HAL Id: jpa-00208881
https://hal.archives-ouvertes.fr/jpa-00208881
Submitted on 1 Jan 1979
HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access archive for the deposit and dissemination of sci- entific research documents, whether they are pub- lished or not. The documents may come from teaching and research institutions in France or abroad, or from public or private research centers.
L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non, émanant des établissements d’enseignement et de recherche français ou étrangers, des laboratoires publics ou privés.
Magnetic properties and giant moment clusters in Be2Mn 1-xFex compounds
R. Jesser
To cite this version:
R. Jesser. Magnetic properties and giant moment clusters in Be2Mn 1-xFex compounds. Journal de
Physique, 1979, 40 (1), pp.23-38. �10.1051/jphys:0197900400102300�. �jpa-00208881�
Magnetic properties and giant moment clusters in
Be2Mn1-xFex compounds
R. Jesser
Laboratoire Pierre Weiss, E.R.A. n° 464 au C.N.R.S., Institut de Physique,
67084 Strasbourg, France
(Reçu le 19 juin 1978, accepté le 9 octobre 1978)
Resume.
2014Les propriétés magnétiques des composés Be2Mn, _xFex ont été etudiees sur toute l’étendue de concentration 0 x ~ 1 et de champ 0 ~ H ~ 150 kOe à basse temperature (T ~ 100 K). Une representation
des données d’aimantations en 03C32
=f(H/03C3) jusqu’a 150 kOe, a confirmé la nature inhomogène de la transition
magnétique observée antérieurement dans ce systeme. Mais les mesures d’aimantations à bas champ (0 ~ H 1 kOe) ont montré que cette transition était graduelle : évolution graduelle du paramagnétisme (x ~ 0,06) au mictomagnétisme (0,11 ~ x ~ 0,30) jusqu’au ferromagnétisme (0,30 ~ x ~ 1,00). Le moment
moyen 03BC des berylliures ferromagnétiques (0,30 ~ x ~ 1,00) décroît rapidement et de manière non linéaire
quand on augmente la teneur en Mn. Mais les valeurs supérieures à l’unité que l’on a trouvées pour le moment normalise du fer (rapport 03BC/x03BC0) indiquent que deux types d’atomes (le Fe et le Mn) peuvent porter un moment dans ces bérylliures. Les données d’aimantations des composés Be2Mn1 _xFex à x allant de 0,06 à 0,25, ont été analysées en termes d’amas magnétiques à moments et concentrations dépendant de la temperature. Nous avons
discuté les résultats insolites de cette analyse et nous avons tenté de les interpréter en invoquant les concepts (i)
d’amas à moments géants ayant leur propre point de Curie 03B8c, augmentant avec la taille des amas, (ii) d’impuretés
presque magnétiques devenant magnétiques en abaissant la température, vu les champs élevés utilisés ici
(H ~ 80 kOe), et (iii) d’interactions antiferromagnétiques à courte portée, reliées au comportement mictomagné- tique de ces composés. Tout l’ensemble des résultats obtenus dans ce travail, peut être décrit en termes de magné-
tisme d’environnement local, mais seulement dans un modèle adéquat, tenant compte de 2 types d’atomes por- teurs de moments (Fe et Mn). Il reste à élaborer un tel modèle au moyen d’autres techniques que les mesures
d’aimantations (spectroscopie Mössbauer, diffraction de neutrons, etc.).
Abstract.
2014The magnetic properties of Be2Mn1 _xFex compounds have been investigated over the whole concen-
tration (0 x ~ 1) and field (0 ~ H ~ 150 kOe) ranges at low temperatures (T ~ 100 K). The inhomogeneous
nature of the magnetic transition previously observed in this system, has been confirmed by means of 03C32 versus H/03C3 plots up to 150 kOe. But low field (0 ~ H 1 kOe) magnetization measurements showed that this transition is gradual : gradual evolution from paramagnetism (x ~ 0.06) to mictomagnetism (0.11 ~ x ~ 0.30) then to ferromagnetism (0.30 ~ x ~ 1.00). The mean magnetic moment 03BC of ferromagnetic beryllides (0.30 ~ x ~ 1.00)
shows a rapid non linear decrease with increasing Mn content but the corresponding normalized Fe moment
(03BC/x03BC0 ratio) was found higher than unity, indicating that two kinds of atoms (Fe and Mn) are able to carry a
magnetic moment in these beryllides. The magnetization data on Be2Mn1-xFex compounds with x ranging from
0.06 to 0.25, have been analysed in terms of magnetic clusters with temperature dependent moments and concen-
trations. The unusual results of this analysis have been discussed and tentatively interpreted by invoking the concepts of (i) giant moment clusters with their own Curie temperatures 0, increasing with the cluster size, (ii) nearly magnetic impurities which become magnetic by lowering the temperature, in the high fields considered here
(H ~ 80 kOe), and (iii) antiferromagnetic short range interactions related to the mictomagnetic behaviour of
these compounds. All of the results obtained in this work may be described in terms of local environment magne- tism, but only with an appropriate model which takes into account two types of magnetic atoms (Fe and Mn).
Development of such a model would be aided by the use of techniques other than magnetization measurements
(Mössbauer spectroscopy, neutron diffraction studies, and so on...).
Classification
Physics Abstracts
75 . 30C
1. Introduction.
-There are several alloy or compound systems in which magnetic properties are presently understood in terms of magnetic polarization
clouds (magnetic clusters) :
-
the inhomogeneous nature of the transition from
paramagnetism to ferromagnetism observed in such
systems, has been related to the existence of magnetic clusters ;
Article published online by EDP Sciences and available at http://dx.doi.org/10.1051/jphys:0197900400102300
-
giant moment clusters persist as superparama-
gnetic entities well into the paramagnetic composition
range, even in perfectly random solid solutions ;
-
the cluster concentration and magnitude increase
when the magnetic carrier concentration is increased up to the critical composition ;
-
the onset of ferromagnetism can be considered as
resulting from the ferromagnetic coupling of giant
moment clusters -;
-
these giant moment clusters have to be related to
local environment effects [ 1 ], [2].
Let us mention as a justification of the above
propositions, some typical investigations on such alloys or compounds in the papers referred to below.
In all these papers, the magnetization data on the investigated alloys or compounds, were analysed
with the concept of magnetic clusters and the results obtained were described or discussed using various
local environment models of magnetism.
The most extensively studied system is that of Ni
binary alloys, especially Ni-Cu [3] ; Ni-Rh [4] ; Ni-Cu, Ni-V and Ni-Mo [5] ; Ni-Pd [6]. Giant moment clusters
are shown to exist in other binary alloys, such as
Fe-V [7] or Cu-Mn [8].
It appears in several studies on MCX interme-
tallic compounds (with c ~ 1, M
=Fe, Co or Ni
and X being a non magnetic element) that giant
moment clusters can arise from excess M atoms
occupying X sites. A detailed study on Co,Ga com- pounds [9] shows the existence of non magnetic, nearly magnetic and magnetic impurities (Co atoms occupying Ga sites). The superparamagnetism
observed in Fe,Al, CoAl and Nival compounds was
also attributed to Fe, Co or Ni atoms occupying Al
sites [10].
The magnetism of other binary or ternary alloy
systems, which present a transition concentration z from paramagnetism to ferromagnetism, can be
characterized in terms of magnetic clusters. This is
the case of the Be2Mn1 _xFex pseudo-binary system.
We summarize briefly some aspects of previous investigations on these compounds. The ferroma- gnetic compound Be2Fe and the paramagnetic com- pound Be2Mn form an uninterrupted series of hexa-
gonal C14 solid solutions Be2Mn1 _xFex (0 x 1) ferromagnetic for x > 0.30 [11]. The critical compo- sition for ferromagnetism in this system has been
located at xc, ~- 0.18 by means of specific heat [12]
and magnetization [ 13] measurements. The properties
of Be2Mn1 _xFex compounds near the critical xCr
composition (0.06 x 0.25) have been attributed to magnetic clusters :
-
an essentially temperature independent compo- nent has been found in the specific heat ;
.-
the large deviations from linearity observed for
some magnetization 62 = f(Hla) isotherms showed that the ferromagnetism occurs in an inhomogeneous
way;
-
samples in the paramagnetic region (x = 0.11
to 0.175) seem to obey a simple model of cluster
superparamagnetism [14].
A more recent work [ 15] reports specific heat measu-
rements on Be2Mno.865Feo.135 at low temperatures (0.1 K to 23 K). The temperature dependence of the
excess heat capacity (anomalous term), somewhat
like a Schottky function, could be reasonably inter- preted in a magnetic cluster model.
The present work was undertaken in order to obtain
more information on the magnetic behaviour of
Be2Mn1 _xFex compounds over the whole concen-
tration range 0 x 1, with special regards to the compounds in the critical composition range for ferro-
magnetism (0.06 x 0.25). Therefore, we have
carried out a systematic magnetization study on these beryllides over the whole field range 0.00 to 150 kOe at low temperatures (T 100 K). After a brief des- cription of the experimental procedures (section 2),
we report in section 3 the new series of magnetization
measurements on our Be2Mn1 _xFex samples (0.06 x 1.00) in fields up to 150 kOe at low temperatures (T 100 K). The high field magneti-
zation measurements offer a more accurate deter- mination of the saturation magnetization by allowing
a true evaluation of the superposed paramagnetic xH(T ) susceptibility. As will be seen in section 3,
we simplify our Q(H, T) data analysis by attributing
the main part y(H, T ) of the magnetization to clusters
assumed to exist in all the investigated beryllides (0.042 x 1.00) in different magnetic states (super- paramagnetic, -mictomagnetic or ferromagnetic, depending on T and x). The new measurements in low fields (0 H 1 kOe) enabled us to observe micto- magnetic behaviour on Be2Mn1 _xFex samples with
0.11 x 0.30 at low temperatures (section 4). The
occurrence of mictomagnetism was ignored in our
earlier investigations [13] on these compounds.
Section 5 deals with the magnetization data analysis
on Fe rich beryllides (0.30 x 1.00). A detailed analysis of the cluster superparamagnetism in beryl-
lides with x around xCr (0.06 x 0.25) is presented
in section 6. The unusual results of this analysis (clusters with average moments and concentrations
depending on T) are discussed and tentatively inter- preted in section 7. Finally, a summary and a conclu- sion are given in section 8.
2. Expérimental procedures.
-The Be2Mn1 _xFex samples were prepared by melting together appro- priate amounts of the pure constituents [11]. All the beryllides have the expected hexagonal C14 structure
without any parasitic phase, as shown by X rays
analysis and Curie temperature measurements. All
samples were slowly cooled (with a rate of about
150 °C . h -1) after annealing in an argon atmosphere
at 1 100°C for 48 h. Such a heat treatment cannot exclude any partial ordering in our samples, so we
have to expect some deviation from complete random
solid solutions. But this heat treatment ensures very
homogeneous samples.
Magnetization measurements were carried out on
ellipsoidal samples at different temperatures between 1.7 K and 100 K in the field range 0.00 to 150 kOe.
Two types of apparatus were necessary to cover such
a range of fields and temperatures. The measurements in low and moderate fields (0 H 20 kOe) between
1.7 K and 120 K were performed with a temperature controlled Foner type vibrating sample magnetometer developed in our laboratory [16], [17] and the measu-
rements in high fields (H 150 k0e) at temperatures between 4.2 K and 44 K (or 100 K for three samples)
were performed with the experimental set up at the S.N.C.I. (Grenoble, France) described elsewhere [18].
The two sets of apparatus were calibrated against Gd2o3 [19] and Ni [20] standards. The relative uncer-
tainty of our magnetization a(H, T) versus tempe-
rature and field measurements is estimated to be less than 2 %.
3. Général features of the magnetization.
-First,
we summarize briefly some results on dilute Be2Mn1 _xFex compounds (x 0.042) in order to
obtain the concentration where giant moment clusters
appear. Paramagnetic behaviour was observed over the
entire temperature range 4.2 K to 1 100 K on the
Be2Mn and Be2Mno.988Feo.012 compounds. At 4.2 K
these compounds have a magnetization linear with field from 0 to 20 kOe, with respective susceptibilities of
12 x 10- 6 and 15 x 10- 6 emu . g-1. Oe-1. The magne- tization versus H isotherm of Be2Mno.978Feo.022
at 4.2 K shows a part linear with field from 0 to 20 kOe, with a susceptibility of 21 x 10-6 emu. g-1. Oe-1,
while the slight curvature observed on this isotherm for higher fields (30 kOe H 150 kOe) may be attributed to the magnetism of isolated impurities. The
stronger curvature observed on the magnetization Q
versus H isotherm ofBe2Mno.958Feo.042’ and its higher
itiitial susceptibility (x = 55 x 10 - 6 emu. g - 1 . Oe - 1
between 0 and 2 kOe) allow us to locate the appearance of giant moment clusters in the Be2Mn 1 _ xFex com- pounds at a concentration x between 0.03 and 0.04.
Therefore the interesting concentration range for
investigations on cluster superparamagnetism lies
between x
=0.04 and 0.25, but the available measu- rements we have, concern only the samples in the.
concentration range 0.06 to 0.25.
’Then, we report the magnetization, (in emu . g -’ )
of each Be2Mn1 _xFex sample in the critical concentra- tion range 0.06 x 0.25, at different temperatures between 4.2 K and 44 K (or more for three samples) as
a function of field H (corrected for demagnetization)
from 1 kOe to 150 kOe. A a2 versus Hlu representation
of the data up to 150 kOe confirms the inhomogeneous
nature of the magnetic transition previously observed [13] in the Be2Mn1-xFex system. All Q versus H isotherms show continuous curvatures over the whole
Fig. 1.
-Magnetization isotherms a (emu. g- 1) versus H (kOe) of some Be2Mn1-xFex compounds at 4.2 K : + v = 0.19 ;
OX = 0.175; x x = 0.16 ;>x = 0.135; A x = 0.11; 6x = 0.082;
y --, 0. 06.
field range. Figure 1 displays such isotherms at 4.2 K as examples.
Our new magnetization measurements on Fe rich
Be2Mn1 _xFex compounds (0.30 x 1.00) at
4.2 K, in fields ranging from 4 kOe to 150 kOe, are presented as a (emu. g-1) versus H isotherms (Fig. 2),
the field H being corrected for demagnetization.
These compounds show ferromagnetic saturation in moderate and high fields, in agreement with our earlier investigations [13]. But the higher fields avai- lable here enable us to determine the superposed paramagnetic susceptibility XH and the saturation
magnetization as with a higher accuracy (section 5).
Fig. 2.
-Magnetization isotherms 6 (emu. g-1) versus H (kOe) of Fe rich Be2Mn1 _xFex compounds at 4.2 K : + x = 0.88 ; Ox=0.76;x x = 0.62; 0 x = 0.50; Yx=0.40; V x = 0.30.
We have now to choose a suitable model for ana-
lysing the a(H, T) data on all the investigated beryl-
lides (0.06 x 1.00). The most general view point
consists in attributing the main part of the magneti-
zation to the non localized and localized 3d states
(Fe and Mn) responsible for the magnetism in these
beryllides. Such a procedure was successfully applied
by Acker and Huguenin [21] ] to their magnetization
data analysis on weakly magnetic Ni-V alloys. But
the analysis of our 6(H, T ) data using this procedure appeared rather complicated and needed some simpli-
fication. We attribute the main part y(H, T) of the magnetization z(7/, T ) to magnetic polarization clouds (clusters) assumed to exist in all the beryllides with 0.042 x 1.00. As will be shown in section 4, these clusters are mictomagnetic or superparamagnetic (depending on T ) in beryllides with 0.042 x 0.25, and ferromagnetically coupled, forming ferromagnetic
domains in the Fe rich beryllides (0.30 x 1.00)
at sufficiently low temperatures. Therefore, we analyse
the Q(H, T ) data on all investigated beryllides (0.06 x 1.00) by means of the simplified expres- sion (1) : a(H, T) = y(H, T) + HxH(T).
The y(H, T) magnetization, considered as arising
from giant moment clusters in different magnetic
states (superparamagnetic, mictomagnetic or ferroma- gnetic, depending on T and x), may thus be described in a local environment model of magnetism. All other magnetic contributions (nearly magnetic and non magnetic impurities, magnetism of the non localized
3d states, host magnetism) are gathered in the unique magnetization term HXH(T) assumed linear with field up to 150 kOe and representing the superposed paramagnetism of the beryllides. The analysis of our experimental data by means of the simplified expres- sion (1) implies the non evident assumption of a non
localized 3d state magnetism linear with field up to 150 kOe. Therefore, it is necessary to discuss the
validity of our 6(H, T) representation by expression (1)
over the whole investigated temperature T and composition x ranges ; this will be done essentially
in section 7. A brief comment will be useful here : for us an impurity is nearly magnetic if it has a local magnetic moment, but its magnetization component remains linear with field up to 150 kOe.
Expression (1) offers the advantage of simplifying
our Q(H, T) data analysis by assuming an 1 IH or 1/H2 behaviour for the y(H, T) = a(H, T) - HxH(T) magnetization at sufficiently high fields. With this
assumption, expression (1) allows the best evaluation of the xH(T) susceptibility through the high field slope du(H, T )/dH and yields a good fit with the experimen-
tal data. The main results on the xH(T) susceptibility
are summarized in sections 5 (Fig. 8) and 6 (Table II).
We treat the cluster magnetism of all investigated beryllides in the following classical way : we take the cluster, superparamagnetism as ruled by Langevin
functions (sections 3 and 6) and the ferromagnetism
as ruled by classical saturation laws (section 5). Thus,
the asymptotical form of the cluster magnetization y(H, T) in high fields, is given by the assumed 1 /H
or 1 /H 2 behaviour.
In a first step of our cluster superparamagnetism analysis on Be2Mnl _xFex samples with
we have verified that the simplified form (2) of expres-
sion ( 1 )
represents fairly well the magnetization of these beryllides in the high field limit Ha 60 kOe at all
investigated températures, the relative deviations did not exceed 1 %. With the assumption of a cluster superparamagnetism ruled by Langevin functions,
the as(T) and A(T) parameters in (2) yield the average cluster moment M and concentration N independent
of the cluster size distribution. The quantities M and N
are found to be temperature dependent, their values
are not shown here ; we report in section 6 an improved analysis of the magnetization data by taking into
account a small interaction between clusters, which
was neglected in (2).
We also report in this section our initial Xi suscep-
tibility data on all Be2Mn1 _xFex samples with
0.06 x 0.25, as (Xi - xH)-1 versus T plots (Fig. 3).
Fig. 3.
-Inverse cluster susceptibility (x 1-xH) -1 in emu -1. g . Oe
versus T(K) for some Be2Mn1 _xFex compounds : Y x
=0.06 ; Ô x = 0.082 ; + x = 0. 1 1 ; o x = 0. 1 35 ; x x = 0. 1 6 ; A x = 0. 1 75 ; Aj-=0.19;Vjc=0.2î.
The initial susceptibility xi of each beryllide is defined
as the slope a / H of reversible magnetization 6 versus H
isotherms in low fields (0 H 1 kOe). A x; 1
versus T representation of the data showed that no
classical Curie Weiss behaviour could be found on
any beryllide in the temperature range 4.2 K to 100 K : the inverse cluster susceptibility (x; - xH) -1 1 shows
continuous curvatures in its (x; - xH) -1 1 versus T
graphs. This fact too, supports the concept of super-
paramagnetic clusters with temperature dependent
moments in these beryllides.
4. Magnetic behaviour in low fields : mictomagnetism
and ferromagnetism.
-Low field magnetization
measurements performed on Be2Mn1 _xFex com- pounds with 0.11 x 0.25 at temperatures ranging
from 1.7 K to 20 K or more, indicate mictomagnetic
behaviour in the following way. Two series of measu- rements were done on each sample. First, we measured
the magnetic reversible susceptibility after cooling
the sample in zero field : this procedure ensured us a magnetization. proportional to H at sufficiently low
fields (0 H 0.3 kOe) and defined the initial
susceptibility xi given in section 3. Then, we deter- mined the temperature T. of the reversible susceptibi- lity maximum ; measurements done on
Be2Mno.94Feo.o6 and Be2Mno.918Feo.082
indicated that the characteristic T. and Tf tempera-
tures of these samples (if they exist) lie below 1.7 K.
The second series of measurements were done by cooling each sample in a given field (H = 0.1 to
0.3 kOe, depending on the samples) and showed an
irreversible magnetization at temperatures below the characteristic Tf temperature higher than Tm. The
cases of Be2Mno.865Feo.135 and Be2Mno.81 Feo.19 are given as examples in figure 4. The values of the cha- racteristic temperatures Tf and T. are reported on
table I. Such behaviour is characteristic for spin glass
or mictomagnetic alloys [8, 22] with spin freezing temperature Tf where irreversible magnetization sets
in. No scaling law [23] is applicable here, allowing
us to consider these beryllides as mictomagnets.
However, the difference between Tf and T. seems
somewhat too high and we have no explanation for
this fact. The reversible magnetization showed a time dependence at temperatures below T., which is also
typical for mictomagnetic alloys [24, 25]. In order to
obtain more informations on the mictomagnetic
behaviour of these Be2Mn1-xFex compounds, we performed isothermal magnetization measurements at 4.2 K on some samples (x
=0.16 to 0.25) in both
states obtained after zero field cooling and after field
cooling (H = 3 or 5 kOe). Figure 5 represents the
case ofBe2Mno.81 FeO.19 as an example. The hysteresis loop of each sample at 4.2 K (taken after field
cooling) is symmetrical, the coercive fields are low
Fig. 4.
-Mictomagnetic behaviour of Be2Mno.S65Feo.135 (a) and Be2Mno.,,Fe..,, (b); a (emu . g-1) versus T (K) isotherms
+ after zero field cooling and 0 after cooling in a field H= 0.3 kOe (a)
or H = 0.2 kOe (b).
(HC~ 0.1 kOe), but the reverse sections of the loop
are time dependent and the magnetization curve starting from the zero field cooling state lies nearly
outside of the hysteresis loop. Such magnetization
isotherms were reported for Au4Mn compounds and
were attributed to mictomagnetism [26]. From all
the above mentioned properties, we can deduce that the Be2Mn1 _xFex compounds with 0.11 x 0.25
behave as mictomagnets at low temperatures and are superparamagnetic at temperatures above their spin freezing temperature Tf.
In order to examine the evolution of the magnetism through the Be2Mn, -xfex system, we have extended
our low field investigations to more Fe rich beryllides (0.30 x 1.00). It is not yet clear whether these
beryllides can be described as ferromagnets or micto-
magnets with high T. and Tf temperatures. These
samples clearly show ferromagnetic saturation in
Table I.
-Characteristic Tm and Tf temperatures of Be2Mn1_xFex samples in the mictomagnetic state : Tm
temperature of maximal reversible susceptibility Tf spin freezing temperature.
Fig. 5.
-Magnetization isotherms of Be2Mno.8,Feo.19 at 4.2 K :
a (emu . g-1) versus H(kOe), corrected for demagnetization,
0 hysteresis loop after cooling the sample in the + 2.85 k0e field, the dashed portions of the loop are found to be time dependent ;
+ magnetization curve after zero field cooling.
moderate and high fields (Fig. 2), but their magnetic
behaviour in low fields resemble rather that of micto- magnets with high T. and Tf temperatures. The
Be2 Mno .7 oFeo.30 sample shows all characteristic pro-
perties of a mictomagnet at low temperatures : the variation of its reversible magnetization (after zero
field cooling) with temperature, goes from a broad maximum at H ~ 0.1 kOe to a cusp at H ~ 0.013 kOe, time dependence of the reversible magnetization and
irreversible magnetization after field cooling were also
observed below the characteristic temperatures T. - 32 K and Tf - 60 K. In view of their magnetic
behaviour in low fields, Be2Mno.60Feo.40 and Be2Mno,soFeo.so may be considered rather as micto- magnets than ferromagnets at low temperatures : the broad maxima observed on their reversible magne- tization (in fields H N 25 Oe) versus T graphs, provided only an estimation to be made for the characteristic
T. (or Tc ?) temperature, but irreversible magneti-
zation was observed on each sample, after field cooling
below a Tf temperature higher than T. (Table I).
The reversible magnetization of the Fe rich beryllides (0.62 x 1.00) was only obtained after cooling
each sample in a zero field from 800 K (or more) to
300 K, then to 4.2 K. As will be seen below, the question whether these beryllides can be considered as
ferromagnets or mictomagnets with high Tm and Tf temperatures, remains open. The reversible magne- tization of each beryllide (x
=0.62 to 1.00), taken in a
field H ~ 80 Oe, was found to be nearly constant or to
slightly increase with T over a wide range of tempe-
rature (4.2 K to more than 300 K), then rapidly
decrease on raising the temperature. The temperature T, corresponding to the rapid decrease of this magne- tization was identified in our earlier work [13] as the ferromagnetic Curie point of each beryllide. The magnetization irreversibility resulting from the field
cooling of each Fe rich beryllide below its Tf (Tf ~ Tc)
temperature, may be attributed to thermal effects
occurring for annealed ferromagnets or to high tempe-
rature mictomagnetism. However, isothermal magne- tization measurements at 300 K showed very narrow, but symmetrical hysteresis loops (Fig. 6) after cycling
each Fe rich beryllide (x = 0.62 to 1.00) in a 16 kOe or
18 kOe field (remanent magnetization a r ~ 0.2 emu. g -1,
Fig. 6.
-Hysteresis loop of Be2Fe at 300 K : magnetization
6 (emu . g-1) versus H (kOe), corrected for demagnetization 0
by decreasing H from + 14.7 kOe to - 14.7 kOe and + by increasing
H from - 14.7 kOe to + 14.7 kOe.
coercive fields HC ~ 5 Oe, while the magnetization at
16 kOe ranges from 74.7 emu. g-1 for x = 0.62 to
136.4 emu . g -1 for x = 1.00).
,If, we interpret all the above mentioned pro-
perties on the Fe rich Be2Mn1 _xFex compounds (0.30 x 1.00) by the onset of ferromagnetism,
this implies something unusual about this ferroma-
gnetic order : existence of a network of small domains, high anisotropy effects, ..., points which remain to be cleared up by further investigations.
In an attempt to clarify the exact nature of the
magnetism in our Fe rich beryllides (0.3 x 1.00)
we used Môssbauer spectroscopy (14.4 keV resonance
of 57Fe). Preliminary Môssbauer experiments were performed at 4.2 K on Be2Mn1 _xFex compounds
with x ranging from 0.175 to 0.40 [27]. These com- pounds were chosen, because they cover the concen-
tration range where ferromagnetism is thought to
set in. An examination of the spectra (not shown here)
confirms the appearance of magnetic ordering in the Be2 Mn 1 _ xFex system at a concentration XCr between 0.25 and 0.30. In the meantime, we simply interpret
this magnetic ordering as ferromagnetism resulting
from the formation of small domains by the ferro- magnetic coupling of giant moment clusters. This
interpretation has to be justified by further investi- gations.
We tentatively assume here that the magnetic
transition in the Be2Mn1 _xFex system occurs gra-
dually from paramagnetism (x 0.06) to mictoma- gnetism (0.11 x 0.30) then to ferromagnetism (0.30 x 1.00). This assumption may be reaso-
nable, according to a study on Ni-Cu alloys of Ododo
and Coles (1977), where it is predicted that in general
the onset of ferromagnetism in giant moment alloys,
is necessarily preceeded by a mictomagnetic region.
5. Ferromagnetism in the Be2Mn1-xFex system.
-This section deals with the ferromagnetic properties
of the Fe rich beryllides (0.30 x 1.00) at 4.2 K
in moderate and high fields (10 k0e H 150 k0e).
We analyse the magnetization data on these beryllides
at 4.2 K by means of the simplified expression (1)
mentioned in section 3 :
a(H, 4.2 K) = y(H, 4.2 K) + HXH (4.2 K) .
The high field slope of a versus H isotherms (Fig. 2) yields the XH (4.2 K) susceptibility. As shown by (Q - XH H) versus H - 1 or H - 2 graphs (Fig. 7), the y(H) magnetization of all Fe rich beryllides at 4.2 K
could be represented by the classical expression y(H) = Qs - Am H -M with an accuracy better than 0.2 % over a wide range of moderate and high fields (H > 20 k0e to H >, 60 k0e, depending on the samples). The integer m has the value + 1 for x 0.50 and + 2 for 0.62 x 1.00. This classical expres- sion represents the rotation of the magnetization and yields the saturation magnetization u. at 4.2 K by
linear extrapolation to infinite fields of (a - XH H)
versus 1 /H or 1 /H 2. Moreover, the saturation magne- tization u. could be obtained directly for sufficiently
Fe rich beryllides (0.62 x 1.00) by full saturation
of their magnetization in the high fields available here
(H > 120 kOe to H >, 70 k0e, depending on the samples). The relative difference between the two types of 65 (4.2 K) values observed on all these samples, is
less than 0.1 % : the Be2Mno,12Feo.ss sample has a as(4.2K) value of 135.61 ± 0.01 emu . g -1 obtained
by full saturation of its magnetization in fields
H > 70 k0e, while the extrapolation to 1 /H 2 = 0 of
its (a - XH H) versus I/H2 graph, yields
as (4.2 K) = 135.70 ± 0.05 emu . g-1.
Fig. 7.
-Behaviour of Fe rich beryllides in high fields : (a) linear part of the a-m H(emu.g-1) versus H-2 (in Moe-2) isotherm
of ]Be2Mno.38Feo.62 at 4.2 K, corresponding to fields between 151.04 k0e and 24.65 k0e ; (b) linear part of the Q-xH H (emu . g-1)
versus H-1 (in MOe-1) isotherm of Be2Mno.6oFeo.4o at 4.2 K, corresponding to fields between 151.36 kOe and 49.58 kOe.
The as (4.2 K) values agree qualitatively for all Fe
rich beryllides (0.30 x 1.00) with that reported
in our earlier work [13], but no linear relationship
could be found between us (4.2 K) and x for high Fe
contents (0.76 x 1.00). The XH (4.2 K) suscep-
tibility is weak for beryllides with high Fe content (10’XH-5 to 2 emu . g-1 for x = 0.76 to 1.00);
its order of magnitude is consistent with classical band polarization susceptibilities of transition metals.
The variations of as (4.2 K) and xH (4.2 K) with x over
the whole composition range 0.06 x 1.00, are illustrated by figure 8. The as (4.2 K) and xH (4.2 K)
values for beryllides with x between 0.06 and 0.25, arise from our cluster superparamagnetism analysis (section 6). By raising the Mn content, one observes a
sharp non linear decrease of as (4.2 K) and correla- tively a large increase of the XH (4.2 K) susceptibility.
The maximum in the XH (4.2 K) versus x graph, occuring at the concentration range 0.175 to 0.25, close to the concentration where ferromagnetism sets in, may be ascribed to exchange enhancements of the band polarization susceptibility, according to Muell-
ner and Kouvel [4]. We have performed magnetization
measurements over the field range 3 kOe to 150 kOe
Fig. 8.
-Results of the high field magnetization data ; analysis
on Be2Mn1-xFex compounds at 4.2 K :
-
left scale 106XH (emu. g-1. Oe-1) versus Fe content x
-
right scales
(a) 0 saturation magnetization 6S (emu . g-1) versus x ; (b) A normalized Fe moment (ulXuo ratio) versus x.
on the Be2Mno. 70Feo.30 and Be2Mno.6oFeo.4o samples
at 1.5 K in order to verify that the as (4.2 K) saturation magnetization represents the absolute as (0.0 K)
saturation magnetization for all Fe rich beryllides (0.30 x 1.00), within the experimental error.
The saturation magnetization as (1.5 K) of thèse samples at 1.5 K was determined by extrapolation of corresponding (a - ln H ) versus 1 /H plots. It can
be noted that (1s (1.5 K) = 37.19 emu . g-1 against
as (4.2 K) = 37.18 emu. g-1 for Be2Mno.70Feo.30,
while QS (1.5 K)
=57.62 emu . g-1 against
for Be2Mno.6oFeo.40- We think that our saturation
magnetization 6S(t) values are given with a relative uncertainty of 0.1 % to 0.5 % (depending on the samples) ; the assumption 6S (4.2 K)
=as
s(0.0 K)
for all Fe rich beryllides (0.30 x 1.00) is thus justified. The QS (0.0 K) values yield the absolute
mean moment y of each beryllide (in y. per mean atomgram of transition metal) and the corresponding
Fe moment JlFe = MIX (in YB per Fe atomgram).
We call po the Fe moment in the pure Be2Fe com- pound ; we found po = 1.842 uB/Fe, a value smaller
than that of 1.87 uB/Fe extrapolated from u, (0.0 K)
data on BexFe1-x compounds near Be2Fe [28].
The observed difference in the po value can be
explained by small shifts in the Be composition occuring in the preparation of our Be2 Mn 1 _ xFex samples.
We interpret the obtained results on the Fe rich beryllides in a local model of magnetism and we justify this interpretation as follows. In our earlier
work [13] we calculated a qC,qS, ratio of magnetic
carrier numbers per mean atom of transition metal
(qC was deduced from paramagnetic Curie constant
measurements and qs from saturation magnetization values). This ratio was found to increase from 1.25 to 2.00 by decreasing x from 1.00 to 0.40 and this led us to
interpret the magnetism of these beryllides as being
rather collective than localized. But Môssbauer expe- riments performed on the same samples [29], [30]
showed that Mn and Fe do not form a common band in our beryllides, but are well localized : the isomer shift of 57Fe was found to be independent of the Mn
content over the whole investigated concentration range 0.06 x 1.00, within the experimental error.
If Fe is the sole transition element able to carry
a magnetic moment in our Be2Mn1 _xFex samples, the
ratio ,u/xuo called normalized Fe moment should remain less than unity over the whole composition
range 0 x 1. Figure 8 shows this ratio plotted against x for 0.30 x 1.00. As can be seen on this figure, the Jl/Xuo ratio becomes higher than 1 for
0.40 x 1, indicating that another element, in
addition to Fe, is able to carry a magnetic moment
in these beryllides; we assume that it is Mn. This
explains why an Fe atom with full Mn nearest neigh-
bourhood (4 Mn nearest neighbours in the hexagonal
C14 structure) should still carry a moment of 1 uB,
according to the Môssbauer experiments of Vincze
et al. ( 1974).
The simple local environment model of magnetism
described by Jaccarino and Walker [1] and by Perrier
et al. [2] or that improved by Pataud et al. [7] are not applicable in the present case. It appears necessary to clear up the role played by the Mn atoms, in order to
elaborate a local environment model of magnetism.
6. Analysis of the cluster superparamagnetism.
-In this section, we present a detailed analysis of the
cluster superparamagnetism in the Be2Mn1-xFex compounds around the critical composition range for
ferromagnetism (0.06 x 0.25). It was not pos- sible to use a simple model of local environment
magnetism, so allowing us to identify the various
cluster contributions to the magnetization by the
concentration dependence (simple cluster expansion
of the magnetization in successive powers of x) as
was done for Cu-Fe alloys [31] and Co,Ga compounds [9].
These beryllides are only superparamagnetic at sufficiently high temperatures (T > Tf, section 4).
Nevertheless, we have analysed the magnetization
data u(H, T ) over the whole investigated temperature and field ranges with the general expression (3)
Although this analysis yields only qualitative features
of the cluster configuration for T T f (mictomagnetic state), this analysis is worth performing over the
whole investigated temperature and field ranges
(sections 6 and 7). In expression (3), L represents the Langevin function, while Mi and N; are the indi-
vidual cluster moments and concentrations. The values of xH(T) are given in table II (order of magni-
tude XH 1’-1 25 x 10- 6 emu.g-1.0e-1 and an impor-
tant increase of xH with T). No assumption is made concerning the parameters in expression (3), except for the interaction field h between clusters, taken as
a molecular field h = W(a - XH H). In low fields, the magnetization is given by
with C(T) = E(i) N; pf/3 k and O(T) = W(T) C(T).
In the high field limit, the magnetization reduces to
From these two expansions of the magnetization,
we deduce, without any assumption on the cluster size distribution, the three quantities rx(T) = Ei N; ui2 ; us(T) = Xi Ni Mi and N(T) = Xi N;, which yield the
average cluster moment M(T) and total cluster concentration N(T).
The values of the W parameters were estimated from the T dependence of the inverse cluster suscep-
tibility (Fig. 3) written as
A quantitative determination of W was not possible,
since the exact form of C(T) is not known ; we
simply assumed temperature independence for the
W parameters. We think that the interaction fields h between clusters are well represented by W para- meters of the order of + 1 kOe. g. emu -1 (Table II).
The determination of a(T) = Ei N; ,Mi2 is achieved by C(T) = T[W + (x; - XH)-1]-1. For each beryllide,
we have observed a maximum CM in the variation of C(T ) with T at a temperature T1 higher than the spin freezing temperature Tf. The values of CM and Tl are listed in table II.
We have verified by means of a - XH H versus (H + h)-1 isotherms, that the magnetization of the beryllides with 0.06 x 0.25, at all the investi-
gated temperatures, follows the expression (4)
with an accuracy better than 1 % in fields H > 60 kOe.
Some (a - XH H) versus (H + h)-’ isotherms are displayed on figure 9 as typical examples. The average cluster concentration N(T) and moment M(T) were
calculated by taking
and
in expression (4). The variations of M and N with temperature T and composition x are shown on figures 10a and b respectively. The non-smooth
variation of M(T, x) and N(T, x) with x may be
explained by the onset of partial ordering in some
of our samples (due to the heat treatment undergone by the samples, as mentioned in section 2). The
small values (M N 4 JJB) of M (4.2 K) correspond
rather to the paramagnetic Fe moment 1ÀF,, - 3.5 YB
[ 11 ] than to the expected giant moment clusters. But
one notes an important increase of M(T) with T (M ~ 30 UB or 40 YB at 44 K) and a steady decrease
of N(T). In order to situate the magnitude of N(T),
we mention that the value N= 6.9 x 1019 cl . g-1 cal-
culated by Flotow et al. [ 15] from specific heat data
on Be2Mno.865Feo.135 corresponds to its N(15 K).
Table II.
-Main results of the cluster magnetization data analysis in high and low fields on Be2Mn1-xFex samples with x around XCr (0.06 x 0.25) ; susceptibilities xH in emu. g-1. Oe -1, interaction parameters W in k0e . g . emu-1, maximal Curie constants CM in emu . K . g-1; saturation magnetization at 15 K (in emu . g-1) corresponding cluster concentration N (15 K) in 1021 cl . g-1.
LE JOURNAL DE PHYSIQUE.
-T. 40, NO 1, JANVIER 1979
Fig. 9. - Cluster magnetization (1-XH H (emu.g-1) versus 1 OOO(H + h)-1 (in kOe-’) isotherms for Be2Mno.94Feo.o6 at
+ 4.2 K ; 0 8.0 K , x 15.0 K; O 22.0 K; Y 30.5 K; V 41.3 K.
Fig. 10.
-(a) Average cluster moment M (in IlB per cluster-gram)
and (b) total concentration N in Be2Mnl-xFex compounds with 0.06x0.25,atQ8.OK; x 15.0 K ; 0 33 K ; + 44 K.
The saturation magnetization 6S(T ) = N(T ) M(T)
of each beryllide decreases with T in spite of the increasing M(T) ; the as (15.0 K) values are reported
in table II. The ratio U = u2 >. u > - 2 gives an
indication of the cluster size distribution in our
Be2 Mn 1 _ xFe x compounds. This ratio was found to be temperature dependent with a maximum um at a
temperature close to Ti . The variation of um with x
(Table II) is consistent with the concept of a maximum
giant moment increasing with Fe content x. All these
results concern only the two limiting parts of the magnetization data on the beryllides with 0.06 x 0.25 : low fields with Mi H « kT and
high fields with Mi H » kT. We have now to consider
the whole set of data, i.e. the field dependence of
the magnetization a(H, T).
We separate the cluster magnetization u(H, T)- HxH(T) into its various components, according to expression (3) and using the quantities a(T), as(T)
and M(T). An attempt to fit the data with discrete bimodal distributions of moments M, and M2, was
unsuccessful. But all (6 - XH H ) versus (H + h). T -1
isotherms could be represented over the whole field range 1 kOe H 150 kOe with an accuracy better than 5 % by discrete distributions with three types of temperature dependent moments :
-
very high moments M3(T), ranging from 100 YB to 2 000 y. or more, characterize large clusters
saturated in low fields (H - 2 to 3 kOe) ;
-
high moments M2(T), ranging from 15 uB to
500 PB or more, characterize clusters of moderate
size, saturated in moderate fields (H - 30 to 70 kOe) ;
-