Action at local level
John Martin
A
mother walks a long, long way to the nearest health centre, carrying her sick baby for treatment. There are no drugs. Yet, in the same country, at the large teaching hospital, people are given expensive antibiotics to treat their sore throats when health workers know that such treatment has no effect.The same mother, perhaps, asks for family planning advice. Not possible.
She has come on the wrong day. Yet, in another country, health centres and clinics are organized to provide all their services every day.
A nurse is worried and depressed.
Her salary is late as usual and she has school fees to pay. What's more, she does not feel confident to treat some of the difficult cases which are brought to her. She has never had the chance to attend refresher training since the day she graduated, and she has not seen her supervisor for more than a year.
A school teacher is concerned that her pupils should know how to be healthy. In addition to knowing about healthy food and good hygiene, she wants the children to resist cigarette
Now more than ever, primary health care is seen as the way to health for all the world. A nursing mother in Chad, and child care in India.
smoking and drug taking which have become common amongst older age groups. She wants a health educator to guide her. She wants books both for her fellow-teachers and the children.
There are none available.
WHO's initiative on Strengthening District Health
Systems
Ten years after all countries of the world agreed that Primary Health Care (PHC) is the only way to achieve health for all the people of the world, problems such as these are still commonplace. To be sure, economic crises have deprived many countries of the money which might otherwise have been used to buy more medicines, equipment and even hospitals.
But the root cause of problems like those above is not lack of money.
Rather it is a lack of know-how and skills in planning, organizing and man- aging PHC. These skills may seem very mundane, particularly when contrasted with the drama and glamour associ- ated with the search for new vaccines and drugs, or with the development of high technology medical equipment.
Yet it is a fact. The greatest obstacle to achieving Health for all is poor plan- ning, organization and management, particularly at the local level where the action is supposed to be.
In response to the evidence which has been emerging from country after country, WHO has launched an initiat-
--,,-..._'!"''l!l"'r"'~ .c
01 c:
ijj
o,;
~
Cover: The striking logo designed by Moses Gichuiri Kahugu for Kenya's District Level Health Services.
IX ISSN 0043-8502
'----~~===-'
World Health is the official illustrated magazine of the World Health Organization.
Editor:
John Bland Deputy Editor:
Christiane Viedma
This Month's Theme Editor:
Sylvia Moore Art Editor:
Peter Davies
News Page Editor:
Philippe Stroot
World Health appears ten times a year in English. French. Portuguese. Russian and Spanish. and four times a year in Arabic and Farsi. The German edition is obtainable from German Green Cross.
Schuhmarkt 4. 3550 Marburg. FRG.
Articles and photographs not copyrighted may be reproduced provided credit IS given to the World Health Organization. Signed art1cles do not necessarily reflect WHO's views.
World Health. WHO.
Av. Appia, 1211 Geneva 27. Sw1tzerland.
Contents
Action at local level
by John Martin ........... 3-4 A health care paradox
by Kausar S. Khan. Kamal Islam and John H. Bryant ............. 5-7 Light at the end of the tunnel by Gunnar Bolstad ........... 8-10 Money for health
by Sidney Ndeki .......... .... 11-13
"Health first" in Bolivia
by Ramon Granados. Angel Valencia and Juan Sotelo ...... 14-15 Reach out for health . : ..... 16-17 Health across barriers
by Sylvia Moore .............. 18-19 District approach to primary health care ................... 20 Ethiopia's success story
by Gebre Selassie Okubagzhi ... 21-22 Allied health professionals
by Edmund McTernan and Lee J. Holder ..................... 23-24 A world fit to live in
by Monroe T. M organ ......... 25-27 The birth of WHO
Interview with Szeming Sze .... 28-29 News Page ............... 30-31
3
Action at local level
An old man in China gets the message - just two tablets at a time. A wise mother cleans the latrine in Mozambique.
ive called "Strengthening district health systems." Its overall objective is to find better ways of putting primary health care into effect. The basic idea stems from the fact that better health is not just a matter of going to the doctor for treatment when one is sick. For one thing millions of people have no doctor to go to, even if they wanted to!
But the point is that treating the sick is not enough.
To be healthy, people themselves need to know how to adopt more healthy lifestyles and how to make changes in their home and community environments which are both effective and feasible, especially for the very poor. But more than that, they need support to obtain better nutrition, better sanitation, better education, and better housing, as well as better health care.
It is immediately obvious that better health is not the responsibility of the
4
Photos in this issue not marked WHO or C for copyright are entries in WHO's
40th anniversary International Photo Competition
ities, and particularly their leaders who are members of health and develop- r~'lt ment committees, as well as traditional //. ~ midwives and community health
r
IE
workers. The final group comprises~ those people such as the school / ~ teacher, community development ...: worker, and so on, who staff these -~ sectors which already contribute to
rJ5 social and economic well-being. To be
health sector alone. Ordinary people have a key role to play, and so do those personnel who staff all the other sectors which contribute to social and economic development. Some may work for government, whilst others work for private and non-governmen- tal organizations. The challenge is to influence the way in which they work, and to coordinate their efforts so as to increase the benefit to people's health.
One group comprises the personnel who staff the clinics, health centres and local hospital. Another group comprises people in their commun-
practical and effective the coordination of all these group's activities must be carried out on a local basis. That is why the term "District" has been chosen - to indicate a local area which is manageable in size. Many countries already use the word district whilst others use indigenous names such as Au.raja, in Ethiopia, and Kabupaten, in Indonesia.
Just as the names vary, so must the ways in which primary health care is implemented. Each country is unique and must find its own solutions to the obstacles which currently obstruct the road to Health for all. Nevertheless, the sharing of experiences is an extremely valuable way to stimulate good ideas as well as to avoid the repetition of mistakes.
With this in mind, we hope that the articles that follow in this issue of World Health may prove both interesting and instructive. •
WORLD HEALTH, May 1989