Aggregation of ordinal data and open problems related to possibilistic approximation of monotonic set functions

(1)

,

P é) w..lIt ..AM clA. ...~

(2)

-A ~ f\.l g ~.t;-'\ ~ ~~J.i~.J da.fl ~

rA~J

(f.)

~

r/l~~L

..~.tla..td ~

f:~..8'~""~~~/~..lt,~'ll4

é.

CJHtI1.P

'X

~ ali;~ ~ d

r

~

1 d e.a..

~

~ t. H ltA..(..'

ciJ

,

i:

UM.A.tl/~ 1 u\~

e <'l'fIA ~ ~ v i ~~ oÙ CX"""'O(

\1 JJL: CA~.tL./IA. ~ dl.. ~..(..iM ctA. ' J

Ll~ l 'v-i~.2.2 1 /~~t

!

(3)

---:i" II'-~.64 ..L.(.c.b:o-M

-.S.eJ-

~ Fj.a.A~.l.A~ N = f -i, ---, .M t

.G-~ 'l)- ~ ~(N) ~ fR r-" -1... 0 , ~~~~dJ1- C..aM.I~ ;..

.~~aL~J~kA-c.

d ~

f';

p t.-œ5) .: D ; f tR) =- 2: P (.i) \f R ~ IV ..<6~ .~~~.è..b.J:)'h..b: '- ~ ~ Tt. : n (~) =~', rr.LR) = V Tt (...i) V R ~...v ..4.ER .?e>w~ ~.clA:~ rI>.:)J ~ Ii<

(4)

1. .2- C9l..lt..~..iW\a 1 (.l'W\.'tlx. J -~ d4

(

)

\r ~ v- ~ ilJ"(R) ~ tr'CS) ~ V"CRJ ~ U""(s) Vt".s:CN

~

::3 'Y'.: {R /R ~4

t Â.I:. .(:% t(..,

~

o.-'l.cl~~t

~ ~

v lA oI.lJ~

.., a.. .t..f-

...

pl.llLo-t.olLt. V M <y (AI ) ~

( .i -e.. ~ ~ ~

c.I\..r.

~

a,.."l ~~4/)

~ .v.(.

4J.Ia..t~,

Y M <n#) )

(5)

(6)

-~--r k

f .w!IL 1,...

Dlt

.~

~ a..u.. oI+~

~ A. l.4a.l

p~D~.tJI. ~ ~ ;A./.

~ -'>---

-!! j

..

.A.. ci

~1 =. ~ ~ Ji

t!..è

'>,.

f5

J. ry: ~

~ o~J.'(~dl ci ~

V 1 ~ «It.L

~

O"'l~~

F. w-l..o't

~ ~' cM ! (V) :

.

':

-V

~

~(v)

f

[~;:=:;:~::~J

~

IV

-r 6:f..l puC1't~ A ~)/

.,.

~ ttl pA.t61J"-

~ ~ (N )

J!~ lAi.

uJ JtLp~.Lo.L~

~

a.h~ 6j~.

L.eJ-- .i> ~ -..~ ~

.llJla~.t;\I1

q\o'\

)/. -t.J.,.lM

~.l.. ..

)::.,J;: ".1 f"l\LtlzJ .k. -"4 ~d ~..i;f ..3;: .AI RÂ. t.

Ti;- = ~ ~ L tI,.' ~ ~.

~ (.A.M ~ .J.D,' ..J (1.0 ~ .= ~ .1 '.

(7)

~~

~J_"l~Ah

..' .

.

~

.h.h..

2 ~ L~~~~)( ~

2. .-f e.a.ltJ~ ~

c..",~.~.~J:

-r ...t... b.t.t- li,~.a.ft .A~

~.c.t. ~ k-

ru-

'"

(8)

(9)

(10)

~,' --'L

₍

r- --L J,fA U J..J _L

)

L..~ J~.l~.A L...Il'~-~~ 1 "l«Jl..c.l~ 1 Dl~~

Z ~ = * s l 'Y oS

L\ ['I f( f ~~~] J V s S:

."

:

lAk .s ~..AI ~ d a...&~1. t~a.l- z. ~ 1 11":

~.~

V TC S , T # oS

.

~

CÂ'-' c""'~f.t.A.t~

z ~ 1

1T; ~

t) ~

:. 0 ( r)

-k"5S 'â

-..f.

"*

~ O~ ~ ~p~ ~, ~., iT-iJ",-__,1TN Â.M

0 (l ~ 8M) = 0 ( 1 ( "') :. 0 il '1) ~~lJllal -le = "At: !.Pc.ll)/'

~~~~f:!~ -..::. 0 z.

.

.3 .3 '1 ..y

...

.{; .3 2~ z., .1'1 .~ .l,!

..

Al3 ..oi2c, A3~ Z:J.c,.

(11)

-3

A x.)..'

~ &~~~

4-~ 4-~ 4-~ c.aAol.i".~l

c..~...G.~)-Cy'v~ V"'

1 ~ ~ M..4Il

dJ..: ~

'C~).

A >t:..c:,'hII\ A .~::::~~~~~:.:~~~~:~;~1-.b~1 :.-)?5 (V' + 'l,(I'-) :. ,; l"') .,.. "(,,,..) l i11 (C.1)-) = c. ;llV")

.~:~~~~:~ ~ (~ )

:-V(Ri) = V'(R)+t1(..t') V R ~ w\"",- =!) ~.('V-) = 11( )

.~""' .t ~' ~ (~

v- ",~.M.A.l4~ c.. = ) c;I A.' ( l/") '». 0 VA.. E AI

.-:§~~~~~f~

( SL

V <r = ph~"'.A.Ai4-a.b ~ ~ .JI 1 ~. (v-) :. J1f cri A.) (crI/") if ..(- E: AI

(12)

-c <:oF ~ ~t ~c.t.. :

.B

~ zL~

p«>

w-tlz. ~:

b.( Lv.) = ~

~

[ f/'CR..i)

-WR>

]

2. M--1 R~;4I\..i

=. ~

[

_~ _WR..c.'_{) -:l:"} _tI{~)

]

zA-1 R~JI~ ~S:AlIA.

""

œ

~ '

e

çyCN)

À !J>(N l i. )

.stcc-~

~w.tII.. ~~

~.,À (t)'-) :.::!:- '2: -k ! ~ -~-A) ~ ["'(Ri.) -u{E:)] M! R'sIJ\i.

(13)

---(!)l/ldkAa

J

C..l~.tl~} -,

o/~

VJ ~.k

MAJ\~

r

.1'('1)0 !

(V

k

"'... c..

)

AJCi~

-.1~~~2_~= M ~

pIt.L~~~~--~":"""o c-~~rJ,..t~t~..

!rI1.IJ' E.AI.. .1"1 CV}.=.-f ~ ! J-.l, (V) = -"l

-~

.~~l.t.

v:J, ..

\1 Â'i,~E::N' ~ ~(y)= ,. .'lj"l"trJ =...'f ~ .i".i"rr)z!

(14)

.-.J:M~~~ ~

ML (. I) ~

~~

V 1 lu- V' =. v ~ u.,I- J.~(~J

3 R,:Ç N\1j h.r. ".'(RÀ) > 'lJ"-(R..i) o.'t ",4(~i) < tl;I--{!~Jo) ..

-r~

ilj (1f') '>;.

..f~ (Y) ~

..iJ.i (11(1

~ I,~. (V~

.:D~~~(.A.. (~) .!

V ( ~J f?J') % -1 V R ~N(~ (.J.:t. viR..c.") ~ "'{i:J°) -==> J",l'Y}% t

.~~:~~~~#J..I~~~ cA... (~) ~ y (~i, Ri) -= -i VR~J/\ÀJ

r

"%

lV

"-~ ,1 -:=:0 :s:r. )-0

3 RI: V{~J/~):O

~

.::r~~~~ ~oI..a ~U ~ ~~v~

l:c6«1~ .t(~

c.

'I ~~

Ilj(VJ cl&u J

cl.t~ M faiAb (R,S) çA/KA!

r ~.L~~

1,j ~ Ru S O"l 1,J ~ Rns Ô"'l i.i E R\'S ...lJ

ES\i

~~~~

L ~ 'lM ~"

~ a:t1,.,.JJ

)

cP A' (V) = L f~ [V(RÀ.J S) -1[(S, R.i)]

R,S S N\i

.= ~

p ~ ~ur" L lV"(R..i) -'ZJ"

(oS

) ]

R,S SN\~

~

l ~ = tRI, A = 15 l ) P"'t '> ()

fJPl.

N, S,I ,D" .L~I "IC ,

(15)

~ ~ ~ t ~Q

:

.~

~~~

p.""J'l c.:.J

S

bA- (V J =. ~ -A't" (1J"li~) -~!(Jt') J

R,s ;Ç.N\A

~.N)

.

A. B~ck h tA ~~,.I... ('T((c,) > 1't(3) = 1((A) '> T({2Jj .. 63 C1r) > b4 (Y) > 6-1 (V) '> 6Z (V)