• Aucun résultat trouvé

Review Form

N/A
N/A
Protected

Academic year: 2022

Partager "Review Form"

Copied!
1
0
0

Texte intégral

(1)

Review Form

Reviewer (it will remain anonymus to the writer(s):

Paper title:

Author(s): Anonymous for the reviewer Referee’s comments:

1. Title of the article: Is it adequate for the content of the article?

2. Abstract: Does it contain the essential information of the article? Is it complete?

3. Keywords: Do they contain the essential information of the article? Are they complete?

4. Diagrams, photos, archival documents, figures, tables and captions: Are they essential and clear?

5. Scientific merit: rigor, accuracy and correctness 6. Clarity of expression: communication of ideas;

readability and discussion of concepts

7. Discussion of the context of the work, and suitable referencing

8. Originality: Is the work relevant and novel?

9. Motivation: Does the problem considered have a sound motivation? All papers should clearly

demonstrate the scientific interest of the results.

10. Length: Is the content of the work of sufficient scientific interest to justify its length?

11. Conclusion: Does the paper contain a carefully written conclusion, summarizing what has been

learned and why it is interesting and useful?

12. Other suggestions:

Références

Documents relatifs

While most of the Minnesota collection is also available on the Internet, documents from the British American Tobacco Company stored in England are not, except for a small subset

2001)---145 F IGURE 3: P REVALENCE RATES BY AGE ACCORDING TO DIFFERENT SCENARIOS , FOR B ELGIUM IN 2050 ---152 F IGURE 4: P ROJECTIONS OF DEPENDENCY PREVALENCE RATES AT

The New Zealand Immigration and Protection Tribunal made a point of saying that the effects of climate change were not the reason for granting residency to the family, but

Table 01: Sum-up of teaching and testing English process from the middle schools up to high schools at Biskra University………...47 Table 02: The approaches to test English

Table 40: Recapitulation of interlingual Vs in trilingual errors Table 41: Types of errors in grammar suggested by teachers Table 42: Reasons of making errors in grammar. Table

Several potential drivers are suspected to connect climate change to ecosystems, virus transmission to Human and heath care policies : - reservoir species (i.e. bats) and

Low-income countries must reinforce their health systems to detect infectious disease and control outbreaks, by adapting their sanitary strategy and policy to climate change.. Indeed,

First, if one takes as a baseline the performance of the original network of Advanced detectors – LIGO Hanford with two full-size interferometers, LIGO Livingston, and VIRGO –