• Aucun résultat trouvé

Évaluation croisée d’une stratégie de dépistage de MICI ou de rhumatisme inflammatoire chez les patients traités par anti-tnfα en hôpital de jour de rhumatologie et gastroentérologie

N/A
N/A
Protected

Academic year: 2021

Partager "Évaluation croisée d’une stratégie de dépistage de MICI ou de rhumatisme inflammatoire chez les patients traités par anti-tnfα en hôpital de jour de rhumatologie et gastroentérologie"

Copied!
76
0
0

Texte intégral

(1)

HAL Id: dumas-01661941

https://dumas.ccsd.cnrs.fr/dumas-01661941

Submitted on 12 Dec 2017

HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access

archive for the deposit and dissemination of sci-entific research documents, whether they are pub-lished or not. The documents may come from teaching and research institutions in France or abroad, or from public or private research centers.

L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non, émanant des établissements d’enseignement et de recherche français ou étrangers, des laboratoires publics ou privés.

Évaluation croisée d’une stratégie de dépistage de MICI

ou de rhumatisme inflammatoire chez les patients traités

par anti-tnfα en hôpital de jour de rhumatologie et

gastroentérologie

Sofya Latrache

To cite this version:

Sofya Latrache. Évaluation croisée d’une stratégie de dépistage de MICI ou de rhumatisme inflam-matoire chez les patients traités par anti-tnfα en hôpital de jour de rhumatologie et gastroentérologie. Médecine humaine et pathologie. 2017. �dumas-01661941�

(2)

!"#$%&'()*+&,(-,()'-,#*.,(,&(-,(/0"1)"#*,(

-,(12$,.(

"..',(345673458( (

!"#$%&'()*&+%&,(-!(*.!&%/&01,%-2/%&

3,456789&:;%<=<>&

/9:(

%"&1"#0,(;<=>9(

.?@(A@(54(<BC<D:@(5EF6(G(;"%'(

( ( (

&

/:?H@IC?@(@C(H<JC@IJ@(KJDALMJ@N@IC(A@(54(<BC<D:@(3458(

(

/:?HLO@IC(OJ(PJ:>(Q(

)<IHL@J:(A@(/:(RJLAA9JN@(R2$1#,12%(

-L:@BC@J:(O@(CSTH@(Q(

)<IHL@J:(A@(/:(RJLAA9JN@(;"U2V,(

)@ND:@H(OJ(PJ:>(Q(

)<IHL@J:(A@(/:(&SL@::>(%,W$,11,(

(

)9O9N@(A@(-:(%9J:9("1),.R2%(-,X,*1(

(

(

%?.+).!2(/&-*(2$1%&,;)/%&$!*.!1@2%&,%&,1'2$!.@%&,%&02-2&()&,%&

*")0.!2$0%&2/A+.00.!(2*%&-"%B&+%$&'.!2%/!$&!*.2!1$&'.*&./!2C!/Aα&

%/&"('2!.+&,%&D()*&,%&*")0.!(+(@2%&%!&@.$!*(%/!1*(+(@2%&

(3)

ANNEE UNIVERSITAIRE 2016 - 2017

U.F.R. DE MEDECINE ET DE-PHARMACIE DE ROUEN ---

DOYEN : Professeur Pierre FREGER

ASSESSEURS : Professeur Michel GUERBET

Professeur Benoit VEBER Professeur Pascal JOLY Professeur Stéphane MARRET

I - MEDECINE

PROFESSEURS DES UNIVERSITES – PRATICIENS HOSPITALIERS

Mr Frédéric ANSELME HCN Cardiologie

Mme Isabelle AUQUIT AUCKBUR HCN Chirurgie plastique

Mr Fabrice BAUER HCN Cardiologie

Mme Soumeya BEKRI HCN Biochimie et biologie moléculaire

Mr Ygal BENHAMOU HCN Médecine interne

Mr Jacques BENICHOU HCN Bio statistiques et informatique médicale

Mme Bouchra LAMIA Havre Pneumologie

Mr Olivier BOYER UFR Immunologie

Mr François CARON HCN Maladies infectieuses et tropicales

Mr Philippe CHASSAGNE (détachement) HCN Médecine interne (gériatrie) – Détachement

Mr Vincent COMPERE HCN Anesthésiologie et réanimation chirurgicale

Mr Jean-Nicolas CORNU HCN Urologie

Mr Antoine CUVELIER HB Pneumologie

Mr Pierre CZERNICHOW (surnombre) HCH Epidémiologie, économie de la santé

Mr Jean-Nicolas DACHER HCN Radiologie et imagerie médicale

Mr Stéfan DARMONI HCN Informatique médicale et techniques de communication

Mr Pierre DECHELOTTE HCN Nutrition

Mr Stéphane DERREY HCN Neurochirurgie

(4)

( Y(

Mr Fabien DOGUET HCN Chirurgie Cardio Vasculaire

Mr Jean DOUCET SJ Thérapeutique - Médecine interne et gériatrie

Mr Bernard DUBRAY CB Radiothérapie

Mr Philippe DUCROTTE HCN Hépato-gastro-entérologie

Mr Frank DUJARDIN HCN Chirurgie orthopédique - Traumatologique

Mr Fabrice DUPARC HCN Anatomie - Chirurgie orthopédique et traumatologique

Mr Eric DURAND HCN Cardiologie

Mr Bertrand DUREUIL HCN Anesthésiologie et réanimation chirurgicale

Mme Hélène ELTCHANINOFF HCN Cardiologie

Mr Thierry FREBOURG UFR Génétique

Mr Pierre FREGER HCN Anatomie - Neurochirurgie

Mr Jean François GEHANNO HCN Médecine et santé au travail

Mr Emmanuel GERARDIN HCN Imagerie médicale

Mme Priscille GERARDIN HCN Pédopsychiatrie

Mr Michel GODIN (surnombre) HB Néphrologie

M. Guillaume GOURCEROL HCN Physiologie

Mr Dominique GUERROT HCN Néphrologie

Mr Olivier GUILLIN HCN Psychiatrie Adultes

Mr Didier HANNEQUIN HCN Neurologie

Mr Fabrice JARDIN CB Hématologie

Mr Luc-Marie JOLY HCN Médecine d’urgence

Mr Pascal JOLY HCN Dermato - Vénéréologie

Mme Annie LAQUERRIERE HCN Anatomie et cytologie pathologiques

Mr Vincent LAUDENBACH HCN Anesthésie et réanimation chirurgicale

Mr Joël LECHEVALLIER HCN Chirurgie infantile

Mr Hervé LEFEBVRE HB Endocrinologie et maladies métaboliques

Mr Thierry LEQUERRE HB Rhumatologie

Mme Anne-Marie LEROI HCN Physiologie

Mr Hervé LEVESQUE HB Médecine interne

Mme Agnès LIARD-ZMUDA HCN Chirurgie Infantile

Mr Pierre Yves LITZLER HCN Chirurgie cardiaque

Mr Bertrand MACE HCN Histologie, embryologie, cytogénétique

M. David MALTETE HCN Neurologie

Mr Christophe MARGUET HCN Pédiatrie

(5)

Mr Jean-Paul MARIE HCN Oto-rhino-laryngologie

Mr Loïc MARPEAU HCN Gynécologie - Obstétrique

Mr Stéphane MARRET HCN Pédiatrie

Mme Véronique MERLE HCN Epidémiologie

Mr Pierre MICHEL HCN Hépato-gastro-entérologie

M. Benoit MISSET HCN Réanimation Médicale

Mr Jean-François MUIR (surnombre) HB Pneumologie

Mr Marc MURAINE HCN Ophtalmologie

Mr Philippe MUSETTE HCN Dermatologie - Vénéréologie

Mr Christophe PEILLON HCN Chirurgie générale

Mr Christian PFISTER HCN Urologie

Mr Jean-Christophe PLANTIER HCN Bactériologie - Virologie

Mr Didier PLISSONNIER HCN Chirurgie vasculaire

Mr Gaëtan PREVOST HCN Endocrinologie

Mr Bernard PROUST HCN Médecine légale

Mr Jean-Christophe RICHARD (détachement) HCN Réanimation médicale - Médecine d’urgence

Mr Vincent RICHARD UFR Pharmacologie

Mme Nathalie RIVES HCN Biologie du développement et de la reproduction

Mr Horace ROMAN HCN Gynécologie - Obstétrique

Mr Jean-Christophe SABOURIN HCN Anatomie - Pathologie

Mr Guillaume SAVOYE HCN Hépato-gastrologie

Mme Céline SAVOYE–COLLET HCN Imagerie médicale

Mme Pascale SCHNEIDER HCN Pédiatrie

Mr Michel SCOTTE HCN Chirurgie digestive

Mme Fabienne TAMION HCN Thérapeutique

Mr Luc THIBERVILLE HCN Pneumologie

Mr Christian THUILLEZ (surnombre) HB Pharmacologie

Mr Hervé TILLY CB Hématologie et transfusion

M. Gilles TOURNEL HCN Médecine Légale

Mr Olivier TROST HCN Chirurgie Maxillo-Faciale

Mr Jean-Jacques TUECH HCN Chirurgie digestive

Mr Jean-Pierre VANNIER (surnombre) HCN Pédiatrie génétique

Mr Benoît VEBER HCN Anesthésiologie - Réanimation chirurgicale

Mr Pierre VERA CB Biophysique et traitement de l’image

(6)

( [(

Mr Eric VERSPYCK HCN Gynécologie obstétrique

Mr Olivier VITTECOQ HB Rhumatologie

Mr Jacques WEBER HCN Physiologie

MAITRES DE CONFERENCES DES UNIVERSITES – PRATICIENS HOSPITALIERS

Mme Noëlle BARBIER-FREBOURG HCN Bactériologie – Virologie

Mme Carole BRASSE LAGNEL HCN Biochimie

Mme Valérie BRIDOUX HUYBRECHTS HCN Chirurgie Vasculaire

Mr Gérard BUCHONNET HCN Hématologie

Mme Mireille CASTANET HCN Pédiatrie

Mme Nathalie CHASTAN HCN Neurophysiologie

Mme Sophie CLAEYSSENS HCN Biochimie et biologie moléculaire

Mr Moïse COEFFIER HCN Nutrition

Mr Manuel ETIENNE HCN Maladies infectieuses et tropicales

Mr Serge JACQUOT UFR Immunologie

Mr Joël LADNER HCN Epidémiologie, économie de la santé

Mr Jean-Baptiste LATOUCHE UFR Biologie cellulaire

Mr Thomas MOUREZ HCN Virologie

Mme Muriel QUILLARD HCN Biochimie et biologie moléculaire

Mme Laëtitia ROLLIN HCN Médecine du Travail

Mr Mathieu SALAUN HCN Pneumologie

Mme Pascale SAUGIER-VEBER HCN Génétique

Mme Anne-Claire TOBENAS-DUJARDIN HCN Anatomie

Mr David WALLON HCN Neurologie

PROFESSEUR AGREGE OU CERTIFIE

Mme Dominique LANIEZ UFR Anglais – retraite 01/10/2016

(7)

II - PHARMACIE

PROFESSEURS

Mr Thierry BESSON Chimie Thérapeutique

Mr Jean-Jacques BONNET Pharmacologie

Mr Roland CAPRON (PU-PH) Biophysique

Mr Jean COSTENTIN (Professeur émérite) Pharmacologie

Mme Isabelle DUBUS Biochimie

Mr Loïc FAVENNEC (PU-PH) Parasitologie

Mr Jean Pierre GOULLE (Professeur émérite) Toxicologie

Mr Michel GUERBET Toxicologie

Mme Isabelle LEROUX - NICOLLET Physiologie

Mme Christelle MONTEIL Toxicologie

Mme Martine PESTEL-CARON (PU-PH) Microbiologie

Mme Elisabeth SEGUIN Pharmacognosie

Mr Rémi VARIN (PU-PH) Pharmacie clinique

Mr Jean-Marie VAUGEOIS Pharmacologie

Mr Philippe VERITE Chimie analytique

MAITRES DE CONFERENCES

Mme Cécile BARBOT Chimie Générale et Minérale

Mr Jérémy BELLIEN (MCU-PH) Pharmacologie

Mr Frédéric BOUNOURE Pharmacie Galénique

Mr Abdeslam CHAGRAOUI Physiologie

Mme Camille CHARBONNIER (LE CLEZIO) Statistiques

Mme Elizabeth CHOSSON Botanique

Mme Marie Catherine CONCE-CHEMTOB Législation pharmaceutique et économie de la santé

Mme Cécile CORBIERE Biochimie

Mr Eric DITTMAR Biophysique

(8)

( 8(

Mme Isabelle DUBUC Pharmacologie

Mme Dominique DUTERTE- BOUCHER Pharmacologie

Mr Abdelhakim ELOMRI Pharmacognosie

Mr François ESTOUR Chimie Organique

Mr Gilles GARGALA (MCU-PH) Parasitologie

Mme Nejla EL GHARBI-HAMZA Chimie analytique

Mme Marie-Laure GROULT Botanique

Mr Hervé HUE Biophysique et mathématiques

Mme Laetitia LE GOFF Parasitologie – Immunologie

Mme Hong LU Biologie

Mme Marine MALLETER Toxicologie

Mme Sabine MENAGER Chimie organique

Mme Tiphaine ROGEZ-FLORENT Chimie analytique

Mr Mohamed SKIBA Pharmacie galénique

Mme Malika SKIBA Pharmacie galénique

Mme Christine THARASSE Chimie thérapeutique

Mr Frédéric ZIEGLER Biochimie

PROFESSEURS ASSOCIES

Mme Cécile GUERARD-DETUNCQ Pharmacie officinale

Mr Jean-François HOUIVET Pharmacie officinale

PROFESSEUR CERTIFIE

Mme Mathilde GUERIN Anglais

ASSISTANT HOSPITALO-UNIVERSITAIRE

Mme Sandrine DAHYOT Bactériologie

ATTACHES TEMPORAIRES D’ENSEIGNEMENT ET DE RECHERCHE

Mr Souleymane ABDOUL-AZIZE Biochimie

Mme Hanane GASMI Galénique

Mme Caroline LAUGEL Chimie organique

(9)

LISTE DES RESPONSABLES DES DISCIPLINES PHARMACEUTIQUES

Mme Cécile BARBOT Chimie Générale et minérale

Mr Thierry BESSON Chimie thérapeutique

Mr Roland CAPRON Biophysique

Mme Marie-Catherine CONCE-CHEMTOB Législation et économie de la santé

Mme Elisabeth CHOSSON Botanique

Mr Jean-Jacques BONNET Pharmacodynamie

Mme Isabelle DUBUS Biochimie

Mr Loïc FAVENNEC Parasitologie

Mr Michel GUERBET Toxicologie

Mr François ESTOUR Chimie organique

Mme Isabelle LEROUX-NICOLLET Physiologie

Mme Martine PESTEL-CARON Microbiologie

Mme Elisabeth SEGUIN Pharmacognosie

Mr Mohamed SKIBA Pharmacie galénique

Mr Rémi VARIN Pharmacie clinique

(10)

( E(

III – MEDECINE GENERALE

PROFESSEUR

Mr Jean-Loup HERMIL UFR Médecine générale

PROFESSEURS ASSOCIES A MI-TEMPS

Mr Emmanuel LEFEBVRE UFR Médecine Générale

Mme Elisabeth MAUVIARD UFR Médecine générale

Mr Philippe NGUYEN THANH UFR Médecine générale

MAITRE DE CONFERENCES ASSOCIE A MI-TEMPS

Mr Pascal BOULET UFR Médecine générale

Mr Emmanuel HAZARD UFR Médecine Générale

Mme Lucile PELLERIN UFR Médecine générale

Mme Yveline SEVRIN UFR Médecine générale

(11)

ENSEIGNANTS MONO-APPARTENANTS

PROFESSEURS

Mr Serguei FETISSOV (med) Physiologie (ADEN)

Mr Paul MULDER (phar) Sciences du Médicament

Mme Su RUAN (med) Génie Informatique

MAITRES DE CONFERENCES

Mr Sahil ADRIOUCH (med) Biochimie et biologie moléculaire (Unité Inserm 905)

Mme Gaëlle BOUGEARD-DENOYELLE (med) Biochimie et biologie moléculaire (UMR 1079)

Mme Carine CLEREN (med) Neurosciences (Néovasc)

M. Sylvain FRAINEAU (phar) Physiologie (Inserm U 1096)

Mme Pascaline GAILDRAT (med) Génétique moléculaire humaine (UMR 1079)

Mr Nicolas GUEROUT (med) Chirurgie Expérimentale

Mme Rachel LETELLIER (med) Physiologie

Mme Christine RONDANINO (med) Physiologie de la reproduction

Mr Antoine OUVRARD-PASCAUD (med) Physiologie (Unité Inserm 1076)

Mr Frédéric PASQUET Sciences du langage, orthophonie

Mme Isabelle TOURNIER (med) Biochimie (UMR 1079)

CHEF DES SERVICES ADMINISTRATIFS : Mme Véronique DELAFONTAINE

HCN - Hôpital Charles Nicolle HB - Hôpital de BOIS GUILLAUME

CB - Centre Henri Becquerel CHS - Centre Hospitalier Spécialisé du Rouvray

CRMPR - Centre Régional de Médecine Physique et de Réadaptation SJ – Saint Julien Rouen

(12)

( 55( ( ( ( ( ( ( (

'=E&:F64GFE=<4HI&9I&:=<9&:J&K&8=EL&MNOPQ&6=&R=SJ6<F&=&=EET<F&UJ9&69L&

H54I4HIL&F84L9L&:=IL&69L&:4LL9E<=<4HIL&UJ4&6J4&L9EHI<&5EFL9I<F9L&

:H4V9I<&T<E9&SHIL4:FEF9L&SH889&5EH5E9L&W&69JEL&=J<9JEL&9<&UJ;9669&

I;9I<9I:&69JE&:HII9E&=JSJI9&=55EHG=<4HI&I4&485EHG=<4HIX&

&

&

&

&

&

&

&

(13)

*%0%*-2%0%/!$&

"()<IHL@J:(A@(/:(R2$1#,12%\(

#]@HC(K<J:(N<L(JI(LNN@IH@(S<II@J:(MJ@(^<JH(K:?HLOL@_(N<I(`J:>(O@(CSTH@a(P@(I@(K@Jb( 9HH@_(^<JH(:@N@:BL@:(K<J:(C<JC@(^<C:@(B<I=L9IB@\(^<C:@(H<JCL@I\(@C(^<H(@IH@LcI@N@ICH( I<C9NN@IC(K@IO9IC(N<I(HC9c@(@I(KS>HL<A<cLMJ@(N9LH(?c9A@N@IC(K<J:(A9(K:?K9:9CL<I(O@( N<I(N?N<L:@a(U<JH(9^@_(?C?(JI(KLAL@:(K<J:(N<L(@C(^<JH(B<ICLIJ@:@_(G(A]dC:@a()@:BL(O@( N]9^<L:(K:<K<H?(KAJHL@J:H(=<LH(OJ(B9=?(9A<:H(MJ@(`@(I]@I(D<LH(K9H(eB]@HC(OL:@(^<C:@( K@:H?^?:9IB@f\(N@:BL(O@(N]9^<L:(A9LHH?(9D9IO<II@:(N<I(K:@NL@:(HJ`@C(O@(N?N<L:@(HJ:( A@H(N@HJ:@H(C:TH(9KK:<bLN9CL^@H(OJ(OLS>O:<cTI@(OJ(c9_(@bKL:?\(@C(N@:BL(O@(^<H(B<IH@LAH( HL(K:?BL@Jb(K<J:(A9(K:?K9:9CL<I(O@(N<I(N9:L9c@\(`@(I]<JDAL@:9L(:L@I(O@(C<JH(B@H(N<N@ICHa(

(

"()<IHL@J:(A@(/:(;"U2V,\(

$I(HLIBT:@(N@:BL\(O]9D<:O(K<J:(^<C:@(c@ICLAA@HH@(G(C<JC@(?K:@J^@\(^<C:@(SJNLALC?\(@C(^<C:@( H<JCL@I(H9IH(=9LAA@(MJL(^<JH(=9LC(C9IC(9KK:?BL@:(O@H(LIC@:I@Ha()@:BL(O]9^<L:(?C?(K:?H@IC(G( N@H(O?DJCH(OL==LBLA@H(O9IH(A]LIC@:I9C(O@(N?O@BLI@(@C(O@(N]9^<L:(9LO?(G(:@K:@IO:@( B<I=L9IB@a()@:BL(O@(^<H(9CC@ICL<IH(K9:CLBJALT:@H\(O@(N]9^<L:(=?ALBLC?(K<J:(A]<DC@ICL<I(O@( N<I(K@:NLH(O@(B<IOJL:@\(N<I(N9:L9c@(e@C(K@JC(dC:@(9J`<J:O]SJL(K<J:(A9(^9ALO9CL<I(O@(N9( CSTH@(gfa()@:BL(O@(^<H(@IH@LcI@N@ICH\(I<C9NN@IC(h(LIOL:@BCH(i(@I(^LHLC@(N?OLB9A@( A<:HMJ@(^<JH(O<IIL@_(O@H(LI=<:N9CL<IH(9Jb(@bC@:I@H\(MJL(N]?C9L@IC(@I(=9LC(O@HCLI?@Ha(,C( @I=LI\(JI(c:9IO(N@:BL(O@(^<C:@(9LO@(@C(^<C:@(OLHK<ILDLALC?(K<J:(A9(:?O9BCL<I(O@(N9(CSTH@\( MJL(^<JH(9(=9LC(K9:=<LH(:?^@LAA@:(CjC(A@(N9CLIk( (

"()<IHL@J:(A@(/:(%,W$,11,\(

,I(?B:L^9IC(B@H(KS:9H@H\(`]9L(A@(H<J:L:@(9Jb(AT^:@H(@I(N@(H<J^@I9IC(O@(N<I(HC9c@(@I( :SJN9C<A<cL@(MJ@(`]9L(C@AA@N@IC(9KK:?BL?a(P@(A]9L(9KK:?BL?(c:lB@(G(C<JC@(A]?MJLK@\(A@(/:( ULCC@B<M\(A@(-:(-9:9c<I\(A@(-:(/<JKALI\(RLAA@H\()9HS9\(#S:LHC<KS@:\("II@7/:LHBLAA@\(A@H( B<LIC@:I@H\(MJ@(`@(I@(N9IMJ@:9L(O@(:@N@:BL@:(@C(KJLH(^<JHa()@:BL(O@(C<JC@(^<C:@( B<I=L9IB@(@C(^<H(@IH@LcI@N@ICH(HL(K:?BL@Jba(()@:BL(O@(^<C:@(OLHK<ILDLALC?(@C(^<C:@( B<NK:?S@IHL<I(MJL(H<IC(^<H(c:9IO@H(MJ9ALC?Ha( ( (

(14)

( 5Y(

"()9O9N@(A@(-:("1),.R2%7-,X,*1\(

%9J:9\(`@(C@(:@N@:BL@(HLIBT:@N@IC(O@(DL@I(9^<L:(^<JAJ(=9L:@(K9:CL@(O@(N<I(`J:>(O@(CSTH@a( P]9L(A@(:@c:@C(O@(I@(K9H(9^<L:(9HH@_(C:9^9LAA?(9^@B(C<L(O9IH(A@H(JILC?H\(N9LH(B@(MJL(@HC(Hm:( B]@HC(MJ@(`]9L(D@9JB<JK(9KK:?BL?(A@H(MJ@AMJ@H(`<J:H(<n(I<JH(C:9^9LAAL<IH(@IH@NDA@a(&J(=9LH( C<J`<J:H(K:@J^@(O]JI@(c:9IO@(O?ALB9C@HH@(@C(O]JI@(c:9IO@(c@ICLAA@HH@(MJL(C@(=9LC(9KK:?BL@:( O@(A]@IH@NDA@(OJ(H@:^LB@\(@C(`@(I@(O?:<c@(K9H(G(A9(:TcA@a(( (

"()<IHL@J:(A@(/:()*#0,%\(

U<JH(I]9^@_(K9H(KJ(dC:@(K:?H@IC(9J(`<J:(O@(N9(CSTH@\(@C(`]?BS9KK@(O<IB(G(^<C:@(9I9A>H@( KH>BS<A<cLMJ@\(N9LH(K9:(BJ:L<HLC?(`@(K9HH@:9L(C<JC(O@(NdN@(:?BA9N@:(N<I(Oma()@:BL(O@( I<JH(@IB9O:@:(B<NN@(^<JH(A@(=9LC@H(OJ:9IC(I<C:@(LIC@:I9C\(`]@I(:@HH<:H(B<I=L9IC@(K<J:( N<I(9^@IL:(K:<=@HHL<II@Aa(P@(=9LH(A@(H@:N@IC(O@(I@(K9H((<JDAL@:(O@(N@CC:@(O@H(?CLMJ@CC@H( O9IH(A@H(O<HHL@:H\(IL(O@(I<C@:(A@(C9Jb(O@(N9:MJ@J:H(HJ:(A@H(B<NKC@H(:@IOJHa( (

"()9O9N@(A@(-:(R21*"\(

2OLA@\(I<C:@(h(N9N9I(i(O@(A]LIC@:I9Ck(LA(I]>(9(K9H(9HH@_(O@(N<CH(K<J:(O?B:L:@(A]LNN@IH@( :@HK@BC(MJ@(`@(C@(K<:C@\(O]9D<:O(K<J:(C9(B<I=L9IB@\(C9(c@ICLAA@HH@\(@C(A]?I@:cL@(MJ@(CJ(N@CH( G(I<JH(=<:N@:a()@:BL(O@(N]9^<L:(K:LH(H<JH(C<I(9LA@(O9IH(N@H(N<N@ICH(A@H(KAJH(OL==LBLA@H\( B<NN@(CJ(A@(^<LH(`]9L(KJ(:@K:@IO:@(B<I=L9IB@(@I(N<L(@C(9^9IB@:a(P@(I]<JDAL@:9L(K9H(C<I( LNKALB9CL<I(9JHHL(DL@I(HJ:(A@(KA9I(K:<=@HHL<II@A(MJ@(K@:H<II@Aa(( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( (

(15)

"J(/:(-JB:<CC@\(N@:BL(O@(N]9^<L:(K9HHL<II?(K<J:(A9(KS>HL<A<cL@(OLc@HCL^@a( "J(/:(%@:@D<J:H\(N@:BL(O@(C<JH(^<H(@IH@LcI@N@ICHa( "(RS9HH9I\(N@:BL(K<J:(C9(D<II@(SJN@J:(B<IHC9IC@((@C(C9(DL@I^@LAA9IB@a(( "(-9^LO\(N@:BL(K<J:(B@H(D<IH(N<N@ICH(O@(:Lc<A9O@(e@C(O@(C:9^9LA(K9:=<LHfa( "(!:?O@:LB\(N@:BL(O@(^<C:@(OLHK<ILDLALC?a( "(0?ATI@\(#A<?\(@C(#<:9AL@\(N@:BL(O@(I@(N]@I(9^<L:(`9N9LH(^<JAJ(O@(^<JH(=9L:@(:@^@IL:(@I( c9:O@a( "("ALB@\(/9JA\(%JBL@\(9LIHL(MJ]9J(-:(&<JBS9LH\(9J(-:(U9I(-@:(,@Bo@I\(@C(9J(-:(X9:O<Jb\( N@:BL(K<J:(^<H(C<JH(@IH@LcI@N@ICH(HL(K:?BL@Jb(@I(@IO<HB<KL@a( "J(-:("IC<IL@CCL\(`@(B:<LH(MJ]<I(^<JH(A]9(H<J^@IC(OLC(Q(N@:BL(O@(^<C:@(c@ICLAA@HH@(@C(D<IC?a( "(19L@O\(N@:BL(K<J:(C<JH(B@H(N<N@ICH\(C9(OLHK<ILDLALC?\(C<I(?B<JC@a( "(;C?KS9I@\(N@:BL(K<J:(C<JC\(N@:BL(O@(C9(c@ICLAA@HH@\(B@:C9LIH(N@ND:@H(O@(N9(=9NLAA@(I@( H]@I(:@N@CC@IC(K9Ha( $I(c:9IO(N@:BL(G(C<JC@(A]?MJLK@(O@(KS>HL<A<cL@(Q("II@()9:L@\(%9J:9\(#SA<?\(@C(/9JALI@(p( $I(c:9IO(N@:BL(G(A]?MJLK@(O],AD@J=(Q(#9:<ALI@\(U9A?:L@\("II@()9:L@\()9JO\(%9J:@IB@\(@C(A@( -:(-@H@BS9AAL@:Ha( ,IB<:@(JI(c:9IO(N@:BL(G(C<JC@(A]?MJLK@(O@(:SJN9C<A<cL@a(( $I(c:9IO(DLc(JK(G(N@H(9IBL@IH(B<LIC@:I@H(O@^@IJH(BS@=H(Q(/9JA\(#S9:ALI@\(%9J:9\(#SA<?\( #<:9AL@\()?A9IL@\(!9II>p()9LIC@I9ICaa(B]@HC(G(N<I(C<J:(p("(^<H(:LHMJ@H(@C(K?:LAHa( "(N9()9CSLAO@k(OL==LBLA@(O@(O?B:L:@(C<JC(B@(MJ]<I(9(KJ(K9:C9c@:(@IH@NDA@\(`@(K@IH@(MJ@( B@A9(:@HC@:9(O9IH(I<H(N?N<L:@H(K<J:(A9(^L@a(P@(C@(H<JS9LC@(C<JC(A@(D<IS@J:(OJ(N<IO@( 9JHHL(DL@I(HJ:(A@(KA9I(K:<=@HHL<II@A(MJ@(K@:H<II@A(I<C9NN@IC(9^@B(A]9::L^?@(LNNLI@IC@( O]JI@(9O<:9DA@(K@CLC@(B:?9CJ:@(MJL(@HC(C:TH(9CC@IOJ@(p( P@(I]<JDAL@(K9H(B@Jb(@C(B@AA@H(MJL(N]<IC(?c9A@N@IC(9LO?(G(c:9IOL:(K@IO9IC(N<I(LIC@:I9C\( @C(`@(K9:A@(DL@I(Hm:(O@(C<JC@(A]?MJLK@(K9:9N?OLB9A@a()@H(O?DJCH(I]9J:9L@IC(K9H(?C?(A@H( NdN@H(H9IH(*H9D@AA@\(U9A?:L@\(%9J:L@\(;9IO:LI@\(-9ALA9(@C(/9HB9A@(eA9(ALHC@(I]@HC(K9H( @bS9JHCL^@f(9J(HJO(MJL(N]<IC(BS<JBS<JC?@Ha()@:BL(G(A]?MJLK@(O@H(S?N<H\(@I(K9:CLBJAL@:(G( ULIB@IC<(@C(qLoLa()@:BL(G(B@AA@(O@(A]@HC\(`@(^<JH(9O<:@\(@C(I]<JDAL@_(K9H(A9(X$(K<J:( A]"^9HCLI(pa(()@:BL(G(C<JC@(A]?MJLK@(O@H(@IO<H(MJL(9(OJ(N@(HJKK<:C@:(K@IO9IC(B@H(6(A<IcH( N<LH(9^@B(N@H(NJACLKA@H(K?:LK?CL@Ha(P@(^<JH(H<JS9LC@(G(C<JH(D<II@(B<ICLIJ9CL<I(@C(MJ@( I<H(:<JC@H(H@(:@B:<LH@IC(JI(`<J:a( ( (

(16)

( 5[(

.&89L&SHC4I<9EI9L&=:HEFL&

.@(N]@I(^<JA@_(K9H(HL(`@(B<NN@IB@(N@H(:@N@:BL@N@ICH(K9:(;9D:LI9\(N9(;9DLBS@(9O<:?@a( )@:BL(O@(C<JH(B@H(N<N@ICH(K9:C9c?H(@IH@NDA@\(K9:=<LH(C:TH(?BA@BCLMJ@H\(N@:BL(O@(N@( A9LHH@:(AL:@(O9IH(C@H(K@IH?@H\(N@:BL(O]9^<L:(:@NKAL(A@(:jA@(O@(N9LC:@HH@(O@(B?:?N<IL@(9^@B( K@:=@BCL<I\(N@:BL(O]9^<L:(C<J`<J:H(?C?(AG\(@C(N@:BL(O@(N@(:@IO:@(N<I(B:9><I(G(H<J:BLA(`@( A]9CC@IO(C<J`<J:H(e@C(9JHHL(N<I(K>`9N9fa(( "(;LN<I@CC@k(CJ(^9H(N@(N9IMJ@:(ppp(&<I(SJN<J:\(I<H(H<L:?@H(O@(-,;\(C9(K:?H@IC9CL<I(O@( N?N<L:@\(C<I(IrJO(K9K(p(.@(N9:C>:LH@(K9H(C:<K(A@H(K@CLCH(B<LIC@:I@H(JI@(=<LH(BS@=(S@LI(p(( "()9:L<I\(N@:BL(O]9^<L:(C<J`<J:H(K@IH?(G(O@N9IO@:(O@H(I<J^@AA@H(O9IH(A@H(K?:L<O@H( OL==LBLA@Ha(,^LC@(O]@HB9A9O@:(A@H(BS9LH@H(@C(?A<LcI@H(C<L(O@(C<JC(B@(MJL(K@JC(:@HH@NDA@:(G(JI( :?C:<K:<`@BC@J:a( "()9:L@\(N@:BL(K<J:(I<H(A<IcJ@H(OLHBJHHL<IH(K@IO9IC(A@H(`<J:I?@H(O@(-,;(@C(C9(O<JB@J:a( P@(C@(H<JS9LC@(D@9JB<JK(O@(D<IS@J:(O9IH(C<I(=JCJ:a(( "(PJAL@I(%a(N@:BL(O@(C<L(@C(G(#9NLAA@(K<J:(C<JH(B@H(N<N@ICH(K9HH?H(@IH@NDA@(@C(O@(C<JC@H( C@H(LI^LC9CL<IHk(JI(`<J:(C<L(9JHHL(CJ(K9HH@:9H(C9(CSTH@p(HL(HL(p( "(#S9:A<CC@\(N@:BL(K<J:(B@(HJK@:(H@N@HC:@(@IH@NDA@\(N@:BL(O@(C]dC:@(H9B:L=L?@(K<J:(MJ@(`@( KJLHH@(9^<L:(JI(K@J(O@(C@NKH(ALD:@(K<J:(N9(CSTH@\(`@(C]9KK:?BL@(?I<:N?N@ICa( "(#>:LA(MJ]<I(I@(^<LC(KAJH(N9LH(MJL(c:9^LC(A@H(H<NN@CH\(G(PJ`J(C<J`<J:H(AG(K<J:(9LO@:(@C(MJL( I<JH(=9LC(C@AA@N@IC(:L:@(es9(N@(N9IMJ@:9f\(G(Rt@I(eI@(K<JHH@(K9H(C:<K(A@H(;"/f\(@C(G( /L@::<C(@C(H<I(LI<JDAL9DA@(D@A@CC@a( "(N9(K@CLC@()9:L@(CJ(^9H(C@AA@N@IC(N@(N9IMJ@:(eN9LH(K9H(C<I(BS9Cf(ppp\(G(1<b>\(9O<:9DA@( @C(C<J`<J:H(AG(K<J:(9LO@:\(X@JD@J(@C(H9(c@ICLAA@HH@(H9IH(=9LAA@\(G(#S9:A<CC@(MJ@(`@(^<LH( c:9IOL:(O@(`<J:(@I(`<J:\(G(.<I<:@(MJL(I<JH(LNK:@HHL<II@(@C(MJ]<I(9(K9H(=LIL(O@(O?B<J^:L:a(( ,C(@I=LI\(JI(c:9IO(N@:BL(A9:N<>9IC(G(N@H(C<JH(K@CLCH(Q(*A9I9(N9(=LAA@\(MJ@(A]9^@IL:(I@( C]9KK<:C@(MJ@(A@(N@LAA@J:\("O:L@I(N9(:@B:J@(O@(:SJN9C<\(MJL(N]9(:@K:LC(A9(N9`<:LC?(O@( N@H(c9:O@H\(@C(H9IH(MJL(B@CC@(CSTH@(I@(H@:9LC(K9H(9BS@^?@\(#9KJ(I<C:@(K@CLC(:9><I(O@( H<A@LA\(N9(#S?BS?(MJ@(`]9L(@J(C@AA@N@IC(O@(BS9IB@(O@(B<II9uC:@\(@C(UL:cLI@(A9(t9::L<:(G( C<JC@(?K:@J^@a( (

.&89L&SH5=4IYL&=:HEFL&

)@:BL(G(*AS9N\(MJL(@AA@(N@(B<II9uC(O@KJLH(N9(C@IO:@(@I=9IB@\(@C(MJL(9(9KK:LH(G(N@( B<II9uC:@(O@::LT:@(N@H(NJACLKA@H(DL_9::@:L@Ha(

(17)

)@:BL(G(N9(K@CLC@(2IOLI@\(O<IC(`]9L(OJ(N]?A<LcI@:(K@IO9IC(Z(9IH\(N9LH(MJL(9(C<J`<J:H(?C?( AGa(P@(:@^L@IH(I@(C]@I(=9LH(K9Ha( "(N9(K@CLC@(#A9L:@\(:@c9:O@H(C<JC(B@(MJ]<I(9(9BB<NKAL(BS9BJI@(O9IH(I<C:@(^L@\(<I(9( K9:C9c?(I<H(N<N@ICH(OL==LBLA@H(N9LH(HJ:C<JC(I<H(N<N@ICH(O@(D<IS@J:\(@C(B@A9(I]@HC(K9H( K:dC(O@(H]9::dC@:a( "(*AS9N(%a(K<J:(C<JH(I<H(N<N@ICH(B<NKALB@H(K9:C9c?H(K@IO9IC(N9(C@IO:@(@I=9IB@a( "(;9:9S(@C(;9SL:(9^@B(MJL(`]9L(K9:C9c?(A9(N9`<:LC?(O@(N<I(@bC@:I9Ca( "(*HN9LA(@C(q9tC9:(9^@B(MJL(`]9L(K9:C9c?(N@H(?CJO@H(9J(A>B?@a(( )@:BL(G(1<:<(v(U9A?:L@\(#LIO>(v(-@ILH\(%<wB(v()9OA>\()LI(v(X@I<LC\((#?O:LB(v(;9DLI@\( PJAL@I\(K<J:(C<JH(B@H(N<N@ICH(K9HH?H(@IH@NDA@a( "(N9(C@9N(O@(/5(Q(%L<I@A\(/SLALH<==\(@C()9:L@a( "(N@H(B<LIC@:I@H(O@(BSL:J:cL@\(&9CL9I9\(RJLAA9JN@\(,O<J9:O\(/9JALI@\(/9JA\(;@:^9I@(Q( N@:BL(O]9^<L:(S?D@:c?(I<H(K9CL@ICH(p( "(N<I(I?I?\(!:9IBS<LH(@C()9CSLAO@\(.LB<A9H\(#S:LHC@AA@\(RSLHA9LI\()9:CLI\("II9D@AA@\( "DO@::9SN9I@\()<:c9I@\(@C(/@::LI@(Q(N@:BL(O]9^<L:(B:<LH?(N9(:<JC@(K@IO9IC(I<C:@( LIC@:I9Ca( "(C<JC@(A]?MJLK@(O@(A]"!*0R,(Q("IC<LI@\(#S9:A<CC@\()9:L<I\(-L9I@\(%9J:9\(,NN9\(2AL^L@:\( &SLD9JC\("DO@AA9Sa( ( (

.&8=&R=84669Q&

"(N<I(N9:L(1?NL\(JI(c:9IO(N@:BL(K<J:(C<JC(B@(MJ@(CJ(9H(=9LC(K<J:(N<La(&J(C]@H(H9B:L=L?( K<J:(MJ@(`@(KJLHH@(K<J:HJL^:@(N<I(LIC@:I9C(O9IH(A9(HK?BL9ALC?(MJ@(`@(O?HL:9La(&J(I@(C]@H( `9N9LH(KA9LIH(O@(N<I(9DH@IB@(A<:H(O@(N@H(`<J:I?@H(G(:9AA<Ic@(G(A]SjKLC9Aa(&J(9H(C<J`<J:H( ?C?(AG(K<J:(N<L\(@C(`@(C]@I(HJLH(C@AA@N@IC(:@B<II9LHH9IC@a( "(N@H(K9:@ICH\(N9(N9N<JI@CC@(@C(N<I(K9K<JI@C\(MJL(N@(N9IMJ@IC(C@AA@N@IC(@C(MJ@(`@( ^<LH(HL(K@J\(N@:BL(O@(C<J`<J:H(N]9^<L:(=9LC(B<I=L9IB@(O9IH(N@H(?CJO@H\(@C(N@:BL(O@( N]9^<L:(O<II?(B@CC@(?OJB9CL<I(ALD:@(MJL(N]9(K@:NLH(O@(N]?K9I<JL:a(P@(HJLH(S@J:@JH@( 9J`<J:O]SJL(@C(B]@HC(c:lB@(G(^<JHa( "(N<I(B<JHLI(*HN9LA\(MJL(I<JH(9(MJLCC?(C:<K(CjC\(N9LH(MJ@(`@(c9:O@:9L(C<J`<J:H(O9IH(N9( N?N<L:@a( "(N@H(<IBA@H(@C(C9IC@H\(@C(B<JHLIH(B<JHLI@H(MJ@(`@(^<LH(HL(K@Ja( "(N9(C9C9(X<JBS:9\(MJL(@HC(HL(A<LI\(N9LH(MJ@(`@(K<:C@(O9IH(N<I(BrJ:a(

(18)

( 58( "(NN?\(MJL(LIB9:I@(A9(D<IC?(NdN@\(@C(`]@HKT:@(c9:O@:(9JK:TH(O@(N<L(A@(KAJH(A<IcC@NKHa( "(q9:LN9\(N@:BL(O@(C9(c@ICLAA@HH@(@C(O@(C<I(H<JCL@Ia( "(X:LcLCC@(@C(V^@H\(N@:BL(O@(N]9^<L:(9BBJ@LAAL(G(D:9H(<J^@:CH(O9IH(^<C:@(D@AA@(=9NLAA@(<n(`@( N@(H@IH(HL(DL@Ia( "(;>A^L@\(2AL^L@:\(&SL@::>\(%JBLA@\(,NN9\("OTA@\(@C(#S9:A<CC@(Q(N@:BL(K<J:(H<J:L:@Ha( )@:BL(G(1?cLI@(@C("A9LI\(,ALH9D@CS(@C(P@9I()9:L@\(q9:LI@(@C(#>:LA\(RJLAA9JN@(@C(#A9L:@\( -9^LO\(#S:LHCLI@(@C(2AL^L@:\(V^<II@\(X:LcLCC@\(#A9JO@\()<ILMJ@(@C(X@:I9:O\(RJLAA9JN@(@C( "II@(;<KSL@\(1?cLH(@C()9:L@(/9JA@\(-9NL@I(@C(;9IO:LI@\(#A9JOLI@(@C(#A?N@IC\(@C(`]@I( <JDAL@a( ( ( ( ( ( ( (

&

&

&

&

&

&

&

&

&

&

&

&

&

(19)

!.Z+%&,%$&0.!2#*%$&

2&[&2/!*(,)-!2(/kkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkk35( & .&[&+9L&0=6=:49L&4IR6=88=<H4E9L&-\EHI4UJ9L&:9&6;2I<9L<4Ikkkkkkkkkkkaaakk33& 5f ,KLO?NL<A<cL@(kkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkk33( 3f /S>HL<K9CS<A<cL@kkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkaakk33( 9a !9BC@J:H(c?I?CLMJ@H(@C(LNNJILC9L:@Hkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkaaa3Y( Da !9BC@J:H(@I^L:<II@N@IC9Jbkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkaa3Z( Ba %@(NLB:<DL<C@kkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkaa3Z( Oa %9(:?K<IH@(LI=A9NN9C<L:@kkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkaaa3[( Yf #ALILMJ@(@C(OL9cI<HCLBkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkka3[( Zf )*#*(@C(;>IO:<N@(O@(A]LIC@HCLI(L::LC9DA@kkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkka36( & Z&[&+9L&L5HI:]6=E<\EH5=<\49Lkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkaakkkkkkkkkkkk3E& 5f ,KLO?NL<A<cL@kkkkkkaakkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkaakkkkkkkkkkka3E( 3f /S>HL<K9CS<A<cL@kkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkaakkkkkkkkkkka3E( 9a !9BC@J:H(c?I?CLMJ@H(@C(LNNJILC9L:@Hkkkkkkkaakkkkkkkkkka3E( Da !9BC@J:H(@I^L:<II@N@IC9JbkkkkkkkkkkkkaakkkkkkkkkkY4( Yf #ALILMJ@(@C(-L9cI<HCLBkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkaakkkkkkkkkaaY5( & -&[&+;=^9&@J<CDH4I<kkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkakkkkkkkkkY[& 5f ;K<IO>A9:CS:<K9CSL@H(@C()*#*kkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkakkkkkkkkkaY[( 9a $I(C@::9LI(c?I?CLMJ@(@C(LNNJILC9L:@(B<NNJIkkkkkakkkkkkkkkaY[( Da %]9CC@LIC@(9:CLBJA9L:@(O9IH(A@H()*#*kkkkkkkkkkkkakkkkkkkkaaY[( Ba %]9CC@LIC@(OLc@HCL^@(O9IH(A@H(HK<IO>A9:CS:<K9CSL@HkkkaakkkkkkkkaaY8( Oa -@H(CS?:9K@JCLMJ@H(B<NNJI@H(kkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkYE( ( 22&[&(G_9S<4R&:9&6;F<J:9kkkkkkkakkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkakkaaZ4& & 222&[&0=<FE496&9<&0F<\H:9LkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkaakkaZ5& 5f /9CL@ICHkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkaakkaZ5( 3f )?CS<O@HkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkaakaZ3( Yf "I9A>H@(HC9CLHCLMJ@kkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkakaZZ(

(20)

( 5E( & 2?&[&*FLJ6<=<LkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkaZ[( & 5f #<S<:C@(O@(:SJN9C<A<cL@(kkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkaaaaZ[( 9a ;>NKCjN@HkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkZ6( Da -L9cI<HCLBH(?C9DALH(kkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkaaaZ8( Ba 1@BS@:BS@(O@(=9BC@J:H(K:?OLBCL=H(9J(OL9cI<HCLB(O@()*#*(kkkkkkkkkaaZF( 3f #<S<:C@(O@(c9HC:<@IC?:<A<cL@(kkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkaa[[( 9a ;>NKCjN@H(kkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkaa[6( Da -L9cI<HCLBH(?C9DALHkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkk[8( SX !9BC@J:H(K:?OLBCL=H(kkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkaaa[F& & ?&[&,4LSJLL4HI&kkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkka64( & ?2&C&&-HIS6JL4HI&kkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkaa6[( & *FRFE9IS9Lkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkka66& &

&

&

&

&

&

&

&

&

(21)

+2$!%&,%$&.Z*%?2.!2(/$&

";-";(Q("Io>A<HLIc(;K<IO>ALCLH(-LH@9H@("BCL^LC>(;B<:@( X";-"*(Q(X9CS("Io>A<HLIc(;K<IO>ALCLH("BCL^LC>(*IO@b( X";!*(Q(X9CS("Io>A<HLIc(;K<IO>ALCLH(!<IBCL<II9A(*IO@b( #0$(Q(B@IC:@(S<HKLC9A<7JIL^@:HLC9L:@( #1/(Q(K:<C?LI@(#(:?9BCL^@( -";(Q(-LH@9H@("BCL^LC>(;B<:@( ,U"(Q(?BS@AA@(^LHJ@AA@(9I9A<cLMJ@( *)*-(Q(()9A9OL@H(LI=A9NN9C<L:@H(G(N?OL9CL<I(LNNJILC9L:@( %"/(Q(%?HL<IH(9I<K?:LI?9A@H( )#(Q()9A9OL@(O@(#:<SI( )*#*(Q()9A9OL@(LI=A9NN9C<L:@(BS:<ILMJ@(O@(A]LIC@HCLI( 1#0(Q(1@BC<B<ALC@(S?N<::9cLMJ@( ;"(Q(;K<IO>A9:CS:LC@(9Io>A<H9IC@( ;**(Q(;>IO:<N@(O@(A]LIC@HCLI(L::LC9DA@( ;K"(Q(;K<IO>A9:CS:<K9CSL@( &.!(Q(CJN<:(I@B:<HLH(=9BC<:( U//(Q(U9A@J:(K:?OLBCL^@(K<HLCL^@( U/.(Q(U9A@J:(K:?OLBCL^@(I?c9CL^@( U;(Q(ULC@HH@(O@(H?OLN@IC9CL<I(

&

( & & & & & & & & (

(22)

( 35( *(x(2/!*(,)-!2(/(

(

%@H( N9A9OL@H( LI=A9NN9C<L:@H( G( N?OL9CL<I( LNNJILC9L:@( e*)*-f( H<IC( JI( c:<JK@( O@( K9CS<A<cL@H( K<J^9IC( C<JBS@:( A]@IH@NDA@( O@H( <:c9I@H\( K9:C9c@9IC( O@H( N?B9ILHN@H( B<NNJIH(@C(H@(B9:9BC?:LH9IC(K9:(JI(O?H?MJLALD:@(O@H(B>C<oLI@H(@I(=9^@J:(O]JI@(^<L@(K:<7 LI=A9NN9C<L:@(K<J^9IC(H@(N9IL=@HC@:(O@(N9ILT:@(9LcJ@(eK<JHH?@Hf(@Cy<J(BS:<ILMJ@(e5fa( #@H(N9A9OL@H(H<IC(A9(:?HJAC9IC@(O@(KAJHL@J:H(=9BC@J:H(c?I?CLMJ@H(@C(@I^L:<II@N@IC9Jb\( O@( NL@Jb( @I( NL@Jb( B<IIJH\( H9IH( MJ]9JBJI( I]9LC( ?C?( LO@ICL=L?( B<NN@( I?B@HH9L:@( <J( HJ==LH9ICa(,AA@H(B<NK:@II@IC(O@(N9ILT:@(I<I(@bS9JHCL^@(A9(HK<IO>A9:CS:LC@(9Io>A<H9IC@( e;"f\( A@( KH<:L9HLH\( A@( :SJN9CLHN@( KH<:L9HLMJ@\( A]9HCSN@( @C( A@H( N9A9OL@H( LI=A9NN9C<L:@H( BS:<ILMJ@H( O@H( LIC@HCLIH( e)*#*f( B<::@HK<IO9IC( G( O@H( 9CC@LIC@H( A<B9ALH?@H( G( JI( <:c9I@a( &<JC@=<LH( B@H( 9CC@LIC@H( K@J^@IC( B<IB@:I@:( KAJHL@J:H( <:c9I@H( O9IH( JI( NdN@( C@NKH\( B<::@HK<IO9IC(G(JI@(H>HC?N9CLH9CL<I(O@(A]LI=A9NN9CL<Ia(,I(@==@C\(KAJHL@J:H(9HH<BL9CL<IH( @IC:@(9CC@LIC@H(LI=A9NN9C<L:@H(OLc@HCL^@H(@C(:SJN9C<A<cLMJ@H(<IC(?C?(NLH@H(@I(?^LO@IB@( O9IH(A9(ALCC?:9CJ:@\(A9(KAJH(B<IIJ@(?C9IC(A]LIC@:9BCL<I(@IC:@(A@H(N9A9OL@H(LI=A9NN9C<L:@H( BS:<ILMJ@H( O@( A]LIC@HCLI( e)*#*f\( @C( A@H( HK<IO>A9:CS:<K9CSL@H( e;K"fa( #S@_( A@H( K9CL@ICH( 9CC@LICH(O@()*#*\(:@c:<JK9IC(N9A9OL@(O@(#:<SI(e)#f\(:@BC<B<ALC@(S?N<::9cLMJ@(e1#0f\(@C( B<ALC@(LIBA9HH?@\((35(G(ZYz(O?^@A<KK@IC(JI@(9CC@LIC@(@bC:9OLc@HCL^@e3\Yf\(O<IC(54(G(34z( O@( HK<IO>A9:CS:<K9CSL@H( eZfa("( A]LI^@:H@\( JI( I<ND:@( I<I( I?cALc@9DA@( e8zf( O@( K9CL@ICH(

9CC@LICH( O@( HK<IO>A9:CS:<K9CSL@H( O?^@A<KK@IC( JI@( )*#*( 9J( B<J:H( O@( A@J:( SLHC<L:@( I9CJ:@AA@(e[fa(

%9(HJ:^@IJ@(O@(H>NKCjN@H(OLc@HCL=H((BS@_(A@H(K9CL@ICH(9CC@LICH(O@(HK<IO>A9:CS:<K9CSL@H( O<LC( 9A@:C@:\( @C( O<LC( B<IOJL:@( G( JI@( ?^9AJ9CL<I( BALILMJ@\( ^<L:@( @IO<HB<KLMJ@( @Cy<J( :9OL<A<cLMJ@\(9=LI(O]?C9DAL:(JI(OL9cI<HCLB(K<HLCL=(@C(<:L@IC@:(A9(K:LH@(@I(BS9:c@a(-@(NdN@\( A]9CC@LIC@(9:CLBJA9L:@(O9IH(A@H()*#*(O<LC(dC:@(OL9cI<HCLMJ?@\(O]JI@(K9:C(9=LI(O]9N?AL<:@:(A9( MJ9ALC?( O@( ^L@\( @C( O]9JC:@( K9:C( 9=LI( O@( ALNLC@:( A]9CC@LIC@( HC:JBCJ:@AA@( 9:CLBJA9L:@( @I( B9H( O]9CC@LIC@(LI=A9NN9C<L:@a( ( ( ( ( ( (

(23)

.>&C&+9L&0=6=:49L&2IR6=88=<H4E9L&-\EHI4UJ9L&:9&6;2I<9L<4I&302-2>& &

&

M> %54:F84H6HY49&&

(

%@H( )*#*( <IC( ?C?( O?B:LC@H( K<J:( A9( K:@NLT:@( =<LH( @I( 5E[4a( %@J:( K:?^9A@IB@( @C( A@J:( LIBLO@IB@( ?C9L@IC( @I( B<IHC9IC@( 9JcN@IC9CL<I\( KJLH( H@( H<IC( HC9DLALH?@H( O@KJLH( JI@( ^LIcC9LI@(O]9II?@Ha(("J(IL^@9J(@J:<K?@I\(A]LIBLO@IB@(O@(A9()#(^9:L@(@IC:@(3(G(Ey544a444( S9DLC9ICH\( @C( B@AA@( O@( A9( 1#0( O@( Z( G( 56y544a444( S9DLC9ICHa( %@J:( K:?^9A@IB@( ^9:L@( :@HK@BCL^@N@IC(O@(F\Y(G(35Zy(544a444(S9DLC9ICH\(@C(35\Z(G(3EZy544a444(S9DLC9ICH(e6fa(( *A( >( @HC( <DH@:^?( JI( c:9OL@IC( .<:O7;JO( e8f\( 9^@B( A@H( KAJH( =<:C@H( LIBLO@IB@H( O@( 1#0( @I( *HA9IO@(@C(A@H(KAJH(=9LDA@H(9J(/<:CJc9Aa(-@(N9ILT:@(KAJH(:?B@IC@\(JI(c:9OL@IC(2J@HC7,HC(9( ?C?(NLH(@I(?^LO@IB@(O9IH(JI@(?CJO@(K:<HK@BCL^@(NJACLB@IC:LMJ@(eFfa(

,I(!:9IB@\(A@(:@cLHC:@(,/*)"-((@HC(A@(K:@NL@:(:@cLHC:@(=:9Is9LH(@I:@cLHC:9IC(A@H(I<J^@9Jb( B9H( O@( )*#*( O@KJLH( 5EFF(Q( %]LIBLO@IB@( N<>@II@( @IC:@( 5EEF( @C( 3448( O@H( )*#*( ?C9LC( O@( 6a4y( 544a444( S9DLC9ICH( O9IH( A9( N9A9OL@( O@( #:<SI\( @C( Za5( K<J:( A9( 1#0a( %9( )#( @HC( KAJH( =:?MJ@IC@(MJ@(A9(1#0\(B<IC:9L:@N@IC(9Jb(9JC:@H(K9>H(O],J:<K@a((

%]lc@(O]9KK9:LCL<I(@HC(O@(34(G(Y4(9IH(O9IH(A9(1#0\(@C(Y4(G(Z49IH(O9IH(A9()#\(B@K@IO9IC(LA( @bLHC@( JI( O@JbLTN@( KLB( O]LIBLO@IB@( ?N@:c@9IC( BS@_( A@H( K@:H<II@H( lc?@H( O@( 64( G( 849IHeE\54fa( $I( H@b@( :9CL<( @I( =9^@J:( O]JI@( K:?O<NLI9IB@( =?NLILI@( O9IH( A9( )#( @HC( <DH@:^?\(LI^@:H@N@IC\(O9IH(A9(1#0\(B@(H<IC(A@H(S<NN@H(MJL(H<IC(A@(KAJH(:@K:?H@IC?Ha(#@( H@b@(:9CL<(@HC(<KK<H?(O9IH(A9(K<KJA9CL<I(K?OL9C:LMJ@a( ( ( `> '\]L4H5=<\H6HY49& (

%@H( N9A9OL@H( LI=A9NN9C<L:@H( BS:<ILMJ@H( O@( A]LIC@HCLI\( H<IC( B9:9BC?:LH?@H( K9:( JI@( :?K<IH@( LNNJILC9L:@( LI9O9KC?@( O@( A9( NJMJ@JH@( OLc@HCL^@\( :?HJAC9IC( O@( KAJHL@J:H( N?B9ILHN@H( B<NKA@b@Ha( /AJHL@J:H( =9BC@J:H( O@( :LHMJ@( <IC( ?C?( LO@ICL=L?H\( B@K@IO9IC\( O@( N9ILT:@(LIOL^LOJ@AA@\(9JBJI(I]@HC(I?B@HH9L:@(<J(HJ==LH9IC(9J(O?^@A<KK@N@IC(O]JI@()*#*a( ((

( (

(24)

( 3Y(

=X +9L&R=S<9JEL&YFIF<4UJ9L&9<&488JI4<=4E9L&

(

%]@bLHC@IB@( O]9IC?B?O@ICH( =9NLAL9Jb( O@( )*#*( @HC( A@( K:LIBLK9A( =9BC@J:( O@( :LHMJ@( O@( )*#*\( K9:CLBJALT:@N@IC( O9IH( A9( N9A9OL@( O@( #:<SI\( HJcc?:9IC( A]LNK<:C9IC@( KA9B@( O@H( =9BC@J:H( c?I?CLMJ@H( O9IH( B@CC@( K9CS<A<cL@( e55fa( -@H( ?CJO@H( HJ:( O@H( `JN@9Jb( N<I<_>c<C@H( @C( S?C?:<_>c<C@H( ?C9>@IC( B@CC@( S>K<CSTH@(Q( A@( C9Jb( O@( B<IB<:O9IB@( @IC:@( `JN@9Jb( N<I<_>c<C@H(H@:9LC(O@(Y[z(K<J:(A9()#\(@C(O@(56z(K<J:(A9(1#0(e53fa(%@(:LHMJ@(K<J:(A@H( 9KK9:@IC?H(OJ(5@:(O@c:?(H@:9LC(O@(5(G(Yz(O9IH(A9()#\(@C(O@(5z(O9IH(A9(1#0a(

/AJH(O]JI@(B@IC9LI@(O@(NJC9CL<IH(c?I?CLMJ@H(<IC(?C?(LO@ICL=L?@H(O9IH(A@(O?^@A<KK@N@IC( O]JI@()*#*(e5Yx5[f(Q(%9(KAJH(?CJOL?@(@HC(A9(NJC9CL<I(OJ(cTI@(.2-3y#"1-5[(O9IH(A9()#\( 9^@B(KAJH(O]JI@(C:@IC9LI@(O@(NJC9CL<IH(LO@ICL=L?@H\(O<IC(A@H(^9:L9ICH(1843{\(RE4F1(@C( 5448=H( :@K:?H@IC@IC( A9( N9`<:LC?( O@H( BS:<N<H<N@H( NJC?H( e56\58fa( .2-3( @HC( K:?H@IC( O9IH( A@( B>C<KA9HN@( @C( 9( K<J:( :jA@( A]9BCL^9CL<I( O@H( ^<L@H( O@( HLcI9ALH9CL<I( K:<7 LI=A9NN9C<L:@H( ^L9( A@( .!7oX\( LNKALMJ?( O9IH( A9( :@B<II9LHH9IB@( O@H( D9BC?:L@H( LIC:9B@AAJA9L:@Ha(.2-3y#"1-5[(@HC(I<C9NN@IC(@bK:LN?(K9:(A@H(B@AAJA@H(O@(/9I@CSa(#@H( B@AAJA@H( H<IC( O@H( B@AAJA@H( H?B:?C:LB@H( @b<B:LI@H( G( 9BCL<I( 9ICL7NLB:<DL@II@( eA>H<_>N@\( KS<HKS<ALK9H@("3\(O?=@IHLI@fa(%]@bK:@HHL<I(O@(O?=@IHLI@H(@HC(@==<IO:?@(@I(B9H(O@()#\(@C( @IB<:@( O9^9IC9c@( @I( B9H( O@( NJC9CL<I( .2-3y#"1-5[\( @IC:9LI9IC( JI@( :?K<IH@( LI=A9NN9C<L:@(LI9O9KC?@(e56f(O<IC(A9(B<IH?MJ@IB@(@HC(A]9KK9:LCL<I(O@(A?HL<IH(O@(A9(K9:<L( OLc@HCL^@a(

$I@(O>H:?cJA9CL<I(O@(A]LNNJILC?(OLc@HCL^@(@HC(<DH@:^?@(O9IH(A@H()*#*\(B<IH?MJ@IB@(O@(A9( O>HDL<H@( @C( O]JI@( K@:C@( O@( A9( =<IBCL<I( D9::LT:@( O@( A]?KLCS?ALJN( OLc@HCL=( e55f( :?HJAC9IC( O]JI@( 9I<N9AL@( O@( `<IBCL<IH( H@::?@H( MJL( K@:N@C( 9Jb( D9BC?:L@H( K9CS<cTI@H( O]@I^9SL:( A9( A9NLI9(K:<K:L9(e5Ffa(#@(N?B9ILHN@(@Ic@IO:@(JI@(9JcN@IC9CL<I(A<B9A@(O@(B>C<oLI@H(K:<7 LI=A9NN9C<L:@H\( =9LH9IC( O?DJC@:( A@( K:<B@HHJH( LI=A9NN9C<L:@a( %9( :@B<II9LHH9IB@( O@H( D9BC?:L@H( K9CS<cTI@H( K9:( A@H( B@AAJA@H( K:?H@IC9C:LB@H( O]9ICLcTI@H\( @C( A9( K:?H@IB@( O@( B>C<oLI@H( LI=A9NN9C<L:@H\( @IC:9LI@( JI@( H?B:?CL<I( 9BB:J@( O]*%753( @C( A]9BCL^9CL<I( O@H( A>NKS<B>C@H( &a( %@H( A>NKS<B>C@H( &( H<IC( ^<A<ICL@:H( O@( C>K@( &S58( O9IH( A9( N9A9OL@( O@( #:<SI(9D<JCLHH9IC(G(A9(H?B:?CL<I(O@(B>C<oLI@H(K:<LI=A9NN9C<L:@H(e&.!α(\(*%5X\(*%6\(*%Ff( K9:(A@H(N9B:<KS9c@H\(B@AAJA@H(?KLCS?AL9A@H(@C(N?H@IBS>N9C@JH@H\(`<J9IC(JI(:jA@(O9IH(A@( :@B:JC@N@IC( O@( I<J^@AA@H( B@AAJA@H( LNNJILC9L:@H( =9LH9IC( K@:OJ:@:( A]LI=A9NN9CL<I\( N9LH( ?c9A@N@IC( O9IH( A9( H>ICSTH@( O]*%33( LNKALMJ?@( O9IH( A9( H?B:?CL<I( O@( K@KCLO@H( 9ICL7 NLB:<DL@IH\(@C(O@(NJBLI@Ha((

(25)

GX +9L&R=S<9JEL&9IV4EHII989I<=J^&

(

%@(C9Jb(O@(B<IB<:O9IB@(O@H()*#*(@IC:@(A@H(`JN@9Jb(N<I<_>c<C@H(@HC(B@:C@H(?A@^?\(N9LH(LA( I]@HC(K9H(C<C9A(Q(B@BL(HJKK<H@(A]LNKALB9CL<I(O@(=9BC@J:H(@I^L:<II@N@IC9Jba(

%]JI(O@H(K:LIBLK9Jb(=9BC@J:H(?CJOL?H(@HC(A@(C9D9cLHN@(Q(*A(=9^<:LH@(A@(O?^@A<KK@N@IC(O@(A9( )#( 9^@B( JI( :LHMJ@( :@A9CL=( O@( 3( e5Ef\( 9^@B( [4( G( 64z( O@( =JN@J:H( 9J( OL9cI<HCLBa( ,I( :@^9IBS@\( A@( C9D9cLHN@( @b@:B@( JI( @==@C( K:<C@BC@J:( BS@_( A@H( K9CL@ICH( 9^@B( JI@( 1#0\( B@BL( O]9JC9IC(KAJH(MJ@(A9(MJ9ICLC?(B<IH<NN?@(@HC(LNK<:C9IC@a(

%]9KK@IOLB@BC<NL@( 9( JI( @==@C( K:<C@BC@J:( HJ:( A9( HJ:^@IJ@( O@( 1#0\( B@C( @==@C( I]@HC( K9H( :@C:<J^?(BS@_(A@H(K9CL@ICH(9CC@LICH(O@()#(e34x33fa(

%@H( =9BC@J:H( 9ALN@IC9L:@H( `<J@:9L@IC( ?c9A@N@IC( JI( :jA@( O9IH( A@( O?^@A<KK@N@IC( O]JI@( )*#*(Q(@I(@==@C\(JI@(B<IH<NN9CL<I(?A@^?@(O@(H9BBS9:<H@\(O@(K:<C?LI@H(9ILN9A@H\(@C(JI@( OLNLIJCL<I(O@H(=LD:@H(9ALN@IC9L:@H(=9^<:LH@:9LC(A9(HJ:^@IJ@(O]JI@()#(e3Yx3[fa(

-@H(=9BC@J:H(S<:N<I9Jb(H<IC(?c9A@N@IC(LO@ICL=L?H(e36fQ(LA(@HC(<DH@:^?(JI(:LHMJ@(9BB:J(O@( HJ:^@IJ@( O@( )*#*( BS@_( A@H( K9CL@ICH( H<JH( B<IC:9B@KCL<I( <@HC:<7K:<c@HC9CL^@\( @C( O@( 1#0( BS@_(A@H(K9CL@IC@H(H<JH(C:9LC@N@IC(S<:N<I9A(HJDHCLCJCL=a(

,I=LI\(A9(^9BBLI9CL<I(<J(A@(HC:@HH(I]<IC(K9H(?C?(LO@ICL=L?H(B<NN@(=9BC@J:H(O@(:LHMJ@a( (

SX 04SEHG4H<9&

(

%@( NLB:<DL<C@( B<::@HK<IO( G( A]@IH@NDA@( O@H( NLB:<7<:c9ILHN@H( ^L^9IC( O9IH( A@( CJD@( OLc@HCL=\( @C( `<J@( JI( :jA@( K:?K<IO?:9IC( O9IH( A@H( )*#*a( *A( @HC( N9`<:LC9L:@N@IC( A<B9ALH?( 9J( IL^@9J(O@(A]LIC@HCLI(c:dA@(@C(OJ(B<A<I\(MJL(K@:N@CC@IC(JI@(B:<LHH9IB@(<KCLN9A@(K9:(A@J:H( K:<K:L?C?H( KS>HLB<7BSLNLMJ@Ha( *A( H@( N@C( @I( KA9B@( OTH( A9( I9LHH9IB@( @C( H@( N<OL=L@( @I( =<IBCL<I(O@(A]9ALN@IC9CL<I\(O@(A]9AA9LC@N@IC\(@C(O]9JC:@H(=9BC@J:H(@IO<cTI@H(<J(@b<cTI@H( `JHMJ|G( <DC@ICL<I( O]JI@( HC9DLALC?( ^@:H( A]lc@( O@( 3( G( Z9IHa( "( K9:CL:( O@( B@( HC9O@\( A@H( N<OL=LB9CL<IH(<DH@:^?@H\(c?I?:9A@N@IC(LIOJLC@H(e9ICLDL<CS?:9KL@f\(I@(H<IC(MJ@(NLILN@H\( @C(O@Jb(CL@:H(O@H(@HKTB@H(O<NLI9IC@H(<DH@:^?@H(H<IC(K:<K:@H(G(JI(NdN@(LIOL^LOJ(e38fa( "(A]lc@(9OJAC@\(A@(NLB:<DL<C@(@HC(@HH@ICL@AA@N@IC(B<IHCLCJ?((O@(C:<LH(KS>A9(D9BC?:L@IH(MJ@( H<IC( A@H( !L:NLBJC@H\( A@H( X9BC@:<LO@C@H\( @C( "BLI<D9BC@:L9a( *A( <BBJK@( O@H( :jA@H( NJACLKA@H( O9IH( A@( N?C9D<ALHN@( O@H( cAJBLO@H\( K:<CLO@H( @C( ALKLO@H(}( A@( N?C9D<ALHN@( ?I@:c?CLMJ@\( @C( O9IH( A9( :?cJA9CL<I( LNNJILC9L:@( e3Ffa( %9( OL^@:HLC?( OJ( NLB:<DL<C@( K@JC( dC:@( 9AC?:?@( K9:( A]9ALN@IC9CL<I\(A@(HC:@HH\(O@H(K:<DL<CLMJ@H(@b<cTI@H\(<J(A9(K:LH@(O]9ICLDL<CLMJ@Ha(

(26)

( 3[( ( 1@K:?H@IC9CL<I(O@H(OL==?:@ICH(KS>A9(OJ(NLB:<DL<C@(H@A<I(!"#$%&'()*(+,( ( -9IH(A@H()*#*\(LA(@HC(<DH@:^?(JI(O?H?MJLALD:@(O@(B@(NLB:<DL<C@(LIC@HCLI9A(eO>HDL<H@f(9LIHL( MJ]JI@(K@:C@(O@(H9(HC9DLALC?a(#@(O?H?MJLALD:@(:?HJAC@(O]JI@(OLNLIJCL<I(O@(A9(K:<K<:CL<I(O@( D9BC?:L@H( OJ( KS>AJN( !L:NLBJC@H( e@I( K9:CLBJAL@:( -+)"+,.$+"*)&.%/( @C( 012)$%&.+f( ( @C( X9BC@:<LO@C@H( e3E\Y4f\( @C( O]JI@( 9JcN@IC9CL<I( O@H( @IC?:<D9BC?:L@H( @C( O@( A]@HKTB@(

0%/.31"1""%2('3+4%2(MJL(@HC(K:<7LI=A9NN9C<L:@a((

$I@( 9JC:@( D9BC?:L@( 9^@B( O@H( K:<K:L?C?H( K:<7LI=A9NN9C<L:@H( 9( ?C?( LO@ICL=L?@( O9IH( A@H( )*#*(Q( A],HBS@:LBSL9( #<AL( @IC?:<7LI^9HL^@\( K<HHTO@( O@H( B9K9BLC?H( O]9OS?HL<I( @C( O]@I^9SLHH@N@IC( O@H( B@AAJA@H( ?KLCS?AL9A@H( LIC@HCLI9A@H\( @C( @HC( 9HH<BL?@( G( A9( NJMJ@JH@( LA?9A@(O@H(K9CL@ICH(9CC@LICH(O@()#(LA?9A@H(O9IH(@I^L:<I(35z(O@H(B9H\(^@:HJH(6z(O@H(HJ`@CH( B<IC:jA@H(eY5fa(,AA@(H@(AL@:9LC(G(JI(:?B@KC@J:(?KLCS?AL9A\(A@(#,"#")6\(MJL(@HC(HJ:@bK:LN?( BS@_(A@H(K9CL@ICH(9CC@LICH(O@(N9A9OL@(O@(#:<SIa(

"( B@H( 9I<N9AL@H( OJ( NLB:<DL<C@( H]9`<JC@IC( O@H( 9I<N9AL@H( O@( A9( D9::LT:@( LIC@HCLI9A@\( @I( K9:CLBJAL@:(OJ(NJBJH(LIC@HCLI9A(@C(O@H(`<IBCL<IH(H@::?@H\(K@:N@CC9IC(9Jb(B<NK<H9ICH(OJ( NLB:<DL<C@( O]9BB?O@:( KAJH( =9BLA@N@IC( G( A]?KLCS?ALJN( @C( O@( O?BA@IBS@:( JI@( :?K<IH@( LI=A9NN9C<L:@(LIC@HCLI9A@a(

(27)

:X *F5HIL9&4IR6=88=<H4E9&&

(

%9( :?K<IH@( LI=A9NN9C<L:@( LIC@HCLI9A@( :?HJAC@( O@( A]9BCL^9CL<I( O@( ^<L@H( O@( C:9IHOJBCL<I( K:<LI=A9NN9C<L:@H\(9N@I9IC(G(A9(K:<OJBCL<I(O@(N?OL9C@J:H(MJL(A]9NKAL=L@ICa(#@H(^<L@H(O@( C:9IHOJBCL<IH(H<IC(K:LIBLK9A@N@IC(:@K:?H@IC?@H(K9:(A9(^<L@(OJ(.!oXy*oX(@C(A9(^<L@(O@H( )"/( oLI9H@H\( B<IOJLH9IC( G( A9( K:<OJBCL<I( O@( B>C<oLI@H( LI=A9NN9C<L:@H( 9K:TH( C:9IHA<B9CL<I( IJBA?9L:@( @C( =Lb9CL<I( HJ:( A]"-.\( B@( MJL( @IC:9LI@( JI@( HJ:@bK:@HHL<I( O@H( cdI@H( K:<7LI=A9NN9C<L:@H( @C( A9( K:<OJBCL<I( O@( B>C<oLI@H( @C( BSLNL<oLI@H( K:<7 LI=A9NN9C<L:@H(eY3fa((

%@( O@JbLTN@( KS?I<NTI@( <DH@:^?( @HC( A9( HJ:@bK:@HHL<I( O@( N<A?BJA@H( O]9OS?HL<IH( O@H( B@AAJA@H(LI=A9NN9C<L:@H(G(A9(K9:<L(LIC@HCLI9A@\(N?OL?@(K9:(A@H(B>C<oLI@Ha(%@H(LIC@:9BCL<IH( LNKALMJ?@H( H<IC( A]LIC@:9BCL<I( @IC:@( A@H( N<A?BJA@H( A>NKS<B>C@( =JIBCL<I( 9ICLc@I( <J( A@H( ^@:>( A9C@( 9ICLc@I( e%!"\( U%"f( @C( A@H( LIC@:B@AJAA9:( <J( ^9HBJA9:( 9OS@HL<I( N<A@BJA@( e*#")\( U#")fa(%<:HMJ]@AA@H(H<IC(HJ:@bK:LN?@H(B<NN@(O9IH(A@H()*#*\(B@H(N<A?BJA@H(@IC:9LI@IC( JI(:@B:JC@N@IC(9BB:J(O@H(B@AAJA@H(LI=A9NN9C<L:@H(O9IH(A9(K9:<L(LIC@HCLI9A@a(

%@(H>HCTN@(LNNJILC9L:@(@IC?:9A(@C(A@(NLB:<DL<C@(H<IC(?C:<LC@N@IC(AL?H\(@C(I?B@HHLC@IC(JI@( :?cJA9CL<I( B<IHC9IC@(Q( @I( @==@C\( A9( A9NLI9( K:<K:L9( B<ICL@IC( JI@( K<KJA9CL<I( LNNJILC9L:@( B<NKA@b@( 9>9IC( K<J:( :jA@( O@( O?=@IO:@( A@( H>HCTN@( LIC@HCLI9A( O@H( K9CS<cTI@H\( C<JC( @I( K@:N@CC9IC( JI@( C<A?:9IB@( OJ( NLB:<DL<C@( e38fa( %9( :JKCJ:@( O@( C<A?:9IB@( ^LH( G( ^LH( OJ( NLB:<DL<C@\( A]9JcN@IC9CL<I( O@( A9( K@:N?9DLALC?( LIC@HCLI9A@\( @C( A9( N<OL=LB9CL<I( O@( A9( B<NK<HLCL<I( OJ( NLB:<DL<C@( O9IH( A@H( )*#*( :?HJAC@IC( @I( JI@( :?K<IH@( LI=A9NN9C<L:@( LI9KK:<K:L?@(O<IC(A9(B<IH?MJ@IB@(@HC(A9(B<IHCLCJCL<I(O@(A?HL<IH(LIC@HCLI9A@H(<J(B<ALMJ@Ha( (

(

K> -64I4UJ9&9<&:4=YIHL<4S&

(

%@( OL9cI<HCLB( O@H( )*#*( :@K<H@( HJ:( JI( =9LHB@9J( O]9:cJN@ICH( BALILMJ@H\( DL<A<cLMJ@H\( @IO<HB<KLMJ@H\( @C( :9OL<A<cLMJ@H( eYYfa( )9LH( A@( OL9cI<HCLB( O@( B<I=L:N9CL<I( :@HC@( SLHC<A<cLMJ@a(

,I( @==@C\( A@H( )*#*( H<IC( G( ?^<MJ@:( H>HC?N9CLMJ@N@IC( O@^9IC( C<JC@( OL9::S?@( K:<A<Ic?@\( O]9JC9IC( KAJH( MJ@( B@AA@( BL( H]9HH<BL@( G( O@H( cA9L:@H\( ( O@H( :@BC<::9cL@H\( JI( 9N9Lc:LHH@N@IC\(( JI@(N9A9DH<:KCL<I\(O@H(A?HL<IH(K:<BC<A<cLMJ@H\((JI(H>IO:<N@(LI=A9NN9C<L:@(LI@bKALMJ?( <J( JI@( 9I?NL@( =@::LK:L^@( eYZfa( ,AA@H( H<IC( ?c9A@N@IC( G( ?^<MJ@:( @I( B9H( O]9KK9:LCL<I( O@(

(28)

( 38( B@:C9LIH( HLcI@H( @bC:9OLc@HCL=H( O<IC( A]?:>CSTN@( I<J@Jb\( A]9KSC<H@( DJBB9A@\( <J( JI@( BS<A9IcLC@( HBA?:<H9IC@a( ,I( B9H( O]9HH<BL9CL<I( O]JI( <J( KAJHL@J:H( HLcI@H\( LA( B<I^L@IC( O@( :?9ALH@:(JI(DLA9I(@IO<HB<KLMJ@(9^@B(DL<KHL@H(?C9c?@Ha(

%]9HK@BC( @IO<HB<KLMJ@( H@( C:9OJLC( K9:( JI( 9HK@BC( ?:>CS?N9C@Jb\( c:9ILC?\( =:9cLA@( O@( A9( NJMJ@JH@( K9CS<A<cLMJ@\( H9LcI9IC( 9J( B<IC9BC(a( 0LHC<A<cLMJ@N@IC( A@H( A?HL<IH( A@H( KAJH( ?^<B9C:LB@H( H<IC( A@H( DL=J:B9CL<IH( @C( OLHC<:HL<IH( cA9IOJA9L:@H\( @C( A]LI=LAC:9C( A>NKS<7 KA9HN<B>C9L:@( OJ( BS<:L<Ia( %]9HK@BC( @IO<HB<KLMJ@( O@( A9( 1#0( @HC( c?I?:9A@N@IC( B9:9BC?:LH?( K9:( JI@( 9CC@LIC@( B<ICLIJ@( 9HB@IO9IC@( O?DJC9IC( G( A9( `<IBCL<I( 9I<7:@BC9A@\( H]?C@IO9IC( O@( K:<BS@( @I( K:<BS@\( H9IH( O?K9HH@:( A9( ^9A^JA@( LA?<B9@B9A@\( @C( O]LIC@::JKCL<I( D:JHMJ@a(%@H(JAB?:9CL<IH(H<IC(c?I?:9A@N@IC(HJK@:=LBL@AA@H(<J(@I(KJLCHa(0LHC<A<cLMJ@N@IC( A9( NJB<H?B:?CL<I( @HC( C:TH( OLNLIJ?@\( JI@( OLNLIJCL<I( I@CC@( O@( A9( O@IHLC?( B:>KCLMJ@\( JI@( OLHC<:HL<I( H?^T:@( O@H( B:>KC@H\( A]9CC@LIC@( @HC( HJK@:=LBL@AA@( I<I( C:9IHNJ:9A@\( @C( LA( I]@bLHC@( K9H( O@( c:9IJA<N@( ?KLCS?AL<wO@( cLc9IC<7B@AAJA9L:@a( %]9HK@BC( @IO<HB<KLMJ@( O@( A9( N9A9OL@( O@(#:<SI(9(K<J:(K9:CLBJA9:LC?(JI@(OLHB<ICLIJLC?(O@H(A?HL<IH(9^@B(LIC@:^9AA@(O@(NJMJ@JH@( H9LI@\(A9(K:<=<IO@J:(O@H(JAB?:9CL<IH\(@C(A]9CC@LIC@(O@(A]@IH@NDA@(OJ(C:9BCJH(OLc@HCL=(O@(A9( B9^LC?( DJBB9A@( G( A]9IJHa( 0LHC<A<cLMJ@N@IC\( @AA@( H@( B9:9BC?:LH@( K9:( JI@( 9CC@LIC@( C:9IHNJ:9A@\(9^@B(c:9IJA<N@(cLc9IC<7B@AAJA9L:@(eY[fa( ( ( a> 02-2&9<&L]I:EH89&:9&6;4I<9L<4I&4EE4<=G69&3$22>& ( %@H(B:LCT:@H(O@(1<N@(*U(O?=LILHH9IC(A@(H>IO:<N@(O@(A]LIC@HCLI(L::LC9DA@(<IC(:?B@NN@IC(?C?( :?^LH?H(eY6fa(-?H<:N9LH\(A@H(B:LCT:@H(O@(1<N@(:@CL@II@IC(A@(OL9cI<HCLB(O@(H>IO:<N@(O@( A]LIC@HCLI( L::LC9DA@( A<:HMJ]LA( @bLHC@( JI@( O<JA@J:( 9DO<NLI9A@( :?BJ::@IC@( HJ:^@I9IC( @I( N<>@II@( 9J( N<LIH( 5( =<LH( K9:( H@N9LI@( O9IH( A@H( Y( O@:IL@:H( N<LH( 9^@B( 9J( N<LIH( 3( O@H( B:LCT:@H( HJL^9ICH(Q( A]9HH<BL9CL<I( G( A9( O?=?B9CL<I\( A]9HH<BL9CL<I( G( JI@( N<OL=LB9CL<I( O@( A9( =:?MJ@IB@(O@H(H@AA@H(<J(O@(A@J:(B<IHLHC9IB@a(("(I<C@:(MJ@(C<JC(HLcI@(O]9A9:N@(O<LC(=9L:@( :@BS@:BS@:(JI@(<:LcLI@(<:c9ILMJ@(9Jb(H>NKCjN@Ha(

%@( H>IO:<N@( O@( A]LIC@HCLI( L::LC9DA@( C<JBS@( 54( G( 34z( O@( A9( K<KJA9CL<I( eY8fa( ( )*#*( @C( H>IO:<N@( O@( A]LIC@HCLI( L::LC9DA@( <IC( A<IcC@NKH( ?C?( B<IHLO?:?@H( B<NN@( O@Jb( @ICLC?H( OLHCLIBC@H( @C( I<I( HJK@:K<H9DA@Ha( %]<DH@:^9CL<I( :?B@IC@( O]9AC?:9CL<IH( B<NNJI@H( O@( A9( K9:<L( LIC@HCLI9A@( @IC:@( B@H( O@Jb( K9CS<A<cL@H( 9( N<OL=L?( B@( K<LIC( O@( ^J@(Q( @I( @==@C\( JI@( 9AC?:9CL<I( OJ( NLB:<DL<C@\( JI@( O?:?cJA9CL<I( O@( A]LI=A9NN9CL<I( LIC@HCLI9A@( 9LIHL( MJ]JI@(

(29)

9JcN@IC9CL<I( O@( A9( K@:N?9DLALC?( LIC@HCLI9A@( H<IC( C:<LH( N?B9ILHN@H( K9:C9c?H( K9:( B@H( O@Jb(K9CS<A<cL@H(eYFfa(-@(KAJH\(A@(:LHMJ@(O@(O?^@A<KK@:(JI@()*#*(9K:TH(JI(OL9cI<HCLB(O@( ;**( H@NDA@( HLcIL=LB9CL^@N@IC( KAJH( ?A@^?( MJ@( BS@_( A@H( K9CL@ICH( H9LIH\( 9^@B( JI@( LIBLO@IB@( NJACLKAL?@( K9:( F\6( O9IH( JI@( ?CJO@( @==@BCJ?@( HJ:( 3F45E( K9CL@ICH( eYEf( a( %@H( ?CJO@H( O@( K:?^9A@IB@( <IC( NLH( @I( ?^LO@IB@( JI( C9Jb( ?A@^?( O@( ;**( BS@_( A@H( K9CL@ICH( 9CC@LICH( O@( )*#*( MJL@HB@IC@\( 9^<LHLI9IC( A@H( YEz( O9IH( JI@( N?C979I9A>H@( eZ4f( ^@:HJH( Z\FEz( BS@_( A@H( K9CL@ICH(B<IC:jA@H\(9^@B(JI(2OOH(19CL<(O@(Z\YEa(#@AA@(BL(@HC(O]9JC9IC(KAJH(?A@^?@(BS@_(A@H( K9CL@ICH(9CC@LICH(O@()*#*(MJ@(BS@_(A@H(K9CL@ICH(B<IC:jA@H\(@C(H]9HH<BL@(G(JI@(?A?^9CL<I(OJ( HB<:@( 9IbL?C?\( G( JI@( 9AC?:9CL<I( O@( A9( MJ9ALC?( O@( ^L@( eZ5f\( N9LH( ?c9A@N@IC( G( O@H( B<N<:DLOLC?H(KH>BS<A<cLMJ@H(eYFfa((

-@H( =9BC@J:H( c?I?CLMJ@H( B<NNJIH( H@NDA@IC( ?c9A@N@IC( dC:@( K9:C9c?H( @IC:@( A@H( )*#*( @C( A@H( ;**(Q( A@( cTI@( &.!;!5[( B<O@( K<J:( A9( K:<C?LI@( &%5"\( ALc9IO( OJ( &.!( LNKALMJ?( O9IH( A9( O?=@IH@(B<IC:@(A@H(K9CS<cTI@H(@C(O9IH(A]LIC@:9BCL<I(9^@B(A@(NLB:<DL<C@a(#@(cTI@(9(O]9D<:O( ?C?( LO@ICL=L?( B<NN@( =9BC@J:( O@( :LHMJ@( O@H( )*#*\( C<JC@=<LH( H<I( LNKALB9CL<I( O9IH( A@( H>IO:<N@(O@(A]LIC@HCLI(L::LC9DA@(H@NDA@(?c9A@N@IC(9^?:?@(eZ3fa(

%]@IH@NDA@( O@( B@H( N9IL=@HC9CL<IH( :@IC:@( O9IH( A@( B9O:@( O@( A]9b@( B@:^@9J7LIC@HCLI( <J( h(D:9LI7cJC(i\( H@A<I( A@MJ@A( LA( @bLHC@( O@H( LIC@:9BCL<IH( @IC:@( A@( H>HCTN@( I@:^@Jb( B@IC:9A\( H>HCTN@( I@:^@Jb( 9JC<I<N@\( cA9IO@( KLCJLC9L:@\( @C( A@H( ?A?N@ICH( B<IHCLCJ9IC( A@( C:9BCJH( OLc@HCL=( MJ@( H<IC( A@( NLB:<DL<C@\( A9( D9::LT:@( ?KLCS?AL9A@\( @C( A@( H>HCTN@( LNNJILC9L:@( LIC@HCLI9Aa( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( (

(30)

( 3E(

Z>&+9L&L5HI:]6=E<\EH5=<\49L&

(

%@H( HK<IO>A9:CS:<K9CSL@H( :@c:<JK@IC( A@H( 9CC@LIC@H( 9:CLBJA9L:@H( LI=A9NN9C<L:@H( BS:<ILMJ@H( K9:C9c@9IC( JI( C@::9LI( c?I?CLMJ@( B<NNJI( Q( ,AA@H( B<NK:@II@IC( A9( HK<IO>A9:CS:LC@(9Io>A<H9IC@\(A@(:SJN9CLHN@(KH<:L9HLMJ@\(A@H(9:CS:LC@H(:?9BCL<II@AA@H\(A@H( 9:CS:LC@H( 9HH<BL?@H( 9Jb( @IC?:<B<A<K9CSL@H( LI=A9NN9C<L:@H\( @C( A@H( HK<IO>A9:CS:<K9CSL@H( LIOL==?:@IBL?@Ha(

(

M> %54:F84H6HY49&

(

%]?KLO?NL<A<cL@(O@H(HK<IO>A9:CS:<K9CSL@H(O9IH(A9(K<KJA9CL<I(c?I?:9A@(^9:L@(O]?CJO@(@I( ?CJO@( @I( :9LH<I( O@H( OL==?:@IB@H( N?CS<O<A<cLMJ@H( @C( O@( A9( BA9HHL=LB9CL<I( JCLALH?@\( A9( K:?^9A@IB@(H@:9LC(C<JC@=<LH(B<NK:LH@(@IC:@(4\45(@C(3\[z\(9^@B(JI@(LIBLO@IB@(@IC:@(4\ZF(@C( 6Yy544a444( S9DLC9ICH( eZYfa( %9( K:?^9A@IB@( O@( A9( HK<IO>A9:CS:LC@( 9Io>A<H9IC@( ^9:L@( O@( 4\45(G(3z(eZY\ZZf\((@C(OJ(:SJN9CLHN@(KH<:L9HLMJ@(@IC:@(4\5(@C(4\Zza((

%@(H@b7:9CL<(@HC(O@(Y(Q5(@I(=9^@J:(O]JI@(K:?O<NLI9IB@(N9HBJALI@\(N9LH(O9IH(JI@(:?B@IC@( ?CJO@( 9AA@N9IO@\( A@( C9Jb( O@( =@NN@H( 9CC@LIC@H( H@:9LC( @I( 9JcN@IC9CL<I( O@( Z6z( O@KJLH( 5EE4( eZ[f\( `JHMJ]G( <DC@IL:( JI@( K:?^9A@IB@( ?c9A@( O9IH( A@H( O@Jb( H@b@H( @I( K9:CLBJAL@:( @I( !:9IB@( eZ6fa( %@H( =<:N@H( =?NLILI@H( I@( OL==T:@IC( K9H( O@H( =<:N@H( N9HBJALI@H( K<J:( A9( N9`<:LC?(O@H(9JC@J:Ha(

%]lc@(O]9KK9:LCL<I(O@H(HK<IO>A9:CS:<K9CSL@H(@HC(HLCJ?(A@(KAJH(H<J^@IC(O9IH(A9(C:<LHLTN@( O?B@IIL@\(N9LH(K@JC(O?DJC@:(G(C<JC(lc@(eZ8fa(%@H(=<:N@H(`J^?ILA@H(:@K:?H@IC@IC(54(G(34z( O@H( HK<IO>A9:CS:<K9CSL@H\( @C( H<IC( c?I?:9A@N@IC( 9HH<BL?@H( G( JI@( 9CC@LIC@( KAJH( H?^T:@( 9^@B(JI@(HJ:^@IJ@(O@(B<bLC@H(KAJH(=:?MJ@IC@a( ( ( `> '\]L4H5=<\H6HY49& & =X A=S<9JEL&YFIF<4UJ9L&9<&488JI4<=4E9L& &

%@H( HK<IO>A9:CS:<K9CSL@H( H<IC( A@( :?HJAC9C( O@( N?B9ILHN@H( B<NKA@b@H\( LNKALMJ9IC( 9^9IC( C<JC( JI( C@::9LI( c?I?CLMJ@( K:?OLHK<H9IC( B<NN@( @I( C?N<LcI@( A9( =:?MJ@IB@( O@H( 9c:?c9CL<IH(=9NLAL9A@H(O9IH(B@CC@(K9CS<A<cL@a(

(31)

,I( @==@C\( A@( C9Jb( O@( B<IB<:O9IB@( O@( A]9KK9:LCL<I( O]JI@( HK<IO>A9:CS:LC@( 9Io>A<H9IC@( O@H( `JN@9Jb(N<I<_>c<C@H(H]?AT^@:9LC(G([4z\(@C(G(34z(BS@_(A@H(`JN@9Jb(OL_>c<C@H\(K<:C@J:H( O@(0%"X38eZFfa( %]9HH<BL9CL<I(9^@B(A@(B<NKA@b@(O]SLHC<B<NK9CLDLALC?(0%"7X38(@HC(B<IIJ@\(@I(@==@C\(9A<:H( MJ@(H9(K:?^9A@IB@(^9:L@(O@(6(G(Fz(O9IH(A9(K<KJA9CL<I(B9JB9HL@II@\(3(G(6\8z(O@H(K9CL@ICH( K<:C@J:H(O?^@A<KK@IC(JI@(HK<IO>A9:CS:LC@(9Io>A<H9IC@(eZE\[4fa((;9(K:?^9A@IB@(BS@_(A@H( K9CL@ICH(O?`G(9CC@LICH(O]JI@(HK<IO>A9:CS:<K9CSL@(^9:L@(O@([4(G(E4z\(@C(O?K9HH@(A@H(E4z( BS@_( A@H( K9CL@ICH( 9CC@LICH( O@( HK<IO>A9:CS:LC@( 9Io>A<H9IC@( e[5fa( -@( KAJH\( A9( K:?H@IB@( OJ( cTI@( 0%"7X38( @IC:9LI@:9LC( JI@( 9KK9:LCL<I( KAJH( K:?B<B@( O@( A9( N9A9OL@( @I( B<NK9:9LH<I( 9^@B( A@H( K9CL@ICH( I<I( K<:C@J:H( e[3f\( @C( H@:9LC( KAJH( =:?MJ@NN@IC( 9HH<BL?@( 9J( O?^@A<KK@N@IC( O]JI@( J^?LC@( 9IC?:L@J:@( 9LcJ@a( %9( K:?H@IB@( O@( N9IL=@HC9CL<IH( @bC:97 9:CLBJA9L:@H( @HC( =:?MJ@IC@( O9IH( A@H( HK<IO>A9:CS:<K9CSL@H(Q( %9( HJ:^@IJ@( O]JI@( )*#*( @HC( <DH@:^?@(O9IH(8z(O@H(B9H(O@(HK<IO>A9:CS:<K9CSL@H(e[fa(

,I(O@S<:H(OJ(B<NKA@b@(N9`@J:(O]SLHC<B<NK9CLDLALC?\(O]9JC:@H(K:?OLHK<HLCL<IH(c?I?CLMJ@H( <IC( ?C?( LO@ICL=L?@H( O9IH( A@( O?^@A<KK@N@IC( O@( HK<IO>A9:CS:<K9CSL@H(\( B<NN@( A@H( K<A>N<:KSLHN@H(9AA?ALMJ@H(OJ(cTI@(*%751.e[Yf\("1&;5\(*%3Y1(<J(OJ(cTI@(#V/3-6(e[Zfa( ,I( B@( MJL( B<IB@:I@( A@( cTI@( #"1-5[y.2-3\( =9BC@J:( K:?OLHK<H9IC( O9IH( A9( N9A9OL@( O@( #:<SI\(LA(I]9(K9H(?C?(NLH(@I(?^LO@IB@(O@(^9:L9IC(9HH<BL?(G(A9(N9A9OL@(A<:H(OJ(H?MJ@Is9c@( B<NKA@C( OJ( cTI@e[[f\( IL( O]9HH<BL9CL<I( LIC:9=9NLAL9A@( @IC:@( A@H( C:<LH( K:LIBLK9Jb( ^9:L9ICH( 9HH<BL?H(O9IH(A9()#(@C(A@H(HK<IO>A9:CS:<K9CSL@H(<J(A9(HK<IO>A9:CS:LC@(9Io>A<H9IC@(H@JA@( e[6\[8fa( ( ( GX A=S<9JEL&9IV4EHII989I<=J^& ( /AJHL@J:H(=9BC@J:H(@I^L:<II@N@IC9Jb(<IC(?C?(LO@ICL=L?H(O@H(A@H(HK<IO>A9:CS:<K9CSL@H(Q(( %@( C9D9cLHN@( H@:9LC( =9BC@J:( O@( :LHMJ@( OJ( O?^@A<KK@N@IC( O@( A9( KAJK9:C( O@H( HK<IO>A9:CS:<K9CSL@H( e[Ff( \( N9LH( LA( @HC( ?c9A@N@IC( JI( =9BC@J:( O@( N9J^9LH( K:<I<HCLB( O@( A]9BCL^LC?(O@(A9(N9A9OL@\(@C(O@(A9(:?K<IH@(9Jb(C:9LC@N@ICH(K9:(9ICL&.!(e[Efa((

%@H( c@:N@H( K9CS<cTI@H( <IC( JI( :jA@( LNK<:C9IC( O9IH( A@( O?^@A<KK@N@IC( O@( B@:C9LI@H( HK<IO>A9:CS:<K9CSL@H( @I( K9:CLBJAL@:( O@H( 9:CS:LC@H( :?9BCL<II@AA@H\( MJL( H<IC( =<:C@N@IC( 9HH<BL?@H(G(O@H(LI=@BCL<IH(G(c@:N@H(R:9N(I?c9CL=H(e56,+/78.+9(:6.'),,+9(;)&2.3.+fa(

(32)

( Y5( %@( HC:@HH( ?c9A@N@IC( 9( ?C?( LO@ICL=L?( B<NN@( =9BC@J:( O@( :LHMJ@( O@( A]9BCL^LC?( O@( A9( N9A9OL@( O9IH(JI@(?CJO@(K:<HK@BCL^@e64\65fa(( ( K> -64I4UJ9&9<&,4=YIHL<4S& ( %@H(HK<IO>A9:CS:<K9CSL@H(H@(K:?H@IC@IC(O@(N9ILT:@(S?C?:<cTI@(O]JI(LIOL^LOJ(G(A]9JC:@\( @C(A@J:(OL9cI<HCLB(:@K<H@(HJ:(O@H(9:cJN@ICH(G(A9(=<LH(BALILMJ@H\(DL<A<cLMJ@H(@C(O]LN9c@:L@a(( ,AA@H(H@(N9IL=@HC@IC(K9:(A]9KK9:LCL<I(O@(O<JA@J:H(9:CLBJA9L:@H(LI=A9NN9C<L:@H(BS:<ILMJ@H\( O@(KS?I<C>K@(^9:L9DA@(Q( 7 %@(H>IO:<N@(K@A^L:9BSLOL@I(<J(9bL9A(B<NK:@I9IC(Q( o (A@H(O<:H<7A<ND9AcL@H\(

o A@H( K>c9AcL@H( B<::@HK<IO9IC( G( A9( N9IL=@HC9CL<I( BALILMJ@( O]JI@( H9B:<LALLC@\( K<J^9IC(dC:@(JIL\(DLA9C?:9A@H(<J(G(D9HBJA@a(

7 %@(H>IO:<N@(9:CLBJA9L:@(K?:LKS?:LMJ@\(S9DLCJ@AA@N@IC(H<JH(=<:N@(O]<ALc<9:CS:LC@( O@H(c:<HH@H(9:CLBJA9CL<IHa(

7 %@( H>IO:<N@( @ICS?H<K9CSLMJ@(K?:LKS?:LMJ@( Q( B<::@HK<IO9IC( G( A]9CC@LIC@( LI=A9NN9C<L:@(O@H(@ICSTH@H\(H@(N9IL=@HC9IC(K9:(O@H(C9A9AcL@H\(JI@(O9BC>ALC@\(<J(JI( H>IO:<N@(CS<:9BLMJ@(9IC?:L@J:(

7 %@( H>IO:<N@( @bC:979:CLBJA9L:@(Q( J^?LC@( 9IC?:L@J:@( 9LcJ@\( @IC?:<B<A<K9CSL@( LI=A9NN9C<L:@\(KH<:L9HLHa(

XL<A<cLMJ@N@IC\( LA( @bLHC@( JI( H>IO:<N@( LI=A9NN9C<L:@( LIB<IHC9ICa( ;J:( A@( KA9I( LNNJI<A<cLMJ@\( A@H( HK<IO>A9:CS:<K9CSL@H( H<IC( OLC@H( h(H?:<I?c9CL^@H(i( @I( :9LH<I( O@( A9( I?c9CL^LC?(O@H(=9BC@J:H(:SJN9C<wO@H\(@C(O@H(9JC<79ICLB<:KHa(

,I( LN9c@:L@\( I<JH( OLHCLIcJ<IH( ?c9A@N@IC( A@H( 9CC@LIC@H( K?:LKS?:LMJ@H( O@H( 9CC@LIC@H( 9bL9A@H\(K<J^9IC(dC:@(B<NNJI@H(<J(K:<K:@H(G(BS9MJ@(C>K@(O@(HK<IO>A9:CS:<K9CSL@a(,AA@H( H<IC(A@(:?HJAC9C(O@(KS?I<NTI@H(LI=A9NN9C<L:@H\(9D<JCLHH9IC(G(O@H(A?HL<IH(O@(O@HC:JBCL<I( e?:<HL<IHf\(KJLH(G(O@H(A?HL<IH(O@(:?K9:9CL<I(eHBA?:<H@\(H>IO@HN<KS>C<H@\(9Io>A<H@fa( "LIHL(A]9CC@LIC@(9bL9A@\(^LHJ9ALH?@(K:LIBLK9A@N@IC(O9IH(A@H(HK<IO>A9:CS:LC@H(9Io>A<H9IC@H(\( H@(C:9OJLC(K9:(e63f(Q(

7 $I@( 9CC@LIC@( :9BSLOL@II@( 9^@B( JI@( NLH@( 9J( B9::?( O@H( ^@:CTD:@H\( A9( K:?H@IB@( O@( H>IO@HN<KS>C@H\(@C(O]JI@(9Io>A<H@(@I(h(B<A<II@(D9ND<J(i(<J(h(@I(:9LA(i(O9IH(A@H( 9CC@LIC@H(?^<AJ?@Ha(%]*1)\(KAJH(H@IHLDA@\(K@:N@C(KAJH(=9BLA@N@IC(A@(OL9cI<HCLB(O@( OLHBLC@(=A<:LO@\(O]9:CS:LC@(O@H(9:CLBJA9CL<IH(_>c9K<KS>H9L:@H(K<HC?:L@J:@H(@C(B<HC<7

(33)

^@:C?D:9A@H\( @C( O@H( @ICS?HLC@H( O@H( ALc9N@ICH( LIC@:7?KLI@Jba( %9( HK<IO>ALC@( KH<:L9HLMJ@( 9( JI@( K:?OLA@BCL<I( K<J:( A9( :?cL<I( B@:^LB<7O<:H9A@( @C( G( A]LI^@:H@( JI@( :9:@C?(O@(A]9CC@LIC@(A<ND9L:@a(

7 $I@( 9CC@LIC@( O@H( H9B:<7LAL9MJ@H( G( A9( :9OL<c:9KSL@\( MJL( K@JC( dC:@( O@( HC9O@( 5( A<:HMJ]JI( KH@JO<7?A9:cLHH@N@IC( O@H( D@:c@H( @HC( <DH@:^?\( O@( HC9O@( 3( @I( B9H( O]?:<HL<I(O@H(D@:c@H\(O@(HC9O@(Y(@I(K:?H@IB@(O]JI@(B<IO@IH9CL<I\(@C(O@(HC9O@(Z(@I( B9H( O@( =JHL<I( O@( A]LIC@:ALcI@( B<::@HK<IO9IC( G( H<I( 9Io>A<H@a( ,I( B9H( O@( I<:N9ALC?( O@H( :9OL<c:9KSL@H\( JI@( *1)( O<LC( dC:@( :?9ALH?@( 9=LI( O@( :@BS@:BS@:( O@H( HLcI@H( K:?B<B@H(O@(H9B:<7LALLC@a(

%]9CC@LIC@(K?:LKS?:LMJ@(H@(C:9OJLC(K9:(O@H(HLcI@H(:9OL<A<cLMJ@H(O]9:CS:LC@a(%9(B9AB9I?LC@( @HC( =:?MJ@IC@( @C( H@( C:9OJLC( K9:( O@H( ?:<HL<IH( O@( A]?KLI@( B9AB9I?@II@a( %9( B<bLC@( @HC( JI( ?A?N@IC( O@( N9J^9LH( K:<I<HCLB( O]JI@( HK<IO>A9:CS:LC@( 9Io>A<H9IC@a( %]9CC@LIC@( O@H( 9:CLBJA9CL<IH(LIC@:KS9A9IcL@II@H(K@JC(dC:@(LH<A?@(<J(H]9HH<BL@:(G(JI@(C?I<H>I<^LC@a(( (

%@H(HK<IO>A9:CS:LC@H(BL(H<IC(O?=LIL@H(K9:(KAJHL@J:H(BA9HHL=LB9CL<IH\(A@H(KAJH(B<IIJ@H(?C9IC( B@AA@H( O@( A],J:<K@9I( ;K<IO>A9:CS:<K9CS>( ;CJO>( R:<JK( ^9ALO?@( @I( ,J:<K@( e6Yf\( O@( X@:I9:O("N<:(^9ALO?@(@I(!:9IB@(e6Zf\(<J(KAJH(:?B@NN@IC(O@(A]";";(c:<JK(^9ALO?@(O9IH( JI@(LIHC9IB@(LIC@:I9CL<I9A@e6[fa(

%],;;R( :@CL@IC( A@( OL9cI<HCLB( O@( HK<IO>A9:CS:<K9CSL@( @I( B9H( O@( O<JA@J:H( 9bL9A@H( LI=A9NN9C<L:@H( <J( A9( K:?H@IB@( O@( H>I<^LC@H\( 9HH<BL?@H( G( 9J( N<LIH( JI( O@H( B:LCT:@H( HJL^9ICH(Q(A9(K:?H@IB@(O]9IC?B?O@ICH(=9NLAL9Jb(O@(HK<IO>A9:CS:<K9CSL@H\(O@(KH<:L9HLH\(O@( )*#*\(O]J:?C:LC@\(O@(OL9::S?@(9LcJ@\(O@(=@HH9AcL@H(G(D9HBJA@\(O]JI@(@ICS?H<K9CSL@\(<J(O]JI@( H9B:<7LALLC@(:9OL<A<cLMJ@(e&9DA@9J(*fa(( ( ( <+$,)+%(=(>(5&.*?&)2(8%('&1%@)()%&1@A)3(8BA*%8)(8)2(2@1387,+&*6&1@+*6.)2(C!::D(EFFEG(

(34)

( YY( (

%9(BA9HHL=LB9CL<I(9AC@:I9CL^@(O]"N<:(@C(9A(e&9DA@9J(**f(9(?c9A@N@IC(?C?(K:<K<H?@\(LIBAJ9IC( A]SLHC<:LMJ@( O@H( H>NKCjN@H\( A@H( :?HJAC9CH( :9OL<A<cLMJ@H\( A@( C@::9LI( c?I?CLMJ@\( @C( A9( :?K<IH@(9J(C:9LC@N@IC(e6Zfa(

(

(

<+$,)+%(==(>(5&.*?&)2(8BH/1&9(EFFI(

(

WJ9IC( G( A9( ;K<IO>A":CS:LCLH( LIC@:I9CL<I9A( ;<BL@C>( e";";f\( @AA@( 9( K<J:( D?I?=LB@( O@( OLHCLIcJ@:( A@H( B:LCT:@H( K:<K:@H( G( JI@( HK<IO>A9:CS:LC@( 9bL9A@( e&9DA@9J( ***f( O]JI@( HK<IO>A9:CS:LC@(K?:LKS?:LMJ@(e&9DA@9J(*Uf\(BS@_(A@H(K9CL@ICH(lc?H(O@(N<LIH(O@(Z[9IHa( (

(

<+$,)+%( ===( J( 5&.*?&)2( H:H:( KIIF(8B%3)( 2@1387,+&*6&.*)( +L.+,)( "6)M( ,)2( @+*.)3*2( N'A2( 8)( /1.32(8)(OP+32(+4)"(&+"6.+,'.)2(A41,%+3*(8)@%.2(@,%2(8)(*&1.2(/1.2(

(35)

(

<+$,)+%( =Q( J( 5&.*?&)2( H:H:( KIIF( 8B%3)( 2@1387,+&*6&.*)( @A&.@6A&.R%)( "6)M( ,)2( @+*.)3*2(N'A2(8)(/1.32(8)(OP(+32(+4)"(27/@*S/)2(@A&.@6A&.R%)2( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( (

(36)

( Y[( ->&&+;=^9&@J<CDH4I<& & M> $5HI:]6=E<\EH5=<\49L&9<&02-2&& & =X )I&<9EE=4I&YFIF<4UJ9&9<&488JI4<=4E9&SH88JI& & %]9HH<BL9CL<I(@IC:@(HK<IO>A9:CS:<K9CSL@H(@C()*#*(@HC(SLHC<:LMJ@N@IC(B<IIJ@a(,I(@==@C\(A9( K:?^9A@IB@( O]JI@( HK<IO>A9:CS:LC@( 9Io>A<H9IC@( H]?AT^@( O@( 5( G( 6z( BS@_( A@H( K9CL@ICH( 9CC@LICH( O@( )*#*( e66\68fa( #@AA@( O@( A9( )*#*( O9IH( A@H( HK<IO>A9:CS:<K9CSL@H( H]?AT^@( G( 8z( eZYfa( #@CC@( 9HH<BL9CL<I( :@K<H@:9LC( HJ:( A@( K9:C9c@( O]JI( K<A>N<:KSLHN@( c?I?CLMJ@( K:?OLHK<H9IC\( B<O9IC( K<J:( A@H( 9BC@J:H( O@( A9( :?K<IH@( LNNJILC9L:@a( #@K@IO9IC\( A@H( K:<B@HHJH( LI=A9NN9C<L:@H( LNKALMJ?H( O9IH( B@CC@( 9HH<BL9CL<I( H<IC( K@J( B<IIJHa( #@:C9LIH( 9:cJN@ICH( ?^<MJ@IC( MJ@( A]<:LcLI@( O@H( HK<IO>A9:CS:<K9CSL@H( :?HLO@:9LC( O9IH( A9( H>HC?N9CLH9CL<I( O]JI( K:<B@HHJH( LI=A9NN9C<L:@( LHHJ( O]JI@( LI=A9NN9CL<I( OLc@HCL^@a( #@CC@( H>HC?N9CLH9CL<I( LNKALMJ@( MJ]JI@( 9BCL^9CL<I( O@( B@AAJA@H( LNNJILC9L:@H( HL?c@9IC( O9IH( A@H( c9IcAL<IH( N?H@IC?:LMJ@H\( @IC:9LI@:9LC( JI@( NLc:9CL<I( O@( B@H( B@AAJA@H( O9IH( A@( C:9BCJH( OLc@HCL=H( 9LIHL( MJ]9Jb( B@AAJA@H( @IO<CS?AL9A@H( H>I<^L9A@H\( K9:( A]@bK:@HHL<I( O@( N<A?BJA@H( O]9OS?HL<I(B<NNJI@H(e6Ffa("(CLC:@(O]@b@NKA@\(O@H(K<A>N<:KSLHN@H(c?I?CLMJ@H(OJ(cTI@( *%73Y1(H@NDA@IC(dC:@(K9:C9c?H(O9IH(A@H(O@Jb(K9CS<A<cL@H(e6Efa(

,I( B@( MJL( B<IB@:I@( A@( B<NKA@b@( O]SLHC<B<NK9CLDLALC?( 0%"7X38\( H9( K:?^9A@IB@( BS@_( A@H( K9CL@ICH(9CC@LICH(O@()*#*(@I(B<NK9:9LH<I(9^@B(A9(K<KJA9CL<I(@HC(A9(NdN@a(,I(:@^9IBS@\(LA( @HC( <DH@:^?( JI@( 9JcN@IC9CL<I( O@( A]LIBLO@IB@( O@( 0%"( X38( BS@_( A@H( K9CL@ICH( 9CC@LICH( O@( )*#*(9HH<BL?@(G(JI@(HK<IO>A9:CS:LC@(9Io>A<H9IC@(e84fa(( %9(NJC9CL<I(OJ(cTI@(#"1-5[y.2-3(=<:C@N@IC(9HH<BL?@(G(A9(N9A9OL@(O@(#:<SI(I]9(K9H( ?C?(:@C:<J^?@(O9IH(A9(HK<IO>A9:CS:LC@(9Io>A<H9IC@(e[6fa( (( GX +;=<<94I<9&=E<4SJ6=4E9&S\9b&69L&02-2& (

%9( K:LIBLK9A@( 9CC@LIC@( @bC:9OLc@HCL^@( O9IH( A@H( )*#*( @HC( A]9CC@LIC@( 9:CLBJA9L:@( eZfa( #@AA@( BL( K@JC( H@( N9IL=@HC@:( H<JH( KAJHL@J:H( =<:N@Ha( %9( K:@NLT:@( @HC( B@AA@( O@H( HK<IO>A9:CS:<K9CSL@H( H?:<I?c9CL^@H( B<NK:@I9IC( 9:CS:<K9CSL@H( K?:LKS?:LMJ@H\( :SJN9CLHN@( 9bL9A\( @C( @ICS?H<K9CSL@H\( O<IC( A9( K:?^9A@IB@( @HC( O]9JC9IC( KAJH( LNK<:C9IC@( MJ@(A]9CC@LIC@(OLc@HCL^@(@HC(?C@IOJ@e85fa((

(37)

(

%]9CC@LIC@(K?:LKS?:LMJ@(@HC(A9(KAJH(=:?MJ@IC@\(C<JBS9IC(55(G(34z(eZf(O@H(K9CL@ICH(9CC@LICH( O@()*#*a(,AA@(H@(B9:9BC?:LH@(c?I?:9A@N@IC(K9:(JI@(9CC@LIC@(KAJ:L9:CLBJA9L:@(K:?O<NLI9IC( 9Jb(N@ND:@H(LI=?:L@J:H\(A@(KAJH(H<J^@IC(9H>N?C:LMJ@\(@C(B<IB@:I@(K:?=?:@ICL@AA@N@IC(A@H( 1#0( K9IB<ALMJ@H( @C( A@H( )#( 9^@B( 9CC@LIC@( B<ALMJ@a( %@H( H>I<^LC@H( 9HH<BL?@H( N<IC:@IC( H<J^@IC( O@H( 9CC@LIC@H( SLHC<A<cLMJ@H( 9HK?BL=LMJ@H\( C<JC@=<LH( O@H( H>I<^LC@H( c:9IJA<N9C@JH@H(K@J^@IC(dC:@(^LHJ9ALH?@H(O9IH(A@H(N9A9OL@H(O@(#:<SIa(

*A( @bLHC@( O@Jb( C>K@H( O]9CC@LIC@( 9:CS:LCLMJ@H( K?:LKS?:LMJ@H( 9J( B<J:H( O@( )*#*( H@( OL==?:@IBL9IC(K9:(A@J:(HC9CJC(0%"\(A@J:(BALILMJ@\(@C(A@J:(?^<AJCL<I(eZf(Q(

7 %]9:CS:LC@(K?:LKS?:LMJ@(O@(C>K@(5(OLC@(K9JBL(9:CLBJA9L:@\(@HC(9HH<BL?@(9Jb(c:<JK@H( 0%"( X38\( XY[( @C( -1X5\( @C( C<JBS@( N<LIH( O@( [( 9:CLBJA9CL<IH\( O@( N9ILT:@( 9H>N?C:LMJ@\( 9^@B( JI@( K:?O<NLI9IB@( K<J:( A]9CC@LIC@( O@H( c:<HH@H( 9:CLBJA9CL<IHa( ,AA@(@HC(9HH<BL?@(G(A]9BCL^LC?(O@(A9()*#*\(9LIHL(MJ]9Jb(9CC@LIC@H(@bC:979:CLBJA9L:@H(O@( C>K@( ?:>CSTN@( I<J@Jb( <J( J^?LC@( 9IC?:L@J:@( 9LcJ@\( @C( ?^<AJ@( HJ:( KAJHL@J:H( H@N9LI@Ha(;9(K:?^9A@IB@(^9:L@(O@(Z(G(6za(( 7 %]9:CS:LC@(K?:LKS?:LMJ@(O@(C>K@(3(eK<A>79:CLBJA9L:@f\(N<LIH(=:?MJ@IC@\(@HC(9HH<BL?@( 9J(cTI@(0%"(XZZ\(@C(C<JBS@(9J(N<LIH([(9:CLBJA9CL<IH\(9^@B(JI@(K:?=?:@IB@(K<J:( A@H(K@CLC@H(9:CLBJA9CL<IHa(,AA@(@HC(LIO?K@IO9IC@(O@(A]9BCL^LC?(O@(A9()*#*\(?^<AJ@(HJ:( KAJHL@J:H(N<LH(^<L:@(9II?@H\(@C(I]@HC(9HH<BL?@(MJ]G(JI@(J^?LC@a(;9(K:?^9A@IB@(^9:L@( O@(5(G(Yza( ( %@(:SJN9CLHN@(9bL9A(B<::@HK<IO(9Jb(N9IL=@HC9CL<IH(LI=A9NN9C<L:@H(9bL9A@H(K<J^9IC(H@( N9IL=@HC@:(9J(B<J:H(O]JI@()*#*a(*A(K@JC(H@(K:?H@IC@:(H<JH(=<:N@(O@(C:<LH(KS?I<C>K@H(Q( 7 %9(A<ND9AcL@H(BS:<ILMJ@(LI=A9NN9C<L:@(MJL(:?K<IO(9Jb(B:LCT:@H(O@(#9ALI(eZ(O@H([( B:LCT:@H( I?B@HH9L:@Hf( LIBAJ9IC(Q( JI( lc@( O@( O?DJC( LI=?:L@J:( G( Z[9IH\( JI@( OJ:?@( HJK?:L@J:@( G( Y( N<LH\( JI@( LIHC9AA9CL<I( LIHLOL@JH@\( JI@( :9LO@J:( N9CLI9A@\( @C( JI@( 9N?AL<:9CL<I(K9:(A]@b@:BLB@a(;9(K:?^9A@IB@(^9:L@(O@([(G(Y4ze83fa(

7 %9(HK<IO>A9:CS:LC@(9Io>A<H9IC@\(O?=LIL@(K9:(A@H(B:LCT:@H(";";\(@HC(K:?H@IC@(O9IH( A@H()*#*(O9IH(5(G(54z(O@H(B9He8Yfa(*A(@HC(G(I<C@:(MJ@(A9(K:?^9A@IB@(OJ(c:<JK@(0%"( X38(O9IH(A@H(;"(9HH<BL?@H(9Jb()*#*(@HC(C:TH(^9:L9DA@(O]JI@(?CJO@(G(JI@(9JC:@(e3[(G( 8Fzf(e83f(N9LH(:@HC@(KAJH(D9HH@(MJ@(O9IH(A@H(;"(H@JA@H\(C<JC@=<LH(H9(K:?^9A@IB@( O9IH( A@H( )*#*( @I( A]9DH@IB@( O@( ;"( @HC( HJK@:K<H9DA@( G( B@AA@( O@( A9( K<KJA9CL<I( c?I?:9A@a(

(38)

( Y8( 7 %@H( K9CL@ICH( K<:C@J:H( O]JI@( )*#*( 9^@B( H9B:<7LAALLC@( LH<A?@( 9H>NKC<N9CLMJ@( I@( :@IC:@IC( K9H( O9IH( A@H( B:LCT:@H( O@( A],;;R( @C( B<::@HK<IO@IC( O<IB( G( JI@( @ICLC?( K9:CLBJALT:@a( ,AA@( C<JBS@( 55( G( Y4z( O@H( K9CL@ICH( H@A<I( A9( N?CS<O@( O]LN9c@:L@( JCLALH?@( e:9OL<c:9KSLMJ@( <J( HB9II<c:9KSLMJ@f( e8Zfa( ,AA@( I]?^<AJ@( c?I?:9A@N@IC( K9H(^@:H(JI@(HK<IO>A9:CS:LC@(9Io>A<H9IC@a(

(

%@H( @ICS?HL<K9CSL@H( B<::@HK<IO@IC( G( JI@( LI=A9NN9CL<I( O@H( LIH@:CL<IH( C@IOLI@JH@H\( MJ9IC( 9Jb( O9BC>ALC@H( @AA@H( B<::@HK<IO@IC( G( O@H( C?I<H>I<^LC@H( O@H( O<LcCH( <J( O@H( <:C@LAH( O<II9IC(JI(9HK@BC(h(@I(H9JBLHH@(i(a(,AA@H(H<IC(^LHJ9ALH?@H(O9IH([(G(54z(O@H()*#*a((

(

-@H( 9:CS:9AcL@H( L9C:<cTI@H( <IC( ?C?( O?B:LC@H( O9IH( A@H( )*#*( H<JH( C:9LC@N@IC( K9:( BLBA<HK<:LI@\(9_9CSL<K:LI@\(6(N@:B9KC<KJ:LI@\(LI=ALbLN9D(<J(9O9ALNJN9D\(c?I?:9A@N@IC( :?H<AJCL^@H(G(A]9::dC(OJ(C:9LC@N@IC(B9JH9Aa(

(

-@H(9CC@LIC@H(<HH@JH@H(H<IC(?c9A@N@IC(^LHJ9ALH?@H(O9IH(A@H()*#*(<n(A]<IC(K@JC(<DH@:^@:(Q( 7 $I@(<HC?<K?IL@(@C(<HC?<K<:<H@(Q(O9IH(A@H(?CJO@H(K:<HK@BCL^@H\(JI@(OLNLIJCL<I(O@((

[( G( 54z( O( A9( O@IHLC?( <HH@JH@( @HC( =:?MJ@NN@IC( :@C:<J^?@\( @I( K9:CLBJAL@:( @I( B<IC@bC@( O@( C:9LC@N@IC( K9:( B<:CLB<CS?:9KL@a( ,I( :@^9IBS@\( B@AA@( BL( @HC( HC9DA@( 9J( B<J:H( O@H( )*#*( MJL@HB@IC@H\( @C( LA( K@JC( dC:@( <DH@:^?( JI( :9CC:9K9c@( O@( A9( O@IHLC?( <HH@JH@(9K:TH(C:9LC@N@IC(BSL:J:cLB9A(O@(A9()*#*(e8[fa(

7 $I@(<HC?<9:CS:<K9CSL@(S>K@:C:<KSL9IC@(O<IC(A9(K:?H@IB@(@HC(B<::?A?@(G(A]9BCL^LC?( O@( A9( N9A9OL@( @C( O<IC( A9( :?c:@HHL<I( K@JC( dC:@( <DH@:^?@( 9K:TH( JI@( :?H@BCL<I( LIC@HCLI9A@a(,AA@(C<JBS@:9LC(5[z(O@H(1#0(@C(YFz(O@H()#a(

7 %]<HC?<I?B:<H@(9H@KCLMJ@(O<IC(A9(K:?^9A@IB@(@HC(@HCLN?@(G(4\[z(e86f(@HC(H<J^@IC( @bKALMJ?@(K9:(JI(C:9LC@N@IC(B<:CLH<ILMJ@(N9LH(K@JC(?c9A@N@IC(dC:@(<DH@:^?@(@I( O@S<:H( O@( C<JC@( B<:CLB<CS?:9KL@\( O9IH( JI( B<IC@bC@( ^9HBJA9L:@\( N?C9D<ALMJ@( <J( N?B9ILMJ@a( ,AA@( C<JBS@( c?I?:9A@N@IC( A@H( B<IO>A@H( =?N<:9Jb\( A]SJN?:JH( @C( A@H( C9A<IHa(

(

SX +;=<<94I<9&:4Y9L<4V9&:=IL&69L&L5HI:]6=E<\EH5=<\49L&

(

/AJHL@J:H(?CJO@H(H@(H<IC(LIC@::<c?@H(HJ:(A@(HC9CJC(LI=A9NN9C<L:@(OLc@HCL=(BS@_(A@H(K9CL@ICH( 9CC@LICH( O@( HK<IO>A9:CS:<K9CSL@Ha( "A<:H( MJ@( A9( K:?^9A@IB@( O@H( )*#*( @HC( O@( 8z( BS@_( A@H(

Références

Documents relatifs

Mr Pierre FREGER (surnombre) HCN Anatomie - Neurochirurgie Mr Jean François GEHANNO HCN Médecine et santé au travail Mr Emmanuel GERARDIN HCN Imagerie médicale.. Mme

Les résultats expérimentaux semblent prometteurs, puisque nous avons réussi à déduire à l’aide des outils RMN du solide plusieurs formes du phosphore dans la micelle de caséines

considérée comme une fin crédible des règles de droit, l’efficience ne peut pas être une fin.  L’efficience est une propriété

Nous avons constaté que les patients âgés ayant eu une découverte de cancer en service de CSG (groupe 1), étaient majoritairement des femmes, présentaient moins de troubles

- tuteur et tutoré peuvent intervertir leurs rôles peuvent au cours du processus ; - le dispositif pédagogique mis en place peut être plus ou moins

Mais tout au contraire, se sont, comme le montre le passage de La Grande maison, des mères tout aussi capables de sentiments et ayant au moins, pour leurs enfants,

La qualité de l'ajustement entre les résultats expérimentaux et le modèle de prédiction laisse à suggérer que le modèle HAM peut être approprié pour prédire la génération

This paper analyses the relationship between employment suburbanisation in the Paris metropolitan area, the growth of reverse commuting and changes in the weekday travel