• Aucun résultat trouvé

Etat et usages de l'occitan au Languedoc.

N/A
N/A
Protected

Academic year: 2021

Partager "Etat et usages de l'occitan au Languedoc."

Copied!
40
0
0

Texte intégral

(1)

HAL Id: hal-00344810

https://hal-univ-lyon3.archives-ouvertes.fr/hal-00344810

Submitted on 5 Dec 2008

HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access archive for the deposit and dissemination of sci- entific research documents, whether they are pub- lished or not. The documents may come from teaching and research institutions in France or abroad, or from public or private research centers.

L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non, émanant des établissements d’enseignement et de recherche français ou étrangers, des laboratoires publics ou privés.

To cite this version:

Francis Manzano. Etat et usages de l’occitan au Languedoc.. International Journal of the Sociology of Language, De Gruyter, 2004, pp.63-89. �hal-00344810�

(2)

"!#%$&'!&()+*-,/.&010123)45)6*374)$")8(7.&0%9

:;=<?>A@CB?;=<D:FEG;HI@J<

K

;L@NM8@PO=<QSRE3HTHU<QSHVEHI@

K

O8Q<WHX<T>A:YIE[ZL<W>A<?OGHDH]\G:

K Y K

M8@J^[_L<D`=<

YaK ZLZ@JHVEGOLbcYIEGOM[_<T` K Zd@J<TO

ebfE=gShjiJkmlonJnChjp1hjqk

rstmujvwxtmy{zSu|tmw}~wjs€T‚uToƒ…„†s~u{Uy{zƒ‡fzSƒ‰ˆSujsŠz†s~u}~ƒ…‹c‹cƒ‚ŒzSŽŠ/Ltmjuj…‚u[3s‘€v[vuxtTow

‚wjs„zSu’‘“|”CuŠW}~u–•‚ŠzS}~u—rLs1su˜†uz~Š™u}~x“SwxtctmwPmujt‹–wjŒjƒ‚oujvujs{ŠW}~uŒuŠoŠ/u}šƒ…‹–‹cƒ‚Œz›Š/jœ

y{zSƒ†u{–Š#…ƒ‚u?z†s~u~ƒfŠ/‘†ƒžtmuLm‘†Œxƒ…‘†Ÿƒ…s~„zSƒfŠ/ƒ…y{zSuuŠƒ…}†u sŠ–ƒŽŠ/wjƒ…tmu?Š–‘z†tcv[ujs{Š/¡u—

rs¢˜†‘z†tctmwxƒŽŠ˜†wxtm…u|tD}~u¤£[…wjs„zSu¡}~‘€Œjƒ‚ujs¥~œ-v3w ƒ¦Œ~•oufŠ)z†s~u§wx˜~˜†uj‚owJŠcƒ…‘~s¨y{zƒ

˜~t™u{my{zSu¨wz~Š/‘~v[wŠ/ƒ…y{zSujvu sŠ©t™j}{zƒ›ŠA…w ‚wjs„zªu¨}•‚‘†Œ ™‘šs«Œjwxtmw¡ŒŠ/¬xtmufŠ–t/ƒ…ŒŠ/ujv[ujs{Š

}~ƒ…wj‚ujŒŠ/wj­cuj‚ouG}~u¡ˆ†ƒ‚ujs{Š]wj…‘~tP‡z†s~udˆšwxtmƒowjsŠ/uL„†j‘~„~tmwx˜~ƒ‚y{zSu}~wjs†VzSs’ujsmujv“†‚uy{zu–•‚‘šs

t™ujŒj‘~ss~wJ®ŸŠW˜†žz#=‘z&v3‘€ƒ…s€GŒjowjƒžtCujvujs{Š–¯J—°]u'‰w s±„zSuj}†‘€Œxƒ‰u s&™uxtmwjƒŽŠ²wjƒŸsmƒT–•oƒ‚}~ƒ…‘€vu'‰‘Œjw{

}~w|s#Š/ux†‘z8Š/u|†Œjwjs{Š/‘~s~œ{Š/ux…‚u˜†wxtfŠ/ƒ…u}~u}~x˜†wxt–Š/uxvu sŠ/œ~Œjuy{zSƒ~˜†uz~г}•owjƒ…o‚uz†tPFŒj‘šs}{zƒ…tmu

–•¡y{zƒžˆSwj‚u sŒjuowjs±„zuj}~‘†Œjƒ…ujs´µ˜wŠ/‘~ƒoN—¶z’vƒouJz€·uJŠ#˜†‘z†t‡y{zSux…y{zSu#zSs€T™uz‚ujvujs{Š/œ€…u

‚wjs„zSu¡}~‘€Œjƒ‚ujs6u{fЏ˜†uz~Š/¹/ºNŠ–tmu‰utmux˜~tm{CujsŠ/wxs{Š»wjŒŠ‚zSujD}~u¼–•owjs~Œjƒ‚ujs~s†u½‚wjs„zSu¾}~u

Š–t/‘z~“†wj}~‘z~tP™œ-}{zÀ¿T‘~vLŠ/§}~u§ÁV‘z†…‘zmu§uŠ/Œ±—ŽœµŒju§y{zSƒ%–z†˜~˜†‘ª™u§}~u{¦Œj‘~s~s~wjƒJmwjs~Œju

~ƒ–Š/‘štcƒ‰y{zSu{TuŠ]…ƒŽŠŠ/xtmw|ƒžtmu{Uy{zSudŠ/‘z±Š…uv[‘†s~}~uLs•‚wL˜†w|—ÂDwjƒoVŠ/‘zŠFŒjux…w=tmu{fŠ/uŠ–~j‘~tcƒ…y{zSujœ

Œ¡wxtW}~wxs‚uW‹cwjƒŽŠmW–•wx˜~˜†ujo‚wŠ/ƒ…‘~s-s•‚ufŠ]tmuŠ/uxszSu8y{zSu˜SwxtTÃ~ÄÅ}~u{T˜†uxtP™‘šs~suWujsy{zºŠ/¡u{

‰‘štPF}•‰zSsm‘~s~}~w|„†uŒj‘šs}{zƒ›Šujs1Æ|Ç~Ç#ÆWuŠy{zSus~‘z‡u·~˜~‰‘€ƒŽŠ/uxtm‘~s€³˜€Žz#“šwN—

°W•‚wx˜~˜Su …‚wŠ/ƒ…‘~sÈ£[‘†ŒjŒjƒŽŠ/wxs¥«ufŠAv[ujƒ‚o‚uz†tmujœ"su¼muxt™w ƒ›Š/¹cŒjuy{zSu¨˜†wxtmŒju+y{z•ouj…u

N•oƒov[˜†‘mu’’ujsˆ†ƒžtm‘~s©Æ|É)‹–‘€ƒ˜€žz=}~u˜†uxtP™‘šs~su=}~wjs€=‚w'tm|„€ƒ…‘~s)‘“muxtcˆšju’­xÆ|ÇÄÊ}~u{

™‘šs}~{c¯N—ÂDwjƒGu …‚uµu–Š/‘z†tmŒjuµ}~u7/ƒŸv[˜†oƒ…‹cƒ‚ŒwŠ–ƒ…‘~sw¡“±zmƒžˆSujœIŒjwxtGwz~Š/wxsЁ…w’˜~tmjŒ¡j}~ujs{Š/u

Jˆ†‘†y{zSuLuxs[˜~tmƒ…‘~tmƒŽŠ/L…wtmx„†ƒ…‘€suŠ‡…u=…‘€Œ¡w ‰œwz~Š/wxsЇŒjuj…uj¹/Œ ƒSxˆ†‘†y{zSud˜†Žz~Š/Ë{Ё‚uL}~ƒ‚w{cÌ–Š/¬jvu

„†|s~xtmwjˆ†‘€ƒžt™u3–•‚wx“fŠ–t™wjŒŠ–ƒ…‘~s’‚wL˜€›z#]˜z†tmu­f–•oƒ‚}~ju}•žzsu3‚wjs„zSuzs~ƒ‚uy{zSƒs•owL˜†uJz~Š/¹cºNŠ–t™u

”CwjvwjƒÍux·†ƒfŠ/"™‘z…w%‹–‘~tmv[u)y{z•o‘~sDƒŸvwj„†ƒŸs†u|¯J—I¿TuŠ‚Š/u%w|˜~˜†ux…owJŠcƒ…‘~s&£LzSs~wjs~ƒovƒmwjs{Š/u¥

Î ÏÐmіÒӞÔPÕIօÑ×mÕjØm×mӅÒÐ#ӛÕjÙmÚxÓÜۅÐJÝPÞաЀßjÐmіÒӞÔJÕI×mÕjàJáž×mӅÒÐ#Ú|Ð#âmÐۅÐmãÛ…Ð×äj×mџåUÚJ׿ՠÒ{çèjé›êæë–èjì|é›ížîè¡ìJï

ð

îxñJë–èjì|ïjîžòµéŽó|êô¡î|õæíöîxïžîc÷Cøî…òù~ìJèP÷±ñJìæ÷±êú…ûoümýJþ†ÿPÕ jÝ

(3)

„†‘~v[vu ujs¢‘z~Š–tmuA…u&w{/˜|t惛Š/{&}•žzSs†u ˆ†ƒ…‘€‚ujs{Š/u ~ƒ–Š/‘šƒžt™u }~u ‚w Š/uxtmv[ƒ…s~‘€‰‘š„†ƒ‚u¤fz†t

‚wjy{zSuj‚ou”Cutmuˆ†ƒ‚ujs~}tmwjƒzSs˜†uz˜†Žz#“Sw{J—

†ƒ–•‚‘€st™zs~ƒ›ŠI‚uT}~uz†· wx˜~˜†ujo‚wŠ/ƒ…‘~s€™œ‚uI˜~tm‘“†‚¬ vu{™‘šsŠIv3‘€ƒ…s€Wwjƒ…„zJ—³wxtVzs

sj‘€…‘~„†ƒomvu Œj‘~v˜†‘mjœ‡”mu"˜~tmj‹c¬|tmu&}~‘šsŒ&xˆ†‘†y{zSuxtz†sA£~‘†ŒjŒjƒŽŠ/wxs~¹c‚wjs„zSuj}~‘†Œjƒ…ujs[¥—Wrds

t™u{fŠ/uL˜†Žz]˜~tm‘€Œ|~u[}~uowLŠ–Ì±˜†‘š…‘~„†ƒou‚ƒŸs~„zSƒfŠ/ƒ…y{zSuL˜~tm‘~˜~tmujv[ujs{Š]}~ƒŽŠ/ujœuxstmzSs~ƒJmwjs{Š]wjƒ…sPƒ

}~u)v[wjs~ƒ‚¬xtmu"m‘z†˜€‰u%‚u{j‚ vujs{Šm}{zDŠt/‘~s~Œ)Œj‘~v8vzSsD­c‘zA}ƒ…wcÌSfŠ/¬jv[u)}~u%‚w%‰w s±„zu

}•‚‘†Œx¯uPŠWŒjuz~·7y{zSƒ}~jvwxtmy{zSujs{ŠT‚u‚wjs„zSuj}~‘†Œjƒ…ujs1}~wjs†–•ujs€Cujv“†ou-–z†˜~tmwj¹ft™x„€ƒ‰‘šsw ‡}~u

‚wjs„zSu}•‚‘†Œ—

 •oŠ/w|s{Ї}~c”C=u s˜†wxtfŠ–ƒ‚u=wx˜~˜z€Ìš8fz†t]ou[m‘~s~}~wx„†u}~u’Æ¡Ç~Ç#Æ|œ ”™uL}~‘€ƒ]wc”m‘z~Š/uxtIy{zSu‡”Pu

su[Œj‘šs†muxtcˆšu3˜†w–•wx˜~˜†uj‚owJŠcƒ…‘~s’}~u[£˜†wŠÍ‘šƒ¥œª˜†‘z†tfŠ/wJs{ЇtmuJŠ/uxs{zSuL˜†w|tÄ6}†u{m‘~s~}~mœ

u|s m‘†v8vu ‚w ˜~tmujv[ƒ‚¬xtmu }~u6w|˜~˜†u …‚wŠ/ƒ…‘~s fz†tŁ…u Š/uxt/tmwxƒ…s— °]w mƒ…„†s~ƒŸ‹/ƒoŒwŠ–ƒ‰‘šs

™‘€Œjƒ…‘~…ƒ…s~„zƒfŠ/ƒ…y{zªu-}~uµŒju1mŒj‘~tmuµu{Š=ˆ†ƒ‰}~u vvu sŠ=y{zšu-…u{=„†ujs€GŒj‘~sj‘†ƒ‰ˆšujs{Š=…w-‰w s±„zu

t™x„€ƒ‰‘šsw ‚uŒj‘†v8vu?zSs[v[‘€}~u}• u¡·˜~tmu{Cmƒ…‘€s[Ì~˜†uxt™¹ftfz†tmwj†uŠˆ†ƒo‚‚wx„†uj‘€ƒo™œª–Š–tmƒ…ŒŠ/ujv[ujs{г…‘€Œ¡w 

uJŠwzAv[ƒ‚uz†·AŒjwjsŠ/‘šsw —VÂDwjƒµŒju%˜†‘~ƒ…s{Š}~u1ˆzSujœy{z³•oƒ…=‹cwz~Š mujv“†ou¡¹ÍŠ/¹cƒŸ²wj}~vuJŠŠ–tmu"uPŠ

uJ·~˜†…‘€ƒŽŠ/uxtujsAm‘†Œ ƒ‰‘€…ƒŸs±„zƒ–Šcƒ‚y{zSujœ…u"…ƒ…s~„zSƒÍ–Š/u)}~‘€ƒŽŠ3wzPmƒ‚u1tmuj‹Íz™uxtmœWŒjwxtƒ…žzSƒ‹cuxt™w ƒ›Š

˜†u|tm}tmu…w‹–‘št™Œju}{z }ƒ…wcÌfŠ/¬jvujœ†Œjuj…ouL–z†tV‰wjy{zSujo‚ujœ†wz‹–‘šs}~œš£[‘†ŒjŒjƒŽŠ/wxsG¥8ƒ…smƒfŠ/u?Š–t/‘~˜—

jbfE! k#" i%$h%&a'"()(jl…k#*~q+* Y%*~q-, h)$-"(jR.i/"01&32p+*kml54- hjn76

°W•‚wx˜~˜Su …‚wŠ/ƒ…‘~s"}•‚‘€ŒjŒjƒŽŠ/w|s~œF“†ƒ‚ujs)tmx˜†wjs~}{zSuµwz¡”m‘z†t™}•ozƒ‰œVs•oufŠ˜†‘z†tŠ/wxs{ŠW˜†w{Š–t™¬{

w|s~Œjƒ‚u s~s†u±—8†‘~s%ƒ…s–Š/w …‚wŠ/ƒ…‘~s)uŠ=m‘~s"fzªŒjŒj¬Lt™u v3‘šsŠ/u sв’y{zSu ‚y{zSu{G}~ƒ:9wjƒŸs†u}•w s~sju{

™uzSoujvujs{Š/œ†Œjuy{z†ƒ†ufŠ˜†uz }~wxs†V‚w}{z†tm¡u}•žzsud‚wjs„~zSu—±rdsG˜†uz~Šs~jwjs~v[‘€ƒ…s‡‘“Cu|tfˆ†uxt

y{zSu …u6ƒ…sfŠ/ƒŽŠz~Š–ƒ…‘~s€ ™Œj‘€…wjƒ…tmu{Å­c–•oƒ…sfŠ/ƒŽŠz~Š–ƒ…‘~s zSs~ƒžˆSuxtPmƒŽŠ/wjƒ…tmu ujs ˜~tmujvƒ‚uxt6oƒ‚uz†¯mœ

}~ƒ…‹f‹/xtmujsŠ/u{wx„†ujs~ŒjuŒzSŽŠz†tmuj…‚u{mœ‚u{vj}~ƒowmœ‘~s{Š JŠ/XŠtm¬ux‹f‹/ƒoŒ¡w{Œ¡u{&fz†t1z†s§˜†owjs

cÌv“†‘€‚ƒoy{zSu¡œVs~‘zÌ1tmuxˆ†ƒ‚ujs~}tm‘~s€N—¶z¡”m‘z†tm}•ozƒ]ujs"uj‹–‹cuJŠ/œF• wx˜~˜†ujo‚wŠ/ƒ…‘šsmujv“‚u“†ƒoujs

w¡}~‘š˜Š/ju­fs‘šsµmwxs†TŒxtmƒJmujvujs{ŠmI˜†w|tc‹–‘€ƒc¯TuJŠz†s~ud“š‘šs~suL˜†wxtfŠ–ƒ‚u}~u{Twx“†ƒŽŠ/wjs{ŠmT}~w|s€VzSs~u

ˆšwfŠ/u t™x„€ƒ‰‘šsy{zƒ’ˆSw ­/u s+mƒov[˜€…ƒ‚‹cƒ‚w sŠ–¯&}~u ‚w<;3wxz~Š/uj¹==wxt/‘šs±s~u wJz>==wxtm}uŠ}~u w

? ‘~tm}‘~„~s~u§§–•o¶zS}~ujœ-‚u{Ds~wJŠcƒ…‹mDŒj‘€v[vu¤‚uDs~j‘†¹c…wjs„zSuj}~‘†Œjƒ…ujs©mujv“SoujsŠ&wJˆ†‘€ƒžt

ƒ…sŠ/x„~tmL–•‚‘š˜†ƒ…s~ƒ…‘€s[˜~tmƒŸs†Œjƒž˜Swj‚uLy{zSuL–•‚‘€Œ¡Œ ƒ›Š/wxswd˜z'ºŠ–tmuz†s~uL‚wjs„zSuŠ–tm¬{‡~‘†v[‘š„†¬|s~ujœšzSs~u

‚wjs„zSu=}~uLwz~Š/uLŒJzŽŠz†t™ujœwxsŠ/tcƒ‚uz†t™uLwz ‹tmwjswjƒI}~wjs]ŒjuŠ‚Š/udt™x„~ƒ…‘~suJŠv[ƒ…s~‘~tmju=}~ux˜zƒ

‚u ÂD‘~Ì~ujs¹™¶„†u©˜†wxt‚w ‚wjs„zSu swŠ/ƒ…‘šswjou±—¿T‘šv[vu …u m‘zSŸƒ…„†s~uA@‡Š–ƒ…ujs~s~uA;wjv[vu

­|Æ|Ç~ÇB~¯mœ€}~w|s€‡…w˜†wxtfŠ/ƒ…u?Š/uxt/v8ƒ…s†wj‚u}€u8C+DEFGF)HJILKMON/MPCKMRQ-SNUTVEFGW5X%ESYZY[H3\5\5EMSœ~–•oƒ…s†}šƒ‚Œju}~u

s‘ŠÍ‘št/ƒ…Š/D}~u ŒjuJŠoŠ/u"…wjs„zªuDu{fŠ[Š–tm¬{ x‚uxˆ†¡œ3v3º vu mƒGŒjuŠŠ/u&s~‘{ŠÍ‘št/ƒ…Š/&£s•owDwzSŒzSs~u

vufz†t™uwˆ†ujŒLCwŒ¡‘šs±s~wjƒJmwjs†ŒjuuŠ‡mw˜~t™wNŠ–ƒ…y{zSu¥S—

¶‡”m‘z~Š/‘šs†y{zSu%}~wjs†‚u"Œ¡w{}{z©°]wjs„zSuj}~‘†Œ1£[wj}~vƒ‚s~ƒÍ–Š–tmwŠ–ƒ…‹#¥D­/Œš•‚u{–Š[…w1tmx„†ƒ…‘€s

w¡}šv[ƒ…s€ƒ–Š–tmwŠ–ƒžˆ†u’}{z°]w s±„zSuj}~‘†Œj¹^]²‘zCmƒ…o…‘€sœU–z†tL‚wjy{zªuj…ou’s~‘z=s~‘ztmux˜†…ƒ…‘€s†‚u˜€žz

„†|s~xtmwj‚ujvu sŠ–¯mœf•‚wx˜~˜†ujo‚wŠ/ƒ…‘~s)u{–ŠwPfzSvu-mwjs€„~t™w s}€GŠ/wNŠmd}•5_jvujœ˜†‘z†t…wt™w ƒ™‘šs

uPmujsŠcƒ…uj‚ou=y{zSuL–•‚‘€ŒjŒjƒŽŠ/wjsw=Š/d‹–‘~tŠ/uxv[ujs{ŠFw{P™‘€Œjƒ…=L–•`;3ƒÍ–Š/‘šƒötmuL}{z°]wjs„zSuj}~‘†ŒjœuPЁ•‚‘€s

Jˆ†‘†y{zSuwj…‘~tP˜~t™u™y{zSu’wz~Š–‘~v[wŠ/ƒ…y{zSujvujs{ŠW‚wv[‘z†ˆ†wjsŒju’}{z ¿?‘~vLŠ/}~u’ÁV‘z†…‘zmujœy{zƒ

}~u[…wO==w{™Œj‘š„~s†u[wz+]Ëšs†u[uŠU}~u{Ìt™ s†¡u{Œ¡u sŠ–tmwx‚u{WwzbaGu ‚wxÌ7w8‹–‘€s}~8uJŠT‘~tc„†wxs~ƒoC

z†s&ˆ†|t惛Š/w¡“†‚u)Œ)cdz†t[~ƒfŠ/‘~tcƒ…y{zSuŒj‘~s€fŠ/wjv[vujs{ŠGtmwˆ†ƒžˆS%˜†wxt…u}šƒ™Œj‘z†tC}~u%–•d;[ƒfŠ/‘~ƒžtmu

‘~‹–‹fƒ‚Œjƒ‚u ‚‚u—

e

s•oujs’ˆ†w˜†wW}~u8v[ºjvu˜†‘z†tW}~ƒ…‹f‹/xtmujs{Š/uTtmx„†ƒ…‘šs†W}šƒ›Š/u{£3‘€ŒjŒjƒŽŠ/w|s~u¥~œz†s’˜†uxz

˜†ŽzWj…‘€ƒ…„†s~juU}~u8Œ¡u3£3ŒUcdz†t¥«ujs’vº vuLŠ/ujv˜Ty{zªuL˜~tm‘†Œxu{…ƒ…s~„zSƒÍ–Šcƒ‰y{zujvujs{Š/œy{zƒ

™u-m‘~s{вŒj‘~s€–ŠcƒŽŠzS¡u{=wz~Š–tmujv[ujsŠL–z†tL‚u˜†‚w sƒ‚}~u sŠcƒ›Š/w ƒ…tmugfŒjujo‚u{G}~u'–•‚‘zSufв­c}~‘~v[wjƒŸs†u

„†wmŒj‘~s¯mœŒjuj…ouW}{z)s~‘~tm}’­c}±‘švwjƒ…s†u8}~ƒŽŠ]£s~‘~tm}~¹–‘€Œ¡Œ ƒ›Š/wxs[¥¯WuŠUŒjux…‚u{W}~u8–•u{–ŠT­/}‘~v[wjƒŸs†u

˜~t™‘ˆšuxsjwj…¯J—

(4)

³‘z~tŠ/wxs{Š/œI‘~s&wJz†tmwxƒŽŠ[™w s†[}~‘z~Š/u ŠÍ‘t͊G}~uµv8ƒ…s†ƒ…vƒCuxt‚w-˜†uxt™Œjux˜Š/ƒ…‘šs&£=z†s~ƒŽŠ/wjƒŸt™ud¥

w¡ŒŠzSux…‚u%}~u)‚w%‚wjs„zªu%y{zSu)s~‘zˆ†ujs~‘~s}•‚¡ˆš‘€y{zSu|tJ—Gs©mƒ‚¬jŒjou1˜†žzŠ/Ë{Š™uz†…u-zs†u

ƒ…s†‹fƒ‚vu v8ƒ…s‘štmƒŽŠ/6}~wjs–•j‚ƒŽŠ/u m‘†Œ ƒ‚wj‚u6}~u¨t™x„€ƒ‚‘~s€+‚w s±„zSuj}~‘†Œ ƒ‰u s~su¾Cu v“†‚wjƒžŠ

Œ¡‘šs†mƒo}~|tmuxt=y{zSu’ow’‚wjs„zSu’…‘€Œwj‚ujœ‡Œju˜†wŠ/‘~ƒo=y{z³•o‘~s&J•‚u ‹/‹–‘št#¡w ƒ›Š}•‚ux·~˜z†tc„†u|t=‘z˜†Žz~Š/Ë{Š

}•‚wjs~jwjsŠcƒžt™œ?˜†‘z~ˆ†wjƒŽŠ3‘z¦}{z¦v[‘€ƒ…s€wxˆSwjƒŽŠG˜z ™‘z}±u{‹–‘štmv[u{[˜†žzwz~Š/u{[tmƒžˆ†wjoƒCuxt

­ˆ†‘€ƒžt™uL}~x˜†wPmu|t¯]…wL‚wjs„zSuLswŠcƒ‰‘šsw ‚ujœ…u=‹tmwjswjƒÍN—¶§‚wL‹–ƒŸs }{z

e

Fmƒ‚¬jŒj‚u=u suj‹–‹cuŠ/œ

Œ¡uŠµ‘†ŒjŒjƒŽŠ/wxs¹™‰w s±„zu¡}~‘€Œjƒ…ujs§JŠ/w ƒ›Š’z†s~u©‚w s±„zu&Š–tm¬{-z–zSujŸ‚u fz†t)‚uXŠ/uxt/tmwxƒ…s¤“†ƒ‚ujs§y{zSu

‹–‘~tfŠ/uxv3u sŠ=}~jŒ¡‘{Š/ju-}~w|s€‰u7cÌSfŠ/¬jvu-}~u{=ˆ†wj‚uz†tP[m‘†Œjƒ…‘€…ƒ…s~„zƒ–Šcƒ…y{zSu™œIŒjwxtGwˆ†wjsŠ?ŠÍ‘z±Š

t™ux˜~tm{™uxs{Š/wŠ–ƒžˆšu-}{z v[‘€s~}~ut–z†tmwj…œI}~u{=vƒ‚oƒ‚uz†·)˜†‘~˜z‚wjƒžtmu{Gwjs~wj…˜†~wx“†¬Š/uJ—[s~u’‚w s±„zu

£G~‘~tPWŒzSŽŠz†tmu¥~œ#£G~‘~tPƒ…s–Š–tfzSŒNŠ–ƒ‰‘šs[¥~œy{zSu8‚u8‹tCwjswjƒWuŠT–•L@TŒj‘~…u[˜z€“†…ƒ‚y{zSu}~uxˆ†wjƒ‚ujs{Š

Š/u|tftmwPmu|t  Š–tm¬{ Œ|‘z†tŠ©Š/uJtcv[u— [sutmujoƒ‚y{zSujœ"z†s ˜†‘~ƒ…}€ v[‘~tfŠ/œ"z†s~u¾uxsŠ–tmwˆ†u¾wJz

}~Jˆ†uj…‘~˜~˜†u vujs{Š/œ“~tmuj‹?zSs~uµvwjs~ƒ‚¬xtmuµ}~u’˜†wxtm…uxtŠ–tcƒžˆ†ƒowj‚uµuŠ‘štPG}•3_x„†uµ­Íz†s)£˜†wŠ/‘~ƒo‡¥¯

}~‘~s{ŠG‘~s©m‘z†~wjƒŽŠ/wjƒŽŠG‚u1˜€Žz[„†js~xt™w ‚ujvujs{Šmu)}~“†w|tæt™w{P™uxtŒj‘šv[vu)‘šsAm‘z†~wjƒŽŠ/wjƒŽŠmu

}~J“†wxtct™w{Jmuxtwz¦˜†‰z[ˆ†ƒŽŠ/u)}~u"Œju{ ‘~tcƒž˜†ujwz†·¦˜†w¡ÌSCwjsy{z•o‘~s ˜†‘~tŠ/wxƒŽŠ/œu|s&˜†wCCwjs{Š3}~u{

™wx“†‘ŠmWwz~·)m‘z†…ƒou|tP?ˆSu|tcs~ƒJ—¿T‘€v[vu8–•¡ŒxtmƒŽŠ”fzfŠ/ujv[ujs{Š @‡z†„†uxs ux“†uxtW­xÆ|Ç~ǯ™œ#}{z†tmwxsŠ

Œ¡uŠoŠ/u ˜†xt/ƒ…‘€}~u¡œÀz†s ˜†uJz ˜†w|tfŠ–‘zŠÅ£…u ‹–tmwjsjwjƒ mƒž„€s~ƒ‚‹cƒ‚wjƒŽŠ ‚u Ÿƒž“Sxt™w ‚ƒmvu uŠ

–•jvwjs~Œjƒ…˜†wŠ/ƒ…‘šsG¥—

Gs¼mƒ‚¬jŒj‚u ˜†Žz#&Š/wxt™}~œ%m‘zDs~‘ ̆uJz€·šœ7‚u§˜~tm‘“†o¬jvu ™u¤˜†‘mu }€u vwjs~ƒ‚¬xtmu

ŠÍ‘{Š/wx…ujvujs{Š5ƒ…sˆ†uxtCmu— e  Ì wÊ}~™‘št/vwjƒ¾zs Œ‘~s{Š–tmw{Š/u mwjƒomƒJmwjsŠ5uxsŠ–tmu z†s†u

t™ux˜~tm{™uxs{Š/wŠ–ƒ‰‘šs„†jsxtmwj‚u vujs{Š“†ƒ‚ujsˆ†ujƒo‚‚w sŠ/uuxs[‹–wxˆ†uzSt‡}~u…wowjs±„zSutmx„†ƒ…‘šs†wj‚ujœ†}šƒ…‹–‹ÍzCu

}~w|s-‰w"˜†‘š˜zS…wŠ/ƒ…‘~s~œ=uŠ[‚w"tmjwj…ƒŽŠ/&}~u"˜†Žz#'uxs©˜†‰zµvujs{zSu&}~u{ ˜~tmwŠ–ƒ…y{zSuµ}~u&ŒjuJŠoŠ/u

‚wjs„zSuD}~wjs€ ou1}~ƒ…‹c‹/xtmujs{ŠmµŒ¡‘€v˜†wxtfŠ–ƒ…vujs{Šm’t™x„€ƒ‰‘€s†wz~·»uŠµm‘†Œjƒ…wz†·¸}{z °]wjs„zSu¡}~‘€Œ—

ƒ…ujs[ujs{Š/ujs~}{z ŒjuŒ¡‘šs†fŠ/wŠs~uL™wz†tmwjƒŽŠ³ºŠ–tmu?ˆšwj…wx“†ouy{zSu˜†‘z†t#…umuzSS‘€ŒjŒjƒŽŠ/w|s~œ€…u‡vºjvu

‚ƒ…„€su{ }•xˆ†‘€Žz~Š–ƒ‰‘šs¸uŠ …u-vºjvu’tmƒÍ™y{zSuµŠ/wxsŠ˜SwxtfŠ/w|„†{’˜†wxtµ}~ƒ…‹f‹/xtmujs{Š/u-‚wjs„zªu{

t™x„€ƒ‰‘šsw ‚u{}~uªtmwxs†Œjujœ¦Œj‘šv[vu¼‚u¼v[‘~s{Š–t™u ™wxs€ w v“šwx„†u{§Š/‘z±Š/u½‰w¼…ƒŽŠŠ/xtmwŠztmu

™‘€Œjƒ…‘~…ƒ…s~„zƒfŠ/ƒ…y{zªu}~u{#ˆ†ƒ…s~„г}~uxtcs~ƒ…¬|tmu‡wxs~s†ju{N—

~bc:‡i/"0&32p+*kml54- hjnlonmk#"~i|l54- hjnIhxkk-2)"~i|loh¡n* 2{i¡h{qkmh¡n

zSu –•o‘~sA˜†wxtm…uD}•‚‘€Œ¡Œ ƒ›Š/wxs¸‘z¤}~uX…wjs±„zSuj}~‘€Œjƒ‚ujs~œ‘{z¤}•o‘†ŒjŒjƒŽŠ/wxs¹c…wjs„zªuj}~‘€Œjƒ…ujs

Œ¡‘šv[vuI”PuŠ/uxs}’L‚u3‹–wjƒ…tmujœS‘šs u{fŠFu s[˜~tmCu sŒju=}•žzsƒ}~ƒ…‘€v[utm‘€v3w stmwŠ‚Š/wjŒx~Š/wxsŠ/Ë{Їwz

„†wj……‘†¹ftm‘~v[wjs1­/‘šs1‚u’Œj‚w{Jmuwj…‘štC}~wjs‚u£„†wjo‰‘€¹ft™‘vwjs1vxtmƒ‚}~ƒ…‘€s~wj†¥¯mœŠ/w|s{Š–Ë{ŠUv8ƒ=

˜†w|tfŠ=­fƒ…T}~uxˆ†ƒ‚ujs{ŠGwj…‘~tP£3‘€ŒjŒ|ƒŽŠ/wxs~‘†¹ftm‘~v[wjs¥ Œ uU9 ³ƒuxtct™u

ujŒc¯J—

ƒ…ujs&ujsŠ/uxs~}{zSœT•Š/wŠ

}•‚u{/˜~t惛Їy{zSƒŒj‘~s~}~ƒŽŠcƒ‰‘€s~s~u=}€uŠ/uj…ouVŠ/w·†ƒ…s~‘†v8ƒ‚uIs•‚ufг˜†w{I‚uLvºjvuuŠ‡ƒ…su–Š˜†w{TCwjs€

t™u™”™w ƒ‚o…ƒ…tIfz†t‡…wvwjs~ƒ‚¬xtmu}~‘~s{Š‘šs˜†u|t#x‘~ƒŽŠ³uŠ‘~sLˆ†ƒŽŠ‚w‚wjs„zSu—

¿•‚u–гŒjuy{zSus~‘z#ˆ†u|tctc‘~s€F˜~tm{mu|s{ŠC—

rs©˜†uz~Š}~ƒžtmuy{zSuX‚w)tmj‹c‚u¡·†ƒ‰‘€s fz†t’–•‚‘€Œ¡Œ ƒ›Š/w s¹c…wjs„~zSuj}~‘€Œ|ƒ…ujsA}~‘€ƒŽŠ[˜~t™uxs~}tmuu{s

Œ¡‘šv˜Š/u’wJz&v[‘€ƒ…s†Š–tc‘~ƒ=wx·†u{[–z†tL…u™y{zSu =ƒo]‹–wz~ŠWs†jŒju{CCw ƒötmujvujsŠ˜†wPmu|tzs1˜†uJz&}~u

Š/u|v˜˜†‘z†tWºŠt™u8˜†uz ˜~tm¬{Wujsµvu–z†tmu[}~u[Œj‘€v˜~tmujs†}tmu[Œju[y{zSƒV™u8˜†w{J™u8LŠ–tmwJˆ†uxtP²ou

°]wjs±„zSuj}~‘€ŒuJŠm‘zs~‘#Ìuz†·—

! #"$&%&')()*,+.-0/&132546 879;:/&(=<>9?%2!*A@B DCFEG/&HA*A%)IA&7B2

?

wxsWouWŠzS}~uTtm‘€v[wjs~uW}~u‚w8‹/ƒŸs }{zJ

e

?mƒ‚¬jŒj‚ujœ…uŠzS}~uW}šƒ‚wjŒjt™‘šs~ƒ…y{zSu

uJŠŒx‘~v˜†wxt™wŠcƒžˆšu)Š/uxs}~u sА }~j‹–ƒ…s€ƒžt)zs “†…‘€Œ§y{zSu§‘šsy{zSwjoƒo‹–ƒ‚u „†js~xtmwj‚ujvu sŠ}~u

£G„†w ……‘†¹ftm‘†v[wjs vxtmƒ…}~ƒ…‘€swj¥—LK‘{ŠÍ‘šs†5ƒŸvvj}šƒ‚wŠ/u|vujsоy{zSu Œ¡uŠoŠ/uȊ/uxtcv[ƒ…s~‘€…‘~„†ƒou

M N±ÓžÐmÑoÑÐOÐmâ Pù~ìIïžìJèm÷±ñxêîJõPõPí›éžìJè|êxÝNÑÐCÒfÒÐCҚÞÕ¡ÓÜßjÐmіÒÍÓŽÛ‰×æÓ›ÑÐCҀÚ|ÐQPÑ‚×æÕ¡âæÐ GRTS Ý

(5)

™ŒjƒoujsŠ–ƒŸ‹/ƒoy{zSu}{zA„†wjo…‘†¹ftm‘~v[wjsDtmujŒ¬jou1Š–‘z’…u{' ‚jvuxs{Šm }&zs†u)tmj‹oz~Š/wŠ–ƒ…‘~sXzSŽŠ/xtmƒ‚uz†tmu

­–s~‘Š/wxv[vujsŠ#˜†w|t…u{˜†wxt–Š–ƒÍ™wjs‡}~ud‘†ŒjŒjƒŽŠ/wxs¯N— @]…ouu–Šuxs[uj‹–‹cuŠ³tmu|˜€…w¡Œjuxt‡}~wjs€‡‚uŒjwj}tmu

}&zSs~u"ƒ‚}~j‘€‰‘š„†ƒ…u%˜†‘~…ƒŽŠ/ƒoy{zSu1zswjs~ƒovƒ–Š/u"y{zSƒtmujŒ|~uxtmŒjw ƒ›Š[˜€›z#’zSs~ƒŽŠ/"}~u’…wjs±„zSu uŠ

ŒJzŽŠz†t™u{tm|„€ƒ…‘~s~wj‚u{3}~u ªtmwjs~Œju1y{zSu1‚uz†tPGtfz†˜Šz~t™u{[ˆšujs{ŠzSuj…ouN— ? u1ŒjuJŠoŠ/u-ƒ…}~¡‘€…‘~„€ƒ…u

Š/|v[‘€ƒž„†s~u‘~˜†ƒŸs†ƒ…‘€s3}{z’„~tmwjs~}[vw®…Š–tmu}~u‡ŠzS}~u{t™‘€vwxs~u‡}~uL–•|˜†‘€y{zSujœV==w{fŠÍ‘šsP³wxtmƒmœ

y{zSƒ†}~jŒj‚wxtmuy{zSuj…y{zSu˜†wxt–Šf

SF)SMVN \5H HJI:N)N)\3\5N MVN Y K NP\3NUYZKMUKVH5YTVS E7TOTVN/Y7KM/KVHdYTVS H:TVH

DSMESVI \ DKVSVI N TVS Y E\ MKIdH3EMKV\MVEYK[\3N[YE S\dKVH![NUY" IdNUMTVNUMI%SMVN

#

KY IdN+ILK$HdY7Y N%[H5NOTVEMI \5NUY FGES\5N)S&[Y

#

K[H GN Y Y[N('EMTVNUMIY S& IdESY!\5NUY(EH:MI`Y N/M

MVSKMVF)N/YHdMY NUMY[H)\5N N/MI T7Q*7KTGNUY,+

°]u[vºjvu­/wˆSujŒP@—~°]wjs„†…‘€ƒc¯mœ}~wjsIzs ‘z~ˆtmwx„†u[y{zSƒw…‘€s±„Š/ujv˜Œ¡‘šsŠ–tcƒž“zS

‹–‘~tmv[uxt‡–•ojoƒ›Š/udƒ…s{Š/uj…‚uŒŠzSujŸ‚u}{z˜†wx̆mœ†˜~tm‘š˜‘ªF}~u?–•oujs†Cu v“†‚u}~u˜†wxtm…uxtC‡}~u#tmwjs~Œ¡u f

- N I`KVHdMY IZKVHJI`Y.\5SY ES/ EH:MY FUKZKVFRI [H:Y/I:H 0SN)Y EMI(N1 HdY TVN2,)SMVH! F)N)Y

K \5NZY TVH

#

N[Y+NUM TVN)S43 Q* ES N)Y[HdMVFGHKVS5376 KVS8 H:TVH \dK \dKMRQ-SN T DEF9PKVS

E&7T \dK \dKMRQ-SN T DE::\ KVHdMY[HOMVE&9.)NUY T DK$<;UY \JN/Y IdN= NUY EF N IOE:d\>0SH

N,3?[H KVH5N/MI \ DK?' 'H!1 KIdH3EM TKMY \5NUY TVN)S43@,7Q-H3EM Y+BAMVN \5HQMVN

#

KRQ-SN NUMI

NUM)N%TVNC%E&ZTVNUKVS53 C SYZY7KF TVNC SY[YZKVF EMId\5S)EMVTVN( EMId\3S)EM KVSEDVST

TVS T K/I:N NUMITN \ DF7Y,;<[NGN)SVIIHRI[N F)EMVY[H:T<)N FRE& N SMVN \5H HJI:N NUMI[N \5N)Y

TVN)S53 Q* ES N Y+JESVIdNK'EHdY F)NRI3IdN TVHdY IdH:MVFRIdH3EM M DKL0S DSMVN

#

KV\3N)S& TN F)EM

#

NUMIdH3EMM

N)\3\5N%M DN/Y/IN)N)\5\3NO0SN*ES&\5N/Y\dKMRQ-SNUY \5HJI3IZKVH NUY,P +

Gs~uw|˜~˜†u ‚‚wŠcƒ‰‘šs Œj‘šs†fŠ/wxsŠ/uu{–Š]Œjux…‚u}~uL£[‚w s±„zSu}•‘†Œ¥— @]…‚uu{fЇ˜†w|tc‹–wjƒŽŠ/ujvujsŠ

JŠ/w“†…ƒouG}~w s†T–•d;[ƒfŠ/‘~ƒžtmuuJЇf•‚‘~s-mwjƒŽŠ]y{zSu…u=˜†‘€¬Š/u=ƒŽŠ/wjŸƒ‚ujs

?

wjs{Š/u­/Œx~uxˆšw –z†t?‰u e e

uJŠ e e e Amƒ‚¬jŒj‚u/¯mœ&Œj‘~v[vu Š/‘z mu{»Œj‘~s{Š/ujv˜†‘~tmwxƒ…s ‹–‘štfŠ/u|v[ujs{Џv[wxtmy{zS˜†w|t§ow

‚ƒŽŠŠ/xtmwPŠz†tmu}~uVŠ–t/‘z~“šwj}~‘ztPmœˆš‘€y{zSuG}šƒžt™ujŒŠ/ujv[ujs{Š]…w \5H:MRQ-SK T DEF)E†œ–•‰zSs~u}~uWm‘z†tmŒju{

}~u[–•owx˜~˜†uj‚owJŠcƒ…‘~szSŽŠ/xtmƒ…uz†tmu[}•dEFGF)HJILKM—¿TuŠŠ/u[wx˜~˜†ux…‚wxŠ–ƒ…‘šsœªz~Š–ƒ…oƒ™{u[[s~‘Štmu[x˜‘€y{zSu[uxs

wjŽŠ/u|tcs~wjs~Œ¡uwxˆ†ujŒ£[‘†ŒjŒxƒŽŠ/w|s8¥œu{–Їowm‘z†tmŒjuˆ†ƒÍmƒž“S‚uL}z’s‘€v¨}~utmx„†ƒ…‘€s~œ‚u°Twjs„zSu¡}~‘€Œ—

¿•‚ufŠGŒju1y{zSƒW}•‚wjƒo‚ouJz†tP[˜†‘ª™u'zSs"˜~tm‘“†‚¬ vu1}•‚w™”czfŠ/ujv[ujs{Š/œTŒj‘~v[vu%‚u{wx˜~˜†ujo‚wŠ/ƒ…‘~s€

–zƒžˆSwjs{Š/umœ#Œ¡u8y{z†ƒ‹–wjƒŽŠT}~ƒžtmu[[Œjuxt–Š/w ƒ…s†W­Íˆ†‘€ƒöt?˜†ŽzI“Sw{Wou˜†‘~ƒ…s{ŠU}~uGˆ±zSu[}~u ]—

u¡Œx¯Wy{zSu

–•w|˜~˜†u ‚‚wŠcƒ‰‘šsœ“†ƒ‚ujs[y{zSuv[‘€ƒ…s„†ºjs~wjs{Š/uy{zSuŒ¡u …‚u‡}†ud…ƒov3‘zmƒ…suŠ³}~u˜~tc‘ˆ†u|sVjwj…œ€s•‚u{fŠ

˜†w˜†wxtm‹–wjƒŽŠ/u˜†‘z†t³wzŠ/w|s{ŠC—

Gs~uÈwJz~Š–tmuÈwx˜~˜†uj…‚wŠcƒ‰‘šs w sŒjƒoujs~suÈ}~u¨owjs±„zSu{+}{z zS} wȏNŠ/«ŒjujŸ‚uÈ}~u

£[…ƒov3‘zmƒ…s8¥+­c‘†Œ—O\3N EY[HdM†¯N—’rds¨s•‚ujs{Š–tmuxt™w¤˜†w{¦}†wxs©‚u }~Š/wjƒ…)}~u©‘~tcƒž„†ƒ…s†u©}~u

–•w|˜~˜†u ‚‚wŠcƒ‰‘šsœ€v[wjƒV–•žzsu}~u‡Œjwz™u³˜~tm‘“šw“†‚u‡}{zµfzSŒjŒj¬#z›Š/xtmƒ…uz†t‡}{z’v3‘ŠufЁ‚u‹–w ƒ›Š

y{zSuD…u{1v3‘€ƒ…s†u{ }~u †wjƒ…s{Š/¹ÍÂXwxtfŠ–ƒ‚wj­Í°]ƒov3‘š„†uc¯ wz~· e uŠ ee ’mƒ…¬jŒj‚u s‘Š/wxv[vujs{Š

‹z†tmuxsвu s ˜†‘€ƒ…s{Š/u’}~wxs†‚w'vƒmuµu s)‹–‘~tmv[u'‚ƒŽŠŠ/xtmwjƒžt™u-uŠ”fz†tmƒ‚}~ƒoy{zSu’}{ztm‘~vwjs%swjƒÍJ™wjs{ŠC—

rs’˜†uz~Š]˜†ujs€mu|t?˜†w|tux·šu v[˜†‚u8y{zSu[}†uz†·+cdz†ˆ~tmuƒ‚v˜†‘~t͊/wxsŠ/u{W}{z e œ C+DQ

#

KMRQ-H:\5N TVN

DKVH:MIdW R NUKM uŠW…uSE; NOY S&OC%E;GF)NœIm‘~s{Šƒ‚JfzSu{=}†uµŒjuŠoŠ/uv3‘z~ˆšw sŒutmujŸƒ…„†ƒ‚uz#™u—rds

wc”m‘z~Š/uxtmwGy{zSuL‚u{I˜~tmujvƒou|tPVŠ–tm‘z~“†w¡}~‘z†tPUŒj‘~ss{z™‘šsŠTm‘z~ˆ†ujs{Š]‘~tcƒž„†ƒ…s†wjƒžtmuT}{z K‘št™}’uŠ

}{z K‘št™}~¹cr²zSu͊³}~u{³˜†w¡ÌS‡}†ud‚wjs„zSu}•o‘†ŒuŠ‡J•‚ux·~˜~tmƒovujs{г}~wxszsuL‚w s±„zSud‰‘€s„Š/ujv˜

T UVÝN±×æÑ‚Ó…ÒVXWÝmþ†×æÕ¡àJážÔJӅÒ)šó|ëcê$Ycéžî,Z‡ìJéží›ê([Jñ*\î–øêæè^]÷ê|Ý`_³×Pâ$ajÐc۞ۅРRjÝ

(6)

vwxt™y{zSju ˜w|tDŒjuŠŠ/u ‘~tcƒž„†ƒ…s†u „†j‘~„~tmwx˜~~ƒ‚y{zSu—°•žzs+}~u§Œju"Š–tmwjƒŽŠmD‹tmjy{zSujs{ŠmXu–Š&…w

˜†wj…wJŠ/w …ƒCwŠ/ƒ…‘~s©}{zA„~t™‘z†˜†u¿U¶=¹}{z¸…wŠ/ƒŸsS—a‘~ƒ…Œjƒ˜†wxtµu·šujv8˜†‚u"‚u"}~x“z~Šv[wx„†s~ƒo‹/ƒoy{zSu

}•žzSs Y H

#

NUMI)Y }~u

u|tfŠ/wxs~}}~u

‘~tcs­c}{zg³xtcƒž„†‘~tm}~œ‡-Œxuxˆ†wjfz†tGou8

ee WuŠ

e'ee

‚¯mœ

‹/wjƒmwjs{г•oj…‘~„Su}~ud…w„zSu|tctmu f

C N8\:KI%\3E QKVH:YI:N YTVN*KY[F)E&=

SN'KVH'SE\YN5'\3E&7Y

#

N/MVH

Q@\dKI H!0SKM KVSF \dK> KVSTVE&

N)\dYKVSUN)\:Y1^0SN'KME[NRI:NUMIdH!

C E&F KM N \5E EY[F KIQ-N9

Q \dKI H^0SKM

#

N)H Y E [N\:Y7KI

JNUMTKYN*K

#

H5\VEYG'N=PKIO

QI KVHRQ*7KM KV\5N7Q*ZKIQ-N

SKM

#

N)H1N F KIKMK NUM KI

- K

#

KV\3H5NZYNRI F K

#

KV\dYK=PKI<+

R DKVH N9NUKVSF)ES \5N I:NIYVN)S[NGS53PTVS[H:MIdN Y1^0SH 'KVHJI

#

NUMVH\3NUY5'N)SH3\5\3NUYNRI

\3NUY '\5N)S&ZY NRI%F)N)\:K2 NO\dK3IO0SKMT DNUMI:NUMTY+\dK EH5N TVNUY+EHdY NUKVS53 0SH'EMI

UY[EMMVN%+\5NGSN+F KMI<I7K

#

N[Y+\3N E FUKRQ-N9 NRI%FGN)\5K2 NO\dK3I0SKMTN

#

EH5Y

I:NUMIdNUY NRI%K

#

H5\3\5EMY T[N)Y7Y)YPY SN \5NUY ,UY NRIN Y SHdY(\3N)HdMbT DNUMIZKVHdM 0SKMTN

#

EH:Y7KMRQ/Y I7K

#

N[Y\dK FUK KRQMVN F VN

#

KV\5H5N<7YNRIVF VN

#

KVS53PK=EUY+

°]u{Š–tm‘z~“†w¡}~‘ztP]­f‘†Œ—I[E KTVE&7YN¯IwJˆ†wjƒ‚u sЇŒj‘~s€™ŒjƒoujsŒ{u=}&jŒxtmƒ…tmu=}~w s†zsuL‚w s±„zu

‚ƒŽŠŠ/xtmw|ƒžtmu tmuj‚wŠ–ƒžˆSujvu sŠ"“†ƒ‚ujs¼–Š/wxs~}~wxt™}šƒCjujœ u s¨„~tmwjs}~u ˜†wxtfŠ–ƒ…uŒj‘šsˆšujs{Š/ƒ…‘šs~sujo‚u¢uŠ

ƒ…sŠ/u ‚oƒ…„†ƒ‰“†‚uzsG˜†uz˜†wxtfŠ/‘zŠ­c}~u@Wc˜Swx„€sud

e

Š/wjŸƒ‚uujs˜†wP™wjs{Š˜†wxt‡…u˜†wẋ}†ud‚wjs„zSu

}&‘†Œx¯mœ#v[wjƒ=y{zSƒtmuxsˆš‘šÌ†wjƒŽŠWzsu3zSs~ƒŽŠ/ŒJzŽŠz†t™u …‚u’Œ‘šv[vzSs~u}~j‹cwz~Š?}~u8tmuxsˆš‘šÌuxt

z†s¨˜†wxÌ Œj‘€v[vLzSs~œ1ujsŠ–tmu …u e "uJŠD…u eee mƒ‚¬Œ ‰uN— @Vz~·š¹fv[ºjvu©y{zSwj‚ƒo‹–ƒowjƒ‚ujs{Š

„†|s~xtmwj‚ujvu sгŒjuŠoŠ/u‰w s±„zSu}~u£[Ÿƒ‚v[‘z#mƒ…s[¥[­c‘z }~u?£˜~t/‘ˆšuxsVjwj†¥~œˆ†‘€ƒžt˜†Žz“†w/¯J—

ÂXw ƒ Œu £[…ƒov[‘zmƒ…s¥¸}{z ÂX‘šÌ†ujs~¹–¶„u su }~‘†ƒŽŠ’˜†w{ ºŠ–t™u Œj‘~s~‹–‘~s~}{z wxˆšujŒ©ou

‚ƒov[‘zmƒ…s }wz¡”m‘z†tm}{zSƒ ­c}~ƒowj‚ujŒŠ/u }{z £s‘št™}~¹c‘€Œ¡ŒƒŽŠ/wjs¥±¯J—¸¿?uJŠŠ/u wx˜~˜†ux…‚wŠcƒ‰‘šs }~u

£[…ƒov3‘zmƒ…s8¥œ˜†uz~Š/¹/ºŠtmu˜~ŽzWy{zSuŒ¡u ‚‚u8}~u£G˜~tm‘ˆšuxsVjwj†¥µ­/ˆš‘€ƒžtT˜†Žz#T“†w/¯mœ#w˜†‘z†t͊/wxsŠ

‹–‘z†tcs~ƒ‡‚u{Œ¡‘šsŠ/‘ztP}•žz†s~uƒ‚}~ujs{Š/ƒŽŠ/[ƒŸsŠ/uxtm¹ft™x„~ƒ…‘~s~wj‚u3Š–tm¬{W‹–‘~tfŠ/u}~u{IŠ/u|tftmuy{z†ƒ#ˆš‘šsŠW}{z

ÂXw{Jmƒ…‹W¿?ujsŠ–tmwj…w¿wŠ/wx‰‘š„~s†u—rsµ˜†uz~ŠT˜~tmuxs}tmuŒ¡‘šv[vu–•‰zSs1}~u}~uxtms~ƒ‚uxtP²ƒŸs}šƒ‚Œu{

}~u=ŒjuŠŠ/uƒ…}†ujs{Š–ƒ…‹cƒ‚ŒjwŠ/ƒ…‘~s8zSs~ƒŽŠ/wjƒžtmu‚uL‹cwjƒŽŠFy{zu=s~‘€v“~t™u}~uLŒ¡wŠ/wj…wjs~ƒÍ–Š/u{”fzmy{z³•owJz’˜~tmujvƒ‚uxt

y{zSw|tfŠ[}{z 8mƒ‚¬jŒj‚uX™u%}~ƒ…tm‘~s{Š3uŠ™u"muxsŠcƒžt™‘šsŠ£[…ƒov[‘zmƒ…s‡¥©ujsDjŒxtmƒžˆSwjs{Š3ŒjwŠ/wx‰w sœ

wJˆ†wjs{Š]–•owj‹–‹cƒ…tævwŠ/ƒ…‘~s’Œj‘~s{Š/ujv˜†‘~tmwxƒ…s†u}{z Œ¡wŠ/wj…wjs’ujs8Š/wxsŠ]y{zSudŠ/ux˜†w|t8³‘šv˜Suzwx“tmwuŠ

–•e sfŠ–ƒŽŠz~Š}•L@WfŠzS}ƒoµ¿TwŠ/wj‚wjs€N—¼¿•ufŠŒjuy{zSuX‹/wjƒŽŠƒ‚Œ ƒ ‘šswxˆ†ujs{Šz†tmw¿Twxtm…u’¶tmƒ‰“SwJz

­|ÆA ¯ f

QM \5\5N< EY Y[EM \5E9 N)S( H N

#

KRQ-HI

SKM TVN)\ S)Q*EPKI:N7M \:K TVE\UK \3\5NRI*N

#

HdK

QM \5\5N< EY N)\DVNUM1E&[N7QK

#

KOF/KTK TVH:K

NÔPå¡ÑážÐµâmÔJÑoäxå ÒÚxÐCÒ#åJßjÑÐCÒÚjÐCÒLۅÑÔPåj×CÚxÔPå¡Ñ–ÒUÓöá?ւ׿å|ÛâmÔJÕÒoåjá›Û…ÐmÑLÕjÔPÛ‰× !TÐcÕJÛá#"›ÔPåJßjÑ×CàxÐ

ÐCҖÒÍÐmÕxۉӞÐmáÚxÐ%$[×mџÛ'&›ÕÚ|Ð%(Ó)JåjÐmÑWú R*,+ xÿ–Ý.-#Õ[äjÐcå|ۇÙmàx×mážÐTÐmՍÛ]ÒÐLÑÐcä¡ÔJџۅÐmÑ/(Ô{ÐmÑoÛþ†×mÖoÔJÕ|Û V

N4ajӛážÓŽäJä¡Ð(U#×mÑÚ10Tú GR|ÿÍÝ

(7)

Q FMIdH3FUY\5\3N EY[HdMYY[E& MVHdK

# K FUKTK MVHJI +

- DNUY IN/Mg\5H! ESY[H:M 0SN RKVH5\5\3HJII EM9 N H3N% F%[H! 0S KMTNMS

#

KVHdY \3N TVES53 \dKVH I

TVS Y[NGHdM PKI:N7MVNG\Q M \3H ESY[HdM N*[HdKVH:Y\5NDVNGHQMVN)SF K0SN ES&1NRI NH

#

KVH5Y

TVN FUKMI:H 0SNUY \5H ESY[H:MYF K0SN%MVSHI+

Gs~u’wz~Š–t™u’}~u{ˆ†wxtmƒ‚Š/{=}~u’‚w'‚wjs„zSu’}•‚‘€Œjœ…u˜~tm‘ˆSuxs {wj…œ‡w’x„Swjoujvujs{в}~‘~ss~

™‘šs s~‘€v5’ujs€™u v“S‚u˜†wxtzs ˜~tm‘€Œ¡u{P–z=}&ux·Š/u|s€mƒ‘~s)}~u‚w’}~js~‘~v[ƒŸs†wJŠcƒ…‘~s)y{z=‘šs)s~u

˜†uJz~Š˜~Žz]wj}švuŠŠ–t™uL­cŒ|‘~v8vu˜†‘z†t]…uŒjw]}{zµ£[oƒ…v[‘z#mƒ…s¢¥±¯IŒwxtIƒ…‹/wz#CCu²Š/‘zŠ/u“†‘~ss†u

Š/wJ·†ƒŸs‘€v[ƒ‚u—#°]u{LŠ–t/‘z~“šwj}~‘z†tPG‘šsŠzŠ–ƒ…oƒmµtmx„zSŸƒ‚¬xt™u vujs{ŠGŒ¡u'Š/ut/v[ujœVŠ–tm¬{=“†ƒoujs wŠoŠ/u{–Š/xœ

y{zSƒ|•ow|˜~˜€‚ƒoy{zSu)}~‘~s~Œ)%‰w†‘~ƒ…s†º%…ƒŽŠŠ/xt™w ƒötmu)}~™”™%vujs{Š/ƒ…‘šs~sju)uŠGs~‘~sDwzA}~ƒ…wj‚ujŒŠ/u)}~u

t/‘ˆšujs~Œju­Í“†ƒ‚ujs[y{zSu}~ƒ…‹c‹c|tmujs{Šm˜~t/‘ˆšuxswz†·[˜†wxt–Š–ƒ…ŒjƒŸ˜†ujsŠwJzv3‘z~ˆšu vujs{Š–¯N—

°]u{T‚ƒ…s~„zƒfŠ/uT}{z e 8³‘šsŠ]uxs€–zƒ›Š/uL˜†wxtm‚Ltmx„zS…ƒo¬|tmujvujsŠ]}~uL£˜~tm‘ˆ†uxs w †¥’­/‘z

£3w sŒjƒoujs ˜~tm‘ˆšuxswj†¥¯ ˜†‘z†t y{zSwj…ƒ…‹cƒ‚uxt …u Š/u·±Š/u{ w|s~Œjƒ‚u s† }{z „†wj……‘†¹ftm‘~v[w{s

vxtmƒ‚}~ƒ…‘šs†wjmœV}±‘šsŠTs~‘{Š/w|v8vujs{ŠW‚u{˜~t™‘€}{zSŒPŠ–ƒ…‘~s=}~u{=}~ƒŽŠmŠ tc‘z~“†wj}~‘z†tPN—ªÂXwxƒ=}~wxs=Œju

£G˜~tm‘ˆšuxsVjwj†¥xˆš‘€y{zSwz[Š/‘z~tcswxs{г}~u{.

e

¹ mƒ¬jŒj…u™œ€‚u{Š/u·Š/u{³˜†‘z~ˆšw ƒ‚ujs{гwzCmƒ

“†ƒ‚ujsµºŠ–tmu[}&‘~tcƒž„†ƒŸs†u[˜~tm‘~˜~tmuxv[ujsŠI˜†wxt/ou|t?˜~t™‘ˆšuxsjwj‚uœ#y{zSu[}&‘št/ƒž„€ƒ…s†u[…wjs„zªuj}~‘€Œjƒ…ujs~sujœ

wJz~ˆ†uxtc„†s~wJŠ/uuŠ/Œ—

,"$* A79

EG9')*6&1A@?*T<*A@1A/&%< &()*A%)1A*<

¿TuŠ‚Š/udv[wjs~ƒ‚¬xtmu}~uŒ¡‘šsmƒ‚}~xtmu|tV‚u{‡‚wjs„zªu{]uŠ˜†wxtc‚uxtP]}~ƒ‰ˆšuxtP‡}{z fzS}[}~uL‚w,tmwjs~Œju

‹z~ŠGuxs&v[ºjvu'Š/ujv˜Gtmuxs~‹–‘~tmŒjju1uJŠGwx‹f‹/wjƒž“‚ƒouµ˜†wxt[?wjŒxŠ–ƒ…‘~s&}{z  ‚ƒž“~tmƒ…„†u1­^]²‘zSv[wjs~ƒo‚‚ujœ

¶z†“†wjsu  uŠ/Œ—ܯuŠ7}~u ªtmj}~xtcƒ‰Œ ÂDƒfŠ–tmwjŠ–‘zŠ ˜†wxtŠ–ƒ‚Œz…ƒ‚¬xtmujvujs{Š/œ}{z†tmwxs{Š …w CujŒj‘~s~}~u

v3‘€ƒŽŠ/ƒo’}{z e dmƒ‚¬jŒj‚u—]²wx˜~˜†uj…‘€s=y{zSu’‚uI')\5H) [Nµu{–ŠŒ¡u ›zƒ‡y{zSƒIŒj‘€ƒmƒŽŠ²}~u’Œxtmjuxt=ujs

‚wjs„zSu’}•‚‘†ŒuŠW}~u[˜†uxtc˜†ŠzSu|tŒjuŠ‚Š/u…wjs„zSu—°]u‹/ ‚ƒž“tmƒž„†uu–ŠWwj…‘~tP‚w8tmJzs~ƒ…‘†s1}†uŒju

vƒo‚ƒŽŠ/wjs{Šm‡}~u…wt™u swjƒÍJ™wjs~Œjuv[‘†}~uxtcs†u—

°]w&‹–‘št™Œju&}{z joƒž“~tmƒ…„†uX‹z~Š }~u7Š/uxs}tmu&"tmu{–Š/wz†tmuxt‚wXs‘“†‚u{J™u"˜†uxtm}{zSu&}~u&ow

‚wjs„zSu}‘€Œ¡œ€v[wjƒI?Š–t™wˆ†uxtC#zsutmujs~wjƒJmwjs†ŒjuoƒŽŠŠ/|tmwxƒžtCu}•‚w¡“š‘št™}8‹–‘~s~}~juL–z†tV‚u˜†wxtm‚uxtP

}{z“†w]Ëšsu— @]svºjvuŠ/u vG˜I‘~s-™ujv3“S‚wjƒŽŠ‡Œj‘~s€CŒjƒ‚uxsЇy{zSu=ŒjuŠŠ/utmuxswjƒÍJ™wjs~Œju=}~uxˆSw ƒ›Š

 wx˜~˜z†Ì†u|tfz†t[ujs€Cujv“†‚u)}~u{˜Swxtm…uxtP3}€u1‚wjs„zSu1}‘†Œ1uPŠ=tmuf”mwjƒ‚ooƒ…t[’Š/uxtmv[u%fz†t3uz€·ª—

¿TujŒjƒCu²ˆš‘€ƒŽŠ˜†wxt‡u·šujv8˜†‚uLŒjuU9dÂDƒ–Š–tmwj†y{zƒSujs8˜†Žz]}&ºJŠ–tmud‰ud˜†‘†¬Š/uLmwjŽzSuJŠŒ¡‘šs†mwjŒxt™jœ

 u{–ŠWwŠ‚Š/wjŒx~3zSs†uŒj‘†Ÿ‚ujŒJŠ/u}~x“†‘~tm}~wxsŠT‚wxtc„†ujv[ujs{ŠW}†u…w tm‘ˆ†uxsŒu8„†j‘~„~tmwx˜~~ƒ‚y{zSuujs

s‘z‡…wjƒJmwjsŠ#˜†w|t‡u·†ujv˜†‚u?zs£3ÁFtmm‘~t‡}{z x…ƒ‰“†tmƒ…„†u¥~œ†u·†Œjuj‚oujsŠ}ƒ‚ŒŠ–ƒ‰‘šs~s†wjƒžtmuy{zSƒSu{fŠ

Œ¡uxtfŠ/wxƒ…s~ujvujs{Šˆ†wj‚wx“†‚uwzS¹c}~uj‚}~ud…w tm‘ˆ†u|s~Œju—

ÂXw ƒD‚w¤‹/wjƒž“‚u{J™u¤‹oz~Š u{CCu sŠ–ƒ‚u …‚ujvu sŠ }~u Š/uxs~}tmu§ mƒ›ŠzSuxt ‰u§ŒUcdz†tD}~u§w

t™uxs~wjƒJmwjs~Œ¡u }~u ‚w ‚w s±„zSu tm‘†v[wjs~u }{zÀfzS}¢}~wjs"z†s¨muŒŠ/uz†t„†x‘~„~tmwx˜~~ƒ‰y{zSu “†ƒoujs

}~JŠ/uxtcv[ƒ…s† }~u …w #t™‘ˆšu sŒjujœ’uŠ%}~u t™uxs{ˆš‘šÌ†uxt˜~tmu{™y{zSu ƒŸsxˆ†ƒŽŠ/wx“†oujvujs{ŠwJz~·¨wz~Š–t™u{

t™x„€ƒ‰‘šs†mœ}~‘~s~ŒAwz°]w s±„zu¡}~‘€ŒAy{zSƒs~‘zƒŸsŠ/xtmu{CCu ƒ…Œjƒ‚œ3zSs~u ƒ‚vwx„†u }~u©tmx„†ƒ…‘€s }~u

‚wjs„zSu¡­æc¯tfz†t™w ‰uj­æc¯I™wjs€‡wPmƒCu{F‘zŠ–t™wj}ƒŽŠ–ƒ…‘~s‡Ÿƒ›ŠŠ/xtmwjƒ…tmu{#“†ƒ‚ujsLˆ†ƒPƒž“†‚uJ—

ÓÜۅÙä¡×mÑU#ÐcÑ#/ ÔJážÔJÕWú R xÿÝ

NÑ×m۞Ó)å¡Ð-Õ¡ÔJÑT×PážÐ ׿åDÚ|Ùxå|ÛGڍåGÒÍÓæâmážÐJÝN±×PÑÐmãxÐIäjá›Ð W#ÝOªÔPåjÑâmӞÐú + GR|ÿ

ÑÐmàJÑÔPå|äjÐá#"Ü×mÕjâmӞÐmÕVւÑo×mÕjØm×PӅÒ~ÐcÛážÐä|ÑÔmßjÐæÕ¡Øæ×CáÚJ×æÕ Òšå|Õ TÐ#â a¡×™ä¡ÓŽÛöÑÐJÝ

(8)

1"$* +&*E>%)9?*E D*

ufŠdŒjujŽzSƒT}~u1owŠ–~¡‘štmƒ…u-£3‘€ŒjŒjƒŽŠ/w|s~u¥— e ]Œj‘šs†Œ¡uxtms~uµ}~u'˜†žz#

˜~t™¬{‡uxsŒj‘št™uowt™x„€ƒ‰‘šs[‘“™uxtcˆ†ju±—

rstmu|˜†wxtfŠ]}~uLwx·†uL˜~tm¡Œjj}†u sŠC—°]u j…ƒ‰“†tmƒ…„†ujœuxs˜€žzW}~udŠÍ‘zSŒxuxtIswŠz†tmux…‚ujvujsŠ

}~u©˜~tm‘ˆ†ujs¡wz€·šœ)w¢Œj‘€v˜Š/}~wxs ™u¦tmwjs„ }~u s‘€v“~tmuJz€·5‚wjs„zSuj}~‘†Œjƒ…ujsJ—’¶z

ŠÍ‘z†t/s~wxsŠ]}~u{ e uŠ.8‡mƒ‚¬jŒjou™œ–•oj‚ƒŽŠ/uLtmx„†ƒ…‘€swjoƒf–Š/u8mujv“†‚uLˆ†‘€ƒžtUu ‹–‹/ujŒŠ/ƒ‰ˆšujvujsŠI…u

 ‚ƒž“~tmƒ…„†u-Œj‘~v[vu'‚w1muzS‚u'ƒ…s†‹tmwfŠ–tfzSŒPŠz†tmu-m‘~…ƒ…}†u’}~u'tmufŠ/wz†tmwPŠ–ƒ…‘~s)}~u’ow’‚wjs„zSu’}•o‘†Œ—

? u{ jŒxtmƒžˆSwjƒŸs }~u%˜~t™u v[ƒ‚uxt˜€‚wjs©Œ¡‘€v[vu tm‘ª/˜†uxt @–Š–ƒ…uz¸­|ÆA ~É~¹xÆ|Ç~ǯ‘zA¶sŠ/‘šs~ƒ…s

³uxt–“†‘mŒ­|ÆA #Æ|¹xÆ|ÇBB~¯}~“±z~Š/uxs{Š?uNŠ™uŒj‘~s~‹–ƒžtmvujsŠW}~wxs‚uŒ¡wj}tmu‘zwz ˆ†‘€ƒomƒ…s†wx„Su}~u

Œ¡u-v[‘z~ˆ†ujvu sŠC—

?

u-ŒjuPŠ=uc˜~tcƒŽŠduNŠd}~u-Œ¡uNŠ‚Š/u'˜†uJtmŒjux˜Š–ƒ‚‘~s}~u'…wO]²ujs†w ƒCCw sŒjuµy{z•oƒoT‹–wz~Š

™wxˆ†‘€ƒžtt™u{mƒŽŠzSuxt‡uxs[…wt™ux˜€‚w)¡w sг}~wxs€I™‘šs3x˜†‘€y{zSu¡œ{Š/v[‘†ƒŸ„†s~u?zSs[ŒjwJŠ/wx‚w sœN‘€w|s¶Lvwj}~u

­|Æ|Ç~É ¯µy{z†ƒ…œLw|˜~tm¬{zSs~u"ˆ†ƒmƒŽŠ/uX‹/wjƒŽŠ/u&%ÂDƒfŠ–tmwj=­cŒ|†w ˜— ~œ£L°]u"˜†‘€¬PŠ/u&}~u t/‘ˆšuxs†Œjujœ

ªtmj}~xtmƒ‚Œ?ÂDƒfŠ–tmwj†¥~œ~˜~˜—Ç#Æ|¹cÇÃ~¯™œ€Š/wJ“†Ÿƒ›ŠzSs˜Swxtmwj…‚¬ ‚uu|s{Š–tmu#‡—jÂDƒfŠ–tmwjSuŠj—Rau|tm}~wx„zSuxtmœ

˜†‘†¬PŠ/uŒjwNŠ/w|…wjs+f

H:Y/I7KV\NRI N7TKRQ-SN% EH5\ TVN)S53PMVE& Y0SH[N/Y/IdN%/EMI KI3I`KVF /YES& IdES# ES&7Y

\ DSM \ DKVSVI N%+(DVH\5NE;RI:N FUKI`KV\:KM 'SVIT DSMVNOMKIdS& N\5SY ,H

#

N)SY[N NRIF)E&9 N

\3SY F)EMVF)NUMI<)NN IY[H\5N E;RIdN([E

#

N/MUKV\Y N \5N(%\3SY T5E&7TKMITVN KY[Y[H3EM

VS& KVHdMVNF)NUY TVN)S53 NUY+F)E&9 SMVH3NUMIES&/ILKMI TKMY+\dKBEH< N'EH%TKMY+\3N

.H N NUMIVESY HdKY= N7ERI:H 0SN F)E&9 N \dK IdN<1/N F)KI`KV\:KMVN SM N)S$[N NRI

N5N)\5\3NK NUMT[EHJILY1 NRI\dK IdN=[N E #

NUMUKV\5N<Y[ES

#

N)MI%\5SY QUM[NGSY/NONRI%\5SY

')FGEMTVN I[N/Y7Y7KVH3\5\3NUMI IdESVI:NUY TVN)S53 Y[ESY \3NUY EH< N)Y 7K1EMY TVN<Y E\5N)H3\ NRI Y[N

\:KVHdY7Y NUMI* KVHQMVN E\5\5N< NUMI$K\dK .H N N \3N)SN%KVS53'\3EVI`YY EMVE&[NUY+

CK"S[E

#

N/MVF)N NRI8\:K - KILKV\5E)QMVN M DNUY IdWF)NKY KVS 'EM T \5N7.H NKY Y[ESY TVN)Y

KYKN)FRI`Y TVH''[NUMILY N I1FGN YTVN)S43(E;RIdN)YMVN F KMI:NUMI5WH5\:YKY TKMVY \5N)YTVHdKV\3N)FRIdN)Y

TVN \:K .H N \dKMRQ-SN

ÂXw ƒ‚u‹/wjƒoo‚u{d}~™”C-mƒž„†s†wj‚ju{=­f˜~t™ ‹–|tmujs~Œju²‘z‘~˜{Š–ƒ‰‘šs†L£G˜~tm‘ˆšuxs¡w ‚ƒCw sŠ/u{¥

}~u=…wL…wjs„zªuL‹–joƒž“tP¡u s~sujœ€£t–z†tmwjŸƒ™wŠcƒ‰‘šs[¥ƒ…s}šƒ…tmujŒJŠ/uL}{z owjs±„zSuj}~‘€Œjƒ…ujs[˜~tm‘~˜~tmuxv[ujsЇ}ƒŽŠ

uJŠ/Œ—¯&m‘~s{Š7 …w§m‘z†tmŒjuA}•žzs†u©˜~tmƒmu }~u¸Œj‘~s€mŒjƒ‚ujs†ŒjuAuŠ7}~u t™u¡ˆ†ƒötPujvujs{Šmy{zSƒˆ†‘~s{Š

Œ¡‘šsˆ†uxtc„†u|tUˆšuxtPT‚w˜~tm‘†}{zSŒNŠ–ƒ…‘~s’}~u[‚wdŠ–~j‘~tcƒ‚u‘†ŒjŒjƒŽŠ/wxs†u—°W•L@™Œj‘€…wGrŒjŒjƒŽŠ/wjs~wu–Ї‹–‘šs}€ju

u|s1Æ|Ç#Æ|Ç~œ€•

e

s€fŠ/ƒŽŠz~Š}•L@ŠzS}~u{‡r=ŒjŒjƒŽŠ/wxsuV‰uLmuxtmwujs1Æ|ÇB —

Nu7sS•oƒ…sPƒ–Š/uxtmwjƒI˜†wLŠ–t/‘š˜&ƒ‰Œ ƒ=fz†t[‚u{[w/˜†ujŒŠm˜†‘~‚jv8ƒy{zSu{[y{zSu ŒjuŠŠ/uŠ–~j‘~tcƒ…u1uJŠ

Œ¡uŠoŠ/u¸jŒj‘~…u ˜†uz†ˆ†ujs{Š)˜~t™{mujs{Š/u|tJ— †wxs€D‚u{Dj}{zS‚Œj‘~tmuxt%ŠÍ‘z±Š/ux‹–‘€ƒo™œ’Œwxt& v[‘†smujsmœ

}~ƒ…‹f‹/xtmujsŠ/u{ }šƒ…‹c‹cƒ‚ŒzSŽŠ/{ wŒŠzSux…‚u }~u –•o‘†ŒjŒjƒŽŠ/wjs~¹c‚wjs„zSuj}~‘†Œjƒ…ujs ˜†uJz€ˆšu sŠ ºŠ–t™u

t™w ƒ‚m‘~s~s~wx“†‚u vujs{ŠUtmwx˜~˜†‘~t͊/juŒjuŠŠ/uw|v3“†ƒ‚wjs~Œu[˜†‘€…jvƒ‚y{zSu—&K‘Š/w|v8vujs{ŠWƒ…‡‹cwz~Š]“†ƒoujs

}~ƒžtmuy{zSu…w8˜†ujsŠ/uGŠ–j‘~tcƒ…y{zSu3zSsµ˜†uz1Št/‘~˜"cƒ…v[˜€‚ƒfŠ/uy{zSƒwŒj‘~s~}{zSƒŽŠW8˜‘ª™uxt‰uv[‘€s~}~u

‘†ŒjŒxƒ›Š/wxs’Œj‘†v8vuzs’v3‘€s~}~uŒ¡‘€…‘~s~ƒÍ™jœux·~˜†…‘€ƒ›Š/uŠ‡v[ƒf]ujs˜†ƒ‚¬jŒju‡˜†wxtI‚w8tmwjs~Œju=}†ux˜zƒ

‚w©“†wŠ/wjƒ…o‚uA}~u Âz†tmuŠ7­f‘¢‹oz†t™uxs{Š7}~j‹–w ƒ›Šm&wz†·

eee

1mƒ‚¬jŒj‚uA‘€ŒjŒjƒŽŠ/w|suŠ)Œ¡wŠ/wx…wjs~‘†¹

w|tmwx„†‘~s~wjƒWŒj‘€wj…ƒC{c¯Ttmu¡Œzujƒ…o‚uŒjuxtfŠ/wjƒ…s~ujvujs{Š]˜€ŽzW}•wj}{ˆ†u|tPCwjƒžtmuWy{zSu}~u[˜†wxtfŠ–ƒmwjs€=fz†t

‚u8Š/uxt/tmwxƒ…s—°•‚wj}~~mƒ…‘~s-Š–tm‘~˜1‹–wjƒž“‚u’}~u=…‘€ŒJz~Š/uz†tPtm|uj=Œj‘~s{Š/uxv˜†‘~tmwjƒ…s=}~u’f•‚‘†ŒjŒjƒŽŠ/wxs~¹

‚wjs„zSu¡}~‘€Œjƒ‚ujs¢©zs ˜~tm‘x”muJŠ}~u s~‘~tcv[wjoƒCwŠ/ƒ…‘~s¢y{zSƒ1‹–‘~s~ŒŠ/ƒ…‘~s~s~u vwjƒ…s{Š/ujs~wjs{Š%}~ux˜zƒ

˜†Žzmƒ‚uz†tJ]}šƒ:9wjƒ…s†u]}•‚wjs~s~jumœS}~u¡ˆtmwjƒŽŠI™wjsI}~‘z~Š/u=wx‚u t–Š/utTfz†tI‰uL‹cwjƒŽŠFy{zu=ouTvJŠ–~‘†}~u{

}•‚ƒŸ‚žz#–Š–tmwNŠ–ƒ‰‘šs[}~u–•o‘†ŒjŒjƒŽŠ/wxs[sS•o‘~s{Š˜†w{‡JŠ/}~u{˜~Žz‡Œ¡‘šsˆšw ƒ…s†ŒjwjsŠ/u{J—

? ƒ‚m‘~s’mƒŸv[˜†‚u vujs{ŠGuJŠG‘“|”muŒŠ–ƒžˆSujvujs{Š/œfz†tLz†s˜€‚wjs©fŠ–t/ƒ…ŒŠ/ujvu sЁ…ƒ…s~„zSƒÍ–Šcƒ‰y{zSujœ

y{zSuµ…w'Š–~¡‘štcƒ‰u7£3‘€ŒjŒ|ƒŽŠ/wxs†u¥ N•u{–Š=j…wx“†‘~tmjuµujs%t™jwjŒxŠ–ƒ…‘~s"wJz€· }~uz†·Dwx·†u˜~tmjŒ¡j}~ujs{ŠmJ—

?

wxs&–•‚‘št™}tmujœ’Œ•‚ufŠ1z†su Š–~j‘~tcƒ‚u y{zSƒ’tmuc”CuŠŠ/u }•‚wx“†‘~tm}¢uxs¢„~t™w s}~u ˜†wxt–Šcƒ…u§–•ow¡ŒŠcƒ‰‘šs

(9)

vƒfŠ–tmwj…ƒ‚u s~sujœuJŠÈ•‚‘~s Œj‘€v˜~tmujs} ˜†wxt–Š–ƒ…ujo‚ujvujsŠÈ˜†‘z~tmy{zš‘šƒf¢wjv˜†~ƒž“†‘€‰‘š„†ƒ‚u }~u

–•w|˜~˜†u ‚‚wŠcƒ‰‘šs©£G˜~tm‘ˆšuxsVjwj†¥~œ‹–‘€Œjwj‚ƒÍCwJŠ–ƒ…‘šs }~u"ow&‚wjs„zSu&}•‚‘€Œ&fz†t8zSs†u%˜†w|tfŠcƒ‰u"}~u&ow

t/‘ˆšujs~Œju1uJŠ/Œ—¶z†s&wz~Š–tmu’s~ƒžˆ†uwzSœT…w'Š–~¡‘štcƒ‰u-tmjwx„†ƒžŠ=wzCmƒT1–•o‘~˜Š–ƒ…‘~s"tm‘~v[wjs~ƒfŠ/ƒ…y{zu

Œ¡uxs{Š–tmwj…ƒCwŠ–tcƒ…Œ¡uy{z•‚ux·~˜~tmƒovujs{Š]wPmu/93“†ƒ‚ujs’‚uI˜~tm‘~˜~‘T}~u ==w{–Š/‘šs w|tcƒmœŒjƒŽŠ/L˜†Žz#Twz~ŠC—

Gs~u-Š/uj…‚u%‘~˜Š–ƒ…‘~s"Š/uxs~}~wjsŠ[)PŠ–‘z†‹f‹/uxt–•‚‘št/ƒž„€ƒ…s†wjoƒ›Š/"uxsDvº vu-Š/ujv˜Š–̘†‘†…‘š„†ƒ…y{zSu)uŠ

˜†‘~…ƒŽŠ/ƒoy{zSu}~u‚wd‰w s±„zu}•‚‘†Œjœ€Œ±•ou{–гŒju„†uxst™u}~udvujs~wjŒu{Fy{z•wtmx˜†‘~s~}{z„†…‘“šwjoujvujs{Š

‚w Š–~¡‘štmƒ…uA‘†ŒjŒjƒŽŠ/wjs~ujœ[s~‘Š/wxv[vujsŠ"™‘z‚w ˆ†u|tPmƒ…‘€s EF)F)HI`KMVEW E&PKMVN¸ƒoožz–Š–tmju©˜†wxt

³ƒ…uxtct™u

ujŒ— Nu-tmwx˜~˜†uj‚ou|tmwjƒujs y{zSu ‚y{zªu{[v[‘Šm˜†‘z†tcy{zS‘~ƒTŒjuJŠŠ/u'Š–~j‘t/ƒ…u1tmujowJŠ–ƒ‰ˆSujvujs{Š

t™jŒjuxsŠ/uu{fгŒjwx˜~ƒ›Š/w ‰u˜†‘z†ts‘{Štmutm|„~ƒ…‘šs3}•oŠzS}~u±—

¶˜~tm¬5wxˆ†‘€ƒžtÀ}~jŒj‚wxtm ‚u¾wx˜~˜†uj‚owJŠcƒ…‘~sB[E

#

NUM)KV\¢uJŠ \dKMRQ-SN T DEF s‘šs

™wŠ–ƒm‹cwjƒmwjsŠ/u{’–•‰zSs†u"uJЁ–•‚wz~Š–tmu­cŒjwxt w v“†ƒ…„z

/¯mœ ƒ‚uxtct™u

ujŒ"}~j‹/ujs~}©ujsAŒju8Š/uxtmv[u

–•w|˜~˜†u ‚‚wŠcƒ‰‘šs[}•‚‘†ŒjŒjƒŽŠ/wxs+f

- DNUY IIES& F)N)\:K 0SN \5N I:N1 N7\3SY KTG0SKI T D EF)F)HI`KM ES&gTUY HQMVN

\ DNUMY[N< \3N TVNUY K \5N%7Y . HdTVH3EMKVS53 Y[NM, KMT TN \3SYON/ME\5SY 6%\3NUY MVE&PY

TVNUY TVH''[N/MI`Y TVHdKV\5NGFRIdNUY Y[SY[HdY IdNUMI KVHdMY H K #

N)F>\3N)S&7Y Y[NUMY )F)H5Y+ - DNUY/I

T DKVH3\5\3N)S&7Y \DKT HdMVH:Y/IZKIdH3EM E KV\5N N)\3\5N)W .H N 0SH T;UY \3NF Y H ;)FG\5N \DK

F)EMYZKVF, N/M7[NGF)EMMKVHdY[YZKMIN IdESY\3NUY5'H5NK'YE<[HdTVH3E MKVS53 SMVN%YK)F)H'H3F)HJI!O0SHNUM

'KVH:Y7KVHJIOSM EMTVN K/I TKMY \3N X%E KVS& N%+%M K[\dK TVEMVF TVN!\3HdMRQ-SK

EF)FGHJI`KMK TVN KI HdK TVN NUYS\3H5FUK EF)F)HI`KMK TVNIKI HdK \5H:MRQ-SKVN

EF)FGHJI`KMKVN FGE& NOEMOK[\:KVHJIT D F)FGHJI`KMVH:K E EY7KMIKVHdMY H8\:K!\3HdMRQ-SK

EF)FGHJI`KMK \dK \5HdMRQ-SK QKV\3\dH3FUKE0SH TUY HQMKVH I \5N5' ZKMUKVHdY+

? •ow|˜~tm¬{ƒ‚uxtctmu ujŒux·†ƒfŠ/uz†s1ujs€™ujv3“S‚uy{zSƒ‡}~x˜†wJmu}~u3“†uwzSŒ¡‘z†˜1‚u{²£8‹–ƒ‚uj‹æ

vxtmƒ‚}~ƒ…‘šs†wJz€·[¥D}~‘~s{ŠGŽzSƒ‚¹™vºjvu1s~‘zu sŠ–tmuPŠ–ƒ…ujs{ŠG˜€Žz[~wJz~ŠC—I¿TuŠGuxs†mujv“‚u)wjv¬jsu%

t™ux„~tc‘z†˜†uxt«}~wxs€5zs s~‘z~ˆ†ujwJz Š/wx·†‘~s tm‘šv3w s ‚u¼ˆšwxtmƒ‚Š/{5„†j‘~„~tmwx˜~~ƒ…y{zªu{«­cuŠ

~ƒ–Š/‘štcƒ‰y{zSu{c¯W}†u8–•o‘†ŒjŒjƒŽŠ/wjsµ}•‰zSs~u˜†wxtfŠ/œuŠ]…uŒjwJŠ/w ‰w s }•‚wz~Š–tmu˜†wxtfŠ™—š°W•žzsµ}~uT˜†‘€ƒ…s{ŠmW}~u

ˆ±zSu[}~u ƒ‚uxtct™u

ujŒs‘z]tmwjv¬jsu8‚w[y{zSu{fŠ/ƒ…‘~sµ}~uŒuy{z•oƒ‚wx˜~˜†ujo‚u–•5EF)F)HI`KM" E 1NUM—

³ƒ…uxtct™u u¡ŒjŒxtmƒŽŠ³wxƒ…smƒf

F[\ NUY I TVH' 'H3F)H5\3NONUMbESVI N TVN Y, K N \3NOFUKILKV\dKM TVN \DEF)F)H I`KM Y H8\ DEM M DKVF)F)E&7TVN

KY \5N .H N Y[E/IPKVSAQKVY[F)EM 0SH MVESY

#

NUMVEMY TVN \5N

#

EH=(,UY NUMI5NASMVN

E& HQ-HdMKV\3HJI!

#

ZKVH NUMI [N<PK,0SK^\3N%+8F[\ Y[N \5N%7KVH'I .H N 0SN>\5N FUKI`KV\:KM

\5HI5I<7KVH N TVS EHdMVY Y[EH I&\5SYOTVH![NRFRI:N N/MIKVFRF)N/Y[Y/H \5NM SM FRF)H I`KM E -N/M

0SN F)N/ILKVHdMY K \5N[Y QKY/F)EMY F)E&E NOF)NGS53 TNUY%CKVMTVNUY ES TVNUYOS.,/M)N)Y,+<+

C N \5SYgY[H!I\3N Y N7KVHI NGSVIdW HRI[N T DKT NRI5I[N SM NUMY N \3NAEFGF)HJILKMVEW [E& KM

H:MIdN=EUTVH:KVH N NUMI[N \3N QKV\3\5EW E&PKM E [N!N MI TVHJI NRI \ DH & EW [E& KM

NUMY N \5N 0SHgF)E& [NUMT7KVHI TVEMVFbF)E& N MVESY

#

NUMVEMY TN \5N/ EMI[NO6

\ DEF)F)HI`KM E<[HdTVH3EMKV\ V\3N%MVE&7TVWEFGF)HJILKMV\5NQKY[FGEMON I \3N FUKI`KV\:KM+

e

Gu{fеƒ…v[˜†‘ªCmƒž“‚uD}•‚ujs{Š–tmuxt }~wxs†1‚u©}~Š/wjƒ…[}~u1ƒ…v˜†…ƒ‚ŒjwŠ/ƒ…‘šs†)}~ƒžˆSuxtPmu)}~uDŒ{u

}~ƒoCŒj‘z†tPN—dÂDwjƒo ‘~s }~‘€ƒŽŠ7‘“Smuxtcˆ†u|t"ujs§˜~tmƒ…‘~tmƒŽŠ/Ay{zuAŒjuŠŠ/u&Š–~j‘~tcƒ…uA‹cwjƒŽŠ7 s~‘z~ˆ†ujwJz

“šwmŒzS‚uxt‚uŒjujs{Š–t™u}~u8„~t™w¡ˆ†ƒ›Š/}~u‚w8ÂDj}~ƒŽŠ/uxt/tmwjs~ju[tP‘~v[wjs~u‹–tmwjs¡w ƒCuu s1“t惂Cw sŠIz†s~u

N†ÝOÐmâ |ÔPå|ßjÑ×Pà|Ð#âmÓÜۅ٠Nä±Ý +GRÝ

#å)JåjÐmá׿ä|ä¡×æÑ…Û…ÓžÐcÕ|Û#áöÐá›×æÕ¡àå¡ÐmÚxÔJâmӞÐmՀá›×Tßj×PтӞÙcۅÙáö×äjáŽå Ò ?ÙmтӎÚ|ӞÔJÕj×mážÐ €×må[âmÔJÕx۞×CâcÛ#Ú|ӛÑÐæâcÛÚJå

âm×mۅ×Pá›×mÕTúžÕjÔPۅÐ#Ú|Ð#á "×måJۅÐcåjÑÿÝ

Références

Documents relatifs

L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non, émanant des

L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non, émanant des

L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non, émanant des

L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non, émanant des

L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non, émanant des

L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non, émanant des

L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non, émanant des

L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non, émanant des