• Aucun résultat trouvé

Resonantly enhanced neutron intensity in a surface segregated polymer blend

N/A
N/A
Protected

Academic year: 2021

Partager "Resonantly enhanced neutron intensity in a surface segregated polymer blend"

Copied!
11
0
0

Texte intégral

(1)

HAL Id: jpa-00247967

https://hal.archives-ouvertes.fr/jpa-00247967

Submitted on 1 Jan 1994

HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access archive for the deposit and dissemination of sci- entific research documents, whether they are pub- lished or not. The documents may come from teaching and research institutions in France or abroad, or from public or private research centers.

L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non, émanant des établissements d’enseignement et de recherche français ou étrangers, des laboratoires publics ou privés.

Resonantly enhanced neutron intensity in a surface segregated polymer blend

L. Norton, E. Kramer, R. Jones, F. Bates, H. Brown, G. Felcher, R. Kleb

To cite this version:

L. Norton, E. Kramer, R. Jones, F. Bates, H. Brown, et al.. Resonantly enhanced neutron intensity in a surface segregated polymer blend. Journal de Physique II, EDP Sciences, 1994, 4 (2), pp.367-376.

�10.1051/jp2:1994134�. �jpa-00247967�

(2)

J. Phys. II IFance 4

(1994)

367-376 FEBRUARY 1994~ PAGE 367

Classification

Physics Abstracts

61.40 42.10 61,12E

Resonantly enhanced neutron intensity in

a

surface segregated polymer blend

L.J. Norton

(~),

E.J. Kramer

(~),

R.A.L. Jones

(~),

F-S- Bates

(~),

H-R- Brown

(~),

G-P- Felcher

(5)

and R. Kleb

(5)

(~) Department of Materials Science and Engineering and the Materials Science Center, Cornell University~ Ithacai NY14853, U-S-A-

(~) Cavendish Laboratory, Madingley Rd., Cambridgei CB3 OHE, U-K-

(~) Department of Chemical Engineering and Materials Sciencei University of Minnesota, Minneapolis, MN 55455, U-S-A-

(~) IBM-ARC, 650 Harry Roadi San Jose, CA 951201 U-S-A-

(~) Materials Science Divisioni Argonne National Laboratory, Argonne, IL 60439, U-S-A-

(Received

14 October1993, accepted 10

November1993)

Abstract. We have formed a resonant cavity for a massive particle, the neutron, in an attractive potential between a surface segregated polymer film and its substrate. Standing

waves occur when incident waves interfere with the waves reflected from the substrate. Multiple

internal reflections lead to an enhanced intensity at resonant wave vectors below the wave vector for total reflection. At these resonant wave vectors the enhanced neutron intensity incoherently

scatters from the hydrogen containing polymer of the potential well causing a marked decrease in the reflectivity. The position of the resonant dips provides

an aid to fitting the reflectivity data by restricting the possible scattering length density profiles. This phenomena may find application in the study of in-plane correlations by enhancing off-specular scattering.

Introduction.

In the last six years neutron

reflectometry

has advanced the

understanding

of

polymer

science

by providing

the

depth sensitivity

necessary for a

rigorous

test of theories on bulk and interface

polymer thermodynamics

[1-4]. The excellent contrast between blend components

provided by

selective deuteration

gives

a

depth

resolution of10

1

for

sharp gradients

in the composition

profile

normal to the

sample

surface. Since

phase

information is lost in

reflectivity experiments,

educated guesses about the nature of the

sample

are essential to successful and reliable data

analysis

[5]. We have observed an

interesting phenomena

that can aid in the isolation of the

composition profile

that best fits the

reflectivity: resonantly

enhanced neutron

intensity (REN)

that occurs inside a

potent1al

well

during

total external reflection. Jannink [6] has

predicted

(3)

368 JOURNAL DE PHYSIQUE II N°2

z

~x

Fig.

I. Illustration of the reflection geometry.

REN for neutron reflection from the

potent1al

well formed

by

a

polymer

adsorbate in deuterated solution. REN can be

exploited

to

produce polarized,

monochromatic neutron beams

using

a

Fabry-P4rot

neutron interferometer constructed with

magnetic

films as

suggested by

Maaza et al. [7]. Flux enhancement has been demonstrated with

electro-magnetic

X-radiation in a

resonant bearn

coupler by Feng

et al. [8] and with a

stepped potent1al Wang

et al. [9] have

observed enhanced

X-ray intensity,

in a thin

lipid

film on a

highly

reflective substrate. We have been able to prepare

polymer

film

samples

that self-assemble to form structures

showing

strong resonances; we will discuss our

experimenta1findings

and suggest

applications

for the

phenomenon.

Since the

scattering

vector is

always

normal to the

sample

surface in a reflection experiment the

reflectivity provides

one-dimensiona1structural information. A neutron beam of

wavelength

is incident on a

sample

at a

glancing angle

0 m

(see Fig. I)

and the

reflectivity

R

(the intensity

of the reflected beam divided

by

the incident

intensity)

is measured as a function of the

perpendicular

component of the neutron wave vector k = (27r

/~) sin(0)

[10]. To model the

reflectivity

R

= [r[~, where r is the

amplitude

of the reflected wave ifi, the

time-independent Schr6dinger equation

fi2 ~2~fi

~2m

dz2

~~~~ ~~

is solved for the component of the neutron wave function

perpendicular

to the

surface,

where

m is the neutron mass and the

effective

incident neutron energy E

=

h~k~/2m.

Since

27r/k

is

large compared

to the

spacing

of

nuclei,

the

potential

can be considered continuous with 27rh~ b

~~

m V

where

b/V

is the

scattering length density,

the sum of all nuclear

scattering lengths

b in a volume V.

Inside a uniform

layer

the

perpendicular

component of the wave vector ki is

given by

k; = 47r

For an

infinitely

thick material of uniform

b/V,

total reflection of neutrons occurs for k~ <

k)

=

47rb/V.

In this case ki is

imaginary

and ifi is evanescent in the material. For k~ > 47rb

IV,

above the critical wave vector for total reflection kc, ki is real and the wave propagates in the material.

Consider a

sample comprised

of three

layers

that form a potential well with a

scattering length density profile j(z)

such

as shown

by

a thin line in

figure

2. The

probability density

(4)

N°2 RESONANTLY ENHANCED NEUTRON INTENSITY IN POLYMERS 369

8 8 8 8

«

6 6/< 6

6/~

~

~ ~ ~O i' ~~

~w~ ~

« ~w~ ~ j

2 2

~

2 2

I

~

-

~

O o O

-2000 o 3000 -2000 O 3000

depth

I

depth

I

a> b>

~~ 2

o

30 6 7

[<

j~ o 8

~

' 4

j

o 6 ~i

~

i I ' " Z

lo 2

~

o

I 2 -

m

o

' ~

o ° ~

-2000 o 3000 Do

depth Ao oooo ooo3 ooo6 ooo9 oo12 oo15

C)

~

~

Fig.

2. The probability density, ~*~

(thick

line) versus depth for a given value of the per-

pendicular component of the neutron wave vector, k, is superimposed over the scattering length density profile

(thin line).

The potential is based on numbers for deuterated

poly(ethylene

propy-

lene) [dPEP]/poly(ethylene propylene) [PEP]

mixture. ~*~ is calculated assuming

b/V

has an imagi-

nary component in the well of 0.00007

l~~,

a value based

on a well material of 90 i~ PEP and lo i~

dPEP. The surface barrier is 100 1 thick and the well is 1400 1 thick. The effective incident

energy E is shown with an arrow in units of b/V. In

(a)

k

= 0.0079 i~~ and is above the critical

wave vector for total reflection kc

= 0.0051 l~~. In

(b)

k

= 0.0035 l~~ The two resonant conditions

are shown in

(c).

The solid line is ~*~ calculated at ki " 0.0030 l~~ and the dashed line at k2

= 0.0043

l~~,

the wave vectors where the reflectivity R, plotted versus k in

(d),

is

a minimum. An instrumental resolution of

6k/k

= 0.05 is assumed.

ifi*ifi(z)

is

plotted

in

figure

2a as a thick line for the condition when the incident neutron has E

(shown

with an arrow in units of

b/V)

less than the surface barrier

potent1al

yet greater than the total reflection condition of the substrate Ec =

h~k)/2m.

The neutron tunnels

through

the surface barrier and propagates in the low

b/V

mater1al on the other side. In the well

region

ifi*ifi is a

standing

wave because of interference between the wave transmitted

through

the barrier and the wave reflected from the well-substrate interface. Since there is no reflected

wave in the

infinitely

thick

substrate,

ifi*ifi is constant in that

region.

When the total reflection condition is met, E <

Ec,

and E is greater than the

potential

energy for the well

mater1al, Ewejj, standing

waves with

resonantly

enhanced

intensity

can

occur. In

figure 2b,

there is

tunneling through

the barrier with the

boundary

conditions on

the wave function at the well sides

resulting

in little constructive interference between the transmitted wave and the wave reflected

by

the substrate. The

intensity

inside the well is less than

just

outside the

sample

where ifi*ifi has a maximum of

4,

the condition at total reflection

(5)

3m JOURNAL DE PHYSIQUE II N°2

fl120

(

~ loo

~~' 80 i'

E 60

)

w

40 E

I

20

§

P o

o oo2 o oo3 o oo4 o oos

k

(I")

Fig.

3. The maximum value of the probability density, ~*~, in the well is plotted versus the

incident wave vector, k, for the scattering length density profile shown in figure 2. The attenuation of

~*~ because of incoherent scattering is not included in this calculation.

in the absence of loss mechanisms

(incoherent scattering

or

absorption). However,

in

figure 2c,

a resonant condition is achieved. The well thickness and wave vector of the neutrons inside

the film are such that nodes of the wave function occur at the well boundaries. The neutron

wave is

internally

reflected many times,

constructively interfering

to

produce

a

standing

wave

with a maximum in the

probability density

ifi*ifi m 33 for the lowest order resonance, shown as

a solid thick

line,

an enhancement of

nearly

ten times the maximum value outside the

sample.

The

higher

energy resonance with two antinodes inside the well is shown as a dashed line in

figure

2c. The existence of even

higher

order states is

prevented by

the shallowness of the well.

The resonant wave vectors are

analogous

to the

eigenstates

of a square

potential

well. How- ever, since the

potential

has a finite thickness wall on one side, the states are not bound but have a finite lifetime. In

figure

3 the maximum value of ifi*ifi is

plotted

versus the incident

neutron wave vector k for

)(z)

of

figure

2. At each resonant k there is a

sharp peak

that corre-

sponds

to an increased lifetime in the well. The lifetime can be estimated from the

Heisenberg

uncertainty

principle

~

m

~

" hkAk

For this

)(z),

the lifetime at the lowest order resonance,

ki,

Ti * 1.30 x 10~~ s

and,

for

k2,

T2 * 0.27 x 10~~ s. We take Ak to be the FWHM of the

peak

at kn

(k;nc;dent).

If no loss mechanism were present in the

film,

R = I at k < kc and the resonances would be unobservable.

However,

if the well material is a neutron absorber or

incoherently

scatters

neutrons, resonant

dips

are found in R below kc. When the lifetime in the well increases on

resonance the

probability

of

being

absorbed or

incoherently

scattered increases,

decreasing

R at

the resonant wave vectors. The

scattering length

of a nucleus is modeled as a

complex quantity

b = a +

ill

where the

imaginary

component describes

absorption,

which is

significant

for a few

naturally occurring

nuclei such as

~Li, 1°B,

ll~cd and

15~Gd,

or incoherent

scattering

from nuclei with

spin

such as

hydrogen (protons). Figure

2d shows a linear

plot

of R versus

k,

for the

potential ) (z)

shown in

figures

2a-c, where

b/V

of the well material is

complex.

R is decreased

by

about 30 ~o at the first and 20 ~o at the second order resonant wave vectors,

assuming

an

instrumental resolution

Ak/k

= 0.05. We have observed

dips

in the

reflectivity,

indicative of

resonantly

enhanced neutron

intensity,

in a system that

naturally

creates a

potent1al

well.

(6)

N°2 RESONANTLY ENHANCED NEUTRON INTENSITY IN POLYMERS 371

Experiment.

With neutron

reflectometry

we

probed

the

j~(z)

of a thin film blend of

hydrogenated

and

deuterated

polymer.

The small entropy of

mixing

of

long

chain

polymer

molecules is

easily outweighed by

the

microscopic

difference between the two components of the system

producing phase separation

below a critical temperature. In

addition,

at

high

molecular

weights

the lower

polarizability

of the C-D bond

compared

with C-H bond encourages the deuterated

polymer

to segregate to the air surface. For a

sample

with one bulk

equilibrium phase

and

sufficiently long molecules,

surface

segregation [I, iii

of the

highly

reflective deuterated

polymer depletes

the thin film reservoir of

deuterium, reducing

the bulk

b/V.

For substrates with a

b/V

greater than the bulk

polymer,

a

potential

well is formed.

The

polymer

system we studied was a mixture of

poly(ethylene propylene), (PEP),

with its deuterated

analogue (dPEP),

in which

nearly

all the

hydrogen

atoms were

replaced by

deu- terium. The components had

nearly

identical

degrees

of

polymerization, NpEP

= 2140 and

NdPEP " 2360 [12], and were cc-dissolved in toluene at an init1al dPEP volume fraction of 0.137. The solution was then spun cast onto a silicon substrate that had been

stripped

of its native oxide and then annealed at 70 °C for 44 h to allow the surface

layer

to reach

equilib-

rium with the bulk

polymer.

The

samples

were cooled

quickly (m

4

min)

to a temperature of -55 °

C,

the

glass

transition temperature of PEP. Neutron reflection

experiments

were carried out at

this,

temperature to prevent any

change

in the

composition profile during

the measure-

ments.

Figure

4a shows a

plot

of R versus k for this

sample.

The inset

enlarges

the

region

of k < kc. The solid line

through

the data is a fit based on

j~(z)

shown with a thin line in

figure

4b. The fit was determined

by

an iterative process [2] and a detailed discussion of the

profile

will be

presented

in a future

publication

[13].

Immediately,

one notices in

figure

4a two

dips

in R below kc

corresponding

to the resonant conditions of the

potent1al

well shown in

figure

4b. The loss of reflected

intensity

in this

sample

is a result of incoherent

scattering

from the

highly protonated

bulk

polymer

film as the wave

undergoes multiple

internal reflections. In

figure 4b,

ifi*ifi is

plotted

with thick lines versus

depth

for the two resonant wave vectors. The maximum neutron

intensity

at the first order

resonance is about 64, sixteen times the

intensity just

above the

sample

surface. For this

instrumental resolution of

Ak/k

m 0.05, R is decreased from i

by

about 17 l~. For the second

order,

the maximum ifi*ifi QS 27 with R decreased

by

8 l~.

Discussion.

In reflection

experiments

there is

always

a

question

of

uniqueness

of

fit,

a consequence of the loss of

phase

information.

Although complementary experiments

with direct space

profiling techniques

are

best,

certain features of the data can

guide

and limit the

possible profiles.

For

example,

a noticeable feature of the data at k > kc are

oscillations,

or thickness

fringes,

a result of interference between waves reflected from the

air-polymer

and

polymer-silicon

interface. The

period

of these

fringes provides

a

precise

determination of the total

polymer

film thickness

and,

with the initial film PEP concentration, mass conservation can be maintained for each

attempted

fit.

The resonant features

provide

an additional constraint to the

fitting procedure

since the

position,

width and

depth

of the

dips

are

strongly

tied to the well

thickness,

the barrier thickness and the

hydrogen

density in the well mater1al.

Borrowing

from the case of the infinite square

well,

the resonant wave vectors or

eigenstates

are located at kn

= 7rn

IL

where n is the quantum number and L is the well thickness. In this

experiment

the

positions

are shifted

(7)

372 JOURNAL DE PHYSIQUE II N°2

jo

~~-l W

X'o~'

(

~o5

j~-2 f

~ ~

i

xli~

) li~

oj

G 2 3 4 5

~

~ -30-j

lo~ k(xlo A

j~-5

oooo coos cola o.ols oo20 oo25 oo30

k (Aa-j

a)

80 8

60 6

«

(~

£H ~

~~

w ~~

7

>

1

I j

20 / 2

2 -

I /

I /

-

o o

-2000 o 3000

depth

I b)

Fig.

4. Reflectivity, R, is plotted versus the perpendicular component of neutron wave vector, k, in figure

(a)

for the sample described in the text. The inset is a log-linear plot in the region of

total reflection. Neutron reflectometry measurements were performed using the POSY II reflectometer at the Intense Pulsed Neutron Source of Argonne National Laboratory [26]. The spectrum of wave

lengths in each pulse ranges from 3 to 12 I. Three incident angles were used to extend the range of k

probed. Error bars are not included for clarity. The best fit was determined by minimizing the x~ per point. Values less than 6 for data taken at each angle were achieved for the fit corresponding to the solid line

through

the data calculated from the

scattering length

density versus depth profile shown in

(b)

with a thin line. The neutron wave function squared, ~*~, versus depth for a given value of

the perpendicular component of the neutron wave vector is superimposed over the scattering length density profile in figure

(b)

at ki

= 0.0028 l~~

(solid

heavy

line)

and at k2

# 0.0042 l~~

(dashed

line).

The effective incident energy E is shown with an arrow in units of

b/V.

(8)

N°2 RESONANTLY ENHANCED NEUTRON INTENSITY IN POLYMERS 373

f 200

~

w

~ lso

. .

i'

. .

~w . .

% loo

. . . .

~ . .

~ ~ . . .

§

. .

"

.

j

50 . .

"

~

.

E "

. ".

.

« .

~ . . .

a . .

~ o "

o loo 200 300 400 soo

Barrier Thickness

Fig.

5. Using the real and imaginary components of the three layer potential of figure 2 the maximum achievable value of the probability density ~*~ at the antinode in the well is plotted for the resonant conditions ki

(squares)

and k2

(circles)

as the surface barrier thickness is increased while

holding the width of the the well constant at 1400 1.

slightly

to lower values of k

primarily

because one side of the well

(that

formed

by

the dPEP

segregation)

is of

finite,

rather than an infinite

potential height

and width.

Thus, subtracting

L from the total

polymer

film thickness

gives

one an estimate of the adsorbed surface

layer

thickness.

The amount of reflected beam lost to incoherent

scattering,

can be correlated with the

concentration of the

hydrogen-containing

PEP and the enhanced

intensity

in the well. This information aids

fitting

since the bulk

polymer

in these

samples

has a

b/V

less than that of the silicon and therefore does not

strongly

affect the

shape

of the

reflectivity

above kc. For a

qualitative understanding

one can examine the transmission

coefficient, T, through

a barrier derived

using

the WKB

approximation

in the limit where the

"optical"

thickness of the

barrier, A,

is

large

[14],

~n ~

~-2A

~~~~~

A "

~

lG(X)dX

and

~(x)

=

) jv(x) Ej.

The barrier

shape

influences the transmission

through

the limits of

integration,

which define the effective barrier thickness at

E,

and the barrier

height, ~t(x).

Since

tunneling

occurs with

higher probability

for thinner barriers and

higher

neutron en-

ergies

there will be a barrier thickness where the neutron wave function will have a maximum enhancement determined

by

the balance of two effects. Below this

optimum

thickness the barrier is

leaky:

the transmission

probability

of the neutron is

large

and the wave enters and leaves the well

easily.

Above the thickness for maximum

enhancement,

the lifetime of the neutron in the well is

high

but the

probability

of it

entering

the well is small and the

resulting

(9)

374 JOURNAL DE PHYSIQUE II N°2

enhancement is decreased. To illustrate this

point,

we

plot

in

figure

5 the maximum value of the

probability density

in the well at the two resonant wave vectors,

ki (squares)

and k2

(circles),

as the surface barrier thickness is varied

()(z)

of

Fig. 2).

There is a maximum at a barrier thickness of m 150

1

for

ki

For

k2,

the maximum enhancement occurs for a thicker

barrier than for

ki

at

(m

270

I)

since

higher

energy neutrons are more

effectively trapped by

a

thicker barrier. In Jannink's paper [6]

analytic expressions

for the

dependence

of T on a more

complicated profile

are derived and

presented

as three-dimensional

plots

of T versus a reduced

wave vector and a parameter

describing

the well

shape.

Thus

fitting

the resonant

dips

in the

reflectivity

below k

= kc

provides

added constraints on the form of the

j~(z)

over and above those obtained

by fitting

the data at k > kc.

However,

the resonance enhanced neutron

intensity

can

potent1ally provide

more than

just

information about the one-dimensional

scattering length density profile

when

coupled

with other

scattering techniques.

One

example

would be

experiments analogous

to those done

by

Wang

et al. with resonant enhanced

X-ray

induced fluorescence [9] where one could monitor

enhanced emissions of prompt gamma or

alpha particles

from neutron

absorbers,

similar to Neutron

Depth Profiling

NPD [15].

Thus,

the

depth

of trace amounts of a

specific

type of nucleus could be

separated

from the overall

scattering length density profile.

Resonantly

enhanced neutron

intensity

also shows

promise

in

breaking

the

ambiguous

in-

terpretation

of

specular

data and

providing

information

complementary

to

j~(z) through

en-

hancement of the

off-specular scattering

that holds information about strucjure in the

plane

of the

sample parallel

to the incident

beam,

x-direction of

figure

I.

Length

scales are estimated to be about a micron for the

grazing

incidence geometry. Substant1al progress is

already being

made to sort out the

origin

of

off-specular scattering

from these

in-plane

correlations. Wu

recently

derived

expressions

that relate

scattering

from interfaces with

in-plane density

fluc- tuations to the

perpendicular

structure

probed by specular

reflection as a means to limit the

possible potent1als

that describe R [16]. At

pulsed

neutron sources, where it is

possible

to

measure the

specular

and

off-specular scattering simultaneously, experimenters

are

recording

rich patterns that

result,

for

example,

from strong correlations between two

rough

surfaces of

a

bilayer

[17] or from ordered but

imperfect

block

copolymer

films [18].

We also suggest the use of REN to assist in

elucidating in-plane

structure via enhanced off-

specular scattering.

Since the lifetime of the neutron in the mater1al is

substantially

increased at resonance, the

plane

wave

traveling parallel

to the surface will have a

higher probability

of

sampling

the

in-plane

structure. With a

complementary

mathematical

analysis,

a

comparison

of the

off-specular scattering

on and off resonance may

provide

a tool for

sorting

out the

origin

of the

off-specular scattering

and thus

help distinguish

between different features of the

in-plane

structure. To broaden the

utility

of this

technique artificially

constructed

potential

wells would optimize the lifetime or

intensity

enhancement. Because the

degree

of confinement is affected

by

the surface

inhomogeneities phase separation

in

lipid layers,

where contrast is

achieved

through

selective

deuteration,

could be

investigated

with the membranes

deposited

on top of a low

scattering length density

well material.

In

addition, understanding in-plane

correlations in

polymer alloys

could benefit from the careful

study

of

off-specular scattering.

For

example,

the crossover from one-dimensional to three-dimensional structures

during spinodal decomposition

in thin films in the presence of

an attractive surface can be

measured, building

on the information from direct space

depth profiling

[19,

20].

Additional

topics

of interest include:

capillary

waves at immiscible

polymer

interfaces where the surface tension has been reduced

by copolymer

brushes [3,

21],

correla- tions within

grafted polymer

brushes

[22-24]

and deformation of

polymer

brushes [25]. These topics have been treated

recently by

theorists but have not been

experimentally investigated.

(10)

N°2 RESONANTLY ENHANCED NEUTRON INTENSITY IN POLYMERS 375

Enhancing

the

intensity

of incident neutron beams

using

resonant structures may well allow

in-plane

information on these to be obtained.

Conclusions.

An attractive

potential

well for neutrons was formed in a surface

segregated polymer

film between a silicon substrate and a

highly

reflective thin

layer

of deuterated

polymer.

At resonant

wave vectors, below the critical wave vector for total

reflection,

nodes of the wave function occur at the well boundaries.

Multiple

internal reflections increase the lifetime of the neutron thus

enhancing

the

intensity

in the well. With

long

lifetimes the

probability

of incoherent

scattering

from the

mostly hydrogenated

well material increases

leading

to a decreased

intensity

at the resonant wave vectors. The

reflectivity

features

provide

sensitive additional constraints for

fitting

b

IV profiles.

In

addition,

the

resonantly

enhanced neutron

intensity

may find

application

for

investigations

of

in-plane

correlations

through complementary analysis

of both the

specular

and

off-specular scattering.

Acknowledgments.

We

gratefully acknowledge primary funding

from the National Science Foundation

Polymer Program

NSF-DMR grant number 922-3099 with

additiona1support

for FSB on NSF-DMR grant number 895-7386. LJN is funded

by

a

Department

of Education

Polymer Fellowship.

We

appreciate

discussions with Sushil

Satija

and

Alamgir

Karim. The

reflectivity

measurements were done with the

help

of William Dozier at IPNS at

Argonne

National

Laboratory

that is

funded

by

the US

Department

of

Energy

under contract W-31-109-ENG-38. We benefited

from the use of the National Nanofabrication

Facility

and the facilities of the Materials Science Center at Cornell

University

both of which are

supported by

the NSF.

References

[1] Jones R. A. L., Norton L. J., Kramer E. J., Composto R. J., Stein R. S., Russell T. P., Karim A., Felcher G. P., Rafailovich M. H., Sokolov J., Zhao X, and Schwarz S. A., Europhys. Lett. 12

(1990)

41.

[2] Jones R. A. L., Norton L. J., Shull K. R., Kramer E. J., Felcher G. P., Karim A, and Fetters L. J., Macromolecules 25

(1992)

2359.

[3] Russell T. P., Anastasiadis S. H., Menelle A., Felcher G. P, and Satija S. K., Macromolecules 24

(1991)

1575.

[4] Reiter G, and Steiner U., J. Phys. II France 1

(1991)

659.

[5] Kramer E. J., Physica B. Condensed Matter173

(1991)

189.

[6] Jannink G., J. Phys. I France 3

(1993)1405.

[7] Maaza M., Pardo B, and Bardou F., Nucl. Inst. and Meth, in Phys. Res. A326

(993)

531.

[8] Feng Y. P., Sinha S. K., Deckman H. W., Hastings J. B. and Siddons D. P., Phys. Rev. Lett. 71

(1993)

537.

[9] Wang J., Bedzyk M. J, and Caffrey M., science 258

(1992)

775.

[10] Russell T. P., Mat. sci. Rep. 5

(1990)

171.

ill]

Hariharan A., Kumar S. K. and Russell T. P., J. Ghem. Phys. 98

(1993)

4163.

JOURNAL DE PHYSIQUE ii -T 4 N'2 FEBRUARi 1~~4 11

(11)

376 JOURNAL DE PHYSIQUE II N°2

[12] Gehlsen M. D., Rosedale J. H., Bates F. S., Wignall G. D., Hansen L. and Almdal K., Phys. Rev.

Lett. 68

(1992)

2452.

[13] Norton L. J., Kramer E. J., Jones R. A. L., Bates F. S., Felcher G. P. and Karim A., Manuscript

in preparation.

[14] Merzbacher E., Quantum Mechanics 2nd Ed.

(John

Wiley lc Sons, New York,

1970).

[15] Downing R. G., Lavine J. P., Hossain T. Z., Russell J. B. and Zenner G. P., J. Appl. Phys. 67

(1990)

3652.

[16] Wu W., J. Ghem. Phys. 98

(1993)

1687.

ii?]

Pynn R., Phys. Rev. B 45

(1992)

602.

[18] Felcher G. P., Goyette R. J., Anastasiadis S., Russell T. P., Foster M. and Bates F. S., Am.

Ghem. Soc. Abst. Papers 204

(1992)

PMSE0087.

[19] Jones R. A. L., Norton L. J., Kramer E. J., Bates F. S. and Wiltzius P., Phys. Rev. Lett. 66

(1991)

1326.

[20] Krausch G., Dal C.-A., Kramer E. J., Marko J. F. and Bates F. S., Macromolecules 26

(1993)

5566.

[21] Fleischer C. A. and Koberstien J. T., Am. Ghem. Soc. Abst. Papers 204

(1992)

PMSE0051.

[22] Ross R. S. and Pincus P., Europhys. Lett. 19

(1992)

79.

[23] Yeung C., Balazs A. C. and Jasnow D., Macromolecules 20

(1993)

1914.

[24] Marko J. F. and Witten T. A., Phys. Rev. Lett. 66

(1991)

1541.

[25] Fredrickson G. H., Ajdari A., Leibler L. and Carton J.-P., Macromolecules 25

(1992)

2882.

[26] Felcher G. P., Hilleke R. O., Crawford R. K.~ Haumann J., Kleb R. and Ostrowski G., Rev. Sci.

Instmm. 58

(1987)

609.

Références

Documents relatifs

More precisely, we find a two-step dynamics, where both the center-of-mass position and the width of the wave packet show transient localization, similar to the white-noise case,

Annales de l’Institut Henri Poincaré - Physique théorique.. of hamiltonian systems of differential equations) are described in literature on classical mechanics e.g.. A

Conclusions: Anti-black racial attitudes are a critical barrier to enacting health policies that 19.. stand to improve health equity in the

For a spherically symmetric and purely attractive potential, Calogero [1] obtained, some time ago, the sufficient condition. in which the choice of R is

A 3R2C network of the partition wall could also be obtained by connecting the 2R1C models associated to both parts of the wall when it is shared with a null heat flow plane and

We wish to make clear that our result, namely that Levinsons’ theorem is an index theorem, is quite different from a result encountered in supersymmetric quantum mechanics about

The zero potential surface for the Caesium Chloride charge distribution shares the same crystallographic symmetry and the same topology, as does the derived Mackay surface..

A sharp step of fi lm parameters such as e ff ective magnetic fi eld or saturation magnetization results in partial re fl ection of a spin wave incident on the step.. There is a jump