Biomedical Ontology Matching Using the AgreementMaker System

!"#$%&"'()*+,-#)#./*0(-'1",.*23",.*

-1%*4.5%%$%,-0(6%5*7/3-%$* *

!"#$%&'()'*+,-^./'*0"123'45+0%^./'*#52#'6%"7,25#⁸/'(+#392"90':)'*0,50⁸/';#&%+2%'*+0""^<''

.=>;!4'?#$0+#50+@/'A32B%+"25@'0C'!&&2302"'#5'*D29#E0/'A4=^''

8(#9,&F#F%'F%'*2G392#"'F#'A32B%+"2F#F%'F%'?2"$0#/'60+5,E#&^''

<*01H,5%+'492%39%'#3F'40C5I#+%'J3E23%%+23E'>%H#+51%35/':2#12'A32B%+"25@/'KLC0+F/'KM/'A4=' '

483-5('-9'ND%'$JUHHPHQW0DNHU'0350&0E@'1#59D23E'"@"5%1/'ID29D'D#"'$%%3'F%B%&0H%F'23'5D%'

=>;!4'?#$0+#50+@'#5'5D%'A32B%+"25@'0C'!&&2302"'#5' *D29#E0/'D#"'$%%3'F%H&0@%F'50'F0-%3"'0C' ,"%+"'23'#'B#+2%5@'0C'F01#23")'!3'5D2"'F%10'I%'9039%35+#5%'03'+%"%#+9D'#FB#39%"'5D#5'1#O%' 5D%' $JUHHPHQW0DNHU' "@"5%1' H#+529,&#+&@' ",25#$&%' C0+' $201%F29#&' #HH&29#5203"P' Q.R' =3'

%L5%3"2$&%'#+9D25%95,+%S'Q8R'=,501#529'901$23#5203'0C'5D%'+%",&5"'C+01'1#59D23E'1%5D0F"S'Q<R'

!35%E+#5%F' 1#59D23E' #3F' %B#&,#5203S' #3F' QTR' 4,HH0+5' C0+' %L5%+3#&' B09#$,&#+2%")'

$JUHHPHQW0DNHU' D#"' +%9%35&@' 0$5#23%F' 5D%' $%"5' +%",&5"' %B%+' 23' 5D%' K=J!' =3#501@' N+#9O' 901H%525203)' '

+,-#)#./*0(-'1",.*7/3-%$*

$JUHHPHQW0DNHU' ",HH0+5"' #' I2F%' B#+2%5@' 0C'

!"#$%&'()#3F' 1#3,#&' 235%+B%35203' 50' 90++%95'

#,501#529#&&@'C0,3F'1#HH23E"'0+'#FF'3%I'03%")'

=3'0$U%95V0+2%35%F'#+9D25%95,+%'2"',"%F'50'F%C23%'

#' E%3%+29' 1#59D%+/' ID29D' F%C%+"' 03&@' #' C%I' 0H%+#5203"' 50' 5D%' 9039+%5%' 1#59D%+' %L5%3"203"' W8X)' :#59D%+"' 9#3' $%' 901H0"%F' 23' "%+2%"' 0+' H#+#&&%&' Q"%%' (2E,+%' .Q#RR/' I25D' 5D%' "@"5%1'

",HH0+523E' 5D%' "*#+!"#,$) (&-&$#,+.) 0C' 5D%' I%2ED5"'#""2E3%F'50'5D%'+%",&5"'0C'%#9D'1#59D%+)' ND2"'9#H#$2&25@'2"'235%E+#5%F'I25D'#3'&/"-*"#,+.)

$+!0+.&.#) 5D#5' 2"' ",HH0+5%F' $@' 5D%' ,"%+' 235%+C#9%'Q"%%'(2E,+%'.Q$RR'W<X)' '

0(-'1",.*4,(-#$/*+,-#)#."%3*

!3' 8YYZ/'$JUHHPHQW0DNHU' I#"' +#3O%F' #' 9&0"%'

"%903F'23'5D%'K=J!'=3#501@'N+#9O'901H%525203' WTX)'!5',"%F'#"'#3'%L5%+3#&'B09#$,&#+@'A:?4)'!3' LW ZDV UDQNHG ÀUVW DQG WKH UHVXOWV WKDW I%+%' 0$5#23%F' I%+%' 5D%' $%"5' %B%+' W[X)' ND%' 21H+0B%1%35'0B%+'5D%'H+%B20,"'@%#+'I#"'H#+5&@' F,%'50'5D%',"%'0C'#'H+2392H&%F'#HH+0#9D'C0+'5D%' 235%E+#5203' 0C'/+$"1*-"',&()W\X)' !3' H#+529,&#+/'

%#9D' 1#59D%+' I#"' %L5%3F%F' 50' 2390+H0+#5%'

&%L2903")'="'%L5%+3#&'B09#$,&#+@/'03&@']0+F^%5' I#"',"%F'5D2"'521%)* *

:#))(8#5(-"#,*

4%B%+#&' 9#H#$2&252%"' 0C' 5D%' "@"5%1' I%+%' F+2B%3'

$@'5D%'+%#&VI0+&F'H+0$&%1"'0C'%3F',"%+"'ID0'#+%'

"0HD2"529#5%F' F01#23' %LH%+5")' N0' C0"5%+' 5D2"' O23F'0C'235%+#95203/'$JUHHPHQW0DNHU'2"'#B#2&#$&%' C0+' F0I3&0#F' QIII)#E+%%1%351#O%+)0+ER)' (0+'

%L#1H&%/' I25D' 5D%' A32B%+"25@' 0C' ?2"$03/' 5D%'

&2#&.(,1,-,#3) 0C' $JUHHPHQW0DNHU I#"' 5%"5%F)' ND%@' F%B%&0H%F' 3%I' 1#59D%+"' 5D#5' 90,&F' $%' +HDGLO\ LQFRUSRUDWHG LQWR D QHZ FRQÀJXUD5203' C0+'5D%'=3#501@'N+#9O'901H%525203'W_X)']%'#&"0' E#23%F'#'$%55%+',3F%+"5#3F23E'0C'5D%'3#5,+%'0C' 5D%'0350&0E2%"',"%F'23'5D%'=3#501@'N+#9O'Q#3F' 23'H#+529,&#+'0C'5D%2+'#3305#5203"R/'ID29D'&%F'50' 2390+H0+#523E'&%L2903"'2350'5D%'1#59D%+")']25D' :2#12' A32B%+"25@/' 5I0' $201%F29#&' 0350&0E2%"' I25D' E+%#5%+' D%5%+0E%3%25@' 5D#3' 5D0"%' 0C' 5D%'

=3#501@' N+#9O' I%+%' 903"2F%+%F)' ND%' 2F%#' 0C'

%LH&0+23E' 5D%' 3#5,+%' 0C' 5D%' 0350&0E2%"' #3F' 0C' ,"23E' &%L2903"' I#"' C,+5D%+' %LH&0+%F' $@' ,"23E'

#3305#5203'H+0C2&23E'W.X)' '

;%$#*;%3'5"<-"#,*

*03C%+%39%' H#+5292H#35"' 9#3' &0#F' 5D%2+' 0I3' 0350&0E2%"'0+',"%'5D0"%'#&+%#F@'1%35203%F)'ND%@' 9#3'#&"0'%LH&0+%'5D%'"@"5%1'C+%%&@'0+'C0&&0I'#'I#&OV' 5D+0,ED/'903"2"523E'0C'$+0I"23E'5D%'0350&0E2%"/' +,3323E' F2CC%+%35' 901$23#5203"' 0C' 1#59D%+"/' ,"23E'5D%'#3305#5203'H+0C2&23E'901H03%35/'#3F'

%B#&,#523E'5D%'7,#&25@'0C'5D%'1#59D23E") ,&%2,QWHUQDWLRQDO&RQIHUHQFHRQ%LRPHGLFDO2QWRORJ\

-XO\ā%XIIDOR1<86$

! ! ! ! ! !

! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! "#$! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! "%$! !

!"#$%&'()!"#$%%&%'()*+%$,!)*(-./'#!0$1-%22!*$-./(%-(3$%!*'4!32%$!/'(%$5*-%6!

&'()*+,-./-0-)12!

"#$%! &'()*+,! $%! &-',$-../! %0&&(',*1! 2/! 345!

67-'1%! 884²9:;<::<! -=1! 884²9>;??:>! -=1! 2/!

,#*! 8=,*..$@*=+*! 61A-=+*1! B*%*-'+#! C'()*+,%!

6+,$A$,/! D86BC6E! A$-! 6$'! 5('+*! B*%*-'+#!

F-2('-,('/! D65BFE! +(=,'-+,! =0G2*'! 56>H:9I!

;9IJIK9H;L!"#*!ML4L!N(A*'=G*=,!$%!-0,#('$O*1!

,(! '*&'(10+*! -=1! 1$%,'$20,*! '*&'$=,%! P('!

N(A*'=G*=,-.! &0'&(%*%! =(,7$,#%,-=1$=@! -=/!

+(&/'$@#,! -==(,-,$(=! ,#*'*(=L! "#*! A$*7%! -=1!

+(=+.0%$(=%! +(=,-$=*1! #*'*$=! -'*! ,#(%*! (P! ,#*!

-0,#('%! -=1! %#(0.1! =(,! 2*! $=,*'&'*,*1! -%!

=*+*%%-'$./! '*&'*%*=,$=@! ,#*! (PP$+$-.! &(.$+$*%! ('!

*=1('%*G*=,%Q! *$,#*'! *R&'*%%*1! ('! $G&.$*1Q! (P!

86BC6Q!65BFQ!('!,#*!ML4L!N(A*'=G*=,L!

"#$%! &'()*+,! $%! &-',$-../! %0&&(',*1! 2/! 5J"!

0=1*'! ,#*! S0.,$-==0-.! 50=1$=@! C'(@'-GG*!

-=1! ,#*! C#T! @'-=,! 45BUVWTVX?X>;V?99K! -=1!

2/!,#*!Y0'(&*-=!J(GG$%%$(=!P('!,#*!YC8Z[B\!

&'()*+,! 0=1*'! ,#*! 4*A*=,#! 5'-G*7(']!

C'(@'-GG*!DN'-=,!^?<;>9KEL! ! 3-4-5-)'-2!

;L! ! _L! J'(%%Q! JL! 4,'(*Q! `L! U0Q! CL! 4$.7-.Q! SL!

C-=-#$-O-'Q!8L!5L!J'0OQ!CL!C-'$]#Q!-=1!6L!4#*,#L!

6.$@=$=@!,#*!C-'-%$,*!YR&*'$G*=,![=,(.(@/!-=1!

,#*![=,(.(@/!P('!W$(G*1$+-.!8=A*%,$@-,$(=%!M%$=@!

6@'**G*=,S-]*'L! 8=!!"#$%"&#'("&)* +(",$%$"-$* ("*

.'(/$0'-&)*1"#()(23*4!+.15Q!?9;;L!

! !

?L! ! 8L! 5L! J'0OQ! 5L! C-.-=1'$! 6=,(=*..$Q! -=1! JL! 4,'(*L!

$JUHHPHQW0DNHU (IÀFLHQW 0DWFK$=@! P('! F-'@*!

B*-.IZ('.1! 4+#*G-%! -=1! [=,(.(@$*%L!6789.Q!

?D?Ea;:>H²;:>bQ!?99bL! !

<L! ! 8L! 5L! J'0OQ! 5L! C-.-=1'$! 6=,(=*..$Q! -=1! JL! 4,'(*L!

(IÀFLHQW 6HOHFWLRQ RI 0DSSLQJV DQG $XWRG-,$+!

c0-.$,/I1'$A*=! J(G2$=-,$(=! (P! S-,+#$=@!

S*,#(1%L! 8=!!:;+* !"#$%"&#'("&)* ;(%<=>(?* ("*

1"#()(23*@&#->'"2*41@5Q!A(.0G*! ::;!(P!+ABC*

;(%<=>(?*6%(-$$0'"2=Q!?99bL! !

XL! ! 8L! 5L! J'0OQ! 5L! C-.-=1'$! 6=,(=*..$Q! JL! 4,'(*Q! ML!

\*.*%Q!-=1!6L!S-10](L!M%$=@!6@'**G*=,S-]*'!

,(! 6.$@=! [=,(.(@$*%! P('! [6Y8! ?99ba! [A*'A$*7Q!

B*%0.,%Q! -=1! [0,.((]L! 8=!!:;+* !"#$%"&#'("&)*

;(%<=>(?* ("* 1"#()(23* @&#->'"2* 41@5Q! A(.0G*!

::;!(P!+ABC*;(%<=>(?*6%(-$$0'"2=Q!?99bL! ! :L! ! 8L! 5L! J'0OQ! JL! 4,'(*Q! SL! J-+$Q! 5L! J-$G$Q! SL!

C-.G(=-'$Q! 5L! C-.-=1'$! 6=,(=*..$Q! -=1! ML! JL!

\*.*%L!M%$=@!6@'**G*=,S-]*'!,(!6.$@=![=,(.(@$*%!

P('![6Y8!?9;9L!8=!!:;+*!"#$%"&#'("&)*;(%<=>(?*

("* 1"#()(23* @&#->'"2* 41@5Q! A(.0G*! H>b! (P!

+ABC*;(%<=>(?*6%(-$$0'"2=Q!?9;9L! !

HL! ! dL!Y0O*=-,Q!6L!5*''-'-Q!JL!S*$.$+]*Q!dL!C-=*Q!5L!

4+#-'PP*Q! CL! 4#A-$](Q! UL! 4,0+]*=%+#G$1,Q! [L!

4Ae2If-G-O-.Q!_L!4Ae,*]Q!-=1!JL!"L!1(%!4-=,(%L!

B*%0.,%! (P! ,#*! [=,(.(@/! 6.$@=G*=,! YA-.0-,$(=!

8=$,$-,$A*!?9;9L!8=!!:;+*!"#$%"&#'("&)*;(%<=>(?*

("*1"#()(23*@&#->'"2*41@5Q!A(.0G*!H>b!(P!+ABC*

;(%<=>(?*6%(-$$0'"2=Q!?9;9L! !

KL! ! JL!C*%g0$,-Q!JL!4,'(*Q!8L!5L!J'0OQ!-=1!5L!J(0,(L!

WF[[S4!(=!6@'**G*=,S-]*'a!B*%0.,%!P('![6Y8!

?9;9L! 8=! !:;+* !"#$%"&#'("&)* ;(%<=>(?* ("*

1"#()(23*@&#->'"2*41@5Q!A(.0G*! H>b!(P!+ABC*

;(%<=>(?*6%(-$$0'"2=Q!?9;9L!

! !