Lightpath assignment for multifibers wdm optical networks with wavelength translators

Texte intégral

(1)Lightpath assignment for multifibers wdm optical networks with wavelength translators David Coudert, Hervé Rivano. To cite this version: David Coudert, Hervé Rivano. Lightpath assignment for multifibers wdm optical networks with wavelength translators. RR-4487, INRIA. 2002. �inria-00072101�. HAL Id: inria-00072101 https://hal.inria.fr/inria-00072101 Submitted on 23 May 2006. HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access archive for the deposit and dissemination of scientific research documents, whether they are published or not. The documents may come from teaching and research institutions in France or abroad, or from public or private research centers.. L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non, émanant des établissements d’enseignement et de recherche français ou étrangers, des laboratoires publics ou privés..

(2) INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE. Lightpath assignment for multifibers wdm optical networks with wavelength translators David Coudert — Hervé Rivano. N° 4487 – version 2 version initiale Juin 2002 – version révisée Aout 2003 THÈME 1. ISSN 0249-6399. apport de recherche.

(3)

(4)

(5) !#"%$&' )(+*% ,!-. /.0( 123( 4( 5/

(6) 6 7

(7) 8%9;:<>=@?BADC!= EGFIHKJ;LNM/EOFI:DPRQ,<>:S9UT!ADV WYX0Z\[2]2^`_ba'cIde]Ifhgji7]kldemjdnkoZ\[2]Id prqosutn]klvxw`y0z'{`W'W'| afh}~}Ushqek'~]qe] X~]\q X~]@U O O;O]\q dsh%O_bO]\q dsh/~kefu]hg~xuOO_bh]Iqodesh7qoc\;dcI] wlshgjkhhh/^}0fhh]Id / I\ ~¡hh¢¤£ ]2\sh0dej]\qkeX~]2}~qosh¥0]I[¦su§©¨S0j~xf7OXGke}0fukeXRfOdedeh~[2]\Gk`§ªshqf/hh]\Rd]\k

(8) sh§ \sh[2[g0~IfkosO qo]I«Gg~]dnk dYsh¬f2[g~®ko®¨S¥S]Iql¯,°±²sO}jke\fh³~]\kn´µsOqe¶,´'keXxÝfKh]I]I~ukoX7koqofh0defukeshq dI· ¸ h]IdgS Xf'~]kn´.shqo¶D¹Ifh0

(9) ºkeX0]©;g~[¥U]\q su§jÝfKh]\]\0ukeXSd»fKKfhfu¥0]rsO]Ifh X`¨0¥U]\q¹u¼`keX0]N;g~[¥U]\q sh§¨0¥U]\q'}U]\q'~¶7fuS7½lkeX~];g~[¥S]Iq.sh§ }0fhqkofhD´.fKO]\]\~hkeX,koqofh0defukesh7fKfufu¥~]sO/]fh X/~sjj]h¹ sOg~q }~qesO¥~]\[@dnk fu00d§ªsOq ~]Ij~`´'X~]koX~]\q!k!d }SsGdede¥0]µkes¨00flº'¾ ¿ÁÀ®ÂuÃOÄÅjÆuÄ>Ã'§ªsOq ]fh Xqo]I«Gg~]dnk! koX~]lde]kYdg0 X2koX0fk©keX~]Iqe]dN0s~¶2\fhqeqom;~[2sOqe]YkoX0fk'¼BhXGke}SfkeXSdNg0de0

(10) keX~]`defh[B]l´.fKO]\]\~hkeX 0shqN~sjj]l´'X~]\qo]'[2shqo]YkeX0fh,½Y´.fKO]\]\~hkeXkeq fu0defukesh0drkofu¶O]'}~fh]O·r{g0qN[fu2keX~]Ishqo]ke\fh~qo]Ideg~®k dkoX~]¬´'qo®ko0Çsu§

(11) keX0d7}~qesO¥~]\[Èfhd,f}Sfuqekeg~fuq,0dkofh0]¬sh§Gke]Ihq fu'[g~®ko\sh[2[2sjj®knmÊÉ0s´¹ X0]\0\]Gko]\hq fko0Bqoshg~ke~,fu0%ÝfKh]I]I~ukoX fOdedeh~[2]\GkxkeX0]defh[2][Bsjj]IË· £ ]koX~]\x}~qos;~] koX~qo]\]lX0]\g~qodke\dµ[fu~mB¥Sfhde]Ig~}Ush7qofh0jsh[2Ì\]2qesOg~0j~sh§»§ªqofO#kosO0fuS[g~kesO[B[2sjjknm2É0s´ fh0R]\~X0fh0]I[2]\Gkod`koX0fkfuqo]keX~qo]\]jÍU]Iqe]IGkfu0de´µ]Iqodlkes koX~]2keq fhj]\¾ÎshÍ¥S]\kn´µ]I]\Ï]Ð,]\0\m&fuS koOXGke~]ded©su§³fu}~}0qesKij[2fukeshfuSjdogSdedNkeX~]Iq.}~q fh#koIfu~}U]\qe§ªshqo[fu0\]IdrsO,¥UsukeX,keX~]Ishqo]ke\fh0fuS qo]Ifh®¾Ñ´.shqo0dkofh0]d\· ÒxÓGÔDÕoÖ× Ø h¢ v%g~ke¨0¥U]\qsO}jke\fh 0]kn´.shqo¶;dI¹D¯,°±¹~]kn´.shqo¶xj]IdeO³¹»ÝfKh]\]\0ukeX¬keq fu0defukesh³¹ [g~kesh[2[2sjjknmÉ0s´¹jq fu0jsO[2ÌI]I/qesOg~0j~0¹jX0]\g~qodkeu·. ÙµñNÚSò Û>Ü ÝËÞß ànÜ#á'á.âKãäåhæhçèKéÁåhæhéëêGèKìOåhçêíUêOçäîhïïuð øOíDé®èKé®çnðúûKÛ>Ü Ý>ÞßNíUêOçnäîOïïuð ü!ý þ'æêOÿ åOäß ð`Ü#ã ó©ðIKô#Þ ðäîGâIíRßÎÞnõ©âKÛ ö' ÷ù á ã \â ãßÎÞ ã ÿ ÞnÛ Ü#ã

(12) Ü#Û ã ÿ Þ . . . . . . . .

(13). . . . Unité de recherche INRIA Sophia Antipolis 2004, route des Lucioles, BP 93, 06902 Sophia Antipolis Cedex (France) Téléphone : +33 4 92 38 77 77 — Télécopie : +33 4 92 38 77 65.

(14) , 7 / * /+' '' b(+* !#"%$/ ' 5'-.5' I ¢ shgSdlsO0dejcIqesO0dY]}~qosh¥~Z\[2]jgxqoshg~kofuO]sh}jko«Gg~] g0¬]\0de]\[¥~]jsh~0cj]qo]¾

(15) «Gg\ke]d.~]

(16) \sh[2[g0~IfkosO0dµ0fu0d.g~ qecd]fug,¯,° ± [g~®ko®¨S¥~qe]d'fKh]lsO;h]\q desO}0fuqeke]\]O· !kofhOk ~sh~~c`g~7ke]\»qocIde]Ifhg,jd}UsOdofuGk'j]º sh~Og~]\g~q d. sO0j]`}0fuqµ¨0¥~qo]h¹~¼¨0¥~qo]Id.}0fuq.]I/]\kY½sh;O]\qe¾ desh0d©}SsGdede¥0]dN}0fhq© g0~g,qecd]fug³¹G]}~qosh¥~Z\[2]qo]\;]\Gk ~cIj]Iqµd S]dnkµ}SsGdede¥0]`j]koqesOg~h]Iq g0/ X~]I[B,º'¾sOsOqecl}SsOg~q' X0fh«Gg~]qo]I«Gg \ke]O¹;~]deshqeke]«Gg fug7}~gSdµº X~]\[20dµgjkede]\Gk.g0~][ I[B] sh0hg~]Ig~q sO0j]Ydg~q!g~B[ \[2]Y]\2jgqecd]fug]\k!«Gg fugSg~B g0 sO}SZIqe].}~g0drj]Y½µ\sh;h]Iqodesh0dI· sukoqe]qecdg~kofuk}~qo0}0fu!qocIde~]~fh0dl cIqokeg~qo]j]2]B}~qosh¥~Z\[2]BdsOg0dlf7§ªshqo[B]B g~~]B0dkofh0] }Sfuqekeg~ZIqe]` g~7[g~®ko®ÉSsukY]\Gke]\q¹;GkecIhq fuGk.0fu0dµg~ [ I[2][2sjjZ\]`]`qesOgjkofhh]]\k. fÍD]I#k fkosO ~]sh~Og~]\g0qod

(17) sh0~]h· shg0d§ªshg0qe~dodsO0dl]I0deg~®ko]BkeqoshdX0]\g~qodke«Gg~]Id`¥0fOdcI]Id`dg0q` fuqoqesO0j!fucIf¾ koshqe]%j] [g~keÉ0shkod§ªqofO#kosO~0fuqo]IdI¹N«Og0dsOOkBkeqoshdqecI}SsO0d]d~®ÍDc\qo]\Gke]d2fug sh[2}~qosh[2d]\Ð,\f¾ \®koc }~qecdsh j]dfu}~}~qosKij[fukesh0dI· sOg0d]Idfujsh0d

(18) ]Ish[2}0fhqofhGk

(19) ]\g0q}S]Iq§ªsOqe[fh0]d`deg~q ~]IdY0dnk fu0\]Id.koX~c\sOqe«Gg~]IdY]\kl fhgjkeqo]IdI¹;dodeg~]Id'jg%[2shSj]qecI]\Î· ¡ %¢ a'cd]fugji sh}jko«Gg~]d\¹0¯° ±¹Dj[B]I0desO~~]\[2]IOk¹0[g~®ko®ÉSsukI¹S[g~ke¨0¥~qo]h¹UsOGO]\q dsh¹ )× Õ ! fhqeqoshSj»fucIfkoshqe]O¹;X~]\g~qodnko«Gg~]O·.

(20) rÀ®ÂÃGÄ®Å~ÆÄËÃ¬Æ#À®Â 0Ä

(21) j¿ÁÄÎÀ ÅUÄËÀ Æu¿

(22) \Ä !"rÀ ÄËÃ#©Æ$\¿% GÂhÄ>Ã%Ä eÆ& ¿ÆÄ' (. ). . *%7-© . *,+-*. .0/21. 3,42576-8:9<;>=&3?@576-A2B. *,+ON. .P9RQS;-SATB,5VUW5V=79<A2XY;-9Z576-3A. *,+Ok. l\3,9</H1m9J4. £ Kf h]I]I~ukoXDC;dshÇv%g0®ko}~]ij~FEª¯,°±HG`dg~qoqe]IGkem%keX~][2sOdk}~qosh[2de~/]\ijdke~%sh}jkoIfu 0]kn´.shqo¶ko]I X~0shshhmO¹Gde0]`®kfhs´dr§ªsOq.]\Ð,]\Gk'g0d]`su§keX~]

(23) X~hX/¥0fu0~´';koX/shÍU]Iqe]¥;msh}jkoIfu 0]kn´.shqo¶;dI·JI0j]Iq'¯,°±¹0fOd]Iq.¥U]Ifh[d'\fuqoqo],sh%jÍU]Iqe]IGk´.fKO]\]\~hkeX0d.fuqo]

(24) g0d],kos2[2}~]\[2]\Gk ¨0i;]]\S;¾Ëkosu¾Ñ]\0\sh~0]I#kosO0d_ Ifu] hXGke}SfkeXSdkeX0d2sOGke]i;k_ ÇkeX0]7~]\kn´µsOqe¶D·&WYX~] [futnshqsO0dkeq fuOk[2}SsGd] ¥Gm&keX~dko]I X~0shshhm&d

(25) koX0fkBj®ÍD]\qo]\GkOXGke}0fukeX0dIfu~0sukdeX0fuqo]2keX~] dofu[2]

(26) ÝfKh]\]\0ukeX/sh]Iq©koX~]defh[2]¨S¥S]IqI· WYX~dBshSdnkoqofhGk]IfO~dkos&[2®ij]qesOgjke~&fh0Ç\shshqo~xdodg~]d\·RWYX~]\qo]§ªsOqe]koX~]/Ifu}0fOknmRsh§ ]fh X/¨0¥U]\q%ke]Iqe[dYsu§!ÝfKh]\]\0ukeXSdµ[fKm/¥S]jq fu[fuke\fum,g~0j]Iq¾Ñ]ij}~shke]»·NW s,sh}U]´'keX%keX0d koX~]\sOqe]\ke\fh0[2kofkosO,sh2koX~]`]Ð,]\0\msh§µ¯,°± sh}jkoIfuS~]kn´.shqo¶jd\¹hkn´µs[futnshqNko]I X~0shshh]Id©fuqo] ~]\}~smh]/´'X0 XxOO][BsOqe]

(27) ÉS]ij¥0®knm%%keX~]g0de]su§rÝfKh]\]\0ukeX X~]I0][2}~qosG~2koX~]~]\kn´µsOqe¶ ]\Ð,]\0\mh· WYX~]¬¨0qodk/\sh0dedkod, }0XGmjdeIfum Gko]\q sh0~]Ike~ kn´µs0s;~]Id,sh§

(28) keX~]¬0]kn´.shqo¶ ´'keX [fu;m ¨S¥S]IqodI·WYX~d`dnkoqofuke]\Om7dfhdes,[2sukofuke]I¬¥Gm koX~]sO]\qo´'X~]\[2~,\sOdklsu§rkoqe]I0 Xj¾jhh~2kos7¥~g~qom koX~]Ïsh}jkoIfu¨0¥S]Iqod sO[2}0fuqo]IÊkos koX~]RfO#kegSfu

(29) sOdk/sh§f¨S¥S]IqI· WYX~]Iqe]\§ªshqo]xke]I]sh[2[g~~\fkosO sO}S]IqofukesOqodµqofukeX~]Iq'Sdnk fu< Kj¿ÁÄÎÀ L:Ä !"#· WYX~]&sukeX0]\qko]I X~~«Gg~]¬0qo]IfOd]dBkeX~]ÏsO[B}0]\i;knm sh§~sjj]Idqoshg~ke]\q d¥;m fO~j~M ©Æ $\%¿ GÂhÄ>Ã Ä eÆ 7#¿ÆÄÎÀ ]«Gg~}0[B]IGkI· YW X0]BgSd]Bsu§Yf7ÝfKh]I]I~ukoXxkeq fu0defkesOq f7¯,°± ~]\kn´µsOqe¶xfhs´dkes% X0fu~O]koX~]2´.fKO]\]\~hkeX¬sh§ fhSsh[2~&sO}jke\fh©¥U]Ifh[ kosRfh~sukoX~]\qÝfKh]I]I~ukoX³·¬WYX~]/´.fKO]\]\~hkeXÏkeq fu0defkeshXSfKh],¥U]\]I ]\i;ke]\Sdh]Imxdkeg0j]I&shÏj®ÍD]\qo]\Gk

(30) [2s;~]\d`fh0¬XSfhd`¥S]I]\R}~qesO]I%koX0fk`kes%jq fu[fkoIfum [B}0qesO] koX~]7]\Ð,]\0\mRsh§sh}jkoIfu©¥Sfu0j´';koX fusjIfkesh\ [ al^v ]O~¹ y~wVy ]_]~¹!wlz a¸ ` ~û¹!Yy bO cÑe· ds´.]\O]\q¹ ÝfKh]I]I~ukoX7koqofh0defukesh df2h]\qom,]\i;}U]\Sdh]

(31) ko]I X~~sOsOhm fu0 kldl~sukqo]Ifhdke`kes7fOdedeg~[2]

(32) §ªg~®¾ koqofh0defukesh/Ifu}0fh¥~ke]Id.kos2fh~sjj]IdYsh§ koX~]~]kn´.shqo¶D· WYX~]Iqe]\§ªshqo]h¹Okn´µs}~qe]Ifu]\Gk.fh}~}~qosOfh X0]IdNfhqe]lfO~jqo]Idod]2,keX~]`ke]Iqofukeg~qo]l\sh0\]\qo~0¯,°± sh}j¾ koIfur~]\kn´µsOqe¶jd`´'keXÏ´.fKO]\]\~hkeX¬koqofh0defukeshg f

(33) d}Sfuq d]keq fu0defkeshÏfu0R[2ke]IRkoqofh0dfkosO³· h f&~]kn´.shqo¶Ï´'®koXÊde}0fuq de],´.fKO]\]\~hkeX koqofh0dfkosO³¹Nfx§ªq fhkeshÇsh§keX0]/~sjj]dfhqe]/]I«Gg~}~}U]IÇ´'keX ÝfKh]I]I~ukoX2keq fu0defkesOqodrkeX0fukYfhqe]`fu¥~]kos}U]\qe§ªshqo[ fu/fhqe¥0®koqofhqemGg0[¥U]\qYsu§de[g~kofu0]\shgSdNkoqofh0dn¾ fkosO0d [ëyjw`Vy ]i]c j»sOxkeX~]BsukoX~]\q`X0fh0¬f,0]kn´.shqo¶/´'keXR[2®ko]Ixkoqofh0defukeshxOko]\q sO~~]Ikodl~sjj]Id ´'X0 X%X~sGdnk'ÝfKh]\]\0ukeX7keq fu0defkesOqodI¹;¥~gjkkoX~]Ide]j]IG]d'\fh/sO~m/}S]Iq§ªsOqe[f2[2®ko]I ;g~[¥U]\qsh§ koqofh0defukesh0Ld [ wlz a¸ ` ~û¹SVy bh cÎ· WYX0d©´µsOqe¶Bfh~jqo]Idode]Id!koX~]lsO}jke[2Ìfkeshsh§DkeX~]`j]IdeOsu§»[g0®ko®¨0¥U]\q.¯,°± sh}jkoIfu00]kn´.shqo¶;d!´'keX [Bke] ´.fKO]\]\~hkeX,koqofh0defukeshDEÎ±HnZoRpRG#·©y;0\]koX~d'd'fB[g~®ko®¾qoke]\qofsO}jke[2Ìfkesh }~qosh¥~]\[%¹ ´.]X0fh0j]klkoX~qesOg~hX%koX~]dkegSjm%su§!keX~]Bfhdodsj\fuke]Ix~]IdesOx}~qesO¥~]\[ su§NOXOko}0fkoX¬fhdodh0[B]IGk. qZq. ãr7stsuv.

(34) . , &i #Ä À $KÆ

(35) . E

(36) 7G#¹l~]¨0~] ùy;]#kesh j· y;]#kosO Çd,koX~]R~]Ij\fuke]I kesÇkoX~]&´'qoke~ sh§keX~]

(37) fhd7f [g~kesh[2[2sjjknm É0s´ sh§qe]fhdesh0fh¥~]xdeÌI]R\sh[2}0fuqo]I kosÇ}~qo]\;sOg0d,´.shqo¶ [ yj0^tc`fh®koX~shg~OX ´µ] Ifu}jkog~qo]/[2shqo]7O]\~]Iqe7dekeg0fukesh0dI· £ ]/koX~]\ }~qosh}UsOde]7koX~qe]I]/X0]\g~qodke\d2fhOshqo®koX~[d y;]#kosO S·WYX0]Ide]&X~]Ig~qedke\d fuqo]¬¥0fhde]I sh eÆ

(38) _ BÀ V

(39) uÀ GÂ&su§koX~]&[g~®ko\sh[2[2sjj®knm ÉSs´

(40) G¾ qo]\fi~fukesh³¹\fuk jÍU]Iqe]IGk³}SsGdkesh0d`koX~]rkeq fh~]¾ÑsuÍ¥U]kn´.]\]I

(41) \sh[2}~gjk fkosO0fuu]\Ð,]\0\mfuS«OgSfu®knm sh§fu}~}~qosKij[fukesh j]\}U]\0~~ sh X~s´ Sj]\}U]\0~]\GkemÊkeX~]RKfhqefu¥0]dfuqo]xqesOg~0j]»· £ ]xkoX~]\ fh~fko]©koX~]Ide].X~]\g~qodnkoId2yj]I#kosOB¥Gm\sh[2}0fhqe~koX~]\[ fu0

(42) koX~]Y]i~fhk

(43) sOkn´.skoX~]\sOqe]\ke\fu fh0/sh~]

(44) fuqoh]`qe]fu¾Î´.shqo7]i~fu[2}~]h·. . /# #"%$&' \ /

(45) !¦ Ï( ¦( 5\7

(46) !¦ /.

(47) ! zµsO~~]#keshSdlRf7¯° ±0]kn´.shqo¶%fhqe]qe]fuÌI]I%¥;mxfhde]\q`¥S]fu[dIfuqoqe]I¬sh¬sO~]fKfufu¥~]ÝfKh]\¾ ]\0ukeX·%w3¥S]fu[ qe]fh X~~xf%~sjj]koX~qesOg~hXf%¨S¥S]Iq\fh ¥S],sO}jke\fhm fu0Ï}0fOdedeO]\mRj]\É0]Ike] ¥;m/keX~]qosOdodn¾sO~~]Ike]IqYfh0%}~qosh}0fhOfuke]Id.kos´.fhqo fu0sukeX0]\q~sjj]keX~qoshg~OXxfu~shkeX~]Iq¨0¥U]\q´'®koX~shgjk XSfu~O~

(48) kodrÝfKh]I]I~ukoX³· wl®ko]\qo0fkoO]\mkoX~]'¥S]fu[ \fhB¥U] ©Æ $\%¿ GÂhÄ>Ã2OÄ oÆ 7#¿ÆuÄ "!Y¥;mfh;m¶;S sh§ sO}jke\fh»shq'sh}~kesu¾Ñ]\]Ikeqosh~\fhS[2]fu [ #%$Dp ` O c¥U]§ªshqo]

(49) ¥S]I0qe]\keq fu0de[2®k'sh/keX0]]\hqo]Idodµ¨0¥U]\q· WYX~]

(50) de]kµsh§³¥S]fu[ qo]IfhÌ\~fsh0~]Ikesh,dµIfu],f,¿®À®ÂÃGÄ®Å~ÆÄËÃfu0,f%º &¿ÁÀ®ÂuÃOÄÅjÆuÄ>Ã§k.g0de]Id.fk [2sGdnk'º²´.fKO]\]\~hkeX0dI· ' Ó (*)+ +ª,× )./]1k 0.243 57698;:N¥S]fB~]kn´.shqo¶D¹Oº@fB;g~[¥U]\qYsh§ ÝfKh]\]\0ukeXSd\¹;fu0= <>6@?BAC5)kn´µsB~sjj]IdYsh*§ 0B· w)º'¾ÎhXGke}0fukeXxshD§ 0 §ªqoshE [ <¬koBs ?/dlfde]I«Gg~]I0G] F sh§NI½ HCJLK}0fuq Md 3NPOQ6Rº O@: OTSUQV´'X~]\qoW] NXO©d f,}0fkoX¬Y 0 dgS X%keX0fuk NXZdnk fuqekodf[k < \¹ NPUQV ]I0~d`f1k ?U¹»fu0^ ],_RAa`bKcdcdc I½ HeÑf¹ NXOµdnk fuqekod´'X0]\qo1] NXOTg h dkesO}0dI· ]_"6µRº OrdYkeX0]´.fKO]\]\~hkeX7Ifuqoqem;~koX~]¥U]Ifu[ j]Idoqo¥~0i NPO· £ ]dofKm7koX0fik F d ©Æ $%¿ GÂhÄËÃ¬OÄ eÆ 7#¿ÆuÄ j! E>shq¹SdeX~shqekemh¹Skeq fu0defke]& G'fukl]IfO Xx~sjj]´'X~]Iqe]f NPOrdnkosh}0ad ET_7kÊI½ H<G#,· dl]\0\]I½ HÇdY]\ijfO#komkoX~];g~[¥U]\q'sh§ ÝfKh]I]I~ukoX,koqofh0dfkosO0dYjsh0]`sOl F2· WYX~]hXGko}0fkoX2fOdedeh~[2]\Gk©}0qesO¥~]IW [ E

(51) &GN\fh2¥S]`dnk fke]fhdN§ªshs´d fOO]\f~]\kn´µsOqe¶D¹hfde]k hs §0sO[B[g~~\fukeshqo]I«Gg~]IdkodI¹fu0fhh]Ifu[2shg0Ok su§~qo]Ideshg~q ]d,EªÝfKh]I]I~ukoX0dI¹\¨0¥U]\q dI¹´.fKO]\]\~hkeX koqofh0defukeshq dG#¹~¨S0&f7hXGke}SfkeX¬§ªshql]fh X¬qo]I«Gg~]dnk`g~0j]IqlkoX~]\sh0dkeq fuGklkoX0fk`sh~m%sh~]}0fkoX&\fh gSd]fBhh]I/ÝfKh]I]I~ukoX7sh%fBhh]I7¨0¥U]\q· C]\}U]\0~~`shkeX~]µ´.fKm`qe]dsOg~q ]Idfuqo]Nfh\\shg~Gko]I»¹keX0]µfhdodes;\fuke]j]I\desO}~qosh¥~]\[²d´'qo®keke]I ~®ÍD]\qo]\Gkemh· ' Ó (*)+ +ª,× )nmpo@q7+srt I u j t ~ +Tr,)

(52) fÓ ) u × Ó

(53) wv xy) u ³O¢ w~]\kn´µsOqez ¶ 0{2E3|5D6j8}:e¹ f/de]ksu§YsO[B[g~~\fukesh&qo]I«Gg~]dnk id ~S¹f ;g~[¥S]Iq`sh§µÝfKh]\¾ ]\0ukeXÏº¹!f/§ªg~0#kosOÇ¼ 8D %O;~7koX~];g~[¥U]\qsh§µ¨S¥S]Iqod

(54) sOÏfhGm&~¶¬sh§ 0B¹!fu0 E>f Gf §ªg00#kosO%½ \5ùh;0koX~];g~[¥S]Iq'su§ keq fu0defukesh0d'fKfhfu¥~]fklfhGm7~sjj]suD§ 0 shq Eª

(55) ¥ G.keX~] [fui;[g0[3;g~[¥U]\q'sh§ koqofh0dfkosO0dYfKfufh¥~]`C 0B¹S½ R~· ³ u h¢ C]I\j]B§©®k

(56) d}UsOdode¥~]kos,¨0S»¹D§ªshq`]IfO w X 3T6@,:1A~S¹»f7º'¾ÎhXGke}0fukeX&§ªqesO [ Ïkos deg0 X/keX0fuk s q ý.



(59) \Ä !"rÀ ÄËÃ#©Æ$\¿% GÂhÄ>Ã%Ä eÆ& ¿ÆÄ' . . ^h·l{xfu;m~¶%A^8¹0fk[2sGdnkl¼3:NhXGke}0fukeX0dYgSd]`keX0]defh[B]

(60) ÝfKh]I]I~ukoXgf ],_"6 ]6 F3 6@_j:

(61) ¼ 3 : j ja· E>f G~sOqfhGm ~sjj%] <A 5,¹UkeX~];g~[¥S]Iqsh§r´.fKO]\]\~hkeX keq fu0defkeshSd'X0fu}0}S]I~07fki<&dlfk [2sOdkl½ 3 : j shq Eª ¥ GWYX~]`kesuk fu³;g~[¥S]Iq'su§ ´.fKO]\]\~hkeX,koqofh0defukesh0d E H I½ H<G.d'fk'[2sOdkl½ R~· WYX~l]

(62) RX0fOd¥U]\]\]\i;ke]\Sdh]ImÏdnkog0j]I shde0h]¾Î¨0¥S]Iq~]\kn´µsOqe¶jd E ]6¼3 :i2 KG

(63) ´'keXshq ´'keX0shgjk ´.fKO]\]\~hkeX keq fuSdfkosOg[ av^]h;¹'yjwy7]i]~¹yj0û¹YyVbhcÎ¹¥~gjk%X0fhd7~suk% keX~] \fOd]¬sh§ [g~ke¨0¥S]Iq7~]\kn´µsOqe¶jd2´'X~]Iqe]¬keX~] ©Æ$\¿% GÂhÄ>Ã Æ#À®Âi& SÄlÅ

(64) _¿% fOd¥S]I]\ [fh~m fO~jqo]Idod] [ëv¬yjOjX ¹ / yjhj¹ !pNa ` ~û¹Sa'j0^tcÎ· mT-: oVÃ j%¿ Æ !&ÄËÃ;ÆuÄÆ/%º &¿ÁÀ®ÂuÃOÄÅjÆuÄ>Ã Æ ¿ %¿ 3Æ

(65) P& #À lÅU%¿ ÅjÆuÄ>ÃÇÀ ÄËÃY /Ó

(66) j :Ä !# $À ÄËY Ã Æ !VÃ 2Ä>VÃ RNXOµÅ~ÆÄËiÃ Æ #À ÅS%¿ À 7#ÄÆ :WNXOa Æ &Â e_Æ t!%Æ%¿ GÂ ÆÅjÆ #LÄ - RNXOTg h VÑ

(67) Å #À #À GÂh¿ &^Æ : X& #À ÅS%¿ Å~ÆÄËDÃ Æ D

(68) Å~Æ #aÄ ,Æ ÅUÄËÀ Æ,¿ u¿ jÄÎÀ - %

(69) ÄËYÃ hÂÃ À ÄµÀ Æ Ï_Æ ttV ! \Ä !VÃ D©Æ $¿ ;ÂuÄËÃ Ä eÆ 7#¿ÆÄÎÀ RÀ a

(70) ÄYÆ $ÆÀ ¿Æ #¿ I "

(71) iB%¿ \<Ä YTtKÅh7Å

(72) ÄËÃ;Æu<Ä Æ `À xÄËYÃ $#n&Æ % Æ 0À ÄÎÀ '(2Æ 'ÂuÀ $&Æ V:ÄÎÀ ½ 5{ WKÅh7Å V

(73) À ;Â%ÄËYÃ ,Æ jÄ>VÃ #À " &V ©Æ $\%¿ ;ÂuÄËÃ&Ä eÆ &#¿ÆÄÎÀ &2ÆLÄ o_Æ #DÃ

(74) "i } "xÄ>ÃGÀ >oÆ µÆ`Å~ÆÄË^ Ã \OÄ ;<ÊÆ

(75) ?D2)Æ _Â 2ÄË_Ã hÂuÃ% Æ : _R !VÃ À <Ä VÃ j%¿ OÄ oÆ 7#¿ÆuÄ " Æ¿ ¿UOÄ oÆ 7#¿ÆuÄËÀ 7lÆ,Ä Æ

(76) Æ¿ iÆ >Y ÄËYÃ :H Æ +*ëÅUÀ t! &'K-Å ,YÆÄ eÆ &#¿ÆÄÎÀ %ÆÄrÆ

(77) uÄ>VÃ 2

(78) "i .2 ¿ ¿ rÀ GÂxÆÅ~ÆÄËÃ 'Ä % Y#À GÂ7Ä>VÃ K #À®ÂuÀ DÆ¿ ©Æ $¿ ;ÂuÄËÃº h ©ÄËYÃ OÄ eÆ 7#¿ÆuÄ T º h 'Ä

(79) 0º //ÆuÄ Æ

(80) 2,DÆ¿ ¿ @ ¿ ¿ rÀ GÂxÆ

(81) ÅjÆuÄ>HÃ &'Ä rÀ ÄËÃ7ÄËYÃ a©Æ $\%¿ GÂhÄ>ÃB0º / rÄËYÃ attj¿ÁÄÎÀ GÂ ¿®À®ÂÃGÄ®Å~ÆÄËÃ ¿ !À ;Â7¿®À !G3T<^ = 6º h :j6 3} l ?P6e1º /:" K:L: P& À ÅS¿ .ÅjÆuÄ>_Ã HÆ Æ $KÆu¿ÁÀ K ¿ jÄÎÀ ^!VÃ e

(82) `Ä #À tl'Ä BÀ 0À BÀ Ä>VÃ L23Æ 2hÀ Æ¿ lÅU%¿ 2OÀ Ä

(83) Æ

(84) "i# Æ #n&Æ % R0À ÄÎÀ 4'5% j<Ä rÀ ¿ R¿

(85) Ä À lÄËYÃ ! \ÄËÀ $À 'Ä À SÀ À " ÄËYÃ l'Ä ÄÆ7¿ V @ - YOÄ oÆ 7#¿ÆuÄËÀ 76# Æ 7#-8%> 70À ÄÎÀ 9'5%;:.¿ oÆ T: 'Ä ÄËÃ;ÆuZÄ Y#À GÂ

(86) X& #À lÅU%¿ Å~ÆÄËÃ/À a: Ä

(87) P& & ¦Æ'Ä #Ã

(88) u%¿ eÂhÀ Æ¿0VÅ uÀ 0@Ä a$À 7

(89) /*>= ( vxsOdk`sO[2[g~~\fukesh¬}0qesO¥~]I[dlX0fKO]}~]\Gknmxsu§©~®ÍD]\qo]\Gk

(90) ´'qeke~Od`fhdOko]\O]\ql~]Ifhq}~qoshOqofh[d E

(91) &G¥~gjkB[2sOdksu§YkoX~]\[ fuqo],0fhO]keq fuSdfkosO0dsu§ X~sO\]IdGkes&¥~SfuqomRfuqofu¥~]IdI¹ ]IfOj~xkes }0qesOhq fu[d.´'X~ Xx~]Ifhqqe]Ifui~fkeshSdYX0fuq jm7hh]

(92) j§ªshqo[fkosO0d'shxGke]Ihq fu³deshgjkesh0dI·YWYX~]sh~m Gke]Iqe]dnk'su§ keX~]d%]

(93) 7§ªshqo[g~fkosO0d.]IdY keX~]

(94) ]ijdnko]\0\]

(95) su§!]Ð,]\GkdsOO]\q d\·!WYX~%]

(96) 7\shg~ ¥S] fh~sukoX~]\qY]\ijfh[2}~]

(97) sh§ koX~d nqog~] !´'keX~sOgjklfu;m,¥U]keke]Iqg~0j]Iqodkofh0j~2su§ keX~]}~qosh¥0]I[ · hkoX~]§ªsOs´'0x´µ]}~qosh]2koX0f} k

(98) Ïdf¬[g~kesO[B[2sjjknm&ÉSs´ }~qosh¥0]I[ fufug~i;fhqem Oqofh}~X³·ù{g~q´.shqo¶Çd0d}0qo]IÊ¥;mÇkoX~]¬dnkog0jm su§`keX~]¬qoshg~ke~ su§f [g~ke\fOdn.k ?/sh d~O]\¾Ë¨0¥U]\q DC ÿ @ ÿ ßWKÞ Ë Ü#ß âKàÛ>Ü#àâ Þ Bã AuÞ©Þ á'Qà Ü#W

(99) ÛËÞ Û>Þà ànànû âKÞnÛ ã ßßËÞYX ßËÜ ËûuÞ AhÜ#âI1ß E;F3G HJILK!FMIONQPDRQH TS Û TU»VÞ U ãß!ßËÜÞ Ëß A W û ß W7AuÞ!ß U»ÞnÞã <. . . . qZq. . ãr7stsuv. . . . . . . . . . . . . . .

(100) , &i #Ä À $KÆ

(101) . koqofh0defukeshj¾Î§ªqe]I]Y¯° ± ~]\kn´µsOqe¶jd!}~qo]Ide]\Gke]B^[ dlp,]OcÑ· a']]IOkomO¹Gf

(102) O]\qomde[2fhqNj]If

(103) X0fOdN¥U]\]I fh}~}~],kosh]I~]\q fu»sO[2[g~~\fukesh }0fkeke]Iqe sh/keX~]dofu[2]

(104) ~]\kn´µsOqe¶jd.¥;m [ y~~^tcÑ· £ ].¨0qodk!h]\0]\q fuÌI]rkeX~]'Ifhde]©su§S[g~ke\fOdnk!}0fkeke]Iqe0d kosO]\~]IqofhG±HnZoRp2´'X~]Iqe].´.].deshh]©keX~]R

(105) ´'keX¬fBÉSs´·.w§ ke]\qoÝfuq /´.]]i;ko]\0 koX~dkeskoX~]O]\~]Iqofh³\fhde]´'X~]Iqe]´.]g0de]f2[g~kesO[2[Bsjjknm ÉSs´ ´'X~ X/ddehXGkom,[2sOqe]`]Ð,]\Gk'koX0fu keX0]sh~]

(106) [ yj0^ c j]Ide}~ke]

(107) koX~]h]I~]\q fu®knmO· . k@+-*. ?2;'576 8:9JX_5. 9<A2/. BSATSg=&9J;=7S?2SX_57X. w.k

(108) koX~]B¨0qodk

(109) hfu0\]h¹DkeX0]B¥Sfhde}0fuqek

(110) su§.f sO[2[g~~\fukeshR}0fkeke]\qoÏdkeX0]Bqo]I«Gg~]dnk

(111) ¥U]kn´.]\]\Rkn´.s 0s;~]Id`´'X~ XRdfÍD]Ike]IÏf/hXGke}SfkeX·WYX~]Iqe]\§ªshqo]koX~]\qo]Bfhqe]BRO]\~]Iqofh f%«Gg0fh~qofuke;g~[¥S]Iq`sh§ ~®ÍD]\qo]\Gk¶;00d

(112) su§µqo]I«Gg~]dnk d`RkeX~]0]kn´.shqo¶U¹DsO~]2}S]Iq}0fuq

(113) su§µ0s;~]IdI·,{&keX~]shkeX~]Iq

(114) X0fu0³¹³sh~] [fKm fuhOqe]IOfuke]keX~d¥0fOd}0fhqk d'xshq j]\q'kos,[fu~}~g~fko]sO[2[g~~\fukesh%}0fukke]IqeSdfkf,X~OX~]\q ]\O]\Î¹jX~]\S]sO[B}0gjkofukesh0fhm,[2shqo]`keq fh#k fu¥~mh· s. t. Og~qo]B^_fNw²[g~ke\fOdnk'qo]I«Gg~]dnk· h0~]\]I³¹~fsO[2[g~~\fukesh,}Sfkko]\qo ~ \fh,¥U]

(115) de}~®kYOkoskoX~]

(116) d]\k.sh§³[g~ke\fOdnk d2 3 6@,:D 3 6@,:DA=~. G¹j]IfO X/sh§keX0]\[+GfkoX~]\qo02fh»qo]I«Gg~]dnk dYsu§!dsOg~qo\]

(117) O· £ ]/deX~s´ koX~],§ªsOs´'~%keX0fukkoX~]l

(118) \fh¥S] dsOO]IÏ¥;mÏfxÉ0s´ ÇfhÇfugjijfuqom&Oqofh}~X. ´'X0]\/keX~]\sh[2[g~0Ifkesh }0fukke]Iqe%d'fB[g~ke\fOdnk· k@+ON. . ?2;'576 8:9JX_5. 9<A2/ L3. {g0q'´'qeke~2su§ keX~]

(119) /sh [g~ke\fOdnkfOd'fÉSs´ }~qosh¥~]\[+g0d]dYkeX0]

(120) §ªshs´'~keX~qo]\]

(121) ¶h]Im,j]IfOd\· ^h·'WYX~]\fh}0fh\®knm7g0d] ¥Gm Rg0~®k d'su§ É0s´ùhsh~B§ªqosh[+0s;~]

(122) kesµ¬fÉ0s´ù~]kn´.shqo¶7Ifu%¥S] j]I\sh[2}Ushg~0 Gkes Ïde[B}0]

(123) }0fukeX0dY§ªqosh [

(124) kes µg0de~2sO~]

(125) g~~ksu§r\fu}Sfhknmh· j·'wùde]kYsu§ }0fkoX0dNkoX0fk'\fh,g0de]lkoX~]

(126) defh[B]´.fKO]\]\~hkeX/f¯° ± 0]kn´.shqo¶X0fOd©sOfOsh7~¶9 EnTÀ 'koX~];g~[¥S]Iqsu§r}0fukeX0d'Osh~2keX0qesOg~h4 X G'fk[2sGdnk` ¼ 3 :NkeX0];g~[¥U]\qsh§!¨0¥S]Iqodsh%keX0d ~¶D· ~·'w de]k

(127) su§µ}0fkoX0dlOO]\¬¥;m%koX~]B~]IsO[2}SsGdkesh¬sh§µfÉSs´@X0fhd`f7sOfOxsh&~¶ 2]i~fO#kem keX~] defh[2]koX0fk'koX~]\fh}0fh\®knmgSd]/¥;mkoX~]

(128) É0s´ùsh O·. s q ý.



(131) \Ä !"rÀ ÄËÃ#©Æ$\¿% GÂhÄ>Ã%Ä eÆ& ¿ÆÄ' . . WYX~]Iqe]\§ªshqo]h¹;hh]I fB~]\kn´µsOqe¶0B¹~fB[g~®koIfhdk}0fkeke]Iqe 6qos;suke]7fuk'f2deshg~q ]`~sjj] O¹~fuS/fh koX~]lqo]Ideshg0qo\]Id!su§DkoX~]l~]\kn´µsOqe¶ Eªº¹~¼3 : fuS½ 3 : G¹;´µ]´'S¥~g0,f

(132) É0s´Ê~]\kn´µsOqe¶Bdg0 X2koX0fkµkeX~]Iqe] dYfÉ0s´ su0§ Og~0®k dY¥S]\kn´µ]I]\/keX~]deshg~q ]`fu07keX~]de0¶,®§!fu07sh~m,§koX~]\qo]]\ijdkod'fhXGko}0fkoX ¥U]kn´.]\]I lfh02]IfO Xqe]}~]\GkN´'®koX~keX~]qe]dsOg~q ]Y[2®k d\· hg~qo]j]de\qe¥U]Id!koX~]É0s´Ê~]\kn´µsOqe¶ koX0fkdeshh]koX~^]

(133) Ï§ªsOqkoX~] ~]kn´.shqo¶Ïfh0koX~]7[g~ke\fhdk2}0fkeke]\qo deX~s´'Ç hg~qo]&^/´'X~]\ ÝfKh]I]I~ukoX0d'fuqo]fKfufh¥~ ] Eª§ªshq}~g~qo}SsGd]sh§!qo]IfO~fu¥0®knm/sh~m7sO~[] GÄ eÆ &#¿Æ'Ä arÀ I_Â \Ä !dl~qofK´'³· WYX0]\qo]`dYsh0]§ªsOq']IfO X/~sjj] G#· s1. t1. t2. s2 S. S’ trans_+ u. trans_− u super_t s3. t3. hg0qe]VfNWYX0]

(134) fOdedesjfko]IÉSs´ ~]\kn´µsOqe¶´'keX%ºn2 · hnj]fhdYi Grfh0, GNjqoO]g0d©kes\sh0dej]\q.fÉ0s´ ~]\kn´µsOqe¶ ´'X~]\qo]koX~]\qo]fhqe]ºùsh}0]dNsu§0 ´'keX I fu}0fOknm ¼3 :©§ªshq`fu \sh}~]Idlsu§rkoX~]0¶G·lw)¥S]fu[ Y0 g0de~7´.fKO]\]\~hkeX^_.Ifu¬¥U][2sjj]I] ¥;m7fBg~0®ksh§ É0s´ù koX~]M_2sh};m,sh§*0)²· {¥;;sOg0dem fde]k/su§

(135) ¥S]fu[dg0de0º¦´.fKO]\]\~hkeX0dfh0 ¼3 :¨0¥U]\q dsh fhGm ~¶ RIfu ¥S] [2sjj]I]7¥;m/f2de]k'su§!g~~kodsu§ É0s´ ´'X0]\qo]

(136) keX~]Ifu}0fOke]IdYfuqo]

(137) qe]d}U]Ike]I³· W s`\sh}U]Y´'®koXº'¾ÑOXOko}0fkoX0dI¹´µ]Yfh~fÄ eÆ 7#¿Æ'Ä rÀ I_Â \Äj§ªshqrfhGm0s;~] <2su§0B·ryjg0 Xf´'~h]k dNf

(138) [fh~]'su§³`~sjj]I d

(139) ` fu0

(140) g ¹Of

(141) ~¶¥U]kn´.]\]IBkeX~]d]Ykn´.sg~sjj]IdN´'®koX,\fu}Sfhknm½ 3<: fh0 º²g~0Ifu}0fOke]I/~¶jdY§ªqosh[+]Ifh lX <Okos

(142) ` fu0/§ªqosh [

(143) ke}s <On· w+hXGke}SfkeX´'X0 Xdkoqofh0defuke]IR§ªqosh[ ´.fKO]\]\~hkeX 1º hBkos¬º / fkB ~sjjB] <Ê\fu¥U]7[2sjj]I] ¥;m }~qo]\;sOg0dem7~]Idoqog ¥U]I%g~0®k dsu§!É0s´ §ªsOq'keX~]¥S]fu[dlfh0xf2g~~ksh§!É0s´ §ªqosh [ <lkoBs <`;f.

(144) ` fh0

(145) · {¥;;sOg0dem ®§fÇde]k7sh§hXGke}SfkeXSdg0de]Id,]Idod2koX0fu ½ 3T<:keq fu0defkeshSdfk/fhGm ~sjjz] < ¹'®k/d [2sjj]I]7¥;m/f2de]k'su§!g~~kodsu§ É0s´ sh qo]Ide}S]#ko~fh³Ifu}0fOke]IdI· h¬sOqo~]\qYkes,¨00xOXGke}0fukeX0dl¥S]\kn´µ]I]\x~sjj]d Bfu0 . 0B¹S´.]fh0xf~sjj] S¹Sf2~¶ §ªqesO! [ kos]fh X O ¹jf~sjj] #" $%&

(146) (' D¹OfuS7f~¶§ªqosh[ ]IfO X O ke)s #"*$(%&

(147) (' U· Ws2fu;m2hXGko}0fkoX,§ªqosh[ kes ´µ]\fhRfOdedesjfke]Bf7g0~®ksh§©É0s´@§ªqosh+ [ /ko,s -" $(%&

(148) ('. %fuS&sO;h]\q de]\m E>g0d~%j]IfR"^ GK· d]I0] koX~]]\[2[f~·. qZq. ãr7stsuv.

(149) . , &i #Ä À $KÆ

(150) .

(151)

(152) - :

(153) uÀ GÂ V0À ÄO @ Ä Æ:)-" $(%&

(154) ('. À ²À jÀ $Æ¿ SÄÄ

(155) xº & ¿®À®ÂÃGÄ®Å~ÆÄËÃi /Ä'

(156) À l0; zµsO0dj]Iqe~/f/[g0®koIfhdk`}0fukko]\qo ¤qos;suke]&fuk O¹ dlkoX~]BÉ0s´~]\kn´µsOqe¶ ´'X~]Iqe]keX~]Iqe]Bd`f 0s;~] #" $%&

(157) (' §ªshqYfu 7A sO~~]Ike],fhdµj]Idoqo¥U]I,}~qe]I;sOg0dm2fu0,ffOdnk.~sjj]©sO~~]Ike] kosBfh #" $(%

(158) (' 0s;~]Id.¥;m,f0¶,su§ Ifu}0fOknm X3 j: koX~]

(159) ;g~[¥U]\qYsu§ hXGke}SfkeXSd©kos¥U]§ªshg~07§ªqosh[ kos · Æ

(160) \OÄ ! 0G'Æ Kj¿®ÄËÀ Æ #Ä Å~ÆÄÎÄ t uÄ ÆÄlÆ V K

(161) "i YÆ

(162) %Æ¿ ¿. tÓ;× Ó

(163) m

(164) YÀ $Ç# ÄËYÃ > V - ÄËYÃ >

(165) \OÄ !4#%º ¼ 3 :Æ :½ 3 : % , ¿ $À GÂ/ÄËYÃ

(166) À KjÀ $Æ¿ SÄ.'Ä T

(167) ,À RÄËYÃ Æ 2OÀ ¿ÁÀ>Æ & :Ä ! Æ @ RÄ K #À " X3 j:" ×³× ¢ 0qesO[ keX~]hXGke}0fukeX0d.kosBkeX~]

(168) É0s´ùdldnkoqofhOXOke§ªshqo´.fhqo³· 0qesO[+koX~]É0s´ kos,keX0]OXOko}0fkoX0dd'§ªsOqo\]I%¥U]IIfug0de]keX0]sh0m ~¶jdqe]fh X~~ \sh[2]§ªqosh[ #" $(%&

(169) ' D¹ [A ¹»´'®koXRIfu}0fOkn m P3 j:o·WYX~]Iqe]\§ªshqo]h¹U®§NkoX~]\qo]Bd

(170) fÉSs´su§µdeÌ\] P3 j:'¥U]kn´.]\]I /fuS \¹0]\i~fh#kom X3 j:µg~0®k dsu§rÉSs´ùOsG]dYkeX0qesOg~hX%]IfO Xx~¶/§ªqesO[ #" $(%

(171) (' ko)s · d]\S]h¹0§ªshq ]fh X A koX~]\qo]

(172) d X3 j:Ng~~kod'sh§ É0s´ §ªqesO! [ Bko)s #" $(%&

(173) ' D· /]\[2[f ^ÒO]Id.koX~]sO0g0desO³·. qµÓ. £ keX%§ª]I´ de[2}~§ªmG~2su§ keX0]~]Ifhq'}~qoshhq fu[%¹G´µ]Ifu ´'qeke]

(174) koX~]

(175) 7fOd.keX~]

(176) §ªsOs´'0;

(177) D·. "! $#%&('*),+. -.0/%1243658709;:=<?> @ABC D?CFE%G@FHJIJKG L L A A Z ehg @AM?B NPiORQE$SGjTUW@FVYH`XZIJ[JK\^G U ] V Z`_ MbaPORQS%T(UWVYXZ`_\dU c V f L L AFm A M?L NPORQS T U VYXZ[lk L U V Z`_ M;aPORQS T U VYXZ e g h E E e g h @AM?BNPC O D?S C T UE G VYXZ`_ M;a4O S T U Von%Z`_qp?r U L L A A e g h @AB UtisFu E$G \Û ] V Z`_ Usu \dU c V Z L AFm A A k U V Z`L _wvV AZ e g h UL su p?rtUx_ Q;ybz|{ vV Z e g h U s u } 9F~49F1.01?3t</$96.t<?> @ B G@FHJIJKG @AX BC D?CFE%G L T(UWVYA XZhVYA XZ \Û ] V Z%V Z Usu s q ý.



(180) \Ä !"rÀ ÄËÃ#©Æ$\¿% GÂhÄ>Ã%Ä eÆ& ¿ÆÄ' k@+Ok. SA2Sg=79<; 8:9JX S. 9<A2/. 1. ?2;'576 8:31. 1m3@/H6'5. ]. L3. £ ]2~s´ fO~jqo]IdodkeX~],Ifhde]sh§Yf h]I~]\q fur\sh[2[g~0IfkeshR}0fkeke]IqeY~ 2 · £ ]h]I~]\q fuÌI] koX~]l}0qe]IGshgSdN~]\kn´µsOqe¶ ¥GmfO~j~fOqesOg~}2su§³~sjj]d #" $(%&

(181) ' !§ªsOq©]fh X[g0®koIfhdk · WYX0=]

(182) &d0s´ ]«Og0fu]\Gkkos%¨00j~&fhGko]\hq fu!ÉSs´ sh§ X3 6 j:lg~~kodsO[B[2sjjke]Id ¥U]kn´.]\]I ,fu0 µ§ªshq']fh X MAC8·NWYX~]O]\~]IqofhDdeX0fh}S]

(183) su§ d'd X~s´'{ / hg~qo]~· WYX~]qo]Ideg~ke~;

(184) /X0fO d

(185) 3D 5bc3D 8 J 5 :9c Mº :©fuqofu¥~]IdYfuS

(186) 3D 5 c %º :©shSdnkoqofhGkod.´'X~ X d de[fu~sO[B}Sfuqo]Ikos`keX~]

(187) 3D 5 / cJ 8 bc %º : fu0= 3 5 c Mº :³sh§SkoX~]Ysh~]Y}~qo]Ide]\Gko]I [ yj~^ c0´'X0 X2js;]Id 0suk\fh}jkeg~qo]

(188) [g~ke¨0¥U]\q d'~]\kn´µsOqe¶jd.~shq'ÝfKh]I]I~ukoXkeq fuSdfkosO³· WYX~d`[ftnshq[2}~qosh]I[2]\Gklsh¬keX~]2dÌ\]su§rkoX~]}0qesOhq fu[+XSfhd`jqofh[fke\sh0de]I«Gg~]I0]dsh&keX~] koqofO#k fu¥~knmsu§lkeX~]¬\sh[2}~gjko~R§ªshq2¥UsukoX koX~]%]i~fh;k

(189) fu0 shg~q eÆ

(190) i À "F V

(191) uÀ GÂ oÆ fh}~}~qosKij[fkosORfhOshqo®koX~[d\· WYX~]\qo]§ªsOqe]2´.],\fuÇfO~jqo]Idod

(192) fhqeO]\q~]\kn´µsOqe¶jd

(193) fuSsh[2[g~~\fkosO }Sfkko]\qo0dI· S’1. S1. S2 S’2. S’3. S3. Og~qe]

(194) 7f ¸ ]I~]\q fu³deX0fh}S]

(195) su§ keX0]

(196) fOdedesjfko]I7É0s´ ~]\kn´µsOqe¶D·. / 7\

(197) ! vxg~®ko\sh[2[2sjj®knm7É0s´ }0qesO¥~]I[d.fhqe] ¾ÑX0fuq 7fh0%fu[2sh0koX~]X0fuq j]dnk· hs 0]keX0]\]Idod.keX~]Ishqo]k¾ \fh»´µsOqe¶jd.sh%fu}0}~qesKij[fkesh/X0fKh]`hh]I dkeqosh0qo]Ideg~kodI· . qZq. . ãr7stsuv.

(198) ^. , &i #Ä À $KÆ

(199) . WYX~>] eÆ :i BÀ "> V

(200) uÀ GÂsu§DkeX~]'[g~kesh[2[2sjjknmÉ0s´ÊX0fOdr¥S]I]\}~qosh]kosfh X~]\O]'fhs;sj koX~]\sOqe]\ke\fhlfu}~}0qesKij[2fukeshÊqofukesÇj]Ide}~ke]&keX~]&de[B}0knmÊfh0 sh¥;;shg0d,deg~¥j¾Ñsh}~ke[2fhknm sh§keX~] }0qesj]deKd [ëvxTa ]O cÎ·BWYX~dfuhshqokeX~[ ¨0q dk

(201) deshh]keX~B]

(202) G¾Ñqe]Ifuijfukeshxkos%sh¥jk fu¬§ªq fh#kosO0fu É0s´dI·w §ªq fhkesh0fhjh]IqodesOsh§SkoX~]'¶h]Im~]IfhdNhh]\Byj]I#kosO~·ë\fh[d koX0fk©f`§ªq fhkesh0fh;É0s´ sh§ g~~kod §ªqosh[ µkos \fu¥S]'j]sh[2}Ushg~SOkosl[fu;m}0fukeX0d ´'keX}SsGdkeh]µ§ªqofO#kosO0fuG´µ]IOXGkod dg~[2[2~g0} ko

(203) s r· WYX~]Yq fu0~sh[2ÌI]IqesOg~0j~`]Idod]IOkofhmsO0dedkod Bde]\]Ike~fkrqofh0jsO[@sh~].su§SkeX~]d]Y}0fukeX0d ´'keX }~qosh¥0fh¥~knm2®k dY´µ]IOXOk'j;j]7¥;m r·rw²de[2}~]fu0fhm;Ì\]`dX0s´d©koX0fkYkoX~]

(204) Gke]Ihq fuD\fh}0fh\®knm sO¥jkofh0]I7fu§ ke]Iqµq fu0~sh[2m2qoshg~Sj0f´'X~sh][g~kesh[2[2sjjknm2É0s´ dYfBdg0[ su§ .]\qo~sOg~Ukeqofhd ´'keX ]\i;}U]Ikofh0m&keX~]2§ªq fhkesh0fhN\fu}Sfhknmh·,WYX0]\qo]§ªshqo]BkeX~]Gfu} ¥U]kn´.]\]\ÏkoX~]qesOg~0j] dsOgjkosO fh07keX~]

(205) §ªq fhkesh0fh»sh~]

(206) dYs´ù´'®koX X0OX }0qesO¥0fu¥~®knmO· WYX~][fhsO[2}~gjkofukesh0fhNjq fK´'¥0fh ¶%su§.keX0d}0qesj]ded`d

(207) keXSfkkeX0]Gg0[¥U]\qsu§Y}0fukeX0dIfu ¥S] ]\ij}SsO~]\GkefuÎ<· dsO}S]\§ªg~m sh~]\fh/}0qesO]´'keXxfB[fuqeke~Ofh]fuqohg0[B]IGkµkoX0fk'koX~]Ide]}0fkoX0d'fuqo]

(208) ~suk ]\ij}~kem7qo]I«Gg~qo]I»·NWYX~]

(209) §ªq fhkesh0fhDg~~klsu§ É0s´ù~]Idoqo¥U]IdY%keX~]0]kn´.shqo¶,f2´µ]IOXOko]I À \Ä Æ .i\¿ÁÀ Â eÆ#Å0Ã EË° ZG'´'X~ X¬qo]I«Gg~qe]d0]Ifuqlke[2]B\sh[2}~gjk fkesh¬kes7¥U]Bh]\0]\q fke] §ªqesO[ keX~]É0s´ _ fhqefu¥~]IdI· w¦q fuSjsh[ ´.fh¶ 0dej]xkeX0d7° OO]Id,f }SfkeX ´'X0 X sOg~ ¥S]&de]\]Ike] ¥;m keX~] q fuSjsh[2Ì\]I,qesOg~0j~0· hÑ§koX~]

(210) }~qosh¥0fh¥~knmkosOskoX~qesOg~hX fu/]IjO]d.}~qesO}SsOqkosO0fu0kesB®k dY´µ]IOXGk koX~]}0fukeX dde]\]Ike]7´'keX keX0]defh[B]

(211) }~qosh¥Sfu¥~knm7fOd.keX~]q fu0~sh[2ÌI]I7qesOg~0j~0· £ ]X0fKh]`[B}0]I[B]IGke]I/koX~dlfu}~}~qosKij[fukesh/fhOshqo®koX~[ ´'X~ X/XSfhd.keX0]~\]}~qosh}U]\qeknm2kes2qeg0 §>fhqom«Gg~ ¶Gmde0]NksO~m~]\]~d»kosdsOO]!keX~]

(212) G¾Ñqo]\fi~fkosOsO0]Nfh0`keX~]Ijs;]I-d { P3 6 j: q fuSjsh[ Ýfu¶;dµsu§ ]I~ukoX

(213) 3 5 c Mº :e· hÑk.d.Gke]Iqe]dnko0kos~shke]keX0fukµkoX~]sO[B}0gjkofukesh,sh§keX0]q fuj¾ ~sh[ Ýfu¶;d.d.~]\Oh¥~]`\sh[2}0fuqo]I,keskeX~]desh;~su§ keX~%]

(214) G¾Îqo]\fi~fukeshsh%fu;m,deÌI]sh§~]\kn´µsOqe¶ fh0 sh[2[g~~\fkosO/}Sfkko]\qo fh0 ]\O]\ g0d~2sh0]`sh§ koX~]¥U]IdWk

(215) dsOO]\q¹ PX

(216) N· WYX~sOg~hX,keX~dµfh}~}~qosKij[fkosOfuhshqokeX~[dµh]IqemB]Ð,\]IOk¹OkYdµsh¥;;sOg0d!koX0fkY®k.d.deg~¥SsO}jke[fu de0]2fu!}0fkoXÏde]\]Ikesh0d

(217) fuqo]2jsh~]B0j]\}U]\Sj]\Gkemh·{g~q

(218) ~]If dkos/k fu¶O]}~qo]\;shg0d

(219) X~sO\]IdGkes fO\\shg~Gk

(220) ´'X~]\ X~s;sOde0/f }0fkoX³¹³X~]I0]fKOshj0,kes sh]Iq¾ÑsOfh%~¶jd`keX0fuk

(221) XSfKh]2fuqe]fhjm%X~hX~m sOfOj]I³· WYX~]Y¨0q dkrke]I X0~«Gg~]'´.]'X0fKO]µ[2}~]I[2]\Gke]^ E

(222) G dNfkrkoX~]'sh}0}SsGdke]'sh§SkoX~]'qofh0jsO[¾ Ì\]qoshg00j~BkeX~].koqofOj]¾ÑsuÍ¥U]kn´.]\]\B]Ð,\]I0mfh0kehXGke~]dedI·

(223) sO0dedkod![2sjj§ªm;~ koX~]\fh}0fh\®knm2§ªg~S#keshSd¼7fh0/½su§ keX~]`É0s´ ~]kn´.shqo¶,f§ ko]\q.keX~] X~sO\]

(224) su§ fBOXOko}0fkoX/´'X0 X X0fhd 0shj¾ÑGko]\hq fuµ´µ]IOXGk koX~]7§ªq fhkesh0fh.deshgjkosO³¹©fuSkesÏqo]IsO[2}~gjke]7keX~z]

(225) G¾Ñqe]Ifuijfukeshsh§keX~] [g~kesh[2[2sjjknmÉ0s´ ´'X0]\qo]koX~]qo]\]\fuGk'qe]«Gg~]Idk'X0fhdY¥U]\]I%~]Iqo]IfOd]»· {¥;;sOg0demxkoX~]sh}~ke[2fhknm&Gfu}Ïsu§.keX~]7Gke]Ihq fuNdeshgjkeshÏ´.]h]\0]\q fke]2ds´µ]IqkoX0fu keX~] qo]\Og~fuq2qofh0jsO[BÌ\]ÊqesOg~0j~0·@{g~q,]\i;}U]\qo[B]IGkodfu~fko]%keX~d7\fh[%· Ilj§ªshqekeg00fko]\mh¹YkeX0d fh}~}~qosKij[fkosO[2}~qosh]I[2]\GkµdYsh¥jk fu~]I/fk.kn´µs2sGdnk d\·rWYX~]¨0q dnkYd.keX0fuk.´.]`~sB0sukY¶G0s´ X~s´ kossh¥jk fu¬fBkehXGkfh0fumjdd'su§ keX0]fu}0}~qesKij[fkesh/qofukes0·YWYX~]¥U]Idkl´.]\fh%~s,dsh¥jk fu~]I%¥;m/f dkeq fuhXGke§ªshqo´.fhqoxfh0&s;sOde]g0}~}S]Iq¾Ñ¥Ushg~0~~%Ïf [fuqeke~Gfu]}~qosj]Idod

(226) fu0ÏjqoO]Idkes koX~],defh[2] qo]Ideg~kYfOdµkeX~]

(227) q fu0jsO[2ÌI]I,qoshg00j~0·rWYX~]

(228) d]sO07\sOdk.d'sO[B}0gjkofukesh0fhDde0]`´µ]

(229) [fKmX0fKO]kes deshh]`[fu;=m

(230) jdI· £ ]X0fKO][B}0]I[B]IGke]I&f[2®ij]I%X0]\g~qodkeu¹

(231) U¹U´'X~ XxqesOg~0~dl0~]\}U]\0j]IGkem sO~]g~0®k sh§ ÉSs´ }U]\q[g~®koIfhdk'¥S]\§ªshqo]dsO;~f0]\. ´

(232) D¹0qe]dg~ke~2%f2[2sOqe]

(233) ]Ð,\]IOk¥0gjk}SsGdede¥~m7]ded fO\\g~qofuke]

(234) fu}~}0qesKij[2fukesh³·. s q ý.



(237) \Ä !"rÀ ÄËÃ#©Æ$\¿% GÂhÄ>Ã%Ä eÆ& ¿ÆÄ' Ô^ h koX~]¬§ªsOs´'0Ï´.]¬fu~fko]xshg~q7fhOshqo®koX~[dshÊkn´.s keX~]Ishqo]koIfu]\ijfh[2}~]d,fuS f fhqeO] qo]Ifh®¾Ñ´.shqo0]kn´.shqo¶U·. . I

(238) !4 ' /**% -./ /. @+-*. SZA28&UH1. 9 =. @+ON.

(239) 6-XY8R?2XYXY6 3AW3 #=7SXY?2; 5VX 3T5V9<6-A2S/. 6-AHXi5V9<A28:SZX. 500 450 400 350 300 250 200 150 100 50 0. 80. Randomized rounding Heur1 Heur2 ILP. Optimal solution Randomized rounding. 70 Number of fibers. Time in seconds. {g0qd[g~fkosO0d

(240) ´.]\qo]Bqog~ shÏkn´.s%~]kn´.shqo¶jd ffÏÎ ~sjj]dqo~x0]kn´.shqo¶¬fu0 f%}0fhj¾Ñfh[2]\qoIfu 0]kn´.shqo¶,Gko]\q sh0~]Ike~ 2ke]IdlsOfOdnk'kos,sGfhdkY´'keXRhB¥~jqo]Ikesh0fh»~¶jdI·.W ´µs\sh[2[g~0®¾ IfkosO,}0fkeke]Iqe0dµsh7keX~]`qo~´µ]Iqe]qofh0jsO[Bm2h]I~]\q fko]Ifhd©§ªshs´d\·rWYX~]Iqe]dYf\sh~0]I#kosO§ªqosh[ 0s;~1] < kes~sjj[] ?B´'keX }~qesO¥0fu¥0®knm fuS,]IfO X,sO~~]Ikesh,qo]I«Gg~]dnk dN§ªqosh[ ^lkes ÎOXGke}0fukeX0d ´'keXÏg~~§ªshqo[ }~qosh¥Sfu¥~knmh·BWYX~]B¨0q dnk

(241) }0fkeke]Iqe\ Es~h Gqe]I}~qo]Ide]\Gkod

(242) G OXGke}0fukeX0dI¹»keX0]2de]I\sh0&sh~] ET~5/GY~^ · WYX~]`sO[B[g~~\fukesh}0fukke]Iqe7shkoX~]l}0fhj¾fu[2]\qoIfu2~]\kn´µsOqe¶Bdµfqo]Ifh®¾Ñ´µsOqe0dkofh0]´'X~ X ;hsOO]IdÎhGhXGke}0fukeX0dI· WYX~]\sh[2}~gjk fkosO0dY´µ]Iqe]

(243) qog~%sh%f ]hOO^v dlÌ`<p h h-h'sO[2}~gjke]Iq´'keX¬j^Khv%sBsu§rawv·0WYX~ ]

(244) ´.]\qo]

(245) dsOO]I/g0d~ ,

(246) r·. 60 50 40 30 20 10 0. 0. 10. 20. 30. 40. 50. Number of wavelengths. q. 60. 70. 0. 10. 20. 30. 40. 50. 60. 70. Number of wavelengths. A âKá AuÞÛ»ÜDSAuÞnÛ âKãKã ã ß á'Þ hg~qo]

(247) &fra'g~0dsh/keX~]^¾Ñqe~ . . WYX~]qe]dg0®k d'su§rshg0qde[g~fukeshxsO/koX~]qo~7fuS%sh%keX0]}0fu~¾Ñfh[B]Iqe\fh%~]kn´.shqo¶7fuqo]}~sukeke] 4 Gd\·! 0¹ fh0xj·. qZq. ãr7stsuv.

(248) ^K. , &i #Ä À $KÆ

(249) . Time ratio ILP over Heur2 500 450 400 350 300 250 200 150 100 50 0 14 12 4. 6. 8 Number of fibers. 8 10. 6. 12. 10 Number of wavelengths. 14 4. hg~qo]Vfra'g~~0~q fkosBsu§D

(250) ,jdTdl]\g~q#. 60000. Time in seconds. 50000 40000. Number of fibers. Randomized rounding Heur1 Heur2 ILP. 30000 20000 10000 0 0. 10. 20. 30. 40. 50. Number of wavelengths. q. 60. 70. 200 180 160 140 120 100 80 60 40 20 0. Optimal solution Randomized rounding. 0. 10. 20. 30. 40. 50. 60. 70. Number of wavelengths. A âKá AuÞÛ»ÜDSAuÞnÛ âKãKã ã ß á'Þ Og~qo] fra'g~0d'sO7koX~]}0fhj¾Ñfh[2]\qoIfu70]kn´.shqo¶ . . s q ý.



(253) \Ä !"rÀ ÄËÃ#©Æ$\¿% GÂhÄ>Ã%Ä eÆ& ¿ÆÄ' ^ £ ]B¨0qodkqo]\[fhqe¶ keXSfk

(254) ´µ]´µ]Iqe]g~0fu¥0]kes/¨00R\fhde]Idsh¬keX~]2}0fhj¾Ñfh[2]\qoIfux~]\kn´µsOqe¶ ´'X~ X qo]I«Gg~qo]µkoqofh0defukesh0dI· WYX~drd©jg0]YkeX~] ede[2}~\®knm !'su§Dqe]fu¾Î´.shqosO[2[g~~\fukesh20dnk fu0\]Id!koX0fk ´.]

(255) }~qo]\;sOg0dem2§>fO]I /shkeX~]IqdkegSfkeshSd[ !pNa ` ~^tcÑ· £ ]sh0m/~]\]7koqofh0defukesh ´'®koX

(256) sO keX~]qo0´'®koXC~5/u¹ ^

(257) ¨0¥S]IqI¹Sfu0¬ ÝfKh]I]I~ukoX0dI· hBkoX~dµ\fOd]O¹keX~]'X0]\g~qodkeYÝfhd!~shkµfu¥~].kesfh0d´.]\q!koX~]lj]dshB}~qosh¥~]\[ ´'®koX~shg~k©fh~j~]I®koX~]\q ÝfKh]I]I~ukoX0d.shq