HAL Id: jpa-00208606
https://hal.archives-ouvertes.fr/jpa-00208606
Submitted on 1 Jan 1977
HAL
is a multi-disciplinary open access archive for the deposit and dissemination of sci- entific research documents, whether they are pub- lished or not. The documents may come from teaching and research institutions in France or abroad, or from public or private research centers.
L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire
HAL, estdestinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non, émanant des établissements d’enseignement et de recherche français ou étrangers, des laboratoires publics ou privés.
Lifetime, Λ-doubling and hyperfine structure
measurements in the A 2Π excited states of ZnH, ZnD, CdH and CdD
J. Dufayard, O. Nedelec
To cite this version:
J. Dufayard, O. Nedelec. Lifetime,
Λ-doubling and hyperfine structure measurements in the A2Π excited states of ZnH, ZnD, CdH and CdD. Journal de Physique, 1977, 38 (5), pp.449-458.
�10.1051/jphys:01977003805044900�. �jpa-00208606�
449
LIFETIME, A-DOUBLING
AND HYPERFINE STRUCTURE MEASUREMENTS IN THE A 203A0
EXCITED STATES OF ZnH, ZnD, CdH AND CdD
J. DUFAYARD and O. NEDELEC
Laboratoire de
Spectrométrie Physique,
UniversitéScientifique
et Médicale deGrenoble,
B.P.53,
38041 GrenobleCedex,
France(Reçu
le 9 décembre1976, accepté
le26 janvier 1977)
Résumé. 2014 L’hydrure (ou deutérure) est obtenu dans l’état fondamental par décharge radio- fréquence dans un mélange d’H2 (ou D2) et de vapeur métallique à une pression totale de 10-2 torr
environ. Une excitation sélective des niveaux rotationnels de A
203A01
/2,3/2 est effectuée par un laser à colorant pulsé. On obtient la durée de vie par échantillonnage de la lumière de fluorescence :03C4 ~ 70 ns. Des résonances électriques de
radiofréquence
entre les niveaux 039B-doublés de A203A03/2,
v’ = 0, donnent la séparation 039B pour les quatre molécules et la structure hyperfine pour les hydrures.
Les valeurs obtenues des paramètres correspondants, (2 a + c) et b pour la structure
hyperfine
et q pour le doublement 039B, sont en MHz :$$
Abstract. 2014 The hydride (or deuteride) is obtained in the ground state by radiofrequency
discharge
in a mixture of H2 (or D2) and metal vapor at a total pressure of about 10-2 torr. A selective exci- tation of the A
203A03/2,1/2
rotational levels is obtained by a pulsed dye laser. Lifetimes are obtainedby sampling the fluorescent decay : 03C4 ~ 70 ns. Electric
radiofrequency
resonances between the~-doubled levels of A
203A03/2, v’
= 0, provide the 039B-doubling separation in the four molecules and the hyperfine structure in thehydrides.
The measured values in MHz of the relevant parameters (2 a + c) and b for thehyperfine
structure, and q for the 039B-doubling are :$$
LE JOURNAL DE PHYSIQUE TOME 38, MAI 1977,
Classification
Physics Abstracts
5.447
1. Introduction. - Various
techniques
ofspectro-
scopy without
Doppler
effect haverecently
beenapplied
to diatomic molecular excited states[1] : magnetic
resonance and levelcrossing
inH2 [2],
OH
[3, 4],
CN[5], 12 [6], Na2 [7],
NO[8] ;
level anti-crossing
inH2 [9];
microwave andradiofrequency
electric resonances in CN
[10],
BaO[11]
and CS[12],
saturated
absorption
in12 [13], two-photon absorption
in NO
[14]
and beam + laser in12 [15].
In theseexperiments,
a selective excitation is obtainedby
electron
impact [2, 9],
chemical reaction[5, 10],
atomic coincident line
[3, 7, 8, 12],
Ar+ laser[6, 11, 13]
and
dye-laser [4, 14, 15].
This lasttechnique,
whenit can be
used,
is the most flexible tool.We have
already reported
on lifetime measurements in CdH and CdD excitedby
apulsed dye
laser[16].
The
hydride
was obtainedby radiofrequency
dis-charge
inH2 (or D2)
and metal vapor at a total pressurevarying
from10-3
torr to 10 torr. Thealkaline earth
hydrides (and deuterides)
which can beobtained in these conditions are :
HgH, CdH, ZnH, MgH
and BeH[17].
A selective excitation and obser- vation of each rotational and A-doublet H level may beeasily
obtained due to thelarge
values of the rotational constants B in these molecules and to the alternation ofparity
in the rotational levels of theirX 2f ground
state.
This paper reports lifetime measurements, level
Article published online by EDP Sciences and available at http://dx.doi.org/10.1051/jphys:01977003805044900
crossing experiments,
andradiofrequency
electricresonances in the A
2n
state ofZnH, ZnD,
CdH and CdD.A-doubling
andhyperfine separations
up to 1 700 MHz are determined with an error smaller than the radiative width(2 MHz).
We have notyet
observed the fluorescence from theB2L
state, the Frank- Condon factors from the v = 0ground
statebeing
very small.
2.
Apparatus.
- Theapparatus
is the same as in ref.[17].
The linewidth of thedye laser,
about 0.2A (Fig. 1),
allows for a selectiveexcitation
of the A2n
rotational and A-doubled levels. A selective obser- vation can be made with a HRS 1 Jobin-Yvon mono- chromator of 12A/mm resolution,
used in the second order. An EMI 9816photomultiplier
of 3 ns time-spread
is used.In lifetime measurements, the fluorescence
signal
is
sampled
with a PAR boxcar162/163.
Itsgatewidth
is fixed at 1 nanosecond. The
aperture delay
range has been recalibratedby comparison
with asignal
pro- videdby
aradiofrequency synthesizer.
In level cros-sing
and electric resonanceexperiments,
thesignal
is
integrated
with the PAR162/164
boxcar. Itsgate-
width is tunable and was selected to be muchlarger
than the
lifetime,
i.e. 500 ns, to record the averageintensity
variation with theapplied magnetic
fieldintensity
or electric fieldfrequency.
The tunable
frequency
electric field isprovided by
a Boonton
generator, coupled
to a 10 Watt ENI 420 Lwideband
amplifier directly
connected to theplates applied
on the cell. Thefrequency
may vary from 4 MHz to 520 MHz. Itsdisplayed
values have been verified with an electronic counter. The absolute erroris less than 0.01 MHz.
3. Lifetimes measurements. - In ZnH and
ZnD,
the lifetime of A2 n l/2
and A2 n 3/2 (v’
=0)
levelshave been measured in the same way as in our
previous experiments
on CdH and CdD[17].
The resultsgiven
in table I are derived from
extrapolation
to zeroH2 (or D2)
pressure. Thetemperature
of the cell(r =
320°C) gives
for Zn a vapour pressure less than 6 x10-3
torr. We have verified that theintensity
of the R.F.
discharge
has no influence on the measured lifetimes.’
The excitation and observation are made on the band heads of the v" = 0 -+ v’ = 0 and v’ = 0 -+ v" = 1 transitions
respectively,
to remove the laser scatteredlight.
TABLE I
ZnH
and ZnD,
A2n lj2,3j2, v’
= 0lifetimes,
in nanoseconds
451
We have tried to show evidence of a
perturbation
in the
2nl/2 (v’
=1)
state of CdHby
the variation of the lifetime of this levelaccording
to the rota-tional levels J
[18].
From the spectra[19, 20],
it ispossible
to see that the CdH A2 n l/2 (v’
=1)
levelis
perturbed by B 2Z (v’
=0)
at J’ =15.5-, 16.5+,
16.5- and 17.5+. The energy
displacement
B of theperturbed
levels isalways
less than 4cm-1,
and theenergy difference 2 3 between the
interacting
levelsis about 50
cm - 1.
If tn and T_, are the lifetimes of theunperturbed levels,
the lifetimer3
of theperturbed
level is
given by [18] :
We have measured the lifetime of several rotational levels of A
2n l/2, v’
= 1 ofCdH,
andfigure
2 showsthat there is no
appreciable
variation of the lifetime of theperturbed
rotational levels.Taking
into accountthe error
margin
of ourexperimental results,
we can. roughly
estimate that the lifetime of theperturbing
state
B 2L
is between 60 ns and 300 ns.4. Level
crossing experiment
mll3/2
levels. - Thehyperfine
structure due to the nuclearspin
of H(or D)
is
expected
to be smaller than theDoppler width,
as it is the case in the atom. Whereas the
hyperfine
structure due to the nuclear
spin
of themetal,
for oddisotopes,
may be greater than theDoppler
width[21].
We shall measure the
hyperfine
structure due to H(or D)
in radicals with even metalisotopes.
We usenatural Zn and Cd which contain 96
%
and 75%
even
isotopes respectively.
Level-crossing experiments (Fig. 3)
have beenperformed
in ZnH andCdH,
A2II3/2,
v =0,
J =2 .
The - level has been choosen as it allows us to obtain
a
higher polarization
rate, about 20%, by
R excitationand P +
Q
detection. In thisexperiment,
it is necessary to use a boxcar gate much wider than the lifetime rto avoid
observing
the Zeeman quantumbeats,
i.e.a modulation at two times the Larmor
frequency.
The Zeeman
diagram
isgiven
infigure
4a. TheLand6 g
factors are obtained from the formula(2) [22]
FIG. 3. - Experimental set up for level crossing experiments ;
eo : polarization of the laser beam L ; e 1 : observation polarization;
Ho : magnetic field.
FIG. 4. - a) Zeeman diagram. b) Level crossing signals in ZnH,
A 2n3/2, v’ = 0, J = 1-.
and from the values of
Av and Bv given by
the spec- tra[ 19, 20]
Figure
4b shows the levelcrossing
curves obtainedwith two hours
signal averaging,
i.e. 70 runs of 100 s.The Hanle effect is the
superposition
of two curvescorresponding
to F = 1 and F = 2.Their g
factorsare
given
in tableII,
and their relativeamplitudes
are 3 and 7
respectively
obtained from the formulaThe
superposition
to these two curves calculated withT = 70 ns agrees with the
experimental
curve. Thetwo non-zero field level
crossing signals
have a poorsignal-to-noise
ratio andgive imprecise
results. Thehyperfine
doubletseparations
are small and very similar for CdH and ZnH(Table II).
It has not beenpossible
to obtain acrossing signal
for J= 2,
orfor the deuterides. We have also failed to observe
hyperfine
quantum beats without amagnetic
field[24].
Instead of
improving
our apparatus to make suchexperiments,
we havepreferred
to undertake electricresonance
experiments
which areexpected
toprovide
more
precise
results.TABLE II
Calculated
values of
gJand gF in
ZnH andCdH,
A2 n 3/2’ v
=0,
J=3/ 2
level.Experimental
valueof
the
hyperfine
structure.5. Electric resonance
experinienta
- Weperform
a selective excitation of one A-doubled component.
The
applied
electric field induces transitions between the two A-doubledlevels,
which haveopposite parity,
when its
frequency corresponds
to their energyseparation.
Whenscanning
the electric fieldfrequency,
the resonance is detected
by
the appearance of thelight
emitted from the A-doubled level which is notexcited
by
the laser(Fig. 5).
1
FIG. 5. - Allowed electric radiofrequency transitions in ZnH
or CdH, 2n state (I = t).
The +
(or -)
statebeing
excited at time t = 0and the
probability
offinding
the molecule at time t in the -(or +)
state isgiven by
the Rabi formula[25] :
w/2
H is thefrequency
of theapplied
electricfield, 1iw + -
is the energyseparation
of the + and -levels ;
and
V+ _
is the matrix element of theperturbation
between the two states. In our case,
V+ _
is propor- tional to theamplitude
of the electricfield,
to itsfrequency,
and to the electricdipole
moment matrixelement
[25, 26],
which is in Hund’scoupling
case(a) :
p is the electric
dipole
moment of the electroniclevel,
and K is a unit vector
along
the internuclear axis.In our
experiment, only
a small fraction of popu- lation istransferred, i.e. I V, - I h
T.Figure
6represents
the variation of the + and - levels popu- lation with time. The + levelpopulation
decreasesexponentially
=N +(t)
=No e-rt.
The - level popu- lation variesaccording
to the formula :. -- ... I
N- (t)
has a modulated term which appears when(o - w + - is
slightly
different from zero.453
% - - -1
FIG. 6. - Variation with time of the intensity emitted by one of
the A-doubled levels, CdH A
2 II 3/2’
v = 0, J = 6.5. a) Directlyexcited by the laser ; b) Populated by electric resonance, w=w+_ = 431 MHz;
c) Populated by electric resonance, off resonance, w = 424 MHz.
The amplitude of the curves b and c have been multiplied by 10
and 20 respectively.
The
integrated intensity
isproportional
to :The
anticrossing
curve obtainedby varying
theapplied frequency
with agatewidth
muchlarger
thanthe
lifetime,
is Lorentzian. Its width athalf-height
is2[r 2
+4(V+-/h)2]l/2
and goes to 2 r when theelectric field
amplitude
goes to zero, i.e. about 4.5 MHz in ourexperiments.
Theamplitude
ofE,
necessary to obtain anappreciable population transfer, depends
on
J, F,
F’. Thedependence
of the electricdipole
moment matrix elements with the
angular
momentum(3b)
isgiven
in table III. The summation over M has been made :The resonances with AF = 0 are much stronger than those with AF= ±
1,
which become weaker as J increases and may be hiddenby
the tail of the AF = 0resonances.
The Stark
effect,
due to theapplied
electricfield,
shifts the resonancefrequency.
It is theBlock-Siegert shift, equal
to[25]
FIG. 7. - The cell and the applied fields for the electric resonance
experiment.
and is small
compared
to the width of the resonance curves, since 2V, - Ih
r w.The cell used for these
experiments
is shown infigure
7. The measurements are made at low pressure,10-2
torr, in order to avoid collision transfers between + and - levels. We excite the +(or -)
level
by
the R(or P)
component, the laserlight being polarized parallel
toE,
and detect theintensity
emitted
by
the other -(or +)
level on theQ
+ R(or Q
+P)
component(Fig. 8).
Figure
9 shows theanticrossing signal
obtained forthe J =
1.5 +,
2.5 - and 3.5+of ZnH,
A2H 312, V
= 0levels. The central resonance
corresponds
to the twoAF = 0
transitions,
which are unresolved andgive
the
A-doubling separation.
It ispossible
to show thatthe
hyperfine
level F = J+ 1/2
is situated above F =J - 2 by comparing
the intensities of the two satellitelines,
as their intensities areproportional
to the
population
of the level excitedby
thelaser,
i.e.(2
F +1),
andapproximately
toOJ2.
Forinstance,
in
figure I Ob,
the J = 2.5 - level is excitedby
the laser.This level is situated under 2.5+. It can be seen that the lowest
frequency
satellite has the greatest inten-sity :
this satellitecorresponds
to the transfer fromTABLE IV
. t-doubling wlmrations
in A 21I v =0,
obtained in this work andby
conventional spectroscopyF = 3 to F = 2.
By exciting
J =2.5+,
it is the lowestfrequency
satellite which is smaller than the other satellite.When the electric field is strong
enough
for thesatellite resonances AF = 1 to have a sufficient
amplitude,
the width of the central resonance curve isequal
to the limit value 2 rmultiplied by
two or more,and the satellite curves may be hidden. We have reduced the width of the curves
by integrating
in theboxcar
only
a part of thesignal
with a gate of about 50 ns, fixed at 200 ns after the laserpulse. Therefore, only large
lifetimes are selected and the width of thecurves is divided
by
about two. But a quantum beat appears[4]
which should not beinterpreted
as asatellite resonance. The fact that the
hyperfine
struc-ture is not much greater than the natural width limits the
ability
of thisexperiment
to measure thehyper-
fine structure when J increases.
However,
as J increases455
FIG. 8. - CdH, A
2 II 3/2
(v’ = 0) - X 2,E + (v’ = 0), emitted lines : a) After laser excitation of J’ = 6.5+ by R21(0-0) line; b) Additionof an electric field at resonance populating the J’ = 6.5 - level.
the AF = 0 resonances are easier to obtain
experi- mentally.
The electric power necessary decreases as an effect of thephoton absorption probability being proportional
to0)2. Moreover,
there is a better pene- tration of the field in the cell which contains electrons andions,
from thedischarge
whichprovides
theradicals. The resonances at about 10 MHz have been observed with
difficulty
whereas the resonances in thefrequency
range 500-1 700 MHz have been obtained withonly
the harmonics of the generator.It has been verified that the observed
frequency for
a resonance does not vary, whether the observed
region
is the centre of the cell or close to the walls.There is no error due to a static electric field
provided by
the accumulation ofcharged particles
on the walls.TABLE V
6. Determination of molecular constants. -
In
diatomic molecules the
theory
of theA-doubling
has been
developed by
Van Vleck[27],
and thetheory
ofmagnetic hyperfine
structureby
Frosh andFoley [28]. Equations
have been stated in a convenient form forapplication
toexperimental data,
for2n
FIG. 9. - Electric resonance signals obtained in ZnH, A 2n 3 ’2’ l’ = 0.
LE JOURNAL DE PHYSIQUE. - T. 38, No 5, MAI 1977 31
-j
FIG. 10. - Experimental values of the A-doubling separations in ZnH, ZnD, CdH and CdD, A
2 n 3/2’
v’ = 0.states in the
general
intermediate case between(a)
and
(b) [22, 28] :
I r m 1 -
For
regular
fine structuredoublets,
which is thecase in
point,
the uppersign
in front of Xapplies
to states that go over to the pure
Ill/2
state of Hund’scase
(a).
The lowersign applies
ton 3/2’
Thehyper-
fine
doubling
term in dgives equal
andopposite
contributions to each member of the A-doublet. It vanishes for
n3/2
states in case(a), A,IB, >>
1.In our
experiment
where thecoupling
scheme isvery near to case
(a),
the two resonancescorrespond- ing
to AF = 0 areconfused,
asexpected.
For thehyperfine
structure, it remains to determine the cons- tants a, b and c.Moreover,
the coefficients of 2 a and c in formula(7)
are very similar and we canonly
determine the values of
(2 a
+c)
and b(Table VI).
TABLE VI
Hyperfine
structure constants(MHz)
in A
2 n 3/2’ v =
0To obtain the
parameters p and q
it is necessary to consider both the2 n l/2
and2II3/2
levels : inN1/2,
VA
depends essentially
on p(6b),
and inn 3/2’
vAdepends
on a combinationof p and q (6b).
As a firstapproach,
we take the value of p obtained on171/2 by
conventionalspectroscopy [29, 30],
and we obtainq from our results on
173/2 by using
formula(6a).
TABLE VII
A =
Av/Bv.
Ratio x 100of
second orderv(2)A
tofirst
order(6)
terms in the calculationof
theA-doubling
457
TABLE VIII
p and q values
(cm-1)
relative to theA-doubling
in A2 n,
v = 0.Overall
centrifugal
distortion parameter x in ourexperimental
results inn 3/2
To
improve
thesevalues,
severaladjustments
must be made :
1)
The formula(6a)
is valid ifI A I « I AEn,I> I.
If not, second order terms
v (2)
must be taken into account[22].
It is along expression
that we do notwrite here. We have calculated their contribution to the
A-doubling (Table VII).
The variation of thispercentage
with J is very small.2)
Thecentrifugal
distortiongives
a variation of the type(1
+xJ(J
+1)
+ x’J2(J
+1)2 ...) on B,
A, ð.E(ll,I), A, p and q [22, 29, 30].
At this stage ofour
work,
we haveonly
tried to avoid an error dueto this effect in the determination of the
parameters
p and q. This error is notnegligible
when theA-doubling
for the smallest values of J has not been measured.
A few parameters necessary to calculate the centri-
fugal
distortion in these molecules areunknown,
i.e.Av=1
fordeuterides, H,, Fv ...
However it ispossible
to compare theimportance
of this effecton the different
parameters
of formulae(6a), (6b) by using
theapproximate
formulae of ref.[30],
so asto make the necessary
approximations
toextrapolate
vA at small J values.
3)
The effect of the B 2 I + level must be evaluated.Its
vibrational
level v = 0 has the same energy asv = 1 of A
ifI-.
From the energydisplacements,
dueto rotational
perturbations
in ZnH[19]
and CdH[20],
and from the calculated Franck-Condon factors
[33],
it is
possible
to show that the effect of level B on theA-doubling
of level A v = 0 is about thousand times smaller than the observedA-doubling,
and may beneglected.
We have calculated the
parameters p and q by
amean square fit of the
experimental A-doubling separations (Table IV)
on173/2
andn 1/2 [19, 20, 30, 31]
with formula(6a).
This formula has been multi-plied by
a coefficienttaking
into account the secondorder terms
(Table VII).
The formula(6a)
forn 3/2
has been
multiplied by [I
+x.J(J +1)]
to takeinto account the
centrifugal distortion,
where x isan
adjustable
parameter. This treatment is valid sinceformula
(6a)
andv(2)A
haveapproximatively
the samevariation with
J,
and thecentrifugal
distortion forH312
isnearly
the same onp/A2 , ql À,
andV(2)A
butmuch smaller for
Hl/2,
i.e. on p. In each series of results(Table IV), only
the first five have been used to obtain theextrapolated
valuesof p
and q. These values aregiven
in table VIII.The error is
essentially
due to theexperimental uncertainty
for the first rotational levels inn l/2’
The difference between our values
of p
and the values of ref.[31]
is due to the correctionv(2)
that we havemade. Our
values of q
are greater than the values of ref.[29]
and[30].
This is because thecentrifugal
distortion
provides
a reduction of theA-doubling
in
n3/2
of about 50%
forCdH,
and 10 to 20%
forZnH,
at the values of J where it had been measuredby
conventional spectroscopy. We notice that theexperimental
valuesof p and q
are smaller than the values calculated in theapproximation
of pure pre-cession. However their relative values
(Table IX)
between
isotopes
agree with the calculated ratio.TABLE IX .
Ratio
of p and q
values betweenhydrides
and deuterides
Acknowledgments.
- We are indebted to A. Jour-dan,
J. M.Negre
and J. M.Castejon
for technicalassistance,
to M. Merlin and M. Lombardi for writ-ing
the mean square fit program, to R. A. Bell and D. Branch forsending
us their Franck-Condon calculations beforepublication,
and to M. deFilippi
for
lending
us theradiofrequency
generator andamplifier.
References
[1] Spectroscopie sans largeur Doppler de Systèmes Moléculaires
Simples, Colloque C.N.R.S., Aussois 1973.
[2] BALTAYAN, P. and NEDELEC, O., Phys. Lett. 37 (1971) 31.
JOST, R., MARECHAL, M. A. and LOMBARDI, M., Phys. Rev. A
5 (1972) 740.
[3] WEINSTOCK, E. M. and ZARE, R. N., J. Chem. Phys. 58 (1973)
4319.
[4] GERMAN, R. N., J. Chem. Phys. 64 (1976) 4192.
[5] SILVERS, S. J., BERGEMAN, T. H., KLEMPERER, W., J. Chem.
Phys. 52 (1970) 4385.
[6] BROYER, M., LEHMAN, J. C., VIGUE, J, J. Physique 36 (1975)
235.
[7] MCCLINTOCK, M., DEMTRODER, W., ZARE, R. N., J. Chem.
Phys. 51 (1969) 5509.
[8] BERGEMAN, T., ZARE, R. N., J. Chem. Phys. 61 (1974) 4500.
[9] JOST, R., LOMBARDI, M., DEROUARD, J., FREUND, R. S., MILLER, T. A., ZEGARSKI, B. R., Chem. Phys. Lett. 37 (1976) 507.
[10] EVENSON, K. M., DUNN, J. L., BROIDA, H. P., Phys. Rev. 136 (1964) A 1566.
[11] FIELD, R. W., BRADFORD, R. S., HARRIS, D. O., BROIDA, H. P.,
J. Chem. Phys. 56 (1972) 4712.
[12] FIELD, R. W., BERGEMAN, T. H., J. Chem. Phys. 54 (1971) 2936.
[13] HANSCH, T. W., LEVENSON, M. D., SCHAWLOW, A. L., Phys.
Rev. Lett. 26 (1971) 946.
[14] BRAY, R. G., HOCHSTRASSER, R. M., WESSEL, J. E., Chem.
Phys. Lett. 27 (1974) 167.
[15] YOUMANS, D. G., HACKEL, L. A., EZEKIEL, S., J. Appl. Phys.
44 (1973) 2319.
[16] JOURDAN, A., NEGRE, J. M., DUFAYARD, J. and NEDELEC, O.,
J. Phys. 37 (1975) L 29.
[17] DUFAYARD, J. and NEDELEC, O., J. Physique 37 (1976) 81.
[18] DUFAYARD, J., NEGRE, J. M. and NEDELEC, O., J. Chem.
Phys. 61 (1974) 3614.
[19] STENVINKEL, G., Thèse, Stockholm (1936).
[20] SVENSSON, E., Thèse, Stockholm (1935).
[21] PORTER, T. L. and DAVIS, S. P., J.O.S.A. 53 (1963) 338.
[22] DOUSMANIS, G. C., SANDERS, T. M. and TOWNES, C. H., Phys. Rev. 100 (1955) 1735.
[23] GOUEDARD, G., Ann. Phys. 7 (1972) 159.
OMONT, A., J. Phys. 26 (1965) 26.
[24] HAROCHE, S., PAISNER, J. A. and SCHAWLOW, A. L., Phys.
Rev. Lett. 30 (1973) 948.
[25] BERTEIN, F., Bases de l’Electronique Quantique 2 (Eyrolles) COHEN-TANNOUDJI, C., DIU, B., LALOE, F., Mécanique Quan-
tique T2 (Hermann) 1973.
HAROCHE, S., Ann. Phys. 6 (1971) 189.
[26] TOWNES, C. H. and SCHAWLOW, A. L., Microwave Spectro-
scopy (Mc Graw-Hill, New York) 1955.
[27] VAN VLECK, J. H., Phys. Rev. 33 (1929) 467.
[28] FROSH, R. A., FOLEY, H. M., Phys. Rev. 88 (1952) 1337.
[29] MULLIKEN, R. S., CHRISTY, A., Phys. Rev. 38 (1931) 87.
[30] FUJIOKA, Y. and TANAKA, Y., Sc. Pap. I.P.C.R. 718 (1937) 143.
[31] DEILE, V. O., Z. Phys. 106 (1937) 405.
[32] VESETH, L., J. Phys. B 3 (1970) 1677 ; J. Molec. Spectr. 44 (1972) 251; J. Molec. Spectr. 38 (1971) 228.
[33] BELL, R. A., BRANCH, D., private communication.