Job Shop Scheduling via Disjunctive Boolean Formulas

(1)

0123415364789 96 711 7 19

!"#$%#&'#()#$*#&+#,-./$*,.-./ 012345627879:;<=1=>874?:4@A8BC<4D2E=

FGHIJKLLLMHNJOGPMQRSTQOTJOKLUMVWJPMQRSXGJNLJYZOP[K\OIQJHZMLOQS FMXOUWGMPZK]QJHZMLOQ

^_`abcdaef23418g5=h4E;i=5>47@j864524=i;86k6Bl4g54641;8

>4;m=7lm2Em8AA=l:6;=@:2A7;m4l=5k21n;48>6;=g45i=5>;m4g5=h4E;o pm4;48>6854i=5>47@j4>gA=j4468178EE=5721n;=;m48@2A2;j=i;m4>

i=568;26ij21n;m4A=n2E8A54q:254>41;6=i;m4;86k6opm4A48745=i;m4 g5=h4E;74;45>2146i=548Em;86kBA=n2E8AE=1;5821;62172E8;21n;m472r45s 41;4>gA=j446lm=E81g45i=5>;m4;86kot8Em4>gA=j44m86866=E28;478 E=6;i=5g85;2E2g8;21n218;86kB6=;m8;l4m83472r4541;l8j6;=g45i=5>

;m4;=;8Ag5=h4E;817l2;m72r4541;E=6;6o

u4g54641;8>4;m=7i=5g5=E46621n;m4A=n2E8AE=16;5821;6866=E28;47;=

48Em;86kov:5>4;m=7@:2A768AA;m4g=662@A4l=5k21n;48>68178A6=

2;6m=l6;m4E=6;866=E28;47l2;m48Eml=5k21n;48>opm4>4;m=78A6=

w176;m4l=5k21n;48> l2;m>212>:> E=6;i=57=21n;m4;=;8Ag5=h4E;o xyz{|b}`~8;26w8@2A2;j?5=@A4>B=@m=g?5=@A4>Bu=5k21np48>6B

26h:1E;234=5>6

1896 1

&",&",$",&",",','",'&#,#"

&"#&",),","$,'&

,#&&,"#"'#&'#,,'",""""#"&#

") &"#,")#,$&#&'&","&,&,,'&

,#&#"'&&&"&"#&#"&#&' ,#,

'&," ##"&"',,""#,,#"",

"'&,#,&,''#,#',&#&,,"#"#,

#,##""/#"&&",

&),'+"#-#"("'+-($#,,,"#"&"' ,,####$#&'"#"#"",&#&,#&

#'"&##"&",,#"'#&'#"

,#''&"#&""$"&#&"#&" ,"

##"&",,#,,"&#"",&'"&/

#"'#"&

$&,',&#,#,""#,,#'",

#/'&"),#/'), &,'&",

#/',&&,#,"&,,",'&'"#

,""

¡¢

(2)

24415265561225839652 2655613723 265553678175785412345865675786156193 52672484624167412677741683265314712525 81482412656774164869968874142323777741 23745265561239577412352655

345754123379 812415416 !36779 5418235544942457262415814824195774123 2655012345896554152618523"9541772624157"

8241232655112317526541941683265#

751237619237594123458965553797 23456541235874241683265237345$182475

#674127524182416992347127412652362861 72967$824196787762486145396723 7$822741523948698152764125768326541237$8283 81276415256727615962245$18247535238152764125761 26541237$824996558462423645$18247

414169945$18247523265541237$826181$1824 961796% 457&14123458652352'()*%+*2352 56245,65541125%+274152347127412652362861 729237$828249#349-'()*%+*2317 56245,65541125+453614712265861729 237$82

#365416232492352'()*%+35,123 741265348386177237$8261695274123741 26 423414 852655412362236724846241683941 62653656,"8523454162624.62414993922386145 256161246412374126 59824178557 /8412276156712611648

0 123435 2646789:; 5 <5 6495 :=

>2? @ AB_CDEEEDB_FG652H7$825I17$82JB_K@ *L_KCDEEEDL_KM_N+ 7652 2655O6837$82B_KP? 4577416741 266168374126 4565295

O6837$82B_KP? 815452565745815824614127112 2655J*L_KCDEEEDL_KM_N+374561776123265567$824123 41271182341583662362872641265586112411249699 232655231167892

& 11876377818763*Q&R+SK@ *TDU*SK++45492 777512416837$82B_KP?31541S_K77512265561

$41239652265237$82423658469196965B_KO683

*VDW+PU*S_K+6141236223265W 1547829123265V3 78188152764125212655677751212345Q&R237323 5316177512567818796241534214252655

XY

(3)

01 2

3

4

5 6

78898

7

! "#$ %&'()$* +,$*$-./01#2 $* 31#4 5$6(78.9-::&;<"-=>?

$*1 "#! .-1 5#22#";$* <"<$<-:$-./@#1.#2 $<2 .$* <"<$<-:$-./.A;-"#!

1 31 . "$<"BC* "-" 11#1*-.% "3 0#12 !@$* D11#1"#! A;-"!$* E"-:

$-./;<"#91EB91 ;<$<.1 31 . "$ !%&$* FGH:-% :"#! 7I* !91-$<#"#0 -5*$-./<./"#C";-"!$* $-./1 J9<1 .-. $#0 23:#& .$*1#9B*#9$<$.

3 10#12-"5 7

K $L MNOPQORQSSSQOTU% -. $#0G%##: -"V-1<-%: .; -5*V-1<-%: O(WL 1 31 . "$.-" 23:#& 01#2-5#23-"&7>XYZ[\]X<. <$* 1-V-1<-%: #1-" B-$ ! V-1<-%: 7I* %-1#V 1$* V-1<-%: ;O0#1<".$-"5 ;C<::! "#$ -" B-$ !V-1<-%: 7

^#2 $<2 .;C -:.#9. _-.$* " B-$ !#3 1-$#17K $`MNOPQ_OPQSSSQOTQ_OTU

% $* . $#0:<$ 1-:.#V 1-. $#0V-1<-%: .L;-"!: $a-"!b% $C#5#".$-"$.

$*-$1 31 . "$$* c]Xd[-"!Z\e[V-:9 .;1 .3 5$<V :&7fgf! "#$ .-.9.9-:;$*

"92% 1#0 : 2 "$.#0-. $g7 9. h@iA$#<"!<5-$ $* V-1<-%: <"V#:V !%&

$* :<$ 1-:i7

I* !<.49"5$<#"#0!<j 1 "$:<$ 1-:.<.5-:: !-kilmno7*<: $* 5#"49"5$<#"

#0!<j 1 "$:<$ 1-:.<.5-:: !-pqrlno7

s#1+Wt;-+ukilmno@+upqrlnoA<.-kilmno@pqrlnoA5#".<.$<"B#0 v-5$:&

+iw'orlin7> V-1<-%: OWL -33 -1.<"-5:-9. #1-3*1-. k<0O#1O<.-"

: 2 "$#0k7K $h@kAMNOWL xOlppolrnwGkU7

>5#"49"5$<V 0#12 @yzA<.-5#"49"5$<#"#0kilmnon7>+,{s<.-yz 5#",

$-<"<"B#":&+,5:-9. .7>!<.49"5$<V 0#12 @|zA<.-!<.49"5$<#"#0pqrlnon7>

+,=s<.-|z5#"$-<"<"B#":&+,3*1-. .7

>"-..<B"2 "$n0#1-%##: -"0#129:-z <.-%##: -"09"5$<#"nx}@zA~

NQU7>"]ddY[Z5-"% 5#".<! 1 !-:.#-.-. $#0"#"5#23: 2 "$-1&

3-<1.#0:<$ 1-:.70iWn;% <"Bn-"-..<B"2 "$;$* "n$91".iZ\e[-"!ic]Xd[7 {#".<! 1<"B%#$*-5:-9. k-"!-"-..<B"2 "$n-.-. $#0:<$ 1-:.;k<. d]ZYd[%&n<0-"!#":&<0knM;-"!<00#1-::iWk;iWn$* "n0-:.<E .k7

>..92<"B-:.#-3*1-. p-.-. $#0:<$ 1-:.;p<..-$<.E !%&-"-..<B"2 "$n<0

(4)

4698046791980609625

6096250106119670 !"#61 609625 012 6319802692676961390962$ 6096250106119 67015%&!#61 609625012 6319802692670448061$

613909625'044032437 676009620611937 (7 88190469804040)01061190*+380,+91-./

064421399937108604319061261+382046734567869:38 356₇;6₉91<./346₇86₉:

=9 033401738)40>?@./69937324909 0318 -./ 603198026963138)10960467>?@./3 A=9BC./3 D>?@./D9082610469537>?@./>?@834 316961298E 616167 00324B>?@ 3)1961834 3169373)1961 91)83732437 212318-./C 834 60406 FGE349834

H IJKLM LNOPQRSTQUVQWJX

Y3E32)461834 01738)409200937Z[3.)496E 83[9/\34\₇8]]]8\_^:932)4231_ 061385_ 435

`0[3.3883[9/\_a673825Z_a31)96190b\_a3.c_a78]]]8c_a^_d/3 9860e)196043828031990b619083[990b.c_af/ 88199gE990b379[3\_a

`090bc_ah00360920836196i_ah012083[9\_a)9 061273802)96jc_a=9_ah99089967382)4619 90bc_ah+38k3l8]]]8Z99390496909083[9\_a1273834961 0446990b66934963196012696213920@_a'64@$_a2139 993904908261195?_a61382893061940990b\_amno

=9_pqr90b01.9390434963196379)496E83[95E 9/012@$ 99390490826137959)496E3[961396E 6s09631834 316983)4561126102)4379Z83[9909 6166s90b01012993904908261 mtou393[96101 738)409206166s619734430617)19631v

w₇3_pqr3x!64_a^_dyi_ap_dDkml]]]Zo: w₉3@$ 3z_^

a{7m_!6.|8_ap_dyi_ap_d}jc_a/o

*383809301621436183[9019349610251060059 26~819038b61909334198e)681937083[93016 01016990~73825Z43506006442139599v

346₇8]]]86_^:

(1809604186083[9\_a3)42034626126~819 0059096090b61983[9018046s2526~819435 .038b6190/1226~819390804430920382619390896609631 37435738873861029861290b

(5)

012345267839696226956923528198262259223 96 2 992268239989648333982 921388231225922319435688521943 9568852198396227956885296526968123 69226356959321233228999696823!329 126236889387296213416236889362962968912 5!8882392592231262"486223143!2958312812 5692#962$5289623688994!21925922317212 32!8882396193528%259223996899526872 812191262&226989648323!83129622688 1262893185925922398226823

0125692262%2334162368893'5!888239662"486223(96 2138125692#962$522828129983231 9293683!2225869259223

)*+,-.'/(0&882318839611225922/568852 81246623

)*+,1.'/2/₃(0012432834383%!212/45/₃45888 128126912259223/96/₃435688528122961!91

!2912322

)*+,6.'/27/₃(0012432834383%!212/458/₃49&8823 18/₃83912212/3194!2912322&1232 8/8398122 12/₃439!288

)*+,:.'7/27/₃(0012432834383%!28/4 98/₃4 9888 128126/96/₃259223319495688528122!91912 319490143243798178!91259223812322

;,<<*-=>?@A?BCDECEFG@GEHBIJEDKLIB@M?HNBHA?@DBHFIB@?OGHBIEPGNBI

?QLGRBI?H@JEDKLIB?SCD?FF?OGHOGFTLHN@GR?JEDKUVWX

Y968912562789432129893683872!12226 9125692!262682383487296301223398281 2139569283487296Z'(1812923128262 9682318152696 123

[183487296 Z'(!298%27872969\5938893995 ]99689125938899212592212281265688529 568852961243956885281246629682

012329729639296218348969 Z'(996 12693 968$^0143213133398268$^98812 826234!2318152696 12966235983

&298'81129489952696(12_ 83487296312 2569593889964` 4Z'_a(8Z'_b(80008Z'_c(83962`

8!294899834872963#4612696233821 383%23`625623239965695269682182$24212 95692

de

(6)

2824924215482891285823548457125858915 8127 992113589185823518

91151 !"5824233891544318127489282157185 7317188915181#18130114188915335418595 85 63891418 !"2234595851817189175135!897767 548

$ % &'() +,-.'/01./2'3'.4 5'.6) 7(8/+49

:28632127315;916335891587<28551456144857= 7<15484>164851518?@ ABCDDDCAE"911129824AFGH 924 24452812418555312548284126325531257632!9541 751341141889181274992113589185823518I295 8127 4114181275135!

J89541751345! 89135232361K28148928228632173511 764812575185891581278912361L11441489288915=

14517351172581228589158127012345641891 2361=K85281892889114181173511764858282818928 58127

915482842899173511456311352824AFGH21 82432812468157MN AF";69MN AF"114414891#11824 85157 891824AF45891576323614891#118468127492 157 891824I29468157 MN AF"4151895692552 7285548284158124OP

Q5114182718958563891751349942842338915=

48284855891518R48114188231K8917638328128814 64191855416818244AF2AFSB2154118511571 8914271173511

914889115458918231K5891146385821918912=

8285521735114114422824289191411442891 85823518;73232173511764858282812824 2361=K"

541T618391U49133582828189151828233 54VW2X 8918231K"Y8915891928914753Z464191855482842 58158942841191217351176482828128246891 924582828189153358244

[\]^_`a\_bcade`dfgh]`_eij]\kdilaf^mdn_o]\piq

rm_stbu18OF1272858289168157485157 891 824AFu18vwxAxyPz@ {FCP@ KCDDDC|1218551984129198{F

1141848915485891282855891173511}F891518 rm_s~b012324123728763832855891 728=824424

OH@O_B O"DDD O_E" K"

(7)

01234567899

!""#$!%&!'#" ()&' *$#&+,!-!.&/-'$'#" ( '-/" %/.#" &$ !0&$1"'-/" %/.#" ,%#""$!&$"#2/3##%%/0*

456789:'#" ('-/" %/.#" &$ $;-#" &$<3= !0&$ $ "#" ,+#>

#$0"&+!.&$"# $ $?"!>'2&/@#'&,0 $#.!-/" $?!-2'#" (*

A $.!-.&+!%!$"-$!#" !B#2/.&$!"# $"!*

4567 C9D)"&2"# $ $?"B$#/'#" (E + "&-"-$!#" !B#2/&+!1 +#!!&. #""&#.&+ $E #.&!"+ .%!$"".#?"#""

.&!%&$0 $?+&F $?"#' ;-!"!"&%)&' &$""&"#/%&G."*H)#&+

I_JKE !%!$"02>#2 $#>,."&L<M_NOM_POQQQOM_R="$".&!"&)"#"

+&F $?"#' + //2L

STUV<IJ=WX

YZ[\N]^_`ab

:$++ //#,#$;-#/$-'2&).&!"!#!&+!"( !" $"'#" ( E*4567c9:!-/" $?&+!)&'#" (E1#!&"0 $0!.$0 $?&0 + "!%.""&"!" '#"0.&!"!1#$0"&+E + "' $ '-' .&!"+ // 2!/."0#!"+&F $?"#' )&.#>&-"""&"#/%&G."*

D! '%/(#'%///-!"#"!"+#> $+ .&-'"&0+&F!*

defghijklm"V_NOV_P#$0V_n2""#!F!)&' $?#%&G."E*:.&$!"# $"!

+ .0"' $&+"0 o$"'%/&>!&)".&'%#$>.#$%)&' #.

"#!F#L

V_NW<p_Nqrp_s=q<p_Ptp_n=t<<p_Pup_v=qp_n= V_PW<rp_Nqp_nqp_s=t<p_Nqp_Pqp_v=

V_nW<<p_Pqp_v=t<rp_Nqp_n==qp_s

D,."&&).&!"! !? ,$#..&0 $?"&"!#/#>&)#.'%/&>L STUVUW

wp_N p_P p_n p_s p_v xyz{zzyyz|xzyzz

}

~>"#$!/#" $?".&$!"# $"!0B$02>"/#0&)"%&G."#!0 !G-$.

" ,)&'!1+&2"# $")&//&+ $?0 !G-$." ,.&$!"# $"!L

(8)

0823641545479341548549 023485475493641545479

1 8

!

₁2

"

##

$

% % &'% &

% & %'% &

& % % & '%

&'%% & '%

( ))

*

₈2

+'%&%%&

% %&&%

,

2

+& %&%%

'%&%%&

,

-./0/01/%21

/.₁3₈⁴5

"

##

$ ₁

% % &'% &

% & %'% &

& % % & '%

&'%% & '%

( )) ))

*3

"

##

$ ₈⁴ '% %& %

% &

& % ( )) )) ))

* 2

"

##

$

6₇

8 9 9 9 9

% % &'% % 8 9 9 9 9

% % %'% % '% % % % '%

% 8 9 9 9 '% '% % % %

% 8 9 9 9 ( )) )) )) )) )) ))

*

:;1/<=>002111;%&

?>2/121/5

@2A0./;2?;?0B2

? 2/0/1;⁴5

"

##

$

67

% % &'% %

% % %'% % '% % % % '%

'% '% % % % ( )) ))

*3

"

##

$ ⁴

&'%

% &

& %

% %% &

( )) )) ))

* 2

"

##

$

% % & 8 96

% 8 9 9 9

% % % 8 9 '% % 8'% % '% % % % '%

'% 8 9 9 9 '%'% % % %

% 8 9 9 9 ( )) )) )) )) )) ))

*

CD

(9)

01234567813935451515311435487247727567 8139355

01281399757567454344357255674 321!

556745!"71#5673535173679771567$75%

&_'&₍&₎&_* &₊ ,-./

,0./

1719275635567$7531#73725#7314567991!

21!573

34₍54₎54_*631234₎54_*54₊6%

01256721!573 561 45434₍54₎54_*6%

714567472674545354#49"1!567#97 7351!

5675734563531775399567$7553424 47361!5671756567 13945%8643365567#97 4"74935567145315 4354351#974 90:662456!364312155624$15"7 492756717763"7$45472%

; <=>?@ ABC =>B

D32345317463"75 21!573412757E75"792 3$75%86753423$75313!7451492357567453E31257357 5734563531367"71757749541277531574745514%16 745514371711!56735633#95743#957431221972!7 31!56779774663"753946567$75%86747793514 7455143757197567$75313!731267455327567

#7452741%

F4391!56721!57344#347217441!24$15"7 4471!5677977469235357312564764515 71!47853424%867435483#95344!1715474951! 567

#9731937747155672E77153457 5675539$75%

G774715375627441!56724$15"74912725736 5342%F7562313942757176621!573 434435725567 1455321!1514273515635567353517367977 17365342634347845%

HIJ IKI>?IB

LMNOPQRSOTMUVWXYZ[\]^_`\_ab]cXdeUfgOhijSOklSOmnjUoppqM

rs

(10)

338 !"#$"%"&'$ &&"( )*'++,-81./01..08000.1 /176321318)4("54#64789$ #:" 82;3< =8>?@A1

.176BC18=6BC186D318EF3GH1C18I 9#"!$"J $K4!54#:4&"( L4MN:K48:K 9&"(O#4M& 7!8P0000Q8R533315113BS.00A?>15

T12D6UR6B8>??/8J$ 7V$"!W"!# $!8XB56935R3361.56 3BRF1

Y1H36DZ18H3G6GH18[6DX117189663R365\3356135R53 R5656B1C R635B]53D1D^3R5\3_1=D38:"

W"# $O#&& &64789$"(/08P000YQ81Y./1YT?

A1965532131C R63`6R566R3\5353R1 563B 3R3^3R5R3BD38J( 7 $:" 8a1/08 P>?@.Q81@T.1@YA1

@13B=1UD358b#8KcK 4#d'$!88&"$"4!$4O#4M& 7!45:4" $d8XB51

=4CH 3R58>?A@1

?1736e1C183633B=1e18f3B6583BRR36B533338 88&" J$K 7$"&:" !8a1.]PA0Q800>081/.TT1/.YY1

>01e5691=18=D666H1=18Z53653B68*4$ !4*97M # cK 4#dW"!# $ J$K 7$"!>T]P.Q8000?81>1Y

>>1U58218f536B36`653368#$"%"&'$ &&"( gh8 0A/1/008>??Y1

>01a6B68=1918[3R3`55=638U3686B966768 :'J L49#&464789$"(81/?@1.0A8a/>8Z08000>1

>/126\B938C6H6Ri_58U6B73D3856564533R3CE1 R6C6R8jk54#l" #!"$dO# !!8>.A1>T01

mn