Article
Reference
Crystal structures of Eu(II) substituted barium magnesium fluorides:
Ba
0.78(3)Eu
0.22(3)MgF
4and Ba
5.20(6)Eu
0.80(6)Mg
7F
26KUBEL, Frank, HAGEMANN, Hans-Rudolf, BILL, Hans
Abstract
Barium in BaMgF[4] and in Ba[6]Mg[7]F[26] can be partially replaced by Sr or Eu. The single crystal structural analysis of the title compounds (a = 409.06 pm, b = 1452.7 pm, c = 579.02 pm, space group Cmc2[1] for Ba[0.78(3)]Eu[0.22(3)]MgF[4] [Z = 2, R[w] = 0.023 for 998 reflections] and a = 583.47 pm, b = 1209.09 pm and c = 1506.56 pm, space group Immm for Ba[5.20(6)]Eu[0.80(6)]Mg[7]F[26]) MgF[4] [Z = 2, R[w] = 0.019 for 2694 reflections] confirms the substitution of barium by europium. A split refinement of the substituted barium site in both crystals reveals a trend of europium to get closer to the nearest fluoride neighbors by simultaneously reducing the coordination sphere.
KUBEL, Frank, HAGEMANN, Hans-Rudolf, BILL, Hans. Crystal structures of Eu(II) substituted barium magnesium fluorides: Ba
0.78(3)Eu
0.22(3)MgF
4and Ba
5.20(6)Eu
0.80(6)Mg
7F
26. Zeitschrift für Kristallographie , 1999, vol. 214, p. 139-142
DOI : 10.1524/zkri.1999.214.3.139
Available at:
http://archive-ouverte.unige.ch/unige:3710
Disclaimer: layout of this document may differ from the published version.
©
by
R. Oldenbourg Verlag.MünchenCrystal structures of Eu(II) substituted barium magnesium fluorides:
Ba0.78(3)Euo.22(3)MgF4 and Ba5.20(6)Euo.80(6)Mg7F26
F. Kübel*. H.
Hagemann
and H. BillUniversitédeGenève. DepartementdeChimie
Physique,
30q. E. Ansermet.CH-1211 Genève4, Switzerland Received June 2, 1998;accepted
October 14. 1998Abstract. Barium in
BaMgF4
and inBa6Mg7F26
can bepartially replaced by
Sror Eu. Thesingle crystal
structuralanalysis
of the titlecompounds (a
=409.06 pm.b= 1452.7pm, c= 579.02pm, space group
Cmc2\
forBa,,.7S(3,Eu,).22(3,MgF4 [Z
=2, Rw
=0.023 for 998 reflec-tions]
and a =583.47 pm, b= 1209.09pm and c= 1506.56 pm, space group Immm forBa5.20(6)Euo.go(6)
•Mg7F26) MgF4 [Z=2, Rw
= 0.019 for 2694reflections]
confirms the substitution of barium
by europium.
Asplit
refinement of the substituted barium site in both
crystals
reveals a trend of
europium
toget
closer to the nearestfluoride
neighbors by simultaneously reducing
the coordi-nation
sphere.
Introduction
Alkaline earth fluorides are excellent
optical
hostcrystals
which are
transparent
well below 200nm. Certain rare- earthdoped
hosts of thisfamily
exhibitparticularly
inter-esting phosphor
behaviour. We choseEu(Il) doped
hostsas model
systems
toinvestigate
in more detail the relevantproperties by spectroscopic techniques [1]
andX-ray
dif-fraction.
Compounds
ofthetype BavMvF-
whereM=Mn—Znand
Mg
have been studied in thepast [e.g. 2-4].
However,
thesingle crystal X-ray
structures of thethree bariurn
magnesium
fluoridesBaMgF4, Ba2Mg3F|o [5]
andBa6Mg7F26 [6]
haveonly
beenreported
very re-cently.
It has been shownpreviously
thatBaMgF4
canform solid solutions without
structural change
ofthetype
Ba1_.vM.ïMgF4
with M=Eu[7]
or M=Sr[8]
with x ran-ging
from 0 to ca 0.55.EuMgF4
andSrMgF4
do not ap-pearto
crystallize
in the same space group asBaMgF4 [9].
The
compound Ba6Mg7F26
does not meltcongruently.
Ithas been
synthesized
either from anon-equilibrium
cooledbarium-magnesium
fluoride melt orusing
a LiF flux[6].
This latter method has allowed us to prepare and charac-
*
Correspondence
author(e-mail: frank.kubel+el71@tuwien.ac.at)
Present address: Prof. Dr. Frank Kubel. Institut für
Mineralogie.
Kristallographie
und Strukturchemie, Getreidemarkt 9. A-1060 Wien, Austriaterize
Ba5.24(4)Sr().76(4)Mg7F26 [10].
We willpresent
belowthe structures of the two title
compounds
and comparethem with the
parent
structures as well as with the struc-tures of
Sr-substituted analogs.
Experimental
Single crystals
ofBai_vEuAMgF4
with nominal jc-values of 0.25 wereprepared by
slowcooling
of a meltprepared
from
high purity BaF2, EuF2
andMgF2.
The melt wascontained
in agraphite
crucible andkept
under an inertatmosphere. Special
care was taken to avoid contaminationby
oxygen and water.Using
amicroscope operating
underpolarized light,
weinspected
thecrystalline
mass. Wefound,
besides amajor- ity
ofBaMgF4-type crystals (optically biaxial),
severalcrystal
needles with a similarshape
as observed pre-viously [6]
forBa(,Mg7F26 (optically uniaxial).
This pre-paration provided
thesingle crystals
used for thecrystal
structure determinations
reported
below.Table 1 summarizes the
experimental
conditions for thesingle crystal X-ray
structure determinations of both crys- tals.Results and discussion
A.
Ba„.78Euo.22MgF4
As observedfor theSr substituted
samples
inBavSri_vMgF4 [8],
oursynthesis
conditions(cooled melt)
led to ferrroe-lectrically single
domaincrystals,
whereas theBaMgF4 sample
obtainedby
solid reaction[5] presented
~50% offerroelectric
domains.The
crystal
latticeparameters
of thiscompound
areslightly
smaller than thosereported
for acrystalline powder
of nominalcomposition Bao.8.sEuo.i5MgF4 [7]
(a
=409.06(2)
pm,b
=1452.7(
1)
pm, c=579.02(3)
pm and V =344.08(3) 106 pm3
vs a =411.2(2)
pm, b=1452.8(4)
pm and c=581.2(2)
pm andV=
347.2(2) 106pm3).
These reduced unit cell param-eters confirm a further substitution of
Ba2+ by Eu2+.
Using
thereported
unit cell volumes ofEuMgF4 (320.41 106pm3) [9]
and ofBaMgF4 (348.7 106pm3) [5],
Brought to you by | Université de Genève - Bibliothèque de Genève
140 F. Kübel, H.
Hagemann
and H. BillTable1.
Crystal
data(e.s.d.'s inbrackets) and conditions of data col- lection and refinement forBa5.20(6)Euo.8o(6)Mg7F26
andBao.îsai
Hu
0.22U)MgF4
Formula
Ba5.2()(6)Euo.sO(6|Mg7F2(, Bao.78(3)EuU.22(3)MgF4
Formulamass
(g mor1) Space
groupa
(pm)
b(pm)
c(pm)
V(106pm3)
Z
Calc.
density
(gcm"')
Crystal size (mm')
Diffractometer type
Wavelength.
radiation Method
Temperature
0 range(°)
hkl range No. of refl.
mesured No. of
independent
refl.No. of refl.
with />3(7(7) Programused Absorption
coefficient Abs. corr.
anal. Tmin/Tmax
R(Rwbased
on
I/o2)
Number of parameters Goodness of fit Extinction
coefficient Absolute
structurefactor e"
densitymin/max
(KT6 pm"3)
1499.7 Immm(No. 71)
583.47(1) 1209.09(10) 1506.56(14) 1062.83(13) 2
4.695
240.9
Cmc2, (No. 36) 409.06(2) 1452.70(10)
579.02(3) 344.08(3) 2 4.658
0.082 x0.095 x0.230 0.032x0.072x0.096 STOE
Mo/C„ 71.073 pm
2.2-50.0 -8 -> 8, -31 -12-» 12 11355 3106 0.035 2694
12.45 0.055/0.085 0.024 (0.019)
69 1.75
815(17)
-3.9/1.4
(u/0-scan 300 K
2.8-50.0
31, -12 -> 12.
-26 ->26.0 -> 32 7798
1038 0.039 998 XTAL 3.2 13.32 0.031/0.066 0.024(0.023) 40
1.93 177(8) 0.00(3) -1.5/2.0
Table 2.
Partially
standardized (metals and fluoridesareseparated
for clarity) [I4J atomicpositional
parameters, atomicdisplacement
fac-tors and site
occupation
parameters of Bao78(3)Euo.22(3)MgF4
with e.s.d.'s inparenthesis.
Atom U PP
Ba Eu
Mg
F(l) F(2) F(3) F(4)0.3523(3) 0.3411(5) 0.0850(1) 0.0263(2) 0.1646(2) 0.1961(2) 0.5802(3)
0.36655"
0.36655"
0.3282(2) 0.0143(5) 0.5962(6) 0.1335(5) 0.3181(6)
0.0146(2) 0.0146(2) 0.0088(3) 0.0174(6) 0.0177(7) 0.0133(6) 0.0226(8)
0.78(3) 0.22(3)
a: fixed value
Atomicdisplacement parameters
[106pm2]
Atom U\ I 2 Ur Un U\. Uis
Ba Eu
Mg
F(l) F(2) F(3) F(4)0.657(5) 0.657(5) 0.94(4) 2.5(1) 1.8(1) 1.5(1) 0.62(7)
2.11(6) 2.11(6) 0.83(4) 1.35(9) 2.0(1)
1.02(9) 3.6(2)
1.601(9) 1.601(9) 0.85(6)
1.4(1) 1.5(1) 1.4(1) 2.6(2)
-1.101(9) -1.101(9) 0.09(3) -0.59(8) -0.6(1)
0.3(8) 0.7(1)
|The
anisotropic displacement
factor in the structure factorexpression
is:
Uij
=exp-
2jr(c/|,/iV2
+U22k2b"2
+(,.;/r
;+2Unhka"b*
++
lUnhlac*
+2U2iklb'c)].
The
comparison
of the structural data ofBaMgF4 [5|. BaZnF4 [llj
andBa^Mg^,, [6],
as well as theEu-substituted
crystals
reveals asignificant anisotropy
of the atomic
displacement parameters
inBaMgF4
and
Bao.7S(3)Eu().22(3)MgF4 (see Fig. 2)
as well as inBai_xSrvMgF4 [7|
which is not seen inBa6Mg7F26
andBa5.20(6)Euo.80(6)Mg7F26-
A detailed
investigation
onBaZnF4 [11-13]
revealed astructural
instability
related to a rotation of theZnF<-,
octa-hedra. A similar behavior is
probably
alsopresent
inBaMgF4
and its solid solutions.one obtains
by
linearinterpolation
an estimated Eu mole fraction of 0.16 in thecrystal,
which is somewhat lessthan the nominal
composition
of the melt(X(Eu)
=0.25).
The refined Eu
population
was found to be0.22(3).
Table 2 collects the atomic
positional
anddisplacement parameters
forBao.78Euo.22MgF4.
Table3 collects some se-lected bond
lengths.
The
comparison
of therefinedMg—F
bonddistances for thiscompound
with those forBaMgF4
andBai_vSr,MgF4 [8]
shows a trend towards a moresymmetrical Mg—F
en-vironment with
increasing
substitution of Ba in thecrystal
(see Fig. 1).
TheMg—F
distances found inBao.^Sro 27MgF4 [8]
areverysimilartothoseinBao.78Euo.22MgF4. (see Fig. 1).
1 Additional material to thispapercanbe ordered
referring
totheno. CSD 410308 (for
Bao.78Euo.22MgF4)
and CSD 410309 (for Ba.Y2Euo.sMg7F2(,), names of the authors and citation of the paperat theFachinformationszentrum Karlsruhe. Gesellschaft für wissenschaft- lich-technische Information mbH, D-76344Eggenstein-Leopolds-
hafen.
Germany.
The list offy/vdatais available fromtheauthoruptooneyear after thepublication hasappeared.
Table 3. Selected metal fluoride distances for
Bao.78(3)Eu().22(.?)MgF4
(pm).Ba Eu
Eu 16.3(8)
F2 x2 258.71(22) F3 250.1(6)
F3 264.0(5) F2 x2 257.68(21)
F3 x2 265.84(23) F3 x2 262.00(24)
F4 279.2(4) F4 285.4(5)
Fl x2 283.3(4) F2 288.8(7)
F2 303.4(6) Fl x2 293.7(5)
F4 332.3(6) F4 337.5(4)
F4 332.3(4) F4 348.5(8)
Mg
F2 193.6(4)
Fl 194.3(3)
F3 196.9(3)
Fl 200.8(3)
F4 x2 204.73(2)
Brought to you by | Université de Genève - Bibliothèque de Genève
203
206
Ü
204O)202i
-o 21
o LL6)198A
'- 196 a
S. 0
1194
CD£
H W 192-190 188
«I T
MgF2 O MgF1
A MgF3
V MgF1b O MgF4
0.0 0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5 0.6 xin
Ba1_xMxMgF4
M=Sr, x=0.27andx=0.55, M=Eu,x=0.22
Fig.
1.Magnesium
fluoride distances in BaMgF4[5],
and in its solid solutions with Sr and Eu.Fig.
2. ORTEPplot
of the structure ofBao.78<3)Euo.22<3)MgF4 along
the a-axis. The
magnesium
-
fluoride bondsare drawn for
clarity.
B.
Ba5.20(6)EUo.80(6)Mg7F26
Table 4 collects the atomic
positional
anddisplacement
parameters
forBas.20(6)Eu0.80(6)Mg7F26.
Table 5 collectssome selected bond
lengths.
It isimportant
to note thatthis
compound
as well asBa5.25Srn.75Mg7F26 [10] crystal-
lizes in the same orthorhombic structure as
Ba6Mg7F26 [6].
There is no indication of a monoclinic
symmetry
which had beenreported
forBa6Zn7F26 [4].
In
Ba5.20(6)Euo.80(6)Mg7F26, mainly
one of the two Basites is
subject
to substitutionby
Eu. Thispreferential
sub-stitution takes also
place
inBas.25Sro.75Mg7F26 [10].
In a first refinement of the reflection intensities of
Ba5.20(6)Eun.80(6)Mg7F26,
nosplit position
of Ba2/Eu2 wasassumed and a
position
of z=0.3500 was refined. The electrondensity
map revealed a small residual electrondensity
close to Ba2/Eu2 and the atomicdisplacement
fac-tor of Ba2/Eu2 was calculated to
U\\
=0.890(5) l/22
=0.735(4)
andU33
=1.324(5) 106pm2.
The residualdensity
vanished whenseparation
of both elements wasTable 4.
Partially
standardized [14] atomicpositional
parameters, atomicdisplacement
factors and siteoccupation
parameters ofBa5.2Eu().siMg7F26
with e.s.d.'s inparenthesis.
Atom PP
7: 72
Ba(l)
Eu(l) Ba(2)
Eu(2)Mg(l)
0Mg(2)
0 Mg(3) 0.2530(2)0.2329(2)
72
0.2512(3) 0.2544(2) 0
72
o o
Mg(4)
F(l) F(2) F(3)F(4) F(5) F(6) F(7)0.26006(1)
0.26006(1)
0 0 0 0.26957(8) 0 0.11289(6)
72
0.3883(1) 0.16383(9) 0.2837(1) 0 0 0
0.35126(1) 0.35126(1) 0.3531(2) 0.3427(2) 0.22056(6)
0 0 0 0.24214(6) 0 0
0.12692(9) 0.0880(1) 0.0888(1) 0.3704(1)
1.047(2) 1.047(2) 0.79(1) 0.79(1) 0.90(2) 0.91(2) 0.78(2) 0.67(2) 1.32(2) 2.64(4) 1.26(2) 2.12(4) 1.28(4) 1.12(3) 2.50(6)
0.94(1) 0.06(1) 0.72(1) 0.28(1)
Atomic
displacement
parameters[106 pm2]
Atom Ui Ur U33 <Vi: U Ur
Bad) 1.032(4)0.979(4)1.131(4) 0 0 0.008(3) Eu(l) 1.032(4) 0.979(4)1.131(4) 0 0 0.008(3) Ba(2) 0.888(5) 0.732(4) 0.76(3) 0 0 0
Eu(2) 0.888(5) 0.732(4) 0.76(3) 0 0 0
Mg(l) 0.83(4) 0.90(3) 0.97(3) 0 0 0
Mg(2) 0.68(3) 0.77(3) 1.29(3) 0 0 0
Mg(3)
0.59(3) 0.71(3) 1.04(3) 0 0 0Mg(4) 0.62(5) 0.55(4) 0.83(4) 0 0 0
F(ï)
1.15(3) 1.16(3) 1.65(4) -0.26(3) -0.11(2) 0.05(2) F(2) 2.10(8) 1.74(6) 4.07(9) -1.34(6) 0 0 F(3) 1.02(4) 0.72(4) 2.05(5) 0.15(3) 0 0 F(4) 3.24(9) 1.74(5) 1.38(5) 0 0 -0.32(4)F(5) 0.87(6) 1.95(7) 1.02(5) 0 0 0
F(6)
0.87(6) 1.62(6) 0.88(5) 0 0 0F(7) 2.6(1) 4.0(1) 0.90(6) 0 0 0
assumed and the atomic
displacement parameter changed
toUu
=0.888(5) U22
=0.732(4)
andU33
=0.76(3) 106 pm2
and was foundto be more
isotropic.
Further theagreement
values decreasedslightly (Rw
2.0 ->Rw 1.9%).
The distance between both
fractionally occupied
siteswas foundto be
15.7(3)
pmThe
split
refinement of the atomicpositions
of Eu andBa on this site revealed that the
Eu(II)
ion forms shorterbonds
(c/(Eu-Fl)
=256.6(2) pm)
with the four closest sur-Fig.
3. Local environmentaround Ba2/Eu2 inBa5.20(6)Euo.80(6)Mg7F26.
The shortest Eu-Fl bonds aredrawn.
Brought to you by | Université de Genève - Bibliothèque de Genève
142 F.Kübel, H.Hagemannand H. Bill
Bal/Eul Ba2 Eu2 Table 5. Selected metal fluoride distances for
Ba5.2()(6)Euo.80(6)Mg7F26 (pm).
Fl x2 Fl x2 F3 x2 F4 x2 F5 F7 F2 x2 F4
260.16(9) 277.78(8) 281.46(8) 298.30(3) 304.22(5) 315.76(3) 321.63(11) 339.19(14)
Eu2 F4 x2 Fl x4 F7 x2 F2 x4
15.7(3) 263.28(16) 266.19(17) 292.90(3) 297.85(20)
Fl x4 F4 x2 F7 x2 F2 x4
256.62(16) 265.54(16) 294.72(4) 309.70(20)
Mgl
Fl x4 195.35(9) F6 198.47(18)
F7 225.81(21) Mg2
F4 x2 191.98(14) F3 x2 195.90(14)
F2 x2 205.15(16)
Mg3
F5 x2 195.80(13)
F3 x2 198.08(11)
F6 x2 199.22(12) Mg4
F7 x2 195.18(19)
F2 x2 198.28(15)
F2 x2 198.28(15)
rounding
fluoride ions than the Ba ion(d(Ba-Fl)
=266.2(2) pm).This
is illustrated inFig.
3.A similar
approach
was made forB%7g(3)Euo.22(3)MgF4,
where a distance of
16.3(8)
pm between thefractionnally occupied
Ba and Eu sites was obtained. As a conse-quence, the interatomic distances between Ba to F and Eu
to F show some differences. The values of the shortest Eu-F distances are smaller than the Ba-F distances with
250.1(6)[Eu-F3]
pm and257.68(21 )[Eu-F2]
pmcompared
to
264.0(5)[Ba-F3]
pm and 258.71(22)[Ba-F2]
pm inBao.7S(3)EU().22(3)MgF4.
Conclusions
In both
compounds (BaMgF4
andBa(,Mg7F26)
the substitu-tion of Ba
by
Sr or Eu shows a similar behaviour whichcan be associated with the similar ionic radius of
Sr(II)
and
Eu(II).
The
split
refinement of Ba and Eu in both titlecrystals
reveals the formation of shorter bonds between
Eu(II)
andthe nearest fluoride
neighbors.
The concomitant increase of thelongest
Eu-F bondlength
illustrates the trend in- ducedby
the smaller ion to reduce the coordination num- ber ofthe local metal-fluoride cluster. The fact that the Ba site inBa6Mg7F26 preferentially
substitutedby
Sror Eu isthe one with the smaller coordination number underlines this
tendency.
Further
spectroscopic
measurements on rare earthdoped (or substituted)
bariummagnesium
fluorides are inprogress.
Acknowledgment.
This workwassupported by
the Swisspriority
pro-ject "Optique".
References
[1]
Rey,
J. M.; Bill, H.;Lovy,
D.;Hagemann,
H:Europium doped BaMgF4,
an EPR andoptical investigation. J.Alloys Comp. 268(1998)60-65.
[2] Keve, E. T; Abrahams S. C; Bernstein, I. L.:
Crystal
structureof
pyroelectric paramagnetic
barium manganese fluoride. J.Chem. Phys.51 (1969)4928-4936.
[3] Von
Schnering.
H.G.: Kristallstrukturen der Bariumfluorometal- late(ll) BaiMFf, mit M=Zn. Cu. Ni, Co, Fe. Z.Anorg. Allg.
Chem. 353(1967) 13-25.
[4] Renaudin,J.:Samouël,M.;LeblancM.;deKozak, A.;Ferey,G.:
Crystal
structure ofBa(,Zn7F2<;. J. Solid State Chem. 59 (1985) 103-110.|5|
Gingl,
F: BaMgF4 andBaiMgjFio:
newexamples
for structuralrelationships
betweenhydrides
and fluorides. Z. Anorg.Allg.
Chem. 623(1997) 705-709.
|6j Kübel. F.; Hagemann, H.; Bill, H.:
Synthesis
and structure ofBa6Mg7F2„.
Z.Anorg. Allg.
Chem. 623 (1997)573-578.|7] Banks. E.;. Srivastava, A. M.: Concentration and temperature
dependence
of divalenteuropium
line emission inBaMgF4.
J.Electrochem. Soc. 134(1987) 1568-1570.
[81 Kübel, F.;
Hagemann,
H.; Bill, H.:Synthesis, crystal
structuresand
spectroscopic investigations
onsamarium-doped
mixedBai_(>Sr,>MgF4 crystals.
Mat. Res. Bull. 32(1997)263-269.[9| Banks, E.;
Nakajima,
S.; Shone, M.: Newcomplex
fluoridesEuMgF4, SmMgF4
andSrMgF4, and their solid solutions: photo-luminescence and energy transfer. J. Electrochem. Soc. 127
(1980)2234-2237.
[10] Kübel, F.; Hagemann, H.; Bill, H.: Mixed Ba,24Sr() 76Mg7F26.
Acta
Crystallogr.
C53(1997) 1735-1738.[11] Lapasset, J.; Bordallo, H. N.; Almairac, R.; Nouet. J.: Redeter- mination of the crystal structure of barium tetrafluorozincate, BaZnF4,at295 and 113K. Z.
Kristallogr.
211(1996)934-935.[12] Almairac, R.: Bordallo, H. N.; Bulou, A.; Nouet, J.; Currat, R.:
Slow
dynamics
andinstability
in BaZnF4.Phys.
Rev. B55 (1997)8249-8256.[13] Bordallo, H. N.; Bulou, A.; Almairac, R.; Nouet, J.: Anomalies in the Raman
scattering
spectraofpiezoelectric
BaZnF4crystals.J.
Phys.
Cond. Matter 6 (1994) 10365-10376.[14] Gelato,L. M.; Parthé, E.: STRUCTURETIDY: acomputerpro- gram to standardize
crystal
structure data. J.Appl. Crystallogr.
20 (1987) 139-143.
Brought to you by | Université de Genève - Bibliothèque de Genève