqcYed¨I|q{yªWlho §¦§¦|,¨tn| cK|ssem§>tn_e |,¨ d|qs±bp{o,tn£¦|qtn_bo t¯{yemlnp§²tl(£¦ eutx¨I|q{yªsl£¦ ¨F_£µ_ {n|pstn£¦[seTu£µl£¦|qbl¯o {yeKc\oseZ£¦ÆoDb|qs¬ d|W|qed{o,tn£¦®qeKo bÆs£µltn{y£¤¹ptnem³c\o bed{(¹eutx¨Ieded³tn_be\pblem{ylm´K°moqlneK|q«Io ®qem{nw[§µo {yqeKWpc¯¹ed{(|q« plem{ylmº¢ty_e[{yemlnp§²ty£¤b |,¨d|qs±bp{o,tn£¦|q u|{n{yemln|blKty|³ty_eln| do §¦§¦em ¿°oq{y{n|eT¸pb£¤§¦£¤¹b{n£¦pc "f !#¨F_£¦_ £µlY¹boqlnem|qtx¨I|³{y£¦bu£¦§¦emlm¶Æ¼@£µ¾Yoq§¤§F{y|qptneml\oÛtypbo §¦§¤w½pbleT½¹eutx¨Iedem oÆln|qp{ueDo o emltn£¦bo,ty£¤| _oÄ®qe tn_e³lnoqcKe[sem§¦oÄw¼@d|lt¾ÛºFoqb¼*£¦£µ¾Kty_£µl3sem§¦oÄw"¼@|q{3d|lt¾K£µl\| §µo {yqem{Ytn_boq ty_bo,tZoq§¤| o Ww | ty_ed{\{y|qpstyeD¹edtx¨©emedtn_bo t3l|p{ydeu¬semltn£¦bo tn£¦|q boq£¤{T´ tn_e[doleD|q«ho³±b£¤tne ¼@| tK®qem{nw°§¦oq{neT¾Wpc¹em{¯|q«vo qemRtylmº1ty_e3{yemlnp§¤tn£¦ |,¨ d|qs±qp{o,ty£¤|Æd|q{y{neTl|qltn|tn_eDln| mo §¦§¤eT·oqln_½eT¸pb£¤§¦£¤¹b{n£¦pc $ #eu±beTol\o³ln£¤tnpbo tn£¦|q £¤ ¨F_£µ_b|ÆoqqemtY_bolKoq£¦bdedRtn£¦®qe tn| ed®W£¦o tneFpb£¤§µo,tyed{o §¦§¤w´1§¤tn_b|qp_K¿Æo {s{y|qKem¸Rp£¦§¤£¦¹{y£¤pbcÀ_bol;c\o £¦§¤w¹emed\pblnemK£¦Ktn_e{y|oAty{y%o Z d|qRtnedrWtmºW£²t_oql`o §µl|K¹ededDsed±bem£¦bsededsedRtn§¦wZ£¦D| tn_bed{Fo {yemold¶1£¤Demd|q|c¯w[¼@lnede fT$ #*¾Io b£¦ tyed§¦emd|qcYc¯pb£¦mo,tn£¦|ql & #Á£¦³tn_eY«*{o cYed¨I|q{yªD| «`F°Åv|sK·veutx¨I|q{yªsld´K^`_e\·voqln_°em¸Rp£¦§¤£¦¹{y£¤pc!_boql ¹edemedrWtnedl£¦®qem§¤wYpblnem£¤3tnem§¤eTu|qcYcp£µdo,ty£¤|blmºWlnedeheq´ b´ "f sºNfT& #´P¿ _bedDo,ttyedcYsty£¤Kty|pblnehtn_e d§¦olnln£µdo §¢{neTlp§¤tylu|buem{n£¦9¿Æo {s{y|q eT¸pb£¤§¦£¤¹b{n£¦pc |q{·oqln_ em¸Rp£¦§¦£¤¹{y£¦pc «*|q{¯b|qs¬u|W|qed{o,ty£¤®e {y|qptn£¦AoqcYeml;«*|{Ioqbo §¦wWÃd£¦Aedem{yoq§§¤|Rlnl©edtx¨©|{nªslmºq|qbe£¦l¢«@oqdem\¨F£¤tn_3tn_e«*|q§¦§¦|,¨F£¤¯{n|¹§¦edc\ld´ ' ^`_etn_bed|q{ywZty_bo,t_oqlF¹edemDed®qem§¤|eT«*|q{F{y|qpsty£¤\Ro cYemlFolnlnpcYemlIty_bo,tvd|ltyloq{ne(lnpc |q« §¤£¦ª u|ltylm´;^`_£µlF|q¹W®W£¤|pbln§¤wY«@oq£¤§µl`£¤D§¦|lyl`eutx¨I|q{yªsld´ ' ¿Æo {s{y|qem¸Rp£¦§¤£¦¹{y£¤pcDºqoltyoqbo {¯olnlnpcYsty£¤|¯£µlPtn_bo t;o t;em¸Rp£¦§¤£¦¹{y£¤pcDº,ty_eu|RlxtF¼@ed§µoÄws¾ ¹edtx¨©emedAoFln|qp{ue;oqboFsemltn£¦bo,ty£¤|£¦l»tn_e¢lyo cYeP«*|q{1o §¦§qpblned{ld´»^`_b£¦l1s|WemlN|qt»_|q§µ(o WwWcY|q{ye «*|q{F§¦|lyl`eutx¨I|q{yªsld´ boq{ty£¦dp§¦oq{¢{y|q¹b§¤emc oq{n£µln£¤£¤ ·|s¬Âd|W|qed{o,tn£¦®qev§¤|Rlnl©eutx¨I|q{yªslÁ_bol¢¹edem ltnps£¤eTZ£¦ #N£¦ ty_eA«*{o cYem¨©|{nªZ|q«;¿°oq{ys{y|q[eT¸Rp£¤§¦£¦¹{n£¦pc ¼*¨F£¤tn_[ty_elyo cYe(ty|q|q§¦|qwoqltn_e¯tn_bo tv| «;ty_e¯|{n£¦q£¦boq§ (I{o eTlnlhboq{yos|Ärb¾Û´YÅ|,¨Ied®qem{mºN£¤tA£µlAoqlylpbcKeT9ty_ed{yeKtn_bo t(tn_e\¹o bs¨F£µWty_ {neT¸pb£¤{yem¹Rw³emo_³pblned{ £µl¯tn_eDlnoqcYeq´³^`_b£¦lKoqlylpbcKtn£¦|q c\oÄwƹe pblneu«*p§I£¦½cY|ssed§¦£¤b9tnem§¤em_|e3edtx¨©|{nªslmº>¹pstY£¦l| t ®,oq§¤£µÆo WwWcK|{neY£¦ £¤Rtyedq{o,tyem°lem{n®W£µueTld´ )Áeut¯em®qedÆpsed{(ty_e3olnlnpcYstn£¦|qÆ|q«`eT¸Rpbo §Á¹o bs¨F£µWty_ {yem¸Rp£¦{yedcYedRtmº>ty_e[¸Rpemltn£¦|q |q«edrW£µltnedueoqb pb£¦¸RpememlylK| «·oqln_½eT¸pb£¤§¦£¤¹b{n£¦pco ¿Æo {s{n| eT¸Rp£¤§¦£¦¹{n£¦pc_bolh| t¹emed°oqs{yemlylnemNºNo 9|{_boÄ®e¯cYeuty_|slh«*|q{u|cYpstn£¦tn_eYeT¸pb£¤§¦£¤¹b{n£¦pc ¹edemD{n||RleTN´ ty_£¦l3bo ed{3¨©e[±{yltZ{yemlnedRt\tn_ecYo tn_emc\o,tn£µdoq§cY|ssed§µl\«*|{Z¹|qtn_ ¿Æo {s{y|q o b ·oqln_ eT¸Rp£¤§¦£¦¹{n£µo £¦§¦|lyl\eutx¨I|q{yªsldºFoqb tn_bed"ln_|,¨tn_{y|qpbq_lned®qem{yoq§Feuro cY§¦emll|cYe9{y|qed{ntn£¦emlZ|q« ty_ed£¦{{y|qed{ntn£¦emlm´h¿°e\l_b|,¨tn_bo them®qed³£¤tn_e\ln£¤cY§¦emlthtn|q|q§¦|qwD| «¢boq{yoq§¤§¦ed§P§¦£¤ªslmºNed£¤tn_bed{htn_e . Ó1Óñ*ßÛßuÞ+.
(13) .
(14) . Æ¿ o {s{y|q |q{Ztn_e·oqln_ em¸Rp£¦§¤£¦¹{y£¦o oq{ne[pb£¦¸Rpe´~D|{nem|,®qem{mº©ed®qem tn_e9§¦£¦ªptn£¦§¤£¦Ãmo tn£¦|q £¦l3| t pb£¦¸Rpem§¤w[sedtnem{ncY£¦em9o tvem¸Rp£¦§¦£¤¹{y£µo´v^`_£µl£¦l£¤³u|qRty{yolxtty|Zc\o WwD| ty_ed{hu|ltd{n£¤tnem{n£µo\£¦9¨F_£µ_ ty_e·oqln_Zem¸Rp£¦§¦£¤¹{y£¦pc £¦l©ªW|,¨FYtn|¹ep£µ¸pbev«*|{Átn_bevboq{yoq§¤§¦ed§§¤£¦ª\u|s±bqpb{yo tn£¦|q9¼@lnede f$&#*¾Áo £¦°¨F_£¦_tn_eY§¦£¤bª9pstn£¦§¦£¤ÃTo,tn£¦|qlho t(¿°oq{ys{y|qem¸Rp£¦§¤£¦¹{y£¤pc£¦lpb£¦¸RpeK«*|q{edem{yoq§¥ty|q|q§¦|qq£¦emlK¼@lnede fd% #Õ¾u´ ¿³e ty_ed lxtypbsw½o³l£¦cY§¤eD{y|qpsty£¤b{y|q¹§¦edc ¨F£¤tn_ o §¤tnem{nbo tn£¦®qe{n|pstneTlKoqb |¹styoq£¤ l|cYe o {oqs|Ärs£µdo §©¹em_boÄ®W£¤|{¯«*|{Ktn_eD·vol_ em¸Rp£¦§¤£¦¹{y£¤pbc ´½¿³e ±bboq§¤§¦w {yemltn{y£¦utty|ty_e[lemd£¦oq§`moqlne|q« o {o §¦§¤em§»§¤£¦ªsl¨F£²ty_em¸Rpboq§¥¹boqbs¨F£µWtn_{neT¸pb£¤{yedcYedRtl| «¢"£ !ed{yedRthd§¦olnlnemlm´Ç|{vty_bo,th{y|q¹§¦edc¨©e oq{neAoq¹§¦e(tn|Z|¹styoq£¤[pb£¦¸Rpememlylb{n|em{ty£¤eTlF| «>tn_beAem¸Rp£¦§¤£¦¹{y£¦o3oqlF¨Ied§¦§1olvoZd|qW®qedr3{y|qq{o cYcY£¦ d|qcYpsto,ty£¤|bo §¥oq{y|o_eml©tn|Zed{y£¤®etn_emc ´`¿°eA{y|,®W£¦se£¦Dtn_bo t«*{o cYed¨I|q{yªZo\{y£¦d£¤bYly_emcKe ty_bo,tvmo ¹e(pleTln|\oqlItn|\£¦bspue(o\l|sd£¦oq§¤§¦w\|qsty£¤c\oq§N¹em_boÄ®W£¤|{o,t`tn_e(¿Æo {s{y|qem¸Rp£¦§¤£¦¹{y£¤pcD´ ^`_e\ltn{ypbÛtyp{ye|q«¢tn_beKo ed{£¦l(ol«*|q§¦§¤|,¨lm´A¿°eK¹ed£¤°£¦9tn_be\eurWt(leTÛtn£¦|q°¨F£¤tn_³tn_eYcY|ssed§ emlyu{y£¤sty£¤|»´³^`_bed½¨IeZ{yemlnedRtK£¤½tn_e u|qleTupsty£¤®e\tx¨©|°leTÛty£¤|bl(ty_eb|qWp£µ¸RpedeTlnlo b tn_e oq§²tyed{ybo,ty£¤®e9{y|qpsty£¤euro cY§¦emlm´ ¿³e°edbp"¨F£¤tn_"tn_eÆleTÛty£¤||q4bo {o §¦§¤em§v§¦£¤bªWl¨F£¤tn_"eT¸Rpbo § ¹o bs¨F£µWty_ {yem¸Rp£¦{yedcYedRtylm´ $! '& " % # =©|bln£¦sem{©oeutx¨I|q{yªYu|ql£µlxty£¤b¯| « ([§¦£¦ªsld*´ )Áo_Z§¤£¦,ª +K_bol©odoqboqd£²txwY| « -.¹o bs¨F£µWty_pb£²tld´ ^`_bed{ye¢o {ye /u§µoqlyleTlN| «mo §¦§¦lmº,o b¯oqlyl|su£µo,tyem¨F£¤tn_¯d§¦olnl1¬ 0do §¦§µl¥£µl1oq¯o {y{y£¤®,o §{yo tne3º 24Wº oq¯oÄ®qem{yoqqe _b|q§µs£¤bÆtn£¦cKe6º 5847:9 ºFoƹboqbs¨F£µWtn_ {yem¸Rp£¦{yedcYedRtm<º ;=4°o oÆ{y|qptn?e >@4BADCFEFGIHJGLKMKNKMGL( O´ 4edb| tne P 4RQ 2 4TS 5 4 tn_eu§µoqlylx1¬ 0ZU| !em{§¦|oq»´©^`_eA§¦£¦ªmo bou£¤tn£¦emloqbtn_eA¹o bs¨F£µWty_[{neT¸pb£¤{yedcYedRtlFo {ye olnlnpcYem3tn|Y¹e(|Rl£¤tn£¦®qe£¦Rtneded{ld´ Çb|q§¦§¤|,¨F£¦¯iF|Rlnl 3f V"#;¼@lnedeoq§¦ln,| Wem§¤§¦w X #*¾;¨Ie_boÄ®eFtn_be«*|q§¦§¦|,¨F£¤´P¥euZt Y sed|qtneFty_eledt¢| «¥oq§¤§ / d§¦olnlnemlmºW£U´ eq*´ Y Q CTEUGIHJGLKMKNKMG[/\OºWo b] Y . ¹etn_beAledt`|q«>d§¦olnlneml©ty_bo,tpblne§¤£¦^ª +bº Y . Q C30`_aYcbd+e_a>@4fOFK ¼xfT¾ ¥euht g 4 sem| tye¯ty_e\Wpc¯¹ed{|q«Iu§µoqlyli¬ 0do §¦§µl£¦³tn_eZlnwslxtyedcDº»o bk j Qml g 9 G[g]nUGLKMKNKMGogaprqy´K^`_e ltyo tne(lnboqdeh£µl s Qut jvbhw ;=43ga4{|-.FG}+e_~CFEFGIHGdKNKMKMGL( OK ¼Uq¾ 4@xUy:z ·veurWtmº§¤edt s 4v¹e`tn_belp¹ledt>|q«ltyo tneTlP«*|q{;¨F_£µ_¯ty_ed{yeF£µl;oÄ®Äoq£¤§µo ¹b§¤eI¹bo s¨F£¦stn_K«*|q{Áoq| ty_ed{Áoq{n{y£¤®,oq§ |q«PoYu§µoqlyli¬ 0doq§¤§òºs£U´ eq´ s 4 Qt jv_ s bZw ; g {}-*. ;=4fG+^_a>@4 K ¼ ¾ xUy z . Ñ*ÒPÓ»ÑÕÔ.
(15) Ë -
(16) - -3È. . ^`_bedtn_eAltneToqsw3ltyo tneAs£µltn{y£¤¹ptn£¦|q«*|q{`tn_be(§¤|Rlnl`edtx¨©|{nª\£µl. P 4 GIj _ s G g 4
(17). ¼*R¾. P 4 K g 4
(18). ¼Uq¾. x 9 P S g
(19) K. x 9 P S g
(20) . ¼ ¾. C Q j O Q E. ¨F_bed{ye. . 4 . x 4 . Q w. ^`_behb{n|¹bo ¹£¦§¦£²txwZ|q«1¹§¦|sªW£¤Y|q«>oYu§µoqlyl¬i03do §¦§N£µl . 4hQ E< . . . 9 9. . !#"%$'&)(*",+-$)(/.01(. lnlnpcYeÁ|,¨³tn_o,t¥ty_ed{ye¢oq{ne D{n|pblN¨F_£µ_Aln§¤£¤t¥ty_ed£¦{1edc\o bbl»®W£¦oIty_e¢beutx¨I|q{yª´NÂtP£¦l1oqlylpbcKeT ty_bo,t{n|p 1mo DpblneAo WwZ|e| «;o\lp¹ledt Y }YÀ|q«1ty_e¯d§¦olnlnemlm´;^`_eAledt Y 1£µl_boq{yoÛtyed{y£¤Ãmem ¹WwDoZu|cYcK|9l|p{ueAo 9semltn£¦bo tn£¦|qDtn| o §¦§ 0 _ Y oqlv¨©em§¤§>oqlou|cKcY|[bo {o cYeutyed{l ; o 5 ºo b otn| to §»semc\o b | «P{yo tneR2 ´¢Ïh{n|p 1lnedlItn_e«*{oqutn£¦|q |q«1ty_e(£²tlFsedc\oqb ®R£µotn_e {y|qptne > ´Á^`_ed? 2 Q 2 ¼ _]Y @¾©£¦lIty_e{yo tneh| «>z1|£¦lyln|qltn{yemoqc tn_bo tFpblem{ 1ln_£¦blI®W£¦oK{y|qpstye > ºo b P Q 2 S 5 ´ 4eu±be Q%l P 9 GdKNKMKNG P p oqn´ ¿°el_o §¦§Rb|,¨u|bln£¦sem{Ptx¨©|hem¸Rp£¦§¤£¦¹{y£¦od|qbdedstlPededbs£¦(|¯¨F_edtn_em{>tn|emo_Kln£¤bq§¦e©{n|p ty_ed{yev£µlIoqlyl|su£µo,tyem\ol£¦q§¦eemu£µln£¤|\cYoqªqem{mºR|q{©¨F_euty_ed{Iemo_Zq{y|qp\|§¦wYeu±beTl©o¯§¦oq{nevlneut©|q« plem{ylI_boÄ®W£¦\l|cKe(d|qcYcY|q bo {o cYeutyed{ld´ ,2. 43. 6587. 95. 5. 5. 5><. 5><. F. 5=<. 5. : @? 5 =5 < CB. 43. 5 95. 5. 5=<. ;:. 5><. 5. 5=<. A3. ED. GIHKJ'HML .NJ$'OP9.QR",+S$'(.Q1(UTWVYXZ([\.^]_$)H`KHMP'aH$'O. vÅ ed{yeqºq{y|qp ;_boqlho3ln£¤bq§¦e¯semd£¦ln£¦|q9c\o ªed{ho b[£µl¢}xpblxth£¦edRtn£¤±bem¨F£²ty_³oZln£¦q§¦e upblem{ Y¼@£¤ ty_e(tyed{ycK£¦|§¤|qwZ|q« f"&#*¾Û´ vlned{ º¨IeAdoq ®W£¦ed¨tn_be¯ledt Q%l P 9 GdKNKMKNG P p qIoqlF{y|qpsty£¤bZsemd£¦ln£¤| ®,oq{n£µo ¹§¦eml¼@£¤bltneToq | «1tn_eAln§¦£²tntn£¦\{y|q¹boq¹£¦§¤£¤tn£¦eml G _]Y U¾Û´ ^`_evq|oq§| «Npblned{ £¦lÁtn|AcY£¦£¦cK£¦Ãde£²tl¢oÄ®ed{o qeI¹§¦|sªR£¦({y|q¹o ¹£¦§¤£¤txwq´P¿°evdoqYtn_Wpbl¢eu±bevtn_e «*|§¤§¦|,¨F£¦Kd|ltA¼*¨F_£µ_D£¦lFb{n||{ty£¤|bo §tn|Yty_eAoÄ®qem{yoqqe¹§¦|sªW£¤Y{y|q¹o ¹£¦§¤£¤txw\| «>pblned{ U¾Û¶ ( l 9 G @nUGLKMKNKMG GdKNKMKMG q Q w p prK ¼ V ¾ p xUy É *Í B. Q EFGIHJGLKMKNKMG . W3. Sb. c. d3. 'B. Z:. 3. 5=<. K?. 5. 5><. 65. 5><. b. D. '3. 5. B. eB. KB. 5. KBf. D. :. 5=<. . g hi^j j Uik. mlonqprtsou;B v w3 K2yx=z{pq|o}>}~nqW| |zqnq x>}xFux> x sounq|/pW z n uC3 B v 5 5 ;x>1x>;x~nzrF npqsozqr8q Up rFxsqM{x>lon r |or6sorF n u; z n uqz#/nqpx=zxso1z|ouKn B v gQ 3e*sorF n u suKz. ( 5 l Bv 9 G Bv n GLKMKMKNGBov f q Q;D xE=¢ D ( 5 l Bv 9 GBv nFGLKMKNKMGKB 5 GLKMKMKNGBov f qIG£3 Q EUGIHJGLKMKNKMGK2G ¡. Ó1Óñ*ßÛßuÞ+. ¼ !¾.
(21)
(22) . . . nuen x=zSrF n z nrsM #szqzxF} nWlo|o} 1nzWsM lonqprtsou{B Q l P G n GLKMKMKNG P 5=< q x>rF U soaUn |or x>ln 5 5 5=< 9 P 5>< pqs #sonarz Zz1pSr |orwr nCrtsort|o}Que|ortnCrtsen9zqx #ne-x=z2 Q n} |zrpqs#zrFue|ox>1rwx=z u x>rFrtn|z 5. . . w. . . L "%Oy`M.0( (.
(23) . . p 9. . . ¼X ¾. P 5=< p 5 5 Q 2 5 K. $'(.Q1(UT X A1",&\.0]$'H`KHMP)1H$)O. doqlneF| «¥oA®qed{ywK§¦oq{neFRpbc¯¹ed{¢|q«»pblned{ldºRoAlxto bbo {Y¨IoÄw| «»cY|ssed§¦£¤b(tn_ehem¸Rp£¦§¦£¤¹{y£¦pc d|qbdedst d|qbln£µsed{l©o¯pblned{Itn|K¹e(o tn|qcY§¦emlyldºR£ò´ e´>tn_esemd£¦ln£¦|qblI| «Poln£¤bq§¦epblned{I_boÄ®eoed§¤£¦q£¦¹§¦e£¦ pembue | ed{n«*|q{ycYoqbue3cKeToqlnp{yemlA|q«v| ty_ed{pblned{ld´Æ^`_£µl¯£µlYo cY|qpRtl(tn|Æu|bln£¦sem{n£¦o³u|ty£¤Wppbc |q« b§¦oÄwed{ldºseToq_D| «;¨F_£µ_D_boqlvcYolnlÃded{y|b´I^`_£µlcY|ssed§¦£¤b\q£¦®qeml{n£µlety|Ytn_e¯¿°oq{ys{y|qDeT¸pb£¤§¦£¤¹b{n£¦pc "f !#ty_bo,tItnpb{nblI|pst©ty|¹ehc¯pb_emoqln£¦ed{Áty|_o bs§¦etn_boq·vol_em¸Rp£¦§¤£¦¹{y£¤pbc ´>bo {ntn£µup§µo {TºR£²tFdoq |q«ÕtnemZ¹ehu|cKbpstneT\¹WwYln|q§¦®W£¤bAl|cKeu|qW®eurYcK£¦£¦cY£¤ÃTo,tn£¦|q3{n|¹§¦edc ¼*¨F_£µ_3doq\¹eh£¦tyed{y{yeutneT olo eT¸Rp£¤®,oq§¤emt({y|q¹b§¤emc¨F£²ty_°oDln£¤§¤eKpblned{(o ln|qcYeY| tn_bed{(u|Rlxth«*pbutn£¦|q»´K¿³e\ln_bo §¦§;u|cKe ¹oqªYtn|Yty_£µloqlneTÛtF§µo,tnem{¾uºleme fm #´ É *Í . Q EUGIHJGLKMKNKMG g hi^j j Ui. lnqp r su9B v 3 K2 x=z pe|}>}~nq | |ouKuKs *nq x>} xFux> \x %su;nq|Ep{uKs 43 5 rF n_s}>}~s x> s}~z ^sou nq|Epueso W3 %} nr8Y95C7 Y K n rF nz nrAsCuKs r nz|Ep rF1|}>} - z nq wr |orx=z rF nCz nrsMp }~|ozez nz6zq1p-rF |r P 4 J 0_Y95e Q n 5=<. . . . . . sunq|Epe0_]Y65 |o-nq|Epg. _]Y95. 4fl BTv q{ . . . l BUv q. `^ _be3seu±£²ty£¤| £µloD«*|{ncp§µo,tn£¦|q |q«`tn_e3tx¨©|9¿Æo {s{y|qÆ{y£¤u£¦§¤eTld¶\oq§¤§©pbleT bolnlneml(|q«vo[q£¦®qem d§¦olnl¯_boÄ®qe3tn_e lnoqcYeu|RlxtTºÁo b tn_£µlKu|lt£µlK| tKq{yemo tned{¯tn_boq ty_ed|lt| «pWpbleT bo tn_blm´Æ |p{moqlneqºbtn_eKu|ltv£µlv£µsemty£²±em[¨F£¤tn_9¹b§¤|sªW£¤bZ{y|q¹boq¹£¤§¦£¤tn£¦emlm´·| tyeAty_bo,ttn_e|q{y£¤£¤boq§»¿Æo {s{n| eT¸Rp£¤§¦£¦¹{n£¦pc!¨Iol({neTlxty{n£µÛtyem³tn|Dty_e3moqlneYtn_bo to[u§µoqlyl(doq ¹eZ£µsemty£²±emƨF£¤tn_ oDboq£¤{A|q«`ln|qpb{yde emltn£¦bo,ty£¤|»ºNo b[£¤tAs£µ9|qt£¦bu§¦pbseK|qp{lneutty£¤b£¦¨F_£µ_sN£ !ed{yedRtd§¦olnlnemldoq9_boÄ®qeKsN£ !em{nemt ¹b§¤|sªW£¤b¯{y|q¹boq¹£¦§¤£¤tn£¦emlI¹eutx¨Iededtn_behlyo cYel|p{ydehoqb3emltn£¦bo,ty£¤|o §¦|qb¯ty_e(lnoqcKehbo tn_blmºsl£¦bue ty_edwY{yem¸Rp£¦{ne"£ !ed{yedRtIoqcY|qpRt¢|q«»¹bo b¨F£¦Wty_»´Á~D|q{yed|,®ed{Tº,tn_beu|Rlxt©| «¥o(bo tn_Z£µl©pblpo §¦§¤wK{ned«*ed{y{neT ty|Zoql`ty_e¯lnpc| «;§¤£¦ª u|ltylvo §¦|qYty_bo,tvo,tn_¥ºb¨F_£µ_[s|Wemlb| tvo b§¤wtn|\|p{vlneutntn£¦b´`Å|,¨Ied®ed{Tº edrWtnedl£¦|qblvtn| c¯pb§²ty£¦d§¦olnlln£²typbo,ty£¤|blv¨F_b£¦_°u|,®qem{|p{hcK|ssem§;s|edrs£¦ltmº»lnedeKeq´ b´ fdº =©_o »´ %#ò´ )Áedtmº»olv¨Ieln_bo §¦§>lemeqºtn_eYu|bs£¤tn£¦|qblv«*|q{tn_beKpb£¦¸Rpememlyl| «Áem¸Rp£¦§¦£¤¹{y£µoZ{yemlnedRtneTDtn_bed{yeKs|| t _b|q§µ3£¦D|qp{moqlneq´ ÉWÍ É 1 ! " k. Q n uKnn Ex=zrFz9|. ;|uKouKs. nq x>}xFux> . Ñ*ÒPÓ»ÑÕÔ.
(24) Ë -
(25) - -3È V. ͻͽ¿°e|qtne3tn_bo tty_e lneutK| «|q§¦£¦d£¤eTlK£¦l¹|pbseTN´ ^`_e3b{n|W| «Fty_ed½«*|q§¦§¤|,¨ls£¦{neTÛtn§¦w «*{y|qc ^`_ed|{nemc ´¦f\£¦ fm#òºP¨F_£µ_ lxto,tneTltn_o,to[ln|q§¦pstn£¦|qÆedrW£µltylty|o[ledtA| «ln|qcYe\®,o {y£¦o tn£¦|qboq§ £¦eT¸po §¦£²ty£¤eTld´(^`_em»º»^`_ed|{nemc ´¦fd3£¦ fd%#>eTlxto ¹§¦£µl_eTltn_bo tty_eKln|q§¦psty£¤|9tn|3tn_eTleK£¦em¸Rpboq§¤£¤tn£¦eml £µl`£¦bsedeTDo¿Æo {s{y|q em¸Rp£¦§¤£¦¹{y£¤pbc ´ Y !<! ! &% ! " . . . . X A#"%&
(26) 4]$'HK`HP'1HK$'O. ¿°e|,¨ u|bln£¦sem{;tn_beF«*|q§¦§¤|,¨F£¦(edrsoqcY§¤e´P^`_bed{yevo {ye`tx¨©|(o {o §¦§¤em§§¤£¦ªslm´P^`_e±b{ylt¢|eqºRsed|qtneT Common destination. link b, 3 units of bandwidth. link a, 2 units of bandwidth. Common source. PÇ £¦qp{yeYfq¶ÁiF|pstn£¦Ktn|Yboq{yoq§¤§¦ed§N§¦£¤bªWl ¹WwºTd|qbln£¦ltyl¥| «bI¹boqbs¨F£µWtn_Apb£²tldº,oqbhtn_e©leTu|q|qeºTsem| tyem¹Wwh;ĺ,u|ql£µlxtlN| « F¹o bs¨F£µWty_ pb£²tld´Æ^`_em{ne o {ye[{n|pblty_bo,tY¨F£¦ln_ ty|³ln_£¤½tn{o ZY«*{y|qc od|qcYcY|q½ln|qpb{yde\tn|°ou|cYcK| emltn£¦bo,ty£¤|»´%)Áoq_oq{n{y£¦®Äoq§| «Ïh{y|qpb K{yem¸Rp£¦{yeml9f¹bo b¨F£¦Wty_p£¤tylmº¨F_em{neToqlZoqo {y{n£¦®,o §|q« Ïh{y|qpbn©{yem¸Rp£¦{neTlI|q§¦w¹bo s¨F£¦stn_Dp£¤tm´ ¿°eolnlnpcYetn_bo to §¦§¥plem{ylmo [lnedb ty{y%o \(tn_{y|qp_D¹|qtn_[§¦£¤ªslm´`¿³e¯ed|qtne(ty_ed§¦olnlneml`¹Ww ty_eYtnpb§¤e l iG+JqF¨F_em{ne Q G lxto bblh«*|q{tn_be\pblem{Ao ba + Q G;¯ltyoqblh«*|q{ty_e\§¦£¤ª´Z^`_Wpbl Y Q C l G q[G l GI;@qIG l G q[G l G;@qoOR´³§¦§Fu§µoqlyleTl(_boÄ®e\tn_e lnoqcYeln|qp{ueZoqb seTlxty£¤bo tn£¦|q»´³¿³e _oÄ®qe Y Q C l G q[G l GI;@q[O(oqb Y Q C l G qIG l GI;@q[O´>¿°e(_boÄ®qeh£¤Dboq{ty£¦dp§µo {Itn_e(¹o bs¨F£µWty_ {yem¸Rp£¦{yedcYedRtylm*¶ ; Q ; Q E(o ] ; Q ; Q H´ ·v| tne¶Ptn_£µl¢beutx¨I|q{yª£µl¢b| t`em¸Rp£¦®Äoq§¤emRtÁtn|YoAln£¤§¤ebo {o §¦§¦ed§b§¦£¦ªY¨F£²ty_doqboqd£²txw\sºWln£¤bdev¨Ies| b| to §¦§¤|,¨oYl£¦q§¦e(doq§¤§ty|\¹eAln§¦£²tF¹eutx¨IededD§¦£¤bª Zoqb §¤£¦ª ;Ä´ 3. {3. <. Ó1Óñ*ßÛßuÞ+. <. <. <.
(27) !.
(28) . `^ _eAltyo tneAlnboqde£¦lIty_eA{y|sspbÛtF|q«1ty_eAlxto,tyeAlboue| «Pemo_ lnedboq{yo tne§¦£¤ª´Á£¤®edDlxto,tne(|q« §¦£¦ª,+K£¦lIo¯tnp§¦e l G q>¨F_bed{ye £¦l©tn_beWpc¹em{I|q«¥|qbq|q£¦¯mo §¦§¦l©| «¥txwRehÛºWoqb Y£µl©tn_ehWpc¯¹ed{ |q«1|q|£¤Ydoq§¤§µl`| «PtxwWen©|,®ed{`§¤£¦ª^+b´Á^`_beltyo tneAlnboqde . |q«P§¦£¤bª+\£µlItn_Wpblmº . . . . Q C l JG!q[G l EFG qIG l HG Jq[G l JGdE q[O. . oqb Q C l JG Jq[G l EUG!qIG l HJG Jq[G l G!q[G l GLE qIG l EUGLEUqoOTK Çb|q{Fpblned{ ºo\do §¦§N£µl`¹§¤|sªem|q §¤£¦ª Z£²«;£¤t£¦l`|qtedcYstxw´Á^`_£¦l`|smup{l`¨F£²ty_D{n|¹bo ¹b£¤§¦£²txw . . < . Q EU. P. . < P <
(29). P < P < P < P 9 <
(30) P 9 < P ];. <
(31). n. < P < . P. S H
(32) Q FE E. E 9P <
(33) P 9 <
(34) P n < S H. bÇ |q{`q{y|qpb ºoYmo §¦§N£¦l`|qt¹§¦|Wªem3|q §¤£¦ª v£¤«1ty_ed{ye(o {ye|Y|q|£¤Ydoq§¤§µl`| «1tn_bo tq{y|qp|,®qem{ ty_bo,t§¦£¦ª3o 3ty_ed{ye£¦lvo,tFcY|lt`|e(doq§¤§»|q«Pd§¦olnl`©|,®qed{`§¦£¤bª];Ä´;^`_Wpbl . < . Q E< E. P. < . E. P n < S H. P. < . P < S
(35). P. < . P.
(36). < P < . K. Çb|q{F{n|p3Ûº§¦£¦ª Z£µl`¹§¦|sªqem£¤«1ty_ed{ye£¦lFem£²ty_ed{F|e(doq§¤§N|q«Ppblned{`n©|ty_bo,tF§¦£¤bª3|q{`ty_ed{ye(o {ye mo §¦§¦l`|q«1{n|pÛ´^`_b£¦lF|smup{lI¨F£²ty_[{n|¹bo ¹b£¤§¦£²txw
(37). .
(38). P. Q E. < .
(39). < . P 9 <
(40).
(41).
(42). n S H P <
(43) P 9 <
(44) P n < S H. Çb|q{q{y|qp[Ûº§¤£¦ª ;h£µlv¹§¦|sªqeTD£²«Áty_ed{yeA£µlvem£²ty_ed{h|qbe¯doq§¤§P| «;pblned{hoqb[|qbeA| «Ápblned{F|q[ty_bo,t §¦£¦ªZ|q{`ty_ed{ye(o {ye Kmo §¦§¦l`|q«P{n|p3Û´^`_£¦l`|smup{l`¨F£²ty_D{n|¹bo ¹b£¤§¦£²txw .
(45). P < P <
(46) P < S n P <
(47) P < S H
(48) P < S
(49) P <
(50) k5 4 Q EUG:0_ Y 5 479 4P 2 Q E 2 Q JK H P 4hQ 2 4FS 5 4. < . Q E. ¿°eÆu|ql£µsed{yem ty_e³«*|q§¦§¤|,¨F£¦½o {o cYeutyed{ld¶ £¦Rtnem{y_boqqhe 2 4 ¨F£²ty_ ¾ qº s´¼@iFeTdo §¦§»ty_bo,t d§¦oln<l 0ºo b3tn_bo t ´é¾ ¿°e(|,¨4ln|q§¦®qeTZty_eAlneutF| «P«*|qp{FeT¸Rpbo,ty£¤|bl. P. < P < . K. ¼*tn_£µlD_|q£µue³¨F£¤§¦§(o §¦§¤|,¨ pbltn| £µl`tn_eoÄ®qed{o emo §¦§¥sp{o,ty£¤| |q«
(51). ¼fm¾ ¼fqfT¾ Q G K P P Q 2 G ¨F_b£¦_(RoÄ®qe;pbl¥tx¨©|lneutl¥|q«l|§¤psty£¤|blm´ )ÁeutP|q§¦wh|qeÁ|q«stn_eTle©l|§¤psty£¤|bl¥lyo,ty£¦l±beThtn_e©|qbedo tn£¦®W£²txw d|qbltn{o £¦Rtyl P . G 1G +´>^`_£¦lvl|§¤psty£¤|£µl`q£¦®qem¹Ww . P. 5=<. . < . . Q JK H. 5=< . 5=<.
(52). G P. < . l BUq Q. . 5=<. 5=< . l BFqIG. 5. 3. Q. G . 3. 3. . Q K E G P. < . Q JK . . G P. < . Q KNE K. Ñ*ÒPÓ»ÑÕÔ.
(53) Ë -
(54) - -3È. ^`_beh|¹styoq£¤bem {ne}xemutn£¦|q {n|¹bo ¹b£¤§¦£²ty£¤eTl`o {ye . Q. < . . < . Q K . . G. . < . Q. . < . X. Q K H HFHK. ^`_e3«@oqutAtn_bo t¯em¸Rpbo tn£¦|q¼fm¾¬¼fqfľh_boÄ®qeZo9ln£¦q§¦e3ln|q§¦pstn£¦|q s|WeTl(| tKcYemo Æty_bo,t¯tn_em{neZ£µl¯o ln£¦q§¦ev¿Æo {s{y|qZeT¸pb£¤§¦£¤¹b{n£¦pcD´;¿³eln_|qp§µ3ltn£¦§¦§»_emªK«*|q{`¿Æo {s{y|qZeT¸pb£¤§¦£¤¹b{n£µoA£¦¨F_b£¦_3«*|q{Fl|cYe ¢o b +bº P . Q b´ =©_bemªW£¤b\«*|q{tn_eYsN£ !em{nemRt|lyl£¦¹£¦§¤£¤tn£¦emlmº¨©eKdo cYe|qpsth¨F£²ty_9tn_be¯«*|§¤§¦|,¨F£¤b lnemd|qb¿Æo {s{n|3eT¸pb£¤§¦£¤¹b{n£¦pcD¶ 3. 5=<. P. < . Q K . G P. < . . ^`_beh|¹styoq£¤bem {ne}xemutn£¦|q {n|¹bo ¹b£¤§¦£²ty£¤eTl`o {ye . < . Q. . Q JK . < . . Q JK. EUG. . . G P. < . Q G P. < . Q JK HK. < Q JK G < Q < < (. Q JK H K. ¿°e3lnedeKtn_o,t¯_em{ne\¨Ie\_boÄ®e Q ¹pt ´ IpstAty_£¦l¯o q{yedeTl¨F£²ty_Ætn_e ¿Æo {s{y|q{n£¦bd£¤§¦ehtn_bo tlnoÄwsl©tn_bo t`tn_e(u|RlxtF|q«PoKbo,ty_3ty_bo,tF£µl`pblnem°¼*£¦ |p{Fdoleh{n|pstneR;tn_bo tF£¦l pleTD¹RwDpblned{¾uºln_|qpb§¦D¹e¯|3§¦oq{ned{Fty_bo [ty_bo,th| «Áo Ww bo,ty_9|qtvpblnem ¼@£¤9|p{moqlneqº{n|pstne º ¨F_b£¦_ _boql`£¦bsemem §µo {yqed{`¹§¦|sªW£¤K{y|q¹boq¹£¦§¤£¤txw¾Û´ ¿°eId|qbd§¤pse¢ty_bo,t>¨Ie¢_boÄ®e¢_em{ne©£¤bedemAtx¨©| R¿Æo {s{y|qAeT¸Rp£¤§¦£¦¹{n£µo´1Aty_e dlxto bbo { ¿Æo {s{y|q³em¸Rp£¦§¤£¦¹{y£¤pc!ledttn£¦º»£¤°¨F_£µ_ty_eZu|Rlxt| «`oDu§µoqlylhededbl|§¦w9|q³tn_e\ln|qp{ueYo emltn£¦bo,ty£¤|»º¨IeFªW|,¨ tn_bo t©¿Æo {s{y|qYem¸Rp£¦§¤£¦¹{y£¤pbcBememY|qt©¹ep£µ¸Rpevem£²ty_ed{TºR¹pst¢ty_bo,t¢tn_e§¤£¦ª ptn£¦§¤£¦Ãmo tn£¦|qZo {yepb£¦¸Rpem§¤wYseu±emN´;\|qtn_em{¢¨I|q{lmºq¨Ie_boÄ®qetn_em{nepb£¦¸Rpe®,o §¦peml¢| « P . Q P . «*|{em®qem{nwƧ¦£¤ª +Æo tKeT¸Rp£¤§¦£¦¹{n£¦pcDº©lnedeeq´ b´ fdº©»´ %#I|{Yed®qem½ln|qcYecp§¤tn£¤¬Âd§¦olnleurWtnembln£¤|bldº lnede f #ò´9½|qp{KdoqlneZ|qt|§¤w³tn_be3em¸Rp£¦§¦£¤¹{y£µo9o {yeZ|qtp£µ¸Rpeqº;¹bpst¨Ielnede\ty_bo,tYo §µl|9tn_e§¤£¦ª ptn£¦§¤£¦Ãmo tn£¦|qDo,tem¸Rp£¦§¦£¤¹{y£µoK"£ !ed{T´ . . <. <. ox=zr x>Up r. 6b. . 0b. F. VYXZ( [.
(55) ]$)H`HP'1HK$'O. 5. 5=<. v· eurWtmºb¨©e(u|bln£¦sem{`tn_eAlyo cYeeuroqcKb§¤e£¦ty_eAu|RtneurWtF| «>·vol_Dem¸Rp£¦§¦£¤¹{y£¦pc¨F£¤tn_ tx¨©|Y§µoÄwqem{ylmºW oqbDFd|q{y{neTl|qb£¤Kty|\tn_eAtx¨©|\{n|pblF¨IeAsemlyu{y£¦¹eTD£¤Dty_eA{yed®W£¦|qpbllnemutn£¦|q»´ =©|bl£µsem{Ftn_e «*|§¤§¦|,¨F£¦o {o cYeutyed{ld¶*2 Q 2 Q JK ºf5 Q EUGo5 Q Hs´ ^`_em tn_{yedeem¸Rp£¦§¦£¤¹{y£µoKoq{ne|¹styoq£¤eTNº^`_e±b{lt`£µl . ty_eAlnemu|b. 2 < Q JK 2. oqb3tn_ety_£¤{ Ó1Óñ*ßÛßuÞ+. < . Q JK H. . . GZ2. < . Q JK G62 < Q K G62 < Q K G. . GZ2. < . Q JK G62 < Q K . 2 < Q JG 2. < . Q JK . . GZ2. < . . EUGZ2. < . Q JK G. Q JK G<2 < Q K . K.
(56) fT.
(57) . " ! ' ". =©|bln£¦sem{Itn_e(§¦|lyl`eutx¨I|q{yªslI£¤[ÇP£¤p{yemlFKo b ´ . c. c. b. b. PÇ £¦qp{yeK¶·edtx¨©|{nªDÀ¨F£¤tn_³|qe¯«*|q{y¨Ioq{y£¤ Ç1£¦qpb{ne ¶·edtx¨©|{nª (¨F£¤tn_[tx¨I|Z«*|{n¨`o {s£¦ ¹b£¦s£¦{yemÛty£¤|bo §N§¦£¦ª p£µs£¤{yemutn£¦|qboq§N§¤£¦ªsl ^`_eTletxwWeTlI| «¥edtx¨©|{nªsl¢_boÄ®qe¹emedltnps£¤eTZ£¦ VRº !#N£¦Zty_ehd|qRtnedrWtI|q«1sed§µoÄwYcY£¤£¦cY£¤ÃTo,ty£¤| ¨F_bed{yevty_eAsed§µoÄwsl¢|q«1§¦£¤bªWlFd|q{y{neTl|q\tn|\~ q~ Wf¸RpedpeTl`¨F£²ty_£¦s±bb£²tye(¹p!ed{ld´ÁÅved{ye¨Ie(lxtypbsw ln|qcYe| «1tn_em£¤{v{n|em{ty£¤eTlI¨F_ed tn_be(|q¹s}xeTÛtn£¦®qeTlItn|Y¹e(cK£¦£¦cY£¤ÃmemDo {ye¹§¤|sªW£¦b{n|¹bo ¹£¦§¦£²ty£¤eTld´ ^`_em{neo {yeFtx¨©|Aln|qpb{ydeF|ssemlmº Yoqb` ;ĺWo bY|evu|cYcK|Zsemltn£¦bo tn£¦|q ,´;mo §¦§oq{n{y£¤®W£¦(o,t©o ln|qpb{ydev|ssedoq_|W|lnehed£¤tn_em{`oKs£¦{neTÛt`bo,ty_|q«¥|qbe_|»ºW|q{Fo o §¤tnem{nbo tn£¦®qebo,ty_3ty_bo,t`{neT¸Rp£¤{yeml tx¨I|D_|qld´ ^`_eZbo tn_blAoq{neYty_Wpbl Yo b ; «*|q{do §¦§µl(o {y{n£¦®W£¤[o t º>o k ; Koqb\ ; 9«*|q{¯mo §¦§¦l oq{n{y£¦®R£¦Ko,t ;Ä´ ¿°eAu|bl£µsem{©±£²tye§¤£¦ªmo bou£¤tn£¦em<l - º - «*p{ty_ed{ycY|q{yeqºs£¦beutx¨I|q{yªZ"ty_ed{ye£¦l`|e(u|c¬ cY|Z¹£µs£¤{yemutn£¦|qboq§§¦£¦ªY¨F£²ty_doqboqd£²txew - ºR¨F_b ed{yemoql¢£¤3eutx¨I|q{yª (ty_ed{yehoq{nev£¤bltneToqYtx¨I|¯pb£¦£²¬ {yemutn£¦|qboq§§¤£¦ªslF¨F£¤tn_[doqboqd£²ty£¤eT6l - o ba - ºs{neTlemutn£¦®qem§¤w´ ^1|3c\o ªe(tn_be{y|q¹b§¤emc|Rtn{y£¤®W£µo §¥¨Ie¯c\oqªqe¯oq{y|q{y£¦o tne¯olnlnpcYsty£¤|blFty_bo,thqpboq{yoqtyede(ty_bo,t ty_e(«*|{n¨`o {s£¦\§¤£¦ªsl_oÄ®qeAo [£¦ pbedbde¯|qDty_eAeT¸pb£¤§¦£¤¹b{n£¦pcDº£ò´ eq´`tn_bedwDc\oÄw3¹e¯{yemln|bl£¦¹§¦e«*|q{ ¹b§¤|sªW£¤bb´ Çb|q{(edtx¨©|{nª9 ¨IeYln_boq§¤§ÁolnlnpcYeKtn_bo Rt - - - ´Ybedem»º»£²«Itn_b£¦lAd|qb£²ty£¤|³£µl| t lyo,ty£¦l±beT\tn_bed3¨Iedo {nem§µoquetn_be¨F_|§¤elnwWltnemc¨F£²ty_ oKln£¤§¤eln|qp{ueK¼ Zoqb ;vu|qc¹£¦emb¾©o o[ln£¦q§¦e\§¤£¦ª°¹edtx¨©emedÆty_bo,tln|qpb{ydeYoqb°tn_be3semltn£¦bo tn£¦|q Y¨F£²ty_ doqboqd£²txkw - - º>¨F£²ty_|qpst o !eTÛty£¤Kty_e(¹§¦|WªW£¦Y{y|q¹boq¹£¤§¦£¤tn£¦eml¼*psed{voqWwZ|§¤£µuw¾u´ Çb|q{ln£¤cY£¦§¦oq{F{neToqln|qblmºW¨©e(oqlylnpcYe«*|{Feutx¨I|q{yª ( ty_bo,t - {}- oqb] - - ´ 4ed|qtneDty_eDtn|qtyo §edc\o bbl\¹Ww 2 ¼@oqb 2 ¾K¨F_£µ_ u|q{y{yemln|bltn|°tn_beDtn| to §F{o,tyety| ¹e ln_£¦emtn| «*{n|c ln|qp{ue ¼Uo b«*{y|qc ln|qp{uhe ;ĺ{yemlnemÛty£¤®ed§¦w¾Û´ a. a. . . . . . . .
(58) . . . .
(59). . .
(60) .
(61) .
(62). . . Ñ*ÒPÓ»ÑÕÔ.
(63) Ë -
(64) - -3È. '. . X A#"%&. ff. .^]_$)H`KHMP'aH$'O. ¿°eAln_bo §¦§Nemltyoq¹§¤£µln_3ty_e«*|q§¦§¤|,¨F£¦Kc\o £¦Dltn{ypbutnp{o §N{yemlnp§¤tm´ Í ÁÍ *Í <- j j iNk. ,s#zxEn unr sou rF n-pqsoUx>rFxs*rF | r {u- |o`-. . .
(65) . . souIUn r sou En u
(66) Q n -souesorFWnr souz 'r nuenIx=zUs ; rF1|}. |zqz ;x> r |or. . -. -. .
(67). -. . su |ouKx> o | r ;|uKoues Ynq x>} xFux> I!sr nu souez x | zr uxpr } sozx>rFx>lonCquK|/pr x so sSpq|}>} z |uux>l x> rts =x z uKs r nq-rF/uKsEo ;@ r n s s/z|ouux>lx> |o r ;S|ouKn;ueso rtne-rF/uKsEo A|oSl xpqn lon uqz|/. Í»Í =©|bln£¦sem{`eutx¨I|q{yª3A´vlylpcYehtn_o,tvo,tvln|qcYe¿Æo {s{n|3eT¸pb£¤§¦£¤¹b{n£¦pcoYltn{y£¦utn§¦wZ|ln£²¬ ty£¤®eh«*{yoÛtn£¦|q | «;doq§¤§µl`o {y{n£¦®W£¤b¯ty| \£¦l{n|pstneTZty_{n|pq_?;o b®W£¦de(®qed{lyo´ 4£¤{yemut¯u|emutn£¦|qbl«*{y|qc ;Atn| Ko {ye|§¦w9¹§¦|Wªem£²«`§¤£¦ªk; A£µlh«*p§¦§UºP¨F_ed{yemolv£¦bs£¦{yemÛt¯d|qs¬ bemÛty£¤|bl«*{y|qc 9ty| Ktn_o,t¯pblne;Kdoq ¹e3¹§¤|sªem°| t|q§¦w³£¤«; Y£µl«*p§¦§©¹ptKo §µln| £¤« ;£¦lA«*p§¤§ò´ ^`_be§µo,tntned{`c\oÄwY|sdupb{Iem®qem3¨F_em3§¦£¤ª ; £µl©b| t`«*p§¦§U´Á^`_eh¹§¦|sªR£¦Ko,t f;| «>lpb_3£¤b£¤{yemutFmo §¦§¦l _oql|Rl£¤tn£¦®qe{n|¹bo ¹b£¤§¦£²txwDln£¤bdeAty_ed{ye¯£µlhc¯pstypbo §1«*|q{y¨Ioq{y£¤Zoqbln£¦bu^e - - - ´h^`_b£¦l £¦cY§¦£¤eTl`tn_bo t ´ W£¦bde ; F_oql©|Rl£¤tn£¦®qe |,¨ | «1d|qeTÛty£¤|bl;«*{y|qc ºW£²tI«*|q§¦§¤|,¨lÁ«*{n|c ¿°oq{ys{y|q\b{n£¦bu£¦§¦evty_bo,t { ´°¿°eZtn_WpblYd|qbd§¤pbe\tn_bo t ´ (IwÆolwWcYcYeutn{y£µ3o {yqpbcKemRt¯¨©e doq |,¨ ln_|,¨ ty_e|q|ln£²tyeqºW£ò´ e´ ºsoqbZ|¹styoq£¤ od|qRtn{oqs£µÛty£¤|»´P¿³ehtn_Wpbl`d|qbd§¤pbevty_bo,tItn_em{ne mo b| tF¹e(cpstnpo §«*|q{y¨`o {s£¤bb´ ln£¤cY£¦§¦oq{;o {yqpcYedRtP_|q§µlP«*|q{>edtx¨©|{nª (h¶Ä£¤t;«*|q§¦§¤|,¨l>o Ro £¦(tn_o,t>tn_bo t ´>vlylnpcY£¤ cpstnpo §W«*|q{y¨`o {s£¤bbº,speItn|¿Æo {s{y|q¯b{n£¦bu£¦§¦eqºqln£¦bue ; ©_boqlP|ln£²ty£¤®e |,¨ | «u|qbemutn£¦|qbl1«*{y|qc º£¤t«*|§¤§¦|,¨lty_bo,t { ´(¿°eKd|qbd§¤pseAty_bo,t ´ABlnwWcYcKedtn{y£¦o {yqpcYemth§¤eToql ty|Ktn_e(||Rl£¤tne{yed§µo,ty£¤|psed{Fcpstnpboq§N«*|q{y¨`o {s£¤b¯¨F_£µ_D£¦l`£¦cY|Rlnln£¤¹b§¤e´ Í Í B B@s Ê " 6- Q - . . . . . A. . . .
(68) . .
(69) . . . . .
(70) .
(71) . . rF |rZ-.
(72) . . 9. . ,so1zxEn u'rF n'z o Inr uxp6pq|z n. HF- dsouUn r sou s1} x>uKnqpr_}x> z|ouenC z nqE. .
(73) . . . Yk.
(74). . ,. 9. .
(75) . . . |zqz ;x>Wr |orZ-.
(76) .
(77) . . Q. . .
(78) .
(79) . . Zs#zxEn udn x>rF n uAUn r su |ozez ;x> - ] )r |ouKuKs !nq x>}xFux> . . . . . Í»Í =©|bln£¦sem{Fed£¤tn_em{Feutx¨I|q{yª3|{ (´lnlnpcYetn_o,tvo,teT¸Rp£¤§¦£¦¹{n£¦pcDºboYltn{y£¦utn§¦wZ|Rl£¤tn£¦®qe oqcY|qpRtF| « |,¨«*{y|qc Zq|WeTlItn_{y|qp_a;,´Á^`_edDspety|Ytn_e({yed®W£¦|qpblFzÁ{n||Rl£¤tn£¦|q»ºoq§¤§ |,¨«*{y|qc ;|ReTlItn_{y|qpbq_?; ,´©^`_betn| to § |,¨4|,®ed{ ; h£¦lvlxty{n£µÛty§¤w§¦oq{ned{Itn_boqDtn_{y|qpbq_ ´©Åembue(¨Ie(_boÄ®e { ´4^`_RplY¿°oq{ys{y|q {y£¤u£¦§¤eTl\o {yeD®R£¦|q§µo,tyemNº`ln£¤bde tn_e9pleT½bo tn_ ; _boql ltn{y£µÛtn§¦wZ§µo {yqem{`d|lt`tn_boq oq| ty_ed{Fbo tn_D¹eutx¨Iededtn_beAlnoqcKe|{n£¦q£¦oqbDsemltn£¦bo,ty£¤|»´ . . . . .
(80) . Ó1Óñ*ßÛßuÞ+. . .
(81) . . .
Documents relatifs
« La prophétie, ou interprétation et conférence des Écritures se fera par les ministres du Colloque, en l’assemblée où chacun dira la tête découverte ce que Dieu lui
Pendant six ans, jusqu’au premier janvier 1568, le clergé de France doit fournir chaque année au roi l’équivalent de quatre décimes, un million six cent mille livres tournois,
« On ne fait pas que des psychothérapies en clinique/…/On en parlait encore ce matin : est-ce qu’on a le temps de faire des psychothérapies, parce qu’on voit les gens
L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non, émanant des
AMC PAPI : Spécificités du contexte torrentiel – Rapport de Phase 1 Page 18 sur 46 Dans le cas des laves torrentielles, on peut résumer les conditions nécessaires au
Gillard, “Combinaison de la DG-FDTD avec un mod` ele de substitution pour un calcul de dosim´ etrie locale dans un probl` eme variable et fortement multi-´ echelle”, dans 18`
Le jugement porté par les femmes lettrées sur leurs soigneurs doit donc être nuancé en fonction de la personnalité de chacune, de la gravité de la maladie,
3.3 Processus d’alimentation d'entrepôt de données : Nous devons extraire, transformer et charger les données à partir des sources précédemment citées, dans l'entrepôt de