Toolbox
for
In
Vivo
Imaging
of
Host–Parasite
Interactions
at
Multiple
Scales
Mariana
De
Niz,
1,2,7,8,* Florentin
Spadin,
3,8Matthias
Marti,
2Jens
V.
Stein,
4,5Martin
Frenz,
3and
Friedrich
Frischknecht
6Animalmodelshaveforlongbeenpivotalforparasitologyresearch.Overthe
last few years, techniques such as intravital, optoacoustic and magnetic
resonance imaging, optical projection tomography, and selective plane
illuminationmicroscopydevelopedpromisingpotentialforgaininginsights
intohost–pathogen interactionsbyallowingdifferentvisualization formsin
vivo and ex vivo. Advances including increased resolution, penetration
depth,andacquisition speed, togetherwithmore complex imageanalysis
methods, facilitate tackling biological problems previously impossible to
study and/orquantify. Here wediscussadvances andchallenges in thein
vivo imaging toolbox, which hold promising potential for the field of
parasitology.
ImagingToolbox inParasitology
Imagingtechniquesdevelopedforbiomedicalapplicationshave hadanimportantimpactin parasitologyresearch.Suchtechniquesincludeplatformsdevelopedtoimagehost–pathogen interactionsat variousscales, rangingfrom molecules to wholeorganisms (summarizedin
Table1).Thesetechniqueshavecomplementaryadvantageswithrespecttoeachother.This
reviewfocusesonthetechnologicaladvancesusedforvisualizationofhost–pathogen inter-actionseither invivo, orex vivo inwhole organismsinseveral imaging techniques. These techniques are based onnonionizing radiationsuch as intravital microscopy (IVM), optical projection tomography (OPT), bioluminescence imaging, optoacoustic imaging (OAI), and magneticresonanceimaging (MRI),oronionizingradiationsuchas X-raymicro-computed tomography (micro-CT), positron emission tomography (PET), or single-photon emission computedtomography(SPECT).
Advanced FluorescenceMethodsAppliedtoIVM
IVMisa powerfultechniquefor investigatingdynamiccellularprocessesandhost–parasite interactionswithinfunctioningorgans.OrgansstudiedbyIVMinthecontextofparasitology includethebrain[1–4],theskin[5–12],thelungs[13],theliver[14–18],thespleen[19,20],the intestines[21,22],thelymphnodes[23,24],thebonemarrow[25],theadiposetissue[20],and theplacenta[26,27],(summarizedinTable2).Importantadvancesinparasitologyhavebeen achievedusingwide-fieldepifluorescence,confocal,spinning-disc,ortwo-photonIVM.Recent developments,whichhaveexpandedtheapplicationsofIVMincludethegenerationoflonger wavelength excitation lasers; a wider range of fluorescent reporters for dyes; transgenic fluorescencereportermiceandparasites;fluorescencelifetimemeasurements(see Glos-sary);adaptiveoptics;imagingwindowsandmicroendoscopes,butalsosoftware advan-ces for high-throughput automated analyses and motion correction. Moreover, for fixed specimens,tissue-clearingtechniquesprovidingdeeperopticalpenetrationintoorganshave openednewavenuesofresearch[28].
Highlights
TechnologicaladvancesinIVMinclude
ultrafast tunable infrared lasers,
super-resolutionimaginginvivo,and
better access to all organs by
improvedopticsormotion-correction
mechanisms.
Opticalclearancemethodsforusein
OPT andSPIM allowimagingentire
organsandorganisms(suchasmice
orinsectvectors),whileachieving
cel-lularandsubcellularresolution.
OAIcombinesopticsandacousticsvia
thethermoelasticeffecttoinvestigate
molecularmechanisms.
KeyadvancesinMRIincludeimproved
contrast agents, multimodal
meso-scopic imaging, and functional MRI
tovisualizethemetabolicfunctionof
tissues.
Developments in bioluminescence
imaging include red-shifted probes
withhighsensitivity;alargerdiversity
ofprobeswithemissionpeaksat
var-iouswavelengths;ultrabrightprobes,
andtheuseofBRETinvivo.
X-ray-based and gamma-ray-based
imaging platforms are noninvasive
and enablethe studyofanatomical
structures, metabolism, biochemical
compositionoftissues,anddynamics.
1
InstituteofCellBiology–Heussler
Laboratory,UniversityofBern,Bern,
Switzerland
2
WellcomeCentreforMolecular
Parasitology,UniversityofGlasgow,
Glasgow,Scotland,UK
3
InstituteofAppliedPhysics,
UniversityofBern,Bern,Switzerland
4
TheodorKocherInstitute,University
http://doc.rero.ch
Published in "Trends in Parasitology 35(3): 193–212, 2019"
which should be cited to refer to this work.
LongerwavelengthexcitationlasersoffersubstantialadvantagesforIVM.Wavelengthsinthe 700–1000nmexcitation rangeareto some extentlimitedby penetrationdepthand back-groundemissionfromtissueendogenoussignals.Ultrafasttuneableinfraredlasersarenow availablewhichenableimagingat1300nm,overcomingbothproblems[29].Longer wave-lengthlightislessscatteredandabsorbedbytissues,aslongasthewavelengthisshorterthan thewaterabsorptionpeaks,resultingindeeperopticalpenetration.Thisnewgenerationof lasers, coupledwith novel far-redprobes, takeadvantageof wavelengthsthat elicit fewer autofluorescencesignals,thushelpingtoimprovethesignal-to-noiseratio.Moreover, photo-toxicitytotissuesisbelievedtobereducedatlongerwavelengths[30].Further,wavelength mixingofsynchronizedlasers,ormultiphotonexcitation–achievedeitherviadual-outputlaser sourcesorspecializedlaserssuchastherecentlyreportedfemtoseconddiamondRamanlaser
[31]–enablemulticolourimaging,expandingtherangeofstructuresthatcanbestudiedinvivo byIVM.Inparallel, awiderangeoffluorescentprobesintheform ofimmunofluorophores, genetic tags, quantum dots, and organic dyes have been developed to study dynamic processesinvivo,including protein–proteininteractions,andhost–pathogeninteractionsin healthyanddiseasedstates(reviewedin[32,33]).
Microscopytoolsthatare keytoinvestigatingcellorproteindynamics,andinteractionsin vitro,haveinrecentyearssuccessfullypermeatedinto IVM(reviewedin[34]).Examplesof thesemethodsincludeFörsterresonanceenergytransfer(FRET),fluorescencelossin photobleaching (FLIP), and fluorescence recovery after photobleaching (FRAP). FRETinmicehasbeenachievedbyeitheroftwomethods:generationoftransgenicanimals withchromophoresactingaspartnersforresonanceenergytransfer,ortransfectionofcells followedbytheirtransferinto livinganimals[35].FRETposes importantchallengesinIVM, which are usually not encountered in in vitro conditions. These include signal strength limitations,photobleachingandphotodamage.Initially,FRETwasmostlyusedasa ratio-metrictechniqueinIVM,allowingthemeasurementofrelativechangesofdifferent param-etersofinterestathighspeed,generallyusingthefluorescentproteinsceruleanandcitrineas donorandacceptorfluorophores,respectively.DespitethevalueofratiometricFRET,oneof itsmainlimitationsisitsdependenceonrelativequantificationsratherthanabsolute measure-ments.Sofar,FREThasnotbeenreportedinvivoinparasitology,yetcouldbeveryusefulto monitorthe activity of kinases,proteases,and GTPases [36];calcium changes[37]; lipid concentrations[35,38–40]duringinfection;andevenphysicalstressessuchastemperature, mechanical stressors, or electromagnetic fields [41], as well as molecular interactions between host and pathogens; host cell subsets, or parasite molecules. Likewise, there hasbeensignificantprogressinthedevelopmentofsoftwaretoallowseparatequantification ofsignalsfromsinglecellsincomplex3Denvironments,suchasthosepresentinorgansof livinganimals[42,43].
AnothersetoffluorescencemethodsincreasinglyadaptedtoIVMareFRAPandFLIP.Both techniques are generally used to monitor the molecular movement within cells, and are amenabletorepeateduseinvivowithoutcausingtissuedamage.Theyareparticularlyuseful toassessmacromolecularfluxacrosscellsandtissues.Bothmethodsyieldinformationsuch ashalf-timetorecovery,rateofmovementoffluorescentmoleculeswithinandbetweencellular compartments,andmoleculartransferbetweenregionsindependentofrateofmovement.Like FRET,FRAPandFLIPhavebeenlargelyexploredin2Denvironmentsusingcellcultures,but haveonlyrecentlybeenincorporatedintoinvivoresearch[34].Thishasbeenpossibledueto thegenerationoftransgenicmicewithfluorescentreportersexpressedinspecificcelltypes, cell–celljunctions,orotherstructures.Particularlyusefulforthestudyofparasitecellmigration, invasion, and development, wouldbe reporter micethat enable quantification of dynamic
ofBern,Bern,Switzerland
5
DepartmentofOncology,
MicrobiologyandImmunology,
UniversityofFribourg,Fribourg,
Switzerland
6
IntegrativeParasitology,Centrefor
InfectiousDiseases,Heidelberg
UniversityMedicalSchool,Heidelberg,
Germany
7
Currentaffiliation:Institutode
MedicinaMolecular–JoãoLobo
Antunes,FaculdadedeMedicina,
UniversidadedeLisboa,Lisbon,
Portugal
8
Theseauthorscontributedequally
*Correspondence:
(M.DeNiz).
Glossary
Adaptiveoptics:anopticalmethod
wherebydeformablemirrorscan
correct,inrealtime,opticaleffects
causedbyincomingwavefront
distortions.
Elastography:amedicalimaging
methodthatcreatesadistortionin
tissue,andthenmeasuresthetissue
response(e.g.,mechanicalwaves)to
theoriginaldeformation.
Fluorescencelifetime:thetime
thatafluorophorecanspendinan
excitedstatebeforeemittinga
photonandreturningtotheground
state.
Fluorescencelossin
photobleaching(FLIP):animaging
methodwherebyafluorescently
labelledregion(usuallyamembrane)
isbleachedmultipletimesusingthe
laserbeamofaconfocal
microscope,toensurethatall
fluorophoresarebleached.
Measurementoffluorophore
exchangebetweennonbleachedand
bleachedareaovertimeprovides
informationonmembranedynamics.
Fluorescencerecoveryafter
photobleaching(FRAP):an
imagingmethodthatconsistsof
targetingasampleareawithasingle
high-intensityillumination,resultingin
theelapseofthefluorophore’s
fluorescencelifetime.Overtime,
fluorescentprobeswilldiffuse
throughthesampletoreplacethose
innonfluorescentareas,thus
allowingquantificationoflateral
diffusion.
Försterresonanceenergy
transfer(FRET):amechanismof
energytransferbetweenadonorand
anacceptorchromophore.Efficiency
ofenergytransferishighlylinkedto
(i)thedistancebetweentwo
fluorophores,(ii)thespectraloverlap
ofdonorandacceptor,and(iii)the
relativeorientationofdonorand
acceptordipolemoments.
Gradedindex(GRIN)lenses:
lensesofdifferentmaterialsthat
reduceopticalaberrationsbyhaving
arefractiveindexgradient,andaflat
surface.
Imagingwindows/optical
windows:surgicallyimplanted
windowsthatallowvisualizationof
internalorgansinsidealivingmouse.
Windowscanbeacute/terminal,or
chronic,allowingvisualizationover
days–weeks.
regulationofcell–celljunctions(e.g.,E-cadherin–GFP)[44],orstudyingmicrovesselleakiness asaproxyofendothelialbarrierfunctionusingdyessuchasfluoresceinisothiocyanate-dextran oralbumin[45].
Super-resolutionmicroscopyhasgainedsignificantmomentumforuseininvitroimagingover thepastdecade,anditsapplicationinIVMcontextsbringsaboutequallyexcitingprospects. OnelimitationthatpreventeditsfasteradaptationtoIVMisthelightscatteringwhichresultsin depth-dependentdeteriorationofspatialresolution,duetosphericalaberrationstothepoint spreadfunctionincomplextissue[46].Althoughnotyetusedinthefieldofparasitology,other fieldshavedevelopedmethodstoachievesuper-resolutionmicroscopywhileimagingliving animals.Examplesincludearecentlydevelopedsetupwhichincorporatesmultibeamstriped illumination,spatialmodulationofexcitation,andlaserscanningmicroscopy[47],ortheuseof stimulatedemissiondepletion(STED)toachievesuper-resolutiontoobserve morphologi-calchangesinactinwithinthebrain[48].
InadditiontomicroscopymethodsapplicabletoIVM,theuseofimplantedopticalwindowsto replacetheskull,andmicroendoscopes,hasgreatlybenefitedvariousresearchfields,including parasitology,toenablelong-termimagingoforgansthroughoutmultipledays(reviewedin[49]). While most optical windows are limited to the surface of the surgically exposed organs, gradient index (GRIN) lenses and microendoscopes enable access to deeper regions
[50], otherwise inaccessible, including deeper structuresin the brain, the spinal cord, the bonemarrow,thelungs,andtheheart[50–53].Bothmicroendoscopesandtemporaryoptical windowshave benefitedtheimaging ofparasites,giving insightsintophenomenaincluding parasitecrossingofendothelialbarriersenablingtheirdisseminationacrosstissues,dynamics relevanttoparasitesurvival,andmechanismsoftransmissiontoandfromtheinsectvectors. Furtherprogressinpenetrationdepthandresolutioninlivingsampleshasbeenachievedby adaptiveoptics,whichiswidelyappliedinastronomy.Biologicalspecimenshave refractive-indexinhomogeneitieswhichaffectresolution.Adaptiveopticsallowsreversing signal/resolu-tion degradation by predistorting the wavefront ofthe incoming lightto cancel distortions occurringinthelightpath[54].
Finally,asignificantchallengeforIVMismotioninducedbybreathing,peristalsis,and circula-tion,whichmostlyaffects organsinthechestandabdomen.A keyachievement forimage analysis in IVM is automation for motion artefactremoval [55,56]. Thisincludes triggering imagingatspecifictimeperiodstocoincidewiththeheartbeatorrespiration,ortriggeringheart contractionstocoincidewithimageacquisition.Conversely,variouspiecesofsoftwarehave beengeneratedforimageanalysis,whichallowscorrectionofsamplemotionfollowingimage acquisition[57].Thesemethodsareapplicabletodifferentlaser-scanningmodalities,including confocalandmultiphotonmicroscopy.
OpticalProjection TomographyandLightSheetFluorescence Microscopy Photonscatteringintissueshindersimagingatdepthsexceedingafewhundredmicrometres invivo,makingimaging ofwholeorgansimpossible.Hence, imagingatdepthrequires the physical sectioningof tissues due to photon scattering. Theimaging limitof conventional microscopyintermsofpenetrationdepthissetbyaphysicalparameterofphotonsknownas themeanfreepath(MFP)(reviewedin[58]).TheMFPtranslatesasthenumberofscatteringor collisioneventsthataphotonundergoes,each ofwhichmodifies thephoton’sdirectionof travel,ultimatelyresultinginimageblur.Forwidefieldepifluorescencemicroscopyatraditional thicknessfortissuesectionsis10–50mm,whichensuresahigh-qualityimageand diffraction-limitedresolution.Confocalandmultiphotonmicroscopyallowgreaterpenetrationdepthsofup
to 0.5–1mm.Nevertheless, to acquirea 3Dimage of an entiresample usingconfocal or multiphoton microscopy, automated methods for the digital reconstruction of thin serial sectionsrequiretheacquisitionofhundredsofindividualsectionsand/orlongimagingperiods underhigh-energyillumination.Thisultimatelyrendersconfocalandmultiphoton techniques impracticalforimagingintact,largespecimens.
Mesoscopicimaging techniques,suchas light-sheetfluorescence microscopy[LSFM;also knownasselectiveplaneilluminationmicroscopy(SPIM)]andopticalprojectiontomography (OPT),enablevisualizationoflargerfieldsofviewacrossentireorgans.Theprerequisiteisthat theseorgansmustbetransparentoropticallycleared.Tissueclearancehasgainedsignificant momentum inrecent years,asshown bya risingnumberofclearing methodswhichoffer differentadvantages,despitetheirusebeinglimitedtofixedtissues[59–61].Altogether, tissue-clearancemethodsmustsatisfythreebasiccriteria:(i)alltissuesmustbeefficientlycleared,(ii) cellularandsubcellularstructuresmustbeadequatelypreserved,and(iii)tissueclearancemust becompatible withfluorescence detection. Current techniques includethe useof organic solvents[60,62–70],water[59,71–76],andelectrophoresis-basedprotocols[77–79].A sum-maryofrelevantmethodsfortissueclearanceisshowninTable3.
Oncethesampleistransparent,OPTimagingisachievedviatissuetransilluminationand epi-illuminationovermultipleprojections[80].WiththeOPTsetup,thespecimenisrotatedthrough 360inangularstepsaroundasingleaxiswhilebeingheldinpositionforimaging(Figure1A). Virtual sections are independently reconstructed from the acquired images using a back-projectionalgorithm[81].Thismethodallowshigh-resolutionimagingatpenetrationdepthsof upto15mm[80].Asaresult,high-resolutiondigitalsections,and3Dimagereconstructionsof thesampledspecimen’svolume,canbeobtained.
LSFM,bycontrast,usesathinplaneoflight(orlightsheet),thatisshapedbyacylindricallens oralaserscannertoexclusivelyilluminatethefocalplaneofthesampleatanyonetimeand has been used extensively to image living,if small,organisms (Figure 1B) [82]. While, in conventionalmicroscopes,illuminationanddetectionfollows thesamepath,thedetection pathwayinLSFMisrotatedby90.Altogether,thesecharacteristicsmakeitapowerfultool for live-cellimagingoflarge samplesduetoitshighimagingspeed,reducedtoxicity, and photobleaching (reviewed in [83]). 3D image formation is based on raw images being assembled after translation or rotation of the entire sample. Multiple LSFM setups have beendeveloped,includingilluminationfrommultipledirections,enablingdoublingthe pene-trationdepth[84],orcombiningdifferentmesoscopictechniques,includingOPTiSPIM[85],a hybridsetupwhichbenefitsfromthe highresolutionof SPIMwiththe possibilitytoimage fluorescentandnonfluorescentcontrastsofOPT.Thefirstcommercialdevicesweremade available, and an open-source, custom-built version named OpenSPIM was produced
[86,87].OPTand/orLSFMhavebeenusedtoimagemulticellular culturemodels[88–91],
zebrafish[92],sparsecellpopulations[93],thedevelopmentofplants[94],livingembryos, andgenemapping[80,95],aswellasmultiplerodentorgansinhealthanddiseaseconditions
[63,66,96,97].OPTandLSFMwerebothsuccessfullyusedtoobtaindetailedinsightofthe
anatomyoftheflightmusculatureofaDrosophilafly,itsnervousanddigestivesystems,and b-galactosideactivityatwhole-bodylevel[98,99].Whileinitsorigins,theapplicationoftissue clearing andimagingwaslimitedtorodentorgans orsmallwhole bodies(such asthat of Drosophila flies), a build-up on previous hydrogel embedding, tissue-clearing techniques [passive clarity technique (PACT)], imaging reagents [refractive index matching solution (RIMS)],anddelivery routes[perfusion-assistedagentrelease(PARS)]made it possibleto imagewholeopticallyclearedmice[100].
Lateralresolution:theminimum
distancethatcanbedistinguished
betweentwocontiguousreflectors,
perpendiculartotheultrasound
beam.
Mesoscopicimagingmethods:
branchofimagingreferringto
measurementsofsamplesof
intermediatesizes(intherangeof
tensofmicrometrestomillimetres).
Microbubbles:intravenously
injectedmaterialsthatserveas
contrastagentsinultrasound.They
consistofalow-solubilitycomplex
gassurroundedbyaphospholipid
shell.Theyresonateinanultrasound
field,andgenerate‘signature’
harmonicsignals.
Opticalresolution:theshortest
distancebetweentwopoints,within
aspecimen,thatcanbe
distinguishedasseparateentities.
Photobleaching:aprocess
wherebytherepeatedcyclingofa
fluorophorebetweengroundand
excitedstatesleadstomolecular
damageandgradualreductionin
fluorescence.
Stimulatedemissiondepletion
(STED):amethodin
super-resolutionimagingthatreliesonthe
selectivedeactivationoffluorophores
whileleavingonlyasmallfocalspot
active.
Ultrasoundtransducer:adevice
thatproducessoundwaveswhich
interactwithbodytissuesand
produceechoes.Thissignalis
receivedandusedtogeneratea
sonogram.
Table1.ImagingScalesandCurrent/PotentialApplicationsinParasitology
Imagingmethod Resolution Penetration
depth(max)
Advantages Potentailparasitologyapplicationsinin
vivoimaging
Electronmicroscopy
(andcombinationswith
fluorescence microscopy)
2–5nm 1mm(TEM) Visualizesnotjustthefluorophore.Can
nowbecombinedwithfluorescence
microscopy(correlativelightandelectron
microscopy:CLEM)andintravital
imaging.
Observationofultrastructuraldetailsof
host–pathogeninteractions,cells,and
infection-relatedchanges.
STED 20nm(lateral) 100–200mm Enablesfluorescentimagingata
nano-scaleresolution.
Observationofhighlyresolvedstructures
andhost–parasiteinteractionsat
subcellularresolution.
IVM:Advanced
fluorescencemicroscopy
–FRET
2–10nm 100–200mm Enablesquantificationofprotein–protein
interactionsinvivo.
Monitorenzymeactivities,ionchanges,
host–pathogeninteractions,lipid
changes,mechanicalstress,and
moleculequantifications.
IVM:Advanced
fluorescencemicroscopy
–FRAP
2–10nm 100–200mm Enablesquantificationoflateraldiffusion
dynamics.
Monitorhost–pathogeninteractionsatthe
subcellularlevelwithincellsharbouring
intracellularparasites,forexample,
organellehijacking,nutrientacquisition.
IVM:Advanced
fluorescencemicroscopy
–FLIP
200nm 100–200mm Enablesquantificationofmembrane
dynamics.
Monitorhost–pathogeninteractionsatthe
subcellularlevel,forexample,intracellular
parasitemembranefusionandorganelle
segregationduringreplication.
IVM:Confocalimaging 200nm 100–200mm Compromisebetweenhighresolution
andfastacquisitionratesinvivo.
Monitorhost–pathogeninteractionsat
subcellularandcellularlevels.
IVM:Multiphoton
microscopy
400nm 500–800mm Thehighestadvantageoverother
methodsishighpenetrationdepth.Low
backgroundautofluorescence.
Monitoringparasitedynamicsindeep
organstructures.
IVM:Spinning-disc
microscopy
200nm 100–200mm Fastimageacquisitionspeedinvivo. Monitoringdynamicsofhost–pathogen
interactions,membranedynamics,tissue
changes,vasculatureatnearrealtime.
OPT 20mm cmincleared
samples
3Dreconstructionoflarge,optically
clearedsamples.
Visualizingparasiteandtissuedistribution,
vascularchanges,andsystemicchanges
atwhole-tissueandevenwhole-animal
level.
SPIM 200–500nm cmincleared
samples
3Dreconstructionoflarge,optically
clearedsamples.Littlephototoxicityinlive
imaging.
Visualizingparasiteandtissuedistribution,
vascularchanges,andsystemicchanges
atwhole-tissueandevenwhole-animal
level.
OAI Sub-100mmin
deeptissues
cm Imagesnoninvasivelyopticalabsorption
contrastoverawiderangeofspatial
scalesathighspeed.Abletoimage
structuresandfunction.
Noninvasiveimagingofeffectsofparasite
presenceintissues.Visualizationof
vascularandmetabolicchangesin
variousorganslongitudinally.
MRI 100–500mm Fullbody Noninvasiveimaging,applicableto
clinics.Providesdetailedinformationon
tissuearchitecture,morphology,
pathology.
Canbeappliedtoorgansrangingfrom
deeporganstoskin,tostudyparasite
effectsattissuelevel.FunctionalMRIcan
beusedtostudyfunctionintissues
affectedbyparasitepresence.
Radiography cm Fullbody Noninvasiveimaging.Providesdetailed
informationontissuearchitecture.
Applicabletostudytissuediffraction
propertiesuponinfectionwithdifferent
parasites.
Ultrasound Sub-100mmin
deeptissues
Fullbody Noninvasiveimaging,applicableto
clinics.Providesdetailedinformationon
tissuearchitecture,morphology,
pathology.
Canbeappliedtoorganstostudyparasite
effectsattissuelevel,includingmetabolic
changes.
Inparasitology,uses haveincludedthe generationofopticallyclearedgutfrom tsetseflies (vectorsofTrypanosomabrucei)[101](Figure1C)andopticallytransparentAnopheles mos-quitoes(vectorsofPlasmodium)(Figure1D,E).Importantly,theuseofmesoscopicmethods inparasitologyhasremainedscarce,despitetheirrelativelyeasyimplementationanduse.The potentialofthesetechniquestostudyinteractionsathighresolution,andhighthroughput,for thephenotypiccharacterization ofparasite-inducedchanges invectors,rodents,andother modelorganismsishigh,andworthexploringandimplementinginvariousareasofparasitology inyearstocome.
BioluminescenceImaging
Photonproductionisachievedprimarilythroughluminescenceandfluorescence.In lumines-cence,thephotonistheproductofexothermicchemicalreactions,whereanenzyme(e.g., luciferase) oxidizes a substrate (e.g., luciferin),leading to photon emission. Conversely,in fluorescencetheexcitedstates arecreatedbyabsorption andemissionoflight. Themain advantageofluminescenceassaysisaccuratequantificationwithhighsensitivity,whichcanbe appliedinhigh-throughputstudies,bothinvivoandinvitro.
Bioluminescenceimagingreliesonprocessesoccurringinnatureviathegenerationoflightby lower organisms, including beetles, bacteria, molluscs, algae, crustaceans, annelids, and coelenterates[102].Variousbioluminescentsubstrateshavebeenisolatedfromthese organ-isms, and their biochemical properties have been defined (Figure 2). Across parasitology research, the main bioluminescent probe used in vivo is firefly luciferase (reviewed in
[103,104]),withGaussia,NanoLucandRenillaluciferasebeinglesscommonlyused.
Trans-genicPlasmodiumspp.,Toxoplasmaspp.,Leishmaniaspp.,Trypanosomabrucei,and Try-panosomacruziexpressingbioluminescentprobeshavebeenusedforinvestigatingparasite growth and dissemination, virulence,coinfections, parasite stage-specific promoters,drug screening,andmonitoringhost–pathogeninteractions(reviewedin[103,104]).
Inrecentyears,animportantaimhasbeentoachieveultrabrightluminescencetodetectsignals withhigh sensitivityindeeptissues.Thishasbeeninitiallyachievedbygeneratingparasites expressingcodon-optimizedred-shiftedfireflyluciferases[7,105]andultrabrightluminescent probessuchasNanoLuc[106,107].AlthoughNanoLucluciferasehasbeenextremelyusefulin vitroduetoitsbrightsignal[108],itsperformanceinvivoisverypoorduetoitsshortemission
Table1.(continued)
Imagingmethod Resolution Penetration
depth(max)
Advantages Potentailparasitologyapplicationsinin
vivoimaging
CT mm Fullbody Noninvasive3Dimaging,applicableto
clinics.
Canbeappliedtoorganstostudyparasite
effectsattissuelevel.
Bioluminescence imaging
cm Severalcm Enableswhole-bodyimagingina
high-throughputmanner.Consistentwith3Rs
onanimalusage.
Visualizingluminescentparasite
distribution.PotentialtoperformBRETin
vivohasnotbeenexplored.
PET mm Fullbody Allowsobservationofmetabolic
processeswithinthebody,aswellas
parameterssuchasbloodflow,
metabolism,andneurotransmitters.
Observationoftheeffectsofparasitic
infectionsonhostmetabolism,bloodflow
perturbations,orneurotransmissionata
whole-bodylevel.
SPECT Severalmm Fullbody Allowsobservationofmetabolic
processeswithinthebody,aswellas
parameterssuchasbloodflow,
metabolism,andneurotransmitters.
Observationoftheeffectsofparasitic
infectionsonhostmetabolism,bloodflow
perturbations,orneurotransmissionata
whole-bodylevel.
Table 2. Key Examples of Organs and Parasites Imaged by IVM.
Organs/ pathogen
Central/peripheral nervous system
Skin Lungs Heart Stomach/
pancreas
Liver Spleen Intestines Kidneys/
bladder Lymph nodes Bone marrow Adipose tissue Placenta Vector-borne Plasmodium spp. [1] [5,6] [13] – – [14,15] [19,20] – – [23] [25] [20] [26,27] Trypanosoma brucei [2] [7,8] – – – – – – – – – – – Trypanosoma cruzi – [10,11] – – – – – – – – – – – Onchocerca – – – – – – – – – – – – – Leishmania – [9] – – – [16] – – – [24] – – – Wuchereria/Brugia – – – – – – – – – – – – – Schistosoma – [12] – – – [17] – – – – – – – Theileria – – – – – – – – – – – – – Babesia – – – – – – – – – – – – – Food/water/soil-borne Toxoplasma [3,4] – – – – – – [21,22] – – – – – Entamoeba – – – – – [18] – – – – – – – Echinococcus – – – – – – – – – – – – – Ascaris – – – – – – – – – – – – – Ancylostoma – – – – – – – – – – – – – Necator – – – – – – – – – – – – – Strongyloides – – – – – – – – – – – – – Paragonimus – – – – – – – – – – – – – Giardia – – – – – – – – – – – – – Cryptosporidium – – – – – – – – – – – – –
Table3.TissueClearanceMethodsforSPIMandOPT
Clearingmethod Rationale Advantages Limitations Refs
BABB(Murray’sclear;Benzyl
alcohol:benzylbenzoate)
Benzylalcoholandbenzyl-benzoate. Quicktissueclearance.Successful
forclearingconnectivetissues.
Strongquenchingof
fluorescence.Solutionsusedare
toxic.
[62]
3DISCO(3Dimagingof
solvent-clearedorgans)
Tetrahydrofluorane,
dichloromethane,anddibenzylether.
Successfullypreservesfluorescence
intissues(brain)whileenabling
adequatetissueclearance.
Fluorescencequenchinginsome
tissues.Clearancenotveryfast.
[63]
iDISCO
(immunolabelling-enabled3Dimagingof
solvent-clearedorgans)
Usesdibenzylether. Enablesdeepantibodydiffusionin
largeorgans.Compatiblewithuseof
AlexaFluordyes:doesnotrequire
immediateimagingasthereisno
diffusionovertime.
Minor. [64]
PACT(passiveclaritytechnique),
PARSandRIMS
Passivetissueclearingand
immunostainingofintactorgans.
Usesacrylamide,bis-acrylamide,and
SDS(sodiumdodecylsulfate).
Preservesfluorescencesuccessfully.
Lowmaintenanceprocedure.
Longincubationtimerequired.
Cancauseaberrationsintissue
morphology.
[60]
CUBIC(clearunobstructed
brain-imagingcocktailsand
computationalanalysis)
Urea,N,N,N0,N0-tetrakis
(2-hydroxypropyl)ethylenediamine,
TritonX-100,sucrose,and2,20,200
-nitrilotriethanol.
Relativelyfastprocedure,preserves
tissuemorphologyandfluorescence
intensity.Whole-bodyclearanceis
possibleviatrans-cardialperfusion
withreagents.
Minor. [65,66]
RTF Rapidclearingmethodbasedon
triethanolamineandformamide.
Canrendertissuestransparentwithin
hours.Isuserfriendly.Preserves
fluorescencesignal(includingGFP)
andtissuestructure.
Minor.Notyetvalidatedin
multipleorgans.
[67]
TDE(tetrachlorodiphenylethane) Basedon2,20-thiodiethanol,aglycol
derivativeoftenusedasmounting
medium.
Reporteduseinbrainwithsuccessful
clearanceandfluorescence
preservation.
Inhighconcentrations,TDE
quenchesfluorescence,and
affectscellshape.
[68,69]
Spalteholz Benzylalcohol,benzylbenzoateand
methylsalicylateisosafrole.
Quicktissueclearance.Successful
forclearingconnectivetissues.
Strongquenchingof
fluorescence.Solutionsusedare
toxic.
[70]
SWITCH(system-widecontrolof
interactiontimeandkineticof
chemicals)
SDSandcustomrefractive
index-matchingsolution.Requires
glutaraldehydeandthermal
delipidation,followedbyrefractive
index-matching.Increaseshybrid
porosity,facilitatingdiffusionfor
labelling.
Verystrongandfastclearing.Allows
clearingwhilepreserving
fluorescenceandantigenicityacross
thetissue.Bufferallowschemical
reactionsbetweenexogenousand
endogenousmolecules.Suitablefor
multiplexedproteomicimaging.
Canintroducecolouration
artefacts.
[71]
ScaleA2/U2 Urea,glycerol,andTritonX-100 Glycerolcounter-balances
urea-inducedtissueexpansion.Allows
targetinglipophilictissueregions.
Slowclearancerates.
Aberrationscanbeintroduced
duetoreagentsused,including
tissuefragilityandvolume
enlargementofspecimens.Not
goodinheavilymyelinated
tissues.
[72]
ScaleS OptimizedScaleprotocol.
Sorbitol-based.
Preservestissuemorphologyand
fluorescence.Sorbitoliseffectiveat
clearingtissuesotherwisedifficultto
clear.Allowsimagingathigh
resolutionandsignificantdepth.
Notalltissuesaresuccessfully
clearedusingthismethod.As
ScaleA2/U2,notsosuccessfulin
heavilymyelinatedtissues.
[59]
FRUIT SeeDB-derivedmethodthatusesD
(–)-fructoseandurea.
Water-solublemethodhasadditive
clearanceeffects.Allowsarterial
perfusionforenhancedclearance.
Compatiblewithyellowfluorescence
Minor.Usefulnessnotyet
reportedinmultipletissuetypes.
[73]
wavelength.Recently,anovelred-shiftedluciferase–luciferinpairbasedonthecoelenterazine analogue diphenylterazine (DTZ) and a NanoLuc mutant fused to a fluorescent reporter (resultinginanultrabrightprobe knownas Antares2),provedto behighlysuccessfulforin vivo imaging [109,110]. Similarly, another highly successful combination has been that of AkaLuminehydrochloride(AkaLumine-HCl –asyntheticD-luciferinanalogue),which,when catalysedbyfireflyluciferase,generatesnear-infraredemission,andhasfavourabledistribution in deep organs [111]. Randommutagenesis of firefly luciferase-based libraries led to the generationofAkaluc,whichdisplayedhighthermostabilityandthebrightestemissionwhen combined with AkaLumine [112]. The Akaluc/AkaLumine-HCl combination has allowed a revolutionaryadvance,namelyvisualizationofsinglebioluminescentcellsindeeptissuesof freelymovinganimals[112].
Furthertechnologicaladvancesinthefieldofbioluminescenceincludedual-probereporters whichallowthedetectionoftwosignalssimultaneously,atdifferentwavelengths.Thesehave beenuseful inthecontext ofcharacterization ofdifferentpromotersexpressed atdifferent parasitelifestages[113,114].Equally,bioluminescencecanbeusedinthecontextof biolumi-nescenceenergytransfer(BRET),orhybridbiosensors(BRET–FRET,orhyBRET)for investi-gationofprotein–proteininteractions,analysisofxenografts,andoptogenetics,invivo[115]. OptoacousticandUltrasoundImaging
Allopticalimagingtechniquesmentionedabovehavebeenshowntoimagebiological struc-tureswithpotentialsubcellularresolution(intherangeofthewavelengthused)andremarkable
Table3.(continued)
Clearingmethod Rationale Advantages Limitations Refs
proteins.Compatiblewithuseof
lipophilictracers.
ClearT Basedonformamide. Sinceitdoesnotusedetergentsor
solvents,allowstheuseoflipophilic
dyesandfluorescenttracers.
Clearingspeedofsometissues.
Themaincomponentistoxic.
Insufficienttissuetransparency
forfullvolumeimaging.
Quenchesfluorescence,
especiallyGFP.
[74]
ClearT2 Basedonformamideand
polyethyleneglycol(PEG).
Allowstheuseoflipophilicdyesand
fluorescenttracers.Clearingspeedof
sometissues.PEGstabilizesprotein
conformation,thusinhibitsGFP
quenching.
Insufficienttissuetransparency
forfull-volumeimaging.
[75]
SeeDB(SeeDeepBrain) Combinationoffructoseand
a-thioglycerol.
Fastclearingwithoptimal
preservationoftissueintegrityand
fluorescencesignal.Allows
large-scaleimaging.
Viscosityofsaturatedfructoseis
veryhigh.Difficulttopermeate
organs.Arterialperfusionnot
possible.
[76]
CLARITY(clearlipid-exchanged
acrylamidehybridizedrigid
imagingcompatibletissue
hydrogel)
Bioelectrochemicalclearing
technique.Buildsan
acrylamide-basedhydrogelhybridfromintact
tissues.Useselectrophoresis,
acrylamide,bis-acrylamide,andSDS.
Preservesfluorescencesuccessfully. Electrophoresisbasecanbe
challengingtoimplement.Can
damagetissuesorintroduce
artefacts.
[77,78]
MAP(magnifiedanalysisofthe
proteome)
BasedonCLARITYmethod,uses
densergeltoprovidethetissuewith
morestability.
Allowspreservationofthetissue
integritywhileallowingsuccessful
tissueclearance.Allowslineartissue
expansion,andthereforehighly
resolvedimaging.Allowsmultiple
roundsofimmune-labelling.
Minor. [79]
P Tr E OPT LSFM DetecƟon IlluminaƟon IlluminaƟon RotaƟng sample (A) (B) Camera Transmission Objec Ɵve lens Excita Ɵon Ex.Įlter Dichroic Emission Įlter Tube lens (C) (D) (E)
OpƟcally transparent Anopheles mosquito 3D rendered Anopheles mosquito
Figure 1.
(Figurelegendcontinuedonthebottomofthenextpage.)
Optical Projection Tomography (OPT) and Light Sheet Fluorescence Microscopy (LSFM).
(A)PrincipleofOPT.Theopticallyclearedspecimenisembeddedinagarose,attachedtoametalliccylinderwithina
rotatingstage,andsuspendedinanindex-matchingliquidtoreducescatteringandheterogeneitiesofrefractiveindex
throughoutthespecimen.Whenthespecimenisrotatedtoaseriesofangularpositions,imagesarecapturedateach
orientation.Thesetupisalignedtoensurethattheaxisofrotationisperpendiculartotheopticalaxis,sothatstraight-line
projectionsgoingthroughthesamplecanbegenerated,andcollectedbypixelsonthecharge-coupleddeviceofthe
camera.(B)Principleoflight-sheetfluorescencemicroscopy(LSFM).Theopticallyclearedsampleisembeddedinagarose
andsuspendedwithinasampleholderinsideanindex-matchingliquid.Athin(nm–mm)sliceofthesampleisilluminated
perpendicularlytothedirectionofobservation.Scanningisperformedusingaplaneoflight,whichallowsveryfastimage
acquisition.(C)Surfacerenderingmodelofisolatedinfectedflygut.Theintestinaltissueisvisualizedbyautofluorescence
(grey).ThePMisstainedwithrhodamine-labelledWGA(cyan)andthetrypanosomenucleuswithaGFP-reporter(yellow).
contrastbutarelimitedbystronglightscatteringintissue.Optoacoustic(OA)imaging,also referredtoasphotoacousticimaging,offerstheabilitytonotonlyovercomethislimitationbutto providestructural,functional,metabolic,andevenmolecularinformation[116,117].OAisa hybridimagingmodality,combiningopticsandacousticsviathethermoelasticeffect[118,119]. Thethermoelasticeffectconvertsopticallyabsorbedenergyintoacousticwaves,whichare recordedatthetissuesurfacebymeansofultrasounddetection.Opticalabsorptionprovides theimagingcontrastforOA,whichmeansthatanychromophoreormoleculethatselectively absorbstheilluminationwavelengthcanbeimaged[120].Chromophorescanbeendogenous orexogenous.Viatheirspectralfingerprint,endogenouschromophores–suchashaemoglobin –providequantitativeandphysiologicalinformationofthevasculature.Exogenous chromo-phores–suchasantibodiesfunctionalizedbyabsorbingmetallicnanoparticlesordyes–are suitable for the assessment of tumours and other pathologies. These features make OA imaginganinterestingtechniqueforstudyinghost–parasiteinteractions.
Imagingcanbeperformedbothinatomographicmacroscopicsetup,visualizingthewhole animal,orinamicroscopicsetup. Tomographyusesan arrayofultrasound sensors,often partiallyorcompletelysurroundingthetarget,toachieveaxialimageresolutionoftypicallyafew hundred micrometres, determined by the bandwidth of the ultrasoundtransducer, and imagingdepthsofuptofewcentimetres[121].Bycontrast,microscopysetupsuseasingle mechanicallyscannedfocused transducer(Figure3A)oratightlyfocuseddiffraction-limited laserbeamtogenerateanimage.Intheformercase,termedacousticresolutionmicroscopy, the lateral resolution is given by the properties of the acousticlens and the ultrasound transducer(40mmat50MHztransducerfrequency).Inthisconfiguration,OAmicroscopy hasbeenshowntoresolvefinestructuresinthedermisandassessdermalpapillae[122].Ithas
Scalebar:50mm.Figurereproduced,withpermission,from[101].(D)3Dreconstructionandrenderingofafemale
Anopheles mosquito clearlyshowing abdominalsegments,thorax, and head features.Scale bar:70mm.(E) 3D
reconstructionandclearviewofallbodycavitiesofanopticallyclearedAnophelesmosquito.Scalebar:100mm.
Abbreviations:PM,peritrophicmatrix;WGA,wheatgermagglutinin.
Deep-Sea shrimp (NanoLuc) 460 nm Gaussia (GLuc) 470 nm Renilla (RLuc) 480 nm Click beetle >600 nm 560 nm Railroad worm 630 nm Antares FireŇy (FLuc) >600 nm 613 nmRFLuc AkaBLI 675 nm Red-shiŌed Renilla (RLuc8) 535 nm 400 450 500 550 600 650 700 750 800 nm Bioluminescence (emission, nm)
Figure2.BioluminescenceImagingProbes.Bioluminescenceprobescommonlyusedininvivoimaginginclude
Gaussialuciferase,NanoLuc,Renillaluciferase,clickbeetleluciferase(anditsred-andgreen-shiftedforms),red-shifted
fireflyluciferases,railroadwormluciferases,andnovelprobeswithbrightluminescencetoimagedeepintotissuessuchas
AkaBLIandAntares/Antares2.Isolatedfromdifferentorganisms,theseprobeshaveavariedrangeofmolecularweights
andmaximumpeakofemissionwavelengthsasschematicallyillustratedhere,allowingfordualluminescencesystemsto
beused.
alsobeenusedtovisualizethecerebralvascularanatomyinmiceuptoadepthof3.7mmat sub-millimetre resolution (sub-100mm at 1mm depth), greatly surpassing what can be achievedwithpurelyopticaltechniques[123].In thelattercase,calledopticalresolution microscopy,thelateralresolutionisdeterminedbythefocalspotofthelaser,andimaging depthislimitedbyopticalscatteringtoamaximumof1mm,asitisinthecaseofpureoptical microscopy[121,124].Inlow-scatteringtissue,suchasthatfoundinmouseears,theresolution canbepushedto2.5mmatadepthof150mm[125].
Both contrast andpenetration depth are affectedby the choice of excitation wavelength. Shorterwavelengths(typicallynoshorterthan532nm)arestronglyabsorbedbyhaemoglobin andthushighercontrastcanbeachieved,attheexpenseofpenetrationdepth.Forlonger wavelengths (typically up to 1300nm), penetration depth is increased at the expense of contrast.Sincethepropagationspeedofultrasoundwavesinbiologicaltissueiscomparatively low,depthinformationisobtainedbyrecordingthepressurewaveinatime-resolvedmanner. Thus, all OA imaging techniques have the potential to record three-dimensional images. Furthermore,differencesinthewavelength-dependentabsorptioncoefficientsofoxygenated anddeoxygenatedhaemoglobincanbeutilizedforoxygenationmeasurementsinboth tomo-graphic[126]andmicroscopic[123,125]setups.
Currently, only a few commerciallyavailable invivo whole-animal OA imaging devices are capableofcapturingsinglecross-sectionaltomographicimagesoflivingsmallanimalswith estimatedin-planeresolutionsof150mm[127–129].OAimaginghasalsobeencombined withecho-ultrasoundimaginginawhole-bodylivemousetomographysystem,withreported in-planespatialresolutionsof150mm(OA)and350mm(ultrasound)[130].
UsingacousticresolutionOAmicroscopy(Figure3A),wehaveimagedthebrainofmiceaged 4–6weeksinfectedwithPlasmodium.Themicehadtheirscalpremoved(theskull wasleft intact)priortoimagingandwerekeptunderanaesthesiaduringimaging.Wehavefoundthat imagesofhealthymice(Figure3B)showclearlydiscerniblehemispheresandcerebellum,while
AcousƟc wave Water
(A) Photo-detector CL ns laser (532 nm) US transducer FL (B) (C) Rhomboid prism AcousƟc lens 8 8 7 7 6 6 5 5 4 4 3 3 2 2 1 1 0 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1 0 0 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 x (mm) x (mm) y (mm) y (mm)
Figure3.OptoacousticMicroscopySetupandImagingoftheBrain.(A)Optoacoustic(OA)microscopysetup(acousticalresolution).Thelaserillumination
inducesthermoelasticpressurewavesinthesampleandtriggerssignalacquisition(photodetector).Thegeneratedpressurewave(red)iscollectedbytheacousticlens
anddirectedtotheultrasoundtransducer.(B)OAmicroscopicimageofthebrainofahealthymouseshowsclearlydistinguishablehemispheres.(C)Thesameimageof
amouseinfectedwithPlasmodium(5daysafterinfection)showsaberrantstructureofthevasculature.
ininfectedmice(5daysafterinfection)themajorvascularlandmarkscouldhardlybeidentified. Thevasculatureshowedalargenumberofaberrantlydistributedscrew-likebloodvessels,and thetwohemispherescouldnolongerbedistinguished(Figure3C).Inlaterstagesofthedisease (7+daysafterinfection),asignificantdecreaseinoptoacousticsignalamplitudewasdetected, possiblyduetoprogressiveanaemia.
Altogether,OAimaging,whichcombineshighcontrastandspectralsensitivitywiththehigh spatialresolutionobtainedinultrasoundimaging,providesexcellentvisualizationof micro-vasculature, making it a powerful tool for basic parasitological research and preclinical applications.Combinedwithexogenousopticallyabsorbingagentsorgeneticallyexpressed reporters it has been proven to provide molecular information with high sensitivity and specificity.
Ultrasoundimagingitselfhasalsobeensuccessfullyusedinthefieldofparasitologyandin medicalimaging.Ultrasounduseshigh-frequencysoundwaves,whicharereflectedoffbody structures,renderingan image.Key advancesinultrasoundover thepast decade include elastography [131],ultrasound contrast agentimaging usingmicrobubbles (reviewedin
[132]),super-resolutionimaging,2Darraytransducer,andultrafastultrasoundimaging[133].
Whiletheseadvanceshavebeenwidelyexploredinotherfieldsofresearch,theyremaintobe usedininvivoparasitology,andhaveenormouspotential.Elastographyisatechniquereferred to as ‘palpatingbyimaging',enablingmeasurement andvisualizationoftissuemechanical propertiesinhealthanddisease.Intermsofcontrastagents,microbubblesprovide consider-ableadvantagestoultrasoundimaging,includingthepossibilityofstudyingbloodrheologyand tissueperfusion,andofenhancingvascularpermeability, drugandgenedelivery,andlocal heating (reviewed in[134]). Finally, ultrafastand super-resolution ultrasound imaging were achievedusingintravenousinjectionofmicrobubbles,the propertiesofwhichallowed hae-modynamicquantificationandimagingstructuresat10mmunderthecranium.Singleechoes fromindividualmicrobubblescouldbedetected,allowingaccuratequantificationofbloodflow speedsatanimagingrateof1000framespersecond[133].Altogether,technological improve-ments in ultrasound speed and resolution, as well as echosonography applications, hold enormouspotentialforparasitologyintermsofstudyingchangesinrheology,vascular per-meability,tissueperfusion,andchangesinthephysiologyofimportantstructuressuchasthe brain–bloodbarrier.
MagneticResonanceImaging
Magneticresonanceimaging(MRI)isanoninvasiveimagingtechniqueuniquelysuitedtoimage deepinsidetissuewithhighspatialresolutionandwithoutionizingradiation.MRIisbasedon themagneticpropertiesofprotonsandneutronswithinatomicnucleiofthebody,particularlyof hydrogen,aswaterisamajorcomponentofthehumanbody.Thespinofhydrogennucleican bemeasuredastheyshowanunevennumberofprotons.Therefore,afterplacingthebody inside the magnetic field of the MRI scanner, the spins start to process with the Lamour frequencyandalignwiththemagneticfield(inbothdirections,howeverslightlymoreinthefield direction).Upon applicationof a radiofrequency (RF)pulse withexactly the same Lamour frequency,thenucleicanabsorbenergyandtransitionfromlowertohigherenergystates(so calledspinexcitation).AftertheRFpulseisswitchedoff,thenucleireturntotheirequilibrium state. Thisprocess requires timeand depends onthe surrounding tissue(also knownas relaxationtime).Duringtherelaxation process,asignalcanbedetected byRFcoilsinthe scanner,whichcanbereconstructed byadvancedimagingtechniques toanimage ofthe humanbody(reviewedin[135]).MRIoffersextraordinaryadvantages,includinghighspatial resolution, and the opportunity of simultaneously extracting physiological, molecular, and
anatomicalinformationfromthebody.Conversely,itslimitationsincludelowsensitivity,long scanningtime,andprobequantityrequiredforimaging.
MRIhasimproved ourunderstandingofdiseasesinparasitologybydetectingpathological alterations,forexample,inthebrain,causedbyToxoplasma[136](Figure4A),Trypanosoma brucei[137](Figure4B),andPlasmodium[138](Figure4C,courtesyofAngelikaHoffmann).In thissectionwediscusstheadvancesinthetechniquerelevanttoparasitology,inthreespecific aspects: MRI probes, multimodal mesoscopic imaging, andthe uses offunctional MRIto addresstranslationalquestions.
Contrastagentsareexogenouscompoundsadministeredtoimprovetheimagecontrastand detectpathologicalalterationsmoreaccurately.Significanteffortshavebeenmadetoimprove MRIbydevelopingcontrastagentsforuseasprobesandsensors.Theseincludegadolinium agents (Gd3+) and derivatives including gadolinium hexanedione [139], gadofluorine and liposomal-basedgadoliniumnanoparticles[140].Thesecontrastagentsareused,forexample, inthestudyofbrainnervebarrierpermeability[141],blood-vesselremodelling[142],orcellular uptake.Otheragentsincludemanganese-basedagentssuchasmanganesechloride(MnCl2)
[143],manganese oxide(MnO) [144],and silica-coatedparticles, whichallow detection of
(B)
T. brucei
(C1) (C2)
Control
P. berghei ANKA
(A1) (A2)
T.
gondii
Co
nt
ro
l
hrFM
hrFM
Figure4.MagneticResonanceImaging(MRI)oftheBrain.(A)T2*-weightedimagesandhigh-resolutionfibremapsof(A1)uninfectedand(A2)Toxoplasma
gondii-infectedmousebrains.Arrowsininfectedbrainsshowinjuriesinthesomatosensorycortex(T2*-weightedimages),andaffectedfibredensityandcortical
connectivitypattern(hrFMimages).Figurereproduced,withpermission,from[136].(B)MRIscanofamouseat28dayspostinfectionwithTrypanosomabrucei,
followingadministrationofcontrast.Arrowheadshowsmeningealenhancementofthehind-mostsectionofthebrain.Figurereproduced,withpermission,from[137].
(C)T1subtractionmapstoillustrateblood–brainbarrier(BBB)disruptionwithrostralpredominanceinaPlasmodium-infectedmouse(C1)comparedtoamousenot
displayingBBBdisruption(C2)(courtesyofAngelikaHoffmann).
specificcellpopulationsinvivoeitherontheirown,orbycombiningwithothercontrastagents. Equally,paramagneticironoxide(SPIO)agents,perfluorocarbons(PFCs),andhighly-shifted protonMRI[145–147],havebeenparticularlyusefulforsensitivelytrackingandvisualizingcell homing in vivo[148–150]. Altogether, advances in MRI contrast agents and probes have allowedthe monitoringofcellfunctions, includingenzymatic activity,geneexpression,and death,aswellassensitivetrackingofcellpopulations(reviewedin[151]).
WhiletheoutputofMRIisimagingofanatomicalchanges,functionalMRI(fMRI)isbasedon allowingvisualizationofmetabolicfunctionbytissues.fMRIallowsmeasurementofbloodflow
kBq/cc
0 800
0 700
X-ray source
Animal/specimen RotaƟon and acquisiƟon 360°
ScinƟllaƟon screen ObjecƟve lens CCD MulƟple projecƟons 3D reconstrucƟon (A) (B)
Foetal brain vasculature
18F-Ňuorodeoxyglucose uptake
HounsĮeld units
Detector ring
Collimator ScinƟllaƟon site for y rays EmiƩed y rays AbsorpƟon in collimator Positron-emiƫng radionuclide e+ e-AnnihilaƟon (C) (D) y ray y ray y y
Figure5.X-Ray-BasedandPositronEmissionTomography(PET)-BasedImaging.(A)Principalcomponentsofamicrocomputertomographyscannerinclude
anX-raysourcethatproducesX-rayswhichtravelthroughthesampleandarecollectedontheothersidebyanX-raydetector(scintillationscreen,lens,andcharge-coupled
devicecamera).RotationoftheX-raysourceanddetectorallowsacquisitionover360,allowingthegenerationofaseriesofprojectionimages.Theseimagescanbe
processedto producea3Dimageofthe specimen.(B) Maximum-intensity projectionfromanX-raymicro-computedtomography(micro-CT) study ofthe brain vasculatureof
foetusesfrommalaria-infectedrodentmothers.Thebrainvasculatureshownisthatofafoetusfromanuninfectedmouse.Figureadaptedfrom[154].(C)Radioactivetracers
areinjectedintothemouseandwillemitpositronsbyradioactivedecay.Upondecay,positronsarereleasedfromthenucleusoftheradionuclideandannihilatewithelectrons
inthetissue,releasinggamma-photonsthatcanbedetectedwithinacoincidencedetectorring(composedofacollimatorandscintillationcrystals).Thisallowsmappingthe
anatomicallocalizationofthetracer.(D)3DreconstructionofamouseimagedbyPET-CTinastudyinvestigatingglucoseuptakeduringthedarkphaseofa24hlight–dark
cycle.(18)F-fluorodeoxyglucose(FDG)wasusedasatracer,andshowshighestaccumulationinthebrain,heart,andbladder,followedbythekidneysandbrownadipose
tissue.ScalebarsrepresentCTintensity(greyscale),andFDGuptake(colourscale,radioactivitypertissuevolume).Figureadaptedfrom[155].
changes,orbloodoxygenlevelfluctuations,providingapictureofoxygenconsumption.Itis basedontheuseofblood-oxygen-level-dependent(BOLD)contrast,basedonincreasedor decreased concentrationsofparamagnetic deoxyhaemoglobinassociatedwithchanges in neuronalactivity(reviewedin[152]).Theuseofthistechniquehasbeenrelativelyscarcein parasitology,yetithaspotentialforawidenumberofparasites,whichinducemetabolicand/or functionalchanges intissues. Similarly,the generationof MRIscannerssuch as the9.4T equipment[153]offersimprovedimagingresolution.
X-Ray-BasedandGamma-Ray-BasedNoninvasiveImagingMethods
Otherimagingmethodswhichhaverelevantclinicaltranslationpotentialincluderadiography, computedtomography,X-raymicro-CT(Figure5A,B)[154],andradioisotope-basedimaging suchasSPECTandPET(Figure5C,D)[155].
TwocategoriesofX-ray-basedimagingarestructuralandfunctionalimaging,enablingstudies ofanatomicalstructuresandofchangesinbiologicalfunctionssuchasmetabolism,bloodflow, andbiochemicalcompositionoftissues,respectively.Functionalanalysisoftissuesandtheir compositionusingX-rayshasseenprogresswiththeuseofexogenouscontrastagents,andis basedonthepossibleinteractionsbetweenX-raysandmatter.TheseincludeX-ray attenua-tion,X-rayfluorescence,andX-ray-excitedopticalluminescence(reviewedin[156,157]). Equally noninvasive is imaging based on gamma-ray emission from radioisotope-labelled biomolecules within samples upon radioactive decay, namely PET and SPECT. In both methods, radioactive biomolecules, synthesized from radio-nucleotides, are administered, and,followingbiologicalinteractionsinspecifictissues,thereisdecay,resultingintheemission ofgammaphotons.ThesephotonscanbedetectedbyPETandSPECTscannersandcanbe tomographically reconstructed to generate 3D images of functional tissue activity [158]
(Figure5C,D).Theuseofradiography-basedandnuclear-imaging-basedmethodshasbeen
relativelylimitedinparasitology,yethaspotentialforthestudyofhost–pathogeninteraction effectsonorganfunctions,tissuecomposition,andmetabolicchangesuponinfection. ConcludingRemarks
Altogether, multiple methods forin vivo imaging as stand-alone techniques have allowed improved resolution(e.g.,advancedmicroscopymethodssuchassuper-resolutionwithIVM),decreased invasiveness(e.g.,bytheuseofOAI),increasedpenetrationdepthallowingforimagingoforgan regionspreviouslyimpossibletoobserveinvivo(e.g.,throughtheuseofGRINlensesforIVM),and functionalimagingwithhighresolution(e.g.,fMRI,MRI,PET,SPECT).Manyofthesetechniques havesuccessfullyreachedtheparasitologyfield,particularlyIVM.However,theadvancesinIVM methodsandothertechniquesaltogether,stillholdenormouspotentialandapplicability,which needtobeexplored(seeOutstandingQuestions).Forinstance,theseadvancesopenupthe possibilityto imagetheheart upon infection with T. cruzi,the digestive organsupon infection with T. gondii,anddeep-brainstructuresuponinfectionwithT.brucei.FunctionalMRIandadvancesin X-ray-basedandgamma-ray-basedmethodscouldenablethestudyoffunctionalandanatomical changesintissuesandorgansuponinfection,aswellasfluiddynamicssuchasbloodflow.Aside fromtheseadvancesinstand-aloneplatforms,equallyrelevantwillbetheuseofhybrid, multi-modalitysystemswhichcouldprovideinterestingopportunitiestostudyhost–pathogen inter-actionsinvivoatvariouslevelssimultaneously.
Acknowledgments
WearegratefultoVolkerHeussler(IZB,UniversityofBern)forhelpfuladviceandintellectualinputonthetechniques
relevanttoOPT,LSFM,andOAI,andtraininganddiscussionskeytothesemethods,andIVM.WethankalsotheMICat
OutstandingQuestions
Cantheparasitologyfieldtake
advan-tage of motion-correction
mecha-nismstostudyparasitesintheheart
orgutbyIVM?
IVM, OPT, SPIM, and MRI allow
accesstothegastrointestinalsystem.
Whatcanthesetechniquesteachusin
thecontextoffood-borneand
water-borneparasites?
CannewimprovementsinIVM
appli-cations, allowing visualization of
deeperorgan structures,enablethe
imagingofrareinfectioneventssuch
asT.bruceiandT.gondiicrossingthe
blood–brainbarrier?
HowcanOPTandSPIMbemodified
to studythe impactofparasiteson
vector biology, and host–pathogen
interactionswithinvectorhosts?
Can OPT, SPIM,andother relevant
hybrid platforms, help to address
questionsrelevanttoparasite
dynam-icsandspread?
Will MRIandOAI,as wellashybrid
imaging platforms, enable us to
address questionsrelevant to
meta-bolic dysregulation by parasitic
infections?
How can technological advances in
imaging methods,applied toanimal
models,bebettertranslatedtohuman
medicine in the context of
parasitology?
Can experiments be repeated
fre-quently enough to generate robust
statistics?
theUniversityofBern,forprovidingaccessandtraininginallrelevantimagingmethodsherebydiscussed.Wethank
FedericaMoalli,RenzoDanuser(TKI,Bern);EmmanuelG.Reynaud(UniversityCollege,Dublin)andJessicaKehrer(Centre
forInfectiousDiseases,HeidelbergUniversityHospital)forhelpfulinputforOPTandLSFMtechniquesanddiscussions.We
thankRobertNuster(IAP,Bern)forexperimentalhelpduringtheestablishmentofOAIforexperimentalcerebralmalaria
imaging.WearegratefultoAngelikaHoffmann(DepartmentofNeuroradiology,HeidelbergUniversityHospital)forher
helpfulinputonMRItechniques,forkindlyprovidingFigure4C(MRIofaPlasmodium-infectedbrain),andforcarefully
proofreadingthismanuscript’ssectionsrelevanttoMRI.MDNisfundedbyEMBOfellowshipALTF1048-2016,andby
EVIMalaR(242095FP7)andRSHTM(000529)fellowshipswithVolkerHeussler(IZB,Bern)relatedtoOPTandOAIstudies,
aswellasSwissNationalScienceFoundationfellowships310030_159519and316030_145013fundingworkcarriedout
inhislaboratory. FSand MF acknowledgethe financial supportofthe Swiss NationalScienceFoundation(No:
205320_179038/1).WorkinthelaboratoryofFFisfundedbyaHumanFrontierScienceProgramgrant(RGY0066)
andtheGermanScienceFoundation(SFB1129).Weapologizetothemanycolleaguesfornotcitingtheirworkdueto
restrictionsbythejournalandthebroadscopeofthereview.
References
1. Nacer,A.etal.(2014)Experimentalcerebralmalaria pathogen-esis–hemodynamicsatthebloodbrainbarrier.PLoSPathog. 10,e1004528
2. Coles,J.A.etal.(2015)Intravitalimagingofamassive lympho-cyteresponseinthecorticalduraofmiceafterperipheral infec-tionbytrypanosomes.PLoSNegl.Trop.Dis.9,e0003714
3. Konradt,C.etal.(2016)Endothelialcellsareareplicativeniche forentryofToxoplasmagondiitothecentralnervoussystem. Nat.Microbiol.1,16001
4. Estato,V.etal.(2018)TheneurotropicparasiteToxoplasma gondiiinducessustainedneuroinflammationwithmicrovascular dysfunctionininfectedmice.Am.J.Pathol.188,2674–2687
5. Amino,R.etal.(2006)QuantitativeimagingofPlasmodium transmissionfrommosquitotomammal.Nat.Med.12,220– 224
6. Hopp,C.S.etal.(2015)LongitudinalanalysisofPlasmodium sporozoitemotilityinthedermisrevealscomponentofblood vesselrecognition.eLife4,e07789
7. Calvo-Alvarez,E.etal.(2018)Anewchimerictriplereporter fusionproteinasatoolforinvitroandinvivomultimodalimaging tomonitorthedevelopmentofAfricantrypanosomesand Leish-maniaparasites.Infect.Genet.Evol.63,391–403
8. Capewell,P.etal.(2016)Theskinisasignificantbutoverlooked anatomicalreservoirforvector-borneAfricantrypanosomes. eLife5,e17716
9. Peters,N.C.etal.(2008)Invivoimagingrevealsanessentialrole forneutrophilsinleishmaniasistransmittedbysandflies. Sci-ence321,970–974
10. Soares,A.C.etal.(2014)Intravitalmicroscopyandimage anal-ysisofRhodniusprolixus(Hemiptera:Reduviidae) hematoph-agy:thechallengeofbloodintakefrommouseskin.Parasitol. Int.63,229–236
11. Soares,A.C.etal.(2006)SalivationpatternofRhodniusprolixus (Reduviidae;Triatominae)inmouseskin.J.InsectPhysiol.52, 468–472
12. Paveley, R.A.etal.(2009) Fluorescentimagingof antigen releasedbyaskin-invadinghelminthrevealsdifferentialuptake andactivationprofilesbyantigenpresentingcells.PLoSNegl. Trop.Dis.3,e528
13. Frevert,U.etal.(2014)ImagingPlasmodiumimmunobiologyin liver,brain,andlung.Parasitol.Int.63,171–186
14. Tavares,J.etal.(2013)Roleofhostcelltraversalbythemalaria sporozoiteduringliverinfection.J.Exp.Med.210,905–915
15. Sturm,A.etal.(2006)Manipulationofhosthepatocytesbythe malariaparasitefordeliveryintoliversinusoids.Science313, 1287–1290
16. Beattie,L.etal.(2010)Dynamicimagingofexperimental Leish-maniadonovani-inducedhepaticgranulomasdetectsKupffer cell-restrictedantigenpresentationtoantigen-specificCD8+
Tcells.PLoSPathog.6,e1000805
17. Girgis,N.M.etal.(2014)Ly6Chighmonocytesbecome alterna-tivelyactivatedmacrophagesinschistosomegranulomaswith helpfromCD4+cells.PLoSPathog.10,e1004080 18. Coudrier,E.etal.(2004)MyosinIIandtheGal-GalNAclectin
playacrucialroleintissueinvasionbyEntamoebahistolytica. CellMicrobiol.7,19–27
19. Martin-Jaular,L.etal.(2011)Strain-specificspleenremodelling inPlasmodiumyoeliiinfectionsinBalb/cmicefacilitates adher-enceandspleenmacrophage-clearanceescape.CellMicrobiol. 13,109–122
20. DeNiz,M.etal.(2016)Themachineryunderlyingmalaria para-sitevirulenceisconservedbetweenrodentandhumanmalaria parasites.Nat.Commun.7,11659
21. Coombes,J.L.etal.(2013)Motileinvadedneutrophilsinthe smallintestineofToxoplasmagondii-infectedmicereveala potentialmechanismforparasitespread.Proc.Natl.Acad. Sci.U.S.A.110,E1913–E1922
22. daS.Watanabe,P.etal.(2018)Immunocompetenthost devel-opsmildintestinalinflammationinacuteinfectionwith Toxo-plasmagondii.PLoSOne13, e0190155–e0190155
23. Radtke,A.J.etal.(2015)Lymph-noderesidentCD8+
dendritic cellscaptureantigensfrommigratorymalariasporozoitesand induceCD8+Tcellresponses.PLoSPathog.11,e1004637 24. Bajénoff,M.etal.(2006)Naturalkillercellbehaviorinlymph
nodesrevealedbystaticandreal-timeimaging.J.Exp.Med. 203,619–631
25. DeNiz,M.etal.(2018)Plasmodiumgametocytesdisplay hom-ingandvasculartransmigrationinthehostbonemarrow.Sci. Adv.4, eaat3775
26. deMoraes,L.V.etal.(2013)Intravitalplacentaimagingreveals microcirculatorydynamicsimpactonsequestrationand phago-cytosisofPlasmodium-infectederythrocytes.PLoSPathog.9, e1003154
27. Lima,F.A.etal.(2014)Intravitalmicroscopytechniquetostudy parasitedynamicsinthelabyrinthlayerofthemouseplacenta. Parasitol.Int.63,254–259
28. Lagerweij,T.etal.(2017)Opticalclearingandfluorescence deep-tissueimagingfor3Dquantitativeanalysisofthebrain tumormicroenvironment.Angiogenesis20,533–546
29. Schuh,C.D.etal.(2016)Longwavelengthmultiphoton excita-tionisadvantageousforintravitalkidneyimaging.KidneyInt.89, 712–719
30. Friedl,P.etal.(2007)Biologicalsecondandthirdharmonic generationmicroscopy.Curr.Protoc.CellBiol.34, 4.15.1– 4.15.21
31. Perillo,E.P.etal.(2016)Deepinvivotwo-photonmicroscopy withalowcostcustombuiltmode-locked1060nmfiberlaser. Biomed.Opt.Express7,324–334
32. Michalet,X.etal.(2005)Quantumdotsforlivecells,invivo imaging,anddiagnostics.Science307,538–544
33. Zhao,J.etal.(2018)Recentdevelopmentsinmultimodality fluorescenceimagingprobes.ActaPharm.Sin.B8,320–338
34. Nobis,M.etal.(2018)Molecularmobilityandactivityinan intravitalimagingsettingimplicationsforcancerprogression andtargeting.J.CellSci.131, jcs206995
35. Radbruch,H.etal.(2015)IntravitalFRET:probingcellularand tissuefunctioninvivo.Int.J.Mol.Sci.16,11713–11727
36. Komatsu,N.etal.(2011)Developmentofanoptimized back-boneofFRETbiosensorsforkinasesandGTPases.Mol.Biol. Cell22,4647–4656
37. Hires,S.A.etal.(2008)Reportingneuralactivitywithgenetically encodedcalciumindicators.BrainCellBiol.36,69–86
38. Tretiakova,D.S.etal.(2018)Lateralstressprofileand fluores-centlipidprobes:FRETpairofprobesthatintroducesminimal distortionsintolipidpacking.Biochim.Biophys.Acta– Bio-membr.1860,2337–2347
39. Kinoshita,M.etal.(2017)Emphaticvisualizationof sphingo-myelin-richdomainsbyinter-lipidFRETimagingusing fluores-centsphingomyelins.Sci.Rep.7,16801
40. Dai,T.etal.(2018)LiposomesandlipiddiskstraversetheBBB andBBTBasintactformsasrevealedbytwo-stepFörster resonance energytransferimaging.ActaPharm.Sin.B8, 261–271
41. Hirata,E.andKiyokawa,E.(2016)Futureperspectiveof single-moleculeFRETbiosensorsandintravital FRETmicroscopy. Biophys.J.111,1103–1111
42. Welf,E.S.etal.(2016)Quantitativemultiscalecellimagingin controlled3Dmicroenvironments.Dev.Cell36,462–475
43. Woehler,A.(2013)Simultaneousquantitativelivecellimagingof multipleFRET-basedbiosensors.PLoSOne8,e61096
44. Erami,Z.etal.(2016)IntravitalFRAPimagingusingan E-cad-herin-GFP mouse reveals disease- and drug-dependent dynamicregulationof cell-celljunctions in livetissue. Cell Rep.14,152–167
45. Machado,M.J.C.andMitchell,C.A.(2011)Temporalchangesin microvesselleakinessduringwoundhealingdiscriminatedbyin vivofluorescencerecoveryafterphotobleaching.J.Physiol. 589,4681–4696
46. deGrauw,C.J.etal.(1999)Imagingpropertiesintwo-photon excitationmicroscopyandeffectsofrefractive-indexmismatch inthickspecimens.Appl.Opt.38,5995
47. Andresen,V.etal.(2012)High-resolutionintravitalmicroscopy. PLoSOne7,e50915
48. Wegner,W.etal.(2017)InvivomouseandlivecellSTED microscopyofneuronalactinplasticityusingfar-redemitting fluorescentproteins.Sci.Rep.7,11781
49. White,M.D.etal.(2018)Invivoimagingofsinglemammalian cellsindevelopmentanddisease.TrendsMol.Med.24,278– 293
50. Kim,J.K.etal.(2012)FabricationandoperationofGRINprobes forinvivofluorescencecellularimagingofinternalorgansin smallanimals.Nat.Protoc.7,1456–1469
51. Barretto,R.P.J.etal.(2011)Time-lapseimagingofdisease progressionindeepbrainareasusingfluorescence microendo-scopy.Nat.Med.17,223–229
52. Reismann,D.etal.(2017)Longitudinalintravitalimagingofthe femoralbonemarrowrevealsplasticitywithinmarrow vascula-ture.Nat.Commun.8,2153
53. Ducourthial,G.etal.(2015)Developmentofareal-timeflexible multiphotonmicroendoscopeforlabel-freeimaginginalive animal.Sci.Rep.5,18303
54. Rueckel,M.etal.(2006)Adaptivewavefrontcorrectionin two-photonmicroscopyusingcoherence-gatedwavefrontsensing. Proc.Natl.Acad.Sci.U.S.A.103,17137–17142
55. Lee,S.etal.(2014)Automatedmotionartifactremovalfor intravitalmicroscopy,withoutaprioriinformation.Sci.Rep.4, 4507
56. Taylor,J.M.(2014)Opticallygatedbeating-heartimaging.Front. Physiol.5,481
57. Warren, S.C. et al.(2018) Removingphysiological motion fromintravitalandclinicalfunctionalimaging data.eLife7, e35800
58. Ntziachristos,V.(2010)Goingdeeperthanmicroscopy:the opticalimagingfrontierinbiology.Nat.Methods7,603–614
59. Hama,H.etal.(2015)ScaleS:anopticalclearingpalettefor biologicalimaging.Nat.Neurosci.18,1518–1529
60. Tomer,R.etal.(2014)AdvancedCLARITYforrapidand high-resolutionimagingofintacttissues.Nat.Protoc.9,1682–1697
61. Richardson,D.S.andLichtman,J.W.(2016)Clarifyingtissue clearing.Cell162,246–257
62. Dodt,H.-U.etal.(2007)Ultramicroscopy:three-dimensional visualizationofneuronalnetworksinthewholemousebrain. Nat.Methods4,331–336
63. Ertürk,A.etal.(2012)Three-dimensionalimagingof solvent-clearedorgansusing3DISCO.Nat.Protoc.7,1983–1995
64. Renier,N.etal.(2014)iDISCO:asimple,rapidmethodto immunolabellargetissuesamplesforvolumeimaging.Cell 159,896–910
65. Susaki,E.A.etal.(2014)Whole-brainimagingwithsingle-cell resolutionusingchemicalcocktailsandcomputationalanalysis. Cell157,726–739
66. Abe,J.etal.(2016)Lightsheetfluorescencemicroscopyforin situcellinteractionanalysisinmouselymphnodes.J.Immunol. Methods431,1–10
67. Yu,T.etal.(2018)RTF:arapidandversatiletissueoptical clearingmethod.Sci.Rep.8,1964
68. Staudt,T.I.etal.(2007)2,2ʹ-thiodiethanol:anewwatersoluble mounting medium for high resolution optical microscopy. Microsc.Res.Tech.70,1–9
69. Aoyagi,Y.etal.(2015)Arapidopticalclearingprotocolusing2, 2ʹ-thiodiethanolformicroscopicobservationoffixedmouse brain.PLoSOne10,e0116280
70. Spalteholz,W.(1914)ÜberdasDurchsichtigmachenvon Mens-chlichenundTierischenPräparatenundSeineTheoretischen Bedingungen,nebstAnhang,ÜberKnochenfärbung,(Hirzel)
71. Murray,E.etal.(2015)Simple,scalableproteomicimaging for high-dimensional profiling of intact systems. Cell 163, 1500–1514
72. Hama,H.etal.(2011)Scale:achemicalapproachfor fluores-cenceimagingandreconstructionoftransparentmousebrain. Nat.Neurosci.14,1481–1488
73. Hou,B.etal.(2015)ScalableandDiI-compatibleoptical clear-anceofthemammalianbrain.Front.Neuroanat.9,19
74. Ikawa,M.etal.(2018)Arapidandnon-invasiveselectionof transgenicembryosbeforeimplantationusinggreenfluorescent protein(GFP).FEBSLett.375,125–128
75. Kuwajima,T.etal.(2013)ClearT:adetergent-andsolvent-free clearingmethodforneuronalandnon-neuronaltissue. Devel-opment140,1364–1368
76. Ke,M.-T.etal.(2013)SeeDB:asimpleand morphology-pre-servingopticalclearingagentforneuronalcircuitreconstruction. Nat.Neurosci.16,1154–1161
77. Chung,K.etal.(2013)Structuralandmolecularinterrogationof intactbiologicalsystems.Nature497,332–337
78. Poguzhelskaya,E.etal.(2014)Simplifiedmethodtoperform CLARITYimaging.Mol.Neurodegener.9,19
79. Ku,T.etal.(2016)Multiplexedandscalablesuper-resolution imagingofthree-dimensionalproteinlocalizationin size-adjust-abletissues.Nat.Biotechnol.34,973–981
80. Sharpe,J.etal.(2002)Opticalprojectiontomographyasatool for3Dmicroscopyandgeneexpressionstudies.Science296, 541–545
81. Kak,A.C.andSlaney,M.(1988)PrinciplesofComputerized TomographicImaging,IEEEPress
82. Huisken,J.etal.(2004)Opticalsectioningdeepinsidelive embryosbyselectiveplaneilluminationmicroscopy.Science 305,1007–1009